Latest / Consumerpedia / 36 - Dark Patterns: Sales Tactics Designed to Deceive
Transcript
- 0:01We all understand how marketing Works companies.
- 0:04Try to persuade us to buy their product or service, but
- 0:07sometimes they use tricky design techniques or psychological
- 0:10tactics to make the sale such as pre checkboxes, it obligate us
- 0:15to more than we bargained for hard to find as closures and
- 0:18confusing cancellation policies. They're called Dark patterns and
- 0:22is more Commerce moves online, they're growing in scale and
- 0:25sophistication. So you need to know about them.
- 0:28I'm her voice. Mom the Omer man, a contributing
- 0:31editor at checkbook. Dot-org, welcome to Consumer
- 0:33pedia at checkbook, dot-org where the nonprofit that helps
- 0:37consumers select Services, avoid trouble and save money because
- 0:41we don't accept any advertising or take money from any business.
- 0:44We recommend you can rely on checkbook, dot-org to be
- 0:47completely independent and objective.
- 0:50Now, here's the host of consumer pedia America's consumer expert
- 0:54the consumer man, herb Weiss pom, dark patterns, they're
- 0:57designed to deceive to obscure. A consumer choice and decision,
- 1:01making some dark patterns. May violate the law.
- 1:05A recent report from the Federal Trade Commission, shows how
- 1:07companies are increasingly using these sophisticated dark
- 1:10patterns. Let's find out what's going on
- 1:13and how to protect yourself? Sam Levine is head of the ftc's
- 1:17Consumer Protection. Bureau, he joins us from Hefty,
- 1:20see headquarters in the nation's capital.
- 1:22Hi there Sam, thank you for being with us again.
- 1:24Great to be here herb, you know, dark pattern is a, might be a
- 1:28new charm too. Many of your Listeners.
- 1:30But I'm sure it's not a new experience for them.
- 1:33So if you find a dark pattern that appears to be illegal, you
- 1:36sue, the company you did that with Vonage, the internet phone
- 1:39company alleging. It use dark patterns to hide
- 1:41junk fees, and make it difficult or impossible for customers to
- 1:44cancel and in November bondage settled that lawsuit by agreeing
- 1:47to refund a hundred million dollars to Consumers and change
- 1:50their business practices. Tell us more about what varnish
- 1:52was doing. Yeah, I think our action against
- 1:55Vonage makes clear just how seriously we take this problem
- 1:59as you. Ancient heard the company is
- 2:01paying 100 million dollars that we're going to be returning to
- 2:04Consumers, who were victims of some of these practices.
- 2:08What we allege in our complaint. And I suspect this is going to
- 2:11be familiar to Consumers. Whether they have been customers
- 2:14advantage or not is among other things Advantage, made it very
- 2:17easy for consumers to enroll in that service.
- 2:21And very difficult for consumers to cancel one of our blog posts
- 2:24on the top, it describe this like the hotel California just
- 2:28to take one example, we age that Vonage required canceling
- 2:32customers to speak to a live retention agent.
- 2:35Over the phone, they could only call the live retention agent
- 2:39during limited working hours. Also alleged, in our complaint,
- 2:42they made it difficult for consumers to find the contact
- 2:45information so that they could cancel the service and companies
- 2:49use a whole host of techniques to try to prevent consumers from
- 2:53easily canceling their service, and what's frustrating about it,
- 2:57heard in addition to being frustrating for the consumer, I
- 3:00know that companies can make it easy because we know how easy it
- 3:03is to enroll in these services. Companies have gotten very good
- 3:07at making, it very easy for consumers to sign up for
- 3:10services in a seamless way and what were telling companies is
- 3:14you should apply that same know how to make it just as easy for
- 3:18consumers to cancel services that they no longer want, you
- 3:21have to call up to cancel. Any are on hold for 20 minutes
- 3:24or an hour or something like that and they really make it
- 3:26inconvenient for people to say I don't want this service anymore.
