Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Final Settlement E005: Federated Systems with Tony & Ben from Mutiny
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company on ramps. Multi institution custody is a
- 0:35segregated institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:39institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:43unique permissions have been met at on RAMP we understand that
- 0:47your Bitcoin journey is a multi generational pursuit catalyzed
- 0:50by the ideals of perseverance, aspiration and legacy.
- 0:54That's why we're proud to introduce on RAMP Heritage, a
- 0:57suite of private client services dedicated to ensuring your
- 1:00Bitcoin legacy is preserved and passed on, embodying the true
- 1:04essence of wealth that goes beyond mere numbers.
- 1:07If you would like to learn more, please schedule a consultation.
- 1:12It all comes down to computers. Communicating the information
- 1:17superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps and off ramps.
- 1:22Bitcoin is worthless artificial goal.
- 1:26Is it still rat poison? Probably rat poison squared.
- 1:30We need to get into the world of, OK, this is actually
- 1:33foundational technology. What the Internet of Money does
- 1:37is it creates a single network which can do a microtransaction
- 1:42to a giga transaction. The Internet is going to be one
- 1:48of the major forces for reducing the role of God.
- 1:53The one thing that's missing, but that will soon be developed
- 1:57is a reliable E cash. And we're live welcome back to
- 2:04final settlements, very excited for today's conversation.
- 2:08Today on the show we have Ben Carmen and Tony Giorgio from
- 2:13Mutiny Wallet as mentioned super excited for this conversation.
- 2:17I think you know final settlement as a show, we've
- 2:19really tried to help our audience go beyond sort of
- 2:23Bitcoin as a purely a store of value asset, digital gold thesis
- 2:27and really think about Bitcoin as a piece of technology, as an
- 2:31open source protocol that people are building on top of.
- 2:34And and I genuinely view these two individuals as sort of the
- 2:39tip of the spear in terms of catalyzing bitcoins usage and
- 2:43utility as a medium of exchange as opposed to just purely a
- 2:45store of value. So very excited to have them on
- 2:48the show. Tony and Ben welcome.
- 2:51Appreciate it Good to be here. Yeah, some guys.
- 2:54Good to see you again. Very excited to have you guys on
- 2:58being multiple kind of builders and founders in the space.
- 3:02I think you guys have a very unique lens in what you're
- 3:05building and a lot of kind of, I guess, battle wounds or scars
- 3:10and I think that's healthy as you kind of grow.
- 3:13It's like I picked up on this notion of the first people
- 3:15through the Bitcoin door, probably the people that got
- 3:17shot and it's people behind them that are going to be the the
- 3:19winners or leaders in building the right products.
- 3:21And so it's always bullish when somebody has unique experiences
- 3:25from a different firm or building and they can go out and
- 3:27branch out to build something that new.
- 3:29So excited for the conversation. Yeah, awesome.
- 3:33Maybe just likewise too. Let's dive right in and and
- 3:36maybe it'd be helpful. Just a little bit of sort of
- 3:40brief background on on you know what you guys have contributed
- 3:42to the Bitcoin space prior to to Mutiny and then what brought
- 3:46both of you to to found Mutiny and focus on Bitcoin wallets and
- 3:51Bitcoin payments? Yeah, I can start on my side.
- 3:57I kind of got into Bitcoin and 2017 or so when I like had my
- 4:03first job and 2016 or so and started mining with the GPU, my
- 4:08gaming computer and then just like it didn't take too long to
- 4:11go to all the meet ups and kind of see what was going on.
- 4:13I think it was hearing about lightning at at A at a crypto
- 4:17meet up and then just getting hooked and like you know going
- 4:20Bitcoin only shortly after that. I joined a company called
- 4:23learning Machine where we were doing like digital credentials
- 4:26on top of Bitcoin. We were working with MIT and
- 4:29Malta and the Bahamas and a lot of different, you know,
- 4:31certificates or graduation record kind of places after that
- 4:36that got acquired by Highland in like 2020 or so, like literally
- 4:40February 2020. It was wild times, perfect time
- 4:45for them to get acquired. They did, They timed the market
- 4:47really well. But yeah, shortly after that
- 4:50went to bottle pay to build out their Lightning infrastructure
- 4:52and Bitcoin infrastructure there.
- 4:54It's a, it's an exchange and it was an exchange in the UK very
- 4:58similar to a strike like experience but for Europe.
- 5:02They ended up getting acquired by NYDIG a little few years
- 5:07back. I've done Impervious building
- 5:09out some of their Lightning infrastructure and then kind of
- 5:12did some contracting for a little bit.
- 5:13And that kind of just led me to I was doing contracting for
- 5:16voltage, kind of building out their out new LSP that they were
- 5:20building. And that, you know there was
- 5:21kind of like a fork on the road where we're like, OK, you know,
- 5:24me and my one of our Co founders, Paul, it's me, Paul
- 5:27and Ben. And we kind of just like, hey,
- 5:28should we should we build this mutiny thing?
- 5:31Like, it started out as like a little hackathon project that we
- 5:34kind of we won second place out of like 80 participants.
- 5:38And then we were like, hey, do we want to do this?
- 5:40Do we want to go, you know, fall asleep with this.
- 5:42And yeah, brought Ben on along to help with the hackathon.
- 5:46And we all kind of just said, yeah, let's let's quit our jobs
- 5:48and do this. So we've been to company since
- 5:50April first of last year. So it's only been one year in
- 5:53and it's been a wild ride already.
- 5:55But yeah, that's mostly my history.
- 5:57I'll let let Ben say his as well.
- 6:01Yeah, I mean me and Tony got around in the around the same
- 6:04time. Like I got in the Bitcoin around
- 6:06like 2017 and you know bought the top like everyone else, but
- 6:10then you know bought some shit coins and then found the Bitcoin
- 6:14only life. It took me about like a year and
- 6:17I I got a job at shirt bits. Basically we're working on like
- 6:21a Bitcoin Scala library and doing a lot of research on DLCS
- 6:25and stuff there. And then after that it kind of
- 6:30like you know it's just like drudgery of like research and
- 6:32like you know open source work and wanted to go and like try to
- 6:35like you know make a product for users.
- 6:37So me and Ben Price did the Bitcoin company and I was there
- 6:41for about a year and a half, basically just doing like
- 6:43selling gift cards for Bitcoin over lightning.
- 6:46And that basically got me the other side of where like oh,
- 6:50getting all these users, like, you know, actually like, you
- 6:53know, competing with the market. This is fun.
- 6:55But then in the universe it was like all day I was spending my
- 6:58time just like integrating like Fiat payments and I hated my
- 7:02life. So I feel like Mutiny is kind of
- 7:05the unison of both these companies where I had to do
- 7:08like, you know, the fun open source hard Bitcoin stuff while
- 7:10also like trying to get users and like you know, solve real
- 7:14world problems. So yeah, we've just been out
- 7:17grinding for the last year on this now and you know, starting
- 7:20to hit some real headway. So it's been a lot of fun.
- 7:24You need to think about that aspect.
- 7:25There is something very powerful about not having to deal with
- 7:29the Fiat world. Like I know Tony you brought
- 7:31this idea notion of you know non custodials very beneficial from
- 7:35a regulatory perspective and you know the idea of not having you
- 7:39know a lot of real control and being able to effect control.
- 7:42But then the other idea of not having to touch dollars is
- 7:45important right from a just pure like game theory and self
- 7:49preservation perspective. You can provide tools that are
- 7:51independent of any system and just it's a it's very empowering
- 7:54and I didn't think about like you guys have kind of like
- 7:56structure that way with the web wallet or you know the app
- 8:01obviously exists within Apple's framework but doesn't have to be
- 8:04if you don't need it. Yeah, we both had experience
- 8:07touching Fiat from our last jobs.
- 8:10I also had to do some of the, I did all integrations have auto
- 8:13pay. So Bitcoin, Lightning and all
- 8:15the Fiat rails, SEPA and their other one that they have over
- 8:18there in Europe. And that was yeah, the Bitcoin
- 8:21part would like took a month of the lightning part like took a
- 8:24month and then you know it took like a year probably you know
- 8:27six months to a year to really flesh out all the edge cases in
- 8:30the Fiat system. And I know Ben probably has the
- 8:32same experience dealing with like Visa cards and and all of
- 8:35that. So yeah, it's it's just so much
- 8:37simpler building on Bitcoin. And so it's like kind of a a
- 8:40Bitcoin developer's dream. And honestly from a company
- 8:43perspective like we don't have to do all them a speed
- 8:46paperwork, we don't have to get MTL, so we don't have to do any
- 8:48of those things. Like you said, you know our
- 8:51primary focus is being more focused on the, you know, not
- 8:54custodial or even Federated and we can get into federates too in
- 8:58a little bit. But just this whole idea like
- 9:00you said where we don't have unilateral control, we're
- 9:02shipping software. It is everything, you know, most
- 9:06all the key, all the keys and all that you know, Bitcoin
- 9:09payments, all that happens on the user's device.
- 9:11So like that's very important from from both regulatory and
- 9:14also from a privacy perspective for the user as well.
- 9:19Yeah, Maybe I think it'd be helpful.
- 9:21Sorry, sorry. It might be helpful to just take
- 9:23a bit of a step back and and talk a bit about sort of the
- 9:26state of Lightning today. Both of you have worked
- 9:28intimately with Lightning over the past several years.
- 9:30And I'm curious if you could just describe sort of at a high
- 9:34level what some of the limitations of Lightning are and
- 9:37and why that has effectively driven much of Lightning usage
- 9:41to be custodial and why you know really what you know the 2nd
- 9:46order of that is you know your vision for mutiny and focusing
- 9:50on on self custody and and non custodial solutions, why that's
- 9:54important to sort of the long term trajectory of Bitcoin one.
- 9:57And then also just you know from a user perspective why that
- 10:00might be a a more optimal solution than just trusting a
- 10:03few centralized providers. Yeah, but you can take that.
- 10:09You've been talking and writing about limitations for a while.
- 10:12Yeah, I mean, so and there's like 2 limitations.
- 10:15One is just like straight up like the UX of, you know, if I
- 10:18want to tell my mom like what a lightning channel is and what
- 10:21HTLCS are and like all these words, she's just like no thanks
- 10:25and won't use it. So like that this first upfront,
- 10:29like you know, knowledge, cost of like figuring out like
- 10:31liquidity and stuff makes Lightning really hard for a lot
- 10:34of people. And you know a lot of apps like,
- 10:36you know Phoenix and you know we've tried to do this in mutiny
- 10:39as well as like kind of distract away all of that Channel
- 10:42management stuff. But the problem is when you do
- 10:44that, you kind of like the fees become a little high because
- 10:47you're just like opening channels on chain and doing this
- 10:49stuff. And this comes in kind of the
- 10:51other limitation is like lighting doesn't scale to 8
- 10:54billion users. Self custodial at least.
