Latest / Film And Whiskey / An American in Paris (1951) / Evan Williams Bottled-in-Bond Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everybody, it's Bob. And I just want to let you know
- 0:02that today's episode is part of our Season 10 Rewind, where
- 0:06we're revisiting all of our episodes from season #1 this one
- 0:10was released early to our Patrons, and it was released all
- 0:13the way back at the end of 2023. What that means for you guys is
- 0:17if you would like to get the kind of bonus content that our
- 0:19Patrons have been receiving for two plus years, you can go to
- 0:23patreon.com/film Whiskey and sign up at any of our 3 levels
- 0:28of support. Enjoy the episode.
- 0:31In 1951, director Vincent Minnelli and star Gene Kelly
- 0:35gave the world a vibrant musical that never stopped trying to
- 0:38prove itself. In 2023, we try a fan favorite
- 0:42Bottled in Bond bourbon. The film is an American in
- 0:46Paris. The whiskey is Evan Williams
- 0:48White label. And we'll review them both.
- 0:51This is. The Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 1:13Welcome to the Film and Whiskey podcast, where each week we
- 1:15review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 1:18I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad Gee.
- 1:20And this week, we are revisiting 1951's Best Picture winner, An
- 1:25American in Paris. Brad, it's nice to revisit this
- 1:31movie. I have many thoughts.
- 1:33I think I've changed my tune a bit.
- 1:36But have you? There's something about.
- 1:37Yeah. Go ahead.
- 1:38They were super high on this film in season 1.
- 1:42There is something about like going back to our first 456 ish
- 1:47movies that like, even if I don't love the movie as much as
- 1:50I used to it, I have just so much nostalgia for the beginning
- 1:54of this podcast, you know? Yeah, 100%.
- 1:57Man, it is super fun to go back and think through these movies
- 2:03again. It's it's fun to revisit them.
- 2:05We were just little baby podcasters, man.
- 2:07We were recording this in a basement with a conference call
- 2:11microphone because we didn't have two mics to put together
- 2:13between the two of us. Yep man, Fun times.
- 2:17What a what a great time, man. All right, we'll see you next
- 2:20week. Thanks for walking down memory
- 2:22lane with us. And go watch an American in
- 2:26Paris. Yeah, Brad, OK, let's just dive
- 2:28in with this. I would like to hear general
- 2:30impressions on what did you think of this movie The first
- 2:33time around and has your opinion changed this time without
- 2:37tipping your hand too much? Oh man, I I think if I remember
- 2:42correctly, I think I enjoyed it the first time but wasn't super
- 2:46high on it. I'm guessing I gave it like a 7
- 2:481/2 or an 8. And I think that this time
- 2:52around, it just struck me how much fun this movie is.
- 2:57Like it's, it's just like, like I chose the word vibrant very
- 3:01specifically. Like it's just a really vibrant
- 3:04fun world that Minnelli and Kelly have created here.
- 3:09And I, I just absolutely love his friend Adam, I think is his
- 3:15name in the movie. Who's the Who's the actor?
- 3:17Oscar Levant. Yeah, yeah, Levant.
- 3:20I don't know how he says it. He is my favorite character in
- 3:22this. Movie.
- 3:23Oh, he's so good. There he is just.
- 3:25Incredible. I don't mean to derail what
- 3:27you're saying, but there was a moment, one moment in this movie
- 3:30where I laughed out loud. And it's when he is like, he's,
- 3:33he's in the Cafe, Adam is, and he's calling Henri as he's
- 3:39eating dinner. And he just keeps hinting that
- 3:40he wants to come up and eat dinner.
- 3:42And then Henri, he's like, no, no, no, I, I see you later.
- 3:45And he hangs up the phone and just goes, I'm hungry.
- 3:48Hangs the phone up and the way he says it is so like starving
- 3:54artist pouting that it was. It was just perfect and I needed
- 3:58to say that at some point in this episode.
- 4:00Did the inner grad student in your soul just, you know,
- 4:03empathize with him in that? And it was also like, he was so
- 4:06unkempt and just chain smoking through the whole movie.
- 4:09I was like, I get it dude. I get where you're coming from
- 4:12man. I have.
- 4:13I have been there. All right, so this time around
- 4:15you said it's a lot more fun. I think that I'm I'm in an
- 4:19interesting place on this movie, Brad, because if anything,
- 4:22watching another 300 or however many movies we've watched in
- 4:26between has really solidified for me that I love Vincent
- 4:30Minnelli as a director. And I still don't think he gives
- 4:33enough credit. He is a true like painterly
- 4:37artist with the camera and the color palettes and the
- 4:40costuming. Like it's just very much of a
- 4:42piece. I think the thing for with this
- 4:45movie for me is like Singing in the Rain is a movie that you
- 4:49don't really need any context for.
- 4:51If you have never watched a silent movie, if you know
- 4:55nothing about that era in movie history, if you know nothing
- 4:58about movie making, you can get dropped into Singing in the Rain
- 5:01And it it works for everyone from like 2 to 102.
- 5:06Yeah, this movie, it still works, but I feel like listening
- 5:12to a podcast like this will probably help appreciate it
- 5:15more. Like there's just a layer more
- 5:17of like, oh, you. You probably need this context
- 5:19to understand why this movie is considered important.
- 5:22It doesn't quite just work on its face as well as a movie like
- 5:26Singing in the Rain does for me. That's interesting.
- 5:29What, like what are some specific things about the film
- 5:32that you're like, oh, I need to explain this to to Brad, 'cause
- 5:35he clearly doesn't know what's going on here?
- 5:37Well, I think one of the big things is you got to kind of
- 5:40situate it like historically, especially in Gene Kelly's
- 5:43career. So Kelly, you know, comes off
- 5:45Broadway in the early 40s. He becomes a really big star in
- 5:49MGM musicals by the late 1940s. He's really surpassed even Fred
- 5:54Astaire. Cause Astaire is starting to get
- 5:55started, to get a bit older. And Kelly has been pushing and
- 5:58pushing for more kind of directorial control and he wants
- 6:02to do something big and bold and kind of operatic and and
- 6:05balletic with his movies. And so even though Vincent
- 6:09Minnelli is the credited director on this movie, and I
- 6:11think he did obviously direct the movie, it was really Kelly
- 6:14who was spearheading the whole production.
- 6:16And he had basically been begging MGM to let him do a
- 6:20movie like this. So in 194849, they made the
- 6:24movie on the Town, which is a really fun movie.
- 6:26And that was a Co Stanley Donnon movie that Gene Kelly kind of
- 6:30helped Co direct as well. And you get to American in
- 6:33Paris. And he had been like begging
- 6:36Louis B Mayer at MGM for the money to make this ballet
- 6:40sequence. And you got to let me do it my
- 6:42way. Mayer is on his way out the door
- 6:45and new guys coming in. And I think in that interim kind
- 6:48of change up, Kelly gets the permissions that he needs to
- 6:51just kind of make his movie his way.
- 6:52They give him a bunch of money to do it.
- 6:54And this is the result. And it's it's really one of the
- 6:57first MGM musicals that emphasizes like the artistic
- 7:03side of things. Like Brad, this movie closes
- 7:05with an 18 minute ballet. You know what I mean?
- 7:08Like they just weren't doing stuff like this then.
- 7:10And do I think it? Works.
- 7:11Can I say something? Yeah, please.
- 7:13I don't like the 18 minute ballot.
- 7:15That's what I'm saying. Do I think it works perfectly?
- 7:17No. But I think that that's the kind
- 7:20of layer I'm talking about where it's like, OK, like if you want
- 7:22to appreciate this movie, it might not work perfectly just at
- 7:26face value. But if nothing else, I
- 7:29appreciate this movie probably more than I like it at this
- 7:32point. Yeah.
- 7:33Well, I mean, a few seasons back we did a bunch of, you know,
- 7:36director series and and if anybody remembers, we we would
- 7:41rate the directors right. And we would use this scale.
- 7:44I think that this movie would fall so low on the cohesion
- 7:48scale that we used because we use it to talk about like within
- 7:53the world of the movie, how much of the things that happened
- 7:57makes sense. It does it feel like a cohesive,
- 8:00unified world, the the direction of the script, things like that.
- 8:04And I'm like, this movie does not make a lot of sense.
