Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 448. Your Brain on Menopause with Dr. Fiona Lovely
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Thyroid Fixer podcast, where I'm all about helping you lose that stubborn weight that won't come off no matter what you do. Get off your couch at 2 p.m. and get through your day with energy and stop counting the hairs that come out of your head.
- 0:16I'm your host, Dr. Amy, and I'm here to help you get optimized with your thyroid and your hormones. It's all part of living our mantra, better thyroid, better hormones equals a better life. So let's get you back to being the badass human that you're meant to be. Let's approach it from a thyroid and hormone optimization standpoint.
- 0:38Between myself and my guests, you will be loaded down with information to take control of your health and get back to being you. So let's get started. Dr. Fiona Lovely, I mean, you know that I love you. We have such great chemistry, but one of the main reasons I'm excited to have you on the show outside of your personality and our great conversations is that we have not yet discussed what's going on.
- 1:05what happens in the brain as we as women go through perimenopause and menopause. And this is a topic that I really believe needs to be discussed more because like anything in women's health, when we bring it to the surface and we bring it to the table and women become aware of it and it almost like lights them up and makes, it helps them to make sense of their world and what's going on with their body.
- 1:31And the brain in menopause is not something that has been discussed enough. You know, we're just hearing like little trickles of it here and there. But we really need to help women understand not only what's going on with their body and hormones during menopause, but what's going on with their hormones.
- 1:46brain. So your expertise on this subject is just, I'm so excited. It's so needed. Thank you. Thank you. It is. It is very much needed. And what's neat about this subject is that it's, it's emerging. We haven't until very recently understood just how critical the brain is in a woman's experience at perimenopause and menopause.
- 2:13No, it really is. And I mean, you've done the research on it. You're a clinical neuroscientist. But what actually got you interested in with your podcast? It's not your mother's menopause. I mean, what got you interested in this whole perimenopause menopause time in a woman's life and then specifically the brain?
- 2:34Yeah, yeah, great question. So when I was a brand new baby practitioner, I'm a chiropractor, that's my professional designation, I had a patient come in, and it had to be my first month or two of practice. And she was somewhere in her 40s, and she had a toddler. And she was there for me to treat neck pain and headaches, as I recall it. And at some point, she started asking me questions about menopause.
- 3:00what I understood to be menopause, but her as a 40 something woman didn't understand that that was related to menopause. She figured it was because she'd had a child as she was older and etc. And so I just, you know, I had lots of time and not many patients at that point in my career. So I just chatted her ear off. And many times she said to me,
- 3:23Why doesn't my doctor know this? And where can I get more information? Can you tell me more? And then she started sending her girlfriends that were in the same situation in to see me. And so even though I was just barely in my 30s at that point, I knew enough about it because I'd done the functional medicine training while I was studying to be a chiropractor.
- 3:43and I just shared what I knew. I just shared what was in my heart and in my brain, I guess, for her, and she was grateful, and she was the reason why I leaned into being a menopause expert, and that evolved over time because what I realized was that there were so many women that were older than me at that point that wanted help that had no idea how to even ask for the help, whether it was
- 4:11thyroid or sleep or, you know, heavy bleeds or, or now, you know, anxiety and depression are part of the perimenopause spectrum. Anyways, so fast forward to quite a few years later, about 13 years ago, I took some training in functional neurology, thinking it would be kind of a cool weekend seminar.
- 4:3613 years later, I'm still doing it. I took my clinical neuroscience degree in functional neurology. And so I started at some point in my career fixing broken brains. And in my mind, those things were always separate. There was like, okay, you come see Dr. Lovely, because you have a brain that needs help. Or you come see Dr. Lovely, because you're somewhere in need of the
- 4:58the functional medicine cascade for women's health. And typically, that's around perimenopause. And one day, it kind of dawned on me, I thought, Oh, shit, I've got all of the information in my head to start talking about a woman's brain and how a brain changes because of the egress of the
- 5:21somewhere in our 30s, the hormones start to change. And when the hormones change, the neurotransmitters change. And when the neurotransmitters change, we have a different experience in life, both physically and psychologically. And I think that's something that is okay, whatever I just said, I just gave me goosebumps. So there's somebody is reinforcing that from somewhere. I don't know, maybe it's Pearl.
- 5:46It's Pearl. It's Pearl for sure. That's essentially how I ended up doing this. And what's really been fascinating the last few years, as Lisa Moscone's research is really taking a forefront for us, is she, as a PhD researcher...
- 6:03is showing us how estrogen, et cetera, changes the brain chemistry and the brain structure, specifically at menopause. And she started that work because she had a grandmother with Alzheimer's. And she recognized that and there are other family members for her that have Alzheimer's. And she recognized as a younger woman, that those changes for those family members started in the menopause transition. Yeah.
- 6:27And so ultimately, what her research did for me, and Roberta Brinton's research as well, I'm also a huge fan of Luanne Brizendine and her work as well. And those ladies and their work really allowed me to put these pieces together in my own brain. And then I realized that there's just not very many of us talking about it. Mm-hmm.
