Latest / The Koerner Office - Business Ideas and Deep Dives with Chris Koerner / He Built a Simple App and Sold It for $200 Million⏐Ep. #242
Transcript
- 0:00You can either live somebody else's story, or you can write
- 0:03your own story. Sometimes you're 1 tweak away
- 0:06from $200 million, right? Yeah, if they don't say that,
- 0:10the app doesn't blow up and the company goes out of business.
- 0:13It's shot to #1 and stayed there every single day for six months.
- 0:1625 million people a day were playing it.
- 0:18So the number one game in 60 countries in the world.
- 0:21And what did you end up selling it for?
- 0:23$200 million. I mean, I was a high school
- 0:25teacher. It is all of those little things
- 0:28that make a difference, friends, but they all have to come
- 0:31together. OK, well why don't you start by
- 0:36just telling us who you are and what you do, Dan?
- 0:38My name is Dan Porter, I was on an episode of the career ladder
- 0:42on TikTok and I am the CEO and Co founder of Overtime which is
- 0:47a big sports platform that we started in 2016.
- 0:52OK. And what would you say makes you
- 0:55different from your peers, your contemporaries?
- 0:58There are a lot of answers to that, I'd say #1 The nature of
- 1:03my career, like I've, I've been a public school teacher, I
- 1:07worked in the music business, I run a gaming company, I'm in
- 1:11sports. I've just done a lot of
- 1:13different things. And so everything that I do is
- 1:17almost like a combination of all those different experiences.
- 1:20It's really not a straight path. It's probably #1 I'd say number
- 1:26two, I'm very relentless and focused and I don't give up.
- 1:30I don't play a lot of games, but I try to only play games that I
- 1:33can win. And I think #3 is that you could
- 1:37say that maybe I'm an out-of-the-box or disruptive
- 1:40thinker. And I'm not trying to compliment
- 1:43myself in that, but more just like I don't know the way that I
- 1:47think of things. Maybe I don't understand the way
- 1:49things are supposed to be done. So I come up with my own ideas,
- 1:54but I tend to approach problems probably a different way than
- 1:58other people do. So probably those three things.
- 2:02Plus, occasionally I'm very funny.
- 2:06Do you think? Do you think you approach
- 2:08problems differently because of your breath of expertise?
- 2:11Are they correlated? It's a good question.
- 2:13I'd say half of it is that like I just have so many different
- 2:17experiences I draw from and half of it is probably like I'm just
- 2:21really stupid and I don't know the right way to do it.
- 2:24So I just come up with my own way to do it.
- 2:27Sometimes, like you see people who like play some musical
- 2:32instrument in a really weird way, they play like the guitar
- 2:35with both their hands or something like that, and they
- 2:38create entirely new music and maybe they just never learned
- 2:43the other way or that felt natural to them.
- 2:45But I think in general, I don't know if through school and
- 2:51college we do enough collectively to promote kind of
- 2:58creative and different thinking. I think we tend to optimize
- 3:02towards people who think alike. That's why we have tests in
- 3:05school. Tests are like, tell me what the
- 3:07right answer is. That's the right answer.
- 3:09Everyone is like, they're like going right towards the tip of a
- 3:12triangle. I love music.
- 3:14I was a musician. I focused on improvisation.
- 3:20I took a lot of creative writing.
- 3:22I think just taking inspiration from writing and music and arts
- 3:25and all the different way that people have thought about, you
- 3:29know, recreating all kinds of music and, and even writing and
- 3:33stuff like that is probably part of it.
- 3:37But I don't think we do ourselves any favors as a system
- 3:40in this country and promoting people who are either think
- 3:43creatively or, or out-of-the-box.
- 3:46And I think most people in college, I took painting, I took
- 3:50photography, I took poetry, of which I was truly terrible at.
- 3:54And luckily none of those poems survived.
- 3:57And I took either two or three semesters of creative writing.
- 4:00And I just think learning those things, if I ask kids today,
- 4:03they take computer science and economics, and there's nothing
- 4:06wrong with those. That's what I think.
- 4:08Yeah, well, creativity, it's more important than it's ever
- 4:11been, and it's more rare than it's ever been.
- 4:13It's a differentiator. I, I, I think about like, you
- 4:17know, when people apply for jobs, sometimes you interview
- 4:20for a job, you interview people. If you're interviewing A
- 4:23salesperson and it's like everybody worked at a similar
- 4:27company, they all have the same title, they've all sold a number
- 4:30of big deals, how are you going to differentiate like 10 people
- 4:34who come in and have an interview with you or zoomed in
- 4:37an interview with? And I think there's some element
- 4:39where like a lot of times I'll ask questions when I, when I was
- 4:43in the gaming business, when I ran on G Pop and I used to hire
- 4:49game designers and, and builders, software developers, I
- 4:53really used to only ask one question.
- 4:54And the question I asked is like, what is your favorite
- 4:57game? You tell me Final Fantasy or
- 4:59whatever. And then I would say, why is
- 5:01that a great game? And people would say it's fun or
- 5:04whatever. And, you know, one out of every
- 5:06five people would say something like, oh, the way that like this
- 5:10mechanic works and they describe some intricate part of the game.
- 5:14And you just think all those people really think deeply about
- 5:17games and game design. And those were the people that I
- 5:20hired. Someone that that looks at it
- 5:24differently? Yeah, you're able to.
- 5:26Understand why things are the way they are and is is a thinker
- 5:33and some of that is creativity and some of that is thinking.
- 5:35But I feel like those people, they can have an impact on you
- 5:39and your company, but you can appeal to them to try to make
- 5:44something bigger and better versus people who do less.
- 5:48So. And I I think that even though
- 5:49some of that is natural, we can all always be better at learning
- 5:54how to do that. Yeah.
- 5:56How did you get into the gaming business?
- 5:58I was working for Richard Branson.
- 6:01He was a very successful and famous entrepreneur, and part of
- 6:06my job was kind of helping him make the Virgin brand relevant
- 6:11to a whole new kind of generation.
- 6:14And I just thought, let's go to the roots and do music.
- 6:17So we did music festivals and other stuff like that.
- 6:22And I kept reading at that time maybe 20 years ago, like the
- 6:26gaming business is bigger than the movie business.
