Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Beliefs, the Bible, & Brain Freeze: with Matt Dillahunty (and Kat)
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. There is video
- 0:57of this conversation. The you tube link is in the description box of the
- 1:02show. Matt Dillahunty recently for charity, took a drawing that I had done
- 1:11of my cat and I did it in eight seconds as a joke, and
- 1:15he had it tattooed onto his switch calf. Is it. It's on my
- 1:21left leg, on your left leg, okay, and oh look for those
- 1:25watching on YouTube, there is a picture of it. And I'm astounded and
- 1:30amused, horrified and more all at the same time. But I wanted to
- 1:34show you what I had done recently. Matt, I just figured maybe I
- 1:40should have a shirt made. I didn't want to just put it on because
- 1:46then I'd have to pop out of my chair. But I have now a
- 1:49T shirt complete with the signature at the bottom. So apparently the legacy of
- 1:53cat lives on. I don't know. Here he goes how much money ended
- 1:59up being raised for recovering from religion, I can't remember. Sixty eight thousand
- 2:05dollars, sixty eight thousand bucks and a wonderful organization for the three people who
- 2:14don't know who you are, Matt. I always like to start with my
- 2:17guest with an introduction. Who are you Hi? I'm at Dillahney and for
- 2:23the last nearly twenty years, I've been hosting live call in shows, having
- 2:28debates and discussions, disagreements, yelling, calmly, responding to name calling,
- 2:34being patient in all sorts of different ways, conversations about God. I'm also
- 2:40a magician, lecture gamer, and reptile breeder. But yeah, it's not
- 2:47I'm not important. I'm just doing important work. I think you're very good
- 2:53at what you do. When I see you on the debate platform, be
- 2:57it online or whether it's on stage, you guys get into some especially when
- 3:01you get into philosophy. I was talking to doctor Robert Sepalski earlier and we
- 3:06went well off into you know, free will, et cetera. And I
- 3:08found myself with imposter syndrome. Why am I hosting a show I don't deserve
- 3:15to be here. I'm I'm of limited cognitive abilities because I just can't process
- 3:20so much of this. But you know, you get into a lot of
- 3:22that, a lot of philosophy and counter apologetics. Is that just from doing
- 3:27it so long? It is? But it was it was one of the
- 3:30primary interests I mean that I kind of had. But when I realized,
- 3:36hey, I don't have good reason to be a Christian, my studies into
- 3:38the Bible because I was right, you know, I was a Southern Baptist.
- 3:40I was going to be a preacher. And when I realized I didn't
- 3:43have good reason to be a Christian, then it was okay, what kind
- 3:46of God might exist? Am I going to have to explore every other religion?
- 3:50And I joked that I started with Buddhism to find out if I would
- 3:53have multiple lifetimes to investigate this question, because I'll think you can do it
- 3:57in one. And then I realized that to kind of make the process efficient
- 4:02and useful, I needed to find out what kind of God might exist,
- 4:05and that required me to move out of studying independent religions and religious claims and
- 4:12dig more into philosophy and pistemology so that I can figure out what kind of
- 4:15God might exist and how we might go about proving it. And so that's
- 4:17that's how I got kind of deeper into philosophy. But I'm I'm a self
- 4:24taught deletant. I'd love to sit down with Sepolski someday and talk about this
- 4:29because we may or may not agree on aspects of free will, and it's
- 4:32kind of a fun discussion. I mean, the part that cooks my noodle
- 4:36is if it's all part of the you know, the processes, the machine
- 4:42of the brain. How do you put a rapist in prison for life?
- 4:46Right? I mean, that's if he didn't choose it. But it's all
- 4:49nature, nurture, chemistry. You know, the brain is doing what it's
- 4:54doing for a variety of reasons. I mean, I get the protections of
- 5:00society, but in terms of punishment, you know, how do you punish
- 5:03wrongdoing? I think Sepalski's take was punishment is perhaps an outdated concept. Not
- 5:10to get too deep right off the bat, Do you have thoughts on that,
- 5:13Yeah, that's what I was going to say. First of all,
- 5:15it may be the case that sort of punishment is is viable. I'm I'm
- 5:19not convinced. I think that looking for punishment it doesn't do anything. It
- 5:24doesn't bring anybody back, it doesn't do anything to rehabilitate anyone. And so
- 5:29I'm instead of looking for what's what's the justification for locking someone up? Perhaps
- 5:34it's more about protecting others from the likelihood that this person is going to do
- 5:39this sort of thing again. But when it comes down to how do we
- 5:43hold this person responsible if there is no free will, that's easy, and
- 5:48that is I have two cars in my driveway. If one of them breaks
- 5:53down, that's the one that I take to get fixed or take to the
- 5:56to the dump. It's not the other one. And so the car had
- 6:00no free will, no you know, agency with which to decide that it
- 6:03was going to decide to break down. Right now, whether we have free
- 6:08will or not, we don't have any choice but to deal with things at
- 6:11the level of the agent for now. We may eventually have a good enough
- 6:15understanding of the brain and how to repair things so that it's somebody like the
- 6:21ut shooter who begged to have his brain autopsy it after he was dead,
- 6:28and of course they find a big tumor pressing on his brain. If the
- 6:32tumor is the sort of thing that's likely to cause someone to become a violent,
- 6:36you know, mass murderer, and we can then operate and remove the
- 6:40tumor, what's left for that individual. Do we then still lock them up
- 6:46for the rest of their life because they are the agent who did it?
- 6:48Or do we recognize, ah, the thing that was actually causing this is
- 6:53gone, and as awful as it is that, you know, there's not
- 6:58going to be justice for the the families of the people who've died. Necessarily.
- 7:03The notion of merely locking people up as punishment may be so maybe outdated
- 7:11and useless, and instead it may be better to look at it as we
- 7:15should do this, what needs we need to do to protect other individuals.
- 7:17And then once somebody has you know, paid, their done their time,
- 7:25which may just mean having surgery so that you don't do it again. We're
- 7:28not there yet. There's a lot of difficult questions to answer. But I
- 7:31think we at a minimum have to say, if we're looking at imprisonment as
- 7:38a punishment, we need to rethink that even if we're right, even if
- 7:45prison as a punishment is the right thing to do, we need a better
- 7:47justification than this is what we've always done. And it may helps people maybe
- 7:53feel a little better about the difficulties in the situation. I think public safety
- 7:58is probably where I should and I also came out of that. And you're
- 8:03in Texas. I'm in Oklahoma. This is death penalty country, and it's
- 8:07a very emotional issue, right. I remember the comedian Ron White, who
- 8:11I actually think is pretty funny, but he had a joke that was talking
- 8:16about how Texas was going to ramp up executions. His line is, if
- 8:20you kill somebody in Texas, we will kill you back. And on the
- 8:24surface, I get it, Once you have taken a life, have you
- 8:28forfeited your own Emotionally, I understand that it's kind of a knee jerk.
- 8:33I'm not convinced that is about justice as much as perhaps vengeance. I've become
- 8:41very aware of the huge problems with the death penalty, how it is implemented,
- 8:48how it has been racially skewed, how subjective death penalty sentences have been
- 8:54meeted out, the people wrongly executed, the fact that it takes more money
- 9:00need to kill somebody on death row because of the mandatory appeals process, and
- 9:05to lock them up for the rest of their lives. And mostly I think
- 9:09the death penalty process should say more about us than it does about them.
- 9:13And I don't know if you agree or not. I tend to think and
- 9:18I understand people have been shattered and wounded, They're enraged. They think you
- 9:22have nothing left to contribute, your taking up, are you forfeit? We
- 9:26are now going to execute you. But I just don't think we have to
- 9:30kill people, even murderers, to protect society. And I'm not sure that
- 9:37that's a way to advance us in terms of justice. Your thoughts, Matt,
- 9:43Yeah, I My process on the death penalty went from okay, I'm
- 9:46a way back. When I was younger, I was a fundamentalist Christian.
- 9:50Of course, the death penalty eye for an eye, tooth for tooth,
- 9:52and blah blah blah. The Bible prescribes death for all kinds of things,
- 9:56and kill somebody for picking up sticks on this hapbath. Then I got to
- 10:01a spot where I was like, I don't think I'm necessarily opposed to the
- 10:07death guilty, but I have some objections and concerns about the way we're going
- 10:13about it, and problems in the system, the sort of things that you
- 10:15just mentioned. And then I got to a point where I was like,
- 10:18idealistically, I can see where someone might be deserving of death based on you
- 10:26know, what they did, and they're risk to everybody else in very limited
- 10:31circumstances. But I don't think our system, our legal system is sufficient to
- 10:39demonstrate guilt without coercion or any you know, deception, any number of problems.
- 10:46How many people sitting on death row have been exonerated because of a DNA
- 10:50test, And so I think there's a I got to the point where so
- 10:54there's a very small pool of people who are clearly guilty, we have mountains
- 11:00of evidence for it, and may or may not deserve that, And then
- 11:05I moved from that to yeah, I still understand that process, and yet
- 11:11I just still don't. I don't want to kill anybody. I'd rather look
- 11:16for rehabilitation. You wouldn't put Hitler in front of a firing squad of all
- 11:22people who deserve to be executed, right, I mean, that's usually where
- 11:26the conversation goes in my own circles. How do you respond, Oh,
- 11:31I might absolutely want to put Hitler in front of a firing squad, but
- 11:33that doesn't mean it's the right thing. And one of the things that I've
- 11:37kind of come to see is the sort of vigilante justice that we might all
- 11:43like under some circumstances, isn't justice. There's a reason why we don't just
- 11:48let the fathers of abused children do whatever they want with the victim once we're
- 11:54or with the perpetrator, once we know who's actually guilty. And so I
- 12:01think that there are plenty of options, including life imprisonment for somebody like Hitler,
- 12:07that I would much prefer over just killing them. If we know for
- 12:13a fact that this individual is beyond any help, any redemption, any rehabilitation,
- 12:22and they're just going to waste away in prison, then okay, I
- 12:24guess you could do a cost benefit analysis and try and find out which one's
- 12:28you know, the least costful or has the least impact on society. Yeah,
- 12:35I'm tracked. Language is fluid. You can just use whatever word you
- 12:39want. I'm going to make up words all day. I don't care.