- 6:53You know, we can talk about it from a clinical research point of view, but who are the clinicians on the ground that have the toolkit to show a woman how to have a different experience at midlife? Yes, I love that. And I'm so, so grateful that you are one of those women out there talking about it amongst the maybe five or six that are. And you're right. It's a topic that, oh my gosh, we just, we just need to speak more on.
- 7:21I'm not sure which direction I want to go first. I think let's start with just for the ladies out there that might be in that perimenopause state. I mean, like you said, really, even in their thirties, hormones are starting to shift and change. What are they noticing or what should they be paying attention to that is not, I don't want to call, say it normal, but that is, that could be related to hormonal decline as it relates to their brain or their mood. Yeah.
- 7:51Yeah, sure. First, I want to say, I'll come back to that. I want to set the stage a little bit. Out of the top 10 symptoms that are most commonly reported for women in menopause, and this is done by our friend Andrea Donsky and wearemorphous.com. She's done surveys, which are showing us a whole other picture of menopause. It's not just hot flashes.
- 8:21Nine out of 10 of them are brain based. Wow. Okay. I know. Again, goosebumps. What just happened? Yeah, I did. I just, I seriously have goosebumps. Okay. Me too. Me too. So nine out of 10. So what does that mean? It means a woman is absolutely, we are, we are not understood at this point in our lives. And there are so many of us.
- 8:45that have been misdiagnosed, underdiagnosed around brain-based symptoms. What do I mean by that? I mean depression. I mean anxiety. I mean paranoia. I mean pervasive thoughts. One of my favorites to talk about that is called anhedonia in the medical research is the lack of joy.
- 9:11And the lack of happiness, I know. And I've experienced that myself in my menopause transition in the last 18 months. And it's been breathtakingly bad, meaning this is what happens to me, by the way. I understand something because I've read the research, but then I experience and I go, what?
- 9:32Oh, yeah, many people need to know this, whether it's low back pain, or it's insomnia, or it's the anhedonia, right? So as someone who's had a very, how would I say it, very rich emotional life.
- 9:49It's been tough being flat, right? Now, if I was to go to my GP and say to her, I just don't feel the same. I love her, by the way. I'm grateful for her. So let me not diss her. But I'm going to use her as an example. So if I was to go to her and say, I just like everything's just kind of meh.
- 10:09Thankfully, I have a great life. So I have all these habits I can continue to do with muscle memory because there are things I've done and I know they make me happy. Do I feel the same way now about them that I did before? I don't. That's one of the things that happens with the egress of estrogen in particular, although progesterone and testosterone are involved. If I went to see her, she'd say, it sounds to me like you're depressed. Here's an antidepressant. And then if I said to her, well, you know, I don't sleep through the night all that well.
- 10:40The truth is I have great help now. So I do. I've got hormones that I take that keep me asleep at night. But there was a lot of years that I didn't. And I didn't know to ask. This is me as the menopause expert. I didn't know to ask. It started when I was about 37. Mm-hmm.
- 10:57So and I was hustling, I just finished professional school a few years, I was building a practice I had, you know, I had other professionals in the office, I had HR, I had to manage, I had to do the, you know, all of the things, right? Which we talk about autoimmunity. I mean, I think about my girlfriends that are in the same position as me that have done the same kind of work. So many of us have autoimmune disease. Yes.
- 11:20That's a bigger conversation. We'll put that to the side. Stress and running yourself. Yeah. Basically turning away from the feminine spirit is what that is. Hyper masculinizing ourselves to not rest and keep moving and all of those things. Which can serve us well at times. But we need to still pull in that feminine energy and remind ourselves like we still have different needs than men.
- 11:49Yes, very much so very much so. So I could have been easily misunderstood by my medical doctor who knows me really well, but she only has certain tools right. So here's what we know. We know that when a woman's ovaries start to signal.
- 12:06the decline of the hormones. Now, this is what happens in our 30s and early 40s. Estrogen goes up and down, up and down and up and down. So we can be up one day and down the next. Meanwhile, progesterone and testosterone do a slow decline. Progesterone first, testosterone a little later. And over time, to come back to your question, we start to lose the quality of our sleep.
- 12:35So either we wake in the night, can't get back to sleep, or we don't sleep long enough, or we're awake at night because we're busy looking at a phone thinking that it's going to allow us to go to sleep, which we know that's not possible. Right. The quality of our moods change. Right.
- 12:52We don't have the same ability to raise our moods if we're not feeling great. Anxiety can be crushing during this time. It absolutely was for me. Again, if I'd gone to my GP, I knew enough not to go to my GP because I knew enough to know that it wasn't
- 13:13Well, let's be honest, I'm in Canada. And so cannabis helped a great deal, right? It was during a time for me where both my parents were sick. My dad was passing away. I'm trying to run a business. It was right before COVID, blah, blah, right? God, yeah. Yes. I thank God for cannabis. Right. I know.
- 13:31But you were not Prozac deficient and you knew that. I knew it wasn't that. I knew there were just some times that I was just spinning and I couldn't stop spinning. So again, if I'd gone to my GP, I would have likely even get a medication for that. And at this point in my life at 51, I could have had up to six or so medications if I had gone down that road. And listen, if it's warranted, I have no issue with it.
