Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Top 10 Topics In Negotiating the AIR CRE Purchase And Sale Agreement
Transcript
- 0:06I'd like to welcome everybody to today's real
- 0:09estate section program for the Beverly Hills
- 0:11Bar Association. My name is Howard Gould. I'm
- 0:15co -chair of the real estate section for the
- 0:17Beverly Hills Bar, and we're very excited to
- 0:20be presenting a program on the AIR, you know,
- 0:24commercial real estate standard offer and purchase
- 0:27agreement. Before we get to the program, a couple
- 0:31of announcements. I'd like to tell you about
- 0:34the next three or four programs that this section
- 0:38is going to put on. On July 29th, we're doing
- 0:41a program that we've never done before. The general
- 0:45nature of it is to talk about the fire maps that
- 0:48have come out from the state, fire resiliency,
- 0:51insurance issues. Our speakers are going to be
- 0:54Michael. Michael Lynch from Martian McLennan,
- 0:59an insurance advisory firm, and Don Schmitz,
- 1:02who has a land use firm here in the Los Angeles
- 1:05area and has a great deal of expertise about
- 1:08fires. I have heard Don talk before. Larry Hummer
- 1:12and Joe Cobart are putting together that program
- 1:14for us. On August 8th, it's not our usual third
- 1:19Thursday, but August 8th. We're going to do a
- 1:22program called Cash for Keys. Last month in May
- 1:26we did sort of a tenant program talking about
- 1:30tenant. landlord tenant issues and a new study
- 1:36that had been done regarding the handling of
- 1:39landlord tenant cases in the Los Angeles Superior
- 1:41Court. We're going to switch to the landlord
- 1:43side in August and talk about landlords buying
- 1:46out tenants and why sometimes it makes a lot
- 1:49of sense, even though they may be paying $50
- 1:52,000, $100 ,000 or more to a tenant to move out
- 1:54of a residential unit. We're going to have on
- 1:58the financial side, Elliot Pell from Marcus and
- 2:01Mill a chap explaining why the economics work,
- 2:05even if a landlord sometimes is paying a very
- 2:08large sum of money to one or more tenants to
- 2:10get out and how it actually increases the owner's
- 2:13equity in the property and cash flow. And then
- 2:16the principal speaker is Sasha Struthers, who
- 2:19has a law practice that is basically nothing
- 2:21but cash for keys, where she assists landlords
- 2:24in doing the buyout because you do have to comply
- 2:27with the technical requirements of whichever
- 2:29jurisdiction you may be in. September, we're
- 2:33going to do a program pretty unique for real
- 2:36estate section, which is the intersection of
- 2:39intellectual property law and real estate, something
- 2:42people don't really think of as having much relationship
- 2:45to each other. But we're going to have Lindsay
- 2:47Carrotkin and her partner Sarah Albertson, I
- 2:53believe it is, from Aaron Fox's New York office
- 2:57talking to us about Intellectual Property and
- 3:00Real Estate, and Lindsay has published an article
- 3:03on this subject. And then one of the programs
- 3:06in the next couple of months, haven't decided
- 3:08exactly which month, we're going to have a program
- 3:10about risk management for lawyers, basically
- 3:13something like an ethics program. And the former
- 3:16president of the State Bar, who I've known for
- 3:18many years, Heather Rosing, who has recently
- 3:21started a new firm in San Diego, is going to
- 3:23be our speaker for that program. There's a link
- 3:27to the materials for today's program in the chat
- 3:30and we're going to use the Q &A function, not
- 3:34the chat for questions. So if you have questions,
- 3:36please post them in the Q &A and I'll be looking
- 3:39over those and try to bring them up at the appropriate
- 3:42time in the program. It's a great pleasure today
- 3:46to again have Brian Mashin of the Mashin Law
- 3:49Group as our speaker. Brian talked for us last
- 3:53year about the AAR lease form and this year he's
- 3:57going to talk about the AAR purchase and sale
- 4:00agreement form. And he's the perfect speaker
- 4:03for this because Brian is counsel to the contracts
- 4:06committee for AAR commercial real estate. He
- 4:10speaks on AAR events and is a perfect person
- 4:15for this subject matter. He's been on this executive
- 4:18committee for this real estate section and chaired
- 4:21this section for the Beverly Hills Bar. He's
- 4:23been on the committee of the commercial development
- 4:26and leasing subsection of the real property section
- 4:29of the Los Angeles County Bar Association. He's
- 4:32a member of a number of industry groups, including
- 4:34the International Council of Shopping Centers,
- 4:37ICSC, the editorial board for the shopping center,
- 4:42the Law Report, BOMA, the Building Owners and
- 4:45Managers Association, and the National Association
- 4:47of Corporate Real Estate Executives. did his
- 4:51undergrad in economics and political science
- 4:54at UCLA, and then also went to UCLA law school
- 4:57where he was editor of the law review. And his
- 5:00prior law firm affiliations, before founding
- 5:03his own firm in 2006, included Dern, Mason, Swerdlow
- 5:06& Flom, Shea & Gould, and Buchalter, where he
- 5:10was head of the real estate department. Brian's
- 5:13published numerous articles and had a lot of
- 5:16speaking engagements. And Brian, thank you so
- 5:19much for joining us today. The pleasure. Thank
- 5:22you, Howard. And I'm going to start by sharing
- 5:24my screen. And hopefully this is working. So
- 5:30today I'm going to talk about the 10 topics in
- 5:32negotiating the AIR Purchase and Sale Agreement.
- 5:38This is the standard offer agreement and escrow
- 5:42structure for non -residential. As you may all
- 5:44know, we publish three varieties. One is this
- 5:47contract and one for vacant land and another
- 5:50one for multi -family, five units or more. They're
- 5:54all pretty much structured the same way with
- 5:56some nuances for the property type. 10 topics.
- 6:03One of the questions that comes up quite a bit
- 6:05is this a purchase and sale agreement? Is that
- 6:07an option? Is it a contract? What is it? So the
- 6:11purchase and sale agreements have a series of
- 6:13due diligence contingencies and the way the contract
- 6:17is structured is that the closing date for the
- 6:20escrow is a number of days after the actual or
- 6:24deemed satisfaction or waiver of the buyer's
- 6:27contingencies. So The way the contract is set
- 6:30up is that the buyer has a quote -unquote free
- 6:33look during the due diligence period. The buyer
- 6:36can disprove and the earnest money is refunded
- 6:38to the buyer and the parties walk away. Years
- 6:42ago in 2010, the Supreme Court decided the Steiner
- 6:45versus Thexton case. In that case, the buyer
- 6:50contracted to buy 10 acres of a 12 -acre piece.
- 6:56The buyer was supposed to do this this parcel
- 7:00split at buyer's expense and the buyer could
- 7:02cancel the contract in buyer's sole and absolute
- 7:05discretion. After the parties signed the contract,
- 7:09the buyer spent about $60 ,000 and completed
- 7:11most of the approval for the parcel split. Then
- 7:14the seller decided that no, this is not a contract,
- 7:17rather it's an option in favor of the buyer.
