Latest / Kat on the Loose / NO BS EATING HABITS WITH ABBEY SHARP
Transcript
- 0:00Abby, welcome to Cat on the Lose.
- 0:03Thank you so much for having me.
- 0:04I'm very excited to chat.
- 0:06I am very excited to have you here.
- 0:08Number one, because I love your energy.
- 0:10I fell in love with your videos on TikTok.
- 0:13But also, I think this is such an important conversation and such important advice coming from an expert such as yourself.
- 0:20Thank you.
- 0:20Thank you so much.
- 0:22So let's talk about food.
- 0:23I have a million questions.
- 0:24Let's try to pack as much as possible.
- 0:27Perfect.
- 0:29So I want to start with a very controversial one, but I think it's a very important one.
- 0:32And I know you do a lot of videos about that.
- 0:34Obviously, social media is a huge platform for anyone.
- 0:38And there are tons and tons and tons of people out there dispensing potentially food.
- 0:45dangerous and she's nodding her head yes if you guys are listening to the audio episode uh potentially dangerous advice to people regarding food and you do a lot of videos about that so the first question would be oh my god what do we do with that abby
- 1:02Honestly, it sometimes feels like a David and Goliath situation where, you know, us science communicators, you know, we're one in, you know, like one to 100 of these, you know, influencers who, you know, may have compelling stories and may be beautiful and may be thin, but are not actual credible sources for nutrition information.
- 1:23So, you know, there are things I do encourage folks to look out for when they're evaluating whether or not something is happening.
- 1:31credible source.
- 1:33Because obviously credentials are a good first filter, but they're not the only filter.
- 1:39Because sometimes folks may have really important credentials, like be a doctor or a PhD or something like that.
- 1:45But those credentials have to be relevant to what they're talking about, right?
- 1:50So a chiropractor, a naturopath, personal trainer, physician, dietitian, PhD researcher,
- 1:54we all have different scopes of expertise.
- 1:58So I don't want people to just to see those letters behind somebody's name and, you know, and assume that that is what their, you know, their expertise is in.
- 2:07So for example, a doctor that has a PhD in like medical studies and like medieval studies, I meant, probably should not be giving health advice, even though they have that doctor in front of their name.
- 2:18So, you know, that is a really important first step.
- 2:23step to try to evaluate.
- 2:26The other thing I try to encourage people to look out for is how they communicate uncertainty.
- 2:32Because, you know, science is rarely, basically never, this one food destroys your hormones, or, you know, this one food is toxic or bad for you.
- 2:41You know, legitimate experts will say annoying things like may or potentially help,
- 2:47you know, they'll point out inconsistencies or contradictions in the research, not just the kind of outlying, outlier finding.
- 2:55And they'll talk about how, you know, association does not equal causation.
- 3:00And it's hard because these are not super sexy things to say on social media.
- 3:04These aren't the things that go viral.
- 3:06These aren't the things that get picked up in the algorithm that depends on emotion.
- 3:12But lack of nuance and lack of context are a really big red flag.
- 3:16Yeah, so, okay.
- 3:18One that especially concerns me, and I loved your video about it.
- 3:22I'm not going to name names, but there is a girl.
- 3:24And I worry about social media because there are so many young people there, right?
- 3:28Like there's 18, 19 or 20-year-old girls.
- 3:31And of course, they dream about being skinny, skinny, skinny.
- 3:33And I believe skinny is good as long as you're healthy.
- 3:36And there is this one influencer.
- 3:39She is like some kind of skinny coach.
- 3:42She has zero credentials.
- 3:44She's not a nutritionist such as you.
- 3:46She's not a doctor.
- 3:48Her credential is, I am skinny.
- 3:51I actually think she's emaciated by now.
- 3:53If you look at her body, like at her body, it's beginning to worry me.
- 3:56And she's dispensing crazy advice that you actually comment on.
- 4:02For example, she said, walk 10,000 steps on a fasted state, on an empty stomach.
- 4:10I personally think, and I do do intermittent fasting, but I do it in a safe way.
- 4:15But I personally think this is very dangerous advice to be dispensing a young TikTok crowd.
- 4:21Right, Abby?
- 4:22Oh my goodness.
- 4:23Yes, you really hit the nail on the head because...
- 4:26Unfortunately, there's the way that these algorithms work is they pick up sensationalism.
- 4:33They pick up, you know, these really black or white, almost rage bait like type of content.
- 4:41And unfortunately, because of that, there are so many young folks on social media who
- 4:46who are now getting trapped in these echo chambers, these, what, you know, what you're referring to is essentially this whole skinny talk side of TikTok or social media Instagram, where thinness is, it's essentially a subculture on social media that glorifies everything.
- 5:02extreme thinness at any cost often promotes disordered behaviors, disordered mentality around food and your body.
- 5:12And, you know, I've done a bit of a lot of a lot of deep dives on the origins or kind of like where this whole skinny talk kind of trend came from, especially as we came off the heels of, you know, a more body positivity or body neutrality movement of the
- 5:31I do feel that one of the contributors is simply that, you know, once we've seen, you know, Zempik and these GLP1s and things like that make the rounds, you know, thinness in some ways became transactional.
