Latest / Serial Killer Documentary Show / The Diary of Martha Moxley
Transcript
- 0:10Speaker 1: Yeah, you mentioned you grew up in Grantwich and you
- 0:12Speaker 1: were there in seventy five. The first thing people ask
- 0:15Speaker 1: you is, did you know Martha Moxley?
- 0:22Speaker 2: Bell Haven, Connecticut is a small private community. It has
- 0:25Speaker 2: big estates and almost no crime, but a fifteen year
- 0:30Speaker 2: old girl has been brutally murdered there bell Haven.
- 0:34Speaker 3: This was a virtually exclusive, very wealthy community in Greenwich, Connecticut,
- 0:41Speaker 3: where murders just don't occur.
- 0:46Speaker 1: My name's Richard Burns, and I lived in Greenwich back then.
- 0:51Speaker 1: That's the first time in forty five years we'd ever
- 0:52Speaker 1: talked about it.
- 0:53Speaker 4: My name is Torri Holland. I grew up in Belle
- 0:55Speaker 4: Haven and in nineteen seventy five, I was fifteen along
- 0:59Speaker 4: with Martha. She just had this beaming personality and her
- 1:05Speaker 4: beautiful blonde hair smiled all the time.
- 1:09Speaker 1: I just smiled, you know. It just made you feel
- 1:11Speaker 1: like you were the center of the world.
- 1:16Speaker 5: The SCA girls lived across the street from the Moxleys.
- 1:20Speaker 4: They were a family of all these boys except for Julie.
- 1:25Speaker 1: I went to school with them, and Michael was a
- 1:28Speaker 1: year behind me, and Tommy this year ahead of me.
- 1:32Speaker 4: It was a lovely place to grow up. You just
- 1:34Speaker 4: felt safe, and that all changed after that night.
- 1:41Speaker 6: The instrument used in the striking of the Moxley girl
- 1:46Speaker 6: it was a golf club.
- 1:47Speaker 4: We know that. It's absolutely devastating.
- 1:53Speaker 7: Nearly a quarter of a century would pass before police
- 1:56Speaker 7: would make an arrest for the murder of Martha Moxley.
- 2:01Speaker 5: Thirty nine year old Michael Skekel was charged with murder.
- 2:05Speaker 8: Michael, did you kill her?
- 2:07Speaker 9: I was shocked, like Michael, I know Michael's innocent. The
- 2:14Speaker 9: evidence is much stronger, suggesting that other people may have
- 2:19Speaker 9: committed the crime.
- 2:21Speaker 5: Bobby Kennedy Junior is Michael's cousin and he never believed
- 2:26Speaker 5: for a minute Michael Skeegel committed this crime.
- 2:30Speaker 9: Twenty seven years after the crime, kennedy cousin, Michael Skeakel
- 2:34Speaker 9: convicted in the murder of Martha Moxley.
- 2:39Speaker 7: Michael Schegel spent eleven and a half years in prison
- 2:43Speaker 7: until his conviction was overturned on appeal.
- 2:48Speaker 10: An innocent man now goes free.
- 2:50Speaker 7: But if Michael didn't kill Martha Moxley, then who did.
- 2:56Speaker 11: This little girl?
- 2:57Speaker 1: This cute, little amazing girl was murdered brute believed by somebody,
- 3:01Speaker 1: and I think it was somebody in that neighborhood.
- 3:04Speaker 8: Could Martha's diary hold the glue?
- 3:07Speaker 5: I believe all through this case there's someone who's been
- 3:10Speaker 5: keeping a secret.
- 4:01Speaker 1: After she was murdered, everything had changed.
- 4:05Speaker 4: You have no sense of peace. You've lost it all.
- 4:10Speaker 1: I think you she's sodesting.
- 4:12Speaker 7: Tory Holland and Richard Burns have waited decades to speak
- 4:16Speaker 7: publicly about the event that forever marked their lives, the
- 4:22Speaker 7: death of their friend, Martha Moxley.
- 4:25Speaker 4: My backyard sort of melded into her front yard.
- 4:29Speaker 7: Both Tory and Martha were just fifteen years old, living
- 4:33Speaker 7: in Belle Haven, Connecticut. Martha's family had moved to the
- 4:37Speaker 7: neighborhood a year earlier from California, and Martha wasted no
- 4:42Speaker 7: time becoming the it girl.
- 4:45Speaker 4: She was not a wallflower. She wanted to meet everybody,
- 4:48Speaker 4: but everybody in Gretige.
- 4:50Speaker 1: You know, it was very kind of reserved Northeastern personalities.
- 4:54Speaker 1: She was very an extrovert.
- 4:56Speaker 4: She was the California girl of all of us. She
- 4:59Speaker 4: was jo to be around.
- 5:00Speaker 11: You know, how can you kill someone like that?
- 5:07Speaker 7: It so guests you.
- 5:09Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 5:11Speaker 7: It was the night before Halloween, October thirtieth, nineteen seventy five,
- 5:16Speaker 7: also known as Mischief Night.
- 5:18Speaker 8: What is mischief night?
- 5:20Speaker 1: Basically you would throw toilet paper into the trees, which
- 5:24Speaker 1: was fun.
- 5:26Speaker 7: Martha headed across the street to hang out with her
- 5:29Speaker 7: very wealthy neighbors, the Scagol family. The Scagles were cousins
- 5:35Speaker 7: of the Kennedys.
- 5:38Speaker 8: Rushton.
- 5:38Speaker 7: Scagel's sister Ethel had married Robert Kennedy in nineteen fifty.
- 5:43Speaker 7: Rushton had inherited a fortune from the family's mining company.
