Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / BC Proposes Changes that Would Undermine the Independence of Lawyers
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: time for a regular segment, legally speaking, joined by barister and solicitor with maligan defense lawyers.
- 0:05Adam Stirling: Good morning, michael maligan.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: How we doing.
- 0:08Michael Mulligan: Hey, good morning, I'm doing great, I was good to be here some interesting items on the docket for this week.
- 0:13Adam Stirling: It's that word that we've discussed in the past, a venture, and what the bc government's proposal to modernize the regulation of the legal profession might impact regarding the abilities that role carries with it you know that's right.
- 0:27Michael Mulligan: And I was saying is, sometimes you need to be a bit worried when the uh government rationale for doing something is quote, modernization always.
- 0:36Michael Mulligan: But, uh, this may be one of them, uh, and so the the background of this is that there are a number of professions of that are regulated.
- 0:43Michael Mulligan: They would include things like uh doctors, engineers, architects, nurses and, indeed, lawyers, and the reason for that regulation should be obvious when you think about it that it's to ensure the uh public is safe.
- 0:58Michael Mulligan: Right, you don't want anyone who feels like it, uh, purporting to be a doctor or an engineer or something.
- 1:05Michael Mulligan: People would be dying and bridges would be falling down, right, and so if you wish to be any of those things, you would need to meet various uh requirements, like educational requirements, testing requirements, that sort of thing, so that you don't have uh incompetent doctors, engineers, uh, nurses, teachers are uh, various other things.
- 1:24Michael Mulligan: Uh, and in many cases, that is really the concern to ensure uh competence to protect the public.
- 1:34Michael Mulligan: Right, you want to make sure when you go to a doctor, uh, the doctor knows what they're doing.
- 1:39Michael Mulligan: Right, for the engineer that signs off on the bridge knows what they're doing.
- 1:43Michael Mulligan: Uh, lawyers are a bit of a special case, because there is both that requirement or that desire to make sure the public is protected, right?
- 1:52Michael Mulligan: You don't want somebody being a lawyer who is uh dishonest, for example, in the steel your money, and you don't want somebody who's purporting to be a lawyer, who's incompetent in giving you bad advice.
- 2:03Michael Mulligan: Obviously those would be problems, right?
- 2:05Michael Mulligan: Yes, so that's yet another reason why, uh, you know lawyers other professionals need to be regulated to make sure there's competence.
- 2:13Michael Mulligan: Lawyers have a special requirement in that lawyers are in frequently in opposition to things the government might want to be doing right.
- 2:27Michael Mulligan: For example, if the government is looking to prosecute you for something and send you to jail, right, or is suing you or trying to take your children away, or doing a host of things, right, the lawyer that you hire may be working in opposition to what the government wants to do to you, right.
- 2:47Michael Mulligan: And so, for that reason, you want to make sure that lawyers are independent of government, right, and not just somebody who's sort of beholden to the government in any kind of a direct way, so that you know the lawyer is not going to be concerned that they're going to be disciplined or fired or something bad is going to happen to them when they're working for you, right, and so lawyers are.
- 3:13Michael Mulligan: In addition to making sure that lawyers are competent, they need to be separate and independent of government, and so lawyers are a self-governing profession, and one of the ways that's maintained is that the organization responsible for regulating lawyers, so the law society, is set up to be separate from government, and so the board of directors, the people on it, are called ventures it's a bit of an old term, but basically it's the board of directors for the law society.
- 3:47Michael Mulligan: The majority of them are elected by other members of the profession 25 of them are elected in that way.
- 3:57Michael Mulligan: Usually senior lawyers are elected to serve on that role.
- 4:01Michael Mulligan: The government does appoint some members six of them and the attorney general sits on that board of directors, and so that's how it's worked for a long period of time.
- 4:12Michael Mulligan: And there's a proposal now, which has caused any grave concern in the legal profession, which would quote modernize that regulatory scheme to allow the government to appoint more of those ventures board of directors, so the government could exert greater control over how lawyers are regulated.
