Latest / Catalyst: A Podcast of Thought / Flow with Force Series Finale: What I Think I Might Now Know
Transcript
- Catalyst - Final Final Episode: What happens when the very things that made you successful begin getting in your way? The discipline, the determination, the willingness to step forward, solve problems, take responsibility, and make things happen. For much of my life I trusted those qualities. They served me just fine. They served me well. They helped me build a career, develop relationships, compete, lead, become someone other people could count on. Over time I've begun to recognize something. The same qualities that help me succeed in one environment sometimes make it harder to succeed in another. Sometimes I don't need more effort. I need a different relationship with effort. Sometimes I don't need more control. I need more trust. Sometimes the most productive thing I can do is stop trying to make everything happen. Welcome to Catalyst, a podcast of thought. I'm Dr. G. Over the past eight episodes I've explored an idea I've come to call flow with force. I've looked at identity, human body, leadership, relationships. Golf, attention, and the experience of being fully engaged in something without constantly evaluating myself. Today I want to bring those conversations together in a final final episode of the series. Not to offer a formula or to suggest I've figured it all out, but to reflect on what I've learned, what I've begun to recognize in myself and what I think this distinction might mean for how I live, how I work, how I relate to other people. Including myself. I don't think this is really about choosing flow over force. I think it's about knowing the difference between the two and recognizing the situation I am in when using them. Force earned its place. Let's start where this series started. Why does force work? Well, because it does. I practice, I prepare, I work harder, I become more disciplined, I develop competence, I get results. When I was eleven I stepped in when a younger neighborhood kid was being bullied. I wasn't particularly stronger than him, but I was willing to intervene and the bullying stopped. I learned something that day that force could protect, it could stabilize the situation, it could make a difference. That lesson reinforced itself throughout my life. In football and hockey, physical intensity had a purpose. In school effort produced results. In my professional life, reliability and preparation created opportunities. I learned these relationships with force early. I put in effort and something came of it. I took responsibility and people trusted me. I solved problems and people could depend on me. The equation became familiar. More effort, better results. Eventually I stopped thinking of force as something I used. It became part of my identity. Here's the distinction I wanted to establish from the beginning of this series. Force wasn't and isn't the problem. Misapplied force is. There are situations that require force, an emergency, a boundary that needs protecting, a decision I can't postpone a difficult conversation that I really need to have. Force has its place. I know now I need to know that place. The trouble began when a successful strategy, using force, became my default response, regardless of what the situation was actually asking of me. Force based identity. In the second episode, I explored what I called the fixer identity. Think about the person everyone relies on, the one who notices what needs attention, organizes the details, anticipates the problem, and steps forward when something needs to get done. I recognize that person. Growing up, my mother would leave me a list of chores during the summer, I'd get them done immediately, not mostly, but completely. If there were leaves tucked between tree roots, I'd get to those two. Years later, a college supervisor selected me to lead a summer work crew. When someone asked why, the answer was simple, because I know Schnagel will show up. That felt good. All those situations reinforced something I already believed about myself. I was reliable, I was useful. I was someone people could count on. Something subtle happened when I received all that reinforcement for being useful for so long. I began to associate my value to others, to the world, to myself with usefulness. Helping became my identity. Being needed became evidence that I actually mattered. Before long I found myself fixing things that did need fixing, making decisions for other people that could have made themselves, and getting involved in situations where my presence wasn't necessary. Sometimes my need to feel useful got in the way of letting others become capable. A significant shift in my perspective came through reflection and others' accountability. The question changed from how could I feel useful to What does the situation really need from me? Force became friction. In the third episode, I examined what happens when force stopped working. I used the example of golf, but the pattern shows up everywhere. The conversation isn't going well, so I would just talk more. The employee wasn't responding as expected, so I supervised more closely. The relationship felt uncertain, so I tried to resolve everything immediately. I pushed, I tightened up, I increased the pressure of the situation. And sometimes that worked, at least temporarily. Sometimes the situation became less responsive or the person withdrew. What once felt productive began to feel strained. I put more in and I got less back. I think that's one of the most important observations in this entire conversation. At some point, my additional effort stopped helping and started interfering. Research on complex systems helped explain why. In relatively predictable environments, A particular action may produce a