Latest / The Freight Buyers' Club / Risks and Opportunities for 2027: FIATA’s Stéphane Graber on Disruption, Protectionism and the New Cargo Document Convention
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker A: Hello, Mike King here at the Freight Buyers Club. We're over here in London at the IAPH World Ports Conference at Olympia and I just want to say before we start. This content is produced with the support of Freight Suite, the modern alternative to legacy TMS platforms. It's a multimodal tms. It was built by forwarders, you know what operators do day to day and it's been transformed with AI. So check out the frictuite.com and as you may have guessed already, I'm here today with Steffen Graber who is the Secretary General of fiata. Stefan, welcome to Freight Buyers Club.
- 0:45Speaker B: Thank you very much Mike.
- 0:47Speaker A: We're here today on. Well, it's quite a day really, isn't it? There's a lot going on. We've just had the midterm US election results, big changes in the us but this is for freight forwarders. We've had a year of disruptions, haven't we? Can you tell me what that's been like for your members?
- 1:03Speaker B: Yeah. So hopefully we can hope that there will be a little bit more predictability going on in the in trade and international trade. But I think something that we need to recognize is that since 2020 we are going from disruption to other disruptions. So uncertainty has become really the new normal in which the logistics operators are operating day to day. And it's also bringing an evolution of their role because from architects of the logistics, they are more and more working as an orchestrator of the global logistics, responsible for managing changing routes, costs, navigating complex regulatory requirements, all kind of short term disruptions. They play a role and what we see is that supply chain resilience, digitalization, regulatory compliance is really completely modifying their role and the value adding they bring. And they are evolving to this responsibility to more than arranging the transport is really to providing integrated supply chain solutions, risk management and strategic advice. Freight forwarder are really becoming the orchestrator of complex globalized supply chains and logistic exo system while acting as a little bit of shock absorber. With all the disruption that we are seeing in the last five years and even if we might expect a little bit more calm on the tax side and change of policy day to day in the US there might be other disruption going on.
- 3:06Speaker A: Just looking at one of those disruptions in the Middle east we've had the closure of the Strait of Hormuz and we've had traffic either going through the Red Sea and the Suez Canal or it isn't. What can a forger do to manage those situations that Maybe a shipper can't do themselves. Maybe an SME shipper.
- 3:20Speaker B: Yeah. So in fact they are really the shock absorber in this kind of disruption because the shipping lines will just declare end of voyage. So the container will end up in a port and it will be to the freight forwarder to deal with it. Generally it's not the port that was expected at destination. The paper are not corresponding. You need to redo the wallpaper work. You need to find a way to bring the containers to its final destination. So today there are two areas. First, acting in urgency and trying to ensure that the cargo is continuing to fleeing and reaching the destination. But also it's working on bringing more optionality in the supply chain, so helping to build this resilience of the supply chain, working on new corridors, different corridors approach. And that's what our members are doing now. They are visiting different places, trying routes that they are not sure if it works or not to see if that could be an alternative. So really exploring, developing corridors, multimodal corridors, because multimodality is also becoming very essential. You cannot only rely, even if maritime shipping is the majority in volume of the movement of cargo. You don't know if suddenly you don't need to move on to another mode of transports. So you need multimodality. In the same time, environmental requirements also push for more multimodalities. So we need to invest on these corridors, digital of these corridors. Digitalization is also a very important aspect where freight forwarders have to now integrate in their operation because it allows to reduce the over cost coming from disruption by having more efficiency, using AI for more prediction and anticipation be planned alternative scenarios. So we have a lot of tools today that allows the forwarders to play their role as more an orchestrator and really someone that is bringing value in advising solution to the disruption.
- 5:34Speaker A: Stefan, there's two divergent things in terms of how I see this for forwarders. When I look at things like tariff policy, end of de minimis exemptions. We've had changes to similar systems in the eu. There's a lot more emphasis on what the shipper provides to the customs authority wherever you look. And it seems to be accelerating. On the one hand, this lends itself to forwarders providing these solutions, but on the other, are you concerned about the rise of protectionism?
