Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Why Consistency Beats the S&P 500 from now on?
Transcript
- 0:00You know that feeling when you're you're driving in a
- 0:02totally unfamiliar city and your GPS confidently tells you to
- 0:05turn right, but your own two eyes are looking directly at
- 0:09like a massive, uncrossable lake?
- 0:11Oh yeah, the classic technology versus reality standoff.
- 0:14It's it's a very specific kind of anxiety where you have to
- 0:18decide, yeah, do I trust the machine or do I trust my own
- 0:21senses? Right.
- 0:23And the standard advice is usually, well, trust the system.
- 0:25I mean, it's a machine, it computed the fastest route, it
- 0:28obviously knows better than you do.
- 0:29Sure, usually it does. But if you blindly follow it in
- 0:32that exact moment, you are going to literally end up underwater.
- 0:37And today we're looking at a financial road map that
- 0:39basically proves the standard advice like just blindly dumping
- 0:43your money into an S&P 500 index fund might actually literally
- 0:48drown your portfolio the next decade.
- 0:50Yeah, it's a huge shift. We're diving into this
- 0:52fascinating transcript from my first Million interview, and it
- 0:55just completely flips everything we know about compounding wealth
- 0:59upside down. It totally does, and our mission
- 1:02for this deep dive is to figure out how you know an ordinary
- 1:05person with a normal income could theoretically turn $10,000
- 1:09into $1,000,000 by 2025. Right, and without needing a PhD
- 1:12in finance or like a crystal ball, the time the market.
- 1:15Perfectly exactly. So whether you're sitting on a
- 1:17four O 1K or you're scraping together either your first
- 1:20savings, or maybe you're just insanely curious about how
- 1:23wealth actually compounds in the real world, we're going to
- 1:25explore a few counterintuitive absolute aha principles.
- 1:30And just a quick housekeeping note before we jump into all
- 1:33that. Oh, right, yes, go ahead.
- 1:35Yeah. So all the analysis we're doing
- 1:37today is based on publicly available sources and maybe
- 1:41subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 1:43All the contents from this channel are for educational and
- 1:47research purposes only. So you know does not constitute
- 1:49investment advice. Right.
- 1:51Always conduct your own due diligence before making any
- 1:53investment decisions. OK, let's unpack this.
- 1:56The most common universally agreed upon financial advice of
- 2:00like the last couple of decades is pretty simple, right?
- 2:03You buy a low cost S&P 500 index fund, you set it on autopilot
- 2:07and you go to Sloop. Yeah, it's the vanilla ice cream
- 2:09of finance. It's safe, diversified, easy.
- 2:12Right. But historically, that strategy
- 2:14yields what about a 10% return over the long term?
- 2:17Roughly, yeah. But the sources we're analyzing
- 2:20today, they drop a massive warning sign on that specific
- 2:23strategy for our current economic reality.
- 2:28And why is that? Well, they argue that right now
- 2:30you cannot simply go to sleep at the wheel with the S&P 500.
- 2:34The engine is dangerously overheated.
- 2:36OK, so this brings up some really vital data from JP Morgan
- 2:39that was in the transcript. Late in 2024 they published the
- 2:42scatter diagram and it tracked a very specific metric, right?
- 2:46Yes, the price to earnings ratio or PE ratio of the S&P 500.
- 2:50Right at the exact moment an investor bought in.
- 2:52And then they plotted that against the actual annualized
- 2:55return that investors saw over the following ten years.
- 2:58Which is such a brilliant way to look at it.
- 3:00But to really understand why this matters, we kind of need to
- 3:04demystify what APE ratio actually is for, you know,
- 3:09anyone who might not live and breathe finance.
- 3:11Yeah, please give us the simple version.
- 3:13OK, so think of it like buying a local bakery.
- 3:16If that bakery earns say $100,000 a year in pure profit
- 3:20and the owner asks you to pay $2.3 million to buy the
- 3:23business. Then you are paying 23 times its
- 3:26annual earnings. Exactly.
- 3:28You've paid such a massive premium upfront that even if the
- 3:32bakery thrives, you will not see a real compounding return on
- 3:36your investment for over a decade just to break even.