- 12:41Natalie's her nickname is Stella, and that's a long story. But whenever,
- 12:48occasionally she'll throw something out that I'm like, I don't think that's a word,
- 12:50so we call it a stellar word. She'll throw it out and be
- 12:54like, I don't think that's a real word, but we just made it
- 12:56a word. It's now a stellar word. That's yeah. Well, she
- 13:01used to carry the Stella McCartney tennis bag, and so her team went to
- 13:05Nationals fifteen years ago and everybody on the team got a nickname, and so
- 13:09hers was Stella. I've got links in the description box, phone number,
- 13:13and web link if you have a comment question you want to be part of
- 13:18a discussion. I don't have a whole lot planned, which is usually how
- 13:22we roll when Matt comes on, because you don't need a whole lot of
- 13:26prep for a guy that's been doing this for twenty years and I've been at
- 13:30it for I've lost count I saw a tweet Christians are the number one cause
- 13:39of atheism today. It was a believer, one of these sort of progressive
- 13:46pastor types, and he was lamenting online that because Christians haven't been Christianing correctly
- 13:52the way christ would want them to christian that they are essentially pushing people out
- 13:58of the faith. If only the believers were practicing true Christianity, then everybody
- 14:05would be sort of reversing that stream and coming back to the fold. Do
- 14:09you have any thoughts on Christians not Christianing correctly according to progressives. I'd like
- 14:16to get a handful of them together so that they can decide what Christianing correctly
- 14:20is. I remember there, I was at one of the debates and there
- 14:24were four apologists standing around me, and they were all objecting to my characterization
- 14:31of the Bible's take on slavery, and all four of them had a different
- 14:35explanation for it, and I just looked at I literally looked at them and
- 14:39said, you guys, figure out what the right explanation is and nominate that
- 14:43person to come back and talk to me, because I don't need to be
- 14:46fighting four of you on four different fronts. If you guys can't get your
- 14:48stuff together, I'll just wait. You know, let me know. I
- 14:52never heard back from any of them, but on the on the you know,
- 14:56Christians making more atheists my debate or brain immediately put that into like three
- 15:01different buckets, where well, I was a Christian and I'm the reason I'm
- 15:05an atheist, So a Christian gets credit for turning me into an atheist.
- 15:11It just happens to be me. And I think for a lot of people,
- 15:15they find problems in the church. For sure, that causes them to
- 15:20perhaps question and begin a deconversion process. But people leave the faith for many
- 15:26reasons, and people change their minds or are convinced of things for different reasons.
- 15:31I'm more interested in what they think Christian incorrectly might be, then whether
- 15:37or not that ultimately ends up being what leads to atheism. And their primary
- 15:43reason for that is the whole case that this person's making seems to make the
- 15:48suggestion that there's a right way to Christian which would absolutely not result in people
- 15:54being atheists. And the problem with that is that as a skeptic an atheist
- 16:00because Christianity failed to meet its burden of proof, I never had a bad
- 16:03experience with anybody. I didn't get mad at God, I didn't pray for
- 16:07a pony and not get it. I didn't lose a loved one to a
- 16:10disease that God failed to heal nothing. All I wanted to do is be
- 16:14the best Christian I could be in order to convince atheists, and it turns
- 16:18out well that backfired spectacularly. So if somebody is a Bible literalist, I
- 16:23mean, if the Bible is the foundational book of the whole religion, and
- 16:29someone else says, well, I'm a Christian, I believe in Jesus,
- 16:32I loved God, but I don't hold it the Bible, don't know the
- 16:34Bible, don't care. Couldn't it be argued that the literalist was a more
- 16:41was more Christian? And I'm just throwing it out there. I guess what
- 16:45I'm asking is, has the progressive made up a new religion? Oh?
- 16:49Absolutely? See. Just yesterday there was someone who, or two days ago,
- 16:53there was someone who posted a picture of two Christian preachers and some gay
- 17:00Christian church somewhere, so they had their robes on and just rainbow everything all
- 17:04over, and they were like, I don't know if these people are true
- 17:08Christians are not, but I think the world will be better if they were.
- 17:11You know, the best representatives are the common representatives of Christianity, and
- 17:18I probably would agree that the world might be better off if you know,
- 17:22some not as bigoted branch within Christianity happened to be the dominant one. But
- 17:27I found a hoodie, a storm Trooper hoodie that was also covered in you
- 17:33know, rainbow stuff for pride, and I was like, is this a
- 17:34true storm Trooper outfit? And I've many times pointed out that Westboro Baptist Church
- 17:41is vile and disgusting, but they're not wrong when they say what the Bible
- 17:45says. They're accurately saying what the Bible says. They the fact that people
- 17:51find that distasteful or harsh is saying more about what the Bible says than Westboro
- 17:57Baptist Church and the progressive wing of Christians have. There are genuinely things that,
- 18:06you know, Oh, is annihilationism true? Are all the non believers
- 18:10just going to cease to exist? Or are they going to be tormented forever
- 18:12in hell? You can make a case for those things. And I watched
- 18:15one of my favorite debates was two Christians arguing about what must happen to be
- 18:22saved. They were discussing two different Christian doctrines. All those things are up
- 18:26for grabs, but if the notion is, hey, there's a right way
- 18:32to do this, I want to know how and why they figured that out
- 18:37and why they can't agree. I always think it's funny which version of the
- 18:40Bible KJV and IV New American New Revised, American Living Bible, the Message
- 18:47Bible. I remember being in youth group and they were trying to like appeal
- 18:51to us kids with a cool Bible that was written in teen language. And
- 18:56then there was a rift because some people said, well, you can't do
- 18:59that to God's work word. That's a false version of the scriptures. Is
- 19:03that a Bible that you just brought out in front of the screen. Look,
- 19:07it happens to be in a bright green some my green screens taking it
- 19:10out. I have loads of Bible, but this is the Extreme teen Bible.
- 19:18It is. It actually belonged to Beth. She didn't want it anymore.
- 19:22But I mean, it's a Bible, but it's all done up the
- 19:26extreme teen version. Now I have within reach the Extreme team, the n
- 19:30i V, my King James and some others. But primarily I use an
- 19:36electronic tool I talked about just the other night, which is e dash Sword
- 19:38dot net And now I have I don't know how many fifty Bible translations that
- 19:45are. Let me see if I can actually get this to pop up in
- 19:51a share screen. Yeah, so what we're seeing here is this is the
- 19:57King James version plus. And so if we just go to like you know,
- 20:02Genesis chapter three, verse six, and so, here's the whole thing.
- 20:07But what you see these are little hover over points so you can see
- 20:11the Hebrew word that's used for woman. Right there is not a shem.
- 20:14It'll give you the pronunciation. It'll show you different versions of it. You
- 20:18can click it. You can also search to find out there are seven hundred
- 20:22and eighty King James occurrences of this. And then over on the right hand
- 20:26side, I can look and you know, I've got a bunch of Bible
- 20:30commentaries, so like the Geneva Commentary on three six, or John Gills or
- 20:34Bible Illustrator, there's all kinds of other things. This is a great research
- 20:40tool. And down here at the bottom it's not just Strong's dictionary. There's
- 20:45the King James Concordance, which will show what the occurrences are. You can
- 20:48use this. It's an amazing tool and I'm sure it probably irritates the author
- 20:56how much time I spend using it. But I was trying to use it
- 21:00basically as a tool as it was meant to be, to make me a
- 21:03better preacher and get a better understanding of the Bible. And now it's being
- 21:08used to completely demolish people, as on yesterday's show, who show up and
- 21:14dishonestly misrepresent what the Bible actually says. I can check. So is that
- 21:18a website or a downloadable program? What was it called? And where do
- 21:22we find it? It's edssword. Dot net is where you can go to
- 21:26download it. It's just a Windows application and you can install a bunch of
- 21:30bibles. There are some you can pay for because some of the Bibles,
- 21:33like the NIV, are copyrighted, so you can't just get the NIV without
- 21:40paying for it. So I don't have the NIV there, which is why
- 21:41I keep on next to me on the desk. I read, or narrated
- 21:47rather my thirteenth audio book that I've participated in with doctor David Madison. He
- 21:52has a book called Guessing about God. I think it was in that book
- 21:55he was talking about the Red Letter Bible, and I grew up with this
- 21:59and for those who don't know what read letter Bible is. I had a
- 22:02pocket New Testament with my name engraved on it, which was a big deal
- 22:06because when you bought the Bible, you take it to the front of the
- 22:08store and then they would put your name on it, and there was something
- 22:11very special about it. But the red letter Bible had the alleged supposed there's
- 22:17one. I have two of them. This is the one that was given
- 22:19to me when I was a baby by the preacher. The idea is whatever
- 22:25Jesus said, any of his actual words are printed in red. And I
- 22:32remember, as a believer, I was like, oh, well, Jesus
- 22:33said those just because it was highlighted in that way. I thought, oh,
- 22:38well, of course Jesus said that. I never once stopped to question,
- 22:42well, wait a minute, how do I know he said it?