- 6:29It's bigger than the music business.
- 6:31And in fact, funny enough, I have two sons and I took them to
- 6:36an outdoor concert that I put on and they spent the whole time
- 6:39playing the Nintendo DS backstage.
- 6:43And I was just kind of was like, wow, gaming is kind of relevant
- 6:48to culture in a way that music probably was in the 80s,
- 6:51nineties. Not that music isn't, but it's
- 6:53gaming is. So it's so widely played and
- 6:57it's so pervasive. I don't know, 90% of kids play
- 7:01Roblox or anything else like that.
- 7:03I just kept thinking about it. One day this investor said to
- 7:07me, oh I know this guy, he's starting a gaming company, could
- 7:12use some help. So I met with him and I honestly
- 7:16didn't understand anything that he said to me.
- 7:18I didn't understand his website. It literally made no sense to me
- 7:21whatsoever. And so I quit my job and took an
- 7:2680% pay cut and became the CEO of the gaming company.
- 7:31That's a big leap, Yeah. You just thought, you just
- 7:35thought this is a tidal wave that I want to be riding, so
- 7:37it's worth taking this big pay cut to ride it.
- 7:40Yeah. And also I was like, there's so
- 7:42much I don't understand about this.
- 7:44Like I want to figure it out. And I'm like, I was like, this
- 7:47is hard. They they know a lot about
- 7:49something I don't know a lot about.
- 7:51I clearly get where gaming is going.
- 7:54And it was it was before we had digital goods and everything
- 7:57else. But he understood that stuff was
- 7:59going to come from China and from other places in terms of a
- 8:03business model and come here. So I just jumped and took a
- 8:07risk. And what happened after that
- 8:09point? How did you get from that point
- 8:10to Draw Something? He was a really cool guy and
- 8:13everybody worked at a company, was super cool and lived in New
- 8:16York and Williamsburg and like went to coffee shops and like
- 8:19made like really cool games for people like them.
- 8:23And it was a really multiplayer game site.
- 8:26It was one of the first chances that people could really play
- 8:28online with each other as opposed to by themselves.
- 8:31There was no iPhone or anything else like that.
- 8:34And I said, who are the users? Who are the customers?
- 8:37And they said people like us because that's what we make
- 8:38games for. Got deep into Google Analytics
- 8:41and so forth. And I realized that the
- 8:43customers were actually almost entirely 14 year old girls in
- 8:47California. They were just assumed, yeah,
- 8:49and they were wrong. That's who was playing the games
- 8:52for five hours a day and I was like, well, baby, that's our
- 8:55customer. And then the name of the company
- 8:57was I'm in like with you, which is really funny.
- 9:00And I. Well, that matches with a 14
- 9:02year old girl, I mean. Well, I realized that when
- 9:05people typed it into Google, they misspelled it and we were
- 9:07losing traffic. So we changed the name.
- 9:10We understood who the audience was and we started to grow and
- 9:14we added more and more games and built just kind of like a a
- 9:19gaming site where people came and played with each other.
- 9:22And the guy who started it was enormously creative and just
- 9:26just visually talented. Like everything about the games
- 9:29were really great. I remember once we did a a talk
- 9:33at a conference and he got up and he just said my goal is to
- 9:37make a game that's so good that some kid mows lawns to make
- 9:41money to pay for it. It was good.
- 9:43And then we were successful and we had millions of users.
- 9:47Average time on site was 4 1/2 to five hours.
- 9:51And then Farm Bill came out and Farm Bill was built on top of
- 9:55Facebook. All of a sudden they had 100
- 9:58million users. We had like 3,000,000 users.
- 10:01All of a sudden we were big and then we were small and the whole
- 10:04world was playing FarmVille and other Facebook games, and the
- 10:10iPhone had just come out and I was like, wow, we missed
- 10:12Facebook. We didn't make Angry Birds.
- 10:15You know, sometimes you wonder if it's too late.
- 10:19Sometimes it is, but sometimes you feel like it's too late, but
- 10:21it's not. We started to make some iPhone
- 10:24games and then it's like there's a hard part where you don't
- 10:27fail, but you don't succeed. So you're somewhere in the
- 10:30middle. Like it's not like you have no
- 10:31users, but it's not like you have a zillion users.
- 10:34It's kind of like the. Messy middle like.
- 10:37You're not Uber. Valley of Death.
- 10:39Or something like that. Or worse, yeah.
- 10:41Long story short, we had a drawing and guessing game that
- 10:44we had tried to make for Facebook and we've made for our
- 10:47site. And I decided to try to be the
- 10:50game designer and work with a couple people in the company.
- 10:53And we just made it as an iPhone game and we released it and it
- 10:57did OK. And then it kind of bombed.
- 11:00And then some of our developers were like, I think there's a lot
- 11:02of people trying to play it. I think there's a technical
- 11:04problem. And they worked all weekend,
- 11:06They fixed it and it shot to #1 and it stayed there every single
- 11:09day for six months. 25 million people a day were playing it.
- 11:13So the number one game in 60 countries in the world and a
- 11:16quarter of a billion people downloaded it.
- 11:18OK, All right. I want to get to that before we
- 11:22get there. I find it so interesting that,
- 11:24you know, Facebook releases games and you suddenly feel like
- 11:27a very small company and you are compared to FarmVille.
- 11:30It made me think like a lot of times we talk about platform
- 11:32risk, like platform risk to watch out for those platforms,
- 11:35you know, don't want to be relying on one platform, but
- 11:38that same platform risk can put like non platform businesses out
- 11:42of business because that platform is so big and strong
- 11:45and scary, right? It's the other side of the
- 11:47argument. You know, I'm trying to reach
- 11:49young people. So I built this website and I
- 11:51was like, who goes to a website? Like you think they're going to
- 11:55your website? Like have you ever seen a young
- 11:58person open a browser on their phone they don't go to?
- 12:00Web only to do homework. Yeah, exactly.
- 12:03Why didn't Draw Something for as a Facebook game work?
- 12:07Do you think I know exactly why it didn't work?
- 12:09It's kind of not working. Inspired.
