Latest / The Checkout Point / Week 41 - Google Enters the Checkout Wars: A Record $275 Billion Holiday Forecast, the Agentic Commerce Standards Fight, and WP Engine's Antitrust Twist
Transcript
- 0:05[Max] Welcome to The Checkout Point, your quick dive into this week's ecommerce
- 0:08[Max] buzz with me, Alex, powered by BLIK.
- 0:12[Max] These 20 minutes pack the latest trends, news, and insights.
- 0:15[Max] Let's navigate the digital marketplace together.
- 0:18[Max] Ready?
- 0:19[Max] Let's go.
- 0:27[Rachel] Okay, okay.
- 0:28[Rachel] Before we even start, did you see the number for this holiday
- 0:31[Rachel] season?
- 0:32[Speaker 3] Which number, Max?
- 0:33[Speaker 3] There's like four flying around.
- 0:36[Rachel] The big one, the one that made me spit out my coffee
- 0:38[Rachel] this morning.
- 0:40[Speaker 3] You're a simple man.
- 0:42[Speaker 3] Big numbers do things to you.
- 0:44[Rachel] This is The Checkout Point.
- 0:46[Rachel] I'm Rachel, that's Max, and apparently he's already losing it in the
- 0:50[Rachel] first 30 seconds.
- 0:51[Rachel] Guilty.
- 0:52[Rachel] But seriously, wait till you hear this thing.
- 0:54[Speaker 3] I've seen it.
- 0:55[Speaker 3] I'm still not over it.
- 0:57[Rachel] And here's the part that's gonna bug people.
- 0:59[Rachel] A huge chunk of it isn't even coming from people clicking around
- 1:02[Rachel] like normal.
- 1:03[Speaker 3] Right.
- 1:04[Speaker 3] It's coming from somewhere else entirely.
- 1:07[Rachel] Somewhere weirder.
- 1:10[Speaker 3] Ominous.
- 1:12[Rachel] Seriously, once I tell you where it's coming from, you're gonna get
- 1:14[Rachel] why I choked on my coffee.
- 1:16[Speaker 3] Now I really wanna know.
- 1:18[Rachel] I mean, come on.
- 1:19[Rachel] Once you hear where the traffic's actually coming from, you're gonna ask
- 1:22[Rachel] the same question I did.
- 1:24[Speaker 3] Which is?
- 1:25[Rachel] Who actually owns the checkout button anymore?
- 1:28[Speaker 3] Yeah, that's not a small question.
- 1:31[Rachel] It is not.
- 1:32[Rachel] And it gets messier before it gets clearer, trust me.
- 1:35[Speaker 3] Okay, now you have to just tell me the number.
- 1:38[Rachel] Patience.
- 1:40[Speaker 3] Fine, fine.
- 1:41[Rachel] Okay, okay, deep breath.
- 1:43[Rachel] It's a big number.
- 1:44[Rachel] It's got layers, and there's a twist buried in it that took
- 1:46[Rachel] me by surprise.
- 1:48[Speaker 3] A twist?
- 1:49[Speaker 3] Now you're just teasing me on purpose.
- 1:52[Rachel] Alright, alright.
- 1:52[Rachel] Let's start with the forecast itself because it's the biggest one anyone's
- 1:56[Rachel] put out yet.
- 2:02[Rachel] Okay, so Adobe just dropped their Holiday forecast, and I need you
- 2:05[Rachel] to sit down for this one.
- 2:07[Speaker 3] I'm sitting.
- 2:07[Speaker 3] Hit me.
- 2:08[Rachel] Actually, hold on.
- 2:09[Rachel] Before I give you the top line figure, let me set the
- 2:11[Rachel] stage.
- 2:12[Rachel] This is Adobe's own numbers, not some analyst guessing from the sidelines.
- 2:16[Speaker 3] Okay, so this is the horse's mouth.
- 2:18[Speaker 3] I like that.
- 2:19[Rachel] Two hundred and seventy-five point one billion dollars.
- 2:23[Rachel] That's what they're projecting for US online holiday shopping this season.
- 2:27[Speaker 3] Wait, that's a record?
- 2:28[Rachel] Record.
- 2:29[Rachel] Up six point seven percent from last year.
- 2:32[Speaker 3] Okay, six point seven doesn't sound crazy on its own.
- 2:35[Speaker 3] What's driving it?
- 2:37[Rachel] Well, hold that thought because the what's driving it answer is basically
- 2:40[Rachel] the whole segment.
- 2:41[Speaker 3] Great.
- 2:42[Speaker 3] No pressure then.
- 2:43[Rachel] That's Adobe's own release from September 28th, and Adweek picked it up
- 2:46[Rachel] the same day.