- 7:21Since the seller wasn't paid a separate consideration
- 7:23by the buyer, that it was not an enforceable
- 7:27agreement and the seller could revoke it, which
- 7:29is what the seller did. Then Steiner, the buyer
- 7:32sued, the case worked its way up to the California
- 7:34Supreme Court. The California Supreme Court said,
- 7:38Yeah, the contract is called a purchase contract,
- 7:42but we're going to go past the title and we're
- 7:43going to look to see what the contract really
- 7:45functions. How does it function? And the fact
- 7:48that the court noted that the agreement was in
- 7:50fact an option contract because only the seller
- 7:53was bound while the buyer retained full discretion
- 7:56to withdraw from the sale. The buyer's initial
- 8:01promise to seek approvals might have been illusory
- 8:04because initially buyer hadn't done anything,
- 8:07hadn't spent any money, hadn't spent any effort.
- 8:10And the court noted that the express language
- 8:12in the contract overrode the implied covenant
- 8:14of good faith and fair dealing. Ultimately, the
- 8:18court ruled that the option was an irrevocable
- 8:22contract because there was sufficient consideration.
- 8:25And the consideration was the substantial performance
- 8:28provided by the buyer. That was the bargain for
- 8:31consideration that the parties had a meeting
- 8:36of mind about. That's the reason that the buyer
- 8:39spent significant amount of money and went through
- 8:41and did most 75 % to 90 % of the parcel split
- 8:45work was done by the buyer by the time the seller
- 8:48revoked the contract. The court noted that that
- 8:51was the party's bargain for consideration and
- 8:53the fact that the buyer subsequently provided
- 8:56that bargain for consideration, cured the defect,
- 8:59and made it a binding contract. The court also
- 9:04noted that the parcel split benefited the seller
- 9:07who was retaining the two -acre piece that it
- 9:09could then subsequently sell. After that case
- 9:12came down, the AIR contracts were revised to
- 9:17add the section of the 4 .4, which you'll see
- 9:19in a lot of even tailor -made contracts that
- 9:23are prepared by lawyers, it basically says that
- 9:25the escrow is supposed to release $100 of the
- 9:28deposit, of the buyer's deposit to the seller
- 9:30as an inducement for an independent consideration
- 9:34for seller entering into the contract with the
- 9:37buyer and giving the buyer the contingency period
- 9:40to do due diligence. This $100 is not refundable
- 9:45to the buyer, but is credited toward the purchase
- 9:48price at the closing. This is like an insurance
- 9:53clause in the contract to make sure that a disgruntled
- 9:57seller can't come back and subsequently say,
- 10:00hey, because this contract really gives the buyer
- 10:01free look, this is an option. It's not a binding
- 10:04contract and try to get out of it. So as I mentioned,
- 10:13the contract in section 9 .1 has quite a few
- 10:18set of contingencies and the closing date is
- 10:21keyed off of the satisfaction or waiver or actual
- 10:25or deemed satisfaction or waiver of the buyer's
- 10:27contingencies. 9 .1A is where the seller is required
- 10:31to provide the mandatory disclosure statement
- 10:33and a property information sheet. The buyer has
- 10:36a physical inspection under subparagraph B. The
- 10:40buyer has a right to do a hazardous substance
- 10:42condition report or a phase one or phase two
- 10:44report. The buyer can do a soil inspection, seek
- 10:48government approvals, review and approve of title,
- 10:51which includes the underlying documents and a
- 10:54scaled and dimension plot plan of the easements.
- 10:57and conduct an also survey, and do review the
- 11:03leases and estoppel certificates. The owner's
- 11:07association, if this is part of a condominium,
- 11:09is also another contingency where the seller
- 11:12is supposed to provide some of the documents
- 11:14related to the property owner's association.
- 11:17Other agreements such as management agreement,
- 11:20parking service agreement, et cetera. And then
- 11:24finally, contingency for new loan financing is
- 11:27part of the overall contingencies for the buyer.
- 11:33The buyer taking over existing notes, either
- 11:37assuming them or taking it subject to is 9 .1L.
- 11:44And finally, it's the buyer to review and approve
- 11:47of the personal property that's included as part
- 11:49of the sale. Most of these have a start date,
- 11:53which is from the date of agreement or from the
- 11:55seller's delivery of the applicable due diligence
- 11:58document. From the buyer's perspective, let's
- 12:05talk about how would a buyer expand? And obviously
- 12:08a seller is going to try to tighten these contingencies.
- 12:11What our contract does not call for is a rent
- 12:14roll. can add for a rent roll certified by the
- 12:18seller. This is really more appropriate for,
- 12:21let's say an apartment building in a multifamily
- 12:23where there's a lot of units, and the buyer wants
- 12:29the seller to provide a rent roll that says how
- 12:32much is the monthly rent, how much is the security
- 12:34deposit, who's current on paying the rent, et
- 12:37cetera, et cetera. So this is a perfectly good
- 12:40addition by a buyer. Whether the seller is willing
- 12:43to do it or not really depends on, a lot of these
- 12:45depend on who's got the leverage and matter of
- 12:51negotiation between the parties. One other item
- 12:55for a buyer to add to expand the scope of buyer's
- 12:58contingencies is to add a requirement for the
- 13:01seller to provide a schedule of the leasing commissions.
- 13:04and a copy of the agreements that the seller
- 13:07has with the current brokers. So the leasing
- 13:11commissions could come into play, for example,
- 13:13for existing leases that have been signed, and
- 13:16there may be commissions due to brokers still
- 13:19under those existing leases, or if a tenant exercises
- 13:24an option. there may be a broker who may be entitled
- 13:27to commission. For example, if a tenant exercises
- 13:30an option to extend the term of a lease, then
- 13:32the broker may be entitled to additional commission.
- 13:36From the buyer's perspective, it's a perfectly
- 13:38good due diligence item to determine what are
- 13:42the potential commissions that may be payable
- 13:44by the buyer as the then owner of the property
- 13:47if a tenant exercises an option to extend, purchase
- 13:51a right of first. First refusal, write a first
- 13:54offer, purchase option. That's a good ad by a
- 13:57buyer. We see in a lot of attorney prepared contracts
- 14:03that the seller is required to provide the property
- 14:06taxes. It's not in part of the AIR contract,
- 14:09but it's a good ad to get the property tax bills
- 14:11for the past two, three years. It's helpful to
- 14:14a buyer to see what those current taxes are and
- 14:17how much is the likely increase in the assessed
- 14:19value of the property. after the sale is closed.