- 12:12The thing that made it work. So basically on Facebook, it's
- 12:17like Pictionary. It's like a drawing guessing
- 12:18game. So it's open.
- 12:19You go into a lobby and there's three other people there, and
- 12:24all of a sudden the word comes up and you draw it and people
- 12:28guess. Well, if you put people in a
- 12:29lobby with three strangers, they're either going to draw
- 12:32anatomical body parts or they're just going to be rude.
- 12:37And what could be really fun was basically kind of toxic most of
- 12:41the time. Not all the time, but most of
- 12:43the time. And so when we made it for the
- 12:45phone, we only let you play your friends because we were like, we
- 12:49can't stop people from drawing funny things or being annoying
- 12:54phallic things. Yeah, but if you know that
- 12:57they're with their friends, their friends are either going
- 12:59to say knock it off or they're going to think it's funny.
- 13:02And so I think what didn't work is kind of like a wide open
- 13:05space. Worked amazing on a friend
- 13:07basis. It's almost like a version of
- 13:09niching down, like preventing other people from playing it.
- 13:13Kind of like Facebook in the early days, right?
- 13:14Like you have to be a Harvard student.
- 13:16It's like you couldn't solve changing people's bad behavior
- 13:20on the Internet. So it wasn't like you could then
- 13:23penalize people and they could report them and everything else
- 13:27like that, but you could solve just not having it open to
- 13:31everyone on the Internet. So it was easier to solve that
- 13:34than it was to solve the former. Yeah.
- 13:37And then you you have a built in virality because you can invite
- 13:39all your friends in your contact list, right?
- 13:41Yeah, I remember somebody told me I'm getting invites for Draw
- 13:45Something on like people that I was on instant messenger with
- 13:49that I haven't even talked to in five years.
- 13:53Yeah. What aside from like the built
- 13:56in virality of it from a base principal perspective, why do
- 14:00you think it resonated so well? I think it was really simple.
- 14:03I'm not a game designer, so I made something that was so easy
- 14:06to understand and play. Number 1, I think it was very
- 14:10collaborative. It was funny.
- 14:13It was the first thing they use your finger on the phone.
- 14:15It was tactile. It was what the phone was meant
- 14:17to do, not be a joystick replacement.
- 14:20We didn't make it based on winners or losers.
- 14:22You tried to have a streak with the person that you were playing
- 14:25with that made people feel like they weren't competing with each
- 14:29other, but it just was like a little more social.
- 14:32It was actually, in a weird way, it was just very it was social
- 14:37at a time when most games were not social.
- 14:39Yeah. Do you think at the time there
- 14:41was less competition for people's attention on the phone?
- 14:44At that time, I would say that maybe 7 of the top 10 apps were
- 14:50games. I'd say now 0R, they're mostly
- 14:53either Uber or Instagram or TikTok.
- 14:58Short form video. Yeah, short form videos.
- 15:00So that was a moment by from 2010 to 2015 when games just
- 15:06dominated the phone. That's what you did.
- 15:08And then I think social media really knocked that out and game
- 15:12discovery was like, people be like, what are the new games all
- 15:15the time? And there's not a lot of games,
- 15:19there's not a lot of mobile games that like since then, like
- 15:24people still play. They might play that they play
- 15:26Words with Friends or Candy Crush or whatever.
- 15:30But in the last five years, I'm not sure there's been a mobile
- 15:33game that I can think of that's just like taking over.
- 15:36And everybody's done it because most of their attention is on
- 15:39social endeavors. I'm just continually amazed at
- 15:42how innovative and addicting short form video is.
- 15:45Not just the medium, but the algorithms that drive it and
- 15:48just how accurate it is. It's showing me what I want to
- 15:50watch. It's it's scary.
- 15:52Yeah, I mean, you know, technology is good and it it
- 15:56knows you. I, I uploaded 50 essays that I
- 15:59had written into ChatGPT and I said, I want you to reverse
- 16:04engineer my writing style. And then I'm going to give you a
- 16:06prompt and I want you to write it like I write it.
- 16:09And I'd say it was like 90% that literally sounded like I wrote
- 16:13it. Oh.
- 16:14Man, in your story I think you glossed over something quickly
- 16:18and let me make sure I get this right.
- 16:20You you were running the company initially, right?
- 16:23Yeah, I was the CEO. You were not a a developer by
- 16:26any means. I'm not a software developer.
- 16:28And you had this idea and for some reason you said, I want to
- 16:31build this one. Is that because you just wanted
- 16:34to learn how to build games, or you were so passionate about it,
- 16:36like you just wanted to own it? In the movie version, it's
- 16:40because I'm so passionate. But in reality, I just think
- 16:45like, we were starting to be like, we didn't make Angry Birds
- 16:48and we didn't make FarmVille. Like, are we effed?
- 16:51Like what's going to happen to us?
- 16:53I was like, maybe we're going to fail.
- 16:55Like if we're going to fail, at least maybe I could try to make
- 16:57a game. Yeah, So it wasn't like this is
- 17:00the best idea I've ever had. This is going to save the
- 17:02company. Let me go on the front lines and
- 17:04do it. It's more like. 90% of the
- 17:07company was working on other games.
- 17:09Yeah, So you're like, all right, We're kind of in flight mode.
- 17:13We're in survival mode right now.
- 17:15I have this idea. And you weren't thinking like,
- 17:17this is genius. This is for sure going to work.
- 17:19I'm fully confident. But it was kind of like, I think
- 17:21there's something to it, but I don't want to distract my team.
- 17:23They're just trying to keep their head above water.
- 17:25So why don't I try to build it? I had no idea if it would work.
- 17:29Also just was like, I don't know, I just want to try to make
- 17:32a game. I do overthink some things.
- 17:34In this case, I didn't really overthink that.
- 17:36I just was like, I think I can make something that.
- 17:39It's funny because the company that bought us was called Zynga
- 17:44and they were the makers of FarmVille.
- 17:45Ironically, I went to the offices in San Francisco when we
- 17:49were in the process of contemplating an acquisition and
- 17:54they had all the stuff on the wall and all these game
- 17:56designers were reverse engineering the game and trying
- 17:59to figure it out. Why was it successful?