- 8:08And, and, and it's hard to say that because obviously musicals
- 8:12in general don't make sense. Like something that my wife
- 8:15always says about musicals, she's like, this doesn't make
- 8:18sense. People don't just break out and
- 8:20song and dance in normal everyday life.
- 8:22And I'm like, yes, that is very true.
- 8:25But that's part of the charm of musicals, right?
- 8:26It's it's an exaggerated way of looking at emotions and feelings
- 8:31in daily life. Some people love that, some
- 8:33people don't. That's fine.
- 8:35But even within the world of a musical, where people just
- 8:38randomly break out into song and dance, it felt like they were
- 8:42reaching for for a few of the things.
- 8:45Yeah, I like, you know, I wouldn't say that singing in the
- 8:48rain has a ton of plot, but there's a lot of complications
- 8:52in singing in the rain. Like this person gets fired and
- 8:54this person is angry and you have to navigate all these
- 8:57relationships in this movie. It really felt like a film in
- 9:00search of a plot. Like they're they're a few
- 9:03people who are in a love triangle and then there are a
- 9:07couple periphery characters and every character gets a big
- 9:11either ballet number or dream sequence or performance piece
- 9:16that are almost always unrelated to the plot of the movie.
- 9:19And Brad, even when you look up this movie on Wikipedia, like
- 9:22the first thing it says is that it's a tone poem movie.
- 9:26And what they're basically saying is like, it's, it sounds
- 9:29like an admission that this movie has no plot.
- 9:31And they're just saying like, you need to just go on vibes.
- 9:34Like this movie is all about vibes and I I.
- 9:37Like like a licorice pizza. Yeah, it's like the Terrence
- 9:40Malick of musicals and like, I kind of agree with that.
- 9:45Especially like the 1st 15 ish minutes of the movie where
- 9:48you're just meeting the characters and hanging out in
- 9:50the neighborhood, but then they start introducing these other
- 9:53characters like Gene Kelly's benefactor.
- 9:56And I just don't know like which plot is supposed to be the A
- 9:59plot and which is the B like a subplot And and like
- 10:02everything's kind of given equal weight and then we go off and do
- 10:06a dream sequence and like it. It just really feels messy from
- 10:11a script standpoint. Yeah, it it really does.
- 10:15And I don't think it necessarily like it doesn't ruin the movie.
- 10:19I think there's still a lot of fun sequences here.
- 10:23They build a really beautiful vision of, you know, what it
- 10:27looks like to kind of struggle in Paris.
- 10:30And overall, all of those things work.
- 10:32I, I think the, the hard part for me kind of revolves around
- 10:36the fact that I just, I did not enjoy Leslie Quran this time
- 10:41through. She she wasn't my favorite.
- 10:43I I don't think that her character is given enough to be
- 10:47a draw for Gene Kelly and for, I'm going to try to say his name
- 10:55Bob George Gwettari. Is that is that good?
- 11:01Yeah, I think is it, is it Gatari?
- 11:03I don't know. We'll, we'll.
- 11:05Gatari. George, we're going to call him.
- 11:06George, we'll call. Yeah, we'll call him George the
- 11:09the gentleman who plays Henri. Henri, I don't.
- 11:13Totally understand the obsession with the with Leslie Koran.
- 11:17Well, I don't, I don't get. It if I can briefly press pause
- 11:21on this thread because I think this is an important thread.
- 11:24I've mentioned 100 characters in this movie.
- 11:26You've mentioned the stars of the movie.
- 11:27We haven't actually explained this movie yet.
- 11:30And so I think it might be time for us to throw over to our
- 11:33first segment of the day, which we call, Brad explains.
- 11:36Brad's going to give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 11:39taken on the clock, so let's go ahead and do your take with this
- 11:43little segment that we call, Brad explains.
- 11:45Brad Explains is the part of the podcast where Brad breaks down
- 11:49the plot of the movie that he has just seen.
- 11:51We're going to say for the second time this year, Brad,
- 11:54have you watched this at all in the interim?
- 11:57No, I have not. That was a very confident no.
- 12:00Like, come on, no. There's there's certain movies
- 12:03that I've come back to. There's other movies that I've
- 12:06like, man, I need to get back and watch, you know, XY or Z.
- 12:11Then there's other movies that I haven't thought about since we
- 12:13recorded the episode. I'm not going to say which
- 12:17category. This one.
- 12:18Went to I mean, you already did. So Brad, you have 60 seconds on
- 12:22the clock to break down the plot of this movie.
- 12:25Tell us all about the weird plot mechanics if you can spoil the
- 12:29heck out of it. So if you haven't seen an
- 12:30American in Paris, listen, folks, I would still say that
- 12:33it's worth the watch. It is a beautiful movie to look
- 12:35at, and you've got Gene Kelly smiling and dancing like there's
- 12:38not. Yes, the life doesn't get much
- 12:39better than that. He has one of the best smiles.
- 12:42Just a beautiful man. Yeah, all right, dude, it's
- 12:45incredible. One minute on the clock and go.
- 12:49And American in Paris is a film about a struggling painter, a
- 12:53struggling pianist and a super successful singer who are all
- 12:57friends with one another. Two of the three fall in love
- 13:00with the same woman but do not know it.
- 13:02We follow mostly the painter played by Gene Kelly, as he is
- 13:07courted by this extraordinarily wealthy woman, even though he is
- 13:11in love with this beautiful young dancer.
- 13:16That is that it? Oh, OK.
- 13:17Is that the? Whole I was just here waiting
- 13:18like and and then. Well, I, I literally, I was like
- 13:22thinking, I was like, what else is there to this movie?
- 13:25And I realized. That's about it.
- 13:27Did you mention the love triangle?
- 13:30Yeah, yeah, yeah, the the singer and the painter are both in love
- 13:33with the same girl. Got it.
- 13:34OK. And and the painter has a
- 13:36wealthy benefactor who's I wouldn't even say she's in love
- 13:40with him. She's she's in love with the
- 13:42idea of flings. Yes, it seems to be.
- 13:45Yes, OK. Do you want to go back to Leslie
- 13:49Quran or do you want to cause 'cause the the benefactor Gene
- 13:53Kelly relationship is kind of like the thing I'm most excited
- 13:55to talk to you about so. We can hit on.
- 13:58Let's talk about that, OK? I actually really like the
- 14:01character of Milo this time around.
- 14:03I do too. And we actually, we spent a good
- 14:05deal of time talking about that in our original episode on this.
- 14:08And I was very proud of us that we were like, I'm kind of on her
- 14:11side. Like I don't understand why Gene
- 14:12Kelly is such a Dick to her all the time.
- 14:15Yeah, yeah. I I like her character a lot.
- 14:19I think that Nina Fock does an incredible job, you know,
- 14:23portraying this woman who's searching for meanings,
- 14:26searching for a relationship that will help her cope with the
- 14:30daily, you know, struggles of being wealthy there.
- 14:34There's a certain charm about her in this film that I don't
- 14:38know if I can fully describe, you know, where it comes from.
- 14:42But the way the Gene Kelly acts towards her is so rude.
- 14:47Like truly. Yeah.
- 14:48Like, she's very clear and upfront about what she wants
- 14:52from the start. She's like, hey, I I think
- 14:54you're attractive. I like your painting.
- 14:57And I'm curious about supporting you and kind of, you know,
- 15:00having you as a date to these balls and, and things like that.
- 15:03And he's just like, no, I'm, I'm interested in this other woman,
- 15:08but also you can, you can kind of help me out and I'm going to
- 15:10use you. Let's go a little bit deeper on
- 15:12the the actual like plot mechanics here.
- 15:14So Gene Kelly is set up on a street corner, not prostituting
- 15:18but selling his paintings. And she rolls by in her Rolls
- 15:21Royce or whatever and finds him and says, I'll come back to my
- 15:24place. I want to buy your paintings.
- 15:25And it's very clear what she's doing.
- 15:27But, you know, he hangs up his paintings.
- 15:29And she says, I'm throwing a party later, come by.
- 15:31And he comes back dressed all to the nines.
- 15:33And it's just the two of them. And he's like, hey, lady, I'm
- 15:37not a gigolo. And she's like, I don't want you
- 15:39for a gigolo. I just wanted to get to know you
- 15:40better. And you would have told me no if
- 15:42I'd been upfront. OK, fine.
- 15:45Well, then she starts bankrolling him and she's like,
- 15:47I'm going to set you up in a studio.
