Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Q1 2026 NCUA Data: A Quiet Quarter With One Loud Number
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey, everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Trakel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm here with Steve Farr, and if you're watching on video you
- 0:06can see the name Todd there, but Todd's camera's not working.
- 0:09We're having some technical difficulty.
- 0:11Anyway, guys good to see you.
- 0:12We're gonna be doing a podcast on the quarterly NCUA data that
- 0:17came out a couple weeks back.
- 0:20We got into a routine of updating the listeners and watchers on
- 0:23what's going on in the credit union data every three months.
- 0:27And they got ⦠Next week, they're doing their briefing on the CAMELS ratings
- 0:32and I'll be watching for that one.
- 0:33Some other things going on at NCUA.
- 0:36The new board member's supposed to get his c- confirmation hearing next Thursday.
- 0:41There's a board meeting next Thursday, as I mentioned.
- 0:44By the time this comes out, that may have already passed, so I'm gonna stop
- 0:47talking about what's happening next week.
- 0:48But with that if, ⦠Guys, if, just in case there, there's a new
- 0:52listener who hasn't seen us before or listened to us before, if you could
- 0:56give a little bit of your background.
- 0:58Let's start with Todd this time down there in black and white.
- 1:02Miller: Good morning, everyone.
- 1:04So I was spent 34 years with NCUA.
- 1:07I can break that career and my time with NCUA into three general groups.
- 1:11The first third of my career, I was an examiner and a problem case
- 1:15officer in the Western region.
- 1:17Then the middle third of my career, I spent roughly a decade as a regional
- 1:22capital markets specialist in the Western region, of course dealing
- 1:26with large and complex credit unions.
- 1:28And then the last 11 years of my career, I was the director of special actions in
- 1:32the Western region, supervising problem case officer, regional capital markets
- 1:37specialist, regional lending specialist.
- 1:40Very fun part of my career.
- 1:43Was involved in a lot of complex credit unions.
- 1:47Did a few conservatorships, returned a couple to the members.
- 1:50Those are highlights of the career when you can do that.
- 1:53And there's a lot of those instances you end up liquidating them or doing purchase
- 1:57and assumption to assist with mergers.
- 1:59So was involved in all of that stuff.
- 2:01All in all, enjoyed my 34 years with NCUA.
- 2:04It was very enjoyable working with credit unions that entire time.
- 2:09Good people at NCUA to work with as well.
- 2:12Treichel: Very good.
- 2:12Very good.
- 2:13And now we've been doing this five, six years.
- 2:14And Steve g- give a, g- give us a little bit of your background then and now.
- 2:20Farrar: Oh, I gotta tell you about my background and my, behind me there.
- 2:23Treichel: That's
- 2:24Farrar: good.
- 2:24It's a mountain lake.
- 2:25The, I'm not at this mountain lake, but in one just about like it, and I,
- 2:28we literally ran off of the boat to get in, up in time to do this thing.
- 2:32So I tell every- I would say this morning, I probably caught 10 pounds worth of fish.
- 2:39But I never kept a single one.
- 2:40They were all pretty little.
- 2:42But lots of activities.
- 2:43That was fun.
- 2:43Treichel: That's good.
- 2:44That's better than the amount of fish you and I caught when I came through Montana.
- 2:48Farrar: Yeah, but you guys went through a lot of bobbers.
- 2:50Treichel: Yeah, that's, ⦠I tend to do that.
- 2:52I tend to do that.
- 2:53Yeah.
- 2:53Farrar: Yep.
- 2:54My career at NCUA was 30-plus years broke into two parts.
- 2:57The first half was predominantly as a pr- a problem case officer, and
- 3:01did a lot of work with Todd in that we helped the troubled institutions
- 3:06primarily out on the West Coast.
- 3:08And a lot of satisfaction from that job and getting those turnarounds
- 3:13to, to be successful, and many of them are still around today.
