Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / How Marketplaces Use Cross-Selling to Raise Take Rate
Transcript
- Lucas: So, Luna, we've spent a lot of episodes on how marketplaces protect their take rate—preventing disintermediation, minimum orders, that sort of thing. But there's a quieter lever that a lot of platforms use to grow revenue without ever raising the commission. It's cross-selling. Luna: Cross-selling in a marketplace? I mean, Amazon's 'buy it with' is the classic, but for a two-sided network, it feels trickier. You can't just toss a toaster in the cart. Lucas: Right, because you're not selling products, you're connecting buyers and sellers. But think about Fiverr—you go on to buy a logo, and suddenly they're showing you social media kit design, business card templates, even a full brand guide. That's cross-selling services on the supply side. Luna: So they're basically saying, 'you came for a logo, but you probably need the whole package.' And each of those add-ons is another transaction Fiverr takes a cut from. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the core idea: cross-selling in a marketplace means increasing the number of transactions per user, not the take rate per transaction. It's a volume play. And it works because the marginal cost of showing a recommendation is basically zero, while the incremental revenue can be significant. Luna: But isn't there a risk of annoying the user? I mean, I've been on sites where every click is like, 'you might also like...' and it just feels spammy. Lucas: There's definitely a line. But the best marketplaces use data to make cross-sells genuinely useful. They look at what similar buyers have purchased, what the seller's other offers are, and what the user's context is—like if they're a small business owner who just bought a logo, they probably need a website next. Luna: So it's about relevance. And that brings in the whole data moat angle. The more transactions you have, the better your recommendations get, which drives more transactions. It's a flywheel. Lucas: That's exactly the loop. And it's why marketplaces like Fiverr or even Uber Eats are so focused on cross-selling. Think about Uber Eats—you order a burger, and they suggest drinks, dessert, maybe even a meal deal from the same restaurant. That's cross-selling, and it directly boosts their take rate because each add-on is another transaction. Luna: And it's not just about the immediate sale. It's about deepening the user's relationship with the platform. If I can get everything I need in one place, I'm less likely to go elsewhere. Lucas: Exactly. And that's where the take rate effect gets interesting. A higher take rate usually means you're capturing more value per transaction. But cross-selling can actually allow you to keep your take rate stable—or even lower it—while growing overall revenue, because you're doing more transactions. Luna: So it's a subtle strategy. I'm curious about the numbers. Do we have any sense of how much cross-selling actually moves the needle for a marketplace like Fiverr? Lucas: Well, Fiverr's public filings show that they've been growing revenue per buyer consistently. A few years back, they reported that existing buyers were spending more over time, and that's partly because they're buying more categories. They've also introduced Fiverr Business, which encourages teams to use the platform for multiple services. That's a deliberate cross-sell strategy. Luna: And it's not just Fiverr. I think of Airbnb—they've been pushing experiences, which is a cross-sell from just booking a room. Lucas: Right, though experiences are a whole separate vertical. But the principle is the same: getting a user who's already booked a stay to book a cooking class or a tour. That's another transaction, another take rate. Luna: But here's the thing: cross-selling only works if the supply side can deliver. On Fiverr, if I buy a logo and then a website, I need different sellers, right? They have to have the inventory. Lucas: That's true. And that's where liquidity comes in. If you have a deep pool of sellers in adjacent categories, you can cross-sell effectively. If not, you risk offering something that's not available, and that's a bad experience. Luna: So it's not just a demand-side trick. It depends on the supply side being diversified. That's a two-sided problem. Lucas: Right, and that's why some marketplaces are better positioned for cross-selling than others. Take a horizontal marketplace like Amazon, where the inventory is massive, and cross-sell is easy. But a vertical like StockX, which we talked about earlier, is all about sneakers and streetwear—there's not much to cross-sell beyond maybe accessories or cleaning products. Luna: So the cross-sell opportunity really depends on the adjacency of the categories. And that's something operators have to think about early on. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's why you see marketplaces expanding their categories over time. Fiverr started with gigs like 'I will design a logo' and now they have everything from translation to programming. Each new category is a cross-sell opportunity for existing buyers. Luna: But wait—doesn't expanding categories dilute the brand? I mean, if I think of Fiverr as the place for quick, cheap gigs, do I trust them with a complex programming project? Lucas: That's a real risk. But they've managed it by tiering their offerings—you have Fiverr Pro for higher-end services, and they're careful about quality. Plus, the data helps: if a buyer has purchased multiple graphic design gigs, recommending a programming gig might not be relevant. But if they've bought a WordPress fix, then a full site build makes sense. Luna: So it's all about the data. Which brings me to the point: the best cross-selling is invisible. It just feels like the platform understands you. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the goal. Now, there's a whole set of tactics that marketplaces use to make cross-sell work. Let's talk about a few. First, there's the 'bundle' approach, where you package services together—like a logo plus a business card design for a discounted price. That's a direct way to increase average order value. Luna: And that's similar to what we covered in the Fiverr episode about service bundles. But we're looking at it from the cross-sell angle now, which is more about suggesting those bundles at the right moment. Lucas: Right. And then there's the 'post-purchase' cross-sell. After you buy a logo, Fiverr might send you an email saying, 'Hey, you bought a logo, here's a designer who can make a matching social media kit.' That's a low-pressure way to cross-sell. Luna: I've seen that. It feels like a helpful nudge rather than a pushy upsell. And it works because it's timely. Lucas: Another tactic is the 'seller-led' cross-sell. On Upwork, a freelancer might offer a package that includes both writing and SEO optimization. The seller is essentially cross-selling their own adjacent services. That raises the take rate for the marketplace because it's a larger contract. Luna: So it's not just the platform recommending things; the supply side can also drive cross-sell. That's interesting because it aligns incentives—the seller makes more, and the platform takes a cut. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why you see marketplaces encouraging sellers to expand their service offerings. It's a win-win. But there's a catch: if a seller becomes too broad, they might lose focus, and quality could suffer. So the marketplace has to manage that balance. Luna: Let's talk about the economics. How does cross-selling actually impact the take rate? Is it just about volume, or does it also affect the commission structure? Lucas: In most cases, the take rate stays the same percentage, but because you're doing more transactions, the absolute revenue increases. For example, if a marketplace has a 20 percent take rate, and a buyer who used to spend one hundred dollars a year now spends one hundred and fifty because of cross-sell, the platform's revenue from that buyer goes up by ten dollars without any change in the take rate. Luna: So it's a direct lift to revenue per user, which is a key metric. And that's why cross-selling is such a popular growth lever. Lucas: But there's another angle: cross-selling can actually reduce the cost of acquisition. If you can cross-sell to an existing buyer, you don't have to spend money on marketing to acquire a new one. So it improves the overall economics of the marketplace. Luna: But wait, is there a downside? Could cross-selling cannibalize the core service? Like, if I bundle a logo with a website, maybe I end up paying less than if I bought them separately. Lucas: That's possible. But the goal is to increase the total spend, not to discount the core. And if the bundle is priced right, the buyer feels they're getting value, and the platform still earns more because they're capturing two transactions instead of one. Luna: So it's about expanding the pie, not just slicing it differently. And that's a healthy way to grow a marketplace. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why we're seeing more marketplaces invest in cross-sell features. For example, Etsy has been pushing 'shop the look' and personalized recommendations, which are basically cross-sell tools. And they've seen increases in average order value. Luna: I've also noticed that some marketplaces are using cross-selling to move into new verticals. Like, a ride-hailing app might start offering food delivery, and they can cross-sell by giving you a promo for a restaurant after a ride. Lucas: That's a classic strategy. Uber is famous for that—they used their driver network to launch Uber Eats, and then they cross-sold by showing food options when you were in the car. It's a way to leverage existing liquidity in one side to build a new marketplace. Luna: But that's a big bet. It's not just a recommendation; it's a whole new business line. But the cross-sell logic is the same: get the user to do more transactions on the platform. Lucas: Right. And that brings us to a key insight: cross-selling isn't just a tactic, it's a growth strategy. Marketplaces that master it can compound their growth because each new category or service adds more cross-sell opportunities for the existing user base. Luna: So what's the takeaway for our listeners who are building or running a marketplace? How should they think about cross-selling? Lucas: First, start with the data. Look at what your users are already buying and identify natural adjacencies. Second, make sure you have supply in those adjacent categories, or you'll disappoint. Third, test cross-sell recommendations gradually, measure the impact on revenue and user satisfaction, and iterate. Luna: And don't forget the balance. It's easy to overdo it and turn users off. The best cross-sell feels like a helpful suggestion, not a hard sell. Lucas: Exactly. I mean, if today's conversation gave you a useful lens on cross-selling, the way we keep this show ad-free is through listener support. If you're finding value in what we're doing here, consider buying me a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It really helps us keep going. Luna: Yeah, and it's a small gesture that goes a long way. We appreciate the listeners who do. Lucas: So, to wrap up, cross-selling is a powerful lever for marketplaces to increase revenue without raising take rates. It's all about deepening the relationship with your users by offering them more of what they need, when they need it. And with the right data and supply, it can be a game-changer. Luna: And it's something every marketplace operator should have on their roadmap. Thanks for listening, and we'll catch you next time.