Latest / Epic Fury: The US-Iran War Podcast / Iran War Day 42: Hormuz Still Closed, Islamabad Talks Begin | Nuclear Deal Showdown Explained
Transcript
- 0:16The Strait of Hormuz is still largely closed.
- 0:19The talks begin tomorrow. Islamabad is being locked down.
- 0:24Shipping containers across Kiev roads.
- 0:26Hundreds of paramilitary forces deployed.
- 0:28The red zone sealed. Iran's parliament speaker and
- 0:32foreign minister are flying in. JD Vance is already wheels up,
- 0:36and the most consequential diplomatic encounter of this war
- 0:40begins on Saturday morning in a city that was never supposed to
- 0:43be the center of the Middle East peace process.
- 0:46It is Friday, April 10th, 2026, day 42 of Operation in Epic
- 0:51Fury. The ceasefire is holding, just
- 0:54barely. The war has paused over Iran.
- 0:58Hezbollah has set a halted attacks on Israel.
- 1:01The Lebanese death toll from Wednesday's Israeli strikes has
- 1:04risen to 182. The Strait of Hormuz, the
- 1:08waterway whose reopening was the explicit condition for the
- 1:10ceasefire to hold, remains largely closed three days after
- 1:14it was supposed to have been reopened immediately, completely
- 1:17and safely. And in 24 hours, the two
- 1:21delegations that have been at war for 42 days will sit across
- 1:23the table in Islamabad and attempt to do in two weeks what
- 1:2640 days of bombing could not agree on what the future of
- 1:30Iran's nuclear program, its regional role and the global
- 1:33energy order is going to look like.
- 1:35This is episode 42 of Epic Fury, the US Iran war podcast.
- 1:41Follow on Spotify, an Apple podcast to stay with this story
- 1:44as it develops. Let's get into it.
- 1:47Start with the Strait. Because it is the ceasefire
- 1:50single, measurable test, and by day 42, it is failing it in ways
- 1:54that the oil market, the shipping industry and the White
- 1:57House have all noticed. Trump's ceasefire announcement
- 2:00on Tuesday night was explicitly conditional on what he called
- 2:03the complete, immediate and safe opening of the Strait of Hormuz
- 2:073 days later. As of Thursday morning, the
- 2:10Strait remains largely closed. Bloomberg confirmed that the
- 2:13straight had not picked up. Beyond the slow trickle of
- 2:16traffic seen throughout the war, 2 bulk carriers carrying dry
- 2:20cargo transited in the immediate hours after the ceasefire.
- 2:24No significant oil tanker movement has resumed.
- 2:28Before the war, between 100 and 120 ships transited daily, the
- 2:33overwhelming majority of them oil tankers.
- 2:35As of Thursday, the figure remains a fraction of that.
- 2:39The reasons for this are multiple and interconnected.
- 2:42Iran has said that safe passage requires coordination with
- 2:45Iran's armed forces and with due consideration of technical
- 2:49limitations, language that shipping companies and their
- 2:51insurers cannot operationalize without knowing what those
- 2:54technical limitations are, who in Iran's military is
- 2:57authorizing individual transits, and what legal liability and
- 3:00physical risk the vessel operators assume if something
- 3:03goes wrong, one shipping executive told CNBC.
- 3:07Plainly, we have no information about how we could transit the
- 3:10Strait of Hormuz during the ceasefire.
- 3:12We are not in contact with Iranian authorities.
- 3:16The most important thing for us is the safety of our crew
- 3:19members. We need absolute guarantees.
- 3:22Insurance premiums remain at war level highs.
- 3:26The underwriting community has assessed the ceasefire as a
- 3:28positive development, but one carrying significant residual
- 3:32risk. Before the war, protection and
- 3:34indemnity insurance for vessels transiting the straight was a
- 3:37routine line item During the war.
- 3:40War risk premiums for the same transit reached 6 year highs,
- 3:43and if their peak were high enough to make the economics of
- 3:46sending a tanker through the straight impossible to justify,
- 3:50even a successful Islamabad session will not immediately
- 3:53change that calculus. Insurers will need days or weeks
- 3:56of demonstrated safe transits before they lower premiums
- 3:59enough for commercial shipping to become viable again at scale.
- 4:03Shipping companies and operators are waiting to see whether the
- 4:05Islamabad talks produce a concrete operational protocol
- 4:09for transit, one with named authorities, defined procedures
- 4:13and enforceable guarantees. Until that protocol exists, the
- 4:17Straight will not reopen in a way that Trump's Tuesday
- 4:19announcement implied. And until the Straight reopens
- 4:22in meaningful volumes, the economic relief the ceasefire
- 4:26was supposed to deliver will remain partial.