- 3:17Todd and I like to talk about that we were able to save credit unions with
- 3:20even negative capital back in the day.
- 3:23Then I followed Mark when he went to the central office and went to work for
- 3:28the Division of Risk Management, where I spent another 15 years basically.
- 3:32And in, in that job I got to work in just so many different things.
- 3:37I, I dealt with a lot of the accounting for the insurance fund.
- 3:42And then w- we were still involved in all of the major problem credit
- 3:47unions, including the corporate system.
- 3:49Todd and I both worked a lot of time on that.
- 3:52And that was an interesting part of our career that wasn't exactly
- 3:57the most enjoyable, but necessary.
- 4:00And then I ended as the vice president of the CLF when I
- 4:03actually went and moved back to Alexandria, Virginia for a few years.
- 4:07And, then we've been doing this consulting now for quite a while, and
- 4:10that, it, that's been super enjoyable to be able to keep active in the
- 4:15industry and keep our saws sharp.
- 4:17Treichel: Yep.
- 4:17No, it is a lot of fun, and I always enjoy chatting with you guys about what's going
- 4:21on and looking forward to seeing what we got to say about the March 31, 2026 data.
- 4:27So with that, is there one particular thing or either
- 4:31of you wanna jump in first?
- 4:32Do we wanna walk through, the camel from a capital asset quality earnings liquidity?
- 4:37How do we wanna approach this one, guys?
- 4:40Miller: Maybe a little background before we start- That's good ⦠just
- 4:42to what's going on with conditions.
- 4:44Treichel: You got it
- 4:46Miller: What you'll find as we go through this podcast, there hasn't been a lot
- 4:49of changes other than credit unions' performances improved a little bit.
- 4:54Inflation is still persistent.
- 4:56Interest rates have been fairly stable.
- 4:59The short end was inverted a year ago.
- 5:01It's normal now.
- 5:03Longer term rates have went up 50 basis points or so.
- 5:07But in general, there hasn't been a lot of changes to interest rate.
- 5:11Inflation has been fairly persistent.
- 5:14The Fed can't seem to get that under control.
- 5:16But despite that, credit quality is holding up.
- 5:20Wages are growing about the same as inflation, not quite as much.
- 5:25Unemployment trends are all over the place.
- 5:28I use a FRED tool from the Federal Reserve just to track a lot of data,
- 5:32and one of those things I track is unemployment in all 50 states every month.
- 5:37In the last year, we have 31 states where unemployment is
- 5:42higher, 15 states it's lower.
- 5:45Somewhat interesting along with the whole government reduction in
- 5:49force is the District of Columbia's got the highest unemployment rate
- 5:53in the country right now at 6.2%.
- 5:55And then the other places where you see high unemployment is the tech
- 5:59sector, California, Washington, Oregon.
- 6:03Those tech hotspots all have unemployment numbers over 5%.
- 6:08Little bit in Michigan is that way too, and a couple other states.
- 6:12South Dakota's got the lowest at 2.2%.
- 6:15Savings rate have been- but,
- 6:17Treichel: but South Dakota only has 74 people.
- 6:19No, I'm just kidding.
- 6:21Miller: They've got like 174.
- 6:23Come on.
- 6:24They get a couple thousand when they have the motorcycle rally.
- 6:27Treichel: That's right.
- 6:27Sturgis.
- 6:28That's right.
- 6:29Miller: Sturgis.
- 6:30So you know, things are fairly the same.
- 6:33Things are moving around at state-to-state level.
- 6:36But in general, country's been pretty resilient even though
- 6:40inflation is a little high.
- 6:42I do know with all three of my vehicles, it takes 50 bucks
- 6:45to fill up the gas tanks now.
- 6:48You notice it when it crosses over that $50 a tank mark.
- 6:52But for the most part, credit unions have held up well.
- 6:55Earnings are improving.
- 6:57Despite the fact we're in a shooting war and inflation is quite high, our
- 7:00economy seems to be fairly resilient.
