Latest / Omni Talk Retail / Vogue’s AI Model Sparks Backlash | Fast Five Shorts

Transcript

Vogue’s AI Model Sparks Backlash | Fast Five Shorts · Omni Talk Retail

• 0:00
  A
• 0:00
  Guess
• 0:00
  ad
• 0:01
  featuring
• 0:01
  an
• 0:01
  AI
• 0:02
  generated
• 0:02
  model
• 0:02
  appeared
• 0:03
  in
• 0:03
  Vogue
• 0:04
  magazine's
• 0:04
  August
• 0:05
  issue.
• 0:05
  And
• 0:05
  critics
• 0:06
  say
• 0:06
  it
• 0:06
  looks,
• 0:07
  quote,
• 0:07
  cheap
• 0:08
  and
• 0:08
  desperate.
• 0:09
  Sounds
• 0:09
  like
• 0:10
  my
• 0:10
  kind
• 0:10
  of
• 0:10
  model.
• 0:11
  According
• 0:11
  to
• 0:11
  Fast
• 0:12
  Company,
• 0:12
  in
• 0:12
  the
• 0:12
  August
• 0:13
  print
• 0:13
  edition
• 0:14
  of
• 0:14
  the
• 0:14
  magazine,
• 0:15
  a
• 0:15
  Guess
• 0:15
  advertisement
• 0:16
  features
• 0:17
  an
• 0:17
  almost
• 0:17
  too
• 0:17
  perfect
• 0:18
  model
• 0:18
  wearing
• 0:18
  a
• 0:19
  striped
• 0:19
  dress
• 0:19
  and
• 0:20
  a
• 0:20
  floral
• 0:20
  playsuit
• 0:20
  from
• 0:21
  the
• 0:21
  brand's
• 0:21
  summer
• 0:21
  collection
• 0:22
  in
• 0:23
  very
• 0:23
  small
• 0:23
  print.
• 0:23
  There's
• 0:24
  a
• 0:24
  note
• 0:24
  saying
• 0:24
  that
• 0:24
  she
• 0:25
  was
• 0:25
  created
• 0:25
  using
• 0:26
  AI
• 0:27
  While
• 0:27
  Vogue
• 0:27
  states
• 0:27
  that
• 0:28
  the
• 0:28
  AI
• 0:28
  model
• 0:28
  was
• 0:29
  not
• 0:29
  an
• 0:29
  editorial
• 0:30
  decision,
• 0:30
  the
• 0:30
  fashion
• 0:31
  magazine
• 0:31
  has
• 0:31
  still
• 0:32
  faced
• 0:32
  considerable
• 0:33
  backlash
• 0:34
  online.
• 0:35
  Some
• 0:35
  critics
• 0:35
  have
• 0:35
  gone
• 0:36
  so
• 0:36
  far
• 0:36
  as
• 0:36
  to
• 0:36
  call
• 0:36
  it
• 0:36
  the,
• 0:37
  quote,
• 0:37
  downfall
• 0:38
  of
• 0:38
  Vogue.
• 0:40
  And
• 0:41
  do
• 0:41
  you
• 0:41
  think
• 0:41
  the
• 0:41
  critics
• 0:41
  of
• 0:42
  Vogue
• 0:42
  surrounding
• 0:42
  their
• 0:42
  AI
• 0:43
  models
• 0:43
  need
• 0:43
  to
• 0:43
  take
• 0:44
  a
• 0:44
  chill
• 0:44
  pill
• 0:45
  or
• 0:45
  do
• 0:45
  you
• 0:45
  think
• 0:45
  they
• 0:45
  have
• 0:45
  a
• 0:46
  point?
• 0:49
  I
• 0:49
  don't
• 0:49
  know
• 0:49
  that
• 0:49
  that's
• 0:50
  the
• 0:50
  question
• 0:50
  I
• 0:50
  would
• 0:50
  ask.
