Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 186 - You're Not Allowed to Say This | Eric Kaufmann
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 186 of the Free Cities podcast.
- 0:36Hello, hello, welcome indeed.
- 0:38I hope you've had a wonderful week since the last time we spoke.
- 0:42I certainly have.
- 0:43Things are really ramping up at Podcast HQ.
- 0:48A little bit more about that later.
- 0:49Anyway, on to today's show.
- 0:51Now, often on this show, you'll hear me talking about exit,
- 0:55about new jurisdictions, charter cities.
- 0:58basically the freedom to go and build something better somewhere else. Well, this week we're doing
- 1:05something different. In fact, you could say it's the opposite. We're zooming all the way out and
- 1:09looking at the thing that most of us are actually trying to escape from or to fix in the first place,
- 1:17culture. Plus, how on earth did it get to where it is today? My guest on the show this week is Dr.
- 1:25Eric Kaufman. He's a professor of politics at the University of Buckingham and the author of two
- 1:33acclaimed books, Taboo and White Shift. You'll hear me bring up Jordan Peterson's name more than once
- 1:41in this episode and that's because the two of them are circling roughly the same cultural storm,
- 1:47I would say. However, where Peterson brings the emotion, I would say Eric brings the evidence.
- 1:54survey data instead of sermons is one way you can look at it i suppose now eric argues that
- 2:01most of what we call woke isn't new at all we tend to think of it as something that arrived
- 2:07with social media around 2015 he says no the whole thing's been quietly unfolding since the 1960s
- 2:15it's just that it lived on campuses in the gender studies and sociology departments for 50 years and
- 2:23And then social media and clickbait media came along and blasted it out into everything.
- 2:28Newspapers, the government, the police, probably your workplace too.
- 2:34His big claim is this.
- 2:36It all traces back to one thing, a taboo around race that formed in the mid 60s.
- 2:43What started as essentially a good instinct, i.e. not wanting to be racist,
- 2:48hardened into something black and white with absolutely no nuance. Then it got stretched
- 2:55and weaponized and that's where we are today. Criticise immigration? You're a racist. Question
- 3:01of policy? You're a racist. He walks through how affirmative action quietly mutated from equal
- 3:08treatment into enforced equal outcomes in literally just a few years. He's got the numbers too.
- 3:15if you're interested who actually holds these views you can see them broken down by age and sex
- 3:21and i'd say they're genuinely surprising towards the end we get into what i would call is the
- 3:28trickiest part for me still not decided on it immigration and identity eric's view is that
- 3:34a majority worrying about the pace of demographic change is a perfectly legitimate thing in a
- 3:42democracy and that group attachment is just a normal feature of human beings rather than
- 3:47something sinister. Fair enough. Where he and I actually part company is a little bit further
- 3:53up the road. He thinks race and ancestry are going to matter more in the coming decades,
- 3:59not less. Now, I probably don't dispute that, but where I'm not convinced is that it should matter
- 4:06at all. For me, it's all culture that counts, not colour. Eric reckons the lines will blur over time
- 4:12through intermarriage and that group identity itself isn't going anywhere and that we'd be
- 4:18naive to pretend otherwise. We finish looking ahead. He thinks the woke era has peaked and
- 4:24stalled, but he's not promising a happy ending anytime soon. He's predicting years of polarisation
- 4:30and populism before anything settles and he's pretty clear about who he thinks needs to back
- 4:37down first of course we did this the old-fashioned way calmly two people disagreeing properly without
- 4:44anything catching fire and i have thought about this since we spoke and i'm definitely still not
- 4:50with him on the white culture bit i still don't know what it is i think it's way too broad a
- 4:57category however i don't expect it to not become adopted more prominently in culture i mean just
- 5:05this week we've seen ireland erupt after a particularly disturbing attack in belfast this
- 5:12is our reality it seems now but i'm genuinely interested in what everyone thinks about these
- 5:19ideas please comment somewhere nostr fountain email if you want to remain anonymous just use
- 5:26the contact form on freecities.fm put a fake name in there whatever i'm genuinely interested in what
- 5:32people think here you'll hear me struggling throughout the conversation trying to grasp
- 5:37why eric believes what he believes let me know what you think he's a very interesting guy very
- 5:42intelligent very academic i want to understand i'd love to hear what you think obviously right
- 5:49if a conversation like this leaves you feeling that the west is drifting somewhere you'd rather
- 5:54not follow i'd say you are very much not alone and the whole premise of this show is to show you
- 6:02that you always have another option you don't have to just sit and watch you can exit you can go and
- 6:08build something better somewhere else was that a good segue or not which brings me nicely to the
- 6:16people who make this episode possible and that's veritas villages they're building off-grid energy
- 6:22self-sufficient communities for freedom lovers across Latin America, Panama, Nicaragua and Costa
- 6:28Rica places. You can grow your own food, generate your own power, own your home outright and live
- 6:35amongst neighbours who actually share your values. And yes, for those of you who think like I do,
- 6:42Bitcoin is accepted at every village right down to the buying of the property itself.
- 6:48Call it a plan B if you like.
- 6:50Somewhere to go if things back home keep heading in the direction Eric and I were just talking about.
- 6:56Or honestly, just call it a better way to live.
- 7:00www.veritasvillages.com forward slash free cities to see the communities and talk to the team.
- 7:08That's www.veritasvillages.com forward slash free cities.
- 7:14Right. My OG listeners, who are the OGs this week?
- 7:21Top five, number one. Now, there's a name I recognize.
- 7:25Peter Young, a big donator this week. Many thanks, Peter.
- 7:29Number two, just Shadrach.
- 7:32Number three, Christopher Albany's number four, A.N.T.
- 7:36Number five, Set in Stone.
- 7:39Many, many thanks for your wonderful donations of Bitcoin through various platforms.
- 7:44streaming via fountain.fm
- 7:48Noster comments
- 7:49and some people sending donations
- 7:52through Stripe
- 7:54all available to do in the show notes
- 7:56they mean a lot
- 7:57and they're really helping
- 7:59many thanks
- 7:59right
- 8:00comments
- 8:01Shadrach
- 8:02amazing chat remarkably
- 8:04or is it
- 8:05I was halfway through this pod
- 8:07on my travels
- 8:08and then I met Oswald
- 8:10at the Bitcoin Film Fest
- 8:12I've only just realized
- 8:13it was the same person whilst finishing this episode well done mate chadrak thank you that talking about oswald horowitz episode 175 the last free place about an absolutely brilliant film that a seasteading
- 8:29film that will be coming out i think this year possibly early next year uh an incredible story
- 8:36that one go and give it a listen justin bianchi talking about nicholas's episode last week just a
- 8:42great donation thank you um who have we got then hypno everyone should listen to testimonies of
- 8:48people who actually lived under socialism slash communism especially people thinking they're a
- 8:54solution to the world's problems i agree and you can do that because you can listen to the same
- 9:00episode hypno listen to 173 the hidden path to tyranny with mylin salabria right news about the
- 9:08conference in prospera before we go amazing lineup forming absolutely amazing there's a huge list of
- 9:15speakers i'm not sure if they're up on the website yet but i can give you a few sneak peeks amongst
- 9:21all the usuals we get updates from every big project in the scene we've got some interesting
- 9:27folks stefan kinsella is coming lou perez is coming he's the comedian lou perez per byland
- 9:34jeremy kaufman from the free state project patrie freeman there's so many great names here yours
- 9:42truly yes i'm actually going to take the stage for the first time create some space around my
- 9:49busy calendar while i'm there and i will be talking about this year's events in the free
- 9:56world as seen through the guests on my podcast that's 52 people probably won't be able to speak
- 10:03about all of them but i'll try i'll bring out all the good ones right more info www.freecitiesconference.com
- 10:09obviously come early and leave late there's events happening either side of the main days which are
- 10:15september the 3rd till the 6th right i'm absolutely buzzing at the moment i've literally just ordered
- 10:22a new computer to run local llms here at podcast hq i can't wait it's going to be great i'm going
- 10:29to create an agentic center for the show here and streamline everything hopefully and just tinker
- 10:36and it's amazing what you can achieve right now anyway settle in this one's a proper think
- 10:42time to get into it just sit back relax and enjoy my conversation with eric kaufman
- 10:59I was listening to you speaking with Jordan Peterson.
- 11:07Very interesting.
- 11:08I'd love to go really deep like that.
- 11:09Obviously, we can't.
- 11:11I think it's quite funny that you're both Canadians
- 11:13and you're both kind of social scientists, I suppose,
- 11:16is the way to describe it.
- 11:19You must really, just before we get into the conversation,
- 11:21you must really tread a very sort of tightrope walk
- 11:26in your profession.
- 11:27Is that right?
- 11:27I mean, you are in the belly of the beast and one of the, a bit like Jordan Peterson, but obviously you're in the UK.
- 11:35Probably a lone voice, is that right, in the institutions that you're in?
- 11:40I'm probably, you know, one of very, very few.
- 11:44Now, obviously, I am now at the University of Buckingham, which is probably the freest environment in the UK in terms of academia.
- 11:52But for 24 years, I was in University of Southampton for four and then Birkbeck University of London for 20.
- 12:00Those were environments where there was a very strong progressive conformity amongst faculty, for example.
- 12:09So you step essentially kind of kept in the closet for the most part.
- 12:14Have you come?
- 12:16Forgive me for not investigating this a bit deeper, but have you had have you tried to be canceled?
- 12:20Have you had all that stuff happen to you?
- 12:23I have.
- 12:24So my cancellation story really, you know, starting around 2016, I started to come out of the closet, you know, almost without even thinking about it.
- 12:35You know, I did a book called White Shift, which was all about populism.
- 12:41And that wasn't why I got canceled.
- 12:42But I started to become a bit more outspoken on social media.
- 12:46and all of the cancellations really had to do with me essentially either making light of or making fun of the social justice movement of the, you know, of the great awokening.
- 12:57So when Justin Trudeau couldn't pronounce after three tries, you know, LGBTQ and he stumbled, you know, and I retweeted that and, you know, joked about it.
- 13:08You know, that's the kind of thing that would go on your record and someone would put in a complaint.
- 13:12and then you have to show up at a hearing.
- 13:15And then you go through and they'd find you guilty.
- 13:18Well, what's the punishment?
- 13:19Well, you know, if you do it again, you know, they won't specify it
- 13:22because if they get legal, they're probably going to lose.
- 13:24But still, so that's kind of the, I faced a number,
- 13:29a total of four internal investigations over between like 2018 and 2022.
- 13:35Some stuff in the higher education press.
- 13:38So there was one social justice warrior right out of central casting
- 13:41who was the youngest member of staff in our department,
- 13:44and she was just a complete rabid nutjob.
- 13:47No one liked her, but that's beside the point.
- 13:49I mean, she basically was, you know, she left the department.
- 13:55I was head of department for a while, and, you know,
- 13:58I was very sort of scrupulous in any dealings with her,
- 14:01but she left and claiming I was the reason she left
- 14:04and wrote this great big, you know, whine in the Times Higher,
- 14:09claiming I pushed her out of academia.
- 14:10I mean, it's ridiculous.
- 14:13And the reason is because I made her feel unsafe because of what I wrote, right?
- 14:17Not because of anything I've done directly,
- 14:19but being very critical of the kind of critical race theory,
- 14:23essentially scholar activism that she was engaged in.
- 14:26The reality is she got a job across the street at SOAS
- 14:29and didn't tell anybody because she wanted the story to be,
- 14:32oh, I got pushed out.
- 14:34Poor me.
- 14:36But yeah, just all these kind of pressures.
- 14:39And because of the stuff that had been in the press, you know, all my colleagues were aware of where I stood.
- 14:45And so they were perfectly cordial for the most part.
- 14:48But on the other hand, you know, they would basically support or a number of them would support tacitly these kind of internal investigations against me.
- 14:59So it was just kind of getting weird.
- 15:01It wasn't anything that was going to push me out or where I really feared for my job.
- 15:04But, you know, at the end of the day, I thought, you know, Buckingham has got this Thatcherite free speech founding tradition.
- 15:14And that's sort of more where I wanted to be.
- 15:16Forgive me for making the comparison again, but I will with Jordan Peterson.
- 15:20It's unavoidable, but you seem a lot more lighthearted than him.
- 15:26Well, I love Jordan Peterson and I would say, you know, I'm a very long standing fan of his work.