- 14:24Next is the financial information, such as the
- 14:26operating statements that the seller has for
- 14:28the past three years, owning and operating the
- 14:30property. This is very valuable information to
- 14:33a buyer who can determine what's the typical
- 14:37cost to maintain and repair the property. What
- 14:41is the typical utility expenses that run? And
- 14:45this is very helpful for projecting the income
- 14:49in the future during the buyer's ownership of
- 14:51the property. Next is the seller's liability
- 14:56fire and casualty insurance. Today with the insurance
- 14:58business being so different and some properties
- 15:01being so difficult to insure, it's very helpful
- 15:04for a buyer to get the seller's liability fire
- 15:06and casualty insurance policies and determine
- 15:09whether they can actually, whether the buyer
- 15:11can take over those policies or this is going
- 15:14to be cost effective. Can the buyer actually
- 15:16get insurance? This has become a real... issue
- 15:19and whether I see some buyers adding as a contingency
- 15:25the ability to get insurance at reasonable premiums
- 15:28as a contingency to the deal. Continuing with
- 15:33the list of the buyer's contingencies, getting
- 15:36copies of the certificates of the tenant's insurance
- 15:38policy. So if you want to find out how much insurance
- 15:42does the tenant carry, and that's going to be
- 15:46very helpful. for the buyer to determine what
- 15:52kind of insurance the buyer may want to carry.
- 15:55Next item is materials regarding condition of
- 15:59the property, and that's the seller's phase one
- 16:01or phase two reports that the seller may have.
- 16:04Now, section 9 .1D of the purchase and sale agreement
- 16:09requires the seller to provide a copy of the
- 16:11soil report, but that's different. than the phase
- 16:15one or phase two report. So if there is a phase
- 16:19one or phase two, arguably, if they show bad
- 16:23facts about the property, if they show that there's
- 16:26potential contamination, the seller would be
- 16:28duty bound to disclose that anyways. But it's
- 16:31always a good idea for a buyer to ask for the
- 16:34seller to provide a copy of a phase one or phase
- 16:36two report that the seller has in their control
- 16:38and possession. Next is a list of license and
- 16:43permits that benefits the property, especially
- 16:47if there's conditional use permits or very unique
- 16:49permits that are applicable to this property.
- 16:51Those are always good to get copies of those
- 16:53license and permits. Any plans, drawings, and
- 16:57specifications that the seller has for the property,
- 16:59this is invaluable for the property management
- 17:02and for doing remodeling or construction work
- 17:05post -closing. Having those plans and drawings
- 17:07is very, very helpful. to the building engineers
- 17:11and also to the architect if there's going to
- 17:13be a remodeling. Next is the list of warranties.
- 17:19What are the warranties with respect to the heating,
- 17:21ventilation, and air conditioning system, the
- 17:24roof, and if there was a contractor who did some
- 17:27work, what is remaining of the contractor's warranty?
- 17:33Finally, a zoning verification letter from the
- 17:37city, the municipality regarding the property's
- 17:39current zoning and compliance with laws. This
- 17:42is a great item to get as you need the zoning
- 17:44verification letter to get the title insurance
- 17:46company to issue a zoning endorsement. There's
- 17:51a little bit of a ramp up time. You have to remember
- 17:53to do this with the municipality right when you
- 17:56open Estro so it doesn't jam you up and you run
- 18:00out of time. From the seller side, the estoppel
- 18:08certificates are a critical item because as I
- 18:10mentioned earlier, providing estoppel certificates
- 18:13is a due diligence contingency. So if you have
- 18:18a property that has obviously a lot of tenants,
- 18:20that's going to be a lot of work for a seller
- 18:21to go get estoppel certificates signed by every
- 18:24tenant, not knowing whether the buyer is actually
- 18:26going to go through with the deal. Quite often,
- 18:29people would revise the STAPL certificate arrangement
- 18:32to change it from a due diligence contingency
- 18:35to a closing condition. In other words, the buyer
- 18:39signs off on all the other contingencies and
- 18:43a condition to the closing will be the seller
- 18:47to deliver estoppel certificates that are clean
- 18:51or there's some other definition of the estoppel
- 18:54certificate form that's going to be acceptable
- 18:56to the buyer. So this is something important
- 18:59if you have a lot of tenants in the project and
- 19:03from a seller's perspective it's a very helpful
- 19:06change to make so you don't end up spending a
- 19:08lot of time getting these estoppels and the deal
- 19:12then doesn't close for some other reason. Brian,
- 19:15do you see many cases where the seller just can't
- 19:19get estoppel certificates and what generally
- 19:22happens then? Well, in the AIR purchase and sale
- 19:26agreement, the contract allows the seller to
- 19:29deliver an estoppel certificate instead of the
- 19:33tenant. If I'm a buyer, I would not be too happy
- 19:38with relying on a seller estoppel certificate
- 19:40since that means that if the seller's misrepresented
- 19:45the state of the lease in the seller's estoppel
- 19:47certificate, then now I have to sue the seller
- 19:50for breach of warranty, etc. And that's just
- 19:52the buying a lawsuit. The fact that a tenant
- 19:55refuses to give an estoppel certificate is a
- 19:58telltale sign that there is a problem there.
- 20:00So that should alert the buyer right away to
- 20:03find out what's really going on with this tenant
- 20:06and what's the reason that the tenant is refusing
- 20:08to give the estoppel certificate. So if you have
- 20:13to rely on an estoppel certificate, be good to
- 20:15combine it with some kind of a hold back in escrow
- 20:18so that there's some of the money held in case
- 20:21there's a breach of the seller's statements in
- 20:24the estoppel certificate. So there's something
- 20:27securitizing that seller estoppel certificate.
- 20:33As I mentioned earlier, the contract gives the
- 20:39buyer a free look. And as a seller, you may want
- 20:42to change this to have that buyer actually perform
- 20:45due diligence, for example, doing an inspection
- 20:48or adding a provision that the buyer has to use
- 20:51commercially reasonable efforts. I've seen this
- 20:53quite often with getting a loan and have the
- 20:56buyer submit loan application and provide seller
- 20:59copies of the loan applications, etc. Or you
- 21:01want to get a pre -qualification letter before
- 21:05you accept the buyer's offer. My experience has
- 21:09been that with these kind of additions, what
- 21:13you're inevitably gonna end up with is a dispute
- 21:16as to whether or not the buyer did meet the requirements
- 21:20in the contract that you've added. And oftentimes
- 21:22that ends up prolonging a termination of the
- 21:27contract. When the buyer has decided not to buy
- 21:29and the seller is trying to... get the buyer
- 21:31to forfeit a deposit, it ends up prolonging the
- 21:35dispute and puts a cloud on title of the property
- 21:37when the seller wants to sell it to the next
- 21:40buyer. So I don't see this happening quite a
- 21:45bit where people actually commit to require a
- 21:48buyer to do this kind of a commitment to perform
- 21:50due diligence. In long -term escrows, for example,
- 21:54if there's an entitlement deal where the land
- 21:56is being subdivided and the developer is a home
- 21:58builder who's going to go through the parcel
- 22:02split and get the entitlements to create a subdivision.