- 18:02And I went over and looked and they were like, oh, you made the
- 18:05game. And it's like, I just have this
- 18:08question for you. Like why didn't you use XP in
- 18:11the game? Experience points?
- 18:12And that woman, I thought I forgot, I didn't use it, but
- 18:17it's just like totally slipped my mind and like that it's like,
- 18:22and they just couldn't believe that that was the case.
- 18:26And that was the honest answer. So it's like, I don't know,
- 18:30sometimes things just work themselves out or it's good
- 18:34enough as is. And sometimes you have people
- 18:40who are from outside of an industry who are good at making
- 18:44something. I had, I, I met up with a friend
- 18:46of mine had been the Internet business and then he was in the
- 18:50fashion business outside of the United States.
- 18:52Then he came back to the United States and he's like I said, oh,
- 18:56what, what are you up to? He's like, let's catch up.
- 18:58He said, I'm making like a sparkling water, like a soda
- 19:01stream competitor. I was like, you worked in
- 19:04Internet and fashion. What do you know about sparkling
- 19:08water? Like, and he goes, I'll know
- 19:10anything about it, but I'm an entrepreneur.
- 19:12That's what I do. I learn about stuff.
- 19:14Yeah, whoa. It's pretty powerful.
- 19:16Outsiders are powerful. Like you could have gotten hung
- 19:19up on adding XP and that could have like held up the whole
- 19:22project and then you move on to something else and maybe it
- 19:24never happens or maybe you had. It less fun.
- 19:27It could have made it less fun, could have changed the whole
- 19:29dynamic of the game, the whole culture of the game. 80 year
- 19:32olds played my game. It was so simple.
- 19:34Yeah, I say this all the time, but people get so hung up on
- 19:38researching and doing market research and talking to people.
- 19:41And what features do I add when like the building of The thing
- 19:44is the best research you can do. The building is the research I.
- 19:48Think that everything is like, it's like an idea.
- 19:52Like I'm going to make a brand new toothbrush.
- 19:54I have an idea, but it's just a premise and it's just an excuse
- 19:59to get started. Sometimes your assumptions are
- 20:01wrong or sometimes you discover something else, but you need
- 20:04something to get started. You need an idea and a premise.
- 20:07People like I'm pivoting. I'm like pivoting is like, you
- 20:12know, when you start out in the Internet business and all of a
- 20:14sudden you're in the underwear business, like that's a pivot.
- 20:17But like everything else, is just you're testing, you're
- 20:20learning, you're getting visibility into.
- 20:24What's happening? People are giving you feedback
- 20:26on your idea and telling you what works and doesn't work, or
- 20:29you're observing that and you know you're building it going
- 20:32forward. And I don't think that's a
- 20:34pivot. I just think you need that first
- 20:36premise and you just need to pay attention.
- 20:38Yeah, what? What first gave you the idea for
- 20:41Draw Something? What was that moment?
- 20:43It was the 3rd iteration of the game that we had made for
- 20:47ourselves and for Facebook. So I had thought a lot about
- 20:50about why it didn't work. And then the inspiration really
- 20:54was I went to park with my son and his friend and they were
- 20:58playing catch. And I was like, if you guys can
- 21:00catch the ball back and forth 50 times, I'll buy you an ice
- 21:03cream. And then I was like, oh, it's
- 21:05like a streak. And then I was like, oh, a
- 21:07streak is a way that two people can play a game and be on the
- 21:10same team and not be competitive.
- 21:13And that was like part of the core insight.
- 21:17Like the triggering event for the idea was the feature of the
- 21:20idea, and then you built the actual core idea on top of the
- 21:23feature. It was fixing something that
- 21:27other people had built and designed, but I had thought a
- 21:29lot about, and it was that. And then there was one thing
- 21:32that I didn't have anything to do with, but one of the
- 21:36developers, Will Chen did, which was he figured out how to play
- 21:41back the drawing. So if I drew a picture of a
- 21:45house and I sent it to you to guest, you watched me draw it
- 21:49and it felt live. You could see me erase with
- 21:52money versus me just sending you a picture of something.
- 21:56And that aspect of it, which I didn't create it at all.
- 22:00It it just made it feel so alive and so different.
- 22:04And I think that a great game, a great car, a great product, a
- 22:10great jacket, whatever it is that you experience, like it has
- 22:15to make you has to feel amazing. Like I own one suit that I've
- 22:20owned for 12 years. Somehow I still fit into it.
- 22:24And when I put it on, I'm like, this suit makes me feel amazing.
- 22:28I've I look good. I feel like it's a great suit.
- 22:31The cut still works. I have a car with a really nice
- 22:34steering wheel. It makes me feel amazing.
- 22:36And that aspect of the game just made it feel great.
- 22:38First question. How successful do you think Draw
- 22:41Something becomes if you'd never incorporate that feature of
- 22:44like, seeing it drawn live? Do you think that was a core
- 22:47part of it? 100%, I think it does not become
- 22:51as successful without that, Yeah, all those things, streaks,
- 22:56lack of competition, solving the toxic part and that that
- 23:00everything came together to make it work.
- 23:03And what did you end up selling it for?
- 23:05$200 million. And I feel like if you don't
- 23:08have all of those ingredients, right, it's not like take away
- 23:12the streaks. We sell it for 160.
- 23:14Take away the live feature, we sell it for 1:20.
- 23:17It's kind of like if you missed one of those, it doesn't.
- 23:20Yeah. If you take one of them away,
- 23:22it's kind of like your bacon bread.
- 23:24You take the yeast away, you're like, it'll just be a little
- 23:26smaller because there's only 1% of this is yeast.
- 23:28It's like, no, now you have flatbread and it sucks.
- 23:31You take one of those four key ingredients away, then it's a
- 23:34nothing burger. You never get off the ground
- 23:36right? I agree.
- 23:38On the pessimistic way of looking at that is like, well,
- 23:40that's kind of depressing. I have to like put all these
- 23:42ingredients together and I don't know what'll work.
- 23:44And I look at that, it's like, that's freaking amazing.
- 23:47You're a chemist in a lab. You were that easy to make a
- 23:50great product. Everybody would make a great
- 23:52product, but you've got to assemble all those things.
- 23:54It's like you asked me about myself and my career.
