Latest / The Vegan Report / The Pope Denounces Tyrannical Anthropocentrism. With Daniel Mascarenhas, S.J. | Ep. 09
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you're listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:05If you're vegan for the animals and you care to do more for animal rights, but you're not sure
- 0:12where to start, then this podcast is for you. Every week, let yourself fall in love with
- 0:18passionate animal rights leaders who will inspire you to find your voice, your own special
- 0:25contribution to the animal rights movement, however small or big it is. Today, we are going
- 0:33to talk about Catholicism and veganism. The Catholic Churches count around 1.3 billion believers,
- 0:42which represents the largest Christian grouping worldwide. Historically, the influence of the
- 0:48Catholic Church has been transformative to say the least. Nowadays, it still represents a far
- 0:54reaching cultural and political force. And I wonder, what would the world look like if the
- 1:01Catholic Church embraced the cause of veganism? I know what you're thinking, this is just a fantasy,
- 1:08it will never happen, but that means you have not been paying attention to the Church, which is
- 1:14slowly but surely getting more and more concerned for animal welfare, opening the door for vegan
- 1:21advocacy. Let me give you one example among many. Back in 2015, Pope Francis wrote in an encyclical
- 1:30which is basically a letter addressed to the entire Church, clearly, and I'm quoting now,
- 1:37clearly the Bible has no place for a tyrannical anthropocentrism, unconcerned for other creatures.
- 1:45And I looked up the definition of anthropocentrism and it means regarding humankind as the central
- 1:52or most important element of existence, especially as opposed to God or animals.
- 1:59And he continues, this responsibility for God's earth means that human beings endowed with
- 2:06intelligence must respect the laws of nature and the delicate equilibria existing between the
- 2:13creatures of this world. And let me just repeat the first part. Clearly the Bible has no place
- 2:19for a tyrannical anthropocentrism, unconcerned for other creatures. This sounds strangely as a
- 2:26denunciation of animal exploitation, like we know it to be. To talk about this topic, I have with me
- 2:34Daniel Mascarenhas. Daniel is a Jesuit scholastic studying to be a Catholic priest. As a vegan,
- 2:42he speaks publicly in defense of animal welfare, making a point that the teachings of his faith
- 2:49go hand in hand with veganism. He is notably the one behind the website vegancatholic.org,
- 2:57and you will find the link in the description, which offers resources and arguments encouraging
- 3:03Catholics to become vegan. Daniel, welcome to the podcast. Thank you, Ryan. It's good to be here.
- 3:09It's good to talk about veganism. Can you tell me a little bit more about yourself?
- 3:15Where are you based? How old are you? Those kinds of things. Yes. So as you mentioned,
- 3:20I'm a Jesuit scholastic, which basically means a seminarian. So I'm studying to be a priest.
- 3:27I have been in the Jesuits in the Society of Jesus for seven years now. God willing,
- 3:32I'll be obtained in three years. So I'm currently studying theology at Boston College.
- 3:37I'm 36 years old. I grew up in South India and I moved to the US about 14 years back for graduate
- 3:45school in mechanical engineering. I worked in tech for a while in California, and then I entered
- 3:51the Jesuits. I grew up Catholic. I had my ups and downs with the faith during my college years,
- 3:57but now I can say that I'm devoutly Catholic. You are in training, like you said, to become a
- 4:04Catholic priest. And I mean, no disrespect, but most of what I know about Catholic priests,
- 4:10I learned from horror movies. And recently there was one released called The Pope's Exorcist,
- 4:17and I think it featured the actor Russell Crowe. So let me ask you, what is the function of a
- 4:23Catholic priest? What kind of commitment does it require from you? And is it like any other job,
- 4:30any other job, but your employer is your church like a rabbi?
- 4:35I have watched The Exorcist, which is the, I think it's from the seventies or the eighties,
- 4:40a famous movie. It was actually, I think, based on a story in St. Louis where I lived for three
- 4:44years. So I had some idea about the movie. I don't like horror movies, so I don't know much about
- 4:49how the Catholic church is portrayed in horror movies. As a priest, you know,
- 4:55my role is basically to kind of accompany people in their faith. In the Catholic church, we have
- 5:02something called the sacraments, which is the most common one that you might think of as Holy
- 5:07Communion. So when you go to church, you will see Holy Communion. So as a priest,
- 5:13you can think of a priest as a mediator, someone who is chosen by the people of God
- 5:19to kind of mediate a relationship between them and God. Obviously, we cannot relate to God directly
- 5:25as well, but the Catholic church believes that all of us have different functions. And so the
- 5:31priest's main job is to accompany people in their faith by providing the sacraments.
- 5:38I think that would be kind of a very basic overview of what the priest does.
- 5:43In terms of like employer-employee relationship, you know, since I worked with the Catholic church,
- 5:48I worked in tech for a while, I would say it's very different. I hope I'm serving God first.
- 5:56I do have a local boss, if you may be called them, superior. So basically, my superior kind of talks
- 6:04to me and sees, how am I doing? What am I interested in? Where is there a need? A church?
- 6:11And so we are sent to different places. Right now, I'm obviously studying, so that's my main job.
- 6:15But once I finish studying, then my superior will talk to me and see what am I interested in.
- 6:22And he might suggest certain things that there is a need in the church or in the country where I can
- 6:29be sent. So it's a very dialogue-based relationship with my employer.
- 6:34So as I understand it, it's a life call. It's a 24-7 function. It's not something...
- 6:47Do you take breaks? As a Catholic priest, do you take like a week off or something like that?
- 6:52Or is it really like a full-time commitment?
- 6:57Yeah. So we take vows. They're called the vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience.
- 7:01So it's a way of life, as correctly mentioned. It's not like I can switch off being a seminarian
- 7:08or a priest, but we're not studying or working all the time. So it is a way of life. So every day,
- 7:16we need to live our lives as a good witness to the gospel. All of us should... At least all of us
- 7:22Christians should be doing that. But as a priest, we are especially called to be good witnesses to
- 7:26the gospel all the time. But that doesn't mean we work all the time. As a student, I basically have
- 7:33a student schedule. There's classes and homework and reading and so on. I enjoy being outside. So
- 7:43in the summer, during fall break or spring break or winter break, I like to go camping and hiking
- 7:50when I can. I like to ride my bicycle, play tennis. And so depending on what hobbies we have,
- 7:56that is free time. And we also do some ministry at a church, but as it's in the Bible, God took
- 8:03rest on the seventh day. And so we are all invited to make sure we have a good balance of work and
- 8:10rest and see how do we like to use the time for relaxation in a way that brings us joy.
- 8:19So for me, it's mainly being outside or I like to work on my vegan website or I like to bake.
- 8:27So those are my hobbies. Well, thank you. I'm learning new things about, you know,
- 8:33Catholicism and what it's like to be a priest because in my mind, it was very something like a
- 8:40mystical calling. Like you go in top of a mountain and you become unreachable, but you're making the
- 8:48point that no, you're reachable. You're still, you know, human being. You don't, you know,
- 8:54there's no saint aura around you. Once you become a priest, you still have, you know,
- 9:01hobbies and things like that, which is good to know. Yeah, it is. It is a healthy to have.