- 2:47[Speaker 3] Right.
- 2:47[Speaker 3] I saw the Adweek piece too.
- 2:49[Speaker 3] They frame it as AI tools and buy now, pay later, basically
- 2:53[Speaker 3] propping up spending while people are still kind of squeezed.
- 2:55[Rachel] Exactly.
- 2:56[Rachel] Value hunting, but still spending.
- 2:58[Rachel] And get this, October alone is expected to pull in ninety-five point
- 3:03[Rachel] eight billion just from online.
- 3:05[Speaker 3] That's just one month.
- 3:06[Rachel] Yeah.
- 3:07[Rachel] And remember, that's not the whole season.
- 3:09[Rachel] That's just people getting a head start before Halloween candy is even
- 3:12[Rachel] off shelves.
- 3:13[Speaker 3] Which tells you shoppers aren't waiting for Black Friday deals to start
- 3:16[Speaker 3] spending.
- 3:17[Rachel] One month.
- 3:18[Rachel] And Prime Day, that's October sixth and seventh this year, projected at
- 3:21[Rachel] nine point nine billion.
- 3:23[Speaker 3] For two days?
- 3:24[Rachel] For two days.
- 3:25[Rachel] Up nine point two percent year over year.
- 3:28[Speaker 3] Okay, that's wild.
- 3:29[Speaker 3] What about Cyber Week?
- 3:30[Rachel] Forty-seven point five billion.
- 3:32[Speaker 3] Wait, wait.
- 3:33[Speaker 3] Forty-seven billion in like five days?
- 3:36[Rachel] Five days.
- 3:37[Rachel] I had to read that stat twice.
- 3:38[Speaker 3] That's basically the entire GDP of a small country crammed into a
- 3:42[Speaker 3] long weekend of turkey leftovers and doorbusters.
- 3:45[Rachel] Yeah.
- 3:45[Rachel] That's basically Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday, basically carrying almost a tenth of
- 3:50[Rachel] the whole season.
- 3:51[Speaker 3] I mean, come on.
- 3:51[Speaker 3] That math is nuts when you say it out loud.
- 3:54[Rachel] And that's before we even get to the part that made me
- 3:56[Rachel] do a double take.
- 3:57[Speaker 3] Oh, here we go.
- 3:58[Rachel] Right?
- 3:59[Rachel] But here's the number that actually stopped me.
- 4:01[Rachel] AI-assisted traffic to US retail sites is projected to jump a hundred
- 4:06[Rachel] and thirty percent year over year this holiday season.
- 4:09[Speaker 3] One hundred and thirty percent?
- 4:12[Rachel] Not like ten, not twenty, a hundred and thirty.
- 4:16[Speaker 3] One hundred and thirty.
- 4:17[Speaker 3] Just so I'm tracking, that's not total traffic.
- 4:19[Speaker 3] That's specifically stuff Adobe is attributing to AI assistants and tools sending
- 4:24[Speaker 3] people to retail sites.
- 4:26[Rachel] Right.
- 4:26[Rachel] This isn't just traffic is up.
- 4:28[Rachel] This is traffic that showed up already primed because some chatbot told
- 4:32[Rachel] them exactly what to buy and where.
- 4:34[Speaker 3] Where's that traffic even coming from, though?
- 4:36[Speaker 3] Like, is that chatbots sending people to sites?
- 4:39[Rachel] Basically, yeah.
- 4:40[Rachel] Tools like that recommending products and pushing people straight to checkout pages
- 4:44[Rachel] instead of a regular search result.
- 4:46[Speaker 3] So it's not even really traffic in the old sense.
- 4:49[Speaker 3] It's more like referrals with intent already baked in.
- 4:52[Rachel] Exactly.
- 4:53[Rachel] And that's a totally different animal to design a checkout flow around.
- 4:57[Speaker 3] So people aren't browsing anymore.
- 4:58[Speaker 3] They're getting handed a link and told, "Go buy this."
- 5:01[Rachel] It's less like window shopping and more like somebody handing you a
- 5:04[Rachel] shopping list already filled out.
- 5:06[Speaker 3] Which is efficient for the shopper, sure, but it changes what a
- 5:09[Speaker 3] retailer even needs to optimize for.
- 5:12[Rachel] Kinda, yeah.
- 5:13[Rachel] And that's genuinely a different shape of traffic than retailers are used
- 5:16[Rachel] to planning around.
- 5:17[Speaker 3] So if a huge chunk of your holiday traffic is coming in
- 5:20[Speaker 3] through some AI assistant instead of your own site or app, who's
- 5:24[Speaker 3] actually running that checkout experience?
- 5:26[Rachel] It's the question every retail exec I talk to is quietly panicking
- 5:30[Rachel] about right now.