- 3:29Exactly. Exactly.
- 3:30And we know they have the capability in most instances for
- 3:34consumers to cancel online. We actually put it a policy
- 3:37statement at the end of 20 21 where we made clear.
- 3:41The company should make it as easy for consumers to cancel
- 3:44Services as it is to enroll, but we know that this remains a
- 3:48problem and that's why we brought a high-profile action
- 3:50against Vonage. We've brought a high-profile
- 3:52action against Credit Karma for other forms of dark patterns and
- 3:56there's going to be continued aggressive enforcement work by
- 3:59the FTC. To get this message across the
- 4:01dark patterns will not be tolerated when they harm
- 4:04Consumers. Credit Karma is such a big name.
- 4:06Everybody's heard about that. Can you give us some idea of
- 4:09what the FTC allege? They were doing the dark
- 4:11patterns involved there. Sure.
- 4:12So Credit Karma is not a case about cancellation.
- 4:15It's about another technique that we see what credit karma is
- 4:19accused of doing is telling consumers, based on testing,
- 4:22they had done that. Showed this was effective,
- 4:25telling consumers, they've been pre-approved for credit offers
- 4:29when in fact, They had not been pre-approved for credit.
- 4:31Offers might be a legitimate, our complaint.
- 4:34Is that credit Carmen knew that this practice would drive
- 4:37consumers to pursue the offer, you know, regardless of the fact
- 4:40that many of them actually, had not been pre-approved.
- 4:43We did something quite unique in that case that I hope other
- 4:46companies, pay attention to Consumers, did not directly lose
- 4:50money from the practices, we alleged, but it did waste their
- 4:53time and what we were able to secure in that case is 1.3
- 4:58million dollars. Excuse me.
- 4:59Three million dollars for consumers, who lost time, at
- 5:03time is money, we recognize that, and we want to make sure a
- 5:07that companies are paying a price for engaging in these
- 5:09practices and be that consumers can see some compensation.
- 5:13When their time has been wasted, or when their money has been
- 5:16wasted, there are lots of dark patterns, but there are four key
- 5:18ones. The FTC is identified.
- 5:20Let's go through them one at a time, techniques that mislead,
- 5:22consumers and disguise Ed. So this dark pattern includes
- 5:26advertisements that are made to look like independent editorial
- 5:29content. Tent again, this is not a new
- 5:32issue. We've had cases decades ago
- 5:34around companies, for example, on television, having doctors
- 5:38advertised products when they're actually being paid, but digital
- 5:41Commerce in the digital environment, is creating many
- 5:44more opportunities for this type of deception in an environment.
- 5:48That's far, more immersive and that's making consumers more
- 5:51susceptible to deception. So this is indeed a major
- 5:53concern. Another trick in this category
- 5:56is comparison shopping sites, that claim to be neutral but
- 5:59really When companies based on compensation, there is a lot of
- 6:02that going on. There is a lot of that going on
- 6:05there. Also, we brought cases against
- 6:07companies like lend edu. There were accused of engaging
- 6:10in this kind of practice, it's basically pay-for-play top ten
- 6:14colleges. If you want to be a nurse top
- 6:1610, winter, jackets, whatever, and you think it's an objective
- 6:20ranking and actually, it's companies paid to be on that
- 6:23list and it's manipulative is disclosure enough.
- 6:27If the website said we get paid for Rankings or paid by the
- 6:31people. We raided does that take care of
- 6:32this or not, not necessarily, we've brought cases where
- 6:36companies have somewhere on their website include
- 6:39disclosures, but companies can, in fact, use dark patterns to
- 6:42conceal disclosures. They can put disclosures and
- 6:46fine print that can put it sort of, with a gray background.
- 6:49So they're hard to read all of us.
- 6:51I'm confident all of your listeners have been to websites
- 6:54where they see disclosures, where they need to put on their
- 6:56glasses to read it and maybe they still can't read it and
- 6:59maybe It won't read it because there's so much text.