- 5:48Speaker 1: They were a very famous family. They just had a
- 5:50Speaker 1: lot more attitude about you know. They could do anything.
- 5:54Speaker 7: Martha was friendly with the seven Scagol kids, spending time
- 5:58Speaker 7: mostly with Michael, who was also fifteen, and his older brother,
- 6:03Speaker 7: seventeen year old Tommy. On Mischief Night, Martha and two
- 6:09Speaker 7: other friends met Michael at the Scagle house around nine pm.
- 6:14Speaker 7: They all piled into a Lincoln like this parked in
- 6:18Speaker 7: the driveway.
- 6:19Speaker 12: Michael and Martha are in the front seat of the Scagole.
- 6:23Speaker 7: KRP reporter Len Levitt, now deceased, was interviewed in two
- 6:29Speaker 7: thousand and three. He spent more than thirty years investigating
- 6:34Speaker 7: the night of Martha's death.
- 6:35Speaker 12: Tommy comes and joins them, so the three of them
- 6:37Speaker 12: are sitting in the front seat, Martha's in the middle
- 6:41Speaker 12: between Tommy and Michael. They're listening to music.
- 6:47Speaker 7: They were in the Lincoln until around nine thirty PM,
- 6:50Speaker 7: when two other Scago brothers said they needed the car
- 6:54Speaker 7: so they could drive their cousin, Jimmy terran to his house.
- 7:00Speaker 8: To watch the US.
- 7:01Speaker 7: Premiere of Monty Python's Flying Circus. Michael told police he
- 7:07Speaker 7: left with his brothers and cousin. Well, Martha and her
- 7:11Speaker 7: friends stayed behind with Tommy.
- 7:14Speaker 12: What goes on between Martha and Tommy then a sort
- 7:17Speaker 12: of playful pushing back and forth with sexual overtones. At
- 7:22Speaker 12: one point, Tommy pushes Martha down and falls on top
- 7:26Speaker 12: of her, and the friends are so embarrassed that they
- 7:29Speaker 12: leave and go home, leaving Martha with Tommy. Martha never
- 7:33Speaker 12: gets home.
- 7:34Speaker 7: Martha's mother, Dorothy, spoke with forty eight hours in two
- 7:37Speaker 7: thousand Marri's Martha and remembered that around one am the
- 7:42Speaker 7: next morning, she began calling Martha's friends and alerted the police.
- 7:50Speaker 13: I was getting more worried and more worried. I mean,
- 7:52Speaker 13: it just was not like her.
- 7:57Speaker 7: When the sun came up and Martha still hadn't reached
- 8:00Speaker 7: turned home. Dorothy walked over to the Scagoad house. Michael
- 8:04Speaker 7: answered the door.
- 8:06Speaker 13: I'm Dorothy Moxley and I live across the street and
- 8:09Speaker 13: I'm looking for my daughter Martha. Do you know if
- 8:12Speaker 13: Martha is here. No, Martha was not there. And he
- 8:15Speaker 13: looked he didn't look healthy. He looked well. I actually
- 8:20Speaker 13: think he looked hungover.
- 8:22Speaker 7: Hours past, it was now almost noon on Halloween. Tory
- 8:30Speaker 7: was on her way to join the search when another
- 8:33Speaker 7: friend discovered Martha's body under this tree towards the back
- 8:39Speaker 7: of the Moxley property.
- 8:43Speaker 4: And I could see missus Moxley at the front door,
- 8:45Speaker 4: and she's going. She didn't want me to come any further,
- 8:49Speaker 4: but I could see the devastation with Missus Moxley's.
- 8:54Speaker 7: Steve Carroll was among the first investigators from the Greenwich
- 8:57Speaker 7: Police Department to walk up to Martha his body.
- 9:01Speaker 10: It was a maniacal attack that should have stopped, but didn't.
- 9:07Speaker 7: When Carol spoke with forty eight hours in two thousand,
- 9:10Speaker 7: he was still shaken by what he had seen.
- 9:16Speaker 10: We didn't even know what color hair she had because
- 9:18Speaker 10: it was all blood red and all of the blows
- 9:23Speaker 10: or damage were all to her head, and then we
- 9:29Speaker 10: could see a path that she had been dragged down
- 9:32Speaker 10: in the high grass down to where her final resting place,
- 9:37Speaker 10: which was under the pine tree.
- 9:39Speaker 7: Investigators traced the trail of blood to the Moxley driveway.
- 9:44Speaker 10: She had been bludgeoned right near the driveway because there
- 9:47Speaker 10: was a huge pull of.
- 9:48Speaker 7: Blood there, they discovered a piece of the murder weapon,
- 9:54Speaker 7: the shaft of a golf club. Former Hartford Current reporter
- 9:59Speaker 7: and Hours consultant Lynn Towhey.
- 10:02Speaker 5: It was a Tony Penna six iron golf club and
- 10:08Speaker 5: she was struck so violently that the shaft of the
- 10:13Speaker 5: golf club shattered and one portion of the shaft was
- 10:19Speaker 5: driven through her neck.
- 10:22Speaker 7: Just a few hours later, while camising the Scagle property,
- 10:26Speaker 7: police discovered a matching golf club that came from the
- 10:29Speaker 7: same set as the six iron that was used to
- 10:32Speaker 7: kill Martha.
- 10:35Speaker 5: It came from a set owned by Anne Scakle, Michaels
- 10:39Speaker 5: and Tommy's late mother.
- 10:41Speaker 7: Police began taking a hard look at the scalicles and
- 10:44Speaker 7: they would find what sounded like tantalizing clues left by
- 10:48Speaker 7: Martha herself in her diary.
- 11:07Speaker 4: I think I was still in shock that she was gone,
- 11:11Speaker 4: but that this had to be a beautiful tribute to
- 11:17Speaker 4: her to send her off.