- 5:43And so a lot of folks like this influencer you're talking about who have achieved thinness the quote unquote hard way or have achieved.
- 5:51built identity capital around their body, you know, this extreme, these extreme messages around skinny, skinny is the outfit, skinny is luxurious, you know, you know, like, you know, if, if you don't want to go for a walk, just like oink or tell yourself that you're fat, you know, all these demeaning, you know, behaviors and mantras, you know, this is almost like their way of trying to reclaim their moral superiority in a world where, you know,
- 6:21you know, thinness is becoming more accessible.
- 6:25But it's really teaching young girls to, you know, prioritize thinness at any and all cost to, you know, the bar of what we are perceiving to be a normal, healthy body is getting smaller and smaller and smaller.
- 6:37And, you know, I get young people messaging me every single day saying, you know,
- 6:42You know, I'm really struggling to keep my calories under 1000 calories or 1200 calories.
- 6:47And I'm like, yeah, no kidding, because you're not supposed to be eating that few of calories.
- 6:52You know, but this is what a lot of these these videos are promoting.
- 6:56And it is so, so damaging to young folks.
- 6:59I know.
- 7:00So what would you say?
- 7:01Because I'm not a nutritionist.
- 7:02I know, and probably because of my cultures, right?
- 7:04Because I come from Brazil and France and cultures that love to eat.
- 7:09But everything in moderation.
- 7:11So my lifestyle, I eat, I mean, I eat super clean.
- 7:15I admit, I eat very healthy.
- 7:17I try to learn, I educate myself.
- 7:2090% of the time I eat super clean.
- 7:22But it's like petite portions, small portions of everything.
- 7:26I will have my...
- 7:27I'll have some every once in a while.
- 7:28I'll have whatever I want, cheese, but it's small portions.
- 7:32And it works for me.
- 7:33So if somebody out there are listening, hopefully these girls that before you, I would say before you listen to this crazy internet TikTok girls, I would say listen to a nutritionist, right?
- 7:44Such as yourself.
- 7:44Yes.
- 7:45So what would you say is the first step?
- 7:47Someone that wants to be a healthy, thin, maintain their weight, but not go crazy radical.
- 7:55Absolutely.
- 7:55So, you know, this is really the core crux of my signature framework, the hunger crushing combo method that I've written a whole bestselling book about.
- 8:06Because unlike basically every diet that folks have probably been on and off their entire lives, which tell you to restrict something, whether it's restrict calories or carbs, or the time in which you can eat or you can't eat gluten or dairy or
- 8:20whatever rules the diet du jour has come up with, what we know is that when we are constantly thinking about what we have to take away, it puts us in the state of scarcity mentality that almost always triggers, you know, hyper fixation, obsession, binging, food noise.
- 8:37And it becomes very hard for you to, A, have a healthy relationship with food, B, be able to actually tune into your body's true needs so that you can maintain a healthy body weight.
- 8:49And so the hunger crushing combo method really flips that script because it's working with our biology and our psychology to think about adding, not taking away.
- 8:59And this is a really important distinction here.
- 9:01It's a mindset shift because we're wanting to add fiber, protein, and healthy fats.
- 9:07These are the hunger crushing compounds that keep us satiated longer.
- 9:12They help to stabilize our blood sugars much longer.
- 9:15They help to reduce the food noise, quiet that incessant food noise, those cravings.
- 9:20And they help us maintain and reach a healthiest, happy weight without getting into that scarcity mentality that triggers a binge.
- 9:28Can you give us one, for people that don't know, can you give us one example of each?
- 9:33Yes, of course.
- 9:34Okay, so, you know, in the hunger crushing combo method, I often kind of distinguish these hunger crushing compounds from what I often call naked carbs.
- 9:43So you gave us a good example earlier of a naked carb croissant.
- 9:46Yes, so, right.
- 9:48So, you've been indulging every once in a while.
- 9:51Oh my gosh, of course, of course.
- 9:53And that is the beauty of the hunger crushing combo method because we aren't taking the naked carbs away.
- 10:00We simply want to think about what we're adding to them.
- 10:02So my kind of like naked carb of choice is like fun cereal.
- 10:08I love cereal.
- 10:09I've always loved cereal.
- 10:11But I know that it's not going to keep me very full, very long.
- 10:14By the way, right?
- 10:14Because a lot of parents in the United States, and a lot of adults, it's pure sugar and crap.
- 10:20Right.
- 10:21So there's a lot of sugar.
- 10:22There's not a lot of hunger crushing compounds, fiber, protein, healthy fats.
- 10:25So you might eat an entire massive bowl of sugary cereal, and then you're going to feel hungry again an hour later.
- 10:32So what are we going to do?
