Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Construction Litigation Through the Lens of Engineering: Differing Site Conditions, Design Errors, and Construction Defects
Transcript
- 0:03Nice to have you all join us. My name is Jeffrey
- 0:06Hunt, and I'm joined here by my colleague, Dr.
- 0:11Saj Salam. And we will be giving a webinar today
- 0:15on construction defects, design errors, deficiencies,
- 0:20and talk about some of our experience in working
- 0:25with lawyers in construction litigation. And
- 0:29we'll present some of our views. Maybe some tips
- 0:34and tricks that we've learned in working with
- 0:37construction lawyers. Again, this is from an
- 0:40engineering point of view. So we'll walk through
- 0:44some of the typical steps that we. Step through
- 0:50in an investigation and then on the 2nd half
- 0:53of the presentation. We will go through some
- 0:57case studies. So. Saj, if you want to advance
- 1:04to the next slide, we can give a quick introduction
- 1:07to ourselves. So again, Dr. Jeffrey Hunt, I am
- 1:17a principal engineer in exponents Orange County
- 1:22office in our civil and structural engineering
- 1:24practice. I've got a PhD in structural engineering.
- 1:29I'm licensed. in California and several other
- 1:32states and I primarily work in the investigation
- 1:37of damage or collapses of buildings and structures
- 1:44and I investigate design issues or construction
- 1:49defects and various types of construction including
- 1:52residential commercial and industrial facilities
- 1:56and specialize in evaluating the standard of
- 1:59engineering care. Saaj. Good afternoon, everyone.
- 2:06Thanks for joining us. My name is Saaj Salam.
- 2:09I'm a managing engineer in the civil and structural
- 2:12engineering practice at Exponent. I am licensed
- 2:17in California, Texas, and Illinois. And my education
- 2:22background is in civil and geotechnical engineering.
- 2:26as well as data science. And I have experience
- 2:29in providing both reactive and proactive consultation
- 2:33to my clients. And today we are gonna present
- 2:37about the construction litigation through the
- 2:42lens of engineering. And as Jeff mentioned, we
- 2:47are gonna focus on construction defects, design
- 2:51errors, and in particular, we are going to look
- 2:56at how experts and engineers can work effectively
- 3:00together from the beginning of an investigation
- 3:04toward the litigation and successful dispute
- 3:09resolution and trial. So moving forward, we have
- 3:14divided this presentation in three sections.
- 3:17We are going to start with common construction
- 3:20disputes and key project participants. And then
- 3:24we are going to talk about the investigation
- 3:26process in forensic engineering. We are going
- 3:30to look at this process from two perspectives.
- 3:33One's from experts' perspective and one's from
- 3:36the console perspective. And we go over what
- 3:39actions they can take at each step. And lastly,
- 3:44we are going to look at the application of this
- 3:46forensic engineering process in some real cases
- 3:50and some examples. When an engineer becomes involved
- 3:56in a construction dispute, usually we are provided
- 3:59with some legally framed questions. But behind
- 4:03those, there are some technical questions that
- 4:05we need to answer. So here we have a framework
- 4:09that shows those technical questions that an
- 4:12expert needs to answer in construction disputes.
- 4:17At the top level, we have four categories that
- 4:20are frequently used to describe the construction
- 4:23disputes. There are differing site conditions
- 4:26or DSC, design errors, construction defects,
- 4:31and product failures. And at the lower level,
- 4:33we have delays, cost overruns, and fatality and
- 4:38or injury. And we have intentionally separated
- 4:41these from the one above because these three
- 4:44categories are usually the consequence of one
- 4:47or more technical issues that we see at the higher
- 4:51level. For example, if during the excavation
- 4:54they noticed some different material like hard
- 4:57rock that pushed the contractor to change their
- 5:00excavation method and that can become a different
- 5:03site condition, it can itself result in some
- 5:07delays or additional cost for the excavation.
- 5:11So we are going to go over each of these categories
- 5:14in more detail so we will have a better understanding
- 5:17of what each of these mean and what they can
- 5:21involve. So let's start with differing site condition,
- 5:26which in my opinion is one of the most complicated
- 5:29one. It is defined as a physical condition that
- 5:34is encountered during the construction and is
- 5:38materially different than what was identified
- 5:40during the contract and what could be reasonably
- 5:45expected or predicted before before the construction.
- 5:49We have to note that something unexpected does
- 5:53not automatically mean deferring site condition.
- 5:57Let's go over one example as it's shown in this
- 6:00cartoon here. Your contractor may have access
- 6:03to the boring logs and some subsurface explorations
- 6:07that has been done before the construction or
- 6:10before the design and based on those information
- 6:12they may expect soil below some soft soil below
- 6:16the ground but while they start the construction,
- 6:20they may encounter some blocks. So they may need
- 6:23to change their construction method and they
- 6:26may claim that, okay, we are encountering something
- 6:29materially different and this is a different
- 6:30site condition situation. But from an engineering
- 6:35perspective, like what we do, we are gonna review
- 6:38all the available informations, all the information
- 6:42in the contracts. and what was discussed in the
- 6:46geotechnical report and expected variability
- 6:49in what was mentioned in the contract. And then
- 6:53on the other side, we're going to characterize
- 6:55the actual condition and be able to evaluate
- 6:57these two against each other. And then we can
- 6:59say if the claim is valid and if indeed we have
- 7:03a different side condition, something that is
- 7:06materially different and causes the contractor
- 7:10to change their method of construction or method
- 7:12of excavation. And at the same time, council
- 7:16can do some actions like going through the contract
- 7:19to review the contractual DSC provision, risk
- 7:24allocations, notice requirements, or some other
- 7:27things that is beyond the scope of expert. So
- 7:30let's go to the next one. It's design errors
- 7:33and omissions. It can involve deficiencies in
- 7:37plans, specifications, or engineering calculations
- 7:41and these things usually can result in unsafe
- 7:44conditions or even failure of your structure
- 7:47element. But this category is not limited to
- 7:51mathematical mistakes. It can involve some incorrect
- 7:56assumptions, some missing details in drawings
- 7:59or something that technically exists in the drawings
- 8:02but is really hard or impossible to construct
- 8:06in reality. And we are going to go through a
- 8:11few examples. Actually, Jeff is going to go through
- 8:14some examples that shows this type of category
- 8:17that is kind of common in reality. The next one
- 8:21is construction defects. So here we are shifting
- 8:24our focus from design to what actually was constructed.