- 15:49I'm going to get you a showing in three months.
- 15:52And you can pay me back for 'cause you know, Gene Kelly's
- 15:54very proud about his money. You can pay me back from the
- 15:57sales of your paintings. And I think, Brad, that this is
- 16:01where the script really fails. Because watching at this time, I
- 16:06think the script really wants us to think that she is the the
- 16:09quote UN quote villain of the movie.
- 16:13And it just doesn't work. Like even at the end of the
- 16:15movie, they're at this big like artist's ball and he goes with
- 16:19Milo, this woman, and they run into Adam, Gene Kelly's best
- 16:23friend. And Adam knows exactly who she
- 16:25is and kind of gives her a, you know, a lashing of sorts and
- 16:29says, like, let's toast to my friend Gene Kelly because he's
- 16:35got a big showing in a couple months and he's going to take it
- 16:37in the neck or whatever. Like he's going to get
- 16:39criticized because he sucks at painting, basically.
- 16:42And she's like, oh, why do you say that?
- 16:43And he says, well, he has a benefactor that has more nerve
- 16:46than she does cash. And what he's saying is like,
- 16:50she's forcing him into this because she wants him so badly
- 16:53and this is her way of doing it. But like, I just don't kind.
- 16:56Of like a it's kind of like a Citizen Kane, you know, his
- 17:00second marriage. Yes.
- 17:01Trying to force her to be an opera.
- 17:03Singer and I just don't buy it. Like that's how artists make
- 17:06money. Like you get a benefactor and
- 17:08she's doing, you know, whether or not she is wanting, you know,
- 17:12to to jump on the Gene Kelly train is a completely different
- 17:17point. Like I don't see anything
- 17:18unethical in what she's doing and she's pretty upfront about
- 17:21it. Is train a euphemism?
- 17:23It sure is. Man the the Gene Kelly disco
- 17:27stick. The the Gene Kelly Alfred
- 17:30Hitchcock train going into a tunnel type of deal.
- 17:36Yeah, that, that was the thing that constantly confused me was
- 17:39like, I feel like that, like you said, that's the whole shtick of
- 17:44being an artist is like, I'm going to make enough art until
- 17:49somebody with money notices me and pays me for what I do.
- 17:54And if they don't, I will die penniless and I'll cut my own
- 17:57ear off and life's going to be miserable.
- 18:00Right? Like I, I don't, I don't
- 18:02understand what the supposed moral issue is that that Minelli
- 18:07and Kelly are trying to to portray here with.
- 18:10Script. Yeah.
- 18:11Once again, I feel like they they just got the barest
- 18:14semblance of a plot that they could try to link together all
- 18:17these really good musical numbers.
- 18:19Like you can tell in their planning process, whoever wrote
- 18:21the movie, they were like, Gene Kelly, what kind of dances do
- 18:25you want to do? We got all these.
- 18:26We got the rights to all these old Gershwin songs, which, first
- 18:29of all, I am such a sucker for George Gershwin.
- 18:32Like, I like. Oh my gosh.
- 18:34But Kelly's like, all right, I want to do this ballet.
- 18:37I want to do, I got rhythm. We could should probably throw
- 18:39in. It's wonderful at some point.
- 18:41And they're like, great, we'll write a story around that.
- 18:44And you can tell that they tried and it makes absolutely no
- 18:47sense. Well, here's the other part of
- 18:50it. When we're looking at
- 18:51performances, I think Milo, you know, just is so charming and so
- 18:58kind and, and like, she feels like the most real human of all
- 19:04the characters in this movie. Like the scene where she gets
- 19:06upset in the car about, you know, Gene Kelly going out with
- 19:10her and then completely, like, mooning over this other girl the
- 19:15whole time was so relatable. I'm like, yeah, I would be
- 19:19upset, too if I, like, took a girl out.
- 19:21And the entire time we were out together, she was like checking
- 19:24out some other guy. Well, and even in that scene,
- 19:26the throw a fit, they're, you know, all the companions are
- 19:30like, now, Milo, you've done this before.
- 19:33You only ever want a fling. And it's like, OK, first of all,
- 19:37there's nothing wrong with that. If that's how she wants to
- 19:39approach relationships and she's upfront and honest with people
- 19:41about it, then like you live your life, Milo.
- 19:45But but it's like they keep trying to make her seem
- 19:48villainous. And it's, I don't know if it's
- 19:50just that she is such a good actress, like she does such a
- 19:53good job in this movie that it undermines that because like,
- 19:57maybe you needed a singing in the rain type of, you know, Jean
- 20:01Higgins performance in that one where she's just like an over
- 20:04the top villain on purpose. Maybe that's what it needed.
- 20:07But I I like what we got, honestly.
- 20:10Well, I don't know if I'm, I'm like going way too deep than a
- 20:141950s musical is asking for, but it seems like, you know, the,
- 20:19the message they are trying to to say is good, is like Nina is
- 20:25getting in the way of true love. And true love can be established
- 20:30in a moment like, you know, love at first sight.
- 20:33And how dare she get in the way of that and her version of love
- 20:38of like, hey, let's, let's try to be open and honest.
- 20:41And I'm going to clearly. That's not love at all.
- 20:43My desires for this relationship, that's not love,
- 20:47that's evil and bad. And I'm like, I, you know, I'm
- 20:51sure that they didn't think about that too deeply when they
- 20:53were making, but that's kind of the message that I got as I was
- 20:56watching the film. And I don't know, I I think that
- 20:59true love is something of a mixture of the two.
- 21:01Well, and. Like, you know.
- 21:02Even if you grant them that, her courting of him is somewhat
- 21:08coercive. Like, Gene Kelly does the exact
- 21:11same thing to Leslie Caran's character.
- 21:13He runs into her and she's like, please leave me alone.
- 21:16You just took me out of the dance floor.
- 21:17I feel unsafe and uncomfortable. And he's like, ah, come on,
- 21:20baby. I'm Gene Kelly.
- 21:21And she's like, please, no. Then he, like, finds out where
- 21:25she works. He tracks her down.
- 21:26He's, like, essentially stalking her.
- 21:28And she's like, I would really prefer if you leave me alone
- 21:31forever. And then he just, you know, hams
- 21:34it up enough that she's like, ah, OK, I'll go out with you.
- 21:37But you know I I know that. It's supposed to be when when
- 21:41Milo does that, it's not OK. Right.
- 21:43And I know that it's supposed to come across as charming.
- 21:45And because it's Gene Kelly, like the audience is charming.
- 21:49Well, the audience inherently trusts that he's not a creep.
- 21:53But then you watch it through 2023 glasses and you're like,
- 21:56oh, like she's she's very clearly asking him to leave her
- 21:59alone and he's just not doing that.
- 22:01I was going to say, I always remember a bit of film analysis
- 22:06that has always stuck out to me is Patrick Williams and another
- 22:11YouTube talked about the movie Passengers with Jennifer
- 22:14Lawrence and Chris Pratt. And, and they talked about how
- 22:18if you filmed that movie solely from Jennifer Lawrence's
- 22:23perspective, then it becomes a true suspense horror film.
- 22:27Like is Chris Pratt evil? Is he like, you know, is he
- 22:31good? Is he bad?
- 22:32What's his motives here? We don't know what's going on
- 22:34and why he woke her up. I think that if you filmed this
- 22:38movie solely from Leslie Carran's perspective, I, I think
- 22:43that it turns into like, you could turn it into a
- 22:46psychological creeper drama where Gene Kelly is this
- 22:50terrifying figure that won't leave her alone and he keeps
- 22:53popping up at inopportune times. And she's trying to, you know,
- 22:57be faithful in this relationship to Henri.
- 23:00And and like, it could be a completely different movie if
- 23:03you just filmed it from a different perspective.
- 23:06Let's finish out talking about these performances.
- 23:08So we've got, you know, at least four more people to talk about.
