Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP218: Things Aren't Always What They Seem
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Hi everyone, welcome to this episode of
- 0:39Crimes and Consequences. I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, my lovely co host,
- 0:44and I have a great story for you all today. I mean, shouldn't
- 0:50say great. Yeah, you know what we mean. But yeah, this
- 0:54story has a lot of twists and turns, and sometimes things aren't always what
- 1:00they seem. That's ominous. Ominous. I'm gonna tell you about the Trover
- 1:07family. The Trover family exemplified the quintessential, wholesome all American family. They
- 1:19had There was a father and that he had a wife, and there was
- 1:27a daughter and a son, and everything was going really well for them.
- 1:34John was the dad and Cheryl Trover was the mom, but she went by
- 1:40Sherry, okay, and they lived this just so you know, this happens
- 1:45in December of nineteen ninety eight, and this quintessential family first in a shocking
- 2:00but let me explain. They lived in this very small town. It's called
- 2:06Gillette and it's in Wyoming. I think I had like, well seventeen thousand
- 2:12people, which isn't I guess all that small considering where I grew up.
- 2:15Yeah, there were like two two people. It's a coal mining town.
- 2:22Like I said, there's about seventeen thousand people. It's surrounded by rolling prairies
- 2:30and antelopes would roam free, like I mean, we're in Wyoming. Yeah,
- 2:37have you been, No, I say when I picture Wyoming, though,
- 2:40there's a lot of I've been there, land and mountains and yeah,
- 2:46animals, yea natural nature nature. The trop family was well known around town.
- 2:53I mean everybody liked them. The parents, for example, Sherry,
- 3:00she was a math teacher at one of the high schools. And John worked
- 3:07at a coal like for a coal mining company. But he wasn't a coal
- 3:14miner. He did like office work okay, okay, and he was he
- 3:21was an accountant for them. He had been previously married once and he had
- 3:27an older daughter. And I don't know if I said that. They had
- 3:31two children. One was named Tory Okay, she's thirteen. And then they
- 3:38had a son, and his name was Jackson and he's ten. So John
- 3:45had been married before he had custody of his older daughter. I believe her
- 3:50name was Brooke. I'm not one hundred percent sure. It was very hard
- 3:54to find information on this case, and there's a reason why, but I'll
- 4:00talk about that later. So John's forty three, Sherry is thirty eight.
- 4:05They got two children. You know, she's elementary school math teacher. He's
- 4:13gotten an accountant job. Everything is good and in public, everything seemed fine
- 4:21with the family. There's nothing to know. They were just a normal family.
- 4:29However, on Friday, December fourth of nineteen ninety eight, that's when
- 4:38something horrendous happens. Yes changed, That's when the bubble. So the Trorer
- 4:46family, it's a Friday night. They want to go out teat. They're
- 4:48going to go out tea, so they decide to go to this local sports
- 4:51bar. It's called Humphrey's Bar and Girl. It's maybe ten minutes away from
- 4:59their house. It's not far. They go there, they're having dinner and
- 5:03when they get done, they head back to their home and it's on Granite
- 5:09Street. The home is just to describe it a little bit, it's two
- 5:14stories. It's twenty eight hundred square feet. It actually has five bedrooms,
- 5:18two bathrooms. Yeah, two bathrooms. But in America, it's kind of
- 5:26like your normal house, right, that's kind of big. Twenty one hundred
- 5:31square feet is big. Okay, Well, I'm just saying. I'm just
- 5:34saying. I mean, I mean five bedrooms. That's a big house.
