Latest / Situational Awareness Tactics / WE CHAT WITH DAVID OF THE DAVID THE DOG TRAINER PODCAST ON DOG BEHAVIOR
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to Situational Awareness Tactics Podcast. This podcast provides the crucial art of understanding
- 0:09current elements in an environment to increase your safety and survival. Here's your host,
- 0:15forensic psychologist and consultant, doctor Carlos. Welcome back everybody. Well you
- 0:29probably figured out we're starting to do a series on dog training and dog psychology,
- 0:33what's going on in the brain of the canine. To help us out
- 0:35today is David Turpak. He's the owner and training director of Miracle Canine Training
- 0:40Miracle Canine Training dot com. You can also catch his podcast, which is
- 0:44a great podcast called David the Dog Trainer Podcast and catch them on YouTube,
- 0:48Spotify, They're everywhere. You can also follow them over on Instagram at Miracle
- 0:52Canine Training on Instagram, and again I mentioned Miracle Canine Training dot com check
- 0:56out more about it. We're gonna be talking about some of the episodes he's
- 1:00had on David the Dog Training or podcast which really caught my eyes. So
- 1:03I think it's gonna be fascinating to see what's going on with these dogs,
- 1:06what's the where is it going, what's all about dog training world? I
- 1:10can't even talk what is the dog training world about let's how about that before
- 1:15we get started. You know what to do, share, subscribe, hit
- 1:17that like but you know we like it. It's not waste any more time.
- 1:19Welking on to the show, David, Welcome, sir, happy to
- 1:22be here. Thanks for having me. Yes, my voice changes when I
- 1:25do the show. So, David, first things first, I'm always curious
- 1:30because I've interviewed now several dog trainers and it's always fascinated me. Motive.
- 1:34What got you in the business. Yeah, good question. So I don't
- 1:38have the phenomenal origin story that a lot of people do, if they had
- 1:42a knack with dogs since they were kids and grew up with them and helped
- 1:47all their friends with them and all that kind of stuff. I actually never
- 1:49had dogs growing up. I was never really a big animal person. I
- 1:53was just not really exposed to them very much when I was a kid.
- 1:56And sometime, I would say in my mid to late teens, some friends
- 2:00of mine were getting dogs. Seemed pretty cool. I was kind of noticing
- 2:04how how neat it seemed, you know, being able to go out and
- 2:07take your dog for a walk, and you know, have a buddy to
- 2:08come home to me and all that kind of stuff, so it kind of
- 2:10sparked the idea. I wound up getting my very first dog, I think
- 2:15when I was gosh, probably eighteen or nineteen somewhere around there. And because
- 2:22I have a fairly obsessive personality, and my only exposure to dogs up until
- 2:25that point was the handful of friends that had them that would just jump all
- 2:29over me or bark at me, or you know, just basically be a
- 2:31nuisance anytime I would come over their house. I knew I didn't want my
- 2:34dog to be that way, so I wanted to learn about training. So
- 2:38as soon as I actually adopted my first dog, I had already enrolled in
- 2:42classes and immediately got into it and just kind of kept learning more and more.
- 2:49It was like this endless cycle of I would, you know, learn
- 2:51as much as I could from that trainer that I was working with, and
- 2:53then I would try to find somebody else that could teach me more, and
- 2:55then learn as much as I could from that person, find somebody else that
- 2:58could teach me more. And that kind of led me down a path where
- 3:02an old buddy of mine had started working for a dog training kind of in
- 3:06the Cleveland area. I was seeing the videos he was posting, it looked
- 3:08really cool. It's very different from a lot of the training that I was
- 3:10doing. I wound up signing up for classes there and then just basically went
- 3:15there every single day after work, hanging out, trying to learn as much
- 3:19as I could. Was offered a job there and that's what really kick started
- 3:22the journey into professionally dog training that at that point fascinating and actually was an
- 3:27interesting is you led to one of my questions I was going to ask you.
- 3:30I've heard this couple times now. I actually heard it from different podcasts.
- 3:32I haven't been able to ask anybody here the first one. It just
- 3:36started hearing these phrases. There was one guy I mentioned that's on this podcast.
- 3:40I don't love dogs. I like dogs a lot, and I think
- 3:46you can still be a dog trainer. And he said, if you don't
- 3:47love dogs, but you like them, you think that's ye. Yes,
- 3:52I think what most people mean when they say that, because I hear that
- 3:53quite a bit in the dog world as well. It's not that they don't
- 3:57love dogs, right, It's that, you know, you realize once you
- 4:00get into this industry, if you're going to be successful in this industry,
- 4:04just a love for dogs isn't enough. And frankly, a lot of the
- 4:08people that just love dogs, they don't make it very far in this industry.
- 4:11It's just it's too much of a people industry, right, that's really
- 4:14you know, on the end of the day, it's like the age old
- 4:15saying, if we're training people, not you know, the dogs don't need
- 4:17the training, The people need the training. Like that holds very true,
- 4:20right, Like training without human education goes nowhere and ultimately fails. Right,
- 4:26So I think you need to you know, I was just on a podcast
- 4:30with a with a fellow trainer just just last week, and he said,
- 4:32you know, the dogs he really likes helping people, right, and the
- 4:39dogs is just his vehicle to be able to help people basically, right,
- 4:42So he likes dogs, right, He loves dogs, right, But he
- 4:45really enjoys helping impact people's lives in a positive way, and being good with
- 4:49dogs allows him to do that more effectively. Interesting because using it has a
- 4:54vehicle, it's a better communicate with people. And that's it. You've been
- 4:59a great point, which we'll get to later on in the show, seeing
- 5:00what your opinion is about. I'm not gonna get two political in there.
- 5:05But there are several ideologies, like in any any disappointments, all these different
- 5:09philosophies and theories, and everybody's got it, whether it's criminology, psychology,
- 5:14medicine, or at different ideas. And dog wears same thing right, force
- 5:16free and what does it balance? Training or sometimes I call it high bred
- 5:20train whatever, But the anthropomorphic concept of a lot of people anthropomorphosize their dogs,
- 5:29giving them human traits and characteristics. And I keep hearing that this is
- 5:32a no no, you can't go around acting like they're going to respond to
- 5:35you like a human being. And I know it's a bummer, you know,
- 5:39it's kind of one of these the used to say Debbie Downers. It's
- 5:42kind of one of these bump bumber of things to say to people because they
- 5:45don't they utilize dogs for certain reasons. I don't know what's your take on
- 5:48the anthropomorphisizing of dogs. Is it so much of a big deal or is
- 5:54it really it's it's a big deal I think from the standpoint of the more
- 5:59you do so and the more you put these human traits on dogs that dogs
- 6:01just frankly just aren't in a position to like comprehend and understand, Like you
- 6:04just can't communicate the same way with a with a dog as you would a
- 6:08human. The more you can create like stress and frustration and anxiety, which
- 6:13ultimately leads to a lot of behavioral issues. Now, listen, we're all
- 6:15guilty of Like as society moves along and we put ourselves in a position where
- 6:19we could do more with our dogs, and we could take them more places
- 6:23and integrate them into more parts of our life, you know, that's inevitably
- 6:28going to have them start to fill that child role more, you know what
- 6:31I mean. Like, it's like I think right now, like statistics are
- 6:34like people are getting married later, having children later, or not having children
- 6:39at all, and they're getting dogs instead. Right, So yeah, I
- 6:43think it's a big problem. I think it can create a lot of issues.
- 6:46And it's interesting a lot of people when we tell them, like don't
- 6:47treat your dog like a child, and obviously it's a more nuanced conversation than
- 6:50that, you know, they almost get like offended by it. But like
- 6:54if you looked at it on the reverse side and we said, well,
- 6:57treat your child like a dog, they would be just as offended by that.
- 7:00Right. So if you really break it down in that type of a
- 7:02manner, it's like they're two different species that have different needs, right,
- 7:05and we just have to be mindful of that. And as long as we're
- 7:08mindful of that, you could do all the things you want to do.
- 7:11Like I can cuddle on the couch with my dogs, and they sleep in
- 7:13bed with me, and I baby talk them. We do all that kind
- 7:15of stuff like you would to a child. Right, But because I understand
- 7:19how dogs kind of think, right, and how they process the information I'm
- 7:24giving them, I could make sure that none of it creates any big roadblocks
- 7:27later on. That's a great point. Now, I know. I've been
- 7:30fostering dogs for a few years now, and I try to train a little
- 7:34bit, helped out the people who buy there or adopt them later on.
- 7:40And it's interesting because they're so similar to children. Yeah, but it's kind
- 7:45of like a seven year old or six year old. They know enough,
- 7:48they don't know a lot, and their emotions are still kind of there.
- 7:51They're kind of nut And it's interesting to see that comparison because we operate the
- 7:56same way where they're children, with the type of what do they call the
- 8:00behavioral conditioning components positive reinforcement and negative re enforcement. I'm taking the video game
- 8:03away from you. We're gonna give you a treat tonight. Things of that
- 8:07nature. It's just funny how similar they are. Yeah, learning theory,
- 8:11right, is the same across most species. Right. The difference is just
- 8:16like their biological needs they have past how they learn things. I think that's
- 8:18where things really get lost with people sometimes. That's a great point. And
- 8:24I guess we'll stay on the same thing for a second. As I had
- 8:26this question, and I want to see what your take is it. I
- 8:28know that where your take is. I know there's debate about it. And
- 8:33again not to get political, because I was been reading some books an avid
- 8:37reader, and I can see the nuance that they're using little tints of little
- 8:45jabs that they were throwing at the balance training world and they're attacking the concept
- 8:50of dominance, which I get. I understand what they're going after there.
- 8:56But I guess my question to you is is it important to understand that the
- 9:00dog comes from a wolf? We know one group says, hey, you
- 9:05gotta know this is a wolf, and the other group says, this is
- 9:07a long time ago, this is not a wolf anymore, and they kind
- 9:09of go back and forth with this argument. What's your take on that.
- 9:13I think that's a really interesting way to phrase the question, right. I
- 9:18think it's important to understand like where we came from, right, But it's
- 9:22no different than if you believe in, like, you know, evolution.
- 9:24It's like, is it important for us to look at, you know,
- 9:28what chimpanzees are doing in order for us to live a really good life?
- 9:31Like I would argue, probably not right, because we have different needs at
- 9:35this point. We live in a vastly different world, right, And you
- 9:39know, in the end of the day, I think that when you get
- 9:41into dog behavior, what really controls behavior, past genetics and all of that
- 9:45kind of stuff, is environment, right, And you know, wolves are
- 9:48living in a different environment than you know, your modern pet dog is at
- 9:52this point, and that just dramatically changes the entire game than at that point.
- 9:56So so you know, I think it's it's it's interesting to look back
- 10:00on and look at some of the studies that you know, we're referenced about
- 10:03studying wolves and stuff like that, But past that, I don't think it's
- 10:07ridiculously important to hold it to such a merit that you let it dictate everything
- 10:11that you're doing. And I think it made an interesting point about we were
- 10:15at one point and we've all did another point against if you're into evolution,
- 10:18And it was interesting because it makes me think immediately about carnivore diets. So
- 10:22this isn't against the knock against it or not, but they kind of,
- 10:26you know, obviously advocate for going back in time thousands of years ago.
- 10:31Yeah, right, we ate. It's kind of like, okay, because
- 10:31I'm also seeing it now in the dog world, and for me, it's
- 10:35hard sometimes to separate what's a marketing genius ad compared to what's really true.
