Latest / The MaineHealth Podcast / Public Health Grand Rounds hosted by Dr. Dora Anne Mills with guest David A. Higgins, MD
Transcript
- 0:00This is Dr. Dora Ann Mills, Senior Advisor for Public Health at MaineHealth.
- 0:07Welcome to our Public Health Grand Rounds, where about every month we explore a relevant
- 0:12public health topic with national and Maine experts.
- 0:17These Grand Rounds are posted to the MaineHealth podcast channel on Podbean and at MaineHealth.org,
- 0:24where you can hear current and past episodes.
- 0:27Please note that guests' opinions are their own.
- 0:31I'm just thrilled to have Dr. Higgins with us today.
- 0:35David Higgins is a board certified, double board certified, pediatrician and preventive
- 0:40medicine specialist.
- 0:41He's an assistant professor of pediatrics at the University of Colorado School of Medicine,
- 0:47and he sees patients on a regular basis as an attending physician at the Child Health
- 0:51Clinic at Children's Hospital in Colorado.
- 0:55And he brings really a distinctive combination of clinical experience, having practiced in
- 1:00both urban and rural settings in Colorado and Montana, alongside really serious research
- 1:07jobs.
- 1:08So his scholarship focuses on vaccine delivery, communication strategies, and what he calls
- 1:14the science of vaccine confidence.
- 1:17He's published in some of our field's most prestigious journals, including the New England
- 1:22Journal of Medicine, the American Journal of Public Health and Pediatrics, often alongside
- 1:26his collaborator, Dr. Sean O'Leary.
- 1:29A recurring theme in his work is punctuating misconceptions about vaccines, vaccine hesitancy
- 1:36in particular.
- 1:38He's also a board member of Immunize Colorado and has been recognized with the Emerging
- 1:42Leader Award from the Colorado Public Health Association.
- 1:46So at a moment when Maine, like the rest of the country, is navigating real challenges
- 1:51around vaccine confidence, Dr. Higgins really brings to us both the research and the practical,
- 1:58clinical, pragmatic perspective that we need.
- 2:01So please join me in welcoming, and Dr. David Higgins, I usually say, welcome to Maine.
- 2:07You're here virtually with us.
- 2:09So thank you so much for spending your time.
- 2:11I know you're extremely busy and we're just honored to have you with us today.
- 2:16So thank you.
- 2:17And I'm going to pass the baton over to you, Dr. Higgins.
- 2:19Great.
- 2:20Well, thank you so much, Dora.
- 2:21And unfortunately, I'm virtual because I would love to have your weather today.
- 2:26We went backward instead of going into summer with schools ending here.
- 2:31We're back to forties and sleet.
- 2:33I am really excited to be with all of you today and talk about this topic that is obviously
- 2:39front and center for many of you, whether you're a clinician, whether you're a public
- 2:44health professional, you are dealing with this every single day.
- 2:50And what I want to do in the next 60 minutes is I wish in 60 minutes we could solve the
- 2:56problem of low vaccine uptake and leave time for questions and answers.
- 3:01But we're not going to be able to do that.
- 3:03So what I really want to do is give you some practical tips and tools to address hesitancy
- 3:08about vaccines.
- 3:10And I'm going to start first by just saying I have nothing to disclose other than I will
- 3:16say I think vaccines are one of humanity's greatest achievements.
- 3:20If that makes me biased, then so be it.
- 3:23So here's the objectives for today.
- 3:25First, I really want to just briefly describe the current landscape of vaccine preventable
- 3:29disease and explain how federal policy shifts have kind of changed the picture.
- 3:36Now I'm not going to go into a lot of detail on this because I know that most of you on
- 3:40this call and watching today are well experienced in this.
- 3:45You're living this day to day.
- 3:47What I really want to get into is evidence-based communication strategies, not only for individual
- 3:54conversations that you may be having with patients, clients, families, but also communities.
- 4:01And I want to zoom in a little bit, especially for you in Maine, on religious communities
- 4:06and communities that may not be a part of some of your school and child care vaccine
- 4:11requirements.
- 4:13And then finally, like I said, I want to zoom out to the community level and not only talk
- 4:18about individual face-to-face communication about vaccines, but also how do you do it
- 4:23effectively at the level of a community.
- 4:26But we need to start with why this moment matters.
- 4:28We're going to talk a little bit about the return of vaccine preventable diseases, disruptions
- 4:34to vaccine governance at the federal level, and then this low trust environment that we
- 4:38are all operating in.
- 4:42So if I was with you in person, I'd have you raise your hands and tell me how effective
- 4:47is the influenza vaccine that's in these vials right here.
- 4:51And when I give this talk and I'm in person, I get a lot of smart people who say, well,
- 4:56it depends on how well it's matched with the strain that's going around, somewhere between
- 5:0030% in a bad year and 60% effective.
- 5:03The answer is zero.
- 5:06When the vaccine's sitting in these vials, it's 0% effective.
- 5:10And you all know this, right?
- 5:12There's this mantra that we talk about in the vaccine delivery world, that vaccines
- 5:15alone don't save lives, vaccination saves lives.
- 5:19The most incredible vaccine can be created.
- 5:22And if nobody accepts it, it doesn't do anything.
- 5:27So vaccine preventable diseases are back.
- 5:30I have yet to see and treat a case of measles in my career.
- 5:35And I've now been very close and had patients that could have come in and seen me in my
- 5:42community and ended up seeing somebody else in the emergency room.
- 5:48But measles is back.
- 5:50So this is a map of measles cases among residents in 2024.
- 5:54And as you can see, there were cases scattered across the United States.
- 6:00Here's 2025.
- 6:01We are just getting deeper and deeper blue here on this map spread across the United
- 6:06States of measles cases that are occurring in our country.
- 6:12If you look over time at the epidemiologic curve, what you see is that since the late
- 6:191990s, we have had sporadic years where there have been large outbreaks.
- 6:26And most of those have been due to a single large outbreak.
- 6:29Well, 2025 and now 2026, we're seeing larger numbers of measles cases and multiple outbreaks
- 6:38more than we have in several decades.
- 6:40In 2026, we're already up to over 1800 cases.
- 6:44We are easily going to eclipse 2025 numbers for measles.
- 6:50So why does this matter?
- 6:52Well, measles is a unique infectious disease.
- 6:56The are not for measles.
- 6:58That's the number of cases that will occur from one person who's infected, mixing with
- 7:05a community that's vulnerable.
- 7:08The are not is 12 to 18.
- 7:10This is the highest of any vaccine preventable disease.