- 23:57I assembled all of those different things from my
- 24:00different experiences. I mean, I was a high school
- 24:02teacher. Every single thing.
- 24:04You put something together like great products feel great even
- 24:09around the edges. Like when you buy a shirt or you
- 24:14buy like a really beautiful shirt, you'll notice the
- 24:16stitching on the beautiful shirt and everything else like that.
- 24:19Like it is all of those little things that make a difference,
- 24:24but they all have to come together.
- 24:26I mean, you said too like your developers are like, damn, I
- 24:30think people are trying to play this, but something's broken,
- 24:33right? What if that conversation never
- 24:34happens? Like the, the optimistic way
- 24:36that I look at your story is that all these little tweaks
- 24:40make such a difference. And sometimes you're 1 tweak
- 24:43away from $200 million, right? One tweak away if they don't say
- 24:47that. The app doesn't blow up and the
- 24:49company goes out of business. I feel like it's never been that
- 24:52critical little tweaks and changes since before the age of
- 24:56the Internet. Like if I'm running a Facebook
- 24:58ad campaign with a big budget and I check a box that says
- 25:02optimize for conversions, optimize for add to cart, that
- 25:06could be the difference between me spending $10 to acquire a
- 25:08customer and $100. That could be all the
- 25:11difference. So in this Internet connected
- 25:13age, these little tweaks are everything.
- 25:15And so we don't want to over optimize everything and tweak
- 25:18everything to death, but we want to just keep testing everything,
- 25:20right. Yeah, it's kind of like yoga.
- 25:23Or if you work out, like most of us end up doing it wrong.
- 25:26So you're doing some pose and then the instructor comes over
- 25:28and they say, actually your hips have to be forward.
- 25:30And you're like, oh, I was just wasting two weeks thinking I was
- 25:34stretching when I wasn't really doing anything.
- 25:36Yeah, yeah. So you sell for 200 million.
- 25:40What do you do after that? What's next?
- 25:43So I work for the company that bought my company for a year
- 25:46because that's how those things go.
- 25:49And then I end up meeting Sky Ari Emanuel, who's the founder
- 25:55of Endeavour, William Morris Endeavour, famous talent agent.
- 25:59And Long story short, he pitches me and I say no and he keeps
- 26:05pitching me. And I end up joining WME, as
- 26:09it's called, which is biggest talent agency in the world, is
- 26:11their head of digital. And I build the foundation of
- 26:13the modern creator economy by signing, building, signing 20
- 26:18agents and 250 Youtubers. And, you know, everything that
- 26:22we think about creators now, who's doing 2013 to 2016?
- 26:27And a lot of people who I worked with, who worked for me and all
- 26:30those are now run digital for companies all over the US.
- 26:35What's an accessible version of that Business Today, if you were
- 26:38to keep all your skills, you're 20 years old and you want to
- 26:41make money in that way, kind of in that industry, how would you
- 26:45go about it? Like I would try to be a creator
- 26:48in a niche that I could own. So either you're broadly popular
- 26:54or there's creators whose specialty is talking about how
- 26:58to be successful on YouTube. There's finance, there's
- 27:01cooking, there's health, there's exercise.
- 27:03I mean, they're all crowded, but there's always room for people
- 27:07who are creative and, and a lot of people under the age of 30
- 27:12rely on other people to help them filter information.
- 27:15So if I'm walking down the street and I see some restaurant
- 27:20or coffee shop and there's a massive line, pretty much 100%
- 27:23of the time someone's like, Oh yeah, that just blew up on
- 27:26TikTok. This one person went there and
- 27:28talked about it and now everyone's gone there.
- 27:30So I, I would think about that. I mean, listen, what do they
- 27:33say? 40% of Gen.
- 27:35Z wants to be a YouTube? So it's just a different form of
- 27:38being an entrepreneur. How do you think AI plays into
- 27:41that with AI generated content? Do you think that makes like,
- 27:44unique creators even more valuable because they stand out
- 27:46even more or less valuable? I don't have a perfect answer
- 27:50for that because a lot of what we see now is probably only the
- 27:58tip of the sword. I do think that humans are able
- 28:03to make connections about what resonates with people and what's
- 28:10different and what's distinctly human better than AI, but I
- 28:15think AI can accelerate their ability to create it.
- 28:23I think like I'll teach a book in my class.
- 28:27Let's say I've picked a book, I've assigned it and now we talk
- 28:30about it and whatever the reality is, I could also just go
- 28:33to ChatGPT and say, hey, I just read this book.
- 28:36What do you think it's about that?
- 28:37Does this ask me some questions? I can talk to him for two hours
- 28:40and have a really in depth conversation about the book.
- 28:44But does anyone want to go and just talk to ChatGPT to learn
- 28:48books all day? Or do they want to go to class
- 28:49with a professor and other students and feel different way
- 28:53and body language and everything else like that?
- 28:56So I think there's a role for both.
- 28:58Yeah, And as you're reading that book, you're thinking, oh, this
- 29:01character reminds me of my mother.
- 29:02Or in ChatGPT doesn't know that your students, they want to know
- 29:06from you without even knowing it.
- 29:08They want to know from you like how that book ties into your
- 29:11life experience, right? And you're able to deliver a
- 29:13unique experience there. Whereas anyone could just
- 29:16regurgitate the ChatGPT summary, just like SparkNotes, right?
- 29:20Yeah. It it's.
- 29:22I'm going to be more likely to have an opinion which they might
- 29:25agree or disagree. I'm more likely to say, hey, in
- 29:29my life when I made this game or I signed this YouTube, I was
- 29:34reading this book and it made me think about XY and Z.
- 29:37So I think we are trained to think in this world that B is
- 29:42going to replace A and C is going to replace B.
- 29:45But I think there are ways that it is additive in a lot of
- 29:50different ways. So I think that human creativity
- 29:55is still going to be important. I think there's a lot of AI
- 29:59creativity. I mean, sometimes we'll be
- 30:03working on a project at work and we're like, we just don't have a
- 30:05good name for this competition we're doing.