- 10:41And the more I study dogs, the more I realized it really isn't a
- 10:46whole lot of studies done on dogs. It was weird. The one book
- 10:50I was reading, I won't mention the guy's name. It was funny because
- 10:52he kept using dolphins and gray foxes and everything. I was but a dog
- 10:58because he didn't have any dogs, that is to quote. So it's kind
- 11:01of, yeah, weird. And you know, when you get into you
- 11:05know, you were talking briefly about the ideological differences of you know, force
- 11:09free trainers and balance trainers are kind of the two ends of the spectrum,
- 11:13basically meaning, you know, a force free trainer is going to rely exclusively
- 11:18on the use of positive reinforcement and negative punishment, which is basically just removing
- 11:22you know, some sort of reward in order to try to increase unwanted behavior
- 11:26with a fair shriff like management and kind of you know, working the dog
- 11:28under threshold and all those types of things which we could dive into later.
- 11:31And then the balance side of the community, which is they're going to use
- 11:35those quadrants as well, but in addition to that, they're going to use
- 11:37some sort of physical aversive in order to stop unwanted behaviors, right, whether
- 11:43that's correcting a dog for jumping up on the couch, or you know,
- 11:46negative reinforcement of removing some sort of pressure in the form of maybe a leash
- 11:50or a collar or something like that in order to teach a dog how to
- 11:52get onto a dog bed, or any number of different things. Right.
- 11:56And you know, I think the important thing that a lot of people in
- 12:01that conversation really fail to recognize is getting back to the humanizing of things.
- 12:07A lot of people would say, like, well, would you do that
- 12:07with your child? Or there's there's better ways in order to decrease unwanted behaviors
- 12:13or teach certain things, But we forget that. Dogs, though we say
- 12:16they're extremely smart, and they are very smart in their own capacity, they
- 12:20don't have the learning ability to comprehend the things that we're speaking to a human
- 12:24child. Right. I can't reason with them, right, I can't explain
- 12:28if I'm going to put them in a time out somewhere, exactly what that
- 12:31time out is for. Right. I can't talk to them and say,
- 12:33well, you know, three days from now, we're not going to go
- 12:35for that walk that I was going to take you on because of your behavior
- 12:39in this type of way, you know what I mean. So because of
- 12:41that, we have to we have to simplify things and get a little bit
- 12:46closer to the bare bones of creating boundaries and creating consequences for behavior in real
- 12:50time in ways that they're actually going to understand, no different than nature would
- 12:54provide. But in addition to that, balancing out, utilizing all of those
- 12:58good method of positive reinforcement and and you know, increasing and want to behavior
- 13:03and stuff like that, that the force free community is preaching in order to
- 13:05teach things where we can as well. So, you know, I think
- 13:07the problem lies anytime there's extremes with things, you know, like you can
- 13:11get people that lean so far into one direction of the balance training where they
- 13:15say, oh, we don't need positive reinforcement, we don't use it,
- 13:16why would you want to carry treats around with you all the time? Etcetera,
- 13:20etcetera, etcetera. And you can get the opposite extreme, which is
- 13:22you can't even say no to your dog basically. And I always equate it
- 13:26to like, you know, there's so many similarities in the in the dog
- 13:28training world to like US politics. And I think if you look at the
- 13:31vast majority of the world right that looks at whether it's dog training or like
- 13:37say, US politics or something like that, most people sit somewhere in the
- 13:41middle with it right where they agree with some of this side, they agree
- 13:43with some of this side, and they're able to kind of come up with
- 13:46their own conclusions and find something that's going to fit their life the best one
- 13:52that's interesting, I'm hoping. I'm hoping, yeah, and then the ex
- 13:56generations will start realizing with this this tribalism mentality. This bifurcating people into two
- 14:05groups, and that's it. If you believe one thing, you believe all
- 14:07the rest of it too. Hopefully that'll end. And I think it's starting
- 14:11to see some of the younger teenagers starting to what the heck's going on with
- 14:15this generation kind of mentality which every generation does, right, nobody wants to
- 14:18be like mom and dad where they're the teenagers or the early twenties and I
- 14:22don't want to listen to mom and dad's music. That's old stuff. And
- 14:24then they get to thirty five, and what do they start listening to mom
- 14:28and Dad's music all of a sudden, Oh, I remember this. Yeah,
- 14:31I'm hoping the next generation changed that mentality. Yeah. I was sad
- 14:33when I saw that. I was sad when I saw that in the dog
- 14:37training world, because I was like, Wow, this seems to be one
- 14:39of these pure disciplines, and yet here we are and it's interesting, you
- 14:43know, like I'll you know, we have you know, different dog trainers
- 14:46and stuff that come on the podcast that I'll talk to, and obviously within
- 14:48my circle, like I you know, talk to my friends and colleagues and
- 14:52stuff that are involved in the industry, and you know, I think as
- 14:56a reasonable individual, we could look at the best of both worlds and we
- 15:00could try to pull from both sides right and not get ourselves too too polarized
- 15:05with things. And that's really where I think, like, you know,
- 15:07per progressiveness kind of comes from, the end of the day, is I
- 15:11could look at like this extreme over here, or you know, getting into
- 15:15two books and resources out there, like you know, some of the best
- 15:18force free books, like there's one by Karen pryor Don't Shoot the Dog,
- 15:20which has been around for freaking ever, right, and there definitely is a
- 15:26lot in that book that is simply kind of defending against the other side,
- 15:30but there's also some bits of knowledge in there in ways that the force free
- 15:33community has of understanding kind of the canine body language and behavior and trying to
- 15:39get a little bit deeper into like why is the dog rehearsing some of the
- 15:41behaviors they're rehearsing, So you know, we could actually prevent thee what they
- 15:46refer to as like the underlying cause of like I might not need to punish
- 15:50this behavior away if I could just get the dog to feel differently about this
- 15:52trigger, you know, what I mean, and taking some of that and
- 15:56applying it to your dog training program is extremely import on top of saying okay,
- 16:02cool, Well, there are just some things where it doesn't matter what
- 16:04the underlying causes, Like if my dog is stealing food off of the counter,
- 16:07the underlying cause of them stealing food off the counter is that they're motivated
- 16:11by the food that they're getting off of it. Right, So I could
- 16:14poppy prove my house all day long, but in the end of the day,
- 16:15if I'm in the middle of Thanksgiving dinner, right and I need to
- 16:19step out of the room for two seconds, I shouldn't need to put everything
- 16:22away out of reach in order for my dog to just understand. There's still
- 16:26some boundaries for things, you know. So I think we could find some
- 16:29sort of happy middle ground with all of this, where it's like we focus
- 16:32on those important things with more serious issues like aggression, Like I want my
- 16:34dog to feel more comfortable around people. I don't want my dogs to be
- 16:37perpetually stressed out when I leave the house. But they still have to understand
- 16:41that there are rules and if they're going to fit in this society that we've
- 16:45created for them, particularly as it evolves into a place where we take them
- 16:48more and more places that are like unnatural for dogs to begin with. I
- 16:52think that we're we're gonna have a really, really great live with our dogs
- 16:56if we could do that. Man, we hit our current's nest there by
- 17:00the way, Folks, again, we're talking to David Turpack. He's the
- 17:02owner and founder of Miracle Kanai and Training. You can find i'm a Miracle
- 17:04cana and Training dot com. You can also check them out on Instagram,
- 17:07Miracle Canain and Training, and check out his podcast, David the Dog Trainer
- 17:11Podcast. I highly recommend. It's on YouTube, Spotify and the rest of
- 17:14the platforms. It's just too many. They even say, David, you
- 17:18need I don't even know where to start now. There's so much. But
- 17:22one thing I learned. I always try to teach my students critical thinking.
- 17:26You mentioned the word reasoning a few times, and so when I look at
- 17:29things we have them studied, look at articles and try to look at a
- 17:30news article. He's been on news articles. You know, they just want
- 17:33the clicks. I get it, there's a business. They want to do
- 17:36what they're gonna do. But I started noticing you can tell me if this
- 17:40is a fair assessment I'm looking at. I'm reading a lot of these books.
- 17:41When I was first beginning to foster dogs and work with them, I
- 17:45started realizing, this is really just a bunch of tools. They're not really
- 17:48once better than another. Certain dogs responded really well to certain types of corrections.
- 17:53Other dogs were finding great to food. Other dogs didn't really give a
- 17:56rat's we're about food. And I just realized they seemed like a lot of
- 18:00tools and you have to kind of adjust in my wrath, no, you're
- 18:04you're actually a hundred percent correct And that led me to I feel like I
- 18:07kind of sidestepped your entire last question you had for me, which was,
- 18:11you know, in a lot of the studies you've experienced or seen, right,
- 18:15a lot of them are like dolphins or wolves or mice or different types
- 18:19of animals, and the commonality between it is virtually all of them are in
- 18:22captivity right to some extent. Right, So you know the problem is if
- 18:29we were to try to look at things of well, there's this one way
- 18:32that we have to be able to train dogs, right, or this is
- 18:34the most efficient way to train dogs or the least stressful way to train dogs.
- 18:38We would have to know that we could control every single aspect of the
- 18:42dogs environment. I mentioned earlier that environment tends to create a lot of the
- 18:45problems, right, And you could look at you know, a lot of
- 18:48people will say things like, while killer whales and dolphins and all those types
- 18:52of animals that they used to train in captivity, while they could get them
- 18:56to do all of those things predominantly with positive reinforcement, obviously they're not put
- 18:59least and collars on dolphins right in order to give corrections and things like that,
- 19:03And frankly, you know, with an animal that big, it's not
- 19:04going to be very effective anyways. The problem is dogs live in a ever
- 19:11changing world. Right the second we step out our front door, we lose
- 19:15control of ninety nine percent of the things that the dog is going to experience,
- 19:18right, And we could try to do our best to stay a couple
- 19:19of steps ahead of the dog and think, you know, two steps ahead
- 19:23of what's going on on on the walk, and predict triggers and all of
- 19:27that kind of stuff. But in the end of the day, I look
- 19:30at dog training as kind of an art, right, So you have all
- 19:36of these different tools, like you were saying, right, we have the
- 19:37ability to use different leashes and collars and different quadrants of learning and different rewards
- 19:42and play and food and you know, all of those types of things.
- 19:47But in the end of the day, somebody's needs that lives in downtown Manhattan
- 19:52with their dog are going to be very different than somebody's needs that live on
- 19:56one hundred and twenty seven acres in the middle of Montana. And the training
- 20:00approach that's going to be the most conducive to getting past certain problems, and
- 20:03the time constraints that we're going to have are going to predicate which ones of
- 20:07those methods and tools that I'm ultimately going to wind up using. Right,
- 20:11So, yes, they are all ultimately tools. And I think as long
- 20:15as you're a new trainer, you're studying the tools that are at your disposal,
- 20:19and you're studying the why behind why certain trainers might be putting those tools
- 20:23in certain parts of their program. You'll be able to pull from different ones
- 20:26based on all of the variables of the owner's life and the dog's life to
- 20:33be able to find kind of the best combination of them. Folks, if
- 20:36you want to take a deeper dive, into this, or if you're more
- 20:38familiar with the dog training world, you can check out the Day of the
- 20:41Dog Training podcast episode where he talks about Gary Wilkes and Karen pryor as you
- 20:45can see it here, the distinction where Gary's kind of combining more stuff where
- 20:49Karen kind of went to, hey, this is the only way to do
- 20:52it. The clicker. They can do amazing things. We can even click
- 20:53the bear to go down. So it's kind of interesting to see that.