- 9:07I mean, interest besides your work, even though serving the church and serving God's people is
- 9:14like my highest calling, I think it is helpful to have other pursuits and interests that
- 9:21open up ourselves to other things in the world or to new relationships with other people,
- 9:28something that brings the creative side out. So I think we all look for a good, healthy balance.
- 9:34To have good relationships, you know, to make friends, it's very important to have time.
- 9:39You're working all the time. It would be really hard to have good relationships with friends and
- 9:44family. So we are encouraged to have those relationships with people around us. That needs
- 9:50time or that needs common interest. And so I live with a bunch of guys here and we're always trying
- 9:56to figure out what people like to do. Like yesterday, I played tennis with one of my
- 10:00Jesuit brothers. He's from France and we had a really good game. I mean, it's kind of fun to
- 10:05find somebody who's about the same level as me, so it was a good competitive time.
- 10:10Lennon How did you come to, was it something
- 10:16like a true calling? Like you did not have control over it. It was like an overwhelming feeling and
- 10:24you had to become a priest. Or is it like a gradual discovery of the faith? And at the most
- 10:33more basic level, how did you discover Catholicism and you became interested? Was it
- 10:41where you raised as a Catholic? So I'm really curious about, because I mean, you have chosen
- 10:48something, a vocation that is, you don't see many people making that choice. It is a bit radical.
- 10:58It is a bit like becoming vegan actually in how radical it is. So could you talk about that?
- 11:07Dr. Sajad Zalzad Yeah, I grew up Catholic. I grew up in South India and my family had been Catholic
- 11:15for many years now, I guess going back around 250 years or so, maybe longer. I had, you know,
- 11:24I grew up in a pretty traditional sense of being Catholic culturally. And I kind of fell away from
- 11:29my faith during college. But there were a couple of things that made me think a little bit. One was
- 11:37incident in college where I was involved in an outing to the beach and some of the students
- 11:45drowned. And so being close to death as a college student made me reflect on the big picture, you
- 11:54know, what is life about? And how is God supposedly present in this moment of grief and suffering?
- 12:02What is the point of things that happen around us? Is it this pure accident that is completely a luck
- 12:09of the draw that these young men died or was there some sort of over out purpose? So that kind of
- 12:18made me think a little bit more and helped me kind of like go beyond my engineering studies.
- 12:26And then when I moved to the US, I met a priest who I felt was the first person who I could talk to
- 12:34about suppose that conflict between science and religion. And, you know, the basic questions about
- 12:41Genesis, obviously, how did the world come to be, or the Galileo affair, so on. And it was
- 12:50really helpful for me to work through those ideas with a companion, great great great father Bob,
- 12:57who, you know, kind of tried his best to answer the questions, but more importantly, encouraged
- 13:03me to seek the answers myself through conversation, through reading, and so on. And so gradually, I
- 13:09came to be more comfortable with the idea of the Catholic faith, that it makes sense, it's logical,
- 13:18you know, obviously, it cannot be proven scientifically, that faith is a different
- 13:22kind of knowledge. So it's not the same as scientifically proving something.
- 13:28And so I was, I got more comfortable with the idea of different kinds of knowledge,
- 13:34you know, scientific knowledge, and the kinds of knowledge. And, yeah, and so I think that was a
- 13:40good, good meeting with Father Bob. And so I see my faith more from a standpoint of,
- 13:47if you have heard about Bayes theorem, so in statistics, there's, when you're trying to predict
- 13:53a future outcome, there's no 100% certainty. All you can do is you can increase or decrease
- 13:58the probability of something happening based on current evidence. And so, with my faith as well,
- 14:04I'll be honest, there's no way to 100% know that Catholicism is true. There is just no way.
- 14:10And so all you can do is continue seeking out what is out there, what are people talking about,
- 14:17what about scripture, what about experience, like how do you sense God's presence in your life?
- 14:24Does morality make sense in the Catholic Church? Does morality make sense without the Catholic faith
- 14:29or without the Christian faith? And so all these things give me the confidence that, that, that
- 14:36God is present and God wants me to follow a certain path. It is not 100%, nothing in life is 100%.
- 14:43And so I think why my faith is mostly based on the idea of acquired confidence that increases
- 14:49my experience and God is continuously inviting me. So when you talk about a call, you know,
- 14:56it's not like God told me that you should do this or else, you know, it's more like a sense of
- 15:02God gently inviting me. And for me, I never thought I would be a priest when I was younger.
- 15:08It was not something I ever thought about. I got the call, if you may, one fine day when I was
- 15:15praying, I was just sitting in this chapel. I wouldn't even call it praying. I would just sit
- 15:19there two or three times a week kind of in silence. This is a way to collect myself because
- 15:25life is pretty busy when you work in tech. And I just got to start, what would I be happiest doing?
- 15:32I just had to start like, what would I be happiest doing? And I was like, I'm going to be a priest.
- 15:38And for some reason, the answer came a priest. And I talked to myself about that has not happened
- 15:44before. I have never thought of being a priest. But I thought, okay, this would be a good time
- 15:48to continue reflecting on that idea because I felt more energized and excited when I talk to people
- 15:55about the bigger picture, right? Where are we going after this, after our life here? What is the point
- 16:02of our life here? And things like that. What is the meaning of suffering? Things like that. Those
- 16:08kinds of conversations gave me more energy and excitement as compared to working in tech. And so
- 16:14I felt like through that, and then I talked to some priests and asked them, what gives joy to
- 16:19their life? What makes them happy? What makes them excited to get out of bed every morning?
- 16:24And so the more conversations I had with people who were in this life, the more I felt like,
- 16:29I want to do that. I want to be part of this where I can journey with people as they seek
- 16:34something deeper, something more meaningful. Eventually, there was no way again, my life is
- 16:39not 100% certainty. It's always going to be the case. There's no way to know if that's what God
- 16:44wants me to do. So I figured the only way to do it is to try it out, see how I feel. And so for seven,
- 16:50it's been seven years now, I'm still here. And I just feel like this is where God wants me to be.
- 16:55There's joy in my life, there's excitement, there's a sense of purpose. And I feel that's how God calls
- 17:02us by giving us a sense of purpose and a sense of feeling like this is what it's meant to be. Now God
- 17:08will not be unhappy if I leave or try something else. The main thing God wants from me is to
- 17:14seek Him. There are many ways to follow God and there might be some other way out there. But for
- 17:21me, it seems like this is the place that God wants me to be. So it's more of an invitation, I would say.
- 17:27The word call can sometimes have a more like a strong connotation. An invitation respects my
- 17:34freedom and my choice.