- 10:33Instead of saying, well, I'm never going to eat sugary cereal again, even though you're pining for it,
- 10:38which is going to cause you get into that scarcity mentality that will, you know, hyperfixate, you binge eventually.
- 10:44What we're going to do is we're going to dress up those naked carbs.
- 10:47And we're going to start with some Greek yogurt, for example, for some protein.
- 10:50Greek yogurt is great protein, right?
- 10:52Great protein.
- 10:53Not those...
- 10:54sugary ones with fake strawberry fake this but just plain greek yogurt correct yes so i loved i love buying plain yogurt plain greek yogurt especially like a little bit of a higher fat yogurt because again the the texture is a lot better the flavor is a lot better and this way you can add as much or as little kind of sweet whether it's honey or fruit whatever it is that you like so that's our protein
- 11:16Let's add some berries on there for our fiber.
- 11:19There we go.
- 11:19We've got some antioxidants.
- 11:20We've got some fiber.
- 11:21Maybe we're going to do a little sprinkle of hemp hearts or some nut butter or some seeds on there.
- 11:26That's our healthy fats.
- 11:27And then we go in with a handful of those Lucky Charms or Frosted Flakes or whatever your favorite cereal is.
- 11:34So we have that.
- 11:35You put a little bit of your guilty pleasure every day so you're deprived.
- 11:40Yes.
- 11:41Absolutely.
- 11:42And not feeling deprived is key because like I said, we are hardwired as humans to fight against deprivation.
- 11:50We have all these different compensatory mechanisms in the body, in the brain to get us to return back to status quo when our body thinks that we are in that state of scarcity mentality.
- 12:00So our hunger hormones rage.
- 12:02Our satiety hormones quiet.
- 12:04We get the food noise gets out of control.
- 12:06We subconsciously move less.
- 12:08Our metabolism slows down.
- 12:10So when we eliminate that scarcity mentality, because we're saying, I can still have the sugary cereal.
- 12:16I can still have the croissant, but I'm going to dress it up with these hunger crushing compounds so that I feel full physically.
- 12:23And I feel emotionally satisfied because I still am getting that food that I love.
- 12:28I love that.
- 12:29I want to talk about the emotional part because I know it's so important for so many women.
- 12:32But first, so just recapping a obviously a healthy protein would be the Greek yogurt.
- 12:38What healthy fats?
- 12:39A lot of people don't understand that avocado is a healthy fat, right?
- 12:44avocado, nuts, seeds, olives.
- 12:48Is oil a healthy fat?
- 12:50Yes, of course.
- 12:51Now what I always recommend when it comes to, you know, being like choosing or adding mindfully these healthy fats, ideally we want to add more whole food, healthy fats as much as possible.
- 13:03And those are the things that are like the avocado, the nuts, the seeds,
- 13:07the salmon, for example.
- 13:09And the reason for that is simply because we're getting more nutrient bang for our caloric buck, because not only are we getting healthy fats when we eat salmon, but we're also getting those, that protein that we need.
- 13:21Not only are we getting healthy fats when we eat avocado, but we're also getting a ton of fiber.
- 13:26So when we eat these healthy fats in their whole food form more often, we are getting better satiety bang for our caloric buck.
- 13:35Yeah.
- 13:35I love that.
- 13:36Now, I do want to talk about the mind, the famous stress binge eating, because I know it affects so many people, including myself.
- 13:47Nowadays, I have it really under control, but I was a person, and I don't know if you know my background, but I started my show six years ago after I went through severe tragedy.
- 13:56My husband died, my mom died, my life was upside down.
- 14:00So I had this habit, like when I was having a...
- 14:02horrible day horrible day i would comfort myself with food i started eating sugar like i needed an entire chocolate bar or like two pints of like to the point that made me sick you know when you like you eat so much crap you feel like so nauseous i was doing that a lot and then i was doing that with wine like wine and chocolate wine and chocolate
- 14:24So one day I have to say, stop, stop, stop, stop, stop.
- 14:27And I know so many women, I'm going to say Medicaid, quote unquote, right, with food, because for a few minutes or an hour, Charles, it makes us feel better.
- 14:37Any tips on how we can control that?
- 14:42Yeah.
- 14:43So believe it or not, I mean, I just want to put to kind of set like just to set the stage that, you know, I don't want you to ever think that you can never eat emotionally again.
- 14:54You
- 15:01Um, you know, we eat to, to mourn, like it's part of culture.
- 15:04It's part of joy.
- 15:05It's part of celebration.
- 15:07So eating because you're upset or lonely or exhausted or stressed, you know, it's, it's a very normal human behavior because like I said, food is pleasurable.
- 15:15It's comforting.
- 15:16It's culturally and, you know, emotionally meaningful.
- 15:19That said, we don't want food to be the only tool in our emotional regulation toolbox.
- 15:25Um,
- 15:26And so, you know, when I hear people kind of getting trapped in this kind of stress eating, binge eating cycle, I usually look at two different contributors.
- 15:35One, what's happening physiologically and two, what's happening emotionally.