- 11:20Speaker 7: A few days after Martha's murder, on November fourth, nineteen
- 11:24Speaker 7: seventy five, about five hundred people gathered for her funeral,
- 11:29Speaker 7: and while family and friends mourned the teenager, investigators were
- 11:34Speaker 7: learning more about Martha's relationship with Michael and Tommy Schegel.
- 11:39Speaker 7: Do you remember either of the scaeguls having a crush
- 11:43Speaker 7: on Martha?
- 11:44Speaker 1: Well, it would be hard not to, I know I did.
- 11:49Speaker 7: Martha's friends told police that Tommy wanted to date her,
- 11:52Speaker 7: but his advances may not have always been welcomed. On
- 11:56Speaker 7: September twelfth, Martha wrote in her diary about going for
- 12:00Speaker 7: ice cream with Michael and Tommy.
- 12:03Speaker 8: Went driving in Tom's.
- 12:04Speaker 7: Car and I was practically sitting on Tom's lap. He
- 12:09Speaker 7: kept putting his hand on my knee. And on October fourth,
- 12:13Speaker 7: a little over three weeks before her murder, Martha wrote,
- 12:17Speaker 7: I went to a party. Tom s was being an
- 12:20Speaker 7: ass at the dance. He kept putting his arms around
- 12:24Speaker 7: me and making moves.
- 12:28Speaker 4: I did not know she was spending the time that
- 12:31Speaker 4: she was spending with them. Well, I did not hang
- 12:34Speaker 4: around with them. They scared me a little bit. Why
- 12:36Speaker 4: what do you mean, well, because they were very rambunctious.
- 12:44Speaker 7: Two years earlier, the seven Skagle siblings lost their mom,
- 12:48Speaker 7: Anne to cancer. Their father rushed and struggled.
- 12:52Speaker 8: To parent them.
- 12:54Speaker 7: On the night of Martha's death, he was away on
- 12:57Speaker 7: a hunting trip.
- 13:00Speaker 4: Their father traveled quite a bit. They were allowed to
- 13:02Speaker 4: do whatever they'd like.
- 13:03Speaker 1: They definitely got into a lot of trouble, with a
- 13:06Speaker 1: lot of partying going on in that house.
- 13:08Speaker 7: I read that Michael Schaegole had a drinking problem at
- 13:12Speaker 7: age thirteen.
- 13:13Speaker 1: Really obviously say that's true.
- 13:16Speaker 7: And that drinking may have created conflict with Martha. In
- 13:20Speaker 7: her diary the month before her death, Martha wrote, Michael
- 13:24Speaker 7: was so totally out of it that he was being
- 13:27Speaker 7: a real He kept telling me that I was leading
- 13:30Speaker 7: tom on Michael jumps to conclusions. I really have to
- 13:34Speaker 7: stop going over there.
- 13:39Speaker 5: Tommy and Michael were both known to have very explosive tempers.
- 13:44Speaker 5: The two of them were fierce rivals for anything, you know,
- 13:50Speaker 5: from sports to affection a girl's attention. Martha's possibly.
- 14:00Speaker 7: It was daylight when Martha's body was found, but based
- 14:04Speaker 7: on reports of neighborhood dogs barking the night before. Investigators
- 14:09Speaker 7: believed that Martha was killed sometime between nine thirty and
- 14:14Speaker 7: ten PM, around the time she was thought to be
- 14:17Speaker 7: at the Scagles. Remember, Michael told police that around nine
- 14:26Speaker 7: thirty he had left to go to his cousin Jimmy
- 14:29Speaker 7: Terrian's home, and Martha had stayed behind with Tommy.
- 14:35Speaker 12: Tommy's story is that he last sees her at nine
- 14:37Speaker 12: thirty and he goes inside home to write a paper
- 14:40Speaker 12: on Abraham Lincoln. The police later find out that no
- 14:44Speaker 12: teacher at Tommy school ever assigned this paper.
- 14:51Speaker 7: Levitt says police initially considered Tommy a strong suspect, but
- 14:56Speaker 7: it turns out that even if Tommy lied about writing
- 14:59Speaker 7: that page, he had an alibi witness.
- 15:03Speaker 12: Tommy is seen again shortly after ten o'clock with Ken Littleton.
- 15:10Speaker 7: Ken Lyttleton was a new tutor who had just moved
- 15:13Speaker 7: into the Scagle house that very day. He told believes
- 15:17Speaker 7: that Tommy was watching TV with him around ten pm.
- 15:22Speaker 7: He noticed nothing unusual about Tommy, and that's significant because
- 15:27Speaker 7: Martha had been murdered violently.
- 15:30Speaker 12: How does Tommy do this? How does Tommy manage to
- 15:32Speaker 12: beat to death, move her body, clean himself up, compose
- 15:37Speaker 12: himself so that ken Lilytleton says of Tommy, I noticed
- 15:40Speaker 12: nothing about him out of the ordinary.
- 15:43Speaker 8: No arrests were made.
- 15:44Speaker 7: Months passed by, and with advice from Tommy's lawyer, rushed
- 15:49Speaker 7: in Scagle stop cooperating with police. He also fired ken Lyttleton,
- 15:54Speaker 7: whose life unraveled shortly after he moved to Nantucket.
- 16:00Speaker 5: Rank heavily did drugs, committed crimes of petty larceny.
- 16:07Speaker 7: Investigators pned in on this, schaegled tutor, speculating that his
- 16:12Speaker 7: downfall could be rooted in his involvement in Martha's murder,
- 16:17Speaker 7: but there were problems with that theory.
- 16:19Speaker 12: He's got no motives to kill Martha. He never knew Martha.
