Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 10/30/26 EPISODE 038: BOTTLE BREAKDOWN: BLACK MAPLE HILLS SMALL BATCH
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: you All right. So, ⁓ kind of a funny story. I was sitting downstairs. My wife had planned, ⁓ an evening of filming, ⁓ the book club in the three, two, bourbon library podcasts. And so they just finished filming like five episodes and I had this bottle, ⁓ on my list of, of new releases that I wanted to review. John Carlo was here. I'm like, shit buddy, let's film a podcast. Let's talk about, let's talk about this bottle. ⁓ So this is a brand, so we're gonna be talking about the brand new release from Black Maple Hills. ⁓ I wanted to give a little history on this. This is not a new brand, but this is a new release. And this most recent release is coming out of Rare Character. So Rare Character purchased the rights to the Black Maple Hill branding. And I'll share some details about it, but ⁓ formerly Black Maple Hills, was historic. Like this was some of the most sought after bottles out in the industry. I remember when I first got into bourbon and I was cruising Instagram, ⁓ was, I was seeing bottles of like Pappy ⁓ and other things and Black Mabel Hills. And so I was like, what is this Black Mabel Hills? I don't know anything about it. So for those that don't know anything about it and that are just getting into this new, new release, now that Rare characters taken over the rights to it, I wanted to give a little history of what Black Maple Hills is. And so Black Maple Hills is arguably one of the most enigmatic ⁓ stories named in American whiskey community. Its history spans ⁓ distinct eras, moving from legendary Kentucky sourcing to craft Oregon farm to bottle phase, and most recently a revival back to Kentucky. So initially, we'll just call this the golden era of Kentucky sourcing. started in the ⁓ sounds funny, late 19 hundreds, ⁓ or the late 1990s, ⁓ and the early two to the early 2010 era. ⁓ so black Maple Hills was created in, in, in the late 1990s by CVI brands, which is a California based independent importer and bottler. CVI didn't distill anything themselves and said instead they sourced ultra-aged high quality barrels from Kentucky's finest distilleries. The sourced, ⁓ some of these early bottles featured legendary liquid rumored to come from Stitzel Weller, Heaven Hill, and even the Julian van Winkle Old Hoffman Distillery, which is great, which is awesome. So the iconic bottlings like Black Maple Hill 16 year, 18 year old single barrel and 21 year old became instant secondary market unicorns. They were praised for their deep oak, dense dark fruit and velvet like mouth fill. The classic tall dark labeled bottles gained a cult status almost identical to Pappy Van Winkle. Then it kind of went dormant and it shifted in about 2014 to about the mid 2020s to the Stein Distillery in Oregon. ⁓ So as the original Kentucky barrel contracts begin to dry up, CVI brands moved production out of the west, or excuse me, out west to Oregon. They partnered with Stein Distillery, a small family run craft distillery located in Joseph, Oregon. They redesigned the packaging to a shorter, Squatty your bottle actually have one of those somewhere downstairs And with a rustic red and green labels and drop the proof down to the standardized 95 proof This transition alienated many old-school Kentucky fans because the Kraft Oregon profile Tasted radically different from the original vintage, Kentucky stocks ⁓ Move forward till just recently, the brand entered a new chapter through a partnership now with Rare Character. Guided by meticulous barrel selection, the brand was brought back to its original Kentucky roots with aged small batch and single barrel releases, including a high aged 11 year old and a 16 year old. think the 11 year old went for like $200 a bottle, 16 year old's going for $500 a bottle MSRP. alongside what we're going to taste tonight, which is their core release, a small batch at 90 Fight Proof. ⁓ Let's go now for these rare character blends. So this just came out here in 2026. All three just released in the months of like, believe maybe late June, July timeframe of 2026. And they marked the return of this historic brand back to Kentucky. And so is this really a 700 milliliter bottle? It is a 700 milliliter Shrinkflation again. Shrinkflation got us. So they're now bottled in back to these wine shaped bottles, 700 milliliters. This one that we're tasting tonight, 95 proof. It's a $70 MSRP. Like I said before, they have an 11 year old, $200 MSRP version. I believe it's a blue label writing and then a black label 16 year old, which is 500 bucks MSRP. I've seen these going for like a thousand dollars on the secondary. I'd love to try it. I'm really curious since it is a 16 year old, if it's buff turkey juice. I don't know if it is or not. Could be a Barton high aged heaven hill, whatever. don't know. Haven't tried that one, but we are going to talk about that. We're going to review the, the 95 small batch right now. So for this one, ⁓ what they were focusing on is it basically says Pablo Moy and Rare Character team thought through a sensory evaluation prioritizing balance, oak influence, and that classic Kentucky sweetness without pushing into the very heavy tannic category. ⁓ I'm interested. Let's get this thing cracked, start tasting it, nosing it. I know you were looking at like... Yeah, since I don't know much about it, it's first time I've heard it coming into today. Nobody knows the lore or where these bottles are coming from, the distillery. The liquid. Yeah, what's inside, which is interesting. Let's get that pop. Nice. So by just the color, it's not very dark. It's a nice little amber color. Definitely on the lighter side. Younger. It doesn't say any age on the... Do you know I took a little sniff on it? I think I might have a guess as to where this was distilled. Let us have it. I have no