- 13:59But so often the misunderstanding of what a woman is actually going through with her body and her brain between 35 and 55, there's a whole cluster of things that can show up in that time. And it turns out most of them are brain based. Isn't that fascinating? Crazy. Crazy. Crazy.
- 14:21I know that's a lot of information I just threw at you, wasn't it? I know. Well, that's a lot of information. That's all right. We're going to unpack this. So when you say brain-based. Yes. Okay. So we know the sleep, the mood. Are there any symptoms? And maybe they're not, but I'm just spitballing this question. Are there any symptoms that we get that really start in the brain? So I'm thinking about the gut-brain connection. You know, we tend to get really bloated.
- 14:48When we're low in estrogen, is there, is that being triggered by something in the brain or are all the brain-based symptoms exactly what we would think? The mood, the even hot flashes could be controlled by the brain. Are they the basic ones or am I missing ones that like, oh, we didn't even think that that would be brain related? Yeah.
- 15:07Well, you're, you're getting it right. It's that sense of not having the happiness or satisfaction. It is anxiety, depression, paranoia, and hedonia, the loss of, of, of joy and happiness, et cetera. It's all of those things. Yep. It's, it's libido. That is also brain-based. That's brain-based for sure. Basically, it's not your vagina that's causing your menopause. It's your brain. Yeah. So, which is how I actually opened my book. Oh, well, there you go. That's perfect. Yeah.
- 15:37That's a beautiful opening. It is. It is attributable to my book coach. Thank you, book coach, if you're listening. So, you know, it's the answer is we've got to look at what the brain function is doing, right? Like so often we make...
- 15:56Anxiety and depression are the most common. Forgetfulness, memory, memory lapses, can't concentrate. See, that's the thing. If I'd gone to my doctor and said, I can't concentrate them all over the place, ADHD meds. So again, you can't take your Maserati to the Ford dealership. Yeah.
- 16:16Yeah, exactly. You got to think if you need nutritional advice, don't go to your GP. Right. If you need diabetes medication, go to your GP. You break a leg, go to the ER. Don't go to your nutritionist. Your nutritionist can help you a little bit later on getting the things to help build bone, right? So it's all a matter of thinking about that. Now, to go to your question, it's the obvious ones that we are most concerned with, and
- 16:43hot flashes are absolutely to the best of our knowledge, a brain based mechanism around the hypothalamus. Of course, the thyroid is involved in the hypothalamic function, as you know. And so those are the things we want to really look at. And listen, this is a huge number of things like a woman is more likely to be diagnosed with depression and anxiety between the ages of 35 and 45 by a factor of two. So double, double the number of women.
- 17:12And, you know, the other thing to consider is that there is an entire estrogenic network in the brain. And the brain estrogen network includes the same parts of the brain that decline in Alzheimer's.
- 17:28Okay, so pause there because I wanted to ask you something very specific with that. So we'll just jump right into that. And then I'll go back to the question I had in my head. Literally today, a friend of mine sent me a post on Instagram. It was Halle Berry being interviewed. I don't even know what she was being interviewed for.
- 17:46But she was saying, and I hope I get this right. She was basically saying that in menopause, all of those hot flashes that we have are like mini strokes. So that's why I wanted to ask you is, are there any symptoms that are more connected to the brain that we wouldn't think? I see.
- 18:01So she said they're like mini strokes so that when we look at someone with Alzheimer's and my mom and my grandpa both died of Alzheimer's, I'm APOE4, you bet your ass I'm taking hormones to protect my brain. But those are like little mini strokes. And then when we look at the brain of Alzheimer's, we see...
- 18:19a lot of, I guess, markers where many, many strokes have occurred, contributing to the amyloid plaque and the damage to the brain. Is there truth in what she's saying? I mean, it's Halle Berry. She's not a functional nutritionist or practitioner, but I guess she's just speaking from what she's diving into since she's in menopause now.
- 18:40Yeah. So there's a reason why she's speaking out, which I'll talk to here in a minute. And also, she is taking something that's very complex and making it very simple, which is great, because then it's accessible for everyone. And you and I are having, you know, smart ladies having an educated conversation here. But this language may be a barrier for some people, in which case she's just bypassing all of that. So let's get back to her in a minute.
- 19:10you know, predisposes us to having Alzheimer's in particular. And so the way that the parts of the brain work around Alzheimer's are that again, there's this estrogenic network that comes down and the mini strokes you asked about. So that is the vascular type, by the way, there's different types of Alzheimer's. And there is a very much a vascular component for many, many of the
- 19:37other dementias as well as Alzheimer's. Alzheimer's sort of the most well-known of the dementia disorders, okay? So I will say that. However, this was a big part of Moscone's research was she recognized that there was some kind of menopause switch for Alzheimer's.
- 19:55So she went about finding it. And so it is indeed that decline of estrogen in the parts of the brain that control memory and mood and emotions. Now, you've spent time around someone with Alzheimer's, so have I. And you know, they become a very much a, like a baser version of themselves. Those higher functions are gone. And they are really about, you know, this is when, you know, sort of end stage, right? It's eating, sleeping.