- 7:04Treichel: Steve from that 10,000-foot level walking- Yeah
- 7:06through that data any thoughts on that?
- 7:09Farrar: Yeah, Todd and I shared it when we first looked at this data when
- 7:12it came out, and it was like nothing really changed, that liquidity seemed
- 7:16to improve just a little bit, but, that the, this quarter was, uneventful.
- 7:21No real, glaring negative trend jumping out.
- 7:25I did my usual comparison to the community banks.
- 7:29Miller: Yeah.
- 7:30Farrar: And we still have the same ⦠the competitive disadvantage
- 7:34that credit unions have against the community banks is the loan losses
- 7:38continue to be significantly higher than they are in the community banks.
- 7:43Their n- their net charge-off ratio is very low, and it went lower.
- 7:47It's down to 0.18%.
- 7:51And the credit union's net charge-off ratio was they have .78
- 7:56written down.
- 7:57So that is a, a ⦠And it gets reflected in the provision expense,
- 8:03that the losses are higher.
- 8:04And that's a competitive disadvantage that we have ag- when you compare a-
- 8:08against the community banks right now.
- 8:11'Cause they were really strong in profit.
- 8:14Their pre-tax return on assets was 1.42%,
- 8:19which is higher than it was in the fourth quarter, and the credit unions were .83,
- 8:24but, as ⦠When I read summaries of that, they point out that, the bankers,
- 8:28banks have higher earnings, as they're more driven for that, of course.
- 8:31Sure.
- 8:32But credit unions have much more in terms of growth of members than and more growth
- 8:39in loans than they're seeing in those, both have some good things going for them.
- 8:43Treichel: When you talk about the loan losses, I guess if I was trying to figure
- 8:46out a glass half full, maybe it's because credit unions are trying to meet their
- 8:50purpose of serving people of modest means.
- 8:53Maybe not.
- 8:53I don't know.
- 8:54But that's a, that's an interesting stat.
- 8:56Todd, do you have any thoughts on that?
- 8:58Miller: I think credit unions have always had slightly higher
- 9:00charge-off ratios than banks.
- 9:03A little bit more liberal lending type of policies across the industry.
- 9:08So that's not unusual.
- 9:11I don't know if you have it at your fingertips, Steve but usually the FDIC
- 9:16used to publish a percentage of credit union or banks that are negative earnings.
- 9:22You have to dig for it at NCUA and do a custom query.
- 9:25That may be one negative spot in the credit union industry.
- 9:29There's 639 credit unions that are negative earnings
- 9:31here in the first quarter.
- 9:33That's a pretty big number out of 4,250 credit unions.
- 9:35So what percent- about what percent is that?
- 9:35There, Is that 15?
- 9:35Oh.
- 9:3515-ish.
- 9:44I have it written down here somewhere, Steve.
- 9:47Yeah, so-
- 9:52I don't know where I have it written down.
- 9:53I'm gonna-
- 9:53Treichel: Let's see ⦠I'm gonna pull out my ⦠I'm gonna guess it that it's 15%.
- 9:57Let's see if I'm right.
- 9:5816-
- 9:58Miller: It
- 9:58Farrar: is
- 9:58Miller: about 15%.
- 10:00Farrar: Yeah.
- 10:00Yeah, the per- percent of unprofitable community banks was 4.98%,
- 10:07so basically 5%.
- 10:09It's a little lower than it was a year, with in fourth qu- quarter.
- 10:13Yeah.
- 10:14Now,
- 10:14Treichel: and a lot
- 10:14Miller: of those- So for credit unions, it's up.
- 10:17By way of comparison, I have pulled this when we did our
- 10:20podcast at the end of the year.
- 10:22At year end, there was 498 negative earnings credit unions,
- 10:25and now there are 630 of them.
- 10:2818 of those are over a billion.
- 10:3018 are between 500 and a billion.