- 30:08And sometimes the names that come out through AI are amazing
- 30:12and everyone's like, that's perfect and sometimes they suck,
- 30:14but it's just like, it's a tool. But I don't think we're all
- 30:19going to just be sitting at home, boy, because AI is making
- 30:23amazing YouTube videos and other content.
- 30:25But I think it's, you know, it's, it's going to, it's going
- 30:29to work together. Tell me about the genesis of
- 30:31overtime and what overtime is. Overtime is a sports platform,
- 30:37sports brand for next generation of sports fans.
- 30:41I was working in sports at my job at the talent agency and I
- 30:46heard from a lot of sports leagues that young people
- 30:48weren't watching live sports. And I'm like, they're all
- 30:51watching all the Youtubers that I work with, but they're not
- 30:53watching live sports. I wonder if there's an
- 30:56opportunity. So again, I just quit my job and
- 30:59I was like, let's see if we can start a company to figure out
- 31:03how to get every young person to care about us.
- 31:05Oh, by the way, we have no highlights, no live rights.
- 31:09We can't cover any pro sports. But still, we're going to figure
- 31:12it out. And that's ultimately what we
- 31:14did. So today, every week, 1/4 of a
- 31:17billion people watch a video that we make.
- 31:20We have over 110 million followers.
- 31:23We have a basketball league that kicks off on Halloween this
- 31:26Friday the 31st. We have a Football League, we
- 31:29have a girls basketball league. We're in a bunch of different
- 31:32league and event businesses, media businesses, and we've
- 31:36created a really dominant brand and maybe the largest kind of
- 31:40creator in sports. Tell me about the crowdsourcing
- 31:43side of that. How do the How does a kid with
- 31:45an iPhone play into your business model?
- 31:47Yeah, honestly, it doesn't. I think it's a misconception
- 31:51about our business and I don't know how to get people to stop
- 31:53writing that. But I think the perception was
- 31:56we just used UGC videos, but we did it.
- 31:59What we did was we built our own camera technology for the iPhone
- 32:03and then we paid people $20 to go to certain games and film
- 32:08stuff that we then published. So it was actually an end to end
- 32:11network where we had a deployed army of maybe 800 iPhone
- 32:15filmers. We used our software, tagged it
- 32:17and did it. But for some reason people
- 32:20thought that that was UGC and that part I'm, look, I'm
- 32:23answering your question and I haven't even published a UGC
- 32:26video like that for nine years. Over time of these 800 kids, are
- 32:31you able to find ones that are just like, spectacular?
- 32:33And you're paying them more, you're giving them more roles?
- 32:36I feel like there's a lot of surface area for finding rock
- 32:38stars. Yeah, some of them work for us
- 32:40now, like full time, and they started when they were 16, just
- 32:43like filming games for us. But over time we also ended up
- 32:47starting our own league, so I didn't need to have 800 people.
- 32:51But there's definitely people who work at the company and
- 32:53that's how we know them. What kind of business ideas or
- 32:57other opportunities has working within overtime shown you that
- 33:01you're too focused on to chase after?
- 33:03I think TikTok shop is super interesting.
- 33:06I think that a lot of products are going to be driven by
- 33:13creators. I think that product categories
- 33:17are going to change over time. I think we're in a like a food
- 33:23product world where functionality is a huge aspect
- 33:26of that. So I think that's pretty big.
- 33:29I think that second, colleges which engage NIL name, image,
- 33:36likeness to to play a part in attracting athletes, There's
- 33:41just going to be a lot of change in that space.
- 33:42I mean, you know, Reggie Bush lost his Heisman Trophy and then
- 33:47four or five years ago now where people are making millions of
- 33:49dollars in college playing sports.
- 33:52I think it's an incredibly growing and disruptive space.
- 33:56So those are two that I would think about where I it's not on
- 33:59exactly for the business, but I think there's the opportunity
- 34:03there. What about the genesis of 6-7
- 34:06water? How did that come about and
- 34:07where's it at today? Similarly, I.
- 34:13Oh, there it is. You know, we built a water brand
- 34:17off of a meme. I I picked water because it was
- 34:21just easy to make and we didn't have to do testing and tasting
- 34:24and stuff like that. We turned around the whole thing
- 34:27in eight weeks and we've sold 10s of thousands of them with
- 34:3041,000 people on our wait list. We're one of the most followed
- 34:33water brands in the world. But right now we have a couple
- 34:38interns who go to gas stations and bodegas in New York, and
- 34:41they just talk to people and they're coming back and they're
- 34:44saying, you know what? I think we need a flavor and
- 34:47this why? So like, it starts as this kind
- 34:51of instinct. We're sitting in a room and
- 34:54we're like, this would be crazy, let's do it.
- 34:56But now a lot of the decisions are being made because people on
- 35:01the street are spending time with bodega owners and talking
- 35:04to kids in middle school who come in to buy a drink and
- 35:06seeing what they're buying and asking them why.
- 35:09So I wouldn't call market research, but I'd call it like
- 35:12customer development and a deep understanding there.
- 35:15And that's going to drive the product innovation as it should.
- 35:19Yeah. Are you still looking for
- 35:21distributors and you're still trying to scale that?
- 35:24I'm really focused on distributing it in Kentucky,
- 35:26where Taylon Kenny, who is the main athlete who started this
- 35:31and started 6-7 and everything else like that, lives.
- 35:34A, because he's from there, and B, because I feel like everyone
- 35:39who makes a product tries to launch it in LA, San Francisco
- 35:42and New York, which is a really hard place to get traction.
- 35:45So I just somehow feel like maybe Kentucky's the right place
- 35:48to launch it. Yeah, it's so funny.
- 35:51Like I thought that thing was going to die.
- 35:53The 6-7 was going to die a month ago, six months, five months
- 35:57ago, like a month after it came out.
- 35:59I have 4 kids between the ages of nine and 15.
- 36:03And so when I, when I heard you on MFM, like explaining to them
- 36:05what it was and what it meant, like, doesn't everyone know
- 36:08this? Like I hear it 10 times a day.
- 36:10It's everywhere. Yeah.
- 36:12I mean, you know, I think boys think like culture is at its
- 36:16peak and then it gets to a higher peak and a higher peak
- 36:21definitely when it's in the Wall Street Journal and on the Today
- 36:23Show. We might be towards the end, but
- 36:25when we started this, we were not there at all.
