Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E025: Deep Dive on Bitcoin’s Full Potential Valuation with Dylan LeClair
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that the last
- 0:03trade is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:14management platform built on multi institution custody.
- 0:17We serve high net worth individuals, institutional
- 0:20investors and financial intermediaries with the best in
- 0:23class suite of products which include multi institution
- 0:26custody, a spot Bitcoin fund, Onram Wealth for Rias and
- 0:32private wealth services for high net worth individuals.
- 0:35Leveraging our partnership with Bit Go and other industry
- 0:38leaders, Onram's Multi Institution Custody is a first
- 0:41of its kind institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:46institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:50unique permissions have been met.
- 0:52Our multi institution vaults utilize cold storage, key
- 0:55signing and authentication at the direction of the client to
- 0:59maximize security for client assets.
- 1:02This pioneering approach to custody is the foundation of On
- 1:05Ramp's financial products which reduce counterparty risk
- 1:09associated with trusting a single institution.
- 1:12To learn more about how On Ramp can help you secure a new or
- 1:16existing Bitcoin position, please visit our website at on
- 1:19rampbitcoin.com, where you can schedule a consultation and
- 1:23connect directly with our team. What you're telling me is that
- 1:28music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:31the biggest bag of odorous excrement ever assembled in the
- 1:36history of doctors 1974198792972000.
- 1:44And whatever we want to call this.
- 1:45It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:47We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell, hey, I say
- 1:53when we sell. Welcome back to the last trade.
- 2:01Is that the new intro, Marty? I think so when we're pumping
- 2:05like we are, you got to, you got to bring the energy week in and
- 2:07week out sitting at 37 K right now, gentlemen, how we feeling?
- 2:12Feeling good? Good.
- 2:14I want to know what the. I want to know what the price
- 2:17was when we launched the pod. Look it up, Logan.
- 2:20Look that up for us, please. You.
- 2:22Know. I'm already starting to have
- 2:25that problem you have in the in the bull markets where it's like
- 2:28the price is going up. I have almost all my net worth
- 2:31in Bitcoin and so I should just be happy about it.
- 2:33But like it also diminishes any additional Bitcoin that I can
- 2:38add to my stack and that hurts a little bit.
- 2:41So, like, already at Mixed feelings.
- 2:43Well, that means you just got to go out and make more money.
- 2:45It's it's actually a a very good motivator to be productive
- 2:49throughout the economy. You're not wrong.
- 2:52Got to increase your revenue to keep the pace of sat stacking at
- 2:58a sufficient level? Yes, it was roughly 2526
- 3:02thousand in May when the pod pod launched.
- 3:07Look and I like that you're using stat muse to look up the
- 3:09stat. That's what came up for me too.
- 3:11Did it. Yeah, there we go.
- 3:14When when I looked it up I went straight to stat muse. 10/21
- 3:17portfolio company. Eli, if you listen to this, we
- 3:20know you're out there somewhere. Don't give a a shield of stab
- 3:26Muse 1031 portfolio company incredible Sports data, but
- 3:31they're getting into finance data as well, starting with
- 3:33Bitcoin. This is a little off topic but
- 3:35there's wimby muse. You know Wimby just a freak
- 3:39sanction. Spurs going to see the game
- 3:40tonight he there. The Twitter Wimby Muse is
- 3:43amazing if you just want to see like highlights of what's going
- 3:46to be like a generational. Athlete.
- 3:49We're just looking like 7 fours. Like dribbling up the core,
- 3:51shooting threes anyway. Wimi muse SAP.
- 3:54Muse. We need to go to one of those
- 3:56games in Austin. Spurs are playing in Austin 3
- 3:59three times this year. You gotta get to one of those
- 4:01games. But we digress.
- 4:06This started because we're talking about the price.
- 4:09Obviously we've seen a big price bump over the last month.
- 4:15I'm gonna pull up the stats. The price of Bitcoin's up 40% /
- 4:1910,000 dollars, almost $11,000 over the last month.
- 4:23We'll start the conversation. There's gonna be a broad
- 4:25discussion about bitcoins full potential valuation.
- 4:29But to start where we are today and to discuss this 40% increase
- 4:36in price over the last month, what is it?
- 4:38Many people think it's the ETF. What do you guys think we're in?
- 4:41This was an 8 day period where the SEC has the ability to
- 4:45approve. Do an omnibus approval of all
- 4:50the ETF applications out there. It seems like the price is
- 4:54moving in a way that would lead many to believe that they're
- 4:58going to get approved. You guys have any thoughts on
- 5:00this? Yeah.
- 5:03Dylan, do you you want to start there?
- 5:05I. Sure.
- 5:07I mean, yeah, I I think the ETF is a driving narrative, but you
- 5:11know, it's it's interesting to me because and this is a bit
- 5:13anecdotal, but also. You know, just from like a, you
- 5:17know, volumes perspective and all that like it seems like it's
- 5:20still the same pool, not like the same pool of incumbents.
- 5:23Obviously there's, you know, there's outside capital that's
- 5:26increasingly looking at this. You know when Larry Fink comes
- 5:28out and it's like hey, it's you know, it's an international
- 5:31asset that's obviously you know, a stamp of approval.
- 5:34But like none of the people that you'd think are, you know,
- 5:37massive buyers of this bought ETF or Bitcoin as it's like kind
- 5:41of legitimized in the eyes of. Wall Street or you know the
- 5:44traditional financial institutions like none of them
- 5:46have actually allocated any size.
- 5:48It's it's just the supply of Bitcoin is is actually more
- 5:52tightly held than ever and it's super liquid like like spot
- 5:56volumes as of like a month ago they've they've risen a bit but
- 5:59our you know we're all time lows or like lowest lowest since
- 6:022018-2019 ish and so. You know, we're 50% from the
- 6:07highs, but you know, it's essentially just like the same
- 6:11group of of people that have been beating the drum.
- 6:13And a lot of these outside institutions are looking at this
- 6:16and like watching it start to run.
- 6:19And you know, we feel FOMO as you know, bitcoiners that are,
- 6:22you know, talking about this on, you know, 25 straight podcasts
- 6:25and every single day doing this full time and like we are fully
- 6:30allocated or like you know, or very, very much exposed.
- 6:33That's not true for like. You know, a couple trillion
- 6:36dollars of capital out there that's looking at this thing
- 6:39saying, damn, I wish I had, you know, a 1% exposure.
- 6:43But like the crazy part is putting a couple billion dollars
- 6:47to work in this market even at a $700 billion valuation, it's
- 6:52it's going to do a lot of of damage to the upside, if you
- 6:56will. So this thing can really rip.
- 6:58The illiquidity is obviously a future in a bear market.
- 7:01It's it's known as a bug, but. Yeah, that's pretty, that's
- 7:04pretty exciting in my view. So whether the ETF is approved
- 7:06in the next, I don't know eight days or whatever, I think
- 7:10they're going to probably table it back, maybe that's a cold
- 7:12take in a week from now. But yeah, I mean I think the ETF
- 7:16is actually is not like the driving feature.
- 7:18The driving feature is the fundamentals which brought about
- 7:21the, the demand for the ETF, right, Like Larry Fink's not a
- 7:24bit Coiner just has clients hammering on his on his desk to
- 7:29to get an ETF across, right. So like.
- 7:31I think people are are reversing the causality here.
- 7:34It's because bitcoins, an institutional asset and
- 7:37legitimate in the 1st place that an ETF is, is now entering the
- 7:40conversation after all these years.
- 7:43Oh, yeah, I I thought I was going to have the contrarian
- 7:46take by saying that, you know, I I'll believe the ETF when it
- 7:50happens. And until then, I'm not going to
- 7:52expect anything. And you know, it could very well
- 7:55be this week, It could be 3 months from now, It could be six
- 7:59months from now. I'm not going to allow myself to
- 8:02be surprised by any of them, but for me the price action right
- 8:06now feels like it feels like summer 2019, which is a bit of a
- 8:13departure from yeah, so, so in, you know, after the 2017 bull
- 8:20market we got to. We got to 20,000 and then the
- 8:26price bounced off of 6000 several times before breaking
- 8:30down at the end of 2018 and staying you know in the 3000
- 8:34range for three months before starting to tick back upwards
- 8:39and had this crazy rally off the bottom going from 3000 up to
- 8:44like 12,000 in in Q 2/20/19 and so we we.
- 8:52Blasted through the the point of resistance, which would have
- 8:55been 6000 at that point, 'cause that had been the support in the
- 8:58bear market. And then we broke down under
- 9:00that and in that first go we managed to breakthrough that
- 9:04$6000 resistance and there was so much excitement at that point
- 9:09in time, Marty and Matt were were doing rooftop podcasts.
- 9:16Encouraging everyone to stack at what ended up being the exact
- 9:20top of that rally. Pico top.
- 9:24And and I feel like that's what's happening right now and
- 9:27just in terms of the mechanics of this or I I think this rally
- 9:31is, is actually just the market accepting that the bottom the
- 9:34bottoms in and and you better get on board if and if you you
- 9:39know if you haven't bought back in.
- 9:41And so that's, I think, fuelling this rally right now.
- 9:44The difference versus 20/19 was that obviously that was that
- 9:48rally happened a a full year before the the halving in May
- 9:562020 and right now this is happening five months before the
- 10:01halving. So I don't think we have time
- 10:05for what happened last time which in in 2019 which was
- 10:09tailing off. You know and kind of slumping
- 10:12for nine months before the excitement of the having the
- 10:16imminent having really started to cause the market to pick up
- 10:20and and find support at around 10,000 and then go up from
- 10:23there. So I think we're just we just
- 10:26sort of shifted this rally from a year in advance to having to
- 10:32five months in advance of the having and that's going to mean
- 10:35I think that we like don't have time to really.
- 10:39Like test the lows again and I think we'll find some sort of
- 10:42support anyway. I think that that's like the
- 10:45actually what's happening and that if that's the case as as
- 10:48Dylan was saying that you know this is really just the same old
- 10:52participants. That means that all of the yet
- 10:56to arrive participants, all of that is additional demand that
- 11:01has not come online yet and will add to the tailwinds that we're
- 11:06already starting to experience. Yeah, there's.
- 11:09A few things I want to add here because we we did a live Rabbit
- 11:11Hole recap in Nashville last night and this conversation came
- 11:15up like is this 2019 Bull Trap Part 2?
- 11:19And it's very interesting. Maybe not even like the 2019
- 11:24Bull Trap that happened in the early parts of the summer.
- 11:27But if you look at the macro themes at the end of 2019,
- 11:32beginning of 2020, and then you line it up with what's going on
- 11:35now, it's not exactly the same, but.
- 11:37Fall of 2019, we had that repo spasm and the liquidity crisis
- 11:43in the the repo markets which leaked into the broader
- 11:48financial system. Then obviously we had the
- 11:51lockdowns in 2020 and then we had that Bitcoin get cut in half
- 11:55overnight in March of 2020. Then Fast forward to fall 2023
- 12:02and it seems like I we mentioned.
- 12:05The Treasury auction before we started to record, but the the
- 12:09Treasury auction that happened yesterday was piss poor, worst
- 12:14demand for for an auction in in some time.
- 12:19Who knows whether the Chinese ransomware attack really
- 12:22affected that particular auction, But whatever.
- 12:26Seems like there's some stress in the banking sector, some
- 12:29liquidity problems that may be arising, and so I think that's
- 12:33an interesting. Sort of data point to to take
- 12:38into consideration too. There's something similar
- 12:41happening, not exactly the same this cycle in 2023 that was
- 12:45happening back in 2019 leading up to a halving.
- 12:49So who knows whether that provides some downward pressure
- 12:53on the price at some point in the future of people need to get
- 12:57dollar liquidity and therefore need to sell their Bitcoin.
- 12:59I'm not so sure that's going to happen.
- 13:03For them, beyond that, one thing I want to clarify going back to
- 13:09the ETF and there's a lot of people out there saying that
- 13:13part of what's driving this 40% rise in the price of the last
- 13:18month is BlackRock buying Bitcoin in anticipation of ETF
- 13:22approval. And Jesse?
- 13:24I know you've gone through the filings and don't I know you've
- 13:27been covering the ETF stuff quite a bit as well.
- 13:30But like does that mechanic like that doesn't make sense to me.
- 13:33Like you mentioned to Jesse, like Blackrock's customers are
- 13:36demanding this product. And the way I understand it, the
- 13:40only way BlackRock will buy Bitcoin is if people basically
- 13:46express that they have demand to buy shares in the ETF and then
- 13:48they go out in the market and buy spot after that demands
- 13:51expressed. And that how this works
- 13:53mechanically, like they can't buy Bitcoin.
- 13:55Or stop buying Bitcoin. Yeah.
- 13:57Blackrock's not buying Bitcoin. Yeah.
- 13:59Yeah, I. Think.
- 14:01Of a vehicle like this are that when when an investor wants to
- 14:05put dollars in, then that fund turns around, uses those dollars
- 14:11to purchase Bitcoin and grant units to that investor.
- 14:17Based on whatever the the amount of Bitcoin is generated from
- 14:23converting those dollars into Bitcoin.
- 14:25And so that happens when the investor arrives and when the
- 14:29fund obviously when the fund is active there is probably,
- 14:33there's probably some amount of like you probably want to have
- 14:37like you you want to test it I guess and you want to maybe
- 14:41BlackRock is you know trying to. Make sure that those mechanics
- 14:48work, but like that would be just just negligible volume.