- 3:40OK. So applying that to the stock
- 3:42market, the higher the PE ratio you pay upfront, the lower your
- 3:46return is going to be over the next decade because you're just
- 3:48overpaying for the bakery. You're grossly overpaying.
- 3:50And the tragic number on that JP Morgan access was 23, right
- 3:54whenever the S&P 500's PE ratio hit 23.
- 3:57Historically, in every single case, with absolutely no
- 4:00exceptions, the investors annualized return over the next
- 4:0310 years was between 2% and -2%. Wait, really?
- 4:07No exception. Zero.
- 4:09It's basically a flat line. So the S&P 500 hit a PE of 23
- 4:13recently, meaning anyone buying in right now is mathematically
- 4:18locking themselves into a decade where their money does
- 4:21absolutely nothing. Pretty much it's just treading
- 4:24water. Or, you know, slowly sinking
- 4:26when you factor in inflation. Wow, so the GPS is actively
- 4:30pointing us into the lake? Exactly.
- 4:32And by the way, if you actually want to track that total market
- 4:35temperature yourself, you can search and download the iOS app
- 4:38called Buffett Indicator from the Apple App Store.
- 4:40It's a great tool for. That oh, nice, good tip.
- 4:42So if the broader market is too expensive to guarantee a return,
- 4:46our source material suggests a really fascinating Plan B.
- 4:49Yeah, treating Berkshire Hathaway Class B shares as your
- 4:52new index fund. Right.
- 4:54And the strategy is to simply dollar cost average into
- 4:56Berkshire, meaning you ignore the Daily News cycle.
- 4:59You blindly buy a set dollar amount every single month no
- 5:02matter what the stock price is doing.
- 5:04And just for those who might not know, Class B shares are just
- 5:07the accessible version of Berkshire stock.
- 5:09Because a single Class A share costs what, over half
- 5:12$1,000,000? Yeah, it's insane, but a Class B
- 5:15share is priced like a normal stock so regular people can
- 5:17actually buy it. Right.
- 5:19And the math on this compounding strategy is kind of mind blowing
- 5:22because of a concept called the Rule of 72.
- 5:25Oh I love the rule of 72. It's such a brilliant mental
- 5:28shortcut. Break it down for us.
- 5:29So if you want to know how long it takes an investment to double
- 5:32in value, you just divide the number 72 by your expected
- 5:36annual rate of return. OK, so if we assume a very
- 5:39reasonable 10% annual return for a huge corporate powerhouse like
- 5:44Berkshire, 72 / 10 is roughly 7. Yep, your money double s every
- 5:49seven years. And the source makes a great
- 5:51point here, which is that wealth is all about double S Like if
- 5:55you are a 20 something listener right now with $10,000 and you
- 5:58just let it sit there for 49 years.
- 6:00Which is 7 distinct doubling periods.
- 6:03Right, it goes from 10,000 to 204081632640 and then boom to
- 6:10$1.3 million. You get over 128 times your
- 6:14money just by sitting there watching paint dry.
- 6:17It's incredible math. But OK, I have to push back
- 6:19here. OK, let's hear.
- 6:21It isn't treating a single company, even one like Berkshire
- 6:24Hathaway, as an index fund. Kind of like trading a crowded
- 6:29sinking cruise ship for a really sturdy single lifeboat.
- 6:34I mean, I see where you're going with that.
- 6:35Like, how safe is that? Actually?
- 6:37We're putting all our financial faith in one corporate entity
- 6:40instead of 500 different companies.
- 6:42Well, if we look at the standard textbook definition of risk, you
- 6:45are absolutely right. But we have to redefine what
- 6:48risk actually is in the stock market, OK?
- 6:51The real risk doesn't typically come from a massive, highly
- 6:54diversified holding companies suddenly going bankrupt.
- 6:57The real risk comes from human behavior.
- 7:00Meaning, what exactly are you saying the risk isn't that a
- 7:03company fails, but that we as humans just do something stupid?
- 7:07Precisely when people get carefree and euphoric, their
- 7:10collective fear of missing out drives prices to these absurd
- 7:14heights. Right.