- 10:33So not very many negative earners at the larger size.
- 10:37Yeah.
- 10:37523 of that 639 now are credit unions under 100 doing this.
- 10:42Yeah.
- 10:42There's a lot of small credit unions out there generating negative earnings.
- 10:46Treichel: They- they're tread- they're treading water until the CEO retires
- 10:50and then probably merge, a lot of those.
- 10:54Yeah.
- 10:56Miller: So that's a big number that changed is look at, intangible assets
- 11:01and equity acquired in mergers.
- 11:03Okay.
- 11:04That's a huge jump in the first quarter of this year.
- 11:06There had to be a very large mega merger or two or three that closed
- 11:12here in the first quarter, 'cause those numbers went up quite a bit.
- 11:17Treichel: Yeah, that's interesting.
- 11:18I've, I did some ⦠I've got some data analysis I've, was
- 11:22getting ready to do on mergers.
- 11:23I'll have to, I'll have to make a note of that and take a look at that.
- 11:26Yeah that that phantom equity, right?
- 11:28That equity that per GAAP accounts as equity, but it's not, doesn't
- 11:31have a whole lot of tangible value.
- 11:33Miller: It went from 9.2
- 11:35to $11.9
- 11:36billion, so 28% increase in one quarter.
- 11:43Treichel: That, That's an alarming number.
- 11:45That- ⦠I'm definitely gonna dig into that.
- 11:47That's huge.
- 11:48That's huge.
- 11:50So the topic of capital, some of the, that, that equity related to those
- 11:54mergers any other thoughts on, or any thoughts in general on capital as
- 11:59we're walking through what's happening?
- 12:01Miller: So if you go dig around NCUA's website, they put out a chart
- 12:07pack with each of these quarters.
- 12:09I don't know, there's 20, 30 graphs in them.
- 12:11One of them is net worth ratios and percentage of net worth ratios.
- 12:16Capital-wise, 98.5%
- 12:20of our credit unions are above 7%, and there's not a lot of
- 12:25credit unions subject to PCA.
- 12:2864 of them in the whole country is all, out of 4250.
- 12:33So capital-wise, the industry looks really good, and there's not a lot
- 12:39of credit unions out there subject to net worth restoration plans or
- 12:42pro- corrective action at the moment.
- 12:45Treichel: That's
- 12:45Miller: a good thing.
- 12:45I think there was probably a time when I was a director of special actions, we
- 12:48had more than that just in our region.
- 12:50Treichel: Yeah.
- 12:51No, I think you're right.
- 12:52I think you're right.
- 12:54Steve, any thoughts on capital?
- 12:56Farrar: N- not really.
- 12:57It's ⦠We- we're, st- staying pretty steady on that, and real
- 13:02comparable to what in capital in the communi- with the community banks,
- 13:06I think, it is interesting when you talk about, those 64 in PCAs.
- 13:11'Cause as the industry, the numbers look really good and solid
- 13:14and repeating itself th- this, between one quarter and the next.
- 13:18But we do know that there are those individual institutions
- 13:21that are they're facing problems.
- 13:23I don't think it's any one thing.
- 13:25I think, it's just something inside of, what their kind of
- 13:29core business ended up being as deteriorated or something like that.
- 13:33Some of them could've been where they tried something new and are having
- 13:36negative results and working through it.
- 13:39But I don't see any common trend in why the credit unions end up into
- 13:46a kind of a, the PCA situation.
- 13:49Usually it's loan losses, right?
- 13:51Treichel: Yep.
- 13:51Farrar: That's, that usually what it comes down to.
- 13:53It c- could always be, for a couple or few, big frauds, which
- 13:57we know occurred and are affe- affected the industry recently.
- 14:01But I c- you know, can't find ⦠Here's the one thing it always comes down to.
- 14:05Are granting decent loans, and can you stay out of trouble?
