Latest / Success School / We Hit $110K Then Lost It All - Here's How We're Rebuilding (Live Coaching Breakdown)
Transcript
- 0:00Sam, Taylor, welcome to the Success School Podcast.
- 0:03Should it be Taylor or Sam or Sam or Taylor?
- 0:05Is there a way?
- 0:07Taylor and Sam, always made first.
- 0:10Yeah.
- 0:12So I'll make sure I address Taylor first, otherwise she'll get pissed off here.
- 0:15How are you guys doing?
- 0:18Good.
- 0:19Coming well?
- 0:19Good.
- 0:20Okay, cool.
- 0:21They're nervous, they can't talk.
- 0:23We are on our business breakthrough section guys.
- 0:26The whole purpose of today is we're gonna find the constraint in the business of Sam and Taylor.
- 0:30We're gonna work through it one, two, three, and give you guys a look into what the process looks like of finding that and moving forward with a constraint.
- 0:37Guys, let's kick off.
- 0:38Like who are you, where are you from, and what's the big business goal?
- 0:44Can I have that one?
- 0:46So we are Sam and Taylor, we're from Melbourne.
- 0:48We have a online coaching company for women.
- 0:54Busy, professional, career driven women, 30 plus, wanting to lose weight essentially without making fitness their entire personality.
- 1:02I think a lot of people, a lot of fitness coaches online are very much obsessed with fitness and we're kind of the opposite.
- 1:09It's like something that we do but it's not our entire personality.
- 1:12That's kind of our point of difference.
- 1:16Okay, awesome.
- 1:17And what's the business goal?
- 1:21I think first off, getting to a consistent 100K months would be the first target.
- 1:27Awesome.
- 1:27And where are you guys at now?
- 1:30So at the moment, we're sitting between 30 and 40K.
- 1:3530 and 40.
- 1:37And what causes the fluctuation?
- 1:41It's just ink.
- 1:43We just...
- 1:44need to book more calls consistently.
- 1:48Need to book more calls now.
- 1:50Yeah, that's really what it comes down to.
- 1:52And how are you guys booking calls now?
- 1:55So it's the follower funnel, like running follower ads.
- 1:59We've got a set of the works in the account and books calls and then I will jump on the calls and try to close them.
- 2:06Try to close them.
- 2:07That doesn't sound confident.
- 2:09That doesn't sound confident at all.
- 2:11Okay, so follower funnel is the only funnel at the moment.
- 2:14Yeah.
- 2:15Okay, cool.
- 2:16And how hard are you running that in terms of like daily spend?
- 2:20Well, at the moment it's $100 a day.
- 2:23Last year we got it up to as high as, I think it was like $250 a day.
- 2:29And we had to make some adjustments this year.
- 2:33It's a bit of a back story.
- 2:34We've been working with another business coach for a couple of years and then at the end of last year, we had the bright idea that maybe we should go look elsewhere, even though we'd just come off a $110K month in November.
- 2:46For whatever reason, we decided that, oh, we need to change something.
- 2:52We need to change something.
- 2:53So we went and invested into another business program thinking that it was going to be really,
- 3:00it turned out to be not very good.
- 3:02We spent a lot of money on that.
- 3:04And basically everything that we were doing that was working for us, we blew that up completely and stopped doing all that.
- 3:12And then we tried to start doing other stuff.
- 3:14And then we kind of got to the point where we were burning cash and we got to the point where we had to turn the ad spend down right, and just really, really scale everything back to just
- 3:26preserve cash flow.
- 3:27We had no recurring at the time, because pretty much last year we were just doing paying fulls the whole time.
- 3:33So when all these changes happened, we had no sort of foundation of recurring.
- 3:38So we had no money coming in.
- 3:40And then, so pretty much the entire year has just been about building back up the recurring, back to the point where it is.
- 3:47So we've gone from like 9K recurring back up to like 30 odd.
- 3:49So it's getting there, but it's been a shit show.
- 3:52Well, congrats for hitting 100K.
- 3:54That's the elusive 100K, but you guys just decided to fuck it off and just blow shit up and start again.
- 4:00Love making that hard for yourselves, let's go.
- 4:02What happened, what were you doing to get to 110?
- 4:05Like what did you guys do to get there?