- 8:29And this type of technical issues usually involve
- 8:32improper workmanship, failure to follow plans
- 8:36and specifications, poor quality control or deviation
- 8:40from industry standards. And what experts can
- 8:43do in this category, they basically go and look
- 8:46at what was built and evaluate it against the
- 8:49specifications and drawings. So now I can say
- 8:53that in many construction disputes, there is
- 8:56one central question like, was the design adequate
- 9:01or was an adequate design constructed incorrectly?
- 9:05Sometimes the answer is one, sometimes it's the
- 9:08other and sometimes it's both. Each of these
- 9:10contributes relatively to the alleged damages.
- 9:17So moving to the next one is product or material
- 9:21failure. This can involve the failure of the
- 9:24material itself or manufactured equipment or
- 9:28construction product or simply something that
- 9:31has been used it's not suitable for the project
- 9:35specification. For this type of construction
- 9:39dispute, the preservation of the evidence is
- 9:42very important and consoles need to facilitate
- 9:45the site access and taking evidence and example
- 9:50as soon as possible. We are going to discuss
- 9:52this later when we go through the forensic engineering
- 9:55investigation process. Next one is construction
- 10:00delays and disruptions. This can be due to many
- 10:03different technical circumstances. For example,
- 10:08design change or weather, owner actions, supply
- 10:13chain issues. So some of these may not sound
- 10:17technical, but basically your expert can go and
- 10:22review the situation, do the analysis and evaluate
- 10:26the technical circumstances that has led to the
- 10:30delay. For example, if there is a change and
- 10:34some rework is needed and the contractor is claiming
- 10:37that we needed to redo some work, we can go and
- 10:42study if that work was just a corrective work
- 10:45or if it was because of a design change or it
- 10:48was included or a part of the original document's
- 10:52original design. And besides, the engineering
- 10:55experts for this type of construction disputes
- 10:58usually scheduling experts go and look if the
- 11:03event was part of the critical pass and how much
- 11:05of that claim is compensated. So this one, just
- 11:08one example that sometimes you have different
- 11:11experts working together to help you to resolve
- 11:14a dispute. Next one is payment and contract disputes.
- 11:21This one is less engineered, focused, and it's
- 11:25more like what is in the contract. But again,
- 11:29there are some technical issues underlying this
- 11:32type of construction disputes, and your expert
- 11:35can go and do analysis to establish those technical
- 11:39issues and see if, for example, the change order
- 11:42that was submitted by the contractor is a valid
- 11:45one or it was something that was already included
- 11:48in the original design. And lastly is fatality
- 11:53and injuries. This one can involve safety conditions,
- 11:59temporary works, or structural stability. The
- 12:03stakes are different here, but still those basic
- 12:07forensic methodology remains the same here. So
- 12:10we have to go preserve the evidence, understand
- 12:14the mechanism of the event, reconstruct the sequence
- 12:18of the events. and identify the root cause and
- 12:22evaluate the causation. Okay, so this was about
- 12:26the construction dispute categories that I showed
- 12:29in the diagram. And now we can move forward and
- 12:33look at the multi -party communication and the
- 12:36importance of this concept in construction disputes.
- 12:41Jeff, do you want to take over? Yep. I think
- 12:45a lot of the issues Saaz has mentioned involving
- 12:49design errors and construction defects or workplace
- 12:54accidents even come down to issues with communication.
- 13:00And there are multiple people involved, multiple
- 13:02firms, multiple parties. I'm showing that graphically
- 13:07here with a simple sketch. And this is for a
- 13:11traditional project delivery method of design
- 13:16bid build here where the owner developer hires
- 13:19a design team. Those are the architect or engineers
- 13:24involved and the owner hires a construction team
- 13:29quarterbacked by the general contractor. The
- 13:34owner has for both of those parties has to define
- 13:37their scope and communicate some level of their
- 13:42vision for the project. And you can see with
- 13:45the arrows deliverables or ways of communication
- 13:50between these parties. So the design team for
- 13:53example has to memorialize their design back
- 13:59to the owner through design drawings and calculations.
- 14:03They have to communicate with the construction
- 14:07team through responses to requests for information
- 14:11or review of submittals, comments on those submittals,
- 14:17to make sure that the construction team's interpretation
- 14:21of their design follows the design team's intent.
- 14:26And then the construction team has to communicate
- 14:29with the owner through its actual physical construction
- 14:33and purchasing of materials, and with the engineer
- 14:37through RFIs and submittals. So these two -way
- 14:44paths of communication become very important,
- 14:47and it's important that they're clear and follow
- 14:51the duty of care that engineers and contractors
- 14:55owe to each other and to the owner. Off to the
- 15:01side on this slide, you can see a couple of other
- 15:04examples of other parties. The HJ or authority
- 15:08having jurisdiction, you know, the local building
- 15:11department issuing permits or performing inspections.
- 15:14They also communicate and work with. Design team
- 15:18and the construction team. Special inspectors
- 15:23also are involved and sometimes 3rd party representatives
- 15:28for the owner. Their technical eyes and ears
- 15:31are sometimes hired separately. to communicate
- 15:35with the general contractor on progress and making
- 15:39sure that the owner stays involved from an independent
- 15:43point of view. So any one break in the link here
- 15:47can cause or initiate some of these types of
- 15:51claims. Okay, so yeah, that's about the first.