- 22:07It's pretty typical to ask the buyer to pay as
- 22:10you play. So the longer that the property is
- 22:13tied up in escrow, the seller will require the
- 22:15buyer to either put additional deposits into
- 22:18escrow or have the buyer pay those additional
- 22:22deposits to seller outside of escrow in order
- 22:24to have more due diligence time or extend the
- 22:28closing date. That change is where the rubber
- 22:33meets the road. If the buyer is really interested
- 22:36in still pursuing the deal, then they will put
- 22:39up the additional money. If they're not, then
- 22:42they'll cancel and they won't waste any more
- 22:44time. One of the things that I've seen happen
- 22:47quite often is where people have this additional
- 22:50deposit. They're not very clear as to what is
- 22:53this additional money for. This also happens
- 22:56with deals where the parties sign and go hard,
- 22:58which is not happening in today's market. It
- 23:00was very prevalent three, four years ago. You
- 23:03have to be clear about what this additional money
- 23:07is for. And oftentimes, it's money that's given
- 23:12by the buyer to the seller to either extend the
- 23:15due diligence period or extend the closing date.
- 23:17And when the buyer makes those payments, that
- 23:20has been earned by the seller. And you want to
- 23:25make sure that you don't characterize it as liquidated
- 23:28damages, because that only gets paid to the seller
- 23:30if the buyer has signed off on all the contingencies
- 23:33and fails to close on the scheduled closing date.
- 23:37And it's important to make sure you properly
- 23:40characterize the application of the money and
- 23:43what it's for and is it refundable or not, and
- 23:45is it applicable to the price. Let's talk about
- 23:51the retrade process. And what I mean by the retrade
- 23:54process, it happens pretty much in every deal
- 23:56where a buyer does an inspection, comes back
- 23:59and says, the roof needs to be replaced. I want
- 24:01a $50 ,000 price reduction or credit. Section
- 24:069 .1 of the AIR contract provides what we call
- 24:10is a passive approval, meaning if the buyer does
- 24:14not actively disapprove of a contingency, then
- 24:17the buyer is deemed to have approved of that
- 24:20contingency. So it's important for the buyer
- 24:24or the buyer's broker to make sure that they
- 24:26closely monitor the due diligence timeframes
- 24:30to make sure they don't inadvertently allow a
- 24:33contingency to become approved or deemed approved.
- 24:38So the way the contract works is that buyer's
- 24:41disapproval or conditional approval is considered
- 24:45a disapproval. The buyer concurrently with a
- 24:50disapproval or conditional approval can ask for
- 24:52price reduction or credit, can ask the seller
- 24:55to perform some kind of repair, ask for more
- 24:58time for either the contingency or more time
- 25:01for closing or anything else. If the buyer just
- 25:05disapproves and doesn't ask for anything, then
- 25:08the contract is over. Then the buyer is refunded
- 25:12its money, the party's part ways and the contract
- 25:15is over. If the buyer does ask for some repair,
- 25:21price reduction, more time, et cetera, then the
- 25:24seller has 10 days to respond to the buyer's
- 25:26request. If the seller accepts the buyer's request,
- 25:29that automatically amends the contract. So you
- 25:32don't have to go through the process of getting
- 25:33escrow to prepare a separate amendment. The acceptance
- 25:37automatically amends the contract, provided the
- 25:39seller's acceptance of the buyer's request is
- 25:42without modification. If the seller doesn't do
- 25:47anything and is silent for 10 days, then the
- 25:49seller is deemed to have rejected the buyer's
- 25:51request and then the buyer then has 10 days to
- 25:53decide to cancel the deal and get his money back
- 25:56or accept the seller's response if there was
- 25:59a response or withdraw buyer's request and go
- 26:01back to square one. So ultimately the buyer is
- 26:05the one who's driving this process. buyer gets
- 26:08the last word in this back and forth. And the
- 26:11reason for that is the buyer who's more likely
- 26:13to be at risk and more likely to be suing. So
- 26:18this gives the buyer a lot of leeway to try to
- 26:23renegotiate something that the buyer's unhappy
- 26:25with. A lot of sellers don't like this back and
- 26:27forth. You can eliminate this back and forth
- 26:29altogether and modify the contract, provide that
- 26:33if the buyer disapproves, the contract is over.
- 26:36or reduce the timeframes. Now, the timeframes
- 26:41can be reduced pretty dramatically and it probably
- 26:47is not an unfair thing to a buyer because most
- 26:51buyers really don't need that much time to approve.
- 26:54But the reason these timeframes are so long is
- 26:57to allow the parties to work out a deal. So as
- 27:01a seller, you think this is too long, you can
- 27:04modify the contracts by going in there and altering
- 27:07the actual text of the contract to reduce the
- 27:12timeframes or eliminate this back and forth process
- 27:15altogether. So here's a chart that summarizes
- 27:20this process that I just described. If the buyer
- 27:25does not disapprove, then the buyer is deemed
- 27:28approved. and the contingency is waived. If the
- 27:34buyer disapproves, if the buyer doesn't make
- 27:37a request, the contract is terminated. If the
- 27:40buyer does make a request, then it's up to the
- 27:43seller to accept, in which case the contract
- 27:45is modified. If seller rejects or does not respond,
- 27:48then the buyer can withdraw this approved item
- 27:51or the buyer can cancel the contract and get
- 27:54its money back. So this is in there primarily
- 27:59to make sure that the deal can be made which
- 28:01is really beneficial for the buyer and the brokers
- 28:03because the brokers are the ones who work hard
- 28:04to put the deal together and they don't want
- 28:06to see the deal evaporate in the thin air just
- 28:09because the seller has and the buyer have something
- 28:12to work out as a retrade process. The next point
- 28:18to talk about is the closing costs. Our contract,
- 28:23the base contract is the Southern California
- 28:27custom for splitting closing costs. The escrow
- 28:33charges are split 50 -50. The seller pays the
- 28:37recording fees. The seller pays the documentary
- 28:41transfer taxes, and that includes the ULA or
- 28:44the mansion tax. And the seller pays for the
- 28:48standard title issuance policy premium. The buyer
- 28:52pays for the upgrade to an ALTA policy and it
- 28:56is very, very important for a broker or lawyer
- 28:59to pay attention to the section if you're doing
- 29:02a deal in Northern California or you're doing
- 29:05a deal in another jurisdiction. By the way, the
- 29:08AIR contracts are now available in, I think,
- 29:1148 out of the 50 states. They'll be available
- 29:13in all 50 states pretty soon. It's important
- 29:19that if you're doing a deal outside of Southern
- 29:21California to modify this split of closing costs
- 29:25to match the local custom. And the local custom
- 29:31can significantly cost you or save you money.