- 23:10And we had touched on Leslie Quran earlier in the episodes
- 23:14and let's go back to her. I don't remember, Brad, if this
- 23:16is her actual debut movie, but she was 19 years old when Gene
- 23:21Kelly discovers, quote UN quote, discovers her, wants to cast her
- 23:25in this movie. Gene Kelly very famously, as he
- 23:28gets older, wants to have 19 year old Co stars because it's
- 23:31the same thing that happened in singing in the rain the
- 23:33following year. It's an interesting thing, Brad,
- 23:37because I don't think that she's a very good actress, at least at
- 23:39this point. You like really wouldn't acting
- 23:43It works like her. Her ability to dance works
- 23:46really well for what Kelly wants to do with the sort of like
- 23:48dialectic thing here. You know, like we we talked in
- 23:52Singing in the Rain about how Debbie Reynolds was not a dancer
- 23:55at all and Gene Kelly kind of forced her into dancing and and
- 23:57it's good. Like her dancing is very good,
- 24:00but it's really tap heavy and you know, American jazz
- 24:03inflected when you're first introduced to Leslie Quran in
- 24:06that sort of embraceable you dream sequence when when Aubrey
- 24:11is describing her and she does like 8 different dances to try
- 24:14to piece together what kind of girl she is.
- 24:17I was immediately like, oh, OK, like this is this is what they
- 24:20used to do in movies. Do you see like the level of
- 24:23control and dancings that she's capable of?
- 24:26Like it's physically an incredible performance.
- 24:30Yeah. Oh, it's absolutely beautiful.
- 24:33The that see that sequence might be my favorite like scene, you
- 24:38know, or sequence of scenes in the movie because it feels like
- 24:42the plot and the vibe of the movie.
- 24:47That's like the one time in the film that they are in perfect
- 24:51alignment. Like the vibe of like, let's
- 24:54let's think about this world impressionistically and, and,
- 24:57and, and the nuances of character and what we bring to
- 25:01the table. Like they illustrate that so
- 25:04well and so clearly. And they they make it clear why
- 25:08Henri has fallen in love with this woman.
- 25:11And I'm like, OK, I'm in that. That I can do.
- 25:15But you're right in saying that Leslie Caran just isn't a great
- 25:18actress. And also the script doesn't do
- 25:22her any favors. You know, to go to go back to
- 25:24the the perfume selling scene, Gene Kelly is just being AD and
- 25:32she out of nowhere goes from get away from me, I don't like you
- 25:37to OK, let's go on a date. And I'm like, wait, what?
- 25:42What just happened? This does not this does not flow
- 25:45well. There's, there's no continuity
- 25:47here. And it just, I don't know, it's
- 25:50not the worst thing in the world.
- 25:51It's, it's just, you know, some of my, my nitpicks.
- 25:54Let's talk about our Boy George as Henri Burrell.
- 25:57He's really good in the movie. He's a very charming like it it.
- 26:02You look at the guy and you're like, I understand why you would
- 26:04be a famous French singer. Like you're very French, but
- 26:07you're really good looking and super dapper and like, that's
- 26:11kind of all he's there to do. Like he again, not a great
- 26:13actor, you know? And and they did this thing a
- 26:16lot in Hollywood musicals where they would try to introduce like
- 26:18a famous opera singer is now going to be a movie star.
- 26:21And they try that for two movies.
- 26:22Then it didn't work. So they'd go back to the drawing
- 26:24board. Like it's really clear that
- 26:26they're trying to introduce this guy to American audiences and it
- 26:30works for what this movie is supposed to work for.
- 26:32And I have really have not much else to say about him.
- 26:35Yeah, he's super charming. I think he's pretty funny.
- 26:38The the inner. It's the innocence in him that's
- 26:41funny as a character that, you know, especially because he kind
- 26:45of gets put opposite of Oscar Levant a lot of the movie.
- 26:50He has that world weariness. You know, Henri has this, like,
- 26:54world innocence, and he's just taking things as they come.
- 26:57And I'm going to go to America and go on tour and get married.
- 27:01And even at the end of the film, it's implied that, you know,
- 27:04Leslie Quran tells him that she's actually in love with Gene
- 27:08Kelly. And so he just naively is like,
- 27:11well, all right, then that makes sense.
- 27:13You're in love. Go for it.
- 27:14And just releases her. Yeah.
- 27:16And I'm like, that's, that's charming.
- 27:18It's fine. Yeah, I do love that.
- 27:20Like, the the French stereotype of how they think about love is
- 27:25embodied in this guy. Like, you imagine what that
- 27:28conversation is like in the car. And, you know, to a Frenchman in
- 27:32the world of this movie, it's like, well, love, love conquers
- 27:36all. Love is the supreme thing that
- 27:37we worship. So like, I can't get in the way
- 27:39of that. Of course, I had to take you
- 27:40back to Gene Kelly instead of being like, yes, you've been
- 27:43doing what, behind my back. You know what I mean?
- 27:48Yeah. And it's not like, you know,
- 27:50there's there's a world where back in the day, people would
- 27:52just go on dates with each other and they they didn't mean as
- 27:55much as they do nowadays. And so this wasn't that.
- 27:59This was like a man who was desperately in love with her and
- 28:02ready to marry her. And she's, you know, leaving or
- 28:06she's not going to his performances because she's
- 28:08hanging out with Gene Kelly. She's, you know, leaving dates
- 28:11with him early so that she can be with Gene Kelly like she is.
- 28:15She is being a slimeball here, to be clear.
- 28:17I do love the, I don't know what it is about the French.
- 28:21Even in old Hollywood movies, they're always, they're always
- 28:24chasing after the barely legal girls, You know, like, the back
- 28:28story here is like, she came to my family during the war and she
- 28:31was just a little girl. And we didn't fall in love until
- 28:34she wasn't a little girl. And I'm like, OK.
- 28:36Until she was. Yeah. 18 years old and one day
- 28:39I. Was like, OK, bud?
- 28:40Yeah, yeah. You've had no feelings for her
- 28:42until then, you freaking groomer.
- 28:45Poor Leslie Quran. Like, the two options in the
- 28:48world that she has are guy who stalks her and guy who has been
- 28:52grooming her since childhood. Yep.
- 28:54Yeah. Big, big, big red flag, man.
- 28:57We are. We're really off the rails
- 28:59today. OK, Two people left to talk
- 29:02about Oscar Levant. We've already touched on him a
- 29:03bit. He is all of the Comic Relief in
- 29:06this movie. They try to give Gene Kelly a
- 29:08couple funny things to do, and they don't work.
- 29:10And so like, when you're watching Oscar Levant piece
- 29:13together that Gene Kelly and Henri are talking about the same
- 29:17girl, and he's, like, fumbling with his cigarette and dropping
- 29:20it in his coffee. And there's some really great
- 29:23physical humor to go along with the drawl, sarcastic voice.
- 29:28I just absolutely loved every moment he was on screen.
- 29:33Yeah, it feels like William Wyler took a little bit of that
- 29:37scene at the cafe and implemented it in Roman Holiday
- 29:41when, when Cary Grant is like, you know, tripping his friend
- 29:44and spilling coffee on him. And, and there's this like,
- 29:47playfulness there that like those two scenes reminded me of
- 29:50each other. And I yeah, you're right, man.
- 29:52Oscar Levant, there's something about his character and his his
- 29:58performance that felt the most real out of anybody in this
- 30:03movie. And I and so, yeah, I'm, I'm
- 30:05with you, man. I love me some Oscar in this
- 30:08film. Right.
- 30:09I think maybe let's let's hit pause here.
- 30:11We'll talk about Gene Kelly after the break because he did
- 30:14spearhead this whole project. And I think that talking about
- 30:17his performances, talking about, you know, the musical numbers
- 30:20themselves. I want to talk about the
- 30:22costumes in this movie because I think Gene Kelly's costumes are
- 30:24like next level stuff in this movie.
- 30:27And then we'll kind of finish out talking about the fact that
- 30:29this movie won the Oscar for Best Picture and that was a
- 30:33controversial pick even in 1952. So let's take a break here.
- 30:38Let's try this. Evan Williams, what do you say?
- 30:40Let's get to it. All right, so today we are
- 30:50checking out Evan Williams Bottled in Bond colloquial,
- 30:55colloquially known as colloquially known as Evan
- 31:01Williams white label because the regular Evan Williams has a an
- 31:04all black label. This one is the complete
- 31:06opposite, all white with black lettering on it.
- 31:10It is as most bottled and Bond whiskies are.
- 31:12It is 100 proof. It has a four year age statement
- 31:16on it. I I, I don't think it's most
- 31:17Bob. I I think it's all every single
- 31:20one. You can have like a five year
- 31:23bottled and bond. This one is very specifically
- 31:25like meeting the bare minimum required.