- 17:37Well, I'm really happy to hear that. You know, another perception I have of our Catholic priest is
- 17:43the austerity that comes with this vacation. And you don't think about being a Catholic priest as
- 17:50something joyous or, you know, that brings a lot of happiness in one's life. You think of someone
- 17:58who is very, who has, you know, lots of austerity, lots of, you know, just being very serious. But
- 18:07yeah, I'm so glad that we live in a world where this is an option, where you can choose to become
- 18:14a Catholic priest to just go beyond, you know, worldly matters and things like that, and find a
- 18:23lifestyle that truly, truly suits your needs or your personality in that way. Because thinking
- 18:33about it, there are not a lot of jobs resembling Catholic priests. Maybe a philosophy teacher in
- 18:41the university, maybe. So becoming vegan is, I said earlier, a bit like becoming a priest, but
- 18:54actually it's more like converting to another religion, because you make such radical changes
- 18:59in your life that there is no other comparable experience than converting to another religion.
- 19:07At least that's my perception. But becoming vegan was a decision closely related to your fate, and
- 19:15you actually published some essays related to that on your website. So tell us the story of
- 19:22your vegan journey. How did you become vegan? And why did you start advocating veganism?
- 19:28Because it's wanting to become vegan, but to take the step further, you know, to create your website
- 19:35and start speaking up about veganism, that's something else entirely.
- 19:40Yeah, that's the two parts of that question. The first thing about why I became vegan, you know,
- 19:46I would say, I think I always had that at the back of my mind. So when I was young, I grew up
- 19:52in the village. And so we had chickens and pigs for a while. And every time we slaughtered any of
- 19:59them, there was always something in me that would move me and I would try to be out of the house and
- 20:05I knew that, but that we're going to be slaughtering a chicken or a pig in our backyard,
- 20:09because I didn't want to hear the noise, the squealing, right? There was when I was young.
- 20:14And I think as we grow up, we are forced to think about like, okay, that's just how it is.
- 20:18You know, that's what we do. That's what we eat. So you would just have to deal with the pain
- 20:23somehow, because there's no other option. And I think I grew up to that. And then when I was,
- 20:30when I finished college, I was kind of like briefly interested in care for the environment.
- 20:36And I think I read an article saying that, you know, that meat and dairy is like the biggest
- 20:41contributor to global warming and things like that, or climate change as they call it. And so
- 20:46I became vegetarian for a while, right after college for maybe about a year or so,
- 20:52because I cared about the environment. Then I moved to the US. It was really hard to be
- 20:56vegetarian in the US, or at least I didn't try hard enough. So I forgot about that.
- 21:01Then Pope Francis wrote that encyclical, which you mentioned at the beginning, and I thought,
- 21:05okay, like I'm Catholic and the Pope says we need to care for creation. I don't seem to be doing
- 21:10anything about it. And so I remembered my time of being vegetarian. I was like, okay, I guess I
- 21:16could do that again. And so I became a weekday vegetarian. So I would not eat meat at all,
- 21:22Monday through Saturday, no need of Sunday. And so I thought, okay, everybody could reduce their
- 21:27meat consumption by 90%. We would, you know, really reduce our carbon emissions. I was like,
- 21:33okay, that makes sense logically. So all of us should aim to reduce our meat consumption.
- 21:37So those were, I think, baby steps. And then one day, I mentioned this in my website, this is like,
- 21:43you know, an important part of my journey. I met a student. So I was at St. Louis University
- 21:47studying philosophy. You know, I did think a little bit about the problem of evil, like the
- 21:52problem of suffering. There's so much suffering in the world. Like, what is God doing about this?
- 21:58Like, why is God not putting an end to suffering? So I had that sense of like, okay, I'm going to
- 22:03suffer in the world. Where is God? What is God doing about this? And one day when I was
- 22:09at the university, a student, he was a Hindu, and from India, or at least of Indian descent.
- 22:15So he recognized that I'm from India. So he came and talked to me and said, Okay, like, you know,
- 22:20you, you are Catholic, you're going to become a priest. And you say that you are following Jesus
- 22:25supposed to be like this really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really, really
- 22:31be like this really role model about peace and compassion and kindness, you know, the gospel,
- 22:38Jesus talked about love and care. So how can you as a follower of Jesus participate in something
- 22:46that's so cruel, something that's, you know, so unnecessary, and still call yourself a disciple?
- 22:53Right. And I thought, you know, wow, that's a good question. And I said, the Catholic Church,
- 22:58I've never really heard that eating meat is a sin. It's considered bad, like everybody's meat and
- 23:06those who are Catholics. But I gave it some thought. And it really made sense to me that
- 23:11like, the idea of being a Christian being a Catholic is about following Jesus. And if I'm
- 23:18going to be a disciple of Jesus, then I need to live the way he called us to live, show kindness
- 23:25and compassion. And obviously, showing kindness to a human is different from showing kindness to
- 23:31a dog or a cow. And it's different from showing kindness to a tree. Because a tree and a dog,
- 23:38and human experience love and kindness differently, but they all do experience kindness. And so what
- 23:43does it mean to show kindness to all and so that really stood with me. And I was like, you know,
- 23:48what, this is an important thing to think about. I'm also physically very healthy.
- 23:55And so I thought, okay, I don't want to like spoil my health, you know, maybe meat is needed for
- 24:01good functioning of my physical body. And I thought, I don't want to just give up meat and
- 24:06then become unhealthy. So I started doing some online research on Mayo Clinic and Cleveland
- 24:12Clinic, like reputed websites in the US. And they seem to suggest that it is quite okay to be vegan
- 24:19and be healthy, you get all the nutrients that you need. And then I watched the documentary Game
- 24:24Changers. And, you know, they talk a lot about how it actually improves one's health. But for me,
- 24:30it was less about high performance. I mean, I like being outside, but I'm not a high performance
- 24:35athlete. All I wanted to know was whether a vegan diet is neutral, meaning, can I just be healthy?
- 24:43I don't have to be a high performance athlete. And it turned out to be the case. Yes, it was. So
- 24:49you can be vegan, you can get all the nutrients you need. And that's it. Like, so why am I eating
- 24:54meat? Like, I don't need to eat meat. If I eat meat, or dairy or eggs, I'm causing unnecessary
- 25:01suffering. And around the same time, I also started reading about the Catholic Church stance on the
- 25:07issue. And there were a couple of lines that stood out to me, like two points, specifically,
- 25:13besides the idea of following Jesus. One was in the Bible, Genesis, that says, God gave humans
- 25:20plants to eat, very clearly said in the creation story that God gave humans plants to eat, not
- 25:26plants and animals. Later on, obviously, people started eating meat. But the idea is that God
- 25:33initially intended humans to eat plants. That's in the Bible. And the other is, there's a line in the
- 25:39Catechism. So besides the Bible, the Catholic Church also has a book called the Catechism,
- 25:44which is like a list of teachings on all sorts of topics. And there's a line that talks about
- 25:50our relationship with animals that says, it is contrary to human dignity, so it's not good for
- 25:56humans to cause animals to die needlessly. So it is not good for humans to cause animals to die
- 26:05needlessly. Now the word needless is doing a lot of heavy lifting there. Meaning, you can cause
- 26:12animals to die if it is needed, obviously. But it is not good if you cause animals to die needlessly.
- 26:20Now the question is, is need needed? So in an English sense, the word need is something that
- 26:28you cannot do without, like you have to have it. So I'd like to give the example of driving a car.