- 16:00section of the presentation today, and now we
- 16:02can move toward the investigation process in
- 16:06forensic engineering. In this section, we are
- 16:09going to go over a five -step framework called
- 16:14investigation process in forensic engineering,
- 16:18and we are going to do it here, both engineering
- 16:23expert and consult perspective. So you will have
- 16:27the gold color which represent the actions that
- 16:31needs to be taken by the console at each step.
- 16:34And then we switch back and forth between gold
- 16:38and blue or teal color that represents the actions
- 16:42that are taken by the expert at each step. So
- 16:47let's start with step one, which we call it gather
- 16:51facts. So in this step, the console is supposed
- 16:56to notify the insurance and engage their experts
- 17:00as early as possible and preserve evidence. For
- 17:04example, for construction disputes, for most
- 17:06of them, specifically for the product or material
- 17:10failure, this step is really important because
- 17:13what is the subject of the dispute could be or
- 17:17that evidence could be perishable or it could
- 17:19be gone, like one failed retaining structure
- 17:24can be repaired. or an excavation can be backfield.
- 17:28So you want to be timely and be at the site and
- 17:32take examples and make observations. So following
- 17:35up on that, the console needs to collect relevant
- 17:39records and get as much as documents that they
- 17:42can. either it's design, construction, or whatever
- 17:45else, and also facilitate site access and testing,
- 17:49because you will see shortly that your expert
- 17:52during the first step needs to do a site visit
- 17:54or site inspection. And it's helpful to identify
- 17:58key witnesses so your expert can communicate
- 18:02with them and understand better what happened
- 18:05and basically reconstruct the sequence of the
- 18:08events. So meanwhile, during the step one, your
- 18:11expert is going to meet with project team and
- 18:14do interviews, do the document reviews. Hopefully
- 18:18they have received some documents before going
- 18:21to the site and review them beforehand. And they
- 18:24will do site inspections. And when they're at
- 18:27the site, they can do some observations, do interviews
- 18:32with the owner or some other key witnesses that
- 18:36hopefully are present to help to explain what
- 18:39happened and how the failure occurred. And they're
- 18:42going to do some data collections like taking
- 18:45evidences, taking examples. And they can do even
- 18:48some testing at the site. And for some specific
- 18:51projects, they may need to take some samples
- 18:53to do additional testing and measurements in
- 18:56the lab. Throughout this process, we are going
- 18:59to use one example as this retaining wall failure
- 19:03to just make you follow the actions in different
- 19:07steps and understand everything easier. So let's
- 19:12move on to step two. We call it determine the
- 19:15failure mechanism. At this step, console needs
- 19:19to help their expert and obtain the missing records.
- 19:22Your expert to do their analysis may need documents
- 19:27from the design phase, like contracts, design
- 19:30drawings, calculations, or any report that was
- 19:33produced. during the design phase, and they may
- 19:37need to review the construction phase documents,
- 19:40like again contracts, erection drawings, shop
- 19:43drawings, all the way to even photographs or
- 19:46daily reports from during the construction. And
- 19:49if the failure happened during the operation,
- 19:52they may need to review the documents that were
- 19:55produced during the operation, like any renovations
- 19:59or remodels that caused some additional load
- 20:01or removal of some supporting elements from your
- 20:05structure. And while you provide all these documents
- 20:10and establish the timeline of the project from
- 20:13the idea to the construction and then operation,
- 20:17you need to allow independent analysis. So you
- 20:21only need to frame the question, the legal question
- 20:25to your expert and basically tell them what questions
- 20:29matter. what you need to answer, but you need
- 20:32to let them to approach the problem from their
- 20:34own engineering perspective, because there is
- 20:37a very important concept in forensic engineering
- 20:41that says that evidence first, hypothesis second.
- 20:45So you shouldn't put anything in their mind about
- 20:49what could have happened or what could be the
- 20:51mechanism of failure. So you need to allow the
- 20:54independent analysis by your expert. So at this
- 20:57point, let's move to what the expert is doing
- 21:00during the step two, which is determine the failure
- 21:02mechanism. So in the photo, you can see that
- 21:07now there is a lateral pressure to the retaining
- 21:10wall and some outward movement of the wall. So
- 21:13that is basically showing that what is happening
- 21:15to this wall. And that is what your expert is
- 21:18doing during the step two. They are back from
- 21:21their site inspection. They have reviewed some
- 21:24documents that they have been provided up to
- 21:26that point. They have required some additional
- 21:29document from you. By putting all those things
- 21:32together, they are forming their opinion about
- 21:34the mechanism of the failure, which says how
- 21:38that failure happened. So this is different than
- 21:41why the failure happened, because the question
- 21:44why is related to the root cause of this failure.
- 21:48So at this point, we only need to define the
- 21:50physical behavior of the system during the failure.
- 21:54Moving forward during step three, which we call
- 21:58it determine the root causes, the council needs
- 22:02to provide competing evidence or if the opening
- 22:06parties have produced any reports and it's shareable,
- 22:10they need to share that with their expert. They
- 22:12need to identify the contractual requirements
- 22:16and also discuss alternative theories and test
- 22:19assumptions because at this point your expert
- 22:21has started to form some opinions about the root
- 22:25causes of this failure. And I would like to explain
- 22:28the last two bullet points using this photograph
- 22:31that you see on the right. That cat apparently
- 22:36did not cause the failure or the sagging in that
- 22:40steel roof. So that means that the correlation
- 22:43does not imply causation. So at the failure,
- 22:47a crack may exist, a construction deviation may
- 22:51exist at the failure. An unusual weather event
- 22:55may exist, but the engineering role is not if
- 22:59something existed at the failure or not. Their
- 23:02role is to tell if that factor had a causal role
- 23:07to the observed failure. So at this point, you
- 23:11need to question your expert. If they come to
- 23:14you about the mechanism of the failure and some
- 23:16root causes that they have identified, you need
- 23:18to challenge them. You have to question them.