- 5:40I know. I don't know how they have five bedrooms and twenty eight hundred
- 5:43square feet though. Yeah, but they also had a basement, so maybe
- 5:46there was a budget. Yeah. So they get home, it's Friday night,
- 5:53it's about ten thirty. What are the kids do? They go to
- 5:56the rooms. That's what I would have done. They're done, Yeah,
- 6:00hanging out with mom and dad. I already hung out with mom and dad,
- 6:01did my time. I'm done. So John decides he's going to get
- 6:08ready for bed, and Sherry is like cleaning up around the house, locking
- 6:15the doors, shutting the lights off, doing whatever moms do at the end
- 6:19of the day, which you all, you know, cleaning up all the
- 6:24messes and cleaning up everybody else's along with my own, right, And so
- 6:31she shuts up the lights, locks the doors, and John goes into the
- 6:36master bedroom suite and then somebody starts knocking on the door and John goes to
- 6:48open the door because Sherry is somewhere, maybe in the basement, I don't
- 6:54know. And he's he's wearing his box or shorts, but he's very cautious,
- 6:59Okay, he's not just like a wide open And he does open the
- 7:05door, and when he does, there is somebody wearing a mask in overalls,
- 7:15and immediately John gets attacked by this person and they're struggling. Nobody else
- 7:26in the house can hear it. I don't know the layout of the house,
- 7:30but nobody could hear it. But then this intruder fired two shots at
- 7:38John. One struck him in his arm and the other was his head,
- 7:44but neither one was life threatening, so I don't know exactly where it hit
- 7:50him in the hud, but it did damage but not enough to kill him.
- 7:56Okay, he wasn't dead. He managed eventually to get up and stumble
- 8:03slowly around the living room, but it took a while. It took a
- 8:09little bit. I mean, there's probably shock going on for him, and
- 8:15he's bleeding and he's like what that? Yeah, what what the hell is
- 8:18going on? The intruder shifted his focus onto the children, and he went
- 8:26into the rooms and he tied their hands and their feet together so they couldn't
- 8:33move, and then they could hear like a stirring. The children could around
- 8:43the house noises, arguing, voices arguing, but they were bound and they
- 8:54were gagged too. Sherry, here's the commotion, and from wherever she is,
- 9:01and I don't know where she was at the time, she bumps into
- 9:07the intruder and he restrains her. Similarly, he's got her hands and her
- 9:13feet bound. And eventually, as I was saying, so you have Sherry
- 9:24bound, you have Tory bound, and then you have Jackson bound, and
- 9:31you have John who's been shot in the arm and shot in the head.
- 9:35John is stumbling now around the house. So the intruder realizes like John's getting
- 9:41up and decides to spend his attention on John because John isn't dead. The
- 9:52intruder retreat a knife, and I'm not sure where the knife came from,
- 9:56but I believe it was a hunting knife. I don't know if it was
- 9:58brought at the scene or there's, like I said, minimum information on this
- 10:07case. For a reason. He was stabbed multiple times and then his throat
- 10:15was cut o man, and then he was dragged from the main living room
- 10:22into the family's basement. Okay, and that's where he was actually finished off.
- 10:28Was in the basement. That's where the throat being cut happened. This
- 10:39intruder decides to take Sherry and put her in the family truck and drive off.
- 10:48That had to be terrifying. Yeah, with her kids tied up and
- 10:54her husband, she probably didn't even know where he was. I mean,
- 11:03so she's bound, she's gagged. The intruder walks her into their own truck
- 11:11and he secures her. He puts a seatbelt done okay, just for safety
- 11:18reasons, I don't know. And he drives her to this secluded place and
- 11:24it's in the southern part of Jellette. It's it's known as like South Road.
- 11:31Okay. So this truck comes to a halt and then Sherry is forcibly
- 11:39well why she's sitting there. Her clothes are like ripped from her while she's
- 11:46restrained, which is strange, okay, And she couldn't defend herself, and
- 11:52then she was raped after she was I mean, Sherry fought really hard for
- 12:01the record, just want everybody to know that she managed to escape. Wow,
- 12:05which is amazing, amazing because her feet in her hands are bound and
- 12:13she runs from the truck and the intruder chases her into the woods, but
- 12:22somehow or somehow she escapes. The assailant decides give up the chase and light
- 12:33the truck on fire. What but he didn't do a good job, Like
- 12:37I don't know, I don't know how he did it, like try to.
- 12:43But it did catch on fire, but it wasn't like a huge blaze.