- 20:24Pooping, that kind of thing. That's their whole existence, right? Right. So obviously the frontal lobe is toast at that point. And the prefrontal cortex is part of the brain estrogen network, as are the hypothalamus, the brain stem, the limbic system, the amygdala, etc. Now let's go to Halle Berry. So Halle Berry is actually...
- 20:44She's out there talking about menopause. And here's why. She went to her doctor because she found she was very irritated. Her vulva was irritated. She went to her doctor. Her doctor took a quick look and said, you have herpes.
- 20:59And gave her herpes medications. When in fact what she had was the genital urinary syndrome of menopause. Which is that the tissues of the vulva get very friable. They get very fragile. And I know I've had a number of women tell me that they can't even wipe with regular paper towel. Or toilet paper because it hurts. Or it cracks and then they have bleeding. So here we have an Oscar winning actress. Who is well known.
- 21:27And a doctor who knows her well, who was so uninformed about a woman's body at midlife,
- 21:36that she had this misdiagnosis and she just started talking about it. Okay. And she was picked up by some of the senators, I believe. Again, American system, I'm going to get that wrong. I'll butcher it somewhere along the way. And they together went about talking about how we need to have laws that protect information and education for doctors for women around midlife. That's why Halle Berry is talking about it.
- 22:01Now in terms of, yes, right? I mean, it's good. Let her use her celebrity for it. It's great. So in terms of the mini strokes that happen at hot flashes, okay? So here's what we know. We know that women who have the vasomotor symptoms of menopause, which are things like hot flashes and night sweats, have an increased risk for a cardiovascular event or heart disease.
- 22:28So what our physicians should hear when they hear us come in and say, we're having hot flashes 27 times a day, is I need to do all the things I need to do to take care of this patient of mine for prevention of heart disease, but also to give her some hormones to manage the hot flashes. So we have been able to connect the vasomotor symptoms like hot flashes and night sweats to heart disease. Isn't that fascinating? Okay.
- 22:58Yeah, it really is. Okay, so here's what we know. We know that women who take HRT have a decreased risk of heart disease by 50%. So I have many members of my family who have had their demise because of a cardiac event. So I'm really paying attention to that one. Yeah. We know that women who take HRT have a 38% decreased risk of Alzheimer's.
- 23:25That's huge. That's huge. I mean, that's huge. Yeah. I don't know the numbers around osteoporosis, but it is also significant. So ultimately, when you're taking HRT, you're not just protecting your brain and your heart, but you're protecting your bones as well.
- 23:41Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So many benefits. We're going to get into the benefits as well, but I want to stick with these, these brain symptoms. Thank you for clarifying what Halle Berry was saying. Cause I was like, oh, is this true? That's interesting. Why is she talking about this? So that's interesting. And I am happy she's speaking out for sure.
- 24:00Now, I've heard Lisa Moscone interviewed and our friend, Dr. Mindy Pels, talks about this as well. And when I heard both of them talk about this particular aspect of menopause, it really clicked for me. And I went, oh, that's exactly what's happening. Yeah.
- 24:18For lack of a better description, it's that all fucks are no longer given. Like literally your armor comes down. I spent all my fuck bucks. The armor is down and literally the things that would normally bother you don't anymore. And that is a beautiful thing. So it's also something in your research that is tied to menopause. And this could actually be a positive that we can ride the wave on.
- 24:46Yeah, I think it's a good question. So we know that with the estrogenic decline, what happens is we have less connectivity in the brain. We have changing brain fuel systems. We have less gray matter volume. We have less cerebral blood flow. We have less neuroplasticity. And that's the ability for the neural networks to come together and create new pathways. Yeah.
- 25:16So what does that mean? It means, this is Moscone's research. She's shown that the fuel system changes. There's a renovation that happens in the brain at midlife. And during that time, there's a period of time where things go a little bit dim. Now, let me explain that because I don't want anybody feeling like this is going to be the rest of your life.
- 25:36I say dim, we sense dim as in there's at least twice now that you've been talking like, what the hell was I talking about again? Yeah. Okay. Right. So I do have a pen. Just a little bit. I have a little pen of paper to start talking about the brain and estrogen. Fiona will be fine. It'll come out.
- 25:57But this is what the research is showing. Okay. So first of all, huge renovation that happens where all of those things I just mentioned, less processing power, less blood flow, less all of those things are happening. But what the research also shows us is that within four years of our last menstrual period, we have exactly the same function as we did before.
- 26:17OK, so we go it's not that we go back. We have renovated forward. OK, the renovation is a terminology that Dr. Moscone uses, and I think it's a really good one. It's useful. Now, I know for me as a woman who's in that not yet at the four year mark, what I worry about is I mean, my brain is my entire life.
- 26:38Right. If that disappears, I'm hooped. So, you know, this was this was the reason I created the brain health master course for women, which is a course I run once a year and talk about in the book as well, was because I took my own tools when I started to feel my own decline happening back in 2020. Yeah.