- 20:57So check that out, folks. It's a really good podcast. That's kind
- 21:02of what got me thinking about it too. When I was listening to your
- 21:03podcast, It's like, yeah, I remember this because I remember the clicker.
- 21:06Don't use the clicker, use this, don't use food. It's like,
- 21:08whoa, this is crazy. So I think I was reading the Keeler
- 21:11Method. Yeah. I think I was like, wow, this is a
- 21:15different type of method. Yeah, which is like I believe, like from
- 21:18the forties, I believe was the Keeler method sometime something like that. Yeah,
- 21:22because he was the guy who was training I think Disney's dogs or something.
- 21:26Yeah. Yeah, And the Keeler method is something that's you know,
- 21:27looked at now as you know, a little bit taboo because it was getting
- 21:32back to extremes of the spectrum, Like there was very very minimal positive reinforcement
- 21:37involved in that. It was basically forced compliance of the dogs and you know,
- 21:41consequences for unwanted behaviors and basically you just gotta do it right. And
- 21:48the one thing that I think Keeler did a good job with though past that
- 21:52is he was one of the first people to really systematize dog training for people,
- 21:56right, so he created obviously the Keeler Method of Dog Training KMDOT or
- 22:00whatever it was, and that really helped your average owner be able to take
- 22:04this book and look at, oh, here's a step by step approach I
- 22:07could do to get my dog well behaved, and frankly, it did if
- 22:11you followed it properly, get you very good results in the end of the
- 22:15spectrum. But as you know, history moves along and we get more and
- 22:19more methods at our disposal, and the movement of positive training and clicker training
- 22:23and all of that stuff kind of came about. You realized, okay,
- 22:26we could still leverage some of this kind of stuff, but we could also
- 22:29get the dog to enjoy the process, right, We could also get them
- 22:33to want to do this training. And in the end of the day,
- 22:34if you want to do something, you're ultimately going to be more motivated to
- 22:38do it, you know what I mean. You're gonna do it with more
- 22:41enthusiasm, gonna do it with more speed. Look at in your day to
- 22:44day life things you want to do versus things you have to do, and
- 22:47look at your state of mind when you're approached with those situations. So it
- 22:51is important to leverage, you know, both sides of the spectrum. And
- 22:53obviously positive reinforcement has its place, and that kind of stuff has its place
- 22:56based on the variables of where these animals are in the needs of the owner
- 23:00and the dog. I love that. I love that, Yeah, it's
- 23:03I think the best thing I liked from them was the standing. I thought
- 23:07that was a neat little tech tricks. I've never thought about just having them
- 23:10stand and working at them and people can pet them, and I thought that's
- 23:12pretty Yeah. It also led me to another group, I guess, since
- 23:17I'm heading down the world of nostalogy here, the new the Monks of a
- 23:21New sket They were interesting too because they didn't use treats very much. It
- 23:25seemed to be a lot of who the high pitched voys, the praise kind
- 23:29of thing, and really working with a lot of these dogs, and they
- 23:32did a great job. Again, obviously, now that I'm probably a little
- 23:36bit of an attack, I'm not sure if the argus with the different ideologies
- 23:41if they're being attacked, because they're not. They're definitely using corrections. But
- 23:45either way, what do you think about the monks of New Ski because they
- 23:47kind of have an interesting style. So I'm actually using I believe it's the
- 23:52art of raising your puppy or raising the perfect puppy as a laptop stand right
- 23:56now, so I've gotta stack a book. I'm gonna stack a books right
- 24:00here. It's actually in it. I'm a big fan. Again, Like
- 24:02I could look at a lot of these types of people or types of trainers,
- 24:06and I could respect what they've brought to the industry in their given time.
- 24:10Right again, Keeler method of dog training. Right now, if you're
- 24:11exclusively following the Keuler method of dog training as the holy grail of training,
- 24:18you're a little bit outdated at this point. Right But at the time,
- 24:22like I said, what he was able to provide for the general public of
- 24:25systematizing training in a way that's really digestible for your average owner was extremely important,
- 24:30and to this day people use methods from that and the systems in order
- 24:34to train dogs in their own kind of way. Right, the Monks of
- 24:37New Ski it was very, very very similar. Right. They were able
- 24:41to break things down in a little bit more holistic of a wave of an
- 24:45approach. Right. I think that their training style actually is very similar to
- 24:49the Kueler method of dog training, and I think, if I'm not mistaken,
- 24:52most of them learned through that and they still kind of implement that to
- 24:56some extent. But they had this really unique approach of understanding that dogs are
- 25:00dogs still, right, and there's certain there's certain things that they're gonna do,
- 25:06and they're gonna act in a particular way just because they're animals, and
- 25:10sometimes it's okay to not have this like militant Robot Dog twenty four seven and
- 25:15allow them to kind of satisfy on some of those biological urges that they have.
- 25:21And I think that the monks did a really really phenomenal job of that,
- 25:25and they, I think, to their credit, have done a very
- 25:26good job of kind of evolving with the times, like they're still regularly putting
- 25:30out books. Mark Goldberg, he's not a part of the Monks, a
- 25:33new skeet, but he's very very close friends with them, I know,
- 25:37and they write a lot of books together. I think they literally just came
- 25:38out with one in the last couple of weeks, if I'm not mistaken,
- 25:41or last the last month or so, of how to Play with Your Dog
- 25:47or something like that. And you know, again they're still following a lot
- 25:51of the same methods. They have a really really concrete system. They now
- 25:53have moved pretty exclusively to being like the e collar people, right, so
- 25:59they have to kind of gentle art of training your dog with the collar.
- 26:03I think it's one of their books that they recently came out with, and
- 26:07they've been able to market themselves as you know, kind of the holistic,
- 26:11nice e collar trainers that are still getting good, good results, you know.
- 26:15But I think really where they shine is helping people understand their dog as
- 26:19a dog, right and not as a human. Yeah, I think you're
- 26:25absolutely right, because I can definitely see that. I mean, I can
- 26:27see watching some of their old videos the you're learning how to be a human
- 26:33yourself when are watching the video, how to be mindful of your own emotions,
- 26:40be mindful of their emotions, how they're responding, And it's like,
- 26:42wow, this is kind of like it's almost therapeutic in this video. You
- 26:48know, people like the Monks, people like you know, Caesar is a
- 26:51really big name in dog training that again like points of contention that that get
- 26:55flak over certain nuanced details because they've been in the public for so long,
- 26:59But you know, he really teaches. I think his whole new show is
- 27:02called like Better Human, Better Dog, right, and it rings so true.
- 27:06Like just using myself as a personal example, like when I got my
- 27:07first Malonwaw Vinny, like he is a unbelievably high drive, neurotic dog,
- 27:14right, And to anybody that doesn't know anything about malon Waw, they're they're
- 27:17they're nuts, right, They're not for your average dog owner. And I
- 27:21have never been like a patient person. I would say, like, it's
- 27:23just not me at my core, right, And when I first got him,
- 27:27because I wanted like immediate compliance, and I wanted like immediate just when
- 27:33I got out of all of my other dogs that I had up into that
- 27:34point, and I wasn't getting it. We would just butt heads, Like
- 27:37for the entire first year that I owned him, butting heads constantly every training
- 27:41session we had, myself, him, somebody was leaving frustrated, somebody was
- 27:45leaving unhappy with things. And you know, I just like unintentionally realized,
- 27:52like if I want him to get better with some of this stuff, like
- 27:55I need to become better, right. And as I got more patient with
- 27:57him in his core and just accepted some of his dogness that he has,
- 28:03if you will, what wound up happening is almost like placebo effect, where
- 28:07it seemed like he was getting better from that, and he was becoming less
- 28:10anxious and less neurotic, and our relationship just got like a hundred times better.
- 28:14But I had to look internally at myself first in order to get there,
- 28:18you know what I mean, Like he wasn't going to change for me.
- 28:19I kind of needed to change to meet his needs, which ultimately made
- 28:23my life better with him. Watch out, Watch out. Now they're gonna
- 28:27say you were a follower, he fell prey to the alpha leader. Yeah,
- 28:33that's interesting. I think you're right. I think Caesar Milan reminds me
- 28:36a lot of what hok Hogan was through the world of WWF. If you're
- 28:40a WWF fan, sure he was. He was the first one that really
- 28:42set set the thing on fire. And Caesar Milan, I think, really
- 28:47took the dog industry blew a whole new level. Man. H up.
- 28:51Yeah, nobody, nobody even knew what a dog trainer was prior to that,
- 28:53you know, I mean, and that just like it made the idea
- 28:56of dog training and being a good eater for your dog, and like all
- 29:00of those types of concepts, it made them so normalized, you know,
- 29:03And to this day people come in they're like, oh, yeah, the
- 29:06dog whisperer guy, or I watch his shows or this or that, and
- 29:10again looking at like there's there's certain things we could look at. It's like,
- 29:11all right, well, yeah, I mean whatever, this isn't great.
- 29:14I don't really like this. But I could do that with anybody,
- 29:17you know what I mean. Like, if you put any trainer in front
- 29:18of me, and you put four dog trainers in a room and said,
- 29:22hey, watch seven hours of this person's training or content, you're gonna be
- 29:26able to find a bunch of things that you don't like. Right. But
- 29:29what he brought to the table. That was invaluable was getting people to realize
- 29:33that in a lot of cases, they're the problem, you know. And
- 29:37he did it in such a way that wasn't like shaming or blaming or anything
- 29:41like that. He's just just making you self aware of like, hey,
- 29:45these issues you're having, Look at how you're the one that's ultimately allowing it.
- 29:49Look at how if you just make some adjustments here, here, and
- 29:52here, you could have such a better life with your dog. And he
- 29:56just did such a great job with that. I think I agree. Yeah,
- 29:59I think he's gotta he's got a really good heart, it looks like
- 30:02and he really cares about people and dogs, and he did he changed it.
- 30:06I guess the first time everybody thought he was like a David Copperfield kind
- 30:08of guy. Yeah, I guess he's start doing what is this and now
- 30:11look at an Instagram It's like, Okay, we'll see it a lot.
- 30:15And it's interesting because it reminds me. I don't know if thesther did this
- 30:18or not, doesn't matter. And he contributed a lot of good things.
- 30:21I think it's a great show for kids. It teaches them how to act
- 30:22around dogs and you learn my daughter's nine to thirteen. They I both have
- 30:29them watched it. They love the show because they can resonate. It's got
- 30:30dogs, because love dogs. And now he's going to start teaching you how
- 30:34to act around him, and that's kind of fun. But the interesting thing
- 30:40is you did an interview. You did it not an interview, but an
- 30:42analysis, a breakdown of a particular dog trainer. Again, i'll even name
- 30:45less. I'm sure you'll figure it out once I get more detailed, but
- 30:48you can catch us on David the Dog Trainer podcast too. You did want
- 30:53when you broke it down. He was training this really aggressive dog. I
- 30:57think he had a muzzle on him, and you didn't really agree with a
- 31:03lot. Initially you were thinking, why is this person doing this? He
- 31:07keeps saying he's going to do something, but he's not really doing anything.