- 10:56Like you know, there's only so much room in the blockchain to
- 11:00create channels. And then you know when fees get
- 11:03to a certain level, channels need to be like a certain size
- 11:06to make like economically feasible.
- 11:08Like I think like today this transaction like fee rates on in
- 11:12the mump or like 300 SaaS per V byte, it's like OK, so like any
- 11:16channel under like $1000 might not be really viable for alias
- 11:21opening today. You know, maybe fees will go
- 11:22down and you know you just hopefully had your channels open
- 11:26already. But like you know having that
- 11:28like variable cost makes it really hard to like economically
- 11:30calculate when to do it. And you know if we expect
- 11:33Bitcoin to go to, you know, 8 billion users in the future,
- 11:37pricing to be, you know, $100 million.
- 11:39Well on chain fees are not going to be $3 like they're going to
- 11:42be a lot higher. So you know, we're not going to
- 11:46have everyone onboarding into on chain, light onto like on chain
- 11:48and then thus lightning because that just doesn't scale.
- 11:51So and that's why we're seeing, that's why we kind of see like a
- 11:55lot of custodial solutions take off because they don't have,
- 11:58they can extract away all that you know, hard channel
- 12:00management stuff And then all this fee stuff that we're
- 12:02talking about of like scaling and stuff, it's like kind of
- 12:05just gone because you just have one lightning note that serves
- 12:09you know 10,000 users, 100,000 users and you know so now
- 12:13instead of having one on chain transaction per user, it's you
- 12:17know 100 thousandth of a transaction per user.
- 12:20So it's way cheaper and then you can use to amortize that across
- 12:24transaction fees and stuff. So it makes it a lot easier to
- 12:26do. But you know it does you know
- 12:29breakdown bitcoins you know whole thesis of like self
- 12:32estodial privacy, all this stuff.
- 12:35But you know, thankfully things like E Cash is kind of breaking
- 12:38this model where we can have like a lot of those privacy
- 12:42stuff still valid in SO solutions and you can kind of
- 12:45make the trust assumptions better with like Fetty Mins.
- 12:49I think one important things that that's important to you
- 12:52know me, Ben and and Paul and a lot of bit corners too is that
- 12:56Bitcoin is used as a currency. Like I have no doubt like yeah
- 13:00Bitcoin is a great you know medium, sorry, store value you
- 13:06know the digital go perhaps you know that's why you know we all
- 13:09stay in right. But I think it's important to us
- 13:11that we, you know, keep the original vision of Bitcoin as
- 13:15being used as a currency. And you know, if it's not just,
- 13:18if it's not being used as a currency, then its usefulness is
- 13:21just to collect and then sit there and then never touch it
- 13:24and never use it. I think, I think there's a lot
- 13:27of important pillars in, you know, Bitcoin usage across the
- 13:30industry. You know, I have Bitcoin that's
- 13:33like locked up in multi sig. I have Bitcoin that's like on a
- 13:35single hardware wall and I have Bitcoin that's on my munity
- 13:38wallet and across all the walls that I test.
- 13:41And so like there's definitely a purpose for, for your net worth,
- 13:45right. And and a portion of that should
- 13:47be used for currency, as a currency and for payments
- 13:51itself. And one of the you know, as as
- 13:54we talk about custodians one of the things that we're trying to
- 13:57get away from over the last, you know decade or two really is
- 14:00just this idea that you know PayPal and Venmo and cash app
- 14:04they can shut down your account at will.
- 14:06You know and and some people are using them for just you know
- 14:09transactions or paying their merchant or or you know paying a
- 14:12tattoo artist or a haircut you know salon person.
- 14:15Like all these things that we're using payments for in the daily
- 14:19basis like people are using those accounts and then those
- 14:21are getting shut down with with almost no no support or customer
- 14:25support that you get. It's like no questions asked.
- 14:28It's just like OK something went internally wrong with that
- 14:31account. We flagged it and then now
- 14:32you're all of a sudden banned even though there's nothing even
- 14:36illegal about what you're doing. It's just these policies and
- 14:39regulations and and you know all the things that that financial
- 14:44institutions kind of like, you know have have started adopting
- 14:47and pushing for. So it's it's one of those things
- 14:50that if we're going back and we're using Bitcoin again as
- 14:54payments but we're only going through custodians, we're only
- 14:57going through and you know I'm not throwing any shit at any
- 14:59particular ones. I love Strike, but if we're only
- 15:01using Strike, which is just say you know Fenmo on top of
- 15:04Bitcoin, then they can shut down anyone's account at will and and
- 15:07take their funds and and stop the payments from even going
- 15:11through at all. So I want to just get back to
- 15:13the world of like OK, can we build something that can mimic
- 15:17these apps like Venmo, PayPal, Strike you know, River.
- 15:21But on the Bitcoin side for digital payments because the
- 15:24digital payments, you know, market is very high.
- 15:27And if it is just going through like OK you have to sign up and
- 15:30you have to KYC yourself and upload a 3D image of your face
- 15:33and and your ID in order to participate in Bitcoin like than
- 15:37that even we've lost the plot along the way.
- 15:40I think it's important that we can go to these financial
- 15:43institutions to swap you know digital like digital dollars or
- 15:47or something or a digital Fiat in any way for for Bitcoin.
- 15:51But we still need to be able to participate in this Bitcoin, you
- 15:55know, currency market without being stopped or censored.
- 16:00Yeah, I think there's a lot of things you guys touched on are
- 16:03important there. I think like this whole notion,
- 16:06it needs to be said out loud about whether it's self custody
- 16:09or lightning channels. Just the the idea that it does
- 16:11not scale to the amount of people.
- 16:12If everybody's going to participate in the future state
- 16:15global economy settling back to Bitcoin and then recognizing if
- 16:19that's to be true, then not bitching about it but then
- 16:22figuring out well how do you actually get it done within the
- 16:24the the the design space that exists.
- 16:27And you actually hit the nail on the head Tony.
- 16:29And something like we talk about a little bit you called out
- 16:32strike but just in the in the sense of like it.
- 16:36I think it's just a proxy for because we've been so early that
- 16:39the existing firms for the past 15 years look exact exactly like
- 16:43the old whether it's Wall Street or traditional finance firms.
- 16:47Like you took Bitcoin and then you just like you have a soccer
- 16:50bond and you just custody at Coinbase or you create a
- 16:52brokerage just like you buy a sock or anything and then you
- 16:55just like park it at strike. And it's like a 2D version of a
- 16:58world where this asset is 3D. And so this is how I think about
- 17:02like multi institution isn't dynamic of like no single entity
- 17:05holds it or similar to what you guys are talking about whether
- 17:08it's through mutiny and not having to do all this or the E
- 17:10cash dynamic. It's like almost even lightning
- 17:12channels or a derivative of like a payment, a payment rail like a
- 17:15Visa or MasterCard and you can get shut off, but then when you
- 17:18throw an E cash that kind of like throws it for a loop and
- 17:21now starts to use the asset in a 3D way.
- 17:24And I think this like next 15 years we're going to just see
- 17:26more and more of this for the 1st 15 years we're just like the
- 17:29the extensions of the old Fiat world and it got us to where
- 17:32we're at. But now as we need to scale and
- 17:34build trustless or trust minimized versions, this is like
- 17:36you can start to squint and see how it plays out.
- 17:41Yeah, No, I I 100% agree. I mean there is a lot to be said
- 17:44where take existing business. I mean, I think we all kind of
- 17:47agree like take existing businesses that exist in the
- 17:49Fiat world and let's you know make the Bitcoin version of
- 17:52that. There's a lot of value in that.
- 17:54But but like you said, like we don't have to limit ourselves to
- 17:57just those kind of institutions and we can kind of you know,
- 18:00grow bigger ones that like aren't confined to the same
- 18:02constraints just because of those facts.
- 18:05And yeah, like you said, like E Cash can kind of like play in
- 18:08this kind of realm where you know, it could do both things.
- 18:13It can do. You can have this E cash bare
- 18:15asset basically and you can do lightning payments with it.
- 18:18You can do on chain payments with it.
- 18:20You kind of you know the way we're kind of thinking about it
- 18:23with with 20 minutes we have this Federated Ed cash where not
- 18:25a single custodian takes control of it.
- 18:28You have it distributed across multiple key holders and so not
- 18:32a single key holder can stop your transactions or get in the
- 18:35way of it. It's like a majority, you know,
- 18:37it's like a majority multi sig and so you can kind of do these
- 18:41things where it's like you know you have gateways that are
- 18:43attached to these federations and you can do payments across
- 18:47different currency types like Lightning.
- 18:48You know, if there's another Bitcoin layer too, and you know,
- 18:51we we can talk about as well like alternatives to Lightning.
- 18:54But, you know, if there's another layer two like Arc or,
- 18:57you know, I feel like there's like a new layer 2 on Bitcoin
- 19:00popping up every day. Like whatever one comes on
- 19:02board. If you can have an E cash token
- 19:04that represents, you know, if you have one sat of an E cash
- 19:08token, if you can have one sat of Bitcoin, right.
- 19:10And you can send it across to any layer that you want, just
- 19:13kind of going through these service providers that their
- 19:15whole functionality is just to swap E cash for whatever native
- 19:19currency, whatever digital currency you're trying to
- 19:22transact with. So from a from like a layer
- 19:25perspective, you know Feniment kind of like Feniment and
- 19:28Lightning too kind of are the glue to the financial
- 19:32transactions on top of Bitcoin that you can, that you can
- 19:35partake in. And maybe just drilling down a
- 19:38bit more on that, like can you elaborate on what Feniment and
- 19:43you know different E Cash solutions solve for in terms of
- 19:48those limitations that we are referring to with Lightning
- 19:51earlier? So whether it's the channel
- 19:53liquidity or you know offline receives like what can these
- 19:59other interoperable protocols offer when you're sort of
- 20:02combining them as you mentioned, what can they offer in terms of
- 20:06solving for some of those hurdles that exist today?
- 20:10Yeah, in my opinion it's it's less that self custody is hard,
- 20:16that there's there's a certain threshold, right, Like if you're
- 20:18trying to secure a ton of money versus you're trying to secure a
- 20:21little bit amount of money, you know you can get into different
- 20:23degrees. But you know, the degree we're
- 20:25talking about here is like, you know, we're trying to create a
- 20:28Bitcoin spending law. And so we're talking about like
- 20:30whatever you carry around in your cash, maybe it's a few 100
- 20:32bucks worth of Bitcoin at a time that you're walking around with
- 20:35quote UN quote. So it's not that custody is
- 20:37hard. It's not that writing down 12
- 20:39words and keeping them mostly secure, you know, maybe, you
- 20:43know, maybe you're just writing them down on a piece of paper.
- 20:45It doesn't make sense to get a steel plate, you know, and etch
- 20:4812 words on it if you're just talking about like a few 100
- 20:51bucks, like that steel plate might be worth more than that.