- 4:29Oil prices fell 13% on Tuesday night.
- 4:32By Thursday, as the straights continued closure became clear,
- 4:36some of that relief was already beginning to erode.
- 4:39Markets were pricing and the possibility that the Islamabad
- 4:42talks might not produce a rapid and durable Hormuz reopening,
- 4:45that the ceasefire might be a pause in the bombing without
- 4:48being a restoration of the global energy system.
- 4:51The practical arithmetic of the Straight problem is significant.
- 4:55The ceasefire is a two week window.
- 4:58If the Straight requires a concrete operational protocol to
- 5:01be agreed in Islamabad before shipping companies will move,
- 5:04and if that protocol takes several days of negotiation to
- 5:07produce, and if the protocol then takes several more days to
- 5:10communicate to port operators, vessel owners and insurance
- 5:13underwriters, then the actual window of resumed oil flow may
- 5:17be measured in days rather than weeks before the ceasefire
- 5:20expires. A2 week ceasefire that produces
- 5:23four or five days of partial oil flow is not the dramatic
- 5:26economic relief that markets priced in on Tuesday night.
- 5:29It is a brief respite followed by the same uncertainty that
- 5:32will accompany the question of whether the ceasefire is
- 5:35extended. Eurasia Group had already noted
- 5:38that even a successful ceasefire would take months to restore
- 5:41Gulf energy infrastructure. The Straits continued closure 3
- 5:45days and adds to that uncertainty and begins the clock
- 5:48on whether the oil markets initial relief was justified.
- 5:52Tomorrow is Islamabad, the delegations are confirmed.
- 5:56The White House has confirmed JD Vance will lead, joined by
- 5:59special envoy Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner.
- 6:03Secretary of State Marco Rubio will play a supporting role,
- 6:06according to the White House spokeswoman, alongside officials
- 6:09from the National Security Council, State Department and
- 6:12Pentagon. Iran's delegation will be led by
- 6:15parliament Speaker Mohamed Bagar Galabaf and Foreign Minister
- 6:19Abbas Arachi. Islamabad's red zone has been
- 6:22sealed. Shipping containers have been
- 6:24placed across key roads leading to the diplomatic quarter.
- 6:28Hundreds of additional police and paramilitary forces have
- 6:31been deployed. More than 30 international media
- 6:34outlets have submitted visa applications, with at least 20
- 6:38journalists approved. A 30 member US security team
- 6:41arrive in Islamabad on Thursday. The composition of the Iranian
- 6:45delegation is worth examining closely.
- 6:48Abbas Arachi is Iran's foreign minister, a career diplomat, a
- 6:52veteran of the original Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action
- 6:55negotiations, and the man who has been publicly representing
- 6:59Iran throughout the war. He was in the room when the
- 7:01JCPOA was negotiated. He understands the specific
- 7:06technical and political architecture of a nuclear deal.
- 7:09His presence confirms that Iran's civilian foreign ministry
- 7:13has a seat at the table. Muhammad Bagar Galabath is
- 7:16parliament speaker and a former IRGC commander.
- 7:20He commanded the IRGC Air Force. He ran for president multiple
- 7:25times. He lost to Posseschian in the
- 7:27last election, but his political standing within the conservative
- 7:31and military establishment remains considerable.
- 7:34He is hardline, politically powerful, deeply connected to
- 7:38Iran's military establishment, and critically, a man who will
- 7:41report back to the IRGC and a common A about what was agreed
- 7:45in those rooms. His presence alongside Arachi is
- 7:48a deliberate Iranian statement about who is leading.
- 7:51This negotiation is not only the civilian diplomatic
- 7:55establishment. The Irgc's political wing is in
- 7:58the room, and whatever Arachi agrees at the table, Galabaf can
- 8:03either validate or undercut when he returns to Tehran.
- 8:06Whether any active IRGC military representative will attend has
- 8:10not been confirmed. Al Jazeera noted that it is
- 8:13unclear whether any representative from the IRGC,
- 8:16which has been leading Tehran's military response in the war,
- 8:19will attend the talks. That ambiguity is itself
- 8:23significant. The IRGC has been the
- 8:26organization that actually conducted the war.
- 8:29Its commanders decided which targets to strike in the Gulf
- 8:32states. Its commanders manage the Hormuz
- 8:35blockade. Its commanders have been
- 8:37continuing drone operations against Kuwait and the UAE even
- 8:41after the ceasefire was announced.