- 4:39Michael Mulligan: And that's a serious worry if you're concerned about making sure that lawyers are independent of the government, and it's come to a bit of a head in Victoria and elsewhere, and this is, I should say, following on submissions made by the law society itself the Victoria Bar Association and the Canadian Bar Association all in opposition to what the government has proposed doing, which would allow the government to exert greater control over the legal profession.
- 5:17Michael Mulligan: And what's underway right now is a election to determine who would be the venture or member of the board of directors for Victoria, and that one of the people who's been doing that now for the last couple of years is Crown Counsel in Victoria and the norm is that somebody who's serving in that role and is a volunteer position would do so for typically a term of about eight years or so.
- 5:50Michael Mulligan: They get elected every couple of years but typically the person would just continue to do it as a volunteer.
- 5:56Michael Mulligan: The lawyer who's been doing it, paul Pearson, indicated that he doesn't feel that he's able to continue in that role because he is also working for the government as Crown Counsel and he's indicated it's so pivotal and important so that the person in that role be able to oppose what the government has indicated it's wanting to do, that he's not going to run again so that somebody can take over that job to be able to, in a full-throated way, oppose what the provincial government is wanting to do, and he sent out a message to the profession exactly to that effect, talking about how, in his view, what's proposed here would amount to a seismic shift in the relationship between the law society that's supposed to be independent and the government.
- 6:54Michael Mulligan: And his concern was that, given the fact that he is employed by the government, he would not be able to, in a completely unfettered way, serve to oppose what the government is trying to do.
- 7:10Michael Mulligan: And so what's going on now is an election to determine who could take over that job and oppose what the government is wanting to do here.
- 7:25Michael Mulligan: And I should say you might wonder why would the government want to do this?
- 7:29Michael Mulligan: Why would they want to take control?
- 7:31Michael Mulligan: And there are a couple of reasons for that.
- 7:35Michael Mulligan: One of them may be a general desire to have some greater control over an entity that can act in opposition to the government, and we've seen a trend in that regard over the past few years, including with things like ICBC.
- 7:54Michael Mulligan: Right, we've seen them move to this note fault scheme.
- 7:57Michael Mulligan: Where there's, it's can be harder to challenge decisions being made by them, and so there may be a generalized interest in maintaining greater control over an organization that can act in an independent way in opposition to government desires.
- 8:15Michael Mulligan: Another stated reason is a government.
- 8:19Michael Mulligan: There's been for years and we've talked about this a serious underfunding of legal aid in British Columbia.
- 8:28Michael Mulligan: We are the only province where there's a special tax that lawyers have to charge their clients who are hiring them.
- 8:35Michael Mulligan: That tax was supposed to go to pay for legal aid.
- 8:39Michael Mulligan: It was fed up by the NDP when they were in government last time, yeah, and the government now diverts more than half of the money it collects to other purposes, doesn't give it to the organization that provides legal aid to help the poor, and part of this proposal would be to set up a scheme of paralegals who would be intended to provide legal assistance to the poor, and the concern about that is whether those people would have the same degree of training a lawyer would have, and there is a worry in the profession that it's not appropriate to offer a lower quality of service potentially to somebody and it would be rather than properly funding legal aid.
- 9:36Michael Mulligan: Giving people who had less training.
- 9:39Michael Mulligan: Having them provide the assistance to people who can't afford to hire a lawyer is not necessarily an appropriate solution to that problem, and what should happen is proper funding, and the money shouldn't be diverted.
- 9:56Michael Mulligan: That's been collected.
- 9:57Michael Mulligan: So that's one of the things that's underlying this as well, and so it's a serious issue, and one of the important things to remember is that the independence of the legal profession, much like the independence of the judiciary right, is not something which is intended to be a benefit to the judges or to the legal profession.
- 10:20Michael Mulligan: That's not why it exists.