- 20:55So it's not that self custody at this scale is hard or difficult
- 20:59that people can't or people aren't capable of comprehending
- 21:02to write down 12 words. It's it's mostly about you know,
- 21:06opening up payment channels to end users.
- 21:09It's the liquidity involved in that from both an operation
- 21:12perspective and the user perspective.
- 21:13There's you know when when you open up a payment channel with a
- 21:16user, there's all of these hurdles that get in the way.
- 21:20It's like OK, well that payment channel has to close at a
- 21:22certain point, right, to be able to so both parties can get their
- 21:26funds on chain eventually. And so there's like channel
- 21:29reserves that get in the way if channel fees spike up really
- 21:32high like they have been. You know we had some users with
- 21:35lighting channels that like the fees would have eat eaten the
- 21:39entire capacity of the channel. So they couldn't send or receive
- 21:43because if they did so the potential to incur an on chain
- 21:47transaction from the result of a forced closure would have taken
- 21:51up the entirety of the channel. They would have no money left if
- 21:54they closed the channel at those fee rates.
- 21:56So you know when you talk about like you know if you open up a
- 21:59channel in low fee environments and all of a sudden spikes up
- 22:01really high, now you can't use your channel and it's like
- 22:04what's the point? And then also the onboarding,
- 22:06onboarding perspective. If if to use lightning, you have
- 22:10to invest at least 50 to $100 worth of Bitcoin to open a
- 22:15channel to yourself for the LSP to open a channel to you, you're
- 22:19talking about like making users pay 50 to 100 bucks to use your
- 22:23app before they even know what it is or how to use it or
- 22:26anything like that. Like the cost of user
- 22:28acquisition is really high from the from the user's perspective.
- 22:31And when you get, when you're competing with apps like Venmo
- 22:34or Strike or or or cash app or some of these other payment apps
- 22:38where they you know, kind of say like hey get 5 free dollars to
- 22:41start up. You know, we, you know we're not
- 22:43a multi billion dollar institution.
- 22:44We can't, we can't give out $5 Willy nilly for one.
- 22:48But for two it's the opposite. You need to, you need to give,
- 22:53you need to have 50 to 100 bucks a Bitcoin to even get started
- 22:56with this wallet. And so like you know when we're
- 22:58talking about things that like Fettyman can kind of solve this
- 23:00or you, you know, you have some liquidity provider do the swaps
- 23:04between you know in and out of lightning and the federation you
- 23:07choose and you just hold E cash. In the end when you get enough E
- 23:11cash and you have enough Bitcoin to open a channel, you can do
- 23:15that. But until then you know it's not
- 23:18it's not reasonable to open a channel to you.
- 23:20So then you can't use the app. So Fedement kind of solves that
- 23:22for us where you can get, you can get started with like a
- 23:25single SAT in Mutiny wallet right now by adding a federation
- 23:29and it creates a lightning invoice in the end.
- 23:31So it's not this, I know there's, you know, a lot of
- 23:34distinction between like Feni Man and lightning and Liquid and
- 23:37all of these, but what comes together in the end is, is it
- 23:41all goes over lightning. And so the fact that I can show
- 23:45this, I can show my Mutiny wallet with the federation
- 23:47added. I can show that invoice to, you
- 23:51know, someone that's using Aqua, which is using Liquid to do a
- 23:55similar, you know, federation thing.
- 23:57Behind the scenes. They're both interoperable
- 24:00because they go through lightning and it's just like
- 24:02this, you know, on the Fettima side, it's just this E Cash
- 24:05layer that does it. On the Liquid side, you know,
- 24:07they have another federation that doesn't use E cash.
- 24:09It uses like a Bitcoin based blockchain to do it.
- 24:11But it's the same concept. It's like using alternative
- 24:13layers to do these swaps because it's just unfeasible to do these
- 24:17swaps or you know, or small transactions on top of Bitcoin
- 24:21today. Yeah, I think something
- 24:24important to highlight is like before Fettyman, like the kind
- 24:27of default flow of people to do with something like Wallace
- 24:31Atosi where it's just like fully custodial wallet and like the
- 24:35there is no like E Cash. It's just like a database that
- 24:38these people that we don't know are running and like it worked.
- 24:42It's it's almost the exact same experience as like a federation.
- 24:46But the problem is it's a single signer that can rug pull
- 24:49everyone and there's absolutely no privacy and Fettyman is
- 24:52basically like the exact same experience but perfect privacy
- 24:56as well as it's a federation. So you have like you know a
- 25:00three or four multi sig instead of a single person that can rug
- 25:02pull you. So it makes that trust trade off
- 25:04like a million times better. And you know, it's kind of
- 25:08solves that. Like, you know, it goes back to
- 25:09the Bitcoin ethos of like we're now we're we're doing this
- 25:12Walter to Toshi, but the right way kind of thing Instead of
- 25:14like, you know, just getting it to work now we're doing it with
- 25:17strong principles that, you know, we can actually like
- 25:20confidently launched without, you know, like risking users to
- 25:23launch as well as it makes us like regulatory way easier.
- 25:25Like while Satoshi shut down in America and it's like, you know,
- 25:29federations won't be shut down in America because they're not
- 25:31custodial. You know, a single user or
- 25:34single guardian, the federation doesn't have custody of funds
- 25:37the same way, like Liquid has been running for six years.
- 25:39They're not being targeted by the government because, you
- 25:43know, they don't have custody of the funds.
- 25:44If if you go after a single person, they can't steal the
- 25:47money. So it makes it like that much
- 25:49easier. Yeah, I think this is all like
- 25:52really important landscape, you know our audience not to
- 25:55generalize, but I think is on the, not on the most technical
- 25:59side. And so like explaining the
- 26:02existing landscape with like custodial offerings, how you
- 26:04reference you know the wall of Satoshi had a user experience,
- 26:08but then it leaves you with this thing that it works until it
- 26:11doesn't. Similarly with like a single
- 26:13custodian holding your assets, it's good until it's FTX and you
- 26:16don't know what the next FTX block by and So what you guys
- 26:20like using the design space. I think super savvy.
- 26:23And you guys talked a little about with Matt about like
- 26:26looking at well what worked in the existing world like PayPal,
- 26:29famous for the 1010 model. And you guys had the opposite
- 26:32problem. It's like I want people to use
- 26:34this and we got to get virality, but they need to pay us to
- 26:36start. That's like fucking crazy.
- 26:38So then how do we actually do this?
- 26:40And it's like this idea of counter position.
- 26:41It's like you guys are startups, So what do you do in your
- 26:43startup? You have to use the leverage of
- 26:45it's like thinking about innovation.
- 26:47And E cash is a great example. If it's interoperable, it's not
- 26:49something that like somebody that's been backed with a lot of
- 26:51money is going to go do because they just aren't incentivized to
- 26:54do it. But it's actually a better
- 26:55experience across the board. And you can let people start to
- 26:58play in this economy and then they can start to figure out,
- 27:01you know, learn more and there's probably digital native apps
- 27:03that will be coming in different ways.
- 27:05That technology will start to adopt E cash that will just like
- 27:08further kind of mutinies like you know, adoption in itself.
- 27:12And so I just thought it was very like elegant of the way
- 27:15that anybody like you said once SAT to whatever they want to
- 27:17come in and they can leave as quickly as they can come in.
- 27:20And then you don't have to deal from a company perspective of
- 27:23all that like regulatory burden of like having to give the user
- 27:26experience in a seamless way, but also have to manage like you
- 27:29know, millions of dollars for MTLS and compliance and all
- 27:32those things if you're going to manage all those channels.
- 27:35Yeah, One thing that's interesting there you brought up
- 27:38is the idea that, you know, the existing players aren't going to
- 27:42switch their entire infrastructure to do something
- 27:44like, you know, Federated E Cash.
- 27:46And I think that's interesting because I mean you're exactly
- 27:48right. Like if someone existing has
- 27:52already got their MTLS and you know, I'm just going to say
- 27:55general exchange and exchange would greatly benefit from
- 27:58switching to something like Federated E Cash, especially if
- 28:01it's a Bitcoin only exchange anyways.
- 28:02And you know there's a few out there, but they've already got
- 28:05their MTLS, they've already got, you know, they're already
- 28:07operating as a money service business.
- 28:09They're already doing all the compliance thing.
- 28:11They have a whole compliance team.
- 28:12They have everything already there.
- 28:14I mean they would still benefit from the, the users would still
- 28:18benefit from the privacy gains if they switch to something like
- 28:20Federated E Cash and their users would still benefit.
- 28:24I mean I think that's, I think that's the biggest one.
- 28:26This is the privacy gains for the users and then yeah, no
- 28:29account login tracking or anything like that.
- 28:31It's just like the seed words that the user controls that
- 28:34back, you know, that secures the E cash behind that federation.
- 28:38So they're they're not, they're not going to switch their entire
- 28:43infrastructure to go to something like Federated E Cash
- 28:46just so the user has better privacy.
- 28:49You know, most when you ask general users, I mean we started
- 28:52out very, very privacy focused and and that's still ingrained
- 28:57into our ideals and our tech. But when you ask people if they
- 29:01care about privacy though, maybe they'll say yes, but nine times
- 29:05out of 10, like they don't care. So from that perspective it's
- 29:10like no one is going to, no one's going to change their
- 29:12whole infrastructure, switch to Federated cash just to provide
- 29:15something to the user that the users aren't asking for.
- 29:18So that's another model where it's like you know we can kind
- 29:20of come in and as as as a brand new startup with you know with
- 29:25just a dev team of three and no money for MTLS or you know you
- 29:31know any of the any of those regulations because we don't,
- 29:34you know, we don't have to anyways.
- 29:35And then also on top of that, you know there's there's with
- 29:38the Fedement movement, you know Fede has done a great job of of
- 29:41Spearing up a lot of adoption for Fedeiment across the world.
- 29:46You know, their whole, their whole pitch is like, you know,
- 29:48this is Federated custody for communities.
- 29:51So they're going boots on the ground trying to get fetamine
- 29:53adoption, trying to get more fetamine spun up that benefits
- 29:56us as well. So, you know, we're not even,
- 29:59you know, we're not even operating in this area where
- 30:01like oh, OK, it's it's technically legally, you know,
- 30:04not custodial because the, you know, one of the members is not
- 30:07considered a custodian. It's like we're not running the
- 30:08myth at all. So, you know, we're in this
- 30:11operation, we're in this perspective that we can
- 30:14interoperate with this open, you know, quasi custodial, Federated
- 30:21E Cash, you know, open source software without even having to
- 30:24touch it at all. We just interface it with it
- 30:26directly. It's it's like if if Wallace
- 30:28Satoshi had built up their exchange to be like, you know, a
- 30:31specific API and they got every other custodian to implement the
- 30:35same APIs. It's the same way to interface
- 30:37with it. You know, it's the same thing
- 30:38with the Fedi minutes, like it's this way to do Federated
- 30:41custody. It's got the same APIs.