- 22:47Who decided he said it, who reported that he said it. The fact
- 22:49that it was there and it was in red was all I needed to be
- 22:52impressed. I'm a little bit embarrassed by that. I don't know, did
- 22:56you hold any credence, did you give any extra credence rather to the red
- 23:00letter Bible. Oh? Absolutely, I'm this one, This blue one This
- 23:06was basically given to me April nineteen sixty nine, so the month after I
- 23:10was born by brother Moody and so passed me the family. It's almost never
- 23:15been touched. It's literally still in the box that they presented it to me.
- 23:19It's not a red letter edition though, And since you're asking about,
- 23:22you know that, me and red letter Bibles, I'm actually working. I
- 23:26did the Sermon on the Mount I did a series of video going through the
- 23:30Sermon on the Mountain, pointing out the raious problems with it. But what
- 23:33I've decided I'm going to do is, except for the Sermon of the mount
- 23:36which you've already done, I'm going to go through everything that is red letter
- 23:41in the Bible and do a video series on there, just the words of
- 23:45Jesus to show because even some prominent atheists have said, you know, I
- 23:52still find I find the words of Jesus good and comforting. And you know,
- 23:57you know, we're we're not against everything in the Bible. And I'm
- 24:00like, well, you know, I'm not against everything in the Bible.
- 24:03But whether or not something was red letter, first of all, I have
- 24:07no reason to think that Jesus actually said it, But even if he did.
- 24:11Let me just assess those, because there's a lot of things in red
- 24:15letters that are problematic at best. The sermon on the Mount is and I
- 24:22already did videos on that kind of a high to me, A Life of
- 24:23Brian. You know, how did all of those thousands of people manage to
- 24:29hear the words that are coming out of Jesus's mouth? He had no form
- 24:33of amplification. So I always picture people on the not even in the periphery,
- 24:37but one hundred and you know, ten feet away from the you know,
- 24:41the focal point, going what what? Honey? What did he say?
- 24:45I didn't get it, you know, and everybody misinterpreting Life of Brian's
- 24:48a classic. I was taught it was blasphemous when I was when I was
- 24:52growing up, people were boycotting money Python's Life for Brian. The people who
- 24:57hadn't seen it were critique specific plot points. We saw some of this with
- 25:03Scorsese's Last Temptation of Christ. People were out front saying this is in the
- 25:07film and it's satanic, And I was like, well, have you seen
- 25:10the movie. No, no, we haven't actually seen the movie, but
- 25:12we know it's evil. You a Python fan, Matt I am, and
- 25:17not only did people you know protest who hadn't seen it, but actually I'm
- 25:22a huge fan of a number of different British comedy troops. Fry and Laurie
- 25:29did a bit where Laurie's basically in Drager playing a woman who's objecting to something,
- 25:37and then they finally get her to acknowledge that she hasn't seen it,
- 25:40she doesn't know anything about it, and it kind of harkens back to that
- 25:44Python and Life of Brian Objections more with Matt Dillahunty, we're going to get
- 25:49into platforming. We've got plenty of calls coming in with questions and comments,
- 25:56Lots to do next. You may not realize how much your support means.
- 26:08On Patreon, thank you so much for supporting me in this channel, my
- 26:12work, the podcast, the videos at Santa you can determine how much and
- 26:18for how long, and the website is patreon dot com. Slash Seth Andrews
- 26:26with my thanks. Continuing with Activist Debater, host of the Atheist Debates channel
- 26:33as well as occasional host on some of the shows on the Line YouTube channel,
- 26:38Matt Dilla hunting I was making the mistake of browsing Jordan Peterson's page.
- 26:48I don't know why I subject myself to that, but he was talking once
- 26:52again about those atheists. Now I can't pin Jordan Peterson the philosopher. How
- 27:00do I even introduce him because I don't think even his philosophilosopher. He calls
- 27:03himself one. I can't recall what his degree is in. Okay, I'm
- 27:07pope. He's a psychologist. He's a psychologist. He doesn't know crap about
- 27:12philosophy. And we proved that. One of the two of us sat down.
- 27:15You guys did do a debate, which is where I'm going. But
- 27:18he was talking about those atheists, and he said, to be an atheist
- 27:22is like doing an illegal chess move. You and I apparently are breaking the
- 27:29laws of space, time, physics, reality by saying we do not believe
- 27:33in a God. What do you think the best argument for atheism is.
- 27:40I don't think there is a good argument for atheism. I think it's based
- 27:42on a fundamental misunderstanding about the nature of the world. So it's just it's
- 27:48it's it's what would you say, it's an illegal chess move? Okay,
- 27:53it's based on the wrong. This might this might just show that I don't
- 28:00understand you. But we'll get to it if I do the best argument for
- 28:02athems, what's the best materialist? Materialistic determinism is the best argument for atheists.
- 28:07But isn't that a philosophical sort of assumption or axiom? Hell yeah,
- 28:11that's a problem. Like for me, I think it would be if this
- 28:15and let's just choose the Christian God, if he exists and wants me to
- 28:19know him and save me, wouldn't he make it easier? Why does he
- 28:23make it so difficult? What does he seem to hide? Because you have
- 28:26something to do? I don't think he suggests. If I had to guess,
- 28:30I wouldn't think that he's suggesting that you and I are violating the laws
- 28:33of space time. So much as he often seems to have this god concept
- 28:41that isn't about a literal being or a literle agent, but is about this
- 28:47strong metaphor that everybody appeals to. You know, you all have some god.
- 28:52Your God is your own intellect, your own mind. Your God is
- 28:56science, Your God is this and so bias pretending from his view that we
- 29:00don't have a god. Perhaps he's looking at that is you know that that's
- 29:04breaking the rules. I don't, you know, I don't have a god
- 29:08that I know of. I don't worship my mind or science or anything like
- 29:15that. So it's very difficult when somebody comes along and says, oh,
- 29:21you know, what you're doing is essentially like philosophically illegal. And yet he's
- 29:27the one who demonstrated he has no good understanding of the burden of proof of
- 29:33skepticism when we should actually believe something, and that he'll buy into any sort
- 29:41of pseudoscience clap trap that comes along. His daughter, who has no expertise
- 29:48in nutrition, convinced him and his wife to stop eating anything other than meat.
- 29:52And so when we went out for dinner before that event, they both
- 29:56ordered a steak cooked on a clean grill with no that's it. That was
- 30:03the only thing in to play, no vegetables, nothing else could be cooked
- 30:06with it. I think he allowed a little bit of salt. And you
- 30:11know, anybody that's taken any nutrition course will tell you that if that becomes
- 30:17your only food source, just meat, meat, meat, meat, meat,
- 30:21meat, meat, you're going to die sooner than you probably would have
- 30:23otherwise. And this is the same guy who tried to beat his addiction by
- 30:29going for an experimental treatment and ending up in a coma. It's it is
- 30:36bizarre to me that someone is rewarded for gullibility, for promoting gullibility, rewarded
- 30:45for an intellectual paucity and a misunderstand and inability to understand skepticism, to argue
- 30:52reasonably or honestly, and ends up, you know, making enough money to
- 30:59where any any threat that they were afraid of of potentially losing their job or
- 31:03anything else. It allows them to run around and keep spewing nonsense. I
- 31:07am every day, and not just with Jordan Peterson, stunned at the world
- 31:12that I find myself in, where there are flat earthers and anti vaxers,
- 31:17and where we may be electing Trump a second time, where we've, you
- 31:22know, we've taken a lot of steps backward on in justice. Forty nine
- 31:30percent of people think that the economy is on the decline when it's not.
- 31:37Forty nine percent of people thought that the unemployment was at a fifty year high,
- 31:44when it's at a fifty year low. I mean, how is it
- 31:47that, fully, you know, we're almost exactly evenly divided on any number
- 31:51of political subjects. How is it that half the people sincerely believe something which
- 31:56is demonstrably false, and not just believe that, but believe the opposite.
- 32:04We're at a fifty year low for unemployment rate, and near forty nine percent
- 32:07of people pulled I think we're at a fifty year high for unemployment rate.
- 32:12I don't understand how we can continue to function like that. There are people
- 32:16who are voting out there based on what they think reality is, when reality
- 32:22is the exact opposite, and we know it. The Earth is not flat.
- 32:29I watched the HBO documentary The Truth Versus Alex Jones, and it was
- 32:34chronicling how this monstrous guy had been essentially torturing the Sandy Hook victims, you
- 32:43know, the families, the community, saying it's false flag, it didn't
- 32:47happen, they're crisis actors. It's all a big conspiracy, over and over
- 32:53and over again. And after he'd been beating that drum for who knows how
- 32:59long, was a poll taken and an alarming percentage of Americans now say,
- 33:05well, they don't even if they think it's true, there are parts they
- 33:08think that might not be true. The seeds of doubt, you know,
- 33:14and I just think, how can you look at Sandy Hook and not realize
- 33:17what reality is. I'm also frustrated with freaking Joe Rogan. He's talking to
- 33:23Tucker Carlson. They were talking about Alex Jones and what a laudable revolutionary act,
- 33:30a free speech acted was. And I have to say, your willingness
- 33:37to platform or to have a conversation with Alex Jones I think was a revolutionary
- 33:43act. Actually, not that everything Alex Jones says is right. It's not
- 33:47not everything I say is right, or anyone says is right. But Alex
- 33:51Jones is an interesting person. And even if he's not interesting, he has
- 33:54been walled off from the rest of us yea, through name calling, in
- 33:58your willingness to be like, no, actually, we're just gonna listen Alex
- 34:00Jones, and you can decide for yourself. Well, Alex has been my
- 34:02friend for more than twenty years. Well exactly regardless of what he said.
