Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage a Team Member Who Always Says Nothing Can Be Done
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, I want to talk about a phrase that drives me up the wall in a one-on-one. It’s when you bring up a challenge, a new initiative, a process improvement — and the person across the table just says, ‘Nothing can be done.’ Luna: Oh, that one. It’s like a door slamming shut before you’ve even knocked. Lucas: Exactly. And the frustrating thing is, sometimes they’re right — about the surface-level obstacle. But the phrase itself shuts down all creative problem-solving. So today I want to dig into why people say that, and how you as a manager can coach through it without just overruling them. Luna: Is this different from the ‘that’s how we’ve always done it’ resisters we covered in episode 86? Lucas: Good question. That one is about tradition and inertia. This one is about learned helplessness — the person genuinely believes no solution exists. They’re not being stubborn on purpose. They’ve probably been burned before, or they’ve internalized a culture where trying and failing is punished. Luna: So it’s less about resistance and more about resignation. Lucas: Right. Let’s give it a concrete case. I was talking to a logistics manager at a mid-sized e-commerce company last month. She had a team member — let’s call him Rob — who handled shipping exceptions. Every time a package got stuck in customs, or a truck was late, Rob would say ‘Nothing can be done, it’s the carrier’s fault.’ He wasn’t wrong about the carrier, but he never escalated, never asked if there was a backup option. Luna: So the manager’s stuck. If she pushes too hard, Rob might feel micromanaged. If she lets it slide, delays pile up. Lucas: Exactly. What she did — and I think this is a good blueprint — she stopped accepting the statement as a conclusion. She started treating it as the beginning of a different conversation. She’d say, ‘Okay, the carrier’s beyond our control right now. But what is within your control? Can you call the customer proactively? Can you reroute through a different hub tomorrow?’ Luna: She’s shifting his focus from the obstacle to the tiny actions he can still take. Lucas: That’s the core of it. Psychologists call this the ‘locus of control.’ People with an internal locus believe they can influence outcomes. People with an external locus see everything as outside their power. That phrase ‘Nothing can be done’ is a textbook external-locus statement. Your job as manager is to gently — without being preachy — expand their sense of agency. Luna: But isn’t there a risk you’re just asking them to do busywork? Like, calling the customer might feel like a pointless gesture if the package really is stuck. Lucas: It’s a fair point. And that’s where you need to show them the downstream impact. In that logistics case, calling the customer actually reduced complaint escalations by a measurable amount. So the manager could say, ‘I hear that the carrier is the bottleneck. But last week, when you called the customer first, their satisfaction score stayed high. That’s something you did. That’s actionable.’ You’re connecting a small action to a positive outcome. Luna: So you’re not just saying ‘try harder.’ You’re giving them evidence that their effort matters. Lucas: Right. And you have to be patient. Learned helplessness doesn’t unlearn overnight. I recommend a three-step coaching script. Step one: acknowledge the constraint. Say ‘You’re right, that part is out of our hands.’ That builds trust — you’re not dismissing them. Luna: So they feel heard instead of argued with. Lucas: Exactly. Step two: ask a specific expansion question. Not ‘What can you do?’ — that’s too vague. But ‘What’s one thing you could try, even if it’s imperfect?’ Or ‘If you had to make this 5% better, what would you do?’ That small target feels achievable. Luna: I like the 5% framing. It lowers the stakes. Lucas: Step three: follow up and celebrate the attempt. If they tried something, even if it didn’t fully work, you reinforce the behaviour. You say, ‘I saw you called the alternate hub. Good for you. Let’s see what else we can try.’ Over time, the person starts to default to ‘Let me see what I can do’ instead of ‘Nothing can be done.’ Luna: I’ve also seen a version of this where the problem isn’t helplessness — it’s fear. The person knows a solution exists but is scared to suggest it because if it fails, they’ll be blamed. Lucas: That’s a slightly different dynamic, and it’s common in high-blame cultures. In that situation, the manager has to explicitly reduce the cost of failure. You can say, ‘I’d rather we try something and learn than do nothing. If it doesn’t work, we’ll adjust, no finger-pointing.’ But you have to mean it. Luna: And you have to model that yourself. If you as a manager shoot down ideas or get visibly frustrated when something fails, you’re teaching them that ‘nothing can be done’ is the safe answer. Lucas: Absolutely. The mirror test is important here. Ask yourself: when was the last time you said ‘Nothing can be done’ in a meeting? Your team watches you. If they see you pivot and problem-solve, they’ll start to mirror that. Luna: Let me ask you about the team level. What if it’s not just one person — it’s a whole department that has this mindset? Lucas: That’s a bigger culture fix. I’d start with a team exercise around ‘locus of control.’ Have everyone list three recent obstacles. Then, next to each, write one thing they could have controlled or influenced. Share them out loud. It normalizes the shift from external blame to internal agency. I’ve seen teams do this as a weekly 10-minute stand-up ritual. Luna: And it makes the phrase ‘Nothing can be done’ almost embarrassing to say, because everyone else is talking about what they tried. Lucas: Exactly. Peer pressure in a good direction. I should also mention — sometimes the person is right. Sometimes nothing genuinely can be done. But that’s rare. Usually there’s a small lever. And even if the lever doesn’t move the big problem, it moves something. The act of trying builds agency. Luna: I think about this from the construal level theory angle. ‘Nothing can be done’ is a high-level, abstract construal. You’re seeing the whole mountain. But if you drop to a low-level construal — what’s the next rock in front of you — you can step over it. Lucas: That’s a great way to frame it. The manager’s job is to help the team member zoom in from ‘this is impossible’ to ‘what’s the next tiny move.’ And you don’t need to be a psychologist to do it. Just a simple question: ‘What’s one thing you could try, even if it’s small?’ Luna: It’s also worth noting that this episode, like all episodes on this show, is ad-free. We keep it that way because we think the content should stand on its own. If you find value in these conversations and want to support that choice, there’s a link: buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just a way to keep this independent. Lucas: Yeah, and it’s listeners like you who make this possible. So thanks for that. Now, back to the coaching. Let’s say you’ve tried the three-step script for a few weeks, and the person is still saying ‘Nothing can be done.’ What then? Luna: Then it might be a fit issue. Some people genuinely prefer roles where they execute clear tasks without ambiguity. That’s not bad — it’s just a mismatch for a role that requires proactive problem-solving. You might need to have a honest conversation about whether the person is in the right seat. Lucas: I agree. But before you jump to that, check your own behaviour. Are you giving them enough autonomy? Sometimes managers inadvertently train helplessness by jumping in too fast. If you always solve the problem for them, they learn to stop trying. Luna: The fix there is to pause. Next time they say ‘Nothing can be done,’ don’t offer a solution. Say, ‘Okay, what do you recommend?’ And then wait. Silence is powerful. Lucas: Right. And if they still can’t think of anything, you can scaffold it: ‘Would you like me to brainstorm a couple ideas, and then you pick the best one?’ That keeps ownership with them. Luna: So the through-line is: don’t accept the statement as final. Treat it as a starting point. Acknowledge the constraint, expand the frame, and reinforce agency. Lucas: That’s the takeaway. One concrete thing to try this week: the next time you hear ‘Nothing can be done,’ take a breath, don’t argue, and ask ‘What’s one small thing you could try?’ See what happens. I think you’ll be surprised. Luna: I’m going to try it. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. Good luck out there.