- 15:32I haven't really, I kind of lost touch with it a lot recently because he went through that big, you know, pump of fame about three or four years ago.
- 15:42But he often picks up on the darker side of what's going on.
- 15:47And I think you do as well, judging by what briefly I've seen of your work.
- 15:52However, you do it in a much more lighthearted way.
- 15:55He's a bit of a black pillar, I think, sometimes.
- 15:57And you appear to be someone who can talk about these things.
- 16:00And I can't wait to discuss some very controversial things with you because you basically what you write about is incredibly controversial in this day and age.
- 16:10But I find it exhilarating when you watch people have it, have a sort of just a normal conversation about things and speak unemotionally, I suppose, is the correct way.
- 16:20Well, yeah. And that's probably the biggest difference.
- 16:22I've been in rooms where Jordan Peterson, you know, he will cry at the drop of a hat.
- 16:28He was talking to a Penguin sales force media something as dry as that and he kind of got into some story and started crying That the kind of guy he is He just so emotional right And that is one approach And that one of the reasons he so effective
- 16:46But on the other hand, that's not really my style.
- 16:50I mean, I'm kind of, yeah.
- 16:51So let's zoom out and look at culture currently.
- 16:57Over the last, let's say in my lifetime, 50 years,
- 17:01I've obviously noticed it change.
- 17:03I'm sure you can point me in a much more specific direction of what exactly has happened over that
- 17:09period of time. But can you just kind of generally describe the situation we find ourselves in now,
- 17:15which is, seems unusual to me, but I'm not even sure historically, whether this isn't just a
- 17:20cyclical thing that happened up sort of like the pendulum that swings backwards and forwards.
- 17:24Yeah, boy, that's a, that's a really good question. So I think the first thing to appreciate is we,
- 17:29We are living in the backwash, or we're living in the aftermath of the cultural upheavals of the 1960s,
- 17:39whose full flowering wasn't clear at the time.
- 17:44It was to some degree, but it's taken a while for the logic of the cultural revolutions of the 60s to fully unfold.
- 17:53and what we're living through is kind of the late stage post-60s culture
- 17:59and what it really means.
- 18:02And that's one of the reasons why in my book, Taboo,
- 18:05my argument is actually it's not as new as you think.
- 18:09It's just that it was much more self-contained.
- 18:11It was contained on campus and within the campus.
- 18:14It was in the gender studies department and the black studies department
- 18:17or maybe the sociology department, but now it's everywhere
- 18:21and it's off campus.
- 18:22It's in the newspapers. It's everywhere. It's in the government. It's in the institutions.
- 18:26So I think what's occurred in the 2010s with what Matthew Iglesias calls the Great Awakening is this massification spread off campus due mainly to a couple of things.
- 18:37One is social media because social media allows academics and journalists to talk to each other and feed each other with ideas.
- 18:46The second is the new media away from classified ads towards clickbait, which means driving emotions on social media is key.
- 18:55And therefore, all of a sudden, the media is sucking all of this ideological stuff out of gender studies, which had been talked about in academia for decades.
- 19:06So it's not new.
- 19:07If you were in a gender studies or women's studies seminar in the 70s or 80s, you wouldn't notice that much difference between then and now.
- 19:15it's just that if you were in the engineering or in medicine then you would notice a big difference
- 19:21because the stuff has spilled into your sphere and you've got to do DEI now and where you know
- 19:26and talk about trans and all this kind of stuff so yeah that's kind of the the culture I call the
- 19:31and I actually think that the self the source the big bang if you like of our moral universe
- 19:37was the sort of anti-racism taboo that emerges in the mid-1960s in the U.S.,
- 19:46particularly in polite society.
- 19:49It's good to have a norm against racism, but when you go to a taboo,
- 19:54that's a very black and white thing.
- 19:55There's no nuance, there's no gray zones,
- 19:58and all of a sudden this is a powerful piece of kryptonite that somebody can weaponize.
- 20:03So they're incentivized to stretch the meaning of the term racism
- 20:06to include, oh, you criticized immigration levels or multiculturalism, you are a racist, right? Or
- 20:13you want to talk about the grooming gangs, you are a racist. So by essentially stretching this
- 20:17taboo, it gives a lot of power to the cultural left. And they've used it and institutionalized
- 20:24it as DEI. And so that's really where the culture has gone. And it's just exploded more recently
- 20:30because of social media and the new media, which has allowed for this rapid takeover.
- 20:35However, I want to state that as somebody who came of age, you know, in what I call the second awokening, late 80s, early 90s, with political correctness and dead white males and all that, I mean, that is, it was very evident already then that this was happening if you knew where to look.
- 20:56But it just hadn't hit, you know, the scale was just, the New York Times was not all over it the way it was in the 2010s.
- 21:02That's interesting. I was at university 89 to 93 in Leeds. And my version of this was there was a very small group.
- 21:13Probably they were selling the Socialist Worker magazine. Do you remember that?
- 21:16Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 21:17I don't know if it's still going. And there were demonstrations about pretty much everything, but they were very small.
- 21:23But they were into the politics of universities. Definitely.
- 21:28they were the sort of very much politically active but really didn't have a voice most people
- 21:32there was a small group of say four of them outside the union when you walk past shouting
- 21:38about something um so it's interesting that um what i want to know is why why did it take on
- 21:45why did it take off so much i understand that social media and and clickbait etc etc have
- 21:52facilitated it but why did it take off i mean most people i i'd say the general population
- 22:00would walk past it and think that's you know quiet and down you're being a bit over the top
- 22:06this is a bit extreme this is a bit unnecessary so why has it taken hold in such a way
- 22:11well i think what i what's interesting to me well first of all there's a couple of things i do think
- 22:17that when you can just press a like button from anywhere in the world to dogpile somebody
- 22:22and cancel, that does give just a lot more mobilizing capacity to a movement, right?
- 22:30What I would say is that when you certainly had cancellations going back to the 60s,
- 22:35let's just take an example. In the mid-1970s, James Coleman, president of the American Sociological
- 22:42Association, wrote some papers saying, well, busing does contribute to white flight. And so
- 22:48that was seen as critical of this policy of racial integration through busing. And he was,
- 22:53you know, people went on stage calling him a Nazi and a racist, whatever. So that was already
- 22:57happening. And there were people scheming behind the scenes to have his professional ethics question.
- 23:03And then in the 90s, similar things were happening. You know, 1988, UCLA student newspaper made fun
- 23:09of affirmative action, it was shut down by the university. So this idea that cancellation wasn't
- 23:14happening is wrong, and the idea that there was a lot of robust protection against cancellation,
- 23:20people criticizing it, is wrong. The doors were open, but the number of people to push the doors
- 23:26open was not that high. It wasn't so easy to mobilize. But the ideas, you know, the sacredness
- 23:32of race, the sacredness of sex, sacredness of the homophobia narrative, which later becomes the
- 23:38transphobia narrative, all of those symbolic touchstones of this new religion were already
- 23:44in place. It's just a matter of expanding the scale and power of them. So this is where I differ
- 23:50with some other people who think this is all new. I don't think it is new. And this is one of the
- 23:54reasons why we've got to go back to the beginning if we want to fix this thing. If you look at
- 23:59Trump's executive order rescinding affirmative action, you know, affirmative action was an
- 24:05executive order from 1965. So that's how far back this rot goes, or what's called disparate impact.
- 24:14If you have a test for a firefighting department and men do better on this than women because it
- 24:20involves carrying people around, then that is indirect discrimination against women. You've
- 24:27got to get rid of the test. That kind of stuff, 1971. So this stuff really goes back a long way.
- 24:34it's just that you know Canada another example they had laws on the books that you can discriminate
- 24:39on the basis of race in the name of some kind of positive action but it just wasn't used and then
- 24:46suddenly oh somebody starts using it and then it gets used more and more now jobs are advertised
- 24:52openly they say we want somebody who isn white or male that is now legal and it happening all the time so a lot of the potential was there It just hadn been fully realized And this is why I think there this unfolding logic
- 25:05that was already nascent there.
- 25:08And we didn't have immunities against it.
- 25:10I think we kid ourselves.
- 25:12We did not have the immunities.
- 25:14It's only now that it's gotten so bad
- 25:16that we're starting to develop the defenses.
- 25:20But the thing I don't understand is
- 25:22what you've just described there,
- 25:24that hiring on the basis of characteristics you don't have let's say um that seems obviously
- 25:32antithetical to the origins of what dei should be i'm as i understand it it's it's people wanting
- 25:40to be nice to other people i think probably that's where it stems from correct me if i'm wrong and so
- 25:46what do those people think when they look at that like what does that not cause a glitch in the in
- 25:52their thought process when they see that? How does it work? You'd be surprised. People can
- 25:58convince themselves of all sorts of things. So what happened is within, so the original letter
- 26:04of the affirmative action executive order was about non-discrimination on the basis of race.
- 26:11And it's really about affirmative action to prevent discrimination. Within the span of a few
- 26:16years, it was goals and timetables for equality of outcome. So you go from equality of treatment,
- 26:23equal treatment, to equal outcome within the span of a few years. Why? Well, there were some riots.
- 26:29The government says, oh, yes, we've got to deal with, you know, inequality, racial and racism.
- 26:34And then there's this blurring between non-discrimination and equal outcomes. Oh,
- 26:40we need to have equal outcomes, so we're going to discriminate against whites and men. So instead
- 26:45Instead of you went from it was illegal to discriminate on the basis of race to, as Richard Hanania puts it, it became illegal not to discriminate on the basis of race within a few years.
- 26:55And that was all justified as being within the spirit of the law.
- 26:58So they're kind of it's a shell game where they're keeping the label of equality, emptying out the kind of more classical liberal meaning of that and replacing it with the more kind of radical, I guess you could call it cultural socialist, critical race type approach.
- 27:14Do you think that's acknowledged at a high level?
- 27:17Do you think that it's obviously a weaponizing action?
- 27:23Yeah.
- 27:23So do you think it's acknowledged that that's what it is?
- 27:26Do you think the distance between the original intention to what it's become is that far now?
- 27:35That it's obvious and people go, look, it just is what it is.
- 27:39Let's just keep doing it because it actually benefits us.
- 27:42Well, yeah, there were a lot of contortions.
- 27:45So they first, they changed it to, well, yeah, okay, it's not about reparations for past
- 27:50injustice.
- 27:51It's about diversity.
- 27:53So they tried to change the rationale.
- 27:55But they're always, what you'll get with the academic left is they will come up with a
- 28:00kind of word salad that goes something like this.
- 28:03Well, unless we discriminate against whites and men, minorities aren't going to feel welcome
- 28:11enough to have the freedom to be treated equally. So therefore, we have to treat unequally in order
- 28:18to have equal treatment. So it's a complete word salad and a word game. It's kind of what George
- 28:23Orwell talked about, where you kind of empty the meaning of words and you change them into something
- 28:27political. So the word anti-racism no longer just means, you know, not discriminating on the basis
- 28:34of race, but it means that whenever whites are doing better than blacks, that's racism.
- 28:42We're not going to look at family structure. We're not going to look at savings behavior. We're not
- 28:45going to look at anything else. We're just going to call that systemic racism. And so it's just this
- 28:52kind of redefinition of words on the basis of ideology and then believing your own propaganda.
- 28:59And I think that's kind of where we are.
- 29:01Now, then you get something like when there's a big challenge.
- 29:04What's interesting is so when Trump goes in and when the Supreme Court in the U.S. outlawed the use of affirmative action or basically racial preferences, which we're actually discriminating a lot against Asians as well in order to engineer the makeup of these universities, student bodies to reflect the population.
- 29:22You know, in the public, it was like 70 to 30 in favor of getting rid of these sorts of things.
- 29:31And what's interesting is even on these university campuses, there's kind of a grudging acknowledgement that there was a problem.
- 29:38And in fact, some of the people even were quite quietly quite pleased at what Trump was doing because they themselves never really bought into this.
- 29:46So they actually haven't resisted.
- 29:48You know, the attack on DEI in the U.S. has really not been resisted tooth and nail, I would say.
- 29:56It's in fact largely been acquiesced to, which shows actually it was pretty soft.
- 30:02Something that I learned of this morning listening to you speak with Jordan Peterson, which is relevant here, I think.
