Latest / SWOP Behind Bars Advocacy from the Margins / The Cornell Seven: Now We Know Why Women Don't Report Rape
Transcript
- 0:00The Cornell 7. Now we know why women don't report rape.
- 0:04A swap behind bars weekend hot
- 0:06take. For decades, we have asked the same question after sexual violence.
- 0:12Why didn't she report it? Why didn't she call the police immediately?
- 0:16Why did she wait three weeks?
- 0:18Why did she keep talking to him?
- 0:20Why did she say something different the next morning?
- 0:23Why didn't she call it rape right away? Why didn't she sound traumatized enough?
- 0:29Why didn't she remember everything? The unfolding case of the Cornell 7 suggests
- 0:34that perhaps we have been asking the wrong question.
- 0:37Maybe the better question is, what happens when she does report?
- 0:42Because Jane Doe did. And now we know why so many women don't.
- 0:46She went to the police. The allegations are horrific and remain under litigation and reinvestigation.
- 0:54Jane Doe alleges that in October 2024, when she was a 20-year-old Cornell student,
- 1:00she was drugged and sexually assaulted by members of the Chi-Fi fraternity.
- 1:05Her civil lawsuit named seven former fraternity members.
- 1:09Some of the accused have denied wrongdoing. But one fact is particularly important for this conversation.
- 1:15She reported what happened to police. About three weeks later,
- 1:20after she says she was emotionally ready, Jane Doe went to Cornell University police.
- 1:26According to recently reported records, her interviews took place over two days.
- 1:31In the transcript of those interviews,
- 1:33she reportedly said, I can say with 100% confidence I was raped.
- 1:39She also described herself as extraordinarily intoxicated and unable to make
- 1:44decisions. And then something remarkable happened.
- 1:48The district attorney who initially decided not to prosecute the case says he
- 1:53never saw that transcript.
- 1:55Instead, his office received a six-page sworn statement prepared from the interviews.
- 2:01He says the statement did not contain that unequivocal declaration that she
- 2:06had been raped. Think about that.
- 2:08A woman went to police. She sat through interviews. She described what happened.
- 2:14She explicitly said she had been raped.
- 2:17And the prosecutor responsible for deciding whether the case warranted criminal
- 2:21prosecution says he never saw the transcript containing those words.
- 2:26If we want to have a serious national conversation about why rape survivors
- 2:30hesitate to report to law enforcement, start there.
- 2:34Not with another lecture about why women should trust police,
- 2:38but with the more honest question.
- 2:40Why would any woman trust a system that has already shown it may not accurately
- 2:45carry her story forward?
- 2:47Is rape a crime? This is where I want to give a very specific shout-out to Michelle
- 2:52Baudler and her extraordinary book, Is Rape a Crime?
- 2:57A Memoir, An Investigation, and a Manifesto.
- 3:00Baudler wasn't asking whether rape appears somewhere in a criminal code. Of course it does.
- 3:06She was asking a much more uncomfortable question.
- 3:10Does the American criminal legal system actually behave as though rape is a serious crime?
- 3:16Baudelaire was raped in her Boston apartment in 1984.
- 3:20She underwent a rape kit. She spoke with police.
- 3:24And then she essentially never heard from them again.
- 3:27Decades later, she went looking for answers about what happened to her case
- 3:32and, in the process, investigated the broader institutional treatment of rape survivors.
- 3:38Her book examines cases closed before meaningful investigation,
- 3:42untested rape kits, and survivors who discover that reporting a crime does not
- 3:47necessarily mean anyone will seriously investigate it.
- 3:51The Cornell case feels like an awful contemporary footnote to Baudler's title.
- 3:56Is rape a crime? Legally, yes. Institutionally?
- 4:01That question suddenly doesn't sound rhetorical. And if police cannot be trusted
- 4:06to preserve a survivor's words accurately, completely, and honestly,
- 4:10then they cannot expect survivors to trust them with their safety.
- 4:14We tell women to report.
- 4:16Then we put them on trial. There is another reason this case matters.
- 4:21Survivors are routinely expected to behave according to a script written by
- 4:26people who have never experienced trauma.
- 4:29A credible survivor is supposed to immediately recognize what happened,
- 4:33immediately leave, immediately report, remember everything in chronological
- 4:38order, never communicate with the accused again,
- 4:42and describe the event exactly the same way every time.
- 4:46Human beings don't work that way. Trauma certainly doesn't.
- 4:50Reporting about the Cornell case shows exactly the kind of complexity that so
- 4:54often becomes ammunition against survivors.
- 4:58Jane Doe reportedly had memory gaps. She initially used language that appeared
- 5:03to minimize some of what happened.
- 5:05She communicated with people involved afterward.
- 5:08At other points, she described coercion, incapacitation, and unequivocally stated
- 5:14that she had been raped. Those facts don't tell us what a jury should ultimately
- 5:18decide about the seven accused men.
- 5:21Due process still matters. Evidence matters. The defendants are entitled to
- 5:26contest the allegations.
- 5:29But investigating is what allows evidence to be tested.
- 5:32A survivor shouldn't have to arrive at a police station already functioning
- 5:37as her own detective, prosecutor, trauma expert, and appellate lawyer simply
- 5:42to convince the system that something worth investigating may have happened.
- 5:47She also shouldn't have to wonder whether the officers taking her statement
- 5:50will accurately record it.
- 5:52Whether the report will reflect what she actually said, or whether the prosecutor
- 5:57will ever see the full account.
- 5:59The internet version of this story has sometimes been simplified to,
- 6:03seven men were accused of gang rape, and Cornell made them write essays.