- 4:08So it was November, so it was a Black Friday promo which went really well.
- 4:12And then we did a, so we had another bright idea which wasn't our bright idea.
- 4:18It wasn't bright.
- 4:18It's what we were told to do.
- 4:19We basically did an internal Black Friday offer.
- 4:23So we offered nine months for the price of six as long as they paid up front.
- 4:27So we probably had.
- 4:29And we had a lot of people take that up.
- 4:30Yeah, probably had 25% of the clients take up that offer.
- 4:33So that was a massive influx of cash and then obviously collecting cash on the front end
- 4:38with the Black Friday offer.
- 4:41But that tanked out recurring.
- 4:42We had all this money coming in and then it was like December was nothing and then we're like, yeah, let's go find another business coach.
- 4:48And then that just all went to shit.
- 4:49And then we're like, oh fuck, we have no one paying us anything.
- 4:54Oh God.
- 4:55So that's like a, so you hit 110, but really it was like just taken from all the months ahead.
- 4:59So it was just like, you just collected it.
- 5:01That month.
- 5:02Correct.
- 5:03Yeah.
- 5:03And then you got a disgusting ATO bill and a bass bill and all that kind of stuff as well.
- 5:09Yeah, well, I mean.
- 5:11Didn't like 50% of what we made in November go straight to the ATO?
- 5:14Because we had all these outstanding tax bills anyway, so.
- 5:17Oh, dude.
- 5:18Sorry about that.
- 5:19Yeah.
- 5:20Apologies, sorry about the situation, but you know.
- 5:24It's a learning curve team.
- 5:25Learning curve.
- 5:26Oh yeah.
- 5:28You guys built this great kind of brand equity and then you cashed in the brand equity is essentially what I'm hearing here.
- 5:35Basically, yeah.
- 5:36Yeah, we had a lot of clients.
- 5:37We'd signed up a lot of clients last year and that sort of around November time, a lot of them were getting to the point of needing to re-sign anyway, so.
- 5:45Yup.
- 5:47Yeah, but we obviously shot ourselves in the foot because the next six months was dog shit.
- 5:54Okay, cool.
- 5:55Well, we're out of it now.
- 5:56So from the 100 a day, how many are becoming followers?
- 6:00How many followers a day?
- 6:01Do you know any of the data around that?
- 6:03So the cost per follower is about between, anywhere between $2 and $3.
- 6:08$2, okay.
- 6:11Yeah.
- 6:11So about 50, 60, 70 clients per day, depending on the day.
- 6:15Okay, cool.
- 6:1850 per day.
- 6:19And are you reaching out to all of them?
- 6:22Yeah.
- 6:23And how many of them have been replied at like the intro message?
- 6:27So the reply rate's anywhere between 20 and 25%.
- 6:3020 and 25%, okay, cool.
- 6:34So that's probably like issue number one, you probably wanna get that to around 50%.
- 6:38So there'd be something with that opening message that's going wrong there.
- 6:4220, 25% of reply, okay, cool.
- 6:44And then from there, how many chats of these 20, 25 would go to a call?
- 6:50So it's about, it's about 1%.
- 6:53All right, 1%.
- 6:57Even last year in our- Bro, do you have like the worst AI ever, like in your DMs?
- 7:02What is happening in there?
- 7:03Well, this is the bane of my existence.
- 7:07Who is this person?
- 7:07We gotta like put a boot through the camera and fucking kick him.
- 7:10Come on, man, what's going on?
- 7:11Oh, I mean, so just a bit of backstory.
- 7:13So last year, so just to paint the picture, our, the way that we were doing things was like obviously like new followers, but then really heavy re-engagement.
- 7:22So we were sending out-
- 7:25I mean to hit around 300 messages per day.
- 7:27So we had setters in the account just fucking firing off messages to anyone that they could find.
- 7:32The account's getting shut down, it got blocked a few times.
- 7:35Okay, cool.
- 7:36So we sent out like, last year we sent out like, I don't know, 80,000 messages.
- 7:43And most of those were re-engagement.
- 7:44So one, there was about 1.5% of those outbound messages went through to callers' booking.
- 7:50So it looked really, really bad.
- 7:53But then this year, we haven't done that as much yet.
- 7:56It's still really bad, so that's definitely a problem.
