Latest / The Vegan Report / Reminding You of Slaughterhouses. With Dr. Amy Fitzgerald | Ep. 39
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you are listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:06There is one thing that Big Ag absolutely does not want us to talk about and that is
- 0:11slaughterhouses.
- 0:13So let's talk about it in depth for this entire episode.
- 0:17Let's talk about why they are hidden, the harm they cause not just to animals but also
- 0:23human societies and the environment.
- 0:26And most importantly let's talk about how to close them down for good.
- 0:32To discuss this topic I have with me Dr. Amy Fitzgerald, a professor and researcher at
- 0:38the University of Windsor.
- 0:40She has written multiple books such as Animal Advocacy and Environmentalism Understanding
- 0:46and Bridging the Divide, Animals as Food Reconnecting Production, Processing, Consumption and Impacts,
- 0:54Animal Abuse and Family Violence, Researching the Interrelationships of Abusive Power and
- 1:01A Social History of the Slaughterhouse from Inception to Contemporary Implications, which
- 1:07is not a book but the article that inspired me to reach out to Dr. Fitzgerald, a must
- 1:13read you can access by following the link in the description below.
- 1:18Thank you Amy for having accepted my invitation and for being here.
- 1:23It's my pleasure.
- 1:24I want to first get to why slaughterhouses are such unique institutions.
- 1:30And let me start by this.
- 1:32You quote in your paper, V.I.S.
- 1:34I think his name is, who writes, whereas the slaughter of a few animals may be a festive
- 1:41occasion, slaughter on a larger scale is different, it is disturbing.
- 1:47Therefore means must be found of putting it out of mind.
- 1:52Why do we differentiate the slaughter of a few animals versus the slaughter on a large
- 1:58scale?
- 1:59I mean psychologically because we hear lots of vegans talk about speciesism and the absurdity
- 2:05of treating a dog according to a certain set of standards and a cow according to others.
- 2:11But I don't think I have heard much talks about the number of animal slaughters and if
- 2:18that made a difference.
- 2:20Yeah that's a great question and I think in order to properly answer it I need to kind
- 2:27of contextualize slaughterhouses historically.
- 2:33So the slaughterhouses we currently know it is relatively new.
- 2:40So historically people killed you know a few animals in their backyards for their own personal
- 2:49consumption.
- 2:52But then in the 19th century there was a shift from you know small scale backyard slaughtering
- 3:00of animals to moving it to a more central place.
- 3:05And interestingly one of the reasons for that move was that reformers at the time were concerned
- 3:11about the public being exposed to the visuals of animals being slaughtered and also the
- 3:20sounds the smells etc.
- 3:23And so they were moved from public places and became unique institutions.
- 3:31So instead of you know in the past when they animals were killed small scale in people's
- 3:38backyards or personal consumption now you had a unique space being created for that
- 3:45purpose.
- 3:47And so actually in France in the 19th century it became necessary to coin a term abattoir
- 3:55to refer to this new space that was created.
- 4:02And it was when they shifted out of public spaces they were made quite nondescript so
- 4:12you wouldn't necessarily see one and know one just like today right.
- 4:16They're hard to identify and viales actually refers to it as a place that is no place right.
- 4:24It's hard to pinpoint what you're looking at unless you know what to what to look for.
- 4:32And so then then there was a shift where they started industrializing.
- 4:40So they went from you know concentrated killing of animals to all of a sudden this larger
- 4:48scale killing of animals that was made possible by mechanization you know increase in worker
- 4:58number of workers into the facilities etc.
- 5:03And so then through this industrialization then we see large slaughterhouses emerge which
- 5:10are quite different and actually not just conceptually different but also empirically
- 5:17have different relationships with things like community impacts than small-scale slaughterhouses
- 5:26do.
- 5:27LR And what is it about you know coming back to my question why you know do we react you
- 5:36know we're joyful when it's like a village festival or something a farming festival and
- 5:44we're killing a few pigs but with slaughterhouses you know there's something graphic the footage
- 5:52of it makes people deeply uncomfortable and even some of them become vegan as a consequence.
- 6:04So what is it psychologically in humans that make us you know make that differentiation?
- 6:10KM Well there are a number of perspectives on that.
- 6:18One individual Norbert Elias has referred to it as part of a broader so-called civilizing
- 6:25process where instead of you know instead of serving animals with the full body on the
- 6:35table for instance right which had been standard practice people became increasingly uncomfortable
- 6:42and it was a shift away from you know our own animality right that we needed to separate
- 6:51the you know the actual visual of the animal that we were consuming and so then you see
- 6:58the shift towards you know the more out of sight out of mind the better and with the
- 7:08you know currently the industry it has helped to serve their ends right because people don't
- 7:14go poking around looking for slaughterhouses generally you know unless they're activists
- 7:22who have have an interest in you know in that specific space but we don't we don't consumers
- 7:31don't search them out right so the less they know the better you know that's the way the
- 7:38industry feels and it's certainly the way a lot of consumers feel.