- 30:09you were talking about that the possibility that or whether jordan was talking about the possibility
- 30:16that the sort of evolution of wokeism as you call it has gone hand in hand with a certain
- 30:23feminization of culture and one of the things i think jordan pointed out was that in a feminized
- 30:30culture you tend to go with the consensus so if the consensus from the top down is right dei is
- 30:37off the table now, then you're far less likely to resist it. Is that fair to say? Or is that a
- 30:44correct understanding of what you were talking about? Well, that's interesting. I mean, I think,
- 30:47you know, I think the debate we were having was a lot about, you know, a lot of professions,
- 30:52because women have been getting degrees and they've been entering professions. So a lot of
- 30:56professions have become a lot more female just in their demographic makeup. You know, university
- 31:01academics is one example of a profession that's become majority female, but more extreme in
- 31:08teaching, for example, or medicine is another. And one of the questions is, does that demographic
- 31:13shift explain the rise of woke, which is really about, oh, well, we want to care for people. We
- 31:20don't want to make them feel offended or not included by confronting an argument they don't
- 31:26like, that's more important than truth and freedom.
- 31:31And so I think that one of the things we were debating
- 31:34was whether this was about the demographic entry of women
- 31:37into the professions.
- 31:38My argument is that it's actually not so much about that,
- 31:41but it is much more about you can have feminine ideas.
- 31:45And so ideas that say emotional safety is more important
- 31:50than free speech, for example, that is a feminine idea
- 31:52in the sense that it prioritizes things that, you know,
- 31:58in women's evolutionary makeup they would tend to prioritize.
- 32:01However, I think the feminization of ideas is different from the demographics.
- 32:08So if you take a convent, a convent where you have very strict,
- 32:13it's all female run, but they are certainly not touchy-feely
- 32:17in the way they're approaching running that convent.
- 32:19So the ideas are not very feminine,
- 32:21even though the demography is very feminine.
- 32:23I think what we've gotten now is, yes, the institutions are more demographically female,
- 32:28but the bigger issue is not that.
- 32:31You can have DEI in the police.
- 32:33You can have DEI in the military.
- 32:35It's not so necessarily the personnel as it is the ethos and the culture,
- 32:40which has kind of moved in a feminine direction.
- 32:42So that's sort of where I felt, whereas Helen Andrews, her argument,
- 32:47which I think Jordan was mentioning,
- 32:49was really that it's all about tipping points
- 32:51with women making up over 50% of the staff
- 32:54and then pushing, say, the university
- 32:56to essentially be a daycare rather than pursuing truth.
- 33:00So I'm not saying there's nothing in that.
- 33:02Women are more woke on average, particularly younger women.
- 33:06So there's no question that that female makeup
- 33:08will make a difference.
- 33:09But I don't think it's enough.
- 33:10It's kind of, you know, you take a university,
- 33:13it's gone from 60-40 male to 40-60 or 55-45.
- 33:16I just don't think that on its own is enough to explain
- 33:19where we went so the feminine but feminized ideas and you know
- 33:26feminized ideas wouldn't would they necessarily appeal to a man and then what's the what's the
- 33:33what's the appeal if it's not to do with um by the way i fully acknowledge that people are going
- 33:42to listen to this and go what the hell are you talking about yeah yeah yeah it's hard to follow
- 33:45Oh, yeah, I know.
- 33:46But I like challenging my own ideas about things like this.
- 33:51And I'd never actually thought about it, I think, until I heard you talking about it.
- 33:55But it makes a lot of sense to me.
- 33:57It does.
- 33:57And I agree that, and you obviously will back this up with data, that you're more likely to be woke if you're a young woman.
- 34:05Because we see that anecdotally.
- 34:08But I understand that it's absolutely true as well.
- 34:12Yeah, like if we just give you one example.
- 34:14I mean, there's a survey taken of American undergraduates every year by Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, like 70,000, like monster, massive sample.
- 34:24And so you take a question like, should somebody who says trans is a mental disorder, should that speaker be permitted to come onto the campus and speak?
- 34:34And women are, you know, 20 points less likely than men to say that.
- 34:40And that's across the political spectrum.
- 34:41So right-wing conservative women are 20 points less likely than right-wing conservative men to say such a person should come to speech.
- 34:49So there's no question that women are more likely to want to emphasize protection from speech than freedom of speech.
- 34:58But still, most of the variation is going to be left to right.
- 35:04If you identify as very left-wing versus very right-wing, that matters a lot more than whether you're male or female.
- 35:10The other thing to say is that, you know, we obviously as a world have gone through, you could call, for example, the ending of cruel punishments and blood sports and dueling, you could call all of that more feminine ideas, right?
- 35:25If it's about prevention of cruelty.
- 35:27So to some degree, this is part of like the process of civilization.
- 35:32But, of course, any of these things, and they are independent of whether you're a male or a female.
- 35:38But I think there's also a degree to which if you have more females in a profession,
- 35:43then just because women are more likely to support some of these ideas,
- 35:47they're going to be more powerful within the sort of rank and file.
- 35:51Okay, let's talk about the civilization then, because does that mean,
- 35:56I'm looking for the correct answer here.
- 36:01Not that, you know, does that mean that that if we believe in free speech, for example, we're necessarily excluding the feminine?
- 36:10Are we excluding women from that from if we want to pursue free speech, if we want to try and enact free speech, does that mean?
- 36:17How does that work? Who's right? Who's wrong? How do we include everyone? Is that even necessary?
- 36:23Is inclusivity even necessary?
- 36:24Yeah, yeah. Well, these values are our intention.
- 36:27I mean, the woke left will pretend they're not and say, oh, yeah, we believe in free speech and we believe in emotional safety.
- 36:35And there's no contradiction. Of course there is.
- 36:37Like, I mean, all of these are tensions, right?
- 36:39So if you, for example, even to say something like I think that immigration should be reduced because we don't want the culture to change so quickly.
- 36:51and if someone says, well, that's offensive to people who aren't white
- 36:55because they make up most of the immigrants and most of the natives are white,
- 36:59that would be the kind of argument that would be made, right?
- 37:03So you can't say that.
- 37:05So I guess what I'd say, there's a couple of things.
- 37:08First is, I mean, there is a clash, but in a sort of classical liberal,
- 37:12the values that made the West great are essentially freedom of speech
- 37:18so ideas can collide and the best ideas win,
- 37:21a truth-based order. And now, in your private life, so this is where there's a difference.
- 37:27In your private life, if my mother-in-law has put on a lot of weight, I'm not going to sort of point
- 37:32that out. That's called, right? So that's called... You're not going to plead free speech in that case.
- 37:38No, no. So that's where kind of, you know, regard for not offending somebody trumps free speech
- 37:45in a private setting. You know, obviously... You still have the free speech, though.
- 37:49You do, yeah.
- 37:50It's a personal choice.
- 37:51You're not worried about the government telling you off for free speech in that sense, but yes.
- 37:57No, but you might be worried about norm violations.
- 37:59So even though it's not government, it is some sort of a norm that's socially upheld.
- 38:05But then if you try and transpose that into the public realm, which is what the left's done, to say, well, we want to be nice.
- 38:11And just like being nice to your mother-in-law, we're going to mean being nice means not telling native, you know, Aboriginal Canadians that there are no mass graves.
- 38:21And, you know, their claims that there are all these bodies buried around these residential schools is crap, which it is, is complete hoax.
- 38:29So we're not going to say that because, well, they've had a hard time and, you know, we don't want to upset people and blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 38:35That's actually, I think, the wrong approach, because what you're now saying is we no longer have a truth-based society.
- 38:41we no longer have a free speech.
- 38:42So I think in the public realm,
- 38:43it's got to be free speech and truth.
- 38:46If we want to solve problems
- 38:47and get ahead as a society,
- 38:51then we need to have free speech.
- 38:53And the other thing is, of course,
- 38:55who sets the taboos?
- 38:57Well, because we don't care about
- 38:58what white working class people think
- 39:01or conservatives think
- 39:02or religious people think.
- 39:03So there are certain groups
- 39:05that we want to be nice to
- 39:06and there are certain groups
- 39:07you've got to be mean to, right?
- 39:09So, you know, white males.
- 39:12It's open season on them, and the meaner the better.
- 39:15So, in fact, it's not empathy towards everybody.
- 39:17It's empathy towards groups that are approved of by the cultural left,
- 39:21which is essentially historically marginalized race, gender, sexual minorities.
- 39:25That's who are the kind of sacred groups in the system who have the oppression points.
- 39:30And those who have very few points are the whites, the males, the conservatives.
- 39:34They're at the bottom.
- 39:34and so actually you want to dehumanize those people
- 39:37and call them just faceless whiteness
- 39:40and agents of systemic racism
- 39:43and a sort of shameful past.
- 39:46So yeah, this is the point,
- 39:48it really isn't empathy,
- 39:49it's very selective empathy.
- 39:51That's what I was about,
- 39:52I was just about to say,
- 39:53it is selective empathy.
- 39:55So what would be the,
- 39:57according to you at least,
- 39:58according to the data let's say,
- 39:59what would be the correct way to be in the world,
- 40:03the correct way to govern,
- 40:04the correct way to sort of exist according to you and and particularly here from a sort of male
- 40:10female perspective because you know empathy is good we know that but when it's when it's not good
- 40:17it can be not good as well when it's selective for example so how do we how do we go about this
- 40:21how do we sort of marry these two things together because i don't know maybe maybe i'm wrong but i
- 40:26my interpretation of history is that like you say there is an evolution happening so you know it's
- 40:33easy to see it as a bit of a as a bit of a pendulum swinging one way and then another one way but i
- 40:37think and i think that does happen but i think it also does tend to evolve a little bit so what
- 40:44happened in the 60s was a big movement individualism feminism you know all these kind of things were
- 40:52obviously a good thing as well um there is an argument to say that it's just a pendulum like i
- 40:58say and it it'll swing to the individual side it was doing to the collective side it was going to
- 41:02the interview but i i am i'm at least under the impression that there is a bit of an evolution
- 41:08going on so as we reach 2026 we've got this we've got an opportunity to look back and
- 41:13say right we've what have we learned how do we live how should we how should we exist
- 41:19you know culturally as a as a speak you know as a group necessarily or as individuals what would
- 41:24your your um take on that be well my take on it a couple of things i mean first i think we're in a
- 41:29period of overreach and diminishing returns to particularly group equality and emotional harm protection for groups right So those ideas which maybe at the beginning in the 60s really did have you know some merit right
- 41:47I mean, it was true when you did have real racial discrimination on the basis of race, for example,
- 41:52you know, probably looking at who applied and who got hired was a useful starting point in trying to say,
- 41:59okay, that's probably good evidence if it was 50% black who applied for this construction job and none of them got it.
- 42:06That's probably pretty good evidence there's some discrimination going on.
- 42:09Because it's very hard to prove discrimination exactly without getting in people's heads.
- 42:14But on the other hand, this thing then solidifies and then becomes a quota and becomes racial preference.
- 42:20And so you actually have to be able to say, well, we had an arc here, which these things did good and then they overreached
- 42:28and we're past the optimum point.
- 42:30And that's, I think, really the kind of place that we're at.
- 42:34The other thing is I'm not so sure about this pendulum thing.
- 42:36So if you take attitudes on cultural issues,
- 42:42the left has not lost anything in the last 60 years
- 42:46until the last two, three years on trans.
- 42:49This is their first defeat in public opinion.
- 42:52Public opinion's gone about 20 or 30 points,
- 42:55or 20 points, let's say, against the trans activist position.
- 42:57women in, you know, natal males in female sports, female prisons, all that sort of stuff. So that's
- 43:03kind of been a battle that they've lost, but it's the first one they've lost in 60 years.
- 43:08And many of the things that were in the early part of the 60s civil rights were very laudable,
- 43:15black rights, women's rights, gay rights. But as we get into this now, the trans rights thing,
- 43:20it's really a clash of rights, you know, people wanting to enter women's sports, women not wanting
- 43:26them there. This is not like, you can't just say, oh, trans rights. No, it's like there's women's
- 43:31rights versus trans rights, and a democracy adjudicates who wins on that. It's not the courts.
- 43:37So it isn't that. Now, there are a couple of, there are some issues where, so if we take, you know,
- 43:43not wanting to marry a black person, or not wanting women to work, or not allowing people
- 43:50to be gay, you know, all these issues, opinions got more tolerant. And so the general direction
- 43:55has been favorable to left liberalism.