- 8:00Okay, could be a problem.
- 8:02And I know you guys have had a bit of a niche change recently.
- 8:04Tell us about that.
- 8:05So you've got like 57,000 followers that I was looking this morning.
- 8:08I was looking at landing page, I was looking through your account.
- 8:11Of those, how many do you think are the ideal client?
- 8:19I don't know, it's hard to tell.
- 8:20I mean, so the follow-up, yeah, the follower ads that we've always traditionally run, just like your viral sort of style, calorie comparisons and like, just shit that gets you a lot of followers, but the followers that come through, yeah, obviously, and it's like basically trying to find a needle in a haystack.
- 8:41It's essentially our process that we've always followed.
- 8:44Okay, cool.
- 8:45So you guys, you've got your viral like trending shit and then you're putting boosts behind that and then like it's a fingers crossed thing.
- 8:53Basically, yeah.
- 8:55Okay, cool.
- 8:56All right, cool.
- 8:57So we got some strategic like numbery shit that we need to fix here.
- 9:01Then I'd say there's like a messaging thing as well.
- 9:04So the messaging you've got now isn't translating over to the actual like what you're boosting, is it?
- 9:13Well, we've changed that as of last week.
- 9:17So since we've joined you guys, we've literally just ripped everything up and completely started again.
- 9:22So like the ICP and the messaging and stuff, really, really good.
- 9:25Like Tay spent a lot of time building that out and then I got some ads scripted and they're actually performing quite well.
- 9:31Way more than these things.
- 9:32So in the last couple of weeks, we have pivoted.
- 9:36And the calls were booking much better.
- 9:37And the calls were booking, they're people that actually work.
- 9:40Look at that, that's great.
- 9:42Yeah, so what a lot of people get wrong is they try to boost the viral shit, but the viral shit isn't really like ICP.
- 9:47So the people that come through are not great.
- 9:49So do you have updated stats on like the $2 to $3?
- 9:54Is that like a new cost per follower or is that like old cost per follower?
- 9:59No, it's about the same.
- 9:59Okay, cool.
- 10:01So you've just basically got better people in.
- 10:03Okay, and then the 20% to 25%, is that still, you know, that's the first message reply rate?
- 10:10Um...
- 10:13Yeah, it's about that.
- 10:14That's okay.
- 10:15Okay, sweet.
- 10:16It's about that.
- 10:16It hasn't jumped up massively.
- 10:19Okay, cool.
- 10:19So messaging's fixed now, which is great.
- 10:21Okay, let's go further down.
- 10:23And then in terms of when you get on the call, what's the show rate on the call and then what's your close rate?
- 10:31So the show rate is about 60 to 70%.
- 10:35I'll tell you exactly what it is for this year.
- 10:38So for the year it's 61%.
- 10:4061%, okay, cool.
- 10:43And then what are you doing to get that show rate to 61% and beyond?
- 10:46Are you doing all the texts and pre-call messages?
- 10:49Are you doing any of that shit?
- 10:52So we have three emails that go out, three texts that go out when they book.
- 11:0024 hours before and then an hour before.
- 11:03And then what I do as well, I'll reach out via WhatsApp and just send them, I guess, an introductory message for me because I'm the one that takes calls and just send them.
- 11:12What I have been sending recently is almost like a, not a VSL, but kind of like, this is what it looks like inside the program, like showing them through the actual coaching software, some meal plans and how it actually works on the inside to give them a bit more context.
- 11:27Okay, sweet, sounds good.
- 11:29And what about the close rate from there?
- 11:31What does that kind of look like typically?
- 11:34So close rate this year is about 38%, 38%.
- 11:4438%, okay, cool.
- 11:46All right, so you guys listening back at home, so we've got a 25% reply rate and then a 1% booking rate.
- 11:54Then we've got a 60 to 70% show rate on the calls and a 38% close rate.
- 11:58If we had to double any of those metrics, and I'm curious to hear what you guys are thinking, what is the easiest metric to double out of all of those?
- 12:06Is it the reply rate, 25%?
- 12:09Is it the 1% of people that book a call?
- 12:10Is it the 60 or 70%?
- 12:12show rate or is it 38% of people that buy?
- 12:15I think it's the response rate.
- 12:20Yeah.