- 31:11And he kept the owner really close. He tried to get the owner to
- 31:14help out in a moment that they shouldn't have helped out with the leash,
- 31:18and then at the very end he said no, what ended up happening.
- 31:21It was really the trainer acted as if taking the treat was actually success from
- 31:27this dog, or if I remember correctly, it might be a little off,
- 31:30sure, but it wasn't. I remember you said before that it looked
- 31:37like he was he acted like he was interacting with him better. Now you
- 31:41mentioned to think in the interview, you said he had a hard time,
- 31:45he was really a tough, aggressive dog, and then he fed him and
- 31:47acted like he was now interacting. And you were expanding on this a little
- 31:51bit before the show. Yeah, So so in a nutshell, if if
- 31:55I recall correctly, what was going on was you know, there was this
- 31:57dog I was here for. You know, call it aggression, call it
- 32:00just really really pushy dominance behavior it, call it whatever you want to call
- 32:05it. But he tried to get the dog from the woman. The dog
- 32:08obviously was giving him quite a bit of attitude over it. He was giving
- 32:12the woman some attitude over it, And initially it seemed as if his goal
- 32:16through the training session was to get this dog okay with him interacting with him.
- 32:22Right, And in a lot of cases, when you're working with dogs
- 32:24like that that aren't necessarily acting aggressively in like a fearful way. They're doing
- 32:29it in more of like a controlling kind of way. It doesn't necessarily mean
- 32:34they're scared. In most of those cases, if you give them something that
- 32:36they want, you know they're going to take it from you. And throughout
- 32:39the course of that training session, I believe he tried to touch the dog
- 32:43a couple of times. The dog would growl at him. Touch the dog
- 32:45gog growled at him, and he kind of started avoiding that and shifted his
- 32:49expectation to giving the dog some treats, which the dog willingly took the treats.
- 32:52And my issue with it was just that it was framed in a way
- 32:55where it's like, Okay, look, we got all this progress with this
- 32:58dog because the dog's taking treats, when in actuality, the dog very well
- 33:00may have taken treats from the rip out of the session. But we'll have
- 33:05plenty of dogs that you could do food training with them for a week,
- 33:07but then the second you go to actually interact with them, they're still going
- 33:09to revert back to those aggressive ways. We had a dog in recently very
- 33:12similar to that, actually maybe six to eight months ago. I would say
- 33:16his name was four. He was a pit bull. You could actually see
- 33:19him on our Instagram page. He's one of the pinned videos at the top
- 33:22because I think it wound a blown up on TikTok at like ten million views
- 33:24or something like that. And basically the dog was acting aggressively every time I
- 33:28would touch him. Every time I would touch him. The story of that
- 33:30dog was very interesting in the story of how we work with that dog.
- 33:35Initially, he came in for a boarding train We worked with them for the
- 33:37first week that he was there, and we did predominantly food training. We
- 33:42kind of took the route of, all right, well, he seems nervous,
- 33:45let's kind of build a little bit of a relationship with him. Then
- 33:47we'll kind of move back into pushing these boundaries a little bit more. We
- 33:51did an entire week of just food training, so no prong collar, no
- 33:54E collar, nothing like that, just relationship building, playing with him,
- 33:58food training, stuff like that. And week number two we're like, all
- 34:01right, let's go ahead and put a training collar on him, and we're
- 34:04gonna start moving things along. Let's go put the training collar on him.
- 34:07He bit the trainer. Actually, you actually had to go home for a
- 34:10week because I was I was actually out of town at the time. And
- 34:14you know, it's interesting because listen, we could look at you know,
- 34:16there's there was probably a handful of mistakes made along the way as far as
- 34:20how we were going to collar him and things like that that ultimately led to
- 34:22that. But it goes to show that using the example you were referring to,
- 34:29we could do all this relationship building all day long, but in the
- 34:32end of the day, whenever we hit that point where the dog has a
- 34:36boundary and they want to set that boundary, still, no matter how much
- 34:39they might like us, no matter how much they might like the thing it
- 34:43is that we're providing for them, they're still going to revert back to setting
- 34:45that boundary with us if we don't have them in the right state of mind
- 34:49at that time. And I think that's really where I had the issue with
- 34:51that video was the dog taking treats was not a win there. Like that
- 34:54dog did not have respect for handler. That dog had no interest in comple
- 35:00lying in any way, shape or form. It was basically doing whatever it
- 35:02wanted to do to get what it wanted right, And that's really the root
- 35:06of the problem with dogs like that. That's a great fun It reminded me
- 35:09so much. It was a great Pyrenees were fostering at one point model dog
- 35:14inside the house. I mean, it could have been a show dog.
- 35:16And the minute we walked outside, I act like I never met me.
- 35:20Yeah, it's wrong with this guy. And we kept walking around, but
- 35:23like you mentioned, I would give him a treat. Oh oh, well,
- 35:27I'm right here for your pal. And then the minute the treat was
- 35:29gone, he was gone, like what's the matter with you? And it's
- 35:32interesting because they, yeah, sometimes the minds of their own and it kind
- 35:37of reminds me of something. See what your take on this is, because
- 35:39I haven't seen many lately. I've seen them in the past, and I
- 35:44don't see many saying this anymore. But I think a lot of owners and
- 35:47we can get into that to the psychology of people who want to get a
- 35:51dog or who get a dog, because I think their gender difference is in
- 35:53how they view dog ownership. But some people think you can control them one
- 36:00hundred percent of the time. When I say move, this dog moved.
- 36:05When I say sit, this dog sits. Doesn't matter what distractions are out
- 36:07there, nothing this dog listens to one hundred percent of the time. And
- 36:12I don't know is that really something you can count on with an animal like
- 36:15that? That you can say, yeah, even if there's a rabbit running
- 36:19by and treats are tied to its back, that dog's not gonna move every
- 36:23single time. I don't know is that possible. That's a great question that
- 36:30really comes down to the handler, I believe, right. I don't think
- 36:34there is a degree of training you're gonna put on a dog that they hit
- 36:37a point where they never ever make a mistake ever again, right, I
- 36:40don't think that's I don't think that's real life. Right. But if your
- 36:45skills as a handler are at a point where you could always be a couple
- 36:50steps ahead of the dog, you have contingency plans in place where if the
- 36:53dog makes acts mistake, I do this. If the dog makes why mistake,
- 36:57I do this, et cetera, et cetera. I do believe that
- 37:00under ninety nine point nine nine percent of distractions, you could make sure the
- 37:05dog is under control. Like I You know again, I four dogs,
- 37:08all of which have had various degrees of prey drive and intensity and stuff like
- 37:13that. And when I used to live on the east side of Cleveland,
- 37:16before I moved to where I'm at now, there used to be a ton
- 37:19of deer in squirrels and rabbits and stuff like that in the neighborhood, and
- 37:23you know, they were all very prey driven, and initially that was a
- 37:25tough distraction for them, but we tackled it head on and we got them
- 37:29to a place where some of my more popular videos from four or five years
- 37:32ago were my dogs all just holding a down stay while a family a deer
- 37:36walks, you know, twenty feet away from them or things like that.
- 37:38Right. So, yeah, I think it's definitely possible to gain that level
- 37:43of training. But that gets to the deeper point of training is not this
- 37:47thing you put on a dog and they're just trained, right. Training is
- 37:50a language and a communication system, right, and both parties need to understand
- 37:57that language extremely flu at the same degree if you want to get the highest
- 38:01levels of training. Right. I think that's gonna be a good segue into
- 38:06the discussion. I wanted to do dog walking because I think it's going to
- 38:08be more intense than people think. It's not simply I am about dog walking.
- 38:12I'll make that point in a minute when I ask David and the next
- 38:15question, by the way, again talking to David the dog trainer and check
- 38:16him out his David the Dog Trainer podcast. Check out Miracle Canine Training on
- 38:21Instagram and Miracle Canine Training dot com. So, David, you mean you
- 38:27put highlighted two points. It stood out to me one of them is you
- 38:30have a contingency plan. You're thinking two steps ahead. Two You have to
- 38:35have a good dog handler. This makes me think those numbers of ninety nine
- 38:37point ninety nine percent has to drop quite a bit when you have a regular
- 38:42dog owner who thinks, David took my dog for four weeks, this dog
- 38:46should even budge. If there's fool food falling from the sky, this dog
- 38:51shouldn't move. But I'm looking at that going your odds really went down.
- 38:55Now you have the average dog trainer who's on their cell phone not paying attention
- 39:00to dogs coming around the corner to whatever it is happening. Am I far
- 39:05off on that? No? No, you're You're spot on right. So
- 39:08there's two variables, right. Variable number one is the dog and the owner.
- 39:14Right. So you have certain dogs that are on a sliding scale of
- 39:17more or less challenging, right, And if you get a really easy dog
- 39:22or dogs maybe somewhere in the middle of that scale, your skills as an
- 39:25owner don't need to be quite as high. Right, You could get that
- 39:30same level of success and stability and control without as much work from you.
- 39:35But as you get into the more extreme cases and the more difficult dogs,
- 39:38you know, if you want to be successful with that dog without the need
- 39:42of tons and tons of like avoidance and management of certain behavioral issues, your
- 39:45skills as an owner and as a trainer or a handler need to be significantly
- 39:51higher. Right. So that's one big variable in it. The other one
- 39:53is you have two mindsets you could have with your dog. Right. One
- 39:59is when you know, we commonly see post boarding trainer, I would say
- 40:02before, we used to kind of market ourselves in a way that makes sure
- 40:06this doesn't get in people's head where some people think, you know the dog
- 40:08did the training that you're just saying, my dog just stayed for four weeks.
- 40:12Things are great, Right, I come home. My dog will never
- 40:15make a mistake again. You know, the dog's doing so good, it's
- 40:19never going to rehearse this, this or this right, And that is the
- 40:22most dangerous state of mind you can get into with your dog. Because myself,
- 40:24even with my personal dogs, I get into what I refer to the
- 40:28second state of mind of which is cautiously optimistic. Right, So, anytime
- 40:36I do anything with my dogs, aside from just hanging out in the house,
- 40:39I go into those situations with the mindset of cautiously optimistic. And what
- 40:44that means, or what I mean by that, is that I'm optimistic that
- 40:49under any distractions or issues that might present themselves, I'm going to know what
- 40:54to do in order to handle that. But I'm always cautious of the unknown
- 41:00variables that might throw themselves present, like the squirrel popping out of no where,
- 41:02the family, a deer that shows up over there, the child that
- 41:05tries to come running across the park at me, you know, and the
- 41:09various mistakes my dog might make when they're presented with those those those variable distractions,
- 41:15Right. And I think that if we could always go into situations even
- 41:20now, Like I said, my dogs are all like nine, ten eleven,
- 41:22They've been trained for a very very long time. They're very reliable with
- 41:25things. But I'm always always always waiting for the mistake that they make so
- 41:30I could capitalize on it, I could address it, and I could further.
- 41:34They're training along more and more, I think, you know, obviously
- 41:37this one too is I think sometimes dog owners look at it going that's a
- 41:43lot of work, man, I gotta stay on this dog. I just
- 41:45want to walk the dog. Brother. Yeah yeah, But you have to
- 41:49be situationally aware, situationally aware and listen. It's no different than like,
- 41:52you know, when you go driving right, they call it defensive driving.