• 0:51
  I
• 0:51
  think
• 0:51
  what
• 0:52
  you
• 0:52
  have
• 0:52
  to
• 0:52
  think
• 0:53
  about
• 0:53
  when
• 0:53
  it
• 0:53
  comes
• 0:54
  to
• 0:55
  AI
• 0:55
  models
• 0:56
  and
• 0:56
  when
• 0:56
  and
• 0:57
  where
• 0:57
  those
• 0:57
  are
• 0:57
  appropriate,
• 0:58
  you
• 0:59
  have
• 0:59
  to
• 1:00
  think
• 1:00
  back
• 1:00
  to
• 1:00
  something
• 1:01
  that
• 1:01
  Chad
• 1:01
  Lusk
• 1:02
  said
• 1:02
  on
• 1:02
  our
• 1:02
  show
• 1:02
  a
• 1:02
  few
• 1:03
  weeks
• 1:03
  ago.
• 1:03
  And
• 1:03
  that
• 1:03
  is,
• 1:04
  is
• 1:04
  it
• 1:04
  right
• 1:04
  for
• 1:05
  your
• 1:05
  brand?
• 1:06
  AI
• 1:06
  models
• 1:07
  do
• 1:07
  not
• 1:07
  make
• 1:07
  sense
• 1:08
  for
• 1:08
  every
• 1:08
  brand.
• 1:09
  In
• 1:09
  fact,
• 1:09
  a
• 1:09
  lot
• 1:10
  of
• 1:10
  brands,
• 1:10
  especially
• 1:11
  high
• 1:11
  fashion
• 1:12
  brands,
• 1:13
  it
• 1:13
  will
• 1:13
  be
• 1:13
  important
• 1:14
  and
• 1:14
  almost
• 1:15
  necessary
• 1:15
  for
• 1:16
  their
• 1:16
  success
• 1:16
  for
• 1:17
  them
• 1:17
  to
• 1:17
  use
• 1:17
  real
• 1:18
  models
• 1:18
  to
• 1:18
  show
• 1:18
  diversity,
• 1:19
  to
• 1:20
  show
• 1:20
  their
• 1:20
  commitments
• 1:21
  to,
• 1:21
  to
• 1:22
  keeping
• 1:23
  these
• 1:24
  photo
• 1:24
  shoots
• 1:25
  and
• 1:25
  these
• 1:25
  product
• 1:26
  shoots
• 1:26
  pure
• 1:27
  and
• 1:27
  truly
• 1:28
  representative
• 1:28
  of
• 1:29
  their
• 1:30
  whole
• 1:31
  brand
• 1:31
  mission.
• 1:32
  It
• 1:33
  will
• 1:33
  have
• 1:33
  to
• 1:33
  be
• 1:33
  unreal
• 1:34
  models.
• 1:35
  That
• 1:35
  said,
• 1:36
  there
• 1:36
  are
• 1:36
  some
• 1:37
  use
• 1:37
  cases
• 1:37
  where
• 1:38
  this
• 1:38
  makes
• 1:38
  sense.
• 1:39
  I
• 1:39
  think.
• 1:41
  I
• 1:41
  don't
• 1:41
  know
• 1:41
  that
• 1:42
  there's
• 1:42
  a
• 1:42
  binary
• 1:42
  answer
• 1:43
  to
• 1:43
  this.
• 1:43
  I
• 1:43
  think
• 1:44
  there's
• 1:44
  some
• 1:44
  especially
• 1:45
  smaller
• 1:45
  retailers
• 1:46
  who
• 1:47
  it.