- 12:20Would be the easiest.
- 12:22Response rate or the one or 2%.
- 12:25So if you doubled either of those, you guys would double your business and you'd go from 30 or 40K a month now to 60 or 80K a month.
- 12:31So you'd be pretty close to 100K if we just doubled that one metric.
- 12:35So a lot of people think that, you know, scaling a business is like, you gotta change all this crazy shit at once.
- 12:40And you gotta shut down the funnel, you know, run a call funnel, run a webinar, run all this other shit.
- 12:44And really it's just about fixing like a single metric.
- 12:47And that's what we're talking about here.
- 12:49So let's get into the actual plan if you guys don't mind.
- 12:51Cause I've got, well, we've got four problems, but we'll focus on one problem for now.
- 12:56So what is the like, what is the sell by chat sequence?
- 12:59Like tell us about, let's get into the nitty gritty of this.
- 13:01What does this actually look like?
- 13:04So this has gone through probably a thousand iterations in the past.
- 13:09So basically what we do is the opening message is, hey, thanks for the follow.
- 13:13We try and pick something off the profile.
- 13:15So like, oh, I see that you went on a holiday recently.
- 13:18Where was it?
- 13:19Or your dog's really cute.
- 13:23What's its name?
- 13:23Or just as an example, trying to pick off something personal from the page.
- 13:27If you can't do that, then it's like whereabouts you're from.
- 13:30Just something really- Personal connection, cool.
- 13:33Then from there, it's like, you know, responding to whatever they've said, and then it's been like, you know, what made you hit follow, basically.
- 13:40And then from there, it's like, okay, cool.
- 13:42Are you working on any goals?
- 13:44And then it's into like, you know, what are your struggles?
- 13:46What have you tried?
- 13:48You know, why is now important for you?
- 13:50And then essentially, it's just making an offer for help.
- 13:52Like, hey, you know, it sounds like we can help you with this.
- 13:55Are you interested in getting some help?
- 13:57And then making the call offer, look at the goal.
- 14:00Okay, cool.
- 14:01And typically are these just like super cold people?
- 14:05Yeah, essentially they're just the new followers that come through.
- 14:08Okay.
- 14:09And is there any other nurture than that?
- 14:11Like are you extending them off to anything like warm?
- 14:13Like so in terms of like what, check out this podcast episode or watch this VSL or like any of that?
- 14:20Not really, we kind of shoot our shot.
- 14:22And if they're in a book, then we put them into like a re-engagement pipeline.
- 14:27And the re-engagement pipeline is kind of the senders know to message at certain time points.
- 14:32So it might be like three weeks later, a month later sort of thing.
- 14:37So we go back to them and re-engage.
- 14:39But outside of that, there's nothing that really gets done in terms of like sending them stuff.
- 14:44Yeah, okay, cool.
- 14:45I think the easiest thing here to take this, you know, like booking rate from one to 2% is just sending them content throughout this period of like long form stuff.
- 14:53This could be like podcast episodes, this could be VSLs, this could be you guys getting interviewed on other stuff, this could be YouTube videos, this could be literally anything.
- 15:00So Google have the 7-11-4 principle that prospects need seven hours of content produced over 11 touchpoints in four mediums.
- 15:08So not just like Instagram DMs.
- 15:10This is like emails.
- 15:11This is WhatsApp.
- 15:11This is all the different touchpoints that you have to create like a, well, not a parasocial relationship, but some form of relationship with people here.
- 15:18So I think that would tremendously help.
- 15:20So if you think about it, like Sam, you and I going on a date might be a little weird, but like if we actually went on a date and you were just like taking me through the process, going for a home run, like, and we just met.
- 15:30I feel like the kind of relationship or the kind of girl or guy you'd attract there would probably not be one that you wanna date long term, you know, so you can see why that doesn't work super well for you.
- 15:40I would add that in and I think that would take the, a lot higher.
- 15:45In terms of this like opening message, let's focus on this.
- 15:48So it's literally just like pick something off their profile and if not where you're from?
- 15:54Yeah, pretty much.
- 15:55Yeah, okay, cool.
- 15:56And that's text?
- 15:59Yeah.
- 16:00Yeah, okay, cool.