- 41:57Right. You go defensively driving. You're aware of what's going on around,
- 42:00but you're not in a panic every time you're driving right. Like, frankly,
- 42:02half of these people that are driving are distracted anyways. They're they're eating,
- 42:07they're talking on their phone, they're doing something like that right, and
- 42:09they're able to you know, hopefully fingers crossed right, I stay aware enough
- 42:13of their surroundings to make sure nothing bad happens. It's the same deal.
- 42:15Like, it's not like I never check my phone when I'm on a walk
- 42:17with my dogs. Like my wife and I go for walks through the neighborhood
- 42:21with the dogs and we're chit chatting with each other, we're showing each other
- 42:23things on our phone. Our dogs are walking nicely with us. But because
- 42:27things are so patterned in at this point, the probability that something happens is
- 42:30so much lower because we've been so consistent with them up until this point.
- 42:35And like I said, I'm still being mindful of what's happening around me,
- 42:38and it doesn't cause tons of stress. It's not like overly difficult for me
- 42:43to do or anything. But that's because I put in the groundwork early on,
- 42:45and I was taught everybody, if you could just be really, really
- 42:49aware of that kind of stuff for your first couple of months, you could
- 42:52then kind of take off of the gas a little bit and find like that
- 42:55happy medium where you could enjoy yourself but still be cautious optimistic of the things
- 43:00going on around you. That's a beautiful analogy. I like that a lot.
- 43:05And now we go back a little bit to the psychology of the owner,
- 43:07and we'll get the dog walking in a second, too, is part
- 43:09of it. I have to kind of get this set up here. So
- 43:14what I've noticed that people are gonna wonder how do we get to sex and
- 43:16mixed martial arts in this conversation, But they're there because when I had looked
- 43:20at both of those. For instance, for guys, every time I've talked
- 43:24to any of my instructors, I've interviewed MMA fighters whatever it is, they
- 43:30tell me the same thing a lot of times. I don't know why,
- 43:31but guys think they know how to fight even though they've never fought. And
- 43:36I'm looking at that, going, yeah, that's true. Even I was
- 43:38there before, I didn't mix argial arts. Yeah. And sex, everybody
- 43:43knows how to have sex perfectly, and even I've never had it before,
- 43:45and it's like, Okay, I can see that. And for guys,
- 43:51I almost see it as another one of these cat igories and maybe there's many
- 43:53from that. I don't know, one of these categories of that dog better
- 43:58listen to me, because if not, that makes me look weak as a
- 44:00person. So you see the guys kind of aggressive, and I see when
- 44:05I see a lot of unleashed dogs. And this is a completely anecdotal,
- 44:07folks, this is not studied. It's just from my own personal experiences.
- 44:12A lot of them tend to be males that are walking around, and for
- 44:15some bloody reason, it always seems to be a pit. I don't know
- 44:19why. I saw one the other day. It was one hundred and ten
- 44:21pound pit and he's walking around the corner unleashed, and my dog looks at
- 44:25him and she's like, what the hell is that? And I'm looking at
- 44:29it going my god. So we start backpedaling a little bit real slow to
- 44:32see what the dog was doing and thinking the dog was like eleven years old
- 44:36so it wasn't really moving that fast. But the owner was like, no,
- 44:38we're in sight. Nor than hell. The owner was and I'm looking
- 44:43at this going okay. And women are different. They have a different view
- 44:45and it comes to dogs. They feel like I'm gonna over or love them
- 44:51a lot, a lot of affection if they're scared, which a lot of
- 44:53people underst the mean how scared dogs are a lot of times it's kind of
- 44:58interesting to see that maybe we can tackle later. But they'll kind of always
- 45:00hug them and kiss them and everything, and if they're barking at the fireworks
- 45:06or this, they'll cuddle with them. And they have these two totally different
- 45:09paradigms of how to deal with the dog. I don't know, is there's
- 45:14something there. I'm just losing my mind here. No, that's that.
- 45:17That is an interesting conversation because okay, so there has been some time,
- 45:22you know, in these debates of you know, different methodology and stuff like
- 45:27that. One debate that has been getting fairly loud, right, or certain
- 45:32trainers have been kind of preaching, is this idea that the use of balance
- 45:37training methods and compulsion and things like that is coming from this place of like
- 45:43toxic masculinity, they say, right, And it's this idea that like a
- 45:47trait of toxic masculinity is the need to control at all times, right,
- 45:53which would equate to your examples of mixed marshal, you know, fighting,
- 45:58sex, dog training. Right. Uh, you know you probably can categorize
- 46:01all three of those things within that umbrella, right. I think there's probably
- 46:07a degree of truth to it. You know, I think if we were
- 46:09to look at like biological traits we have as men, right, Yeah,
- 46:15I mean, you know, the strong capable leader, right, it's kind
- 46:21of like what we like to envision ourselves as. So you know, when
- 46:23we're in this position with our dogs where we don't have to were we're at
- 46:28their mercy, that kind of hurts your ego a little bit, you know
- 46:31what I mean. Now, I say, you know, like, I'm
- 46:36sure there's a degree of truth to it, right, But I would also
- 46:39you know, then go the opposite direction and say I've seen many, many,
- 46:43many many women that come in that are in the same exact vote right
- 46:45where they just they want the dog to listen to them, right, They're
- 46:47like, enough of this, right this, this dog needs to listen to
- 46:50me, right. And I've also seen the opposite when it comes to men
- 46:53that come in that are the softest, most permissive, most lovey dovey creatures
- 47:00in the face of the planet to their dog, you know what I mean.
- 47:01So, you know, I think I've probably seen it all ways,
- 47:07and I try to avoid stereotyping it one way or another too too much with
- 47:12it. But but we've yeah, we've definitely seen some of that before.
- 47:15Interesting. I like that. I can definitely see there's got to be a
- 47:17variety in there. Yeah, it's fascinating when you watch again human behavior with
- 47:23dogs. It's an interesting world. When we go to dog walking a couple
- 47:30of things here, there's obviously a lot of well, there's been there's been
- 47:34two, two people that I've listened to three four not maybe four people that
- 47:38kind of debated whether or not sent walking was a good idea. Some I'm
- 47:44saying no, no, no, no, wellhead Niffy walks, Sniffy walks.
- 47:47Yes, no, no, we do that already for fun and the
- 47:51other ones. You can do a little bit of it, but if you
- 47:53want a good walk, you don't let them sniff at all. They can
- 47:55sniff plenty by being one foot above the ground already. They don't need to
- 48:00stick their nose into anything. Other people say, Look, it uses up
- 48:02a lot of gluecoats in the brain. It tires them out. It gets
- 48:05them, you know, to think more, which wears them out. What's
- 48:07your thoughts? No, again, another really great topic. I will be
- 48:13the first to say that when it comes to the actual science behind what they're
- 48:16referencing with the I think the way it was quite I think there's a book
- 48:21recently where they coined like the sniffari right, and basically the idea was like
- 48:24providing long It was a book on providing longevity to your dog or something like
- 48:28that. They were basically saying, like going for sniffing walks or your sniffari
- 48:32having your dog of a natural ability to explore and engage with their environment is
- 48:37really really good biologically for them right now. I don't think any dog trainer
- 48:42on the face of the planet will disagree that harshly with the concept that we
- 48:45want to let our dogs be dogs and let them explore and let them act
- 48:51naturally. Right. I think where it gets a little too extreme is where
- 48:54a lot of people will preach it like you should only take your dogs on
- 48:58these sniffy walks, and the walk is for them and they should be able
- 49:00to do whatever they want to do at all times. Because the way that
- 49:02I look at the walk right like meaning I'm going out and I'm in I
- 49:07don't remember what trainer coined this, but as somebody said, I'm in like
- 49:09migration mode, like we're moving from point A to point B right now.
- 49:14Right. The purpose of that for me is to get physical exercise and mental
- 49:20stimulation, right, And in my opinion, the best way to provide physical
- 49:24exercise and mental stimulation is to walk, but walk while the dog is in
- 49:29some sort of structured command where there's direction they need to follow. Right.
- 49:32Anytime you're you're working really hard on something, whether you're a human, whether
- 49:37you're a dog, it's taken some mental capacity to focus, like me focusing
- 49:40on this conversation in this podcast, like I'm probably gonna turn this podcast off
- 49:44and be like I need five minutes to just like get myself together because I'm
- 49:46a little tired for that. That was a lot of thinking, right and
- 49:50providing that in the form of that walk. I think it's really really,
- 49:52really really good for dogs, and we hear it, you know, anecdotally,
- 49:57but like from all of our clients, I come back and say,
- 49:59you know, I used to walk my dog five miles a day, but
- 50:00now I walk them in a structured heel for fifteen minutes, and they're just
- 50:06as tired, if not more tired than they were for that fifteen or for
- 50:08that five mile walk. Right now, how do we try to balance this
- 50:14because I do think, like I said, allowing your dog to explore and
- 50:17be a dog is one of the best privileges that we can give them.
- 50:21Right. The more we can make things kind of natural right and allow them
- 50:24to make their own decisions and not be kind of micromanaged all the time with
- 50:29stuff, I think, the better relationship you're ultimately going to have with them,
- 50:31because we could find ourselves in a trap where if we're controlling twenty four
- 50:35seven and never allowing them to move freely through the house because they're always in
- 50:37command and out on walks, they're always in a heel position, and we
- 50:40go to the park and they just need to down stay with me, or
- 50:44chase the ball and bring it right back and never be able to go off
- 50:45and do their thing. I think you're going to kind of create a little
- 50:49bit of a bottled up mess of an anxious dog. Right. So what
- 50:52I try to do is I focus first and foremost on the control. I
- 50:54make sure whatever environment it is that I want to be able to give my
- 50:59dog the ability the ability to explore in, whether it's a hiking trail,
- 51:02whether it's a big field, whether it's a dog park where you want to
- 51:06go let them run around. And when I say dog park, I don't
- 51:07mean like your average dog park. I mean like you know, you're meeting
- 51:09up with some friends at the park that have dogs to interact. And again
- 51:13that's a separate conversation. But if I could establish the control and know that
- 51:19with one hundred percent certainty or at least ninety nine point nine percent certainty that
- 51:22in this environment, I can get my dog to reel it in and focus
- 51:24on me very very easily if I need to, then I could feel confident
- 51:29giving them that ability to go off and explore and know that if one of
- 51:32those variables we were talking about earlier presents themselves quickly, I'm not shit out
- 51:37of luck, right, I can get them to focus back in really really
- 51:39quickly and get them back under control, so everybody ultimately stays safe, because
- 51:44if not, if you just jump right into all the freedom of the sniffari
- 51:47walk and letting them off leash at the park and doing all these different types
- 51:51of things, you're always going into it like this, fingers crossed. I
- 51:53hope nothing bad happens, and I hope my dog listens to me later on.
- 51:58That's such a good point. Yeah, it's it's interesting because I know
- 52:01I watch sometimes not necessarily the sniffing component, but I'll see dog owners walking
- 52:07their dog and I'm thinking, man, it's a recipe for disaster. That
- 52:10the person's lollygag and kind of heads in the clouds and the dog's head in
- 52:15one way, heading another and about ten feet in front of them, and
- 52:17it's all over the place, and you know, then they started saying the
- 52:22name like a hundred times. It's like, WHOA, you got problems?
- 52:24So probably yeah, and the dog walks again. One of the well looking
- 52:32to say Caesar on this case. But Caesar was really big on dog walking
- 52:37to develop a relationship with the dog, especially if you first got a dogs,
- 52:40if you adopted a dog, got them from a breed, or whatnot.