- 30:43Anyone can plug and play a wallet into any federation that
- 30:47exists without having to do an additional work.
- 30:49So one of the things that we've sort of done, one of the
- 30:53problems when we launched some of the fedement integrations is
- 30:55people were asking us like hey, where do I find a federation?
- 30:58Can you can you put one in the app so we can we can find out
- 31:02how to, how to, how to find a federation, how to join a
- 31:05federation, things like that. We built something along with a
- 31:10few players in the whole NOSTR ecosystem to discover
- 31:14federations and to kind of have this web of trust model of you
- 31:18know if if I join a federation and I like it, I I can recommend
- 31:22it and people that you know follow me on roster or follow me
- 31:25and mute you all. It's it's kind of this open
- 31:27source social media software. If they follow me in that way
- 31:32and they see which meant meant, I recommend which meant I use,
- 31:36you know, they might be able to discover that meant and use it
- 31:38and trust it as well. So it's just kind of like a way
- 31:41to signal like you know, almost like a rating system for banks
- 31:45like I use this, it's good and kind of have you know, the open
- 31:49market kind of figure out, you know, which banks are good
- 31:53basically. Yeah, that's a, it's a really
- 31:58fascinating point that you know we've talked with Max Webster in
- 32:02the past around these sort of webs of trust or or market
- 32:06ranking types of systems. I think it's a super interesting
- 32:11and unique way to actually get better outcomes for users and
- 32:16individuals that are, you know, whether it's deciding which
- 32:19federation to use or which LSP to use like having actual, you
- 32:24know, market forces be able to ascribe value to you know,
- 32:29better options out there. I think is a super fascinating
- 32:33way that that these open protocols actually unlock as a
- 32:35possibility. And one thing I want to just go
- 32:40back to was around, you know, the the idea of fetamines.
- 32:45You know when I first heard about fetamines I guess almost
- 32:48two years you know a little over two years ago now, it really it
- 32:53it excited me in the sense that and and correct me if I'm wrong,
- 32:57but I think you know in some sense fetamines present the
- 33:01opportunity to better scale Bitcoin without potential soft
- 33:06forks at least in the interim. And I'm I'm curious you know
- 33:10what your thoughts around effectively you know do you view
- 33:13fediments and things like E Cash as sort of ways to get better
- 33:18scalability you know reach those billions of people using
- 33:21lightning sort of in the absence of soft forks or do you think
- 33:25you know ultimately some some amount of soft forks will be
- 33:27necessary for the usability of Lightning to really flourish?
- 33:31Just sort of trying to determine like what can we build with what
- 33:35exists today versus you know where are the stop gaps in terms
- 33:39of like actual Softworks that might be necessary in the
- 33:43future? And I wouldn't say that vitamins
- 33:47are scaling Bitcoin the same way.
- 33:49Like Coinbase doesn't scale Bitcoin because you can send
- 33:51transactions internally. Like at the end of the day, it's
- 33:54like an alternate kind of thing that you know you're no longer
- 33:57using Bitcoin or using E Cash now.
- 34:00But I do agree that the general idea is the same, though, of
- 34:04like, you know, without, you know, like, like we were saying
- 34:07earlier, lightning does not scale to 8 billion users.
- 34:09So, OK, then what do we do to get Bitcoin and everyone on
- 34:12Bitcoin, like, right now? Yeah, if we got zero soft forks
- 34:15ever, it's basically like fighting mints is kind of the
- 34:18idealized way to get people using, you know, the closest
- 34:21approximation to Bitcoin of, you know, you know, technically
- 34:25there could be inflation inside of a fighting mint, but the
- 34:28incentives are best modeled where it won't likely happen.
- 34:31And if it does, that vitamin will end up like, you know, just
- 34:34getting a bank run and shut it down because of that, at least
- 34:37somewhere like FTX did versus like if we didn't do vitamins,
- 34:41we did something like, you know, a bunch of coin bases.
- 34:43Well now you know those coin bases are going to turn into
- 34:45FTXS and you know, blow up. So I think vitamins are like,
- 34:50you know, if we get absolutely no soft forks, vitamins are
- 34:52probably the ideal ways way to like, you know, get the most
- 34:55like Bitcoin, like payments happening in the world.
- 34:58But you know, even if we did get like every soft work we'd ever
- 35:01want under the sun to like enable all the scaling, it still
- 35:04might not even like actually end up scaling Bitcoin to 8 billion
- 35:08users. Like you know Bitcoin is hyper
- 35:11optimized for verifiability and like you know slow moving
- 35:16transactions that you know happen at the fine intervals.
- 35:20So we can actually predict the system and being able to like
- 35:24skill that the 8 billion users is like kind of like an
- 35:27impossible dream And you know maybe we can get it closer and
- 35:31closer. You know instead of having only
- 35:331,000,000 users to be self sovereign, we could have you
- 35:36know 100 million like that's a lot better but that's still you
- 35:41know not 8 billion. So you know getting that I think
- 35:44you know I in my opinion I would I would like to see software so
- 35:47we can you know raise that barrier and get more and more
- 35:50people able to like end up being those like self sovereign
- 35:54people. But you know getting all 8
- 35:56billion people on earth to be self sovereign I think is
- 35:59probably an unachievable goal on Bitcoin.
- 36:01But fighting mints is like lets you get to that closest
- 36:04approximation where like you know we're not going to hit this
- 36:06idealize you know every single person has you know their multi
- 36:10sig on chain like that's just never going to happen.
- 36:12So for not doing that, fighting mints are probably the best
- 36:15alternative where we can have, you know, people with extremely
- 36:18private payments that are, you know, in this Federated custody.
- 36:22So it's hard to rug pull, hard to inflate all this stuff.
- 36:24And you know, without that, and you know, it'd be a lot harder.
- 36:29Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 36:31exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 36:34about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 36:37allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 36:41We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 36:44I. Think I think it's also worth
- 36:46just calling out. Then I'll be the guy like we can
- 36:49debate or or just like it's worth throwing out.
- 36:52I think the framing and this whole idea we talked about it on
- 36:55the last trade Marty about like fed speak when people talk about
- 36:58inflation and all these fucked up like terms that just aren't
- 37:01true as I feel like that's how almost like talking about self
- 37:04sovereignty for 8 million people and everybody needs to hold
- 37:06their keys I think is absolute bullshit and just not like based
- 37:10in reality because it's ultimately A bearish take on
- 37:12like society in general. That means that we can't trust
- 37:15anybody which historically that that doesn't make any sense if
- 37:18we're going to like flourish and grow.
- 37:20And so everybody that comes into space generally you know doesn't
- 37:24sit and look at these problems for very long.
- 37:25So they take it at face value and they're like oh this doesn't
- 37:28look at like look like what I thought Bitcoin was going to
- 37:30scale it look like versus just like looking at this notion of
- 37:33trust, minimize and you have the version that's the base lever
- 37:36layer of 12 seed words and you can always take delivery and
- 37:39then you build on top of that and you hold people accountable
- 37:41and if they fuck up then you basically don't trust them and
- 37:44they rug themselves. And so we grow a a version of
- 37:47the world in that way And like it's just like when you're
- 37:50building and you're actually in the reading, you're like, Oh
- 37:52yeah, this is actually how it has to work.
- 37:53Because if I don't, I get to like take the ball.
- 37:55I go home with no money and and shame because I was an idiot and
- 37:58didn't realize that I had to look past like like ideologies
- 38:02and you just have to build what the market will, will take.
- 38:05So anyway, I just think it's important because I think most
- 38:06people thinking like everybody has to hold their own keys and
- 38:08stuff like it's just like it doesn't make sense from like
- 38:10even coordination of economic activity if everybody's have to
- 38:13go in a cave to go figure out how to spend their money.
- 38:16I don't think it's been well, well thought through.
- 38:20Yeah, I mean that's that's definitely something we've
- 38:22internalized at on ramp and and spoken a lot about in terms of
- 38:27you know you do want to live in a world where you can still
- 38:29trust institutions. And you know there's some
- 38:31interesting sort of analogues and similarities between what
- 38:36fetamine provides and what we're doing with multi institution
- 38:39custody in the sense that the user isn't holding any keys, but
- 38:43those keys are distributed to various holders who don't have
- 38:47unilateral control. And that and that becomes the
- 38:49key element that allows you to minimize trust to to the
- 38:54greatest extent possible and makes it an order of magnitude
- 38:58greater than just trusting a single counterparty.
- 39:00And so there's some interesting similarities there in terms of
- 39:03of what can be built with fetamine.
- 39:05And I think you know that's something that we're going to be
- 39:07thinking critically about going forward is you know this is is
- 39:11sort of mapping to the institutional landscape of, OK,
- 39:14you still want to be able to trust institutions, but you
- 39:17don't want to give them enough power to rug you.
- 39:20You want to give them enough power where they actually have
- 39:22to prove themselves in their worth over time.
- 39:25And if if they don't uphold that level of trust, then they're out
- 39:29of the quorum effectively. Well another thing I think it's
- 39:32worth, I was going to just add one thing because I'm curious to
- 39:36get your guys to take because I know you have stuff to add on.
- 39:39This is like I think they even term institution right from like
- 39:42the Bitcoin lens is like you know this like fucked up
- 39:45conglomerate, right. It's just made-up of people and
- 39:47incentives and it's like something that I hadn't had a
- 39:51chance to talk with Justin about on the Fetty side is I'm curious
- 39:55how they're thinking and you guys are thinking about like
- 39:57scale of mints to the point where I think it was you talking
- 40:01about a Tony about like. Putting like a termination or
- 40:06whatever the term is of like so then you know you can
- 40:08consistently move to another one.
- 40:09It's like that doesn't seem like the most scalable or like user
- 40:12friendly approach versus imagine if the holders are people that
- 40:16are held accountable by the proxy of their business.
- 40:19They have a window that you can call like it's not all
- 40:22anonymous, it's basically entities that have to be all
- 40:25accountable and if they don't their business goes under.
- 40:27So the game theory requires them to facilitate doing what they
- 40:30said they're going to do. And then my proxy of that you
- 40:32would get larger amounts of capital, larger amounts of
- 40:35revenue. Because it just feels like a
- 40:36natural thing. And it's why I've been very
- 40:39captivated on what you guys and FETTI means coming.
- 40:41Because it feels like there's just going to be this natural
- 40:42intersection between like trust of entities holding keys coupled
- 40:46with the skill layer that is bound to like Intersect or like
- 40:50Integrated at some point. The the cool thing is that we it
- 40:55it almost feels like you know I know Unchained was like you know
- 41:00they were they were really early you know years ago pushing multi
- 41:03sig especially you know then institutional perspective and
- 41:08you know we're trying to we're almost kind of get into that
- 41:10middle ground where we're seeing this experimentation between
- 41:14alternative forms of multi sig. You know I I think there's going
- 41:18to be some federations that operate anonymously.
- 41:22I think there's going to be federations that operate you
- 41:24know just for their local community.