- 36:28And I also think there's aspects of culture that are exclusionary
- 36:34if you know, you know, and there are aspects that are
- 36:37inclusionary. And I actually watched this
- 36:39TikTok from this mom and she was saying, like, the thing about
- 36:436-7 is everyone can say it and everyone is in on the joke.
- 36:47And there's actually not a lot of things that are really
- 36:49inclusionary, like on a broad level, where if you're cool or
- 36:53you're not cool, if you sit in the front of the class or the
- 36:55back of the class, if you're a jock, if you're not a jock.
- 36:58I think that in a way, looking back at it, there's a deep
- 37:03understanding that there was some power to it, that just, it
- 37:08was just funny. And I, I think, you know, the
- 37:12idea of like monoculture, like we're all watching the same
- 37:16thing or everyone's going to see Taylor Swift or whatever those
- 37:19things are the Super Bowl. Like those things are less and
- 37:21less than I think when we were kids, but when they happen, I
- 37:25think it's just funny. I mean, my grandparents were
- 37:29still alive. They would probably think it was
- 37:30funny to say that I don't know those types of things on a
- 37:34participation basis. Like people are too obsessed
- 37:36with the fact that doesn't mean anything.
- 37:38Nothing means everything. Everything is a word is just a
- 37:41symbol with an arbitrary meaning attached to it.
- 37:44So like, that's not the point of it.
- 37:46The point of it is it's fun, it's funny, it gives people a
- 37:49way to be included. I wrote this on LinkedIn, but I
- 37:55forgetting that it it like comes with a hand gesture.
- 37:58Like I can say what's up, but there's no hand gesture.
- 38:01So it's like sometimes you like watch like a baseball game or
- 38:04football game. People are doing this in the
- 38:05background. You know exactly what they're
- 38:06doing. Even with the sound off it just
- 38:09it was meme so to speak That just was built for video, audio,
- 38:15social school, camp, everything. Well it doesn't hurt that the 2
- 38:19numbers are right next to each other, so we're going to be
- 38:21hearing them together forever and it's going to be hard to
- 38:24like untrain our brain to not hear it in that tone.
- 38:28How many students have you taught, give or take, roughly?
- 38:30Probably 400 to 450. When you talk to a student,
- 38:35you're 5 sentences into the conversation.
- 38:37What's something that you hear or notice that just signals to
- 38:40you? This kids got it.
- 38:42He's going to make it. He's going to be OK.
- 38:44Interesting. I thought you were going to ask
- 38:45me a different question, which is like, what are all the
- 38:48misconceptions about life they have?
- 38:50I'd like to hear that too, but. It's hard to know that unless
- 38:55you're talking about like a specific assignment or anything
- 38:58else like that. If you look at a class, most
- 39:01people don't ask any questions. Some people ask bad questions,
- 39:05and other people ask really, really good questions.
- 39:07Some people ask good questions. You get it.
- 39:11They're just people who operate at a different level.
- 39:15Like they're confident about the knowledge, they're engaged.
- 39:19They're not asking you if it's going to be on the test.
- 39:22It's an in person class. So I'm biased because people
- 39:24with interpersonal charisma, I make I, I run out of time every
- 39:28year, but I try to make every student stand up and tell a
- 39:30personal story about something that happened to them in their
- 39:34first year in New York City. And sometimes you just realize
- 39:37like some people are just really gifted and or some people are
- 39:42just really fearless and the rest of them are just like, is
- 39:46it going to be on the test or I go to do the grading and I'm
- 39:49thinking like, I don't even know who this person.
- 39:52Is what's a category or an industry that you have no
- 39:55experience in, but just kind of a you're obsessed over for some
- 39:59reason, something you find interesting?
- 40:00I pay a lot of attention to skin care and beauty.
- 40:05I don't really know anything about it.
- 40:07On the influencer side, it was the first business that
- 40:10influencers were really, really successful in.
- 40:13It feels like cutthroat competition, like this is the
- 40:17brand now. It's not the brand.
- 40:20I really like packaging and like visual communication
- 40:23information. It's fascinating to go into a
- 40:26Sephora and look at all the design stuff.
- 40:29I like functionality and health, so trying to understand what's
- 40:33functional and what's not functional.
- 40:35And then I like the idea of products that make like clothing
- 40:41or makeup or that you know, they'll be like skinny leg, wide
- 40:45leg. Like, it's not trends.
- 40:47It's like, what are we all doing together to express who we are
- 40:51or who we aren't? And I think those things are
- 40:53super interesting. You mentioned early on that you
- 40:57you're very focused, like you focus on things.
- 41:00You also have a a a broad array of knowledge.
- 41:03You've been in different industries.
- 41:05How does that balance? What are your thoughts on focus?
- 41:07When is the right time to focus? When is the right time to chase
- 41:10the shiny object? I'm very obsessive so I'm a mesh
- 41:14network in my house and sound like AD link in the basement
- 41:19with like 18 different Ethernet cords that came in from when I
- 41:23renovated my house and put jacks and everything and everybody
- 41:27complaints the Internet sucks in our house.
- 41:29It's too slow and this isn't working or whatever.
- 41:32So I have this week probably spent 12 hours like so deep.
- 41:38I just got one of those tools you stick in the wall and you
- 41:41measure the 8 pins and whatever. And my son says to me yesterday,
- 41:47he's 24. He's like, why don't you just
- 41:49hire someone? Like like you're spending so
- 41:53much time on like trying to figure out why the why these are
- 41:57like full Gigabit and these are not.
- 42:00And I was just like, I'm not giving up.
- 42:02Like I just will not give up. And then last night he's like,
- 42:06wow, the Internet, my room is really fast.
- 42:09Everywhere else it's slow, but at least in his room is bad.
- 42:12And I was like, no, I haven't figured out the other 8 rooms in
- 42:15the house and I know I can always hire someone and then
- 42:19I'll give up. But I'm I'm like crimping and
- 42:22cutting the ends off and whole things and whatever and I'll
- 42:25probably never use. I'm just like I will figure this
- 42:29out. Yeah, well, and you're going to
- 42:32appreciate the Internet even more when it's your Internet,
- 42:34right? That part I just don't.