fairly predictable result. Human relationships, organizations, and other complex environments, however, don't always respond that way. People have their own interpretations, motivations, experiences, and choices. A leader cannot simply increase control and expect people to become more engaged. A coach cannot talk someone into a particular insight. A parent cannot force every lesson into their child. We cannot always make uncertainty disappear by thinking harder or longer. The important question became is this the kind of situation where force works best? That's a different question from asking how to apply. More force. My body the informer In the fourth episode I spoke of my experience with my own body, including a long period of health challenges and the frustration in trying to solve something that wouldn't respond to my usual approach. For much of my life, I treated my body like a simple machine. If something wasn't working, I assumed I just needed the right adjustment. Work harder, prepare better, tighten the routine, apply a little more force here or there. Eventually I began to consider another possibility. Maybe my body wasn't betraying me. It was simply informing me. That distinction changed how I thought about the experience of pain, discomfort, illness, and Research on stress and the body offered another perspective. Researchers like Bruce McGuin described how repeated demands in chronic stress can accumulate physiological costs. Our bodies continually respond to the demands we place on them even when we don't consciously recognize those demands. That doesn't mean stress causes every physical symptom, it does mean our bodies aren't separate from the environments and situations we are experiencing. Sometimes a signal isn't asking us to push harder, sometimes it's asking us to pay attention. That brought me to a question I keep returning to What kind of situation am I actually in right now? And again, what might it need from me? Performing versus participating. In the fifth episode, I returned to golf. I came to the game with decades of football and hockey experience. Those sports rewarded intensity. I learned to compete by increasing effort, emotion, and commitment. Naturally I brought that approach to golf. I squeezed the club, tightened my muscles, and gauged everything. Trying to drive every ounce of effort through the club and into the ball. I literally wore out the grips of my clubs. I was preparing for combat with this little white ball, and golf kept teaching me the same lesson over and over again. The more I tried to control every variable, the more difficult the swing became. Turns out, performing and participating are different. Performing often asked me to demonstrate something competence, value, achievement, status. Participating was asking me to engage with what's actually happening. I didn't need to prove that I belonged on the golf course. I didn't need every round to demonstrate my ability. I could enjoy the walk, the conversation, the challenge, and the occasional beautiful shot. I could care about the outcome without allowing it to control the entire experience. That was a meaningful shift for me, participating without performing. Flow is not passive. By the sixth episode I wanted to address a confusion that developed around this idea. If I wasn't supposed to force everything, does that mean I simply let go, back down, back away? Do I wait for things to happen? Do I become passive? No. Flow is not the absence of action. It had a different relationship with action. I could prepare, I could establish an intention, I could I could make a decision, I could exercise discipline, I could take responsibility, I could influence what happens without needing to control what happens. One story I revisited was teaching six year olds. I thought leadership meant developing the solution and getting people to follow it. Instead I discovered that leadership sometimes meant creating the conditions for others to discover the solution for themselves. That lesson has stayed with me. In my work with leaders, I now think more about influence than impact. Impact asks, what did I make happen? Influence asks, what did my presence make possible? Those are different questions with different perspectives, different intentions. I think the second one creates more room for other people to contribute. I once thought confidence meant knowing how to fix a problem. Now it sounds more like Whatever happens, I can meet it. I can knowing I can work through the problem with the problem, and that little preposition with matters. I don't have to control every variable to trust myself to respond effectively. I can work with the variables. Conditions for flow in the seventh episode I explored what made flow possible. I kept coming back to four conditions attention, trust, timing, and relationship. Attention. Attention means being present enough to recognize what's actually happening rather than responding to the story I've already created it in my head. Trust. Trust means believing I can respond without controlling every variable, and that other people can handle what belongs to them. Timing. Timing means recognizing that not every situation requires immediate action. Sometimes I need to act, sometimes I need to wait. Sometimes I need to give an idea or a relationship room to develop. Relationship. Focusing on relationships reminds me that flow rarely happens in isolation. The people in the systems around us shape our experiences in any given situation. These conditions of attention, trust, timing, relationship don't guarantee flow. They do create a space for it, however. And that's an important distinction. I can create the conditions, I cannot command the experience. Feel of flow. That brings us to episode eight. I asked a deceptively simple question. What