- 23:21What evidence is supporting your opinion? What
- 23:24other theories you have considered to form your
- 23:27opinion? And what other evidences may cause you
- 23:31to change your opinion? And I keep saying challenging,
- 23:34not changing, because you shouldn't make your
- 23:37expert to change their opinion. You just need
- 23:39to challenge your expert. Okay, let's move to
- 23:44the third step. I briefly discussed that when
- 23:47I was talking about the console. actions during
- 23:50step three. So during this step your expert knows
- 23:55about the failure mechanism. Hopefully they have
- 23:58been provided a lot of documents and they have
- 24:01reviewed them and they are in the process of
- 24:03doing their engineering analysis to answer some
- 24:06important questions. Like if the work done by
- 24:11firm X or contractor Y played a role in this
- 24:15failure, if the design was appropriate. if construction
- 24:19was appropriate, or maintenance was appropriate,
- 24:23like was environmental loading extreme? And they
- 24:26also need to identify some irrelevant errors
- 24:29on missions and actions. To better explain these
- 24:33bullet points, I'm going to again use the cartoon
- 24:36that we have on the right. We have, as you can
- 24:40see, we have added rainfall to this cartoon.
- 24:44So let's assume we had an unusual weather event,
- 24:47a lot of rainfall. a lot of seepage behind the
- 24:50wall. So it will cause, it may cause some hydrostatic
- 24:53pressure to the wall, but the rainfall by itself
- 24:57cannot establish a failure because we have to
- 25:00look at the drainage condition and ask the question
- 25:03if the drainage was properly designed. And then
- 25:07we have to ask if the drainage was properly designed,
- 25:10was it constructed properly? If it was constructed
- 25:14properly, Was it maintained properly and was
- 25:17letting water to just be drained and be out from
- 25:22behind the wall? So we have to answer all these
- 25:24questions and identify all the factors and among
- 25:29all those, find the root cause. So there is one
- 25:32important, another important concept in forensic
- 25:36engineering that is to understand that something
- 25:39can be deficient, but not causative. So we have
- 25:43to find the one that is the primary cause of
- 25:47the failure. So let's now move to the step four.
- 25:52We call it evaluate contributing factors. So
- 25:57at this point, you have been provided some opinions
- 26:00about the root cause and maybe some other contributing
- 26:03factors to the failure. And you need to start
- 26:06connecting findings to claims and defenses. And
- 26:11in a multi -party construction disputes, which
- 26:14is very common. You rarely have one construction
- 26:18dispute that there is only two parties. Usually
- 26:20there are several parties. So you need to explore
- 26:24multiple causes and multiple parties. And also
- 26:28at this point, you need to assess need for further
- 26:31investigations. Now let's move on and look at
- 26:35what the expert is doing at this step. So at
- 26:38this step the engineering analysis has been done
- 26:41and they are looking at different factors and
- 26:44they are trying to identify the primary cause,
- 26:48secondary causes and relative contribution of
- 26:52each factor. So as I mentioned before something
- 26:56can be wrong but not important to the failure
- 27:00or there might be some separate factors that
- 27:04individually may not have produced the failure,
- 27:07but they may have interacted with each other
- 27:10leading to the failure. And here in the cartoon,
- 27:14I have added the added search. So maybe we had
- 27:17a lot of water behind behind the wall and the
- 27:22drainage was not working properly. But maybe
- 27:25the load. that was being applied by the hydrostatic
- 27:30pressure was not enough to cause the failure.
- 27:33But when you combine that with the added surcharge
- 27:36behind the wall, that caused the failure. So
- 27:39this is a very complicated step for the experts
- 27:43to just do the sensitivity analysis and to determine
- 27:47what was the primary cause and what were the
- 27:52secondary causes for the failure. Okay, let's
- 27:56move on to step five, which is the last one.
- 27:59It's called develop engineering opinions. I definitely
- 28:02don't mean that the console is developing the
- 28:06opinions. They are going to be provided the opinions,
- 28:09but they need to use those and define relevant
- 28:13litigation questions. And still they need to
- 28:16challenge and test the opinions by their expert
- 28:19and also prepare their expert for testimony and
- 28:23deposition. and they have to practice to communicate
- 28:26those findings clearly and sometimes in plain
- 28:30language for the jury. And finally, the last
- 28:35step, step Y, your expert is gonna draft the
- 28:39report and explain the scientific method that
- 28:42they have adopted for their analysis and also
- 28:45all the engineering conclusions in their report.
- 28:49And sometimes we are being asked about the standard
- 28:51of care, so they need to include that in the
- 28:54in their report. So this is the complete process
- 28:59for the investigation process in forensic engineering.
- 29:04This looks linear but this process is not linear
- 29:07and in fact it's an iterative process because
- 29:11at each step you may be provided with some additional
- 29:14documents or a report from other parties can
- 29:18become available or a new piece of information
- 29:22is disclose in the position. So sometimes you
- 29:25need to go back to some earlier steps and rework
- 29:28your assumptions or your analysis. So it's not
- 29:32like you when you pass a step two or step three,
- 29:35you never go back to that step. So this is an
- 29:38iterative process. So you're done with the With
- 29:45the investigation process now, let's look at
- 29:48the application of this forensic engineering
- 29:51process to construction litigation. In this section,
- 29:55we are going to go over some examples that shows
- 30:00those different types of construction disputes
- 30:02and how those different parties work or the correspondence
- 30:07between those parties can cause a dispute during
- 30:11the project. So I'm gonna start with one project
- 30:18that I'm sure most of you are familiar with.