- 26:36So if you want to go from point A to point B, I need a car, say it's really far away, I need a car
- 26:44to go from A to B. But do I need a Ferrari? No, I could drive a Toyota. I still need to get from
- 26:52point A to point B, but what would be the best way to do it that would be in line with being a
- 26:59follower of Jesus? So Toyota would be something that's simple, it uses less money, it uses less
- 27:04gas. So do I need a car? Yes. Do I need a Ferrari? No. So I think of it as need as being a Ferrari.
- 27:14It is like a luxury. It is not needed. I could still survive and be happy and healthy by eating
- 27:20beans. So in that sense, need is needless. That's the way I see it. Need could be needed if you are
- 27:30on a desert island and you're dying of hunger and the only thing you can eat is like a deer. Well,
- 27:36you have to eat it. But in our culture here, I think need is needless. So anyway, those are the
- 27:42two lines about the Catholic faith that I think point towards the idea of care for animals.
- 27:49As to why I speak out about it, I think I wrote an essay about when silence is not an option. The
- 27:59idea basically is in our culture, we are very used to the idea that, hey, you do what you want,
- 28:05don't tell me what to do. It's a very libertarian view of things. I don't subscribe to it, but a
- 28:11lot of people say that's how we are supposed to be. But okay, fine, you do you. But the problem
- 28:17with you do you is when there is a victim involved, then what happens? So for example,
- 28:25if I steal something from somebody else, from Jim on the street, we don't say, okay, Daniel,
- 28:33you do you. You want to steal something from Jim, fine. No, we speak on behalf of Jim because Jim
- 28:39is a victim of robbery. We think we should care for Jim because Jim might not be able to care for
- 28:47himself. Maybe he's old or maybe he's disabled or maybe, I don't know, didn't want to fight.
- 28:53So in our society, we do speak on behalf of victims, like all sorts of victims, murder,
- 28:59theft, rape, other things. And so animals are voiceless victims. And so we cannot really just
- 29:08say you do you, right? Okay, I'm not eating meat, but I cannot just say you do you because
- 29:15we always speak up for victims in other cases, like robbery. We don't say, hey, you can go and
- 29:22rob whatever you want. I will not rob, but you can do what you want. That's not how it works.
- 29:27And so our Catholic faith calls us to speak on behalf of the victim, right? Especially in
- 29:35the victim's voices. And so that is my motivation, the idea that God calls us to love and also to
- 29:44encourage other people to love. So it's not like I just do my loving, I follow God's commands,
- 29:51and hopefully I will get to heaven. I don't care about you. I don't care about you. I don't care
- 29:56about you. So my idea of speaking up about veganism, I think that veganism is a good thing.
- 30:03Okay, it's a way that is calling me to love more fully, more completely, right? And so if I have
- 30:10found something good, I want to tell my friend Mike about this idea that shows me how to love
- 30:19more completely. So if Mike is my friend, I would want to tell Mike, hey, Mike, you know, I think
- 30:25God is calling us to love all creatures. And I think I want to invite you to consider loving
- 30:31all creatures as well. So it comes from a place of love, both for the victim and for the person
- 30:37who's committing problem, right? So when it comes to meat, I want to love the animals who are
- 30:43voiceless and supprent. So I want to love them and speak on their behalf. And I also want to love
- 30:49Mike who's eating meat because I want to tell Mike, I think there's a better way to live here,
- 30:53but you can show more kindness. And so it's from a place of love, right? So in the Catholic faith,
- 30:59the definition of love is, is to will the good of the other for their sake. Okay, so I must wish
- 31:06the good of the other for their own sake. So when I speak about veganism, it's from a place of love.
- 31:12I want to love the animal. I want to wish them well, one animal should suffer. And I also want
- 31:18to love Mike who's eating meat because I feel Mike is not being fully kind and compassionate.
- 31:25And so if, if I think this is a joyful and meaningful life of being vegan, I want my friend
- 31:32Mike to also participate in a joyful and meaningful life. Is that making sense?
- 31:37Yes, it makes a lot of sense. And I'm so happy that you put it that way, because that's how
- 31:42I actually feel. You know, when people ask me about my veganism, I always say it comes from
- 31:48a place of love. It's not that I feel pain thinking about animals and what they're going through,
- 31:57or I feel guilt or I feel anger. It's truly because I love animals. And I want people around me to
- 32:06to share that love for animals. Yeah. And you know, I think it's important to also talk about
- 32:13love for people who eat meat because I myself ate meat for many years. But secondly, to see that it
- 32:20is not casting judgment on meat eaters. So if I tell my friend Mike about veganism, it's not because
- 32:27I want to feel superior or I want to kind of put him down and kind of criticize his life and pass
- 32:33and pass some judgment on Mike. But I want to tell Mike like this idea of caring for animals,
- 32:39this idea of showing kindness and compassion is a more meaningful life. It is a more joyful life.
- 32:46And it is this living more closely to the call of love and passion that Jesus talked about. So if
- 32:52Mike is Catholic, I will, I will obviously approach Mike from a Catholic standpoint and say,
- 32:57like, Jesus calls us to love and show compassion. So, like, what does it mean to show love and
- 33:03compassion to a cow or a dog? And so if you think this will be a better way to live according to
- 33:11what Jesus is inviting us to do. So it's important to also talk about love for people who eat meat.
- 33:18Because I think a lot of times vegans can be seen as judgmental, you know, and like trying to like
- 33:25prove you wrong. But no, I think if we approach it from a space from the standpoint of love that
- 33:30Mike, like, I love you, I care about you. And so here is something I think of more meaningful
- 33:36and joyful way to live. That would be a very different approach from trying to prove that Mike
- 33:41is wrong. Well, that's a difficult one. And I certainly had to work on it because, you know,
- 33:50when I first became vegan, I had so much anger for people around me and for meat eaters. And,
- 34:00you know, I almost became that vegan who, you know, will not sit at the table where there is
- 34:07meat served or something like that, who, you know, I'm, I don't want to put judgment on vegans who
- 34:14take that stance, because it might be a good way to advocate for veganism, you know, showing,
- 34:21showing how veganism is important for you, to your to the people around you by, you know,
- 34:28taking the radical position of not sitting at the same table as they are. So maybe this is like,
- 34:36you can see it as a advocating technique, strategy. But if I'm thinking about the feelings,
- 34:48you know, I had that anger. And I often talk about it in my in those in this podcast,
- 34:55about the upset and the anger that many vegans feel toward other meat eaters, how they are
- 35:03frustrated with the situation, how they don't feel understood, how there's this horrible thing
- 35:10happening out there, and nobody seemed to pay attention to it. And the pent up feelings that
- 35:19you have thinking about it. So yeah, I really had personally had to work on it, just for the sake
- 35:27of my mental health. And that's what I say to vegans, you know, you don't have to forgive the
- 35:34the meat eaters or the people participating in the exploitation of animals, or not even love them,
- 35:41maybe you're not at that, you know, level. But at least don't feel upset about it, because it's
- 35:51going to eat away your mental health. Would you agree with that? Yeah, you know, we all have our
- 35:58journeys on how to come to terms with when the rest of the world doesn't seem to care. I'm
- 36:04actually working on an essay about the idea of living in hope. So for a Catholic, hope is a very
- 36:11important virtue. So for us, hope is the idea that God has good things planned for us in the future.