- 31:27I thought you were. I thought you were talking about
- 31:29the proof point I. Was like, Oh yeah.
- 31:32It's kind of all of it's 100 or 100 proof.
- 31:35That's a good point. So Brad Evan Williams is,
- 31:38according to the Heaven Hill Distilleries website, the second
- 31:42largest selling Kentucky Straight bourbon whiskey in the
- 31:45world as a brand. So this is the 100 proof version
- 31:49of that. I have found out since we first
- 31:51recorded this many, many years ago that Heaven Hill's mash bill
- 31:56for some of their bourbons is identical across brands.
- 31:59So the Evan Williams mash bill is 78% corn, 10% rye, 12% malted
- 32:06barley. So it's a low rye mash bill.
- 32:09It's the exact same mash bill that they use for Elijah Craig
- 32:13and also for some of their more inexpensive bottle than Bonds
- 32:16like JW Dance. And I just happened to have a
- 32:19bottle of Elijah Craig and a bottle of JW Dance on my shelf.
- 32:24And so I thought it would be kind of fun, like to not only
- 32:27pour the Evan Williams, but to pour the other two and to see
- 32:29like, is this just the same whiskey in three bottles or
- 32:32like, what are the differences here?
- 32:35I mean, is that is that cool with you if I just kind of do
- 32:37this project while you give reviews of what the whiskey at
- 32:40hand? Bob, you live your best life.
- 32:42I don't think you have so much fun with this.
- 32:45I won't stand in your way. I'll put up no obstacles.
- 32:48I will say that JW Dance sounds like a cheap local hometown
- 32:53lawyer that like you call when you've gotten like hassled by
- 32:59the police or something. There's.
- 33:01Just something about the initials.
- 33:02JW Yes, yeah. Like it just seems like a like a
- 33:06really shady lawyer. Yeah, like the judge kind of
- 33:09sighs heavily when he sees him walk into the courtroom.
- 33:12All right, man, so I'm going to say this.
- 33:14Part of the reason that I poured both of these other two brands
- 33:17is I have never been a huge fan of Evan Williams bottled and
- 33:21Bond. It is a beloved budget bourbon
- 33:25among a certain sector of people.
- 33:27It's just never been my thing. And so I really want to see
- 33:30like, am I just falling victim to the bottle?
- 33:33Like am I just seeing that it's Evan Williams and telling myself
- 33:35I don't like it? Or is there an actual difference
- 33:38between this and Elijah Craig and JW Dant?
- 33:42So without further ado, let's dive into to the Evan Williams.
- 33:46Brad, what are you picking up on the nose here?
- 33:48This is a decent nose. It's definitely a little bit
- 33:51alcohol forward. The the proof points are coming
- 33:55through and and not in the most pleasant way, but it it's got
- 33:58some nice brown sugar. There's some caramel vanilla, a
- 34:01little bit of oakiness. It's a decent nose hovering on
- 34:07the edge of being like solid. I'll give it a 6 1/2.
- 34:15Yeah, close to A7. All of our scores today are
- 34:18going to be considering the fact that this is like a $15 bottle
- 34:22of whiskey. So like, you know, it is what it
- 34:24is. I just finished nosing all three
- 34:27of these, Brad, and my suspicions have really been
- 34:30confirmed here. So Elijah Craig has this really
- 34:33kind of fruit character to it. Like there's a lot of red apple.
- 34:37I got some orange. It has a much more like, it
- 34:40smelled more like a cocktail than straight bourbon, and I
- 34:44like that a lot. But then I went to knows this JW
- 34:46Dance, and it was like sawdust and manliness and like, it had
- 34:52much kind of like darker, mustier notes to it.
- 34:55And I really like that as well. JW Dan.
- 34:57Yeah, exactly. JW Dan is one of my favorite
- 35:01budget pours. The Evan Williams is like, it's
- 35:03not even in between those two. It's like if you just kept going
- 35:06down the dark musty hallway into a door you're not supposed to go
- 35:11into. Like it just smells a little bit
- 35:12too oaky. It smells a little bit like it's
- 35:15going to be bitter. I don't get those kind of
- 35:17classic vanilla brown sugar notes on this so much.
- 35:20It just seems like a like an excessively oaky spicy bourbon.
- 35:26I'm going to give it a 6th and 1/2 on the nose but I have a
- 35:29feeling I know where this is going on the taste.
- 35:32Yeah, as as I got into the palate, the the note I took was.
- 35:38Like. Like it's not quite orangey.
- 35:42It's kind of like the essence of orange, but a little bit sour,
- 35:46and it's just kind of a hint of orange there.
- 35:49There's some vanilla, there's some pepper.
- 35:52It the the texture. That's not even the right word.
- 35:56There is something about it that reminded me of Pop Rocks a
- 35:59little bit that I don't know what it was, the way it
- 36:02interacted with my palate, but it kind of reminded me of Pop
- 36:05Rocks. It's OK, it's not bad.
- 36:08I'll give it a 6 1/2 here. Yeah.
- 36:11So again, like, I just, I drank the Elijah Craig and then I
- 36:14drank the JW Dance, and there's market differences there.
- 36:18The damp, I'm going to be honest with you, the damp tastes really
- 36:21cheap, but it tastes cheap in a way that's like, it appeals to
- 36:24me who is forever a poor college student at heart.
- 36:29Like it has like a lot of oak. It gets a little bit bitter.
- 36:33There is like more rye spice to it than I was expecting.
- 36:36And then you get like a fake sweetener note at the end.
- 36:39Yeah. The Evan Williams is all of that
- 36:42without fake sweetener for me. Like I just don't, I don't get
- 36:46much on this except just like here's a bunch of oak and here's
- 36:50some really bitter notes. I have a feeling that people
- 36:53like this because it probably mixes really well in like an old
- 36:56fashioned or any whiskey based drink because it's higher proof
- 37:00and it just brings like the wood character to it.
- 37:04But sipping it neat. I, I, I just don't know that I
- 37:07love this man. I'm going to give it a 5 1/2 on
- 37:10flavor. Yeah, for me, I'm actually at a
- 37:135 1/2 on the finish. The the finish is just dry oaky
- 37:19there. There's some black pepper going
- 37:21on, but it's just kind of saps my soul a little bit.
- 37:27And it, it's, it's fine. It like a 5 1/2 is not a good
- 37:32score, but it's also not a bad score.
- 37:35So it's it's OK. It's nothing to write home
- 37:37about. I'm trying to find the right
- 37:39word to describe this whiskey because it's not like today I
- 37:43had to have a cup of coffee at a place that I don't usually get
- 37:45it. And you know what?
- 37:47You're just like used to. Drinking a not the gas, not the
- 37:50gas station. No, it's even worse than that.
- 37:53You know, like sometimes when you get like mass produced, like
- 37:55Folgers, it just kind of tastes like they've accidentally or
- 38:00purposefully ground up bits of cardboard instead of coffee.
- 38:04Like there's a, there's like a stale old paper flavour.
- 38:08Yeah. I'm trying to decide if, like,
- 38:10this is the whiskey equivalent of that.
- 38:12I know I wouldn't call it stale, but it definitely tastes like if
- 38:17someone stuck this in front of me, it would be, like, my least
- 38:22favorite kind of bourbon. Yeah.
- 38:25Like all the notes that I I tolerate in other bourbons, it's
- 38:28like those are the only notes. Here, yeah, they're prominent.
- 38:31You know what I mean? Yeah, no, I mean, I love the
- 38:34coffee analogy because for me, I remember growing up and thinking
- 38:39that coffee smelled pretty good, like when my parents made in the
- 38:42morning. But once I was a teenager and I
- 38:44tried it a few times, I literally remember I would have
- 38:48to brush my teeth twice and then also like chew a stick of gum to
- 38:53get that bitter coffee out of my off of my palate.
- 38:59And it wasn't until I was in my late 20s that I had a really
- 39:03good cup of coffee and was like, oh, I could like coffee.
- 39:07That's not, you know, Maxwell House like.
- 39:12And I, I'm with you, man. There's definitely some whiskeys
- 39:14that fall into the Folgers Maxwell Houses of the world.
- 39:19Now, again, I don't know if this is one of them, but it has a
- 39:22similar thing where it's like this is a completely different
- 39:24kind of coffee. This is a completely different
- 39:26kind of whiskey that I do not prefer.