• 1:47
  It's
• 1:47
  the
• 1:48
  choice
• 1:48
  between,
• 1:49
  you
• 1:49
  know,
• 1:49
  a
• 1:49
  lay
• 1:50
  down
• 1:50
  on
• 1:50
  white
• 1:51
  where
• 1:51
  you
• 1:51
  don't
• 1:51
  get
• 1:52
  to
• 1:52
  see
• 1:52
  the
• 1:52
  product
• 1:52
  on
• 1:53
  anyone,
• 1:53
  or
• 1:54
  an
• 1:54
  AI
• 1:54
  model
• 1:55
  that
• 1:55
  may
• 1:55
  be
• 1:55
  representative
• 1:56
  of
• 1:57
  a
• 1:57
  multitude
• 1:57
  of
• 1:58
  sizes,
• 1:59
  you
• 1:59
  know,
• 1:59
  or,
• 1:59
  or
• 2:00
  forms
• 2:00
  or
• 2:00
  figures
• 2:01
  or
• 2:02
  3D
• 2:02
  models.
• 2:03
  So
• 2:03
  they're
• 2:03
  trying
• 2:03
  to
• 2:04
  show
• 2:04
  it
• 2:04
  on
• 2:04
  somebody
• 2:05
  as
• 2:05
  a
• 2:05
  real
• 2:05
  body.
• 2:06
  So.
• 2:06
  And
• 2:06
  they
• 2:06
  can't.
• 2:07
  Those
• 2:07
  brands
• 2:07
  can't
• 2:07
  afford
• 2:08
  to
• 2:08
  do
• 2:08
  photo
• 2:08
  shoots
• 2:09
  and
• 2:09
  can't
• 2:09
  afford
• 2:09
  to
• 2:09
  hire
• 2:09
  models.
• 2:10
  And
• 2:10
  this
• 2:11
  is
• 2:11
  the
• 2:11
  direction
• 2:11
  that
• 2:12
  things
• 2:12
  are
• 2:12
  going
• 2:12
  in.
• 2:13
  So
• 2:13
  I,
• 2:13
  I
• 2:14
  think
• 2:14
  that
• 2:15
  in
• 2:15
  this
• 2:15
  particular
• 2:16
  use
• 2:16
  case,
• 2:16
  the
• 2:17
  Guess
• 2:17
  brand
• 2:18
  thought
• 2:18
  that
• 2:18
  it
• 2:18
  was
• 2:18
  appropriate.
• 2:20
  They're
• 2:20
  paying
• 2:20
  Vogue
• 2:21
  money.
• 2:21
  Vogue
• 2:22
  didn't
• 2:22
  have
• 2:22
  to
• 2:22
  take
• 2:23
  their
• 2:23
  money.
• 2:23
  Vogue
• 2:24
  could
• 2:24
  have
• 2:24
  said,
• 2:24
  no,
• 2:25
  you
• 2:25
  can't
• 2:25
  use
• 2:26
  AI
• 2:26
  models
• 2:27
  in
• 2:27
  here.
• 2:27
  That's
• 2:27
  an
• 2:27
  editorial
• 2:28
  decision
• 2:28
  based
• 2:28
  on
• 2:29
  Vogue.
• 2:29
  And
• 2:29
  I
• 2:29
  think
• 2:30
  readers
• 2:30
  will
• 2:31
  support
• 2:31
  Vogue
• 2:32
  or
• 2:32
  support
• 2:32
  the
• 2:32
  brands
• 2:33
  that
• 2:33
  choose
• 2:33
  to
• 2:33
  use
• 2:33
  AI
• 2:34
  models
• 2:34
  or
• 2:34
  not.
• 2:35
  And
• 2:35
  that's
• 2:35
  the
• 2:36
  real
• 2:36
  thing
• 2:36
  here
• 2:37
  that
• 2:38
  people
• 2:38
  have
• 2:38
  to
• 2:38
  be
• 2:38
  thinking
• 2:39
  about.
• 2:39
  So
• 2:39
  that's,
• 2:40
  that's
• 2:40
  My,
• 2:41
  my
• 2:41
  assessment
• 2:42
  of
• 2:42
  this,
• 2:43
  I,
• 2:43
  I
• 2:44
  don't
• 2:44
  like
• 2:44
  it.
