Latest / Newcomer Pod / Not Exactly AR And Not Exactly VR (with Lauren Goode & Anand Agarawala)
Transcript
- 0:01Hey, it's Eric newcomer with newcomer, we've got a great
- 0:04episode for you this week. I have two awesome.
- 0:06Guests to talk about the Apple Vision grow in the future of
- 0:10augmented reality and virtual reality.
- 0:13We've got Lauren good. A senior writer at wired co-host
- 0:16of wired's have a nice future and Gadget Labs podcast you can
- 0:20follow writing on wired.com and she got her hands on the device
- 0:24so she's rare human at the moment so she walked us through
- 0:28her experience with The Apple Vision, bro, and then also on
- 0:32the podcast, Anand agrawal of the CEO of spatial company that
- 0:37helps people build 3D worlds. He's been along for this journey
- 0:40of virtual reality devices, and sort of has been in the waiting
- 0:45game of a real hit. And so he had a lot of smart
- 0:48perspective about the Apple Vision Pro.
- 0:50So we had a really fun conversation.
- 0:52I think you'll enjoy the episode.
- 0:54Thank you both so much for coming on.
- 0:56I really appreciate it. Thanks Eric.
- 0:58It's great to be on your show. All right, when you actually
- 1:02have used the Apple Vision Pro, so we want to start with you.
- 1:05Like we're going to be sort of speculating and talking about it
- 1:08but you have experience the product.
- 1:10So yeah. What was it like can you walk us
- 1:12through the whole experience of trying it out?
- 1:15So I'm actually wearing the Gen 3 version right now, you just
- 1:19can't see it. Oh yeah, you've got all the
- 1:22shrunk it down. Yeah, that much.
- 1:24Okay. So I think it's probably worth
- 1:27noting that when you first you try the In Pro there's a
- 1:31preamble, right? And this I think is going to be
- 1:33the experience for people when they eventually buy it.
- 1:36You're most likely going to have to go to an Apple store or some
- 1:39other kind of pop up and get, you know, scanned for this
- 1:42device because when I first went into the super-secret building
- 1:46that was I later found out was built specifically to give demos
- 1:50of this device. An Apple employee, first
- 1:52scanned, my face, and my eyes, and my ears.
- 1:56These ears are the weird one. Yeah, the ears a me, that you
- 1:59think that, Going to peer directly into your ears.
- 2:02It's not quite like that. They're measuring the space
- 2:04between them, so they can Mouse spatial audio to you.
- 2:07And then an apple employed optometrist measured in my
- 2:10prescriptive lenses. I was wearing contact lenses
- 2:12that day, but I brought my glasses with me anticipating
- 2:14that something was gonna happen. And so, by the time I got into
- 2:18my private demo room to put the thing on my face, it had been
- 2:23personally calibrated for optimal fit and optimal like
- 2:27just Vision I guess. So then the vision.
- 2:29Pro is waiting for me on a coffee table.
- 2:31There are two apple representatives.
- 2:33There they are. Not wearing your headset
- 2:35muttering at this moment or you like know you have like a
- 2:38limited window as a reporter, right?
- 2:40Do you get 30 minutes with it? Yeah, you know, it was about 30
- 2:43minutes. I didn't get your record
- 2:45anything. Like, I couldn't record audio, I
- 2:46couldn't take notes, I couldn't like take a photo of myself, so
- 2:50I don't have actual like timestamps.
- 2:52And you know, when you're in the reality Distortion field, you're
- 2:54in this vertex and you're like, what is time?
- 2:57But I think it was approximately 30 minutes And I put it on and I
- 3:01think the first thing that struck me, was actually how
- 3:03Hefty it felt, considering that they've offloaded the battery.
- 3:06Because there is that external battery pack.
- 3:08I fitted it like, there's the soft strap, that goes over the
- 3:11top of the head, the soft rap that goes in the back of the
- 3:13head. I started to know as I looked at
- 3:15it. How much of it seemed to borrow
- 3:17a little design elements from other Apple products, like the
- 3:20soft foam, cushioning that frames your face looks a lot
- 3:23like the are pods Max and the strap that goes in the top of
- 3:27the head. Looks a lot like that Apple
- 3:28watch strap sweet. Talk about that a little bit.
- 3:31And then the thing was on and that I did like an eye
- 3:34calibration thing, that was very aptly, and pretty intuitive.
- 3:38And that it actually even sort of concluded with this.
- 3:41Like, little approval, click that sounds like an Apple Watch
- 3:44collection. Apple pay click her.
- 3:46Something is going to be an apple without something like the
- 3:48Click was really thought through.
- 3:50Yeah. It was really the best time
- 3:53ever. Do you want me to keep going?
- 3:56Or like, I'm like, I'm like, I don't know, I start the device
- 3:58start the experience. So we have to stop the
- 4:03collection is just as exciting like Kelly.
- 4:06Usually this way in a podcast I paused because said like the
- 4:09host wants to jump in and be like okay, so get to the boy.
- 4:13So yeah. So then I put it on and I think
- 4:16that another thing worth noting is that this isn't exactly a are
- 4:22and it's not exactly VR. And the company is positioning
- 4:25it as a spatial Computing platform.
- 4:28Sorry, on Angela. That shuddering right now he's
- 4:31like oh what we did, they call it spatial or are they naming?
- 4:35Its spatial but knowing that it's like, is there obviously,
- 4:38that is an honest company name, okay, it's right, Google it,
- 4:42Google it. So then your face is fully
- 4:45enveloped and I think Apple made a big point to say that you can
- 4:50see the world around you but it's a little bit of Miss
- 4:53marketing because while you can see the world around you it is
- 4:56video pass through. It's not like there's any sort
- 4:59of Trance Spare and see to the lenses of glasses like your face
- 5:03is in it. The reason why you can see the
- 5:04world around you, is because there are so many cameras on the
- 5:07device that are recording and streaming to you.
- 5:10Okay. Yeah.
- 5:10Same to you. This is fascinating.
- 5:12So does it look like when I'm looking at like an iPhone camera
- 5:14to take a picture and it's sort of like that or what is sort of
- 5:18the vibe of the real world as seen through the cameras.
- 5:22It feels like a slightly fuzzier version of the real world.
- 5:26Like, you know, when you put on, I'm going to assume it on a
- 5:29dyno. You have the Derek.
- 5:30I'm going to see me. You have used a quest to.
- 5:32Yeah I don't do that but you have used a quest.
- 5:36Yes. We've got to make this happen.
- 5:38It's basically PR is listening to this right now.
- 5:40They're like shipping on to you at.
- 5:42This is hard. I know you guys are.
- 5:44We have them here. Will bring one, I'll bring one
- 5:46over. Yeah.
- 5:47Okay, so when you, when you put on the quest, there's a moment
- 5:50before you get fully immersed. In virtual reality, where you
- 5:53map your living room, you create these barriers around your
- 5:56living room or wherever you're standing in a real environment.
- 5:59So that Creates like these virtual wall so you don't bump
- 6:02into things once you can no longer see.
- 6:05And so you see in that moment, this very grainy
- 6:07black-and-white, although newer versions have color passed
- 6:10through. But you see a very grainy
- 6:11black-and-white like image of your living room, and then a
- 6:14draws the barriers. It's like that, but like a lot
- 6:18better in my Serene color. So I was seeing this, you know,
- 6:21very Normcore, Scandinavian Apple demo living room, but I
- 6:25was not seeing it. Like, I would see through
- 6:27glasses. I was seeing as I would see it
- 6:29as Like a video broadcast to me. It's weird because I know you
- 6:32said it didn't feel like a are but like, I mean, they are just
- 6:35done too many of those paths to demos, but that's usually, after
- 6:39a few minutes, your brain kind of should be like, yeah, that's
- 6:40my living room now. Like, you know what I mean?
- 6:42You kind of adapt pretty quickly like in true.
- 6:44A, our devices you're seeing the real world, right?
- 6:47Is Optical paths 3s. So it's like, you're actually
- 6:49seeing, like, you're actually your, I like the photons are
- 6:52going like, the couches. You're right.