- 7:41So just to illustrate that point historically like in the stockyards in Chicago which in
- 7:51the U.S. was kind of the Mecca of animal slaughtering at one point in history you used to be able
- 7:57to do tours and they were quite you know celebrated right that was like the tourist thing to do
- 8:05when you were in Chicago now you can't you can't get near a slaughterhouse I certainly
- 8:12can't right it's it's quite quite uncommon that they invite they would allow the public
- 8:21to come in to see what's going on there and also you know the flip side of that is it
- 8:27would be relatively uncommon for consumers to to want to see you know how their how their
- 8:35meat is is produced because it's it's not a particularly savory process.
- 8:44That's fascinating and so what I understand from what you're saying is that our ancestors
- 8:52would not be as shocked by slaughterhouses as we would.
- 8:58Yeah and I think you know I this scale also has something to do with it so not only is
- 9:07it part of you know a broader cultural process of trying to separate ourselves from our own
- 9:12animality but also the the scale of it now is is so immense and a lot of consumers I
- 9:24think don't realize how many animals are killed in slaughterhouses how quickly they're killed
- 9:32which is one of the reasons that work in the industry has you know among the highest injury
- 9:38and illness rates because of the speed so remember I was talking about the mechanization
- 9:45of animal slaughtering and part of that was this you know conveyor system so it's you
- 9:53know like in the automotive manufacturing industry there's the assembly line where you
- 9:58assemble cars well this is kind of the disassembly line where you kill and process animal body
- 10:05parts and it's quite fast right a number of authors have have talked about the speed but
- 10:12one of the consequences of that is not only does it raise a number of animal welfare concerns
- 10:20but also you know employee welfare concerns because of the the speed at which they have
- 10:26to work so the workers lost control over the speed of their own work and now it's you know
- 10:31the companies that that set those speeds.
- 10:35If I'm not mistaken Henry Ford get got inspired for his factory model by a visit to a Chicago
- 10:45based slaughterhouse.
- 10:48Yes yeah that story has been cited in a number of a number of papers and books that yeah
- 10:56it became you know there's this connection between the two industries and interestingly
- 11:03animal slaughtering tends to be classified as a form of manufacturing although you know
- 11:10as I talk about in my paper and you know in books that I've written the the industry is
- 11:19it's unique right it's categorized as manufacturing but it's inherently different when you're
- 11:25when you're working on sentient beings you're not just working on you know creating widgets
- 11:30or what have you right it's you're you're engaged with sentient beings and then processing
- 11:39their bodies after after they're after they're killed.
- 11:43I guess there are two characteristics that we have talked about that truly differentiate
- 11:51slaughterhouses as an institution from others.
- 11:54First of all they are hidden and they are trying very hard to get out of our sight.
- 12:04So the business model has to do with killing sentient beings.
- 12:11Can you talk more about that business model how it's fundamentally different from business
- 12:18as we know it and you know ways of making money?
- 12:22Sure and one of the ways that well there are a number of things that point to the differences.
- 12:33One thing that is stands out and this is a relatively recent development in some countries
- 12:42is the the passage of so-called ad gag laws where it criminalizes certain activities by
- 12:54whistleblowers etc. who then can't you know for fear of their own well-being report on
- 13:03what they see in their workplace whether or not they were you know it becomes tricky to
- 13:09identify individuals who were employed in that work and then had concerns or took that
- 13:17work on specifically because they were looking for concerns but regardless the development
- 13:23of ad gag laws is you know quite quite unique to the industry.
- 13:32There aren't many other industries that legislatures determine we need special laws and some have
- 13:39argued that criminalize already criminal behavior right.
- 13:44It's a way of kind of dampening the the resolve to expose what goes on in those industries.
- 13:52So and where I live in Ontario ours was just partially mostly our ad gag law was was shut
- 14:04down and kudos to animal justice here in Canada who was able to argue convincingly argue in
- 14:12court that that the law was problematic and violated a number of freedoms among workers
- 14:20and activists.
- 14:22So there's there's that protectionism of the industry that we see there are also different
- 14:30empirical consequences.
- 14:33So one of the one of the things that I've done in my research and I did this study with
- 14:39doctors Linda Kaleff and Thomas Dietz a number of years ago now and we analyzed the relationship
- 14:49between slaughterhouse employment levels in counties in the US and crime rates and you
- 14:57might be wondering well why you know why do that and the reason is I was actually doing
- 15:04reading because I'm interested in the environmental impacts of animal agriculture and I was reading
- 15:10on that subject and came across a number of studies by anthropologists geographers who
- 15:17were studying slaughterhouse communities and so you know to step back a little bit again
- 15:25back into the historical development of the slaughterhouse in the later mid to late 20th
- 15:32century slaughterhouses in a number of countries started to move from urban centers to rural
- 15:38communities because they realized it would be more cost effective to move the slaughtering
- 15:43closer to where the animals are are raised and so as a consequence of that shift a number
- 15:51of rural small communities ended up with these large industries coming in and it changed
- 15:59the communities in a number of ways.