- 43:59But what you see on certain issues like immigration,
- 44:03affirmative action, this idea of racial preferences,
- 44:08on some of these other trans issues, for example,
- 44:10is that in fact what's happened is you've seen a polarization of opinion.
- 44:13There's not been this unidirectional liberalization.
- 44:17And I actually think that there's now a loss of...
- 44:21For a long time, I think the cultural left thought
- 44:24We are the direction of history.
- 44:27We are on the right side of history.
- 44:29We have to overcome obstacles.
- 44:32It's almost like a messianic, quasi-religious,
- 44:35we are heading to the promised land.
- 44:38And this is, I think, one reason why it's so difficult for them
- 44:41to give up on any one of the prongs of this movement.
- 44:44So for them to say no to trans,
- 44:46oh, well, actually people don't want trans women and women's sports.
- 44:51We've got to give up on that one.
- 44:52We lost that one.
- 44:53it's not possible because this is religious and if you if you pull one strand out the whole thing
- 44:59comes apart so they can't give on anything because they this is such an all-encompassing belief
- 45:05system and i so i think we're in a really interesting place because the the progressive
- 45:12post-1960s thing i think has really come is stalled you know you see it in so many ways you
- 45:18You see it in the failure of progressive cities, you know, where they've got homelessness and drug use out of control and crime.
- 45:25And it's clearly not the utopia.
- 45:28And I think there's now a rethink.
- 45:30The smarter progressives, I had a piece in the Wall Street Journal on this, what I call post-progressivism,
- 45:35that we've come to the end of the progressive era, 1960s to the 2020s.
- 45:40And so, yeah, I think we're entering into a new period.
- 45:43and the taken for granted, oh, we are the future,
- 45:48this is where right-thinking people have to go,
- 45:50I think that's finished now.
- 45:52And we're now in a period of polarization
- 45:54and where these ideas are finally being contested.
- 45:58I'm wondering whether that just isn't the free market
- 46:01marking the boundary between people.
- 46:05I've often thought that there's 50% left-leaning people
- 46:09and 50% right-leaning people,
- 46:10and it changes depending on age and certain things like that maybe maybe it's started to to annoy
- 46:17more than a certain percentage of the other 50 so now they just push back and up until that point
- 46:23it wasn't really an issue i don't know do you believe that i mean i mean is that because i think
- 46:28you know progressivism and conservatism say for example are are personality types basically
- 46:35they tend to incorporate a bunch of things which are personality types and as a result you get a
- 46:42pretty even distribution of those kind of personality types i think if you if you if you
- 46:47if you look at across age as well because i think you know when you're younger obviously you're much
- 46:52more progressive than when you're older as soon as you take on certain responsibilities you start
- 46:56realizing okay idealism isn't as good as i used to think it was because now i actually have to deal
- 47:01with it etc etc i mean that's something certainly what's happened to me right i mean i just to give
- 47:07you an anecdote we're you know we're at a margaret thatcher event here i grew up thinking margaret
- 47:12thatcher was an ogre literally i was i i only really in the last probably five years went back
- 47:20to that idea and addressed it because i was pumped full of propaganda that this lady is evil and
- 47:29selfish and you know but but that's but that's a really important comment you just made which was
- 47:35pump full of propaganda right so the it's not just personal i mean personality differences are real
- 47:41and they really do matter um which i'll come to in a minute but you know what also matters is the
- 47:47content of the youth culture of the education system so britain for example the young people
- 47:51in this country are far more left-wing, particularly on cultural issues, than has ever been the
- 47:59case since the records that we have, which go back to the 1964 British election study.
- 48:05We can look at under-25s versus the over-65s, and there was never much difference between
- 48:10the share who voted Conservative or Labour.
- 48:13It starts to expand in the 2010s.
- 48:17and also at that time, you know, the young people's views on immigration got a lot more liberal
- 48:23where they weren't in the past. So young people in the 2010s start to move in this very kind of
- 48:30cultural left direction and then you had Brexit which kind of the way that was framed by the
- 48:38by the sort of youth culture kind of radicalized the young and so now what you have in Britain is,
- 48:45you know, maybe 10% in some YouGov polling I've seen of people under 25 would vote for either
- 48:51reform or the Tories. In Canada, which is in many ways a very similar kind of place to Britain
- 48:56culturally, the young population under 25 is more conservative than the population over 65
- 49:05in a very similar society. And so we, now, of course, the woke indoctrination is as severe,
- 49:14probably more severe there than it is here.
- 49:16So that on its own isn't enough to,
- 49:18I mean, there are many dynamics.
- 49:19So one is, who do you blame, you know,
- 49:21who's been in power?
- 49:23There are stories that develop
- 49:25based on who's in power.
- 49:27If it's the Liberal Party in Canada,
- 49:29the stories are about, oh, the Liberals,
- 49:31they've screwed the young people,
- 49:33they've brought in all these immigrants,
- 49:34they're the problem.
- 49:36In Britain, it might be, oh, the Tories, it's Brexit,
- 49:38that's why I have my problems.
- 49:40And so that becomes the storyline
- 49:41that shapes a generation.
- 49:43So I think these kind of environments and storylines are quite important in shaping the consciousness of generations.
- 49:52Now, personality, though, is important.
- 49:54So we know that psychology do you see change as exciting or as a loss culturally Do you see difference again as stimulating or as disorderly Now the overwhelming you know people who are
- 50:11voting for the populist right, they don't want immigration changing their societies the way
- 50:16they're changing them. And so for them, change is loss, difference is disorderly, predominant. And
- 50:22And that is a third to a half heritable studies have shown that.
- 50:26Your belief in whether you should have a dress code at Wimbledon tennis and all tennis tournaments should have a dress code is linked to your views on immigration.
- 50:36And that's kind of what I mean.
- 50:37So personality is there.
- 50:39But also, I think, you know, these cultural environments are important.
- 50:43You mentioned immigration there.
- 50:45from my observations albeit anecdotal immigration is becoming one of the biggest talking points
- 50:54on the on in the western hemisphere let's say i don't know whether it's true on the planet i'm not
- 50:59sure but certainly in the western hemisphere and it seems to be propelling almost everything
- 51:03people talk about in the political realm and it's spilling over into absolutely everything
- 51:08and that is obviously well is it let's just decide that first is that on why is that what
- 51:15why is it that i know you've written about um white culture which i find fascinating because
- 51:22number one i can feel people clenching up even at the mention of white culture absolutely it's a
- 51:28it's a it's a beautiful thing to talk about because no one talks about it and it and i feel it myself
- 51:33you know like it it really does make me feel uneasy but there is other reasons not just the
- 51:40kind of you know that you shouldn't say that kind of reason but is that and i often wonder this about
- 51:45people who talk about black culture as well white culture for me didn't really exist if i think
- 51:50about it like i've got bulgarian friends that i was visiting recently in bulgaria and i'm
- 51:54and i don't think of their skin color in any shape or form as being the thing that unites us at all
- 52:00you know i so and but we're both in inverted commas white so but there's that i i don't
- 52:07interact at that level and i've had i've never had a reason to interact at that level
- 52:13so arguably now if people start talking about white identity i'm a i'm a bit suspicious of it
- 52:20i'm thinking why and and number one because it doesn't make sense to me really i can imagine a
- 52:25cultural identity yeah and and for me personally because I've heard I've heard the murmurings in
- 52:32the UK now of of some parties saying that there is a white identity which is a British identity
- 52:38now as someone who grew up in a very white Britain I still don't think of my identity as white because
- 52:46we had Indian people living in our community we had a small number of black people but we did have
- 52:52all that stuff so that and and i and when i think about when i think back to that time they were very
- 52:57much british it was part of britain you know it was a british person who had you know who was part
- 53:06of the lexic who you know we everyone you know what the brits are like we all take them we all
- 53:10take the mickey out of each other everyone's got a caricature of themselves and so of all you know
- 53:16and so all those things for me make me a little bit suspicious of it now i know you've written a
- 53:21lot about it. So tell me more about white. Okay. I mean, you've written a whole book about it,
- 53:26right? Well, well, the book, the book was, you know, the book was a lot about the rise of populism
- 53:31and which is really about the immigration issue. And the immigration issue is, is I would argue,
- 53:39first and foremost about ethno-cultural change, at least in relation to the speed of assimilation
- 53:47and melting, right? And the ethnocultural change through immigration getting way ahead of the
- 53:53melting. And so, yeah, if you look at voters for the AFD in Bavaria, there was a poll taken,
- 54:02you know, 100% of them say, agreed with the statement, Germany is gradually losing its
- 54:06culture compared to 20% of, you know, green and SPD voters. Or, you know, you're one nation in
- 54:12Australia. Do you want immigration reduced? It's like 97%. Sweden Democrats, 99%. This is by far and
- 54:21away the engine of right-wing populism in the world. I mean, to my mind, it's just an open and
- 54:28shut case. The Brexit vote, even you look at the Brexit vote, top issue Brexit voters, 40%
- 54:34immigration, top issue, right? Economic inequality, all this sovereignty, all these, I mean,
- 54:39It depends what we mean by sovereignty, but basically the engine of the Brexit vote was immigration.
- 54:46I know there are people who don't want to really admit that, but that is really what people were talking about.
- 54:51And now there's a view that, you know, this is racism.
- 54:54If you don't like the pace of ethnocultural change, then you're a racist.
- 54:59And this is sort of one thing I would push back on.
- 55:01I would say there's a difference between saying, I don't like, you know, Hindus and Pakistan.
- 55:07I don't like, that's racism because you're saying something negative about a group, or
- 55:12you are hating a group, you're thinking you're superior to them, discriminating, that's racism.
- 55:18So attitudes to outgroups, but that's something different from attachment to in-group, or
- 55:24attachment to an ethnic composition that you've grown up with and are familiar with, and that
- 55:30forms part of your view of what the nation is.
- 55:33So attachment to, and in fact the psychology research shows attachment to and dislike of are separate dispositions.
- 55:40They develop at different ages when you're younger.
- 55:44Attachment to kind of comes from attachment to the mother.
- 55:48So they are separate things, and yet the left liberal society has managed to sort of ostracize those things as being the same.
- 55:57You know, if you like the way London was, if you are attached to that, you are a racist.
- 56:02Well, no, actually.
- 56:04Your attachment to is not the same as your hatred of.
- 56:07You may, you know, in many cases, so an example in the survey data, if you take white Americans who, you know, they're asked, this question's been asked for a long time, you know, how do you feel towards whites on a 0 to 100 thermometer?
- 56:21How do you feel towards blacks on a 0 to 100 thermometer?
- 56:24So the whites who are warmer towards whites are not colder towards blacks.
- 56:29If anything, they're slightly warmer towards blacks than whites who are cold towards whites.
- 56:33So that's the first thing to say, is that attachment to is not racism.
- 56:39Unless it gets about race purity, then it is racism.
- 56:42But if it's just about, okay, no, we want to keep this slow, manageable.
- 56:47The other thing is white culture.
- 56:49Okay, so this is a trickier area, right?
- 56:52Because I wrote this piece recently.
- 56:56I was commenting on the U.S. case.
- 56:59The U.S. is a bit different in the sense that what's occurred there is you've had a lot, extensive intermarriage between Irish, Italian, British origin.
- 57:07And so almost nobody is just one thing anymore.
- 57:12In that sort of situation, no, no.
- 57:14In that situation, what happens also is that popular culture becomes attached to skiing and playing.
- 57:23Country music might be associated with whites and hip-hop with blacks.
- 57:28That doesn't mean that nobody who isn't white listens to country music or plays hockey or whatever.
- 57:36And it also doesn't mean that you don't find white people listening to hip-hop.
- 57:41So the cultural products can be consumed by other groups, but they are associated with the groups who originated them.
- 57:49And they are disproportionately indulged in, perhaps, by that group.
- 57:55So I think there is, and in a way, these symbols are appropriated by different groups in different ways.
- 58:01So pizza, yes, it's Italian culture.
- 58:03It's eaten by many different people.
- 58:05It doesn't mean it's no longer Italian culture.
- 58:08I just think that, I mean, this gets into a lot of hair splitting,
- 58:11but I think it is a meaningful to talk about white culture black culture and so on Is meaningful Is meaningful even though members of the different groups can consume across that boundary So what is white culture then Well white culture would be practices that are associated disproportionately
- 58:30that were first of all originated with whites and are disproportionately associated with them
- 58:36and have become part of how they are identified.