- 41:26I think there's going to be federations for digital
- 41:28community as well where you just know someone based on their
- 41:32reputation online and then there's and then there's the
- 41:35multi institution based federations and and you know
- 41:38think you know on ramp fits in there as well where you kind of
- 41:40see you know 100% agree like you don't want to have to trust a
- 41:43single federation or sorry a single custodian.
- 41:47But if you get into this especially if it's a single
- 41:50institution custodian, right, like you know you get in the
- 41:52whole FTX scenario but you know imagine if it was something like
- 41:58you know your Coinbase is basically custody and every ETF
- 42:00that exists right. You know that's that's a big
- 42:02problem. I'm surprised every single ETF
- 42:05folder is, is, is OK with that. But you get into, you can get
- 42:10into a scenario where it's like, Oh, well, it's like it's the top
- 42:1310, you know, biggest companies in the United States.
- 42:16Like they're, you know, competing with each other and on
- 42:19one hand so, but, you know, on another hand, they're just, you
- 42:23know, they're also providing the reputation to provide a service
- 42:26for their users, right. Like imagine if Starbucks and
- 42:29Coca-Cola started a federation together with a bunch of other
- 42:32companies like, you know, Starbucks is doing it to the
- 42:34benefit of their, their customers and their consumers.
- 42:37But they also don't want that liability and they don't want
- 42:40that negative perception that they could just completely rug
- 42:43all the users, right. Like they're, they have other
- 42:45institutions keeping them accountable just like they are
- 42:49to the other institutions. So it kind of, you know this,
- 42:51it's almost like, you know, a tug of war in a way where OK, we
- 42:55we can't do anything because we're all as stalemate here.
- 42:58But we all win, win. It's almost a win win scenario
- 43:01for the institutions that could be in competition to each other
- 43:04to some degree and then also the consumers that now don't have to
- 43:09trust a single entity they get to.
- 43:12You know, it'd be it'd be a complete suicide mission if like
- 43:15the top ten companies in the United States all decided, OK,
- 43:18we're going to, we're going to rug all of our users all at the
- 43:21same time. Like that would be like a
- 43:23disaster story of a lifetime. I mean, it could happen.
- 43:26Anything can happen in this world, but it's just like you're
- 43:30not going to see billions and billions of dollars, trillions
- 43:35even just thrown away in the blink of an eye just for like a
- 43:39short monetary gain. So yeah, it's it's interesting
- 43:43to see. I do think there's going to be
- 43:45the multiple layers that we, we get to now experiment with.
- 43:49You know, I'm even excited for like the Anonymous and like
- 43:52digital community, one where you know, you can kind of keep them
- 43:54small, you can kind of keep them close knit, You know, they they
- 43:58shouldn't grow to be like huge ones, right.
- 44:00But But if it's just something that like, oh hey, like, you
- 44:03know, me and my family can join the Federation and I can keep it
- 44:06to just that and it would still be better than, you know,
- 44:09putting them all on while Satoshi today.
- 44:15I do want to push it back against Tanguma's original
- 44:18point. Like I think like fettiment.
- 44:20Like we have to settle for fettiment.
- 44:21Like if if we could feasibly scale self custodial to the
- 44:26entire world, like, you know, get rid of all the X hurdles and
- 44:29do it, that's the ideal solution.
- 44:31Like we don't. Ideally we remove all forms of
- 44:33trust because you know, like we're having this communication
- 44:37right now over the Internet using a like you know encrypted
- 44:40like our browser's encrypting all this communication.
- 44:42Like we don't do that because we like don't think it's a good
- 44:47idea. It's just like OK, that's just
- 44:48the default because it's better to do that because why trust our
- 44:52ISP with our Internet traffic? Why trust all this data when
- 44:56it's, you know, easily to just encrypt it and not have to do
- 44:59with that? If we could just, you know, have
- 45:02self constilled everywhere, don't need to trust
- 45:04institutions, that's a better world.
- 45:06It's just we don't live in that world because there's, you know,
- 45:09physical limits of what we can do and you know, that's why we
- 45:13have to do feta mints. I think if we could actually
- 45:15scale it, it would be a lot better.
- 45:16But you know, we sadly can't. Yeah, but that's not true
- 45:20because we could do that with gold and we didn't do that with
- 45:23gold. We parked it in institutions
- 45:25because we had to coordinate from an economic perspective.
- 45:28Well, you can't scale gold like self custodially like at least
- 45:32like, you know, sending gold across the world is like, you
- 45:36know, extremely costly. You can't give, I can't give you
- 45:38like $5 worth of gold. Like, that's why we use silver.
- 45:41But I mean for like capital formation, like for building to
- 45:44be built and for to go to Mars and like for projects and
- 45:47capital markets to form, like that's natural for like a
- 45:50civilization to grow. So like you have to have central
- 45:53firms. It's just like it's the idea of
- 45:55trust minimized, where the thesis, at least on our end is.
- 45:58It looks more like this whole notion.
- 46:02I think you guys are stumbling on this.
- 46:03It's like the world actually early.
- 46:05I won't put this in you. You tell me if I'm right.
- 46:08Directionally is everybody thought we were going to
- 46:11recreate the wheel in Bitcoin and I'm convinced we're
- 46:13repurposing it. And so it looks more like the
- 46:17old world with the trust, minimize the function IE like if
- 46:20you look at the ETFs, you called it out like one of our first
- 46:23things was like the honor Bitcoin Trust, Three different
- 46:25institutions hold a key. You can take delivery of the
- 46:27Bitcoin, right. Like in your kneecapping
- 46:29bitcoin's properties. You can't actually take it.
- 46:30So it's built into the fabric. But it kind of looks similarly
- 46:33like the GBTC. It's just a better product from
- 46:36like somebody that would want that security like exposure and
- 46:38then they get caught up on why you want the underline and be
- 46:41able to take delivery. I'm convinced that's what large
- 46:44pools of capital long term and the key sits in the UAE and
- 46:47Singapore and all these geopolitical things like farm
- 46:50out. But it doesn't take away the
- 46:52fact that like people for the next 10 plus years are going to
- 46:54want large pools of Bitcoin like set endowments institutions.
- 46:58And so similarly like with a big bank or financial intermediary
- 47:01that has to like move around large scale capital and build
- 47:04you know the fucking roads or whatever from the large scale
- 47:06settle, settle. Like they're going to need
- 47:08somebody to facilitate that and lock it in and lend it out and
- 47:11do all of these things. And so you have to be able to
- 47:14manifest that it's like doesn't exist in somebody going in back
- 47:17to their self consorted wallet sending it like it just doesn't
- 47:19equate. So I think that's like the angle
- 47:22where I I don't think it's scales like even if it did
- 47:24scale, it wouldn't make sense in my mind for everybody to hold.
- 47:27It, yeah. I mean you'd still have like
- 47:29companies and stuff, but it's like ideally like you know this
- 47:31company has their own self custodial stack versus like this
- 47:35company, you know, it's not big enough.
- 47:37So it's using like a federation or something like.
- 47:39I guess that's more what I'm getting at.
- 47:43Yeah, the the federation that Tony, Tony brought up and this
- 47:49is where I I I was in, I fell off and I'm curious where it
- 47:53went Tony or been to pick up and I don't know if Brian you heard
- 47:56it, were you referenced merchants?
- 47:59I thought it was like fascinating.
- 48:01I hadn't been able to think through how it would be.
- 48:02But I know it like just like instinctually makes complete
- 48:05sense for a merchant to be able to launch or you leverage E cash
- 48:09to take goods and services from a privacy perspective.
- 48:12And it's literally like, you know, the idea is like you
- 48:15couldn't tell him, you wouldn't even know if they were accepting
- 48:17it because you would just send some goods and then you would
- 48:19get paid and then you can swap out for whatever you know, in
- 48:22the lightning or the, you know, BTC.
- 48:25But it just makes too much sense.
- 48:26It's obviously what we know with interchange too.
- 48:29And I'm curious how far you guys have thought through that or if
- 48:31you got on that pile with Matt on like why would somebody adopt
- 48:35something like that? Yeah.
- 48:37No, it's a great question and just a good timing too.
- 48:40Like just today we launched our integration with Zaprite.
- 48:44So you know, starting today you could SAP, right?
- 48:47It's like a merchant solution, you know, invoicing solution for
- 48:50merchants basically mostly targeting for like online, you
- 48:54know, digital sales or you know, contracting or things like that.
- 48:57So essentially you know, Muni can be the recipient of
- 49:03someone's SAP, right, invoice terminal.
- 49:05So you go, you pay the invoice, you see how much it costs, you
- 49:08select, OK, I'm going to pay over lightning and the user pays
- 49:11for the service and it will go straight into the mutiny wallet
- 49:14of the of the recipient of the of the merchant itself.
- 49:17So it's kind of cool to see because you know, there there's
- 49:20a few solutions that exist out there today for for, for users,
- 49:26for merchants itself that you know, there's the open node
- 49:28approach where like they're basically the custodian.
- 49:31I know light sparks trying to get into that realm as well.
- 49:34They are operating basically as the Wausatoshi for merchants.
- 49:38It's pretty much the exact same model and they'll charge their
- 49:411% fee. It starts to turn into something
- 49:44that's almost exactly like the Visa network, it's just Bitcoin,
- 49:48right? And so like we can do so much
- 49:49better than that. On the opposite end of the
- 49:51spectrum, you have you know like BTC pay server where it's like
- 49:55OK, you you've run your own node and you manage your own channels
- 49:58and you know you're you're telling merchants to do the
- 50:02exact same thing that like general bitcoiners like don't
- 50:05want to do in the first place manage channels and liquidity
- 50:08and like requesting inbound and all of those things.
- 50:11And merchants have bigger you know they have liquidity
- 50:14constraints way more than average bitcoiner does today on
- 50:17lightning. An average bitcoiner that's
- 50:19using lightning. Maybe they have a Raspberry Pi
- 50:21at home or something. They're opening some channels
- 50:24with their Bitcoin stack and they have some inbound outbound
- 50:26they make a few payments a month and then and that's it.
- 50:31But for a merchant, like they need to be receiving payments
- 50:33all day, every day, They can't have a payment failure happen.
- 50:37If if you're ever at a grocery store, like when was the last
- 50:39time you had a payment failure? If it happens once a year that
- 50:43you know, I'm embarrassed. Like what?
- 50:44What did I do wrong? Like, am I broke?
- 50:46Like, what's going on? Like it's a very embarrassing
- 50:49situation to be in for both the merchant and and the person
- 50:52paying because you don't know where the problem is.
- 50:55And and in the Bitcoin war, you don't, you don't know if it's if
- 50:58it's the person sending or the person receiving if they have
- 51:00enough inbound. All that to say like now we're
- 51:04starting to get this middle ground where we can have
- 51:06Federation's power merchant payments and they don't have to
- 51:12worry about the inbound outbound.