- 16:01So these researchers were documenting these changes and they pointed to a number of changes
- 16:07that they saw like increased demand for housing, social services, etc. but one of the interesting
- 16:16things that they mentioned was that crime increased and they you know they weren't sure
- 16:23why why crime would increase when slaughterhouses came in because it was outpacing the increase
- 16:30in population right so we couldn't explain it just based on population increase alone
- 16:36and so we did a study to assess are these is there a relationship between slaughterhouse
- 16:45employment and crime and we so we statistically controlled for a number of variables that
- 16:52would be associated with crime like proportion of young men in the population etc. and we
- 17:01also included comparison industries so we identified industries where they they were
- 17:08similar to slaughterhouse employment as far as you know relatively high injury and illness
- 17:14rates but the difference was you weren't you know killing and processing animal bodies
- 17:22in those industries and so when we ran the analyses it was it was clear that slaughterhouse
- 17:29employment level was associated with crime rates specifically violent crime rates but
- 17:36the comparison industries were not so empirically that indicates that there's something unique
- 17:44about slaughterhouse employment levels and you know we need further research to kind
- 17:52of unpack that to figure out okay what's going on that you know accounts for these differences
- 18:03but it is it is interesting that empirically they're different and what we found in the
- 18:07analysis was when we looked at small-scale slaughterhouses they really didn't have that
- 18:15strong association with crime rates it was these large slaughterhouses that that had
- 18:23you know the the strongest relationship statistically significant relationship with crime rates
- 18:29and like I said we controlled for a number of other correlates of crime like population
- 18:35density proportion of young men and proportion of immigrant population in the county because
- 18:44that's one thing that when communities had voice concerns because of increasing crime
- 18:49rates a number of the the companies were scapegoating the employees and saying oh it's because you
- 18:58know we can't find local workers so we've had to bring in immigrant workers so basically
- 19:04blaming immigrant labor but the criminologist in me you know read that and thought well
- 19:10that's interesting because there are a number of studies that show that in the proportion
- 19:16of immigrants in a community is not associated with increased crime rates in a number of
- 19:20studies it's actually associated with a decrease in crime rates so that's not the explanation
- 19:26either so that's just a very long way of saying there's something unique about slaughterhouse
- 19:32employment and the industry because of the the nature of the work you know killing and
- 19:40processing animals I want to get back to the workers but first yes you're right this industry
- 19:50is in bed with the government and they receive subsidies they have captured some of our MPs
- 20:02who then push their unconstitutional laws how did that relationship that that union
- 20:14between slaughterhouses and big ag industry and the government was created well I think
- 20:24part of it has to do with the consolidation in the industry so increasingly throughout
- 20:31the you know late 20th century there was a consolidation of you know slaughterhouse
- 20:42facilities were being bought up by large companies so increasingly it was you know has become
- 20:51an industry run by a handful of companies for the most part so it really it gave those
- 21:00industry it gave those companies enhanced power and it made lobbying that much easier
- 21:07right because you had fewer people at the table and so it has it has certainly made
- 21:15you know the animal agriculture animal slaughtering and processing you know one of the largest
- 21:23lobbying groups in a number of countries and I and that lobbying I think as we're seeing
- 21:33more more concerns being raised you know the the law it seems like the lobbying has amplified
- 21:42as well right historically you know there there wasn't that much to be concerned about
- 21:50I suppose from animal groups but now especially you know one of your guests on an earlier
- 21:58episode was talking about social media and social media has had a significant role I
- 22:05think because now you know you don't need to rely on news media to show videos undercover
- 22:11videos and slaughterhouses or animal agriculture more generally right someone can just post
- 22:17it on social media and all of a sudden you have you know thousands if not millions of
- 22:23people seeing that video and and that certainly has an impact so I have you know I've noticed
- 22:35and a number of other academics have spoken about the the increased defensiveness among
- 22:43the among the industry because it's it seems like these these efforts are having an impact
- 22:50if they weren't there would be no need to have add gad laws and yet they you know different
- 22:56jurisdictions you know have have been implementing them in recent years that's I guess a kind
- 23:04of silver lining you know it's a it's a positive spin to their efforts of you know closing
- 23:14down the discourse around what they're doing they feel threatened yes they it they certainly
- 23:23they certainly do and it's and it's also industries around them as well like now it with you know
- 23:37transport companies that transport animals to slaughter increasingly they're they're
- 23:43concerned about you know activists showing up at slaughterhouses as you know vigils and
- 23:51we had an interesting legal case here in in Ontario where an activist was charged criminally
- 23:57for giving water to a pig on the way to slaughter you know it it I think it could be argued
- 24:05that in the past that wouldn't have happened because that activists wouldn't have been
- 24:10seen as as a threat right and inconvenience maybe but but not a threat that warranted
- 24:19calling the police and and having charges laid and you talked about the mechanization
- 24:27aspect and I guess you know we think about science and innovation as a way to maybe free
- 24:37ourselves from this industry and have lab-grown meat and things like that in the future but
- 24:48but maybe they're also thinking you know big slaughterhouses we can maybe go further with
- 24:58that mechanization process maybe we can get rid ourselves from the workers entirely and
- 25:04have you know automated entirely automated slaughterhouses is that science fiction or
- 25:13have you read or heard about plans of doing that well I can't speak to whether or not
- 25:23there are specific plans of doing that but you can see the trend over time of fewer workers
- 25:32and that's one of the reasons that the the labor power of workers in the industry has
- 25:38weakened historically in a number of countries you know slaughterhouse work was relatively
- 25:47well paid but then you know as we see this consolidation of ownership over animal slaughtering
- 25:55we see a you know a declining number of workers and a declining power of of their labor and
- 26:06unionization so I can say that there there has been that certainly that trend over over
- 26:14time and of course you know as as we see further developments technologically perhaps that