• 2:45
  But,
• 2:46
  but
• 2:46
  that's
• 2:46
  my
• 2:46
  personal
• 2:47
  opinion,
• 2:47
  so
• 2:47
  I
• 2:47
  don't
• 2:47
  have
• 2:47
  to
• 2:48
  support
• 2:48
  that
• 2:48
  brand.
• 2:48
  But
• 2:48
  what
• 2:49
  do
• 2:49
  you
• 2:49
  think
• 2:49
  about
• 2:49
  AI?
• 2:50
  Yeah,
• 2:50
  well,
• 2:50
  so
• 2:50
  I
• 2:51
  want
• 2:51
  to
• 2:51
  make
• 2:51
  sure
• 2:51
  I
• 2:51
  understand
• 2:51
  too.
• 2:52
  So
• 2:52
  going
• 2:52
  back
• 2:52
  to
• 2:52
  the
• 2:52
  question,
• 2:53
  so
• 2:53
  if
• 2:53
  you
• 2:53
  were
• 2:53
  Vogue,
• 2:54
  would
• 2:54
  you
• 2:54
  be
• 2:54
  allowing
• 2:55
  AI
• 2:55
  models
• 2:55
  in
• 2:56
  your
• 2:56
  advertisements?
• 2:58
  I
• 2:59
  don't.
• 2:59
  Or
• 2:59
  in
• 3:00
  your
• 3:00
  magazine
• 3:00
  at
• 3:00
  all?
• 3:00
  I
• 3:01
  don't
• 3:01
  think
• 3:01
  you
• 3:01
  can
• 3:01
  ask
• 3:02
  that
• 3:02
  question.
• 3:02
  Like,
• 3:03
  Vogue
• 3:03
  is
• 3:03
  a.
• 3:03
  There's
• 3:04
  a.
• 3:04
  There's
• 3:04
  so
• 3:04
  much
• 3:05
  to
• 3:05
  that.
• 3:05
  Like,
• 3:06
  can
• 3:06
  Vogue
• 3:07
  withstand
• 3:08
  being
• 3:09
  a
• 3:09
  magazine
• 3:09
  if
• 3:10
  they
• 3:10
  don't
• 3:10
  allow
• 3:10
  it?
• 3:11
  Like,
• 3:11
  can
• 3:12
  they
• 3:12
  need
• 3:12
  this,
• 3:13
  this
• 3:13
  advertiser
• 3:14
  revenue?
• 3:14
  So
• 3:15
  I,
• 3:15
  I
• 3:15
  don't
• 3:16
  think
• 3:16
  that.
• 3:16
  And
• 3:16
  I
• 3:17
  think
• 3:17
  an
• 3:17
  advertisement
• 3:18
  is
• 3:18
  different
• 3:18
  than
• 3:19
  Vogue
• 3:20
  actually
• 3:20
  using
• 3:20
  AI
• 3:21
  models
• 3:21
  for
• 3:21
  their
• 3:22
  editorial
• 3:22
  content.
• 3:23
  Like
• 3:23
  that,
• 3:23
  to
• 3:24
  me
• 3:24
  seems
• 3:25
  fraught
• 3:26
  with
• 3:26
  error
• 3:26
  because
• 3:27
  that
• 3:27
  is
• 3:27
  an
• 3:27
  art.
• 3:28
  Vogue
• 3:28
  is
• 3:28
  an
• 3:28
  art
• 3:29
  form,
• 3:29
  an
• 3:29
  art
• 3:30
  magazine
• 3:31
  showing
• 3:31
  style,
• 3:32
  showing
• 3:32
  fashion.
• 3:33
  I
• 3:33
  think
• 3:33
  if
• 3:34
  you
• 3:34
  are
• 3:34
  going
• 3:34
  to
• 3:34
  start
• 3:35
  using
• 3:35
  AI
• 3:36
  models
• 3:36
  for
• 3:36
  that,
• 3:37
  then,
• 3:38
  no,
• 3:38
  that
• 3:38
  doesn't
• 3:39
  work
• 3:39
  for
• 3:39
  you
• 3:39
  as
• 3:39
  a
• 3:39
  platform.