- 30:22It's the Boston Big Big. During the peak of the
- 30:27construction in this project, this was the biggest
- 30:30public works project in the states. And it included
- 30:36more than 13 mile of tunneling. and a lot of
- 30:41deep excavations in very developed urban area
- 30:44as you can see in the top left photos. And you
- 30:48can see the scale of the excavation in the bottom
- 30:51left photo and some tunneling on the offshore
- 30:55areas. So what made this project very complicated
- 31:01was the type of material that they were dealing
- 31:05with in this area. The downtown Boston was is
- 31:10built on top of some uncompacted field and some
- 31:16abundant utility lines. So during the excavation,
- 31:22they encountered some centuries old seawalls,
- 31:27some abandoned utilities, and even a completely
- 31:31intact sunken colonial ships during the construction.
- 31:36This kind of complexity and this type of details
- 31:40or subsurface information that not all of them
- 31:45were basically discussed in the geotechnical
- 31:50reports and contract documents caused a lot of
- 31:54delays or additional costs or different side
- 31:57condition claims. And the resolution of those
- 32:00claims actually lasts 15 years after the project
- 32:04completion. that the last chapter of the dispute
- 32:08resolution actually happened in 2014, almost
- 32:1210 years ago. So, and here I just want to show
- 32:17like just two examples of what was going on and
- 32:21what caused a lot of disputes. On the right,
- 32:25you are looking at the depths of the bedrock
- 32:27where they were supposed to build the tunnel.
- 32:31So they had to, in some sections they had to
- 32:33trace the level of the bedrock to place the tunnel.
- 32:38And you can see that in the geotechnical report,
- 32:42in some stations, there was a big difference,
- 32:45almost a 10 feet difference between the bedrock
- 32:49level in the reports and what was encountered
- 32:52in the field. So just imagine what would happen
- 32:57if you need to do 10 feet additional rock coring.
- 33:01or excavation of rock to be compliant with the
- 33:05design drawings. And on the right, you can see
- 33:08the map of all the utility lines under the ground.
- 33:13So it looks that it's almost impossible without
- 33:17running to some of these utility lines that will
- 33:20cause some difficulties in the excavations. So
- 33:24there are so many different site condition claims,
- 33:27which some of them were awarded. and they're
- 33:31valid and so many others that were not awarded.
- 33:34So I don't want to go into the details because
- 33:38of the scale of this project. I will let Jeff
- 33:41to continue with some of the examples that we
- 33:45have done in the past and it will cover the different
- 33:48type of construction disputes that we presented
- 33:51earlier in the presentation and also some of
- 33:54those investigation process steps that you need
- 33:57to take in every construction dispute case. Thanks,
- 34:04Saj. The first example I'll discuss here relates
- 34:09to a project in Las Vegas. It's right on the
- 34:14strip at the city center development, specifically
- 34:20what was the Harmon Tower. as part of that city
- 34:26center development. So this is right at the south
- 34:29edge of the strip for those of you familiar with
- 34:32Las Vegas across the street from Plano Hollywood
- 34:35and right near the Cosmopolitan. But the problem
- 34:41child here with this city center development
- 34:44was the Harmon Tower. I've circled it in red
- 34:48there on the photo on the left. It's a reinforced
- 34:53concrete tower and it's sort of that oval shape
- 34:57and plan and it was originally designed to be
- 35:01a 50 -story tower. The bottom 25 floors was planned
- 35:07to be hotel and then the top half was planned
- 35:12to be condominium units and the construction
- 35:15of this development was happening around the
- 35:182006 through 2008. and nine timeframe, not a
- 35:24great time for Las Vegas given the market collapse
- 35:28in 2008. And that was a thread in the story here
- 35:33that we'll get into. But during construction,
- 35:37there were some issues that arose. And they arose
- 35:43around about halfway up floor 18 or 20. An inspector
- 35:51from the building department for Clark County
- 35:55noticed some issues and that threw a wrench into
- 35:59the whole construction process and the design
- 36:02was put under a microscope and the owner who
- 36:06was MGM initiated a lawsuit against the general
- 36:10contractor and then the general contractor then
- 36:13brought in all of the subcontractors including
- 36:16the reinforcing steel subcontractor. and the
- 36:19formwork subcontractor, and also third -party
- 36:24inspectors who worked on the project. So, Saj,
- 36:29if we can go to the next slide, I can talk a
- 36:32little bit about what happened about halfway
- 36:35up when that inspector from the county visited
- 36:38the site as they do periodically to observe construction.
- 36:42They saw an iron worker. For the rebar subcontractor
- 36:46had a torch out and was cutting off Rebar they
- 36:51were getting ready to place concrete for one
- 36:54of the floors and Mind you they were they were
- 36:57pouring a new floor every five days. So they
- 37:00had a really fast schedule moving up Contractor
- 37:04wanted to meet their schedule. So the inspector
- 37:06asked the iron worker. What are you doing cutting
- 37:09steel? With your torch and he says well this
- 37:13rebar it's in the way We can't get our vibrators
- 37:16in to vibrate the concrete. We've got to move
- 37:18on and keep with construction. So we're cutting
- 37:21the steel off that's poking up. And in the bottom
- 37:25photograph there, you can kind of see some torched
- 37:28off rebar. That's the top hook of what's called
- 37:32a stirrup for a beam. And these were called link
- 37:37beams. These beams are very important for the
- 37:39structure. They connect the concrete walls together.
- 37:43So Las Vegas is in a seismically active area
- 37:47and those link beams help the walls move together
- 37:52side to side an earthquake and provide strength
- 37:54and utility so the building doesn't fall over.