- 14:51It's like the mean black rock's just poking the the Bitcoin,
- 14:54just trying to make sure make sure it works, they can, they
- 14:56can purchase. It and move it.
- 15:00The the BlackRock this this price action actually does feel
- 15:03like the ETF and and I I'm probably I could be wrong or I'm
- 15:06probably wrong but my thought is.
- 15:09I anchor back to Block Fi in Celsius.
- 15:11When they both crashed, they were already kind of priced in
- 15:14like the market already knew. Remember when Celsius like
- 15:16dumped in there was announced, the price already fell.
- 15:19And then similar with Block Fi, it's like market participants
- 15:22already know certain things. It's just the nature of like the
- 15:25way these things work especially smaller such a nascent market
- 15:27that that's what I was thinking. When the price is moving, it's
- 15:30like oh, they already know there's a certain like cohort.
- 15:33It's not somebody buying, like, it's not BlackRock buying for
- 15:35the ETF. It's just people knowing and
- 15:37that we do probably get it. You know, in a relatively short
- 15:42order. And then the other part of the
- 15:4319 is I was thinking about that. But then I was thinking about
- 15:46like that's a careful, delicate balance on like, you know,
- 15:50thinking that oh, it's going to run and then we're going to
- 15:52crash and then having. Because if it doesn't happen,
- 15:55it's like we all know to expect like when things we expect them
- 15:58to happen, they don't. And other than exogenous effects
- 16:03of like global macro. If it doesn't happen, then there
- 16:07might not be that kind of like retrace that we saw in early 20,
- 16:11I guess it was 2019 and then 2020 there was like 2.
- 16:14Yeah, yeah. It's just sort of trailed off
- 16:16for for nine months going from 12,000 back down to 6000 before
- 16:23finding support there. But yeah, we just don't have
- 16:25time for that kind of bleed out to occur with how little time
- 16:29there is before the halving. And the ETF excitement to, to
- 16:34Michael's point, maybe it is really ETF stuff, but it it's
- 16:36also quite possible that market participants realize that the
- 16:41narrative is enough, you know, and they're participating in
- 16:46this narrative of the ETF is imminent knowing that other
- 16:48people are going to be thinking that and acting on it and it
- 16:50creates its own, you know, bullish demand and narrative,
- 16:56even if it's not yet happening in reality.
- 16:59So that's also possible. The fidelity writing every week
- 17:02about it doesn't hurt. Yeah, yeah.
- 17:05And and this the Bloomberg ETF experts that that that Dylan
- 17:11follows closely. I think they their current
- 17:14expectation is 75% likelihood before the end of the year, I
- 17:18think is it 80, now 80. So you know, they they think
- 17:23it's real. We'll see.
- 17:27I think there's, there's a couple of interesting points.
- 17:29One, and this is kind of the Marty's point could just be like
- 17:32you know, coincidence or anecdotal.
- 17:34But if you think about the last time that Bitcoin topped and
- 17:37also this kind of aligns with like in 2019 that that echo
- 17:41bubble. And then also just if you look
- 17:43at the previous kind of the Fed tightening cycles, you know,
- 17:46everybody likes to think like oh you know, yield curve inverts or
- 17:49like this esoteric employment indicator.
- 17:52But you know, pretty simple. It's like once the Fed starts to
- 17:55cut. That things are get a bit ugly
- 17:58you know like in the in the real economy and and that translates
- 18:01and bleeds into asset prices. Just look at the last time like
- 18:04line it up look at the S&P 500 look at the the Fed cuts rates
- 18:08and if you look the Fed cuts cut rates for the first time during
- 18:12that cycle in July 2019. All right.
- 18:16So like and again there was like a whole bunch of exogenous
- 18:19factors. There was a plus token thing.
- 18:20There was all sorts of like bit next derivative shenanigans
- 18:24like. This is obviously like there's a
- 18:26ton of entropy in this market. You can't just attribute it to
- 18:28one thing. And I do think that this, you
- 18:31know, this time with like the expected BlackRock flows or you
- 18:34know, just institutions now viewing this thing because of
- 18:36BlackRock stamp of of approval in a different manner could
- 18:40definitely change the, the dynamic.
- 18:42And you know that's being reflected in the price action.
- 18:44That's why, you know, bitcoin's up 30 percent, 40%.
- 18:47And, you know, the S&P and NASDAQ are just, you know, kind
- 18:49of flat over the last month. But I think it's just just
- 18:52interesting to look at because you know 2024 we have a few
- 18:55things lining up. We got the halving obviously
- 18:57probably the approval of of these you know, investment
- 19:01vehicles, ETFs and then also there's a good chance and you
- 19:05know a lot of the macro people including myself were banging
- 19:07the drum too early on this. But I don't think we've escaped
- 19:10the realities of like a tightening cycle and and
- 19:13somewhat of an economic downturn, you know, whether it's
- 19:15like devastating or not is one thing, but we've kind of had
- 19:18this like artificial. You know steroid steroid up
- 19:23economy for the last 15 years post great financial crisis
- 19:26COVID was like this you know this kind of last burst of
- 19:30adrenaline to to save a dying patient and now we're a severely
- 19:35over embedded economy still and real rates are positive right.
- 19:39Like not to you know like I'm not trying to be a doomer but
- 19:42like the math doesn't check out with real rates being positive
- 19:45with this much debt. So the longer that we're here,
- 19:48the the more. You're going to see this
- 19:51proliferate, which is happening and the more you're going to see
- 19:54actual pain on the other side. And so I'm not saying this in
- 19:56terms of the Bitcoin exchange rate.
- 19:58I'm saying this in terms of like the global financial system, the
- 20:01global economy, right, the global sovereign debt levels,
- 20:04like the whole 9 yards. Yeah, we can obviously go down a
- 20:06whole rabbit hole talking about that.
- 20:08All this to say on the other side of whatever comes of of
- 20:13this tightening cycle, right? Whatever comes of the result of.
- 20:16Across the curve, 30 years to three months real yields as
- 20:21indicated by inflation expectations again, which taken
- 20:24at face value, they were hilariously wrong in 2020.
- 20:27They can be wrong again. And if they're wrong again, that
- 20:29means we get more inflation. All is to say that like real
- 20:32yields can't be positive or as positive as they are.
- 20:36You know 15 year highs, the highest they were since before
- 20:39the greater financial crisis in 07/08 with this much debt out
- 20:43there. So either we get a whole burst
- 20:46of inflation or they cut rates because things get ugly and
- 20:49you're going to see probably at some point in 24 globally A
- 20:53fiscal and monetary cannon combined with the having
- 20:57combined with the ETF narrative all at once or you know kind of
- 21:01in in a row. Combine that with like bonkers
- 21:05price action and and you get like an environment that's
- 21:08probably not as crazy in in, you know, relative terms as COVID
- 21:12was just 'cause, you know, the magnitude of that stimulus was
- 21:15unprecedented. Maybe, I mean, maybe you do, but
- 21:18I highly doubt that we get, you know, an economy locked down in
- 21:21an employment at 12, unemployment at 1215% overnight
- 21:25again, but regardless, like we haven't experienced a real
- 21:28downturn. People don't like, know what a
- 21:30recession is globally, right? So that's something that you
- 21:35know is a natural result of these cycles, right?
- 21:38You can't just escape reality or gravity for this long without
- 21:41facing consequences And I think that that comes and the reaction
- 21:44function to that whatever it looks like you know whatever
- 21:48tread fed treasury you know kind of like facility comes of this
- 21:52whatever like this this times TARP or you know bank funding
- 21:57bank term funding program or QE or yield drift control like
- 22:00whatever it is. You know, TLDR, like it's excess
- 22:04money in the system, right? Like that's just, you know, boil
- 22:06it down to that. And so that sets up 2024 to just
- 22:10be like, in my opinion, just a crazy bonkers year.
- 22:15And you know, I don't know exactly how it plays out.
- 22:17No one does, of course, but it's, it's going to be exciting.
- 22:21Yeah. Yeah, the, you know it.
- 22:23It follows with the sort of theory that, you know, every
- 22:26time you kick the can down the road, you have to put more
- 22:29effort into kicking it the next time.
- 22:32And the last round of stimulus for COVID was $10 trillion
- 22:37globally. And we obviously saw what that
- 22:39did to price of all assets. So if we have to you know muster
- 22:44a greater kick in 2024 and or beginning in 2024 in terms of
- 22:49stimulus, I don't know what we're talking about.
- 22:51Is it, is it 10, is it 15, is it $20 trillion of stimulus that
- 22:55that is needed to prop up the economy because we haven't
- 22:58allowed a proper recession since 2008 or or really earlier than
- 23:04that? And that's also happening with
- 23:07like you know Citadel yesterday Ken Griffin saying that he's
- 23:12expecting sustained high inflation this decade now.
- 23:15And so that's a shift from a a prominent investor saying that
- 23:22you know the part of that I think is the interest expense on
- 23:25national debt and and how that is actually kind of stimulative
- 23:30to and and expands the monetary base because suddenly you're
- 23:33having to spend more. As the as the the government you
- 23:39try you have to spend more in order to service your debt and
- 23:42then that flows into the economy and helps create the sticky
- 23:45inflationary effect. All of, yeah, all of these
- 23:49trends are lining up together. But Dylan, I wanted to ask, do
- 23:52you think that? I mean, it kind of impossible to
- 23:56know, but do you think that you know if shit hits the fan in
- 24:002024, even to some extent? Do you think that that
- 24:06negatively impacts Bitcoin or does Bitcoin get recognized at
- 24:11this point as the solution or the lifeboat to all the
- 24:16sovereign debt problems? I mean, Martin Shkreli was
- 24:20tweeting yesterday about about how Bitcoins Rally is because
- 24:25the US is insolvent and people are waking up to that.
- 24:29You know, is that, is that a narrative that that helps
- 24:32Bitcoin become the? Lifeboat asset for for fiscal
- 24:38crisis that it has always been and people haven't realized
- 24:41because they've assumed it's a risk on tech asset.
- 24:45Yeah, I mean that's an interesting question.
- 24:48Do you want anyone want to chime in?
- 24:50Well, I. Was going to say I was going to
- 24:51ask a question before we even jump.
- 24:53There's two parts like I think that's it's a it's to be
- 24:56interested in dill as responsible before going to that
- 24:59is thinking about. We have an ETF, right, like an
- 25:02actual, like financial product that's set to be launched.
- 25:05We have fidelity talking about this stuff is what is going on
- 25:08in people's heads. Like, let's put ourselves in
- 25:11tratify Bob, you know, you know, tratify Bob, Tratify Bob this.
- 25:18Is a nice archetype. I like this archetype.
- 25:19Boomer, Boomer, Billy. You know, yuppie Sally like they
- 25:24they've been hearing about Bitcoin for six years and 17 and
- 25:27now it's it won't go away. You have BlackRock stepping in
- 25:30fidelity. So like, I was going to ask this
- 25:33and I'm asking it, but before going to Dylan.
- 25:35And then also just like, how are people even thinking about what
- 25:38the hell is happening? Like, what is it?
- 25:40Because it's like, well, it wasn't real.
- 25:42It was rat poison, like all the things that we know and all the
- 25:45different like narratives. And now they have to start to
- 25:48think about it. And this is going to tie into
- 25:50obviously like full potential evaluation and how they can
- 25:52start. But we're just like real
- 25:54questions. Like, what are our friends and
- 25:56family like? What the hell are they thinking
- 25:58right now? What?
- 26:01And it finally died in, in November 2022, right?
- 26:04It was like they were proven correct.
- 26:05Finally. It was like, I knew it was a
- 26:06scam. It's like the Zeon thing, you
- 26:08know, he's like at the Pico Bottom, he comes on, it's like
- 26:11Bitcoin 16,000, like, what do you think?
- 26:13And he's like, well, it has $17,000 lower to fall.
- 26:16You know, it's like like Pico bottom.
- 26:19It's like, you know, this guy that's like generally respected
- 26:21on macro views and geopolitical and he's like, you know, maybe
- 26:25it's just an intelligence asset and it's just saying that stuff
- 26:28because. But like, he's like, no, yeah.
- 26:30And it's going to, you know, it's going to zero.
- 26:31It's going negative and it's, it just ripped in his face.
- 26:34And So what do they think? Like, I I think a lot of people
- 26:38don't don't know what to think because, you know, it was an
- 26:41irrational exuberance in 2021, right?
- 26:43Arc, Tesla, you know, just GameStop, Shiba, Inu, Dogecoin.
- 26:48It was like, oh, it's just like that stupidness, you know, VC
- 26:52everything. And then it they were proven
- 26:54right. In 2022, it finally died.
- 26:56And now Larry Fink's going out there and saying, like, no, this
- 27:00is an international asset. It's bounced up, flirting, you
- 27:03know, back with a trillion, again, like 800 billion.
- 27:06And, you know, there's probably 12 months away from, you know,
- 27:10$40 trillion in in national debt.
- 27:13Like, that's, yeah, it's powerful.
- 27:18No, I mean. And not only you have Larry Fink
- 27:20coming out like putting support behind it, but you see this.
- 27:26Particular narrative, flight to safety, he said it.
- 27:28Muhammad al Lorraine said it. I think Paul Tudor Jones said it
- 27:34as well like so the the Bitcoin meme, it's beginning to form at
- 27:39that layer of institutional capital is flight to safety,
- 27:42which is extremely bullish for Bitcoin.