• 3:40
  And
• 3:40
  I
• 3:40
  don't
• 3:40
  think
• 3:40
  you
• 3:40
  have
• 3:41
  success
• 3:42
  as
• 3:42
  a
• 3:42
  magazine
• 3:43
  if
• 3:43
  you
• 3:43
  start
• 3:44
  going
• 3:44
  in
• 3:44
  that
• 3:44
  direction.
• 3:45
  So
• 3:45
  you're
• 3:45
  okay
• 3:45
  if
• 3:45
  they
• 3:45
  use
• 3:46
  it
• 3:46
  as
• 3:46
  an
• 3:46
  advertisement.
• 3:47
  You're
• 3:47
  not
• 3:47
  okay
• 3:47
  if
• 3:47
  they
• 3:47
  use
• 3:47
  it
• 3:47
  in
• 3:48
  their
• 3:48
  own
• 3:48
  generated.
• 3:48
  I
• 3:48
  don't
• 3:49
  think
• 3:49
  they
• 3:49
  have
• 3:49
  a
• 3:49
  choice.
• 3:49
  I
• 3:50
  think
• 3:50
  they
• 3:50
  have
• 3:50
  to
• 3:50
  allow
• 3:51
  people
• 3:51
  to
• 3:51
  use
• 3:51
  it
• 3:51
  as
• 3:51
  an
• 3:52
  advertisement
• 3:52
  because
• 3:53
  they
• 3:53
  need
• 3:53
  advertisers
• 3:54
  to
• 3:54
  keep
• 3:54
  a
• 3:55
  magazine
• 3:55
  going.
• 3:55
  That's
• 3:56
  an
• 3:57
  industry
• 3:57
  that's
• 3:58
  slowly,
• 3:58
  slowly
• 3:59
  dying.
• 4:00
  Interesting.
• 4:00
  Interesting.
• 4:01
  I
• 4:01
  go
• 4:01
  in
• 4:01
  the
• 4:01
  opposite
• 4:02
  direction.
• 4:02
  No,
• 4:02
  I
• 4:02
  mean,
• 4:02
  I
• 4:03
  think
• 4:03
  your
• 4:03
  point
• 4:03
  about
• 4:03
  brand
• 4:04
  is
• 4:04
  right.
• 4:04
  And,
• 4:04
  you
• 4:05
  know,
• 4:05
  that's
• 4:05
  ultimately
• 4:05
  what
• 4:06
  the
• 4:06
  decision
• 4:06
  you
• 4:06
  have
• 4:06
  to
• 4:06
  make.
• 4:07
  And
• 4:07
  so
• 4:07
  I
• 4:07
  think
• 4:07
  if
• 4:07
  you're
• 4:08
  Vogue
• 4:08
  and
• 4:09
  you're
• 4:09
  celebrating
• 4:09
  high
• 4:10
  design
• 4:10
  and
• 4:11
  real
• 4:11
  beauty,
• 4:12
  then
• 4:12
  you
• 4:12
  can't,
• 4:12
  you
• 4:13
  just
• 4:13
  can't
• 4:13
  do
• 4:13
  this.
• 4:13
  And
• 4:14
  that's
• 4:14
  how
• 4:14
  you
• 4:14
  separate
• 4:15
  yourself.
• 4:15
  And
• 4:15
  that's
• 4:15
  why
• 4:16
  you
• 4:16
  get
• 4:16
  people
• 4:16
  to
• 4:16
  come
• 4:16
  to
• 4:16
  Vogue.
• 4:17
  And
• 4:17
  you're
• 4:17
  very
• 4:17
  overt
• 4:18
  about
• 4:18
  it
• 4:18
  and
• 4:18
  you
• 4:18
  talk
• 4:18
  about
• 4:18
  it
• 4:19
  because
• 4:19
  if
• 4:19
  you
• 4:19
  don't
• 4:19
  do
• 4:19
  it,
• 4:19
  somebody
• 4:20
  else
• 4:20
  will.