- 6:53Yeah, right, exactly. It's like, it's like glasses and
- 6:56then there's images on top of the glasses, right?
- 6:58But that are just Blocking it. Where's?
- 7:01This is you're looking at a screen that is shown on the
- 7:03screen thinking, right? Okay.
- 7:05That's right. That's right.
- 7:06Yeah, I don't know glad you explained that because I think
- 7:09it when I say it's not like real AR I think that's what I mean is
- 7:12that it's not using any kind of waveguide technology that
- 7:15refracts light and I put it into your eyeballs like it's not
- 7:18holographic, it's not volumetric but it is AR if you think about
- 7:22the literal definition of they are as augmenting your reality
- 7:26and so once you are like running computer application, Ins into
- 7:30this space in front of you, where you would typically be
- 7:33looking at your real world living room.
- 7:34But actually, you're seeing apps and playing games and doing
- 7:37stuff, like you are augmenting your reality, right?
- 7:39So, it's like, conceptually a are and the responsiveness part
- 7:43of what supposed to make this better than the status quo is
- 7:46just like how quick it is, right?
- 7:48And also high def, right? Can you get into like this sort
- 7:50of quality and how much that is or isn't a game changer in your
- 7:55view? Yeah, I think the obvious were
- 7:57remarkably good. You are when you first fire up
- 8:01the you know the home screen you're looking at just almost
- 8:05like a dock, a floating dock of Apple apps.
- 8:08I didn't see. There might have been
- 8:09third-party apps. I'm like the next page I don't
- 8:11actually recall once again, could not take notice a lot of
- 8:14these have going off the memory but I mostly saw Apple apps like
- 8:17Safari and messages and photos and then once I opened some of
- 8:21them the imagery did actually look remarkably crisp.
- 8:24So the Optics. Yeah I mean they're pretty good
- 8:27I think that the eye tracking And gesture control is a bit of
- 8:30a game changer here. Because typically, when you're
- 8:33wearing a VR headset, you're using game controllers and order
- 8:37for your hands to be able to, like, navigate the world around
- 8:41you. There's so much compute power in
- 8:43this thing. And so many cameras that Apple
- 8:47like the device scans your hands, and after that initial
- 8:51scan, your hands are in the frame.
- 8:52Your real-life hands and you just use them by tapping your
- 8:57fingers together, too. To manipulate and scroll through
- 9:00apps is worse. This is like the future, it's
- 9:03insane, right? You're going in Optometrist it's
- 9:05like I feel like every sci-fi movie, this is like it.
- 9:08I'm not saying that means this is fully functional.
- 9:10It's going to change society. We're all going to use it.
- 9:12But like this is like as living sci-fi as you can get, where
- 9:16your hands are controlling things where like living the
- 9:19world through cameras, like they have like basically medical
- 9:22professionals examining you to make it work.
- 9:25I don't I just want, it's weird like, it's amazing, I don't That
- 9:29scanning stuff is that critical I mean like you know on an
- 9:32Oculus like so one of the things they're doing is ipd checking so
- 9:35that when you get it it just works but like you know Quest
- 9:38has like those three settings and those get 80% of humans or
- 9:4190 percent of humans. So I think some of that stuff
- 9:43and like the spatial audio. Like if you just popped it on to
- 9:46Lauren setting, I think it would be fine.
- 9:47You can take that you know that physician part out of it but
- 9:50otherwise, yes, it is pretty trippy, you know?
- 9:52Yeah. And the other element of the
- 9:53gesture control is that the way you select apps?
- 9:57That's where the eye. Aking comes in because there are
- 10:00the external facing cameras that see what your hands are doing.
- 10:03And then there are the internal cameras at see where your eyes
- 10:05are looking at, and there's almost no latency.
- 10:07I mean, if they're latency, it's Ms. And Apple has said, like the
- 10:10threshold should be like 12 milliseconds, or fewer.
- 10:14And when you look at an app, like when I looked at the in
- 10:17apple was like sort of guiding me and they were also holding an
- 10:20iPad off to the side for. They could see what I was
- 10:22listening. It was very controlled demo.
- 10:25They said, like look at the photos app and I looked at the
- 10:27photos app. And it just sort of was like
- 10:30emphasized in the row of apps, and then it's like look to the
- 10:33next app and that app. So it just it's just like the
- 10:36face computer knows where you are looking and then you click
- 10:38it with your hand to open it. And then there's an expand
- 10:41option and apps and use your finger to like, select the
- 10:44expand option. You can, you know, scroll
- 10:48through the photos. Let's open one up into panoramic
- 10:51mode. Yeah, everything you're doing.
- 10:53Because the voice control was not set up.
- 10:56Yet was not ready, everything you're doing is with your eyes.
- 10:58Eyes or hands. I think this is one of the most
- 11:01powerful things and most breakthrough things that they've
- 11:03done is if like, your eyes are. I think, two orders of magnitude
- 11:06faster than your hands in terms of response rate and speed and
- 11:09everything. And this is the thing that I
- 11:11find, like, in the Tea, Leaves of, all the reviews.
- 11:13I've read MKBHD said, it's magical.
- 11:15I think it's a hyper IO device, a hyper input output device that
- 11:18would speed at, which you can kind of look at stuff and move.
- 11:20Like, it feels like you're just it's almost like mind control
- 11:23and like that, it might be the greatest breakthrough of it and
- 11:26that's maybe why they're leaning towards a productivity
- 11:27applications. I think it's going to be like
- 11:30you know, when you're on your phone and you're like I'll
- 11:31answer this email on my computer because I want to use my
- 11:33keyboard. It's going to be that same level
- 11:35of like oh answer this on my Vision Pro you know, it remains
- 11:39to be seen what you need to do. All that kind of pointing and
- 11:41stuff for. And I've seen some demos to that
- 11:42are like you just get used to looking at stuff and it lighting
- 11:45up like Lauren described, right? And when you look at icons, they
- 11:48light up and then when you look at the real world when you take
- 11:49it off, it's not going to do that and you're going to be kind
- 11:51of like you're gonna want that. Super reality.
- 11:54It isn't really a thing. But I think that like that
- 11:56eye-tracking aside from all the other Other stuff.
- 11:59I'm going to want that on my Mac, you know, without the
- 12:01headset. You know, like I think that's a
- 12:02potential real breakthrough. This may be hidden in here and
- 12:05that fits with sort of like the launch of the iPhone where it
- 12:07came with this, you know, gesture control.
- 12:10That was so perfect and human that it felt like okay this
- 12:14powers and new generation of devices.
- 12:15Now, Catch swipe your TV right? Like because I just used to it
- 12:19and people have tried that on the desktop before, you might
- 12:22roll call me many years ago. There was a startup called Leap
- 12:24Motion, that was doing, really interesting stuff around gesture
- 12:27control on PCS and then Another company called, Toby that does
- 12:30eye tracking and I think those were really cool Technologies in
- 12:34search of applications. Like maybe they would be good in
- 12:37games or maybe they would be good.
- 12:38Even for like consumer surveys to figure out where people were
- 12:41looking on their machines and like what they were gravitating
- 12:43towards. But I think with Babble, like,
- 12:45with anything with apple, there's so much validation that
- 12:48comes with apple entering a market in the technology, so
- 12:51good that all of a sudden you're like, oh, this could actually
- 12:54become mainstream in some other way and your eyes are like the
- 12:57best. Indicator of your intent, right?
- 13:00Like even intent, you're not even aware of where you're
- 13:02looking, you know? I mean think about the
- 13:03revocation to ads and you know it's just fast.
- 13:06I mean it is really much closer at your hands.
- 13:09Your intent of your mind is like two degrees away in your hands
- 13:12but it's like one degree away in your eyes.
- 13:13You know what I mean? Like it's much more automatic
- 13:15right. So then there's the other thing
- 13:17that I thought was pretty. I don't know if I would call it
- 13:19stand out but very different about this was the ability to
- 13:21dial back, the opacity of the immersive - like you could see
- 13:26the living room and then run, you know, Little window of an
- 13:29application in front of you. Or you could twist the dial and
- 13:32then just go almost full of the. Are they when I saw that?
