Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Ten Tips for Client Trust Accounting Compliance: What Every California Attorney Needs to Know
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, good morning and welcome to 10 tips for
- 0:06client trust accounting compliance. What every
- 0:08California needs to know. I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:12our speaker today, Christine Roscoff. Christine
- 0:15Roscoff brings nearly three decades of experience
- 0:18as senior counsel at Roseng, Pot & Strobin. Miss
- 0:22Roscoff's practice focuses on professional liability,
- 0:25ethics, and risk management law. Ms. Roscoff
- 0:28was previously trial counsel at the State Bar
- 0:30of California. Now let's get started. Good morning.
- 0:40Welcome everyone and thank you for the introduction.
- 0:44You are in 10 facts about client trust accounting.
- 0:48And as was mentioned in the introduction, I currently
- 0:52do ethics defense work for the state bar, both
- 0:55for attorneys before the state bar and judges
- 0:58before the Commission on Judicial Performance.
- 1:01I also assist sort of an on -call basis, attorneys
- 1:06and law firms with ethics questions. So informally,
- 1:11I was a prosecutor for the State Bar. So I've
- 1:14been on both sides of these issues. So let's
- 1:18get started. So why client trust accounting and
- 1:22why 10 facts? I created this program. It's a
- 1:26very basic... 10 basic facts about client trust
- 1:32accounting. And I felt that there was a need
- 1:35to get this basic because I found when I was
- 1:42both at the state bar and in advising clients
- 1:45that People get some of the real basics wrong
- 1:50and that's no fault of theirs. I think a lot
- 1:53of people approach client trust accounting as
- 1:55you know, I'm an honest person. I have no intent
- 1:58of stealing clients money. I You know want to
- 2:03handle it appropriately and carefully and they
- 2:06just approach it very logically and unfortunately
- 2:09some of the client trust accounting rules aren't
- 2:11particularly logical. They don't, things that
- 2:15you think would be okay well that makes perfect
- 2:17sense end up being violations when it comes to
- 2:20client trust accounting. So I thought it would
- 2:23be a good just let's get back to basics and get
- 2:25down to some basic facts. So why should we care?
- 2:30Why is this so important? As you can see in your
- 2:32materials Fine and trust account violations are
- 2:37some of the easiest violations for the state
- 2:39bar prosecutors to prove. They are also come
- 2:44with some of the most severe discipline when
- 2:47there are violations. Even first -time offenders
- 2:50can be given long suspensions or even disbarments
- 2:54when they are found to have mishandled client
- 2:56funds. I've added a couple of state bar cases
- 3:00in the materials if you're interested in reading
- 3:03them, where what seems like not innocent activity
- 3:12but not super severe, would seem to be super
- 3:16severe activity, resulted in really severe consequences
- 3:19for attorneys. I added the State Bar cases because
- 3:22I'm aware people who don't do State Bar work
- 3:25have a little bit of difficulty locating State
- 3:29Bar material. State Bar Court has its own court,
- 3:32obviously. It has its own court reporter. Although
- 3:35the reporter is available on the State Bar Court's
- 3:39website. It can be difficult to locate and doing
- 3:44research in state bar court cases can be cumbersome
- 3:47for people who aren't familiar. So those are
- 3:50in your materials if you're interested in reading
- 3:51them. So let's get into the facts. Fact number
- 3:55one, there is a client trust account mandate.
- 3:58If you hold any funds for a client's benefit,
- 4:01you are required to hold that in a trust account.