- 16:23Speaker 12: The manner in which Martha is killed indicates that it
- 16:27Speaker 12: was somebody who had a relationship with Arthur.
- 16:31Speaker 7: Authorities found no evidence to prove Lyttleton was involved. Years
- 16:36Speaker 7: went by, Martha's murder became a cold case.
- 16:41Speaker 5: There were no more leads to pursue. There was no
- 16:45Speaker 5: new evidence.
- 16:47Speaker 7: In nineteen ninety one, the trial of another Kennedy cousin,
- 16:52Speaker 7: William Kennedy Smith, who was charged with rape and Florida,
- 16:56Speaker 7: but acquitted would open a new chapter in the Oxley case.
- 17:01Speaker 12: There's an allegation which is false, that William Kennedy Smith
- 17:04Speaker 12: was at the Scafhele house the night of the murder.
- 17:09Speaker 7: That unfounded rumor and persistent press coverage kept the heat
- 17:14Speaker 7: on the Greenwich Police Department and prompted them to reopen
- 17:18Speaker 7: the investigation.
- 17:20Speaker 12: And now they announced a reward in a hotline.
- 17:22Speaker 8: This time.
- 17:23Speaker 7: In an effort to clear his family name, Rushton Skeakeel
- 17:27Speaker 7: hired his own team of investigators. Their findings became known
- 17:31Speaker 7: as the Sutton Report, but the effort backfired because that report,
- 17:36Speaker 7: for the first time, pointed a finger at another of
- 17:40Speaker 7: Rushton's sons, Michael Skakel.
- 17:44Speaker 12: Michael lied to the police.
- 17:46Speaker 7: Michael told Belie that after watching Monty Python's Flying Circus
- 17:50Speaker 7: at his cousin Jimmy Terrion's house, he came home around
- 17:53Speaker 7: eleven thirty pm and went straight to bed. But he
- 17:58Speaker 7: told his dad's investigation there's another story.
- 18:02Speaker 6: Oh my god, I tell anybody that I was out
- 18:07Speaker 6: that night, they're going to say I did it.
- 18:25Speaker 7: For twenty year's investigators seemed stymied in their effort to
- 18:29Speaker 7: find Martha's killer. But all that changed in nineteen ninety
- 18:33Speaker 7: five when someone leaked the Sutton report to the press.
- 18:38Speaker 5: It was never supposed to see the lighter day.
- 18:40Speaker 8: The report was an eye opener.
- 18:43Speaker 7: Tommy admitted to his father's investigators that all those years ago,
- 18:47Speaker 7: in nineteen seventy five, he had lied to the police.
- 18:51Speaker 5: Tommy told the Sutton investigators that he did not go
- 18:55Speaker 5: into his house at nine point thirty, He stayed outside
- 18:59Speaker 5: making out with my Artha for twenty minutes mutual petting,
- 19:02Speaker 5: semi sexual encounter, and suddenly casts himself as being most
- 19:08Speaker 5: likely the last person to see her alive.
- 19:10Speaker 7: And not just the last person see her alive, but
- 19:14Speaker 7: who's with her at the time that investigators believe she
- 19:16Speaker 7: may have been killed? Correct, But it wasn't just Tommy
- 19:21Speaker 7: who changed his story.
- 19:22Speaker 5: Wasn't No Michael also changed his story.
- 19:27Speaker 7: Remember Michael told Belize that after watching Monty Python at
- 19:32Speaker 7: his cousin's, he came back home around eleven.
- 19:35Speaker 8: Thirty PM and went straight to bed.
- 19:38Speaker 12: The report was devastating to the scal.
- 19:40Speaker 7: Family, but then he described a very different scenario to
- 19:44Speaker 7: those private investigators.
- 19:48Speaker 12: Feeling horny on midnineties drunk, and he goes out and
- 19:52Speaker 12: he climbs a tree outside Martha's window and he masturbates
- 19:55Speaker 12: in the tree.
- 19:57Speaker 7: In fact, in nineteen ninety seven, Michael made a tape
- 20:00Speaker 7: recording of that story while working on a book proposal
- 20:04Speaker 7: for a tell all autobiography.
- 20:07Speaker 6: I pulled my pants out. I've masturbated for thirty seconds
- 20:12Speaker 6: in the trade, and I remember thinking, oh my god,
- 20:14Speaker 6: I hope gotten over comed. But I woke up to
- 20:17Speaker 6: missus Moxley saying, Michael, has have you seen Martha?
- 20:23Speaker 14: Oh my god, did they seen you last night?
- 20:29Speaker 7: Reports had also begun to circulate that Michael had actually
- 20:33Speaker 7: confessed to Martha's murder. It was said to have happened
- 20:38Speaker 7: while he was a student at a lawn, A reform
- 20:41Speaker 7: school that his father sent him to after a drunk
- 20:45Speaker 7: driving incident when he was seventeen.
- 20:50Speaker 8: One former Alan.
- 20:51Speaker 7: Student, Gregory Coleman, recounted to a local news reporter what
- 20:56Speaker 7: he says Michael told him back then.
- 21:00Speaker 1: As you ever said to me, was I'm going to
- 21:02Speaker 1: get away with murder I m kennedy.
- 21:05Speaker 7: Coleman says, Michael detailed what he did to Martha that night.
- 21:10Speaker 12: He had made advances towards her, and she rejected his
- 21:13Speaker 12: advances and quote unquote that he drove her sculling away
- 21:20Speaker 12: the golf clubs.