- 10:22Michael Mulligan: It exists in order to serve the public interest right you want to have, and you should have confidence that the judge deciding your case and the lawyer who's helping you are acting independent of government and they don't need to be concerned that they're going to be disciplined or regulated or something's going to happen to them when they're making a decision or they're helping you.
- 10:49Michael Mulligan: And what's currently proposed would serve to undermine that, and that's why the public should be very concerned about what the government has suggested here, and that's why the lawyer who's been serving in this role in Victoria has indicated he's doesn't feel comfortable continuing in that position, because there just needs to be clear opposition to what the government is proposed, in line with the opposition that's been expressed by all of the organizations that deal with us, and so that's what's going on, and that's why people should be concerned about the government's proposal to try to take greater control over how the legal profession operates.
- 11:43Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking.
- 11:46Adam Stirling: On CFAQs 1070, will continue right after this.
- 11:48Adam Stirling: We've recently discussed the phenomenon of 24-7 camping here in Victoria and a pledge by Victoria Council to phase out the practice of relying on encampments in parks for human beings to shelter themselves who have no otherwise reasonably available alternative shelter.
- 12:04Adam Stirling: But in that sentence itself arises an interesting question what do those words mean?
- 12:10Adam Stirling: Is there some sort of test somewhere?
- 12:11Adam Stirling: How does a court interpret them?
- 12:13Adam Stirling: Well, the BC Legislature, would appear, is lending a hand.
- 12:17Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers is legally speaking.
- 12:20Adam Stirling: Continues in the latest Miscellaneous Statutes and Amendment Act.
- 12:26Michael Mulligan: Indeed, I must say, it's one of those titles of a piece of legislation that you can sometimes not get all the way through without getting tired.
- 12:34Michael Mulligan: That's the Miscellaneous Statutes Amendment Act, I think number four.
- 12:38Michael Mulligan: Now, the background of all of this is a case that actually arose in Victoria and it made its way to the Court of Appeals a case in the Victoria versus Adams.
- 12:50Michael Mulligan: That's a Court of Appeal decision from 2009.
- 12:53Michael Mulligan: And that decision is the one that dealt with the issue of whether a person's got a constitutional right to put up a tent to shelter themselves in a park, and the that case begins with what the Court of Appeal describes as series this way.
- 13:11Michael Mulligan: So this appeal addresses a narrow issue.
- 13:14Michael Mulligan: When homeless people are not prohibited from sleeping in public parks, public parks and the number of homeless people exceeds the number of available shelter beds, does a bylaw that prohibits homeless people from erecting any form of temporary overnight shelter?
- 13:30Michael Mulligan: Is that unconstitutional?
- 13:33Michael Mulligan: That's the essence of it.
- 13:35Michael Mulligan: And so what was described by the Court of Appeal then is that narrow issue whether somebody could erect a temporary shelter at night if there weren't enough shelter beds.
- 13:46Michael Mulligan: Right, and the Court of Appeal agreed with the trial judge that heard that case and said yes, you do have a constitutional right to do that narrow thing.
- 13:55Michael Mulligan: Now, that sort of formed the structure of what can and can't be done in terms of regulating that.
- 14:04Michael Mulligan: Now, like many things in life, as you said, what do these words mean?
- 14:10Michael Mulligan: And since then, there's been a number of cases where there's been arguments about, well, what is reasonable?
- 14:20Michael Mulligan: There have to be food provided.
- 14:24Michael Mulligan: What about restrictions?
- 14:25Michael Mulligan: What if there's shelter beds but they say you can't do drugs or be drinking in the shelter?
- 14:30Michael Mulligan: Does that count?
- 14:31Michael Mulligan: What if the shelter says you have to be in by 11 o'clock at night, you can't just come in at two in the morning.
- 14:37Michael Mulligan: Does that count, right, this kind of thing?