- 27:44And then we were mentioning it before we have recorded, but
- 27:48outside of this show, we talked to a lot of institutions about
- 27:52Bitcoin and. I'll have to speak for myself.
- 27:55I've noticed over the last month or two specifically that the
- 27:59tenor has certainly shifted and people are definitely paying
- 28:02attention, asking more questions and seeking people out like, all
- 28:06right, I need to get smarter on this.
- 28:07Can you help me? I've I've I've experienced that
- 28:10with some pretty large institutional allocators over
- 28:14the last month or two. Yeah.
- 28:18I think one of the things that's fascinating, all this is like
- 28:20one just trying to put ourselves in the the mind frame of like
- 28:23how we're thinking. Because I think ultimately
- 28:25whether it's the institution or the individual that your friend,
- 28:27they're pretty much on the same spectrum of the cohort that is
- 28:30like this is all crap or this is that because it makes up the
- 28:33same people. So like an institution like Paul
- 28:35Tudor and the the folks in those circles are the same kind of
- 28:38circles lower down the rung that are allocating maybe it's less
- 28:41capital and you still have this other group that's looking at it
- 28:44like this thing didn't go away in 17, it's still here in 20.
- 28:47But what is it worth like, OK, can BlackRock custody better
- 28:51than everybody else? So now I go like there's still
- 28:52this frame there. They're trying to wrap like a
- 28:54position around it. Like what is it?
- 28:56Is it physical? Is it digital?
- 28:57Blackrock's offering it up. So it can't be like completely
- 29:01vaporware because I think that's where complete vaporware, that's
- 29:04where it had been like looked at for so long.
- 29:06And so it's just like an interesting thought experiment
- 29:08of like how like the mind is like wrapping itself around this
- 29:12like asset that and we're here and it comes in.
- 29:14It kind of ties into Jesse's question to Dylan of like.
- 29:17Well, how are they going to think when the bonds and all
- 29:19those things go tits up? It's like they don't even know
- 29:22what to think about it today. Like what tits up they're going
- 29:24to be thinking about. There's a there's all these
- 29:25other issues that are coming up around it, and it feels like
- 29:29it's a long way to go for it to get to that point where it's
- 29:31like the this, like the from an order of operations to be the
- 29:35the actual savior or the thing that saved them.
- 29:39Yeah, yeah, I in the in the on ramp roundups, I've been been
- 29:44writing weekly and I I said the same thing just recently in a
- 29:47conversation with Preston Pitch. But there's like 2 extremely
- 29:51strong narrative violations that have that are happening that
- 29:54that have already happened. You know just recently it's, you
- 29:58know for all, for all of bitcoin's history, it's been
- 30:00this, you know, extremely volatile thing that you can't
- 30:03touch because it's far too risky.
- 30:05You know it's massive drawdowns and, you know, stay away.
- 30:08It's toxic. And you know, here we are, you
- 30:11know, a year, almost directly a year after, you know, the second
- 30:15biggest exchange in the world collapsed and Bitcoin is is
- 30:18closer to its all time high than the US long bond, the US
- 30:22Treasury bond. The second, you know, narrative
- 30:25violation is like any single any any person ever that's just
- 30:29bought Bitcoin daily from any date ever is in the green.
- 30:35You start on the all time high. You buy Bitcoin every single day
- 30:38starting at 69,000 in November 2021 to today you're up 40%.
- 30:44So like the the trope of like it's far too risky, don't touch
- 30:49it, too volatile you know stick with like the 6040.
- 30:52While the 6040 has gotten absolutely killed on no
- 30:55volatility, it's been killed in a straight line.
- 30:57You know, no volatility downwards.
- 31:00While Bitcoin, obviously hyper volatile, has provided anybody
- 31:04that's ever just passively accumulated it crazy returns.
- 31:08And so like, there's a shift there, right, where like for the
- 31:11longest time it was just like the, you know, the hardcore
- 31:13Bitcoiners, you know, they got the crazy people that have laser
- 31:15eyes on Twitter that were saying this stuff.
- 31:18And now there's it's most definitely And just from the
- 31:20conversations that we've, you know, we said we had prior to
- 31:23this episode, it's happening in boardrooms, right?
- 31:25Like like like it's not just this small corner of the
- 31:28Internet anymore. That's like saying screw you to
- 31:31the system and it's like, you know, anarchist money.
- 31:34It's like, oh shoot, like my return profile for my my $100
- 31:39billion fund actually is going to suffer if I don't understand
- 31:43this. And that's a that's a different
- 31:46place than we've been ever, right, Micro strategy up a
- 31:50billion. Yeah, I, I, I.
- 31:53For me, my mental model always brings us back to like the the
- 31:57bell curve of technology adopters and Bitcoin is.
- 32:03Slowly making its way through the bell curve of who's going to
- 32:07adopt this technology. And for the 1st 15 years, it's
- 32:11been the absolute bleeding edge of people who have a reason to
- 32:15adopt this, whether it's because they're, you know, anarcho
- 32:20capitalists or or just libertarian or or technologists.
- 32:26And it has been slowly making its way and proving itself out
- 32:30too. That's an important part of
- 32:31this. It's the the the Lindy effect of
- 32:34it. It normalizes as it's around
- 32:36longer and longer and it becomes more reliable because it's been
- 32:40around longer. And so we're we're still so
- 32:43early in the adoption curve, you know by any realistic assessment
- 32:49of like. How far into the global adoption
- 32:52curve are we in terms of people who have adopted Bitcoin as a
- 32:55savings technology? We're still in the first half of
- 32:58percent of adoption, which puts in in the 1st 2.5% of the the
- 33:04classical bell cover of adopters is the innovators category,
- 33:09which is to say that, you know after that is the early
- 33:11adopters. We're not even, we're not.
- 33:13We're 1/5 of the way into the innovators category.
- 33:17Let alone the early adopters category, then the early
- 33:19majority, late majority and laggards.
- 33:22But I think that different types of adopters are on their own
- 33:29version of the adoption curve. Like it has to be the
- 33:32individuals who are bleeding edge and have a reason to adopt,
- 33:36who adopt 1st and then. And institutions, their adoption
- 33:41curve doesn't start right away because it has to be proven out
- 33:44by individuals before any institution will will consider
- 33:47it as a legitimate investment. And we're really just beginning
- 33:51that adoption curve now the the institutional adopters the so.
- 33:57So as we're collectively getting to this point in the adoption
- 34:00curve, new narratives start to matter for the incremental next
- 34:04slice of adopters. Versus the, you know what has
- 34:08happened over the 1st 15 years. And so I think the narratives
- 34:12for the next slice of adoption is more around like how do I
- 34:17make sure I have a diversified portfolio and not miss out,
- 34:21which is very different from from what it's been for the last
- 34:2315 years. And and I think that's part of
- 34:26how like each successive slice of the adoption curve when
- 34:29you're on the front half of it becomes a larger and larger
- 34:32cohort of people who are adopting over the same space of
- 34:35time. And you know, in that sense it's
- 34:37exponential, it's that's where the gradually then suddenly
- 34:40really plays out of we're reaching A exponentially larger
- 34:44slice of adopters just as this thing proves itself self out and
- 34:49becomes necessary to incorporate into the average portfolio and
- 34:53we're really just beginning that era which is extremely exciting.
- 34:57Climbing the S curve, gentlemen. Yeah, and and just like
- 35:01everything in Bitcoin, it's a lot more accelerated because
- 35:04there's asymmetry. And if you're not allocating
- 35:07like traditional tech adoption curve, like if you stay in the
- 35:09standard, maybe you, you're a laggard, but you're not like
- 35:12completely losing where if you stay in a bad form of money,
- 35:15you're you may have no money, right.
- 35:17And so. Yeah.
- 35:18And tying it back to the relative lack of liquidity that
- 35:22exists like this pump has happened on relatively low
- 35:25volume I think. If you're comparing, this is
- 35:30actually a good segue into what we came here to talk about,
- 35:32which is Bitcoin's full potential valuation.
- 35:35But if you're comparing it to like tech adoption, like the
- 35:38Apple App store or something like that, it's much easier.
- 35:40You know that adoption happens very quickly, but there's no
- 35:45like monetary value outside of Apple's stock price, which is
- 35:49somewhat elastic. They can issue new shares or buy
- 35:52them back. But with Bitcoin, it's.
- 35:55It's finitely scarce with 21 million and the reflexivity of
- 36:02the price as more and more people adopt this as we climb
- 36:05the S curve is going to be unlike anything we've ever
- 36:07experienced in human history. Yeah.
- 36:10And I think one thing that ties into this full potential
- 36:13valuation is. People generally that we know
- 36:17value or maybe it's not people we know because we know a lot of
- 36:19crazy people. But people that are generally
- 36:21allocating the Bitcoin, they're holding 123 percent and it's
- 36:24their have a personal account, they have cash and they
- 36:26allocate. They're not thinking about it as
- 36:27like what do I take out of my real estate portfolio if they
- 36:29own 100 pieces of real estate in California?
- 36:31Like that sounds crazy and I think that's where like risk
- 36:35premium lies in like most I think people on this.
- 36:38Chat or holding the majority of their capital in Bitcoin because
- 36:41they've, you know, done the work and seen there's risk premium
- 36:43that exists across spectrum of assets.
- 36:45And it's like all roads lead to Bitcoin and the liquidity
- 36:48profile, counterparty risk and all the things we know about it.
- 36:51But I think that's really where that full potential valuation
- 36:54comes in. And looking at it, it's like,
- 36:55well, all of these other assets that people are holding that
- 36:58make up the majority of global wealth all have certain risk
- 37:01premiums and they continue to increase.
- 37:02As you know, we know inflation's increasing.
- 37:05So I think that's like a big component.
- 37:07There's like asymmetry there. And people are like measuring
- 37:10Bitcoin against maybe their dollar exposure, but not other
- 37:13assets and how they compare. And if you look at it long
- 37:16enough, you're like, oh shit, this actually competes with all
- 37:18these other assets. And again, the risk premium
- 37:21isn't like actually appreciated. And the easiest example is like
- 37:27San Francisco commercial real estate, right?
- 37:29But there that goes down the spectrum of doesn't matter what
- 37:32the asset is. I I think also kind of adding to
- 37:37your guys points about like the S curve and the adoption
- 37:40component. Like I think there was maybe it
- 37:43was like an early Bitcoin talk narrative or just like how
- 37:45people perceive that this like hyper bitcoinization trend would
- 37:49happen. It's like I I don't believe that
- 37:51you know everybody is going to be on their iPhone denominating
- 37:54all things in Bitcoin like in the western world.
- 37:56That's unbelievable. And it's like it was a it's it
- 37:59was always a fundamental kind of misunderstanding of how the
- 38:01whole process would play out. It's like no, you know there's
- 38:05going to be a billion people in the western world that get
- 38:07exposure to this thing. You know, a small like a a small
- 38:10kind of minority cohort will be doing it actively themselves,
- 38:12individually, personally like through their you know business,
- 38:16right. If they're an entrepreneur.
- 38:17But you know the the majority of people probably first are going
- 38:21to be probably not even knowing they own Bitcoin because the
- 38:24pension, the 401K, the, you know, the insurance you know
- 38:29premium that they pay every month for their for their
- 38:31healthcare, right. Like on the back end they're
- 38:33buying the Bitcoin, right. They're like all of these Fiat
- 38:37denominated liabilities that go out 30 years, right.
- 38:40Where the math just doesn't compute right.
- 38:42Like whether it's you know, on the government level but more so
- 38:45like on an institutional level, right.
- 38:48Especially after all these fixed income portfolios took like you
- 38:51know held to maturity they're they're taking losses if they
- 38:54market to market of like you know thirty 4050% on their bonds
- 38:58none of the math makes sense. And so on the back end like
- 39:01Bitcoin as a hard money is obviously like as it's pumping
- 39:05and everyone is looking to it that's going to to play a big
- 39:08role. But so people like I'm trying to
- 39:11say what I'm trying to say here is like people are going to own
- 39:13Bitcoin and obviously as many people, we want as many people
- 39:17as possible to own it self custody, understand it,
- 39:21understand its full potential value.
- 39:23But a ton of people are going to get Bitcoin exposure because
- 39:27they own S&P 500 index or because their pension has it and
- 39:31you know, they have a small allocation that grows from 1% to
- 39:345%, right? Like that's how a lot of people
- 39:36are going to get exposure to this asset And you know, just,
- 39:40you know, 10, maybe a handful of people, 100 people in the US
- 39:44where are going to buy exposure and then the coming years for
- 39:48millions, right. And like that's that's the thing
- 39:50that I think is a bit misunderstood in this whole
- 39:52transition. That's a great point that we are
- 39:57sort of shifting to the. As institutional investors are
- 40:01waking up to this and and the math on you know 30 year bonds
- 40:06that those are the become the decision makers and the
- 40:09trendsetters. You know, like if you want to,
- 40:12if you want to set a trend in the investment community, you,
- 40:14you influence Ray Dalio or, you know, Larry Fink.
- 40:21And those guys are waking up, not so much Ray Dalio, only
- 40:26slightly for him. But yeah, and, and, and so
- 40:30Dylan's right there, like it becomes 100 people making
- 40:33decisions on on behalf of 100 million people in terms of how
- 40:37their pensions are allocated. Or like, what's the standard for
- 40:41corporate treasury incorporation of Bitcoin, you know, into
- 40:46corporate treasury reserves. That becomes how most people get
- 40:50backdoored into normalizing Bitcoin for their portfolios,
- 40:54even if they haven't personally adopted it as a savings
- 40:56technology. Yeah.
