Latest / Falcon Forward / When Carriers Say No: How Great Brokers Turn Claim Denials Around
Transcript
- Peter Brecht: All right. Welcome to Falcon Forward. My name's Peter. I'm here with our president Mike Tangy. we're here for another episode of our podcast. So this has kind of become a weekly occurrence throughout the year. We've been I mean, it's July already, which I can't believe. ⁓ we had our quarterly meeting this morning with our team. you know, tracking up and to the right, which is always good, and we've got some great people just moving along. So ⁓ long fourth of July holiday and we're all ready to get back to it. So, Mike, you have a very ornate background. There's some it looks like gold around that frame, but ⁓ it's a very cool photo you got. So I like your background today. Mike Tanghe: Yeah. thank you. Yes. borrowing from a conference room, so hopefully ⁓ I get kicked out halfway through recording today. But we should be good. Peter Brecht: That would be one for the books if it happened. So ⁓ anyways, all right. So today ⁓ we have two questions and ⁓ again, we've been pretty busy just getting stuff done with clients, but two things we wanted to answer. So we have ⁓ our our sixth academy group is going through and just a remarkable group of athletes actually, that I get to talk to every week right now, four of them. and their last week that they went through, they learned about the oil and gas industry and part of their Mike Tanghe: Ha ha ha. Peter Brecht: like assignments for the week is to come up with three questions ⁓ they're don't have answers to from the material and and see how it works. So I answer half of those questions generally on my other podcast, which is local energy. This one ⁓ was kind of less oil and gas related from Michaela Hall, which was can investments be insured? And I the ⁓ looked at with her, and my first thought was no you know, you can't insure against an investment. Then the other part of me was saying, well, you kind of can, because there's, you know, there's different ways to like in different investments, right? That are technically you could think of it as insurance. What I was kind of struggling with was, you know, you have this speculative risk versus pure risk. So the idea is that pure risk is there's only two outcomes, right? You suffer a loss, things stay exactly the same. So either, you know, you get into an accident or you don't. Your house burns down or it doesn't. ⁓ and there's speculative risk, which is that there's you can you can have a loss, things stay the same, or you can actually have a gain, right? So insurance is never intended to have you, you know, gain something. and so ⁓ there's things like the law of large numbers, moral hazard, and then indemnity that are involved, but that was kind of the big overarching piece. Brought it up to you as a question and you said, Hey, I might have a different spin on this or a different opinion. So I wanted to throw it back to you, and then in our article that we write, we can kind of give maybe both sides a little bit more more heavily. Mike Tanghe: Yeah. excellent. So ⁓ know, if the question is can you ⁓ against investments? so again, like good insurance answer, it's kinda say it depends. so ⁓ to go to traditional insurer like the ones that we would work with that insure your home, your auto, your umbrella, your business, you know, those carriers wouldn't necessarily offer ⁓ insurance against your investment portfolio for exactly the reasons that that ⁓ you noted the pure risk versus speculative risk on it. with that said, I think though you absolutely could insure investments, and again that's kind of what we saw, the the best example of how that could potentially go wrong was when we in the financial crisis of 2008, ⁓ when it was ⁓ AIG not understanding risks they were taking on. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: Or possibly understanding and not caring with the amount of money that they were getting paid to issue these credit default swaps. But ⁓ way you look at it, the end result was when the investments that AIG was insuring against started plummet of value, and specifically these mortgage bonds that were bundled together and ⁓ the ratings gave these AAA ratings on. When those started to lose value banks had owned these now had to mark down the valuations that they had on it or worse tried to sell them, AIG had effectively promised that if these things went south in ⁓ that they would make the the the the people holding these swaps whole. And ⁓ know, if would happened You know, AIG I think at the time was facing a hundred and eighty billion dollar, which like when we're talking Elon Musk trillionaire, then this was eighteen years ago, the numbers almost seem quaint. but at the time, ⁓ and still is a lot of money, you know, it threatened to to basically derail the whole global financial system just because of all the dicing and slicing exposure that other had on AIG. And it Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: Exposed to you know massive weakness in what the had purported to be the the greatest financial system in the world. so why the