- 7:15Creating that PE ratio of 23 we just talked about.
- 7:18Exactly. They make the market precarious
- 7:20by overpaying. Conversely, when people are
- 7:23terrified by bad news, they suppress prices, practically
- 7:27giving away valuable assets. So how does Berkshire fit into
- 7:31that? Well, a vehicle like Berkshire
- 7:33is engineered specifically to prey on those exact human
- 7:37behavioral flaws. They hold billions of dollars in
- 7:40cash reserves and they do nothing.
- 7:42They just wait. Just sitting on it, yeah.
- 7:44And when human panic inevitably crashes the market, they use
- 7:48that cash to buy up incredible companies at a massive discount.
- 7:51Wow. So they are essentially a
- 7:53machine built to capitalize on our emotional breakdown.
- 7:57That's a great way. To put it, yeah.
- 7:58Which naturally brings us to the architect of that machine,
- 8:01Warren Buffett. Because if we are going to trust
- 8:03this alternative index, we kind of need to understand how the
- 8:06guy running it actually operates.
- 8:07And the transcript completely shatters the myth of the genius
- 8:10stock picker. Oh, it's a profound realization.
- 8:14Over his 58 years of running Berkshire, Buffett has made at
- 8:18least 400 distinct major investment decisions.
- 8:23OK. But the source points out that
- 8:25only twelve of those decisions actually moved the needle and
- 8:28created his legendary wealth. Wait, 1212 out of 400?
- 8:32Yep, just 12. Companies like See's Candies,
- 8:35Coca-Cola, American Express, GEICO, Gillette.
- 8:38That is a 4% hit rate. Just 4%.
- 8:41The greatest investor alive, the Oracle himself, gets the needle
- 8:45leaving calls right 4% of the time.
- 8:47So he's basically a baseball player batting .040, but when he
- 8:51hits a home run, the ball just stays in orbit for 50 years.
- 8:54That is the perfect way to visualize it, but we need to
- 8:57explain the mechanism of why a 4% hit rate actually works.
- 9:01Because in almost any other profession, a 4% success rate
- 9:04gets you fired immediately. Right, exactly.
- 9:07But in investing it works because of asymmetric risk.
- 9:09OK, let's unpack asymmetric risk.
- 9:11When you buy a stock, the absolute worst thing that can
- 9:14possibly happen is the company goes bankrupt, right?
- 9:17Right. You lose your money.
- 9:18Yeah. Your downside is capped at 100%.
- 9:21Yeah, you can only lose what you put in, but the upside?
- 9:24The upside is infinite. Mathematically, infinite A stock
- 9:27can go up 1000% or 10,000%. So when Buffett hits that golden
- 9:324%, the staggering math of compounding allows those few
- 9:37massive winners to completely eclipse the 96% of average or
- 9:42losing bets. That makes so much sense.
- 9:44And the true secret wasn't just the brilliance of deciding to
- 9:46buy Coca-Cola in the 1st place, it was the paint drying decision
- 9:50to never sell it. Exactly Sees Kadini stayed in
- 9:53the portfolio for 50 years, Coke for over 40.
- 9:57But this brings up a huge problem for the listener I
- 9:59think. What's that?
- 10:01If the literal God of investing only hits the jackpot 4% of the
- 10:04time, how is a regular person supposed to know which of their
- 10:07picks is the golden 4%? Are we just supposed to guess
- 10:10and pray? Well, what's fascinating here is
- 10:12that you do not need to know the 4%.
- 10:14You don't. No, the lesson isn't about
- 10:16developing some psychic ability to perfectly identify winners.
- 10:21It is about establishing a financial system where you
- 10:23simply survive long enough for the compounding of those rare,
- 10:28inevitable winners to do the heavy lifting.
- 10:31Which fundamentally shifts how we should view the entire act of
- 10:34investing. It really does.
- 10:35I loved this framework in the sources.
- 10:37It shifts us into the concept of finite versus infinite games.
- 10:41Yes. It's a brilliant distinction,
- 10:43originally popularized by the philosopher James Cars.
