Latest / Bloomberg Law / Justices Struggle With International Child Custody
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: Welcome to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. I'm June Grosso. Every
- 0:07Speaker 1: day we bring you insight and analysis into the most
- 0:09Speaker 1: important legal news of the day. You can find more
- 0:12Speaker 1: episodes of the Bloomberg Law Podcast on Apple Podcasts, SoundCloud,
- 0:16Speaker 1: and on Bloomberg dot com slash podcasts. It's rare the
- 0:20Speaker 1: Supreme Court. Here's child custody disputes, and the Justice is
- 0:24Speaker 1: struggled with the issue at the heart of an international
- 0:26Speaker 1: custody battle. The residence of a child is key in
- 0:30Speaker 1: determining what countries law governs custody under the Hague Convention.
- 0:34Speaker 1: So how should courts determine the habitual residence of a
- 0:36Speaker 1: child in the middle of a custody battle. Here are
- 0:39Speaker 1: Justices Stephen Bryer and Samuel Alito and Chief Justice John
- 0:43Speaker 1: Roberts questioning the standard during oral arguments, and as soon
- 0:47Speaker 1: as nine people who know free speaking for myself, know
- 0:51Speaker 1: very little about this start laying down black letters standards.
- 0:56Speaker 1: All we're gonna do is maybe help people in some
- 0:58Speaker 1: cases and just cause chaos and hardship in others. So
- 1:03Speaker 1: either parent at that time could snatch her and possession
- 1:07Speaker 1: would be ten tenths of the law right, it should
- 1:11Speaker 1: have a meaningless concept where the child usually lives. If
- 1:14Speaker 1: you're talking about somebody's eight weeks old, again, it's not
- 1:18Speaker 1: as if they've laid down roots. That's year. Eight week
- 1:21Speaker 1: old infants don't have habits. Well other than one or
- 1:25Speaker 1: two joining me is Steve Sanders, a professor at Indiana
- 1:29Speaker 1: University's Moral School of Law. Steve some complicated international law
- 1:34Speaker 1: issues here. Tell us about the key issue. Well, the
- 1:37Speaker 1: United States is a signatory to something called the Hate
- 1:40Speaker 1: Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction. And
- 1:45Speaker 1: the Hate Convention requires that when a child is wrongfully
- 1:50Speaker 1: removed from a particular country, a court has to determine
- 1:54Speaker 1: what is the child's quote unquote habitual country of residents,
- 1:59Speaker 1: so that at country's courts can make the child custody determination. So,
- 2:04Speaker 1: in this case, because a treaty that the United States
- 2:07Speaker 1: has signed becomes part of federal law, the U. S.
- 2:11Speaker 1: Courts now that ultimately the Supreme Court need to decide
- 2:15Speaker 1: what does it mean to determine the habitual residence of
- 2:18Speaker 1: a child when that child is an infant and they
- 2:21Speaker 1: have been removed from their country of birth. So the
- 2:24Speaker 1: standard that U. S. Courts use when there's child custody
- 2:28Speaker 1: is best interests of the child. Normally, that doesn't apply
- 2:31Speaker 1: at all in these international cases. No, it doesn't, because actually,
- 2:36Speaker 1: even in US domestic law there is a parallel principle.
- 2:40Speaker 1: The best interest of the child standard is used when
- 2:43Speaker 1: basically you have two different parents who are fit and
- 2:46Speaker 1: accord needs to decide between the two of them. But
- 2:49Speaker 1: there is also law in the United States that is
- 2:52Speaker 1: intended to discourage a parent from essentially kidnapping the child
- 2:56Speaker 1: and taking them to another state when they get a
- 2:59Speaker 1: child custody determination that they don't like, and the Hate
- 3:03Speaker 1: Convention essentially mirrors that principle on the international level. It's
- 3:08Speaker 1: intended to attack the potential problem of a parent abducting
- 3:12Speaker 1: their own child and taking that child to a different
- 3:15Speaker 1: country because back in the first country a child custody
- 3:20Speaker 1: determination went against the parent, and so they want to
- 3:22Speaker 1: try their hand at getting a different jurisdiction to render
- 3:26Speaker 1: a different child custody determination. Before we get to the
- 3:29Speaker 1: Supreme Court, arguments, tell us what happened below with the
- 3:33Speaker 1: district court and the circuit court levels. Sure, well, this
- 3:37Speaker 1: case involves a couple of U. S citizen Michellemneski and
- 3:41Speaker 1: an Italian citizen, Domenico Taglieri. They were married in the
- 3:45Speaker 1: United States and then moved to Italy and had a child.