- 34:08That's incorrect. Clearly the Sandy Hook thing was incorrect. You know Alex.
- 34:13I know Alex personally, so I know what he was going through. And
- 34:16you know, everybody wants to talk about mental health and they want to praise
- 34:22people for being honest about their mental health issues and support them on their mental
- 34:25health journey to wellness. Alex has gone through some real issues, and one
- 34:30of the reasons why he's gone through some issues is because that guy is uncovering
- 34:35real shit that's terrifying. Every fucking day I get asked on a regular base
- 34:39and I've never been invited to be on Rogan's show, but people regularly tell
- 34:45me I should go on, And I was like, even if he asked,
- 34:46I would say no, I'm Rogan is another person who I can't understand
- 34:53their popularity other than you know, people like Weed. All all he does
- 35:00is have on controversial Uh. He has some decent guests on. I'm not
- 35:08gonna say every every guest is this way because I know some scientists have gone
- 35:13on, and he tries to do this. But Rogan is a clueless buffoon
- 35:19who doesn't know or understand anything, and so he doesn't know enough to push
- 35:23back on the guests that he has. He doesn't, He's just he's basically
- 35:28sitting there. Hey, let me be the guy that's you know, we're
- 35:30gonna we're gonna smoke a bowl and I'm gonna ask you questions. I'm gonna
- 35:35ask the questions that I think the audience wants, and he's genuinely asking the
- 35:38questions that his listeners want to hear, which is, you know, tell
- 35:43me about this, tell me about this conspiracy or this thing here or whatever
- 35:45else. There's nothing there that is an honest and reliable pathway to understanding the
- 35:53truth of reality. It is let's have a conversation where you can present what
- 36:00ever bizarre idea you have. The host is not knowledgeable and is not going
- 36:06to push back on you. Almost nobody else there is truly knowledgeable and going
- 36:10to push back on occasion. I know some of his crew will say,
- 36:13no, no, that's not true, because they're kind of trying to fact
- 36:16check some stuff. And yet this is the most popular podcast on the planet.
- 36:22Someone who does not have a again, no good understanding of skepticism,
- 36:25no good understanding of critical thinking of epistemology, no good understanding of how we
- 36:30should determine what we should or shouldn't believe. Joe was a moon landing denier.
- 36:37And I remember Phil Plate I think went on the show. Maybe I
- 36:42don't ever watch, but either Phil Plate went on or they had a discussion
- 36:45or something. I have this gigantic coffee book, coffee table book, and
- 36:50it's all, you know, a NASA book, and it's the beautiful pictures
- 36:52of the moon and all these different photographs. Well, when I look at
- 36:55some of them, they look obviously fake. They look cut, and I'm
- 37:00not saying I know they are. I'm not saying I have any special information.
- 37:05But I'm an open minded person. And when I look at it,
- 37:08I say, look, I know I sound like a retard. I know
- 37:10I sound like a crackpot. I know saying that, you know the Earth
- 37:15is hollowed, there's dinosaurs inside of it. I'm sure it's very similar to
- 37:20saying I don't think people landed on the moon. But you know what,
- 37:22I don't think people landed on the moon. And I think Joe changed his
- 37:27position on that based on that discussion, which is a good thing. But
- 37:31when we're you know, I don't understand. So no, No. One
- 37:36of my best friends is Forrest VALKEI. Forrest has tons of followers on Instagram,
- 37:40and yet people outside of that or maybe Instagram TikTok, people outside that
- 37:45still don't know who he is. Forrest could go on Rogan and demolish any
- 37:53of the anti science stuff that Rogan's had on and just there's nobody more excited
- 37:59about that. So all those people who are like Matt, you should go
- 38:01on Rogan. No, see if you can get Rogan to have forest one
- 38:06because the guy needs to be schooled. Wow, sorry about that. That's
- 38:09all right, sought after guests, probably another show. Hey Matt, you're
- 38:15busy. It's a message about reptiles. I saw it as well. You
- 38:17know, it's like when RFK Junior, who is just this whack a dooodal
- 38:22nutbar conspiracy theorist, anti vaxer, he goes on Rogan and Rogan does the
- 38:29same thing. Hmmm hmm, interesting hmm, you know, and just totally
- 38:32allows it unchecked. Then virologist doctor Peter Hotez goes online to talk about how
- 38:38crazy it is, and then Rogan and Elon Musk and others start baiting doctor
- 38:45hotes Well, come on, it's monoemano. Let's have it. I'll donate
- 38:49to charity, let's let's have it out. And I just I remember Hotests
- 38:52saying this is not an adult forum to have scientific discussions, and I tend
- 39:00to agree. Would you have supported Hotez going on for a little back and
- 39:05forth. I don't want anybody to go on, Rogan. I mean,
- 39:07I suggested forrest just as a practical thing, because I know it's not going
- 39:12to stop. I mean, I look, Matt, if he'd never want
- 39:16me, But if somebody said, hey, Seth, would you sit in
- 39:19a room with him? I think I'd be like, all right, under
- 39:23this condition that I get to say whatever I want, and I will challenge
- 39:29him, you know, NonStop. Essentially, my first thing that I would
- 39:32be was, you are being irresponsible with one of the biggest podcast platforms in
- 39:37the world, and here's why you make me crazy. You know, That's
- 39:42what I would have to lead with. I'm not saying I'd never sit in
- 39:45the room, but I find the lack of pushback really discouraging. Yeah,
- 39:52it's one of those they give people the opportit. This is the thing I'll
- 39:58get criticized for. Oh man, he puts everybody on hold and yells at
- 40:00them, shuts them down, And in reality, what's happening is that only
- 40:05happens when somebody's not honestly engaging in conversation. I ask a question, You're
- 40:09either going to answer the question, so we can move on to the next
- 40:13point, or you're going to not answer the question. And I hold people
- 40:19to that, and I've stood up against people with amazing, huge platforms.
- 40:22I remember the well, this will sound braggy, but I remember the first
- 40:29time Neil de Grastaisen and I met and I apologized to him because I'd called
- 40:36him a douche on my show, and he's like, why did you do
- 40:38that? And I explained it, and then we had this back and forth
- 40:42debate for a few minutes, at which I won, and then at the
- 40:47end of it he's like, well, you go ahead and tell the fans
- 40:50of your show. I said, it's perfectly fine to call me a douche
- 40:52for that. And without going into the details, which I've talked about before,
- 40:58I pushed back on stuff like that. Nobody pushes back on Joe.
- 41:01As a matter of fact, his guests who might disagree with him, When
- 41:07they start to push back, Joe caves it's like, oh yeah, yeah,
- 41:13yeah, And I just it's an incredibly frustrating thing because I'll get sent
- 41:20clips of the show and there will be nothing substantive there that is true and
- 41:25useful. And as the world falls apart, and fully half of us are
- 41:30wrong about seemingly everything, from whether or not we're at a fifty year high
- 41:35or a fifty year low, unemployment on unemployment, whether or not climate change
- 41:38is an issue, whether or not it's a human generated whether or not there's
- 41:43anything we can or can't do about it. We all want a better world,
- 41:47but we and even if we could agree on what a better world look
- 41:51like, we can't agree on how to get there. And I'm just why
- 41:55isn't an actual podcast that teaches people something and makes the world better the number
- 42:00one podcast on the planet. I'm not saying it should be mine or yours,
- 42:04but why isn't that the case? Why is it? Why is it
- 42:06something I don't know? I'm not going to be able to say anything nice
- 42:10with that. I'm tracking before I go to the phones, quickly, let
- 42:15me throw this word out and see where you land. I tend to resist
- 42:20this idea that someone tells me you can or cannot have someone on your show,
- 42:25which is why I say if Rogan called, under the right circumstances,
- 42:29I'm not saying I would refuse, but I would go on guns blazing,
- 42:34so to speak. How do you how do you approach the word plat forming.
- 42:40Are there standards that you have, Are there lines that you draw?
- 42:44Are there people you will and will not speak to deal with because you just
- 42:49don't want to give them oxygen platforming? What are your thoughts? Yeah?
- 42:53No, If I'm the host of the show, I'm the one that decides
- 42:58who's going to be on. So so if I decide I'm going to sit
- 43:00down face to face, eye to eye on camera with a neo Nazi,
- 43:05all right, fine, have a seat, let's have it out, let's
- 43:07talk mono Imano. I reserve the right to do that. But there are
- 43:13some who would say, how dare you platform a white supremacist? How dare
- 43:16you give them any of your oxygen? If I have the bigger platform,
- 43:22then I think I'm the one that's that bears the responsibility, And so if
- 43:25there's I can I know that I can honestly address what a neo Nazis position
- 43:35is and represent it and refute it without ever having them on to say a
- 43:40word. So there's not much benefit to me to have a neo Nazi on.
