Latest / Her Chapter: Women, identity, culture & modern life / The Lie I Told on First Dates: Why We Curate Our Past | Her Chapter
Transcript
- I told a man named David that I went to Oxford. It wasn’t true, but it felt like the only way to make him look at me with something other than polite boredom. And if you’re sitting there thinking, 'Karina, you wouldn’t,' then let’s sit with that for a second. It’s strange how much of our identity is tied to the four-letter codes or the prestigious names attached to where we studied. For years, I carried this little secret like a stone in my pocket. Heavy, cold, and impossible to ignore. I didn’t lie because I was malicious. I lied because I was terrified. Terrified that the real me—the one who had scraped by, who had worked two part-time jobs while studying late into the night, who had doubted her own intelligence every single day—wasn’t enough. Not enough to be loved. Not enough to be desired. Not enough to be seen as intelligent or interesting. So, I invented a version of myself that fit neatly into a narrative. A narrative where everything fell into place. Where I was smart, sophisticated, and naturally gifted. I didn’t just say I went to Oxford; I started using words I’d learned from watching documentaries. I adjusted my posture. I changed the stories I told about my weekends. I built a cage of perfection, brick by fragile brick, and locked myself inside it. Here’s what I’m noticing now, looking back with such clarity and shame: I wasn’t lying to trick David or anyone else. I was lying to protect the fragile ego of the woman I thought I needed to be. I thought that if I could just perform the right role, if I could just sound like the person I admired, then I would finally feel worthy of love. But love, real love, doesn’t care about your transcript. It cares about your heart. And my heart was beating so loudly beneath all those lies that I couldn’t hear anything else. We live in an age of curation, don’t we? Before you even meet someone, they’ve already curated their life online. Their photos are filtered, their achievements highlighted, their struggles sanitized. So when you sit across from someone on a first date, you’re not just meeting them; you’re meeting their highlight reel. And suddenly, the pressure to match that performance becomes overwhelming. I remember a dinner with another man, Julian. He talked about his summer in Florence, his internship at a think tank, his fluency in three languages. He was brilliant. Charismatic. Everything I wanted to be. And instead of introducing myself as Karina, the girl from the suburbs who struggled with math until junior year, I introduced myself as Karina, the scholar. I nodded along to his stories about art history, pretending I understood the references. I laughed at jokes I didn’t quite get. I became a mirror, reflecting back exactly what he wanted to see. But mirrors are cold. They don’t hold warmth. They don’t offer connection. They only show you what’s already there. And in that moment, across the table from Julian, I felt utterly alone. Because he wasn’t seeing me. He was seeing a projection. And I was too busy trying to keep the projection alive to realize that I was disappearing. This isn’t just about dating, though. It’s about how we show up everywhere. In meetings. At parties. With friends. We curate ourselves until we barely recognize the reflection staring back at us in the bathroom mirror. Why do we do this? Why do we feel the need to embellish, to exaggerate, to hide? It’s complicated, isn’t it? On one level, it’s vanity. We want to be admired. We want to be the protagonist in everyone else’s story. But on a deeper level, it’s fear. Fear that we are ordinary. Fear that we are flawed. Fear that if people knew the truth—the messy, unpolished, uncertain truth—they would walk away. I spent my twenties chasing external validation in high-pressure corporate environments before pivoting to writing. And in those boardrooms, I saw it happen constantly. People inflating their titles. People claiming credit for ideas they hadn’t conceived. People hiding their mistakes behind jargon. We build these personas because we believe that authenticity is a liability. That if we show our cracks, we’ll be rejected. We’ll be fired. We’ll be left alone. But here’s the thing about cracks: they’re where the light gets in. Or so the cliché goes. But it’s more than that. Cracks are where humanity lives. When I finally admitted to David that I hadn’t gone to Oxford, I expected anger. I expected him to laugh. I expected him to leave. Instead, he sighed. He looked at me with a sadness that mirrored my own. And he said, 'Thank you for telling me the truth.' In that moment, the stone in my pocket dissolved. The tension in my shoulders dropped. And I realized that I hadn’t lost him. I had found him. Because for the first time, we were actually talking. Not performing. Not competing. Just two imperfect humans, sitting in a noisy cafe, deciding if we wanted to try again. There is a specific kind of freedom that comes from dropping the act. It’s not loud or dramatic. It’s quiet. It’s the feeling of taking off tight shoes after a long day. It’s the exhale after holding your breath for hours. When I stopped lying about my education, I didn’t become less valuable. I became more real. And being real is terrifying, yes. But it’s also liberating. I started to notice how exhausting it was to maintain the facade. Every conversation required mental energy. Every compliment felt like a trap. Every silence felt like an interrogation. I was tired. So tired. And I realized that I was trading my peace for approval. I was selling pieces of my soul for the chance to be liked. But here’s what I’m noticing now: the people who matter don’t care about your resume. They care about your curiosity. Your kindness. Your willingness to listen. They care about whether you can make them laugh when they’re sad. Whether you can sit with them in discomfort. Whether you can admit when you’re wrong. These things cannot be faked. They have to be lived. And you can only live them if you’re honest. When I stopped lying, I attracted different people. People who were also figuring it out. People who were also insecure. People who were also trying. And in that community, I found something far more valuable than prestige. I found belonging. I found a space where I didn’t have to be perfect. I just had to be present. We need to talk about worth. Not financial worth. Not social capital. But intrinsic worth. The idea that we are valuable simply because we exist. Because we breathe. Because we feel. Because we try. Society tells us otherwise. It tells us that our value is tied to our achievements. To our degrees. To our job titles. To our followers. But these are external metrics. They are fickle. They change with the wind. Your intrinsic worth is constant. It doesn’t increase when you get a promotion. It doesn’t decrease when you fail. It remains steady, like the ground beneath your feet. But we forget this. We get caught up in the rat race, chasing markers of success that don’t actually satisfy us. We think that if we just reach the next milestone, we’ll finally feel okay. But the milestone moves. And the feeling never comes. Lying about where I went to university was my way of chasing that milestone. I thought that if I could claim the label, I could claim the worth. But worth isn’t claimed. It’s recognized. And it has to come from within. You have to decide that you are enough, exactly as you are. Flaws included. Mistakes included. Uncertainties included. Only then can you stop running. Only then can you start living. Vulnerability is often misunderstood as weakness. We think that admitting our flaws makes us look bad. Makes us look small. But vulnerability is actually strength. It takes courage to show up as yourself. To admit that you don’t know the answer. To say that you’re scared. To share your failures. It takes immense bravery to trust that you will be accepted anyway. When I told David the truth, I was vulnerable. I exposed my insecurity. I showed him my fear. And in doing so, I invited him to do the same. And he did. He told me about his own imposter syndrome. About his own fears of inadequacy. About his own struggles with confidence. And in that exchange, we bonded. Not because we were perfect. But because we were human. This is the power of vulnerability. It creates connection. It breaks down walls. It allows us to see each other clearly. And when we see each other clearly, we can love each other truly. Not for who we pretend to be. But for who we are. And that love is sustainable. It’s deep. It’s real. It’s the kind of love that lasts. So, let’s challenge ourselves. Let’s drop the act. Let’s tell the truth. Even if it’s scary. Especially if it’s scary. Because on the other side of that fear is freedom. Is connection. Is love. Thank you for listening. Thank you for being here. And thank you for being brave enough to be yourself. I’ll see you next time. Until then, be gentle with yourself. You’re doing better than you think. Love, Karina.