- 7:14What that means is that in order to protect a community, you have to have a high level
- 7:20of vaccination.
- 7:21We are fortunate that the measles vaccine is incredibly effective.
- 7:25We have some vaccines that are not as effective, but measles vaccine is incredibly effective.
- 7:31And if you get the community vaccination rate up to that 95%, you can actually stop the
- 7:38outbreak in that community.
- 7:41We frequently hear about vaccination rates at the national, state, and sometimes county
- 7:47level.
- 7:48But the reality that you're all living and understand is that measles outbreaks happen
- 7:53at the hyperlocal level.
- 7:55So even if your state has a good vaccination rate, if you have a town, a religious or cultural
- 8:02community that has a very low vaccination rates, they are primed for a serious outbreak
- 8:08if measles comes into that community.
- 8:10The other reason that measles matters is that it's kind of the canary in the coal mine.
- 8:14This is one of the first diseases to return when vaccine coverage begins to erode because
- 8:20of how contagious it is.
- 8:22So it's important.
- 8:24It's important to follow.
- 8:26Now I'm also not going to belabor this point because I could do a whole talk on what's
- 8:28happened over the past year.
- 8:30This is a nice timeline put together by the common health coalition who's doing some fantastic
- 8:35work in this space.
- 8:38And I've been fortunate to collaborate with them on some of this, but this is just a nice
- 8:41simple timeline to remind you all of the things that have happened in the past year.
- 8:46Okay.
- 8:47So the entire advisory committee on immunization practices, the ACIP was fired and reappointed
- 8:55almost overnight with new members, many of whom a federal judge has said were unqualified
- 9:02to serve in that role.
- 9:05And that ACIP voted to remove thimerosal from flu vaccines.
- 9:10They changed several recommendations, including recommendations for the MMR vaccine and for
- 9:15COVID-19 vaccines.
- 9:17In addition to the hepatitis B vaccine series and the birth dose in particular in December
- 9:23of last year, and then bypassing the ACIP altogether, the CDC really at the discretion
- 9:33of HHS leadership revised the childhood immunization schedule, completely bypassed the normal processes
- 9:39and created a tiered schedule, right?
- 9:43With kind of normal risk, high risk and shared clinical decision-making recommendations.
- 9:50Well, in March, a federal judge blocked the changes that occurred to vaccine schedules.
- 9:56And I wish that was the end of the story, but it's not.
- 10:01That case is ongoing and I am not a legal scholar.
- 10:05I will leave that to some of the other fantastic legal scholars that I collaborate with.
- 10:09But that case is not done.
- 10:11And efforts to solidify these changes are also not done.
- 10:15As we saw, the CDC published a new ACIP charter last month, which has since been removed,
- 10:22I believe, as of yesterday, but the saga will continue.
- 10:27I don't have any doubt about that.
- 10:30So what you've seen is professional societies stepping in to fill that gap.
- 10:35And really the American Academy of Pediatrics led the way in that.
- 10:40The AAP has been making vaccine recommendations since the 1930s, so this is not new.
- 10:46But in this case, they have had to step in and fill the void left by the disruption in
- 10:52leadership.
- 10:55And other organizations have come alongside, including the American Academy of Family Physicians
- 10:59and many others that I didn't list on this slide, have come alongside and said, we endorse
- 11:05or support these recommendations.
- 11:08But here's the reality of what we're living in.
- 11:10So this is a figure from Kaiser Family Foundation, KFF, who has done some incredible polling
- 11:15over the past several years on trust and confidence in vaccines and in those that recommend them.
- 11:23And what they have found is that since the start of the pandemic in March of 2020, you
- 11:30have seen a slow and steady decline in trust in the CDC and in federal health agencies
- 11:38regarding vaccines.
- 11:41And that decline has been, we have seen this among both people who identify as Democrats
- 11:48and Republicans.
- 11:50This is true across the political and ideological spectrum.
- 11:53As you can see, the shifts change depending on who the federal administration is.
- 12:00But we are operating in a low trust environment, at least at the level of our institutions.
- 12:07Okay, I'm going to pause there briefly.
- 12:12So the next thing I want to talk about is the vaccine information ecosystem.
- 12:17Now I want to talk about this because I really want to emphasize what your communities, what
- 12:24parents, and what your neighbors are seeing every day.
- 12:28I run into many public health professionals and well-meaning physicians and clinicians
- 12:32who don't always understand just what the people that they interact with every day are
- 12:38really exposed to.
- 12:40So we're going to start by playing a game.
- 12:42The game is 1800s or 2026.
- 12:46So this quote is either from the 1800s or 2026.
- 12:51Vaccination has caused more deaths since its introduction than those caused by war or famine.
- 12:58That's from the 1800s.
- 12:59Okay, the next quote.
- 13:02Vaccination is a method of mass destruction, a method of depopulation.
- 13:08That one is from 2026.
- 13:11The facts, though often suppressed by pro-vaccine activists, have always been accessible to
- 13:17the people who are willing to question them.
- 13:21That's 2026.
- 13:24Vaccination provides no protection.
- 13:27When exposed to infection, people suffer just as much as others.
- 13:32That in fact is from the 1800s.
- 13:36One final one.
- 13:38Vaccine activists are afraid of the search after truth.
- 13:41They fear uncovering errors.
- 13:45That's from the 1800s.
- 13:47So what is my point here?
- 13:48Well, this is my point.
- 13:50Vaccine hesitancy and many of the messages that you or your community see online or spread
- 13:55through their networks right now are not new.
- 13:58They have been around as long as vaccines themselves.
- 14:01This is a picture of a physician administering the cowpox vaccine in 1802.
- 14:06And if you look carefully at the picture, you will notice that people are growing cows
- 14:10out of their body.
- 14:11This is one of the first examples of kind of this concern about vaccines.
- 14:17There's a famous picture called Death the Vaccinator published by the London Society
- 14:23for the Abolition of Compulsory Vaccination in the late 1800s, picturing the physician
- 14:29or clinician here delivering a vaccine and painting them really as being this bringer
- 14:36of death, right?
- 14:37There's this emotional appeal even then.
- 14:41And I love these postcards as an example.
- 14:43So these are postcards from 1896 that were handed out by the National Anti-Vaccination
- 14:48League in the UK.
- 14:53These postcards could absolutely be a social media post in 2026.
- 14:58Do your own thinking.
- 15:00Search what is truth.
- 15:01Who is profiting from vaccines, right?
- 15:05These messages are coming out in social media in 2026.