- 26:21will you know that will continue another question I have and you know maybe you have the answer
- 26:30maybe not but something I I often think about is the executives of those slaughterhouses
- 26:41I feel like those people are in an office and they don't really leave the office for
- 26:47them you know all of those animals and workers and all of what we were talking about those
- 26:56are just numbers on the spreadsheet what do you think of them you know because we we often
- 27:03put you know focus on the manual workers who are in in the slaughterhouse itself but what
- 27:10about those who witness the the impact of the slaughterhouse from a you know close standpoint
- 27:20you know closer than activists and you know they're aware of what's happening but they
- 27:26don't do anything about it do you have some thoughts about those people well I suppose
- 27:31like any business you know where there were their profits to be made you know it it can
- 27:40facilitate kind of looking in the other direction and not critically examining what you know
- 27:49what you're the type of work that you're doing and I think this is this is one area where
- 27:57you really see the the intersections of you know animal welfare human welfare environmental
- 28:06welfare they they clearly intersect right no one no one wins from this industry except
- 28:15for you know stockholders and you know the executives perhaps but it is it's an area
- 28:25where the that's one reason why I I don't like when people kind of you know try to scapegoat
- 28:38the individual workers right like or or denigrate them and it's tied this has happened historically
- 28:45right where you know in the 18th century people were you know denigrating slaughterers because
- 28:54they didn't want to be associated with them etc because they felt that there was there
- 28:59was something problematic about that type of work the reality is you know individuals
- 29:06need work and this is an area where there are jobs because the turnover is is so high
- 29:13in some companies it's as high as 100 per year entirely new workforce right so it's
- 29:20not it's not the individual workers in the facilities that you know are the are the so
- 29:28called enemy and so that's you know that's one thing that I think would it would help
- 29:35if if people paid attention to these interconnections right that it's it's not just about animal
- 29:45welfare it's about you know the welfare of the workers the welfare of people who live
- 29:51in the community around the facilities so that I think the more that we we help spread
- 30:00that knowledge I think that can be quite quite helpful so that people realize because let's
- 30:07face it some people aren't motivated by the animal welfare arguments right I've been you
- 30:13know trying to I've been voicing those arguments for decades now those arguments don't seem
- 30:20to be the convincing arguments unfortunately it tends to be the arguments where you can
- 30:24say look here's something that's connected with you know animal concerns but also human
- 30:31concerns also environmental concerns that you know are going to negatively impact humans
- 30:36we're a very self-centered species so the the more that we can point to human impacts
- 30:45I think that's strategically helpful but also for the workers caught up in the system you
- 30:55know I think it's it's helpful as well to kind of try to give voice to their experiences
- 31:02and and see the connections between workers rights and animal rights.
- 31:08One last question about the business model.
- 31:12You're a criminologist do you think that the kind of you know people who work as executives,
- 31:20managers of those slaughterhouses and even maybe the manual workers do you think many
- 31:28of them are have anti-social personality that this kind of business attracts people who
- 31:36have a anti-social personality?
- 31:40I don't know and it's an area it's a question I get asked a lot and I think it's an area
- 31:46where we need further research because you know we can based on the research that we
- 31:53have right now we can only kind of speculate but we really do need further research to
- 32:01kind of see okay if empirically there is a relationship between slaughterhouse employment
- 32:07levels and crime in in communities why is that the case and kind of focus in on those
- 32:16potential relationships.
- 32:17Now the problem is it's hard to get you know funding to conduct research like that right
- 32:27it's not like the industry is going to fund that for obvious reasons right so it's definitely
- 32:35a challenge but it's an area where we definitely need more research to see okay what's going
- 32:43on here with you know employment and based on anecdotal evidence you know from workers
- 32:52that I've spoken with and that other academics you know have have quoted in their own work
- 32:59this it's very different the the hands-on you know disassembly line work is very challenging
- 33:08physically emotionally and you know it's probably one of the reasons that the turnover rate
- 33:18in the industry tends to be so high but of course then the the turnover rate exacerbates
- 33:26the underlying problems right because then you have workers who are you know they haven't
- 33:33been there long so they're not as well trained as in other industries which can contribute
- 33:39to you know injuries can contribute to animal welfare issues because you're you don't have
- 33:47people who have been in these jobs for a long period of time so it's you know it's just
- 33:54a very long-winded way of saying that we need I can't I can't draw any conclusions about
- 34:02your question because we really do need more research but it's not a definitive no right
- 34:10yeah I I can't say that it's you know it's definitely off the table but I can't you know
- 34:19empirically confirm it either okay let's now talk about the impact of slaughterhouses on
- 34:28their workers but also the community at large and we touched on that of course and I want
- 34:36to start with something a past guest had told me you know she she she told me about Syrian
- 34:46refugees who came to Canada and how the government pushed them into slaughterhouse jobs and she
- 34:53expressed how horrifying that was you know taking refugees from war zones and then pushing
- 35:01them into slaughterhouses but then I you know posted that you know clip of her saying that
- 35:10and to my surprise many people commented you know how dare they complained you know about
- 35:19this you know we're we're welcoming them into the country and we're offering them a good
- 35:25job why is this cruel so I'm asking you the question why is it cruel to send you know Syrian
- 35:34refugees to slaughterhouses for for work
- 35:38well as I mentioned it's objectively based on you know reports it's among the the highest
- 35:47injury and illness rates the turnover as I said is is really high so it's not like you're
- 35:54setting them up in a career that's going to be you know a great stable safe career right
- 36:02the reality is the industry not just in Canada and other countries needs workers and this
- 36:10is how it you know populates the workforce in some in some places in addition to refugees
- 36:22there are also programs in some countries where incarcerated individuals are used in
- 36:29slaughterhouses which also raises a number of you know issues take even if you take out