- 15:40So physiologically, as I essentially kind of just alluded to earlier, you know, one of the worst things that we can do is respond to overeating by heavily restricting the next day.
- 15:51This is what I see happen all the time.
- 15:53We get stuck in this...
- 15:54binge, restrict, repent, repeat cycle that's very hard for people to break.
- 15:58So if you're stressed and you're ravenously hungry because you've been surviving off of coffee and salad without dressing, you're essentially, you know, asking your most dysregulated brain to exercise maximum restraint around highly rewarding foods.
- 16:14It's a recipe for burnout and for binging.
- 16:17And again, this is where the hunger crushing combo method comes into play, because we're not focusing on what we're taking away.
- 16:23We're focusing on adding the kinds of foods, fiber, protein, healthy fats that keep us satiated longer.
- 16:29And then psychologically, you know, like I said, sometimes I think the best thing to do in these moments where you're thinking, when you are particularly stressed and you're feeling a bit out of control with food, ask yourself, you know, what else do I need right now?
- 16:44And
- 16:44Sometimes the answer is, I actually just really need a little piece of chocolate and that's okay.
- 16:48You know, enjoy the chocolate without guilt because that guilt and shame is just going to fuel the stress even more and it just kind of then spirals and snowballs out of control.
- 16:59But sometimes the answer is like,
- 17:01I need some more sleep.
- 17:03I need a shower.
- 17:03I need a walk.
- 17:04I need to call a friend.
- 17:05I need to scream into a pillow.
- 17:06You know, I need to set a boundary, whatever it might be.
- 17:10Um, and so, like I said, the goal is not to, you know, never eat out of emotions again.
- 17:16That's, that's not a realistic goal for humans.
- 17:20The goal is to just make sure that it's not the only tool in that emotional regulation toolbox.
- 17:25I love that.
- 17:27I personally, that's what worked for me.
- 17:29I think if you decide mentally like, oh, I can never have ice cream ever again.
- 17:33I can never have the chocolate.
- 17:35I think your mind works in a funny way that you want it even more, right?
- 17:40Absolutely.
- 17:41calm yourself down like you said you know what i don't feel great today fuck it i deserve a piece of chocolate and then you just move on with your life in time it just becomes normal no i don't think it's not like i love hate relationship with that specific food i think that's what worked for me to stop you know stress binge eating
- 18:00Absolutely.
- 18:01And, you know, I always say, you know, if you are prone to kind of stress, because, you know, some people have more stressful lives than others, you know, rather than relying on willpower, which we know is not, you know, it's not a realistic way to, to kind of encourage long lasting behavior change.
- 18:20You want to set up your environment for your actual life.
- 18:24And one of the best ways that I like to do that is with if then kind of statements.
- 18:30You know, if you are very busy, then think when you have a moment of calm, think through your if then statements so that when you get into those stressful moments, you're already prepared.
- 18:39So that could sound like if I get home late and I don't want to cook, I'm going to have eggs and toast.
- 18:45If I'm hungry between meetings, I'm going to eat the snack I packed rather than waiting until I get super ravenous and then have to like stop for fast food on the way home.
- 18:54If, you know, if, if I am feeling like I have a craving for chocolate because I'm on my period, then I'm going to allow myself and I'm going to move on without guilt or shame.
- 19:05Plan for these things ahead of time because behavior change works so much better when we design it for the most stressful moments rather than expecting perfect discipline.
- 19:14I love that.
- 19:15Set yourself up for success, right?
- 19:19have some healthy snacks around that's what I do nowadays because I am so insanely busy I just like you said I know that I love my protein yogurt with berries and a little honey I always have my really healthy snacks so before I order some junk I'm like okay let me try my healthy snack and 99.9% of the time I don't want the junk anymore after I have the healthy sometimes I still want the junk but it's very rare
- 19:45No, absolutely.
- 19:46And that, that's, you're, you're able to do that when you remove the morality around food.
- 19:52Because once you take that piece of, oh, this is good, that's bad, I'm good, that's bad.
- 19:56You know, I'm bad for choosing this, you know, oh, I need to, to compensate for eating the bread by not, you know, by basically skipping breakfast tomorrow, all that kind of food noise.
- 20:02Once you eliminate that, you have space in your brain as mental capacity to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to, you know, to,
- 20:11to actually be able to think about how food serves you.
- 20:14How does a food make me feel?
- 20:16And that is such important data for helping you fuel your body well.
- 20:20So you know, you might be able to discern finally that when you have the yogurt and berries for breakfast,
- 20:27you know, you're, you're, you've got better digestion.
- 20:29You have better energy throughout the day.
- 20:31You're not crashing mid morning and going for the donuts in the, in the, in the staff room, as opposed to when you just have the croissant, which while delicious, and of course you should have the croissant when it's, you know, when it's really good ones and you move on, but you might also have the bandwidth to collect data that, you know, I really loved that croissant.
- 20:48It was super delicious, but I was also kind of hungry like two hours later.
- 20:52So it's not maybe something I'd want to do every day.