- 14:08You see the ones that end up with poor liquidity, and when they try to
- 14:13cover that, sometimes they make bad decisions trying to fix liquidity
- 14:17that, that affects their profitability.
- 14:19So it's those well-thought-out plans are still super important.
- 14:25Treichel: S- Todd, w- Steve brought up liquidity.
- 14:28Any thought with your 10 years as a capital market specialist and
- 14:32another 10 years supervising capital market specialist, any thoughts on
- 14:36what you saw on the liquidity front?
- 14:38Miller: If there was incremental improvements.
- 14:41Borrowed money is paid down a little bit across the industry.
- 14:44Non-member deposits are down.
- 14:46You see a lot of credit unions offering money market accounts to capture
- 14:51some of that certificate money.
- 14:53I think people are uncertain, so you see a little bit more money going into
- 14:57money markets as opposed to certificates.
- 15:00Given the inflation and everything else, I'm actually surprised that the credit
- 15:04unions could grow as much as they did.
- 15:06Share growth was 10% this quarter.
- 15:08That was a healthy share growth number.
- 15:11And loans, of course, grew a lot slower.
- 15:14They only grew at 4%, so you had-- Actually, 1%.
- 15:20So when you got 10% share growth and 1% loan growth, liquidity tends to improve.
- 15:25Credit union didn't invest long.
- 15:27There is a nice spread between short-term rates and what
- 15:31they're paying on cost of funds.
- 15:33Cost of funds has dropped a little bit this quarter.
- 15:36Credit unions are still improving their net interest margin.
- 15:39So liquidity just improved.
- 15:41Not by a lot, but it was incrementally improved across the industry.
- 15:45It should cause NCUA to take their eyes off of that and
- 15:50focus on a few other things.
- 15:52So I expect that will continue to probably improve
- 15:57Treichel: That all sounds good.
- 15:59Before we started I've got this little tool I've built where I can analyze some
- 16:03of the 5300 data, and I asked a coupleâ¦
- 16:06I dug into the delinquency side of things.
- 16:10I'm gonna, I'm gonna read off a couple of stats I've got here and see what what
- 16:14it triggers for you guys, if anything.
- 16:15The key takeaways that my questions drove for March was that
- 16:20total delinquency dropped 19.7%
- 16:25quarter over quarter from 13 to 10 and a half billion.
- 16:30And the overall delinquency rate fell from 65 and a half basis points to 60.5
- 16:37basis points, which is the first meaningful decline since at least 2022.
- 16:42But that hasn't been uniform.
- 16:46Con- consumer and residential got better.
- 16:48Used vehicle delinquency dropped 27%, the single largest decline in dollar terms.
- 16:54Firstly, in residential, real estate dropped 34%, biggest absolute drop,
- 16:59though this category is volatile and may reflect seasonal cure patterns in Q1.
- 17:05New vehicle delinquency was down 26%, credit cards down 13%, which
- 17:10conflicts with some things that we heard in a call the other day.
- 17:14Other sur- sec- unsecured loans down 10%.
- 17:16So all of those categories collectively were down tw- 2.6
- 17:21billion.
- 17:22What's going the other way, the one category I didn't
- 17:24mention yet is commercial.
- 17:26CRE construction and development up 42%, the steepest percentage
- 17:31increase in any category.
- 17:33CRE non-owner-occupied up 7.4%
- 17:38continues a relentless climb from 86 in 2022 to 861 million now.
- 17:46CRE multifamily up 3.2%,
- 17:49been rising for four straight years.
- 17:52Ag production agricultural loans, 13%.
- 17:55It's a small number, but that number's up.
- 17:58Commercial non-accruals rose over 2 billion, up 5%, even
- 18:03though delinquency in total fell.
- 18:05The composition shift tells the real story.
- 18:07Commercial real estate share of total delinquency jumped from
- 18:1011 to, 11 and a half to 15.1%
- 18:15in one quarter.
- 18:17The residential real estate is now went from 50% to 44, and consumer held steady
- 18:22at about 33%, which would not have gone down, because of the growth, right?