- 6:03Speaker B: Yeah. And that's where there is a huge responsibility, in fact, for association like FIATA when they work for their members. For trade forwarders, freight forwarders are in the middle of the system with different actors and with the rise of this protectionism, it is even more important today to be able to collaborate and exchange with the other stakeholders in the supply chain. And that's where the role of association, like fiata, like iaph, like other organization, is very important. Because we are the one that can help to link and ensure that the system continue to work. Because finally we are not in politics, protection is more linked to politics. We are in moving goods beyond borders, across different countries, different regimes. And when some are closing up to international trade, others are opening up and trying to attract it to them. So at the end, what we need is to collaborate together in order to move goods from this origin port or origin factory to the destination. And for that, today, in such a complex environment, with also new measure of protectionism, we need to connect the dots. We need to help having the right regulation, trying to work together with others to try to ensure that we are not hindering completely the flows. And that's where this collaboration is so important. And it's also so important because there is the tariffs, there is the regulation and the compliance with these regulations, but there is also digitalization, there is also sustainability and decarbonization. And this will not be achieved by IAP or fiat alone. This is a challenge that is brought to the supply chain as a whole. And even if we are very fragmented, someone needs to bridge the different actors and try to bring solutions that we can make evolve our supply chain together in the right direction. And I think the freight forwarders and FIAT has a special responsibility here because we are the one that are sitting in the middle of everyone. We are interacting with air freight, with maritime, with rail, with customs. We are playing an important role, being the only logistic voice present in all these international organizations from imo, icao, un, wto. So we can really take this responsibility to lead this collaboration and the work together in order to help evolve our supply chain. And there will be time where we will move to more global trade and less protection. You hope, you hope that will come again. It's always about cycle.
- 8:57Speaker A: Is this collaboration? Is this what you're talking about? This is the of part. What are some of the key takeaways of why you're here at IAPH port? You've been on a roundtable talking about the use of data at ports. This ties in for shippers and forwarders, right?
- 9:10Speaker B: Yes, definitely. And I think we did an amazing job here because finally at the end there was a good question asked from the ports is why ports need to do that, they don't care. And effectively the port were very long A black box. But yeah, but they have customers, they have users and the freight forwarders and the beneficial, they want to know where is my container, when is ready to pick, when it was cleared, so when can I bring it out to land transportation? We need the ports to provide this information. We need the ports to contribute and it's also in their interest for their management for making more attractive, more competitive. So in reality that's why we need to really go beyond all these silos. And in reality it's very funny because even in freight forwarding we have these silos. When I talk to people that are much more in air freight compared to maritime, they seem to be living in two different world but in reality they are freight forwarders. So it's the same here at our level we need to go beyond this, we need to connect ports with maritime, maritime with icc, the International Chamber of Commerce, with the people in charge of air freight. Because at the end what we need is moving goods from origins to destination.
- 10:34Speaker A: But one of those points then, I mean I sometimes, I don't know, back to the future is the right word, but I feel like I've been covering electronic bills of laden for two decades now. The uptake is what is around about 50% or something, but by banks it's only 20%. So is the finance industry taking its time to catch up with what's going on with your members?
- 10:53Speaker B: Why
- 10:53Speaker A: is it so slow?
- 10:54Speaker B: Yeah, it's interesting but I think for the banks the challenge is probably the biggest because they are finally they have to finance. So the risk aversion is quite high because there are financial risk linked to the financing, but also because they are also experiencing all this fragmentation that freight forwarder also have and they have not the possibility because of their system and security of their system to interconnect with every platform existing in the world. So I think today what we see is that we recreated in digital ecosystem the same island, digital islands and silos that we have in paper. And that is not the future. And FIATA was really from the beginning saying no, we are not here to create a platform, we are here to help the industry. So let us know what you need from us and from there we will provide the part what we can provide. But it's not a platform for banks. Probably today it's a little bit difficult because they are conservative, they have a lot of risk, they should interconnect with all these different proprietary platforms and they need probably to receive the support of the whole ecosystem in order to address their challenges and help them to move to this digitalization.
- 12:13Speaker A: Do we need FIATA when we have AI? I mean, I think you talked about it at your convention earlier this year. How can you use AI for dispute resolution? But does this help? Could this potentially get rid of some of these silos? Is that one of the ways you look at it? And what part does AI play in terms of transforming the forwarder in that respect?