- 10:45Right, so a finite game has a clear set of rules, physical
- 10:49boundaries, and a definitive endpoint with a declared winner
- 10:53and loser. Think of a game of chess or an
- 10:56American football game. They're referees.
- 10:59A clock runs out and someone holds up a trophy at the end.
- 11:02But life isn't like that, your career isn't like that, and
- 11:05investing definitely isn't like that.
- 11:07No, these are infinite games. In an infinite game, there are
- 11:10no clearly defined rules, no spatial boundaries, and no
- 11:14buzzer that sounds to end the match.
- 11:15So you can't really win. Right, You do not win an
- 11:19infinite game. The game just continues
- 11:21indefinitely. Players eventually either drop
- 11:24out voluntarily or they run out of resources and implode,
- 11:27forcing them out of the game entirely.
- 11:29So the goal isn't to beat the other players, the goal is
- 11:31literally just to stay at the table, to not implode.
- 11:35And understanding that changes the math of success entirely.
- 11:39Most retail investors and honestly even professional fund
- 11:42managers treat the stock market like a finite game.
- 11:45Because they want to win the year.
- 11:47Exactly. They want the highest return on
- 11:50a 12 month scorecard so they can feel like a genius.
- 11:54But chasing that annual heroic greatness usually requires
- 11:57taking on catastrophic unprotected.
- 11:59Risk, which is why the transcription is this incredible
- 12:02story about the General Mills pension fund.
- 12:04Oh, this is one of your examples.
- 12:05Yeah, for 14 years, they tracked this equity portfolios
- 12:09performance against all their peers in the industry, and they
- 12:12were never the rock stars. They were never above the 27th
- 12:15percentile in any given year. Meaning in any single year, 73%
- 12:19of other funds were actively beating them.
- 12:22They were aggressively mediocre. Aggressively mediocre.
- 12:26But, and this is the crucial part, they were also never below
- 12:29the 47th percentile. So they just sat right there,
- 12:33solvably in the second quartile, year after year.
- 12:36Not great, but never terrible. Right.
- 12:39And if you asked a normal person where a fund like that would
- 12:42rank over the entire 14 year period, they'd probably guess
- 12:46somewhere in the middle. Right.
- 12:47You would think so. But the reality is, over that
- 12:49entire decade and a half, the General Mills fund ranked in the
- 12:53top 4th percentile overall, top 4%.
- 12:57We have to look at the statistical math behind that to
- 12:59understand why it happened. Yeah, explain that because it
- 13:01sounds like. Magic.
- 13:03OK, so imagine Fun A is playing a finite game, taking huge risks
- 13:08to win the year. They go up 50% one year, but
- 13:11then they hit a bad market and drop 50% the next year.
- 13:13Ouch, right? And because of how percentages
- 13:17work, if you start with $100, up 50% takes you to 150, but a 50%
- 13:23drop from there takes you down to $75.
- 13:25So you've actually lost money despite having a massive winning
- 13:29year? Exactly.
- 13:30While Fun B, our boring General Mills fund, just goes up 5% and
- 13:35then another 5%. They're sitting at $110.
- 13:37So being consistently average mathematically destroys volatile
- 13:42greatness over a long enough timeline.
- 13:44Yes, this is the exact philosophy of Oak Tree Capital
- 13:48mentioned in the sources. Their motto is fewer losers, not
- 13:54more winners. Fewer losers.
- 13:56Right. It's like finding a local
- 13:57restaurant that is always good, sometimes great, but absolutely
- 14:01never terrible. If you eat there for 40 years,
- 14:04your overall satisfaction is going to be incredibly high
- 14:07because you never once got food poisoning.
- 14:09I love that analogy, but here's the problem right?
- 14:12Nobody makes a motivational YouTube video about being
- 14:15consistently above average and just never shooting yourself in
- 14:17the foot. No, it's so unsexy.
- 14:19It really is. As humans, we are addicted to
- 14:21the narrative of the maverick Rick, who vets it all and wins.
- 14:24Which is exactly why 98% of investment funds eventually drop
- 14:28out or implode. They refuse to play the infinite
- 14:30game. Because it's boring, Yeah.