- 51:14And at the end of the day, you know at any point in the day
- 51:17they can swap that E cash for you know, they can do an on
- 51:21chain withdrawal. I mean that's kind of the beauty
- 51:22of Feniman. It's like you have the E cash.
- 51:24It's basically a single balance, and if you decide to send it
- 51:27over Lightning or you decide to send it on chain, it's your
- 51:30choice. So if you're talking about a
- 51:32merchant that's receiving a lot of white payments on Lightning
- 51:35because maybe they're 5 or 10 bucks, but at the end of the day
- 51:38you have thousands and thousands of dollars worth worth of, you
- 51:42know, Bitcoin. Now you're not going to want to
- 51:45just send that back through Lightning to your bank account,
- 51:48right? Like you're going to have,
- 51:50you're probably going to have payment payment problems sending
- 51:52that large amount on over Lightning, but you can just like
- 51:56take all that money that you received via Lightning on E Cash
- 51:59and then do a non chain deposit to your wallet or to your cold
- 52:02storage at the end of the day and then you're done.
- 52:05So like it's kind of cool. I mean and then there's a
- 52:07privacy perspective as well. But at the end of the day, like
- 52:10you know, the merchant can not have to worry about any of the
- 52:13inbound outbound channel stuff. And now with this integration
- 52:17with ZAP, right, you can use Mutiny wallet and all of that
- 52:19gets converted, all of that, the inbound that happens on the
- 52:23merchant side with this integration that goes into the
- 52:25federation. So like again, they don't have
- 52:27to, they don't have to sit there and manage channels in the
- 52:31mutiny wallet and like do these swap in swap outs all the time.
- 52:34It's just like whenever they feel like it, they open Mutiny
- 52:37wallet, they make one payment out to their cold storage and
- 52:40then they're done. So you know this kind of
- 52:43scenario where merchants can start using infediments as well,
- 52:46like I think I think it'll be huge for that adoption.
- 52:48We can kind of get that middle ground between you know
- 52:50something like Open node and light Spark and and BTC pay
- 52:54server. That's really slick.
- 52:56And just to confirm. So the two things are happening
- 52:58there. Like somebody could be a
- 53:00merchant, small mom and pop and set up like a mutiny wallet
- 53:03first to open up with a large enough balance and then they
- 53:06could you set up ZAP, right? And Lightning could go directly
- 53:10into that Channel that's been opened by you guys from Mutiny
- 53:13or the self custodial wallet? So this bypasses, I mean you can
- 53:17even bypass so Mutiny. I don't know if we talked too
- 53:19much about it but we we've sort of built this hybrid approach
- 53:23where you you know at the beginning we had non Custodial
- 53:26channels and that's that was it and on chain payments but so you
- 53:29had to have a channel open to use Mutiny on at all.
- 53:33Over the last few months we've like done a deeper integration
- 53:36with Fetti Mint. So now we can get that scenario
- 53:38where a user can open up Muniwal for the first time at a
- 53:41federation start receiving and sending without having an
- 53:45opening channel at all. So in this merchant scenario
- 53:48they open up Muniwal, they like, they sign up for a lightning
- 53:54address and then they link that into Zaprite.
- 53:57All they have to do is like paste what their lighting,
- 53:59address name is and then all of a sudden they can start
- 54:02receiving payments through ZAP writes invoice screen and that
- 54:06goes into the Immuniwal and then they don't have to open a
- 54:09channel at all. But, you know, one of the cool
- 54:12things is like after, let's say that they've gone a week or a
- 54:16month and they've accrued a lot of payments into their Muniwal.
- 54:19If it's like, you know, if it's like a million SATS or
- 54:22something, they can open up a channel right there in the app
- 54:26and then take custody of that whenever they're ready.
- 54:28So it kind of like flips A narrative a little bit where
- 54:30taking this hybrid approach, it's like, hey, if you're just
- 54:33starting out with a wallet and like, you don't want to do
- 54:35anything you don't like, you don't even know if you're going
- 54:37to stick around, you know, add the federation.
- 54:40And once you get enough Sats, like take custody into the same
- 54:43app, it's the same user experience you can send and
- 54:46receive. It looks exactly the same
- 54:47whether it's a federation or it's a lightning channel.
- 54:51It's just like we try to move the user towards the lightning
- 54:53channel after they, you know, accrued enough stats, but they
- 54:56never accrued enough stats and it's like was never made sense
- 54:59to open a lightning channel in the first place.
- 55:03Yeah, that's that's super fascinating because it it, that
- 55:06sort of arrangement just drastically reduces the barrier
- 55:10to entry to to using all of this, right.
- 55:12Like you don't need that initial balance in order to to
- 55:17participate this in this and then you know if it is useful
- 55:21for you, you naturally accrue enough balance to ultimately
- 55:24settle that. So I think that's a super super
- 55:27elegant approach. One thing I I maybe just
- 55:30switching gears slightly, I think you know we're in a very,
- 55:34in my mind at least a very interesting spot currently in
- 55:38terms of sort of the Bitcoin development zeitgeist if you
- 55:41will. And I'm curious to get both of
- 55:44your thoughts on just generally you know I think we've seen as
- 55:47you mentioned Tony like you know a new L2 being launched every
- 55:51day. Is it really an L2, is it an L3?
- 55:53What is it really? I'm curious to get your thoughts
- 55:55on, on all of the different sort of scaling proposals being put
- 56:00forth today. And then sort of secondary to
- 56:03that, we mentioned you know potential soft forks like
- 56:07thinking through the different covenant proposals, what in your
- 56:10mind you know is realistic over the next call it three to five
- 56:14years in terms of potential soft forks being implemented?
- 56:18And then also just sort of comment on what we've seen over
- 56:22the past, call it 12 to 18 months of what seems like to me
- 56:25more people getting involved in terms of thinking through
- 56:27different potential solutions. But then that also raises like
- 56:31the sort of interesting dynamic of people's incentives in terms
- 56:36of you know, whether it's flooding lightning because that
- 56:40enables them to get support for what they're building or thing
- 56:44things along those lines. I think it's in one sense it's
- 56:47very good that there's been a bit of a Cambrian explosion in
- 56:50terms of Bitcoin development. But at the same time you have to
- 56:52question sort of everyone's incentives and maybe that's just
- 56:55the paranoid Bitcoin are in me, but curious your thoughts on any
- 56:58of that? Yeah, I mean there's I I guess
- 57:03the, the first one was like all the L twos, like basically all
- 57:06of them aren't really L twos, they're just multi sigs.
- 57:09And it's like if you're doing an L2, that's a multi sig, like
- 57:13just use Fediment, you get all the nice privacy properties and
- 57:16you know interoperability with Lightning on chain like it's
- 57:20basically like, you know, fediment is almost like a
- 57:22platform for building L twos or like you know, fake L twos.
- 57:26I guess it's probably the the better word there but yeah yeah,
- 57:29I I think like you know it's going to the future with
- 57:31Softworks and stuff like timelines are weird because like
- 57:35you know we activated Taproot in like 2021 and like L&D released
- 57:40like recently like Taproot lightning channels and it's like
- 57:43the simple version of them not like the all seeing eye version
- 57:46that we wanted to eventually like all the nice things like
- 57:49PTLCS and stuff. So like you know we could
- 57:51activate every cool software tomorrow and like it could still
- 57:55be like 10 years until we actually get like the the
- 57:57benefits at least on Lightning. I do think like there are you
- 58:00know Lightning is in the end all be all like Arc is a one of the
- 58:05proposals that's been working on a lot lately.
- 58:07They're currently building it like without with no soft forks.
- 58:09But you know if they do get a couple soft forks it's like you
- 58:12know a pretty small code change for them and it makes the system
- 58:15a lot better. So and you know since it's like
- 58:17not a, you know, Lightning is like multi $1,000,000 network
- 58:21with like lots of after participants.
- 58:23So upgrading it is you know, incrues a lot of capital costs
- 58:27and mental costs and all this stuff versus like if you're
- 58:30starting a whole new network you can just, you know, throw out
- 58:33the old code and ship the new version because you don't need
- 58:35to worry about you know backwards compatibility and
- 58:37shipping costs because there are no users yet.
- 58:39So I do think like if we're activating like new software
- 58:43because it's probably going to end up helping things like Arc
- 58:45and you know other competing L2's the Lightning first just
- 58:48because they don't exist yet so they can ship a lot faster.
- 58:52But you know, I do think like you know it would be nice to get
- 58:56some things like CTV or TX Hash. I mean even Opcat would be
- 59:00great. So we can just like have all
- 59:01this new functionality and to try at least experiment and have
- 59:04like a real competitor to Lightning that's not just a
- 59:07multi sig, but you know is that you know we have to go through
- 59:11the software process which everyone seems to hate.
- 59:13So that makes it a lot harder. I think the interesting I think.
- 59:20That makes a lot of sense. Alternative and you guys have
- 59:24mentioned various sort of things that you're working on
- 59:27integrating into the Mutiny app. I'm curious what's on sort of
- 59:30the road map. I know you have have started to
- 59:32dabble in in the world of Noster and and integrating that into
- 59:37sort of those those market ranking systems that we
- 59:39mentioned earlier. But curious, you know, what's on
- 59:41the road map, what's what, what are you excited about in terms
- 59:44of building out the functionality of Mutiny Wallet?
- 59:50We've we've gotten things into a really great place right now.
- 59:53So as you kind of mentioned we're we integrate a lot of
- 59:56Noster integrations. We have have the Feniment
- 59:58integrations as well. We've we're getting to the point
- 1:00:01right now where we can kind of where we can really show the
- 1:00:04point as much as we can and kind of demonstrate like what would a
- 1:00:08open source, you know, Venmo style payments application look
- 1:00:12like. So right now we're just focused
- 1:00:16on that and just like we released that just only like a
- 1:00:19few months ago and so it's really just like cleaning up a
- 1:00:22few you know things post release and you know listening to users
- 1:00:26and implementing the feedback based on our new designs we're
- 1:00:28like re redesigned. The whole home.
- 1:00:31Screen app to kind of make it mimic a sort of Venmo like
- 1:00:34experience where you can, you can, you can add new friends in
- 1:00:38mutiny wallet, you can pay them directly without asking for
- 1:00:41invoices. Like we're kind of moving
- 1:00:43towards this direction of like a social, like a human centric
- 1:00:47Bitcoin wallet where it focuses on like paying humans and not
- 1:00:50focusing on like settling invoices and requesting
- 1:00:54invoices. So we're kind of focused on you
- 1:00:56know, doubling down on that vision.
- 1:00:58But really you know, we're kind of in that place now of like you
- 1:01:01know, seeing what's seeing what's working, listen to the
- 1:01:04user feedback and iterated on that.
- 1:01:06So we're kind of in the good place where we're we're flexible
- 1:01:09with like not having a road map just because we really want to
- 1:01:12focus on like OK, like is this, is this the niche we're like
- 1:01:15doubling down on? Is this working?
- 1:01:17Is it something else we need to be doing instead.