• 4:21
  And
• 4:21
  there's
• 4:21
  niches
• 4:22
  for
• 4:22
  everything.
• 4:22
  So.
• 4:23
  And
• 4:23
  if
• 4:23
  you're
• 4:24
  like.
• 4:24
  But
• 4:24
  to
• 4:24
  your
• 4:24
  point,
• 4:25
  I
• 4:25
  hear
• 4:25
  what
• 4:25
  you're
• 4:25
  saying
• 4:25
  too.
• 4:25
  Like,
• 4:26
  if
• 4:26
  you're
• 4:26
  guessing
• 4:26
  this
• 4:26
  works
• 4:27
  for
• 4:27
  you
• 4:27
  or
• 4:27
  the
• 4:27
  countless
• 4:28
  other
• 4:28
  retailers
• 4:28
  out
• 4:28
  there
• 4:29
  in
• 4:29
  which
• 4:30
  people
• 4:30
  can't
• 4:30
  tell
• 4:30
  the
• 4:31
  difference
• 4:31
  anyway,
• 4:32
  then
• 4:32
  sure,
• 4:32
  why
• 4:33
  not?
• 4:33
  But
• 4:33
  if
• 4:33
  Vogue,
• 4:34
  if
• 4:34
  Vogue
• 4:34
  is
• 4:34
  what
• 4:35
  it
• 4:35
  is,
• 4:35
  you
• 4:35
  know,
• 4:35
  in
• 4:35
  my
• 4:35
  opinion,
• 4:36
  they
• 4:36
  shouldn't
• 4:36
  be
• 4:36
  letting
• 4:36
  that
• 4:36
  type
• 4:37
  of
• 4:37
  advertisement
• 4:37
  in.
• 4:38
  But
• 4:38
  you
• 4:38
  have
• 4:38
  to
• 4:38
  go
• 4:39
  at
• 4:39
  the
• 4:39
  ultimate.
• 4:39
  End
• 4:40
  of
• 4:40
  the
• 4:40
  day,
• 4:40
  you
• 4:40
  have
• 4:40
  to
• 4:40
  go
• 4:40
  with
• 4:41
  your
• 4:41
  brand.
• 4:41
  Now
• 4:41
  there's
• 4:42
  all
• 4:42
  these
• 4:42
  complexities
• 4:43
  to
• 4:43
  this
• 4:43
  too.
• 4:43
  Like,
• 4:43
  what
• 4:43
  is
• 4:44
  an
• 4:44
  AI
• 4:44
  model?
• 4:44
  Is
• 4:44
  it
• 4:45
  the
• 4:45
  person?
• 4:45
  Is
• 4:45
  it
• 4:45
  the
• 4:46
  background?
• 4:46
  You
• 4:47
  know,
• 4:47
  where
• 4:47
  do
• 4:47
  you
• 4:47
  draw
• 4:48
  the
• 4:48
  line?
• 4:48
  I
• 4:49
  think
• 4:49
  that's
• 4:49
  where
• 4:50
  there's
• 4:50
  a
• 4:51
  whole
• 4:51
  host
• 4:51
  of
• 4:51
  other
• 4:51
  questions
• 4:52
  that
• 4:52
  come
• 4:52
  surrounding
• 4:53
  this.
• 4:53
  And,
• 4:54
  and
• 4:54
  you
• 4:54
  know,
• 4:55
  I'm
• 4:55
  not
• 4:55
  as.
• 4:56
  I'm
• 4:56
  not
• 4:56
  as
• 4:56
  big
• 4:56
  as
• 4:57
  a,
• 4:57
  as
• 4:57
  a.
• 4:58
  What's
• 4:59
  the
• 4:59
  word
• 4:59
  I'm
• 4:59
  looking
• 4:59
  for?