- 42:36I don't want to lose like I have like hundreds of chats with
- 42:42ChatGPT where I take pictures of the back of the thing and I'm
- 42:46going with this wiring. Is it this end or that end or
- 42:49the other thing? I walk around with my laptop.
- 42:51So it's like, it's like starting a company or something like
- 42:54that. You just get so obsessed that
- 42:57you have to figure it out and make it work.
- 43:00And that's what it requires when people are like, oh, I own 4
- 43:03businesses. I'm like, well, you own them
- 43:06maybe, but like, I don't know how they can be great because
- 43:09like for me, I, I just got to be obsessed and all in and thinking
- 43:14about it non-stop to make it great.
- 43:16Yeah, regardless of the industry, you don't care.
- 43:19Regardless, I mean, I, I care like there, there's a limit.
- 43:22I, I'm not going to do anything in, in like chemistry, for
- 43:27example, like I will never understand it.
- 43:29And there are things that I tap out on, but other things,
- 43:32especially things that are consumer oriented or culture or
- 43:35like I always say, like I learned so much.
- 43:39Like a lot of what I learned about business, I learned from
- 43:42culture. Like I was a big watch of The
- 43:44Wire and Breaking Bad. And it's not like, oh, I learned
- 43:48tactics about how to start my own lab or how to sell drugs and
- 43:50projects. But I'm like, what is compelling
- 43:53about these stories and why do they resonate with people?
- 43:55And what do they have in common? And even if you look at now,
- 43:58like K Pop, Demon Hunters and Stranger Things are actually the
- 44:01same story. They both have an underworld.
- 44:04They both have kids who alert adults to what's going on in the
- 44:07world. They have all of these things
- 44:09that are very similar, even if they didn't watch each other's
- 44:13shows. So it says to me like, oh, we
- 44:15live in this time of anxiety where young people don't trust
- 44:19that grown-ups are going to be able to figure that out.
- 44:21And when was that true? Also in the early 80s, like war
- 44:25games with Matthew Broderick, Like those themes don't always
- 44:29exist, but they come and go at times when young people are
- 44:32like, I don't really feel that. And I tie that to like my
- 44:36overall thinking about like why a lot of young people really
- 44:39into wired headphones right now versus Airpods.
- 44:42Like I love Airpods. Well, I think to some extent
- 44:44they're just like, how long am I going to trust that technology
- 44:47is better for me? Like what if I just have a bunch
- 44:50of headphones I don't need to charge and one doesn't fall out
- 44:53when I'm writing my like and like good.
- 44:55And so those to me are cultural indicators that I pay a lot of
- 45:00attention to and I try to feedback into what I'm creating
- 45:04or working on. Yeah.
- 45:06Was there something that I should have asked you that I
- 45:08didn't? Anything you want to get out
- 45:09there to the world or anything interesting?
- 45:11What are the things that your students ask you?
- 45:13That or misconceptions or whatever.
- 45:16I'd be curious to hear that as well.
- 45:18Whatever you major in does not matter.
- 45:20Your grades do not matter. And whatever your parents tell
- 45:23you, you should probably not listen to them because it's your
- 45:25life. And I also say that saying that
- 45:27most people's parents still have probably had one or two jobs
- 45:31their whole life. And most young people are going
- 45:34to have 10 jobs given everything else, Like when you're 21 or 22
- 45:39or you're graduating, like you can either live somebody else's
- 45:44story or you can write your own story.
- 45:46And it's way scarier to write your own story.
- 45:48And it's way easier to do what everyone else is doing because
- 45:53the rules are really explicit and you know exactly how to do
- 45:56that. And it's way more risky to try
- 45:58to write your own story. But if you are connected enough
- 46:03to the world, it can be also way more rewarding.
- 46:08And I think like the beginning part of our conversation, school
- 46:12and education and a lot of, you know, functional things that we
- 46:18experience growing up, they tend to go like this.
- 46:21We tend to like like 5 year olds are crazy creative and into
- 46:26dinosaurs and trains and I don't know what your kids were into
- 46:30but like it's all that stuff and it's just kind of all goes like
- 46:33this. We beat it.
- 46:34Out of all, in this little realm where we want to do this, we
- 46:37want to do that. And I'm just like, if you can
- 46:39break out of that, there's so much crazy potential in the
- 46:43world. Yeah, beautifully said.
- 46:45That inspires me to get my kids to do more weird things,
- 46:48honestly. 100% or just, I mean you, you probably do it, but
- 46:53it's like we'll do his parents, you indulge them.
- 46:55I mean, I used to know the name of every Thomas the Tank Engine
- 46:58train and whatever else. I can barely remember them.
- 47:02But like the passion of like a 5 year old who's so emphatic over
- 47:07something, it's like, it's incredible.
- 47:10Yeah. So with that in mind, my final
- 47:12quiet question, passion or profit?
- 47:14Follow your passion, follow the profit.
- 47:17There's two aspects of passion. One aspect is like, I'm into
- 47:20poetry, I'm into music, I like sports.
- 47:22I don't think you have to follow your passion for that that that
- 47:25your passion may not correlate with a high likelihood of
- 47:28gainful employment. You might love poetry, but
- 47:31there's no job. You might love books, but you're
- 47:33not going to be a writer and that that industry is small.
- 47:36But I think you can have passion for things that you do,
- 47:39accounting, marketing, talking to people, sales, live events,
- 47:45like as you get out in the world and you just like, and you know
- 47:48what drives that passion? A lot of times you're good at
- 47:51it. Like I know people who have
- 47:53changed careers in their emergency room doctors and
- 47:56they're just, you know, they're so good at it that that's what
- 47:59that's what the passion is. And I just think separating that
- 48:03idea that the passion has to be your interest versus the thing
- 48:07that you might actually be really good at, because we're
- 48:09all really good at something and it's just a process of unpacking
- 48:13that. And thank you, that was amazing.
- 48:15Where can people find you if they want to reach out or sell
- 48:18some water? TFADP on Twitter and on pretty
- 48:22much every social platform all. Right, what do you think?
- 48:24Please share it with a friend and we'll see you next time on
- 48:26the Kerner office.