- 1:01:20And you know, so far the traction this month has been
- 1:01:22great and so we're kind of just like going to be iterating on on
- 1:01:26on this for now. But yeah, I'm Ben, I'm not sure
- 1:01:29if I'm missing any obvious the road map items that that we've
- 1:01:33had. But for for now, my focus is
- 1:01:35just like, OK, listen to the users and implement what they're
- 1:01:39asking for basically. Yeah, I mean like our like next
- 1:01:43of things is like you know, clean up and like we want to
- 1:01:45like add like push notifications and stuff like that.
- 1:01:47But it's like, you know, those are all like easy wins, like
- 1:01:50large scale features. It's like we're just like really
- 1:01:51nailing down like OK, like what we have is solid.
- 1:01:55Let's like, you know, just emphasize what you like figure
- 1:01:58out what the users are like really finding and enjoying and
- 1:02:00then like even going deeper on that or like finding things that
- 1:02:03we can aid there as well. Like you know, earlier we were
- 1:02:05talking about the merchant stuff.
- 1:02:06It's like maybe we can build APOS system if like the ZAP
- 1:02:09right integration is taking off a lot and stuff like that.
- 1:02:11So and we're just like kind of like we kind of like had this
- 1:02:15road map from when we launched of like one day we'll have
- 1:02:18lightning fight event, lightning address and it'll be beautiful.
- 1:02:21And we hit that like basically like 2 weeks ago.
- 1:02:24So now we're like oh shit, what do we do now?
- 1:02:26So we're kind of figuring that out and you know, just nailing
- 1:02:28down the hatches and making sure everything like continues
- 1:02:30working with, you know, all the stuff we built in the last year.
- 1:02:34I think, I think it's a really awesome approach in the sense of
- 1:02:37like having the bookends of what you want to achieve.
- 1:02:39But then generally it's like it's almost like I don't know if
- 1:02:43Paradox is the right word, but it's like non.
- 1:02:45It's not generally like thought of having enough design space to
- 1:02:49leave open to like what the market pulls forward versus like
- 1:02:52most people like how very strange like we got to do it
- 1:02:54this way and then you like miss everything else that's happening
- 1:02:56around and it feels like leading on the E cash side.
- 1:03:00And then the the merchant stuff is super fascinating not only
- 1:03:04from like payments but this whole notion of like being able
- 1:03:07to have AE form of money from a rewards perspective that is not
- 1:03:11tied to like SAT's in the way that Lightning is and how you
- 1:03:14can do. It's just like something that
- 1:03:15hasn't been seen on like user adoption, client adoption,
- 1:03:19client acquisition from whether it's media, whether it's
- 1:03:22publishers, whether it's like a like AD 2C company, right, like
- 1:03:28how do you like incentivize people or you'd like the wallet
- 1:03:31can participate or they can get these like tokens and then they
- 1:03:35can learn about Bitcoin and then they it's like a, it's a
- 1:03:37flywheel for everybody. It's a fascinating concept when
- 1:03:41you take out having to like deal with channels and lightning and
- 1:03:44all of that. And so I think it's just like
- 1:03:45the very early innings, but as the price appreciates more and
- 1:03:47more talent and like entrepreneurs are going to Start
- 1:03:50learning about this and then they're going to be like talking
- 1:03:52to you guys and like how do I actually get this in there like
- 1:03:54core product to increase kind of like their user acquisition.
- 1:03:59Yeah, we've we've talked to a few Bitcoin rewards companies
- 1:04:04already about you know Fettiment and like hey, this is basically
- 1:04:07like you can reskin it to look like a rewards points like
- 1:04:12system that you can provide to the the users of your app that's
- 1:04:16interoperable. Or you can go to specific
- 1:04:18merchants saying like hey, this is your specific rewards points
- 1:04:21for for your users. And you know you can kind of
- 1:04:23build a rewards platform just like you said on that.
- 1:04:25So yeah, I mean the whole merchants design space is is
- 1:04:28huge and I mean you know there's there's a lot of value to be had
- 1:04:32by focusing on that. So like you know one of our
- 1:04:34perspectives before diving into that it's like OK let's you know
- 1:04:38we're we're focusing on like consumer you know payers of you
- 1:04:42know consumer payments itself. But then at a certain point that
- 1:04:46turns into like OK now we can now we can solve like the
- 1:04:49business problems as well and then meet in the middle have a
- 1:04:51great experience for payers, have a great experience for
- 1:04:54recipients and be that both ends of the spectrum there.
- 1:04:57So that could very well be what we end up working on next.
- 1:05:01But yeah, like Ben said, like we're going to figure that out,
- 1:05:04see if see if Zaprite merchants, you know, end up using Mutiny
- 1:05:07Wall and see what we can fix there.
- 1:05:09If there's any pain points we can solve on both sides, it's
- 1:05:12kind of great because now we don't have to build the whole
- 1:05:14invoicing system, right. You know, we can kind of focus
- 1:05:17on, you know, the recipient payment side and see, you know,
- 1:05:19if Zaprite can solve their problems and then we can kind of
- 1:05:22fit in. I mean that's the cool thing
- 1:05:23about the ecosystem in general. There is so many different
- 1:05:28companies working on different parts of the world essentially,
- 1:05:33right. And so like where do we fit in
- 1:05:35the best? Where can we solve other Bitcoin
- 1:05:38businesses, pain points, other general businesses, pain points,
- 1:05:42merchants pains points, user pain points, where do we fit in
- 1:05:46best? And I think you know before
- 1:05:47starting Mutiny Wallet, we're like, yeah, we're we're going to
- 1:05:49make a wallet and it's going to be a great wallet And that you
- 1:05:52know, we know what makes a great light lightning wallet.
- 1:05:54We know the features of lightning.
- 1:05:56We know how to build in general and now we're kind of the point
- 1:06:00where you know what they don't teach you is like how to how to
- 1:06:02just build in general, how to how to figure out what the
- 1:06:05market wants, how to how to move in the right directions, how to
- 1:06:09do these proof of concepts with you know large gains.
- 1:06:12So like we're kind of in that you know not not pivot per SE,
- 1:06:16you know we're not we're not pivoting in any way.
- 1:06:17But it's it's sort of like how do we, how do we next evolve our
- 1:06:21application. And you know for all of us being
- 1:06:23first time founders and and being one year in with like a
- 1:06:27good, you know good traction, a good proof of concept like the
- 1:06:30next elevation is, is sort of what we're diving into from from
- 1:06:34the mutiny perspective. Yeah, I think Tony was
- 1:06:38highlighting a cool point earlier of like, you know, like
- 1:06:41we're working on ZAP, right. And just kind of like, you know,
- 1:06:44they actually did basically did like 0 work to integrate this.
- 1:06:46They had already done the work with another provider.
- 1:06:48We're just using the same protocol as everyone else.
- 1:06:51So like we're kind of getting all this like free value from
- 1:06:54the ecosystem, just like everything's a protocol.
- 1:06:56So we just is naturally get free integrations like like Coin
- 1:07:01Kite, they have this service called Unleash dot chat.
- 1:07:03It's like ChatGPT but it's like they like uncock the models and
- 1:07:08do it over Noster and like Mutiny has DMS in it.
- 1:07:11So like we have a not AI chat inside of Mutiny for free, just
- 1:07:15on accident and like stuff like that.
- 1:07:18Just like we get these all these like free integrations from the
- 1:07:20ecosystem. So you can kind of find these
- 1:07:22different protocols, how to layer them together to make
- 1:07:24like, you know, a perfect AD versus like the Fiat system.
- 1:07:27It's like everyone has a proprietary API.
- 1:07:29You need to e-mail 13 guys to get, even get access to the API.
- 1:07:32And you know, it breaks every week and it's not open source.
- 1:07:35So when it's broken, you have no idea why and you know it's
- 1:07:38terrible. But here we can just, you know,
- 1:07:40have this Cambrian explosion of different stuff.
- 1:07:44Yeah, no, it's it's a beautiful thing.
- 1:07:46Open open networks interoperability and and
- 1:07:49basically you know being able to iterate on things and and share
- 1:07:53each other's growth effectively. And I think that's that's one of
- 1:07:56the things that, you know, I, I appreciate about what you guys
- 1:07:59have have built in our building. And Michael sort of alludes to
- 1:08:02this around, you know, just being very intentional about
- 1:08:06user feedback and building, you know, the best experience for
- 1:08:10people that want to send and receive value.
- 1:08:12Like very simply like if if we're successful, like you know,
- 1:08:17people don't even shouldn't even need to know that necessarily
- 1:08:19Bitcoin is being used on the back end.
- 1:08:20Like if they're using E Cash tokens and they're sending and
- 1:08:23receive, sending and receiving E Cash tokens like with 0 friction
- 1:08:26and 0 sign up. Like that should be the goal of
- 1:08:30basically, you know, incepting Bitcoin adoption into into the
- 1:08:34into society without even people really knowing.
- 1:08:36And I also you know sort of see that with things like you know
- 1:08:41Zaps on Noster or on on you know up votes on Stacker news, it's
- 1:08:45like it's just a better experience, right.
- 1:08:47Like you actually get value for the value that you create.
- 1:08:51Like it's just a a very organic natural thing that if you create
- 1:08:55a better user experience that is what should create that flywheel
- 1:08:59of adoption. And it's it's it's interesting
- 1:09:01that you know or I think it's commendable that you you're
- 1:09:04you're really focused on just creating the the best user
- 1:09:07experience and that's that's how that's how bitcoin's going to
- 1:09:10win ultimately is like it's it's a it's a better money one
- 1:09:13obviously because of the store value properties but it's also a
- 1:09:16better money because it's easy to use and you might not even
- 1:09:18know you're using it. Yeah, I think.
- 1:09:24I think it's interesting. Looking back, looking back on
- 1:09:27where we started with with Lightning payments and like
- 1:09:30hearing everyone's you know we you know we had some good
- 1:09:32traction early on even even with the you know self custodial like
- 1:09:35it's it's interested the Noster people you know they're they're
- 1:09:38very early adopters into this like new social media that
- 1:09:41exists you know very cipher punk value.
- 1:09:44So we got a lot of like early adopter type users from all ends
- 1:09:48of the spectrum people that like don't know Bitcoin very well.
- 1:09:51The people that like are very experienced and and and know
- 1:09:54everything about how to operate in Bitcoin and lightning and
- 1:09:57open channels. So you know just even listening
- 1:10:00to those users as you know listening to all of their
- 1:10:02feedback that that they provided and it's like this is just how
- 1:10:06lightning works. Like there's absolutely no way
- 1:10:08we can get around that unless we're like not building on light
- 1:10:11paint. And so that's kind of like
- 1:10:13evolved into like hey you know what Fettiment fixes this user's
- 1:10:17problem, this user's problem, all of these user problems that
- 1:10:19are that are having you know issues.
