Latest / Articulated Illustration / Words We Never Question: Cold Turkey
Transcript
- 0:00When somebody quits something all at once, we say they quit cold turkey.
- 0:06But why cold turkey?
- 0:08Why not hot chicken?
- 0:10Why not leftover ham?
- 0:12And who looked at somebody breaking a habit and thought,"Yep, that's a plate of cold poultry"?
- 0:18Well, that leftover ham might be closer to the answer you think Welcome to Words We Never Question, a segment of Articulated Illustration.
- 0:33I'm your host, Dwane Richardson Sr.
- 0:37Every phrase has a footprint, and today we are following two words, cold turkey.
- 0:55And here's what it means now.
- 0:57You stopped all at once.
- 1:00No tapering.
- 1:02No, I'll cut back a little Monday and a little more Thursday.
- 1:06Stop, period.
- 1:08We use it for an app, a bad habit, a routine that isn't doing us any good, and quitting addictions.
- 1:15But those two words didn't always mean that.
- 1:19And the story most people tell about them, it does not hold up You probably heard it.
- 1:26During withdrawal, a person can get chills and goosebumps, skin plucked like a turkey, cold turkey.
- 1:34I get why people repeat it.
- 1:36It's visual, it's memorable, and goosebumps can really be a part of withdrawal.
- 1:42But a story can sound right without being where a phrase came from.
- 1:47We hear an explanation once, we repeat it twice.
- 1:50By the 10th time, we have forgotten that there was even a question.
- 1:55Now, here's the problem with the goosebump story.
- 1:59It only works if the drug meaning came first, and it didn't The earliest use researchers have found goes back to 1878.
- 2:10Back then, cold turkey could mean an easy job, something that took no effort at all.
- 2:16But by the 1890s, it also meant doing something with no preparation.
- 2:21In 1897, a Cincinnati paper praised a ballplayer named Bug Holliday.
- 2:27Yes, Bug.
- 2:29He could come off the bench cold turkey, no warmup, and still hit the best pitchers around.
- 2:35In 1900, a vaudeville performer went on stage cold turkey, no rehearsal.
- 2:42And by the 1910s, politicians were talking cold turkey, speaking plainly, no sugarcoating.
- 2:50Now listen to the thread.
- 2:52No preparation, no softening, no easing in.
- 2:57Straight to it Now here's the one that surprised me.
- 3:01January 1896, a boxer named Kid Baldwin tells a newspaper that he's done with booze and tobacco.
- 3:10And of course, when did he quit?
- 3:12New Year's.
- 3:13How?
- 3:15Cold turkey.
- 3:161896, more than 20 years before the drug meaning shows up.
- 3:22That one arrives by 1919.
- 3:25A Tulsa paper writes about a man taking the cold turkey cure.
- 3:29And that same summer, a New York paper reports addicts themselves calling sudden withdrawal the cold turkey treatment., So the drug meaning did not create the phrase.
- 3:42The phrase was already there.
- 3:45It just got borrowed So why turkey?
- 3:50Well, here's the leading explanation.
- 3:53Think about the day after Thanksgiving.
- 3:56Cold turkey's leftovers, no cooking, no seasoning, no prep.
- 4:01You open the fridge and eat.
- 4:03So something done cold turkey is something done with zero preparation.
- 4:08I told you the leftovers were close.
- 4:11Now, I'll be straight with you.
- 4:13That's the answer that best fits the evidence.
- 4:16Nobody has a document that says,"This is where it started." A old newspaper can show us people were already saying the phrase, but it cannot tell us who said it first.
- 4:28But that does not make the history less interesting.
- 4:31It makes it more honest And the goosebumps?
- 4:36A good story, just not the documented one.
- 4:40If this changed how you hear a phrase that you said your whole life, subscribe and drop the next phrase you want me to question in the comments.
- 4:48This is Dwane Richardson Sr, and this has been Words We Never Question, because every phrase has a footprint.
- 4:55And now we know why we say what we say