- 21:23Speaker 7: After hearing from Coleman and other former Alawn students, State's
- 21:28Speaker 7: Attorney Jonathan Benedict convened an unusual and rarely used one
- 21:33Speaker 7: person grand jury to look at all the evidence and
- 21:37Speaker 7: all the suspects in the case. After eighteen months and
- 21:41Speaker 7: more than forty witnesses, Oh did.
- 21:43Speaker 8: You just skeggle? Don't have anything to say? Michael?
- 21:46Speaker 12: Did you kill her?
- 21:49Speaker 7: The grand jury indicted Michael Schaggel for murder twenty four
- 21:55Speaker 7: years after Martha's death. Michael was forty one years old
- 21:59Speaker 7: when his trial began.
- 22:01Speaker 8: And how big a story was that it was huge?
- 22:04Speaker 5: The scene outside was circus, likely, Skegel, did.
- 22:08Speaker 8: You have anything to say?
- 22:11Speaker 5: All the national media was there, They had tents and
- 22:14Speaker 5: they had lights.
- 22:15Speaker 3: It's Michael's defense and his only defense is that he
- 22:17Speaker 3: did not commit this crime.
- 22:20Speaker 7: Michael Skeekeel was being represented by a well known local
- 22:24Speaker 7: defense attorney, Nicky Sherman.
- 22:26Speaker 5: As charismatic as they come, Mickey is no amateur when
- 22:30Speaker 5: it comes to television.
- 22:32Speaker 7: What's the motive for Michael Skeekell killing Martha Mosley.
- 22:37Speaker 5: The only motive really is jealous rage over the attention
- 22:44Speaker 5: she was showing Tommy Schegel.
- 22:50Speaker 7: In fact, in that same book proposal for his autobiography,
- 22:54Speaker 7: Michael wrote, I wanted her to be my girlfriend.
- 22:59Speaker 13: I think Martha just rebuffed him. She could have been
- 23:04Speaker 13: flirting with Tommy, and maybe that made him angry.
- 23:08Speaker 15: On trial Michael Skeagle.
- 23:11Speaker 7: At trial, prosecutor Jonathan Benedict began with discrediting Michael's alibi
- 23:17Speaker 7: that he had gone for that ride to his cousin's
- 23:20Speaker 7: house around the time.
- 23:22Speaker 8: Of Martha's murder.
- 23:24Speaker 7: Prosecutors called Scagel family friend Andrea Shakespeare, who had been
- 23:29Speaker 7: at the Scapele house that night.
- 23:31Speaker 8: Andrea Shakespeare is one of the witnesses who was certain
- 23:35Speaker 8: that mister Skegold never took that alibi ride.
- 23:39Speaker 7: Benedict put holes in Michael's alibi, but he later said
- 23:43Speaker 7: Michael himself provided the most damaging evidence.
- 23:47Speaker 3: The truth of the matter is that Michael Skeagle couldn't
- 23:50Speaker 3: keep his mouth shut for a quarter.
- 23:51Speaker 9: Of a century.
- 23:52Speaker 7: Benedict is referring to all those admissions Michael allegedly made
- 23:57Speaker 7: to killing Martha, like the one to align classmate Gregory Coleman.
- 24:02Speaker 8: Although Coleman had died from a.
- 24:04Speaker 7: Drug overdose before the trial began, his testimony from an
- 24:09Speaker 7: earlier hearing was read to the jury that infuriated Michael's
- 24:14Speaker 7: brother Stephen.
- 24:15Speaker 4: Greg Coleman was high on heroin, a methadone.
- 24:18Speaker 5: He was doing twenty to twenty five bags of heroin
- 24:22Speaker 5: a day.
- 24:23Speaker 7: It turns out that before trial, Coleman admitted to Michael's
- 24:26Speaker 7: attorney that he was actually high on drugs when he
- 24:30Speaker 7: testified before the grand jury.
- 24:34Speaker 8: But the state put.
- 24:35Speaker 7: On nine other witnesses who told the jury that Michael
- 24:39Speaker 7: implied he had killed Martha. And then, of course there
- 24:48Speaker 7: was Michael's own words from that tell All book proposal.
- 24:52Speaker 7: In closing arguments, Prosecutor Benedict played and edited excerpt for
- 24:58Speaker 7: the jurors.
- 25:00Speaker 14: Dot did they seen you last night?
- 25:03Speaker 6: I remember just having a feeling of the panic.
- 25:05Speaker 5: I think it very well may have been the lynchkin.
- 25:10Speaker 7: What do you mean by that?
- 25:13Speaker 5: Driving the nail into the coffin of Michael Skeegele. In
- 25:15Speaker 5: terms of a guilty verdict.
- 25:20Speaker 8: It took the jury four days.
- 25:22Speaker 7: Michael Skeegell was convicted for Martha's murder, his sentence twenty
- 25:31Speaker 7: years to life.
- 25:35Speaker 9: I know Michael Skeekell and I know he didn't commit
- 25:38Speaker 9: the crime.
- 25:39Speaker 14: Can talk with him.
- 25:40Speaker 7: A few months after trial, Michael Skeekle's cousin, Robert Kennedy Junior,
- 25:46Speaker 7: accused the prosecutor of deliberately misrepresenting Michael's words in that
- 25:52Speaker 7: closing argument.
- 25:54Speaker 9: His tape recorded words were used out of context by
- 25:58Speaker 9: the prosecutor to imply that he was confessing to the crime.
- 26:03Speaker 14: Oh my god, did they see you last night?
- 26:07Speaker 7: Because here's what the prosecutor didn't play in court.
- 26:11Speaker 6: And I remember thinking, oh my god, I hope God
- 26:14Speaker 6: overcome me.
- 26:16Speaker 7: Correspondent Leslie Stall asked Benedict about it.
- 26:20Speaker 15: In hearing this myself, Yeah, without the preamble about masturbating
- 26:27Speaker 15: to anybody, is that he's actually talking about murdering her?