- 58:40so you know again as I say black culture white culture are clearly consumed across the divide
- 58:48I just don't think it's if we're pretending that that you know the other thing is these groups do
- 58:55exist these identities exist I mean we take again if we take the U.S. case where this is clearer
- 59:01because in Britain you know clearly there's a difference between say East Europeans and and
- 59:05white British. The Irish have largely, I think, assimilated into the white British. But if you
- 59:10take the Europeans, they are assimilating, but they haven't yet completely done so. Whereas in
- 59:15the US case, I think it's a complete, you know, the white category is really the most meaningful
- 59:20one, not Irish, Italian, these things which are heavily diluted in any case. And so, you know,
- 59:27in these identities, if you look at surveys, I mean, in the sort of, I think it was in the 2010s,
- 59:32There was a book called White Identity Politics by Ashley Giardino, which really looked at a lot of the survey data.
- 59:38You know, most whites in America have some identification with white identity.
- 59:44It means something to them.
- 59:47And what you actually notice is the strongest predictor of whether you have—
- 59:52if you say, I feel strongly attached to being Italian-American,
- 59:56then you are way, way, way, way more likely to say, I feel strongly attached to being white.
- 1:00:00So it's kind of just an outer, if you like, a pan-ethnic outer skin to ethnicity.
- 1:00:07That's all that it is.
- 1:00:09And it's not that sinister or that mysterious.
- 1:00:12And as the white share declines, so the counties where whites are smaller share,
- 1:00:18there is a higher identification with being white because you're a smaller minority.
- 1:00:22And in fact, in Britain, the higher the Muslim share,
- 1:00:26the greater the likelihood of the population to identify.
- 1:00:29an individual who's white British to identify as Christian rather than non-religious,
- 1:00:34in response to that perception of being a minority.
- 1:00:37So I just think, look, these are facts.
- 1:00:40It doesn't mean people don't mix.
- 1:00:42It doesn't mean there isn't also a British culture that is transracial.
- 1:00:47But there's a kind of discomfort, deep discomfort with kind of formally acknowledging,
- 1:00:51although I would say the discomfort isn't so much with acknowledging black culture
- 1:00:55or Latino culture, for example,
- 1:00:58but there is a sort of reluctance to accept white culture.
- 1:01:02But, you know, as whites are declining and they, you know,
- 1:01:07marriage patterns, friendship patterns remain heavily, not totally,
- 1:01:12but heavily within group, and that's true also for white people.
- 1:01:16So if you take a, if we were to take the city of Los Angeles,
- 1:01:20you know, the average white person, if we allocated friends randomly,
- 1:01:23the average white person should have, of their five friends,
- 1:01:27one or two should be white and the rest should be other backgrounds. And the reality is just so
- 1:01:34incredibly far from that, that, you know, we can kid ourselves, but it's just to say, look,
- 1:01:41you know, is human nature to some degree, not to be totally exclusive, and this is where the
- 1:01:45ethno-nationalists go off the deep end, it's not like to have race purity. But, you know, most
- 1:01:51interactions are more comfortable within group than outside the group but there is still going
- 1:01:57to be mixing outside the group so yes there is and of course the mixed population is going to
- 1:02:02increase as a share of the total and so we could be in a different position in a hundred years but
- 1:02:07right now in this age this is where we are it's interesting i was just thinking then as you were
- 1:02:12speaking i definitely have a real discomfort in in the idea like you say yeah and i mean just
- 1:02:20thinking it through then it's for me it is it is I I struggle to to match it to skin I'll give you
- 1:02:27an example so I come I grew up in a very white culture obviously there weren't a lot of people
- 1:02:33and still where I live now because I've moved to very far the west of England so um but but if you
- 1:02:41were to say to me is your culture white I would say no and I'll give you an example so um there
- 1:02:48are certain things which would identify my culture you know and one of them would be things like you
- 1:02:53know the way we way we do christmas it's very it's very british it's very that's british culture
- 1:02:59so so i could have a an indian neighbor for example and if they put up a christmas tree
- 1:03:05and they celebrated then they would be british i would because i would recognize all the signals
- 1:03:10if they if they didn't and it was diwali then it would be oh this is a different thing that would
- 1:03:16be my my my difference and that i so i i do struggle to to associate it with with with skit
- 1:03:26with color you know do you know what i mean yeah yeah i mean and i get why that's a bit icky right
- 1:03:30because but i think that um look um i don't think you'd have a problem saying that that there is a
- 1:03:37south asian um culture or a black you know i don't think a black person would be as reticent
- 1:03:44to talk about black culture.
- 1:03:46And what we're really talking about
- 1:03:47is a kind of pan-ethnic.
- 1:03:48So what do all of the subgroups of black,
- 1:03:52which would be African, West Indian, and so on,
- 1:03:55is there anything in common there?
- 1:03:57The other thing, too, is that it could be that
- 1:03:59a group which was more homogenous,
- 1:04:03like American blacks who were descended
- 1:04:06from slaves in the United States,
- 1:04:07created a culture when really every black person
- 1:04:10was a descendant of those slaves.
- 1:04:12Now you've got 10, 15 percent from Africa and West Indies and whatever.
- 1:04:17Although I would say that they probably have oriented towards or have assimilated into the culture that was defined by the original black population.
- 1:04:27And so I think there's kind of also assimilation into this thing.
- 1:04:30But I think, look, what are we talking about?
- 1:04:33We're not saying that, you know, there's some blood purity rule that you can't, the cultures can't be cross boundaries.
- 1:04:41But what I would say, you know, but that doesn't mean, you know, you can have a British culture and common elements of British culture.
- 1:04:50You can have minorities who are heavily assimilated, right?
- 1:04:55And that may mean that they then intermarry into the white British majority and ultimately their descendants will become part of that majority.
- 1:05:03So you have people who are heavily assimilated and you have people who are much less assimilated.
- 1:05:07and I just think though that it's in a multi the reason why does race matter and of course
- 1:05:15East Europeans wouldn't be part of the culture you're talking about so it's not like all whites
- 1:05:22not the Hasidic Jew they're not part of this thing and so white is a bit of a shorthand
- 1:05:27because it corresponds roughly crudely to the ethnic majority probably better in the United
- 1:05:33States than here, because there are other white groups that are quite distinctive here.
- 1:05:39But I guess, what have I really talked about? I mean, if we're willing to talk about any
- 1:05:43prefix culture, Italian, whatever, Thai, you know, you could say, well, pizza, that's not Italian
- 1:05:52culture. That's from the south of Italy. There's not really Italian. I mean, you can always kind of
- 1:05:57strip these things down and deconstruct them. But I think if we're going to allow any kind of prefix
- 1:06:03to the word culture. I think, you know, white increasingly does denote something real,
- 1:06:08certainly in the U.S., and eventually I think that will happen here too because the East
- 1:06:13Europeans will eventually become assimilated into that group. Now, it's also blurry, right? You know,
- 1:06:18there's going to be what Michael Lin calls a Beijing, you know, people who are mixed
- 1:06:23will be part of this group as well, who, you know, not everybody's going to be 100%,
- 1:06:28you know, genetically white, right?
- 1:06:31So you're gonna have a,
- 1:06:32but I just think this sociologically
- 1:06:34that the social scientist in me
- 1:06:36still finds it meaningful to talk about these.
- 1:06:38Why do you find it uncomfortable
- 1:06:39Comfortable, I think that reflects partly this ambient post-60s public morality around white guilt, for example.
- 1:06:48The idea that you want to run away from this identity because it's seen as oppressive of other groups.
- 1:06:55So there is this kind of background music ambient public morality, which is almost like a weak form of wokeness.
- 1:07:02It's not wokeness, but it's sort of, it's one of the reasons wokeness is successful.
- 1:07:06Is it because it can key into your white guilt or somebody, and I'm not saying you have white guilt,
- 1:07:09but it can actually play on that pre-existing background music
- 1:07:14and therefore shut people up.
- 1:07:16And this is kind of one of the points in my book
- 1:07:18is we actually are going to have to revisit
- 1:07:19that background public morality,
- 1:07:22which is really based around the biggest sins, racism,
- 1:07:27maybe sexism is second, homophobia is third.
- 1:07:30We actually have to kind of say, well, those are bad things,
- 1:07:33but we need to have a more balanced meaning
- 1:07:37of what it means to be a good person
- 1:07:38than just being nice to people or minorities
- 1:07:41or not your sex or sexuality.
- 1:07:44I think that's too narrow,
- 1:07:46and it's led us into a cul-de-sac.
- 1:07:48So I think that we not just have to sort of limit woke
- 1:07:52in its extremities,
- 1:07:53but we also have to come to a kind of more multi-stranded,
- 1:07:58balanced public morality than we've got right now.
- 1:08:01I suppose one thing I was wondering
- 1:08:03is whether or not the age we live in
- 1:08:06means that defining black and white and color is actually outdated.
- 1:08:12I mean, we live in the age where travel and relocating
- 1:08:16and voting with your feet and all this stuff
- 1:08:18has never been more prevalent and is getting more and more prevalent.
- 1:08:22So I would say it's inevitable that the lines between race get blurred.
- 1:08:28You can't stop that.
- 1:08:30So I wonder what even...
- 1:08:32I actually see from my perspective, I would stop at culture.
- 1:08:36I would say culture is the important metric.
- 1:08:40Skin is not important.
- 1:08:43Culture is.
- 1:08:44And I'm going to give you another anecdotal example.
- 1:08:46I lived in London in the 2000s in a very diverse area.
- 1:08:51Everyone was living there who was everyone.
- 1:08:54But when I looked at my group of friends,
- 1:08:56I mixed along socioeconomic lines.
- 1:08:59You know, if in my group of friends,
- 1:09:02we were all at roughly the same spending level.
- 1:09:04And if there happened to be an Indian guy or a black guy or an Asian lady or whatever, then that would have, that's what would have happened.
- 1:09:14But we, but that's how we mix.
- 1:09:16We didn't mix with the guy down the road who had less spending power than us or more spending power than us.
- 1:09:21you know i wonder whether whether that's really not necessarily socioeconomic but whether or not
- 1:09:28um right using skin color is a is a bad idea because it's it's in the end like you say
- 1:09:35it's a bit like you you you you you get you get stuck because every no one's how do you define
- 1:09:42what it is how do you how do you define it like but with culture it's much easier because it's
- 1:09:47something you can express like the culture but there are groups so culture is the outward expression
- 1:09:53identity is the inward attachment which does link to ancestry in many many cases and you know i don't
- 1:10:00think that will be superseded actually because we've been through history and people have a sort
- 1:10:05of inclination not everybody but an inclination to this so i think when you say culture if what
- 1:10:11you're saying is there's one british culture and that's it i just think that's not reality i think
- 1:10:16that there are group-based cultures underneath that. Now, when you say blurring, there I agree
- 1:10:23with you. So I think you have intermarriage. Again, it's not as large generally as people say,
- 1:10:30but it's happening for real. So I would say yes. If what you're saying is there will be more
- 1:10:34mixing of DNA, yes, but that is not going to lead necessarily to one undifferentiated culture. So
- 1:10:43I mean, if you take a place like Brazil or countries that are multiracial, heavily multiracial,
- 1:10:49you know, most white Brazilians have some black or indigenous in them.
- 1:10:54Most white Bermudians have black ancestry.
- 1:10:59But these groups have not just simply broken down in everybody's brown.
- 1:11:03Now, in other countries, there are cases where over a long period, like thousands of years,
- 1:11:09you do get an undifferentiated population like Central Asia, where countries are an even mix of
- 1:11:15what we might think of East Asian and kind of Turkic, more European looking peoples have
- 1:11:21blended over time over a very long period of mixing. So that is, it can happen too.
- 1:11:28But what I would say is like being realistic, I think we're going to have,
- 1:11:33we are still going to have ethnic groups or pan-ethnic. When I talk about white, that's a
- 1:11:39pan-ethnic. It's like saying European instead of Irish or Italian. So that will exist, I would
- 1:11:45argue. But of course, the boundaries might be blurry. So somebody will be 50% Indian and 50%
- 1:11:53white British. One of my arguments in the book White Shift is, in fact, I think a lot of the
- 1:11:59people of that mixed race background will gravitate into the white identity over a long
- 1:12:03enough period of time. You know, partly because that's the established tradition, the longest
- 1:12:11existing group in this country. But that doesn't mean that you're going to see the complete
- 1:12:16assimilation of all the other groups. I think there will still be, you know, Pakistanis and
- 1:12:21whatever. But I don't think there's a contradiction between saying there's blurry boundaries,
- 1:12:25but that the groups will exist.