- 36:20And we know that God will give it to us. So I think that there are good things in the future,
- 36:27that God will, will bring peace on earth. You know, yeah, it is, it is, we all have different
- 36:36ways of dealing with it. One thing when I get upset, I, so I live with all non-vegans. So I
- 36:41have to see meat every day, my house and dinner, like, and it's hard. So first, I pray, I always
- 36:48pray. So I pray to that God gives me the strength to, to, to persevere, to continue with this cause,
- 36:55but also to just be kind and compassionate to the people around. I pray for the animals who had to
- 37:02die for this. And I pray that God, you know, bless them wherever they are after their death.
- 37:10And I think there's also a prayer in me that says that even if I don't see the results of my activism,
- 37:17it doesn't matter. Right. We are called to do good things. God invites us to do good things,
- 37:24even if nobody else is doing anything good. Right. So I doing good does not depend on how many people
- 37:32are doing, but I'm invited by God to do good. So I am trying my best to do good. I trust that God,
- 37:42the future sometime will bring peace on earth. So in our Catholic tradition, we believe that there
- 37:46will, like Jesus will come again. There will be the last judgment. And, you know, in the end, God will
- 37:53bring justice and mercy for all. So there's a sense that this is beyond my control. Right.
- 38:01Even if I'm the most famous vegan speaker out there, it is not going to change everybody. Like,
- 38:07that's just a given. I'm going to die long before people become vegan. That is just true. Like,
- 38:14not to compare myself, you know, with any great social justice advocates out there, but, you know,
- 38:21Martin Luther King comes to mind. Like, he knew he would be long dead before there's justice,
- 38:27racial justice. Jesus also died well before, you know, everything else that was supposed to happen,
- 38:36happened. So there's a real sense that I'm not in charge. God is in charge. Right. So I say my
- 38:43prayers. I pray that God gives me the strength. I pray for the animals. I pray for my friends
- 38:48and my Jesuit brothers that their hearts will be converted. And I just remind myself that God is
- 38:54in charge. Like, I'm not in charge. God is inviting me to do what I can. I also have a section on my
- 39:01website for prayers, especially for prayers that are asking us to, like, let go and let God be in
- 39:08charge and do what we can. There's a real sense of freedom and confidence that I will not see the
- 39:17results. I will not change the world. That's okay. I do what I can. I continue to ask God, okay, God,
- 39:24what do you want from me? I will try my best. If the world doesn't change, that is God's responsibility.
- 39:32God has a plan. For me, that is a constant prayer, right? That let me let go. I have not converted a
- 39:40single person in my life to veganism. Okay. Nobody has become vegan because of my, like, let me just
- 39:47put it out there, but that's okay. You know, it doesn't mean I should stop talking about it or
- 39:53stop being vegan. It's fine. Even if no one changes, that's okay. This is what God invites me to do.
- 39:59I'm doing my best. God is in charge. I hope that's helpful. First of all, you don't know. I mean,
- 40:05maybe you have influenced someone and that person just did not reach out. You know, that happened to
- 40:12me. You know, someone close to me who one day reached out and said, I'm vegan. And part of the
- 40:19reason why is because of you. You know, you have been a good example and you made me discover that
- 40:24whole world. And I was like, why didn't you say anything earlier? I mean, that would have been
- 40:31great for my self-esteem if I had known, uh, maybe two years earlier, but, um, yeah. And also,
- 40:41I, I am realizing how important religion is, um, in, you know, maintaining, um, a sort of
- 40:50mental health in our modern modern society. We tend to, you know, put religion aside, but
- 40:57truly when you think about the great, um, people behind social justice movements, like Martin
- 41:04Luther King, like Nelson Mandela, uh, and others, faith had played a big role in, uh, their activism.
- 41:13Um, and I think had participated in preventing that, um, activism fatigue that many of us have.
- 41:26Um, but in their case, it was about, you know, racial justice, uh, and other cause, but yeah,
- 41:33I think that spirituality can, can be helpful for, for some vegans out there, um, in, you know,
- 41:41maintaining, um, their, their beliefs, maintaining their, their mental health.
- 41:47Yeah. You know, I don't want to speak on behalf of, of vegans who are not spiritual or not religious.
- 41:53So we all have to figure out what will give us, because I tend to see, or at least in my
- 41:59conversations with vegans in person, but also online, there's a lot of emphasis on, on the
- 42:07effect that they are having. So as I said, nobody has converted because of me. I'm fine with that,
- 42:13because my idea of being vegan is that I can serve God, I can get closer to God.
- 42:19That is independent of what happens around me. So if one does not have that sense of,
- 42:26of a higher purpose, then the purpose has to come from around you. So if it is not from there,
- 42:33it has to come from around, right? And so if around you, you are seeing no effect at all,
- 42:39people are just eating meat all the time, you are surrounded by me. No one seems to care about your
- 42:44veganism. No one wants to talk to you about veganism, or no one wants to talk to you because you
- 42:49are vegan now. Now you've suddenly, your purpose that is coming from around you seems hopeless.
- 42:56My purpose comes from God. So that sense that, okay, like no matter what is happening around me,
- 43:03I'm invited to follow God and try my best to invite other people. You know, and there's a real
- 43:09sense that even if there are no results, that's fine. I have lived the best way I can, the way God
- 43:16invited me. And God is in charge. So there's a real sense of letting go, right? And so I think,
- 43:22for me, spirituality is an important factor. And the other place where I think spirituality
- 43:29has been important for me in the whole conversation about veganism, I've actually had this
- 43:35conversation with people where they say, how do you know, like, why is killing animals bad?
- 43:42And if there's no, like, transcendent element to this, there is no right answer to this.
- 43:50There is no right and wrong. So those who are radical materialists, all that is, is atoms and
- 43:58molecules. I'm made of atoms and molecules. The tree is made of atoms and molecules. The dog is
- 44:03made of atoms and molecules. There is no morality. There's no right and wrong. Like, why is it wrong
- 44:09to kill a dog? If I want to eat a dog, I should eat a dog. The only reason I will not kill a dog
- 44:15is because I might be sent to jail. Because that is, at least in the US, you cannot kill dogs.
- 44:22So then morality becomes dependent only on the law. And so it is impossible to have a conversation
- 44:29with somebody who just does not care, who does not believe there's a right or wrong. There is no
- 44:36sense of heaven or judgment. I'll just do whatever I want, as long as I don't get arrested. That is
- 44:44a very common morality in the US. I will do whatever I want, as long as I don't get arrested.