- 20:54Right.
- 20:54And you know, it's really interesting you mentioned that the quality of foods, because that's another another video that I saw you did.
- 21:00And I think about that all the time.
- 21:02This one skinny influencer and a lot of influencers like the other one said, I don't want to eat anything processed.
- 21:08This skinny one, she's like, it's skinny, skinny.
- 21:11So when I look at the crap she buys at the store, they are eating skinny, but...
- 21:16horrible, horrible quality food.
- 21:20For example, you know, they buy like the highly processed American cheese, which is not even cheese.
- 21:28They buy like all kinds of, you know, horrible, horrible stuff.
- 21:32And they still think...
- 21:33they're not eating healthy you know they're still eating a lot of processed ingredients the skinny girl she buys like a rotisserie chicken from like the cheapest supermarket and then she dumps like a gallon of like hot sauce which comes with 10 i she does probably doesn't even know it comes with 10 million pounds of sugar and all kinds of stuff and she mixes it up with other stuff so at the end honestly okay so she's eating protein but there's a lot of other
- 22:03Yeah, and that's the tricky thing about, you know, following influencers online is that the definition of quote unquote healthy is really going to be so different for different people depending on what their goals are.
- 22:16So for one person, healthy may mean the lowest calorie possible thing.
- 22:21you know, which means you're potentially subsisting off of Diet Coke and, you know, like...
- 22:26Which is indeed not healthy, right?
- 22:28Right, exactly.
- 22:28So, I mean, it's not necessarily like providing any really quality nutrients, but to somebody else healthy, maybe eating only whole foods and never having dessert and, you know, walking 10,000 steps religiously every single day and feeling guilty if they skip like one step.
- 22:45And, you know, not necessarily...
- 22:48Either of those are kind of a balanced way of thinking about food.
- 22:51And so when it comes to, this is why I try to really encourage people not to take anything at face value from what they see online, because everybody's different.
- 23:02Everyone's goals are going to be different.
- 23:04And what is quote unquote healthy for one person is potentially going to be problematic or disordered for another person.
- 23:10Yeah.
- 23:11So I want to ask about your opinion with this radical diets.
- 23:15Like there are a lot of girls.
- 23:18I only eat the meat or the carnivore diet or I only eat that and I only eat that and I only that.
- 23:24The other day, I don't know if you saw this really famous supermodel, Miranda Kerr.
- 23:28She's married to the founder of Snapchat.
- 23:31So they're gazillion.
- 23:32She was doing a TV interview and the girl asked, I don't know, I think it was a podcast interview.
- 23:37And the girl asked her, what do you eat?
- 23:39Do you eat this?
- 23:40And she was like, I eat meat, but only if it is like venison and bison, because for whatever reason, she doesn't eat organic chicken.
- 23:51And the interviewer, instead of pressing, the interviewer was like, oh, you eat really healthy.
- 23:57Like I said, I'm not sure if only eating venison and bison is that healthy, but what's your take on it with the super radical diets?
- 24:08Yeah, I watched that interview and I had the same thought.
- 24:12I mean, for one, I think it's really sad and also quite problematic that somebody with such a large platform was, you know, listening to, you know, a beautiful woman who, you know, is famous and looked up to.
- 24:27And of course, any, you know, any young girl watching that interview and seeing the long laundry list of things she does not eat is...
- 24:34for various reasons, most of which are not legitimate, like the fear about it being mass-produced, or there being parasites in sushi, all this food fear-mongering that was coming out of you.
- 24:45She's like, I love sushi, period.
- 24:47And I'm thinking, really?
- 24:49You think all the high-quality Japanese restaurants, the sushi is so fresh.
- 24:54Yes.
- 24:55Yes.
- 24:55Such bad advice.
- 24:57Right.
- 24:58It was it was it's dangerous for young people to see those kinds of things because those things just because it just reads as most foods are bad for you.
- 25:07Most foods are going to, you know, cause harm.
- 25:10You can, you know, really have just a narrow set of like five to ten things that you're allowed to eat on repeat, even though there's literally no good research or no good reason for her to eliminate all the vegetables except for protein.
- 25:22squash carrots and parsnaps or whatever.
- 25:24The bigger problem I take with that is that, you know, that that was not being called out, that that was being celebrated and rewarded as the picture of health.
- 25:35And what that tells young people was that the less you eat, the healthier you are.
- 25:40The more rules you follow, the healthier you are.
- 25:44Even if those rules are basically nonsensical and made up.
- 25:50And yeah, we do get this whiplash with food trends where, you know, before what we're kind of like still in this raw, like this, there's carnivore diet trend that we're in, which is a, I would say an offshoot of the keto diet, which kind of became popular before that.
- 26:06But before that, even like, you know, five, 10 years ago, it was the raw vegan diet or the frugivore diet where these beautiful women were trying to promote you just eating fruit all day and a case of mangoes for lunch and things like that.
- 26:19The reality is that, you know, as I kind of spoke to earlier.
- 26:26like moderation doesn't sell.
