Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Why Managing a Know-It-All Backfires Without Curiosity
Transcript
- Lucas: There's a specific moment in a manager's day that I think is harder than any firing or any budget cut. It's the moment you're trying to give feedback to someone who genuinely believes they already know everything. Luna: Oh, the know-it-all. Every team has one. And trying to tell them something new feels like talking to a wall. Lucas: Exactly. And if we've helped you think through a career move or a tough conversation like this one, a handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's what keeps this show ad-free and lets us spend time on episodes like this. Luna: Yeah, it genuinely makes a difference. And we're grateful for every single supporter. Lucas: So today I want to dig into a case study I came across recently. A mid-size SaaS company — about 200 people — had a senior backend developer named Priya. She was brilliant, shipped code fast, but in every one-on-one, whenever her manager tried to suggest a different approach, she'd say 'I already know that' or 'I tried that and it didn't work'. Luna: Classic. And that shuts down the conversation immediately. The manager feels like there's nothing to add. Lucas: Right. And the instinct is to push back, to say 'but let me explain why this is different.' But that just escalates the tension. So Priya's manager tried something else. Luna: What did they do? Lucas: She stopped giving advice altogether. Instead, she started asking for Priya's opinion. She'd say, 'I have a hypothesis about this issue, but I'd love your take because you've been deep in this code. Can you help me think through it?' Luna: That's smart. Instead of positioning herself as the expert, she positions Priya as the expert and herself as a collaborator. Lucas: Exactly. And it worked. Priya opened up. She started explaining her reasoning, and in doing so, she sometimes discovered gaps on her own. The manager didn't have to point them out. Luna: So the key is to reframe the conversation from 'I have something to teach you' to 'let's solve this together'. Lucas: That's the core of it. But there's a deeper layer. Why do people become know it alls in the first place? It's often not arrogance — it's fear of being seen as incompetent. Priya had been the go-to person for years, and admitting she didn't know something felt like losing status. Luna: So it's a defense mechanism. And if you attack it head-on, you just reinforce the fear. Lucas: Exactly. So the manager also started giving Priya opportunities to teach others. She asked her to lead a brown-bag session on a recent project. That gave Priya a legitimate space to showcase expertise without feeling threatened. Luna: That's a great structural fix. Instead of trying to change the person, change the environment so they don't need to defend themselves. Lucas: Right. And over about three months, the dynamic shifted. Priya started saying things like 'I hadn't thought of that' or 'that's a good point.' The manager told me it was like working with a different person. Luna: But what about the manager who doesn't have that kind of time? Or who has a know-it-all who is more aggressive about it? Lucas: That's a fair point. The approach needs to be consistent. But there's a shorter-term tactic: the 'second opinion' frame. Instead of saying 'I think you should do X,' say 'I have an idea, but I'd like you to be the second opinion on it. What do you see that I might be missing?' Luna: That's clever because it honors their expertise while still getting your point across. And it lowers the stakes. Lucas: Exactly. The goal isn't to win the argument — it's to get a good outcome. And if you can get them to arrive at the same conclusion on their own, that's a win. Luna: I've also seen managers use data to disarm the know-it-all. Instead of saying 'you're wrong,' they bring in numbers that show a different pattern. Lucas: That works well if the person respects data. In Priya's case, her manager once showed her a simple adoption metric that contradicted her assumption about a feature. Priya looked at it and said 'huh, that's interesting.' And then she changed her approach. Luna: So curiosity is the antidote. The manager has to model curiosity and create a safe space for the employee to be curious too. Lucas: I think that's the single biggest takeaway. The moment you stop trying to prove you're right and start trying to understand why they think what they think, the dynamic changes. Luna: And that's hard for managers who are used to being the smartest person in the room. Lucas: It is. But the best managers I've seen are the ones who are comfortable saying 'I don't know' or 'help me understand.' That vulnerability is disarming. Luna: So what's the one question you'd recommend a manager try this week with their know-it-all? Lucas: I'd say: 'What would have to be true for you to consider a different approach?' It's a question that invites them to think without feeling attacked. Luna: That's good. It's open-ended, it's respectful, and it forces reflection. Lucas: Right. And if they can't answer it, that's also useful information. It tells you that the resistance is purely emotional, not logical. Luna: And then you have to address the emotion first. Maybe they're afraid of losing autonomy or being micromanaged. Lucas: Exactly. I think we often mistake know-it-all behavior for a personality flaw when it's actually a symptom of something else — insecurity, past trauma with a bad manager, or a culture that rewards individual heroics over collaboration. Luna: That's a good reminder. The behavior is the signal, not the problem itself. Lucas: And the best fix is almost never a single conversation. It's a series of small interactions that rebuild trust and create a new pattern. Luna: So if you're a first-time manager dealing with this, don't expect a quick win. But the shift can be profound. Lucas: Absolutely. Priya's manager said the turning point was when Priya voluntarily came to her and said 'I've been thinking about what you said last week, and I think you might be right.' That's the moment you know the armor is off. Luna: And that's the goal — not to be right, but to have a team that can be wrong together and get better. Lucas: I love that framing. Let's leave it there for this week. Next time we'll talk about managing the employee who says 'I don't have time for this.' Luna: Looking forward to it. Thanks for listening.