- 16:01You could try like a
- 16:03like a thumbs up photo, you could do some pre-recorded voice stuff, you could do pre-recorded videos as well.
- 16:09That works extremely well.
- 16:12Or you could have, it's off Taylor's account, so you could have Taylor just go and do all the openers.
- 16:17So someone could script it out, I'm not talking every single opener, but some because if you, you would get like way more replies if Taylor was like voice dropping like, hey babe, like whatever she would say, like great to connect with you.
- 16:28I think that would work super well for the open rate as well, so the opener.
- 16:33So there are two on how I would fix both of those.
- 16:36And then we've got the show rate is not a major issue.
- 16:40Talk to me about the show rate here, Sam.
- 16:42So you're establishing a relationship with them on WhatsApp and they are just no showing or they're canceling?
- 16:49What's kind of happening there?
- 16:51We don't.
- 16:53We don't get that many no shows.
- 16:55No, it's pretty much just canceling.
- 16:57So.
- 17:00We've got a question on the application form, like do you need to speak to someone before making a decision?
- 17:05If they say I need to speak to someone, I mean, it's always around money.
- 17:09So what I basically do in the WhatsApp message is be like, hey, just so you and your hubby can have that chat beforehand, this is the cost per week.
- 17:16Yeah.
- 17:16Sometimes they come back and they'll say, yep, that's sweet.
- 17:19Other times they come back and say, no, it's not too much.
- 17:23So that's something that's been happening.
- 17:25But yeah, outside of that, I mean, people just cancel.
- 17:29Okay.
- 17:30Yep.
- 17:30That's cool.
- 17:31You kind of want people to cancel and not just show up and like waste your time anyway.
- 17:34So I don't think this is bad.
- 17:36Honestly, those first two metrics will change your business if you improve both of those.
- 17:40I think that'll be like crazy for you guys.
- 17:42Just to give you guys a lot of sauce today because that was like very easy.
- 17:47So what's kind of next from here?
- 17:49Like what are you guys working on outside of this?
- 17:51Like the sales nitty gritty on the front end?
- 17:56Well, I guess, I mean, it's been building out all, like, essentially we've rebuilt the program.
- 18:02You know, we've used all the stuff that you guys have given us in terms of the GPTs to build out like the avatar handbooks and all that sort of stuff.
- 18:09So, it's obviously the messaging side of things where we're upgrading the program itself based on the new mechanism, again, from those GPTs, which is really cool.
- 18:18So, we're in the process of building that.
- 18:19So, it's going to be a really good client experience.
- 18:25I've been getting all the backend selling systems set up as well.
- 18:29We haven't got to that point yet, but I really want to do that.
- 18:35And then I guess from there, it's kind of just, if we are to introduce a new funnel, just getting that set up and rolling.
- 18:43Getting that rolling.
- 18:43Okay, epic.
- 18:45Yeah, so you guys have a VSL call funnel kind of booking at the moment.
- 18:48That's where you book most of your people or is it through DM?
- 18:51So it's all DMs.
- 18:52DMs, yeah.
- 18:53DMs, so no one's hitting that page that I see, or not many people are hitting that page in booking?
- 18:59We've had two.
- 19:02Have you ever had two bookings?
- 19:03We've had one other reply, but she didn't book.
- 19:06And we've only had it up for like not even two weeks.
- 19:09Okay, cool.
- 19:10So probably a little bit early for those.
- 19:12Yeah.
- 19:13So after I would, I'd fix both those things that I said today and I'll send you guys a recording of this so we can get that done before this episode comes out.
- 19:20And then I think a webinar funnel would crush for you guys.
- 19:22Like I think that's the best option.
- 19:24A lot of people in the fitness industry don't want to do it.
- 19:27I don't know if it's like they're scared or it's like a lazy thing.
- 19:31but the opportunity for you guys is if everyone else is not going to do it, you can do it and fucking kill and you can, which is great.
- 19:38So VSL call funnel, I think your, um, your tagline is like 10 to 20 K loss.
- 19:43I think that would just be a really good VSL.
- 19:46Oh, that would be a really good webinar topic just on the outset.
- 19:51Cool.
- 19:51Yeah.
- 19:52All right, guys, uh, questions.
- 19:53What questions do you have in terms of, we found the constraint in my opinion, I think it's sales.