- 26:57and put them together in a way that was really easy for me to understand. And then I thought, I bet there's a lot of other women that want it turns out there are. So what we know is that that function returns and the testing that is done on us, the cognitive testing that's done on us in this time period where we feel like we're a little bit dim. We're not as quick. We've got the memory lapses. We lose words, concentration, you know, all those things.
- 27:24The testing shows that we actually test exactly the same way as we did before all that started. So it's only a feeling on the inside. Okay. Isn't that fascinating? That's fascinating. Yeah. Yeah. So do not throw in the towel, ladies. It is all good. Carry on because women are damn good at just that.
- 27:42Oh, we totally are. We absolutely are. So wait, now what I'm hearing is if we can start hormones before these detrimental symptoms start coming on, can that prevent it? Now, like I shared, I've been on hormones since perimenopause and I plan to continue.
- 28:02But I still notice that armor, that brain armor coming down. And I just, you know, more, I guess, more emotional stability, maybe a little bit more flat affect, less emotional, good and bad way that can go either way. But definitely there's a freedom in, in not giving a fuck anymore. And absolutely.
- 28:24And I don't want that to go away, but I do want my brain to function and I don't want hot flashes and I want to protect against Alzheimer's. So is, is really, is it, is it hormones that are the answer or is it hormones and? It's hormones and. Okay. So we have lifestyle things that we can do that are very, very helpful for this. And some things just don't require a whole lot of hormones, right? Some things we just need a little bit to make sure we're staying in that safe zone that we're preventing, we're protecting our heart, our brain, our bones.
- 28:54And it's giving us what we need. For me, I'm not sure where my sleep would be without the progesterone. But then you talk about the no fucks to give, right? Here's what's fascinating about that. You're absolutely right. It's two sides of the same coin. I started this conversation talking to you about my own experience with anhedonia. It's the same process.
- 29:13So I actually said this to my therapist the other day. I said, you know, it's funny. I don't dance with fear anymore. And I know fear really, really, really well. Yeah. Right. But it's just not there, which is, I'll take it. I have so much more space in my brain because it's not there. Right.
- 29:28So is that the, you know, is the is the also losing the edge of what that glorious emotion of seeing a field full of sunflowers or a puppy or whatever, you know, oh, I had a puppy come visit me in the office yesterday. So I'm still excited about those guys. But you know what I'm saying, right? It's a little bit we have to give a little bit to get the benefit of it as well. Now, is taking hormones the answer?
- 29:53Yes, start your hormones if you can before you stop your periods. Whether your GP will get on board with that, your prescribing physician is another story. But the truth is you have experts like Dr. Amy and myself that you can reach out to.
- 30:09If we can't help you, we know people that can help you. So don't hesitate. Don't stay in a place. Right. And and yes, I recognize there is a privilege with that. But I think those of us that are big hearted are working on accessibility for all. And so I'll leave that down. But I think the question is all the lifestyle things really matter. The quality of sleep.
- 30:33The quality of the relationships you have. Do you have toxicity in your life, whether it is mold in your basement or a shitty stepmom? All of those things need to go, right? You need to protect yourself first.
- 30:48And certainly nutrition is a huge part of that. Getting the supplements are a huge part of that that can help with longevity. There's just so many things. Getting great sleep. I think I started with addressing inflammation. Like there's so many things that we can do to help the process. So I had a patient, again, scenario I'll give you. I had a patient come see me yesterday. And she said, I'm here for a second opinion. Okay. She was new to me. She said, I have pellets and I'm not sure how I feel about having these things stuck in me.
- 31:18And I said, and she said, what do you think? Can I just, can I just like take them out and manage this myself with a good diet? And I said, well, first of all, I'm a really good person to ask that of because for so I started the Not Your Mother's Menopause podcast in 2016. And at that time, we hadn't yet had the research that said hormones were safe.
- 31:38And most of us were in perimenopause, but things weren't loud enough yet to really for the rallying cry of the Gen Xers, right? That hadn't happened yet like it is now. And I said, I'm a really good person to ask because for most of the time that I have done this work, I've given the lifestyle. That has been my main, the supplements at the right time, in the right dose for the right thing. That's my toolkit. Yeah.
- 32:04Until I started to see the research come out about 21, maybe 22 is when that started to come out. And I really had to pay attention. I was like, no, just a minute now. At the time, my mother was in the throes of dementia. And my father had passed away. And I was watching this stuff. This was my family history. I was watching and saying, I don't want to go down like that.
- 32:29Right. So for me, I started to really pay attention and it was pretty clear, pretty fast. If you even look at half a dozen of these research papers, there is such benefit for us if the hormones are done in the right dosage for optimization and they're monitored and they are done in a safe fashion. So this is what I said to the patient yesterday. I said,
- 32:53How are you with taking pills and patches and creams and potions? She said, I'm terrible at it. I said, okay, tell me about how your doctor's managing your pellets. She said, she looks at my blood work two to three times a year and adjusts the pellets accordingly.
- 33:09So I said to her, I said, okay, well, I'm not thrilled about the pellets. We don't know a lot. They're not well regulated. They're expensive, all of those things. But if you're not going to be the guy that's going to be testosterone on this side and progesterone on this side, and then you put one of the progesterone you squirted on and the others you take internally, and then you take the...