- 39:29So I'll give it a six on finish. I'll give it a six on balance.
- 39:33And that is because this is like, again, a $1520 bottle of
- 39:37whiskey. Brad, what is this currently
- 39:39retailing for in the state of Ohio?
- 39:41Yeah, Bob, this is a $19.99 bottle of whiskey in the state
- 39:46of Ohio. I am seeing it online for as low
- 39:49as 1099 on sale at some places so it seems like we got to move
- 39:54some units here. Heaven Hill.
- 39:56I don't think this is a great value even at 1999.
- 39:59I'm drinking this JW dance right now.
- 40:02It is. I think 15 bucks now you can
- 40:05only get it in like Kentucky. I get that.
- 40:08It's just significantly better at $5 cheaper.
- 40:12I'm going to give this AI don't know, a six out of 10 on value
- 40:17just because a $20 bottle of whiskey is is pretty much a good
- 40:21value no matter how bad it is. So like I can, I can only give
- 40:24it a low enough score to punish it a bit, but I'm coming out to
- 40:28a six on value. What are you at, Brad?
- 40:30I, I'm also at a six. I, I, I think that this isn't a
- 40:35terrible value. I think it's a decent bottle of
- 40:38whiskey that you can use as a mixer and some of your, your
- 40:41mixed drinks. But overall it, it just doesn't
- 40:44have quite enough going on for it.
- 40:46And there are other options here in the 20 to $25.00 range that I
- 40:51would much more highly recommend.
- 40:53And, and, you know, we'll go to the classic Rebel 100.
- 40:57I'm coming out to a 30 out of 50.
- 40:59Brad, where are you sitting on this one?
- 41:00I am at a 30.5 all. Right.
- 41:03So our average is a 30.25 out of 50 or a 60.5 out of 100.
- 41:11This is nothing to write home about, folks.
- 41:12And even amongst budget bourbons, you know it.
- 41:16It's likely that people just have their preferred budget
- 41:18whiskey. I just, I struggle to understand
- 41:21the cult that has formed around this bottle because I just
- 41:24don't, I don't find it to be anything special.
- 41:26Brad. Yeah, I know.
- 41:28I'm, I'm with you, man. I, I think that this is an
- 41:31example for me of like following the big name brands and just
- 41:36having a loyalty there for some unearned reason.
- 41:40I I don't understand it all. Right, man.
- 41:43Well, before we get too philosophical on that front.
- 41:46Was that was that harsh? Yeah, it was a little harsh, but
- 41:48also like we're opening a can of worms that we do not have time
- 41:52to dive into today. So let's get back into talking
- 41:56about an American in Paris. What do you say?
- 41:58Let's get to it, Bob. All right everybody, That was
- 42:05Evan Williams white label, a whiskey that we will gladly tap
- 42:10dance away from Bob. I am super excited because we
- 42:16are in the midst of a great season for two facts and a
- 42:19falsehood. Yeah, we're only a couple
- 42:21episodes in, man, but I am, I'm feeling more optimistic about
- 42:25this season just 'cause I know the movies better, you know, I
- 42:28can go back and listen to a full episode's worth of context that
- 42:31we've already recorded and hope that you're not doing the same.
- 42:35And so maybe some of the tidbits that you've shared are going to
- 42:38come up again. We'll see.
- 42:39I don't know. I'm feeling good about myself.
- 42:41It may just be because we're watching a Gene Kelly movie.
- 42:44But Brad, that means that it is time for our next segment, which
- 42:47we call 2 Facts and a Falsehood. Brad is going to try to stump
- 42:52you. Ball 2 are right and what is
- 42:56wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 43:00and a Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad presents me
- 43:03with three items about the making of this movie, all of
- 43:06which are presented as fact, one of which is a complete lie, and
- 43:10I have to figure out which one that is.
- 43:13As I've said, I'm very optimistic.
- 43:15I don't know if I actually have reason to be.
- 43:17But none of this goes from here. Hit me with your two facts and a
- 43:22falsehood. Fact number one In an interview
- 43:24later in her life, Quran says that she found the dancing
- 43:27particularly difficult as the studio floors were concrete and
- 43:31not sprung as she was used to. Also, the bright floor paints
- 43:34made the surfaces quite slippery.
- 43:37Fact number 2IN spite of the fact that the film was almost
- 43:40entirely shot on MGM's Lot 44 in Hollywood, they experienced
- 43:45multiple rain delays due to a historically wet summer in
- 43:48California. It rained so hard that they
- 43:50couldn't work around the sound of the downpour hitting the
- 43:52roof. Fact #3 Arthur Freed originally
- 43:56just wanted to buy the rights to George Gershwin's number
- 43:59American in Paris, but Ira Gershwin said that he'd only
- 44:02sell on the condition that if a musical were to use the song, it
- 44:05would only use Gershwin numbers as its other songs.
- 44:09I like that. I don't know if it's true or
- 44:11not, but a bit of Hollywood history here.
- 44:14We haven't really talked much about Gene Kelly in terms of his
- 44:17place in Hollywood, but obviously his biggest competitor
- 44:21in the market was Fred Astaire. And Fred Astaire very famously
- 44:24made a movie called Swing Time where all of the songs were
- 44:27Gershwin songs. Now, this is when George
- 44:29Gershwin was still alive, and so Gershwin wrote every single song
- 44:33for that movie specifically. But it seems plausible to me
- 44:37that any subsequent Gershwin movie or movie using Gershwin
- 44:42would have to use all Gershwin. Say he could also like know
- 44:45about the rivalry between the two and be like, I got, I got
- 44:49all these ones for here. Here's a easy payday.
- 44:52Yeah. If you if you want to be like
- 44:54your competition, you better hire me for the whole thing. #1
- 44:57sounds really plausible too. You know, this was Leslie
- 45:00Caron's first major movie in Hollywood.
- 45:02I can't remember if it's actually her first Hollywood
- 45:05film, but the idea of dancing on concrete sounds terrible.
- 45:09And there are many, many horror stories from the golden age of
- 45:12musicals about bleeding through shoes and everything else.
- 45:15So I'm going to say that one's true #3 sounds pretty true, and
- 45:20#2 sounds really innocuous. So I'm just going to go ahead
- 45:23and say #2 is the falsehood just because I found it to be the
- 45:28most boring fact? Wah wah, boring Bob, you are
- 45:34correct. That is the Gall said.
- 45:37All. Right.
- 45:37Congratulations, Sir. Thank you.
- 45:39You have. Won nothing I've.
- 45:41Won absolutely nothing except the chance to lose next week and
- 45:44balance out this win. That's right.
- 45:47All right, man, let's get back into talking about the movie.
- 45:49And when I say the movie, I mean Gene Kelly, because we've talked
- 45:53about everything else except for Gene Kelly so far.
- 45:57Brad, I I mean, it's kind of hard to talk about Gene Kelly
- 46:00performances in musicals because he is one of these guys that I
- 46:04think he's a very good actor and he had a number of dramatic
- 46:07roles where he wasn't singing and dancing.
- 46:10But when you talk about Gene Kelly in a musical, more than a
- 46:14character, he's just being Gene Kelly.
- 46:17Like the Gene Kelly persona is inserted into different
- 46:21situations. And so it's kind of like, how do
- 46:24you talk about Gene Kelly in this movie?
- 46:26We've already talked about him and singing in the rain.
- 46:28Just go listen to that. And so I think maybe part of
- 46:32part of the conversation needs to be like, what didn't work
- 46:35about Gene Kelly in this movie for you?
- 46:38And or we've both already established we like singing in
- 46:42the rain better. What's different about Gene
- 46:44Kelly there than here? And and why does it make such a
- 46:48difference? Man, I think that An American in
- 46:53Paris feels more just a little slipshod, a little more rough
- 47:04around the edges than Singing in the Rain does.
- 47:06Singing in the Rain just feels like it has this, this airtight
- 47:11command and vision behind the film that just drives it
- 47:15forward. Whereas this one just feels kind
- 47:18of fluffier around the edges. It doesn't quite have the clean
- 47:22ascetic that you have in Singing in the Rain and I I think that
- 47:26affects my view of Kelly in this movie versus singing.