- 13:35I thought, oh, to me, this seems like it's something that's
- 13:38geared towards app developers because an app developer has the
- 13:42option to say I'm building a VR app or an AR app or something in
- 13:45between what did you make of that as someone on the app
- 13:48developer side? It's interesting.
- 13:49You know, the magic leap ship to the reality button and they had
- 13:52two similar intent. They didn't work out that well
- 13:54bike. So you click the button.
- 13:55In the ideas, you go back to reality so much more rudimentary
- 13:57for. Anything is a switching time.
- 13:58Was so long that it like because they thought you'd be wearing
- 14:00this thing all day and you want to be popping in and out of
- 14:02reality. So it's an interesting through
- 14:04line to this switch, I think like, it's cool.
- 14:07I'll I think you need people to feel really grounded and being
- 14:09able to like someone just walked in the door and you need to say
- 14:12hello or you know, you're probably just jumped on your lap
- 14:15like you need that. I don't know if the dial.
- 14:16I mean, it will be nice. I'm sure it'll be nice and
- 14:19happily as an app though. Like you can either dim
- 14:22completely or experience down to reality, or you can dim parts of
- 14:26it. And so like, for us, like in
- 14:27spatial like the a Guitars. Like for you can example you can
- 14:30imagine experience where you DM, just the environment but the
- 14:33avatars are still there. You know what I mean?
- 14:35And so that like I think developers could potentially use
- 14:38it intriguing ways. Like I'm watching, I could be in
- 14:40that space. You're watching the Mandalorian
- 14:42on that crazy spaceship that they showed in.
- 14:44Hopefully my friends are with me and I dim the thing because
- 14:47other people are the room to and now I can see the friends.
- 14:49Still let's just go through the Mandalorian, I think like, if
- 14:51you do selective dimming and he could be quite intriguing but
- 14:54it's also like you definitely need that switch back and forth
- 14:57reality should be really smooth. Cuz it is on your phone to me.
- 14:59The big question here is like, is it enough of an AR device
- 15:02isn't enough of a VR device? Or is it this weird, like half
- 15:05and half? And I think like, the dimmer
- 15:07sort of gets to the, you know, what's interesting?
- 15:10They showed almost no VR mode at all.
- 15:14I can't even remember a single real-time 3D thing they showed
- 15:17except for these immersive panoramas.
- 15:19And even watching the movies, they even the 3D dinosaur thing,
- 15:22which everyone thought they were going to do in 3D was like a
- 15:24pseudo shallow depth Tyrannosaurus, right?
- 15:27It wasn't like Behind you. There's like a thing.
- 15:29You know what I mean? It's not a VR device as it was
- 15:31positioned. I think like didn't show a
- 15:33single game. I experienced a little bit of
- 15:35that in the demo. So when I pulled up, I'm trying
- 15:38to remember which video clip it was.
- 15:40There were a few video clips that were like set up in
- 15:42advance, you know, once again, this is a very controlled demo,
- 15:45I watched Avatar to in 3D I watched this Sizzle reel that
- 15:50Apple will put together of all of these incredible nature
- 15:52scenes and then I watched the Jon Favreau directed dinosaur
- 15:56clip. So at one point Apple said, look
- 15:59to the left and there were these pre crafted environments that I
- 16:02could select with my eyes and hands and one of them was called
- 16:05cinematic mode. So I was watching this, you
- 16:07know, this video content in front of me in the, you know,
- 16:10the living room that I was sitting in and when I chose
- 16:12cinematic mode and actually made it a lot more immersive.
- 16:16There were some edges there, there are these like weird kind
- 16:18of wavy or floaty edges. So it's not like I felt like I
- 16:22could look up at the sky or look behind.
- 16:24Me and just be like, completely in the world but it was like
- 16:28Very close. It was up against the edge of
- 16:30full VR. I would say, but you're not
- 16:32walking around, right? Like it's kind of a it's
- 16:34basically, if you 60 video. I mean, not 36 360 3D
- 16:37stereoscopic video and there's 28 million pixels.
- 16:39I think they speculated, they don't have the processing power
- 16:42to actually render real-time 3D in a way that you can move
- 16:45around. Like, can you game on this
- 16:47device? Like that?
- 16:48That is a big question. I didn't do any.
- 16:50And there were no gaming apps and the demo that I had it was
- 16:53either like, some Face Time, some messaging, although I
- 16:56couldn't even message back with a person.
- 16:58Web browsing and like video watching.
- 17:01There wasn't anything around gaming and a video, like one of
- 17:04the things that I experienced and they are headsets that I've
- 17:07tested like even like snaps spectacles and those are only
- 17:11available to developers and like they only last a half hour or so
- 17:15and they heat up really quickly. Like, but they do like pure wave
- 17:18guide AR and they also do spatial anchoring.
- 17:21So like you would draw this like artistic squiggly into the world
- 17:25in front of you and then it would be anchored.
- 17:27There You could walk up to it, you could scale it up, you can
- 17:31walk around it, you can manipulate it with your hands.
- 17:34There were objects floating in space that you could just
- 17:37manipulate and it lists really cool way.
- 17:38And like, I did not experience that and apple had set on the
- 17:43gaming front. I mean, so one of the developer
- 17:44lab showed apparently I didn't see any yet but Warner
- 17:46devastating rec room in 3D and so that was like, I think
- 17:49immersive but it also raises the question, what's the control
- 17:52scheme for these games, right? If there's just hand tracking
- 17:54like you know, PlayStation VR, not Quest have joypads with
- 17:57multiple buttons. You can I can write like we're
- 17:59just asking how they going to do.
- 18:00Like I get how you do, shoot in rec room.
- 18:02But how do you do run? How do you do, jump?
- 18:03How do you do duck? I mean, you could do those in
- 18:05real life. It's going to get fatiguing real
- 18:07quick, so you need controls. You could imagine a gesture
- 18:10scheme where you do that. They were also like some of the
- 18:12games were actually in 2D mode. And, you know, when we were
- 18:15chatting, the guidance to developers is start with your
- 18:18iPad app and then, you know, that's kind of the 2D frame.
- 18:21And there's even guidance on like, okay, well you can use
- 18:24your 2D iPad joystick with your fingers, which is kind of an
- 18:28awkward way. Play.
- 18:29So is it a productivity device? Like you think it's built its
- 18:32it's like really set up to well I guess to like do Zoom type
- 18:36things and then to watch movies or like what was sort of the one
- 18:38to use case that they were sort of painting for you.
- 18:42In this exciting kind of felt like they threw everything at
- 18:44the wall with this. Frankly, the messaging was a
- 18:46little bit muddled around it, even the demo video that they
- 18:49showed during the WWDC keynote showed like every example in the
- 18:52book, right? There's the person on the flight
- 18:54with it. There's the dad, browsing
- 18:56memories, there's the woman who's doing work.
- 18:58Work. And then goes down to the fridge
- 18:59to get her sparkling water. It felt that way in the demo to
- 19:02it was like, here's a little bit of messaging.
- 19:03Here's a little bit of Face Time.
- 19:05Here's some entertainment. Also, you and Collie can
- 19:07collaborate on this design thing and that's a nice signal is that
- 19:10they don't really have the killer app quite figured out
- 19:13yet. And actually, in one of the
- 19:15comparisons I've been making in conversation with folks, is that
- 19:19it very much reminds me of the iPad in that way.
- 19:22I think everyone's been saying, oh, but what about the iPhone?
- 19:25You know, if you're down on this right now, maybe you're a
- 19:27Luddite because look, Were skeptical about the iPhone and
- 19:30look how that changed the world. I don't think that that's the
- 19:32APT comparison. I think much in the way that the
- 19:34iPad. It's mostly a home device.
- 19:37Some people are power users and might travel with it, or some
- 19:39people might use it as their primary PC.
- 19:41But it is very much a consumption device.
- 19:44It's at home, you give it to your kids.
- 19:46Sometimes, occasionally, you do work on it.
- 19:48It's a little bit more of an isolated experience, right?
- 19:51Like you're using it yourself for the most part.
- 19:53Sometimes it casts other content.