- 5:31[Speaker 3] Because normally you just say, well, whoever built the storefront owns the
- 5:35[Speaker 3] checkout.
- 5:36[Speaker 3] That assumption doesn't hold anymore.
- 5:38[Rachel] Right.
- 5:38[Rachel] Is it the retailer's page?
- 5:39[Rachel] Is it happening inside the chat window?
- 5:42[Rachel] Nobody's really settled that.
- 5:43[Speaker 3] Because if I'm running a retention model and half my new traffic
- 5:47[Speaker 3] is arriving pre-qualified through a bot, I wanna know who owns that
- 5:50[Speaker 3] relationship afterward.
- 5:52[Rachel] Yeah, and that's the uncomfortable bit, right?
- 5:54[Rachel] You might get the sale, but you don't necessarily get the customer.
- 5:57[Speaker 3] Right.
- 5:58[Speaker 3] The assistant could just as easily send that same shopper to your
- 6:01[Speaker 3] competitor next time, and you'd never even know why.
- 6:04[Rachel] Totally.
- 6:04[Rachel] And normally I'd say we wait a quarter or two and see
- 6:07[Rachel] how it shakes out.
- 6:08[Speaker 3] Because normally that's exactly how these things play out, right?
- 6:11[Speaker 3] Everybody waits, watches the data trickle in, adjusts slowly.
- 6:16[Rachel] Yeah, slow and steady.
- 6:17[Rachel] Nobody panics.
- 6:18[Rachel] It's fine.
- 6:18[Speaker 3] But?
- 6:19[Rachel] But that question just got a very loud answer.
- 6:23[Rachel] Google's throwing its own thing into the mix.
- 6:25[Speaker 3] Wait, hold on, back up.
- 6:26[Speaker 3] Very loud answer.
- 6:27[Speaker 3] How loud are we talking?
- 6:29[Rachel] Like, they didn't whisper it in a footnote.
- 6:31[Rachel] They put it on stage at their biggest retail event of the
- 6:33[Rachel] year.
- 6:34[Speaker 3] Wait.
- 6:34[Speaker 3] Google's doing what now?
- 6:36[Rachel] Oh, we're getting into it.
- 6:37[Rachel] It's a whole move.
- 6:44[Rachel] So Google didn't just show up to NRF 2026 with a keynote
- 6:47[Rachel] about search ads.
- 6:49[Speaker 3] They didn't?
- 6:50[Rachel] Nope.
- 6:50[Rachel] Sundar Pichai gets on stage and basically says, "Hey, we built our
- 6:54[Rachel] own checkout thing.
- 6:56[Rachel] It's called the Universal Commerce Protocol, UCP for short."
- 7:00[Speaker 3] Okay, break that down for me.
- 7:02[Speaker 3] What does it actually let a retailer do?
- 7:04[Rachel] According to Google's own write-up of the remarks, retailers can offer checkout
- 7:08[Rachel] and personalized deals right inside Search and inside Gemini.
- 7:12[Rachel] Like, no leaving the app, no redirect.
- 7:14[Rachel] You just buy the thing where you already are.
- 7:17[Speaker 3] Huh.
- 7:18[Speaker 3] So Search becomes a storefront.
- 7:21[Rachel] Kind of, yeah.
- 7:22[Rachel] And get this, in the same remarks, he also talks about expanding
- 7:25[Rachel] Wing, their delivery drone thing.
- 7:28[Speaker 3] Wait, drones in the middle of a checkout announcement?
- 7:32[Rachel] I know.
- 7:33[Rachel] It's a weird flex.
- 7:34[Rachel] Like, one breath, it's, "We're rebuilding the payment layer of the internet."
- 7:38[Rachel] Next breath, it's, "Also drones."
- 7:40[Speaker 3] That's very Google.
- 7:42[Speaker 3] Throw everything at the wall at once.
- 7:44[Rachel] Right?
- 7:45[Speaker 3] Honestly, the drone mention almost feels like a flex just to remind
- 7:48[Speaker 3] everybody Google's got fingers in every pie.
- 7:51[Rachel] Right.
- 7:52[Rachel] Also, we deliver packages by air as a footnote to we're rebuilding
- 7:56[Rachel] checkout.
- 7:57[Speaker 3] Okay, but the drone thing, low priority for me.
- 7:59[Speaker 3] The protocol part, who's actually behind it?
- 8:02[Rachel] This is where it gets real.
- 8:04[Rachel] PYMNTS reported the list of partners who built this thing with Google,
- 8:08[Rachel] and it's not small.
- 8:10[Rachel] Shopify, Etsy, Wayfair, Target, Walmart.
- 8:14[Speaker 3] Hold on.