- 1:12:27That's kind of one of the standard analytic,
- 1:12:31you know, one of the standard theories
- 1:12:32in the study of ethnicity is that, you know,
- 1:12:35you can have people crossing these boundaries.
- 1:12:37The boundaries remain over time.
- 1:12:38They might shift, they might change, you know,
- 1:12:40there may be reasons why they shift.
- 1:12:43Wrap it up in a sec.
- 1:12:44I've still got a couple of questions.
- 1:12:46I've never spoken about this before.
- 1:12:47Oh, okay.
- 1:12:48Really.
- 1:12:49Well, it is fascinating because you seem to be much more concerned
- 1:12:54that it's important than I do.
- 1:12:57And I'm wondering why,
- 1:12:58because, and I'm wondering
- 1:12:59whether I'm going to be forced
- 1:13:00to be concerned about it,
- 1:13:02arguably in the future.
- 1:13:03Like you say, in the States now,
- 1:13:05race is a big issue.
- 1:13:08It's always, has been.
- 1:13:08There's the, one of the biggest things
- 1:13:10I noticed when the first few times
- 1:13:11I went to America was
- 1:13:12how much people care about stuff like that.
- 1:13:15And I come from, I mean,
- 1:13:16this is a silly anecdote,
- 1:13:17but this is, this is,
- 1:13:20I've told this story before on this podcast.
- 1:13:22My, where my,
- 1:13:24where my children have grown up is very white it's rural herefordshire there's no no sign of
- 1:13:32anyone with any strange skin colors everyone looks exactly the same lots of the same surnames
- 1:13:37everywhere this is people living on farms and stuff except ironically next door to us uh a black
- 1:13:45there was a lived a black lady and we've we've we became very good friends over the years um she's
- 1:13:52she's the epitome of non-woke.
- 1:13:55She's hilarious.
- 1:13:55I've interviewed her before.
- 1:13:59And in fact,
- 1:13:59she was known locally
- 1:14:01and this is going to make people shiver,
- 1:14:04but she was called Black Carol.
- 1:14:05Right, right.
- 1:14:06Because that's how you denoted people
- 1:14:07where we live.
- 1:14:08If you're fat,
- 1:14:09if you're tall,
- 1:14:10if you're,
- 1:14:10what's your characteristic?
- 1:14:12Oh, what happens if you lose weight?
- 1:14:13No, if you talk,
- 1:14:14and if you talk,
- 1:14:15her name isn't even Carol.
- 1:14:16Her name,
- 1:14:16she changed her name to Yasmin.
- 1:14:17She changed her name to Carol
- 1:14:19because she wanted to fit in more.
- 1:14:21Her name's actually Yasmin anyway.
- 1:14:22you know yasmin if you're living if you're listening i love you um but she so she we we
- 1:14:27grew up my kids grew up next to her she's very black she's got dreadlocks she's like you know
- 1:14:33unmistakably black and one day so she babysits our kids and you know our kids have known yas for
- 1:14:41for years and i think one day um alice my oldest daughter came home from school and she was about
- 1:14:47about eight and she said, oh, I, you know,
- 1:14:50the conversation about what do you do at school and stuff.
- 1:14:52And she said oh yeah we learned today that we should treat black people the same way we treat everyone else And I looked and I thought about that and I thought that ridiculous Like this is it beginning it beginning
- 1:15:06And I said, Alice, do you realize Yaz is black?
- 1:15:09And she had absolutely no idea that Yasmin was what she was being told about at school.
- 1:15:17There was absolutely no connection.
- 1:15:18After spending days and days and hours with this lady,
- 1:15:22who's got dreadlocks and very dark skin and eight years of growing she she experienced this lady in
- 1:15:30our culture which was a tiny little hamlet in the hills in herefordshire had no concept of it at all
- 1:15:36that's that's kind of like why i find it weird that maybe we should start thinking about skin
- 1:15:41color because my experience is is a version of that i've never thought about it before
- 1:15:46and and and then i go to america in sort of as i've grown a bit older and i'm i start really
- 1:15:51I think, holy shit, people really talk about it a lot here.
- 1:15:55It's really a thing here.
- 1:15:56And then when I go home, I start noticing,
- 1:15:59oh, it's becoming a thing here with us talking about it.
- 1:16:03And, you know, so, but you seem to think
- 1:16:06actually acknowledging it is a good idea, right?
- 1:16:09Yeah, I think it is.
- 1:16:10And look, I mean, just, you know,
- 1:16:12I've got Chinese in my background,
- 1:16:14got Hispanic in my background.
- 1:16:15So I'm a product of the melting pot as well.
- 1:16:17And so I'm not saying that those processes
- 1:16:20are going to go on.
- 1:16:21But I think it's one thing to have a few minorities in your neighborhood or in your social circle.
- 1:16:31But there is going to be much more significant ethno-demographic change in this century than has been experienced for 1,000 years in this country, for example.
- 1:16:44Why?
- 1:16:45Well, the world is going through a kind of global demographic revolution where we're going to, through this transition from high birth rates to low birth rates, but it's happening very unevenly.
- 1:16:54And so the number of people migrating from the global south into the, call it the white west, has increased dramatically.
- 1:17:02So the U.S. will be majority non-white in Canada and New Zealand after 2050.
- 1:17:09In Europe, it'll be later in the century.
- 1:17:11These are actually very important changes.
- 1:17:13So when you're talking about system-level shifts, then I just don't think there is—it's very hard for me to see this not becoming more important.
- 1:17:24Now, how does it happen, right?
- 1:17:26So in the U.S. case, it's not actually the case that racial antagonism—that's gone down, actually.
- 1:17:32And you can see many—one way is that voting is less along racial lines now than it was, say, 10 years ago or 15 years ago.
- 1:17:39but what this ethnic change does is it really splits the white population between people who
- 1:17:48like the change or who don't mind the change and people who don't want that to happen.
- 1:17:54It's not that they're race purists, but they just kind of want things to be kind of the same
- 1:17:58or not change so rapidly. And I don't think there's a problem. I think it's a legitimate
- 1:18:05preference in a democracy, which is currently stigmatized as racist. I think that will have to
- 1:18:10go. Because to the extent it is stigmatized, there's going to be a backlash against saying,
- 1:18:15people are like, no, I don't have a problem with black people or anybody else, but I kind of want
- 1:18:20there to be a majority that, you know, or, and that could be a melting, right? It could be a
- 1:18:26majority that has also absorbed members of different groups into it. But to give up on a
- 1:18:32majority is, I think, you know, if you look at the world, 70% of countries have an ethnic majority
- 1:18:37of at least 50%. 80%, it's at least 40%. We're now talking about the West, by the end of the
- 1:18:44century, going into that 20% minority of countries, which is associated with less economic development,
- 1:18:50with more voting along ethnic lines. So I just think this is a very legitimate topic.
- 1:18:56But you're right. I mean, it doesn't mean you're treating people differently by skin color.
- 1:19:00but it you know there is a kind of probably the relationship between pure skin color and group
- 1:19:07membership and identity will break down over time so that it'll be blurrier and you won't know
- 1:19:13automatically it's like in brazil you don't automatically know where somebody which group
- 1:19:17they fit into the other thing last thing i would say is that you know you talk about who you
- 1:19:22associate with in your friendship group it's socioeconomic but of course even when you control
- 1:19:28for socioeconomics, we know that, in fact, people's friends are not a random draw from the
- 1:19:33ethnic demographics of their area. They're very, very non-random. So in fact, when it comes to
- 1:19:39marriage and friendship and residence, these things actually do matter quite a bit.
- 1:19:45Again, we need to be able to talk about it. There is a certain degree to which it's in human nature
- 1:19:51to birds of a feather flock together, but not totally. We also have mixing, and that's all
- 1:19:58so real. So can we get away from this kind of binary where you have to be, oh, I don't care at
- 1:20:04all, and it doesn't matter what color the country becomes. And I think that is very unrealistic,
- 1:20:09given where most people are. I suppose I was just, my concern is that it creates a new divide. I was
- 1:20:16just thinking about, you know, thinking about my friend group, and thinking that the, for example,
- 1:20:24I have friends that are very Asian.
- 1:20:27They are Asian, but they're very British.
- 1:20:30They speak, you know, they were brought up.
- 1:20:33They lived here their whole lives.
- 1:20:34There's no sign of them, you know.
- 1:20:37I would never think of them as Chinese or Asian or something like that.
- 1:20:42But if we defined ourselves along skin color,
- 1:20:46I might then notice a difference between us.
- 1:20:49Is that a bad thing?
- 1:20:50Well, I think, look.
- 1:20:51I mean, or is, or when you say what, when people talk about white culture, are we talking about, is it a symbolic thing?
- 1:20:57Or is it literally about, you know?
- 1:21:00No, no, it's not.
- 1:21:01And that's the whole point is these cultures can, can be consumed across ethnic racial lines.
- 1:21:07Right, right, right, right.
- 1:21:08Like you're saying, like you're saying, if you're into hip hop, you're into black culture.
- 1:21:12But that doesn't mean that you have to be black.
- 1:21:14That doesn't mean you can say, well, no, you can't call hip hop black culture.
- 1:21:18I just think we can't call anything, anything.
- 1:21:20I mean, Italian culture, I eat pizzas, you can't have Italian.
- 1:21:23I mean, it's ridiculous.
- 1:21:25I think, yes, we can use these terms, these prefixes.
- 1:21:28They are real.
- 1:21:28It doesn't mean they're kind of hermetically sealed.
- 1:21:32But I also think, you know, to say that I just think it's not necessarily accurate to say that you just treat them as British and you don't notice they're Asian.
- 1:21:42I mean, I think even to notice that they're Asian is kind of in a way noticing that there's a difference.
- 1:21:50Again, that doesn't have to be the most salient part of your interaction.
- 1:21:54It could be a low salience, not very important part of that interaction.
- 1:21:59It doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
- 1:22:01And some people are going to want to attach more to that and less to that.
- 1:22:04It's like extended family.
- 1:22:06Some people care about extended family.
- 1:22:08Some people don't.
- 1:22:09That's a choice.
- 1:22:10Some people are going to care about their ethnic heritage.
- 1:22:12Others won't.
- 1:22:13That's a choice.
- 1:22:15One's not better than the other.
- 1:22:16But if someone chooses to attach to that, I don't think...
- 1:22:19And similarly with the pan-ethnic, what we might call racial, I don't think that should be stigmatized until the point someone says, no, I'm a purist and I believe in pure races and non-mixed.
- 1:22:32Okay, then we can talk about racism, right?
- 1:22:36But as long as somebody has an identity, I don't think that in and of itself should be stigmatized.
- 1:22:40Sorry.
- 1:22:42We're overshooting a bit here.
- 1:22:44But like I say, I do find it fascinating.
- 1:22:46And I think what I'm fascinated by is the fact that you consider it important.
- 1:22:51And because you're an academic, you're obviously not a racist.
- 1:22:54You're a very nice gentleman.
- 1:22:56You know, you're also, like you say, full of different races.
- 1:23:00But you seem to think it's something that needs to be addressed.
- 1:23:04So my ears are pricking up.
- 1:23:06Okay, let's finish.
- 1:23:07Yeah, yeah, sure.
- 1:23:08Can you give me some insight into the next few years of culture then What you think Maybe I suppose let say 30 or 40 years What can we expect You seem to think the age of woke is coming to an end
- 1:23:27or at least it's reached its limits, let's say.
- 1:23:31People are pushing back on it now.
- 1:23:33So where do you think we're going from here?
- 1:23:35God, it's really good.
- 1:23:36I mean, I do think we are entering into an interregnum.
- 1:23:40We've reached the end of what I'd call the progressive era
- 1:23:43of where essentially equal outcomes,
- 1:23:46emotional harm, protection for minority groups
- 1:23:48is the dominant value.
- 1:23:49I think that is over.
- 1:23:51It's not that we're going to go back.