- 4:04That's mandatory. That's the rule of professional
- 4:06conduct 1 .15. And rule 1 .15, it's a very long
- 4:11rule. I've included it in your materials. It
- 4:14really lays out for you all of the rules about
- 4:17client trust accounting that you're gonna need
- 4:19to know. What's included in client funds? Obvious
- 4:24ones are cost retainers, fee deposits, settlement
- 4:28proceeds. What about other assets? If you're
- 4:33a family law attorney and your client sells the
- 4:38family residence, they may ask you to hold those
- 4:40proceeds for them in trust. pending an ultimate
- 4:45distribution of assets. If you are doing plaintiff's
- 4:49work and you've got someone who perhaps is a
- 4:51minor and receives a large settlement, sometimes
- 4:54the attorney will be asked to hold the settlement
- 4:56proceeds in trust until the minor reaches the
- 5:00age of majority, those sorts of situations. You
- 5:05are required to hold those funds in trust. You
- 5:08can't just put them in your business operating
- 5:09account. Sometimes you're also asked to hold
- 5:13other property in trust. That would be things
- 5:16like jewelry, art, manuscripts, firearms. You
- 5:21can be asked to hold all sorts of things for
- 5:23a client. If you find yourself in that situation,
- 5:27you don't just throw it into a desk drawer. Make
- 5:29a written record of Not just what you received,
- 5:34but how you received it, the date, the time,
- 5:37whether it was hand delivered, whether you received
- 5:39it in the mail, through a messenger, as much
- 5:41detail as possible. Describe the item. label
- 5:45it with the client's identifying, the client's
- 5:48name, the client's account number, any other
- 5:50information that might be necessary, and you
- 5:53put it somewhere safe. That doesn't mean a desk
- 5:55drawer. That can be a bank safe deposit box.
- 5:59It can be a safe in your office. It can be a
- 6:02locked cabinet. Just don't put it somewhere where
- 6:05it is openly available to other people. That
- 6:10is the first fact, that there is a mandate about
- 6:14holding things in trust for a client. Fact number
- 6:17two, you need to choose your account type. There
- 6:22are actually two different types of client trust
- 6:25accounts, and I want to get the nomenclature
- 6:28here clear, and this is just me being a former
- 6:31prosecutor. People get the names of the accounts
- 6:35mixed up a lot. Client trust account is the general
- 6:39term for any account in which you are holding
- 6:42client funds. Under that umbrella of a client
- 6:46trust account, there are two. There's the client,
- 6:47the dedicated account and the IOLTA. All IOLTAs
- 6:52are client trust accounts, but not all client
- 6:54trust accounts are IOLTAs. Let me do the dedicated
- 7:00accounts first. They're less common. but they
- 7:04can trip people up maybe because they are less
- 7:06common. The dedicated accounts are used for either
- 7:10a single client or a single matter, a single
- 7:13asset. The account must be interest bearing.
- 7:17The interest goes to the client. The client account
- 7:21must, the account name must clearly indicate
- 7:25that it's a trust account. And the financial
- 7:28institution, and this is very important, the
- 7:30financial institution needs to link the account
- 7:33to the clients, not the attorneys, either social
- 7:38security number or tax ID number. I've seen this
- 7:41happen. An attorney was asked to hold funds that
- 7:44was at issue in a transaction. He put it into
- 7:48certificates of deposit. He did segregate it
- 7:50because it was a large amount. It was going to
- 7:52be held for quite a while. And he thought it
- 7:55would be helpful for the client to put it into
- 7:57a certificate of deposit because it was going
- 7:59to earn higher interest than a regular savings
- 8:01account. He initially the bank put his name on
- 8:06it. He did catch that quickly and chain had them
- 8:10change it, which they did. Unfortunately, the
- 8:13bank linked the tax ID number to his business
- 8:17account, not to the clients. And what happened,
- 8:20of course, at the end of the year, when the interest,
- 8:22which was supposed to go to the client and actually
- 8:25did technically go to the client. in tax forms
- 8:29was reported as his earned interest and it created
- 8:32a mess that he needed to unwind and deal with.