- 52:45How important is it to develop the relationship when you first buy the dogs,
- 52:49but also late or do you continue that bond with the dog walking with
- 52:52them? Is it really that strong? Good question? Again, I think
- 53:00if you ask ten different trainers, you'll probably get ten different answers for this,
- 53:04because I think it depends, right, Because again, what's the point
- 53:07of the walk? Right? The point of the walk is to provide physical
- 53:10and mental stimulation. Right now, there are many people that don't have yards.
- 53:15They live in big cities, right, they don't have tons and tons
- 53:20of different ways they could provide physical and mental stimulation, where a walk is
- 53:22going to be a really, really beneficial way of being able to do that,
- 53:25right, And in those types of cases, yes, rigorous daily walking
- 53:30is going to be extremely important to biologically fulfill your dog. Right. I'll
- 53:35be the first to admit that I don't walk my dogs that much. Right,
- 53:37we take them for one good walk a week, I would say,
- 53:40you know, maybe maybe walks a week, depending on whether and all that
- 53:44kind of stuff. But we've got a massive yard. We're home with the
- 53:46dogs very regularly. It's not like we leave for work for nine hours a
- 53:51day every single day. My wife's a nurse, so she's home, you
- 53:53know, freaking five four days out of the week, five days out of
- 53:57the week where she could spend predominantly the whole day with the dogs and keep
- 54:00them engaged and work with them and allow them to run in the yard and
- 54:06they could kind of co mingle with each other, which helps them to be
- 54:08able to kind of develop their social skills and and and you know, fulfill
- 54:12themselves and stuff like that. So we don't really need to be able to
- 54:15provide that much in the form of walking, right. You know. On
- 54:19the contrary, we'll have a lot of clients like some of our some of
- 54:22our trainers, for example, they don't necessarily walk their dogs that much.
- 54:25But what they do do is they bring the dogs to work every day with
- 54:29them, and the dogs get to help out in lessons, and the dogs
- 54:31get to socialize with other dogs every single day, and they're getting their mental
- 54:35and physical stimulation in the form of that where they don't need to go home
- 54:37and do walks all the time, right, So the walk is a tool
- 54:42for being able to provide that, But I don't necessarily think it's the best
- 54:45tool for providing that. But for some people it's very important, you know.
- 54:50And I think it is a great chance to just get out and get
- 54:52them moving around, you know. I think another big key factor with it
- 54:57is that when you first get a dog, I do think a walk is
- 55:01a great way to start to kind of develop a training relationship with them because
- 55:06you're getting them out and about into stimulus. Right, You're not in this
- 55:10like box. You're out in the real world. There's cars going by,
- 55:14there's people, there's animals, there's different sites and smells, and you could
- 55:17start to develop this relationship of being in tune with each other in a little
- 55:22bit more difficult of an environment, which helps them to kind of build trust
- 55:25in you. I think, so, boy, that's a big one.
- 55:29Soon having trust in the owner is huge again, folks talking to David the
- 55:34Dog Trainer. You can find them a David the Dog Trainer podcast, Miracle
- 55:37cana I and Training on Instagram and Miracle can I and training dot Com.
- 55:39I can't believe it, but we're heading towards our last ten minutes. I
- 55:43could keep your ear for hours. And we've got so many topics. I
- 55:45mean, distractions is another one, the different degrees of distractions. I mean,
- 55:51this one is an interesting one. I've heard it a phrase a couple
- 55:53of times. I can't even remember who said it anymore, but I always
- 55:55made me think this is interesting idea. I never thought of it that way.
- 56:00Dog walking again, will continue with that journey. Dogs walking down the
- 56:05block. There's another dog across the way. They both look eyes, and
- 56:10I understood, if I sit there, it's gonna be a problem because now
- 56:15my dog starts building up all this energy and it's just not worth the hassle
- 56:19unless I know the other dog. If not, I'm just gonna keep walking.
- 56:22And my dog usually doesn't just fine with that. Okay, he doesn't
- 56:24want me to stop. Let's keep moving. We got somewhere to go.
- 56:27As you mentioned, we have a purpose and we're out of here. But
- 56:30some people think, hey, every dog gets along with everybody. You know,
- 56:35every dog should get along with everybody, just like humans supposedly get along
- 56:38with everybody. But I don't walk and stop. Everybody I've seen walking down
- 56:42the straight, Hey, how are you? What do you think about that?
- 56:45Should a dog read every dog it sees out there? No, I
- 56:50think this is a This is a really really great topic that can go in
- 56:54twenty seven different directions, right because leash reactivity, right, a dog basically
- 56:59that gets really frustrated and reacts at other dogs out on the walk is probably
- 57:04the number one issue that any dog trainer out there will tell you they get
- 57:08clients come in for right, and in a lot of cases, I think
- 57:12the cause of leash reactivity comes from overdoing socialization while on the walk, right,
- 57:19So we teach time and place for everything. Yes, I want my
- 57:22dog to have dog friends and I want them to have a good, healthy
- 57:27social life and stuff like that. But if you look at interacting with another
- 57:30dog for three seconds out on the walk, it is an extremely unnatural way
- 57:35to interact with another dog. Because let's break it down, right, So,
- 57:37if a dog was going to interact and socialize with another dog, what
- 57:42does that generally look like? That generally looks like they meet each other,
- 57:45they figure each other out, they're sniffing each other for a minute, and
- 57:47then they start playing, right and one the play is generally pretty explosive they're
- 57:53moving around, they're jumping, they're running from one side to another, they're
- 57:57kind of going all over the place. Two, what play really is,
- 58:01if you break it down, is two dogs competing with each other and trying
- 58:06to figure out who's more dominant than the other without actually fighting. Right,
- 58:09That's that's kind of what it is, which is why in play you see
- 58:12all sorts of different things like head over the back and mounting and like doing
- 58:15all those types of things. Where us as humans, if we don't understand
- 58:19it, we're like, WHOA, that's not good. We shouldn't allow that.
- 58:21This that right when you're out on the walk and your dog meets another
- 58:24dog first and foremost that explosive play that would generally happen, they can't do
- 58:29it. They're on a six foot leash. Right. Every time they try
- 58:31to do it, they it's ping at the end of the leash, ping
- 58:34at the end of the leash, and it creates all this frustration. Right.
- 58:37The thing number two is in that critical moment where they are actually feeling
- 58:42each other out and getting this vibe and figuring out who's more dominant than the
- 58:45other and all that kind of stuff, we then end it. We separated,
- 58:49we pull them away from each other. Okay, we're done, we're
- 58:50going We're going our other ways. Right. So I used to joke all
- 58:52the time. I used to joke I was like meeting another dog out of
- 58:55the walk. You're like constantly like blue balls in your dog. Right,
- 59:00It's like you're like edging them up to this point where it's like they're going
- 59:04to figure it out with each other, and then we're stopping it. Right,
- 59:06So all it does is create it's so unnatural, right, creates all
- 59:09this frustration. Then you get the other side of things. Let's say your
- 59:13dog is not aggressive, right, I mean sorry, not aggressive. Let's
- 59:15say your dog is not super friendly. They don't love playing with other dogs
- 59:21all the time, and we're like, we're going to use this as an
- 59:22opportunity to socialize them more. Right, And every single time we go out
- 59:27on a walk, they might be a little insecure of the dog over there.
- 59:30We let that dog come and invade our dog's space repeatedly, over and
- 59:34over and over again. We're doing it with the mindset of we need to
- 59:37socialize our dog more. He needs to make friends, he needs to learn
- 59:39how to interact with other dogs. What that does is immediately kills confidence in
- 59:45handler because he said, you're putting me in this situation that I don't like
- 59:47over and over and over and over again. You're not doing anything about it.
- 59:52I'm on this six foot leash, so I can't even get away if
- 59:53I want to. And what happens is, over time of doing that,
- 59:57they learn that they have to set the boundary in order to make the other
- 1:00:00dog go away, which generally starts in when they start greeting. You'll get
- 1:00:05growling, snapping, stuff like that, or it'll escalate them to the point
- 1:00:08where the dog will start proactively setting the boundary, meaning they see the other
- 1:00:13dog, they think that the owner is going to let that dog come up
- 1:00:15to them, so they proactively react at that dog to make them go away.
- 1:00:20And what happens is every time they react, the person keeps walking and
- 1:00:22they go, Ah, that worked, right. So in my mind,
- 1:00:28teaching time and place for things. When I'm on a leash out in public,
- 1:00:31I don't allow the interactions. I just don't. Right. I'll give
- 1:00:35them social opportunities later, Like I said, I'll meet up with some friends
- 1:00:37that have dogs. We'll let them off leash, We'll let them run and
- 1:00:40play, and we'll do it in a more healthy manner for them. Right,
- 1:00:43I'll take them to a good structured daycare and not one of the big
- 1:00:46box ones that has one hundred dogs loose for twelve hours or anything like that.
- 1:00:51But I'll take them to a good structured daycare that's going to be able
- 1:00:52to get them some social interaction. And I treat it as like a less
- 1:00:55is more kind of thing of the less I'm actually socializing my dog interaction kind
- 1:01:00of way, the more I could guarantee that it's going to go successfully.
- 1:01:04And then the majority of my socialization is done through environmental socialization, which is
- 1:01:08just learning to coexist around this stuff. If you have that dog that's insecure
- 1:01:13around other dogs, and every time they go for a walk and they don't
- 1:01:15react, but they might be a little nervous, but the dog never actually
- 1:01:17comes up to them. At a certain point, your dogs is just going
- 1:01:20to tune it out. It doesn't impact them, right, it is whatever,
- 1:01:23it doesn't matter. It's like it's like if you ever go out and
- 1:01:25you're like in Chicago or New York or San Francisco or something like that,
- 1:01:29and you see like homeless dogs homeless dog or homeless people that have dogs.
- 1:01:32Those are some of the most stable dogs you'll ever meet, because people aren't
- 1:01:37coming up to them all the time, and they're environmentally out around stimulus twenty
- 1:01:42four seven without it intacting them, so they just learn to kind of accept
- 1:01:45it there point. Yeah, that's true. They really don't care very much
- 1:01:49about anything. Yeah, like that. It's kind of interesting. I remember
- 1:01:52doing a walk one of the neighbors down the street. You're gonna have to
- 1:01:58give me some doc tips. You have two dogs, and they kept trying
- 1:02:00to come play with my dog. And then one day I saw her again
- 1:02:05and I just said, here's your first tip. It's free. I said,
- 1:02:08ignore me, yeah, ignore my dogs. I'm going to ignore you
- 1:02:14and ignore your dogs, and I'm gonna walk right by you. And she
- 1:02:17just kind of looked at me, said, don't even look at me,
- 1:02:21just keep doing your thing, and she okay, she didn't know what to
- 1:02:23do, so she started doing her thing and ignoring me and the dogs,
- 1:02:28like you just said, just all of a sudden, well they're not interesting.