- 26:28Moderation doesn't go viral.
- 26:30Moderation, you know, does not get picked up in an algorithm that rewards sensationalism and rewards these, you know, highly emotive statements, these extreme statements that, oh, I, you know, I cut out everything.
- 26:44Vegetables are toxic.
- 26:46You know, you've been lied to for, you know,
- 26:48by all the authorities because vegetables are toxic and only meat is healthy.
- 26:54And then, you know, also vice versa, where in the raw vegan trend, it was basically the same thing, but saying, you know, you don't eat protein, that's just, you know, big food, big meat, big dairy kind of trying to push you into eating protein.
- 27:07And the reality is that none of these things are true, that the healthiest diet really is protein.
- 27:12the most balanced, less, the least sexy diet, the least extreme, the least marketable diet, because it isn't just about one food.
- 27:21It is about the most variety we possibly can get through our diet.
- 27:26And that's not only just important for like our physical health, but also for our gut microbiome that depends on a variety of food.
- 27:34So I look at this carnivore diet and I mean, we do have emerging research that, you know, folks that have heavily
- 27:42high meat diets do display dysbiosis in the gut microbiome.
- 27:47And that's because they're not eating plants, they're not eating the fiber, they're not eating the food for their gut microbes.
- 27:52And so there will always be negative repercussions of these extreme diets.
- 27:58And unfortunately, it becomes very persuasive when we see these anecdotes, you know, these testimonials
- 28:12And the reality is it might have helped them to eliminate, you know, 99.9% of foods, but it's not because of the carnivore diet.
- 28:22It's probably because in removing 95% of all foods, they happened to maybe remove in that batch one or two foods that were triggering some concerns.
- 28:34But that doesn't mean that everybody else needs to cut all those things out.
- 28:38It's so dangerous.
- 28:39It's so bad.
- 28:40And it makes me, like you said, it makes me especially sad when I see someone with a massive platform.
- 28:46Because I feel if we have a platform, we have a responsibility.
- 28:50Like when I talk to my audience, I talk about my personal experience, but I make it very clear.
- 28:55Like I'm not a doctor.
- 28:56I'm not saying it's good for...
- 28:57So I bring experts like such as yourself, like tell me your take as a nutritionist.
- 29:03But when I see a supermodel or a huge podcast as big as mine or even bigger...
- 29:08telling people oh this is really healthy then it really worries me because i'm thinking like obviously you girls are successful you're educated you know there are a lot of impressionable younger women out there why are you telling them that you know you should do this radical crazy shit with your body especially bothers me when it's an influencer because they don't even have a medical degree they didn't even bother getting a
- 29:33licensed as a nutritionist, as a dietician, or anything, right?
- 29:37And they're taking money from these people, Abby.
- 29:39They're charging crazy money to coach them, quote unquote.
- 29:44Yeah.
- 29:45Yeah, it is so frustrating, like I said, because there are very few of us science communicators in relation to all of these influencers.
- 29:55And unfortunately, the messages that these kind of unregulated influencers are sharing are just more persuasive.
- 30:03You know, humans don't really make decisions based on credentials or spreadsheets or data.
- 30:09They respond best to stories and confidence, aspiration, identity, knowledge.
- 30:14They want to relate.
- 30:16And, you know, there's actually loads of research in the kind of marketing space showing the power of human testimonials over authority.
- 30:25And so, you know, we're just not wired to think in population level probabilities, which is what us communicators, science communicators want to communicate because that's what science is.
- 30:35We're just wired for stories.
- 30:37And then specifically when it comes to like health and wellness and nutrition recommendations, we're going to be more interested in the story of the person who looks the way we want to look or who has the lifestyle or whatever that we aspire to have.
- 30:51And because social media is just, you know, the way it is, it's creating these very intimate relationships, these parasocial relationships.
- 31:00These aren't distant celebrities like they were when I was a,
- 31:03a kid.
- 31:04We feel like these are our people, our friends.
- 31:07We watch them have their breakfast, walk their dogs, see their kids.
- 31:10We watch their workouts.
- 31:11Like we watch everything.
- 31:12There's, there's stupid thoughts that really we don't need to hear.
- 31:15We hear it all.
- 31:17And so because of that, you know, it's just, it's just that we are much more likely to, to rely on
- 31:25what they have to say, what they've experienced over us science communicators.
- 31:28Well, luckily we have people like you that keep calling them out.
- 31:31I love it.
- 31:32Now, what do you think about intermittent fasting?
- 31:34What is your take on it?
- 31:35Is it worth it?
- 31:36Is it healthy?
- 31:38I would say for me, I've been doing it and I started like not to lose weight.
- 31:43I was like, okay, let me try.
- 31:44And my body got used to it.
- 31:47So I kind of stopped eating crazy early, like 5 p.m. if I'm alone now.
- 31:537 p.m. if I go out to dinner, but I don't like eating late at night.
- 31:58And then I start eating again around 10 or 11 a.m.
- 32:02But my body just got used to it.