- 7:02So disclosures certainly can help companies need to disclose
- 7:06if they're engaging these types of practices but they are
- 7:09necessary, but not sufficient. We've seen disclosures all the
- 7:12time. It's simply don't actually
- 7:14apprised consumers of what's going on, and here's one of
- 7:17checkbooks favorites. Countdown timers designed to
- 7:20make you believe, you only have a limited time to purchase a
- 7:22product or service when the offer is still available.
- 7:25Well, after the timer runs out. Yeah, that's exactly right.
- 7:28You go to these websites. Sites and you see a clock in the
- 7:32corner, it's ticking the offers about to end.
- 7:35You feel like you're in one of these action movies were bombs
- 7:38about to explode? You know, the reality of course
- 7:41is that most companies don't have offers the last 60 seconds
- 7:45or 60 minutes or whatever. But companies know that creating
- 7:49the sense of urgency creating you know this is sort of related
- 7:52to sense of scarcity that this is the last product or that
- 7:55were, you know, running out of inventory.
- 7:57It has a psychological effect on people.
- 7:59Makes people think, oh, I better buy the product.
- 8:02Now that can certainly be deceptive because again, in most
- 8:05cases, there is not an inspiring offer and often this sense of
- 8:09scarcity is also false checkbook that investigation we found that
- 8:13was some hotels or was some online travel agencies.
- 8:16They put like one room left at this price or something.
- 8:18When in fact, we check several days later and there were many
- 8:21more rooms available. They were just giving this false
- 8:24sense of scarcity. That would be a dark pattern as
- 8:26well, right? I think it would be.
- 8:27And again, what effect does that have?
- 8:29Have the consumer sees that and says, oh shoot.
- 8:32I'd better book the room. Now, even if I'm not yet ready
- 8:36to make the call, so this really does have a distorting effect on
- 8:40the marketplace bad for consumers, bad for companies
- 8:43that are more honest. All right, let's move on to dark
- 8:45pattern. Number 2 hiding the fact that
- 8:48you're signing up for a subscription service and then
- 8:50making it difficult to cancel the subscription or stop.
- 8:53The charges boy, is that one that people run into all the
- 8:56time? Absolutely, we've been very
- 8:59aggressive. Notice the 100 million dollar
- 9:01action against Vonage. Where we allege that the company
- 9:04made it nearly impossible for consumers to cancer their
- 9:07services. We also issued a policy
- 9:09statement and 2021 where we said companies need to make it as
- 9:12easy for consumers to cancer Services as it is to enroll.
- 9:16But again we know that companies continue to engage in these
- 9:20practices and my message to companies is that if they
- 9:23continue to use tricks and traps to prevent people from
- 9:27canceling, their services to trap them in.
- 9:29Versus they don't want or trick them in a way that prevents them
- 9:33from canceling. We are prepared to hold them
- 9:35accountable Vonage, paid a hundred million dollars.
- 9:38I hope that sends a strong message to these companies that
- 9:41these practices won't be profitable.
- 9:43And if consumers do encounter issues and canceling their
- 9:46services, go to ftc.gov and tell us about it report the company
- 9:52to the FTC, that's the best way to ensure that we can hold these
- 9:56companies accountable. You know, a lot of times this
- 9:58starts with a free or risk. A trial offer, which sounds
- 10:01great. No obligation.
- 10:02But as you found in the case of ABC Mouse, it's easy to get the
- 10:07free trial and maybe not so easy to cancel.
- 10:09Yeah, exactly. An ABC Mouse.
- 10:11I believe that was a 10 million dollar case, where, once again,
- 10:15very easy to sign up, this was an educational online education
- 10:18company and then an absolutely hellish as we allege in the
- 10:22complaint cancellation process, where consumers have to jump
- 10:26through all sorts of Hoops to try to get their service.