- 8:15[Speaker 3] Walmart and Target both signed on to the same Google-built thing?
- 8:20[Rachel] Yep.
- 8:21[Rachel] And then on the payment side, you've got endorsements from Adyen, American
- 8:25[Rachel] Express, Mastercard, Stripe, and Visa.
- 8:29[Speaker 3] Stripe endorsed it?
- 8:30[Rachel] Stripe endorsed it.
- 8:32[Speaker 3] Okay, that's the part that gets me.
- 8:34[Speaker 3] Stripe is the one running checkout with OpenAI, so they're building the
- 8:38[Speaker 3] rival rail and also signing off on Google's rail?
- 8:41[Rachel] That's what it says.
- 8:42[Speaker 3] That's not a company picking a side.
- 8:44[Speaker 3] That's a company hedging every side.
- 8:47[Rachel] Which honestly, smart.
- 8:49[Rachel] If you're the plumbing, you don't care whose faucet turns on.
- 8:52[Speaker 3] Sure.
- 8:52[Speaker 3] Smart for Stripe, sure.
- 8:54[Speaker 3] Frustrating if you're the one actually trying to build a roadmap around
- 8:57[Speaker 3] it.
- 8:58[Rachel] Totally fair.
- 8:59[Rachel] It's easy to hedge when you're the pipes and not the storefront.
- 9:02[Speaker 3] Sure, but from a merchant seat, that's a different story.
- 9:05[Speaker 3] If I'm running checkout for a mid-sized retailer, I don't get the
- 9:08[Speaker 3] luxury of hedging.
- 9:09[Speaker 3] I have to pick what I build against.
- 9:11[Rachel] Right.
- 9:12[Rachel] And Google's own language here is interesting too.
- 9:14[Rachel] Their quote is that UCP, quote, "Establishes a common language for agents
- 9:19[Rachel] and systems to operate together," end quote.
- 9:21[Speaker 3] A common language.
- 9:23[Speaker 3] Okay.
- 9:24[Speaker 3] Common according to who, though?
- 9:25[Rachel] That's the question, right?
- 9:26[Speaker 3] Because Amazon's got Rufus doing its own thing.
- 9:29[Speaker 3] OpenAI and Stripe have their agentic checkout, and now Google's saying, "No,
- 9:34[Speaker 3] no, we're the common language."
- 9:36[Rachel] There isn't exactly a UN for checkout protocols.
- 9:39[Speaker 3] There should be.
- 9:41[Rachel] Somebody pitch that.
- 9:41[Speaker 3] Honestly, I don't think anyone's coming to referee this.
- 9:44[Speaker 3] It's just going to get sorted out by whoever wins adoption.
- 9:47[Rachel] Which historically in tech takes years and leaves at least one format
- 9:51[Rachel] basically abandoned in a drawer somewhere.
- 9:53[Speaker 3] But step back for a second.
- 9:55[Speaker 3] This actually reframes something we were just talking about.
- 9:59[Speaker 3] We were treating this like OpenAI and Stripe had this lane basically
- 10:03[Speaker 3] to themselves, like they were early, they'd get first mover advantage, done
- 10:07[Speaker 3] deal.
- 10:08[Rachel] Right.
- 10:08[Rachel] That was kind of the assumption.
- 10:09[Speaker 3] And now you've got Target, Walmart, Shopify, Etsy, Wayfair, plus five of
- 10:15[Speaker 3] the biggest payment networks on Earth all lined up behind a completely
- 10:19[Speaker 3] separate Google-built standard.
- 10:21[Speaker 3] That's not a scrappy challenger.
- 10:23[Speaker 3] It's half of American retail supply chain showing up on day one.
- 10:27[Rachel] It's not nothing.
- 10:28[Speaker 3] It's the retail equivalent of showing up to a fight with the
- 10:31[Speaker 3] entire supply chain standing behind you.
- 10:34[Rachel] And remember, none of these partners are small players who can be
- 10:37[Rachel] bullied into switching later.
- 10:38[Rachel] Once Walmart integrates something, it's there.
- 10:41[Speaker 3] It's not nothing at all.
- 10:42[Speaker 3] And here's what gets me about the timing.
- 10:45[Speaker 3] This dropped at NRF, which is basically the Super Bowl for retail
- 10:48[Speaker 3] executives.
- 10:49[Speaker 3] Every buyer in that room just heard two different companies tell them,
- 10:53[Speaker 3] "Build on us."
- 10:55[Rachel] In the same week, practically.
- 10:56[Speaker 3] In the same week.
- 10:58[Rachel] So if you're one of those retail execs sitting in that audience,
- 11:01[Rachel] you walk out of NRF thinking you had one homework assignment, learn
- 11:04[Rachel] the new checkout standard, and now you've got two.