- 15:09In fact, for my Substack several weeks ago, I created a fake social media post that I
- 15:16intentionally put that this is a historical recreation and not real because I don't actually
- 15:22want it spreading around with these ideas to show this is what we're seeing today.
- 15:27These messages are not different.
- 15:29Okay, but what is different?
- 15:32Well, there are several really important things.
- 15:35So back in the 1800s with the same messages, the reach was a town.
- 15:40People had to bring pamphlets and hand them out in a town.
- 15:43The speed of that took weeks to months.
- 15:46Right now, a post can reach the entire world in seconds.
- 15:52In that time, there was more accountability.
- 15:54Today, you don't even know if that post is from a human being or from AI.
- 16:00There was also more of a shared reality in that time.
- 16:03People in towns and communities and neighborhoods had a more shared reality about everything
- 16:09that they went through in life.
- 16:11Now everyone lives in their custom algorithm.
- 16:14The reality is really determined by the algorithms that feed them information.
- 16:19The amplification of language that's optimized for outrage is incredibly more prescient today
- 16:29than it was in the past.
- 16:32The institutions that were referees for some of this, including things like the CDC, now
- 16:41we are in this low trust environment.
- 16:43That makes it even more difficult to address and referee misleading claims that spread
- 16:50through communities.
- 16:55What is driving hesitancy in 2026?
- 16:57Well, we're going to talk about some of the social and behavioral drivers.
- 17:01We're going to talk about the vaccine hesitancy continuum.
- 17:04And then we're going to talk a little bit about social media.
- 17:07Now I like this framework from the WHO.
- 17:10And I know there are some updated frameworks and there are a lot of different frameworks
- 17:14if you're in this field.
- 17:16But I like this because it's simple.
- 17:18And I like putting things in simple buckets.
- 17:21I'm a simple guy.
- 17:22I like simple buckets.
- 17:23It's not complicated.
- 17:24So there is a motivation, an intention to get vaccines.
- 17:30And that is influenced by multiple different things, thinking, feeling, social processes,
- 17:37social norms.
- 17:38All of these things influence someone's intention to get vaccinated.
- 17:42However, even though I'm not going to talk about this today, in order to move from the
- 17:49intention to get vaccinated to vaccinated, there are a lot of practical issues to overcome.
- 17:55And this is the only slide I'm going to talk about this.
- 17:57But I want you to remember, do not ignore those practical issues.
- 18:01Everyone has a different level of intention to vaccinate.
- 18:06So I, because I love vaccines, I might be willing to drive over two mountain passes
- 18:10in the middle of winter storm and take a day off work because I have a job where I can
- 18:16do that and not lose it in order to get my kids vaccinated.
- 18:20But someone else, they may have the intent to get vaccinated, but they say, there's no
- 18:23possible way I can take off another day of work.
- 18:26I don't think I'm going to have a job if I take off another day of work.
- 18:30And look, keeping this roof over my kid's head is more important than getting their
- 18:35flu vaccine.
- 18:36Right.
- 18:37And so I just want us all to recognize that these practical issues, when you address these,
- 18:43that can overcome so many motivational factors to getting vaccinated.
- 18:51When you make it easier, it's a lot easier to just say yes.
- 18:54Okay.
- 18:55But what we're really focusing on today is what do we do when the vaccines are available?
- 19:00Okay.
- 19:01When they really are truly convenient and available?
- 19:04Well, I want to emphasize that vaccine hesitancy is a continuum.
- 19:10And at the bottom of this continuum, at the bottom of this pyramid, if you will, I really
- 19:15like this figure because the unquestioning acceptors who have no concerns or the cautious
- 19:21acceptors who, you know, maybe they have a question or two, but they're really intent,
- 19:25they intend to get vaccinated.
- 19:27That's a majority of people still.
- 19:30That is the majority of parents.
- 19:31Okay.
- 19:32When you look at the data across multiple studies, multiple surveys, not only the vaccination
- 19:38data, but also intention and survey and poll data, what we find is that most people still
- 19:43want to vaccinate.
- 19:45Okay.
- 19:46And then you have a group that's much smaller, who are concerned enough that they might decide
- 19:52to delay or selectively vaccinate.
- 19:56At the very top of the pyramid, you have people that refuse all vaccines.
- 20:01And what's incredible and a lot of people don't realize is that the number, the percent
- 20:04of children who have never received a single vaccine remains incredibly small, right around
- 20:101% of children have never received a vaccine.
- 20:14And it would be unfair to assume every one of those children who's never been vaccinated,
- 20:21it's all hesitancy.
- 20:22It is possible they face extreme access problems.
- 20:26So the take-home point is that most parents, most family members, most communities are
- 20:33still open to the idea of vaccinating.
- 20:36Even if they have a lot of hesitancy, there's something there.
- 20:39There's a thread that you can pull on.
- 20:42Now there are a lot of reasons for vaccine hesitancy.
- 20:47I have talked in my career to parents about vaccines, I don't know, probably 10,000 plus
- 20:52times now.
- 20:54And each parent has a different specific reason for having concerns or questions about vaccines,
- 21:00but they tend to fall in the same roots of vaccine hesitancy.
- 21:07This is some work from colleagues over at the UK.
- 21:09I just like this model.
- 21:10They talk about two main roots being either fears and phobias or distrust.
- 21:15And I really do see this a lot in my clinical practice.
- 21:19So the fears and phobias can be anything from, you know, I'm worried about side effects
- 21:24to the chemicals in the vaccines, to vaccines cause autism, safety concerns, too many for
- 21:30the immune system.
- 21:31All of those fall into this fears and phobias about something with the vaccine.
- 21:36And then there is this group that has distrust.
- 21:40They either don't trust government, they don't trust healthcare, they're suspicious of people
- 21:46that either are producing, manufacturing, or recommending vaccines.
- 21:52Now when you zoom in a little bit, there are some other roots that are a little bit more
- 21:56specific.
- 21:58Often there's distorted risk perception.
- 22:01We as human beings are not good at risk perception.
- 22:04We like to think that all of us are logical beings, and in fact, we are not purely logical
- 22:10beings.
- 22:11We do not always make decisions based on accurate risk perception.
- 22:14That's all of us.
- 22:17Not just parents or your community.
- 22:20There's also this perceived self-interest.
- 22:23So I saw a lot of campaigns for vaccination really emphasizing, you know, vaccinate your
- 22:29child to protect others.
- 22:32Well, a parent who has a priority of values that says, look, my child comes first, sometimes
- 22:42hears that and says, whoa, you're asking me to put my child at risk so that others can
- 22:47be safe.