- 36:39the animal component entirely objectively speaking when you're talking about high injury
- 36:44and illness rates you know it's it's probably not a good thing to put you know vulnerable
- 36:51people in because it's going to be hard for them to speak against power right so if they
- 37:00see something it's going to be hard for them to say something because they have relatively
- 37:05little power and are concerned about keeping their employment so it's it's definitely an
- 37:14area where I think we need more we need more education to explain you know to the Canadian
- 37:24government other governments that there are some problems here and as I've been you know
- 37:32mentioning the industry is unique you can't just assume it's going to be like putting
- 37:38someone in an automotive manufacturing plant right a different manufacturing they're they're
- 37:44different and they needed they need to be treated differently and I'll give you an example
- 37:51so the the Canadian government correction services Canada closed down we used to have
- 37:58six penitentiary firms they closed them down and then decided a different government decided
- 38:08you know approximately 10 years later that they were going to reopen the farms and the
- 38:17proposal that they put forth was an industrial scale goat dairy where incarcerated individuals
- 38:26would be working and it's and in the the messaging about it there's this conflation of well
- 38:36you know animal assisted therapy is good it's you know been proven to have positive impacts
- 38:43but they they don't critically reflect upon the fact that this is not animal assisted
- 38:49therapy it's very it's a very different context working in a an industrial animal agriculture
- 38:58facility whether it's on the you know raising animals or killing and processing animals
- 39:06it's not animal therapy it's intentionally set up in a way so that people don't form
- 39:13relationships with those animals because that would be problematic to the system right so
- 39:19there's no therapeutic relationship going on there but in the messaging about these
- 39:26programs it's like you know they they don't they don't pay attention to that they don't
- 39:32address it it's like we'll just throw animals in and stir and then we're going to have these
- 39:37therapeutic benefits and so i've you know i've been arguing against that proposal it's
- 39:46as of right now it's been tabled but we'll see what happens with it because there there
- 39:53aren't therapeutic benefits and you know as i've been saying it's it's not an industry
- 40:00where you're going to have you know it where it's going to be an easy job and i mean easy
- 40:08in the sense of you know free of injury illness and it's also increasingly not an area where
- 40:17there's you know a lot of careers being you know set up where you can go into it and then
- 40:26you know you're you're set in a career for life so instead you know programs that help
- 40:31provide meaningful certifications where people can use those certifications whether they're
- 40:38coming out of an incarceration situation or they're coming into the country as a refugee
- 40:46set them up with meaningful work that's going to lead to a meaningful career not you know
- 40:53a job in an industry where the turnover rate is so high you know they're they're not going
- 40:59to be there long it's it's not a it's not a stable working environment i'm thinking
- 41:07of what kind of response they would give to your answer and i guess they could say let's
- 41:15just create trainings you know training sessions more training sessions or revisit our training
- 41:27sessions and let's give our workers more you know protective tools and so i guess my question
- 41:37is is this industry will this industry always harm its workers is it you know fundamentally
- 41:46flawed this way or is there a way to improve the life of those workers there is a way to
- 41:55improve the life of the workers but it would take money which would cut into profits and
- 42:03but i think a lot of people don't realize is that the industry works on a very thin
- 42:09profit line per animal so it it relies on scale so we need they need to have more animals
- 42:21in order to make more profit right otherwise they would have to increase the price that
- 42:28they're charging for their products and that's something as you know we see in the current
- 42:33inflationary you know period that we're in in a number of countries that people are very
- 42:40resistant to a lot of people you know don't want to pay more for animal products a lot
- 42:48of people can't pay more for animal products yet they you know they believe that that's
- 42:55the only way that they can you know exist you know their diet needs to have animals
- 43:04as you know as part of it and so there's there's a real resistance to the industry increasing
- 43:13pricing which would be required i think to to provide the workers with with what they
- 43:22with what they would need for an ideal situation and even to to enhance animal welfare i mean
- 43:29i know there you know we we don't have time to get into this huge debate between you know
- 43:34animal welfare approaches versus you know animal liberation approaches but there are
- 43:42definitely things that could be done in the industry that would enhance animal welfare
- 43:47but they would take time slowing down the you know the disassembly line would improve
- 43:53animal welfare it would improve worker welfare you know some would argue it would it would
- 43:59improve the safety of the the food that's produced in these facilities but it would
- 44:07it would eat into eat into profits so you know there probably aren't a lot of people
- 44:15listening to a podcast focused on veganism who aren't vegan but there you know there
- 44:22might be some and what i would urge those listeners to do is to think about whether
- 44:30or not you want to provide the industry with money knowing what you now know right that
- 44:42it's not there aren't just you know human there aren't just animal impacts there are
- 44:47human impacts as well and i think we need to we need to think about those and keep them
- 44:55front of mind and also you know as as i tell my students and i realize it's it's rare when
- 45:01i teach a class where there's more than like one or two you know students who identify
- 45:06as vegan but i tell them you know even if you're not vegan you should be concerned
- 45:14about an industry that you're buying products from that is doing everything it can to keep
- 45:23keep consumers keep the public out of of that industry you know out of seeing what's going
- 45:30on that has you know such a vested interest in making sure that there is no transparency
- 45:37you know that supports ad-gag laws because they're afraid of what's going to be reported
- 45:43i think anyone you know vegan non-vegan alike should be concerned about that
- 45:50LR Another point i want to bring up is the public
- 45:54health aspect of it there are a lot of vegans out there who make the health argument for
- 46:01veganism but it's always you know an individualistic you know argument you know from a me perspective
- 46:08you know your diet will improve and your health will improve but i don't hear much you know
- 46:15talks about the public health argument around veganism so why are slaughterhouses dangerous
- 46:24for public health?