- 11:06[Speaker 3] Which honestly might be the most realistic outcome of all this.
- 11:10[Speaker 3] Nobody actually consolidates.
- 11:12[Speaker 3] Everybody just builds twice.
- 11:14[Rachel] Twice the integration work, twice the testing, twice the headache come Q4.
- 11:18[Speaker 3] At least two.
- 11:19[Rachel] Yeah.
- 11:20[Rachel] And honestly, probably more than two once you count whatever Amazon and
- 11:23[Rachel] everybody else is cooking.
- 11:24[Rachel] It's less learn the new standard checkout and more pick your fighter
- 11:27[Rachel] and maybe pick three.
- 11:29[Speaker 3] And that's before you even factor in whatever homegrown thing Amazon eventually
- 11:33[Speaker 3] rolls out because you know they will.
- 11:35[Rachel] Oh, 100%.
- 11:36[Rachel] Nobody builds the biggest storefront on Earth and just sits out a
- 11:39[Rachel] standards fight.
- 11:40[Speaker 3] Which is exactly the mess we need to get into because picking
- 11:44[Speaker 3] one horse in this race might not even be an option anymore.
- 11:52[Rachel] Okay, so three standards.
- 11:53[Rachel] Three.
- 11:54[Speaker 3] Not two.
- 11:56[Speaker 3] Three feels like a lot for something that used to just be
- 11:59[Speaker 3] type in your card number.
- 12:00[Rachel] Welcome to the future.
- 12:01[Rachel] Apparently, it comes with acronyms attached.
- 12:04[Speaker 3] Yeah, I saw that breakdown too.
- 12:05[Speaker 3] You've got Stripe and OpenAI's version.
- 12:08[Speaker 3] That's ACP, built for checkout inside ChatGPT.
- 12:12[Rachel] Right, the one we've been talking about all year.
- 12:14[Speaker 3] Then Google's got UCP, which we just walked through.
- 12:17[Speaker 3] That's the Gemini and AI mode play.
- 12:20[Rachel] And then there's a third one nobody's mentioned yet.
- 12:22[Speaker 3] MCP, Anthropic's version.
- 12:25[Rachel] Of course, Anthropic has one too.
- 12:27[Rachel] Everybody's got one.
- 12:28[Speaker 3] At some point, you have to wonder if everybody's got one is
- 12:31[Speaker 3] just gonna be the default state of tech forever.
- 12:33[Rachel] Honestly, probably.
- 12:35[Rachel] Every platform wants to own the rail once they realize commerce runs
- 12:38[Rachel] through it.
- 12:39[Speaker 3] It's not really surprising, though.
- 12:40[Speaker 3] Every big model company wants its own rail into your store.
- 12:44[Rachel] Sure, but from a merchant seat, that's exhausting.
- 12:46[Rachel] You're integrating three different plumbing systems for basically the same job.
- 12:50[Speaker 3] And it's not like these three are in any way remotely similar
- 12:54[Speaker 3] under the hood, so it's not copy-paste work between them.
- 12:57[Rachel] Right.
- 12:57[Rachel] It's basically three separate engineering projects wearing the same trench coat.
- 13:01[Speaker 3] Which is exactly the conclusion this analysis landed on.
- 13:04[Speaker 3] Most retailers are going to need to support at least two of
- 13:08[Speaker 3] these, not pick one and walk away.
- 13:10[Rachel] At least two.
- 13:11[Speaker 3] At least two.
- 13:12[Rachel] Because you don't know yet which assistant your customer showed up from.
- 13:16[Speaker 3] So if you're running a mid-size store, you're basically building for ChatGPT
- 13:20[Speaker 3] traffic and Gemini traffic at the same time.
- 13:24[Rachel] Probably, yeah, and maybe Claude traffic down the road if Anthropic pushes
- 13:28[Rachel] commerce harder.
- 13:29[Speaker 3] It's wild that which chatbot the customer happened to open is now
- 13:33[Speaker 3] a variable in your engineering roadmap.
- 13:35[Rachel] It genuinely is.
- 13:37[Rachel] Five years ago, that sentence wouldn't have meant anything to anybody.
- 13:40[Speaker 3] That's a lot of dev time for something that used to just
- 13:42[Speaker 3] be, you know, a checkout page and a credit card form.
- 13:46[Rachel] Well, welcome to twenty twenty-six.
- 13:48[Speaker 3] I mean, remember when the biggest technical decision a retailer made was
- 13:51[Speaker 3] picking a shopping cart plugin?
- 13:53[Rachel] Simpler times, genuinely.
- 13:56[Rachel] Fair.