- 19:55I think like, this could potentially.
- 19:58If it ends up being as successful as the iPad, then
- 20:01that will be a success for this product because it is
- 20:04ultimately, very hard. I think, to convince people, to
- 20:06wear a face computer for an extended period of time Lincoln
- 20:09on. And I were talking instead of
- 20:10our prep call about like just like getting people to use these
- 20:14VR devices, right? They like use them a lot in the
- 20:16beginning and they fall off and nobody uses them anymore.
- 20:19And it's just like a phone is much easier to grab than a VR
- 20:23device and so to me I don't know, I feel like my view is
- 20:26much more like this is an all-or-nothing thing.
- 20:28There they get it so that people really want it to put on its
- 20:31magical. It feels like way ahead of
- 20:33everything else and so then people are putting it on and
- 20:36then people get word from their friends, like no, I'm like in
- 20:39this thing, I'm doing x y z for a long period of time or like
- 20:43it's early adopters. Who try it?
- 20:45Don't find a sustained use case and it's not even to iPad level.
- 20:48Like I don't quite see this sort of middle case purse I think I
- 20:51can see both I mean I think the iPad thing like you bring your
- 20:56iPad to the airplane because it's just way better.
- 20:58There. Now, would you bring this to the
- 21:00airplane? You know, that's probably the
- 21:01number one place, right? I think that that said first
- 21:05class Envy, they're like, oh my God, five hundred dollar device
- 21:09inverse class wearing these things like that is going to be,
- 21:12that'll be the symbol of like the class divide in America and
- 21:16the morning after the event, I got a text message from a CEO,
- 21:20not a big Tech CEO but more of like a lifestyle CEO who just
- 21:23wrote in all caps, I will not wear the goggles on a player.
- 21:27I thought that's interesting. That's the Ali moment.
- 21:29People lying flat in first class with headset like being
- 21:33entertained and be fed. It's gonna happen.
- 21:35That's the future. It's not the scientist, you
- 21:37know, but I do agree like my number one.
- 21:40Learning after working VR for seven years day in day out is
- 21:43like, the transformative moment will be like, when people
- 21:46actually shifted this device, it needs to be an all-day wear
- 21:49device. Otherwise there's a switching
- 21:51cost and the switching cost is always going to be way higher
- 21:54than your phone, which is in your pocket, and it's so easy.
- 21:56We can't even switch to our watch because the phone is so Oh
- 21:58good. And this is like honest the
- 21:59whole time, right? Like that is the key I think and
- 22:02that's why the thing I was most excited to hear from morning,
- 22:05you know, and folks who tried it is, can you use it like all day?
- 22:07Can you imagine doing that? And I'm hearing not so much.
- 22:10Like Joanna, stir his face, was quite red after her demo and
- 22:13they said it was a fitting or whatever.
- 22:14But I just can't imagine, I mean, I can't wear ski goggles
- 22:16all day and have no Computing them.
- 22:17So I think you've got to go from goggles to glasses for this to
- 22:21be that kind of mainstream thing and that's the path were on and
- 22:23this is like a huge injection of energy and apple you know sex
- 22:27appeal this The Ferrari, the Tesla Roadster of that category,
- 22:32right? And there's a arms race now,
- 22:33between two trillion dollar companies trying to win your
- 22:35face. And so that's great, that's
- 22:37great for the consumer. It's great for the developer
- 22:39Lauren. How long do you think you could
- 22:41wear the device? I know you only got like maybe
- 22:44this 30 minutes with it, but did you feel like at the end you are
- 22:47fatigued or you felt like, no, I'm comfortable.
- 22:49I could keep going, you know, I thought I could keep going.
- 22:52Actually, I have worn. The medic quest to for, I don't
- 22:57know maybe as long as an hour. Our before some friends and I
- 22:59used to play beats paper together, we were all in
- 23:02different cities and we would you know put our headsets and
- 23:05gossip and play Beat saver and like fetus little disembodied
- 23:08avatars floating in the metaverse and that was fun.
- 23:11The setup was always really annoying, like especially if you
- 23:14hadn't used them at a quest to in a while and then you picked
- 23:16it up and put it on. There was almost inevitably some
- 23:18update to download and then you would be like wait, how do I
- 23:20navigate this thing with this dorky hand controllers, again, I
- 23:23don't think I ever used it for more than an hour and I always
- 23:26say that when I take something like that off, it feels like
- 23:28Forehead is breathing a sigh of relief, right?
- 23:30I'm sure after an hour or so. In the Apple had said, I'd feel
- 23:33the same way. I mean, maybe I would get so
- 23:36engrossed in a movie that I would want to keep wearing it
- 23:39for the full duration of movie, but I could also picture at some
- 23:42point being like, you know what? I really just want to take this
- 23:45off and watch this on a big flat screen because it maybe there's
- 23:48a little bit of depth here. Maybe there's a little bit of
- 23:50interactivity like the dinosaur was interacting with me or the
- 23:53butterfly was interacting with me, but once you're over that
- 23:56novelty unit, you reminded me of is like Like the first days of
- 23:59covid-19, spend eight hours a day on zoom and how fatiguing it
- 24:01wasn't when you're done, you're like it's like that's kind of
- 24:05the same thing on 2D experience, but you can last eight hours,
- 24:07you know? Yeah, yeah, that's true.
- 24:10I've done days where I've like, spent like when we've been
- 24:12pitching or whatever talking to businesses like 4 hours, 5 hours
- 24:15and a hololens like it's exhausting for sure.
- 24:17You do lose yourself in it when you're in there because it
- 24:19especially there's another human in there with you because you're
- 24:21just kind of like you know talking but it's tough.
- 24:24Oh my gosh, I can't believe you've spent four or five hours
- 24:27and a hololens. Did you get like a special award
- 24:30for that? That is like my God.
- 24:32I wrote a story for Wired once that was just entirely about how
- 24:36long it took me to get set up for a meeting in Hollands.
- 24:39Like it was so comically bad, that required meetings upon
- 24:42meetings to anyway, kudos to you on.
- 24:45And I just curious like, when you mention this inevitability
- 24:48of shrinking, the form factor, like you think that we're headed
- 24:51to glasses, I think that would be great, because they would be
- 24:53a lot more lightweight, but I just think the physical
- 24:57batteries are still Like there's only so much we can do around,
- 25:00innovating lithium ion batteries, as long as that's
- 25:03what we are using in Silicon, is being innovated on in such a way
- 25:06that it's become a lot more power.
- 25:08Efficient and that helps with battery life but like we are up
- 25:11against like, physical and chemical limitations with
- 25:14batteries. So as long as we have, those are
- 25:15we ever really going to get super lightweight powerful
- 25:18glasses? Yeah, I think.
- 25:19Okay, the wire that is fair and I think the interesting thing
- 25:23about this is that they say it's all day where they actually said
- 25:26that it meaning and that shame, I'm sorry.
- 25:28Well, but I went they mean by that is done, right?
- 25:31But the quest Pro you actually can't run all day if it's
- 25:33plugged in because it draws too much.
- 25:35But you don't like the they fix that and the thing is like this
- 25:38hats, an apple fix that? Yeah.
- 25:40Thank it, right? Yeah.
- 25:41Vision Pro, some fairness in the claim given the quest can't
- 25:45deliver all day, even plugged in quest Pro.
- 25:47I don't think Westbrook one, whatever.
- 25:49But the thing is, they've externalized the battery in this
- 25:51case. So can you imagine a pair of
- 25:53glasses and real X? Real?
- 25:54Now is a couple years old and that's like glasses.
- 25:57He You know, you can imagine an apple caliber device, delivering
- 26:00something like that with external battery.
- 26:02We're not going to solve the battery problem for a while
- 26:04except for, like, kind of Apple watch scenarios where it's like,
- 26:07episodically on during your day, but I can imagine a world where
- 26:11like, that's maybe not too far away.
- 26:12Maybe it's, you know, like where you have a x real style chunkier
- 26:17glasses with a wire, it's going to need a wire.