- 37:58So the inspector got very concerned and ordered
- 38:01a stop to construction and then MGM initiated
- 38:06an inquiry into the process and. questions were
- 38:13asked about the design and the size of the walls
- 38:17and how much rebar was being put in these walls
- 38:20and beams. And it turns out there was too much
- 38:24rebar for that volume of space to be able to
- 38:28place the rebar per the drawings. The contractor
- 38:32and its subs had to move the rebar to the side
- 38:36or push it down to be able to actually Place
- 38:40and vibrate the concrete without forming voids
- 38:43and and honeycombing as we call it rock pockets
- 38:47in the concrete so that that's a design responsibility
- 38:52to make sure that a designer's Work product their
- 38:57design is constructible But at the same time
- 39:01the contractor can't just go and start moving
- 39:03things around and cutting things off Ideally,
- 39:06they should initiate a RFI and said, hey, we're
- 39:10having trouble putting this in the link beam,
- 39:13this rebar in the link beam. What do we do? And
- 39:18meanwhile, it turns out that the special inspectors
- 39:21that were hired were issuing fraudulent reports.
- 39:24They were copying and pasting their reports and
- 39:28issuing those. So they got brought into the lawsuit.
- 39:31One tip I would have for you all is working with
- 39:35your clients. is be careful what, or at least
- 39:41advise them, be careful what you put in emails.
- 39:44So when this issue arose and people started peeling
- 39:49back the layers in terms of what the design looked
- 39:53like, these are some excerpts from emails, part
- 39:58of the document production process that Saj mentioned,
- 40:02emails within the design team talking about shortcomings
- 40:08or failures in their design, you know, hoping
- 40:11that they don't have to defend their design because
- 40:14there's holes big enough to fall through or hoping
- 40:17that MGM pulls the plug on the tower because
- 40:21condos weren't selling in 2008. So they capped
- 40:26the building at half height. They didn't want
- 40:29to build the rest of the building. And the story
- 40:32from the contractor side is Well, they're calling
- 40:35all of these issues defects because they can't
- 40:38sell the condo units because the markets crashed
- 40:41So as part of our work as experts we have to
- 40:47dive into all of these details we have to look
- 40:49at the design we have to look at construction
- 40:53tolerance codes If we go to the next slide sage
- 40:57We could talk about some of the work that an
- 41:00expert typically does at the site for example
- 41:04The owner elected to have over 1200 areas of
- 41:11the structure, not just limited to those link
- 41:14beams, but now they're concerned about all of
- 41:16the construction. So they initiated this program
- 41:21of destructive testing, opening up the walls
- 41:23and opening up the columns, looking at the reinforcement
- 41:27placement. So teams of engineers would then go
- 41:29to the site. and document, measure where the
- 41:32rebar is in relation to the face of the concrete.
- 41:37And you can see on the bottom left photo there,
- 41:40all the orange dots are areas where the structure
- 41:44was opened up. And there were some issues. There
- 41:48were some workmanship issues. The contractors
- 41:51and subcontractors acknowledged that and said,
- 41:54well, it's some areas of sloppy work, but it
- 41:57can be fixed. and the owner was saying, well,
- 42:01it's so bad that we have to demolish the entire
- 42:04building, and we're claiming over $300 million
- 42:06in damages. The contractors were claiming about
- 42:1110 % of that, 30 million, saying that you could
- 42:15fix it for about $30 million if you wrap those
- 42:18columns in fiber reinforced polymers, for example.
- 42:22We ran into some issues that aren't really addressed
- 42:25in building codes. Some rebar, that's supposed
- 42:28to be placed in that bottom photograph, for example,
- 42:33you're supposed to have some of the rebar hooking
- 42:36around vertical rebar. And you look in the code
- 42:39and says that rebar should engage the vertical
- 42:42rebar. Well, what does engage mean? Does that
- 42:44mean touching or close enough to work? And then
- 42:48what about if you have slightly slanted rebar
- 42:51and not parallel with the floor? It's not something
- 42:54that's explicitly defined in concrete tolerance
- 42:58codes. So we wanted to analyze the effect of
- 43:02that and the best way often to do that is to
- 43:05just build it and put a bunch of load on it.
- 43:10So we worked with local professors at UCLA and
- 43:16UC Berkeley to construct a perfect column or
- 43:24a perfect wall, and then what we called a Frankenstein
- 43:28column or wall where we put all of the bad stuff
- 43:31we saw in that one specimen to see if it could
- 43:35hold the same amount of load as the good column
- 43:38or wall. So we had to go to Berkeley for the
- 43:41column test because we needed four million pounds
- 43:44to push down on the column. It's the biggest
- 43:48such testing apparatus in the country. Good news,
- 43:54I think, for us engineers and the public is even
- 43:58when you try to make the column rebar sloppily,
- 44:03you still get the code required strength. There's
- 44:06a lot of fat in the design, which helped the
- 44:12contractors be able to stand behind their view
- 44:15that this could be fixed or this could be addressed
- 44:17and helped push aside some of the claims that
- 44:21the entire structure had to be demolished. So
- 44:28this is all part of our investigation process
- 44:31in terms of analyzing the effect of construction
- 44:36defects, and then casting some of these issues
- 44:40into the realm of design errors, where if you
- 44:45design something that's not constructable, that
- 44:48doesn't help the construction team. Let's move
- 44:54to another example here. This is a port city
- 45:00on the West Coast. Where the port district. Was
- 45:05looking to construct a fireboat station. Along
- 45:10the along the waterfront and this is a. A station
- 45:15that houses specialty boats that put out fires
- 45:17on cargo ships. The structure for this. Fireboat
- 45:24Station is relatively simple. It's a steel framed
- 45:28structure. You can see in that bottom center
- 45:30photograph, it has these tapered steel columns
- 45:34and steel rafters that go up to meet at an apex.
- 45:39You can see it there during construction. All
- 45:44of a sudden, right at about the time that, at
- 45:48the point that that middle bottom photograph
- 45:50was taken, The whole thing collapsed. And two
- 45:55people were injured critically that were working
- 45:59in that area. So the Port District and the project
- 46:06team wanted to understand what happened. Why
- 46:09did this collapse? So they all retained experts.