- 46:25LR Well the industry as a whole has a number of associated problems or externalities with
- 46:38it that you know have been documented in the literature and one of the one of the main
- 46:45reasons is because of and it's again something a lot of people don't want to talk about but
- 46:51it's the amount of manure that's produced.
- 46:55Manure is really problematic because it has you know high levels of nitrogen and phosphorus
- 47:03in it which can then cause problems when it gets into the you know the water you know
- 47:12there are manure lagoons that can be created but of course they're not perfect if there's
- 47:18a natural disaster so for instance hurricanes you know if you just google hurricane and
- 47:24manure lagoon you'll see all sorts of pictures of you know manure lagoons being breached
- 47:32from flood waters and things like that so there are a number of you know a number of
- 47:40public health related concerns around where they're located which is why there's you
- 47:47know as there's increasing awareness about this there's increasing resistance among communities
- 47:54who don't want them to set up shop in their communities so for instance there was a community
- 48:04in Montana that invited me Great Falls Montana that invited me to give a talk prior to a
- 48:11screening of a documentary and there were a number of people who were there to share
- 48:18their thoughts and one thing that I thought was really cool about that event was that
- 48:25they were bringing in a variety of people to talk about the problems of this from a
- 48:29number of angles right so there were people there who were speaking to the environmental
- 48:34impacts people who were speaking to the social community impacts people speaking about the
- 48:40animal welfare impacts so you could really you could really see the connections and I
- 48:46think that that that helped to kind of give a full picture so you know and public health
- 48:54is is part of that there's research that shows that property values around these facilities
- 49:03drop dramatically so for those who you know don't necessarily care about the environment
- 49:10animals other people you know sometimes they're swayed by their their own property values
- 49:17taking a dive as a result and there are also studies that have documented you know the
- 49:25public health impacts for the workers right increased risk of all sorts of respiratory
- 49:30illnesses zoonotic illnesses right COVID-19 kind of shined a light on the on the industry
- 49:40as far as you know the the transmission of COVID-19 between the workers was so was so
- 49:48high and there are studies that you know have shown that individuals who work in animal
- 49:57facilities are at greater risk of contracting zoonotic illnesses and you know and also then
- 50:04transmitting them to their families so you can see you know the public health impacts
- 50:11there there are many potential impacts and and like I said they're they're well documented
- 50:20in the literature you know scientists have been have been documenting them for a few
- 50:27decades now and so it's you know you can just look to the literature and find all of these
- 50:35documented studies that show that the the risks increase with these types of organizations
- 50:43I want to now get to the activism part and how to fight this because you're making you
- 50:50know such great points I mean every argument points to every piece of information and study
- 50:58we have points to you know this is a bad idea this is not a smart idea we should abolish
- 51:05those institutions and then you have activism work around it first of all would you you
- 51:13know rate the efficiency we talked about you know how social media has helped you know
- 51:21putting the pressure on on them and making them feel threatened but then you have you
- 51:27know people breaking in doing you know sit in inside you have you know the animal liberation
- 51:35front who enters those places and liberate animals so you have all kinds of activism
- 51:43around slaughterhouses do you have an idea of which ones are the most efficient in terms
- 51:49of making an impact and getting us near the goal of abolishing those institutions I give
- 51:57it my thoughts are I think the most effective are those where we can kind of form coalitions
- 52:08around the issues so you know joining forces with environmentally focused organizations
- 52:17and individuals and knowing okay there are going to be some differences right you're
- 52:22not going to be dealing with a group that's you know entirely vegan or you know same thing
- 52:29with workers rights groups but I think forming those coalitions is helpful because sometimes
- 52:37I think it's it's easy to for the general public to kind of look away from animal focused
- 52:49messaging right because for all the reasons we've been talking about people don't want
- 52:57to think about where their meat comes from where their dairy comes from their eggs etc.