- 29:35either you're the buyer or the seller. It's very
- 29:37important to pay attention to this. It's significant
- 29:41monies could be affected by the conforming the
- 29:46closing costs split to the local custom. Anyone
- 29:50who does much residential work will note that
- 29:53during the pandemic and with the last big change
- 29:57in the CAR purchase agreement, they move more
- 30:01in favor of the sellers and really away from
- 30:05benefiting the buyers so much. Really, in my
- 30:09view, to the detriment of buyers in what had
- 30:13become really a seller's market during the pandemic
- 30:16when so many people were trying to find new places
- 30:19to go. You need to be careful to make certain
- 30:22that you look at what's in the commercial contract
- 30:26that AIR has because they haven't necessarily
- 30:30behaved the same way that CAR did during the
- 30:32pandemic? Our contracts are modified based on
- 30:37input from our users. We do not often make changes
- 30:41to the contracts based on what's happening in
- 30:43the market. They have worked well, both in the
- 30:51up and the down market, and we haven't had the
- 30:55need from our customer user base to make those
- 30:58kind of changes. Let's talk about seller's reps
- 31:02and warranties. And this is obviously a favorite
- 31:04topic for lawyers. And section 12 .1 of the purchase
- 31:10and sale agreement has a list of areas that are
- 31:18warranted by the seller. I would say this is
- 31:22a healthy list. It's not the most exhaustive
- 31:25list. Obviously, as a buyer's lawyer, you can
- 31:27supplement and expand this to include topics
- 31:32that are applicable to a particular property.
- 31:36But generally, Section 12 .1 deals with the authority
- 31:39of the seller, that the seller has the right
- 31:41power and authority to enter the contract and
- 31:43consummate the transaction, that the seller will
- 31:47maintain the property pending escrow, the seller
- 31:50is unaware of any hazardous substances, that
- 31:53to the best of seller's knowledge, the seller
- 31:55property complies with all applicable laws. The
- 31:58seller will not change the leases or any other
- 32:01agreements while the property is in escrow, that
- 32:04there are no other leases, there are no mechanic
- 32:07liens, no lawsuits, no tenant bankruptcy, and
- 32:11no lien on the personal property. So what's important
- 32:17to, as a lawyer, ask yourself, Are we using the
- 32:21purchase and sale contract that's published by
- 32:23the AIR to try to streamline and accelerate the
- 32:27deal? Or is this just a starting point to start
- 32:31heavily negotiating? And I've seen both, and
- 32:34I'm sure everybody in the audience has seen where
- 32:38you start with a printed document and then it
- 32:41gets ripped to shreds and the addendum is much
- 32:46longer than the actual contract. What the AIR
- 32:51has done is try to provide a set of warranties
- 32:57that if a buyer was represented by a competent
- 33:02real estate counsel would get from a seller who
- 33:04was represented by competent real estate counsel.
- 33:08Is it everything that a buyer would ask for?
- 33:11No. Does this mean that the seller has to agree
- 33:15to all of this? No. But here's the reality of
- 33:19how this plays out when you go to negotiate.
- 33:23Once you strike or modify one of these, inevitably,
- 33:27either the lawyer for the other side or the principal
- 33:30of the other side will look at what you changed
- 33:32or what you added. And that becomes the bone
- 33:35of contention. And although while there's no
- 33:39standard for what is a usual set of reps or warranties,
- 33:45these warranties have stood the test time for
- 33:48many years to be good enough for a buyer and
- 33:51a seller. It's not too much to the landlord,
- 33:54not too much in favor of the buyer, not too much
- 33:57in favor of the seller. So the contract provides
- 34:03that the warranty survived for three years after
- 34:07the closing. Obviously, this is not the law in
- 34:11California, which is four years for breach of
- 34:13contract, but it's there as a placeholder to
- 34:16remind you that if you want to modify, and this
- 34:19is something that gets negotiated in attorney
- 34:22-negotiated purchasing and sale agreements, how
- 34:24long is the seller's warranty going to be good
- 34:26for? It's there if you want to modify it, you
- 34:29could reduce three years to six months or you
- 34:31want to lengthen it, you can do that too. From
- 34:36the seller's perspective, you want to reduce
- 34:38the duration of seller's warranties. And from
- 34:41the seller's perspective, you want to eliminate
- 34:43as many as possible to reduce the seller's exposure
- 34:49for having made these representations or warranties.
- 34:54Brian, this may be a good place for the question
- 34:57we have in the Q &A, which is, do you routinely
- 35:00see buyer's counsel use a very custom form of
- 35:03agreement, especially maybe on deals that are
- 35:0610 million and above? And then if you represent
- 35:09the seller, do you try to convince counsel for
- 35:12the buyer to use the form, the AIR form, and
- 35:15why or why not? For larger deals and more complicated
- 35:20deals, I see the tailor -made contracts being
- 35:26used more often. But I myself have done many
- 35:30what I consider to be large leases and purchase
- 35:33and sale transactions using the AIR contracts.
- 35:35They work just fine. And they actually help limit
- 35:41the negotiations between the lawyers by giving
- 35:46you the basic framework of an agreement. And
- 35:50you focus on what specifically needs to happen
- 35:54in this particular deal. For larger transactions,
- 35:59I think sometimes parties want to have document
- 36:01control, Howard. They want to assert their leverage,
- 36:06especially in today's market where it's a buyer's
- 36:08market. pre -printed contracts like the AIR used,
- 36:18for example, by somebody who puts an addendum
- 36:21on it that becomes so onerous that they might
- 36:24as well use the tailor -made contract that it
- 36:27wouldn't have made a difference. So if you're
- 36:29going to go use the AIR contracts, try to stick
- 36:32with what the point of it is to streamline the
- 36:39transaction and avoid a lot of unnecessary negotiating.
- 36:43Again, that's a question of market, who's got
- 36:45the leverage, and who wants to deal more badly.
- 36:53I think one other big benefit of using the IAR
- 36:57form agreement is because if real estate lawyers
- 37:01tend to be familiar with them, some of the buyers
- 37:03and sellers are familiar with them, and you know
- 37:06where to find particular points. Whereas even
- 37:10if there's a long addendum, Hopefully, the addendum
- 37:13relates to the specific point and heading that
- 37:17was in the AIR contract so you know where to
- 37:19find things. Otherwise, if you have a custom
- 37:22agreement that's really long, you may not remember
- 37:25where something is in that agreement when you
- 37:27go back to try to deal with it. Right. If you
- 37:30use a custom agreement, the one who prepared
- 37:32it and is their form has the upper hand. They
- 37:34have so much more information about the contract
- 37:37that it gives them a real leg up in the negotiation.