government stepped in, it was extremely unpopular, but it did bring stability to the markets, and then eventually with the government which had taken ownership in AIG, which was quite unprecedented, ⁓ was eventually made and then some on it. But ⁓ so ⁓ again, technical, ⁓ very ⁓ Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: I'm not sure if it's the most exciting stuff in the world. someone actually is, I'd love to get your comments or engage further ⁓ on it. But you the again to go back, ⁓ that depends. You absolutely could insure against investments. it's ⁓ a tricky investment to make in some someone that you gotta be pretty sophisticated on because you know some of the allegedly smartest people in the room almost caused a complete global financial meltdown by Getting involved with it. Peter Brecht: Personally, I find this topic fascinating compared to some others that we've talked about. So I think it's to each their own. the big and and like the big shorts, one of my favorite movies. I think I've watched it. I can't even tell you. It's one of those movies I'll just put on in the background. ⁓ and probably because I love Steve Corell so much. But, you know, just you know, you know, truth is like poetry, and most people hate poetry. There's all these like cool little quips and stuff in it. It's awesome. And then Mike Tanghe: Mm-hmm. Yes. Yeah, brilliant. Ha ha. Peter Brecht: The book I I read in college was All the Devils A Here Are Here. so I've spent too much time looking at the O eight crisis, which happened right when I graduated high school. So anyways, ⁓ good Mike Tanghe: Yeah. No, the author, the Michael Lewis is the author and I mean absolutely brilliant author and how I'm actually re reading one of his books now for the second time, on the pandemic. ⁓ so and he's just hi yeah, his way of capturing what happened, even though you know some of the details of it, is it's ⁓ he's ⁓ talented author. Peter Brecht: Yeah. Yeah. Are you okay? Interesting. I might have to check that one out. ⁓ Mm-hmm. Totally. And I think he he wrote ⁓ Moneyball and a bunch of other good ones too, right? So ⁓ yeah, another good another great movie, so okay. Mike Tanghe: Yep. Yep. The the fifth risk was another ⁓ great one that he wrote that and and some of the stuff you're like, man, you get it confused ⁓ and recapping historical events ⁓ or but of the stuff that he wrote about specifically related American politics, or some of the warnings that he had on things, ⁓ it's just like, man, how does he comes across some people and does a very good job of telling their story. Peter Brecht: Yeah, that's that would be a fun I think if I was not a insurance broker, I would probably talk to people and write for a living, but I don't know if that pays the bills anymore. So anyways, we'll move on to something perhaps more interesting and more insurance insurance-y, if we can use that word, which is that we have ⁓ claims that we're ⁓ working through ⁓ it happens And you know, I don't know how to frame this, Mike, but maybe there's a difference of opinion between what the carriers think and what an insurance broker does. So maybe walk us through this a little bit more and and maybe set it up a little bit better than I have here. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, sure. So, ⁓ know, we sell something that hopefully clients never ever have to use. but if they do, you know, they're depending on ⁓ the policy respond really as they intended. And ⁓ there's some when your clients will have an unrealistic expectation of what should be covered, like they'll, you know, or they'll want coverage for something that you've talked about with them and they don't have that coverage. Or they don't have any like I was reading there's an article in the paper about on wildfire claims ⁓ that happened with the the two thousand twenty five Pacific Palisades and Altadina and they talked about a lady whose policy had been canceled. she hadn't gotten coverage and her home burnt down. and so in the article it said how she filed the claim anyway with her old insurance company. and you know, you kinda read that and you're like Well that was that doesn't seem like it makes any sense. But then you also just picture from this lady's perspective of I mean, she's devastated, like she doesn't have insurance. She doesn't, you know, and it's it's too obviously too late, but she just, you know, is desperate, so she filed a claim with a carrier, you know, that she didn't even have. i ⁓ but guess my point with all that is ⁓ when person has a claim, ⁓ now the opportunity for the insurance company to step up. And then for us as brokers to stop it. A lot of stuff's pretty easy, you know. You're up your car and you're you know, you got coverage on the car, you take it, you get an estimate, it gets repaired, you pay your deductible, like those kind of claims we don't necessarily get involved with and they move along, you know, ninety nine percent of the time they'll go along great. Liability claims, ⁓ again, if it's pretty clear, cut and dry of what's going on, then it's just a matter of, you know, is every other party reasonable in what they're looking for and communicative, and you know, again, things should go along pretty smoothly. But occasionally, and this probably happens to me a year, maybe, where a carrier doesn't do what, in my opinion, they should be doing. and there's been a couple of these in my twenty-some year career. Peter Brecht: Mm. Mike Tanghe: that ⁓ could have been very bad. it could have reinforced in my clients' opinion that you or a lot of people stereotype is about insurance is that it's a racket, insurance companies don't want to pay. but in these of instances, we've come out of it looking very good because we were able to get the carriers to pay after an an initial denial. and ⁓ it you in clients' eyes, we were the greatest people ever because they did something. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: that you know they thought wasn't gonna go their way. you know, they ⁓ just it reinforced it it broke the reinforcement that they had or the stereotype they had in their mind of, man, this is a rigged against me where we were able to, you know, understand their situation, understand their business, and hold these adjusters accountable and insurance companies accountable when they weren't doing what they should have been doing. So ⁓ Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: So it's definitely a time as a broker that can kind of make or break the relationship with that client. if you do a good job, you're gonna have a client for life. if you don't do a good job, you're probably gonna not keep that client ⁓ past its next renewal you know ⁓ on it. So ⁓ again, for it's kind of showtime. Up to that point, you know, we've been customer service, sales, ⁓ but this is where we really get to put on our insurance experts' hats and guide our clients through ⁓ what is a, you know. Not a fun process, though. Peter Brecht: Totally. Absolutely. so what are some I mean, do you have any examples of things that we can that you'd look at, like as as maybe you've come across a couple ideas, but anything specific maybe? Mike Tanghe: ⁓ yeah. Yeah, so in ⁓ unfortunately dealing with something here now where we have a client that had a claim come in. somewhat suspect my opinion of of the claim ⁓ itself, but carrier still has the has the ⁓ responsibility to ⁓ defend our client, again, they can't control a frivolous claim coming in against them. ⁓ They need good that's why they bought the insurance. So in this particular case, without going into all the details about the about it, but essentially, you know, we filed the claim and then the adjuster kind of gave it this, hey, ⁓ we're gonna cover this claim. and it kind of was not ⁓ it ⁓ was a response. So ⁓ the first that we do is say, okay, and we'll have a conversation with them on the phone and figure out, hey, you know, what's going on here? Why aren't you covering this? And g get a little bit more detail from them. ⁓ But the thing we'll do is say, Okay, please put it in writing. ⁓ Cause up to that point there's nothing really and especially over the phone, rarely will you get someone because we don't know why they're not covering why they say they're not gonna cover the claim. in every state's a little bit different, but most states will say that by a certain period of time you have to give formal denial letter and cite why on the policy ⁓ you're not covering what are the circumstances of the claim. ⁓ And that does a couple things. One, it shows that the carrier is doing their work, right? They're not just sitting there deny, deny, deny and and and not looking into it. so first step is okay carrier you say you're not gonna cover this claim I need you to put that in writing. and so ⁓ and once you that in writing now you have your your okay ⁓ let's roll up our and get to work. And it's looking at the of the policy that they're citing for it. It's reading the rest of the policy to see Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: ⁓ are there other areas that we think they could find coverage? So just because they deny under one area, doesn't mean that other areas of the policy or policies that they carry could apply. so it's looking for those things. ⁓ then it's also looking at their summation of why they're denying it. Like does that match the actual circumstances? Or are they either omitting facts or missing facts or misconstruing facts on it? so kind of step one is get that letter. Then it's getting together with your client and saying, hey, here's the game plan of what we're going to do. where I think they're wrong. Here's ⁓ what plan is ⁓ to to it, which is ⁓ in to respond to their letter and point out the areas that we disagree with them on. And letting the know ⁓ that we're not you this. This is effectively where we get to prove our worth ⁓ to you. We also let them know though that because we want to be realistic on stuff. We don't want to say, hey, this is so we're never gonna tell a client, hey, this is gonna be covered, ⁓ because we're not the insurance company. We can interpret the policy, but again, we're not the carrier, we're not the adjuster. we can say we disagree with this, but we can't go in there and say, hey, this