- 40:59It's an extremely important point to internalize and
- 41:03understand and that's it. Like while we're on this
- 41:07conversation, I know we need to get to the full potential
- 41:09evaluation. But the question in my mind is
- 41:13how do you have somewhat of a controlled transition?
- 41:17From bond exposure to Bitcoin exposure, 'cause you mentioned
- 41:20obviously a lot of these pensions, a lot of these
- 41:22institutions, these banks, if they were to mark their bonds to
- 41:25market, would be severely underwater.
- 41:29They understand that and they understand they probably need
- 41:34the flight to safety that Bitcoin provides.
- 41:36But how do they do that mechanically without creating
- 41:38like a cascading sort of devolution of the market
- 41:42structure and treasuries? That actually allows them to get
- 41:45a meaningful amount of Bitcoin, Like like the slippage
- 41:49conversation, I guess the banks. The banks are all screwed for,
- 41:54you know, and and that screwed put it lightly, right?
- 41:56Like Bank of America is mark to market insolvent.
- 41:59You know, that's just like an incomprehensible idea a few
- 42:03years ago or even, you know, a a decade ago, especially great
- 42:07before their great financial crisis.
- 42:09And you know, all this was just papered over with 10 years of QE
- 42:12and and. You know, targeting on the long
- 42:14end and zero interest rates. And now, you know, people are
- 42:18kind of waking up that like, oh, you know, the whole higher for
- 42:20longer narrative is like, oh, maybe this fantasy, you know,
- 42:22world like isn't true anymore. And and I'm sitting here just
- 42:27like kind of laughing almost because it's like, yeah, OK,
- 42:29higher for longer. But the debt levels are also
- 42:32higher than they've ever been. So it's like, you know, we had
- 42:3530% inflation over 2 1/2 years, three years.
- 42:38And debt as a relative percent of as relative to productivity
- 42:42is higher. And before the inflation shock,
- 42:45which is the opposite of how, you know you're supposed to do
- 42:47it, if you want to kind of like manage this transition and and
- 42:50get back to somewhere where like you're not past this, you know,
- 42:53supposed like event horizon. So I mean for the banks like who
- 42:57knows like what the the Basel requirements are and like that's
- 43:01kind of a whole boring world. But increasingly like and maybe
- 43:07this is like, I don't know, maybe this is like going to be
- 43:09flat out wrong. I'm not saying like.
- 43:11Super cycle up only there's going to be plenty of
- 43:13volatility, but it's I think there's the potential for this
- 43:17thing to happen quicker than most people can comprehend,
- 43:19right? Like rip faces, like the the
- 43:211015 year thing of like Oh yeah, you know we're going to kind of
- 43:24just like 2X draw down kind of you know bubble up collapse and
- 43:30we're going to do this for another 15 years possibly in.
- 43:33My in my view might be a naive view on things as as you said
- 43:38earlier, like the reflexivity of this.
- 43:41Asset and idea and the technology behind it is
- 43:44compounding and most people are just looking at it on a linear
- 43:48chart, don't understand what's unfolding.
- 43:51And so that's where you know it might it could happen like
- 43:55faster than even the most bullish people believe and not
- 43:57to be like a Moon Boy. But you know what I mean?
- 43:59Like this, this could really, really get.
- 44:02Crazy Dylan. It's a.
- 44:03Friday morning I could use some Moon Boy juice, so thank you.
- 44:07Well, I but I think there's legs to that simply because of this
- 44:11anchor point that the math doesn't add up when people start
- 44:15waking up and there's bags of zeros.
- 44:18Banks are insolvent. It's probably not the states
- 44:19because we'll we'll come up with some, you know BTFP or whatever,
- 44:22but there's going to be other places that are having zeros and
- 44:25that's when stuff goes no bid because people are looking for
- 44:27an asset with a profile that they can take and they can put
- 44:30wherever they need to put it or they can verify that it's theirs
- 44:33and it's it's sitting somewhere. That's the like, I think
- 44:36gradually and suddenly moment is everybody starts to coalesce and
- 44:39we've seen mimetic world in the past, you know couple of years,
- 44:41let alone 10 years. Once it's the thing, it's the
- 44:44thing and everybody wants it, it doesn't matter like if it's a
- 44:46new app, you mean whatever it is.
- 44:48And so that's where like think with Dylan's driving to yours,
- 44:51like all the math doesn't add up and when somebody goes to the
- 44:54bank one day or something real happens and you don't, you can't
- 44:57get that and that's right. Go back to like counterpart risk
- 44:59and we talked about these like Sprott and there's a couple of
- 45:03the it's not. ETFs, they're the quasi ETFs,
- 45:07like the trust that deliver commodities.
- 45:09And everybody's always like, they're those are really small
- 45:12footprints compared to like GLD. And they're like, well, you
- 45:15know, they think of it as like they were either wrong or nobody
- 45:18really wants it. It's like nobody really wants it
- 45:19because they didn't know that they wanted the delivery of it
- 45:21because it was always there when they asked for it.
- 45:23Or they could get the dollars. But I think we're going to a
- 45:26world where people stop making hole in their obligations and
- 45:30that's effectively when this thing gets crazy.
- 45:33Yeah. And that that whole process I
- 45:36think is is kind of the the starting point for full
- 45:41potential evaluation analysis of like when when people do the
- 45:46math and realize that these other asset classes cannot
- 45:51deliver reliable returns in in real terms.
- 46:00Do we lose Jesse? Everyone.
- 46:07Jesse, we're. Losing you?
- 46:11It's not the worst. It's not the worst.
- 46:13Wi-Fi. It's not the.
- 46:14Worst pause phase I've ever seen on this show, but it's not.
- 46:17Not the best either. Maybe.
- 46:20Maybe Logan, we throw up the one of the slides on the full
- 46:23potential and then he'll come back and see it and he'll he'll
- 46:25be ready to. The one that I'm thinking of is
- 46:29the the chart with the different asset classes, but maybe there's
- 46:32a different one. It's the the.
- 46:34Rectangle chart, yeah. I can hop in here for a second
- 46:38and maybe provide some color until Jesse gets back.
- 46:42And this is this is kind of an in relation to the the full
- 46:45potential valuation idea. But when we say like the the
- 46:48numbers don't add up or like you know, the math doesn't compute.
- 46:52Jesse's back. Maybe I'd just let him rip on
- 46:54it. You keep going.
- 46:55You keep going, you got kicked out.
- 46:57You're you're going now? All right.
- 46:59Well, yeah, I'll just share this, this one I guess stat or
- 47:02idea, but like when like we're in very rare air in terms of the
- 47:06debt levels globally, but like in the US right where the world
- 47:09reserve currency, there's only been you know 50 instances ever,
- 47:1353 instances ever of nations with this high of a debt burden
- 47:16and all of them have defaulted except the US today and modern
- 47:19day Japan. And so people, often times
- 47:22you'll have these kind of debates, like these macro, long
- 47:24term macro debates and they'll say, yeah, well, you know, Japan
- 47:27got away with it, right? Like look at what they're doing.
- 47:30And I just sit there and laugh because it's like, yeah, look at
- 47:32what they're doing. They're doing your yields here
- 47:34of control and the yen's collapsing against every other
- 47:36currency that matters. So it's like if your if your
- 47:39base case scenario is like, oh don't worry about it, you know
- 47:42the US can escape this and not just the US like the US as kind
- 47:46of a reference. Point and like the you know the
- 47:49the the dollar as a every other currency is a derivative of the
- 47:52the US dollar essentially and and all the debt is a derivative
- 47:55of the US sovereign debt market like oh OK the analogue's Japan.
- 48:00So we're just going to conduct yield curve control, screw the
- 48:03creditors, screw the savers and the currency is going to utterly
- 48:09you know collapse essentially because like look at the price
- 48:11action of the yen, right, They're they just.
- 48:13OK. Yep.
- 48:14The yield passed 25 basis points or they moved it to 50 and they
- 48:17moved it to 100 basis points on the 10 year.
- 48:20And whether it's explicit or implicit yield curve control or
- 48:23some form of like BTFP facility that you know, it's maybe is a
- 48:28bit more broadened and you know it's definitely some word word
- 48:32salad that like most people don't really understand what's
- 48:34what's happening, right. Like there's not wide scale
- 48:36outrage because who? Who?
- 48:38Besides maybe like? 10,000 people understand the
- 48:41mechanics of the bank term funding program, right?
- 48:44Like it's just this esoteric thing, but what is it?
- 48:46It's like bailing out. It's bailing out Wall Street in
- 48:49the banks instead of Main Street, right.
- 48:51So like you have to do this at a wide scale level because again,
- 48:56the math doesn't work. So what's if if if you're
- 48:59thinking the Bank of Japan and then the Japan analogue is is
- 49:02what we're facing, you know what's what's the other side of
- 49:06the equation? For the dollar, right.
- 49:09Like what? What's the dollar just, you
- 49:12know, devaluing at a rapid pace on is it gold, right.
- 49:15Is it, is it Bitcoin? Like, these are the questions
- 49:18that have to be asked. And like, shockingly few people
- 49:22are asking them. They're like, oh, you know,
- 49:24higher for longer. And I'm just sitting there like,
- 49:26what are you even talking about? Because, like, none of the math
- 49:28makes any sense. Yeah.
- 49:31And to that point too like the I'm looking for a chart now I
- 49:34can't find. I think Lynn Alden was tweeting
- 49:36it out a week or two ago. But if people use like Japan's
- 49:41yield curve control example and be like look they did it.
- 49:44They were fine. They're making a critical
- 49:46mistake where you if you look at like the median and mean average
- 49:51income or the median mean income in Japan, they're much closer
- 49:56like they have a much their their wealth gap is much.
- 50:01Less wide in in Japan compared to the US And so like just like
- 50:05the literal income landscape across the two countries is
- 50:08completely different and that's a cultural thing that that is
- 50:12different between Japan and the US.
- 50:16And so like the that like they've had relative stability
- 50:20in Japan because of the lack of the the wealth gap that exists
- 50:23there compared to the US where if you're trying to do.
- 50:27Try to say that the US can do what Japan did for the last
- 50:31three decades. It's simply not gonna
- 50:32materialize just because the the makeup of the wealth gap in the
- 50:36United States compared to Japan. Culturally they decided to bat
- 50:40down the the hatches and have everybody live somewhat equally
- 50:45from an income perspective. Interesting.
- 50:48I I wasn't familiar with that. That's that makes a lot of
- 50:50sense. Sorry, I got cut off.
- 50:53I could see you guys talking, but I was frozen.
- 50:57Thanks for. Tuning In to the Last trade If
- 51:00you're enjoying the show and want to dive deeper, check us
- 51:03out at on rampbitcoin.com where you'll find a full suite of
- 51:07institutional grade research and analytics, including our
- 51:11recently published white paper, Bitcoin's full potential
- 51:15valuation, and our new tool, the On Ramp Terminal.
- 51:19Now back to the show anyway, so, so to pick up where we were
- 51:24leaving off of like this is the the, the segue into what we're
- 51:29here to talk about the Bitcoin's full potential evaluation.
- 51:31And and this is the path of like of connecting the dots that
- 51:36points to this analysis of you know if we're entering this
- 51:41several decade period where at at all times every every
- 51:46investor has a menu of options for how they can allocate their
- 51:49capital. There's different types of
- 51:52assets they could be sitting in and you care about
- 51:56diversification, but most importantly you care about
- 51:59performance in real terms. And if we're entering this era
- 52:05of of debasement bonds in particular will suffer because
- 52:13those are future promises for dollars.
- 52:16And if you're debasing the dollars that they're paying out,
- 52:19that hurts the value in real terms of of that bond contract.
- 52:23Similarly hurts for for Fiat money if you're holding that.
- 52:27But it also impacts every other asset too.
- 52:30You know, it impacts equities because, you know, if we were in
- 52:34an era of stagflation, for example, you know, we had that
- 52:38in the 70s, Stocks went sideways for a decade.
- 52:42They were down in real terms, sideways and nominal terms, down
- 52:46in real terms because the economy was struggling.
- 52:51And it's harder to deliver strong performance when people
- 52:56are consuming less because they're struggling to pay their
- 52:58bills. And you're also having to
- 53:00devalue future cash flows. In your valuation model, you're
- 53:04discounting them more because you're pricing in higher
- 53:06interest rates as that stagflation becomes stickier and
- 53:09you expect it to last for longer.
- 53:12So anyway the equities start to underperform in real terms and
- 53:17So what performs well in in the 70s it was gold which had a 14X
- 53:25over the course of 12 years and that you know that's hard
- 53:30assets, hard assets do very well in in a period of of high
- 53:35inflation and Bitcoin is a hard asset, Gold is a hard asset as
- 53:39well. And so you know the when I first
- 53:43got into Bitcoin, when I when I arrived at Bitcoin only in 2020,
- 53:50a big part of how I was thinking about you know what's the
- 53:53opportunity here is trying to figure out what can this thing
- 53:56become. You know if if this thesis of
- 54:00you know the changing world order, the breakdown of of
- 54:03sovereign debt, you know the reset of sovereign debt as we
- 54:07know it. If that plays out, what does it
- 54:10mean for Bitcoin in terms of its full potential?