- 12:48It was just enough to eventually, at five am, catch the attention
- 12:56of some passerbys and they noticed that this truck is on fire, and they
- 13:05actually put out the fire. They did. Yeah right, that wouldn't be
- 13:11my first reaction. No, I just feel like nine to one more.
- 13:13Yeah right, No, they put out the fire. So it had only
- 13:18been a few minutes since that fire was started that they put out the fire.
- 13:24And then as they're doing that, they discover Sherry and she is hiding
- 13:31naked in this covert nearby. Her hands again and feet are bound, and
- 13:37she's hysterical. She recounted her ordeal to them and they immediately contacted. It's
- 13:48called Campbell County, the Sheriff's Department to report the incident. Sherry provided law
- 13:56enforcement with a detailed account of the events that transpired at our home. She's
- 14:03an the assault by her attacker, who is, by the way, wearing
- 14:07a mask. Nothing more scary than opening the door and there's someone with a
- 14:13fucking mask. Following her testimony in the description of the assailant, there was
- 14:20this manhunt launched and fifty detectives. I mean, this is a small area.
- 14:26You have to remember, we're helping out trying to figure this out because
- 14:31this is scary. There were sheriffs, detect deputies, police officers, members
- 14:39of the Wyoming I'm sorry, my phone is going off. I'm just gonna
- 14:43be honest. I shut off the volume. Sure you did, I did,
- 14:50but it's going off. But we're not gonna We're not gonna let but
- 14:54traditionally it is not work. But I'm you know, I want to turn
- 15:01it up. Mine never goes off. No, you're beeped the other day
- 15:05once. Okay, Okay, anyway, it doesn't matter. It's one of
- 15:09your quirks that I love so much. I know I don't understand it anyway.
- 15:13Can I just go on, yes? Please? Okay, So we
- 15:15have what the Wyoming Highway Patrol fire agencies. They have two airplanes, two
- 15:20search dogs. You've got the share of. Their primary objective was to locate
- 15:28this person that Sherry described as being dark skinned. It was a dark skinned
- 15:35man who had allegedly fled on foot. Sherry believes she recognized him and he
- 15:43was from minds for John Morton. She also told police officers that John had
- 15:48been receiving, and this is true, threatening phone calls from a woman who
- 15:56was very upset because rumors were going on the mind was going to close,
- 16:03and he's the accountant, and so he was getting in the weeks before his
- 16:08death, these threatening phone calls, but he didn't report him. Not his
- 16:15fault, I know, it's not his I know account they're just pissed.
- 16:22I mean, this woman would call repeatedly with threats. So after Sherry gets
- 16:30discovered and she you know, she's talking to police, the police go to
- 16:36her house, right and when they get there, they see the lifeless body
- 16:41of John Trover and he just he's covered in blood. I mean, he's
- 16:47bent, his throat's been slit, he's been stay dab shot shot twice.
- 16:53Uh. The medical examiner revealed that John had suffered gunshot wounds to his arm
- 16:59had and then multiple stab wounds to his upper tors and then those wounds had
- 17:06punctured his lung and his heart and then his throat slip. In the bedrooms,
- 17:15they found thirteen year old Tory bound on the bed, and then they
- 17:21found ten year old Jackson bound on the bed, but they weren't harmed.
- 17:29And when the police initially saw them, they said they could hear struggling outside
- 17:37of their bedroom doors. So police and investigators from the Wyoming State Crime Lab,
- 17:45they conducted a thorough search of the Trover property right humming through the scene.
- 17:52Need to know what happened. Sherry meanwhile, is taking to the hospital.