- 14:39Michael Mulligan: And so the way that would play out is that if there was a municipality seeking an injunction to stop people camping in a particular park, you've had various trial judges determining whether there should be an injunction granted to prohibit that or not, and those kinds of arguments have been made and there have been different decisions about well, what exactly does that mean, right?
- 15:08Michael Mulligan: And so this, the part of that miscellaneous statutes amendment act.
- 15:15Michael Mulligan: It attempts to define what would be required, and so it says this so the purpose of enforcing, under section 334, a bylaw against a person who is sheltering in an encampment while homeless, alternative shelter is reasonably available to the person and meets the basic needs of the person for shelter, if and I should pause there for a moment bearing in mind the court of appeal when they originally made that decision.
- 15:46Michael Mulligan: So this is a narrow issue about can you put a covering over you at night, right.
- 15:51Michael Mulligan: That's expanded to sort of the basic needs of a person, right?
- 15:56Michael Mulligan: So there's been a movement since 2009 and now Interesting, and so this.
- 16:02Michael Mulligan: This would require the following things the person may stay overnight at the shelter.
- 16:07Michael Mulligan: B.
- 16:08Michael Mulligan: The person has access to a bathroom and shower at or near the shelter I guess it can't be a bathtub.
- 16:15Michael Mulligan: C the person is offered without charge one meal a day at or near the shelter.
- 16:20Michael Mulligan: D the shelter is staffed when persons are sheltering at the shelter.
- 16:25Michael Mulligan: And so what would?
- 16:27Michael Mulligan: What would happen if this passes?
- 16:29Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 16:30Michael Mulligan: Is the government's trying to define what would be the requirement for a bylaw to stop somebody from camping in a park?
- 16:42Michael Mulligan: Right, and so a person would be able to say, well, look, you're out, there's a shelter space available but there's no shower.
- 16:49Michael Mulligan: Well, that wouldn't count, right?
- 16:51Michael Mulligan: Or there's a shelter space available, but no free food.
- 16:55Adam Stirling: Yeah, that wouldn't count how near is near?
- 16:57Adam Stirling: Do we know Cause you mentioned?
- 16:59Michael Mulligan: the shower it's bathroom or shower at or near the shelter, and I'm just wondering Right, the shelter, the yeah, the, the shower and the bathroom has to be at or near the free meal has to be at or near.
- 17:09Michael Mulligan: It's not defined.
- 17:11Michael Mulligan: And so no doubt there would be continued argument about what exactly does this mean, I see, and so there's no shelter spaces.
- 17:19Michael Mulligan: But this seems to be an effort to sort of crystallize what, the exact, what the requirement would be, and it it's more than what the original sort of appeal case seem to deal with.
- 17:34Michael Mulligan: Right, the narrow issue of can you put a covering over you at night if there's no, no shelter space, right?
- 17:41Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 17:42Michael Mulligan: And on the other end of that, there've been arguments about you know things like you know things we mentioned, right, what about shelter spaces available, but it's got some requirement that a person doesn't want to adhere to, right?
- 17:54Michael Mulligan: Like I can't bring my dog there, or it doesn't allow a couple to go there, or they don't allow drug use there, or you have to be there a certain time, right?
- 18:03Michael Mulligan: Those kinds of things.
- 18:04Michael Mulligan: Those things aren't in this list.
- 18:06Michael Mulligan: And so, if this passes, the idea might be to do away with some of those arguments about, hey, that space doesn't count because I can't bring my dog, or that space doesn't count because you need to be in it a certain time.
- 18:21Michael Mulligan: The idea would be, I suppose a municipality would be able to say, well, look, that's not a requirement.
- 18:25Michael Mulligan: There's food, shelter, it's overnight, there's a shower, you get a free meal and there's staff there.
- 18:32Michael Mulligan: That's it right, and so it's interesting and one that I think people should know about.
- 18:39Michael Mulligan: So we can consider that right, because reasonable people can disagree about this policy and, given that it's in an act with a title that deals with, I should say, the legislation deals with 187 various things, and I think no sort of public debate or attention drawn to this, at least so far.