- 54:13And that's that's a management consulting exercise that you
- 54:18often run to try to understand this, the potential scale of an
- 54:23opportunity usually in management consulting context
- 54:27with regard to like a particular business unit or product line
- 54:30for a company. But in this case, what's the
- 54:33full potential for Bitcoin? What can it become in the global
- 54:36asset landscape? And so that was the exercise
- 54:39that I started was kicking around in my own head and doing
- 54:43scratch math on in 2020 and 2021.
- 54:46And I've crystallized it into a full report for for on Ramp here
- 54:54in 2023, which by the way for everyone is available to to to
- 54:59download on Ramp's website. So if you go to on
- 55:03rampbitcoin.com and right there at the top of the page there's a
- 55:07button that says download the full bitcoins full potential
- 55:11evaluation report available to anyone.
- 55:13So you could just click that button and and see this whole
- 55:15report. And so Logan's just pulled up on
- 55:18screen the the first page here of of this report and the the
- 55:26general arc of it is taking stock of first you know what
- 55:31what is a full potential valuation exercise and then what
- 55:34are the necessary necessary ingredients that you have to
- 55:36have in place in order to complete that exercise.
- 55:39And the the big ones are you need to you need to understand
- 55:42what's the total addressable market and that is an exercise
- 55:46of understanding how much value is out there.
- 55:48So you need to have a a size for the total global asset value
- 55:53landscape and so that's step one and then then the exercise
- 55:59becomes what's the ceiling for Bitcoin in this landscape.
- 56:04And that is an exercise of taking stock of the strengths of
- 56:08the other assets versus Bitcoin and figuring out in in in
- 56:13particular relative to these other specific assets what could
- 56:16Bitcoin take. And and bonds is the the best
- 56:20example 'cause we were talking earlier about how for everyone
- 56:24holding bonds in their portfolio, maybe it's 40% of
- 56:27their portfolio in in the classic 6040 portfolio.
- 56:29And and this math isn't adding up going forward.
- 56:33And people may go through their own personal exercises on an
- 56:38individual basis of reassessing what what their portfolio
- 56:42allocation currently is and decide, you know what, maybe I
- 56:45don't want to have 40% in bonds. Maybe I want to have a a piece
- 56:49of that sitting in hard assets. Maybe that's gold, maybe that's
- 56:53Bitcoin if it's both. And as this math plays out it
- 56:57may become clearer and clearer that Bitcoin is performing
- 57:00better than bonds and will perform better than bonds.
- 57:03And so that percent allocation may grow as people become more
- 57:08confident in that math and and people allocate appropriately So
- 57:14and and that's an exercise that has to happen for every single
- 57:18asset bucket in the global asset landscape in order for you to
- 57:22come up with your own personal expectation about what's
- 57:27possible. If Bitcoin siphons away X
- 57:31percent of value from this asset Y percent from this other asset
- 57:36and so on down the list. When you sum up all that the
- 57:41amount that Bitcoin has captured from these different store value
- 57:44buckets to figure out what's the potential what's the full
- 57:47potential for bitcoin's valuation and then what does
- 57:51that mean in terms of the price per coin.
- 57:53So that's the arc of this analysis and and Logan if you
- 57:57want to pull up the the actually the global asset landscape chart
- 58:03we can talk through that because so you know a a big part of this
- 58:08analysis was trying to take stock of how much, how much
- 58:12value is out there and I was sort of surprised that nobody
- 58:17really had a clear answer on on how much value is there in the
- 58:21investment landscape. And so I kind of put to work the
- 58:28management consulting tool kit that I got from my time at Bain
- 58:34to triangulate from various data sources what how much value sits
- 58:39in real estate, in equities, in bonds, in the other smaller
- 58:44categories like precious metals, art, collectibles.
- 58:49And of course there's there's money itself.
- 58:51How much is there? And through that exercise, I
- 58:55came up with this number of there's $900 trillion of global
- 59:00asset value out there, of which Bitcoin is.
- 59:05Well, at the at the time, just a month ago is 500 billion.
- 59:09Now it's a little bit more, but we'll say it's 500 billion.
- 59:12And so that's about 1-2 thousandth of the world's value,
- 59:16which is pretty shocking because that means it's 0.05% of the
- 59:23world's value is sitting in Bitcoin, which is quite a small
- 59:27percentage. And so that's your starting
- 59:30point for this analysis. And and then we get into, you
- 59:35know, what sets the ceiling for these different asset categories
- 59:40in terms of how much value they can store and how Bitcoin is
- 59:44different because it doesn't have the same problem that all
- 59:50of these other asset buckets have, which is that there's new
- 59:53supply being added to any, any store value bucket.
- 59:59Gold being a classic example where there's 1.5 to 2% more
- 1:00:03gold being added from gold mining to the above ground
- 1:00:07supply every single year. And that's been true for the
- 1:00:10last century. And so the ceiling for gold in
- 1:00:15terms of how much value it can possibly store is really based
- 1:00:19on how much value the market can absorb per year from new supply
- 1:00:24coming online, so. 2% of gold is a $12 trillion asset category
- 1:00:32asset class. There's $12 trillion of gold in
- 1:00:35the world and so 2% of that every year.
- 1:00:38Gosh my math is going to be a little fuzzy on that with a six
- 1:00:42hundred 240 billion I believe in in in supply, new supply that
- 1:00:52has to be absorbed by the market every single year And that sets
- 1:00:55your your that the demand side of that coming you know into
- 1:01:00contact with with supply sets your equilibrium in terms of the
- 1:01:04price spot price of gold for you know for gold coming into the
- 1:01:10market and that dictates the price the total value that's
- 1:01:13stored in in in all the existing gold reserves in the world.
- 1:01:19So it's it's really the intersection of supply and
- 1:01:21demand and supply being that key ingredient here for all of these
- 1:01:27categories. It sets the the ceiling for
- 1:01:30what's possible in terms of how much value can be stored in in
- 1:01:33gold, but also in art, in in real estate as well.
- 1:01:39And Bitcoin has this crazy property of increasing scarcity,
- 1:01:46which is to say, decreasing issuance over time with every
- 1:01:49four, every four years, with the halving of the the block reward,
- 1:01:55the block subsidy. And that means that over time,
- 1:02:00Bitcoin's ceiling isn't based on supply, it's based on something
- 1:02:07else. There's there eventually is no
- 1:02:09new supply so it doesn't have the same ceiling that gold has
- 1:02:14the same mechanics for for a ceiling that gold has it.
- 1:02:17In that sense it has an unbounded ceiling.
- 1:02:19And then what becomes relevant is not how much supply the
- 1:02:24market can absorb every year, but rather how much you want to
- 1:02:28hold Bitcoin versus other assets in your portfolio.
- 1:02:34And and then from that comes this final exercise of taking
- 1:02:40stock of the individual categories here and and it then
- 1:02:45it becomes a a personal choice choose your own adventure
- 1:02:49exercise of of going through and and thinking OK, what feels
- 1:02:54right in terms of what Bitcoin as a superior store of value
- 1:02:59asset with these more attractive properties especially in the
- 1:03:03context of the the the end days of Fiat money and the debasement
- 1:03:10that has to follow. How much you know how much of
- 1:03:15each of these categories will Bitcoin attract away from these
- 1:03:19categories in terms of capital? This is so.
- 1:03:22Bearish. Yeah.
- 1:03:24And and so I came up with my with my numbers of of what
- 1:03:28percent from each category and I kept them conservative.
- 1:03:31I that that was at least in my mind conservative.
- 1:03:36And then you sum them all up in terms of how much value flows
- 1:03:40away from these categories and into Bitcoin, sum up all that
- 1:03:43value divide by 21 million and you end up with with $10 million
- 1:03:49per Bitcoin. And so that for me is the I
- 1:03:52think conservative full potential valuation for Bitcoin.
- 1:03:58And so I know that I, I didn't intend for it to turn into a
- 1:04:03monologue of the entire analysis the whole way through.
- 1:04:08But if that was interesting to anybody, if that sounded crazy
- 1:04:13to you and you and you want to test the rigor of that or see
- 1:04:17these numbers and especially if you want to take a look at this
- 1:04:21methodology and input your own assumptions, go check out this
- 1:04:27report available at the on ratbitcoin.com website right
- 1:04:31there at the top of the page and and get your copy and and see if
- 1:04:34it makes sense to you or or update the numbers based on what
- 1:04:37you think it should be. And then compare that end result
- 1:04:40against the price of Bitcoin today and see if you're not
- 1:04:43bullish. Yeah.
- 1:04:45I think there's probably a lot of thoughts.
- 1:04:46The one thing I want to call out is I really love the the, the I
- 1:04:50forget the the title of the graph, the asset valuation or
- 1:04:53the global asset landscape. I I.
- 1:04:57Think if if for anything going to look at that one if you're
- 1:05:01listening and haven't seen it because I think like it's almost
- 1:05:04it's like a cousin in my mind of the stock to flow model.
- 1:05:08It gives somebody like a mental model of how to look at the
- 1:05:10asset and then also question what are the other assets and
- 1:05:13why were they worth that way and then like thinking about the
- 1:05:15properties against Bitcoin. So yeah, I think that it there's
- 1:05:19a it's a good framework to look at and I think a lot of times
- 1:05:22people think about again, going back to tradify Sally or
- 1:05:25whatever her name was. She's just looking at this thing
- 1:05:27like, what the hell is it? It's just an orange coin and it
- 1:05:30keeps disappearing in people from, you know, people's wallets
- 1:05:32or whatever until like start thinking about it as, you know,
- 1:05:36whatever it is and then against other assets I think is helpful.
- 1:05:41Yeah, you you confirm what Hal Finney said in 2009?
- 1:05:45Yeah, you. You actually went and like found
- 1:05:47he had like the roughed estimate, but he went and like
- 1:05:49found the hard details, I think you.
- 1:05:51Stole it. I think you stole it from Al
- 1:05:52probably. But yeah, yeah, I think, I think
- 1:05:57that's right. Yeah, he had a very different
- 1:05:58methodology but he comes up with a a similar number.
- 1:06:02His assumptions there actually is that there's X amount of of
- 1:06:07value in the world and that Bitcoin will consume it all
- 1:06:12which is not the assumption that I that I take here.
- 1:06:15But he he's starting with sort of wrong inputs.
- 1:06:20Yeah. OK Logan pulled it up.
- 1:06:22Heard from Jesse. Powell was wrong.
- 1:06:24As an amusing. Thought for those who can't see
- 1:06:26it, but this is what Hal said in 2009.
- 1:06:28Like right when Bitcoin launched as an amusing thought
- 1:06:30experiment, imagine that Bitcoin is successful and becomes the
- 1:06:33dominant payment system in use throughout the world.
- 1:06:35Then the total value of the currency should be equal to the
- 1:06:38total value of all the wealth in the world.
- 1:06:40Current estimates of total house house worldwide household wealth
- 1:06:44that I found range from 100 trillion to 300 trillion.
- 1:06:48With 20 million coins, which is wrong with 21 million, that
- 1:06:51gives each coin a value of about $10 million.
- 1:06:55Yeah. So obviously Hal was was just
- 1:06:57kind of doing a a rough assessment here he he didn't
- 1:07:00spend several days gathering data points on each of these
- 1:07:06asset value buckets and then triangulating and and adding
- 1:07:09them up. And I think that the the main
- 1:07:13difference the the assumption that I I will say Hal get gets
- 1:07:17wrong here it's kind of rare to be able to don't you dare think
- 1:07:22about anything. I think what Hal gets wrong is
- 1:07:26that the the assumption that all of the value flows into Bitcoin,
- 1:07:32because, you know, today there's $120 trillion of Fiat money and
- 1:07:39yet there's $900 trillion of global asset value, which is to
- 1:07:44say there's there's only 120 trillion, Let's say, let's say
- 1:07:48it's all dollars, there's only 120 trillion greenbacks and yet
- 1:07:53we price all these other assets, we value them in, in dollar
- 1:07:58terms. And so we, you know, that means
- 1:08:01that there's actually 900 trillion greenbacks worth of
- 1:08:05value, even though a small percentage of it is actual
- 1:08:09money. And Bitcoin will end up in the
- 1:08:11same sort of position, assuming it takes over the world of
- 1:08:16money. We will still have other assets
- 1:08:19and they will still have value. Real estate will still be
- 1:08:22valuable. You know, Monet paintings will
- 1:08:26still be valuable and and certainly equities will still
- 1:08:31have value. They may all be priced in
- 1:08:34Bitcoin terms and expressed in in Bitcoin terms and yet there's
- 1:08:38there's only 21 million Bitcoin. So we we started this before I
- 1:08:44I'd said I have a bit of a hot take that I think ultimately
- 1:08:49there ends up the world ends up with 100 million Bitcoin worth
- 1:08:54of value and you know obviously there's only 21 million Bitcoin,
- 1:08:59but it's because we express the the value stored in all these
- 1:09:03other buckets in Bitcoin terms even if that value isn't
- 1:09:08currently held in Bitcoin at that point in time.