- 18:27So if the denominator's changing, that's where you would make up that number.
- 18:31Follow-up question I asked tied to that circled back to CRE
- 18:35construction and development.
- 18:372022 was at 26 million.
- 18:39Next year, 45 million.
- 18:40Next year, 2024, 112 million.
- 18:442025, 121 million.
- 18:46March, 171 million.
- 18:48So the commercial stuff i- is not going in the right direction, which
- 18:52is, when I think back over the years, there's the office buildings
- 18:56causing issues, but it's crept into almost every type of commercial.
- 19:00A- any of those numbers I threw out there attract your attention make,
- 19:04and make you come to any conclusions?
- 19:07Farrar: Didn't surprise me at all.
- 19:09The, the credit card one is interesting because, like
- 19:11you said, we keep hearing it.
- 19:13Credit card is pretty-- is is up pretty good in the community banks.
- 19:17Treichel: Yeah.
- 19:18Yeah.
- 19:19Yeah and Todd and I heard that in a call the other day that it-- that it's up
- 19:21and it's, We haven't seen credit cards up in our conversations with clients
- 19:25generally, but we-- I've heard that stat.
- 19:26Todd?
- 19:27Miller: Outside of the commercial loans, if you go back one year, you're seeing
- 19:33steady increases in delinquency in the second, third, fourth quarters of 2025.
- 19:40And we ended up March of 2026 just about exactly where we were in March of 2025.
- 19:48So over the year, we had some increases, and then it dropped down- Yeah.
- 19:53So back to- ⦠every category except the commercial.
- 19:55The commercial loans, it's interesting.
- 19:57Like I read, delinquents or unemployment numbers are vary widely over the
- 20:02course of the country from 2.2
- 20:04to as high as 6.2.
- 20:07Commercial loans and real estate loans in general are the only loan
- 20:11categories that have consistently been growing over the last decade.
- 20:17So credit unions, we have more and more credit unions getting
- 20:19into commercial lending.
- 20:21They're expanding those portfolios.
- 20:24And there's always a price to pay for experience.
- 20:28You tend to make a few mistakes along the way.
- 20:31So some of this commercial lending delinquency, I suspect it's people
- 20:37gaining some experience in how they're underwriting and servicing those loans.
- 20:42And then the other piece of it, like I said, when you've got these variables
- 20:46unemployment that are so high.
- 20:48And if you look at past recessions too, and commercial loan problems that we
- 20:52had during our 30 years of career, they always tend to be geographically isolated.
- 20:57Sure.
- 20:58So it makes you wonder if all that rise in commercial delinquency isn't
- 21:04happening maybe in three or four states.
- 21:06Not necessarily uniform across the country.
- 21:10The interesting thing is that you can do custom queries at NCUA and
- 21:14get raw numbers, but you can't do custom queries and get percentages.
- 21:19It'd be nice to actually go get individual credit union commercial loan delinquency
- 21:24percentages and see where they're at.
- 21:26I didn't take the time to calculate it.
- 21:28You can get loans and assets and figure that piece out backwards at
- 21:32an individual credit union level.
- 21:35But I think it's gonna be what Steve said just about troubled
- 21:39credit unions in general, that there's no one reason driving it.
- 21:43Treichel: Sure.
- 21:44Yeah.
- 21:45Miller: There are markets where housing prices and commercial real estate
- 21:49values are still high, and there's other places where they're falling.
- 21:52And, So it'll be interesting to see how that one plays out over time.
- 21:59Treichel: Yeah and is it states, specific states and maybe a few ⦠And
- 22:02I didn't, I didn't dig into the numbers.
- 22:04Are there big credit unions that have big portfolios that are driving those numbers?
- 22:07Steve, sorry I interrupted you there.
- 22:10Farrar: That regional differences is really evident
- 22:13in the community bank numbers.