- 22:48And if I see that risk as being extremely high, that's a big ask.
- 22:54We absolutely see the kind of defense of one's own freedoms to make decisions.
- 22:59And obviously worldview and politics is coming into this more and more.
- 23:05Okay, so I would be remiss if I did not talk about the vaccine autism myth, and it is not
- 23:14the only reason that people are not getting the MMR vaccine.
- 23:18And in fact, Andrew Wakefield in this article that I'll explain in a minute was not the
- 23:22first one to recommend this idea.
- 23:24But I think this is a really good example of how a misleading claim, in this case, a
- 23:29fraudulent misleading claim can be incredibly sticky and is around still today.
- 23:35So in 1998, Andrew Wakefield published this paper suggesting a relationship between the
- 23:39MMR vaccine and autism.
- 23:42Unfortunately, it took about 10 years to have this paper retracted.
- 23:45But it was eventually retracted.
- 23:47And this came on the heels of some incredible investigative journalism.
- 23:51And through this investigative journalism, several things came to light.
- 23:56Okay, first, this was a case series methodology.
- 23:58This was 12 cases.
- 24:00That is not the type of methodology that should be used to make any claim about causation.
- 24:07But this was more than just a poorly done study.
- 24:10Most cases were self-referrals from anti-vaccine groups.
- 24:14Several of the cases had symptoms of autism begin before they got the vaccine.
- 24:19And that was not disclosed in the paper.
- 24:22And then what makes this fraudulent is that Andrew Wakefield had applied for patents on
- 24:26a vaccine to rival the MMR vaccine and had received money to prove that the vaccine was
- 24:31dangerous.
- 24:33Since then, we have done dozens of studies across multiple different research groups,
- 24:38multiple different countries that have asked this question.
- 24:41Because look, I tell families, I say, if I give the MMR vaccine all the time, if I was
- 24:46causing autism in patients, I would want to know that.
- 24:49And vaccine delivery experts and pediatricians around the world would want to know that.
- 24:53So we've asked this question time and time again.
- 24:56And we have not found any link.
- 24:59But look, this is what parents are exposed to all the time.
- 25:03Whether they are looking for information about vaccines or whether they are just scrolling
- 25:08their social media feed, these questions pop up too many too soon.
- 25:14Vaccine ingredients, aluminum in vaccines, over and over and over again.
- 25:19And when they pop up, they don't have to share concrete evidence.
- 25:24They just have to scare the parents.
- 25:27So one of the common myths that we see is too many too soon.
- 25:31These next couple of slides, I'm going to show you some great materials from the Unbiased
- 25:34Science group, who I've had the opportunity to collaborate with on different messaging
- 25:39over the years.
- 25:41And they have created some great social media tools and graphics to help try to help parents
- 25:50visualize the truth about some of these statements.
- 25:53So for the too many too soon myth, one of the reality is that compared to the vaccine
- 26:00schedule back in the 1980s, which had over 3,000 antigens, today's full schedule has
- 26:07just over 300.
- 26:08Now, this is mostly because we had the wholesale pertussis vaccine, which had quite a few antigens.
- 26:13But we've actually decreased the number of antigens in the childhood vaccine schedule.
- 26:19That's not something that a lot of parents are talking about.
- 26:22Then the myth comes up about aluminum, which has been circulating for a very long time.
- 26:30When our own federal health agencies bring it up, it tends to get even more attention.
- 26:37These social media examples do a great job of explaining the reality that aluminum is
- 26:44all over our earth.
- 26:45It's in the food we eat, the water we drink, and the air we breathe.
- 26:50And it is actually in extremely tiny doses in vaccines.
- 26:55And children get more from breastfeeding, formula feeding, and eating than they will
- 27:02from the vaccines themselves.
- 27:06Regarding this myth about aluminum causing all sorts of conditions like autoimmune diseases
- 27:13and allergies and stuff, we have some good evidence now that there is no correlation.
- 27:21There is no evidence for a direct cause of aluminum leading to these things.
- 27:27Now, here's the problem.
- 27:29Correlation does not equal causation.
- 27:31But that's really hard for people to understand.
- 27:34So if you look at ice cream sales and shark attacks, there's a direct correlation.
- 27:40There's a direct correlation.
- 27:43Is that because when you buy ice cream, you're more likely to have a shark bite you?
- 27:48No, it's because on a nice day like you're having, not like we're having in Colorado,
- 27:53on a nice day, you're going to get more people going out to the beach.
- 27:55You're going to get more people swimming in the water.
- 27:57You're also going to get more people eating ice cream.
- 28:00And so this is a hard concept for people to understand, but it's really important.
- 28:04Okay, so I think that what we've talked about so far is so important for you to understand
- 28:10because you have to start from a place of understanding what the parents in your community,
- 28:16what the community leaders and your clients and patients are exposed to right now.
- 28:23Because one of the most important things that I'm going to talk about in a minute you can
- 28:26do is really have empathy for people who are confused right now.
- 28:32And you can't have empathy for them if you don't understand just how confusing the information
- 28:36environment is.
- 28:39But what can we do about this?
- 28:40Well, look, here's what families and communities need right now, okay?
- 28:44They are understandably confused.
- 28:47They're asking, what is recommended right now?
- 28:50We have seen the childhood schedule flip-flop several times.
- 28:53Unfortunately, we might see it flip-flop again, depending on how the court case continues
- 29:00to roll out at the federal level.
- 29:03They're asking, why are there these different recommendations?
- 29:06Like, okay, so the professional society say this, this doctor says this, this person that
- 29:11says that, why are there so many different recommendations?
- 29:14And the bottom line is they're just confused.
- 29:16And what they want from you is a trusted navigator who gives a clear recommendation, and they
- 29:22want reassurance that they can trust you.
- 29:25While trust in institutions is falling apart, trust in you is not.
- 29:31And here's the reality.
- 29:33Most families continue to vaccinate.
- 29:35They obviously remain one of the most effective ways to keep children healthy and thriving,
- 29:40and your recommendation still matters.
- 29:44This chart here I made for one of my Substat posts several weeks ago, when there was an
- 29:50alarming headline from a poll that came out that essentially stated that most Americans
- 29:57were skeptical of vaccines now.
- 29:59Well, there were all sorts of problems with that poll, and if you want to learn more about
- 30:04that, I joined several podcasts to talk about the real serious methodologic problems with
- 30:09that poll.
- 30:10The reality is multiple polls from different organizations over the past year have really
- 30:14shown continued support for vaccines, support for vaccines, support for vaccine requirements
- 30:19for schools, all of those things.