• 4:59
  I'm
• 5:00
  not
• 5:00
  as
• 5:00
  big
• 5:00
  of
• 5:00
  a.
• 5:01
  Of
• 5:01
  a
• 5:02
  stentorian,
• 5:03
  I
• 5:03
  guess,
• 5:03
  for
• 5:04
  lack
• 5:04
  of
• 5:04
  a
• 5:04
  better
• 5:04
  way
• 5:04
  to
• 5:04
  say
• 5:04
  it,
• 5:05
  or
• 5:05
  a
• 5:05
  rule
• 5:05
  follower
• 5:06
  on
• 5:06
  the
• 5:06
  backgrounds
• 5:07
  and
• 5:07
  stuff.
• 5:07
  But
• 5:07
  if
• 5:08
  you're
• 5:08
  using
• 5:08
  the
• 5:08
  real
• 5:08
  people
• 5:09
  and
• 5:09
  you're
• 5:09
  celebrating
• 5:09
  real
• 5:10
  beauty,
• 5:11
  I
• 5:11
  think
• 5:11
  so.
• 5:12
  It
• 5:12
  depends
• 5:12
  though,
• 5:12
  like,
• 5:12
  if
• 5:13
  you're
• 5:13
  like
• 5:13
  a
• 5:13
  travel
• 5:14
  magazine,
• 5:14
  you
• 5:14
  shouldn't
• 5:15
  be
• 5:15
  using
• 5:15
  AI
• 5:16
  backgrounds
• 5:16
  in
• 5:16
  your
• 5:16
  travel
• 5:17
  magazines
• 5:17
  really
• 5:17
  either,
• 5:18
  you
• 5:18
  know,
• 5:18
  at
• 5:18
  the
• 5:18
  end
• 5:19
  of
• 5:19
  the
• 5:19
  day.
• 5:19
  So.
• 5:20
  Well,
• 5:20
  and
• 5:21
  I
• 5:21
  think,
• 5:21
  I
• 5:21
  think
• 5:21
  where
• 5:22
  do
• 5:22
  you
• 5:22
  draw
• 5:22
  the
• 5:22
  line
• 5:22
  at
• 5:23
  AI?
• 5:23
  Like,
• 5:23
  is
• 5:24
  Photoshop
• 5:24
  considered
• 5:25
  AI?
• 5:25
  Are
• 5:25
  you.
• 5:26
  Is
• 5:26
  that
• 5:26
  if
• 5:26
  you
• 5:27
  Photoshop
• 5:27
  image
• 5:28
  on
• 5:28
  a
• 5:28
  shoot
• 5:28
  from
• 5:29
  Travel
• 5:29
  and
• 5:29
  Leisure
• 5:30
  magazine,
• 5:30
  like,
• 5:31
  every
• 5:31
  one
• 5:31
  of
• 5:31
  those
• 5:31
  photos,
• 5:32
  real,
• 5:32
  human
• 5:33
  or
• 5:33
  not,
• 5:33
  in
• 5:33
  the
• 5:34
  majority
• 5:34
  of
• 5:35
  cases,
• 5:35
  are
• 5:36
  retouched.
• 5:36
  And
• 5:37
  that's,
• 5:37
  in
• 5:38
  today's
• 5:38
  world,
• 5:39
  a
• 5:39
  use
• 5:39
  of
• 5:39
  AI,
• 5:40
  I
• 5:40
  think
• 5:40
  the
• 5:41
  most
• 5:41
  important
• 5:41
  thing.
• 5:41
  So
• 5:41
  then
• 5:42
  we're
• 5:42
  going
• 5:42
  down
• 5:42
  the
• 5:42
  chill
• 5:43
  pill.
• 5:43
  We're
• 5:43
  going
• 5:43
  down
• 5:44
  the
• 5:44
  chill
• 5:44
  pill
• 5:44
  avenue.
• 5:45
  Like
• 5:45
  these
• 5:45
  critics
• 5:45
  need
• 5:45
  to
• 5:46
  take
• 5:46
  a
• 5:46
  chill
• 5:46
  pill.