- 43:46There are other people where I may not fully understand what their position is
- 43:52or how they're trying to represent it. And if my goal is to either
- 43:58a gain an understand standing and let other people gain an understanding, or be
- 44:05engage in the sort of debate that shuts down this terrible stuff, those are
- 44:10fine if I'm playing. If I'm having someone on like Rogan is a much
- 44:16bigger draw than me by a lot. So what I, under the right
- 44:21circumstances have Rogan on my show or go on rogan show? If I knew
- 44:25that there was a way that I could engage in do it that would be
- 44:30beneficial to movement cool. I don't know what the benefit is of me platforming
- 44:36a neo Nazi, but if somebody came up and said, Hey, here's
- 44:38this neo Nazi. He's gaining traction and audience, and we would really like
- 44:46to have you kind of come in to debate that to try to take the
- 44:51wind out of their sales a little bit, I'd have to consider it.
- 44:54Now, if you can sit on stage with Denesh Desuza, you have ye
- 44:59you know certainly enough patients. I'm not going out like, hey, I'd
- 45:02love to have Nazis on my show, but I've been talking a lot about
- 45:06that. That's what I'm gonna tell everybody please do Yeah, well, it
- 45:09doesn't matter because people are going to do it anyway, because people thinking bumper
- 45:13stickers out there. But I, you know, I'm interested. It's it's
- 45:17who was it who said it's hard to hate people up close? And I
- 45:22think it's almost like when Dia Khan sits down with a white supremacist being a
- 45:25Muslim woman of color, and they can hate her from a distance, but
- 45:30when they're close and they begin to actually speak and they're not yelling at the
- 45:34caricature of who they are, is there a tiny chance that maybe there will
- 45:37be a crack that lets in the light. And that may sound a bit
- 45:40utopian, but if nothing else, it allows us to take a public stand
- 45:45against something that we, you know, we reject as human beings. I
- 45:50didn't mean to go off on that long bunny trail, but I'm interested in
- 45:54these types of These are conversations that we have in the movement. Should you
- 45:59platform, who should you speak to? Under what parameters? And I guess
- 46:02Rogan and everybody else ties into that. I'm going to see if I can
- 46:06get the switchboard to work. I always struggle on the first call, Matt,
- 46:09I've got cat at eight one three. All right, talk to me
- 46:15Cat, what's on your mind? Man? I am just so so excited
- 46:19to be able to talk with you both. Flies. I listen to you
- 46:22guys all the time. First of all, I just want to say that
- 46:27T shirt rocks because obviously I'm Cat, so I collect all things Cat.
- 46:31So if there's any way to get one of those shirts, I would totally
- 46:35be on that because it's really cool. And then just secondly, and really
- 46:44more importantly is I just want to thank you both for everything that you guys
- 46:47did. Matt, you mentioned earlier how sometimes people have a little bit of
- 46:55a problem, they call in, they get upset with you that I have
- 47:00listened to you. I've been in a destruction or deconstruction for a couple of
- 47:06years, and in the beginning, listening to you was a little hard because
- 47:10I was like, man, he's so hard, he's so rough, he's
- 47:15so mean. But you know what, you are right in what you say.
- 47:23And what really got me to open up to being able to hear you
- 47:32is by listening to you debate people, because you're just so knowledgeable and you're
- 47:37so when you're debating. You just have a certain persona that is really confident
- 47:46and calm, and that allowed me to just be like, you know what,
- 47:52this guy, he's smart and I want to listen to him. Man,
- 47:57you got a great voice. I could just listen to you forever.
- 48:00But say things. You say things that are so spot on to me personally,
- 48:06because we're all roughly the same age, and you mentioned things that just
- 48:12cracked me up, because I'm like, oh, I remember that. I
- 48:14remember I was a Christian for the first fifty two years of my life.
- 48:17And so when you like mentioned Carmen, I'm like, I want to crack
- 48:21up, because hello, who didn't love the courtroom up forever? Right?
- 48:24Yeah? But hang on, hang out. We're hearing a bunch of references
- 48:28a lot of people aren't going to understand. For those who aren't familiar,
- 48:31Carmen was a big, big, big recording artist in the eighties and the
- 48:37nineties. It was I don't know how to describe Carmen to the audience.
- 48:44I think for me, he was easily the biggest Christian pop performer experience because
- 48:53when you went to the show or had him in the church, there was
- 48:59fog, machine and light and spectacle and it was put together. It was
- 49:04a little bit more theatrical. I was a huge Petro fan because those guys
- 49:08genuinely like they're just great musicians wh knew how to write great songs and you
- 49:15know, played their instruments. Carmen was a lot more theatrical, and so
- 49:22it was always Pentecostal churches I went to to see him. I just again
- 49:25wanted to say thank you for you know, everything that you guys put out
- 49:30there. You've definitely definitely contributed to my deeper understanding and growing. I want
- 49:40to say, growing in the word. Isn't that money, but growing in
- 49:45myself and learning about it. So that's it. You got to keep up
- 49:50the great work. You're very kindcat, thank you so much for Carmen was
- 49:54known for story songs, and you want to talk about corny, but they
- 50:00were big to us in Christian music circles. He did one called Witch's Invitation,
- 50:07which was like this seven minute chronicle of somebody who was dabbling in the
- 50:12occult and talking to a real witch and then God shows up and kicks Satan's
- 50:17ass. And then there's another story song, one called the Champion. This
- 50:22was back when the Rocky movies were big, and it's an eight minute song.
- 50:27And the whole thing is Carmen just talking and it's an actual ringing and
- 50:32Satan gets into the ring with Jesus and they kick the crap out of each
- 50:36other, except it's not even close because Jesus is the champion. And there's
- 50:39actually I mean there's that's a live show that I remember best. I should
- 50:44do a whole show on just cringey Christian stuff from my youth. Do you
- 50:47remember the Power Team? I know who they are. I never interacted with
- 50:54them. I think they started hitting a little after I was, like it
- 51:00would been after eighty seven, because by the time I went in the Navy,
- 51:04I was not actively participating in church or worship stuff at all, and
- 51:08so Power Team came out. I think there were nineties. Power Team was
- 51:13a group of bodybuilders, and their whole thing would be to do these high
- 51:17impact shows and displays of strength. And they're bending the metal bar and they're
- 51:22ripping the phone book and there's one where you blow up a hot water bottle
- 51:27until it explodes, and all of these feats of physical strength in the name
- 51:31of Jesus. And then at the end of the Power Team event, with
- 51:35a fog and the lights and the loud music and everyone's like yeah, god
- 51:38woo. They would have an actual alter called you know, everybody, you've
- 51:44seen strength, physical strength today. But it's nothing. Nothing, I say
- 51:47in comparison to the strength of Jesus and he wants to save your soul today.
- 51:53Cringe. We should do a whole show on just also we could in
- 51:59the sense it's also when they say it's nothing, they're right because those feats
- 52:04of strength of rolling a frying pan, of ripping through the phone book,
- 52:10those aren't. You don't have to be a big strong person to do that.
- 52:15It's physics. And my friend Brian Brushwood, who runs scam School in
- 52:20Modern Rogue, has had people on to specifically show those that they're old carnival
- 52:25tricks and so there you can go on YouTube and watch instructions on how to
- 52:30learn to roll a frying pan, how to bend you know, bars around
- 52:34your neck, how to rip through a phone book. It's a it's a
- 52:37process that involves kind of crinkling it so that you're essentially ripping through a page
- 52:42at a time, rather than you know, a phone book. Anybody can
- 52:45rip a page. I would hope I've got Jeremiah four to three to two.
- 52:49Thanks for calling. You're on with Seth and Matt. What do you
- 52:51have for us? Hi? I was just calling about like internet hate comments,
- 52:57so like for a little bit of context. I actually had the pleasure
- 53:00of meeting Matt in person when he was in Dallas for NARBC. I was
- 53:04the idiot eating hotwins with R and Raw. You remember, I do.
- 53:07And I know that you just called tac Us a little while ago because I
- 53:10was listening to that before Seth and I went live. So, having met
- 53:14Matt in person, I was just going to say, I've made the mistake
- 53:16of going into the line comments recently and I saw some really hateful, vile
- 53:22stuff directed at him, and I was just wondering, how do you deal
- 53:25with that? And I'm sure you've seen it as well, so I'm sure
- 53:28you've had some hateful stuff directed at you as well. No, no one
- 53:30ever says anything bad about me. I don't know what Matt's problem is.
- 53:35I'm just saying I'm immune. Really, no, go ahead, what are
- 53:39your thoughts? Brother? I genuinely don't know what he's talking about because I
- 53:44don't read the comments. I get enough hate directed at me in places where
- 53:47i'm likely to see it, you know, either on a Facebook moment.
- 53:52I read comments on my own personal channel sometimes and will reply to some of
- 53:57them. I don't read any of the comments on the line, and unless
- 54:00they happen to come across Live if a live comic comes and the moderators tend
- 54:05to take care of that. So I genuinely don't know what's been said about
- 54:08me. And part of the reason for that is I don't care if somebody
- 54:16wants to come in and be like, you know, the latest one is
- 54:22because of Arden, it's your gay homie, It's Matt's gay, Matt's gay,
- 54:28Mats, Matt's married to a man, Matt's gay, Matt's gay.
- 54:30It's NonStop. And they think that it bothers me, but it doesn't because
- 54:38not only did we take the your gay homie thing and turn it into a
- 54:42little slogan, and then we sold T shirts and other stuff, so they
- 54:45made, you know, keep coming at me because you make me a couple
- 54:47of dollars every time you come up with a new thing that's you know,
- 54:51terrible. But I've said this probably twenty times, so it's it's repetitive.