- 37:41pre -printed AIR contract does sort of even out
- 37:44that playing field. So it's not completely lopsided
- 37:47like it is when you start with the other side's
- 37:49form. And I've seen it where sometimes it actually
- 37:54doesn't help to use the pre -printed form where
- 37:56it gets so heavily negotiated, then it becomes
- 37:59kind of clunky negotiating the contract. So sometimes
- 38:02it may make sense not to use it and just go to
- 38:04a tailor -made one. But if you're going to use
- 38:06the pre -printed, try not to just undermine the
- 38:09whole purpose of it by having a lot of changes
- 38:12or a huge addendum. And make certain that the
- 38:15changes relate to the section in the AAR contract
- 38:18that already addresses the subject matter, so
- 38:21it doesn't get too confusing to find. Right.
- 38:24So in the AIR contract, quite a few of the representations
- 38:27or warranties are limited to the seller's knowledge,
- 38:29and it's very commonplace to have a seller define
- 38:35seller's knowledge to be seller's, the actual
- 38:38knowledge of a particular identified person who
- 38:40works in the seller's organization. So, and that
- 38:44duty, that knowledge is without any duty of inquiry
- 38:49or investigation. So it's what that person actually
- 38:53knows at the time the contract is signed. This
- 38:56is a typical ad that I see, and I don't think
- 38:59it's unfair for a seller to add this. It also
- 39:03disclaims the knowledge of sellers, other agents
- 39:05and employees or principals. This provision also
- 39:10typically says that the person who's named in
- 39:13the contract doesn't have any personal liability
- 39:16if it turns out that the warranty was breached.
- 39:19Rather, it's the selling entity that's going
- 39:21to be on the hook, not the individual. One thing
- 39:26to pay attention to the section 12 .3 provides
- 39:30that if the buyer closes after the buyer has
- 39:32learned a rep or warranty is incorrect, that
- 39:35equates to a waiver of the seller's breach. Now,
- 39:40in California, there's a split of authority on
- 39:44this issue of whether or not a buyer waives a
- 39:49breach of warranty by proceeding to close or
- 39:52not. I think as a buyer, you may want to be able
- 39:58to sue and not be deemed to have waived the breach
- 40:01of a warranty. you can recover damages that may
- 40:07be due because of the misrepresentation or the
- 40:10misleading of the buyer to enter into the contract.
- 40:13And then the buyer was stuck in a bad position
- 40:15where they had to close the deal or they would
- 40:18end up suffering significant damages. So 12 .3
- 40:23is something that as a buyer It protects the
- 40:26buyer. As a seller, you may want to flip it until
- 40:30there's some kind of a resolution of the split
- 40:32of authority in California. Our contract says
- 40:36it's a waiver, which is more aligned with what
- 40:39a ordinary person would expect, that if you knew
- 40:43a rep or warranty was incorrect and you bought,
- 40:45then you assume that risk. The seller also provides
- 40:51under our contracts two other documents that
- 40:54are part of the disclosure. The first one is
- 40:56the property information sheet. In this property
- 40:59information sheet, it basically is a list of
- 41:04the different components of the property and
- 41:06it requires the seller to tell the buyer of any
- 41:10defects that the seller is aware of in that part
- 41:13of the property. It covers the equipment, the
- 41:19condition of equipment, soil problems, insurance
- 41:21claims, violations of any laws, any hazardous
- 41:24substance, contamination, or any storage tanks
- 41:27that were on the property, any fire damage, any
- 41:30unrecorded title exceptions, and the leases.
- 41:34So this is the property information sheet. The
- 41:38second item that's required by a contract to
- 41:40be provided by a seller to a buyer is what's
- 41:43called a seller's mandatory disclosure statement.
- 41:46The seller's mandatory disclosure statement basically
- 41:49is to fulfill a seller's duty to disclose things
- 41:58that the law requires be disclosed by a seller
- 42:03to a buyer regarding whether or not the property
- 42:05is, for example, is in an earthquake zone or
- 42:08in a high -fire risk zone or a flood zone, and
- 42:12it requires the buyer be provided a book earthquake
- 42:16booklet and be notified if there was flood disaster
- 42:20insurance and water heater bracing has been done,
- 42:23if there's any mold and there's a notification
- 42:26that's required to be given by law regarding
- 42:28title insurance. The seller's mandatory disclosure
- 42:32statement, as the name implies, is the seller's
- 42:35statutory duty. And a lot of this is taken care
- 42:38of by this cottage industry that's popped up
- 42:40many years ago where a natural hazard disclosure
- 42:44is provided by the seller as part of the seller's
- 42:46mandatory disclosure statement to the buyer.
- 42:49The property information sheet is meant to satisfy
- 42:53the seller's common law duty of disclosure of
- 42:56defects that are known to the seller that would
- 42:59affect the value or desirability of the property.
- 43:03These two, combined with the seller's warranties,
- 43:06and there is some overlap between the information
- 43:09that's in the seller's property information sheet
- 43:11and the seller's warranties in the body of the
- 43:13contract. So, a lot of people will add to the
- 43:21contract as is. And section 12 .2 is the closest
- 43:27thing we have in the contract to... Sorry. and
- 43:33as is provisioned. Section 12 .2 says that the
- 43:38buyer is buying the property in its existing
- 43:40condition and will have either done its investigations
- 43:45or waived those investigations that it thinks
- 43:48is necessary to protect itself. And the seller
- 43:51buyer acknowledges that there's no other promises
- 43:54besides what's in the contract. What does as
- 43:59is mean? If you read the cases, they basically
- 44:02say that's supposed to alert a buyer that the
- 44:06buyer needs to do more diligent and thorough
- 44:09investigation. Commonly, there's a misunderstanding
- 44:13that I'm not amongst the lawyers, but a lot of
- 44:17brokers think that if you sell something as is,
- 44:19you no longer have a duty to disclose the material
- 44:21bad facts, which is absolutely not the law. even
- 44:25if you have an as is, the seller still has the
- 44:28duty to disclose the bad facts to the buyer.
- 44:31So as a seller, you can expand the as is. And
- 44:35one of the most common ways that I've seen the
- 44:37as is expanded is for the seller to add a release
- 44:41of claims by the buyer against the seller. for
- 44:46any claims that arise from the purchase and sale
- 44:49contract or the property itself. For example,
- 44:52the physical condition of the property, the property's
- 44:55compliance with applicable laws, the property's
- 44:57any environmental problems, and that's often
- 45:00combined with a waiver of California Civil Code
- 45:021542, which I've seen more often than I would
- 45:07think would be acceptable in the market. But
- 45:10quite often, I've seen the sellers are able to
- 45:14manage to get that and it's often negotiated
- 45:18to push back on. Obviously, the law doesn't permit
- 45:22release of claims that are based on fraud and
- 45:25things of that nature, but you also carve out
- 45:27breach of sellers representations or warranties
- 45:29and covenants from these waivers. From the buyer's
- 45:35perspective, sometimes buyer try to beef up or
- 45:38strengthen the seller's warranties by asking
- 45:41seller to represent a warrant regarding the mechanical
- 45:43or physical defects in the property. For example,
- 45:46the building systems that they're in good operating
- 45:49order. Usually, the sellers resist this kind
- 45:52of warranty regarding matters that a buyer can
- 45:54discover by its own due diligence. Typically,
- 46:00sellers are willing to warrant things that a
- 46:03buyer could not discover by its own independent
- 46:06investigation of the property or going to the
- 46:09city or doing whatever kind of due diligence
- 46:12that is necessary. Let me go on to the next topic,
- 46:23the assignment. This is a section 1 .1. Our contract
- 46:28is very, very favorable to the buyer. Basically,
- 46:30it gives the buyer the right to assign the contract.