- 46:15And this is a case of needing to get out there
- 46:18early. to document evidence and the site. So
- 46:24if we now go to some of the details, next slide,
- 46:31I'll show some schematics here of the construction.
- 46:36So on the bottom left is, in green you see the
- 46:42tapered columns and then yellow the tapered rafters.
- 46:46The structural engineer, as part of the design
- 46:48team, they are responsible for the design of
- 46:52the finished structure. So it's in its finished
- 46:55state. And in this case, the connection between
- 47:00the green, at the top of the green column, and
- 47:03then the base of that yellow rafter, the engineer
- 47:06called for a welded connection. So essentially
- 47:09taking a torch, an electrode, and welding or
- 47:14connecting those pieces of steel together. Well,
- 47:19the contractor has to build this frame and elected
- 47:22to temporarily bolt those two pieces of steel
- 47:28together, the rafter and the top of the column,
- 47:31with erection bolts. Those are shown as blue
- 47:33dots in the right -hand sketch. The project specs
- 47:38called for the contractor to submit an erection
- 47:41embracing plan, which it did. The contractor
- 47:45proposed to stabilize the structure during construction
- 47:48with these K rails. You can see a sketch of that
- 47:52on the bottom with the concrete blocks and diagonal
- 47:55braces. And you can see them in the photos as
- 47:57well. That was all in place. But what wasn't
- 48:00contemplated was the design of the bolts that
- 48:04the contractor used. And the erection contractor
- 48:08typically uses the same type of bolt for steel
- 48:11structures on every project. an A307 three -quarter
- 48:15inch diameter bolt, which works if you have a
- 48:20high -rise structure with horizontal beams and
- 48:22vertical columns. But in this case, we have vertical
- 48:25columns and slanted rafters, and that situation
- 48:31ends up causing additional stress on the bolts.
- 48:34It's almost like a pair of scissors or bolt shears.
- 48:38Because of the weight of that rafter pushing
- 48:40down and pushing out on the top of the column,
- 48:43you get additional stress on the bolts that no
- 48:46one contemplated because no one thought, well,
- 48:49the erection plan should have also included design
- 48:52of the strength of those bolts. So if we go to
- 48:57the next slide, Saj, we go out there and we didn't
- 49:02know this going out there at the site, but we
- 49:04had to look at the pieces, the columns and the
- 49:09rafters and piece together what piece went where
- 49:12from the construction and looking at some of
- 49:15the details are important here and getting out
- 49:18there early before some of these surfaces start
- 49:20to oxidize or corrode. For example, when we look
- 49:24inside boat holes in that middle bottom photo
- 49:27we want to look for witness marks and you can
- 49:30actually see the threads of the bolt where they
- 49:33were digging into the steel. So I know when I
- 49:35look at that that a bolt was in that hole and
- 49:38was sheared off, we found pieces of the bolt
- 49:40down on the ground. But in this case, those bolts
- 49:46were under designed by a factor of about four.
- 49:51And that's the reason why this frame collapsed
- 49:54is because this missing design of a temporary
- 49:58bolt before the structure was to be welded was
- 50:02never checked. And the submittal requirements
- 50:08in the specs were not specific enough to ask,
- 50:12not only do you need an erection and a bracing
- 50:14plan, but you need a check on the strength of
- 50:18any temporary bolts or welds or connection members.
- 50:27Let's move to the next, and this is the final
- 50:31example. We leave some time for questions if
- 50:33there are any, but I'll go through this example.
- 50:39This project involves the design and construction
- 50:44of a retaining wall for a natural gas refinery
- 50:50facility. This is on the East Coast in a mountainous
- 50:55region. The owner, the refinery, wanted to expand
- 51:01their facility. And to expand their facility,
- 51:05they had to construct this retaining wall. So
- 51:08they're going to put some additional buildings
- 51:10and equipment at the top of the wall, and this
- 51:13retaining wall would hold back the soil and support
- 51:16the surcharge of the load of this additional
- 51:21expansion. So this wall is about a quarter of
- 51:27a mile long, and it's a hybrid retaining wall,
- 51:32meaning that the bottom half is constructed of
- 51:38a 50 foot tall soldier pile wall. So those soldier
- 51:43piles are the blue vertical columns that are
- 51:49encapsulated in the ground, in the rock, and
- 51:52then they go upwards there. That's the item in
- 51:56blue. And then there are these red lines. Going
- 52:03back those are rock anchors. Those are steel
- 52:07bars two and a quarter inches in diameter and
- 52:11they are crowded and anchored into the rock and
- 52:15then they are attached to the front of the wall
- 52:17to hold those soldier piles vertical so they
- 52:21don't bend outward under the weight of the backfill
- 52:25behind the wall. The wall itself is made of concrete
- 52:30panels. These are precast panels that are slid
- 52:34down in between the steel soldier piles. And
- 52:41then back fills place behind this wall. And then
- 52:43another part of this hybrid wall is the reinforced
- 52:47soil slope. That's another 50 feet on top of
- 52:52this rock anchored wall. And then that's where
- 52:56the future plant extension is placed. So this
- 53:00wall is very important. If we get the walls under
- 53:04strength or under designed, it could move significantly,
- 53:07which would cause movement of the backfill. It
- 53:11would cause damage to the building on top of
- 53:14it. There were issues that arose during construction
- 53:19and also two years after construction. The service
- 53:25life of this wall is supposed to be 75 years,
- 53:27but only after two years they noticed some issues.
- 53:31They noticed some of the wall panels moving,
- 53:35which was concerning. So of course the owner
- 53:37hires an expert to look at the design of the
- 53:42wall and look at the construction of the wall.
- 53:47So we get out there and we get in a basket up
- 53:50close to the wall and we start looking at the
- 53:52components. the soldier piles, the anchor points.