- 3:48Speaker 1: In Italy, Michelle claims that Domenico was abusive and that
- 3:53Speaker 1: she was fleeing domestic violence, and she ultimately returned to
- 3:57Speaker 1: the United States with the child. Domenico's attorneys filed a
- 4:02Speaker 1: case in federal court, saying that the child had been
- 4:05Speaker 1: wrongfully removed from Italy, that Italy should be considered the
- 4:08Speaker 1: child's quote unquote habitual residence. The United States courts, a
- 4:13Speaker 1: federal district court and then the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals,
- 4:17Speaker 1: which covers Ohio, which is where Michelle is both ruled
- 4:21Speaker 1: that in this case the child had to be returned
- 4:23Speaker 1: to Italy under the Hade convention that Italy had been
- 4:27Speaker 1: the child's habitual residence. So what was the mother's argument
- 4:31Speaker 1: of the Supreme Court? So first, I think no one
- 4:34Speaker 1: disputes the principle that in general, once again, you don't
- 4:38Speaker 1: want to incentivize parents who get an unfavorable custody determination
- 4:43Speaker 1: to abduct their own child and take them to another jurisdiction.
- 4:47Speaker 1: But in this case, the mother is saying, this is
- 4:49Speaker 1: a different situation. I was fleeing domestic violence. The child
- 4:54Speaker 1: is potentially at risk in Italy, and so that standard
- 4:59Speaker 1: of what is a bitual residence of the child needs
- 5:02Speaker 1: to make some accommodation, needs to recognize the possibility that
- 5:06Speaker 1: even if, in this case, say Italy was the child's
- 5:09Speaker 1: appropriate residence, there may be cases when the child for
- 5:13Speaker 1: its own safety needs to be taken elsewhere. Although her
- 5:16Speaker 1: attorneys are also saying that because the child was only
- 5:20Speaker 1: eight weeks old and because the parents had not come
- 5:24Speaker 1: to some kind of agreement about where the child would
- 5:27Speaker 1: be raised in this situation, the mother's attorneys argue the
- 5:31Speaker 1: child essentially could not be said to have even had
- 5:34Speaker 1: a habitual country of residents, and so there was nothing
- 5:37Speaker 1: wrong with the child being taken to the United States.
- 5:40Speaker 1: So what were the concerns of the justices? I think
- 5:45Speaker 1: that the justices are searching for a clear standard, They're
- 5:48Speaker 1: searching for a rule. This isn't a case where there
- 5:51Speaker 1: was a circuit split that the court had to resolve,
- 5:54Speaker 1: but it's an important question of federal law, and an
- 5:56Speaker 1: international treaty is involved, and you can imagine him that
- 6:00Speaker 1: in this very mobile age. This is going to come
- 6:03Speaker 1: up when children and parents cross international boundaries, and so
- 6:08Speaker 1: I think the Court was primarily concerned to have some
- 6:12Speaker 1: sort of role that it can apply, that lower courts
- 6:16Speaker 1: can apply in these sorts of situations, so that it
- 6:19Speaker 1: doesn't just become a determination of which parent presents the
- 6:23Speaker 1: more sympathetic case. I think commentators who watched the oral
- 6:28Speaker 1: arguments in this case believe the court maybe leaning towards
- 6:32Speaker 1: the father's side. That is the argument that the child
- 6:35Speaker 1: needs to be in Italy, that that is where the
- 6:38Speaker 1: courts should make a child custody determination. But it's not
- 6:42Speaker 1: necessarily completely clear from the oral arguments how the court
- 6:46Speaker 1: may rule in this case. So Justice Samuel Alito seems
- 6:50Speaker 1: skeptical of the mother's arguments. He said, under that position,
- 6:55Speaker 1: either parent could snatch her possession would be tense of
- 6:59Speaker 1: the law. Well, exactly. Again, I think that just simply
- 7:02Speaker 1: gets back to the principle that the whole point of
- 7:05Speaker 1: this Hague Convention, just as the point of federal law
- 7:08Speaker 1: that governs this kind of situation among states in the
- 7:11Speaker 1: United States, is that we don't want parents engaging and kidnapping.
- 7:14Speaker 1: We don't want a parent to be able to say,
- 7:16Speaker 1: because I now have physical control of the child, that
- 7:21Speaker 1: child's custody should be determined by whatever state or whatever
- 7:25Speaker 1: country I end up in. There is supposed to be
- 7:28Speaker 1: a standard for determining which country that is in order
- 7:32Speaker 1: to deter this kind of child snatching, which is what
- 7:35Speaker 1: the father says was involved. It seemed that Justice Ruth
- 7:39Speaker 1: Bader Ginsburg was concerned about the mother's allegations of abuse.
- 7:45Speaker 1: Were any of the other justices. Well, the Hague Convention
- 7:48Speaker 1: actually does have essentially a provision, or you might think
- 7:52Speaker 1: of it as a loophole that says, um, you know,
- 7:55Speaker 1: this habitual country of residence standard may not necessarily apply
- 8:00Speaker 1: in a situation where proof has been presented that the
- 8:03Speaker 1: child would be in a potentially dangerous situation. The lower
- 8:07Speaker 1: federal courts in this case actually found that the mother
- 8:10Speaker 1: had not met her burden to invoke that particular exit
- 8:14Speaker 1: or that particular loophole from the Hague Convention. The mother
- 8:18Speaker 1: has said that she was the victim of domestic abuse,
- 8:22Speaker 1: but the lower court said she had not met her
- 8:24Speaker 1: burden to show that the child would be in danger.