- 19:58Uh, do you have any questions around that?
- 20:03So you said it's getting the open rate up, but also the booking rate as well.
- 20:09Yep, yep, so reply rate and booking rate are the two.
- 20:13What do you recommend for the opening message?
- 20:16Dude, a voice is best or an extremely detailed message.
- 20:21So it depends because you've got a B2C audience, so some of them are on private, which is a little bit more challenging from there.
- 20:28You could start with some value as well.
- 20:30Like honestly, you just need to change it.
- 20:32So a friend of mine, Sean, Sean Ferris, he has a, hey, are you here for the content or for my good looks?
- 20:38Like a bit cheeky, and that does super well.
- 20:41I think it's like 60 or 70%.
- 20:43and then he gets into a chat for them.
- 20:44It's about being creative really, like it's not just like one thing, do this, because they've seen it all, like they've got all these other fitness coaches DMing them.
- 20:54So I think it'd be like, you guys put your heads down and be like, how can we be creative and just put something that they've never seen before there?
- 21:02I mean, could you bang out 50 voice memos?
- 21:04Easy, I could do that like first thing in the morning.
- 21:08I reckon maybe that would be something we could try.
- 21:11We tried doing 11 labs and cloning her voice, but it was like, I don't know.
- 21:15I sounded like I was underwater.
- 21:16It was so bad.
- 21:17I don't know if we're doing it wrong or, cause I know people have success with it, but we just couldn't figure it out.
- 21:24Yeah, it definitely works.
- 21:25You just need a lot of audio in that different audio.
- 21:28Do you guys have a podcast or anything?
- 21:30No, but I started doing YouTube this year.
- 21:34Okay, cool, just export all of those and I think that'll go well.
- 21:37Yeah, if you can get the integration working at 11 labs and just have your VA do it, that would be much better than you having to do it, Tay.
- 21:44Yeah, okay.
- 21:45I mean, we send a voice memo for the follow-up message, so if they don't reply to the open ads, it's like,
- 21:50hey, just letting you know it's me here.
- 21:53It's still generic, you know what I mean?
- 21:55I feel like if it's their name that they hear, it's going to be a lot more like, oh, she's talking to me.
- 22:01Yeah, and especially with your account size as well, they're like, whoa, she's talking to me, she's sending me a message, she said my name.
- 22:07It's very, very, it's kind of fake.
- 22:10Yes, yeah.
- 22:12Yep.
- 22:13Okay.
- 22:15give it a whirl.
- 22:15Yeah, I think we can do that.
- 22:16We'll try 11 labs again, but I think if you can, yeah, if you can send them yourself, it'll make a big difference.
- 22:22Awesome.
- 22:24All right, guys.
- 22:26Sorry, just in terms of like, booking rate, that's obviously, do you, so sending long form content within the chat, is that what you meant?
- 22:34Yeah, for sure.
- 22:35Long form within the chat.
- 22:37Like it's something you wanna test, but if they're coming to you with a problem, say they're like, hey, can't lose weight, struggling for this, got belly fat, like all the shit, you should have resources for that, for the main problem.
- 22:49So you can send it to them, nurture them and then warm them up.
- 22:51I'm assuming Taylor, you're gonna have tons of YouTube content, it's gonna be great.
- 22:55Also a good hack is for your confirmation videos, so if you guys have a confirmation page after someone book, you can put a YouTube video on there, and then as soon as they get on YouTube again, they'll constantly see your stuff, Taylor.
- 23:09So you'll be in the algorithm all the time for them, which is essentially what you want to do.
- 23:14Yeah.
- 23:15Yeah.
- 23:15I'm going to do that.
- 23:18All right, I'll go for a wrap up and we'll wrap this up.
- 23:22All right, guys, thanks for joining us for our first business breakthrough.
- 23:25So this is a bit of a back.
- 23:28So this is a bit of a BTS look into how we run our constraint-based model here at Successful.
- 23:32If you guys are interested in having this done for your business, go to www.startsuccessful.com and book a breakthrough call now and we will chat to you guys soon.
- 23:43Sam, Taylor, it's been great.
- 23:44Thanks, guys.
- 23:46Awesome.
- 23:46Thank you very much, Tim.
- 23:47Thanks for having us, Tim.