- 8:43If the IRGC does not have a representative at Islamabad,
- 8:46then any agreement reached in those talks will need to be sold
- 8:49to the IRGC after the fact, a process that has repeatedly
- 8:53failed throughout this conflict. Iranian officials are skeptical
- 8:56about further engagement with Witkoff and Kushner.
- 8:59Specifically, Al Jazeera reported that Iranian officials
- 9:02point to the earlier negotiations with him in Muscat
- 9:05and Geneva in February and how the United States started
- 9:08bombing Iran even as those talks were ongoing.
- 9:11From Tehran's perspective, Witkoff and Kushner are the
- 9:14envoys who shook hands and then bombed Vance's view.
- 9:18Differently. Iranian officials view him as
- 9:21more open to ending the conflict.
- 9:23He has a long track record of skepticism about prolonged U.S.
- 9:27military involvement in the Middle East, positions he
- 9:30articulated publicly before and during his vice presidential
- 9:33campaign. He has positioned himself as
- 9:35cautious about open-ended foreign interventions and spoke
- 9:39more openly than most in the administration about the risks
- 9:42of escalation during the war's early weeks.
- 9:44AP reporting noted that Vance spent much of the past year as
- 9:47more of a background player in the Trump White House, with Elon
- 9:51Musk and Rubio taking turns as ever present presidential
- 9:54advisors. But his portfolio is expanding
- 9:56rapidly, first with a domestic mandate on government efficiency
- 10:01and now with the highest stakes foreign policy assignment in the
- 10:03administration. He's also, in the background of
- 10:06all this, a potential contender for the 2028 Republican
- 10:10presidential nomination. A successful ceasefire
- 10:13negotiation in Islamabad would be an extraordinary addition to
- 10:17that resume. A failed negotiation that leads
- 10:20to resume bombing would be a liability.
- 10:22Whether that political calculation shapes his approach
- 10:25to the talks, whether he pushes harder for a deal than the
- 10:28administration's maximalist public position suggest is the
- 10:31question that the Islamabad sessions will answer.
- 10:34Whether that perception advance is accurate and whether it
- 10:37translates into a negotiating dynamic that produces different
- 10:40outcomes from the pre war Geneva and Muscat channels is the
- 10:44central question about the Islamabad talks that no one
- 10:46outside the rooms can yet answer.
- 10:48There is also a very specific expertise problem for the
- 10:52American side. When Witkoff and Kushner led the
- 10:55pre war nuclear talks in Muscat and Geneva, Democrats and some
- 10:59nuclear experts questioned whether they had enough
- 11:01technical knowledge to negotiate the complex verification
- 11:04arrangements and nuclear deal requires.
- 11:06Nuclear arms control is among the most technically demanding
- 11:10areas of international diplomacy.
- 11:12It is a field with its own vocabulary, its own history of
- 11:16negotiating failures and breakthroughs, and its own
- 11:18community of specialists who have spent careers thinking
- 11:21about centrifuge cascades, enrichment tales, breakout
- 11:24timelines, and the difference between the Additional Protocol
- 11:27and Safeguards agreements. The specific questions at issue
- 11:31in any Islamabad nuclear framework will include how many
- 11:34centrifuges Iran retains and of what type, What maximum
- 11:38enrichment level is permitted for civilian use of any, what
- 11:41inspection access the IEA receives and at what notice
- 11:44period? What happens to Iran's existing
- 11:46enriched uranium stockpiles estimated in the tons of low
- 11:49enriched material? And what timeline and
- 11:52verification mechanism governs the removal of deeply buried
- 11:55nuclear material from Ferdowand other hardened sites?
- 12:00Those questions cannot be answered by political instinct
- 12:03alone. They require expert technical
- 12:05staff, and they require an Iranian counterpart with
- 12:09equivalent technical depth. The White House is not confirmed
- 12:12whether a nuclear expert is part of the US delegation to
- 12:15Islamabad. Iran's delegation includes a
- 12:18foreign minister who negotiated the original JCPOA and a
- 12:22parliament speaker who is a former IRGC aerospace commander.
- 12:26The technical depth gap, if it exists, will matter.
- 12:30Trump's public position on the nuclear question remains firm
- 12:33and public. 0 Enrichment. He said Wednesday that there
- 12:37will be no enrichment of uranium and that the United States will,
- 12:40working with Iran, dig up and remove all of the deeply buried
- 12:44nuclear dust. White House spokeswoman Caroline
- 12:47Leavitt called Iran's enriched uranium a red line that the
- 12:50president is not going to back away from.