- 33:30Saw palmetto to make sure the testosterone goes down the right pathway. Like, and I literally laid it all out. She's like, I am not that guy. I said, stick with the pellets. Because at least you've got somebody and something. Right. And so many do not even have a doctor that will even listen to them about this.
- 33:49So am I endorsing pellets? Not at all. For this patient, it made sense. And I think this speaks to something that I think is really important in modern menopause care is that we need individuation. And Western medicine isn't great at individuation.
- 34:07Yes. So much. Right? Yeah. Yes. Yeah. At this point, for example, for myself, I don't need estrogen. Some point I will, but progesterone and testosterone. Oh, hell yes. Right? Yes. Everybody is different.
- 34:23Everyone is different. Everyone's unique. Well, it's the same thing that I see with thyroid is that it's a one size fits all, even in functional medicine. A lot of functional medicine practitioners who just don't know the thyroid will give everybody NDT and that's it. And they think that they're doing a miraculous job because they're using natural desiccated thyroid. It's like, well, no, it has to be individualized. The same thing with hormones.
- 34:46Absolutely has to be individualized. And I completely agree with you. I would rather have a woman on erratic, sometimes too much hormone in the form of pellets than no hormones at all. You know, okay, yeah, with a pellet, you might get a little bit of hair loss because there goes the testosterone up to dude levels, but it's better than nothing at all.
- 35:08So I agree with you. Yeah. Yeah, it's true. I mean, and again, this really speaks to that. You've got to have somebody knows what you're doing. Each woman's scenario is different. I asked her what was in her family history. She said tons of Alzheimer's. I said, well, then you better. If you cannot stick to putting the creams on and taking the pills at the right time, if you're not that guy, keep the pellets in.
- 35:31Yep. Put that pellet in your butt and let it ride. So at least you're getting something. Now you had mentioned supplements. Are there any like non-negotiables? This is what you must start taking when you enter perimenopause? The answer is yes, but they're not, they're general support. They're not necessarily hormonal support, if that helps.
- 35:52And I would say the Dr. Lovely trifecta is what we call it in the office have for many years is fish oil probiotics and vitamin D. Everybody, every human needs to be taking that and chances are you're probably taking not enough vitamin D.
- 36:11So, you know, because we just don't, we see those numbers and we think they go, oh, 5,000, 10,000. Oh my God. Okay. Listen, in Canada here, even if we're outside every day in the three months of summer we get, we do not get enough sunshine. We're too far north of the equator. It just doesn't happen. And one of my favorite teachers in functional medicine has a practice in San Diego, it's
- 36:34In San Diego, sunniest place in the United States, right? He tests vitamin D on all his patients, every single one. And he said by far the majority of them do not have enough. So if San Diego doesn't have it, Calgary, Alberta for sure does not have it. Right. Right.
- 36:49So vitamin D for sure. The other things I would add probiotics for gut and brain health. And what's really interesting is we're starting to see probiotics, which are the gut bugs that communicate constantly between the body and the brain via the vagus nerve. What we're really starting to see now is a pretty cool...
- 37:09Creation of formulations based on symptomatology, because we know there are certain bugs that are connected to certain brain-based phenomenon like anxiety, depression, but body things too, which is really quite interesting. So I'm curious to investigate that further. B12. Liquid B12 is a big one for anybody over the age of 40. Men or women, but especially women, because we bleed and lots of times in our 40s, we bleed a lot.
- 37:39And anemia is a real problem. So assessing every patient for anemia that is a female in my practice is a pretty important part of something I do fairly regularly. Because we know, and I've done entire podcast episodes on this, we know that when the brain doesn't have enough oxygen, it's...
- 38:00It doesn't matter what fancy things I do to fix brain, brain's not getting fixed. So you must amend anemia. It literally is the reason probably that you're having the anxiety and depression and low libido, etc. So it's just different for everybody. Maybe it's low hormones. Maybe it's the fact that you've been anemic for 12 years and your doctor said after you gave birth to your last child, oh, it's fine. You'll figure it out eventually. Don't worry about it.
- 38:25Right. You know, and it really is because Western medicine doesn't have a quick fix to that. You can't give a transfusion to every woman that has anemia because there's many of us and many of us. Low B12 is a big part in whether or not we actually have the cells we need to take the oxygen to the brain, which is what we're looking at.
- 38:45In terms of all the tissues actually in the body. What else? Whatever. Oh, magnesium. Magnesium glycinate at bedtime. For sure. If a woman is constipated, then magnesium citrate. You know, and then I would add in other things depending on the history. So if there's a thyroid history or a suspected thyroid, I'd be adding in some, make sure you have a Brazil nut every day. Make sure you're taking some kelp tablets. Make sure, et cetera. Adrenal support is very common in my office. I do lots of that. Mm-hmm.
- 39:14Those are kind of the big ones that I'm thinking of off the top of my head. I may have missed some, but those are the ones I like for pretty much everybody. But we can get far more specific depending on what's going on with someone's symptomatology. Yeah, back to the personalization. So just like we would personalize hormones, you can personalize supplement regimen, but that's a really nice base. And I think it's important for women to know.