- 46:34it doesn't release the buyer, the sentence in
- 46:39the contract is basically declarative of existing
- 46:41law. In other words, contracts are assignable
- 46:43and the assignee is not released. From the seller's
- 46:47perspective, the seller may require an assumption
- 46:50by an assignee, and in fact, the law is that
- 46:52a buyer who wants to sue for a specific performance
- 46:55has to assume the contract. So the assumption
- 46:58is not in the contract, you can add that. The
- 47:02seller can also absolutely prohibit an assignment.
- 47:05And one of the things that burns sellers is if
- 47:07a buyer makes an assignment and makes money on
- 47:12flipping the contract. And that gives the sellers
- 47:15a lot of remorse because they see somebody who,
- 47:19for example, didn't own the property as long
- 47:20as they did, now they made. a hefty profit over
- 47:23a short period of time. So a lot of sellers would
- 47:26try to prohibit the assignment. If you do prohibit
- 47:29the assignment, then you got to deal with, are
- 47:31you going to permit some kind of assignment?
- 47:33And then what's the standard that's going to
- 47:35be applicable to seller giving the consent? Is
- 47:38it going to be arbitrary or reasonable? If there
- 47:41is seller financing, then there may be a separate
- 47:47independent justification for the seller to want
- 47:50to require that the buyer obtain the seller's
- 47:54consent for the buyer to assign the contract,
- 47:57because the seller may not want to finance anybody,
- 48:01even though in California we have the one -action
- 48:04rule and we have the anti -deficiency statutes,
- 48:06which basically grows some area. But if the seller
- 48:11can only foreclose on the property, I can't sue
- 48:17for the buyer for any deficiency if the buyer
- 48:20doesn't pay the loan. Our contracts provide the
- 48:24seller with the right to approve of a buyer's
- 48:27credit and financials in case there's seller
- 48:29financing. A typical car map for a buyer to be
- 48:37able to assign is to its affiliates, for example,
- 48:39an LLC that's owned by the same principles that
- 48:43are transacting to buy the property. Access to
- 48:53the property is something that you need to think
- 48:56about if you're doing an environmentally potentially
- 49:00concerning property, so an industrial property
- 49:03is usually when this issue comes up. Our contracts
- 49:08say that the buyer can't do any invasive testing.
- 49:12without the seller's consent. And the problem
- 49:17or the dilemma is created by the fact that the
- 49:20buyer will do a phase one report, which will
- 49:22now say you need a phase two, but the buyer can't
- 49:25do a phase two without the seller consenting.
- 49:27And our contract says that the seller has to
- 49:29consent reasonably, but the seller may not want
- 49:33to find out about the potential environmental
- 49:38problems with the property. not knowing whether
- 49:40the buyer is going to buy or not. On the other
- 49:42hand, the buyer is the one who spent money doing
- 49:45a phase one report and doesn't want to have the
- 49:48situation where they've reached a point where
- 49:51there's a potential environmental issue that
- 49:53needs to be resolved by further investigation,
- 49:56but the seller won't permit the buyer to do that.
- 49:59Now you're at a standstill. So our contracts
- 50:02say the seller can't be unreasonable in granting
- 50:05the buyer's request to do invasive or destructive
- 50:08testing. As a buyer, you may want to get the
- 50:13seller to consent upfront, especially in an industrial
- 50:18deal where you think you might need to do a phase
- 50:21two if the phase one recommends it. So you can
- 50:24get the seller upfront to say, okay, I'll let
- 50:26you do a phase two to the extent that it's recommended
- 50:28by phase one. From the buyer's perspective, you
- 50:31also want to maybe add something that says buyer's
- 50:33not responsible for discovering any pre -existing
- 50:36environmental contamination, so long as the buyer
- 50:39doesn't aggravate that situation. A typical ad
- 50:44that I see is the sellers will add a requirement
- 50:47for the buyer or buyer's environmental engineer
- 50:49to have insurance. They could have a commercial
- 50:53general liability insurance that names the seller
- 50:55as an additional insured. E &O insurance, auto
- 50:58liability, and workers' comp insurance. Those
- 51:00are pretty typical ads that I see if somebody
- 51:03is very concerned about this issue. So let's
- 51:09talk about liquidated damages and remedies. The
- 51:12earnest money deposit is often the liquidated
- 51:15damages in the contract. And our contracts have
- 51:19a provision for liquidating damages to a seller
- 51:22in case a buyer breaches and doesn't close. Our
- 51:27contracts do not require mediation before you
- 51:31litigate or proceed with resolving the dispute
- 51:36over liquidated damages. Our contracts do include
- 51:40an arbitration provision in addition to the liquidated
- 51:44damages provision. By the way, as most of you
- 51:46know, both of those have to be separately initialed
- 51:49for them to be applicable. The arbitration, however,
- 51:54only applies to the disposition of the earnest
- 51:57money deposit. In other words, does the buyer
- 51:59get it or does the seller get the earnest money
- 52:01deposit? If you're a fan of arbitration, you
- 52:05can broaden the application of the arbitration
- 52:09provision to apply to all or more disputes. From
- 52:15the seller's perspective, it's not uncommon for
- 52:21a seller to establish a deductible for buyer's
- 52:28damages for seller's breach of its warranty before
- 52:31the seller becomes responsible. In other words,
- 52:34if there's a breach of the seller's warranties,
- 52:36the buyer has to suffer at least, for example,
- 52:38$50 ,000 worth of damages before the buyer can
- 52:41proceed against the seller for breach of seller's
- 52:44warranties. That's very commonplace. Conversely,
- 52:51the seller can also put a cap on the seller's
- 52:53liability for breach of warranty. The argument
- 52:57typically goes like this. Well, the buyer has
- 53:01put in usually a 3 % of the purchase price as
- 53:04earnest money deposit, and the contract has a
- 53:07liquidated damages provision. And it provides
- 53:09that if the buyer breaches the contract, then
- 53:11the seller can get the liquidated damages. And
- 53:13that's the extent of the buyer's exposure for
- 53:17breach of the contract and not closing. So the
- 53:20seller's argument is that I should be able to
- 53:22put a similar cap on my liability for my breach
- 53:25of the contract. This is a breach of the warranty.