- 26:31Speaker 15: And isn't that really taking him out of context?
- 26:36Speaker 6: No, I don't think so much.
- 26:36Speaker 8: If I did this forty eight hours I'd be fired.
- 26:39Speaker 2: I think it's a fair suggestion. Based upon the evidence
- 26:43Speaker 2: of the case.
- 26:44Speaker 9: It appeared to anybody who looked at it that he
- 26:47Speaker 9: was confessing. He was saying that he was panicked because
- 26:51Speaker 9: he had committed this crime, and that was really the
- 26:55Speaker 9: segment that everybody agrees ended up convicting Michael Skagel.
- 27:01Speaker 7: And Robert Kennedy was determined to exonerate his cousin. Eight
- 27:06Speaker 7: months after Michael Skeakell was sent off to prison, Kennedy
- 27:10Speaker 7: got a tip he believed would reveal Martha's real killers
- 27:30Speaker 7: to Robert Kennedy Junior. It was the break he had
- 27:33Speaker 7: been hoping for. Kennedy got a tip that a former
- 27:36Speaker 7: classmate of Michael Skeagle, a man named Tony Bryant, was
- 27:41Speaker 7: claiming he knew the identity of Martha Moxley's killers. So
- 27:45Speaker 7: Kennedy and Michael's attorneys track Bryant down in Florida.
- 27:50Speaker 11: Brian has made a full confession of his involvement in
- 27:55Speaker 11: that crime.
- 27:58Speaker 7: This is Tony Bryant in two thousand and three videotape
- 28:02Speaker 7: by Michael Skeaegle's team.
- 28:03Speaker 14: We decided to go up to Greenwich and.
- 28:05Speaker 8: Hangout, he told them.
- 28:07Speaker 7: On the night of the murder, he had taken two friends,
- 28:10Speaker 7: Adolph Hasbrook also known as Al and Burton Tinsley to
- 28:15Speaker 7: Belle Haven.
- 28:16Speaker 11: So do you believe that they killed her?
- 28:19Speaker 14: There's no doubt in my mind that.
- 28:20Speaker 6: They were involved.
- 28:21Speaker 7: Bryant knew the two teams from New York and told
- 28:24Speaker 7: Skeegll's investigators that Hasbrook had become obsessed with Martha.
- 28:29Speaker 10: I mean loved their beautiful blonde hair.
- 28:32Speaker 7: Brian said that Hasbrook met Martha during previous trips to
- 28:36Speaker 7: belle Haven at a street fair and again at a dance.
- 28:39Speaker 4: I'm trying to remember one of the mixers, and he
- 28:42Speaker 4: got jealous of other guys coming up to her and
- 28:44Speaker 4: talking to her.
- 28:45Speaker 7: Tony claims Hasbrook complained to him, saying.
- 28:48Speaker 10: I don't understand why she's spending her time with those.
- 28:51Speaker 7: Guys when she could be with me. On the night
- 28:54Speaker 7: of the murder, Brian says he was with Hasbrooke and
- 28:57Speaker 7: Tinsley when they all picked up golf from this Schago backyard.
- 29:02Speaker 7: He claims that either has Brooke or Tinsley bragged about
- 29:05Speaker 7: wanting to hurt someone.
- 29:08Speaker 13: I got my cave man clove right and I'm gonna
- 29:11Speaker 13: go grab somebody and pulled by hair and.
- 29:13Speaker 14: Do what kates it.
- 29:16Speaker 7: Tony says he wanted no part of it, so he
- 29:19Speaker 7: left Belhaven and then right after the murder, when you
- 29:23Speaker 7: met up with both Adolph and Berg.
- 29:25Speaker 6: They told you we got we did it, We did it,
- 29:27Speaker 6: We achieved our fantasy.
- 29:29Speaker 7: Brian stated that while his friends never mentioned Martha Moxley
- 29:32Speaker 7: by name, I knew who they were.
- 29:34Speaker 14: Impla it was.
- 29:35Speaker 12: It was so lobbyoust because I mean the next day
- 29:39Speaker 12: it was all over, I mean it was everywhere.
- 29:44Speaker 7: Armed with Tony Bryant's story. In two thousand and five,
- 29:48Speaker 7: Michael Skeagel's attorneys filed an appeal asking for a new trial.
- 29:53Speaker 3: You're on the petition for new trial that we filed
- 29:56Speaker 3: on behalf of Michael Skagel claims newly discovered evidence involves
- 30:00Speaker 3: the obligations concerning Tony Bryant.
- 30:03Speaker 7: But at a hearing to present the new evidence, Bryant
- 30:07Speaker 7: refused to testify under oath.
- 30:10Speaker 11: Well, of course he is not going to do that
- 30:12Speaker 11: because he admits that he brought them murderers to Greenwich,
- 30:15Speaker 11: because he could be charged with that crime.
- 30:18Speaker 7: Kennedy says Brian wouldn't testify without immunity, So Skekell's attorneys
- 30:23Speaker 7: played his video statement, but the judge wasn't persuaded and
- 30:27Speaker 7: ruled against Michael Skeakell.
- 30:30Speaker 12: Michael Skekell versus the State of Connecticut has been concluded.
- 30:36Speaker 8: Despite the judge's ruling.
- 30:38Speaker 7: Almost a decade later, in twenty sixteen, Robert Kennedy Junior
- 30:43Speaker 7: repeated Brian's allegations in his book Framed, using Martha's diary
- 30:49Speaker 7: as evidence. Kennedy claims that three weeks before her murder,
- 30:54Speaker 7: Martha wrote that she saw Tony and two strangers at
- 30:58Speaker 7: a dance. But that's not quite accurate. In her entry,
- 31:04Speaker 7: Martha doesn't mention Tony and she never uses the word strangers.
