Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️103 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 28nd Sep Water and the NIEA Day 2 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Coronalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments, and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. Hardly know where to start today. We were back into the water, specifically the discharge consent and the conditions NIEA says would have to be attached to it. And before the morning was very far advanced, Commissioner McParland asked a question which pretty much stopped the room. Is the
- 1:17application ready for inquiry? Then, so how did we get there? Northern Ireland Environmental Agency (NIEA) had previously produced draft numerical parameters, setting out what could be permitted in a discharge. Those figures appeared in its statement of case. They had therefore become
- 1:39part of the evidence, everyone was working from. This morning, mr. Byas appeared for NIEA, told the commission that the figures had been removed from the revised conditions. NIEA had found errors and inconsistencies in some of the inputs used in the modelling, and could no longer rely upon the resulting
- 2:02figures. MacParland immediately wanted to know what that meant in practical terms. Was NIEA saying that it couldn't now tell the commission what would actually be permitted in a discharge? There was a bit of discussion about approach and further calculations, but MacParlin kept coming back to
- 2:26the same fairly basic point: what does NIEA consider acceptable to discharge into these burns? Eventually, mr. Byass acknowledged that NIEA didn't have those parameters now and couldn't provide them in the context of this inquiry. Hence the question: Is the application ready for inquiry then? The
- 2:52commissioner MacParlin then raised another problem. There are representations before the inquiry arguing that the discharges could affect habitats, protected species, and designated sites. How was she supposed to consider those if she didn't know what the regulator itself regarded as an
- 3:14acceptable discharge? She described herself as being in an information vacuum, and those are the commissioner's words, not ours. NIEA's position was that the commission could consider the approach and make recommendations, with the actual numbers being calculated later, and that was really the issue
- 3:39that occupied the rest of the discussion. Can something this important be left until later? After an adjournment, MacParland wanted to know more about how the problem had arisen. What were the errors? Was it background water quality? Was it the flows, and Miss Smith from NIEA said there were
- 4:06inconsistencies across different parameters, and that the figures now needed further quality assurance. Then the commissioner asked what had prompted this latest check. Preparation for today's hearing was the answer, and you could probably see where the next question was going. Shouldn't this have been done
- 4:30before NIEA submitted its statement of case, or even before the matter was referred? Miss Smith said she'd checked the figures previously, but in her words, evidently not thoroughly enough. There isn't much I can add on to that. NIEA did make clear that the underlying water quality
- 4:57information exists. There is monitor. Data, including water framework directive monitoring, and Miss Smith said she believed the raw data needed to rerun the model was available. So the data itself hasn't vanished; it's the calculations upon it that now have to be revisited. Then mr. Honey spoke for the locks
- 5:22agency. He was considerably less troubled by the position. The locks agency hadn't relied upon NIEA's draft numerical parameters in the same way, and mr. Honey's view was that the final limits would need to take account of up-to-date baseline conditions when the consent was actually being determined, he
- 5:45remained broadly satisfied with NIEA's approach and believed appropriate conditions could ultimately be set to protect Atlantic salmon. The LOX agency will also expect to be involved in the later assessment and consenting process. So, in very simple terms, mr. Honey's position was that this could
- 6:07still be dealt with further down the road. mr. Fagan for FODC was not nearly so comfortable with that.