- 10:29Canceled, this makes consumers absolutely miserable depending
- 10:34on the facts. It can also be illegal and
- 10:36that's what we've made clear through our action against the
- 10:38ABC Mouse through our action against Vonage through our
- 10:41policy statement. And we're going to continue to
- 10:43get that message out both to Consumers and to businesses and
- 10:46as I know you're aware and for me talking to victims in many
- 10:49cases, if the risk free trial offer is from a con artist from
- 10:53scammers, you sign up for the risk-free trial and all of a
- 10:55sudden you're signed up for all this other stuff that you can
- 10:58unsubscribe to. So you got to be real.
- 10:59Careful, who you're giving your credit card number out to.
- 11:01Yeah, that's absolutely right. We've seen many I've been
- 11:05involved in cases exactly of that.
- 11:07Nature were scammers say they're signing you up for credit
- 11:11monitoring. When it's actually something of
- 11:13a very different nature or you sign up for the service and the
- 11:17scammer. Sells your information,
- 11:18including your payment information to other scammers
- 11:21who then compound the harm by preying on you themselves.
- 11:25You know credit cards are wonderful thing, online payments
- 11:28are wonderful thing they make Ament a lot easier, but they
- 11:31also make scamming a lot easier because it allows companies to
- 11:35set up. These recurring charges that are
- 11:37very lucrative but that often are without consumers consent.
- 11:41And that's why we're being so aggressive in this space.
- 11:44So here's a dark powder, that's becoming more common junk fees,
- 11:48you agree to a price and when you get the bill you find extra
- 11:51charges tacked on. We're going to talk to Sam about
- 11:53that. Next, this is consumer pedia
- 11:56powered by checkbook. Dot-org.
- 11:59If Like what you hear, we hope you'll consider being a consumer
- 12:02PDS supporter by using the link at the bottom of the show notes
- 12:05to make a small contribution each month.
- 12:08This is consumer pedia. We're going over four key dark
- 12:12patterns. We've already covered one
- 12:14techniques that mislead consumers and disguise ads, and
- 12:18to hiding the fact that you're signing up for a subscription
- 12:20service and then making it difficult to cancel dark
- 12:23pattern. Number three, hiding junk fees,
- 12:26here's how that works. A company will advertise only
- 12:29part of a Ducks total price to lure you in and they don't
- 12:32mention other mandatory charges until late in the buying
- 12:35process. Sam.
- 12:36Tell us more about that. Most consumers.
- 12:38I suspect have encountered something like this.
- 12:41You see an ad for a product says it's 45 dollars.
- 12:45You get excited. That's the price you want.
- 12:48You do some comparison shopping, you see?
- 12:50It's the lowest price. I you begin the process of
- 12:53making the purchase. You go through a number of
- 12:55screens. You enter your payment
- 12:57information, your shipping information.
- 12:59Sign up for our email list, etc, etc.
- 13:01And then at the very end they say oh by the way, there's a
- 13:04four dollar and fifty cents handling fee, there's a
- 13:07five-dollar storage fee, there's a six dollar, you know, they
- 13:11tack on these fees at the very end and by that time consumers
- 13:15have already turned over their information, they've gone
- 13:18through this lengthy process and many of them.
- 13:21Even if they're frustrated, might just say, you know what?
- 13:23Forget about it even though this is no longer the lowest price,
- 13:26I'm just going to agree because there's already a sign cause
- 13:29Cause I certainly understand why consumers do that but it's
- 13:32unfortunate because what these companies that have done is
- 13:37taken more money from consumers than they actually were willing
- 13:40to pay. So, one of the messages were
- 13:41sending through our report and through our enforcement actions
- 13:44is that companies should be upfront about the price.
- 13:46They're charging. That's not only good for
- 13:49consumers. It allows companies to compete
- 13:51on price on the real price rather than a basically a teaser
- 13:56price that isn't real. That's a really important issue.
- 13:59One that Sumer, Advocates are dealing with right now, trying
- 14:01to get the d-o-t to come up with some regulations.