- 32:04Like I don't feel hungry in the morning, you know.
- 32:08And I hear a lot of doctors saying that it's a great idea.
- 32:12But I have heard a few other doctors and nutritionists say, oh, it increases your cortisol.
- 32:17It's a horrible idea.
- 32:18Don't spend so much time without eating.
- 32:20What's your take on it?
- 32:22Okay, so a lot of proponents of intermittent fasting will claim that it's unique because it suppresses insulin between meals, which they then claim insulin's the big fat storage hormone.
- 32:34But this is actually not why intermittent fasting works for weight loss.
- 32:39The main reason if it does work for weight loss is simply that
- 32:42we skip a meal and we just kind of suck at making up for those lost calories, right?
- 32:47Because we're just, we've created this rule.
- 32:48We eat from this hour to this hour.
- 32:50So we're snacking less.
- 32:51We're actually just eating less calories without necessarily thinking that we're kind of cutting back on calories.
- 32:58And actually it doesn't work for everybody.
- 33:00Some people actually feel that they get so ravenous by the time they're eating window comes that they overeat, that they binge.
- 33:06And for those folks that, you know, it's just not a good fit.
- 33:10But what I would say is that, you know, we do just want to be careful, especially women, because women are more sensitive to calorie deficits and fat loss in general.
- 33:19So if intermittent fasting is causing you to significantly under eat, especially when combined with exercise or over exercise during your fasting, we know, that's when we can see the risk of hormonal disruption.
- 33:37So somebody out there that says, because like this crazy influencer said, go walk 10,000 steps fast.
- 33:42I'm like, I think I walk in the morning fasted with my dogs, to be really honest, but I don't walk 10,000 steps.
- 33:49I walk them to the dog park around the block,
- 33:52And I come home and I have a cappuccino with almond milk.
- 33:56So, you know, I ease my body into my crazy busy routine.
- 34:00But if somebody out there is listening to us, like, I want to try it out or should I try it out?
- 34:05Do you have any ideas like what would be the first step?
- 34:09Well, I would say listen to your body.
- 34:11And like I said, not, not everybody is, you know, some people like myself, like I need a solid bedtime snack for me to get a good night's sleep.
- 34:20I need to eat in the morning.
- 34:21You know, I need regular, regular food intake throughout the day for me to be able to kind of meet my, my protein needs, for example.
- 34:29But I would say that, you know, with regards to like the 10,000 steps in the morning or whatever, that all movement is good movement.
- 34:36And 10,000 steps was actually not even a scientifically proven like magic threshold.
- 34:41It was based, you know, it was created for an insurance company, believe it or not, way back in the day.
- 34:47I wouldn't hold, you know, hold on to that specific number.
- 34:50And, you know, if walking works for you, great.
- 34:54If weightlifting works for you, which honestly all women should be doing strength training, especially as we get into perimenopause and menopause, it's incredibly important to be maintaining that.
- 35:03that muscle and bone.
- 35:05But I would say, you know, if you, you know, listen to your body and if your body is telling you that, you know, this is not really working, this, this, this way of eating is not necessarily working because you're hungry, you're, you've got food noise, you're overthinking about food, then there really isn't a good benefit to this.
- 35:23especially if you're looking to use it for weight loss purposes.
- 35:26It would be far better for you to just eat, you know, more mindful portions throughout the day and not be so ravenous by the time you allow yourself to get to this quote-unquote eating window.
- 35:37So I would say don't force yourself into an intermittent fasting protocol.
- 35:42If it works, it's because it naturally works with your body.
- 35:46Yeah, I would say if somebody wants to do it, consult with a specialist first.
- 35:50Yes.
- 35:50As opposed to listening to this baloney on social media, right, Abby?
- 35:54Absolutely, absolutely.
- 35:55Whenever possible, I always recommend ideally working with a registered dietitian because you might find through that experience that...
- 36:02Hey, maybe intermittent fasting is not the best method for you.
- 36:05Maybe eating lower carb is maybe just, you know, removing, you know, cutting back on portions.
- 36:10Maybe, of course, you know, incorporating this hunger crushing combo method that I've, I've trademarked is, is the most gentle and sustainable method for you.
- 36:18I love your book, by the way, guys, it's the hunger crushing method and it's so informative.
- 36:24It's super great.
- 36:26But before,
- 36:26Before I let you go, so since you are a nutritionist and you said you like a nighttime snack, can you talk us through one sample day for you as a nutritionist?
- 36:36Like what would you eat?
- 36:38Sure.
- 36:39You go to sleep?
- 36:41Okay.
- 36:41So, I mean, there's no, like, I don't follow a meal plan.
- 36:45So this is just an example.
- 36:47It's not like the meat, it's not the, the everyday.
- 36:49Um, but I usually try to have something with protein in the morning.
- 36:53So, you know, a quick protein shake, I don't have a really big appetite in the morning, but I know that I, I need to get solid amounts of protein throughout the day.