- 17:59She under went a thorough medical examination. She only ended up with minor
- 18:04abrasions and I think that's from just being like bound during the attack. By
- 18:12mid morning, so this happened Friday night, Okay, by mid morning Saturday,
- 18:18she was released from the hospital. And of course they're not gonna go
- 18:22home. It's a crime scene, right right, No, I yeah,
- 18:26I wouldn't want to go home. And no, no, no, they
- 18:32went to TJ and Kim Ferguson's house and that was their friends. So they're
- 18:37staying at the Ferguson residence. This is a Saturday. Investigators are, you
- 18:44know, continuing to question Sherry and the children regarding this masked assailant who had
- 18:52you know, killed their dad. Recognizing the the Sheriff's department recognized the importance
- 19:02of the safety of this family, so they ended up having officers like surround
- 19:08the house just in case the perpetrator because he's still on the loose, right,
- 19:12he's still on the loose, his back. Yeah. When they were
- 19:18doing the search of the Trover family home, they found a gun in the
- 19:26bushes by the neighbor the Riley's home. Okay, Okay, they found a
- 19:33gun. I mean it was a twenty two caliber pistol and it was same
- 19:38with blood and other tissue I'm biological fluids. Okay, okay. They identified
- 19:49it as the murder weapon based on the autopsy because it was a twenty two
- 19:55caliber that had been used and when the investigated like the gun's background, they
- 20:03really realized it belonged to a man named John Riley, the neighbor. John
- 20:07Riley, the neighbor. He was also a principal at the same school that
- 20:15Sherry worked at. Oh oh that added a whole new dimension to this,
- 20:22like what principal. Yeah, I'm starting to feel a little uneasy about this
- 20:26now, I mean that I was. It raised a lot of questions about
- 20:30did John Riley have something to do with this? I mean it's his gun,
- 20:34right, And does he work at the same school. Yes, he's
- 20:37a principal, same high school. It seems kind of weird. But John
- 20:44Riley was out of town. Oh really, he was an Arizona hmmm.
- 20:48He was a principal of Campbell County High School. And just so you know,
- 20:55the Riley family and the Trover family, they were really close. They
- 21:00were neighbors, They had kids near the same age. They would spend Thanksgiving
- 21:07together, Christmas together. They would alternate like whose house, Wow, this
- 21:11is? You know is going to be a house very close, right,
- 21:15And that is where Sherry was employed as a math teacher. So they're very
- 21:22close. They're celebrating holidays. But John Riley, he's at a town.
- 21:29They call him up and he's like, you can search my house. I
- 21:36didn't have anything to do with this. While I'm in shock, and he
- 21:40mentions to them that he has given the key to his house to so many
- 21:45people so many people because it's friends. I don't even know who is Key's
- 21:52in my house nine and I've made like nine and they're all gone. I
- 21:57don't know between my kids and probably I don't know. But he's like searched
- 22:04my house. And you did mention that one of the people that has keiths
- 22:07or one of the persons was Sherry and John Trover. Okay, and then
- 22:18he mentioned something else. Uh oh, here it comes. He'd been having
- 22:23an affair with Sherry for four years. Four years. I knew it.
- 22:29I knew it. I didn't want to accuse no Ah, shit, okay,
- 22:34uh oh oh shit. But he's out of town, is he though?
- 22:40Did they confirm that? Okay, don't don't. Don't ask me questions
- 22:45like you asked to hold me. During the search of his house, they
- 22:49found another handgun, and they sees that this is pretty unexpected because I mean,
- 23:00this adds a lot of dynamics. Damn. Forty years and it's found
- 23:04in his bushes and it's his gun. It's his gun, and he's been
- 23:08he's been bang in Sherry for four years. They're close, real close.
- 23:15So the police decide they're going to have they're going to continue to interrogate Sherry
- 23:22and the children about everything that happened. And they're going to hold a press
- 23:26conference. A press conference, oh, because the guy's on the loose still
- 23:32right, right? Yeah? So this is Friday night. The press conference
- 23:36is Sunday, December sixth, nineteen ninety eight. The chief of police,
- 23:42he wants to be proactive and he wants to address the public and let him
- 23:48know they're safe. Okay, oh wait, wait, there's a guy who
- 23:55murdered someone on a loose, but we're all safe. Don't worry about it.
- 23:57Yeah, you're saying, and he says in this press conference tomorrow,
- 24:03I'm going to have another press conference and you're going to be shocked at what
- 24:11I tell you. Oh, talk about putting people out of cliffhanger. He's
- 24:15going to divulge more a ton am at a news conference, and the revelations
- 24:22are going to shock the community. Was he running a tabloid? Right?