does flow feel like? I told a story about sitting at my computer completely absorbed in writing when my phone alarm startled me. It was reminding me to turn on the crock pot. Three hours had passed since I started writing. I hadn't noticed the world around me. When I'm in flow, the internal commentary gets quiet. I'm not constantly evaluating how well I'm doing or imagining how someone else might be judging my performance. I'm simply engaged in the act of doing. I described three states of being in my own flow experience hyper awareness, what I call fractionality, and hyperacuity. Hyper awareness, by my definition, is the struggle to make something happen. Fractionality is when My attention begins to break apart while simultaneously becoming clearer. Hyperacuity is intense focus, but without the accompanying tension. These are just my descriptions, not universal, you know, scientific syncputs or anything. They helped me recognize the difference between forcing an experience and participating in it, working with the variables, working with my present state of attention. I know now that. was the larger lesson here in the entire flow with force journey. When I'm writing, I want to write. When I'm exercising, I want to exercise. When I'm having a conversation, I want to be present in the conversation. What I don't want is to spend the entire experience of writing, exercising or conversing, whatever the situation is. I don't want to stand outside myself evaluating how well I'm doing. I can reflect afterward if need be. I can learn afterward, as is always the case. I can make meaning afterward, if at all. sometimes the experience deserves my attention before I turn it into evidence of something else. Closing reflection. So what have these eight episodes taught me? Well I started this series thinking of force and flow as two different ways to approach the world. Over time I've come to see that distinction as more nuanced. Force is not inherently bad. Flow is not inherently good. Force can protect, it can set boundaries, create structure, and help me act when I need to. Flow can create space for discovery, participation, and Trust, responsiveness. Challenge for me now is knowing which one the situation requires of me. I think that requires something more than discipline. It requires discernment. Discernment, I say, is the ability to recognize what's actually happening. Distinguish between what is real and what I'm imagining, and respond accordingly. I've been practicing that in small ways. I sit still more, I pause more, I listen longer, I make fewer decisions for other people. I recognize when I'm anticipating problems that haven't even happened yet. I still tighten up, I still want to fix things, I still feel the urge to get ahead of a situation. The old patterns haven't disappeared. I now recognize them sooner. With recognition comes choices. I've also become more aware of something I used to overlook. Sometimes my need to make an impact is really my need to validate my usefulness. I want to produce something, solve something, demonstrate something. Perhaps sometimes a better question isn't what did I accomplish? It's what did my presence make possible? That question changes how I think about leadership, how I think about relationships, how I think about my time and experiences I choose, how I think about myself. I don't need to manufacture significance. I don't need to turn every interest into an accomplishment. I don't need to manage every relationship. I can participate. I can influence. I can enjoy. I can let the experience be just what it is. I can still act when action is required. That's the part I don't want to lose. Flow isn't an excuse to avoid responsibility, it's isn't a justification for indecision. It isn't an invitation to sit back and hope things work out. It's a different way of being engaged. Not letting go of action, letting go of the need to control every action's outcome. That's the confidence I'm developing. Not the confidence that everything will go according to plan, confidence that I can stick with whatever happens next. I began this series exploring why force works. I think I understand that better now. It works because it has helped me become a capable, reliable, disciplined person. It has helped me protect others, solve problems, accomplish difficult things. I also understand why it became a limitation. When force became my identity, I began applying it even when the situation was asking for something else. I'm not finished learning. And I suspect I never will be. I have a different question now. Instead of automatically asking what do I need to do to make this happen, I'm willing to pause and ask, what is actually happening? What does this moment, this situation, require of me? Sometimes the answer will be force, sometimes it will be patience, sometimes it will be action, sometimes it will be getting out of the way. The point of this exploration wasn't to eliminate force. It was to stop using it indiscriminately. It was about becoming capable of recognizing which one the moment requires. That's what I hope stays with you after this series. Not a formula or checklist, just a little more awareness of how you're engaging with the world around you. The quality of our lives may have less to do with how much force we apply, and more to do with how well we recognize what the moment actually needs. To ask not how we may choose flow over force, but how we may flow with force. Force. Thank you for spending these episodes thinking alongside me. I hope something in these reflections gave you reason to pause, reconsider an assumption, or simply notice your own experience a little differently. This is not the end of my thinking, it's just another place to begin. I'm Dr. G, those are my thoughts. Thanks for listening.