- 26:20You think people will just get used to carrying around the
- 26:22battery pack? If the glass is make it
- 26:24worthwhile enough, well like then what's the world in which
- 26:27we're carrying around Phones. And we have a watch on her wrist
- 26:30and we've got this battery pack, and we're wearing glasses, like,
- 26:32what's the benefit? Then to the glasses that you
- 26:34can't just do on your phone? But you know, what's crazy?
- 26:37Apple has made us all carry around headphones, okay?
- 26:40Who carried around headphones before?
- 26:41They're winning the pocket. Who would have thought we'd be
- 26:44carrying around that and this the watch, you know, there's so
- 26:46much crap were caring for them. If it delivers value, these
- 26:49deliver airplanes deliver a lot of value.
- 26:51So, that's the question. The other thing I've learned is
- 26:53it, the phone is so damn good. And deliver, so much value so
- 26:57quickly and And it just really hard to be.
- 26:59So the bar is really high to replace it really that I feel
- 27:03like optimistic about some of the technology that Apple has
- 27:06just introduced, especially considering it's the first
- 27:09version. I still feel very skeptical
- 27:12about the market the category, the product has a category.
- 27:15I know you have to run around like a shaman, who's seen the
- 27:18future. So your schedule is very limited
- 27:20so we will let you go soon. But like, another writer wrote,
- 27:23Apple vision isn't the future? Do you agree with something that
- 27:26straightforward or what's your prediction?
- 27:28In here. Yeah, that was Kate nibs.
- 27:30It's great piece for Wired. And I have to say, I give Katie
- 27:32a lot of respect because I think that a lot of the tech press is
- 27:35like dancing around the question and maybe being a little bit
- 27:39nice because I think that you risk a lot less when you are
- 27:45optimistic and writing something positive about an Apple product
- 27:49because it's apple and they typically deliver like you're
- 27:52gambling a little bit less when you take that position versus
- 27:55hey this is going to be a flop and is this not the future.
- 27:58And so I give a lot of respect to K for writing that.
- 28:01I think there's a real possibility.
- 28:03This is a fault. I'm not saying I'm calling that
- 28:06right now but I think I tend to think that it's going to find a
- 28:09niche market and that Apple will find a way because it is an
- 28:13operations company as much as a computer company to eke out
- 28:16margins on it or find that Niche, or find a way to make it
- 28:20valuable to some this, a particular consumer device, The
- 28:22Vision Pro they're going to sell.
- 28:24So few of them that they're always going to be able to claim
- 28:26that they don't have any. They could just sell like Day at
- 28:28every store and just never have enough and never run out.
- 28:32You know, I mean it's just obviously Niche product that I
- 28:35think I feel like the bar it has to step over his so solo.
- 28:39Yeah. But as a category, people have
- 28:41been talking about VR headsets for like literally decades at
- 28:45this point. And by the way, I would say that
- 28:47the people who have been prognosticating on this are
- 28:49predominantly men who have these, like techno utopian
- 28:52visions of such things and, and like, it hasn't come to be now,
- 28:57like granted So maybe not.
- 29:09I'm optimistic about the metal, right?
- 29:11That would be the second half. Once you go we're gonna go into
- 29:13full techno utopian and we're just gonna be over here like get
- 29:16out of here already, they don't know anything.
- 29:18Like once you're not here to really shit on the idea, we're
- 29:21just going to go wild you know but what I will tune back in and
- 29:24listen for that later on for sure I want to hear what you
- 29:27have to say. I tend to think that this is
- 29:29something, I still think that there's been that vision of,
- 29:32let's do face Computing for a very long time.
- 29:34And there is a reason why the majority of the population has
- 29:38not opted to spend a lot of their time, hours of their time,
- 29:42wearing something that cuts off, some of the most personal
- 29:45sensory, organs of your body. Like even with apple owning our
- 29:49pocket is on on, put it so. Well when you're wearing the air
- 29:51pods that is augmented reality but you can still see and smell
- 29:55and all that stuff and actually there's like even passed through
- 29:57hearing. When you're using the iPhone,
- 29:59you're still in the real world even though you're digitally
- 30:01connecting with all of your family and friends.
- 30:03Like when you're using iPad, you're consuming entertainment.
- 30:05But you're in your bedroom and your comfy bed and you're like,
- 30:08I just think like putting something on our faces for an
- 30:10extended period of time. Is a really big ask?
- 30:13Yeah, I mean, just, you know, if you said the Tesla, what we saw
- 30:17the Tesla Roadster, he said this is this is not the future.
- 30:20I think that would be quite short, sighted.
- 30:21Like, of course, not everyone's gonna drive a Tesla Roadster,
- 30:23but V's, like it was the gateway drug to EVS, right?
- 30:27But Evie's are solving Such a huge societal problem which is
- 30:32how do we make this particular category of Transportation sexy
- 30:36enough? So that people are less reliable
- 30:38on internal combustible engine vehicles that are contributing
- 30:41and major ways to our climate problem.
- 30:44I'm not sure why I didn't people don't care about.
- 30:50So I mean like just to be cynical like people don't really
- 30:52care about solving the problem, they care about convenience and
- 30:54luxury. And you know what I mean?
- 30:55Like, they also made it wasn't a Prius.
- 30:57It was like, It was sexy, right? Like the other thing just to
- 31:01respond to something. I said earlier, it's look like,
- 31:03you know, bite my head off. Is that like I smile before?
- 31:06I bite somebody like a shark like you know you mentioned like
- 31:11the is there any use case? Because it's like there's a
- 31:14whole bunch of stuff there's living room there's like you
- 31:15know how would you describe? I mean if the bolt case I could
- 31:18that there is I'm skeptical too but that you know the bull case
- 31:21is how would you describe how user iPhone is a lot of
- 31:23different stuff. You know like if you're
- 31:25describing to an alien species, you know like what would you
- 31:27say? Eggs are for social, I use it
- 31:29for email, use it, for wraps true, it's the everything device
- 31:33it is. So it is a general purpose.
- 31:35Like, I think, in some ways, it's okay, part of this is like
- 31:37as VR developers. We never had this caliber of
- 31:40device before to experiment with.
- 31:42So, in some ways it's a development platform.
- 31:44Now that's what I'm really curious about.
- 31:46Are they going to see these devices like water, like magic
- 31:48leap and quested to stimulate development because it really
- 31:51expensive and almost every won't be able to afford them and
- 31:54you're taking a really big and the economics won't necessarily
- 31:56work out to this. Something we talked about
- 31:57earlier is like Like the economics at work in VR.
- 31:59Today are on Quest. There are companies that are
- 32:02made tens of millions, hundreds of millions and those have to
- 32:04charge 2999 out of the gate as a one-time fee.
- 32:08Because why? Because you don't the retention
- 32:10is kind of low in these but none of users and engagement to do
- 32:13freemium and recurring payments, a deadly business, models that
- 32:16venture capital or 199. Like when can you do 199 app on
- 32:19a headset? Like you need crazy volumes for
- 32:21that. So that is a bit out.
- 32:23That's a really great point at this point on.
- 32:25And if you had limited resources and you had to develop for
- 32:28They're The Quest 2 or 3 or this apple Vision Pro, which would
- 32:33you choose? Well, the good news, what we're
- 32:34doing both and the good news is for most developers.
- 32:37It'll be relatively like if you're doing a 3D volumetric
- 32:40app, like if your 3D developer, if you're doing a 3D volumetric
- 32:43app, like a rec room or spatial or something, it's quite easy to
- 32:47like, we already support a, our kids, you know, like our app
- 32:49already sports are kit. So we already have both, you
- 32:51know, and so it'll be relatively easy for people to pick both.
- 32:54And as we talked about yesterday, I think these will
- 32:56have converge a bit like, I think, Probably Quest will have
- 33:00a high-end device in the low end and they're kind of, you know,
- 33:03like a quest Pro in their Quest three or whatever and apples
- 33:07already rumored to be shipping everyday, you know, five for
- 33:09five hundred dollar device as well.
- 33:12So I think like it's pretty easy to support both.
