Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 23)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:03Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're diving right back in
- 0:07to the alex Acosta interview with the OIG investigators, and
- 0:11we're getting close to the end here. Question and just
- 0:15one thing on work release issue. Did you tell the
- 0:18defense that the US Attorney's Office would not object if
- 0:21he got work release as long as he's treated like
- 0:24every other defendant. Answer? So, I don't recall what I
- 0:28may or may not have said specifically around work release.
- 0:32My recollection of our general position is you're pleading in
- 0:35state court to incarceration of eighteen. Now it's eighteen months,
- 0:39it was twenty four. Whether it was eighteen or twenty four,
- 0:44this would have been any conversation I would have had
- 0:46would have been after the agreement was signed. It's our
- 0:50expectation that he be treated just like everyone else. If
- 0:54it was typical to provide that kind of work release
- 0:56in these cases, that would have been news to me.
- 0:59I certainly would not have expected that, and I think,
- 1:01based on our subsequent communication with the State Attorney's office,
- 1:06that was not what our office envisioned. By the same token,
- 1:09I don't want to think our office envisioned that he'd
- 1:12be treated worth that the typical offender. Question Well, did
- 1:16you know that redacted was in fact trying to make
- 1:18sure that he didn't get work release? Answer? Yes, and
- 1:23so I don't see any reason why I would have
- 1:25contradicted that. That's my point. Question all right, you've mentioned
- 1:30the number of times that the sexual offender registration was
- 1:33one of the three important prongs for you and the office.
- 1:37Answer yes, question what was it that you saw the
- 1:40sex offender registration as accomplishing? Answer? So, to some extent,
- 1:45it's putting the community on notice that, irrespective of whether
- 1:49he's in Florida or elsewhere, he's a registered sex offender.
- 1:53To some extent, I don't know if this, but I'll
- 1:56say it anyhow, this was a serious crime, and there's
- 1:59a public sanctions associated with this, and I thought, to
- 2:02the extent that he committed the types of acts that
- 2:05typically are associated with registration, that should go forward. But
- 2:10the primary motivation there was put the public on notice
- 2:14that he is a registered sex offender. Question and did
- 2:17you see any conflict with that as being the goal?
- 2:20With the provision in the NPA that the NPA was
- 2:23going to be kept confidential and the communication in which
- 2:27the US Attorney's Office was having with the defense about
- 2:30continuing to keep things confidential. Do you see any inconsistency
- 2:34between those two? Answer no, and that I genuinely was
- 2:38of the opinion that the NPA would go public, and
- 2:41certainly his public his state core plea would be public,
- 2:45and his registration would be public, and so what he
- 2:48did would be known. Question and given what you know
- 2:52about these offices back and forth on notifying the victims,
- 2:56do you think, looking at the entire course of conduct
- 2:58of the office, that the victims were treated fairly and
- 3:01with dignity and respect. Answer? So, I want to be careful,
- 3:06not because I'm fudging, but because it's a complex question.
- 3:09If looking back in hindsight, we knew that there would
- 3:12be what was it, two eight month periods? Do we
- 3:16have an agreement? Do we not have an agreement? Is
- 3:18this concluded? Is this not concluded? Is this an ongoing investigation?
- 3:22How do we deal with all these notification issues? If
- 3:26we had foreseen all of that, I think I've said
- 3:29before that something I certainly think should have been considered,
- 3:32and it's very possible we would have done something very different.
- 3:35But that was not foreseen, and so it's then a
- 3:38very difficult judgment to be made because there is an agreement,
- 3:42there is concern as to if we go to trial,
- 3:45how do you address this? There is you know, going
- 3:47to the affid David at least one instant, and I'm
- 3:50merging my recollection here and my knowledge after the fact,
- 3:53because your question sort of calls for an after the
- 3:56fact assessment. So you've got the addacted after David, which
- 4:00points out the defense Council did all they could, but
- 4:03is using this to impeach and weaken witness credibility in
- 4:06a case where there's already questions around witness credibility. And
- 4:11so it's a very imperfect situation with discretionary judgments to
- 4:16do the best to sort of balance all of these factors.
- 4:19Is that the best outcome? Probably not, But that's where
- 4:22we were, and that's why I think this case would
- 4:26have been very different than it was October twenty fourth.