- 24:26Like? I'm thinking, oh, you wait till tomorrow. His goal was
- 24:32to have the community feel confident and comfortable that they weren't at risk. I
- 24:40would just be talking about it. What the hell is he going to say
- 24:41tomorrow? Yeah? Right? What there's a mass murderer on thee stay safe,
- 24:52real safe. So the school prepares counselors for I mean this, it's
- 25:00a big deal. It's a small area, and it's the principal, right,
- 25:03I mean, so they've got counselors and they're gonna counsel about John Trevor's
- 25:11Oh, not the principal probably like yeah, the teacher, I mean yeah,
- 25:14yeah, the school. Yeah, not the principal. Yeah, not
- 25:18the principle. Sorry, well he's the principal. There are three high schools,
- 25:21so he's only the principle of one. So maybe the superintendent I should
- 25:25say, well, it's something that affects the community, right, right,
- 25:29And they had makeshift up crisis centers for people, staff by you know,
- 25:33professional counselors, and they range to set it all up before class started on
- 25:38Monday Sunday. Please tell Sherry they found Hey, we found the gun.
- 25:48And great. Throughout the weekend, she'd been in consistent contact with them and
- 25:57both and the children, sharing everything they know she was. They were all
- 26:06eager to assist, even though they were they were traumatized. I mean,
- 26:11oh yeah. But one of the things when they found the gun on Sunday,
- 26:17they told Sherry they found her fingerprints on it. Oh shit, oh
- 26:22shit, And she said, well, I'm always at that house. I've
- 26:29got a key. I can explain it. Sure, sure, sure,
- 26:36Oh we got an explanation for that. And then she said, Okay,
- 26:41the mask man made me shoot John. Okay, that's why my fingerprints are
- 26:48on it. Stop it. This is getting fishier and fishier. The investigators
- 26:56assured Sherry, we are going to get to the bottom of the Yes,
- 27:00it's gonna be okay. They visited the home of Sherry's friends and where her
- 27:08children and she'd been staying, and they did another interview and Cherry was very
- 27:17visibly upset during I don't want to call it an interrogation, an interview.
- 27:25Sensing they could to all teut like she was getting hysterical, she asked if
- 27:30she could have a moment alone, and she retreated to the Ferguson's master suite,
- 27:37their bedroom, locking the door behind her. There, she found a
- 27:45to seventy caliber rifle in the closet. Oh no, what, I don't
- 27:49know. To seventy caliber rifle, point to seven zero caliber rifle in the
- 27:55closet, and she loaded it and she went into their bathroom and she killed
- 28:00herself. Are you kidding me? No, her children, her parents,
- 28:06her siblings, her husband's parents, and her friends and the police were all
- 28:11there and she shot herself in the hud. Oh my god. Oh shit,
- 28:18that's because the house the cards are falling right. Oh shit. And
- 28:22so the police rushed in, they break down the door and they find Sherry
- 28:26dead. These poor kids, Oh my god, these poor children. So
- 28:33Monday, the suicide is announced. I mean, they just thy god.
- 28:38They've got those counselors. The associate principle, his name is Bill Peters of
- 28:44Campbell County High School that's where she worked. He before school started, he
- 28:48had all of the employees from Campbell County High School and some of the other
- 28:56schools get their early to talk about it and talk about how to handle it
- 29:03and let them know. Some didn't even know, and they were provided in
- 29:08like an extra hour to collect themselves. There were sixteen hundred students and obviously
- 29:18it's pretty well, that's pretty fopped up. Yeah, that's it's something to
- 29:22walk into. Matthew killed herself, Yeah, and her husband was murdered and
- 29:29yeah, it's crazy. Wow. So there's that news conference. Oh yeah,
- 29:33that's morning. Now the sheriffs. He's got even more information to share.
- 29:38Campbell County Sheriff's office had a press conference at ten am. They said
- 29:45there was one suspect in the case, and that was Sherry Trover. Wow.