- 44:50Well, there's no way to have that conversation. So I always approach veganism from a standpoint of
- 44:57following Jesus. So I can only talk to Christians. Like, it's really hard for me to talk to someone
- 45:03who doesn't have a wider view of the world. Because if a person doesn't care, there's nothing I can
- 45:11say. But if a person says he's a Christian, then I can ask him, okay, you are a Christian, you claim
- 45:18to follow Jesus. What do you think about Jesus' command to love others? Does the others involve
- 45:25animals? Would you kill a dog or a cow just for the sake of it? If Jesus is standing, imagine Jesus
- 45:35standing next to you. Would you kill a cow or a dog or a pig just for fun? Imagine you've had a
- 45:42nice meal of chickpeas and curry, and you are fully satisfied. You're not hungry or starving,
- 45:50and you are hanging out with Jesus. And you see a pig walking by, would you just take a knife and
- 45:56slaughter the pig? What would Jesus think about that? So I use Jesus as a starting point, because
- 46:02when I talk to Christians, I know I have something in common. If I talk to people who are not
- 46:08religious, it's really hard to find a starting point. Now, if they say that they are compassionate
- 46:13and kind people, okay, that's a starting point. But I've had people who say they don't care.
- 46:18If they say they don't care, I don't know what else to say. There's nothing I can say that's
- 46:23going to change their mind. So it's easier for me, there's some spirituality involved.
- 46:28You know, I would say first of all, to those people who are not religious, because I myself,
- 46:33I'm not someone who's particularly religious, but it brings a lot, a great deal of happiness and peace
- 46:40to follow some moral rules in your own life to know that your presence, your existence is not
- 46:53your existence is not causing harm to other beings, that you're actually making a good
- 46:59difference, a positive difference in this world. I don't know in in my case, that's where I found
- 47:08a great deal of meaning in terms of what I'm doing my actions. Yeah, I mean, that experience you were
- 47:17talking about about people basing their whole moral view of the world on rules, and the legality of it,
- 47:28I actually encountered that with that same scenario with religious people arguing with me how,
- 47:38you know, it's not in my religion. So why should I care? You know, God does not require that from me.
- 47:44So no, I will not give up meat, I will not give up dairy. And that's why I'm so happy to find people
- 47:54like you who, in my book, are more consistent, you know, for me, someone who defends the environment
- 48:03should be vegan. If you care about the environment, and you're not vegan, then I'm sorry, but I won't
- 48:11listen to you. This is not this not making sense. Just as someone who claims to be religious claims
- 48:20to follow a higher purpose, but is not vegan. What are you doing? What about you know, the mass
- 48:27slaughter of billions of sentient beings, and you're just passing by that, that fact that horrible
- 48:34evil, and saying that you're still, you know, a good religious person, you know, doesn't make much
- 48:44sense to me. You should at least show some sympathy to that cause, if you're not ready to become vegan.
- 48:53Yeah, you're right. There are many religious people who follow like a rules based idea of faith.
- 48:59You know, I would invite them. So the way I see the Catholic faith, and I think the Catholic
- 49:05Church is talking more about this idea of moving from a rules based approach to what we call a
- 49:12discipleship approach. So the faith over time became more about following a bunch of rules,
- 49:20doing certain things, and then hoping to go to heaven, right. And but now we talk more about
- 49:25discipleship, like our whole lives now, and in heaven, is about being a disciple of Jesus Christ.
- 49:33So everything needs to be viewed through that lens, right. So the way I talk to people,
- 49:41what I do with my free time, whether I go to church, you know, the way I treat those who are,
- 49:47you know, poor, all that is about discipleship, not about rules based. And so I think I would
- 49:55encourage religious people to view Christianity, I speak of Christianity here, to view Christianity
- 50:02as a discipleship, a sense of every little thing brings me closer to Jesus or takes me away from
- 50:09Jesus. And I need to examine my life through that lens, not whether I'm checking a bunch of things
- 50:15off the checklist, but whether something I do and care about is it bringing me closer to Jesus.
- 50:24I think that would be a healthy way of looking at our faith. And the care for the environment
- 50:31thing, you know, I have a way from when we talk about care for the environment, care for creation
- 50:37for two reasons. One is the word environment, or in Christian terms, we say creation,
- 50:44is this amorphous, faceless entity, this whole universe around me. There's no sense of
- 50:52relationship with that. It's just too big. The universe is so large. What can I, as a small
- 51:00person in this huge universe do to care for the universe, for the environment? It's just so big.
- 51:07It's so out there. It's faceless. There's no relationship. We should talk about creatures,
- 51:15each individual creature. How do I care for a tree? How do I care for a dog? How do I care for a dog?
- 51:21Those are individual creatures. That makes a relationship possible. The other reason I don't
- 51:29talk about care for environment as much anymore is because it becomes a sense of I care about the
- 51:35environment because if I don't, I will be suffering. So when we talk about climate change,
- 51:41oh, I want to care for the environment only because I don't want to suffer, or we humans
- 51:47don't want to suffer. So it becomes a very transactional care and concern. It's no longer
- 51:53about care because for its own sake, it's care because I am worried what will happen if I don't
- 51:59care. And so I think of it more as I have received a gift from God. All of the world around me is a
- 52:07gift from God. How do I treat that gift with respect? So that is my concern about care for
- 52:16the environment. It becomes very transactional versus the idea of receiving it as a gift and
- 52:22respecting it. So those are my two points about what you said. But I hope everybody is caring in some way
- 52:29or the other. I just feel like we could look at care for the environment slightly differently
- 52:35because I think it will help us have a better relationship with the world around us.
- 52:42I'm so glad to hear you say that because I always had the belief that the environment argument
- 52:50is not strong enough to convince someone to make such radical changes in their lives and become vegan.
- 52:59And even if it is, are they going to stay vegan for the following months, years? No. The best
- 53:13way to stay vegan, I think, is to think about the ethical side of things and the creatures that you
- 53:19are impacting. So let me ask you something I'm dying to ask you actually. I'm glad, like I said
- 53:30before, that religious leaders like yourself are concerned with animal welfare and advocating for
- 53:37a vegan lifestyle. However, my criticism has always been that veganism is presented as a good
- 53:44addition to your spiritual, religious practice. It's a plus, but it's certainly not a requirement.
- 53:53A practice that I would compare to that is meditation. It's a plus in your religious practice,
- 54:01but it's not a requirement. Or pilgrimage. You can make a pilgrimage, but it's not a requirement.
- 54:10So, you know, my question is, would you consider talking about vegan lifestyle as not just a plus
- 54:23in a spiritual practice, but really as a requirement, something that is the will of God,
- 54:33actually, and that if you're not vegan, that would be considered as being sinful. You know, eating meat
- 54:45should be considered sinful. So is this too radical or did you ever consider that question
- 54:55in those terms? Yeah, that is a rather deep and complicated question. I will not make any
- 55:02pronouncements on whether it should be a requirement or church teaching. Again, I will go back to the
- 55:09idea of discipleship or the idea of relationship, since that might be a more common word out there.
- 55:16Relationship. So if you love your mom, okay, so every interaction with your mom
- 55:25is something that strengthens or weakens the relationship. So I wouldn't rule something out
- 55:30completely. Yeah, you could hurt your mom, but she might still have a relationship with you. But if
- 55:34you keep hurting her all the time, well, that's not good. So if you really care about your mom,
- 55:40and you love your mom, you might start doing things that will strengthen that relationship, right?