- 13:56[Speaker 3] Honestly, this is starting to remind me of the payment method sprawl
- 14:00[Speaker 3] retailers already deal with.
- 14:01[Speaker 3] You don't pick one wallet, you support, like, six.
- 14:04[Rachel] Right.
- 14:05[Rachel] Nobody standardized on one wallet either, and somehow the industry just learned
- 14:09[Rachel] to live with it.
- 14:10[Speaker 3] Because the alternative is telling half your customers, "Sorry, we don't take
- 14:13[Speaker 3] your money," and no merchant wants that conversation.
- 14:16[Rachel] Oh, speaking of payment method sprawl, did you catch the BLIK news
- 14:19[Rachel] this week?
- 14:20[Speaker 3] I did.
- 14:21[Speaker 3] That's a good one, actually.
- 14:22[Rachel] BLIK just joined Stripe's Dynamic Payments, and now merchants in over thirty
- 14:26[Rachel] countries can automatically offer it to shoppers in Poland.
- 14:29[Speaker 3] Automatically, which is the part I like.
- 14:32[Speaker 3] You're not building a separate integration for one market.
- 14:34[Speaker 3] Stripe just turns it on for you.
- 14:36[Rachel] That's the dream, honestly.
- 14:37[Rachel] Flip a switch instead of writing new code every time a new
- 14:40[Rachel] local payment method shows up.
- 14:42[Speaker 3] If only checkout standards worked that way instead of needing three separate
- 14:46[Speaker 3] integrations.
- 14:47[Rachel] Right.
- 14:47[Rachel] And buried in that same announcement, Stripe flagged agentic commerce as an
- 14:51[Rachel] area they're working on jointly with BLIK.
- 14:53[Speaker 3] Which tells you this isn't just a regional payment story.
- 14:56[Rachel] Exactly.
- 14:57[Rachel] It's the same land grab, just wearing a Polish flag this time
- 15:00[Rachel] instead of a search results page.
- 15:02[Speaker 3] Everywhere you look this year, it's the same fight in a different
- 15:05[Speaker 3] outfit.
- 15:06[Rachel] Now it's the same fight showing up again.
- 15:08[Rachel] Every rail wants to be the one that plugs into the agent.
- 15:11[Speaker 3] It really is starting to look like nobody wins this outright, not
- 15:14[Speaker 3] this year anyway.
- 15:15[Rachel] Which is a weirdly honest place for an industry to land, actually.
- 15:19[Rachel] Usually everybody pretends there's a clear winner when there isn't.
- 15:22[Speaker 3] Yeah.
- 15:22[Speaker 3] Nobody's writing a press release that says, "We're still figuring it out,"
- 15:26[Speaker 3] but that's basically where we are.
- 15:28[Rachel] So where does that leave a merchant listening right now trying to
- 15:30[Rachel] plan next quarter?
- 15:32[Speaker 3] Build for more than one.
- 15:33[Speaker 3] Don't bet the roadmap on ACP or UCP winning outright because right
- 15:37[Speaker 3] now there's no evidence either one is gonna eat the other.
- 15:40[Rachel] So basically insure yourself.
- 15:42[Speaker 3] Pretty much.
- 15:43[Speaker 3] Support multiple rails, keep your checkout flexible, and let the traffic tell
- 15:47[Speaker 3] you which assistant your customers actually prefer.
- 15:49[Rachel] And honestly, that data will probably tell you more about your customers
- 15:53[Rachel] than any survey ever could.
- 15:55[Speaker 3] Way more, because it's what they're actually doing, not what they say
- 15:58[Speaker 3] they do on a form.
- 15:59[Rachel] Which, honestly, might just settle itself over the next year without anyone
- 16:03[Rachel] declaring a winner.
- 16:04[Speaker 3] Could be.
- 16:05[Speaker 3] Or it drags on for years like every other standards fight in
- 16:08[Speaker 3] tech.
- 16:09[Rachel] True, true.
- 16:11[Rachel] All right, before we wrap this one up, we've got a handful
- 16:14[Rachel] of other stories from the week worth a quick lap around.
- 16:17[Speaker 3] Yeah, a few smaller ones that are worth mentioning before we go.
- 16:24[Rachel] Okay, quick lap.
- 16:25[Rachel] Four stories.
- 16:26[Rachel] Let's go.
- 16:27[Rachel] First one's messy.
- 16:28[Rachel] WP Engine versus Automattic, the antitrust fight.
- 16:31[Rachel] Remember that?
- 16:32[Speaker 3] Four stories.
- 16:33[Speaker 3] Let's see how fast we can actually get through these without going
- 16:35[Speaker 3] on a tangent.
- 16:36[Rachel] No promises.