• 5:47
  I
• 5:47
  mean,
• 5:47
  I,
• 5:48
  I
• 5:48
  think,
• 5:48
  I
• 5:48
  think
• 5:48
  the
• 5:49
  real
• 5:49
  line
• 5:50
  is
• 5:50
  when
• 5:50
  you
• 5:51
  are
• 5:51
  showing
• 5:52
  what
• 5:52
  we
• 5:52
  appear
• 5:53
  to
• 5:54
  think
• 5:54
  is
• 5:54
  a
• 5:54
  human
• 5:55
  being
• 5:55
  that
• 5:55
  is
• 5:55
  not
• 5:56
  a
• 5:56
  real
• 5:56
  human
• 5:56
  being.
• 5:57
  I
• 5:57
  think
• 5:57
  that's
• 5:57
  where
• 5:57
  you
• 5:58
  start
• 5:58
  to
• 5:58
  draw
• 5:58
  the
• 5:58
  line.
• 5:59
  And
• 5:59
  I
• 5:59
  think
• 5:59
  the
• 5:59
  most
• 6:00
  important
• 6:00
  takeaway
• 6:01
  for
• 6:01
  me
• 6:01
  of
• 6:01
  this
• 6:02
  whole
• 6:02
  thing
• 6:02
  is
• 6:02
  just
• 6:03
  actually
• 6:03
  applauding
• 6:05
  Vogue
• 6:06
  for
• 6:06
  noting
• 6:07
  that
• 6:07
  this
• 6:07
  was
• 6:07
  an
• 6:08
  AI
• 6:08
  image.
• 6:08
  I
• 6:08
  think
• 6:09
  that's
• 6:09
  the
• 6:09
  biggest
• 6:09
  thing
• 6:10
  to
• 6:10
  take
• 6:10
  away
• 6:10
  here.
• 6:11
  Like
• 6:11
  in
• 6:11
  four.
• 6:12
  I.
• 6:12
  I
• 6:12
  guess
• 6:12
  my
• 6:13
  I.
• 6:13
  I
• 6:13
  have
• 6:13
  less
• 6:14
  of
• 6:14
  a
• 6:14
  problem,
• 6:14
  I
• 6:15
  think,
• 6:15
  because
• 6:15
  they're
• 6:15
  noting
• 6:16
  that
• 6:16
  they're
• 6:17
  watermarking
• 6:17
  this
• 6:18
  picture
• 6:18
  as
• 6:19
  this
• 6:19
  is
• 6:19
  an
• 6:19
  AI
• 6:20
  generated
• 6:20
  image.
• 6:21
  You
• 6:21
  decide
• 6:22
  what
• 6:22
  you
• 6:22
  want
• 6:22
  as
• 6:23
  the
• 6:23
  reader
• 6:23
  of
• 6:23
  this.
• 6:24
  But
• 6:25
  I
• 6:25
  don't
• 6:25
  think
• 6:25
  Vogue
• 6:25
  can
• 6:25
  get
• 6:26
  away
• 6:26
  from
• 6:26
  it.
• 6:26
  I
• 6:26
  think
• 6:26
  they
• 6:26
  need
• 6:27
  their
• 6:27
  advertisers
• 6:27
  too
• 6:27
  much.
• 6:28
  Interesting.
• 6:29
  Yeah.
• 6:29
  And
• 6:29
  I
• 6:29
  don't
• 6:29
  know
• 6:29
  the
• 6:30
  business
• 6:30
  model
• 6:30
  economics
• 6:31
  of
• 6:31
  Vogue
• 6:32
  in
• 6:32
  terms
• 6:32
  of
• 6:32
  how
• 6:32
  important
• 6:32
  that
• 6:33
  is,
• 6:33
  but
• 6:33
  yeah,
• 6:33
  those
• 6:34
  are
• 6:34
  really
• 6:34
  strong
• 6:34
  points.