- 6:17His point was that NIEA is the regulator, and the body with the specialist expertise. It had already provided these figures, and framed its statement of case around them. Every one else had therefore come to the inquiry expecting those figures to be part of the evidence, and now they weren't. And mr. Fadigan
- 6:41made an important distinction. A later assessment or consultation isn't the same as a public inquiry. In a public inquiry, evidence can be examined, questions can be asked, and experts can be challenged, and third parties can respond to it if important information only appears after the inquiry, that
- 7:06particular opportunity is gone. He said that if there were an ordinary appeal, we would probably be in adjournment territory. By now, people around the room, were beginning to wonder how far the problem went. What exactly were the incorrect inputs? Were they the flow rates? Were they the background
- 7:31concentrations, or perhaps they were statistical parameters? And had any of them been used in other calculations? And one contributor summed it up quite neatly. We don't just have something unknown. We don't even know what is unknown. Nobody established today that the other modelling is wrong, but if you
- 7:59discover a problem with an input, it is perfectly reasonable to ask where else that input has been used. Then came submissions about the habitats regulations, the water framework directive, Atlantic salmon, freshwater permutel, and the receiving waters. The commissioner kept everyone
- 8:21fairly tightly focused on the procedural problem in front of her. What did NIEA's announcement mean for this inquiry? Meanwhile, the third parties had another practical difficulty. Revised conditions had only just been handed out. Linda Sullivan pointed out that people had less than half an
- 8:42hour to look at them, and weren't entirely clear what they were supposed to be commenting on, which was probably a fair description of the general mood by then. Doctor Stryker made the point that a public inquiry isn't there to facilitate an application through the system; its purpose is to scrutinise
- 9:01what is before it. The commissioner put it slightly differently, saying the statutory purpose was to consider the representations. Savers Sperrins described what had emerged as a significant lacuna in the information, in other words, a gap. Although a lacuna is undoubtedly what
- 9:22happens to a gap after it has been at a public inquiry for several weeks, our position was that the application was not ready for the inquiry. We also tried to raise what we see as a wider pattern of evidence and positions changing during the proceedings, and MacParlin stopped us there. She wanted the
- 9:44discussion confined to what NIEA had told her that morning. Fair enough, there was quite enough in that. Other third parties were considerably more forthright. Words such as staggering, incompetence, and beggar's belief were to be. Heard. The vocabulary was expanding rapidly, but behind
- 10:06the frustration were legitimate questions about how these problems had emerged so late. Were questions about previous discharge consents, monitoring the information supplied by the applicant, and what NIEA had relied upon in reaching its earlier position, and not all of these questions were answered
- 10:27today. Another third-party member asked, "What data would now be used? How old was it? Had it been used elsewhere? Had outputs from one model become inputs to another? And if NIEA didn't presently have a settled regulatory position, what exactly was the Commission supposed to assess? We then
- 10:54return to the question of whether the application had been ready to come to the public inquiry in the first place. There's nothing unusual about evidence being challenged at an inquiry. That's the point of having one. What is unusual is one of the principal public authorities arriving with
- 11:14figures in its statement of case, and then withdrawing them because problems have subsequently been found in the modelling inputs, and that is more or less where today left us. There were two positions in the room: one was that the regulatory approach remains sound, and the precise limits
- 11:34can be settled later, using updated information and further assessment; and the other was that if those limits are important to deciding whether the environmental effects are acceptable. Then they should be available now, while the evidence can still be examined publicly. And that's important
- 11:54for us third parties, having spent years reading documents, finding experts, learning the terminology, and trying to follow an extraordinary technical process.
- 12:06When the evidence changes, we have to understand the changes and its implications to be ready to respond. And today, it wasn't a third party pointing out the problem. NIEA brought it to the inquiry itself. It could no longer rely upon the discharge parameters it had previously supplied, because problems had
- 12:27been found in the modelling inputs. Its own witness acknowledged that the previous checking had evidently not been thorough enough, and Commissioner McParland asked the question, which I think will be remembered from today, is the application ready for inquiry? Then, and perhaps the fact that
- 12:46the commissioner had to ask that question at all tells us something about where we have arrived on this the 37th day of the public inquiry. NIEA is the environmental regulator. DFI is the department responsible for this planning process. These are public bodies with serious responsibilities, and with those
- 13:11responsibilities must surely come accountability. So, after what we heard today, there is another question to be asked: At what point do their actions in relation to the protection of our environment become socially unacceptable? You have been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from
- 13:36the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends,
- 13:55neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities, and don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the
- 14:16water, the air, and the people who protect them.