- 1:10:21So that's just been the natural progression and like OK cool, we
- 1:10:24just with with one you know one big integration that we finally
- 1:10:29completed. We're like cool, we've like
- 1:10:31check boxed all these user issues that we've had that we
- 1:10:35can't physically solve on Lightning alone.
- 1:10:39And so it's it's been beautiful to be able to get to that point
- 1:10:42where like OK cool, now now what are all the lowest hanging
- 1:10:45fruits. It's like you know almost like
- 1:10:48throw away all those issues now those are complete.
- 1:10:50What's next? With you guys being so close to
- 1:10:56Noster Lightning, the the E cash stuff and then also just, you
- 1:11:00know, naturally being engineers like what's the most exciting
- 1:11:03stuff you guys are seeing right now?
- 1:11:04Whether it's like Noster related or just like in the Bitcoin
- 1:11:07ecosystem that has you're kind of like interested because we
- 1:11:12look at the boring shit. We just talk to like you know
- 1:11:15people a lot of money and help them understand Bitcoin and just
- 1:11:18like you just like park the Bitcoin and don't touch it and
- 1:11:22number goes up, number goes go up works.
- 1:11:25But you know curious on like you guys being at the very edges,
- 1:11:29what's the interesting stuff that you think probably in this
- 1:11:32next like Epoch's going to be Because you think about four
- 1:11:34years ago a lot of stuff we're talking about would just be
- 1:11:36insane to to be talking about And so anything you guys are
- 1:11:41seeing that are is super like compelling.
- 1:11:43I think something that I hope blows up in this cycle is like,
- 1:11:47you know, we kind of mentioned earlier if like Vitamin can be
- 1:11:50this platform for other L twos or like you know quote UN quote
- 1:11:53L twos. And like basically like Vitamin
- 1:11:55is not really like Bitcoin is like almost a side project
- 1:11:59inside of Fediment where it's really just this Federated
- 1:12:01consensus system. And then there happens to be a
- 1:12:04Bitcoin module that you know lets you spend and receive
- 1:12:07Bitcoin, but you can make kind of any system inside of there.
- 1:12:10So I'm really excited to see, you know, some different modules
- 1:12:14that people make that could like really blow up and show like the
- 1:12:17really cool use cases that you can do inside of there.
- 1:12:20And and you know, The thing is too, it's like you always have
- 1:12:23this Bitcoin module in there. So any cool thing that someone
- 1:12:26builds will have like Bitcoin native payments for free, like
- 1:12:29instantly inside of it. So I think some really cool
- 1:12:31things could happen. I mean for example, something we
- 1:12:33talked about was like doing like, you know, gambling inside
- 1:12:36of a fediment where you could have like a contract that is
- 1:12:39validated by the Guardian. So like, you could say, like,
- 1:12:42you know, if I'm betting on the Super Bowl, oh, the Chiefs won
- 1:12:45and the Guardians all see, the Chiefs won.
- 1:12:46So then the money goes to me, you could build like a, you
- 1:12:48know, DraftKings, but it can't be shut down by the government.
- 1:12:53There's no KYC, There's nothing like that.
- 1:12:55And you know, it's that much better.
- 1:12:57But, you know, and that's just like, you know, one example we
- 1:12:59had, you know, I'm sure you know this, you could release it on
- 1:13:0210,000 developers. Some, like absolutely crazy
- 1:13:04stuff can happen as well. Ben's been trying to put
- 1:13:08gambling on the blockchain since I it seems I've been shared,
- 1:13:11shared, shared Vince days and in DLCS and so that does not
- 1:13:15surprise me that creating a chief Super Bowl over a Fetty
- 1:13:19that is the natural, most exciting thing for Epoch 5.
- 1:13:23You got to get them, DJ. That's great.
- 1:13:26Yeah, we tried that. Even on Oscar we tried to do
- 1:13:28like a DLC based system on top of Noster where there is no
- 1:13:32monetary gain at all. We just use the same
- 1:13:34cryptography that creates Noster notes to just say like, hey, I
- 1:13:39won or he won and like the Oracle would come in and prove
- 1:13:42which one won. But you know, that was DLCS,
- 1:13:45man, those. It gets all the hype, but like
- 1:13:48it is incredibly difficult to work with and we have one of the
- 1:13:51top, you know, minds in the DLC space and it's just like still
- 1:13:54too difficult. And that's another thing where
- 1:13:56it's like oh, but we could do it in the Feniman and you have the
- 1:13:59same like Federated, you know, trust, minimize, model.
- 1:14:03It's like, let's just let's just do it that way.
- 1:14:06Yeah I think where this is like so compelling personally is this
- 1:14:10whole idea of E cash is like it's a positive sum game in the
- 1:14:15sense of like it's it's a bank, right.
- 1:14:17And a bank used to be where everybody net benefited until
- 1:14:21they started rugging everyone right and they fucked up the
- 1:14:23money And because of that like positive sum games mean that the
- 1:14:27person that's parking their capital or leveraging it or the
- 1:14:30the bank and you know in this case the federman is also making
- 1:14:33money. These are providing a good in
- 1:14:34service. You can actually see how this
- 1:14:36actually scales and works and has the game theory behind it.
- 1:14:40Because again whether it's you know in a funny Mitt three O 5
- 1:14:43or or whatever, the way it like manifests from game theory and
- 1:14:47keeping everybody honest, it's a better version of what exists
- 1:14:51and you can actually squint and see how it looks like what it
- 1:14:53historically has existed. But you put better like
- 1:14:57governance around it because that's how I think about multi
- 1:14:59sig. It's just effectively governance
- 1:15:01at the protocol level. When you put institutions or
- 1:15:04people with faces across or non faces which is a different
- 1:15:07conversation we'll have a theory on.
- 1:15:08It's like I'm convinced there there's going to be, it looks
- 1:15:11more like the old world than the Aenon world from a commercial
- 1:15:14perspective. Because most people don't not
- 1:15:16want to trust person they don't know as much as we want as like
- 1:15:19you know matter Dell and people will want to believe that it's
- 1:15:21going to be the Anons that run this stuff.
- 1:15:23It's like the realities, commercial and consumer
- 1:15:25behavior. Really likes to know who the
- 1:15:27fucks messing with their money because they know who to go and
- 1:15:29show up to the house or call them or e-mail them.
- 1:15:32And that's a hard pill to swallow because we historically
- 1:15:34have looked at this space and wanted to not, you know, be
- 1:15:36that. And I I recognize that can be
- 1:15:38wrong there. But I think directionally just
- 1:15:40by playing this space and similar to what you guys say is
- 1:15:42you're just taking like the market.
- 1:15:43The market kind of like sends these signals and they just want
- 1:15:46to be able to trust people at the end of the day because
- 1:15:48that's like how we, you know, you want to wake up and know
- 1:15:51that Anon isn't going to rub you.
- 1:15:52So anyway, I think that's like what's super compelling is it's
- 1:15:55a positive sum game in in all of this and everybody gets to like
- 1:15:58win and benefit. Yeah.
- 1:16:00One of the interesting things with FEDI, Mint and just like
- 1:16:04cashew mints in general is the idea that you know there are
- 1:16:09going to be like competing mints as well.
- 1:16:12And so you really get into like some old time bank you know bank
- 1:16:16era dynamics where you know you have other banks that are trying
- 1:16:20to collapse a bank that they suspect is running a fractional
- 1:16:24reserve and they come in with like huge deposits and then late
- 1:16:27later come in with huge withdrawals like banks basically
- 1:16:32creating bank runs on top of other banks.
- 1:16:34And umm you know just the fact that like you know Bitcoin and
- 1:16:38lightning and you know all these like mints can move so fast and
- 1:16:42like information can move instantaneously across the
- 1:16:45entire world. You kind of get into the
- 1:16:47scenario where like if there's any hints of fucker going on at
- 1:16:51all, like we can find out instantly.
- 1:16:53And you have other banks keeping accountable other you know other
- 1:16:56banks in this way because of like if they go down, like if
- 1:16:59there's a suspected run on the bank and they're not going to be
- 1:17:02fully collateralized. All it takes is like 1 user to
- 1:17:05finally go oh I just tried to do a withdrawal and it wasn't going
- 1:17:09through what the hell is going on.
- 1:17:11And you can have another bank basically enact that to happen
- 1:17:14and and if they're fully reserved then boom, there's no
- 1:17:17problem. Everyone does withdrawals out of
- 1:17:20the out of the Femi Mint, out of the mint and there's no issues
- 1:17:23and and guess what we just proved OK that that mint was
- 1:17:26fully reserved. We can go back and trust it
- 1:17:28again. So I don't know.
- 1:17:30It's just like there's a lot of game theory that can like kind
- 1:17:33of happen now that would have been much more difficult to do,
- 1:17:36you know hundreds of years ago with banks itself.
- 1:17:39I mean now we just live in a world where there's no
- 1:17:41fractional, where there's just no reserve at all and and it's
- 1:17:44all 0% reserved every single bank across America.
- 1:17:47And we then there's no fucker going around because like if one
- 1:17:51pin drops, everyone falls and no one wants to live it.
- 1:17:54It's almost like a nuke scenario for banks.
- 1:17:56So you know, there's not much of that going on anymore.
- 1:17:59But yeah, it's just, it's just an interesting era to kind of
- 1:18:02live through like how how would we redo banks if we could and
- 1:18:06you know, kind of. We'll have to pick this up.
- 1:18:10I know, I know we're running up on time, but you literally just
- 1:18:12hit the nail on the head where we think multi institution plays
- 1:18:14out long term. Because if you think about it
- 1:18:16bit goes a $10 billion, roughly $10 billion business in the
- 1:18:19sense of like if they don't sign their whole business starts to
- 1:18:23look a lot weirder. You know in the sense of like
- 1:18:25everybody's leveraging it. And so that game theory starts
- 1:18:28to play out as you have larger larger institutions participated
- 1:18:31in that. And so if they do not keep their
- 1:18:35contractual, you know, engagement, then you still
- 1:18:38aren't rugged, you just move the assets and they just rug their
- 1:18:41whole business and that's how you can actually start to build
- 1:18:43trust from a larger scale perspective.
- 1:18:46It it effectively brings better game theory dynamics to
- 1:18:50accountability, full stop, Right.
- 1:18:52Like in order to gain and maintain trust, you got to go
- 1:18:57prove it right. Like whether it's providing a
- 1:18:59signature or just not wrecking your users, Like you have to
- 1:19:02actually earn that credibility in the market.
- 1:19:05So yeah, it's a beautiful thing. I know, I know Michael, I think
- 1:19:07has to run, but really want to thank both Ben and Tony for for
- 1:19:11joining today. It's an awesome conversation and
- 1:19:13we'll have to do it again because there's there's more on
- 1:19:16the bone here, but great conversation.
- 1:19:19Yeah, you guys pressure. Thank you both.
- 1:19:20Appreciate you joining. Yeah.
- 1:19:23Thanks anytime guys. All right.
- 1:19:25Love it. Take care, boys.