- 33:15There's nothing that like aside from the eye tracking that like
- 33:17you know, and that's pretty. I mean Quest, could you know,
- 33:21definitely support that as well. So I think both answers both
- 33:24because of the unity. It's not expensive to develop
- 33:27for both. Well, I Ford trying spatial on
- 33:29Apple Vision Pro and I think you just made a really good play
- 33:31here, if like Jaws or Tim or listening that you guys should
- 33:34send a freak. It's it to a spatial over there.
- 33:37So. But I do have to run.
- 33:38Thank you so much for having interest has been really fun.
- 33:40Yeah, enjoy. Enjoy the metaverse.
- 33:44We will grate. That was so fun.
- 33:48I want to just like, is it enough VR or enough?
- 33:51AR is the thing. I keep coming back to you.
- 33:53Like, you've got me really worried that it can play video
- 33:56games, which just feels like such a a key.
- 33:58Yeah. Early adopter use case for a
- 34:01product like that and would be classic Apple history to like
- 34:04underestimate the value of video games.
- 34:07It is very intriguing that they really didn't show any Gaming,
- 34:10use cases, on that headset. And it's an entertainment
- 34:13device. And then, secondly, they did
- 34:15announce the game Port kit, I don't you notice that, but where
- 34:18you can easily like they're allowing developers who built PC
- 34:21games too much easier. Bring them to the Mac, direct
- 34:24translation, DirectX API is rising wind kind of thing.
- 34:27So they are Getting game try to improve the Mac.
- 34:30They changed some settings so that you can move into like a
- 34:33gaming mode for higher performance, gaming mode and
- 34:35stuff. So, there is energy in Mac
- 34:38gaming for Mac. For the first time in a long
- 34:40time. The funny thing is, the iPhone
- 34:41is the biggest gaming platform in the world, so it's like now,
- 34:45yeah, I mean, I think that was probably a conscious Choice,
- 34:47maybe it's a positioning Thing versus meta because meta so
- 34:50hardcore, the game's not the game's is the one vertical
- 34:53that's proven games and then Fitness, you know, to a much
- 34:57lesser degree but those Are the two verticals that have really
- 34:59shown to take off for VR and, you know, part of its, I don't
- 35:02know if they view it as a VR device, as much.
- 35:04Right. Can you, you know, give a little
- 35:07bit of your history with a rvr. I feel like we sort of jumped in
- 35:11understandably for the conversation about, like, what
- 35:13is this device? Like, please tell us, you've
- 35:15seen, you've been to the Mountaintop, like, I'm down
- 35:17with, like, you know, tell us but just like.
- 35:20So if you have contacts in your sort of Journey, sort of, I feel
- 35:23like True Believer. But then also sort of exhausted,
- 35:26by how long it takes. So like, oh man.
- 35:29I've got to do one more than just be a true.
- 35:31I don't know. Yeah, charge it out.
- 35:33That is a fantastic question. Yeah.
- 35:34So I've been working at 3D user interfaces for like 20 years,
- 35:37first company called bump top three desktop interface that
- 35:41used a physics engine back. In 2004 was my Master's thesis
- 35:45was looking at do a Ted Talk on it.
- 35:46Sold it to Google in 2010 and I was doing 3D interface on a 2d
- 35:50screen fully 3D interface on a 2d screen onto T touch screen
- 35:54and then spatial So I was part of and reaction, maybe it's
- 35:58worth giving the contact as part of Android starting in 2010,
- 36:01when it was under 100 people, the team and version eclair
- 36:04Froyo, and then watching and then, you know, all the way to
- 36:07Ice Cream Sandwich which was like exponential growth.
- 36:09These are all operating systems. Yeah.
- 36:11Yes. Are you don't know any of this
- 36:13stuff? It's their letters of the
- 36:15alphabet, so it's like you Claire F Froyo Ice Cream
- 36:18Sandwich. So, just to give you a little,
- 36:20you know thing. Yeah.
- 36:21And now they're just numbers, which is way more boring because
- 36:23back then the team would get ice cream sandwiches when we finish
- 36:26The release and stuff. But anyway, that epic expansion
- 36:30of mobile when I left Google, I was like, yo, that's going to
- 36:34like I tried the whole lens. I felt like I was looking into
- 36:37literally a tunnel vision to the Future and that there was a huge
- 36:41opportunity software opportunity to get in there early.
- 36:44And that was in 2016. When I started spatial with my
- 36:46co-founder Jenna, because it was like, Hey, building 3D software
- 36:49is hard. And there's very few people have
- 36:51that skill set, that can combine kind of the 3D graphic stuff you
- 36:54need, which you probably develop.
- 36:56Was that skill sets typically found in gaming but then also
- 36:59the UI and design expertise, you need for Like Making Stuff
- 37:02sensible to the common person. So we started and I anticipated
- 37:08like a lot of people that the headsets would have been ramped
- 37:11much closer to the mobile ramp, right?
- 37:13Like mobile ramped crazy quickly to get to like a billion devices
- 37:17I think, right? I think it was like five years
- 37:19from like 1 million smartphones to 1 billion.
- 37:22Hmm. And so, you know, I think a lot
- 37:23I mean, you know, these were investing to like Facebook ad
- 37:26Just bought an Oculus. Oh yeah there was a ton of
- 37:28excitement. Yeah the whole lens to is out
- 37:31you know like Rollins want was out like they were serious.
- 37:34It was the Fast Times and I mean that sounds of any sort of I
- 37:38mean startup you know you want to time the startup early in
- 37:41this sort of wave up so that you're in the right position
- 37:43when things but you don't want to be too early where it's like,
- 37:46oh it didn't take off at the pace we wanted.
- 37:49And that's when we start in 2016, we thought 2019 2020 for
- 37:53an apple headset and it was always, people make the joke.
- 37:55It was always two to three years out.
- 37:56And every year were kind of push out.
- 37:57I think the problems were physics, hard to get it.
- 38:00Right and you know, I think Apple definitely wanted to
- 38:02launch glass, it's not goggles and, you know, just stop really
- 38:06possible to the type of quality they wanted.
- 38:08So, that's the challenge, you know?
- 38:09And I think it didn't accelerate as fast as folks.
- 38:12Some people will be like, I told you so's going to take five to
- 38:1410 years but you know the Bulls were out there for sure.
- 38:17And thought we could have gotten further faster so that's into
- 38:20spatial moves to be more like you're also going to deal with
- 38:23flat-screen regulars. Yeah, I mean so we We are one of
- 38:27the few platforms that. So we start off on Hall at we
- 38:30basically went to bigger and bigger platforms are off on
- 38:32hololens, which is three thousand dollars.
- 38:34So we've been there, this is, you know, this this price point
- 38:37and then covid happen and then we support quest to.
- 38:39And so our usage grew like 50 x because the market was so much
- 38:44bigger request to and then we supported mobile and then we
- 38:48grew again and then we supported web and then we grew at unlike
- 38:51100x basically, from where we were before.
- 38:53And so now you can join spatial. And the cool thing is You are a
- 38:57first-class citizen on all these devices over whether you're on
- 38:59mobile where they on web or whether you're on VR.
- 39:02And basically our usage is split across these platforms and no
- 39:05surprise majority of our platform, 90% over usages, web
- 39:09and mobile. And then, you know, some
- 39:11templates for game developers to build like experiences games for
- 39:15yeah, people to play around with on these different devices.
- 39:18So anyway, you're deep in. You've been on this journey you
- 39:21sort of like, okay, wow, we can actually get a lot of users on
- 39:23web. You would think so like are you
- 39:26fatigue? Devine optimistic or what's your
- 39:28like having been through that sort of Journey live through
- 39:31this and like hope for the future a lot, like where are you
- 39:34right now with apple Vision Pro? It's that's a great question.
- 39:36I think you'll be seven years in October on the official journey
- 39:40of you know, just any of your company.
- 39:43We gave up on waiting for the perfect headset about halfway
- 39:47through because every year is like this is the year.
- 39:49It's going to come, it's going to come and like it was just
- 39:51like, all right screw this we got to own our own destiny.
- 39:53We got to go where the users are?