- 55:47So that's always a good way to think about what is sin. So again, moving away from the rules-based
- 55:55approach, the idea of sin now is since the past 60, 70 years, is talked more about as turning away
- 56:04from God. So it's not like I did this, therefore it's a sin. It's more like, is my life towards God,
- 56:15or is it away from God? Are my actions and my thoughts moving me towards God or away from God?
- 56:20So any thoughts, words, or actions that move me away from God is a sin. And so if we knowingly
- 56:31participate in cruelty, I think it is turning away from God, because we believe God is love.
- 56:38And so cruelty is not associated with love. And so that idea of participating in cruelty, knowingly
- 56:47and willingly, is turning away from God. So I don't like to use the word requirement. Again,
- 56:56I think I have a strong sense of freedom and free will and things like that. I think if we start
- 57:02viewing things as loving God and moving towards God, we will examine all aspects of our lives,
- 57:10not just what we eat, but the way we talk to people, what do we spend money on? We care for
- 57:15the people. What do I read? What kind of media I consume? Again, this is not because I'm
- 57:22scared of going to hell or I'm in a straight jacket, I'm always walking with a serious face,
- 57:28but the sense is I want to be with God. And so I examine all aspects of my life through that lens,
- 57:35including what I eat. So I wouldn't call it rules or sin or requirement, but more of a sense of
- 57:43really wanting to be a follower of Jesus and then examining all aspects of my life.
- 57:51So I cannot be vegan and then just be really hateful to the people who eat meat around.
- 57:57That's not helpful. Now, it's good to be vegan, but now that I'm being hateful to the guys around
- 58:02me, well, that's not helpful. But all aspects of my life, how am I responding to all situations
- 58:08in the most loving manner? And that is kind of the approach I'm trying to advocate through my
- 58:15advocacy on my website is that we need to view our life as a relationship with God, with people,
- 58:23with animals. And all of those relationships have to have a positive sense to it. You have to have
- 58:31a sense of kindness, compassion, care. And I think I would encourage the church, who I was listening
- 58:39from the church, to start seeing our faith as a relationship with Jesus, not as a set of rules,
- 58:49and whether we're going to go to hell or whether we commit a sin. Is that a helpful answer? I'm
- 58:55not trying to evade your question, but I think that's the way I see it.
- 58:58No, I think I understand it because like you said earlier, you're trying to avoid
- 59:03judging other people. And I guess it's part of that. Then let me ask you, if the church
- 59:13publishes like a decree or something saying, okay, now eating meat is considered sinful,
- 59:22would you agree with that decree? Would you follow that position?
- 59:28Yes, that would be easy for me. I would agree with it. Again, so the definition of sin,
- 59:34right? Again, is any action that turns you away from God, that's a sin. So the church says
- 59:43eating meat turns you away from God. I would agree. Right? So I think that's the way I would
- 59:50agree. Right? I think causing suffering in animals, knowingly, willingly, is moving ourselves away
- 1:00:01from love. God is love. So by causing suffering and pain, we are not being loving. So I would agree
- 1:00:08with that. Whenever you see the word sin, church teaching, I would encourage you and other listeners
- 1:00:15to just have that definition of sin. If the church says something is sin, just think of it as
- 1:00:24turning away from God. And I would agree if the church comes up with a compliment that says
- 1:00:29something like that. And another question I am dying to ask you is about evil. I tend to use
- 1:00:42the word evil to describe the animal industry and animal exploitation. And I cannot find another
- 1:00:50word actually to describe that because it's such a hurtful industry, not just for the animals,
- 1:00:59but also for the workers, for the environment. It's like every way you look at it, this industry
- 1:01:08is doing something wrong or is hurting someone somewhere. So I want to know, am I using this
- 1:01:18word correctly? Can I have your theological approval of the use of this word? Or does evil
- 1:01:30have another meaning here that escapes me? And do you agree with that assessment that this industry
- 1:01:39is actually evil? Yeah, the word evil is rather a strong word. I don't have a clear grasp of
- 1:01:49what is the context in the Catholic faith. The best definition I've heard of evil,
- 1:01:54a shorthand, is the absence of God. So God in the Catholic tradition is all good. God is perfect.
- 1:02:04So God is complete goodness, truth, and beauty. So an absence of God, so an absence of truth,
- 1:02:12an absence of goodness, an absence of beauty is evil. In the animal industry, especially the
- 1:02:22factory farming industry, I think that's an absence of goodness. Sentient creatures, creatures who can
- 1:02:30be pain and suffering are put in such horrible conditions for their whole life. That is an
- 1:02:37absence of goodness. So that's evil. And I would kind of use that lens of seeing the animal industry
- 1:02:47as it is an absence of goodness. And so an absence of goodness would mean an absence of God.
- 1:02:54And so it could be seen as evil. But the word evil can be kind of a strong word,
- 1:03:02mainly because we tend to look at evil from a human suffering standpoint. A lot of people
- 1:03:08don't want to equate humans and animals. So that is where I see there might be some concern about
- 1:03:17using the word evil in a non-human context. If we're thinking about that evil, how is it
- 1:03:25possible to still believe in a benevolent God who is there looking at this and not intervening?
- 1:03:35Because I feel like at least in my personal experience, what makes me the most skeptical
- 1:03:42about the existence of God is looking at pictures of factory farming. It just makes me doubt that
- 1:03:53there is any force of goodness, mighty force of goodness out there. But I feel like this is the
- 1:04:01opposite for you. You talked in the beginning of this interview about that drowning episode
- 1:04:09that truly marked you during your college years. And that made you closer to God and to your faith,
- 1:04:20which in my case, that would have made me take my distance from faith and God. So I'm just wondering,
- 1:04:29how do you conceptualize that whole situation? How do you make sense of that great evil
- 1:04:41existing despite the existence of God? Yeah, before I answer the question,
- 1:04:48I just want to clarify or make a comment about, I personally don't like to compare animal suffering
- 1:04:56with human suffering. It just causes too many problems in the conversation. It diverts our
- 1:05:02attention and people will immediately say, oh, you're comparing animals with humans. So I would
- 1:05:07probably not compare those two. But the wider question about the existence of a loving God
- 1:05:15and the existence of evil. One is, I cannot, this is an emotional response to this. I cannot
- 1:05:24imagine suffering just being random. This seems so pointless. So a homeless person on the street
- 1:05:32or someone who lost his legs in a car crash, that just being completely random and not having any
- 1:05:41meaning just seems completely unfair. That I am living a comfortable life. I'm healthy. I have
- 1:05:50friends. I'm happy. While somebody else is suffering and it having no meaning or no purpose
- 1:05:57just seems so unfair. So that was, I think, my initial point. And you remember what I mentioned
- 1:06:04about my college years. So that was kind of what I was thinking about. But then from a positive sense,
- 1:06:10how do I explain it? I don't want to give any philosophical explanation in case someone is
- 1:06:15actually suffering, either physically or emotionally. And I'm giving some easy answers.