- 16:37[Speaker 3] Oh, the whole Matt Mullenweg thing.
- 16:39[Speaker 3] That's still going?
- 16:41[Rachel] Still going.
- 16:42[Rachel] A judge just declined to toss WP Engine's antitrust claims against Automattic
- 16:46[Rachel] and Mullenweg himself.
- 16:48[Speaker 3] So the lawsuit survives.
- 16:50[Rachel] Mostly, yeah.
- 16:51[Rachel] But Automattic's not walking away empty-handed either.
- 16:53[Rachel] They got seven of the claims against them dismissed.
- 16:57[Speaker 3] So both sides get to claim a win in their press release.
- 17:00[Rachel] Honestly, that's how most of these platform lawsuits go.
- 17:02[Rachel] Nobody gets a clean knockout.
- 17:04[Rachel] Everybody just limps into the next filing deadline.
- 17:06[Speaker 3] Meanwhile, WP Engine customers are just sitting there hoping their hosting doesn't
- 17:10[Speaker 3] become collateral damage.
- 17:12[Rachel] Basically, nobody's popping champagne, but nobody's folding either.
- 17:16[Speaker 3] Speaking of things nobody expected to still be dragging on, the UK
- 17:20[Speaker 3] just said it wants to take services back from outsourcing giants.
- 17:24[Rachel] Wait, back?
- 17:25[Rachel] Like bring it in-house?
- 17:27[Speaker 3] Yeah, actual in-house teams instead of a contractor's contractor's contractor running your
- 17:32[Speaker 3] pension system.
- 17:34[Rachel] Which when you say it like that sounds like it should've been
- 17:36[Rachel] the plan from day one.
- 17:37[Speaker 3] Yeah.
- 17:38[Speaker 3] Whitehall's setting up a new unit specifically to review critical contracts.
- 17:42[Rachel] Why now, though?
- 17:43[Speaker 3] The Capita Pensions mess.
- 17:45[Speaker 3] That apparently made the case for doing it themselves a lot easier
- 17:49[Speaker 3] to sell internally.
- 17:51[Rachel] Ha.
- 17:51[Rachel] Nothing motivates a government department like watching someone else screw up pensions.
- 17:56[Speaker 3] It really is the oldest story in government contracting.
- 17:59[Speaker 3] Outsource it, it goes fine for years, then one bad headline and
- 18:03[Speaker 3] suddenly insourcing is the responsible choice again.
- 18:06[Rachel] The pendulum just swings back and forth forever, doesn't it?
- 18:09[Speaker 3] Right?
- 18:10[Speaker 3] Nothing like a public failure to make in-house look cheap by comparison.
- 18:14[Rachel] Okay, moving to something actually cheerful for once.
- 18:17[Rachel] eMarketer just bought the research arm of RetailX.
- 18:20[Speaker 3] Oh, I didn't see that.
- 18:21[Rachel] It's one of those deals that doesn't make headlines outside the industry,
- 18:24[Rachel] but if you actually use these firms' data, it changes who you're
- 18:27[Rachel] calling for numbers next quarter.
- 18:29[Speaker 3] Fewer independent voices in the room, more of it living under one
- 18:32[Speaker 3] roof.
- 18:33[Rachel] Yeah, the whole thing.
- 18:34[Rachel] RetailX's research team, their tools, and their rankings all folding into eMarketer's
- 18:39[Rachel] retail and e-commerce coverage.
- 18:41[Speaker 3] Consolidation in the data and insights world.
- 18:44[Speaker 3] Feels fitting for this episode, honestly.
- 18:46[Rachel] It's funny, we spend half this episode talking about companies merging their
- 18:49[Rachel] tech stacks, and here's two research shops literally merging their spreadsheets.
- 18:55[Speaker 3] Same instinct, though.
- 18:56[Speaker 3] Bigger footprint, fewer competitors telling a different story with different numbers.
- 19:00[Rachel] Right.
- 19:00[Rachel] Everybody's merging, everybody's picking teams.
- 19:03[Rachel] Even the people who tell us what's happening are merging with each
- 19:06[Rachel] other.
- 19:07[Speaker 3] Very meta.
- 19:08[Rachel] Last one, and this one is the one that actually made me
- 19:10[Rachel] sit up.
- 19:11[Rachel] A localization benchmark just ran seven hundred seventy-four AI translation outputs, English
- 19:17[Rachel] to Chinese.
- 19:18[Speaker 3] And?
- 19:19[Rachel] And human translators lost.
- 19:21[Rachel] Four out of six content types, the AI workflow beat them.
- 19:25[Speaker 3] Four out of six.
- 19:26[Speaker 3] That's not close.