- 31:10Speaker 7: She writes October fourth, Dear Diary, tonight was a sacred
- 31:15Speaker 7: Heart dance. When we walked in, some guy asked me
- 31:18Speaker 7: to dance. Some other guy asked me. It turned out
- 31:21Speaker 7: to be a slow dance. It was stairway to Heaven
- 31:24Speaker 7: at the fast party.
- 31:25Speaker 8: Wouldn't even let go.
- 31:26Speaker 7: I also dance with Dickie Neil and Peter Zamensky a
- 31:31Speaker 7: lot with Dickie. The Dickie she mentioned is actually Richard Burns,
- 31:36Speaker 7: who says he was with Martha much of that night.
- 31:40Speaker 8: Seeing Tony Bryant. Do you remember that at all?
- 31:42Speaker 7: No? Did you ever meet al Hasbruck or Burton Tinsley? No,
- 31:48Speaker 7: don't you think you would have remembered if she was
- 31:50Speaker 7: dancing with someone else who seemed possessive of her.
- 31:54Speaker 1: She didn't, She didn't. We danced the whole night.
- 32:03Speaker 3: Al Hasbrook is innocent.
- 32:04Speaker 7: Al Hasbrook declined to be interviewed, and we were unable
- 32:08Speaker 7: to reach Burton Tinsley, but Hasbrook's attorney, Larry Schoenbach describes
- 32:14Speaker 7: the allegations as false and imflammatory.
- 32:18Speaker 3: The coin of phrase, it's black versus white. Let's blame
- 32:21Speaker 3: somebody else. It's the black guy, Let's blame him. Why
- 32:25Speaker 3: not let's take the most vulnerable person in our society
- 32:29Speaker 3: and accuse him. I am as certain as certain can
- 32:33Speaker 3: be that neither had anything to do with this.
- 32:37Speaker 7: Burton Tinsley and al Hasbrook don't deny that they have
- 32:40Speaker 7: been to bell Haven on several occasions, but Schoenbach says
- 32:44Speaker 7: there's no evidence that either one was in bell Haven
- 32:48Speaker 7: the night Martha was bludgeoned to death.
- 32:50Speaker 3: Nobody saw al Hasbrook. Nobody. They would have seen a
- 32:55Speaker 3: young guy, a black man in a very very white
- 32:58Speaker 3: community and a big but nobody saw him because he
- 33:03Speaker 3: wasn't there.
- 33:04Speaker 4: Somebody would have seen strangers and recognized that they were strangers.
- 33:09Speaker 1: Nobody did, and I just thought that was kind of
- 33:11Speaker 1: a cheap shot that they were going after this black
- 33:14Speaker 1: kid from New York City.
- 33:15Speaker 4: I mean, you know, really, I think it's they're trying
- 33:18Speaker 4: to find a scapegoat.
- 33:21Speaker 7: What's more, Hasbrook's attorney is baffled as to why anyone
- 33:25Speaker 7: would believe Tony Bryant. Bryant has a criminal history that
- 33:29Speaker 7: includes a nineteen ninety three conviction for armed robbery in California.
- 33:35Speaker 7: We tried to reach him, but up until a few
- 33:37Speaker 7: weeks ago, he was serving a seven year sentence in
- 33:41Speaker 7: a Florida prison for tax evasion. Still Showing Box says
- 33:48Speaker 7: Kennedy irresponsibly perpetuates Bryant's allegations.
- 33:53Speaker 3: With no facts and no evidence. He continues to put
- 33:58Speaker 3: forth this lie is a way of trying to clear
- 34:01Speaker 3: his cousin, and I guess by extension the Kennedy name.
- 34:06Speaker 7: In November twenty twenty, Kennedy insisted to us that Tony
- 34:10Speaker 7: Bryant has no reason whatsoever to lie about al Hasbrook
- 34:15Speaker 7: and Burton Tinsley. When we pressed him about it, he
- 34:19Speaker 7: got up from the interview chair. Do you have any
- 34:22Speaker 7: regrets of pointing the finger at two people who've never
- 34:25Speaker 7: been suspects. There's no physical evidence to tie them to
- 34:29Speaker 7: the crime.
- 34:30Speaker 11: There are lots of evidence that tuk to the crime.
- 34:34Speaker 11: You have their best friend who's Satisfaican festival.
- 34:38Speaker 7: But in the end, it wouldn't be the words of
- 34:41Speaker 7: Tony Bryant that changed everything for Michael Schaegel. Michael's did
- 35:00Speaker 7: not give up. On April sixteenth, twenty thirteen, Skegell was
- 35:05Speaker 7: back in court I do with his attorney, Hubert Santos
- 35:10Speaker 7: and a new argument that that media savvy defense attorney
- 35:15Speaker 7: Mickey Sherman, hired to defend Michael at his two thousand
- 35:19Speaker 7: and two trials.
- 35:21Speaker 9: He was advised of his rights station.
- 35:22Speaker 8: Had botched the case.
- 35:27Speaker 3: Mickey had me believing he was the real deal.
- 35:30Speaker 7: He accused his former lawyer of being too chummy with
- 35:33Speaker 7: the press.
- 35:34Speaker 9: He said he was a media whore.
- 35:36Speaker 14: Everything about this trial is unique.
- 35:38Speaker 3: You spent most of your time talking to the media,
- 35:42Speaker 3: right is a question?
- 35:43Speaker 7: Yeah? No, And Skegel claimed that Sherman failed to focus
- 35:47Speaker 7: on a more viable suspect in Moxley's murder, Michael's own brother, Tommy.