- 14:03Is a fact that if you're do search engine prices for things
- 14:06various things could be are fair or whatever, and one has a fee
- 14:09and one doesn't the one with the fee.
- 14:11Looks every bit as good or better than the one that does
- 14:14have the fee, you have no idea what your bottom line price is
- 14:17going to be, that's to me, that's misleading or deceptive.
- 14:19That's exactly right. And, you know, airlines are as
- 14:22your reference are in the department of transportation's
- 14:24jurisdiction. Not ours, how about we brought
- 14:26cases in this area to just to name one, we brought a major
- 14:29Action Against The Lending Club, which is a company, probably
- 14:32many of your listeners are familiar with.
- 14:33And it for exactly, this is what we alleged is that they hid fees
- 14:38that consumers probably did not see during the application
- 14:42process, and they kind of buried the mention of these fees until
- 14:45much later in the application process.
- 14:47Maybe the consumer didn't see it at all.
- 14:50Maybe they saw, but it was already too late.
- 14:52That company ended up paying I believe, 10 million dollars
- 14:55companies that do this and think it will juice their profits.
- 14:59I certainly Stand by they might think that but they can expect
- 15:02to hear from us and they can expect to pay a price because in
- 15:05many cases, this type of practice is deceptive and it's
- 15:08illegal and dark pattern number for maybe the most troubling
- 15:12one. Tricking consumers into sharing
- 15:14data this is hugely problematic. We know that data is as valuable
- 15:20as money from any company's data is valuable for advertising.
- 15:25Data is valuable often for in the political Uncle contents
- 15:30data is valuable for lenders who might want to be able to profile
- 15:33consumers. And we know that companies are
- 15:36eager to get as much data from consumers as they can as much
- 15:40personal information from consumers as they can.
- 15:43So, one of the things they might do is use dark patterns to treat
- 15:46consumers into turning over more personal information than they
- 15:49think, they are turning over. We brought a case against just
- 15:53to name one example, against like smart TV manufacturer
- 15:56called Vizio. And what we allege is if the
- 15:58company in Able to default setting called smart
- 16:01interactivity, which supposedly enable consumers to receive
- 16:05program offers and suggestions. But behind the scenes, while we
- 16:09alleges that vizier was actually collecting and sharing
- 16:12consumers, television, viewing habits with third parties.
- 16:16We don't want companies tricking consumers into turning over
- 16:21their money without their consent.
- 16:23And we feel just as strongly that companies cannot trick
- 16:26consumers into turning over their personal information
- 16:29without out their consent. It's not only a Financial Risk
- 16:32to Consumers. It can harm consumers and other
- 16:34ways for example, compromising their privacy or exposing them
- 16:38to identity theft. We take theft of data just as
- 16:41seriously, as we take theft of money in reading your report,
- 16:44one of the dark patterns in this area was described as giving
- 16:47consumers choices about privacy settings, or the data that
- 16:51shared. But this is really designed to
- 16:53steer consumers towards giving away a whole lot of personal
- 16:55information. That's exactly right.
- 16:57For example, I think we use this.
- 16:59Example in the report companies might tell users that they're
- 17:03collecting information for one purpose and then use it for
- 17:06another purpose or they might give consumers a choice where
- 17:10they say if you want to participate in the service and
- 17:13you to accept all the terms and conditions and the accept button
- 17:16is bold and pretty and you know, it's in a nice color and
- 17:20consumers want to click and it's really big and then the reject
- 17:23button is small and great out and in small print and what that
- 17:27is. It's a nudge, it's saying And
- 17:29accept me and this is not an accident.
- 17:32These companies do Behavioral Studies to assess.
- 17:34What is more most likely to get consumers to accept their terms
- 17:39and these techniques can work. But again, if consumers are
- 17:42being tricked, if they're turning over data without their
- 17:45consent, or it's being used in a way that they did, not agree to,
- 17:49we're prepared to take action just as we did with Visio and
- 17:52many other cases. So, salmon your mind or what do
- 17:55you make decisions whether to prosecute or not?