- 14:33Achieving that boring consistency requires profound
- 14:35emotional regulation. It means actively suppressing
- 14:39your ego's desire to be the smartest person in the room
- 14:42today so that you can quietly be the wealthiest person in the
- 14:46room in 40 years, man. Here's where it gets really
- 14:49interesting, though. Because intellectually, you and
- 14:51I get it. The listener gets it.
- 14:53We hear the math of the rule of 72.
- 14:55We understand that avoiding catastrophic zeros works better
- 14:58than chasing thousands, right? So why is it so incredibly hard
- 15:02for people to actually execute this?
- 15:04Because the math operates in a pristine vacuum, but we have to
- 15:08operate in the messy real world. Yeah, there's a quote from a
- 15:11retired trader in the source material that perfectly captures
- 15:14this psychological roadblock. What's the quote?
- 15:17He says when the time comes to buy, you won't want to.
- 15:20When the time comes to buy, you won't want to.
- 15:22Wow, that hits hard. Because the best time to buy,
- 15:24like the absolute bottom of the market when assets are cheapest,
- 15:28is always, by definition, accompanied by the absolute
- 15:31worst news. Right.
- 15:32It happens during faltering corporate fortunes or widespread
- 15:35job losses, global pandemics, geopolitical crises.
- 15:38Exactly. The environment around you is
- 15:41actively screaming at you to run away and hoard your cash.
- 15:45Source mentions this great old cartoon of a guy in a phone
- 15:48booth. He's sweating, staring at a
- 15:51burning factory in the background, and he's screaming
- 15:54into the receiver. I don't give a damn about
- 15:56prudent diversification. Sell my Fenwick chemical.
- 15:59Yes, it's such a perfect reminder that reality sometimes
- 16:03overrides academic theory. Yeah, your textbook tells you to
- 16:06hold that human Panic says Get Me Out before the whole system
- 16:10burns to the ground. To combat this, they compare the
- 16:13ideal investor to a battlefield hero, and they make a crucial
- 16:17distinction here. Which is.
- 16:19A hero is not someone who is immune to fear.
- 16:21A hero is someone who feels the exact same visceral terror as
- 16:25everyone else, but executes the necessary action anyway.
- 16:28So you have to zig when everyone else is zagging, but you have to
- 16:31do it while reading the exact same terrifying headlines that
- 16:34made them zag in the first place.
- 16:36Exactly. You don't have special
- 16:37information, you just have better emotional control.
- 16:39Which brings us to a really fascinating metaphor from the
- 16:42book. Good to great that the
- 16:43transcript highlights the two gas stations.
- 16:46Oh, this is a brilliant illustration of human
- 16:48psychology. Stand up for us, OK?
- 16:50Imagine 2 gas stations directly across the street from each
- 16:53other. The owner of the first gas
- 16:55station starts making small, smart improvements.
- 16:59He paints the exterior walls. He plants some flowers by the
- 17:02pumps. He lowers his gas prices just a
- 17:04little bit to attract more volume.
- 17:07He is actively, aggressively building his business.
- 17:11And the owner of the gas station across the street watches all of
- 17:14this happen. He sees the customers flocking
- 17:17to the competitor. He has the exact same
- 17:19opportunity to paint his own walls and lower his own prices.
- 17:23But he does absolutely nothing. Nothing.
- 17:25He just sits there in a lawn chair and watches himself lose.
- 17:28It is very easy to listen to that story and call the guy
- 17:30across the street an idiot. It is, But the source asks a
- 17:33really painful question. Aren't we all that guy, right?
- 17:37We hear this advice from Warren Buffett.
- 17:39We see it working for decades. We have the mathematical
- 17:42blueprint right in front of us and we still refuse to copy the
- 17:46successful model. Wait, I have to jump in here
- 17:48because there's a massive irony in this metaphor.
- 17:50What do you mean? It's a great story about human
- 17:52inertia, but it's actually the exact opposite of the investing
- 17:55advice we just talked about. Oh, I see.