- 30:21So there is still a base of people that support vaccines.
- 30:26So remember, the first thing you do when people seem confused, concerned, and have questions
- 30:31is lead with empathy.
- 30:34I mean, example language for that can just be as simple as, I can see why this feels
- 30:38confusing.
- 30:39There are a lot of conflicting messages.
- 30:43That is, start with that.
- 30:46But before I give you more tools on what to do, I want to carefully tell you what we know
- 30:53can backfire.
- 30:55So one of the things that can backfire is the fear appeal.
- 31:00This is a study that was done back in 2014, published back in 2014, and in this study,
- 31:07they randomized parents to receive one of four interventions, either info explaining
- 31:12the lack of evidence that MMR causes autism, info about measles, mumps, and rubella from
- 31:18the vaccine information sheet, images of children who have measles, mumps, and rubella, or a
- 31:23dramatic narrative about a severe case of measles.
- 31:27And what they actually found was that none of those interventions increased intent to
- 31:31vaccinate, and they often backfired.
- 31:33In fact, refuting claims of an MMR-autism link decreased the intent to vaccinate among
- 31:38parents who had the least favorable attitudes.
- 31:42Images of sick children increased a belief in vaccine autism.
- 31:45Now you might say, okay, this was 2014.
- 31:48So let's move to last month.
- 31:50So last month, there was a fantastic paper that was published on the new CDC language
- 31:58on their website about autism and vaccines.
- 32:02So if you remember, in November, they updated their website to suggest that the link between
- 32:08autism and vaccines had not been ruled out, okay, this uncertainty-based statement.
- 32:14And researchers tested three conditions.
- 32:16They tested the old CDC website, okay, they tested that clearly said there's no connection
- 32:24between autism and vaccines.
- 32:26They tested this new language, and then they tested no statement at all.
- 32:30Now the expected finding from this was that uncertainty-based statements, the new one,
- 32:36reduced intention to vaccinate, okay, and increased the endorsement of science denial
- 32:40strategies.
- 32:41That's really not surprising.
- 32:43One of the findings that's underreported, and the authors talked about this, is that
- 32:47actually, people that were exposed to both the old CDC website and the new CDC website
- 32:57had lower intention to vaccinate compared to not receiving anything.
- 33:02So this is important to recognize that raising the question, even to debunk it, bringing
- 33:10this up when parents aren't necessarily concerned about it can sometimes activate doubt and
- 33:14backfire.
- 33:16So be careful with that.
- 33:18One of the other traps I see people get into is the data dump.
- 33:21What if we just give them more information, right?
- 33:23We have all this information, we know all the information about the vaccine efficacy
- 33:27and side effects and risks and all this.
- 33:30If we just give them this information, the light's going to come on, and they will change
- 33:35their mind.
- 33:36And what we know is that this doesn't work, right?
- 33:38This is called the information deficit model.
- 33:41And that's not to say that there aren't people who have real knowledge gaps, okay?
- 33:46So if someone really doesn't understand why you're recommending the HPV vaccine to them,
- 33:52it's important to share that knowledge with them.
- 33:54But this assumption that if you just give them more facts, they're going to change their
- 33:58mind just doesn't work.
- 34:01Two other traps, the persuasion trap.
- 34:04This one can backfire.
- 34:06So this just assumes that decisions are simple decisions made on scientific logic alone,
- 34:10right?
- 34:11This assumes that the person across from you or the community you're talking to looked
- 34:14at the same set of facts that you did, and they just simply came to a different conclusion,
- 34:18right?
- 34:19And this can actually harden hesitancy, and communities can feel judged or dismissed when
- 34:24you are doing this.
- 34:26The other trap that's similar but slightly different is the debate trap.
- 34:30Look, vaccine conversations and talking to communities about vaccines, it's not a debate,
- 34:35okay?
- 34:37It is a place for the good faith debate about scientific facts.
- 34:42That is not what you're doing 99.9% of the time when you're talking to communities, okay?
- 34:47This triggers defensiveness in identity protection.
- 34:50They want to continue to identify with their community, their worldview, and so it's not
- 34:55a debate.
- 34:57What this brings us to is the reality that how we communicate about vaccines is just
- 35:01as important as what we communicate.
- 35:03The facts are absolutely necessary, but they are not sufficient.
- 35:08Okay, so I'm going to give you a simple model for face-to-face communication, and then I'm
- 35:15going to give you some simple tips for community communication.
- 35:20So when you are doing face-to-face communication, one of the most important things is that the
- 35:25person hears a clear recommendation that you do think this vaccine or these vaccines are
- 35:31important for their health or their child's health, and that you initiate it with the
- 35:38assumption that they're probably interested in vaccinating, okay?
- 35:41This is easy.
- 35:43All you do is say something like, hey, I recommend this vaccine to everyone, and have you gotten
- 35:48your flu shot this year?
- 35:49Oh, looks like you're due for it.
- 35:52It is simply announcing what they're due for.
- 35:55When that happens, you'll typically see one of three responses.
- 35:58You will either have someone say, okay, because they wanted to get vaccinated, right?
- 36:02And they're on board with it.
- 36:05Sometimes you will see people who are hesitant right out of the gate, and they say, I don't
- 36:10think I want to do that.
- 36:11I've thought about this.
- 36:12I don't want to do that vaccine.
- 36:13Or you'll see people have a question.
- 36:16Now, one of the important things to recognize is that when people have a question, first,
- 36:22just address the question specifically.
- 36:25One of the things I see, one of the traps people get into is assuming if someone has
- 36:29a question, they have concerns, is assuming that they're hesitant.
- 36:34It is normal as a parent or as anyone to have questions or concerns about something like
- 36:40a vaccine.
- 36:41So answer them with short, digestible, easy to understand answers, and then gauge where
- 36:46they're at.
- 36:47Because frequently, when you answer their question, they'll say, okay, great, thanks.
- 36:51Yeah, sure, let's vaccinate.
- 36:53Sometimes it becomes clear that even after you've answered their question, they are hesitant.
- 36:58And that is when we pivot into using motivational interviewing.
- 37:02Now, look, I don't have time to teach you all motivational interviewing today.
- 37:06So the skills I'm going to tell you on the next two slides are like playing happy birthday
- 37:10on the piano.
- 37:11That I think you can learn.
- 37:13And motivational interviewing is in the spirit of partnership, acceptance, compassion, and
- 37:18empathy, and evocation or elicitation.
- 37:23There are five skills that we teach.
- 37:25Many of you probably already use some of these.
- 37:28One is just simply asking open-ended questions.