- 19:27[Rachel] Yeah, and remember, this isn't some tiny sample either.
- 19:30[Rachel] This was hundreds of outputs they ran through.
- 19:32[Speaker 3] Which makes it harder to wave away as a fluke.
- 19:35[Rachel] Not close at all.
- 19:36[Rachel] And the twist is, which model they used mattered more than how
- 19:40[Rachel] much a human polished it afterward.
- 19:42[Speaker 3] So the editing pass isn't the lever people think it is.
- 19:45[Rachel] Nope.
- 19:46[Rachel] Pick the right model, apparently, and the human touch-up barely moves the
- 19:49[Rachel] needle.
- 19:50[Speaker 3] So the lesson for anybody running a localization team isn't hire less,
- 19:55[Speaker 3] it's pick your tools more carefully before you even bring in a
- 19:59[Speaker 3] human.
- 19:59[Rachel] Right.
- 20:00[Rachel] The model choice is doing most of the heavy lifting here, and
- 20:02[Rachel] the editing pass is just cleanup.
- 20:05[Speaker 3] That's gonna make a lot of localization teams nervous.
- 20:08[Rachel] It should.
- 20:09[Rachel] If you built a whole career on being the safety net after
- 20:11[Rachel] the machine does the first pass, that safety net's getting thinner.
- 20:15[Speaker 3] Not gone, just thinner.
- 20:17[Speaker 3] There's still a place for the human, it's just a smaller room.
- 20:21[Rachel] I mean, come on, every one of these stories, whether it's lawsuits,
- 20:24[Rachel] government contracts, research firms merging, or a translation benchmark, it's the same
- 20:30[Rachel] thread: payments, platforms, research.
- 20:33[Rachel] Everybody's repositioning for a year that's gonna run on AI, whether they're
- 20:37[Rachel] ready or not.
- 20:38[Speaker 3] It's kind of funny how none of these four stories are even
- 20:41[Speaker 3] about the same industry, and yet you can draw the same line
- 20:45[Speaker 3] through all of them.
- 20:46[Rachel] That's usually the sign a trend is real, honestly, when it shows
- 20:48[Rachel] up in places that had nothing to do with each other.
- 20:51[Speaker 3] Yeah, and honestly, that's the frame for the whole episode we just
- 20:54[Speaker 3] did.
- 20:55[Speaker 3] The forecast, Google's move, the standards fight, all of it is the
- 20:59[Speaker 3] same repositioning, just with bigger dollar signs attached.
- 21:03[Rachel] Bigger dollar signs is right.
- 21:04[Speaker 3] So let's actually put a bow on this thing.
- 21:13[Rachel] That ship's kinda sailed.
- 21:14[Speaker 3] Right.
- 21:14[Speaker 3] Build your integrations so you're not locked into a single vendor's plumbing.
- 21:19[Speaker 3] If Google's version stalls or Stripe's changes shape, you want your checkout
- 21:24[Speaker 3] still working.
- 21:25[Rachel] It's basically insurance.
- 21:26[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 21:27[Speaker 3] And with the traffic numbers we saw this week, the checkout flow
- 21:30[Speaker 3] itself is turning into a bigger piece of your margin than people
- 21:34[Speaker 3] think.
- 21:34[Speaker 3] Test now, not in December.
- 21:37[Rachel] That's fair.
- 21:37[Rachel] And honestly, it's cheaper to test the second checkout path now than
- 21:40[Rachel] to explain to your boss in January why the AI traffic bounced.
- 21:44[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 21:45[Speaker 3] A broken rail in December costs you way more than a few
- 21:48[Speaker 3] extra hours of dev time in October.
- 21:51[Rachel] Okay, that's the responsible answer.
- 21:53[Rachel] Mine's dimmer.
- 21:55[Speaker 3] Go ahead.
- 21:56[Rachel] I just think it's funny that everybody's fighting over who gets to
- 21:58[Rachel] be the robot's favorite store.
- 22:00[Rachel] Like, the AI walks in and three different checkout systems are all
- 22:02[Rachel] waving their arms going, "Pick me, pick me."
- 22:05[Speaker 3] That's basically what happened this week.
- 22:07[Rachel] It really is.
- 22:09[Rachel] Anyway, that's it for us this week.
- 22:10[Rachel] Thanks so much for hanging out and listening.
- 22:12[Speaker 3] If you liked the episode, follow the show wherever you're listening so
- 22:15[Speaker 3] you don't miss next week.
- 22:17[Rachel] We'll be back with more numbers, more chaos, probably another new acronym
- 22:21[Rachel] nobody asked for.
- 22:22[Speaker 3] Probably.
- 22:23[Rachel] Take care, everybody.
- 22:25[Speaker 3] See you next week.