- 53:28It's not a failure to convey title. And this
- 53:32will range, depending on the property type and
- 53:35the leverage and the price, it will range from
- 53:39a low of 1 % or 2%, 3 % to 5%, 10%. But the cap
- 53:45on the seller's liability is an important provision
- 53:47to protect the seller in case there are extensive
- 53:51warranties. Another protection for the seller
- 53:58is to have the buyer waive the right of specific
- 54:01performance or add reciprocal liquid damages
- 54:04for seller's breach. Now, buyers seldom agree
- 54:08to this because this allows the seller to sell
- 54:13the property from under the buyer. And if a buyer
- 54:16enters into a contract to buy a property, they're
- 54:18intent on buying that specific property. And
- 54:21I have not seen too many buyers who are willing
- 54:23to agree to either the waiver of the specific
- 54:26performance or reciprocal liquidated damages
- 54:28for breach. Let's talk about the protections
- 54:35that are in the contract for the buyer. for the
- 54:38broker, sorry, the protections that are in the
- 54:40contract for the broker. As you know, AIR is
- 54:43a broker organization. We don't make a secret
- 54:49of it. The contracts are printed to protect the
- 54:51brokers and some of the protections in the contract,
- 54:58I'm gonna highlight here so you can make a note
- 55:01of all these provisions to strike. So if you're
- 55:05representing the buyer to seller. Section 7 .1,
- 55:09the last sentence says that the buyer will use
- 55:11the buyer's broker exclusively for negotiating
- 55:16any deals with this property for one year. This
- 55:21was really meant to be a prophylactic provision
- 55:25to prevent a buyer and a seller colluding with
- 55:28each other near the end of a listing to say,
- 55:31you know what, don't respond to my offer. Let's
- 55:34wait till the listing expires. Then I'll come
- 55:37back and we'll make a deal with save the commission
- 55:40or we'll split the commission. That way we can
- 55:42avoid paying the buyer's broker or the seller's
- 55:44broker or any broker at all. So this is meant
- 55:49to prevent a buyer and the seller colluding with
- 55:53each other to run out the clock on a listing
- 55:58and then make a deal without the brokers. What's
- 56:01happened in California, we had the AB 2992 that
- 56:04became effective January 1, 2025, which requires
- 56:07every broker representing a buyer to have a buyer
- 56:10broker representation agreement. That's the law
- 56:13now. So this is less of a concern for the buyer's
- 56:16broker because they will be protected by the
- 56:19buyer broker representation agreement. Most seller
- 56:23brokers have a registration period in their listing
- 56:26agreement. So this may not be as critical with
- 56:31a passage of AB 2992 in California. So Brian,
- 56:35we have three slides in about four minutes. Yeah,
- 56:39I'm almost done here, Howard. Great. So section
- 56:429 .1 is the payment of the commission at the
- 56:45closing. This is very often stricken. And it
- 56:49doesn't really, that's very often happens. The
- 56:52next one is section 18 .1. This is important.
- 56:55The party who defaults has to pay the broker
- 56:57the fee that the broker would have been paid.
- 57:00If the buyer is the defaulting party, the buyer
- 57:02owes the broker's fee in addition to any liquidated
- 57:05damages. So this is a very important provision
- 57:07to pay attention to, 18 .1. 24 .1 is D is two
- 57:14provisions. One is that says that the reduces
- 57:18the statute of limitation for suing the broker
- 57:20to one year after the date of agreement and puts
- 57:24a cap on the amount of the broker's exposure
- 57:29to the amount of the fee that was received by
- 57:33the broker from the transaction. I just wanted
- 57:40to highlight these for people to have it in one
- 57:42place. With that, Howard, I'm going to - Great.
- 57:47One or two other things. Someone was asking a
- 57:52question about the seller can only foreclose
- 57:54what statute or case. I'm not sure I recall exactly
- 57:58what that related to, but is there some limitation
- 58:02of the remedy to foreclosure? So in California,
- 58:05we have what's called that one action rule and
- 58:07the added deficiency statutes, which are very
- 58:10complex, but generally speaking, if a seller
- 58:14finances part of the purchase price by taking
- 58:17back a note secured by the property that the
- 58:19seller sold, if the seller forecloses and there's
- 58:23a shortfall, the seller can't sue the buyer for
- 58:27a deficiency. That's the added deficiency statutes
- 58:29and the one action rule, very generally speaking.
- 58:36And one gentleman says that when he represents
- 58:39sellers, he likes to strike out the obligation
- 58:41for the property info sheet and when the property
- 58:45is being sold as is. But they still advise the
- 58:48client to disclose all material facts, but he
- 58:51feels the property info sheet is broader than
- 58:54simply those disclosures. So the deleting the
- 58:59property information sheet is not a way to get
- 59:06around the seller's duty to disclose, as the
- 59:08gentleman is correctly noting. You still, as
- 59:10a seller, have a duty to disclose the material
- 59:12facts of which you're aware, which affect the
- 59:14value or desirability of the property. The property
- 59:17information sheet is very thorough. It goes through
- 59:20every aspect of the property and asks the seller
- 59:24to tell the buyer, does the seller know, for
- 59:27example, the HVAC doesn't work, the roof doesn't
- 59:30leak. So it may not be material item in each
- 59:36transaction, but the property information sheet
- 59:38is a generic form that's meant to help the seller
- 59:42think about different aspects of the property
- 59:45and was there something that I need to disclose.
- 59:48And it's also, don't forget, it's prophylactic
- 59:51for the broker because the seller is supposed
- 59:53to disclose the defects and it covers the broker's
- 59:55neck too. buyer or representing a buyer and I
- 1:00:00see that stricken, I almost wonder if that's
- 1:00:02a red flag that they're telling me that there's
- 1:00:05problems they don't want to tell me about and
- 1:00:07whether it's going to make the buyer's investigation
- 1:00:09and questions to the seller a little more detailed
- 1:00:12and thorough than they might be if they get the
- 1:00:14property information sheet. That's an excellent
- 1:00:17point. A lot of these contract provisions are
- 1:00:19meant to be a checklist. And if you see the checklist
- 1:00:22being taken out and the disclosure is removed,
- 1:00:25then is it a red flag or isn't it? Absolutely.
- 1:00:29So we're actually right at 1 .30. We handled
- 1:00:32the questions. Brian, always a pleasure. Your
- 1:00:35knowledge of all this is so thorough and the
- 1:00:38way you phrased everything I thought was fantastic
- 1:00:42and really appreciate you coming back again this
- 1:00:45year to do this program on the purchase and sale
- 1:00:47agreement and look forward to the next time.
- 1:00:50My pleasure. Thank you for asking. Thank you
- 1:00:51to everybody for attending. We appreciate it
- 1:00:54and hope to see you the next few months at our
- 1:00:56programs for the real estate section. You may
- 1:00:59be eligible for CLE credit in your state. Visit
- 1:01:02bhba .org slash podcasts for more information.