- 1:02:31We walked right by and bye, about two feet apart, and nobody
- 1:02:36did a damn thing. Everybody just walked away. She just kind of looked
- 1:02:38at me with his face, So, what the hell just happened? I
- 1:02:42don't know what happened. I said, what's your first tip? That was
- 1:02:44free? And I just kind of walked away. Maunt on charge anyway,
- 1:02:46but it's walked away. And it was interesting because you're so right, But
- 1:02:52it doesn't. It's funny again, they treat them like human well not even
- 1:02:57actually expect more than human beings. But we don't even expect you're right,
- 1:03:00like you said, humans, we don't do that as humans. I don't
- 1:03:02shake every person's hand that I see out in public. Think about the elevator,
- 1:03:07Yeah, exactly, that's a disaster elevate. Just imagine putting five dogs
- 1:03:12on an elevator. I think the on leash greetings things, whether it's with
- 1:03:15dogs or with people, like people that come up and say, hey,
- 1:03:17can I put your dog, It's it's the same concept, right. I
- 1:03:21think that's one of those things where if people could just if there was just
- 1:03:24a universal law that when the dog is on a leash and they couldn't meet
- 1:03:29another dog and they couldn't meet another person, I think a lot of issues
- 1:03:32would go away in the dog world. I think that's one of the biggest,
- 1:03:36biggest contributors to big problems. Oh, man, I tell you,
- 1:03:39I don't know. I'm sure you've had the same kind of success. I
- 1:03:44just know I tell people immediately, I said, you know what I want
- 1:03:46you to do for the first minute, don't even look at the dog.
- 1:03:50Yeah, just talk to me. Ignore the dog and my little My dog's
- 1:03:54name is Nina. She's moving around for twenty seconds. She's ten months old,
- 1:03:59and they have to about twenty thirty seconds. All right, this dude
- 1:04:01doesn't care. I want to move along. That's about the end of it.
- 1:04:05And I'm looking at it going and they just kind of look at me.
- 1:04:09Oh. Actually had one neighbor. It was funny because she said,
- 1:04:12she doesn't like me anymore. No, she still likes you, but now
- 1:04:15she can treat you with respect. Then that jump all over you like I'm
- 1:04:19the animal. So yeah, it's really funny because I think a lot of
- 1:04:23it. Like you said that, I'm curious. I don't know I where
- 1:04:25they even have the statistics, but I'd be really curious to see what the
- 1:04:29dog bites are coming from. I know there's a lot of dog bites.
- 1:04:31I think a couple of million a year, but there's obviously fifty million dogs
- 1:04:35out there that our own. But I know a majority of them are a
- 1:04:39lot of times kids, Yeah, and which is always sad and tragic,
- 1:04:44and I think you have to be really careful with children and dogs. Kids
- 1:04:47don't they treat them like stuffed animals And sometimes that's a big bag, big
- 1:04:53mistake. But yeah, I wonder how much of it because again you get
- 1:04:59to that false bil leaf of they should ever like you. Yeah, I
- 1:05:03think, I think, I think anecdotally, right, A lot of the
- 1:05:08bites that we see come in are you know, out in public. Person
- 1:05:12came up to the dog because they tried to create space and a person got
- 1:05:15bit. That's that's so many of them. You know what about the children?
- 1:05:21Uh? Children is I would say probably similar. A lot of them
- 1:05:27are out on the walk right where where you know they're at the playground.
- 1:05:30Kid wants to come up and pet the dog and there's there's a reaction.
- 1:05:33But you know, the children one is another interesting one because a lot of
- 1:05:38it is also uh you know, when they have young children, they're friends,
- 1:05:42right, friends that come over and and you know, we don't do
- 1:05:45a good enough job of managing the dog, and you know, kids are
- 1:05:48different for dogs, like we you know, we forget it's like even as
- 1:05:50an adult, like you could be around children and you could say, hey,
- 1:05:54listen, sometimes they're a lot right. Well, for dogs, it's
- 1:05:57the same thing. They're running around quick, they're making a ton of noise,
- 1:06:00they're they're they're moving fast, they're they're doing all this kind of stuff.
- 1:06:02And we look at it as just, you know, our dog is
- 1:06:05friendly with adults, so they should just be fine with children. And it
- 1:06:09just it just doesn't really work that way. It's a it's a lot of
- 1:06:11stress on dogs, even the most friendly ones. And I think a lot
- 1:06:15of the bites with kids come from, you know, people who have dogs
- 1:06:16who have never bitten anybody before, and they just think that they're going to
- 1:06:19be fine with children, you know, and it's too much stress for them.
- 1:06:23We don't do a good enough job of advocating for them, and something
- 1:06:26bad happens. Absolutely, absolutely, it's it's interesting to watch that behavior.
- 1:06:30If the kids, so I know, they got the high pitched voices or
- 1:06:34eyes are in the same level as theirs. Yeah, there's so much going
- 1:06:38on, it's crazy. Yeah, yeah, it definitely is. I don't
- 1:06:42know. You also had a good podcast, not really a question. I
- 1:06:45guess there's a statement again if you catch up David the Dog Trainer podcast.
- 1:06:48You were showing some rebuttals against the Force Free Trainer, and you mentioned a
- 1:06:54comment that stood out to me because the one trainer who I respect, actually
- 1:07:00I like him a lot. I guess I could mention him. It was
- 1:07:04Robert Cabral. I like, I like Robert, nice guy, seems like
- 1:07:10a good trainer. I like a lot of stuff. But he was He
- 1:07:13made a comment and then you came in with it back with another comment,
- 1:07:15and then I kept like leaving me kind of still wondering. So I started
- 1:07:19doing some research myself because he mentioned the comment about well he was going rebutting
- 1:07:27Zach George's comment about veterinarians knowing, and it reminded me a lot of the
- 1:07:31fitness world and the fitness world. Personal trainers will, especially strengthen conditioning coaches
- 1:07:39will rebutt medical doctor's advice, especially for a nutrition because they only get two
- 1:07:44or three courses. And when I've talked to veterinarians they tell me the same
- 1:07:46thing. It's very little coaching. Real little education in regards to nutrition or
- 1:07:53even dog training. Yeah, that's not their big thing. So I thought,
- 1:07:57okay, that made sense to me. And then but then the question
- 1:08:00that the problem I had was it went to veterinarian veterinarian behaviorists. Now,
- 1:08:05those individuals were really different than veterinarians because they started to do more training.
- 1:08:11And this is where I wanted to get your insight on it, because I
- 1:08:13was like, well, these individuals, they obviously lean towards a particular ideology
- 1:08:17of dog training. Yeah, so I get that it has to go one
- 1:08:21way or another, I guess for them, so they took that route.
- 1:08:26But what do you think about veterinarian behaviorists do? Are they a little bit
- 1:08:30more in tune with what's going on in the ballgame in your mind? So
- 1:08:35again a lot to kind of unpack with it veteran behaviorists, if I'm not
- 1:08:40mistaken, Are you know veterinarians that have been trained to X degree through animal
- 1:08:46behavior, right, so they're understanding of animals, how they learned, why
- 1:08:50they rehearse behaviors, things like that is going to be much much much higher
- 1:08:55than your average veterinarian obviously, right. My issue with it gets back to
- 1:09:00Again, the studies that have been done that they cite as far as why
- 1:09:04certain methods are good or bad? Are all controlled studies done in boxes?
- 1:09:11Right, They're not like like there's and we're actually going to be having a
- 1:09:14guest on the podcast on Thursday who is in the UK who's uh, he
- 1:09:17is an expert on like the scientific studies of of basically the animal world right
- 1:09:24now because he's one of the leading voices currently in the push to the UK
- 1:09:28is trying to ban different training tools and stuff right now, so he's one
- 1:09:30of the leaders in that right now. He's gonna be on the podcast Thursday.
- 1:09:33But but basically, yeah, all these all these studies that have been
- 1:09:36done, they're done in very very controlled ways, or they're done in ways
- 1:09:43explicitly to disprove certain methods, right where you know, any variability you add
- 1:09:48to a study, like I could I could create a study that you know,
- 1:09:53somehow leads you to the conclusion that, uh, you know, did
- 1:09:56some sort of controversial topic like like the Earth is flat or something like that.
- 1:10:00Right, There's a reason why so many people out there still believe the
- 1:10:01Earth is flat is because there have been certain types of data that have come
- 1:10:05out that have led them to that conclusion that that's accurate. Right. So
- 1:10:11my problem with it is their behavior and the things that they do is guided
- 1:10:15by these studies that we think are flawed, right, as a balanced dog
- 1:10:18training community. Right. And there's a lot of proof out there as far
- 1:10:21as why they're flawed, and their methods they're coaching people to do are done
- 1:10:28under the guise of we have to follow these scientific studies of force free is
- 1:10:31the only way to do it, and they don't factor in the real life
- 1:10:35scenarios that owners are struggled with. Right. So we have clients that can't
- 1:10:41even walk out their front door without their dog being triggered by something. Right,
- 1:10:45And one of the most common force free techniques is, well, you
- 1:10:48have to always work the dog under threshold, right, meaning the dog can't
- 1:10:54be escalated to the point of being triggered by something. You should start working
- 1:10:57with them while they're under threshold to raise that threshold. Right. But if
- 1:11:01they're triggered the second they walk out the front door, or in some cases
- 1:11:04before they even walk out the front door, Like, how are you?
- 1:11:06You can't keep them under thresholds. It's physically impossible given their living circumstances that
- 1:11:12they're in at that point, right, so then they revert back to okay,
- 1:11:15Well, then we need to medicate these dogs in order to bring their
- 1:11:18threshold up a little bit to help be able to train them under threshold more.
- 1:11:23So, they start getting pumped with all these different medications, and if
- 1:11:26you know, you look at it from the top down, like it's no
- 1:11:28different than like big pharma with humans. I mean, there's like a ton
- 1:11:30of profit margins and these medications that are being pushed, and they're being pushed
- 1:11:34by veterinarians, and then you have these people that are veterinarian behaviors that are
- 1:11:38the ones that are prescribing them. And to me and to most of the
- 1:11:41balance dog training community, it feels like a little bit of a top down
- 1:11:45scheme of like, we want to make a bunch of money off of these
- 1:11:46medications. Let's appoint these professionals that are experts in knine behavior to help prescribe
- 1:11:53more of these medications, and you know, push these these studies that have
- 1:11:58been funded by the veterinarian organizations to make it seem like the other methods are
- 1:12:01bad. You get know what I'm saying, Like it sounds like it sounds
- 1:12:03like a big conspiracy theory if you're not within it. But when you're looking
- 1:12:08at the anecdotal evidence of there's no proof by any of these organizations that what
- 1:12:12they're doing is actually working. And then in our case, like we work
- 1:12:14with dogs that have been through these VET behaviors. Right, there's one literally
- 1:12:18less than ten minutes down the road from my house. There's one of the
- 1:12:21top veterinarian behaviorists in our area that we get dogs from all the time.
- 1:12:26And I'm not saying they're a bad person or anything, but it's like,
- 1:12:30you know, these people are going through their program and it's not working,
- 1:12:33and then they're coming to us and it is working. Right. So I'm
- 1:12:38happy for people to train the way that they want to train, obviously,
- 1:12:40but you hit a certain point where it's like, you guys are vilifying us.
- 1:12:44Is like, what we're doing is making everything worse, but the dogs
- 1:12:45that are going through your programs, it's not working with them, right.