- 12:52Iran's position, as stated in its ten point proposal, includes
- 12:56a formal endorsement of Iran's nuclear rights under the NPT,
- 13:00which explicitly includes the right to enrich for peaceful
- 13:03purposes. Those two positions cannot
- 13:05coexist in the same written agreement.
- 13:08But in the history of Iran nuclear diplomacy, seemingly
- 13:11irreconcilable positions have sometimes been bridged by
- 13:14creative ambiguity. Language that each side can
- 13:17present to its own domestic audience is a victory while the
- 13:20technical details are quietly adjusted.
- 13:22Whether Trump's explicit public commitment to 0 enrichment
- 13:25leaves room for that kind of creative ambiguity or whether it
- 13:29forecloses it is the most specific test the nuclear talks
- 13:32will face in Islamabad. At the same time, Levitt made a
- 13:36revealing statement about the negotiating history.
- 13:39She said Iran's original 10 point proposal, the one released
- 13:42publicly by Iranian state media, was literally thrown in the
- 13:46garbage by President Trump and his negotiating team.
- 13:49This is the clearest official American statement yet that the
- 13:5210 point plan Iran has been publicly presenting as the basis
- 13:55for the ceasefire is not the same document that the United
- 13:58States agreed to use as a basis for negotiation.
- 14:01There is, in other words, a gap between what Iran told its own
- 14:04public the ceasefire was based on and what the United States
- 14:07says was actually agreed. That gap between Iran's public
- 14:11facing 10 points and whatever working document Pakistan
- 14:14delivered to Washington is the starting ambiguity that the
- 14:17Islamabad talks must resolve before they can address any of
- 14:20the substantive issues. Arachi has been explicit that
- 14:24Tehran could abandoned the ceasefire if Israeli strikes on
- 14:27Lebanon continue. He said the US must choose
- 14:30between a ceasefire or continued war via Israel.
- 14:33Former Pakistani ambassador to China Masood Khalid told Al
- 14:37Jazeera that the atmosphere had been poisoned before talks even
- 14:41began. He said Israel is playing a
- 14:43spoiler to undermine the process, that it's relentless
- 14:46bombing of Lebanon is designed to trigger further hardening of
- 14:49positions and that at this stage only cautious optimism is
- 14:52warranted. Pakistan has managed an
- 14:55extraordinary diplomatic feat in getting both delegations to
- 14:58Islamabad at all, and it has done so under conditions of
- 15:01exceptional domestic difficulty. When the war began in late
- 15:05February, demonstrations erupted in Karachi and other Pakistani
- 15:09cities. Protesters tried to storm the US
- 15:12consulate in Karachi on March 1st, leaving at least 10 people
- 15:16dead. Pakistan's Shia Muslim
- 15:18population, estimated at 15 to 20% of the country's roughly 250
- 15:24million people, watched the destruction of Iran with
- 15:26particular anguish. Pakistan's army chief Munir,
- 15:30understanding the sectarian pressures, summoned Shia clerics
- 15:33to Rawal Pindi and warned that internal violence would not be
- 15:36tolerated. Simultaneously, Pakistan was
- 15:39managing its own war against the Afghan Taliban in border
- 15:43regions, what officials described as an open war.
- 15:47Al Jazeera's reconstruction of the diplomacy reveals that
- 15:50Pakistan's engagement began almost immediately after the
- 15:53first US Israeli strikes on February 28th.
- 15:57By March 23rd, Pakistan formally offered to host talks.
- 16:01Sharif echoed the offer publicly hours later, tagging Trump,
- 16:05Arachi and Witkoff directly in a social media post.
- 16:09By March 26th, Pakistan had confirmed that the US had shared
- 16:12its 15 point proposal with Iran via the Pakistani intermediary
- 16:16channel. And by Monday, April 6th, Munir
- 16:20was simultaneously in contact with Vance, Witkoff and Arachi,
- 16:24running a two phase ceasefire proposal passed all three.
- 16:28Trump initially rejected it. He set the final deadline and
- 16:32then in the final hours, Munir continued engaging both sides
- 16:36until Sharif's public appeal came with about 5 hours
- 16:39remaining and the breakthrough followed shortly after.
- 16:42Running a high stakes ceasefire mediation between two
- 16:45adversaries while managing an internal security situation of
- 16:48that complexity is a remarkable feat of statecraft and has been
- 16:51LED primarily by one man working through channels that the daily
- 16:55coverage of missile strikes almost entirely missed.
- 16:58The talks begin Saturday morning Islamabad local time.
- 17:02The world's attention, from oil trading desks in London and
- 17:05Singapore to foreign ministries from Berlin to Beijing, will be
- 17:08fixed on whatever comes out of those rooms.