- 37:31So after someone says, no, no, we don't want to do the MMR vaccine, saying something like,
- 37:36okay, I'm really curious, would you mind telling me why you want to wait on the MMR vaccine?
- 37:43Simple, open-ended question, curiosity.
- 37:47Affirmation is the next skill.
- 37:48It is clear you want to do what's best for your health, or it's clear that you want what's
- 37:52best for your child's health.
- 37:54You don't need to affirm a misleading claim or a myth.
- 37:57Affirm that they care about their health or their child's health.
- 38:01Reflection is the next skill.
- 38:03It sounds like you are most concerned about whatever it is.
- 38:09The next skill is autonomy support.
- 38:11Ultimately, this is your decision to make.
- 38:13I can't tell you how important this skill is, especially if you feel the temperature
- 38:16of the conversation rising.
- 38:18Because ultimately, it is their decision to make, and saying that out loud can really
- 38:24help lower the temperature.
- 38:25Finally, I don't see this one used nearly enough, asking permission to share.
- 38:30So before you share a little bit of information, data, facts, or why you recommend a vaccine,
- 38:37say something like, would it be okay if I share with you why I recommend these?
- 38:42A spin on several of these that I think is so valuable.
- 38:47One is asking what benefits they see to vaccines.
- 38:52So instead of asking, why are you concerned over and over again?
- 38:55Tell me more about your concerns.
- 38:56Ask, hey, I'm really curious, do you see any benefits to vaccines?
- 39:00That forces them to consider that there might be benefits.
- 39:04It is okay to hear out negative emotions and negative motivations.
- 39:08You don't necessarily need to refute every single statement that a person makes.
- 39:12Again, this is not a debate.
- 39:14Look for opportunities to refocus the conversation on the benefits and the patient's own positive
- 39:19feelings and promote this change talk, remembering that most people are at least a little bit
- 39:26open to the idea of vaccinating.
- 39:28So here's what this could look like.
- 39:30A patient might say, I've seen a lot about the MMR vaccine and how it causes autism.
- 39:34I'm not sure I want my child to get it.
- 39:38If you fall into the trap, you might say something like, actually, that's wrong.
- 39:42The CDC changed their website recently for political reasons and you can't trust them
- 39:45or anything you see on social media.
- 39:47Measles is bad and it can kill your child.
- 39:50You might be laughing right now, but I have seen this.
- 39:53I have seen this many times, okay?
- 39:56Try this instead.
- 39:58It makes sense that you would have questions.
- 40:00There's a lot of confusing information out there and you want to make sure this is safe.
- 40:04Can I share with you what we know about where that concern came from?
- 40:09And often the parent or the patient or whoever it was will say, sure, you can tell me more.
- 40:12If you, again, fall into a trap, you might say something like,
- 40:18you can't believe everything you see.
- 40:20It all started in 1998 when Andrew Wakefield published an article
- 40:23in a journal called The Lancet and then 10 minutes later, I mean, it's like, wah, wah, wah, wah.
- 40:28The patient or community member, they're not listening to you, right?
- 40:31Instead, in a digestible way, you could say something like,
- 40:34MMR is one of the most studied vaccines we have.
- 40:36Millions of children across dozens of countries.
- 40:39The concern originated from a single fraudulent study that was retracted.
- 40:44The science here is unusually clear, right?
- 40:47Just really simple and concrete.
- 40:52Okay, so briefly, communicating with communities.
- 40:56So let's step beyond the face-to-face interaction.
- 40:58Now, face-to-face might involve multiple people, but when I talk about communicating
- 41:03with communities, I'm saying this is often somewhat asynchronous
- 41:08and often a little bit more of mass communication, okay?
- 41:12Now, I do think even when you're communicating with communities,
- 41:15you need to get feedback on your messages, and it is two-way,
- 41:19but it's not in the same conversation style that I just described.
- 41:23So you've got two modes and two toolboxes.
- 41:25I just described individual communication, okay, one-on-one where you have a relationship.
- 41:30You might be trying to recommend a vaccine at that visit, and the trust is very personal.
- 41:38Public communication involves many people at once,
- 41:41and you're talking about community-level confidence.
- 41:44Now, the tools that work better here are things like narrative over data and facts,
- 41:50trusted community messengers, the messages coming from community messengers.
- 41:55I'm going to talk briefly about pre-bunking and media engagement as well,
- 41:59and the speed and framing in the community messaging really matters.
- 42:04People share stories way more than they share statistics in communities.
- 42:08So lead with the narrative and then back up with the evidence.
- 42:12And look, you can actually get better at this, okay?
- 42:15This is a publication in the New England Journal of Medicine by some wonderful friends
- 42:19and colleagues who really called for this.
- 42:22Look, scientists, doctors, public health professionals, all of you,
- 42:24you need to become effective communicators beyond your own little circles.
- 42:30And that does not mean every single one of you needs to be on social media.
- 42:33That does not mean every single one of you needs to be willing to go on CNN or go on a podcast
- 42:38because that just might not be your style, but you can still be an effective communicator in your communities.
- 42:43And this meets meeting people where they are, okay, and connecting with their values.
- 42:49So many communities prioritize and cultures prioritize face-to-face conversations
- 42:53and meaningful connections over efficiency and social media posts.
- 42:58Take time to build trust without rushing, refraining from judgment, and meeting people where they are.
- 43:06This can strengthen the relationship so much with communities.
- 43:09Also, you have to learn about your community.
- 43:13Invest time in understanding who you are serving.
- 43:17Where do they come from?
- 43:18What religions are practiced?
- 43:20What different aspects about their community?
- 43:23This does not mean that you are going to be the expert in their community,
- 43:26but you need to learn about your community enough that you can communicate more effectively,
- 43:31that you can find the trusted messengers, that you can build relationships with them in their community.
- 43:39And I want to talk specifically about religious vaccine hesitancy for many reasons.
- 43:44I know that you experience a lot of this in Maine, and we see a lot of this across the country.
- 43:49But here's what I want to say about this.
- 43:50It is not monolithic.
- 43:52There are many different religious beliefs, and the religious beliefs, even within, let's say, the broader Christian tent,
- 44:02there are varying reasons for hesitancy.
- 44:04So among kind of the Anabaptist, Amish, and Mennonite communities,
- 44:08often there is more of a communal decision-making and a little bit of a distrust of outside systems and health and things like that.
- 44:16However, they are very close-knit and a very high outbreak risk when immunity drops.
- 44:23Some evangelical Christians will have more of a concern around bodily sovereignty.