- 29:52And then they said she killed herself. She was the only suspect.
- 29:59They believe. They think she did the whole thing out, her kids up
- 30:03and everything. Oh yeah, girl, I'm not done, Okay. They
- 30:07believe she'd been planning it for months. Wow, the chief. The chief
- 30:15said, quote, our investigation has conclusively revealed that Cheryl Trover was responsible for
- 30:21the death of her husband. Holy shit. She'd been described as a delightful
- 30:27wife, mother, and a teacher. And how she could do this a
- 30:37shocking Yeah, so this is what they think happened. First of all,
- 30:42she's been calling, disguising her voice and threatening her husband. She was the
- 30:48one. She was the one, okay, calling giant work making the threatening
- 30:51calls. Mm hmmm. This is insane in advance, So that's premeditated,
- 30:56right right. Investigators disclosed that the family went to Homphrey's Bar and Grill on
- 31:03Friday night and then they all settled in for the night. As the children
- 31:08went to their own rooms, and John went to the master bedroom. They
- 31:14believe that Sherry had already retrieved the twenty two caliber because she knew that the
- 31:22man she was having an affair with, the principal name John Riley, was
- 31:26out of town and she had a key. Oh yeah, that's right,
- 31:29and she could just go and help herself. Helped herself to go get the
- 31:33gun. She'd taken it from his residence. She then, with bare hand,
- 31:41put a mask on in overalls. She knocked on the door. John
- 31:48opened it, and she shot him twice in the hud and once in the
- 31:53arm. So she missed one time, though she tried twice, shot him
- 31:56once in the hud and then once in the arm. He was down to
- 32:01the count for a little bit. Right. Then she went to her children's
- 32:06room. That's what I'm wondering, Like, she went to her children's room.
- 32:09She's got this this mask on, she's got gloves, she's got overalls,
- 32:15and she disguises her voice. Really, you don't recognize your mom's voice.
- 32:20I would My mom could try to sound like mister T and I would
- 32:23still recognize, right, yeah, you would think. And she bound there.
- 32:28She scared them so much with the mask and stuff, maybe they just
- 32:30weren't thinking bound their hands and she together and gagged them and left them on
- 32:37the fence. But you know, it's interesting. When the investigators came,
- 32:44the children said they think their mom might have been the person. They believed
- 32:52that they could kind of recognize her voice and like just the shape of her
- 32:58body. Yeah, like it's the person you see every single day of your
- 33:01life, and it gets weirder. They also noted that the voice that was
- 33:09used resembled their mom's voice when she was mad. Oh oh, that the
- 33:15you know, the mad mom voice, attention to your life when your whole
- 33:22government name right. But despite everything that happened, they thought maybe it was
- 33:30just some twisted game their mom was playing. They didn't I mean, they
- 33:32didn't know. You wouldn't think your Yeah, you don't think your mom's gonna
- 33:36like murder your dad. She's a mad teacher. She never done anything to
- 33:38you, right, So, they later recounted hearing gunshots, but initially mistook
- 33:50them for sounds of They didn't know what it was. They just didn't know.
- 33:52They probably got like airds on. I don't know if they had them
- 33:57back their music. Whatever. They're not paying attention, they're like, whatever
- 34:00mom and dad are doing right now, I couldn't been watching TV in thething.
- 34:05But throughout the ordeal, the children heard this is so strange, various
- 34:09noises outside their bedroom, including what they interpreted as their mother alternating her voice
- 34:19between different tones to potentially create the illusion that there were other people there.
- 34:25This is insane? Is that fucking yes? Soon? Right? And you
- 34:31still sound like yourself? Right? These poor kids, they're like, I
- 34:37like how they didn't check though, and like this is weird, but I'm
- 34:40not going outside my room and I'm so tight up. Yeah, And apparently
- 34:46this happened for hours, hours, hours, because she ended up going back
- 34:52and seeing that John was stumbling oh yeah, and then kind of in the
- 35:00basement. Yeah, I wonder how she got him down there. She dragged
- 35:02him, She dragged him and then stabbed him and then slid his throat.