- 47:30Yeah, it's it's weird because I completely agree with what
- 47:33you're saying. It is rough around the edges in
- 47:34that it feels more unfocused, but it doesn't feel like a more
- 47:39rough and tumble movie. Like if anything, it feels much
- 47:41more stately and kind of not not stoic, but stayed, you know,
- 47:46like it's just it's it's very inert as a movie, even though
- 47:50there's a lot of movement that was just great ballet sequence
- 47:52at the end. Like Vincent Minnelli was such a
- 47:57good composer of shots. And so in a lot of these musical
- 48:01numbers, like there's a number where Henri and Gene Kelly are
- 48:07singing the songs wonderful. And they're just walking down
- 48:10the street and all the camera does is just kind of track
- 48:12alongside them. And then at the very end, it
- 48:15cranes up because they're going in opposite directions on the
- 48:18street. And so in the top right corner
- 48:20of the screen is Gene Kelly, and in the bottom left is his friend
- 48:23Henri. And that's literally the extent
- 48:25of the camera work in those sequences.
- 48:29It's very much like Minnelli's, like, here's the shot, move
- 48:32around within it, and that's what you get.
- 48:34Whereas, you know, Brad, I was listening back to the Season 1
- 48:37version of this episode and was reminded, and I totally forgot
- 48:41about this. Minnelli actually had to move on
- 48:44to making a different movie and just basically turned over the
- 48:47movie to Gene Kelly. And so Gene Kelly directed most
- 48:50of the ballet sequence. And if you watch that ballet
- 48:53sequence, like the camera is weaving in and out of people.
- 48:56It's kind of like chasing Gene Kelly through situations.
- 48:59There's a ton of really weird looking close-ups.
- 49:02And it's clear that Gene Kelly wants the camera to be a
- 49:06character in these dance sequences instead of just like
- 49:11Minelli, which is you are watching my painting.
- 49:13You know what I mean? Like the camera is not there.
- 49:16You're just looking through this porthole that I've established.
- 49:19And I think I say all that to say, like Singing in the rain
- 49:23works so much better because Kelly is able to do this huge
- 49:29like vaudevillian energy through that whole movie.
- 49:33Like it's just you could you could put that movie poster up
- 49:38and just hum. And it's like, that's the energy
- 49:41of that movie. It is like a breakneck pace.
- 49:44It's goofy, it's silly. He totally buys into the
- 49:47slapstick of it. Whereas this movie, he's like, I
- 49:50want to make it feel like I'm a man of the people, but I'm in
- 49:53Paris and everything is so painterly and like, it's just,
- 49:57it's almost like they're at odds, Minelli and and Kelly.
- 49:59And so I feel like Kelly's performance suffers as a result
- 50:03of that. Yeah, I mean, you have him
- 50:05narrating the opening about, ah, so beautiful to live in Paris.
- 50:10And my friends, I have so many friends.
- 50:13And then like the average American is like, yeah, no, I I
- 50:16don't know anything about Paris. Never been there.
- 50:18Like I also don't have friends. We have a pandemic of loneliness
- 50:22here. Move along please.
- 50:25So it just, yeah, this film just it suffers there.
- 50:30There's undeniable issues with kind of the vision of of what
- 50:35they're trying to accomplish here.
- 50:37And I think you're right. I think Kelly is trying to shoot
- 50:39for something different than Minelli and that like that's not
- 50:43the end of the world, but it it definitely leads to a few
- 50:46drawbacks that the film has to overcome.
- 50:50OK, Brad, I, I mean, I really don't have much more to say
- 50:53about Gene Kelly. And I, I hate to say it like
- 50:55that, but like he's Gene Kelly, folks like, you know, he exudes
- 51:00this radiance and this joy. Yeah, Charm, charisma, all the
- 51:05things. If I had to list like my all
- 51:07time favorite Gene Kelly musical numbers, like obviously the
- 51:12Singing in the Rain number is is #1 but right behind it, Brad is
- 51:17when he sings I got rhythm surrounded by a bunch of small
- 51:20French children. And it's just, Oh my gosh, dude.
- 51:24Like, it's just how do you not watch a sequence like that and
- 51:28whatever's going on in your life, just feel 10 times better
- 51:31about like, it's his persona and he was an exacting, not very
- 51:36kind person to work with from what I've heard.
- 51:39But the persona that he could put on when they called action
- 51:44is like unparalleled in the history of movie making.
- 51:49Yeah, and it had to feel jarring for, for the people working with
- 51:53him to be like, man, what what happened to the the guy who was
- 51:57just yelling at me 10 seconds before and and now he's the
- 52:00nicest person. Like, I don't know if you have
- 52:02this experience with your parents, but like, I remember
- 52:05one time my brother and I were just being little crap heads and
- 52:09my mom was like yelling at us. And, and it it's like one of the
- 52:11few times I remember her swearing at us, she and it
- 52:14wasn't even anything. She was like, you guys just
- 52:17don't give a damn about me. Like, like that was it.
- 52:21And then we walked in to get ice cream and her whole, hey, how
- 52:26are you guys? It's great to be we'd love to
- 52:28get some ice cream. Like the nicest, happiest human
- 52:31being. And I was like, look to my
- 52:33brother. And I'm like, what just
- 52:34happened? Like she was just yelling at us
- 52:36and crying like 10 seconds ago. And I feel like that's probably
- 52:40the experience people had to have had with Kelly.
- 52:42That's really funny. OK, So I want to transition to
- 52:46talking about the Oscars because, you know, we've noted
- 52:49it in the first half a little bit.
- 52:50This movie wins the best picture Oscar.
- 52:52It was a huge surprise. Part of it is because the
- 52:55producer of this movie, Arthur Freed, who was the the producer
- 52:58of all these big musicals, he won the Irving Thalberg Memorial
- 53:03Award this night. And so like he was already
- 53:05getting, you know, fated by by Hollywood.
- 53:09And so in addition to that, they come on stage, they announce
- 53:12that this movie has won best picture.
- 53:14And it was a complete shock. Nobody expected this movie to
- 53:17win. And I, I've been thinking about
- 53:20it a lot, Brad, because in the, in the current climate of the
- 53:25Oscars, I feel like the complaint we hear from average
- 53:28people all the time is like, I have never heard of these films.
- 53:31I have never seen these films. They only award like these
- 53:34boring Oscar bait movies. I wish that they would give
- 53:38Oscars to normal movies. And then you have an example
- 53:42like this. An American in Paris wins best
- 53:44picture and it wins over some pretty heavy hitters like A
- 53:48Streetcar Named Desire with Marlon Brando where Marlon
- 53:51Brando basically introduces the world to both himself and method
- 53:57acting and it is like a sensation.
- 54:00There's another movie that comes out this year called Quo Vadis,
- 54:02which is this big epic in Roman times, A Place in the Sun with
- 54:07Montgomery Clift and Elizabeth Taylor.
- 54:09Very controversial movie, but well liked.
- 54:12And I, I can't help but wonder, Brad, if the reason this wins is
- 54:15because Hollywood is kind of sitting on the edge of a bit of
- 54:20a revolution here in terms of how movies get made.
- 54:22And they just don't. The older members of the Academy
- 54:25especially, like, don't want to get dragged into the 1950s.
- 54:29And they're like, let's give it to what we know works and what
- 54:33we like and what is inoffensive and not controversial.
- 54:37And that's Gene Kelly and an American in Paris.
- 54:40But I also wonder, like, looking back on it now, I don't know
- 54:45that anyone would even say today that this is the best movie that
- 54:48got made in 1951. So it's like, do we want normal
- 54:52movies to win over like stuffy dramas or do we actually want
- 54:56the best movie to win? Because this still kind of
- 54:59sticks out like a sore thumb. I don't know why this movie wins
- 55:01best picture. And even as a guy that likes it,
- 55:04I don't know that I would say like it deserves to win best
- 55:06picture. Yeah.
- 55:08And then that's the difficult thing is how do you as a 2020,
- 55:13whatever person, go back and really judge what was happening
- 55:18at that time? But I think that you can say
- 55:22this about American in Paris. I don't think it deserved to win
- 55:25in the best picture. Just just flat out like I, I
- 55:30remember watching The Bishop's Wife with Cary Grant and I never
- 55:37knew this. It's, it's one of my favorite
- 55:38like Christmas movies. And I watch it maybe not every
- 55:40year, but every 3rd or 4th year, I'll put it on.
- 55:44And I looked it up and I realized it was nominated for
- 55:46best picture in like 47 or 48 whenever it came out.