- 54:55Now I'm an out, open public atheist in a relationship with a public trans
- 55:06woman. Does anybody think that if I was gay? I would have some
- 55:10problems saying so's I don't understand the dunk that they're trying to do. So
- 55:17to them, gay is an insult, which really reveals a lot about them.
- 55:22By the way, if you come after Arden, you come after all
- 55:24of us, and it's on, it's on. But I'll browse the comments
- 55:31when something first releases out of curiosity, just to see what the temperature of
- 55:37the response is, to make sure that there's not a factual error. I
- 55:40do that on my actually not true. They'll find it in eight seconds and
- 55:46then I'm like, ah, crap, I gotta go fix it. But
- 55:50you know, I think comment sections have some utility, but they are also
- 55:54in many ways where discourse goes to die. I check my own content that
- 56:00I put up where I'm the manager on my channel, and so I'll watch
- 56:02for comments there in case there's a factual error, or you know, there's
- 56:07an audio gap or there's a video gap. I edited something wrong. That
- 56:10almost never happens because generally I don't edit anything. I tend to do it
- 56:15live here. The reason I don't see the comments that the caller's talking about
- 56:19on the line is because I'm a host on the line, I don't do
- 56:24any moderating stuff. I don't go back and read comments afterwards and I and
- 56:30part of that is because if there's a factual error or problem or anything that
- 56:34I need to know that it is showing up in the comments, somebody will
- 56:37absolutely come tell me. But if I sat around and tried to read comments,
- 56:42I'd never get anything done and it would STI wouldn't bother me. Jeremiah,
- 56:46I appreciate your call, thanks for being a part of the show,
- 56:49and you hang in there. There was a comment let me pull this up
- 56:52because it was the most bizarre thing that I had to screenshot it and then
- 57:00post the screenshot. What was said the other day? Hold please? Oh
- 57:08well? There was someone who said, you have a pathetic podcast, boring
- 57:12to watch nothing but crying and bitching. This will be the only and last
- 57:16time clicking on this site, demon crats. I thought that was I thought
- 57:22that was interesting. Someone else said from the line that I seemed to feel
- 57:27uncomfortable in the host chair. Was I nervous? But there was another one
- 57:32that just blew my mind. And it's worth taking a second to locate it.
- 57:37Hang on just a second. Oh, someone said, if I were
- 57:42a theist, Seth's logic voice would soon have my god panties down around my
- 57:50ankles. I don't even know what to do. Yes, that's outstanding,
- 57:58and assuming they're just being in entirely metaphorical, I get it. We've got
- 58:05more to talk about, including our quest for eternal life via science. More
- 58:13to come with my guest and your calls. Next, for people who love
- 58:22to listen to audio books I have narrated thirteen five are my own. And
- 58:29then also for historians and scientists and X theologians and just educators and activists out
- 58:37there. I have been privileged to be a part of so many projects,
- 58:42and so if you'd like me to read to you, you can just go
- 58:45to audible dot com and type in my name Seth Andrews, and those audiobooks
- 58:51ought to pop up select one or thirteen, and I hope you enjoy listening.
- 58:58Thank you so much for that. Continuing with my guest friend and activist
- 59:04Matt Dilla Hunty, I've got looks like age zero two, Jason, can
- 59:12you hear me? Yes? Uh, you know the topic. You guys
- 59:15are kind of discussing about like who do we give our you know, our
- 59:22engagements to, or you know, like who we choose to interact this week.
- 59:25The whole issue with the football kicker has been going on, and and
- 59:31I thought it was kind of interesting that it kind of lets you see who's
- 59:35who when issues like this come up. It was talk like how do we
- 59:38decide, how do we decide like when do engage these people? And then
- 59:42when when it's just like boosting the algorithm on this subject that, you know,
- 59:49I need to give some context here if I may. He's talking about
- 59:52Harrison, Butker. I don't follow football, so I'm hoping I get the
- 59:58names right. Kicker for the Kansas City Chiefs who gave a May eleventh commencement
- 1:00:05speech at Benedictine College in Atchison, Texas. I don't know why they had
- 1:00:10him come in, but he was advising these college graduates, and he said
- 1:00:16that most women receiving their degrees were probably more excited about getting married and having
- 1:00:23kids, and that some Catholic leaders were pushing quote dangerous gender ideologies onto the
- 1:00:31youth of America. He also went after Pride Month and the LGBT community and
- 1:00:39he got roasted rightly by people saying, what the hell's wrong with you?
- 1:00:45And then of course people said that he is now being canceled, which is
- 1:00:51stupid because I think he's saying as much as he has ever said. Matt,
- 1:00:54did you want to weigh in? Yeah, this is easy. So
- 1:00:59Harrison was invited to speak because he's a conservative Catholic and he was speaking at
- 1:01:01a conservative Catholic university. Nothing he said should be surprising to anyone. Not
- 1:01:07all Catholics hashtag not all Catholics are going to agree with him, but a
- 1:01:10good chunk of conservative Catholics are, which is why you got a massive round
- 1:01:14applause and why his jersey was the second hottest selling jersey after he gave that
- 1:01:21lecture, second to Travis Kelcey. What he said shouldn't surprise anyone, but
- 1:01:29recently someone tried to characterize it if Hey, he was just saying, you
- 1:01:32know, my wife enjoys being a homemaker. Well that's not what he was
- 1:01:37saying. He specifically talked about the diabolic He referenced diabolical lies. Did not
- 1:01:44say what they were, but the implication was that all these women who've gone
- 1:01:49out and gotten their degrees. There are victims of diabolical lies, and some
- 1:01:54of them might be looking more forward to being a wife, mother, homemaker,
- 1:02:00and his wife enjoys that and it's one of the most important jobs.
- 1:02:06It shouldn't surprise anybody that this was said, and it shouldn't surprise anybody that
- 1:02:08there was a backlash. Stuff like this has been said at probably every Catholic
- 1:02:14university commitsment. It just happens that it was a public figure and it got
- 1:02:17some traction publicly. Harrison is just as wrong as all of the people who
- 1:02:23were applauding him and all the people who agreed with him there at the university.
- 1:02:28But he has every right to say it. He has not been canceled,
- 1:02:31he was not fined by the NFL, despite a nonsense clickbait article claiming
- 1:02:38that he was fined. There's nothing remotely bad that's going to happen. That
- 1:02:43the primary reason to point this stuff out is to share the hypocrisy of the
- 1:02:47right who want to be upset about Colin Kaepernick taking a knee exercising his free
- 1:02:55speech and they want him to shut up and kick but they don't say this
- 1:03:00same thing to Harrison because they agree with him, and that's not surprising to
- 1:03:05me either, that the people who agree with him are going to play favorites
- 1:03:09and be hypocritical. I find it interesting too that there's a man like white
- 1:03:15cis male telling women what and what won't make them the most fulfilled, which
- 1:03:21I think is just a monumental demonstration of privilege. And you know, I'm
- 1:03:28also alarmed at so many of the progressive Christians who are going after this speech.
- 1:03:32They're on our side, meaning this is inappropriate, but their reasoning is,
- 1:03:37well, that's not true Christianity, which brings me full circle, right,
- 1:03:42because Jesus, Jesus loves women in the workplace. There was a series
- 1:03:46of Catholic nuns who came to the defense of women in the name of the
- 1:03:52Catholic Church, and they were, you know, speaking out against this speech
- 1:03:54going Butker was absolutely incorrect. And I'm like, you are a nun in
- 1:04:00a Catholic church that forbids you to have any position of priestly leadership because you
- 1:04:08do not have a venus. I just don't understand this disconnect. Did you
- 1:04:13have any other further comments or questions for us, Jason, No, I
- 1:04:17mean, that's spot on. That was my thoughts exactly. And I've you
- 1:04:23know, pretty much been that's been my engagement with that particular subject. But
- 1:04:27you know, thanks for thanks for the insight. I appreciate you. Hang
- 1:04:30in there, We'll see you later. I just did a true story about
- 1:04:34Judith Love Cohen, who back in the nineteen forties was math wiz. Teenage
- 1:04:43girl in high school goes to a guidance counselor and says, Okay, I'd
- 1:04:47like to do something meaningful with my life. I'm thinking I'd like to go
- 1:04:51to college and pursue mathematics. And the counselor said, why don't you be
- 1:04:58part of polite society, go to a finishing school, and then get married
- 1:05:02and have a whole bunch of kids, right, because that's what women do.
- 1:05:06And Judith Cohen said, screw you, and she went and got a
- 1:05:12master's in engineering, worked for NASA and developed the software that helped to rescue
- 1:05:18the Apollo thirteen astronauts, and that became her legacy. But whenever I hear
- 1:05:26this kicker talking about women, I'm like, he sounds like the guidance counselor
- 1:05:30back in the nineteen forties. Anything else on that Matt I made a funny
- 1:05:35joke, which I'll just give myself full credit for. I made a funny
- 1:05:39joke. So Kristin, my ex who is the meme queen of the atheist
- 1:05:45movement, as you're well aware, she had posted that that Harrison Harrison's mom
- 1:05:55was a physicist, and she's like, make it make sense. How can
- 1:05:59this son of a woman who's a physicist have these views? And I replied,
- 1:06:04and I'll preface this by saying everybody understood I was joking, but I
- 1:06:10replied with a comment that essentially said, and if she'd have kept her ass
- 1:06:13in the kitchen, he wouldn't have turned out this way. Oh yeah,
- 1:06:15somebody's gonna sound by that. Yes, I'm reminded of that Emerson quote,
- 1:06:20because you know, the Butker fans are like, he's being canceled. I
- 1:06:25saw John Stewart at The Daily Show did a montage of Fox News hosts talking
- 1:06:30about how they weren't being allowed to say all the things that they were constantly
- 1:06:35saying. Yep, you know, to me, cancel culture is largely just
- 1:06:40such bullshit. I mean, I'm not saying there aren't exceptions, but I'm
- 1:06:44reminded of that. Ralph Waldo Emerson quote where he said, let me never
- 1:06:47fall into the vulgar mistake of dreaming that I am persecuted whenever I am contradicted.