- 1:09:11And so I think it's a that's the departure versus what Hal was
- 1:09:14doing where he assumed that Bitcoin becomes 100% of all the
- 1:09:17value, whereas this analysis assumes it ends up being 20,
- 1:09:21maybe 25%. And that's based on my
- 1:09:23conservative assumptions. It could end up being 50%, maybe
- 1:09:26it's maybe it ends up only being 5 or 10% for some unforeseen
- 1:09:30reason. But that's the sort of the
- 1:09:33challenge to so everyone listening of like go take a look
- 1:09:36at this analysis, see if it's reasonable to you and then
- 1:09:40change it based on what you think is even more reasonable.
- 1:09:44And I I think that's the the the power of of going through this
- 1:09:47report. Yeah, so.
- 1:09:49Let's do this right now in the round table.
- 1:09:51Start with Dylan Logan, pull up the the chart where the last
- 1:09:55chart you none of that one you just had up and Dylan.
- 1:09:59I think this is very bearish, particularly looking at the
- 1:10:01Bitcoin capture section. Of of this and this is
- 1:10:06conservative. I I I am I am being a bit
- 1:10:11facetious here but I do think we could get some valuable
- 1:10:15discussion out of everybody's perspective of how much Bitcoin
- 1:10:19actually captures in these different asset buckets.
- 1:10:21So we'll start with Dylan. What do you think of this
- 1:10:24conservative breakdown put forth by Jesse?
- 1:10:27Too conservative, too? Optimistic.
- 1:10:31I think it's AI think it's a good starting point.
- 1:10:34I yeah, I've I've kind of had a similar.
- 1:10:36You can say it's too bearish. Bearish.
- 1:10:40Well, I mean. Gordon Bearish.
- 1:10:41Honestly, like I think it's, you know that it gets a point across
- 1:10:45of, you know, at a $700 billion valuation currently with all
- 1:10:52these things that we covered beforehand, it's just laughably
- 1:10:55mispriced and then you know. The the entropy of the world and
- 1:11:00you know just Bitcoin kind of monetizing around the world and
- 1:11:05kind of programming us all to to work for it and slave away for
- 1:11:08it every day. That'll do the rest.
- 1:11:10So I don't, I don't know, I don't really have.
- 1:11:13I think it's a it's a great way to ballpark it.
- 1:11:15I actually have a good. Framework to For Jesse's point
- 1:11:17on like, why art 'cause it's always the Mona Lisa.
- 1:11:19But Mona Lisa, if we go through this framework like we can all
- 1:11:22probably agree Bitcoin's a better form and we'll probably
- 1:11:24consume all of. All bonds because you're
- 1:11:27basically going to like price a bond in Bitcoin terms like what
- 1:11:30Bitcoin you get back real estate.
- 1:11:34The question with real estate would be outside of the utility
- 1:11:37of owning 1 to X number of homes that you would need from like,
- 1:11:41you know, vacation. It takes all the investable
- 1:11:45value out of it because you obviously we have, we know all
- 1:11:47the attributes of Bitcoin mirror real estate, but just in digital
- 1:11:51form, you know, gold over time. So you start looking through the
- 1:11:57list, you're like well what what would you price a premium over
- 1:12:01the monetary premium And the the couple that you go to is like,
- 1:12:05well, fine art. But then a lot of people are
- 1:12:07holding fine art because of you know it's a it's a sick like
- 1:12:11there's there's this like natural thing that happens
- 1:12:13whether it's real estate or whatever is in a portfolio that
- 1:12:16somebody gets rid of because they'd rather hold Bitcoin as
- 1:12:18they learn about it. And I think that actually
- 1:12:20happens with fine art as well, because it's like even if.
- 1:12:23It's like, why am I paying the insurance cost and all the like
- 1:12:25overhead? Because it's still not free to
- 1:12:27put the Mona Lisa somewhere. And then equities obviously are
- 1:12:31just a derivative of Bitcoin. Like they'll the money will flow
- 1:12:35from an equity that's worth, you know, dog shit, basically
- 1:12:38somebody holding Wework or rather sell it to go into BTC
- 1:12:41and then you start to reprice equities and then you get
- 1:12:43dividends from the, you know, exposure to it.
- 1:12:46So anyway, going through this I think you end up like.
- 1:12:49I think how is pretty much spot on.
- 1:12:51On the on the margins, you have some like things that people
- 1:12:54like because they look at them and they're pretty, but they
- 1:12:56don't consume A monetary premium, which most of these
- 1:12:59things have done because of inflation, even if it's gold
- 1:13:02inflationary rate, yeah. I'm looking at real estate
- 1:13:05particularly and like I think this is one or two X off.
- 1:13:09At least you bring it back to the quad box.
- 1:13:13So you have like 15 percent, 45% from real estate.
- 1:13:16Yeah, 'cause you think. About like New York City's a
- 1:13:18great example of this. You get all the high end real
- 1:13:20estate in Midtown by Central Park and it's literally just far
- 1:13:24wealth parking their wealth outside of the confines of their
- 1:13:29own country, using it as the savings vehicle.
- 1:13:32They don't. They never live in the
- 1:13:34apartments in the penthouses. They just buy it to store wealth
- 1:13:38in Manhattan real estate over time like.
- 1:13:42Getting back to what Michael said, like real estate has
- 1:13:45utility, which has a cost that's worth paying for.
- 1:13:48Then you have the premium on top of that utility, which is
- 1:13:52typically dependent on aesthetics and location.
- 1:13:56And so like what how big is the value of the utility and then
- 1:14:01how much is the overall premium on the aesthetics and the
- 1:14:04location on top of that. I find it hard to believe that's
- 1:14:0785% of the total real estate market right now.
- 1:14:11Yeah, quite quite possibly. I'm I'm actually fully on board
- 1:14:15with with what you guys are saying and and you know, so I
- 1:14:19think that my conservative assumptions here are are overly
- 1:14:22conservative. I think that's like you know
- 1:14:25when you do an exercise like this, what you are trying to
- 1:14:28defend against in terms of what inputs you're picking is it you
- 1:14:33want people to not attack those assumptions.
- 1:14:36You want people to like actually engage with the analysis and
- 1:14:40that's a big part of why you pick the conservative
- 1:14:42assumptions because you know taking 15% from real estate is
- 1:14:47is plausible to anyone who thinks about it taking half.
- 1:14:52Some people might reject that and and then not engage with the
- 1:14:55analysis. But yeah you're right like who's
- 1:14:57to say it doesn't take 50% of of real estate and and I think
- 1:15:01bonds is is the even bigger case here of you know if if we if
- 1:15:07we're repricing the world in Bitcoin and and shifting away
- 1:15:12from this you know exponential growth monetary base Fiat
- 1:15:16system, then the bond bucket shrinks tremendously and it all
- 1:15:22becomes expressed in in Bitcoin terms.
- 1:15:24But you know you could it could shrink to be 110th the size and
- 1:15:30and then you're talking about all of that value, 90% of that
- 1:15:34value flowing into other things. Bitcoin being that the winner.
- 1:15:39Because because Bitcoin replaces bonds in terms of its functions,
- 1:15:43its function in a portfolio where bonds today are what they
- 1:15:47what they promised to investors is a small guaranteed yield,
- 1:15:53even if it may or may not be real yield and versus just
- 1:15:57nominal yield. And and then what Bitcoin does
- 1:16:00is because of its increasing scarcity and the fact that it's
- 1:16:03the finite supply and that you know it it, it can then reflect
- 1:16:09growth in GDP is then passed down into the expansion of of
- 1:16:16value of Bitcoin over time, because it has that finite
- 1:16:19supply, then Bitcoin becomes a guaranteed yield.
- 1:16:24It's just a totally different way of thinking about it.
- 1:16:26You're not getting more Bitcoin, but because of increasing
- 1:16:30scarcity and the finite amount of it, it's guaranteed to
- 1:16:33appreciate in value if you if you get there.
- 1:16:36In terms of accepting the logic there, it yields.
- 1:16:39You more goods and services throughout the economy,
- 1:16:41essentially, yeah. And then that ends up replacing
- 1:16:46bonds. It it, it does what what bonds
- 1:16:50were able to do over the last 40 years Bitcoin can do going
- 1:16:55forward indefinitely, and what bonds were able to do over the
- 1:16:58last 40 years. Bonds will not be able to do
- 1:17:01going forward. Fiat bonds be because of the
- 1:17:05they have to be debased in real terms and so that like you you
- 1:17:09could end up taking 90% of that bucket instead of the 30% that I
- 1:17:13assumed one of the. The things that's most
- 1:17:16interesting is what is the cost of capital turn into like for a
- 1:17:20bond for somebody to lock out like a Bitcoin bond.
- 1:17:22Or we talk about equities and it's going to reprice, but it's
- 1:17:25like somebody's going to have to pay a dividend on that because
- 1:17:26you're not just going to lock up your capital when you can just
- 1:17:28hold it because of the purchasing power and the risk
- 1:17:30premium on the equity and the execution of the business.
- 1:17:33That's the most fascinating thing because now you're
- 1:17:34starting thinking about everything in a different
- 1:17:36version, which is like some of us already thinking about that
- 1:17:39world. And then it's like, well, do I
- 1:17:40want to, you know, yeah. And that's where the last trade
- 1:17:43comes in, right? Because until we reach this end
- 1:17:46state, like there's no point in holding anything else if if
- 1:17:51Bitcoin's going to outperform, vastly outperform everything.
- 1:17:54Just as it as it monetizes as it bootstraps from no value to its
- 1:17:58end state value and and only in that end state does does it then
- 1:18:02make sense to like to do what Preston Pitch talks about of
- 1:18:05like value investing on a Bitcoin standard in equities.
- 1:18:09Yeah, well, there's been a. Nuance there too.
- 1:18:11I agree, like everything held static.
- 1:18:13If we were in a vacuum that we were able to adopt Bitcoin
- 1:18:16quickly as you hold it till it fully monetizes and then go do
- 1:18:19that value investing. But.
- 1:18:21In the meantime, companies do need to be formed, products and
- 1:18:24services do need to be brought to market.
- 1:18:26So you're like like weighing the opportunity cost within that
- 1:18:28transition is and they're and they're especially valuable if
- 1:18:31they're generating Bitcoin. Like if there are, if that OP,
- 1:18:34that business is operating on a Bitcoin standard and generating
- 1:18:36Bitcoin then it then it is insulated against that and
- 1:18:40that's the other. Beauty of like Bitcoin is
- 1:18:42everybody always talks about like whether it's an investment
- 1:18:45in the Bitcoin or using their Bitcoin or what we just
- 1:18:48referenced and we got caught in it.
- 1:18:49It's like. It's always assumed the end
- 1:18:52state is $20 million Bitcoin. I hold it, it's there.
- 1:18:56But the reality is life happens in between then and that's where
- 1:18:58like fix, you know, everybody has their time preference and
- 1:19:01what they need and that's what money's utility is for.
- 1:19:03So it's always constantly changing that.
- 1:19:06It's very rare, you know somebody holds from X to Y at
- 1:19:09the end state of it. It's like you have all these
- 1:19:11things happen in the middle and it's always discounted.
- 1:19:13They're like, oh, this is the opportunity cost.
- 1:19:14When we get too far down the rabbit hole, it's like.
- 1:19:16Reality is we probably never see that, or like we see it.
- 1:19:19But the capital's being spent because you have, like that's
- 1:19:21what it's used for. It's not meant to just be
- 1:19:22sitting there like dormant this last.
- 1:19:27This last five minutes of conversation is just so alien to
- 1:19:30everybody and. Everybody that's.
- 1:19:33That's that's invested in the last 40 like or really anyone
- 1:19:37alive. It's like it's gonna go with the
- 1:19:39concept of like. He goes, anybody alive.
- 1:19:42Not even anybody invested, just anybody on the planet Earth.
- 1:19:44Right now it's just. I know.
- 1:19:46Anybody alive that's sitting here, think like listening to
- 1:19:49this and it's like, huh, you can save money and gain purchasing
- 1:19:53power and do what and and do what?
- 1:19:56Like where's the passive investing into the S&P 500?
- 1:20:00Come in like where, where, where is that?
- 1:20:01And it's like we live in this world where the money debases in
- 1:20:04perpetuity. The last 10 years the cost of
- 1:20:06capital has been negative. So the the best bet, the winning
- 1:20:10bet has been. Has literally to plow into a
- 1:20:13basket of the 500 biggest companies at any price, every
- 1:20:17day, regardless of what they're what they do, regardless of what
- 1:20:20the economic conditions look like.
- 1:20:22And you print money and it's like going from that world to a
- 1:20:25world where the money doesn't lose value.
- 1:20:27I mean it's obviously hyper volatile now, but delivers, you
- 1:20:30know, positive, you know, compounding positive returns
- 1:20:33over meaningfully longer time frames.
- 1:20:35But in a world where like the the, it's the unit of account,
- 1:20:38it's the denominator and you can just save money, not, you know,
- 1:20:42not lose your shirt due to inflation.
- 1:20:45And then if you, if you are so inclined, if you are, you know,
- 1:20:49if you have an edge, if you think there's an, you know, an
- 1:20:52opportunity to put capital to work, you conduct economic
- 1:20:56calculation. You invest capital into equity
- 1:21:00or a debt instrument with an expected return.
- 1:21:03And you make that calculation. It's not just like, OK, they're
- 1:21:07going to plow money into bonds and hope the Fed buys them.
- 1:21:09It's like, OK, I'm just going to plow money into SP500 and
- 1:21:12they're going to borrow at a negative cost of capital and buy
- 1:21:14back their stock. Like, we live in this world
- 1:21:16that's so disconnected from reality.