- 8:27Speaker 1: In fact, the child has been in Italy during the
- 8:30Speaker 1: pendency of this litigation for some four years now, because
- 8:34Speaker 1: the lower federal court decisions required the child to be
- 8:37Speaker 1: returned to Italy pending the outcome of this litigation, and
- 8:40Speaker 1: there was nothing presented at the oral argument that indicated
- 8:43Speaker 1: that during this time that the child has lived with
- 8:46Speaker 1: its father, that the child has been abused or endangered.
- 8:51Speaker 1: Did Justice Elena Kagan come up with a theory that
- 8:54Speaker 1: had been used by the Six Circuit. But Justice Kagan
- 8:57Speaker 1: basically said that courts would normally presume that a baby's
- 9:01Speaker 1: habitual residence would be the country in which she has lived,
- 9:05Speaker 1: in which case that would be Italy. The mother's attorneys
- 9:09Speaker 1: pushed back on that idea, I think, because again they thought,
- 9:12Speaker 1: that doesn't leave room for the possibility that there may
- 9:16Speaker 1: be reasons why the parents didn't intend to raise the
- 9:20Speaker 1: child in that country, or extenuating circumstances that would require
- 9:24Speaker 1: the child to be removed from that country. Accord in
- 9:27Speaker 1: some senses looking for a rule that makes sense and
- 9:31Speaker 1: can be administered by lower courts, but yet is not
- 9:35Speaker 1: a rule that is not insensitive to the particular circumstances
- 9:39Speaker 1: of particular cases. So can there be some kind of
- 9:44Speaker 1: a midway position? For the court or are they going
- 9:47Speaker 1: to have to, you know, just come down with a
- 9:50Speaker 1: rule and leave it at that. I mean, is there
- 9:53Speaker 1: any kind of gray area here where they could rule
- 9:58Speaker 1: in this case but not make a blank at rule.
- 10:02Speaker 1: One thing the court could do is to send is
- 10:04Speaker 1: to remand the case back to the federal courts in
- 10:07Speaker 1: Ohio and tell them to apply a different standard. Um. Uh.
- 10:13Speaker 1: The mother's attorneys are arguing that these sorts of determinations
- 10:18Speaker 1: should be reviewed by by appellate courts donovo, rather than
- 10:21Speaker 1: giving deference to the district courts factual determinations. Um. The
- 10:26Speaker 1: Court will probably reject that idea, because where a child's
- 10:30Speaker 1: country of habitual residence is really is a fact question?
- 10:34Speaker 1: Is a factual determination? Um? The Court often surprises us,
- 10:39Speaker 1: but I think the Court probably would not have taken
- 10:42Speaker 1: this case if it didn't feel an obligation to provide
- 10:45Speaker 1: some clarity, some administrable rule for lower courts to follow
- 10:50Speaker 1: going forward in cases like this. Finally, does this come
- 10:55Speaker 1: up often because you have a Supreme Court taking this case?
- 10:59Speaker 1: Is this an issue that comes up often international child
- 11:01Speaker 1: custody disputes? Well, again, you know, if if you look
- 11:05Speaker 1: around the web, there are law firms that specialize in
- 11:08Speaker 1: helping parents with these sorts of situations. I don't know
- 11:11Speaker 1: that um, there are any statistics about how often this
- 11:14Speaker 1: kind of thing happens. But once again, this case involved
- 11:17Speaker 1: a US citizen marrying an Italian citizen, and they get
- 11:21Speaker 1: married here, then they moved to Italy. You can imagine
- 11:24Speaker 1: in the world today that is not an uncommon situation
- 11:27Speaker 1: that parents, because of career interests and educational interests and
- 11:31Speaker 1: family interests, move around not just from state to state,
- 11:35Speaker 1: but from country to country. And so UM, just as
- 11:38Speaker 1: there are plenty of child custody interstate battles in the
- 11:42Speaker 1: United States, you know, one can imagine that's not unusual
- 11:45Speaker 1: that this kind of thing happens. And and again I
- 11:48Speaker 1: think the court a circuit split was not an issue here,
- 11:52Speaker 1: But that's not the only way to get the court's attention.
- 11:54Speaker 1: When there's a significant question of federal law that the
- 11:57Speaker 1: court believes is not just an unusual circumstance but may
- 12:01Speaker 1: come up again in the future often enough to require
- 12:06Speaker 1: a rule, then the court will take it. And so
- 12:08Speaker 1: I think we have to assume the court thinks that
- 12:10Speaker 1: this is something that UM is a live issue that
- 12:15Speaker 1: potentially uh courts in the United States will confront on
- 12:19Speaker 1: a regular basis. Thanks Steve. That's Steve Sanders, a professor
- 12:23Speaker 1: at Indiana University's Morris School of Law. Thanks for listening
- 12:29Speaker 1: to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can subscribe and listen
- 12:32Speaker 1: to the show on Apple Podcasts, SoundCloud, and on bloomberg
- 12:35Speaker 1: dot com slash podcast. I'm June Brasso. This is Bloomberg