- 39:39you can have that base of supplementation. Then you can go over here, just like you were saying earlier, go see the nutritionist, work on your nutrition, address any deficiencies or insulin resistance. If you need to cut your carbs, increase your protein, whatever. Yes, you need to get the sleep component. That's 100%. But in your opinion, even doing all of that, is that enough without the bioidentical hormone replacement? For very few women, that would be enough.
- 40:06Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. When we were in our 30s, we could do that. And that was enough. But as we've just come through this massively stressful time as a global community, as our generation are passing through the end bits of perimenopause, if you will, depending on where they are in terms of age, there's just...
- 40:28There's, there's too much, there's too much going on. There's too much stress. We, we glorify it. We glorify busyness, all of those things that saps our resources. Yeah. So I don't know, stack the deck in, in your, in your favor by taking the hormones. I just, here's the thing. I know there's a lot of discussion about, do we test? Do we not test? Now you practice functional medicine like I do for me, we must always look.
- 40:56We're not going to give a woman testosterone unless she has low testosterone. Right. Right. Now, sometimes, like thyroid's a great example, a woman will have all of the symptoms on the checklist and her thyroid still shows in the normal zone.
- 41:11but you and I know enough to know, hold on a minute. We need to support some things. So again, it's that individuation, but you can definitely stack the deck in your favor. Yeah. By doing the lifestyle, the lifestyle and the hormones together. I think it just goes together. It has to be the both hand. Now you had mentioned earlier, and I agree with you that we really do need to make these hormones more accessible and,
- 41:35And I believe I couldn't tell you which country it was. I thought it was the UK, but I might be wrong where they actually they give hormones. Yeah. OK, right. It's like standard of care. Yes. Because kudos to the UK for knowing that hormones provide massive amounts of protection, just like you said earlier, bone, brain, breast, heart, in addition to quality of life.
- 42:00Now, we are not that lucky here. I honestly, my heart of hearts, do not see a time in our lifetime where our governments will give out hormones to men and women for prevention. So if someone is just stuck, what's your opinion on...
- 42:19The over-the-counter creams. I know some people are using wild yam. I always tell women, you're not a yam. So at least do like the OTC progesterone bias that you can get. What's your opinion on the over-the-counter hormones? I know we can't do testosterone. You know, there's some supplements and like tonkata lead tribulus that can increase testosterone. But what about the creams?
- 42:40Yeah, they are not available in Canada. So only in the US are those available. And depends on the person, right? If I, you know, we we have this philosophy, I like to say to my patients with this philosophy that more is better. And which I say, we're not talking about boobies or beer, more may not necessarily be better.
- 43:03Right. Right. But if we put on the cream and we have a really good night's sleep that we got, you know, in the, you know, vitamin cottage or whatever, and we have a really good night's sleep, we go, Oh, I'll put on a little bit more next time. And then a little bit more. Right. So I just think there needs to be caution, but the truth is not everybody. I mean, this is the two of us educated, privileged women having this conversation. We have access to this. Right. Right.
- 43:31So if a woman does not have access to it, could she try it? Yes, but be cautious for yourself. Give it a go. But for God's sakes, don't slather half a bucket on your wrist and go, that's it, I'm fixed. Right.
- 43:46And when you are able, please have somebody take a look at your, do a hormone panel. I call it the Well Women panel at midlife. And, you know, it's all of the important and pertinent hormones, thyroid, inflammatory markers, etc. that I think are really important. And then that'll give you some information as to whether or not you're even absorbing it. And if it's too much or not enough.
- 44:13Nope. I agree with that. So on that note for testing, do you prefer blood? Do you like Dutch tests, saliva? What method do you use? Okay. I think there's a place for all of them. So I'm in Canada, socialized medicine we have here. I can't order the labs myself as a chiropractor, but I can read them. If I send off a letter to a patient's GP and say, can we take a look at these things? And
- 44:39Pretty rarely do they say no, because they're just grateful to have somebody else sort of backing up and looking at these things. But sometimes it does happen. I think most of them are just grateful for the help, to be honest. And then I'll take a look at the labs and say, OK, now you need to go back to your GP and say,
- 44:56It's time for an estrogen patch. It's time for maybe some estrogen cream for the vulva if you're having repeat UTIs or progesterone, bioidentical progesterone, you know, for sleep or whatever. That's when things get a little sticky. So typically we try going through the socialized system first. If it doesn't work, then I recommend a woman to private care, which we can do here as well.
- 45:22A saliva I did for most of my career. I still do it, although I do it more rarely now because we try to run it through. I mean, we pay all these taxes up here in Canada. For God's sakes, they could pay for our blood work, right? Right. So I do less of it. But sometimes a woman is just like, I am so done with trying to be talking to my doctor about it. Let's just do a saliva panel. And this brings up the Dutch. Sometimes a woman gets the estrogen patch and she doesn't feel any better. Why is that happening?
- 45:51That's when we can start to look at the metabolites and get an idea if we can support her better. And that's when I think the dried urine testing can be helpful.