- 55:51And I just, I, I was watching it, I was like, this is not a
- 55:54best picture nominee. It's a, it's a great film.
- 55:57I have nostalgia with it. It's not a best picture nominee.
- 56:00And I, I think that American in Paris is probably worthy of a
- 56:03nomination, but I, I don't know if it's a, it's a best picture
- 56:07winner. And like, I don't know if this
- 56:09is how it happened, but it seems like one of those things where
- 56:12you know you're going to give this memorial award to the
- 56:15producer. And so they're probably like,
- 56:17the hell, like, let's just put American in Paris up for best
- 56:20picture as like just another pat on the back, like it'll never
- 56:23win. And then they start counting the
- 56:26votes that they're just like, oh, crap.
- 56:28Oh, no, oh, no, oh, no. Like as they get farther down
- 56:31the list, I think it's one of those situations.
- 56:33And again, like, maybe not. Maybe everybody really did love
- 56:37this movie. But to read articles from the
- 56:40time, headlines from the time it seemed like this was out of left
- 56:43field and did not really go over well.
- 56:46But it's just, it's funny to me, Brad, that the the debate has
- 56:50never stopped where it's like, do we reward the movie that
- 56:54makes people feel good but is clearly not the best?
- 56:57Or do we give it to movies that everyone's going to look back on
- 57:0115 years from now and just say that was boring and stuffy.
- 57:03So it's like we, we can't, we can't have it either way,
- 57:06apparently. Yeah.
- 57:08And that, and that's that's the difficult part.
- 57:10Like you can be in the common rabble as we often portray
- 57:15ourselves and and, you know, bemoan the the Oscars and how
- 57:20out of touch they are. But I also just look at it and
- 57:23go, hey, man, like the people who choose these movies are not
- 57:28the common rabble. Like they are the best of the
- 57:32best, the people who have been in the industry for forever and
- 57:36they are looking for different things in their movies than we
- 57:39are. And, and there's times where it
- 57:42seems like, you know, they'll, they'll put popular movies in
- 57:46there. But I, I don't always blame them
- 57:48for putting in the things that make sense for them to put in
- 57:52there. I don't know.
- 57:53Does that make sense? Yeah.
- 57:54And it's also like, it does strike me sometimes too, that
- 57:57like, sometimes a populist movie wins and everyone agrees, like,
- 58:01hey, Casablanca was actually a a very worthy best picture winner.
- 58:06But then it's like this movie wins and everyone's like, like,
- 58:09rumbling about it. And it's like, OK, well, I think
- 58:12what you're saying is I just don't like this movie as much as
- 58:14Casablanca. So I'm going to concoct a
- 58:16scenario where this was just an old boys club awarding one guy.
- 58:22And like, they're like, let's be real here.
- 58:24The Oscars is just a boys club awarding one guy every year.
- 58:28It's just that some year we like, some years we like the
- 58:31movie better than others. Let's just be real.
- 58:33Yeah, 100% and that's OK. It's like the Brad G Awards at
- 58:37the end of every season, you know you've only got to impress
- 58:39one person. That's it man.
- 58:42If you impress me, the rest of your life is basically set you.
- 58:46You can die a happy person. That's what I've been trying to
- 58:49do for 10 seasons now, Brad. Good luck man.
- 58:53All right, let's get into our last segment of the day, which
- 58:55we call. Let's make it a double.
- 58:58We're near the end of the episodes of Things, listening to
- 59:01the film and Whiskey Show. Let's have another film with
- 59:04this one, even if it's struggling.
- 59:05It's the final. Segment of the day.
- 59:07Now let's make it a double. Let's Make It a Double is the
- 59:09part of the show where we pick a movie to pair up with this one
- 59:12to make the perfect double feature.
- 59:15I'll get mine out of the way really quickly here, Brad.
- 59:16It is another Gene Kelly Vincent Minnelli pairing.
- 59:20It is one of my personal favorite musicals.
- 59:22It has all of the same faults as an American in Paris.
- 59:25It's a little too long, a little too static.
- 59:29It's it gets a little boring, but I am like in awe of the
- 59:33setting and the songs. And so I it's a 10 out of 10 in
- 59:37Bob Book's book. And it is Brigadoon.
- 59:41Dude, you've you've brought up Brigadoon a few times.
- 59:44It's going to be like a prime candidate for if we ever do
- 59:46another one of those seasons where we just pick like 15
- 59:48random movies that we would never, we would never do any
- 59:51otherwise. And it's very clearly like a
- 59:54movie that Brad will give a 7 to and be like Bob.
- 59:57I don't get it. And and I just have to shrug and
- 1:00:00be like I don't know why this works on me, but it does.
- 1:00:03It's another School of Rock situation.
- 1:00:06No, the School of Rock is a 10 out of 10 man.
- 1:00:08It's not Bob, Bob. You could give that movie a nine
- 1:00:12out of 10 and I wouldn't give you crap because sure, why not?
- 1:00:16That movie is not a 10 out of 10.
- 1:00:20All right, man, what's yours? Let's make it a double.
- 1:00:22My let's make it a double. I think I'm going to choose
- 1:00:25another musical. We're going to stay in the vein
- 1:00:27of musicals that is from a similar era and one that I have
- 1:00:32not seen in a while, but from what I remember it, I remember
- 1:00:35it being shaggy a little too long and and have some issues.
- 1:00:39So basically I'm doing what you did.
- 1:00:41I'm going to choose Guys and Dolls.
- 1:00:43Oh yeah, that's a. Really is way too long.
- 1:00:47Oh it's so long, but I for some reason, man, it is so much fun.
- 1:00:52I just remember really loving that movie.
- 1:00:54I love it, dude. Let's just keep talking about
- 1:00:56musicals. That's what we really should do
- 1:00:58is a season of film and whiskey musicals.
- 1:01:02Yeah, that's not going to happen, Bob.
- 1:01:04I don't think I can do it. I I love musicals, but man oh
- 1:01:07man, that would be a lot. All right, Brad, let's give this
- 1:01:10movie some final scores and get out of here for the day.
- 1:01:13This is a hard one because I think this movie is pretty
- 1:01:15objectively like a 7, but it is so artistically made that I'm
- 1:01:20like, I could, I might enjoy this movie just as much if I
- 1:01:23just had it on mute in the background on you know how they
- 1:01:26make those TV's now? They call them like the frame
- 1:01:28and they, they're supposed to look like a painting in your, in
- 1:01:31your living room. Like you could just put this
- 1:01:33movie on the frame and people will be like, wow, what a
- 1:01:35beautiful impressionist painting.
- 1:01:37That sounds like the snootiest thing I've ever.
- 1:01:40Oh, it absolutely is. But then you could just be like,
- 1:01:43ha, ha, it's Gene Kelly. It's not an impressionist
- 1:01:45painting. Yeah, I'll give it a 7 1/2, but
- 1:01:48I think that's pretty much the highest I can go on this one,
- 1:01:50Brad. Do you think that the frame was
- 1:01:53like directly inspired by Harry Potter?
- 1:01:55Oh 100% 'cause that just. Sounds like a like like somebody
- 1:01:59who is obsessed with Harry Potter.
- 1:02:00Like we need to make moving pictures now.
- 1:02:04Also, can we talk about movies that way?
- 1:02:06Can we just keep calling movies moving pictures like we're in
- 1:02:09the 1920s? Hey.
- 1:02:11Go to see the moving picture the other day.
- 1:02:13I saw the new. I saw the new talkie.
- 1:02:17Tom Cruise in the latest Mission Impossible talkie was wonderful.
- 1:02:237 out of 10 for me, Bob. Yep, yeah, I had nothing more to
- 1:02:27say. It was really good.
- 1:02:28I'm done. That brings our average out to a
- 1:02:317.25 out of 10. But we want to know what you
- 1:02:34think. Have you seen an American in
- 1:02:36Paris lately? Let us know on all of our social
- 1:02:39media accounts, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok and
- 1:02:44YouTube at Film Whiskey. Or jump onto the Discord.
- 1:02:47We are on there every single day talking to you guys, the fans of
- 1:02:51the Film and Whiskey podcast. So if you'd like, you can find a
- 1:02:53link to our Discord at the end of every single one of our show
- 1:02:56notes. All right, next week.
- 1:02:58So join us for that one. But until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:03:02I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.