- 1:06:22All I will say is, I try to be humble and tell myself, I don't know the big picture.
- 1:06:28Right. I have one certain example about like, think about like reading the Lord of the Rings.
- 1:06:35You read the whole book and you kind of know what's happening and they finally finish the quest and
- 1:06:41you know, goodness and kindness eventually wins, that evil is destroyed. Yay, everybody's happy.
- 1:06:47But there's a long quest, right? But imagine if the Lord of the Rings trilogy, the three books
- 1:06:54are like torn up, all the pages are scattered. And you just pick some random page somewhere and
- 1:07:00that page is talking about the depths of evil, right? Of Sauron and all that. And you're like,
- 1:07:08wow, this is such a horrible book. Like, wow, this book is just completely about evil and pain.
- 1:07:14But no, you have not seen the whole book, right? And so, I remind myself that I don't know the
- 1:07:22whole book. God is the only one who knows the whole book. And I have to trust that God,
- 1:07:28who created me, has a point, has a purpose. Otherwise, God is a trickster. God must be laughing
- 1:07:36at me right now. But I think a God who is so powerful and so mighty, doesn't need means
- 1:07:47so that he can make jokes. Like, you know, it doesn't make sense to me that an all-powerful God
- 1:07:52makes humans just so that he can laugh at you. So, I think God has a purpose, has a plan.
- 1:08:01And so, that trust, when I see one page of a 2,000-page book, I have to somehow trust that
- 1:08:08the other pages have meaning and purpose. And in the end, good will win, right? That God will use
- 1:08:16the suffering that is around us for some good. And animals who are suffering, I hope God will
- 1:08:24somehow redeem their suffering. Maybe animals have a faith life, you know, maybe animals,
- 1:08:30like God relates to animals in a way that animals are capable of. Now, I can say a prayer,
- 1:08:37because that is my human capacity, but a cow might be able to relate to God in a way that is
- 1:08:45acceptable to the level of the cow, right? So, if God created me, God gave me a way to relate to God,
- 1:08:54it's a gift from God. So, if God made a cow, I trust that God has given the cow a way to relate
- 1:09:02to God. And so, when a cow is in a factory farm, I just pray that God somehow relates to the cow
- 1:09:08and consoles the cow. And when the cow dies, I hope God will somehow redeem the suffering,
- 1:09:17right? Because God doesn't need our suffering. God is not a masochist, you know, God doesn't make,
- 1:09:24God is not happy by seeing us suffer, right? Because God is all-powerful. God doesn't need us
- 1:09:32to make him happy. And so, that is my way of seeing evil, right? To really trust that God
- 1:09:39wants good things for all of us, animals, plants, myself, you know, and that when we have evil,
- 1:09:45we have to somehow trust that the big picture God is in charge of, right? And so, God is
- 1:09:53God is in charge. God is writing this book that has an ending where we will all be with God
- 1:10:01and filled with love, joy, and peace in the end. This is not the end. So, there's a saying,
- 1:10:08all will be well in the end. If it's not well, it's not the end. And so, we truly believe that
- 1:10:14in the end, all will be well in heaven. Right now, it's obviously not well. And I have to trust it
- 1:10:20is not the end right now. And I think this will be a challenge in your vegan advocacy. Hopefully,
- 1:10:28in the future, you will have a congregation. I think that's the right term. And when you're
- 1:10:33going to talk about veganism, I think people will ask you about that because there are so many
- 1:10:40people out there who just don't want to confront the reality of animal exploitation because
- 1:10:47it's too much, it's too evil, too hurtful. Just accepting that reality would mean to challenge
- 1:10:58your beliefs. And I think many believers, including Catholics out there, need to find an answer to
- 1:11:08that because vegans in general are vocal about it. So, you will be confronted with that reality.
- 1:11:20At some point, you will see anonymous for the voiceless doing, I think they call that a cube
- 1:11:29of truth in the streets, showing footage of what is happening inside slaughterhouses. So, at some
- 1:11:37point, you will be confronted with that and you will have to make a decision. Are you going to
- 1:11:43become vegan? How are you going to make sense of what is happening? And so on.
- 1:11:49Yeah. I mean, I obviously am confronted all the time with people around me or people asking
- 1:11:55questions. And my philosophy is to continue asking questions and to continue my thought process.
- 1:12:02I think someone once said, when you are presented with new information, what do you do? I changed
- 1:12:11my mind. What do you do? So, maybe there might be some other argument out there that I have not
- 1:12:15considered. An argument for eating meat that I have not yet heard. I have not heard anything good so
- 1:12:22far, but I'm open that there might be some argument out there that I've not thought about. So, I
- 1:12:27continue just being open to conversation, to being open to challenge and not to fall into the sunk
- 1:12:35cost fallacy. The idea that because I have spoken so much about veganism and all that,
- 1:12:41I have to hold on to it despite all the evidence. I want to be open that if there's a really good
- 1:12:46argument out there, I would love to hear it and really consider it from a philosophical
- 1:12:51standpoint and also from a faith standpoint. It's a challenge, people. I'm also very doubtful
- 1:13:00about that. I see what anti-vegans just, how they comment on my posts and the messages they send me.
- 1:13:09It's mostly trying to attack your person or just making jokes out of what you're saying.
- 1:13:19It's never a good argument or good, it's quoting a weird study about how I would lose my limbs
- 1:13:28because of my diet or something like that. So, it's always something strange.
- 1:13:35My final question for you would be, did you have something to add?
- 1:13:40My main invitation is this love for all of God's creatures. Ask yourself what is
- 1:13:47the most important thing in your life? What do you want your life's story to be when people talk
- 1:13:53about you in the present or in the future? What would you want them to say about you?
- 1:13:59If kindness and compassion is to be a part of your story, I would invite you to consider
- 1:14:05kindness and compassion to all the creatures out there, plants, animals, humans. To really
- 1:14:12see, to really make your story one that is worth celebrating.
- 1:14:19Amazing. I love that. Those are great final words. So, thank you so much, Daniel, for your time,
- 1:14:25for having accepted to be a guest on the podcast. Thank you so much for the great work you are doing
- 1:14:33and for representing, because I'm sure there are plenty of vegan Catholics out there who see you
- 1:14:41and see what you're doing and thinking, yes, great, some good representation, someone who
- 1:14:47expresses our feelings out loud and who is part of the Catholic Church leadership.
- 1:14:55So, thank you so much, Daniel.
- 1:14:58You're welcome. Thank you for your work as well, Ryan.
- 1:15:01Thank you, everyone, for listening. I really enjoyed this conversation. Daniel is very smart,
- 1:15:07thoughtful and insightful. The Catholic clergy is lucky to have him. And I'm happy to know he is
- 1:15:15vegan. Please visit vegancatholic.org to support his work. If you know people who are Catholic,
- 1:15:22share with them the link to his website or, of course, to this episode. And finally,
- 1:15:29let me know if you liked this conversation. Leave me a good review or reach out to me on
- 1:15:35Instagram at veganreportpodcast. Thank you again for listening. Take care and see you next Tuesday
- 1:15:42for a new episode.