- 35:54Speaker 6: You knew that.
- 35:55Speaker 3: Tommy Schegel was the last person to see Martha Moxley alt.
- 36:00Speaker 11: I believe so.
- 36:02Speaker 7: Sherman never presented evidence of Tommy's infamous temper.
- 36:07Speaker 3: Did you know that he strangled the fellow classmate right
- 36:10Speaker 3: in front of his teacher? I don't recall that.
- 36:13Speaker 7: Sherman also failed to convince the judge to allow Tommy
- 36:17Speaker 7: to testify, which could have raised out about Michael's involvement.
- 36:22Speaker 3: Did you try Who's going?
- 36:23Speaker 13: In both the fifth Amendment?
- 36:24Speaker 11: No matter what we.
- 36:25Speaker 7: Did, Perhaps most shocking, Sherman failed to call it critical
- 36:30Speaker 7: witness who supported Michael's alibi that he was miles away
- 36:34Speaker 7: the night Martha was murdered.
- 36:36Speaker 5: So that was Dennis SiO who was at the Terarian
- 36:40Speaker 5: household the night they were all allegedly.
- 36:43Speaker 9: Watching Quonty five in this flying circus.
- 36:46Speaker 5: Michael was allegedly there.
- 36:49Speaker 11: Mickey sher meant in instead of doing that, instead of calling,
- 36:52Speaker 11: never talked to that witness.
- 36:54Speaker 7: But in twenty thirteen Santos did, was there anybody.
- 36:58Speaker 13: Else at the home the boys were?
- 37:00Speaker 14: There?
- 37:01Speaker 13: Was Michael Skeakell on Michael was with him.
- 37:04Speaker 5: He puts Michael Skeegell at that house and has no
- 37:09Speaker 5: motive to lie. He's not related to Michael Skeegel.
- 37:13Speaker 7: Schegel's team argued that these missed opportunities would have created
- 37:19Speaker 7: reasonable doubt for the jury, and the judge agreed. Six
- 37:27Speaker 7: months later, he overturned Skegell's conviction.
- 37:33Speaker 4: Wednesday, at Connecticut judge granted the fifty three year old
- 37:36Speaker 4: a new trial in the nineteen seventy five murder of
- 37:38Speaker 4: Martha Moxley.
- 37:41Speaker 7: After eleven and a half years in prison, Michael Skekell
- 37:44Speaker 7: walked out of the courthouse, no longer a convicted killer.
- 37:49Speaker 10: An innocent man now goes.
- 37:51Speaker 8: Free, but not for long.
- 37:53Speaker 5: In twenty sixteen, the Connecticut Supreme Court, in in a
- 37:57Speaker 5: sharply divided decision, reinstead his conviction, saying the defense was adequate.
- 38:05Speaker 7: Skeagel, faced with returning to prison, then filed for reconsideration,
- 38:11Speaker 7: and in twenty eighteen, with a new judge on the bench,
- 38:15Speaker 7: the Connecticut Supreme Court reversed itself, now ruling that Skeagel
- 38:21Speaker 7: is entitled to a new trial. That trial would never happen.
- 38:29Speaker 14: Looking at the evidence, your honor, looking at the state
- 38:33Speaker 14: of the case, it is my belief that the state
- 38:36Speaker 14: cannot prove this case beyond a reasonable doubt.
- 38:40Speaker 7: On October thirtieth, twenty twenty, the forty fifth anniversary of
- 38:46Speaker 7: Martha Moxley's murder, the state of Connecticut announced it would
- 38:53Speaker 7: not retry Michael Schagel.
- 38:58Speaker 1: You know, Michael's going to walk around the rest of
- 39:00Speaker 1: his life with that on his head, no matter whether
- 39:02Speaker 1: or not it's been vacated by the court, public opinion matters.
- 39:07Speaker 8: As for his brother Tommy.
- 39:09Speaker 1: Years later, I ended up playing some golf with him
- 39:11Speaker 1: a bunch of times.
- 39:12Speaker 7: I mean, did you ever ask him point blank?
- 39:14Speaker 1: I did, I didn't do it, and it ruined my life.
- 39:16Speaker 5: This case has been a long and winding road, a
- 39:21Speaker 5: very painful case emotionally for many people.
- 39:26Speaker 7: For Dorothy Moxley, time has done little to ease her loss.
- 39:32Speaker 13: Martha, my baby will never have a life.
- 39:40Speaker 5: This was devastating to the Moxley family. Dorothy to this
- 39:44Speaker 5: day remains convinced Martha was killed by Michael Schaigel.
- 39:50Speaker 7: To lose a child is the worst thing in the world,
- 39:58Speaker 7: and so after Amlah, half a century of questions and
- 40:02Speaker 7: two families shattered, all that remains is one terrible truth.
- 40:09Speaker 8: As we sit here.
- 40:10Speaker 7: Today, no one has been convicted of Martha Moxley's murder.
- 40:16Speaker 8: No, that's true.
- 40:18Speaker 4: It's very frustrating, it's very upsetting.
- 40:22Speaker 1: I think it's sad that she's not around of you know,
- 40:26Speaker 1: lived these forty five years.
- 40:30Speaker 4: I think she would have done great things. I think
- 40:32Speaker 4: she would have been a great mother. She was always
- 40:34Speaker 4: a great friend.
- 40:38Speaker 7: Lasting impressions of a life ended too soon, a life that,
- 40:43Speaker 7: in Martha's own words, was full of hope. Dear Diary,
- 40:50Speaker 7: today is the last day of seventy four. Boo who
- 40:54Speaker 7: seventy four has been one of the best years of
- 40:57Speaker 7: my life. Well, hope seventy five life is as good