- 17:57Is there a difference between like marketing?
- 17:59I mean And it's designed to move product, whether you want it or
- 18:01not, the goal is to get you to buy and honest marketing.
- 18:04And marketing that's doing dark patterns, is tricking.
- 18:07I mean, there's clearly difference, right?
- 18:08It's a really important question, herb.
- 18:10And you're right that all advertising to some extent is an
- 18:13effort to get people to buy a product.
- 18:16But to be clear, you know, the FTC is not against advertising.
- 18:20What the FTC is against is very specific techniques that are
- 18:25designed not to give consumers choices Has, which is the goal
- 18:30of advertising, but to impede consumer decision-making.
- 18:35But to obscure information to make it harder for consumers to
- 18:39choose among products and services to choose what kind of
- 18:42data they want to share. So I think big picture the way I
- 18:45would distinguish honest advertising from the kind of
- 18:48dark patterns. We're seeing, is that honest
- 18:50advertising, added spaced is about giving consumers choices,
- 18:54and giving them an opportunity to buy the product or service
- 18:57that most suits their needs dark.
- 18:59Patterns are about manipulating consumers decision making in a
- 19:03way that can lead them with products or Services, they don't
- 19:06want or leave them having showed data that they didn't want to
- 19:09share. I don't know if this is a dark
- 19:10pattern or not, but I remember when I was at the Newhouse
- 19:13school at Syracuse, shout out to the orange.
- 19:15There was a famous case of Campbell's, Soup putting the
- 19:17marbles in the soup bowl that was shown on the TV commercials
- 19:20because it kicked all the vegetables and the noodles up
- 19:22and it made it look like there was more in the bowl than there
- 19:25really was there was action taken against him with that, be
- 19:27that dark pattern, something like that.
- 19:29But potentially I think one of the things we're seeing is that,
- 19:33you know, there were certainly a long history on television,
- 19:35advertising of that nature where the appearance of food is
- 19:39manipulated often. Now when you look at packages,
- 19:42you see little disclaimers that you know, products been enlarged
- 19:46or it's a serving suggestion. Well, we see though Harbors that
- 19:49these techniques are getting a lot more sophisticated in the
- 19:53digital environment, which is, of course, an interactive
- 19:56environment companies have a lot more.
- 19:59Is to shape consumer Behavior. You know on television a
- 20:03consumers can just change the channel.
- 20:05They don't need to be led through a series of screens
- 20:08online. Marketers, have a lot more
- 20:10control. They can use all of the sort of
- 20:13techniques of Television of sound visual Etc, but they can
- 20:18also design user interfaces in a way that you just can't do
- 20:23through television. I should say that's changing the
- 20:25smart television. We're seeing some of the same
- 20:28problems with Smart TV. He's like I reference Visio that
- 20:31we are with traditional television, but I think the key
- 20:34lesson here is that the digital environment, whether it's on
- 20:36your TV, or your tablet, or your phone, or your computer is
- 20:39making it a lot more easier for marketers to manipulate people
- 20:42than it was under say traditional television.
- 20:45As we've been saying, dark patterns are designed to be
- 20:47sneaky and misleading. So how do you protect yourself
- 20:51from companies? A conduct business.
- 20:52This way, that's straight ahead. This is consumer pedia powered
- 20:56by checkbook. Dot-org consumer.
- 20:59Dear fast facts. The term dark patterns was
- 21:03coined by user experience design, consultant Harry
- 21:06brignall in 2010, his website, dark patterns, dot-org is
- 21:10dedicated to cataloging the various types of dark patterns
- 21:13and calling out companies that use them.
- 21:15Brignall has identified, a dozen types of dark patterns, such as
- 21:19sneak into the basket, where a retailer sneak something into
- 21:22your shopping cart like a warranty, or service plan that
- 21:25runs up the bill unless you catch it and remove it.