- 44:29They may be skeptical of government mandates, believe more in the natural immunity type of things.
- 44:36And so these are just examples of how, look, you cannot assume, do not make assumptions about a religious community and why they are hesitant.
- 44:45That's why it's important to work with faith leaders.
- 44:48Okay, so working with a trusted religious leader carries way more weight than any public health flyer.
- 44:58Identify leaders who are already open to the conversation.
- 45:01Offer to come to them.
- 45:02Offer to talk to them.
- 45:03Don't force them to come into your setting, into your playing ground.
- 45:11Provide simple talking points that they can use with their community.
- 45:15Offer in-community or in church clinics.
- 45:17Remove access barriers and all of these things.
- 45:20So there are multiple examples of this working well.
- 45:23Okay, we saw this actually work very well from, and I've heard this from so many wonderful colleagues in Black churches during COVID vaccination.
- 45:33I'm going to share two examples where this worked well in my own experience.
- 45:37I practiced in Montana for several years, very close to an Anabaptist community.
- 45:42Okay, so Anabaptists, this is a wonderful community called the Hutterites, and they're similar in some ways to Amish Mennonite communities.
- 45:51Well, you know, I really found that when I developed trusted relationships with these families, they were very open to vaccinating.
- 45:58But they typically weren't open on the first time that they met me, right?
- 46:02They would see me in clinic and it was over several clinic conversations.
- 46:07It was when I ran into them at the farmer's market and they were selling their incredible produce and talked to them.
- 46:12It's after those interactions that they said, hey, we're going to do these.
- 46:16And they decided to vaccinate not because they learned new information.
- 46:20I asked why they decided to vaccinate.
- 46:23And they said, because we trust you now.
- 46:25Right, so it's building that trust that matters.
- 46:28I had the opportunity to serve this beautiful Somali community in Seattle when I was in residency.
- 46:35None of them wanted any vaccines.
- 46:38They came in and said, we do not want any vaccines.
- 46:40And when we asked and really explored why, it was because their religious leader, their imam, had said no to vaccines.
- 46:47This is not work that I did, but some of my colleagues did incredible work with this religious leader building trust relationship and came to kind of find out that they just had a misperception about vaccine risks.
- 47:00When this religious leader learned that it was a misconception, we had the Somali community flood into clinics asking for vaccines because the religious leader said, yeah, you can get your children vaccinated.
- 47:13Right. No amount of facts, no amount of pamphlets or handouts or education would have changed their mind because it was a part of their community identity and their religious identity.
- 47:23It took working with their religious leaders to really make a difference.
- 47:29OK, finally, I've got two more slides left, but I want to talk about this.
- 47:33Now, this is a little bit of transition to something called pre-bunking.
- 47:36So just like vaccines build immunity to disease, there is this concept of psychological inoculation, which I don't love the term.
- 47:44It sounds kind of science fiction and maybe it sounds scary to people, but pre-bunking is maybe a better term.
- 47:49But this is building immunity to misinformation.
- 47:52This is exposing people to common tactics on manipulation, not the myth itself, but here is how you are being manipulated by the social media posts.
- 48:04OK, so you can actually teach patients in your community how falsehoods spread and how to pause and spot them.
- 48:12This is a handout that I led the American Academy of Pediatrics and Center for Unbiased Science and Health.
- 48:20We made this in collaboration and I'll show you the backside of it in a minute.
- 48:24But it's a very simple handout for families that just simply says, well, everything you see might not be as it seems.
- 48:33And here is a simple checklist, simple checklist.
- 48:37When you see something. Ask yourself, am I being offered something that seems way too simple to fix with the complex that's actually a complex problem?
- 48:46Is this trying to scare me? Is the timing is timing proof of causation, right?
- 48:52Like there's no other evidence other than, well, I don't know, these two things happened in the same year, so they must be connected.
- 48:57Right. Family members and community members can go through this pause briefly and just say, wait, who is maybe making money off of this?
- 49:06There's a link at the bottom of this to some supplements. I wonder if they're just trying to make money.
- 49:13So pre-bunking and teaching people how to spot misleading claims is so important.
- 49:18I mean, I think we probably need this in our education system from a young age anymore now.
- 49:23OK, I shared a lot today and I want to end on resources.
- 49:28These are not this is not a complete list of resources.
- 49:32There are many more and I don't want people who maybe have worked with other organizations to be disappointed.
- 49:36They're not on this page right here. I couldn't fit everyone, but I want to just point out several things.
- 49:40When it comes to vaccine clinical guidance, the professional societies, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the AFP, ACOG, et cetera,
- 49:49they are one of the best places to go right now with the void in federal vaccine guidance.
- 49:54OK, other great guidance is coming out from immunize.org, the Infectious Disease Society of America and the National Foundation for Infectious Diseases or NFID.
- 50:03For patients and I have students on here, but for patients and community members and people that want a little bit more information,
- 50:13I love places like the CHOPS Vaccine Education Center.
- 50:16They're doing incredible work and sharing really good information, voices for vaccines and vaccinate your family.
- 50:22Also incredible information in a format that's a little bit more accessible to some people that want narrative and story.
- 50:31Obviously, the AP, again, healthychildren.org is where I send a lot of people, especially families and parents.
- 50:37And then if you want to stay current, I would recommend following what SIDRAP is doing at the University of Minnesota and the Vaccine Integrity Project there.
- 50:44They're doing incredible stuff. The Evidence Collective and Unbiased Science, who I have collaborated with over the years and continue to is partnering with them as well to try and put out good real time information.
- 50:56And of course, you also can follow me on my sub stack.
- 51:02I get a little bit more in the essay realm of things and don't necessarily put on a lot of practical stuff through that method.
- 51:11But I would love for you to follow me. So here are the other ways that you can follow me as well.
- 51:16And I am happy to take questions.
- 51:20That was fantastic, by the way, David, that was absolutely packed with information that was very, very, very useful.
- 51:28So thank you. I also did put links to your sub stack, your website, your ex account, LinkedIn and everything in the chat as well.
- 51:36So Amy Belial, who is our, works at the state and Maine DHHS and is a pediatrician as well and MPH.
- 51:44And she is a chief, I forget what your title is, Amy, chief pediatric officer for the state or something like that.
- 51:53But anyway, Amy, you've got a question. Yeah. Thank you.
- 51:56Thank you. Great talk. So where do you see us going in the next couple of years with everything happening at the federal level?
- 52:04And what in terms of messaging and what can we do with the state?
- 52:08Yeah, such an important question. And one of the things that I'm exploring right now in my sub stack and in some work with the Evidence Collective is where do we where do we go from here?