- 1:21:19And so, you know, going back to the transition component, like,
- 1:21:21who knows exactly what it looks like.
- 1:21:23But I think even after like this, this whole thing monetizes
- 1:21:26like after this plays out, there's still people that are
- 1:21:29going to be really confused on the other side of like, OK, but
- 1:21:32now what? And it's like, what do you mean?
- 1:21:33Now what? Like we, we live in a world
- 1:21:35where like like the game still goes on, right?
- 1:21:38Like there's still businesses, right?
- 1:21:40You can still do, just do stuff. Like you just got to do good.
- 1:21:43Productive stuff. Because the opportunity cost of
- 1:21:45losing somebody's Bitcoin is very high.
- 1:21:47You know what? I think on the other side of
- 1:21:49that, they'll have learned along the way.
- 1:21:51I think what we're seeing is a great example of the middle is
- 1:21:54the Gemini Genesis. 3% yield is the problem.
- 1:21:58Is that people are still thinking in that framework and
- 1:22:01that's why we always like anchor.
- 1:22:02And what we're building here is like it's easy to buy the
- 1:22:04Bitcoin. It's hard to hold it long term
- 1:22:06and everybody's just trying to rug you along the way, whether
- 1:22:08it's education, get into this cryptocurrency, get into this
- 1:22:11ETF and Gemini was a great example.
- 1:22:13What is it? A bit close to a billion that's
- 1:22:16just like evaporated because the they had their, you know,
- 1:22:19whatever account, custody account and then they send
- 1:22:21emails. There's like you want your 3%
- 1:22:22yield to financial advisors or individuals and they're like, Oh
- 1:22:25yes, I need to generate passive income on this thing.
- 1:22:27Versus sitting on it. And so I think the rugging's
- 1:22:30along the way. Get on the other side of that as
- 1:22:32it appreciates. It's like, Oh yeah, this is
- 1:22:34like, you know, hopefully at least in a wishful thinking that
- 1:22:37on the other side of that people realize you didn't need, you
- 1:22:40don't have to go chase risk. Yeah, I mean.
- 1:22:44Obviously. It's hard.
- 1:22:46To predict exactly how everybody's going to come to
- 1:22:49that realization, but it's the hard way.
- 1:22:53The. Hard way?
- 1:22:53Yeah, it's. But like, yeah, no, it's.
- 1:22:55I mean, Parker. Put out a piece last night about
- 1:22:58like how people are going to begin accepting Bitcoin as
- 1:23:02payment for their businesses. And I think the way he lays it
- 1:23:05out in that piece is exactly how it's going to happen.
- 1:23:07How people are going to come to realization that the mindset
- 1:23:12from which you operate when you're investing in businesses
- 1:23:15or going to build a company, it can each individual comes to
- 1:23:19that decision or that realization individually on the
- 1:23:23at their own pace and then collectively?
- 1:23:25In mass it, it just happens at some point in the future where
- 1:23:30the realization is just hit a critical mass where that's the
- 1:23:32way things happen and that it yeah, just one man at a time and
- 1:23:38it's very rational line of thinking is essentially what
- 1:23:42Parker said. It's like if we've all come to
- 1:23:44the rational decision that Bitcoin is good money because
- 1:23:47there's only ever going to be 21 million, it's distributed, so it
- 1:23:50can't be corrupted and that is extremely logical.
- 1:23:55And particularly to us and rational to us, like it's just
- 1:23:59going to take time before the rest of the world comes to that
- 1:24:01rationality as well. I have a simpler format than
- 1:24:06that and like I've shared it with you and a lot of people
- 1:24:08will talk about like circular economy and all that.
- 1:24:10I think it's just once somebody's cost basis
- 1:24:12appreciates and we're just so low.
- 1:24:14You know like IEI buy it at 10K and now it's 30 and now I have
- 1:24:17some, you know I have some, there's a gap there and I can
- 1:24:20spend the Bitcoin or it's you know bought in.
- 1:24:22Most people are relatively gotten out of underwater or
- 1:24:25pretty flat so they wouldn't spend it.
- 1:24:27And then the price goes to 6075. Eighty 100K hits a certain
- 1:24:30threshold. People has have the delta
- 1:24:32between their cost basis and then they go and use it as a
- 1:24:35form of money and not a moment before then yeah and.
- 1:24:40What's happening? To create that delta, it's more
- 1:24:44people coming to that rational decision and using Bitcoin, not
- 1:24:49using. It buying, I mean using, I guess
- 1:24:51by the form of holding, yeah. Yeah, using it as a.
- 1:24:53Building is using yeah holding's.
- 1:24:55Using but they're not like out spending Bitcoin and that's
- 1:24:57causing it to cause the price appreciating.
- 1:24:59Like people are buying it. They're buying it as as a
- 1:25:02they're not buying it because they think it's gonna go to 20
- 1:25:04trillion or 20 million per coin. They're buying it because
- 1:25:07letter, Fink said. It's daddy, Daddy, BlackRock
- 1:25:10said to buy it. Daddy BlackRock, you've got a
- 1:25:13lot of good nicknames this show. We gotta come up.
- 1:25:16With a name for these boomers that are coming in.
- 1:25:19Hey. Hey, hey.
- 1:25:20We're not an ageist podcast. We love our boomers.
- 1:25:23There's a lot of boomer listeners out there.
- 1:25:24We love you guys, OK? What do you think about that?
- 1:25:26What do you think about the Boomer BlackRock ETF?
- 1:25:33Should we die? I mean, I cannot wait to read
- 1:25:37the legal language in that filing.
- 1:25:39My God, I don't think The funny thing is the crypto, the crypto
- 1:25:43people were celebrating it all yesterday.
- 1:25:45And the first thing that I just, I just laughed at was, you know,
- 1:25:48when you read the Bitcoin filing and there was all these things
- 1:25:51and that make no sense. You know, they just have to put
- 1:25:53it because like, you know, worst case scenario, it's like in the
- 1:25:55case of a fork, like we had the discretion to choose which side
- 1:25:59and and like and they say all this stuff that's like kind of
- 1:26:01nonsensical and you're like hacking the Bitcoin network.
- 1:26:03Like why would you even put that?
- 1:26:05So when you think through like Proof of stake social slashing
- 1:26:10like a 51% attack on on all this stuff, you're like like and this
- 1:26:13is you know, going back to this is a whole rabbit hole.
- 1:26:16But like the stablecoin issuers and the critical mass of the
- 1:26:19DEFY apps and all this stuff. And in the case of a fork,
- 1:26:21right, Or like a protocol level change, they can basically hold
- 1:26:25the entire network hostage by saying hey, you lose DEFY, you
- 1:26:28lose literally all of your applications if tethered and
- 1:26:31circle leaf, right? So if if you're super bullish
- 1:26:34ETH because they're going to buy like X amount of the network,
- 1:26:38well, you obviously haven't thought of like there's quite
- 1:26:41literal stakeholder decision making value on top of that.
- 1:26:45And that's like, I mean that's just the difference in
- 1:26:47architecture and proof of stake and you know, quote UN quote
- 1:26:49like the consensus layer which is like the social layer for ETH
- 1:26:54versus you know, the Bitcoin network.
- 1:26:56So that's my two cents. I thought it was pretty funny.
- 1:26:59Yeah, any. Any.
- 1:27:01Heath bull that is championing this is completely idiotic.
- 1:27:06I mean they they don't even have to amass 50%.
- 1:27:10I think they have to amass some like 33% to have essentially
- 1:27:14full control over the consensus of the network.
- 1:27:16And if you don't think Blackrock's going to be applying
- 1:27:20some KYC AM L travel rule compliance at the protocol level
- 1:27:24when the governments of the world tell them to like you're
- 1:27:28completely. ETH and BlackRock, they're like
- 1:27:31literally a bad match made in heaven.
- 1:27:34You can even see like, maybe BTC ETH.
- 1:27:37Like in in terms, you know, like kind of ETH is there for a while
- 1:27:41until like BlackRock does whatever BlackRock does.
- 1:27:43And then you're kind of like, oh, I don't own any ETH anymore.
- 1:27:47That's not my ETH. Or like, they change consensus.
- 1:27:50Or whatever they do and you're like looking around and like, oh
- 1:27:52wait. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:27:57People are bullish. It's already there.
- 1:27:59It's like it's like Coinbase crack in Binance like and Lido
- 1:28:03which is again like the governance token is controlled
- 1:28:06by entirely by USVCS like it's already there.
- 1:28:10It's already captured on it like at a protocol level.
- 1:28:13Like Bryan Armstrong scrolled through his retweets, he's
- 1:28:15talking. They're talking about KYC
- 1:28:18implementation natively on the network and wallets like not not
- 1:28:22abstracted to the exchange level but like and they're there.
- 1:28:24I forget they called it some buzzword.
- 1:28:27So it's just like if you can't see where all this is going with
- 1:28:29more coins funneled in to centralized hands.
- 1:28:33And again, like there's a fundamental change between the
- 1:28:35network consensus mechanisms where holding, you know, Michael
- 1:28:39Saylor holding 150,000 Bitcoin doesn't give him any more say
- 1:28:43over that work than anybody else.
- 1:28:44He's running a node, you know, anybody running an economic node
- 1:28:47gets their say, right? So it's just a misunderstanding
- 1:28:51of how things work if you if you are championing, you know, Eat
- 1:28:54Proof of Stake funneling into the hands of you know, 3 or 4
- 1:28:57institutions. Yeah, I'm looking for the the
- 1:29:03Mad Odell thread going back to like 2017 where this is all,
- 1:29:08it's all very tiresome, but bitcoiners have been calling
- 1:29:14this out for here we go, this is from, yeah, December 2017.
- 1:29:20I'll pull this up Logan, but this is all very predictable and
- 1:29:23think when you're dealing with Proof of stake.
- 1:29:27Chains the the consensus mechanism, like he who has the
- 1:29:30coins controls the consensus. And so Bitcoin has been warning
- 1:29:35about this for better part of a decade now, and it's all very
- 1:29:39predictable again. And I think it's important to
- 1:29:43bring it up now because it's likely going to this next bull
- 1:29:47cycle. Bitcoin's not gonna be the only
- 1:29:49cryptocurrency, the pump all these.
- 1:29:51Chick Coins will pump as well and the noise is gonna increase
- 1:29:54significantly. There's gonna be a lot of
- 1:29:56cheerleaders out there saying, look, ETH Solana, they're all
- 1:30:00better than Bitcoin. They're appreciating in value,
- 1:30:03like bitcoins, the Boomer coin. You need to get in on this
- 1:30:06stuff. But at a fundamental level, just
- 1:30:11talking about how these networks actually work, if they're to be
- 1:30:13successful and actually be valuable in the long run, they
- 1:30:16need to be sufficiently distributed.
- 1:30:18And any proof of stake chain has no shot in hell of doing it.
- 1:30:21Like this is all very predictable.
- 1:30:23As soon as the exchanges can stake your coin, they're gonna
- 1:30:27accumulate a mass majority of them collectively, just simply
- 1:30:32because the economies of scale that they can provide the market
- 1:30:36and provide better yield. And people, at the end of the
- 1:30:40day, are not gonna care about decentralization.
- 1:30:42They're gonna care about the yield they're providing, and the
- 1:30:44exchanges can inherently just provide them more yield due to.
- 1:30:48Again, their economies of scale. Yeah.
- 1:30:51This is the this is the the Brian Armstrong 111 last point
- 1:30:55going back to kind of along with with what Marty's point is it's
- 1:30:59a quote retweet. It says compliance, innovation
- 1:31:01coming on chain and he's quote retweeting someone at Coinbase
- 1:31:05saying tokenization requires all applications have a KYC
- 1:31:09attestation process. The KYC process today is
- 1:31:11archaic, like the like the system it was built on.
- 1:31:14But this is changing KYC, digital ID, attestation status,
- 1:31:18It's all coming to the wallet. You know, compliance, innovation
- 1:31:22is what it's called. Yeah, I mean, writing's on the
- 1:31:26wall here guys. But you know, I digress.
- 1:31:30Yeah, that's one way to offer unlicensed securities is make
- 1:31:33sure you're capturing KYC AM L when you're doing it.
- 1:31:38Yeah, that boy that's going to be.
- 1:31:42It's going to be ugly for. We'll see what carnage happens
- 1:31:46in the next cycle and beyond. Marty you you said one word that
- 1:31:51that I I I'm realizing we it brought up memories of when I
- 1:31:58was getting into Bitcoin and in the word of shit coins and I and
- 1:32:03I I think that I probably dismissed Bitcoin, the Bitcoin
- 1:32:09community as a serious group. For slightly longer than I
- 1:32:14otherwise would have because bitcoiners were constantly
- 1:32:18saying shit coins and like just off hand dismissing these these
- 1:32:24other projects which you know now I I totally get.
- 1:32:27I totally agree with, but I feel like it it slightly does us a
- 1:32:32disservice. Not not to like, just don't
- 1:32:36browbeat me. On air I'm, I'm.
- 1:32:38Slightly. I'm just like pontificating
- 1:32:40about like. Thinking about how what would
- 1:32:44have helped me get into Bitcoin sooner and and you know I I
- 1:32:51think it all stems from like coming from a yuppie background
- 1:32:54and like people don't speak disparagingly of their
- 1:32:57competitors in in in the non crypto world and.