- 17:57Where you going? Yeah, in the business world, the
- 17:59guy frantically painting his walls and tweaking his prices is
- 18:02the winner. But in the stock market, the guy
- 18:04frantically tweaking his portfolio and trying to outsmart
- 18:07the competition loses to the guy sitting across the street doing
- 18:11absolutely nothing but holding an index fund.
- 18:14That is an excellent observation, and it highlights
- 18:16exactly why investing is so counterintuitive, right in
- 18:21almost every other aspect of human endeavor.
- 18:23You know, sports, business, your career.
- 18:28Frantic continuous effort is rewarded, you at work, the
- 18:31competition. But wealth building is a
- 18:33completely different domain. How so?
- 18:35In investing, wealth is built by ruthlessly managing the
- 18:39relationship between price and value and then letting time do
- 18:42the work. So action is actually the enemy
- 18:45of compounding. Usually, yes.
- 18:48When people love a stock too much, the price detaches from
- 18:51its actual value and you must have the discipline to step back
- 18:54and do nothing. When the market crashes and
- 18:57everyone hates a stock, you must have the courage to step in and
- 19:00buy. It requires acting completely
- 19:02contrary to our evolutionary programming.
- 19:05It really does. So what does this all mean for
- 19:06you listening right now? The biggest take away here isn't
- 19:10about finding the perfect stock or guessing which company is the
- 19:13next Coca-Cola. It is about understanding the
- 19:16mechanics of time and survival. Absolutely.
- 19:19The most important metric in your financial life is simply
- 19:21how long your money has to double.
- 19:23Let's go back to the math. If you were 22 years old putting
- 19:26away $10,000 into a solid compounding engine like
- 19:29Berkshire or a fairly valued index and you just let it run
- 19:33for 42 years. This 6 double S.
- 19:35Right, That 10 grand becomes $640,000 and that is just your
- 19:40first year of savings. If you consistently add to it,
- 19:43ignoring the noise and the panic, the numbers become
- 19:46astronomical. And the beauty of the infinite
- 19:48game is that you don't have to give up your day job or your
- 19:50passions to achieve it. You pursue your life, you build
- 19:53your career, you spend time with your family, and you keep this
- 19:57compounding score running quietly on the side, like paint
- 20:00drying. You make sure you never blow up
- 20:03your portfolio. You accept the unsexy reality of
- 20:06being consistently above average, and you let the math do
- 20:09the heavy lifting over decades. Which leaves us with a final,
- 20:13rather provocative thought to Mull over.
- 20:15I love a good provocative thought.
- 20:16Well, we've established that the entire secret to winning the
- 20:19infinite game of investing is removing human emotion, right?
- 20:24Avoiding the euphoria that causes PE ratios to spike and
- 20:28ignoring the panic that causes markets to crash.
- 20:30Right, the human element is the ultimate vulnerability.
- 20:33Exactly. So it makes you wonder what
- 20:36happens to the stock market in 10 or 20 years when artificial
- 20:39intelligence agents are managing the vast majority of our
- 20:42portfolios. If autonomous machines never
- 20:45feel fear, never experienced FOMO, and never panic sell
- 20:49during a crisis, the market might become perfectly
- 20:51efficient. But if the market is perfectly
- 20:54efficient, who is left to make the emotional mistakes that
- 20:58generate those discounted buying opportunities for the rest of
- 21:01us? Oh, that is fascinating.
- 21:03If the machines eliminate the panic, they might also eliminate
- 21:06the opportunity. Maybe we actually need the guy
- 21:08screaming in the phone booth just to keep the ecosystem
- 21:10alive. It's definitely something to
- 21:12think about, yeah. And hey, if you like to access
- 21:14wider topics including life and investing philosophy, please
- 21:18subscribe to our sister channel at Deep Values.
- 21:20Yeah, and to access more Advanced Research applications
- 21:23and our latest published personal intelligent multi agent
- 21:26deep value intelligence welcome to subscribe on Deep Values dot
- 21:30AI. Don't forget to like this video.
- 21:32Much appreciate it. Thank you so much for joining us
- 21:34on this deep dive. Until next time, keep playing
- 21:37the Infinite game.