- 46:01How about you? What do you think? I'm kind of the same way. I like blood. It's easy. It gives us that baseline. Then as we both do, we always ask the patient, how do you feel? And pair that up, pair up the symptoms with what we're seeing in the labs. And then the Dutch test. So it's funny. I heard this at A4M and it kind of stuck with me. So now I use it. You know, a lot of women will run out and they'll get the Dutch test and they might be 35, 40 years old, not on any hormones.
- 46:29And I'm like, that's great, but you just dropped $500 and you're not even on hormones. And the quote that I heard was looking at a Dutch test for women who are not taking any hormone replacement is like doing an audit of a 16 year old's bank account. You're just not going to see much.
- 46:48Yeah, yeah. Like, I mean, and of course we have our own hormones and yes, it's nice to look and see, are we even metabolizing our hormones down the right pathway and all of that? But it's just, I think an unnecessary cost unless you are taking hormones and now we really wanna see how are you using those hormones? Exactly, exactly. And we have to remember, I've seen medicine get really critical of those of us that don't have a Western medicine license. Oh, sure.
- 47:18And medicine has to remember that they were not listening. They were not picking up the phone for an entire generation of women. And so folks like you and I, who didn't want anything to do with that system in terms of our professional lives, have come up with alternatives. And the Dutch is one of those alternatives. Mm-hmm.
- 47:40I know I've seen some of the big name menopause gals just lamb, like just giving it, lambasting it. And I'm like, okay, hold on a second. Before you judge, you need to look at your own history. And remember, there was a time where you also spoke to women in menopause like you're talking to us now. So we were just here to help long before you were.
- 48:03Mm hmm. So I've been shout, as I say in my book, I've been shouting in the menopause void for 20 years. Now, finally, there are people listening. Oh, my gosh. Well, that's a mic drop moment right there. Keep preaching, girl. Keep preaching. Keep spreading the word because no, that's exactly it. If women did not have voices like yours, we would all be just suffering and moving through life. Yeah.
- 48:29watching different disease states come about, losing our bone mass, watching our memory decline. And I mean, you're like me, like I'm 50. I'm not ready to throw in the towel yet. Hell no. There's so much more to do. And I need my brain and body functioning at a high level. And if that means taking hormones, hell yeah. Hell yes. I'm going to take hormones. One way or another, I will find them. I will take them. If I can put them in my butt, I'll put them in my
- 48:58But hormones are going to be in my body and we need messengers like yourself educating women. This has been fantastic. I love it because women are going to so connect with the brain connection now they're gonna be like, Oh my gosh, that's me. And then just shouting from the rooftops. Listen, ladies, there's a better life. There's more answers. There are more answers than what you're getting from your GP and Western medicine.
- 49:19Yes, and I'd like to say, if you're experiencing any of the mood issues of perimenopause, like so many of us, there's a very good chance the remedy for that, other than to get rid of the toxic relationships, etc., is hormones before perimenopause.
- 49:40antidepressant or any of the psychotropic drugs, anti-anxiety, et cetera. Yes. I wanna be really plainly say that because it is getting missed. There is research that shows that very thing is the most helpful. And the third thing on that list is the lifestyle changes. So the recommendation from a case review of the research that was existing was give hormones first,
- 50:06If that doesn't resolve the psychology, the brain-based symptoms of perimenopause and menopause, then you consider a psychotropic medication and finally the lifestyle. But of course, that bit of information isn't getting out there, but it is out there. Yeah. Progesterone is the new Prozac. I agree. It just is.
- 50:29Well, Dr. Fiona, what do you do with people? How can people find you, work with you, listen to your podcast, all that good stuff? Yes, I love that. Thank you. So all roads lead back to drlovely.com. So people can go there to find us on my Instagram and all of that.
- 50:46But the podcast I just released, I think episode 132 came out this week. So I do solos sometimes and I interview just as I have interviewed you for my show. Thank you very much. And it's called Not Your Mother's Menopause Podcast and you can find it on all platforms. And I just want to say this work is so...
- 51:10It's such a calling for me. And I know you understand that because there's lots of times I'm going through this right now as I'm working on my book proposal is I just get so angry. I get so stuck in the injustice of it. It pisses me off. Yes. Yes. Did I mention it was Gen X? Yes.
- 51:34I know. I get it. No, we're both pissed off and we're not quiet about it. If you don't like it, don't listen, you know, don't listen, go somewhere else. Exactly. You're going to get a sassy and sweary approach for me because that is my irreverence style. And that's,
- 51:49What I respond to, that's what the women around me respond to. But also, I think it comes out in the show. You know, I just, I get pretty excited about these things. And you said it yourself, it's that shouting from the rooftops, like that, that anger is fuel for me. It's like, no more are we going to put up with this small version of what women's health is and should be.
- 52:14Yes. Thank you. Yes. Yes, absolutely. I love it. We speak the same language. That's why we do. So we'll put all your links to the show notes. We're probably going to do more. I mean, we'll probably do a part two on both of ours. So we'll definitely be seeing each other again. I love it. All right, girl. Thank you so much for your time today. It's been amazing. And I know my audience appreciates you as well. You're very welcome. Thanks for having me. I look forward to next time.