- 35:06Jeez. Then she made up the whole story about being abducted and going in
- 35:14rape. She said she was raped, but the I'm assuming like maybe they
- 35:19did. I never heard about a rape kit. There's so little to find
- 35:22on this case because she killed herself, so she couldn't be prosecuted. Yeah,
- 35:27and if she's not prosecuted. There's not going to be the police reports
- 35:30that we usually get on these cases. Yeah, so Sherry ends up after
- 35:39killing John getting inty. Are we gonna say allegedly now because there's been no
- 35:45trial in conviction she's dead. Yeah, that's true. Okay, go on,
- 35:50I'm sorry. She got into the truck and went to the south part
- 35:54of Gillette and then she removed her clothes and she put the mask, the
- 36:00gloves, the overalls, some boots, and the hunting knife in the cab
- 36:07of the truck. And that's why she tried to let light the truck on
- 36:09fire. Okay, but people came by and put it out and put it
- 36:15out. She's probably like, oh fuck, she's trying to burn evidence.
- 36:20Yeah, so she ignites the truck. Then it gets thwarted because these people
- 36:23come, and so she's like once the culvert and acts like she's all was
- 36:30she tied up? Really? Yeah? She was by herself. Yeah,
- 36:36get away from someone still being tied up, like at least your legs,
- 36:38like you can't run. She's hopping away like getting away from an assailant.
- 36:43No. Yeah, that's a good, that's a good. But I didn't
- 36:45want to bring it up at the time. I thought it though, So
- 36:49I'm like, I'm gonna see where the story goes. I think she lit
- 36:51it on fire and thought it would burn, and then like went to the
- 36:55culvert. Yeah, tied herself up, naked, that teacher naked, and
- 37:02then they came and they found her in the ditch. She knew obviously the
- 37:13gig was up. Yeah, so that's why she killed herself. But they
- 37:21think that the reason why she did it is because she was in love with
- 37:24the principal. Yeah, I figured. And during her husband's first marriage,
- 37:30I told you he had a daughter. Oh ye older. He got either
- 37:36fifty to fifty custody or soul custody. I don't know. I know custody
- 37:39was a factor, and she was really nervous about losing her kids part of
- 37:49the time. That's a great reason for killing your spouse. So this well
- 37:57crafted murder, what a mess, really poorly executed. I'm sorry. Yeah,
- 38:01and can you imagine right in the community found out man math teacher,
- 38:07I know, with the principal scandalous then bound her children, Yes, killed
- 38:17her husband, Yeah, faked the rape. So the principal, he was
- 38:24really in Arizona. He was okay, thankfully. On Tuesday, December eighth,
- 38:30he resigned, Yeah, citing personal and professional reasons. Yeah, and
- 38:37he addressed his former colleagues and offered words of encouragement. He was just so,
- 38:43you know, never considered to be a part of this at all.
- 38:50He eventually moved away from Gillette, Wyoming. It's probably good idea. Yeah,
- 38:53And did you say, Mary, do you know does his wife stay
- 38:58with him? I wonder, I don't know. I'm gonna say no,
- 39:02they prob Yeah, it's probably ruined their lives. But damn, there was
- 39:08a fun put up for the children. I mean, if you think about
- 39:15it, Tory and Jackson. Yeah, these poor kids, they lost their
- 39:17dad and their mom. Yeah, in a weekend. Yeah. And this
- 39:22is a wild story. I mean, so Brooke is John's older daughter,
- 39:30and she set up a fund for them and she's been helping to like well
- 39:36now it's nineteen ninety eight, but she helped to take care of them.
- 39:39And that's the story. That's crazy. What mom does that she be in
- 39:50love with that? I mean, come on, I just these stories.
- 39:53Just divorce, I know, like, just divorce him and share your kids
- 39:58with the man that you had the kids with. What's the problem. It's
- 40:02not like he's like a loser. You just share your kids. Yeah,
- 40:05he's got money. You guys can sports. And I don't think you're not
- 40:07gonna get caught. Go your kids go to the school. I mean the
- 40:12girl daughter went to the school. See them. I just I don't know.