- 19:01Michael Mulligan: It was just introduced last week, but that's what's going on, and just so people are aware of it and can think about what should be the requirement from a legal perspective, before there could be a restriction on somebody being able to set up a tent or some other shelter to sleep in, and that's what the government is proposing.
- 19:23Michael Mulligan: So I think people should think about it and we'll see what comes of it.
- 19:26Adam Stirling: Yeah, it's interesting.
- 19:27Adam Stirling: It's been a long time since I've read Adams, but I remember the discussion between positive and negative rights, like negative rights imposed upon the government due to non-interference, whereas positive rights are more about entitlements Governments should provide and, unless I'm mistaken, there is no actual entitlement to shelter.
- 19:42Adam Stirling: Government didn't need to provide shelter in that case.
- 19:45Adam Stirling: It was the non-interference issue.
- 19:47Adam Stirling: But if we're going to talk about supplying one meal per day near a shelter, it sounds like we are moving closer towards that entitlement and away from the liberty aspect.
- 19:57Michael Mulligan: Yeah, or I mean.
- 19:58Michael Mulligan: I suppose the way to look at it is this this, this is past doesn't require that meals and showers and shelter, spaces and staff be provided.
- 20:07Michael Mulligan: The idea here would be that if those things don't all exist, right.
- 20:13Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 20:13Michael Mulligan: Overnight shelter, bathroom with shower, meat free, meal and staffing.
- 20:19Michael Mulligan: What it would mean is that a municipality would not be able to get an injunction to stop people from setting up tents in the park, basically, right.
- 20:31Michael Mulligan: So it's.
- 20:31Michael Mulligan: If the basic requirement of Adams right is that for a government to be able to stop people from, say, covering themselves up at night, that's how it started, right.
- 20:45Michael Mulligan: There has to be some other alternative.
- 20:48Michael Mulligan: The idea was we can't create a circumstance where somebody has no choice and they're forced to, you know, lay outside and be unable to cover themselves up at night.
- 20:59Michael Mulligan: Right, that's where that started, right, which I think is perhaps understandable, right, you know, if you have, if you have a legal regime in place, that means, effectively, a person cannot, you know, cover themselves up at night or keep warm.
- 21:15Michael Mulligan: That's not permissible, right, that sort of falls below the sort of minimum constitutional requirement.
- 21:24Michael Mulligan: And so, you know, even that case it wasn't one that said, look, the municipality must provide shelter space.
- 21:30Michael Mulligan: No, it just stood for the proposition that you can't stop a person from putting a tarp up or attend if they have no other choice, nowhere else to go.
- 21:41Michael Mulligan: But of course, since then, you would then wind up with all the arguments, as people are inclined to do right About.
- 21:47Michael Mulligan: Well, you know, is that a good enough shelter space, and how far away should that be, and what are the requirements?
- 21:51Michael Mulligan: And does there have to be a staff member there?
- 21:53Michael Mulligan: And what about food?
- 21:54Michael Mulligan: There's no shower, and so forth, and so different judges have interpreted that in a different way, and I suppose, rather than trying to go back to the court of appeal and argue about what is the constitutional requirement here, this piece of legislation would attempt to define that.
- 22:15Michael Mulligan: I guess another question would be whether they are able to make that decision, because ultimately it's a constitutional assessment as to whether a person has the right to put up a shelter.
- 22:26Michael Mulligan: But these are the elements that at least the government's proposing be there for that analysis of whether there is an alternative and whether there can be a by-law that would restrict somebody from putting up a shelter in a park.
- 22:41Adam Stirling: All right, that's all the time we have for today, michael Mulligan, but fascinating as always, thank you.
- 22:45Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 22:47Adam Stirling: Have a great day.
- 22:47Adam Stirling: All right, you too, legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour every Thursday on CFAQ's 1070.