- 21:28Yes, the It does make it easier to disguise deceptive designs,
- 21:32but dark patterns such as phony sales and bait-and-switch
- 21:35tactics existed. Well, before the digital age,
- 21:41Sam Levine runs a Consumer Protection Bureau with a Federal
- 21:43Trade Commission. The government agency that goes
- 21:46after businesses that use deceptive dark patterns to trick
- 21:49you Sam, it's clear. The dark patterns are unfair and
- 21:52they're being used more often and companies are getting better
- 21:55at disguising them. So how do we protect ourselves?
- 21:58Well, we provide Two incredibly useful resources at ftc.gov and
- 22:03I encourage your listeners to go to the website.
- 22:06There's a tab right at the top for advice and guidance.
- 22:09We have all sorts of tips on avoiding these patterns and you
- 22:12can also sign up for Consumer alerts where we send regular
- 22:15alerts about the types of all manipulation.
- 22:18We're seeing all that said, I want to be very clear that the
- 22:21onus is not on consumers to protect themselves.
- 22:24These are very sophisticated techniques.
- 22:27The onus is on companies to do not engage in techniques that
- 22:31are deceptive or unfair to not engage in techniques.
- 22:35The lead consumers to lose money when they didn't consent, to
- 22:39lose their personal information when they didn't consent.
- 22:42And many of the other harms we outlined in the report because
- 22:44they're absolutely things that consumers can and should do.
- 22:48But the ftc's expectation, is that companies will comply with
- 22:52the law and not put the onus on their customers to protect
- 22:56themselves. We don't want to see these
- 22:57techniques in the marketplace. Bearded.
- 23:00And while we always assume that the younger generation who grew
- 23:03up in the digital world, knows about all this stuff, it would
- 23:05be a smart idea to talk to the kids or the grandkids or
- 23:08whatever about the tricks that they may experience online
- 23:10because they simply just may not be aware of them.
- 23:13That's absolutely right. We have a workshop on stealth
- 23:16advertising directed to children and many of the researchers said
- 23:19that exactly what you said, even for young people who grew up
- 23:23online digital natives, they may be very good at navigating
- 23:28tick-tock. They might not be so good at
- 23:30distinguishing, for example, between what's an advertisement
- 23:33and wants organic content. So there is a lot even for young
- 23:37people to learn about how these techniques can manipulate them.
- 23:41But I can't stress enough that we are not just asking
- 23:44consumers, especially young people to protect themselves.
- 23:47We were asking companies to be aware of their legal
- 23:50obligations, and to follow them to the letter.
- 23:53I know we're going to be hearing a lot more about dark patterns
- 23:56in the years ahead, Sam. Thank you for taking so much
- 23:59time. To be with us today herb.
- 24:00It's been a pleasure. Well, that's it for this episode
- 24:03of consumer pedia, you can subscribe to us on Apple or
- 24:06Google podcast Spotify, Stitcher or wherever you listen to your
- 24:09podcast. That way you won't miss an
- 24:11episode. Remember we release new ones,
- 24:14every other Thursday, another way you can support this show is
- 24:17to follow us on consumer, pedia on Facebook and Instagram and at
- 24:21my consumer pedia on Twitter, I'm her Weiss bomb.
- 24:25Thanks for listening consumer. Pedia is a public service of
- 24:28checkbook Dot. Org, we're unique nonprofit that
- 24:31helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 24:33You can count on, checkbook to help you find the best services
- 24:36and avoid the worst with local ratings that are accurate and
- 24:40unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 24:43Seven Cities and have enjoying checkbook, yet, check us out
- 24:46Boston. Chicago Philadelphia Seattle,
- 24:50San Francisco, Minneapolis st. Paul and Washington DC to get
- 24:54your free 30-day subscription. Go to check book.
- 24:56Dot org slash consumer pedia if you Like what you've heard?
- 25:00We hope you'll become a supporter by using the link at
- 25:02the bottom of the show notes to make a small contribution each
- 25:05month consumer pedia, empowering consumers to save money and make
- 25:10smarter choices.