- 53:56And these photos show here the anchor points
- 54:00of those rods that go connect all the way back
- 54:04into the rock and to the wall face. They're connected
- 54:08by what are called whalers. And those are these
- 54:12beams that these two anchor rods come through
- 54:17and connect to. and they spread the load from
- 54:22the anchor rods to the soldier piles. Well, you
- 54:25can see here some conspicuous, readily observable
- 54:30deformation, concerning deformation to an engineer,
- 54:36and I think to a lay person as well, a lot of
- 54:39bending at that anchor. That's not supposed to
- 54:42happen. That force in the anchor rod has to be
- 54:47solidly resisted by the whaler. So when we started
- 54:50looking at the design, we realized that while
- 54:55the designer considered the strength of the whalers
- 54:59globally, they failed to consider the local bending
- 55:05of those plates that those anchor rods are connected
- 55:09to. And on the left -hand side in this slide,
- 55:12you can kind of see what I'm referring to with
- 55:16that excessive bending. Because the designer
- 55:19failed to specify these blue sort of cyan colored
- 55:25plate stiffeners, which are required by the code,
- 55:30the designer failed to specify those. So you
- 55:33get this excessive deformation. You don't get
- 55:36the required lock off force from the anchor rod
- 55:39into the wall face. But that wasn't the only
- 55:44issue. There were some... issues with the construction
- 55:47as well. So the contractor, contractors often
- 55:54look for opportunities to save money. And this
- 55:57is one proposal that the contractor had in mind.
- 56:01And I'll start on the left and move to the right.
- 56:04But on the left here is the top and the bottom
- 56:11photo on the left are what the designer contemplated
- 56:14for the wall construction in terms of detailing.
- 56:20I mentioned those concrete panels are slid in
- 56:22between the soldier piles and they bear on the
- 56:27inside flanges of those piles. The designer specified
- 56:31at least three inches of overlap or three inches
- 56:34of bearing of that panel against the soldier
- 56:36pile flange. Well, that would require the contractor
- 56:41to almost like that game of Connect 4, if you
- 56:44played that as a kid, slide those panels down
- 56:47from the top with a big crane. You'd have to
- 56:51get a big crane. Contractors thought, well, hey,
- 56:54I can do this easier and cheaper with an excavator.
- 56:57If you let me make those panels a little bit
- 56:59more narrow, I can kind of shimmy them in from
- 57:03ground level. I don't need a big crane. If you're
- 57:07okay with just an inch of bearing, which I'm
- 57:10showing on the bottom, photograph in the middle
- 57:13if you're okay with if an inch of bearing is
- 57:16enough structurally well this this will save
- 57:18a lot of time in the schedule and the designer
- 57:20allowed it they did a calculation and said a
- 57:23bit inch of bearing is enough and it is strength
- 57:27wise but when you consider that nobody builds
- 57:30anything perfectly straight or plumb it's not
- 57:33okay because these soldier piles you're allowed
- 57:36to to build them a little bit out of plumb, right?
- 57:40There's tolerance in construction. When you combine
- 57:43that with tolerance and the allowable width of
- 57:46the panel, they ended up having some of these
- 57:48panels pop out of place and they had to emergency
- 57:52construct some plates to stop the panels from
- 57:57coming out behind the wall. But it's something
- 57:58that the designer allowed and they didn't really
- 58:01have to. They just were trying to help out the
- 58:03contractor. Saj, do you want to take us home
- 58:14here? No, you can continue if you want. So yeah,
- 58:21I think this is our last slide. I think we want
- 58:24to end as some key takeaways, at least from our
- 58:27experience. And you can see from that diagram
- 58:31we showed earlier of the different pathways in
- 58:35communication. These types of disputes are rarely
- 58:38one -dimensional, and what one thinks is a design
- 58:42issue could be a construction issue or vice versa
- 58:46or both. To sift through those issues, it's really
- 58:52important to have an expert there by your side
- 58:58to walk through what documents should be triaged
- 59:03or collected or what witnesses we should talk
- 59:07to early on because people start to forget things
- 59:10as time passes. What evidence do we need to preserve?
- 59:14Do we need to go and put grease on all of the
- 59:17fractured connections before they start to corrode
- 59:21and then the metallurgist can't look for whether
- 59:25this was a fast fracture or a fatigue fracture?
- 59:28These are all things that that ephemeral data
- 59:31or data that's quickly lost can influence the
- 59:36outcome of the case. It's of course important
- 59:40to do an independent investigation and that again
- 59:46involves having an independent expert. There's
- 59:49probably some research you all do and experts
- 59:52to look at past testimony and what the experts
- 59:55said because you would want to make sure that
- 59:59they're going to be objective and fair and come
- 1:00:02to the correct conclusions in your case. And
- 1:00:07you can see through some of these case examples
- 1:00:09that investigating causation requires a systematic
- 1:00:16process. It's not just reviewing documents or
- 1:00:19talking to the project team. It could involve
- 1:00:21physical testing. The building codes and standards
- 1:00:25for construction only take us so far. They do
- 1:00:28a good job of providing the minimum level of
- 1:00:32safety, but they don't answer every question
- 1:00:34in terms of is a certain example of construction
- 1:00:40inherently safe. So sometimes independent testing
- 1:00:45is needed. And that needs to be discussed early
- 1:00:49on, especially given some case timeline restrictions.
- 1:00:56So I hope this has been helpful. Happy to...
- 1:01:03answer any questions that you would have. Saj
- 1:01:06and I are, of course, available at the following
- 1:01:11QR codes or email addresses, but really enjoyed
- 1:01:16speaking to you all and hope to stay in touch.
- 1:01:23This concludes today's presentation. We'd like
- 1:01:25to thank Jeffrey and Saj for an excellent presentation
- 1:01:28today and also give a warm thanks to our audience
- 1:01:30for joining us. Have a great day, everybody.
- 1:01:34Thank you.