- 53:06And so it's easy for them to shut down but if you're making a broader argument around
- 53:12not just the animals but also you know human rights environmental justice I think then
- 53:21you can you know the effect of the message might spread a little more widely and I like
- 53:34what one of your previous guests Robert Cheek had to say about you know you it's really
- 53:42hard to bring people over to your side if you're you know calling them names and telling
- 53:49them how horrible they are but it helps if you can you know show people these connections
- 53:58and you know convince people that even if you don't care about the animal issues they're
- 54:06interconnected with so many other issues and concerns you know and hit them where they
- 54:13live and that's their own personal well-being for you know for many people and you know
- 54:20point to all of these all of the implications of this industry and also I think it helps
- 54:31to put it into historical context and show people like this is this is historically speaking
- 54:38relatively new development it's not like we're stuck with it right it's not like it's you
- 54:44know part of our you know it's not etched into our DNA or something right it's a relatively
- 54:53new social institution and it can it can be changed it just takes people you know being
- 55:04willing to to mobilize and you know and work with other people and I think that's that
- 55:12helps to you know get the the message out and also fighting as hard as possible against
- 55:19these you know legislative aims and strategies to you know prevent the public from gaining
- 55:30information about what's going on you know I think people should have the right to know
- 55:37how their food is being produced and I don't think there's anything all that controversial
- 55:45in that statement right and so I think conveying that to people might help to kind of make
- 55:56them think okay yeah that's that's a fair point and I also I think it can help sometimes
- 56:07to to put yourself in a position where you can be a model for other people and say okay
- 56:17you know I was once in the position that you were I didn't know what was going on but now
- 56:23I do and here's how I live my life as a result and I think that's important and and to be
- 56:32honest with you it's something I didn't used to do as much as I do now and it occurred
- 56:38to me one day I was teaching a class and it was corporate and governmental crime class
- 56:45and we were talking about you know a number of different industries and we were talking
- 56:49about the animal agriculture industry and at one point one of my students raised his
- 56:56hands and said but what's the solution it's not like we can all be vegan we would die
- 57:02and he really thought that right and so at that moment I realized okay I need I need
- 57:10to start telling my students that I'm vegan because otherwise they really do believe these
- 57:17things right and some of that is you know sponsored by the industry itself right tell
- 57:24people that they're going to die from protein deficiencies or you know that they need meat
- 57:30to to survive and so I think sometimes it can help to put yourself out there and say
- 57:36okay look this is you know this is totally feasible for you for you to do but you know
- 57:44my caveat to that is be ready for people to try to discredit what you're saying because
- 57:55you're taking that position because you're vegan even if you're speaking about something
- 58:00that's totally unrelated and I've had that happen I actually just had an instance of
- 58:07it a couple months ago where I had to appear as an expert witness in a court case and it
- 58:15was totally unrelated to food and one of the first things during cross-examination that
- 58:22was raised was you know Dr. Fitzgerald would you agree that eating meat is wrong and I
- 58:29thought and I answered it honestly but I thought the question has nothing to do with the case
- 58:37but the reason it was raised was to try to do this credit everything else that I was
- 58:42saying so I think the more that people you know put themselves out there and identify
- 58:50you know as healthy vegans I think that you know can help but like I said just be ready
- 58:57because you will have people who will challenge everything you have to say because you've
- 59:03made that position clear but what about the mental health aspect of it because you know
- 59:11you're studying this and it's a dark topic you know and I guess it has its effects on
- 59:19your mental health I mean just thinking about slaughterhouses I often wonder is it my moral
- 59:26obligation to you know do something like animal liberation front activists do and just go
- 59:34there you know it's a hour drive from where I live and try to you know save an animal
- 59:41you know is it not you know my moral obligation and then you have you know the mental charge
- 59:50of having you know just yesterday there was a birthday thing with work and they had some
- 59:59cake and the cake was not vegan so I just you know took a cup of coffee and I was holding
- 1:00:07the cup of coffee and everyone was eating the cake I was thinking yeah there is a mental
- 1:00:13charge there's a cost to identifying as vegan and moving in society and then of course I
- 1:00:21had you know a barrage of questions from co-workers about my veganism so what do you make of the
- 1:00:32mental health aspect of it you know because we want to be strategic we want to be rational
- 1:00:39in our activism but at the same time we have all of those feelings so yeah.
- 1:00:46That's a really good question and I will say as someone who's a long time vegan it has
- 1:00:55gotten easier and I think because we're seeing real social change you know so part of the
- 1:01:04reason it's gotten easier is probably just you know I take it for granted now and that's
- 1:01:09just how I live my life but I think we're seeing real social change around us so now
- 1:01:17you know people will ask questions and I think they're you know they're genuine well-meaning
- 1:01:27questions like you know why are you vegan how'd you become vegan and so you know I like
- 1:01:34to use that opportunity to help explain to people you know as delicately as possible
- 1:01:42sometimes depending on the circumstance but yeah I mean there are you know mental health
- 1:01:53aspects of it too I suppose right living your life in a way that is so counter to the norm
- 1:02:00and I'd be lying if I said it you know it isn't frustrating at times you know when people
- 1:02:07are you know offering you money to if you'll eat a burger you know I'll give you $2,000
- 1:02:15you know things like that so it it can be challenging but it it is I am seeing I am
- 1:02:25seeing that it's improving right that there's there's less view of it as being you know
- 1:02:35problematic or unhealthy right when I when I first started my vegan journey you know
- 1:02:42countless people would tell me how unhealthy I was going to be etc and now I I don't have
- 1:02:49people saying that I have people asking me questions because now they're concerned about
- 1:02:52their own health right so how you know how do you do it do you have any suggestions because
- 1:03:00you know my doctors told me I need to I need to make some real changes so it it has it
- 1:03:08has improved but like I said there's definitely a toll to be paid knowing that you will have
- 1:03:16you know what you say question because because you are a vegan and that you know that frustrates
- 1:03:25me it's always frustrated me and it will no doubt always frustrate me.