- 40:17And I have a feeling that John, I don't know, John wasn't
- 40:21gonna leave his wife. Who knows, right, probably well then kill the
- 40:23wife. Yeah, sorry, I know I didn't kill your husband. Kill
- 40:29the other woman, right, Yeah, I don't know. This is crazy.
- 40:32This I am always just amazed people think they're gonna get away with it.
- 40:36Like I was telling my husband this weekend, and I don't remember why
- 40:39we got on the subject, but he said, most people are murdered by
- 40:42someone they know. Yes, and a lot of times spouses are murdered by
- 40:45their partner, or people are murdered by their partner boyfriend, girlfriend, husband,
- 40:50wife. So it's like those are the people that you get looked at
- 40:52first. Well, I'm not trying to be weird, but I would have
- 40:57been like, hey, kids, do you want to stay at your friend's
- 41:00house tonight? Yeah? Right, sleepover at your friend's house, and then
- 41:06I'm not going to tie up my kids and pretend not mom. I think
- 41:09they're not going to recognize you because I have overalls on and a mask,
- 41:15because that's what they're We're just going to be like moms really lost their ship.
- 41:19Yeah, Like, I just don't get it. It's really sad.
- 41:24It is very sad. I feel really bad for those the community and the
- 41:30kids. Yeah, the kids especially and John. Yeah, and John.
- 41:32John's just standing as a victim here and everything I read said that on the
- 41:37outside, nobody knew there were any issues. Yeah. They were actually one
- 41:44of the most affectionate couples when there were events. Yeah, well that's really
- 41:50sad. I wonder John knew a probably not. I don't know. Maybe
- 41:58I don't know if you had time. Yeah, he's probably busy and I
- 42:01don't know. But yeah, yeah, it's seeming like when you open the
- 42:05door in his underwear. Yeah, they still they start fighting though. First
- 42:12he had to her because there's a struggle, right, he knows what his
- 42:15wife looks like. Feels like, I mean, come on, let's just
- 42:19be honest. He knows it's her anyway, and that is this is crazy.
- 42:24I want to see I want to think my friend Rachel who wrote this
- 42:30for me as a favor, and I want to thank you for listening.
- 42:38I want to thank all of you guys for listening. If you want to
- 42:43find out more about us, get to know us, you can go to
- 42:46Patrion dot com, Slash T and T Crime, t N T, d
- 42:52N, The End, Dynamite, Yeah Crimes, and then every week we
- 42:59have of exclusive Apple episodes released only to those that subscribe and they're AD free.
- 43:07And then you also get our episodes from True Crime Daily released early ad
- 43:12free, and you can get the same thing by going to Apple Podcasts.
- 43:16Yeah. I can go to Crimbsconsequences dot com and see some of our merchandise
- 43:22there, and we have Facebook and Instagram. It's at hardcore true crime.
- 43:30But we're not so good at that. We're still getting our sure. Yeah
- 43:36we were pretty good for a while, but it's a lot of work.
- 43:38The wheels fell off the bus for a little while. I'm just gonna say
- 43:42it. We'll need some things were going on, but ship what's happening,
- 43:45we'll get back and anything else. I don't think so. I think we're
- 43:51good again. I want to thank you guys for all taking time to listen
- 43:54to us. If you want to insult us, you can write comments,
- 44:00because lots of people do that. But if you want to write something nice,
- 44:02lots of people do that too, and we prefer them and something ones
- 44:07are kind of funny. Though they are they are, they don't hurt us,
- 44:10so go ahead. They literally have we're attorneys. We always have a
- 44:15saying you're dead. Said, yeah, you're not going to say something to
- 44:19me that I haven't already heard a billion times from an opposing party right about,
- 44:23So go ahead. But if you want to write something nice, that
- 44:27would be awesome to Yeah, we'd love to hear from everyone. Make us
- 44:30feel good because we do work hard. So until our next episode, don't
- 44:36kill each other. Bye bye