idea. don't say what they... It's almost giving me somewhere between Jim Beam and Green ⁓ River. Green River to me has this like peachy note on some other distillate. I like it a lot, but this one's given me something. Let me dive in here, see what we get more on the nose. I get citrus on the nose from this. Does have a light, yeah, like peach or orange peel maybe. Yeah, I'd say like candied orange is what I'm getting. Has a little bit of a nuttiness to it as well. Yeah. Very, I would say this is an approachable nose. Yeah. It's 95 proof. Obviously it's a simple drink. It's a $70 bottle. Nothing crazy. But man. It smells great. It does smell good. Yeah. I like the fruitiness, a little bit of vanilla sweetness, almost like a powdered sugar or something like that sweetness on the nose. Nice little, I'd say vanilla bean versus extract. Good call. It's got some nice legs on it though for 95 proof and whatever the age. I didn't say any age statement on this, it? Yeah, she does. Nice little leg, nice legs. Let's taste it. Go first, be my guest. Tell me what you think. I hope it tastes as good as it smells. That good, huh? That's good. It's an easy sipper. Let me go in. This to me drinks like a nice daily sipper. It's got a little bit of fruit up front and then it goes into vanilla. And for me on the backside, you get a little like pop of cinnamon, a little bit of baking spice. It just adds a little kick on the back. Yeah. Almost got like a little rye kick on the finish. It's nice. I like it. Yeah. I don't think they say what the mash bill is on this thing, but It's enjoyable. could drink this every day. Absolutely could drink this every day. This is a, this is a nice little drinker for 70 bucks. Yeah. It's not bad at all. Now my big question is the label says limited edition. It says, but that is the historic, the historic label always said limited edition on it. So let us know how limited rare character. we're going to, if we're going to see these shelf stable, I think I might go try to get another one of these. It's pretty good. Now we've to try the 11 and the 16. I need to get an 11 year old and I need to get a 16 year old. Absolutely. So that's another, at least $700 in the making to get those to try. I haven't seen one of those here in any of the stores locally. I've only seen them on... Only seen this one. Yeah, this one is only the one I've seen locally. I put in on the lottery with Sealbox and a couple other places. for the 11 and the 16 year old lost everywhere. It was not a winner on any of those lotteries. ⁓ And now you start to see them on like, I don't, couple of the websites that I look at to purchase bourbon on, but they're really up there with the secondary thousand dollars for the 16 year old. I'm not paying a thousand bucks for it. no. But you should have your own executive codes for like seal boxes. They should. Punch this in and like, front of the line. That would be nice. That would be nice to have an executive code. The ⁓ founders release or, you know, something preferred, preferred customer button. ⁓ This is really tasty though. I like this. This thing, this thing is, ⁓ it's given me that I love the vanilla note. Like soft, said vanilla, vanilla bean. It's smooth. It is smooth. Yeah. Yeah. People hate the word smooth, but velvety smooth drinker. Daily sipper, yes. And if you can get it for 70 bucks, I don't think I'd be, some people are paying charge in like 150, $200 for the bottle. Now don't, don't go pay. Pay them as her pee. Don't go pay secondary. It's not that good. This is one that you got to pick up and enjoy it. Yeah. Drink the sperm in for sure. Yep. Definitely. You know, got your buddies, drink it, share it, enjoy it. You know what? I'm leaning towards this Jim Beam juice. That's just me. You know what? You know what we should try? Actually, just for fun. Grab that Knob Creek Blender's edition right behind you. ⁓ Yeah, is a this ⁓ knob Creek blenders edition So knob Creek usually isn't super sweet for me, but this one was is a little bit sweeter now This is a 10 year old bourbon But I want to see if we can if it's you know tastes similar We'll just give ourselves just a little a little peek behind the curtain here and see if for some reason science Yeah, yeah, we're doing experiments over here. Let's get the white lab coats out. Yeah, this is science The noses. They're very similar, a little more ⁓ fruit on the red character. Or the black maple hills. A little more fruit, a little sweeter. versus the knob creek. This is a. Maybe it's not a... I don't know. It could be a green river. I often know that I'm not getting too much similarities. But you never know. Yeah, maybe it's not a Jim Beam. I don't know. That Blender's addition. Now, obviously that's not a standard release. That's a blend and it's getting a little more spice, more punch. What is the proof on that one? 106, it's 11 proof points hotter. I don't know. I'm really curious now. Let me know in the comments if you have any idea where Rare Characters sourced the 95 proof small batch from. It's got a little bit of a sweetness to it. I'm still in the camp that I feel like it's either Green River or Jim Beam. From that, it doesn't taste similar, but. No, but. That's also a blend. It is a blend and yeah, but that is too, who knows. Yeah. I think it's fun to buy. Man, now should we get a Green River out? The Silk Velvet's a Green River product, but anyway, we could let this episode run on. on for days. It's really good. I think for 70 bucks, grab it. Enjoy it. This is a great one. Appreciate you being here to- Appreciate you having me here. Reviewing it. We're going to ⁓ pop a Monster Bottle on another episode, so stay tuned. We'll see you very soon. Again, like and subscribe, comment. ⁓ Troll, whatever. you need to throw some digs at us, absolutely do it. Let us know how you're enjoying listening to the 323 Bourbon Library podcast. We'll see you again very soon for another episode. Cheers.