- 22:14They're, when you look at their, they break it down with New
- 22:17York, Atlanta, Chicago, Kansas City, Dallas, San Francisco.
- 22:21When you look at multifamily it's just it's twice as high if, for the New York
- 22:27West, East Coast region area there.
- 22:30Their commercial loans are also big differences there in certain- the New
- 22:35York district and Atlanta, really high.
- 22:38San Francisco's super high on that one.
- 22:42And the interesting one is credit cards varies incredibly wide.
- 22:46It you get for instance, the Atlanta one is only 2%.
- 22:51Kansas City, 13.75%.
- 22:55So there's these the, that's a huge aberration that you just wouldn't expect.
- 22:59So I think there is, as you, we talked about, different re-
- 23:03regions are feeling the impact.
- 23:05And the San Francisco one also has really high credit card delinquency,
- 23:09Miller: that's not surprising with all the tech layoffs.
- 23:13Farrar: Yeah, good point.
- 23:14Treichel: But what in the world's going on in Kansas City?
- 23:17Miller: I wonder if some of that isn't just because they have a lot of those
- 23:21credit card banks chartered, like in South Dakota who also- I was thinking the same
- 23:26Treichel: thing
- 23:27Miller: on South Dakota, yeah ⦠which is probably in the Kansas City region.
- 23:29That's just pure speculation on my part.
- 23:31Farrar: That, that would explain that, because it's just, it's so
- 23:34huge, it's gotta be something odd
- 23:39Treichel: So as you a- as we were talking there I pulled up, let's
- 23:44see, what states the state data.
- 23:47Interesting.
- 23:48Kansas c- Kansas it says is the biggest red flag.
- 23:51Commercial delinquency went up from 1.2
- 23:54to 59.4
- 23:55in one quarter.
- 23:57So as I say that I go, gosh, someone could probably go look and see
- 24:01which credit union that was at.
- 24:03That, that's a little precise.
- 24:04Washington State more than doubled.
- 24:08Virginia up from 62 million to 100 million.
- 24:13Florida also went up substantially.
- 24:17And New Hampshire, which doesn't have a lot went from zero to having some, so
- 24:21that number looks statistically large.
- 24:23Farrar: Yeah.
- 24:23Yeah.
- 24:24Treichel: So yeah, so interesting stuff.
- 24:25Any other thoughts on delinquency, asset quality, investments?
- 24:31Farrar: No.
- 24:31As a whole, we'd say asset quality,
- 24:34Treichel: Is holding
- 24:35⦠Farrar: is pretty good.
- 24:36Treichel: Yeah.
- 24:36Farrar: Yeah.
- 24:37We're not that worried about it.
- 24:40Treichel: Very good.
- 24:42All right, so we talked capital, we talked asset quality.
- 24:46We talked earnings from a pers- a perspective of the bottom line.
- 24:51We talked earnings from the perspective provision for loan loss.
- 24:54Yes.
- 24:55Farrar: Yeah.
- 24:55Anyhow, on earnings, Todd, do you have anything to say on, you and I are
- 24:59always so focused on operating expenses.
- 25:01We can't not talk about operating expenses and what you think is going on there.
- 25:06Miller: Aside from the operating expenses, credit unions they're still
- 25:10catching up on improving the yields on their loan portfolio and cost
- 25:14of funds are coming the other way.
- 25:16One of the things that NCUA does in their chart pack is they have a
- 25:2010-year history of yield on loans, yield on investments, cost of funds.
- 25:25Loan spread at 4.4%
- 25:27over cost of funds is the highest it's been in 10 years.
- 25:30So it's taken credit unions a while to catch up.
- 25:33They got behind during the inflation years in 2022 and stuff, where loan spreads were
- 25:38almost the narrowest they've ever been.
- 25:41Now they've generated them back up to the highest they've ever been.
- 25:44Positive for the credit unions.
- 25:46It looks like they're doing a better job of pricing things and that's probably
- 25:50a piece of why earnings went up.