- 1:23:53It's not like Gazer in the Closet
- 1:23:54and women back in the kitchen.
- 1:23:55We're not going to do that.
- 1:23:58But I think that we're in a period
- 1:23:59of polarization, contestation,
- 1:24:01which will continue.
- 1:24:03And actually, I do think the left
- 1:24:05bears more responsibility
- 1:24:06because they are in power in the institutions.
- 1:24:10They are very reluctant to, for example,
- 1:24:13what I've talked about, to split off dislike of outgroups, which is racism, from attachment to
- 1:24:19own. They're not willing to accept attachment to own group only for whites or also for men,
- 1:24:25other categories. Only if you are a subaltern category do you get to have an identity.
- 1:24:31If you are cultural appropriation, it's fine if you're minority and you appropriate quote-unquote
- 1:24:37white culture, but not the reverse. So there are a whole set of double standards. I think that's
- 1:24:42going to feed resentment and it's going to create polarization, but I don't think the left is yet
- 1:24:48willing or doesn't know how to back off some of its very religious beliefs in the sacredness
- 1:24:55of minority groups. The indigenous as a kind of, you cannot offend an indigenous person if they
- 1:25:01claim that they underwent genocide in residential school. You just must honor that and be an ally.
- 1:25:06That kind of mentality, the white guilt mentality, very deep rooted.
- 1:25:11I don't see it going away.
- 1:25:13So I just think we're going to be in a standoff.
- 1:25:15Now, what I'd say is the public opinion, U.S., Canada, Britain, where I've studied it, it's two to one against the woke positions.
- 1:25:21They're not.
- 1:25:22They are.
- 1:25:22What we're going to see is probably the right, if it kind of focuses, can use this as a wedge issue to essentially win elections and force the left off.
- 1:25:33And we'll see.
- 1:25:34I mean, I think that in the U.S., the Democrats think they can win without addressing, say, the trans issue, continuing to be trans activists.
- 1:25:43But over time, if they keep losing, they're going to have to back off that.
- 1:25:46It's going to be interesting to see whether they're pragmatic enough to do that.
- 1:25:50But I think that's where the culture is, very polarized.
- 1:25:53But I think the thinking people, the sort of people who care about truth on the left, and they are there and there are maybe more of them.
- 1:26:02the Noah Smiths and Matthew Iglesias of this world,
- 1:26:05and they are kind of saying, look, guys, we've gone overboard.
- 1:26:10You know, we have to row back.
- 1:26:12So I think there are some sort of saner voices on the left.
- 1:26:15Will they prevail? Not now, but I'm hopeful at some point,
- 1:26:20because if they actually are able to rein in the radical progressives
- 1:26:25and the whole kind of race, gender, sex worship on the left,
- 1:26:33that will start a process of de-radicalization,
- 1:26:37and we can get to a better place.
- 1:26:38But I think it really is going to have to be the left.
- 1:26:41Now, the right, of course, can go off the deep end,
- 1:26:43and we've seen it go off the deep end in certain ways,
- 1:26:46but I just think as long as the left is radical
- 1:26:49and in control of institutions like schools and universities,
- 1:26:52And I just think that this is not going to work and it's going to be a battle.
- 1:26:57So what I would say is polarization and battling over cultures.
- 1:27:02One interesting thing, you can look at young people.
- 1:27:04Young people are more polarized on cultural issues than older people are.
- 1:27:09And I think that's a portent of where we're going.
- 1:27:11I think these issues are going to be more important for politics, deciding elections, for example.
- 1:27:18And these issues have to be decided in a democracy.
- 1:27:21I mean, is someone who's born male, do they go into the women's prison?
- 1:27:25That's an issue that has to be decided by a democracy.
- 1:27:28The attempt to shame everybody into letting them in by claiming it's trans rights
- 1:27:33and you're against rights for a marginalized group, that's been the strategy.
- 1:27:36And using courts and bypassing the democratic process, I don't think that's going to work.
- 1:27:42I think the rights realize that they can get these things and make them political,
- 1:27:45which they should, actually.
- 1:27:47So I think culture wars should be in politics, and this idea that it's ungentlemanly to raise them I think is dead wrong.
- 1:27:55So yeah, I think that's—now, of course, we're also—the other part of culture is this ongoing demographic shift.
- 1:28:00So we are in a period where, you know, ethnic majorities in the West are declining.
- 1:28:06That is going to create more fuel for populism.
- 1:28:09So I would say populism is going to be an endemic feature of politics.
- 1:28:14up until the time we can get rid of these taboos and have a normal conversation. How fast do we
- 1:28:21want this change to occur? And if I say slower, I'm not just put into the racist box and kind of
- 1:28:27no one will invite me for dinner, right? We got to get away from that culture to have a more open
- 1:28:32conversation. And if we can do that, then I think we can get past the polarization. But if we continue
- 1:28:38going as we are now i i don't see it so a choppy few years yeah and then a happy ending yeah yeah
- 1:28:46i think in the long run in the long run i think it will be happier but that's like could be a
- 1:28:51hundred years right but i don't think in the in the next 20 30 we're going to be there is so
- 1:28:56arguably it's just this is a time we live in the the time the time of the internet the time of all
- 1:29:02these crazy inventions we've had recently which have forced certain things especially ideas and
- 1:29:07into the forefront of everyone's mind.
- 1:29:11That's the age we live in.
- 1:29:12I think it's a term.
- 1:29:13The turmoil, like you say,
- 1:29:15may last a long time,
- 1:29:16but I hope it doesn't last 100 years.
- 1:29:18Anyway, Eric, many thanks.
- 1:29:21And sorry, I've run over a little bit.
- 1:29:23That's all right.
- 1:29:23But it's really fascinating talking to you.
- 1:29:25Yeah, I appreciate your candid speech
- 1:29:29because I think, like I say,
- 1:29:32I can just, even the simple fact
- 1:29:34that I feel myself tensing up
- 1:29:36when I talk about this.
- 1:29:37And I'm really open-minded.
- 1:29:39And, you know, I think it's great to discuss it.
- 1:29:45I'm not sure I understand.
- 1:29:48I need to let things sink in, I think.
- 1:29:50Yeah, I should say that academically I have taught nationalism and ethnicity for 25 years.
- 1:29:57So, I mean, I'm kind of interested in all these subtle nuances.
- 1:30:02So, culture versus identity.
- 1:30:04So, I'll give you an example.
- 1:30:06a Pakistani militant celebrating the 9-11 World Trade Center attacks, wearing a Chicago Bears
- 1:30:14t-shirt. Okay, so what is that image telling us? Well, the culture suggests globalization and the
- 1:30:20spread of a common culture. The identity clearly is anti-Western, but clearly not a global identity.
- 1:30:27So that's just one wrinkle, culture versus identity. Then there's ethnicity versus race,
- 1:30:33versus pan and all of these things are separate and then there's all the kind of mixing and and
- 1:30:38boundaries versus cores and so there's a lot of complexity there um and this when i hear people
- 1:30:44talking about is rishi sunak english i just kind of tear my hair out because um it's it's it's just
- 1:30:50such a crude way of approaching it the question should be well is he a member of the english
- 1:30:55nation i would say yes uh is he a member of the english ethnic group no the that's a separate
- 1:31:01categories. You have to kind of, I think you have to be quite forensic about what you're talking
- 1:31:06about here. Or even the idea of British and English. Well, there's a British nation,
- 1:31:10and then within that, there's an English nation. And so there's a lot of complexity there. And I
- 1:31:16think a lot of the commentary is a bit low resolution, or should I say, yeah, pretty low
- 1:31:21resolution, so it can't really answer the question properly. Yeah, I understand. I think, like I say,
- 1:31:27My contention is why even have a high resolution conversation about it That the bit I stuck on I sure that I know in my own mind it gets addressed issues get addressed
- 1:31:46and then I start thinking about them for a long time.
- 1:31:49And slowly I start wondering and looking into other things.
- 1:31:53But I agree that it's almost certainly something
- 1:31:56that will need to be addressed.
- 1:31:58Because like you say, and in the case of,
- 1:32:01it's ramping back up again, I'm not going to,
- 1:32:04I'm just in the case of say, you know, when you talk about white culture in the UK, the way I see it is mostly pumped in the mainstream is Islam versus English people.
- 1:32:18And so how are you going to define the opposition to Islam?
- 1:32:23Oh, let's call it white people, because it kind of is, you know, it's Christianity.
- 1:32:28it's like you know and where it's where it's where it's obvious the most is in traditionally
- 1:32:33ethnic neighborhoods that have become islamic say which is basically you know so so it's easy to say
- 1:32:41it's white and islam or white and whatever that subgroup would you would call maybe not even yeah
- 1:32:47i mean it really is islam i think because a lot of the issues you hear talked about now in the
- 1:32:51in the mainstream political realms are to do with that and and and you know even the one i was
- 1:32:58talking about yesterday which is like halal slaughter you know i i recounted this experience
- 1:33:04to one of my guests yesterday i was down the pub i live in a rural community i was down the pub the
- 1:33:07other day we were talking about rupert lowe because i think he'd just come out and said he's
- 1:33:11going to ban halal and kosher slaughter or whatever and everyone got very animated about
- 1:33:17that and said yes this is a because they're farmers and and they care about they they ship
- 1:33:22their their sheep now get shipped off to slaughterhouses in in um birmingham which is a long
- 1:33:28way away because basically the biggest trade for lamb is is halal and lots of the local slaughter
- 1:33:35houses have closed down and you can sell halal lamb to everyone you know like if you're non-halal
- 1:33:42you'll still eat it and but they hate but the local farmers around my way a lot of them are
- 1:33:46really hate that they hate the thought because they look after their animals and they don't want
- 1:33:50their animals to be killed that way they consider it inhumane so you know it became you know i was
- 1:33:57i was amazed i was like wow that's the kind of you know but there there's one aspect of british
- 1:34:02culture that i think animal lovers british people are animal lovers we care deeply about animals
- 1:34:07therefore that one issue that little issue about how we kill our livestock animated our whole pub
- 1:34:15of people talking, yeah, this is terrible.
- 1:34:19This should be stopped.
- 1:34:21It's fascinating, really.
- 1:34:23There is this argument within people who study this stuff
- 1:34:28that within, so there would be competing versions
- 1:34:31of British culture, competing versions
- 1:34:33of British national identity within the same country.
- 1:34:35Yes.
- 1:34:36And so I think one version of that British national identity,
- 1:34:41it's a bit like British people quiet and reserved
- 1:34:44or are British people kind of yobbish and loud?
- 1:34:47I mean, they're both true,
- 1:34:49and they're different versions of Britishness, right?
- 1:34:52So I think it's very hard to nail down to one version.
- 1:34:56And so you could call it competing versions of Britishness.
- 1:34:59But I just think the reality is in terms of how people live their lives in the world,
- 1:35:04who they marry, who they are friends with, where they choose to live,
- 1:35:08all of these things.
- 1:35:09In fact, if we did this all randomly, we wouldn't,
- 1:35:13Britain wouldn't look the way it does.
- 1:35:16In England, it's like 80% of wards are 90% white or more.
- 1:35:21The number of very deeply diverse ones is actually quite small.
- 1:35:24So it's actually very non-random.
- 1:35:27Friendship is very non-random.
- 1:35:28And I don't think it's enough to say it's socioeconomic.
- 1:35:31I think, again, but it doesn't mean it's exclusive.
- 1:35:34So what you'll notice is, like I live in London,
- 1:35:38gatherings will be mostly white, but there will be minorities there.
- 1:35:42but it's not going to reflect London.
- 1:35:44It might be 10% minority instead of 50%, right?
- 1:35:48But that represents a lot of non-randomness.
- 1:35:52Yeah, that's a socio-intellectual, is that right?
- 1:35:56You're probably mixing with people who,
- 1:36:01part of the universities, which,
- 1:36:03I mean, I'm just thinking about
- 1:36:04even this conference we're at now,
- 1:36:06a lot of old people and a lot of white people.
- 1:36:10I mean, almost exclusively, I think.
- 1:36:12Right. You know, that's and that's conservatism. That's like the culture of conservatism in a way, or at least the culture of people that want to come and talk about conservatism.
- 1:36:21It would be the same on the left, by the way. So I don't think you'd find it. Is that right? Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. So it's Green Party would be the same. I don't think it's the ideology.