- 17:11Whether Vance and Arachi find enough common ground on Lebanon
- 17:14to prevent Iran from walking out in the first session is the
- 17:17first Test. Whether the nuclear question is
- 17:20deferred to a later phase or confronted immediately is the
- 17:232nd. Whether Galabaf's present
- 17:26signals IRGC buy in or simply IRGC surveillance of the
- 17:30civilian negotiators is the third.
- 17:32Whether the Hormuz operational protocol that shipping companies
- 17:35need can be agreed in time to allow real oil flow before the
- 17:39two week ceasefire window expires is the 4th.
- 17:42Analyst Masood Khalid, a former Pakistani ambassador, has said
- 17:46only cautious optimism is warranted and that the talks
- 17:49would surely be complicated and cumbersome and may need to be
- 17:52extended beyond the 15 day deadline.
- 17:54King's College analyst Andrew Krieg noted that Iran has to
- 17:57ensure Israel has no easy way to return to its mowing the lawn
- 18:01approach, the pattern of periodic military campaigns
- 18:04against Lebanon that Israel has conducted repeatedly in recent
- 18:07decades. If the Islamabad talks produce
- 18:10only a nuclear framework, without addressing Lebanon, Iran
- 18:14will be right to conclude that the ceasefire served Israeli
- 18:16interests more than Iranian once.
- 18:19Whether that conclusion leads Tehran to walk out or to
- 18:21continue negotiating under protest is the diplomatic
- 18:24unknown. That Saturday morning will begin
- 18:26to answer back in Washington. The domestic political
- 18:30environment surrounding the Islamabad talks is complex.
- 18:33Trump is in a maximalist communication posture, publicly
- 18:37claiming near total agreement with Iran, describing the golden
- 18:40age of the Middle East, warning that any violation will be met
- 18:44with serious consequences. His approval rating, which had
- 18:47reached its lowest point of his second term before the
- 18:49ceasefire, has begun recovering on the strength of the F15 E
- 18:53rescue and the ceasefire announcement itself.
- 18:56Gas prices at the pump are beginning to soften slightly as
- 18:59oil markets price and eventual Hormuz reopening.
- 19:02The political incentive for Trump is to have Islamabad
- 19:05succeed, to announce a historic deal, lower gas prices, and
- 19:09declare that Operation Epic Fury achieved every objective before
- 19:13handing the region to diplomacy. That is, the outcome he is
- 19:16publicly framing is all but inevitable.
- 19:19The political risk is that Islamabad fails, that Iran walks
- 19:23out over Lebanon, or that the nuclear gap proves unbridgeable,
- 19:26or that the IRGC continues operations against Gulf states
- 19:30in a way that makes continued American restraint politically
- 19:33untenable. If the ceasefire collapses and
- 19:36bombing continues, gas prices spike again.
- 19:39The war that it seemed to be winding down starts another
- 19:41cycle of escalation, and the political benefit of the rescue
- 19:45and the ceasefire announcement evaporates.
- 19:47That scenario is the one that Vance is being sent to Islamabad
- 19:50to prevent. Chuck Schumer's War Powers
- 19:53Resolution, which Senate Democrats have pledged to force
- 19:56on the floor when Congress returns, laying over the talks
- 19:59as a reminder that the war is congressional authorization,
- 20:02remains legally contested. If the Islamabad talks fail and
- 20:06bombing continues, that vote becomes more urgent and its
- 20:09outcome less predictable. The political clock for both
- 20:12sides, Trump facing the midterm environment that Schumer is
- 20:16already pointing at, and Iran's supreme leader managing a
- 20:19population that was told the war's objectives were achieved,
- 20:22is running in parallel with a diplomatic clock.
- 20:25Both expire at the same time when the two weeks ceasefire
- 20:29window closes. If this podcast is helping you
- 20:31make sense of what is happening, please take 30 seconds to leave
- 20:35a review on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
- 20:38It makes an enormous difference to how many people find a show.
- 20:41This has been episode 42 of Epic Fury, the US Iran war podcast.
- 20:47Day 42. The straight is still largely
- 20:50closed. The Islamabad red zone is
- 20:53sealed. Vance, Witkoff and Kushner are
- 20:57in the air. Arachi and Galabaf are expected.
- 21:00The delegations arrived carrying contradictory narratives about
- 21:04who won the war, incompatible positions on Lebanon and the
- 21:07nuclear question, and deep mutual distrust forged in 42
- 21:11days of bombing retaliation and failed deadlines.
- 21:14The hardest diplomatic work of this war begins tomorrow
- 21:17morning, and this podcast will be here for all of it.
- 21:21We will be back very soon.