- 8:35So be very careful when you're setting these
- 8:37up, that it is set up truly as the client's tax
- 8:41ID number, not yours. The other type of account
- 8:46is the one that everyone's more familiar with,
- 8:48the IOLTA. IOLTA is an acronym. It stands for
- 8:51Interest on Lawyers' Trust Accounts. The IOLTA
- 8:55is an aggregated account You hold funds from
- 8:58multiple clients into a single account and the
- 9:02hallmark of this type of account is that the
- 9:05interest earned on those funds goes to the State
- 9:08Bar of California. It does not go to the clients
- 9:12and God forbid it doesn't go to you. It is reported
- 9:16to the... At the end of the month, the bank automatically
- 9:21transfers all interest earned for that month
- 9:23to the State Bar of California. The State Bar
- 9:26of California earmarks those funds for programs
- 9:30related to access to justice. This is not considered
- 9:34a taking. It's not unconstitutional. It's been
- 9:36tested and it is constitutionally permitted.
- 9:41It's a program that's been going on for quite
- 9:43a long time. Notwithstanding how long this program
- 9:46has been in effect, I've actually had a client
- 9:49who had an old aggregated trust account that
- 9:52was not an IOLTA. It wasn't set up as an IOLTA,
- 9:56and the interest was actually going to the client.
- 9:58It wasn't going to the state bar. It created
- 10:00problems. When you think of an IOLTA, I would
- 10:07like you to get a picture in your mind. of a
- 10:11bunch of small savings accounts, each one with
- 10:16a client's name on it. And they're all just huddled
- 10:18together in this one room. And each of these
- 10:21accounts is inside this larger IOTA account called
- 10:25the IOTA Room. That will be helpful later when
- 10:29we're talking about misappropriations and balancing
- 10:33the accounts. Which account to choose sometimes
- 10:38people have questions okay do i put this in an
- 10:40old or do i put this into a dedicated client
- 10:44account. The general rule is administration costs
- 10:48exceed potential interest for the client use
- 10:51the old side of the case here where this was
- 10:53the conversation. Generally, if it's going to
- 10:59cost more to administer a dedicated client account,
- 11:03so if the bank charges are going to be higher
- 11:05and just administrative costs generally are going
- 11:08to be more than the account earns, then... generally
- 11:13it's okay to keep it in the IOLTA. Keep in mind
- 11:16there are going to be situations where even if
- 11:18it's a little bit more expensive or more cumbersome,
- 11:21the client's going to request that they have
- 11:24a dedicated account for their funds and you should
- 11:28work to honor that request and not put it in
- 11:30the IOLTA in those situations. All client trust
- 11:35accounts must be maintained in California unless
- 11:37there is a substantial relationship between the
- 11:40client or their business and the other jurisdiction
- 11:43where the funds are held. This rarely, rarely
- 11:46comes up. I don't know that I've ever had a situation
- 11:49where someone was holding the funds in a non
- 11:51-California account. Usually the question is,
- 11:55Is it okay to use a credit union? Is it okay
- 11:58to use a national bank or does it need to be
- 12:01a local bank? As far as the national banks go,
- 12:05as long as they've got a local branch and the
- 12:08funds are quote unquote managed by the local
- 12:10branch, that's okay. The credit unions usually
- 12:15are also okay. The state bar of California maintains
- 12:20a list of what they call IOLTA eligible. accounts.
- 12:24If you have any question about whether or not
- 12:27a bank that you're planning to do business with
- 12:29does have an IOLTA eligible status, you can ask
- 12:34the state bar. I've put the who to contact in
- 12:39your materials. It's bankingcompliance at calbar
- 12:43.ca .gov. What constitutes an IOLTA eligible
- 12:48bank? I can tell you generally The banks that
- 12:53are IOLTA eligible have agreed to certain compliance
- 12:56issues. One is, of course, the transfer of that
- 13:01interest to that State Bar dedicated account.
- 13:05They've agreed to do that. They also agree to
- 13:08comply with the rules relating to bank reports,
- 13:11which we'll get to later. But basically, they
- 13:14agree to... notify the State Bar of California
- 13:19of certain activity in the IOLTA account. So
- 13:23those are pretty much the basics. There are also
- 13:25some level of interest related issues with the
- 13:32IOLTA eligible accounts. Generally speaking,
- 13:35any bank that you're planning to deal with, most
- 13:38credit unions are all going to be IOLTA eligible,
- 13:41and it shouldn't be a problem. Of course, we're
- 13:45all aware, and this is a whole nother MCLE program.