- 1:06:54And I think that's what's going on. It's not that they're persecuted.
- 1:06:58We're just simply saying that's bullshit, you're wrong. I reject it, and
- 1:07:01they're crying foul. Like I said, Harrison's got every right to say what
- 1:07:05he said. I didn't find it particularly surprising, but I have every right
- 1:07:09to object to it. Nobody. First of all, there's pretty much nothing
- 1:07:13about being canceled. The people who've been legitimately canceled, or people like Carvey
- 1:07:16Weinstein who end up in jail. The rest of it is not cancel culture
- 1:07:23as much as it's accountability culture. And there's that's saying that equality feels like
- 1:07:30oppression when you are used to being privileged and there's a bunch of people who
- 1:07:34are spouting off their views who are used to not being challenged, used to
- 1:07:39not being held respond held accountable for what they actually say, and so it
- 1:07:43feels like they're being canceled when people do this, when what's really happening is
- 1:07:47we are building a world in a community where some of the people who used
- 1:07:51to be afraid to stand up and say something are now in bold and be
- 1:07:56it through internet anonymity or just having some support around them to where they can
- 1:08:02say, you know what I'm gonna actually, I'm going to do something that
- 1:08:08nobody ever. I was raised to not do this. I was raised to
- 1:08:11not use course language. I think I think what you said is I think
- 1:08:14what you said is bullshit, and you should be ashamed of that. And
- 1:08:18what ends up happening is that some of the people who do that, who
- 1:08:21push back, the I've been canceled thing is used as a sort of weapon
- 1:08:29against them, as if you've done harm. I literally got into a very
- 1:08:33brief argument in a reptile discussion group because I was talking about one of the
- 1:08:39potential problems in the community, and somebody replied to my post with kind of
- 1:08:45an attack and a little miniature lecture of explaining to me what life is like
- 1:08:50as a as a breeder, and I'm like, I literally am a breeder.
- 1:08:54You should probably not just assume that I don't know this stuff just because
- 1:08:59we disagree and then go on to lecture me. I'm sorry, snake breeder,
- 1:09:03I just have to throw that out, go ahead, go ahead,
- 1:09:05snake snake breeder, and I was like, you should not assume that because
- 1:09:11you know this is what I do, and it's you know, it's a
- 1:09:14hobby, but it's more than a hobby. And my response to their mild
- 1:09:18attack, I didn't accuse them of attacking me. It's just like, you
- 1:09:23know, if you're if you're going to come at me. I basically said,
- 1:09:27if you're gonna, you know, you're going to care more about lecturing
- 1:09:30me when you don't know anything about me than you are about fixing the problem.
- 1:09:32I'm probably not the guy you want to come at And this person replied
- 1:09:39with a you should go down, lay down and take a nap. You
- 1:09:45definitely shouldn't be coming at me. And I'm like, I made a post,
- 1:09:48you came at me, and when I replied to defend myself, you're
- 1:09:51suggesting that I'm trying to bully you or or attack you when you know none
- 1:09:59of it makes any sense. So that's I went to Facebook and I posted
- 1:10:02all of my atheist friends will be thrilled to know that the reptile community is
- 1:10:05just as teeming with drama and dishonest interlocutors as the atheist, skeptic, and
- 1:10:10religious communities. Maybe the problem is the humans people or people. I was
- 1:10:15going to quit, but I got to do one more. Matt, real
- 1:10:16fast, Do you have a second because this next person wants to talk about
- 1:10:20a subject that fascinates and terrifies me. Is it? Mike? Do you
- 1:10:26got to comment or question? What is it? Well? Well, it's
- 1:10:31weird, but I respect your guy's opinion. So I was wondering what your
- 1:10:36guys opinion is on cryo preservation. I have been reading where was it about
- 1:10:44these people who have more money than God? And when they die, they
- 1:10:48have like their heads preserved, so that maybe one day, when the technology
- 1:10:53exists, they can have their brains transplanted into the body of a eighteen year
- 1:10:59old and start all over again. Not to interject, but you don't need
- 1:11:03more money than God. It's about twenty five thousand dollars to preserve your head
- 1:11:08in about two hundred thousand to preserve your body. Oh really, Oh well,
- 1:11:14let me get right on that. So I could preserve freeze my head
- 1:11:16for you know, a car Loan on a new vehicle that kind of money.
- 1:11:20Is that what you're saying? Absolutely about twenty twenty five thousand dollars.
- 1:11:26But isn't it true that when they go and check on these guys who've had
- 1:11:29their heads frozen or whatever, that it turns out that everything's dissolved a gelatin
- 1:11:33anyway, and it's all just goop and it was money wasted. Yeah.
- 1:11:39Yeah, people will argue that point. But the reason why I'm bringing up
- 1:11:43is because whenever somebody talks about the future with cry of preservation, what they
- 1:11:47never take into account ever, is super intelligence. I mean, we're we're
- 1:11:57one point three to three percent more intelligent than chimp. And look at the
- 1:12:00difference that we've created. Try explaining to a chimpanzee what a laptop is and
- 1:12:04what the internet does. AIS are going to be far more than that intelligence
- 1:12:12than we are, and they're going to be able to discover amazing ways that
- 1:12:15we have in our heads. Right now, in the human brain, we
- 1:12:18have a way to make it work, and that's through nanobots. Trillions of
- 1:12:27nanobots, each one taking care of us sell individually. Okay, as it
- 1:12:30decrussed. So who's to say that the superintelligence won't actually figure out a way.
- 1:12:36I personally believe everybody who's frozen in there will one day be reanimated for
- 1:12:43sure. Okay, hang on again, I want matt Away in real fast.
- 1:12:45But I have two thoughts, well, a few thoughts. First of
- 1:12:48all, how do you even test this, because now you're back to doing
- 1:12:51what the Russians were doing, and you're you know, sawing the heads off
- 1:12:55of dogs and trying to that kind of horrible torture. Secondly, let's say
- 1:13:00that they sow your head on to another body and they're able to supposedly connect
- 1:13:05the spinal tissues, the cord, the nerve endings, the blood supplies,
- 1:13:11and it doesn't work. You are in unbelievable agony. And yet because you
- 1:13:16have been improperly constructed, you can't tell anybody. This is the kind of
- 1:13:24thing that like, how do you even develop that technology? Consideration that if
- 1:13:28we're going to make a factor of superintelligence, we have to respect what's that's
- 1:13:33going to entail. They are not going to bring us back if it's going
- 1:13:36to be agony. Personally, I don't believe we're going to be biological.
- 1:13:40But in any event, except for our prefrontal cortex, I mean, the
- 1:13:44only part of you that's actually you is your prefrontal cortex, Your whole limbic
- 1:13:48system can go and you would still be the same person you are. So
- 1:13:53I don't believe that it's going to be an issue of saving the body.
- 1:13:58It's going to be more an issue how to connect the prefrontal cortex to the
- 1:14:00rest of the digital body is I know it sounds like science fiction. I
- 1:14:04see Matt lapping his head off here. It's ridiculous. Are you telling me
- 1:14:09that you don't fathom this as being a possibility. So anybody that wants to
- 1:14:14freeze their head, go for it. I have no objection to anybody doing
- 1:14:19it. What I have objection to are the people who take this and then
- 1:14:24say they've as you said, they are supremely confident that all of these people
- 1:14:28would be revived. The mere fact that something is conceivable doesn't tell you whether
- 1:14:33or not it's possible. You don't have evidence that it's actually possible to do
- 1:14:39this, or humans in the way. What if we're freezing people the wrong
- 1:14:43way, what if we're doing it. Any number of things could be wrong.
- 1:14:46But you're like, oh, they're not going to bring you back an
- 1:14:48agony. You have no more evidence for that. And the first people who
- 1:14:51come back might end up being in agony. You have no more evidence for
- 1:14:56that than you have for anything else. And then you're like, oh,
- 1:14:58this sounds like science fiction. Yes, because right now it is science fiction.