- 39:55You can have a door we get up. It in the future but we've got
- 39:58to work for the now or start up. We have to live and survive,
- 40:01right? And so I'm still like I think
- 40:03also after I don't know how many hours I've logged in a headset
- 40:07at this point, I mean, probably 1,000 plus, you know, like over,
- 40:10you know, five six years or whatever and watching the
- 40:13keynote on Monday was really inspiring.
- 40:16To be honest. It was like a whole team after
- 40:19was done was cheering. Like we just sent us a lovers in
- 40:21the moon. Like we almost it felt like we
- 40:23were launching something and there was a lot of our stuff
- 40:26that At like, you know, we'd seen a lot of our stuff that we
- 40:28built in the lab and because we kind of grown a little detached
- 40:31from it, not detach, but like it's like, hey the collaboration
- 40:33use case is going to be really tough to make work in this
- 40:36environment and in this kind of state of the market but it's
- 40:39such a sexy device and I we all can't wait to use it.
- 40:42You know it's funny. We did an internal poll about 20
- 40:44people answered. Who's going to buy one?
- 40:46Yes no maybe two people said yes.
- 40:49Think like and the rest were split between know and maybe.
- 40:52Wow that's not very optimistic if you're a sort of a company
- 40:55that sort of plays in this. Right, well, the price of
- 40:57factory. So if it's for 500 bucks, then
- 41:00it's a different equation, right?
- 41:01I mean, that's like a lot of money, we did the math, you
- 41:04know, like a Mac books. Like let's say 3 Grand, we use
- 41:06it. Roughly, let's say,
- 41:07optimistically three years, you're roughly pay.
- 41:09If you used a five hours a day, a work day, you're paying about
- 41:12a buck an hour to use it which is not bad.
- 41:15And you know, a Macbook will solve your problem.
- 41:17Where this you're definitely going to have a MacBook to you
- 41:20know you're not you're going to need like yeah right I mean yeah
- 41:24I mean but I'm so energized. Excited.
- 41:27Like VCS are reaching out and like all these people like press
- 41:30or reaching out, it's right. There's never been so much
- 41:32excitement and I think like because of how mainstream apple
- 41:35is like my sister's reaching out and you know, like I love this
- 41:38idea that your sister stop talking to you and he's like,
- 41:41like I've got that brother of mine is sort of always playing
- 41:44around with this stuff. No, but, you know what I mean?
- 41:46Like a person, like, the Barista knows about area.
- 41:49And I mean versus like, like, like, this is Barista, ready.
- 41:52You know what I mean? Like, it's just, yeah, it's
- 41:53intriguing. How mass-market apple is, and
- 41:56how can The imagination and that Fanboy Community, the fanatical
- 41:59Apple Community can help get the product through, you know, to
- 42:03the promised land. I think, I really like a lot of
- 42:05the argument is like, okay, they have this device.
- 42:07This is the pro. I mean, they expressly branded
- 42:09is pro and then it's like dot dot dot.
- 42:11They'll have the are obviously, will be cheaper.
- 42:13But like, you know, my view has been that like the actual
- 42:15quality of the experience is, like, what's so key and been the
- 42:18barrier and that just like, you know, my TV sharper than some of
- 42:22these VR devices or whatever like those things really matter.
- 42:25So the question is just like Like will a degraded are version
- 42:29of this be sort of a mass-market device if it can't even deliver
- 42:33like the pro level experience, which we're not even sure.
- 42:36The pro level experience has the graphics processing and
- 42:39everything to do what people really want.
- 42:41So are you optimistic about like an air version of this device?
- 42:45Yeah. Definitely, man.
- 42:46I'm off to mr. About any Apple device.
- 42:47They're so good at Hardware. I mean, I'd like, I'm not lucky
- 42:50okay, guilty as charged of an apple Fanboy, but they've got
- 42:52the goods, they watch the iMac, the iPhone, the iPad.
- 42:56IPod. They're so good.
- 42:57At Hardware. The MacBook like they are pods.
- 43:00Each one of these is a multi-billion dollar industry on
- 43:03its own right, but I think the other thing is about this
- 43:06strategy of going hyper high-end.
- 43:08As the technology curve goes, you a lot of that stuff.
- 43:12You'll be able to trickle down or you'll learn stuff about what
- 43:15you built on the high end that you can actually turns out.
- 43:18Maybe you can't get in the for 500.
- 43:19It's like model 3 Model X. I totally agree with the
- 43:23Testament of for us and you know, apples been doing there
- 43:25for a long time and that it makes total sense to me and I
- 43:27think people fixating on the price.
- 43:31Fucking sucks expensive but it's not it's a niche sort of product
- 43:35at the. It's a suck.
- 43:35Not everyone can afford a Ferrari man, it sucks.
- 43:37I read. It's a bummer that technology
- 43:39has to be that way with a first gen is not accessible.
- 43:42But unfortunately, that's just how Tech works.
- 43:44But you know, computers used to cost thirty thousand dollars so
- 43:47it will get cheaper, you know, right.
- 43:49And the beauty of it is that the end of the day they want to be
- 43:52able to sell a device that they can make money on to everybody.
- 43:55And so, yeah, it drives the prices down and then and that's
- 43:58just sort of how this and I think what I About their
- 44:01strategic positioning. Is that like we've seen the
- 44:03devices? You can get for 500 bucks.
- 44:05We're not satisfied with those. And we don't think the public is
- 44:08satisfied with those. And so, we need to like, go to
- 44:10the next level. And yes, it's going to be
- 44:12incredibly expensive, but we hope we can convince the public
- 44:15with like that device that like, the Vision Pro today is maybe
- 44:20what the quest 6 will be like, you know, that Quest, six price
- 44:22point. You know what I mean at that, in
- 44:24that number of years and so they're trying to do that today
- 44:27and see. Okay.
- 44:28What use cases that enable they're trying to really?
- 44:31Accelerate that path to future. I wanted to pull up like Mark
- 44:34Zuckerberg is comments about the Vision Pro like and get you to
- 44:39react. I mean, you know, Apple
- 44:41announced the headset, you know, I was really curious what they
- 44:43were going to ship. He hasn't played with it yet and
- 44:46he says this is Mark Zuckerberg from what I've seen initially.
- 44:49I'd say the good news is that there's no kind of magical
- 44:52solutions that they have to any of the constraints on laws of
- 44:55physics that our teams haven't already explored in thought of
- 44:59they went with a higher resolution display.
- 45:01Between that and all the technology they put in there to
- 45:03power it, it cost seven times, more and requires so much
- 45:06energy. They now you need a battery and
- 45:08a wire attached to it to use it. They made that design trade off
- 45:12and it might make sense for the cases that they're going for.
- 45:15And basically saying, you know, we want to make things for
- 45:17everybody. You know, we have different
- 45:19philosophies, they sell sort of elite stuff and like we feel
- 45:22good about this. I mean, do you think this is
- 45:26good for a Facebook in that a validates the category or is it
- 45:29bad for Facebook in that? That it's a potentially better
- 45:33product that eats his lunch, I think it's good for Facebook.
- 45:36The market at some point of maturity would need all the like
- 45:39all the tech companies to get involved, right?
- 45:41Like if you're just the one company doing it, that means
- 45:43it's probably not a big enough market, right?
- 45:45And so I think that like it absolutely validates it.
- 45:49People get it. Now, I think, especially let
- 45:51like now that there's two trillion dollar companies.
- 45:53I think there's a lot less people you have to answer to in
- 45:56terms of like Wall Street and stuff.
- 45:57It's like, okay. Now it's a competitive thing
- 45:59now, we can't lose, I think. The positioning is interesting,
- 46:03you know about the like lower price point thing.
- 46:06You know, I think the social stuff like I get things like hey
- 46:08this is not the kind of device I want to have, but like there
- 46:11will be social on right and I sort of trust Apple more to get
- 46:15like the human to human things and I don't know.
- 46:18Mark Zuckerberg is company necessarily but he can tell
- 46:21himself whatever he wants. I mean, yeah, apples great.
- 46:24It like, I don't know the human if feeling like human company,
- 46:28like this was built for a person they understand.
- 46:31You know, like, I feel like they get that.
- 46:32So I don't quite see what sucks saying on that point.