- 1:12:48And then I used to have a training facility down in Columbus, Ohio,
- 1:12:51and Columbus at os US campus has one of the top veterinarian behaviors like in
- 1:12:56the country, down there, and same deal. We would see dogs that
- 1:12:59would go through the programs all the time, and you know, they don't
- 1:13:01even touch the dog. They basically you pay them like eight hundred dollars to
- 1:13:05go in the room and they stare at the dog for twenty minutes and then
- 1:13:08diagnose them as like fear intense, anxiety aggressive, And here's fourteen different medications
- 1:13:14to try, and here's a reference for a positive only trainer in the area
- 1:13:16that you can go to to help work on your issues. And it's like
- 1:13:18that's what they do, you know. So I try to not I try
- 1:13:21to not get too crazy with like God, like they're so bad and I
- 1:13:26really hate everything they're doing. But you know, we're being we're being vilified
- 1:13:30by them right now, like as a balance training community, and we're the
- 1:13:32ones that are boots on the ground helping these dogs and helping even the ones
- 1:13:36that it didn't work out that went to their clinics. So that's kind of
- 1:13:41a long winded roundabout way of me saying I don't I don't have much of
- 1:13:45a great opinion on them, just for that soul fact. It revised me
- 1:13:49a lot of psychiatrists I know, I don't know. I don't know how
- 1:13:53much you know about the psychology world. We've ever heard of the DSM five.
- 1:14:00Your wife might it was a nurse, you might have heard of it.
- 1:14:01The DSM five is like the Bible for psychologists and has all the different
- 1:14:04psychiatric disorders in there. And one of the guys who created who was on
- 1:14:09the panel that created the DSM four, I got a purpose for the story.
- 1:14:12Folk. One of the guy who was ahead of the panel had a
- 1:14:15problem because he said, you know what, you folks are broadening the criteria
- 1:14:20for ticking off too many of these disorders, and you're broadening it so much
- 1:14:26at anybody in this room out of fifty people can have anxiety by the broadening
- 1:14:29of your criteria. And he thought it was a big farm of racket because
- 1:14:33they were the ones who were behind funding it, and he had an issue
- 1:14:39with that. Obvious it's hard to prove, but his name was a doctor
- 1:14:43Saws and the other ones doctor Francis. You can read their books if you're
- 1:14:45interests of folks. But he kind of said, look, there are peopleho
- 1:14:47have psychiatric disorders. There's anxiety, there's major depression. By not everybody falls
- 1:14:53under this umbrella, and they're really making it seem like everybody starts to fall
- 1:14:57under this umbrella. So it kind of reminded me that when you talk about
- 1:15:00ternary behaviors, because I think I wonder if it's not really a conspiracy but
- 1:15:02more out of a serendipity for them. Hey, we found a dog training
- 1:15:06method. It works sometimes but not as effective. It helps us to get
- 1:15:12our medications going and we can join forces with them. Is the other one.
- 1:15:16If they are helping individuals or to get their dogs under control, there's
- 1:15:20no medication necessary and the kind of game. But of course it's just my
- 1:15:25speculation on it. I don't know. I did want to mention some things
- 1:15:28in regards to studies since you're having that gentleman or is it a guy or
- 1:15:30a girl or yeah, that things treat me. So if you have Jamie
- 1:15:33coming out on Thursdays. When I started looking at dog studies again, I
- 1:15:38mentioned the other individual. I mentioned the name, but the other individual who's
- 1:15:41quoting studies, you know, going looking at the fox and looking at this,
- 1:15:45and yeah, I get it. There's some translation, but even rats
- 1:15:47to humans, like only fifty percent of the time can translate. It just
- 1:15:49physiological we're not the same. But some of these studies, is you mentioned
- 1:15:54controlled environments is going to be one issue. Type of breed that's limited to
- 1:15:58is going to be another issue. The other thing I kept noticing is people
- 1:16:01and some of the individuals you mentioned in your own podcast that that you've interviewed
- 1:16:05them, but you've mentioned them, we'll do this too. They'll use a
- 1:16:09study. And when I teach, study is always a piece of a puzzle
- 1:16:13to a question. That's all it is. So if I'm teaching, if
- 1:16:16I want to study about sniff walking and how does that improve aggression, one
- 1:16:25study gives me one snippet of a shot if I'm walking Belgian malin laws,
- 1:16:30and that's it. That's all I know about. I don't know about pit
- 1:16:31bulls. I don't know about German shepherds. I can extrapulate and try to
- 1:16:35guess. But what these individuals are doing is what the fifness industry did twenty
- 1:16:40five years ago, which is every time you got to study, it was
- 1:16:43gold. Yeah, until you got to study later that said no, it's
- 1:16:45not gold, and you're like, oh crap, now we got a backpedal.
- 1:16:49And they were even doing policies based on one study, and anybody who
- 1:16:53knows research, or I'm sure your friend does on Thursday, you can't do
- 1:16:57that. It's just one piece of a puzzle. And I'm looking at the
- 1:17:00dog world, going, man, you guys are really that you. But
- 1:17:02some of these people are really relying heavy on one study or two studies,
- 1:17:06and I'm thinking, holy cow, you've barely studied it. I've called I
- 1:17:12called out, but I've reached out to about five different professors who did some
- 1:17:16of these studies. Studies on the heck with it now, the first now
- 1:17:21it escapes me, studies on I think it was sent and aggression. There
- 1:17:28was another study on oh, dog owner behavior influencing the dog, and I
- 1:17:34asked, hey, do you mind coming onto the show and talking about I
- 1:17:39did that ten years ago? Yeah, one guy even was honest about it.
- 1:17:42So there's no money in it. I don't remember. It's fourteen years
- 1:17:45ago, and I'm like, okay, the next guy, No, can't
- 1:17:47do it's been twelve years ago. And then they're all over the place.
- 1:17:51They're in Norway, they're one in the US, one somewhere else. I
- 1:17:55can't even remember. What was Germany or something. I'm thinking, Holy cow,
- 1:17:59we got like five studies that this guy cited in the book. None
- 1:18:01of them are none of them are more recent than a decade. They're all
- 1:18:05over the map. They're not even the same dogs. How do you say
- 1:18:10this is science based. That's the same to me? Well, that's kind
- 1:18:13of the issue. Is you know Ivan Blabinov, who's a very or balabanof
- 1:18:16I believe so I pronounced his last name. He's been very vocal because he's
- 1:18:20one of the more intelligent minds in dog training right now, I would say,
- 1:18:24and he's a balanced dog trainer, and he interviews on his podcast scientists
- 1:18:28very regularly. Right. And he when all this first started really getting pushed
- 1:18:32to light of like, look at all these studies that say what you guys
- 1:18:34are doing is wrong and bad and unethical and this and that, he counteracted
- 1:18:40it with a video that went pretty viral where he cited all of these opposing
- 1:18:44studies, right, peer of viewed opposing studies that said all of your studies
- 1:18:47you did are incorrect basically, right. So it's tough because, like you
- 1:18:50know, again, I'm having Jamie on the podcast next week because I want
- 1:18:54to learn a little more about the studies like I'm familiar with some of them,
- 1:18:57and i know some of the discrepancies amongst them, but I'm definitely not
- 1:18:59an act burd in them, right. I'm not a I don't have a
- 1:19:00psychology degree or anything like that, but I try to I try to stay
- 1:19:03current on those types of things. But at the same time, you know,
- 1:19:06we see this in science with anything. Right, It's there's any study
- 1:19:13can be made to disagree with another study, and if you have it,
- 1:19:16you know, uh, sanctioned off in an X way, right, and
- 1:19:20all of the variables aligned in a perfect way, you could prove pretty much
- 1:19:24any point with a study. So it's like you can only hold so much
- 1:19:27weight behind them, right, And especially in a field like dog training,
- 1:19:30that really is I really push home the point of like it's not a what
- 1:19:34method is best, it's what's going to be best for the dog, the
- 1:19:38owner, the situations that they're living in, the issues that they're experiencing.
- 1:19:43Like it really is kind of an art, right, and and every single
- 1:19:46case we work with is going to be a little bit different as far as
- 1:19:49the needs of them. So yeah, it's it's it's a really interesting conversation,
- 1:19:55and it's you know, it's becoming more and more real now that like
- 1:19:58I said, like there's different legists Asian trying to get past to uh you
- 1:20:01know, create credentials for trainers and ban certain types of tools or approaches or
- 1:20:05methods that have been being used for gosh, I mean you know, seventy
- 1:20:09five years, eighty years, stuff like that. You know, all around
- 1:20:13these studies that again there's not really a general consensus on still, so yeah,
- 1:20:17it's really weird, and I completely agree. I'm looking forward to that.
- 1:20:20I've seen Ivan's some of his podcast shows when he talks to the individuals
- 1:20:25about the studies. He did a good job. I think you guys even
- 1:20:27posted on yours when he broke down some studies and show the limitations. Every
- 1:20:31study has limitations. And again, folks, I'm not poo pooing. Studies
- 1:20:34are really important because they always give us a piece of the puzzle, and
- 1:20:39the more studies you have, more of that puzzle you get, and then
- 1:20:42hopefully at the end you get really solid. But we're talking dozens of studies
- 1:20:45on a particular topic. So if you're looking at what they got, all
- 1:20:49kinds of names a verse of training or whatever, you know, have balanced
- 1:20:54training. But if you use certain techniques, you should have at least a
- 1:20:57dozen or two studies. And it's I think too that they haven't done a
- 1:21:00lot of I have to look. Obviously I haven't read everything, so I
- 1:21:03don't know. But I was looking at more case studies what we call it
- 1:21:11our world feminological studies, where you would get twelve dog trainers and ask them
- 1:21:15what have you found to be effective with the dogs that you work with,
- 1:21:19and you can kind of start getting a snapshot of what they're seeing. So
- 1:21:25if we interviewed you and asked you a survey and what do you do?
- 1:21:29What are the best techniques that you found for this and that? Then we
- 1:21:30get twelve or fifteen of you dog trainers around the country, and then we
- 1:21:34started looking out. Wow, yeah, it looks like every this keeps popping
- 1:21:36up. This keeps popping up every time, whether it's a little snap on
- 1:21:41the slip lead, whatever it is, keeps popping up. Now we got
- 1:21:45something, something that's solid or at least better, I guess. Yeah,
- 1:21:49Yeah, it's really interesting. It's a complicated world. Well, like I
- 1:21:53said, David, I could keep you here forever. I don't want to
- 1:21:55do that to you. But thank you so much again for doing this.
- 1:21:59I truly appreciate it. Yeah, no, this has been great. I'm
- 1:22:02happy, too happy to do it anytime. This is a very interesting conversation
- 1:22:05because I can tell obviously you're you're very, very knowledgeable about the psychology side
- 1:22:09of things. And it's interesting because as dog trainers like we get into learning
- 1:22:12about the psychology side of things because we kind of have to as a part
- 1:22:15of the industry, you know what I mean. So like none of us
- 1:22:17are deeply, deeply experts in it, you know, we kind of just
- 1:22:21learned it as we go. So it's it's the questions you're bringing up were
- 1:22:25very interesting. I think, you know, they presented some kind of different
- 1:22:28insights that I haven't really talked about in certain ways before. So that's great.
- 1:22:31So hopefully everybody it will also get to learn differently with you when they
- 1:22:35watch your podcast. I learned a lot from your show. Again, folks,
- 1:22:39is David the Dog Trainer Podcast. I highly recommend it. Go Miracle
- 1:22:42cana I and training dot com and it Google Miracle cana I and Training on
- 1:22:45Instagram. That's it for now, folks. You know what to do,
- 1:22:48share, subscribe it. I like button, Go train your dogs. You guys,