- 1:33:04I feel like that's a it's like a a a funny thing that I don't
- 1:33:08know what the answer is to it. Like is it just to to just ram
- 1:33:11it down everybody's throats and and until until Bitcoin has
- 1:33:16proven that all these other coins are shit coins or do we
- 1:33:19try to meet people in the middle.
- 1:33:21I I don't know. That's just sort of I I get.
- 1:33:23What you're saying I I agree to a certain extent and I for the
- 1:33:26longest time, even myself, it was rare for me to say shit coin
- 1:33:30still is to this day. I just.
- 1:33:32And Haste said it because I was trying to think of it.
- 1:33:35I do. 'Cause it's true, I usually say
- 1:33:37all. Coins cause yeah, I tried to.
- 1:33:40As well all coins. All coins was the predominant
- 1:33:43nomenclature up until like 20/13/2014 and then shit coins
- 1:33:46took over. Well, since we're kind of airing
- 1:33:50out our our our grievances with how we're going to our
- 1:33:55nomenclature, the one that I'll, I'd probably shock everybody is
- 1:33:58like, I kind of feel like we have to figure out a new way to
- 1:34:01reference ourselves and not be bitcoiners because like, it
- 1:34:05feels very colty. It's like we're just like, you
- 1:34:08know, we're just guys we're we're, you know, it's like the
- 1:34:11bitcoiners. It's like there's going to be
- 1:34:13this chasm we got to cross where we're even like.
- 1:34:15It's even things like orange Pilling.
- 1:34:17I was at we they had a noster event in Nashville and it was a
- 1:34:20great event and everybody there credible people.
- 1:34:22But I was like cringing throughout because many people
- 1:34:25were like, yeah, orange pilled this person.
- 1:34:26Then I purple pilled this person.
- 1:34:28I was like, this is not like how, Yeah, you don't want to be.
- 1:34:30Handing out pills to to you. Know well.
- 1:34:33Heeled professional investors. The people don't want that.
- 1:34:38We'll have a. Strategy call we'll come up with
- 1:34:39wait there's there's there's terms that will will for the
- 1:34:42pill, for the pill. There'll be a term for the
- 1:34:44individual that is recognizing a better form of money.
- 1:34:47There'll be a term and will help incept in the in the market.
- 1:34:50Yeah, I I. Just got lost in my own thinking
- 1:34:53of like of. I was appreciating how effective
- 1:34:57that is for conveying to individuals like like shit coins
- 1:35:01and an orange Pilling like those are very effective like.
- 1:35:05Micro metaphors. You know just.
- 1:35:07It conveys all the rich imagery that you need to know in a
- 1:35:10single word. But you know, when thinking
- 1:35:15about the adoption curve for institutions or or the
- 1:35:17mainstream in general, like are nomenclatures going to have to
- 1:35:22evolve in some way? It's hard though, because
- 1:35:25they're all dog shit, but you just.
- 1:35:29Yeah, let me just. I don't know.
- 1:35:32I have no answers like. I hate like.
- 1:35:34Another one I hate. I never refer to myself as a
- 1:35:36Bitcoin maxi. When I do, I'm like some people
- 1:35:39would refer to me as a Bitcoin maxi.
- 1:35:41I hate that term started by Vitalic.
- 1:35:43By the way, I I. Embrace that one.
- 1:35:45Why do you hate that one? Oh, that one.
- 1:35:47I. Won't even.
- 1:35:47I will never utter That one's the worst.
- 1:35:50I. I embrace I'm a Bitcoin
- 1:35:51maximalist like I I, I, I. So Vitalic tried to put that on
- 1:35:57us right as as like a slur. And I think it is a.
- 1:36:02I don't know. I I like it because I think I
- 1:36:05want to maxim maximize, maximize my Bitcoin exposure because then
- 1:36:11it gets. Then it gets like they call you
- 1:36:13a maxi. Just like I'm just a dude who
- 1:36:15likes Bitcoin and wants sound, money and freedom in the world.
- 1:36:19I'm a I'm a Bitcoin supremacist. Yeah, there is no second best.
- 1:36:29Yeah, there's there's your subtitle for this for this
- 1:36:33episode right there, Logan. A white Bitcoin Supremacist?
- 1:36:39Oh boy. I know he joked with this stuff,
- 1:36:42but I do think it is important because I think to Jesse's core
- 1:36:45point, it like hindered. His full full adoption or like
- 1:36:49in your and there's these things that you hear and you're like, I
- 1:36:52don't want to be a Bitcoiner. Like I just a dude.
- 1:36:54Like I don't want to be a. Yeah, that's and that's the way
- 1:36:57I am. Like, even when people call me a
- 1:36:59Bitcoin, I'm like, I'm just a dude who likes sound money and I
- 1:37:02think Bitcoin's the best sound money.
- 1:37:04I want freedom. You know, I hate, I've always
- 1:37:07hated labels. When people like, try to call me
- 1:37:09right wing, left wing, liberal, conservative, I'm like, stop.
- 1:37:12I'm a dude with my own thoughts. I like Bitcoin.
- 1:37:16It's it's tough because at the end of the day what we like is,
- 1:37:18is money that retains its value. So, like, what's the term for
- 1:37:22that rational? Human being, right?
- 1:37:29Bitcoin rationalist? Yeah.
- 1:37:35Sorry, Marty, that was a total. Tangent.
- 1:37:36I didn't. I didn't mean to go there, but I
- 1:37:38I just was lost in thought of like, huh, Jesse?
- 1:37:41Jesse, you have nothing to apologize for.
- 1:37:43Actually think that was productive.
- 1:37:45A little tangent there, 'cause it is important.
- 1:37:47Language is important. Thank you.
- 1:37:52Was it? Yeah, I was just thinking, yeah,
- 1:37:55well. Maybe, maybe I'll, I'll take the
- 1:37:58the lull to say that again if people are interested in in the
- 1:38:04full potential valuation piece, I think it a big part of why we
- 1:38:09put this together is so that for for bitcoiners or or for for.
- 1:38:14Rationalists. Rationalists out there who
- 1:38:18understand the value of Bitcoin in their portfolio in
- 1:38:21particular, and want to have something to give to the people
- 1:38:25in their life, friends, family, colleagues, to help make the
- 1:38:30scale of what this thing is relevant, salient,
- 1:38:36understandable. This is a great piece of
- 1:38:38collateral to be able to hand off to to the folks so.
- 1:38:43Check it out, at least for that. Also, if people are enjoying
- 1:38:48Dylan's analysis, and I always do, he writes every week for the
- 1:38:54The On Ramp Weekly roundup, putting out all of his market
- 1:38:58analysis thoughts for that week. And if you want to get that in
- 1:39:02your inbox as the the download of what you should be paying
- 1:39:05attention to this week because you're not necessarily what
- 1:39:11would happen. Did it?
- 1:39:12Did I freeze again? Yeah, you try this again.
- 1:39:15It was in the middle of the pit. Yeah, well go go check out the
- 1:39:20On the On Ramp website, go to research and insights, sign up,
- 1:39:24get your name on the the mailing list for for Dylan's weekly
- 1:39:28roundup. And we also put out a a piece
- 1:39:30every weekend that's just general Bitcoin education or?
- 1:39:35Truth from the commoner It doesn't benefit on ramp, but.
- 1:39:38Marty's new website, Awesome Thumbnails.
- 1:39:41I was chatting with Jesse yesterday.
- 1:39:43I was like, I don't know how you're doing or if you're
- 1:39:44purposely pulling it, but if you had the nice Dylan's piece this
- 1:39:47past week on the thumbnail, had the nice on ramp terminal chart,
- 1:39:51yeah. Very good for.
- 1:39:52Social sharing that I like to think it.
- 1:39:54Does help on that exposure? It's.
- 1:39:56Oh, it does. But I just meant like, go sign
- 1:39:58up for Truth for the commoner. There's a lot of good
- 1:40:00information coming TFTC. Dot IO, yeah, become a member of
- 1:40:05all sites. We're gonna win, gentlemen.
- 1:40:07And bringing it back to the valuation framework, the webinar
- 1:40:12you guys have coming up and using this as an asset to pass
- 1:40:16along, I think it's extremely valuable because historically
- 1:40:20still to this day people see the price of Bitcoin.
- 1:40:23So you go up to 65,000, fall down to 15,000 and they just see
- 1:40:27these numbers on the chart that are extremely volatile
- 1:40:31throughout the 1st 15 years of Bitcoin's existence.
- 1:40:35Or like what is this thing worth?
- 1:40:36Why is it going up like this? Is it just some some price chart
- 1:40:41that goes crazy and the numbers get higher and then fall fall
- 1:40:44lower? Like why is it doing that?
- 1:40:46Like to have a framework from which to explain like This is
- 1:40:50why this is happening. Here's the potential addressable
- 1:40:53market of this asset and why you're seeing these volatile
- 1:40:57spikes and crashes in price over the 1st 15 years.
- 1:41:00Because it's people trying to appropriately price this asset
- 1:41:05in real time. The first time humanity's priced
- 1:41:09A monetary asset in the digital age globally.
- 1:41:12At the same time that's driving the volatility.
- 1:41:15You may see these price movements on a chart and think,
- 1:41:18what the hell, it's not worth anything.
- 1:41:20I think this piece does a really good job of laying out the
- 1:41:26landscape of the potential addressable market of Bitcoin
- 1:41:29and why the price is moving this way.
- 1:41:32Yeah, so if you're if. You're rationalist if you're.
- 1:41:35Rationalist out there and have other rationalists.
- 1:41:37You want to understand Bitcoin over Thanksgiving.
- 1:41:40I think the date is 12 the December 1st that the webinar.
- 1:41:43Will occur with Jesse and our Head of Strategy and Research,
- 1:41:46Brian Cabela's and then a special guest TBD when that'll
- 1:41:50be announced. Yeah, Specialist, could be you,
- 1:41:52Marty, could be you. You don't want me on that call.
- 1:41:56Yeah, I'll be like this. This is too bearish. 10 mil.
- 1:42:00It's gonna be 100 at least. What was I gonna say?
- 1:42:04It's something else to say for oh, gentlemen, I don't wanna, I
- 1:42:10don't wanna like pick the pico top here and cause cause a big
- 1:42:15price dump. But this could be like the best
- 1:42:16Thanksgiving we've had in a few years, you know?
- 1:42:19Yeah. True.
- 1:42:20We're gonna be, we're gonna be the Kings at the table.
- 1:42:25Maybe that's the last part. Is Are we at 40K by Thanksgiving
- 1:42:3137252 right now? I'll.
- 1:42:36Say this is. Where?
- 1:42:37I I just have disbelief like and and I'm glad that I'm I'm, I'm
- 1:42:42not on the sidelines like I was in 2019 when I thought I was
- 1:42:46going to be clever and buy lower because then I was forced to buy
- 1:42:50in like when this was happening. And for anyone out there who's
- 1:42:53in that same position. It feels a lot better when you
- 1:42:56finally get back in. So that's my two cents, I I fall
- 1:43:01for the disbelief even now of like, I simultaneously believe
- 1:43:05that we're going to $10 million per Bitcoin in the next couple
- 1:43:09decades in today's dollars. And yet, I have trouble
- 1:43:13believing we'll be at 40,000 at Thanksgiving.
- 1:43:18It's very. Pragmatic.
- 1:43:20Very. Oh, you never know.
- 1:43:22You never know. Who knows?
- 1:43:25We'll see. I mean, we've got, I think 7
- 1:43:28more days. Six more days figure out if that
- 1:43:31omnibus approval of the ETFs comes out.
- 1:43:34If that happens, we could be at like 50K by Thanksgiving.
- 1:43:38I think we could have like another 10K candle, weekly
- 1:43:43candle. One thing's for sure, it'll be.
- 1:43:50Bitcoin rationalist will have a much better time at Thanksgiving
- 1:43:52dinner than they've had the last two years.
- 1:43:55Yeah, all the father in laws looking at their looking at the
- 1:44:00rationalist being like, who did my wife marry and be like?
- 1:44:03Yeah, this year you're gonna be like she married a good one.
- 1:44:06Don't worry Sir. I'm gonna take care of your
- 1:44:07daughter. OK?
- 1:44:12Dylan, do you have anything you want to wrap up with?
- 1:44:17No, I I mean. Yeah, I'd do the weekly letter
- 1:44:21with these guys. Good cadence.
- 1:44:25I mean it was it was a fun rip. Don't really have too much else
- 1:44:27to add. Don't have any short term price
- 1:44:29predictions. I've learned to kind of I've
- 1:44:32learned over the years to kind of just yeah, it's not it's kind
- 1:44:35of irrelevant. So yeah, held a rip.
- 1:44:38Appreciate you having me on. As always.
- 1:44:39That's good. So let's find a background with
- 1:44:42less gold next time, OK? We'll.
- 1:44:45Work on it, I kid. OK, gentlemen, it's a pleasure
- 1:44:51as always. Dylan most most tenured guest on
- 1:44:56this show, almost becoming the 4th, 4th host.
- 1:45:00Mitch is gonna want to come back on he He hit me up the last time
- 1:45:03after his third episode. He's like, am I the tide with
- 1:45:05Dylan for the most like? Not anymore, Mitch.
- 1:45:09You gotta get a good mic too, if you're listening.
- 1:45:13Yeah, let's go. Go forth.
- 1:45:17Be rational. Enjoy your weekend.
- 1:45:20That's all we got today.