claim will be covered. because that's ⁓ just it's we d we don't have that power to do that on it. We'll get the clients buy-in on this, that this is something that's important to them. Some t you know, some clients are like, This is too small. I don't wanna ⁓ you know, it reinforces what I don't like about insurance, but I'm not gonna go further with this. ⁓ or I don't want you to expend it. That's pretty rare. Most of the time they do want you to put up the fight on it, especially because it's not anything additional out of their pocket. ⁓ we also let ⁓ know though. ⁓ Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: At this point that it may be good, you know, who who's an attor do they work with a corporate attorney now? What's that person's familiarity with insurance law? We work closely with attorneys that are specifically on insurance claim denial litigators, ⁓ and insurance coverage experts. And I mean, there's been multiple times where I've had attorneys ⁓ copy I've done, my argument on things. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: ⁓ and just because it's coming from someone with a law firm ⁓ letterhead on top, it gets a different level of response. And I'm not naive enough or you know arrogant enough to think that's not it it it's it absolutely happens. it's frustrating. I don't like it, but it it's it's I've seen it multiple times ⁓ on it. the difference with right to that, I kinda call that like the nuclear option is that's gonna cost the client money. They're gonna have to pay that attorney either ⁓ an fee ⁓ or of these carriers will work on a combination of hourly fee plus a percentage of whatever they're able to collect. ⁓ and again, those attorneys ⁓ will like to see larger ⁓ dollar amounts, six-figure type disputes before they'll get involved on something like that. another alternative to as well is to get the Department of Insurance involved. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: That to me is also kind of a a nuclear option of sorts in that it takes a lot of time for the department insurance involved. They're gonna ask a lot of the insurance of us as as agents, which I'm fine with, but they're gonna ask a lot of ⁓ our clients as well. And if they they gotta be willing to invest that time. it can also I just I guess I haven't had great success in going to the Department of Insurance ⁓ on it. ⁓ 'cause it just involves a level of bureaucracy that and maybe it'd be great to hear if other people have. ⁓ but that's not something that I personally have had. I've had much better luck just working directly with a an attorney on that. So ⁓ excuse Peter Brecht: Yeah. Hmm. Yeah. Interesting. I thinking back to my and I and I know there's a few other things that we could look at there. ⁓ as a as a new broker, I remember the first phone call I got for a claim, I was ⁓ running I was Encinitas Turkey Trot ⁓ and a client calls me, ⁓ had phone with me, answered it on cr on Thanksgiving morning. They had a ⁓ someone threw a brick through their one of their windows and it was in Solana Beach, so just south of it. And ⁓ I was like, hey, look, finish my I'm gonna I'm not gonna I'm I'm not gonna say I ran, but I I'm ⁓ try to keep up with my family here. By the time I get back to the car, we'll we'll shoot over there. So you know, someone it looked like some ⁓ vandalized the the the glass and I just remember ⁓ thinking I've never had to deal with a claim before. like this is like the worst, like it and And it was kind of this like you have to learn as a broker how to go through this stuff. So, you know, who am I? I'm like, it's Thanksgiving. Like, who am I supposed to call? So I call up, ⁓ you know, I call up Matt and he picks up and he's like, dude, just this is what you gotta do. So I'm over there taking pictures of it, whatever, it's all good. We got it handled. But I remember, you know, just trying to navigate that. It it takes ⁓ it can sometimes take a team, right? And I'm not saying that, you know, figuring out a a glass breakage is a lot different, but in some of these larger cases, you need more. people looking at it with you to determine the best way through. So I guess I'm thankful I'm afforded ⁓ some great people around me that walk me through that even if it's just a broken, you know, broken window. ⁓ and I say just a broken window is devastating for them, but get through it pretty quickly. So a lot to learn if you're a new broker coming into it, even just on the claim side. And you won't know how to deal with it until you come across one and then you want good people around you to to help you sort through it. Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Yeah, a hundred percent. And if you're newer, you know, the the basic thing and I tell this to every every person we're working or new people in the industry is does it make sense to you? Like like you know, if if you were explaining it to your mom or dad or whomever, ⁓ ⁓ it make sense what you're saying? And if it doesn't, then start asking questions and ⁓ to be like, Hey, I I'm sorry, I I don't get this. I don't I don't get why you're not covering this claim or I don't understand why you're doing this. Like that doesn't make sense to me. Explain it. And you know, if if it If they're right and they are able to explain it to you, and maybe that you're looking at the wrong way or something, ⁓ okay, great. But if it doesn't, it's like that's you know, put that in writing, because I want to look more into this and I want to like your point, talk to some other people, go talk to the underwriter on it. If you're working through a wholesaler, talk to the wholesaler on it and get their opinion. because again, it's it's an interpretation, right? There's a contract between the insurance company and your client, and this is a person interpreting it. And if you think they're doing that incorrectly, or if you think And a lot of times it's not that I disn necessarily disagree with an adjuster, but if the policy's written in an ambiguous manner, it has to be interpreted for the insured's benefit. They weren't the ones who drew up the policy, it was the insurance companies ⁓ drew it up. So if they ⁓ the opportunity to write a contract and made it ambiguous, those courts have c consistently said that gets decided in your client's benefit. So ⁓ for that wording that's ambiguous. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: Make that argument. You know, the worst they can do is say no, which they already have. you'll find out that a lot of times if they're you know, if they're not correctly saying no, then ⁓ be able to win these cases. And it's ⁓ definitely a great feeling when you're able to come through for your client like that. Peter Brecht: Totally. Yeah, the point you just made about, you know, the the the insurance policy is, you know, it's really supposed to be written towards the insured's favor if it's ambiguous. Like that's a huge piece of this, right? And and something that's gotta be looked at. So I'm gonna take a I'm gonna take a page out of my seven year old son's book and ⁓ just kind of I don't know, ask questions, right? Constantly. It's good. Mike Tanghe: Hundred percent. Yep. Yeah, exactly. There's no harm in me like, Yeah, I don't I'm not following what you're talking about right here. So can you explain that to me again? ⁓ on it. And then if they can't do it, just hey, put it in writing. 'Cause then you get to write, hey, here's my reasoning. And then the beauty of that is then you can try and poke holes in that 'cause they've put plant you know, planted their position on it. I which is their job. They're supposed to do that. They have to do that. ⁓ that's inaccurate, ⁓ then Peter Brecht: Yeah. Yeah. Totally. Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: Hey, here's your here's what you said. And then because we have gotten claims where they've after we've pointed out provision, they're like, Well, we didn't really mean that. Well, no, no, no. You put that in your clo your your letter. You can't change what you're saying on it. And so it's takes a lot of time, can very frustrating, but to me, it's one of those, you know, you ⁓ it the becomes the principle piece of they better do this because. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Sure. Mike Tanghe: they made a promise to pay and they're not holding their promise and I don't like that. Peter Brecht: percent yeah we and I'll and I'll just say if there's one thing that I've learned is that kids will teach you how to become an a better insurance broker or a better client advocate because I I just keep going back and back and back and ⁓ it's been a lot of fun. So ⁓ man and a lot of great family things. I'm just gonna throw this out there. So many like just looking at our so we had our our Zoom call today and it's just so cool to see ⁓ Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Why? But why? Peter Brecht: the growth of the company and like everyone's families and new kids and like all these cool things. Like we did a ⁓ you know, two weeks ago we yeah, we did our our volunteer event and just, you know, we had like half a dozen dozen kids, you know, writing cards out and stuffing, you know, bags with goodies for ki you know, and it just amazing. So I just I don't know, those are the cool things. So ⁓ I don't know, I I wanted to bring that up at the beginning of the podcast, but here we are at the end and so hopefully that was a good ⁓ the day into that button. Mike Tanghe: Engagements, yeah. Peter Brecht: Anyways, it was it was a great it's been a great couple weeks and looking forward to the back half of the year now. So ⁓ anyways, with all that said, ⁓ we'll go ahead and wrap up here. I'll ⁓ I'll have the an article written hopefully in the next couple of days. Love to just really dig myself into to, you know, grammar edits and ⁓ of just just really soak it up for y'all. So we'll have that posted and published if you want to go through it or ask Chat GPT to to look at it. But Mike Tanghe: Hundred percent. Peter Brecht: Anyways, Mike, thank you so much for taking the time. We're at our twenty minute mark, which is kind of our ideal place to to land, and ⁓ we'll do this again next week. Mike Tanghe: Awesome. Sounds great. Thanks a lot, Peter. Peter Brecht: All right.