- 12:34Speaker B: Yeah, I think AI is only as good as the people that use it. So at the end, the most important things remain the people and the decision making remains with the people that have the expertise. So I think today AI can really help in automatization, in simplification, even in interoperability. It's helpful we discuss a lot about AI and we will discuss about AI in arbitrary where it can really allow to reduce the cost of arbitration as AI can reduce and optimize logistics to reduce the cost of logistics. But at the end, when you are facing some challenges and our business and the role of a freight forwarder is not to enter data in 100 different system re enter search for the information. His role is to develop solutions. His role is to help the goods to move and to address when there is a bottleneck or where there is a problem. And that AI will not that is a human being with his expertise that will do with the help and the assistance of AI. So I think we need not to lose the understanding that AI is a fantastic support. But AI is only a support to human beings having the expertise and collaborating.
- 13:55Speaker A: Just as we're finishing up, Stefan, can we get what's the three biggest risks for 2027 for forwarders and their customers and three biggest opportunities
- 14:02Speaker B: so
- 14:03Speaker A: you can do one if you would prefer.
- 14:05Speaker B: The risk is difficult. I think risk,
- 14:07Speaker A: there's plenty of those.
- 14:08Speaker B: It's more. I think we will have challenges, we will continue to see disruption, we will continue to see a shift in routes and events happening because of geopolitical. So I think freight forwarders needs to remain adaptable, needs to have contingency plan, needs not to be too dependent on certain business models because that could become very dangerous for their sustainability. There is challenges in adoption of technology because it has cost in its knowledge. They not necessarily come from this world, the digital world. So we still are working with a generation that has a fantastic expertise, but probably less used to the digital ecosystem. So again here a lot of challenges, but I would not say risk. It's just challenges we need to tackle down and opportunities. I think there are plenty of them to
- 15:09Speaker A: the flip side of risk, aren't they?
- 15:11Speaker B: Yeah. If you take the negotiable cargo document convention that was just signed in Accra two weeks ago, you said you talk about efbl, you hear bill of lading for many years, I'm
- 15:23Speaker A: lung in the tooth.
- 15:25Speaker B: So I think now not only we have digital bill of ladings, fiat bill of lading, multimodal one, but they are also reinforced by this new negotiation, Cargo documents. Nobody 10 years ago would have imagined that this new convention will be there. This convention is really important because it allows to get the benefits of negotiable cargo documents to other mode of transport that maritime, so rail road. It was very much pushed by China because China has all the rail transport from Asia to Europe. But in reality it is a huge, it opens a huge opportunity for the freight forwarding industry in accessing finance from the banks, traditional trade finance of legal certainty and the usage of a unique document for transport from origin to destination. So I think probably I see the NCD convention as really one of the biggest opportunities for the next month. FIATA is very happy to this development because we were serving the UN in developing and testing the new convention because we have the, the only negotiable cargo documents existing today, which is the fiat multimodal bill of leading. The convention also has an aspect that is less known is the adoption of electronic documents. So it's very much backed on the model law for electronic transferable records, which is very interesting because it will help to have a better acceptance of electronic documents and electronic bill of leading, which is something that is a little bit on the side. We were talking lot of negotiability but in reality that will be probably one of the also biggest opportunities that we have for the state that are signing this convention to adopt electronic documents. And I think it's also a huge opportunity for landlocked countries. We have today still a lot of challenges in landlocked countries and here we have the possibility to have a convention that will allow them to leverage their logistics role to reinforce their transit role in logistics. So a lot of opportunities for them for development thanks to a better framework that give them a little bit more competitiveness compared to non landlocked countries.
- 17:59Speaker A: Stefan Graber, thank you very much for joining me today on the Freight Buyers Club.
- 18:04Speaker B: Thank you very much. It's a pleasure. Thank you Mike
- 18:07Speaker A: and thank you all for listening. If you're watching, apologies if the light is rather fierce on my head. Let's call it a tribute to the late and great Patrick Stewart who sadly passed away recently. Very one of one of the UK's greatest actors. And just a quick word at the end here. A big thanks to Freight Suite, the modern alternative to legacy TMS platforms. A multimodal TMS built by forwarders, you know, operators do, and transformed by AI. Check out Freight Suite.com Please subscribe to the Freight Buyers Club wherever you get your podcasts. We'll have more coverage from IPH in the next week few weeks, so please tune in.