- 1:15:01When it's science fact, I'll care about it until then. I'm all
- 1:15:05in favor of the transhumanists trying to go out and demonstrate that this is an
- 1:15:11actual possibility, an empirical possibility, not just a metaphysical possibility or an a
- 1:15:16logical possibility. But you know I'm not. I didn't come into this show
- 1:15:21or any other show saying, man, these transhumanists are really stupid and they
- 1:15:26shouldn't be spending their money getting their heads frozen. By all means, go
- 1:15:29get your head frozen if you want, but don't waste my time on it
- 1:15:32until you actually have evidence that it works. I don't care about your speculation
- 1:15:36or anybody else's that it might eventually work, or that it's a sure thing
- 1:15:41that it might eventually work. There simply isn't evidence to support that. All
- 1:15:46there is is an optimistic hope. You haven't you've talked about superintelligence, have
- 1:15:53it defined it? Haven't shown that it's possible or that that's what's likely to
- 1:15:56happen. So you're banking on a science fiction to solve another science fiction when
- 1:16:00it's actually real, then I'll care. Well, here's the thing, Uh,
- 1:16:05I'm not, you know I I I personally, this is just me
- 1:16:10personally. I personally feel that, yes, we will achieve that. Now,
- 1:16:15with that said, I understand what Matt's saying. There's it's just because
- 1:16:18it's it's it's conceivable doesn't mean that it's true. Well that's true, but
- 1:16:21what what's the what's the harm in giving it a try for something so spectacularly
- 1:16:29beautiful if it should happen. So, first of all, you don't know
- 1:16:32that it's spectacularly beautiful. But also when did I say there was harm in
- 1:16:36giving it a try? Didn't I literally just say that I'm all in favor
- 1:16:41of the transhumans going out and exploring this, and that I don't personally care
- 1:16:45until it goes out of the realm of science fiction. Why are you acting
- 1:16:47as if I'm pooh poohing a beautiful thing that that just costs us nothing.
- 1:16:54It's a lie that it costs us nothing. However, I'm still in favor
- 1:16:59of you and everybody else. Once't you freeze your head today. Well,
- 1:17:04I'll tell you if I had a chronic illness, like a cancer, unstoppable
- 1:17:10cancer or something. I in Canada, here we have the right to die,
- 1:17:14I would get I would pay the twenty five grand, and I would
- 1:17:18put myself down. Yes, like people like aren You know, he seems
- 1:17:27to be so vehemently opposed to it, saying this one life is good enough.
- 1:17:30But you know, when you really think about it, death is not
- 1:17:33a good thing. Death is the loss of everything. It's the loss of
- 1:17:38your loved ones. It's the loss of rock and roll. It's the loss
- 1:17:41of sex. It's the loss of eating good food and wine. It's a
- 1:17:45loss of everything. What's wrong with Okay, not that there's anything wrong with
- 1:17:48it, but with the concept of super intelligence just around the corner, shouldn't
- 1:17:55this be something we should really be pushing. All right, I'm gonna probably
- 1:17:59move off this whichboard Mike can finish this conversation with Matt Any thoughts on what
- 1:18:03he just said. Well, I'm wondering why you would need to wait until
- 1:18:06you have a terminal illness to be willing to freeze your head if you're so
- 1:18:12confident that they're going to actually achieve this and that everybody's going to be unfrozen.
- 1:18:17If you're supremely confident about this, wouldn't it be better to freeze you
- 1:18:21before you get an illness, when you're younger and healthier, and then they
- 1:18:27know what to do. Why would you need to wait till you're older or
- 1:18:29more ill But you keep doing this with supreme or super intelligence right around the
- 1:18:34corner, prove it. Here's the question that cooks my noodle. When I
- 1:18:42was a believer, I would have just laughed at you, Ken. Our
- 1:18:46technology become conscious at some point. If we see the brain as a computer
- 1:18:54and it's simply processing information and that constitutes consciousness this level, then can the
- 1:19:01development of synthetic technology one day become conscious? And with AI and the four,
- 1:19:09of course, these conversations are happening more and more often conscious machines.
- 1:19:13Matt, I don't know if it's possible. I don't see any reason why
- 1:19:19we should by default rule it out. It's going to be, It may
- 1:19:27be inevitable, depending on how we understand consciousness. I think that getting to
- 1:19:34AI or machine intelligence that is sufficient to count for many of the things that
- 1:19:45we tend to count consciousness for and things like that. I don't I think
- 1:19:49that might be inevitable. But I'm saying that not in the sense of that
- 1:19:58should be a goal or we should work toward. It seems that that's the
- 1:20:00direction of trends going. We could hit a hard wall tomorrow that stops the
- 1:20:06progress towards a certain thing. Just like the people who are like, oh,
- 1:20:10we're probably living in a simulation. But whatever simulation is, you have
- 1:20:15to have more process and power than exists in the universe, which means we're
- 1:20:17in a bigger universe than we thought we were. And then you have all
- 1:20:19that. It's still with the people with time travel. If time travel is
- 1:20:23possible, we'd already know about it type thing. There's going to be a
- 1:20:26problem somewhere. I don't know. He was saying something about somebody saying this
- 1:20:30one and only life we've got is good enough. I hope he wasn't saying
- 1:20:33that that was what I said, because that's not what I've said my take
- 1:20:39on life. His life is its own reward, and this is the only
- 1:20:43life I know I'm going to get if in fact, we find a way
- 1:20:45to extend that life. I'd like to live just exactly as long as I'd
- 1:20:50actually like to live, maybe not forever, maybe longer than normal. You
- 1:20:54want to double my lifespan, it's fine. But to say super intelligence is
- 1:21:00right around the corner and that's going to solve and fix all of our problems,
- 1:21:05that's garbage. I mean, that is an assertion that you simply can't
- 1:21:10back up, and no one should believe until such time as it has been
- 1:21:15backed up. But that doesn't mean that I'm saying that won't happen. That
- 1:21:20can't happen. You shouldn't work towards it. You should absolutely work towards it
- 1:21:26as long as the cost benefit analysis works out to make that viable. I
- 1:21:30have no idea if it's possible or not work towards it. If you want
- 1:21:34to. I didn't come in here and haven't been suggesting that anybody not do
- 1:21:40it. If I was in charge of where we spend our money, is
- 1:21:45that one area that I might put some money towards? The transhumanist sorts of
- 1:21:49ideas about long increasing lifespan. Sure, I would put some money towards that,
- 1:21:56perhaps, but that's not where it would go first. There are actual,
- 1:22:00real problems that it won't matter if super intelligence happens day after tomorrow.
- 1:22:08If we are unable to resolve climate change issues or anything else. Oh wait,
- 1:22:12super intelligence will fix that too. It's like some people have decided that
- 1:22:16they've read so much science fiction and that because something can't be shown to be
- 1:22:20impossible, well, we're just right on the verge of a glorious world.
- 1:22:28And I am completely I'm as unimpressed with people that think that way as I
- 1:22:33am with Elon Musk. I think what frightens me? I mean, I'm
- 1:22:39interested and excited about AI and what it can do, but I'm also bugs
- 1:22:44me. It bothers me how fast we're moving. It bothers me that we
- 1:22:47are now training machines to become the creators instead of assisting the creators, and
- 1:22:54the technology goes out and just sort of plagiarizes other creations. And I know
- 1:22:59that were some who say, well, you just sound like some luddite who
- 1:23:02stuck in olden days. You sound like your grandparents. But if I see
- 1:23:06someone who is a wonderful artist, and I'm thinking of several who are their
- 1:23:14painters, and this is their livelihood, and some program can go and sort
- 1:23:21of creates I don't know even if it's not close to the quality. It
- 1:23:27becomes a replacement art. We've removed the human element, and that really bothers
- 1:23:33me. That's probably a whole other show. Matt final thought on that AI
- 1:23:39doesn't bother me at all. You're not worried at all that the people who
- 1:23:44are creating art may one day see art being created by machines. And then
- 1:23:49we already see art created by machines. Art subjective. And I have paid
- 1:23:56for art that was produced by humans, and I have had AI produce art
- 1:24:00that that I then went and paid. I've actually spent more money to get
- 1:24:04humans to modify art ideas that were originally generated by machine. Then I've spent
- 1:24:12on art created just generally by humans without the machine thing. Now, I'm
- 1:24:17not being a total hypocritte. I mean, I've used AI art in a
- 1:24:21pinch when I've needed something, and and but I I everything's moving so freaking
- 1:24:27fast, and there are people who are behind AI technology who are saying,
- 1:24:30hey, whoa, hey, wait a minute, maybe we should slow down.
- 1:24:33This doesn't this is not on your radar. It doesn't bug you.
- 1:24:38No, all right, all right, Well, I've got a shelter here
- 1:24:43when Skynet becomes conscious and things go crazy, then you can come over.
- 1:24:47Well it's seats eight and it's in the floor in the garage and we can
- 1:24:55no but you can bring your snuf. I'm not I'm not weird abouts Where
- 1:25:00do people find you and your channels and your work, sir Oh, primarily
- 1:25:04patreon dot com slash Atheist Debates and patreon dot com slash called the Line YouTube.
- 1:25:12I'm on the Line. I host The Hang Up on Wednesday nights.
- 1:25:14I do the Sunday Show most Sundays. Although this show you're this weekend,
- 1:25:17You're doing the Sunday Show and I'm doing the Sunday Show after dark. So
- 1:25:20all those people who you guys completely clobber, they can get a second chance
- 1:25:26later Sunday night by coming in and engaging with me. And I'm fortunate because
- 1:25:31I get to be on with Erica Gibbon. So my Sunday night it's going
- 1:25:36to be awesome. That's going to probably be a five hour show. You
- 1:25:41get her going and it's all good, like you never look away. I
- 1:25:45did an interview once with Gutsig Gibbon and Forrest Valci in the same room.
- 1:25:49That's too much if I hadn't pulled the plug, we'd still be going.
- 1:25:53I love it. Remarks of it to pieces, they're great, Matt,
- 1:25:58thanks for talking to me, Thanks for hanging out and taking calls with us,
- 1:26:00and be good brom My pleasure. Thank you. Follow The Thinking Atheist
- 1:26:04on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like
- 1:26:10mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and
- 1:26:15resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our
- 1:26:19website, The Thinkingatheist dot com