- 13:50There is a CTAP compliance required. It's going
- 13:54to be required at the end of March this year.
- 13:57You are supposed to report all client trust accounts.
- 14:01That's both IOTA and non -IOTA. So if you've
- 14:04got dedicated client trust accounts, those two
- 14:06are supposed to be reported to the state bar
- 14:08annually. There's actually another rule somewhere
- 14:11that says within 30 days of the creation of the
- 14:14account, or if there's a change to the account,
- 14:15if it's closed, it's supposed to be 30 days,
- 14:18but there is sort of this catch -all. There's
- 14:23a California rule of court 9 .85 that says, at
- 14:27least annually, you are supposed to update the
- 14:29state bar on your client trust accounts. And
- 14:33that is covered these days by your CTAP compliance.
- 14:38Next fact, the danger is danger in commingling.
- 14:42The whole point of commingling the concept is
- 14:45you should never be mixing personal funds with
- 14:48client funds. Think of them as opposite magnets
- 14:52that repel one another. They really should never
- 14:55be held in a client trust account together. There
- 14:59is one very small exception. That is you may
- 15:04maintain a cushion amount in your client trust
- 15:08account. Whether it's an ulta or a dedicated
- 15:11client account to cover bank fees That can be
- 15:15your own business your money or your business's
- 15:18money That is truly a relatively de minimis amount.
- 15:22We're talking ten twenty dollars a month We are
- 15:26not talking as I had one client do Keep twenty
- 15:29thousand dollars in that account as a cushion
- 15:31Because he wanted the assurance that he was never
- 15:33going to bounce a check out of that account That's
- 15:36too much the account. you cannot hold your own
- 15:41funds in the account. The reason for that is
- 15:44the account, the client trust accounts, because
- 15:47they're trust accounts, they are protected from
- 15:49your creditors because they're not your assets.
- 15:53The trust accounts are considered the client's
- 15:56assets, not yours. They're not assets of your
- 15:58firm. I did have an attorney who went applying
- 16:01for a line of credit for his business on the
- 16:05application, listed the client trust account.
- 16:08as an asset and of course the client trust account
- 16:11had a fairly significant balance because there
- 16:14were settlement funds and retainer funds in there.
- 16:17The attorney obtained the line of credit and
- 16:22was defaulted on his payments and the lender
- 16:28then turned around and pulled money electronically
- 16:32out of the client trust account. It was out of
- 16:36the IOLTA for payment of its line of credit,
- 16:41triggering obviously a bunch of bounced checks,
- 16:44a bunch of bank reports, and some serious discipline
- 16:47for the attorney. It all went back to that basic
- 16:50idea that you shouldn't have put this account
- 16:54on your list of assets because it's not your
- 16:56asset. The state bar gets very upset if you've
- 17:00got your own funds in an account, you're holding
- 17:02your own funds in an account like that and for
- 17:05instance, you may be going through a divorce
- 17:07or you may be having creditor issues or tax authorities
- 17:11are looking for funds and you've parked 20 ,000
- 17:15or more dollars into an IOTA. There are going
- 17:18to be consequences for that. Also regarding co
- 17:23-mingling, these are mistakes I see a lot. Mistakes
- 17:28do happen, and what you really want to do is
- 17:31make sure that you've taken some precautions.
- 17:35Make sure that the deposit slips for your IOLTA.
- 17:39look different than they do for your regular
- 17:42business operating account. Make sure the checks
- 17:44are a different color. If you've got red checks
- 17:47for your IOLTA or your client trust accounts,
- 17:51and you have green checks for your business operating
- 17:53accounts, give yourself that extra little visual
- 17:56because mistakes do happen. People grab the wrong
- 17:59checkbook, they grab the wrong deposit slip,
- 18:01and then you've got a situation. trap for the
- 18:08unwary, a lot of banks just automatically issue
- 18:11debit cards for any of their accounts. If you
- 18:16have received a debit card for your client trust
- 18:19account, whether it's a dedicated account or
- 18:22an AOLTA, don't use... Don't use a debit card
- 18:25on that account. You're just asking for problems.