- 52:18Not fully understanding what's going to happen at the federal level over the next couple of years.
- 52:21And I'm reminding people that, look, we're not going to go back overnight to how things were in twenty twenty four.
- 52:30It's not possible to go back overnight. And even if we did, not everything we were doing there worked perfectly either.
- 52:37So what I think we're really seeing, I think what we need to emphasize and do is these states, the communities, local public health,
- 52:47health care organizations across states, especially that have big geographic reach, you need to be involved in good community messaging.
- 52:56The recommendations for vaccines are still at this point going to be fractured.
- 53:01Fortunately, the American Academy of Pediatrics has really stepped up to the plate in offering clear recommendations.
- 53:08Some of the adult recommendations are a little bit more unclear and fractured right now.
- 53:13I think that's going to be the norm for the foreseeable future.
- 53:16I'm not sure we're going to have federal level recommendations that we're going to be able to get behind.
- 53:21So it is your both privilege and responsibility at the state level to be a communicator because people in your state, people in your communities,
- 53:33they trust you. They might not trust the CDC.
- 53:38They might not even trust the American Academy of Pediatrics. OK, but they trust you.
- 53:42You are in their communities. They see your name.
- 53:46They see your information. So you need to be sharing that messaging out.
- 53:50And I also really emphasize you need to be working with community messengers.
- 53:54You need to be identifying those people in communities that are can be messengers.
- 53:59They don't have to be the scientists. They don't have to be a vaccine expert.
- 54:03They don't have to be any of these things. They just have to be leaders in your communities who are willing to pass along simple messages about the importance of vaccines,
- 54:14about where people can find good, reliable information about vaccines.
- 54:18And nobody is better suited to do that than you because you know your state and you know your communities.
- 54:24And Kathy Burgoyne, who is also an MDMPH, is joining us, too, for a question.
- 54:30Thank you, Kathy. Hi, I'm a family doctor from Maine.
- 54:34And throughout my career of like 30 years, I I'm retired now.
- 54:40I would often tell the story of when I had the measles when I was seven and there was no shot and how sick I was.
- 54:48And they usually say, oh, I thought it was just a rash and a fever. You know, you were really sick.
- 54:52And also I would tell them if it was pertussis they were concerned about.
- 54:58I would explain I was up with a baby for 36 hours and I would make the coughing sound that they made.
- 55:05And I never had anyone refuse vaccines. I think a lot of the doctors and nurse practitioners and et cetera these days have never seen these diseases.
- 55:17And they really can't explain as well as we can what it was like and how awful it was.
- 55:24And so I think that is hard. I did go on Blue Sky.
- 55:28And as I put postings on there sometimes and put on my personal experience with measles and an audio of a child with pertussis and explaining those things.
- 55:39And I got a lot of positive responses to those. Yeah, I just didn't didn't really know, you know.
- 55:45Yeah. So I love that you brought this up because one of the things when I talk about the fear appeal, not always being successful.
- 55:53I want to make really clear that personal narrative and personal experience matters.
- 55:57So I share frequently that I in residency had a baby with pertussis die right in front of me despite our best efforts.
- 56:05And I mean. And meningitis. I saw babies die from that.
- 56:09Yeah. And I saw a child with tetanus that was in the ICU for six weeks and had to get a tracheotomy because they couldn't breathe.
- 56:18Right. Right in front of me. And those were traumatizing experiences for me as a physician.
- 56:23I still remember those. And when I share that personal story with families, it does make a difference.
- 56:28So but it's not abstract, right? It's not. Oh, well, you know, because sometimes our fear appeal is abstract.
- 56:35Look, you should be scared of measles for these reasons. But when it's a personal story like you shared of children,
- 56:42you treated with meningitis or pertussis or hospitalized for measles or whatever it was that goes a lot further.
- 56:49All right. So I love that you shared that. I was in bed for 10 days in the dark with a fever of one hundred and five.
- 56:54And I saw the little characters from Get Smart crawling up my quilt.
- 57:00They'll remember that. Right. Right. That's something that stays with you the rest of your life.
- 57:05And I do think it's important to use that personal narrative.
- 57:08The other quick thing I want to mention was I was in Nova Scotia, Canada, and the head of pediatrics up there was presenting on vaccinations.
- 57:17And he said, if the children didn't come in for their vaccinations, they sent inmates to their home to vaccinate them.
- 57:23And when I was there 15 years ago, they had a 98 percent vaccination rate and they were disappointed by that.
- 57:30So I just wonder, you know, couldn't we do that here? I mean, a lot of people probably want to get vaccinated.
- 57:36They just can't. Absolutely. Oh, absolutely.
- 57:38And one of the things I talk about frequently is there is people assume if a community is not vaccinated, that they just don't want them.
- 57:47And that is a dangerous assumption to make. Right. It is a dangerous assumption.
- 57:52And I have seen that in my own experience with communities where people assume, well, this community just they just must be hesitant.
- 57:59And then there's an outreach clinic and they're lining up for vaccines. Right. It's at a school, it's at a church and they're lining up for vaccines.
- 58:06So I love that you brought that up. It can be a dangerous assumption to simply say, well, this community's vaccination rate is low.
- 58:12It's because they're all hesitant or because they're all politically affiliated with someone.
- 58:18Do not make those assumptions. Go in, learn the community, get engaged with the community, bring vaccines to them.
- 58:27And I think you could be surprised. I was like, it's really about relationships, isn't it?
- 58:32It's community relationships, relations with the patients and their families.
- 58:36And now you've really brought that to light and particularly with a number of wonderful, wonderful, pragmatic strategies, too.
- 58:44So and subscripting. So thank you again so much.
- 58:48We're at the end of our hour. Very. That went so fast. And we've had a lot of comments in the 70 people on and at the height and they had to leave because of the end of the hour.
- 59:00But lots and lots of comments thanking you in the chat there for your time.
- 59:05And what a great presentation they've also said. Thank you so much. It was a pleasure to be with you all today.
- 59:11Thank you very much, David. It's great to see you. And we'll see you sometime in person.
- 59:15Hopefully come on out to Maine with your family and visit. I would love it. Thank you all.
- 59:21Bye bye. Bye bye, everybody. Thank you for listening.
- 59:24And we look forward to connecting with you again at Maine Health's Public Health Grand Rounds, where we explore a timely public health topic with national and Maine experts.
- 59:35These Grand Rounds are posted to the Maine Health podcast channel on Podbean and at MaineHealth.org, where you can hear current and past episodes.
- 59:45See you next time.