- 25:55Just an interesting observation that, those yields are better
- 26:01than they've ever been.
- 26:02And, credit unions historically are not necessarily good about watching
- 26:06their marginal yields and marginal cost of funds, but as an industry, they
- 26:10seem to be doing better about it here.
- 26:12Some of this is just catching up from the inflation.
- 26:14The rates went up really quick.
- 26:18Treichel: All great points
- 26:21So any anything we've missed here, guys?
- 26:23Any stats we typically talk about that we want to, or are we ready to give a
- 26:29final wrap on- Well- ⦠on the quarter?
- 26:31Go
- 26:31Miller: ahead,
- 26:31Treichel: Todd
- 26:32⦠Miller: Steve mentioned expenses.
- 26:34They're always an important piece of things.
- 26:37The number or the ratio of operating expenses to average
- 26:42assets stayed roughly the same.
- 26:44But when you dig into the expenses employee compensation and benefits
- 26:49went up 5% in the first quarter.
- 26:52And some of that might be bonuses paid from last year's results, but-
- 26:56Treichel: Sure
- 26:56⦠Miller: that was a, a, a pretty big jump and well ahead of inflation.
- 27:02Treichel: Interesting.
- 27:04Farrar: Yeah.
- 27:04And credit unions as the, compared to the community banks continue to run
- 27:10substantially har- higher expenses.
- 27:14Not substantially higher.
- 27:15The community banks came at it to basically 2.6%,
- 27:18and credit unions are 3.1,
- 27:21so-
- 27:22Treichel: 50 basis points ⦠that,
- 27:23Farrar: that's been there for a while.
- 27:24Treichel: Yeah.
- 27:25Yeah.
- 27:25Yep
- 27:28Very good.
- 27:29All right, guys.
- 27:30Good news is good news, right?
- 27:32So the numbers didn't get got generally a little bit better, I would say,
- 27:37from the discussion we just had.
- 27:38Next week NCUA's gonna be revealing the CAMEL codes.
- 27:41We recorded another podcast that I haven't launched yet, which is about
- 27:45the changes in the CAMEL letter.
- 27:47But I'm guessing with the data getting a little better that we
- 27:51should see CAMEL ratings getting a little bit better next week as well.
- 27:55So I'll be curious.
- 27:57Miller: Finally executive at NCUA who just went through a 25% cut in staff,
- 28:04I'm pretty happy that the credit industry's performance is doing well,
- 28:08'cause it buys them some time to adjust.
- 28:12Treichel: To their new normal.
- 28:13I agree.
- 28:14Yep, and they've got a new board member coming in who's gonna wanna
- 28:17move, make it his place, so they're gonna have some more new challenges.
- 28:20Probably have a couple other retirements coming that of people who don't
- 28:24wanna break in new board members, but we'll have to see how that plays out.
- 28:29Very good, guys.
- 28:30Steve, are you going back out on the boat, or are you done for the day?
- 28:33Farrar: We'll probably go back out this evening, yes.
- 28:35Yeah.
- 28:36Try and catch something worth keeping here.
- 28:37That's the goal now.
- 28:40Miller: And I told my wife I'd come help her weed the garden
- 28:42when this podcast was over.
- 28:44Treichel: Todd, you gotta go tell her that you need to go get an external camera
- 28:47before you can weed the garden Maybe not.
- 28:51Maybe not.
- 28:53Miller: Best Buy is not very far from my house.
- 28:56Treichel: Over the weekend you could get that.
- 28:57So very good, guys.
- 28:58All right, as always, it's fun.
- 29:00We'll be chatting with you I'm sure sometime next week
- 29:03on some of our client calls.
- 29:05Guys, thanks for participating, and listeners and watchers, as always I wanna
- 29:09thank you for listening or watching, and hope you'll do the same again soon.
- 29:14This is Mark Trakel signing off with flying colors.