- 4:31He would have gone in and pled and taken his
- 4:33time and served his time like many other people have done,
- 4:36as opposed to mount all these legal challenges that we
- 4:39then had to work through. Question and I'll preface my
- 4:43question with the fact that we're still investigating this. We've
- 4:47made no conclusions with respect to this. But if OPR
- 4:50determines that your office should be criticized for its handling
- 4:53of this, does the criticism fall on you or does
- 4:57it fall on your senior managers because a non prosecutor,
- 5:00you were relying on them to keep you informed and
- 5:03for their judgment. Answer. So, I was the US attorney.
- 5:07I certainly relied on my staff, but ultimately I was
- 5:11the US attorney, And I don't think it's justifiable or
- 5:14fair to sort of say this was on them. I
- 5:18was sufficiently aware of matters that it was my office.
- 5:21And while I'll say that it was, I might not
- 5:23recall this or I was relying on AB or C
- 5:26for guidance or to handle the matter. Ultimately, I think
- 5:29those judgments always sort of bubble up. Question in your
- 5:34press conference you reference I think July tenth, twenty nineteen
- 5:38press conference, you reference victims. What they went through was horrific,
- 5:43you said, And then you said, I've seen the videos,
- 5:46I've seen the interviews. I have seen the interviews on
- 5:48television of the victims and their stories. Just to be clear,
- 5:52are you talking about interviews and television coverage and videos
- 5:56recently or back in two thousand and six. Answer question Okay,
- 6:02I just wanted to be very clear about that. The
- 6:04US Attorney Manual requires us all in the Department to
- 6:08conduct the fair, even handed administration of the federal criminal law.
- 6:12What's your view as to how the handling of this
- 6:15case comported with that principle. Answer? So, I don't think
- 6:18it was fair and even handed. You know, after the
- 6:21fact may look back and say that two years may not.
- 6:25You know, it shouldn't have been a manifest injustice standard.
- 6:29It should have been sort of denovo. Let's treat this
- 6:32like a new prosecution. That's a judgment you'll all make.
- 6:36But those judgments were made with the eye towards fairness
- 6:40and impartiality. And once those judgments were made, despite all
- 6:43the attorneys involved, and despite all the litigation and all
- 6:48the stuff, all the appeals to DC, you know, we
- 6:51stuck to that position. And I think that speaks to
- 6:54the way the office approached the matter. Question all right.
- 6:57I spoke sort of offline earlier about an issue that
- 7:00was raised in the press conference that was not clearly
- 7:03answered on your part in that context, and the question was,
- 7:07is this on page fifteen of the Internet transcript of
- 7:10that press conference. You were asked whether you ever made
- 7:13aware of mister Epstein as an intelligence asset of some sort,
- 7:17and you, in your response said you could answer it,
- 7:20couldn't address it directly because of guidelines. Can you clarify,
- 7:25first of all, were you ever made aware of that? Answer?
- 7:29If he was, I'm not aware of it. Question all right,
- 7:32did defense counsel ever say to you that Epstein had
- 7:35that status? Answer? Not to my recollection question all right, answer,
- 7:41and to clarify, I also don't know where the press
- 7:43reports from multiple sources, not from multiple sources, but from
- 7:47multiple media outlets that I told someone that he was
- 7:49an intelligence asset. I don't know where that came from.
- 7:53So there are questions that I may be asked publicly
- 7:56that I don't think it's right for me to comment
- 7:59as to what classified information I may or may not have,
- 8:02because that's not the kind of stuff you'd get into.
- 8:05But the answer is no and no. Question all right,
- 8:09without reservation. Answer no and no, all right, excellent, Thank you.
- 8:15A couple of final questions. Answer, Can I address is
- 8:19a second issue that has come up at times? Question? Yes, answer,
- 8:24There are also media reports that this was because of
- 8:26cooperation in some financial matters. I don't know where that
- 8:30may have I don't know where that may have come from.
- 8:32Answer all right, thank you, and we are familiar with that.
- 8:36What you're referring to. Answer was their cooperation related to
- 8:40financial matters? Question? We didn't ask you about it? Answer okay. Question.