- 46:36But certainly the pricing and the accessibility and sort of
- 46:39their strategic, I think so. Yeah.
- 46:41I mean, this is, I think this is great.
- 46:43I may, I think also, I heard on, was it?
- 46:45I think so, this trajectory podcast that like Mark loves
- 46:48playing strategy games and he hates to lose very competitive.
- 46:51And so this will be very intriguing.
- 46:53This kind of will double down is resolved, you know, to really,
- 46:57you know, a up, you know, I sure wasn't that was Ronnie saying
- 47:00that Ronnie above So they have co-founder magically petite and
- 47:02Henry says, he's met both Tim and Mark it's going to be really
- 47:06exciting. I mean, it now it valid.
- 47:08The thing is though, is that like on the cost, the proquest
- 47:13pros, very expensive and so like, I don't know how much is,
- 47:16it thousand? Twelve hundred, something like
- 47:18that. So that's definitely not an
- 47:19every person's device. Right?
- 47:21But maybe I mean, it is great. That they are providing
- 47:24something in a more accessible price point.
- 47:26Although now it's went up in price, they're not subsidizing
- 47:28it as much as I used to be 299, which is Double cheap.
- 47:31And you know, they're done to kind of sensitivity studies were
- 47:34like what price we have to get. It works like you know you know
- 47:39there is a period I think it was during the pandemic where if I
- 47:42like the metaverse was going to be here tomorrow and like we had
- 47:46that whole discussion, it can become a semantic argument and
- 47:48I'm guilty of sort of this semantic games where it's like
- 47:52you know, Fortnight you are Perpetual character and you can
- 47:55go to a concert and that feels metaverse like, can we expand
- 47:58that out? But I just wanted to take stock.
- 48:01You know, now that the metaverse hype sort of died but now we're
- 48:04sort of like back in this sort of like world again with this
- 48:07device like how do you see this? The metaverse conversation they
- 48:11had and what your view on to I think I'm going to be a little
- 48:15cheesy paraphrase. The metaverse is already here
- 48:17it's just not evenly distributed right?
- 48:19Like I think we live in a 2d metaverse the average American
- 48:23spends ten hours a day on a screen.
- 48:25I think roughly four of those on a phone for those on his laptop
- 48:28and then two of those on a TV. So like That is a lot of 2D time
- 48:32now. And what I mean by that is we
- 48:34live in a 2d digital. We spent a majority of our day
- 48:39in digital experiences. All right.
- 48:42And they are 2D and your future computer will be a headset.
- 48:45It's really kind of a matter of time.
- 48:47And so when the device is 3D by Nature, those experiences all
- 48:51become 3D by nature. And so, Netflix will.
- 48:54Now be, I look on my couch, and I'm watching.
- 48:56I've seen my friends with me and we're watching the game
- 48:58together, you know, or the listener.
- 49:00ER, is going to be shouting right now.
- 49:02You sort of did a dot dot dot on.
- 49:03The future is going to be a headset right there are.
- 49:06I see obviously that, why? That could seem intuitive.
- 49:09But there to some, I think there's a perfectly reasonable
- 49:11thing that like, if you believe in a are especially if you
- 49:14believe like, oh man. Continued access to the real
- 49:17world is like a valuable thing of this device.
- 49:19It's like whoa, let me tell you what's a better version of a are
- 49:22like everything else besides your screen is still the real
- 49:25thing. You know what I mean?
- 49:26It's like in some ways like a screen is a great solution to a
- 49:30are because Doesn't block you off from the rest of the world
- 49:32and the part that you want to be a screen.
- 49:34Is there, you know, like, okay, I remember when I was a kid and
- 49:38like, I watched, like futuristic visions of the future and maybe
- 49:41like, I remember like reading I think popular science or
- 49:43something like that, and they show like you're going to have
- 49:45your wallpapers are going to be TV screens and you're going to
- 49:48be like your have like menus will be, you know, TV screens
- 49:52and stuff. And I'm like, there's no way
- 49:53like this is back in the CRT era where the freakin TVs were
- 49:56massive and stuff. I think the big zennith boxes.
- 49:58I'm not that old. But like, you know what I mean,
- 50:00they were Chunky. And now like restaurants, give
- 50:03you an iPad for a menu sometimes.
- 50:05We're like there's TVs, just plastered everywhere.
- 50:08So the digital world is kind of like eating, you know, like the
- 50:12meta versus eating, you know, like sophomore, he eats
- 50:13everything like the hardware or, you know, is kind of eating the
- 50:16world to in that sense. So I hear you but I shouldn't
- 50:19have said, goggles are the future, like, but I do think
- 50:21glasses. Like if you think about it,
- 50:23okay? Here's the question.
- 50:25If you could have a pair of glasses that can be the exact
- 50:28same or maybe slightly bigger than your current laptop, To
- 50:31your eye, or your phone. You look down your hand, you see
- 50:33the phone and it's just a cheap and light, and it's always on.
- 50:36Would you wear that probably yet?
- 50:38Yeah, I'm a Believer. So, that is, when does that
- 50:41happen, right? Why don't you want your screen
- 50:44on demand? If you can project things out,
- 50:46like if it if it's lightweight. I mean the problem, you know,
- 50:50there are these physics questions as Mark Zuckerberg
- 50:53alluded to as like, apples, clearly run into, you know,
- 50:55their device uses cameras. It is not sort of optical.
- 51:00So there are these like intractable physics problems
- 51:03that have been a real barrier. Those are hard for glasses.
- 51:07Yeah, those are hard. I mean, I think we'll get there.
- 51:11I don't know. It feels like inevitable.
- 51:12I mean, it's just a question of when, right?
- 51:14It's like 5 years, 10 years, I mean, the contact lens stuff is
- 51:17kind of crazy too. If you fly, is that talk to
- 51:19people will just there's a company, I forget what it's
- 51:21called now. But they've got like a really
- 51:23compelling contact lens display where you can actually get I
- 51:26think it's like maybe 512 by 512 pixels or something.
- 51:29I mean I'm just thinking like Listen to.
- 51:31Some podcasts are talking about emulating up from the founder of
- 51:34naughty dog. Jason Rubin.
- 51:35It was Boz. Has botched the future podcast,
- 51:37the, you know, inducing a CTO Facebook.
- 51:40Yeah. So he was just, he was just on
- 51:42early this week, and he said that, like, he played mu, he's
- 51:45the founder, Crash Bandicoot, naughty dog.
- 51:47And he said, he plays PlayStation on emulation and
- 51:50their resolution was like 512 by 384 or something crazy.
- 51:54So like we have 4K now in your hand.
- 51:57And so, just looking at the Arc of tech, like it's kind of Of
- 52:01insane, you know, like the stuff we had when we were kids like
- 52:04literally dot matrix, printers. And you know what I mean?
- 52:07And things are exponentially getting faster in terms of
- 52:10innovation, right? So like chat gbt you got to 100
- 52:13million users in months so things are exponentially and
- 52:17they do kind of compound so I wouldn't bet against they're not
- 52:21being glasses, you know in 10 years, maybe 20, 24 sure.
- 52:25I think 20 is of for sure 20. I mean it's the classic thing
- 52:30where what we're The Vegas odds. What are the Vegas?
- 52:32I know. I love to see that.
- 52:34Well, it's been great having you on the podcast.
- 52:35Super exciting. We all are gonna have to have
- 52:38the experience for ourselves. That's our episode.
- 52:41Thanks so much to Lauren, good and Anand agrawal.
- 52:43Allah for coming on the show I'm Eric newcomer who has been the
- 52:46newcomer podcast shout out to Tommy Heron, our audio editor,
- 52:50Riley conselho, my chief of staff, young Chomsky for the
- 52:53wonderful theme music. Subscribe at newcomer dotco
- 52:57really appreciate our pains drivers and like Comment,
- 53:01subscribe on YouTube and please review us on Apple podcast.
- 53:05Thanks so much and see you next week.
- 53:07Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 53:00Comment, subscribe on YouTube and please review us on Apple
- 53:05podcast. Thanks so much and see you next
- 53:06week. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 53:08Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.