- 1:36:31uh is that right yeah but i i assumed the left was very diverse every well no not true okay i mean
- 1:36:40if you were at a green party it would it would be old but they would be you know more hippie uh
- 1:36:45you know so so it's not uh it's it's just concerned white people you mean yeah yeah who went on
- 1:36:52nuclear marches well no that is that is absolutely true the reason i know yeah that that is true
- 1:36:58absolutely i mean i've i've i've been i was a journalist for years in london so i've gone to
- 1:37:05a lot of protests and it's true most protests i went to were white people everywhere you know in
- 1:37:13large quantities it was that you know they were the people that cared it seemed about the issue
- 1:37:20whatever it was lots of the issues were in complete you know opposition to each other you
- 1:37:25You know, but that was definitely the case.
- 1:37:28It's a bit like maybe going to, you know,
- 1:37:30certain kinds of music concerts or rugby matches.
- 1:37:33There's certain things that are going to attract
- 1:37:35a heavily white audience.
- 1:37:37Like, I mean, in London, I'd never been to a rugby game
- 1:37:40and I went to the first one.
- 1:37:42And yeah, I mean, it was, you know,
- 1:37:44it was very undiverse, right, for London.
- 1:37:46Similarly with going to a rock concert, you know,
- 1:37:50again, same sort of thing, right?
- 1:37:51But then if I went to probably some hip-hop event,
- 1:37:54it would probably be a lot more diverse right but but i mean i think isn't it really only one side
- 1:37:59of the aisle that cares that though like i don't mind like for example this podcast our listenership
- 1:38:04is when you look at the data i think it's 95 men you know i'd love to have more women listen but i
- 1:38:12don't care right right men tend to be interested in this stuff a lot more like i mean you know our
- 1:38:18podcast we talk about not not just freedom but free cities in general and all this kind of
- 1:38:23independent jurisdictions places that want to become independent for example that's very much
- 1:38:28a male thing wanting to create you know um i don't care i i don't care if you know what you know i'm
- 1:38:36not i'm not it is literally a free market of ear of ears like bring your ears if you want to listen
- 1:38:43you can and lo and behold it's almost 100 men that listen and it's not because because that's
- 1:38:49what you're aiming at it reminded me of i went on a on a population projections course in demography
- 1:38:54and i was in this class it was like 28 people 26 women in there um and i was okay they're really
- 1:39:00interested in demography and then i thought oh yeah it's because they have children and and you
- 1:39:04know so that's maybe why they're interested in demography and it never occurred to me um but
- 1:39:09yeah these things just happen but what the only thing i would say is i do think that ethnic
- 1:39:14identification, cultural identification, I mean, is a legitimate way. And in fact, so I don't think
- 1:39:21we should stigmatize it. If people want to get interested in their history and their heritage
- 1:39:26and their ancestry, whatever, I think that's perfectly fine. You know, so I don't, I think
- 1:39:31if you try and stick, and of course, it also means that those people are going to care about rapid
- 1:39:37ethnic shifting. And again, you just have to look at human history. I mean, you find me in the
- 1:39:42society where nobody cared about this, or that wasn't a major driver of politics. In Scotland,
- 1:39:48when you had a lot of the Irish coming in, in between the wars, you had populist parties getting
- 1:39:53a third of the vote. So I just think it's not, is it very surprising? Well, I would say try and find me the time in human
- 1:39:59where you didn't get a response.
- 1:40:01No, I agree.
- 1:40:02And I'm definitely going to...
- 1:40:04No, 100% in it.
- 1:40:05I do agree.
- 1:40:06What's definitely sure, though,
- 1:40:08is that it is a contentious issue right now.
- 1:40:11Really, really, it is becoming the issue
- 1:40:14that people are choosing to...
- 1:40:18This is the hill people are choosing to die on, really,
- 1:40:20if you think about it.
- 1:40:21And yeah, let's see how it plays out.
- 1:40:24And anyway, Eric, thanks very much indeed for coming in.
- 1:40:27I've really enjoyed this.
- 1:40:28And I will definitely be committing some of the ideas to memory and just seeing where they go.
- 1:40:37I need to look at more of what you've, there's a lot of your stuff online and you've got a lot of books.
- 1:40:43So I'm going to take a dive in.
- 1:40:45I like the academic approach to all this stuff because I'm fascinated by it.
- 1:40:48It's just very difficult to discuss, I think.
- 1:40:51It's a whole, yeah, I mean, it's a whole kind of, I've done a course with the Peterson Academy, actually.
- 1:40:56And so you might enjoy that.
- 1:40:58I don't know, but what is a nation?
- 1:41:00What is a state?
- 1:41:01What is an ethnic group?
- 1:41:03Can people have multiple ethnic identity?
- 1:41:05Yeah, you could have the national, the ethnic,
- 1:41:08which is more important to you.
- 1:41:09All those kind of things are important in thinking about this.
- 1:41:12It's so easy to call it racist, though.
- 1:41:13It is.
- 1:41:14I mean, just listening to you there, I'm thinking,
- 1:41:16if I were somebody else,
- 1:41:18that's how I would deduce what you're saying.
- 1:41:21And I'm almost certain that someone will listen to this
- 1:41:23and think exactly the same thing,
- 1:41:25because it's so easy.
- 1:41:26Well, it is. And what's interesting, though, is also that that's the cultural cringe in the society. And where does that come from? But I'm quite happy to get into the weeds. So I was even on Moral Maze and Giles Fraser came out. So it's about color then. And I said, well, okay, let's just look at this. Because, you know, there's a lot of interesting wrinkles.
- 1:41:45Like if I say to you, you know, if I could say all accents are British accents because if someone has a foreign accent but they're committed to the country, then they're British.
- 1:41:56So therefore all accents are British accents.
- 1:41:59On one level, that's true.
- 1:42:00You can have any accent and be British.
- 1:42:02But on another level if we say like my accent is a British accent well that ridiculous And so I kind of think you have to be able to differentiate the membership criteria level which should be very open from the system level which cannot be as open
- 1:42:20So we have to, if we care about ethnic change at the system level, that doesn't mean we're
- 1:42:25excluding at the individual level membership.
- 1:42:27And that's a really hard thing to get people to understand, is that you can care about
- 1:42:34ethnic change, radical transformations without being a racist at the individual level. And
- 1:42:40it's just so easy to collapse these. And the problem is the politicians don't have the
- 1:42:46vocabulary to know how to navigate these things. And so they'll go to what's easy. So going after
- 1:42:53Islam is a lot easier because anti-women, anti-gay, anti-Jew, whatever. It's a much easier
- 1:43:00approach than to really say, well, actually, decline of the white British is an issue. And
- 1:43:06it's not just about Islam. And it's a separate issue. And it needs to be addressed. So I just
- 1:43:12don't know, because it's not an easy way to, in our current climate, to get into that discussion,
- 1:43:18if you really don't know your categories and all the fine details. So it's...
- 1:43:23Do you find... Sorry for one last question. Do you find anyone on the other side of the aisle
- 1:43:29understands what you're saying.
- 1:43:32Well, yeah, I mean, what's interesting is,
- 1:43:34so in Moral Maze, for example, you know,
- 1:43:37actually I did get, I mean,
- 1:43:39I think the good faith interlocutors are interested
- 1:43:44because I think they know these things are true
- 1:43:48and that these are legitimate issues.
- 1:43:50So I do think there are people who are willing to engage.
- 1:43:55I don't know who.
- 1:43:56All I can say is like I sat down for an hour and a half with Owen Jones the other day.
- 1:44:02Really?
- 1:44:02Did you?
- 1:44:03And had a really good conference.
- 1:44:05Not on his podcast.
- 1:44:06He's writing a book.
- 1:44:08Now, whether he's, you know, he's not always a good faith interlocutor.
- 1:44:11But what I'd say is there.
- 1:44:12Blimey.
- 1:44:13He's the antithesis.
- 1:44:17Do you mind sharing what the experience was?
- 1:44:20Oh he was perfectly nice I mean now I don know what he going to write I mean of course he of the left He a firm believer in all of this sort of stuff But at least I give him credit for reaching out
- 1:44:33But what did he want to ask you about? Wokeness, presumably?
- 1:44:36Yeah, just where I'm coming from and the source of the ideas. And, you know, he was writing a book, undoubtedly.
- 1:44:44I mean, he's almost certainly going to frame you as, you know.
- 1:44:47Yeah, yeah.
- 1:44:48Well, I don't know.
- 1:44:49Because if he doesn't, he's platforming you, your ideas, which is, from what I understand of those guys, is platforming you is already a sin, isn't it?
- 1:44:58Right.
- 1:44:59Well, I think that he wants to...
- 1:45:00Let alone not bringing your ideas down.
- 1:45:02I think he will undoubtedly pass moral judgment.
- 1:45:06But I also think he will include a lot of what I said.
- 1:45:09And even though there will be some sort of out of contexting, I think it'll probably be, okay, I want to understand.
- 1:45:16I think there is an element of wanting to understand.
- 1:45:20And the truth of the matter is a lot of people on the right don't really articulate it.
- 1:45:26They would much rather say immigration, putting pressure on public services and Islam is a threat to women's rights and all this sort of stuff.
- 1:45:34It's just easier to go there because you're not going to get into super uncomfortable terrain than to talk about the decline of the white British.
- 1:45:42and so I just think that
- 1:45:46but I don't think that's actually the issue
- 1:45:48I mean it's not just about Islam actually
- 1:45:51even though Islam can sometimes be the lightning rod
- 1:45:53but we have to be able to have these hard conversations
- 1:45:56because people you know to some degree are attached to their ancestry
- 1:46:00and to their group
- 1:46:02but you know only now some people are not
- 1:46:05but we have to be realistic I think about where people
- 1:46:09meet people where they are
- 1:46:10and I just think that conversation has to happen.
- 1:46:14So yeah, I think there, I mean, the book, for example,
- 1:46:16I was also on Ezra Klein's podcast around the book
- 1:46:20and I felt, you know, I got a reasonably good discussion.
- 1:46:25Now, granted, Klein is not known as a tack dog reviewer
- 1:46:28and he's one of the smarter people on the left
- 1:46:32and so we had a good conversation.
- 1:46:34So I do think there are people out there who will have that good conversation if you can elevate it into intellectual terms that the problem is you know is getting to that point so i think the
- 1:46:46intellectuals who are who are honest and care about truth on the left you can have a conversation with
- 1:46:51not the james o'brien the shark jock types i don't think so eric thank you very much indeed for
- 1:46:59entertaining my ridiculous questions.
- 1:47:01That's all right.
- 1:47:01And yeah, I'd love to talk about this another time
- 1:47:04in a couple of years
- 1:47:06when I've managed to mature my understanding of it.
- 1:47:10I mean, you know,
- 1:47:12but thank you deeply for coming and speaking to me
- 1:47:15and I've really enjoyed this.
- 1:47:16Thanks for having me, Tim.
- 1:47:17It's been great.
- 1:47:21Right, you made it to the end of the show.
- 1:47:24So I'm going to go ahead and assume
- 1:47:26that you got some value out of this episode.
- 1:47:29If you want to help the show,
- 1:47:31please follow or subscribe right now.
- 1:47:34It takes only two seconds
- 1:47:36and it massively helps.
- 1:47:38If you've got another 30 seconds,
- 1:47:40well, leave a review on Apple Podcasts
- 1:47:43or Spotify.
- 1:47:45Honest reviews apparently
- 1:47:46are the single best way
- 1:47:48to help new listeners find us.
- 1:47:50If you want more,
- 1:47:51you can get bonus episodes
- 1:47:53and early access to episodes
- 1:47:55on fountain.fm for the price of one coffee for a whole month.
- 1:48:01Or you can support the mission by streaming sats
- 1:48:03on any of the value for value platforms
- 1:48:06or use the Bitcoin and fiat donation links in the show notes.
- 1:48:10Every contribution to the show makes a real difference.
- 1:48:14Believe me.
- 1:48:15And one more thing.
- 1:48:16If you know someone who'd love this episode,
- 1:48:18share it directly with them.
- 1:48:20That personal share beats every algorithm in the book.
- 1:48:23All the links, the community and the newsletter are in the show notes and jump on over to freecities.fm for a deep dive into all the episodes with descriptions and more.
- 1:48:36That's the new Free Cities podcast website, freecities.fm.
- 1:48:41Have a good week and see you next time.