- 6:08That isn't accurate. Cornell says there was a range of disciplinary outcomes.
- 6:13University officials have said two accused students were expelled,
- 6:17two were suspended for at least two semesters, one had graduated before punishment
- 6:23could be imposed, and two were found not responsible for sexual misconduct.
- 6:28Some lesser sanctions, including workshops or writing assignments,
- 6:32were reportedly imposed for other conduct.
- 6:35The fraternity chapter itself was closed and barred from campus.
- 6:38That distinction matters.
- 6:41We don't need to exaggerate this story.
- 6:43The verified facts are troubling enough.
- 6:46Cornell's internal process reportedly involved dozens of interviews.
- 6:51Yet the criminal prosecutor who initially declined the case says he never received
- 6:56the complete transcript of Jane Doe's police interviews.
- 6:59He did not personally interview her before deciding against prosecution.
- 7:04That should concern people across the ideological spectrum.
- 7:08It should also concern anyone who has ever been told that police are the people
- 7:12to call when they are in danger.
- 7:14Because safety depends on trust, and trust depends on honesty.
- 7:19Why didn't she go to the police? At Swap Behind Bars, this question has particular resonance.
- 7:26Sex workers hear it constantly.
- 7:29When a sex worker is raped, robbed, beaten, stalked, or threatened,
- 7:33someone inevitably asks, why didn't she call the police?
- 7:37Sometimes the answer is obvious. She fears arrest. She fears being outed.
- 7:43She fears losing housing or custody of her children.
- 7:46She fears immigration consequences. She fears that police will see the word
- 7:51prostitute and stop seeing the word victim.
- 7:54She may also know that police are not neutral observers.
- 7:58They have the power to arrest her, search her, expose her, threaten her,
- 8:03disbelieve her, or use her own words against her.
- 8:07But the Cornell case exposes something larger.
- 8:10Jane Doe wasn't asking police to understand the complexities of criminalized sex work.
- 8:16She was a Cornell student reporting an alleged sexual assault involving other Cornell students.
- 8:22And look at what followed. So imagine walking into that same system carrying a prostitution record.
- 8:29Imagine being transgender. Imagine having drugs in your purse.
- 8:33Imagine being undocumented. Imagine having warrants.
- 8:38Imagine knowing that the person who raped you is a client and that explaining
- 8:42how you met him requires admitting that you committed a crime.
- 8:46Imagine knowing that the officers taking your statement may not record it accurately
- 8:51and that the prosecutor may rely on a shortened version rather than hearing
- 8:55your actual words. Then ask again, why didn't she report?
- 9:00The more honest answer may be, because police are not honest enough to share
- 9:05our stories with, and we cannot safely trust them with our safety.
- 9:09This is the distinction we don't talk about enough.
- 9:12Reporting is not the same as being heard.
- 9:16We measure whether survivors report
- 9:18violence. We should also measure what institutions do with those reports.
- 9:23Was the survivor interviewed by someone trained in sexual violence and trauma?
- 9:27Was evidence collected? Were witnesses interviewed? Were digital records preserved?
- 9:33Was the complete investigative file actually provided to prosecutors?
- 9:38Did prosecutors speak with the survivor?
- 9:40Was the case investigated before someone decided it wasn't prosecutable?
- 9:45Was the survivor's account recorded accurately? Did anyone alter,
- 9:49summarize, or omit the words that mattered most?
- 9:53And when something went wrong, was anyone accountable? Those questions move
- 9:57responsibility away from scrutinizing the survivor and toward examining the
- 10:02institutions whose job it was to respond.
- 10:06That is precisely where it belongs. A woman should not have to trust police
- 10:11simply because society has failed to build safer alternatives.
- 10:15And she should not be blamed when she recognizes that the people claiming to
- 10:19protect her may also be the people most capable of harming, exposing, or abandoning her.
- 10:26Now we know why. The criminal investigation into the Cornell allegations has
- 10:31now been revived, and New York Governor Kathy Hochul has taken the extraordinary
- 10:36step of removing the matter from the local district attorney
- 10:40and assigning Attorney General Letitia James as special prosecutor.
- 10:44Cornell has also agreed to an independent review of its handling of the case.
- 10:49We don't know what that investigation will ultimately conclude about the seven
- 10:53accused men, and we shouldn't pretend that we do.
- 10:56But we already know something important about the system surrounding the case.
- 11:01A young woman went to police. She talked. She tried to explain what happened.
- 11:07And nearly two years later, America is discovering that some of the most consequential
- 11:12words she reportedly said during that police interview apparently never reached
- 11:16the prosecutor who decided there wasn't a case to prosecute.
- 11:20So the next time someone asks why she didn't report, remember Michelle Baudler.
- 11:26Remember the rape kits gathering dust.
- 11:29Remember survivors whose cases were closed before they understood what had happened.
- 11:34Remember sex workers who know that reporting violence can expose them to an
- 11:38entirely different set of dangers.
- 11:41Remember that police are not automatically safe simply because they wear uniforms.
- 11:46Remember that a survivor's story is not protected merely because she tells it
- 11:51inside a police station.
- 11:52And remember the woman at the center of the Cornell 7 case.
- 11:56Because sometimes women don't report rape because they are afraid nobody will believe them.
- 12:02Sometimes they don't report because they are afraid of what the system will do to them.
- 12:07Sometimes they don't report because they know that police may not be honest
- 12:11enough to preserve their stories.
- 12:13Sometimes they don't report because they cannot safely trust police with their
- 12:17safety. And sometimes they do report.
- 12:20The system simply doesn't listen.
- 12:23Or it listens selectively.
- 12:25Or it rewrites what it heard. Now we know why.