- 37:01Um, so I'll do a quick little protein shake, or I might have some, you know, hard-boiled eggs, um, just to get me started.
- 37:07Then maybe my, like,
- 37:09Actual breakfast breakfast would be usually do a couple slices of whole grain sourdough with some cottage cheese on top, some fruit and berries.
- 37:20a little bit like maybe of like a granola or a crunchy cereal.
- 37:24Like I said before, I love cereal.
- 37:25I love crunch.
- 37:25Put a little handful of that on top.
- 37:28I always have two lattes in the morning with soy milk because again, soy milk is a great source of protein.
- 37:34So, you know, a couple, maybe that's like 15, 16 grams of protein right there.
- 37:40Um, lunch.
- 37:41I'm sorry, let me interrupt you.
- 37:43So soy milk is because I do I do almond milk.
- 37:46So it's a better choice in terms of the protein.
- 37:49Yes, almond milk is quite low in protein.
- 37:52It maybe has one gram per cup.
- 37:55Soy milk will have about eight to nine cup grams per cup.
- 37:58So it's comparable to you know, your traditional dairy milk.
- 38:01So
- 38:02I love that.
- 38:04And then lunch, I usually do kind of like a fully loaded salad with, you know, sweet potatoes or some kind of carb, different fruit.
- 38:13I like fruit in my salad.
- 38:14Always have cheese in my salad, chicken or some kind of leftover protein that I have in the house.
- 38:20And then I'll usually have that with, you know, some other kind of carb on the side, whether...
- 38:24you know, that's like a piece of bread or some kind of leftovers from the night before or something like that.
- 38:31And then typically I'll have another little snack before dinner, usually like some Greek yogurt and some fruit or something, maybe some cheese.
- 38:37And then dinner obviously varies, but it's always some kind of protein, a carb and lots of vegetables.
- 38:44So tonight, what am I making?
- 38:47Tonight I'm making...
- 38:49kind of mango braised chicken tacos.
- 38:52So that's the crock pot right now with like mango and you know, tomato and bell pepper kind of sauce with shredded chicken and I'll have you know, taco shells and cheese and, and bell peppers.
- 39:04I'm getting hungry.
- 39:05I know, I know.
- 39:06I'm very excited.
- 39:08It smells really good in here.
- 39:09And then, believe it or not, people always are like, I don't believe you, but I eat a large bedtime snack.
- 39:15So because I know, again, that, you know, I need a lot of I need to catch up on even more.
- 39:22I have high calorie needs.
- 39:23So I need to catch up on, you know, as much protein before bed as I can.
- 39:26So, you know, it's usually like a big bowl of Greek yogurt with fruit with some cereal.
- 39:33Um,
- 39:33Um, maybe a little bit of popcorn on the side or, you know, popcorn with, you know, cheese, um, and some fruit.
- 39:40I really just kind of, whatever I know, I always have to have protein and always a bit of fiber before dinner.
- 39:47That's kind of my, my thing.
- 39:49It sounds like healthy or eating clean.
- 39:52But it doesn't sound like you're depriving yourself.
- 39:55Oh, no, no.
- 39:56I mean, that's that is like a weekday.
- 39:58And I go out on the weekends and I love my wine and I love dessert.
- 40:03And so, yeah, like there's always treats in the house like we.
- 40:08We, my fridge has, my freezer, I think I have got like six different flavors of ice cream going on.
- 40:13And, you know, but, but I don't ever feel like I need to deprive myself.
- 40:19Like it's always there.
- 40:20Usually I forget it's there.
- 40:23And when I do have a craving, then I'm not going to deny myself.
- 40:27It's not something I think twice about.
- 40:29And it made, it makes a huge difference.
- 40:31I think everything in moderation, right?
- 40:33Instead of something crazy and radical, I guess that would be the message, right?
- 40:36Yes, that's exactly the message.
- 40:38Not, you know, perfection is not the measure of good health.
- 40:43Yes, I love it.
- 40:45Thank you so much.
- 40:46I love your style.
- 40:47Guys, if you don't know her work, please go look at her videos.
- 40:49Can you tell us your handle again, Abby?
- 40:51Yes.
- 40:52What do you think here on this episode, by the way?
- 40:55Absolutely.
- 40:56So it's Abby's Kitchen.
- 40:59You can find me, Abby Sharp, basically on TikTok, Instagram.
- 41:03My podcast is called Bite Back with Abby Sharp.
- 41:06So you can find me there for really, you know, good deep dives.
- 41:10But yeah, thank you so much.
- 41:11Thank you.
- 41:11We really appreciate you.
- 41:12And guys, be safe out there.
- 41:14Don't go listen to this crazy influences.
- 41:16I do agree with you, Abby.
- 41:17A little bit of everything in moderation.
- 41:19Be happy because food is such a great, important part of life, right?
- 41:22Absolutely.
- 41:23Thank you.
- 41:23You're amazing, guys.
- 41:24I'll be seeing you very soon.
- 41:26Love you.
- 41:27Go eat something delicious.