- 1:03:32A last question many people use the Holocaust comparison you know to talk about slaughterhouses
- 1:03:41for some you know it is offensive but let me ask you is it accurate and should we use
- 1:03:50it for activism work?
- 1:03:53There are there are a number of you know activists organizations and and even even you know some
- 1:04:02of my fellow academics that point to you know other horrible events in human history where
- 1:04:12people have been enslaved and you know killed and you know in large numbers and I think
- 1:04:23there's I don't see that there's a whole lot to be gained from those comparisons.
- 1:04:32I think that each each is unique in its own ways and I you know I and especially given
- 1:04:44what I think are such the importance of paying attention to the ways that animal well-being
- 1:04:53human well-being environmental well-being are all interconnected I don't think that
- 1:05:00we need to point to other examples and say okay you know this is bad because that was
- 1:05:06bad we know this is this is bad and I think we can we can make that case without pointing
- 1:05:15to to other examples to try and make the case for us.
- 1:05:22Another question I had was about the perspective on this issue and how future generations will
- 1:05:29think of slaughterhouses hopefully you know in a century maybe you know less years slaughterhouses
- 1:05:40will be will have you know disappeared but then we'll have the memory of what happened
- 1:05:46what had occurred and the billions of creatures that were killed.
- 1:05:55What do we make of that?
- 1:05:56How do we you know how are we going to be remembered and what do we make of all that
- 1:06:04loss?
- 1:06:06It's hard and I think you know one of the ways that I think we can do it is to work
- 1:06:18actively against forgetting right and to work against you know currently like it like I've
- 1:06:26been saying you know work for more transparency and if hopefully one day you know there's
- 1:06:34people are no longer killing animals for consumption then you know it working to not forget what
- 1:06:47what was done because you know you know the saying goes you either you know learn history
- 1:06:52or you're doomed to repeat it so I think it's you know it's critical that we don't lose
- 1:06:57sight of it and I know even with my I have a nine-year-old son who doesn't eat meat but
- 1:07:09you know I have talks with him about meat consumption and you know what it means and
- 1:07:17you know those are hard talks because he genuinely you know loves animals and the thought that
- 1:07:24other people are eating animals is you know hard to wrap his brain around but I think
- 1:07:32it's important so that you know so that he knows and then you know he can explain it
- 1:07:38to other people which might not make him the most popular kid on the playground but you
- 1:07:46know it's it's important that we confront it and you know not lose not lose sight of
- 1:07:53it and like I said and not you know and also pay attention to the ways that we've we've
- 1:08:02harmed ourselves in doing it this way too I think that's a very important lesson as
- 1:08:09well.
- 1:08:10So, Amy, did you have anything more to add to the conversation before we stop the recording?
- 1:08:19I can't think of anything else you know that was a good questions that kind of ran the
- 1:08:28full the full gamut of everything yeah I can't think of anything else.
- 1:08:36Well that's a good sign.
- 1:08:41I'm getting better at interviewing my guests.
- 1:08:46Yeah it's definitely you know a skill that you know that you have you have to cultivate
- 1:08:52it's a challenge I know even in my own research when I'm interviewing participants the first
- 1:08:58few interviews are kind of rough and then I hit my stride and it you know it gets better.
- 1:09:04I need I need your tips for you know future interviews.
- 1:09:10I think practice makes if not perfection then then close to it.
- 1:09:16Well I have hours of practice now.
- 1:09:19Yeah well and I've been enjoying your your podcast it's it's nice to have you know the
- 1:09:25the focused vegan attention and you know and the guests that you have on sometimes they're
- 1:09:31areas where you know I haven't really given much thought to and you know it's it's it's
- 1:09:37nice to kind of think outside my narrow little little box.
- 1:09:41Well thank you so much for saying that you know I don't agree with all of my guests you
- 1:09:46know but still it is interesting to hear their views.
- 1:09:50Yeah definitely and it's you know it's helpful because then I think your listeners you know
- 1:09:56it might help because they might not identify with one perspective but you know someone
- 1:10:02else's perspective might be similar to their own and that might be what clicks for them.
- 1:10:08And maybe with time you know I'll think about past conversations with guests and change
- 1:10:13my mind you know.
- 1:10:14Yeah yeah.
- 1:10:15Amazing so Amy thank you so much for having taken the time to answer my questions for
- 1:10:23having been a guest on the show for your great knowledge and scholarship is it you know is
- 1:10:30it only money or can we say scholarship.
- 1:10:34Yeah thank you I appreciate that and thanks again for the invitation.
- 1:10:38Thank you everyone for listening I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the
- 1:10:43vegans you know.
- 1:10:45Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:10:48And thank you so much for caring and I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.