- 8:46As you can tell, OPR obtained many electronic records, mainly emails,
- 8:51but other electronic holdings from the Department. The Department of Justice, however,
- 8:56has not been able to find or recover a portion
- 8:59of your email account as US attorney that contained emails
- 9:02received by you between May twenty six, two thousand and
- 9:05seven and March two thousand and eight. Answer correct, question
- 9:11a period of time rather relevant to this. We've obtained
- 9:14many records, of course, from senders and from other people copied,
- 9:18so we have many of the records. But the fact
- 9:21is there's a gap in the holdings. And this is
- 9:24despite the fact that, as you no doubt no, the
- 9:27law requires that US attorney records be maintained and archived indefinitely.
- 9:33Can you give us any insight, any idea how that
- 9:35might be the case? Answer? I can't and my recollection
- 9:40was after several issues that took place in the department,
- 9:43had some sort of records retention software that automatically retained
- 9:47the emails. Is that not accurate? Question? There was there
- 9:51was a switchover from a period in which the record
- 9:54retention responsibility resided with each US Attorney office, and at
- 9:59the switchover it became centralized. Answer right, question, and this
- 10:04appears to have sort of gotten lost in the he
- 10:07gets cut off here by Acosta. Answer been caught in
- 10:11the switchover my recollection is that there was some automatic
- 10:15retention mechanism. Question okay, answer, and I can't address that,
- 10:19although there's certainly a fulsome record. Question, But just to
- 10:23ask the inevitable question, did you take any action to discard, destroy,
- 10:29or dispense with any official records related to this matter? Answer?
- 10:33Not to my recollection. I think there's a fullsome record
- 10:37and not to my recollection. Question all right, And is
- 10:40there any particular gap that you've discerned in the records
- 10:43that we've provided to you? Answer not that I recall.
- 10:47Do you have the emails that I sent out of curiosity?
- 10:51Answer we do? Answer, okay, so you have the scent
- 10:53but not received. Question Yes, answer, just checking question. And likewise,
- 10:58we retrieved from the Federal Record Center records that were
- 11:02boxed up and sent there hard copy documents after your
- 11:05term ended, and there is nothing that relates to the
- 11:08Epstein case. There were records that were maintained that were
- 11:11kept in the main office after you left because it
- 11:14was an ongoing matter. But do you have any idea
- 11:17why there are not any in those records of yours
- 11:20that were sent answer, so I have a recollection that
- 11:23when I left, there were some binders that I passed
- 11:26along to adacted because it was an ongoing case, and
- 11:29we sort of had binders out of that sort of
- 11:32had correspondence back and forth. All right, and you've already
- 11:36made We've already asked you about the facts, but you
- 11:39addressed sort of a broader statement to us for the
- 11:42record about the case. Is there anything else you want
- 11:45to tell us at this point? Answer, give me a
- 11:47second to think this through. Question. In fact, if you'd
- 11:51like to take a quick break and talk to your attorney,
- 11:54and that will be the last question. Answer, do we
- 11:57need a break? Mister adacted? No? Misreadacted? Your attorney says, no, Acosta,
- 12:02I'll follow up on this nothing that I if something
- 12:05comes up. My understanding is that we're received the transcript
- 12:09and have enough time, given the length of this to
- 12:11review and comment. Question exactly yes, And for the record,
- 12:16when the transcript is prepared, which should be within a
- 12:19couple of weeks, will ship that off to you, and
- 12:21your attorney will ask you to review it, to make
- 12:26not only any corrections, but clarifications, and to add to it.
- 12:29If you feel you have read something that it needs
- 12:31to be clarified or expanded upon, you're invited to do so. Answer,
- 12:37And if I could ask one other question, I'm not
- 12:40familiar enough with the way OPR operates, and this may
- 12:43be weird, so you may not be prepared to answer.
- 12:47If there's a report as opposed to a letter, which
- 12:50is what I typically am familiar with, will that report
- 12:52be shared in advance for comment or is that determined misredacted.
- 12:58I'm going to defer to misredacted from that misredacted. That's
- 13:01a question that doesn't need to be on the record.
- 13:03Do you have anything else that you'd want to put
- 13:05on the record before we close out? Acosta, I do
- 13:09not misredacted? All right, thank you. I want to extend
- 13:14our great appreciation for your willingness to come in and
- 13:16help us with this case. All right, we're off the record,
- 13:21all right, folks. So there you have it, the complete
- 13:24and unabridged version of alex Acosta's interview with the OIG Inspectors.
- 13:31All of the information that goes with this episode can
- 13:33be found in the description box.