- 18:28You don't have the paper trail that you need
- 18:30with traditional deposit withdrawal slips. You're
- 18:33going to be walking around with a debit card
- 18:35in your pocket and grab the wrong card and pull
- 18:39money out for something that's, you know, personal.
- 18:43I have seen attorneys pay for gasoline, pay for
- 18:47groceries out of the client trust account because
- 18:49they were using a debit card inadvertently and
- 18:53it created all sorts of problems. So just take
- 18:56some precautions up front. Next fact, the overdraft
- 19:02red flag for misappropriation. One of the hallmarks
- 19:07of an IOLTA eligible account. is that they will
- 19:11report to the state bar when there is an overdraft
- 19:14on the account. It's an automatic bank report.
- 19:18And it does not matter whether the overdraft
- 19:21was honored or not. Say you've got a check that
- 19:24has insufficient funds. Sometimes if you've got
- 19:26a great relationship with your bank, they'll
- 19:28go ahead and pay the check. They'll honor the
- 19:30check. They won't bounce it. But then they'll,
- 19:33of course, put the bank account into the negative
- 19:37because they They paid the check. They honored
- 19:40the check. Alternatively, they may bounce the
- 19:43check, in which case you're like, well, there
- 19:44was never a negative balance. It was bounced.
- 19:46They'll still report those to the State Bar.
- 19:50They get reported directly to the Office of Chief
- 19:52Trial Counsel, which is the discipline arm of
- 19:56the State Bar. Depending on the amount, other
- 19:59than the most de minimis and the first time it
- 20:03happens, If it's anything more than literally
- 20:08just a few dollars, it's going to trigger a state
- 20:11bar investigation. Now, you may not even be aware
- 20:13that there's a state bar investigation. You may
- 20:16not even be aware that this happened. Hopefully,
- 20:17you'll know at least by the end of the month.
- 20:20If not sooner, you'll get a notice from the bank.
- 20:24But at least at the end of the month when you're
- 20:25doing your reconciliation, you'll discover this.
- 20:28But you may not be aware that the state bar is
- 20:30investigating. And depending on the amount, the
- 20:34state bar may actually even issue subpoena to
- 20:36your bank to get records for your client trust
- 20:40account. And you may not even be aware that any
- 20:43of this is happening. So be aware that that is
- 20:48something that happens. If you are aware that
- 20:50there has been an overdraft, keep an eye on your
- 20:53email for a message from the state bar because
- 20:55you're very likely to get one. The reason the
- 20:59state bar is so I'm keen on finding out quickly
- 21:04whether or not a client trust account has gone
- 21:11into the red or has had any sort of an overdraft,
- 21:13even if it's cured quickly, is because it's a
- 21:16red flag for misappropriation. We'll get to misappropriation
- 21:19in a moment. The misappropriation is the theft
- 21:22or taking of client funds. It's probably one
- 21:26of the most serious ethical violations someone
- 21:30can make as far as the state bar is concerned.
- 21:33It is taken incredibly seriously for obvious
- 21:35reasons. It undermines public confidence in the
- 21:38legal profession and when found misappropriation
- 21:41merits some of the most severe discipline that
- 21:44the state bar can med out. Next fact, balance
- 21:49dip. If a client trust account is being managed
- 21:52properly, There should never be a reason for
- 21:55the account balance to fall below the total amount
- 21:58owed to all clients, meaning the amount owed,
- 22:01meaning the amount being held for the benefit
- 22:03of all clients. This gets back to my little visual
- 22:06of individual accounts, right? So if you've got
- 22:11a bunch of client funds, you can't sort of...
- 22:16even though it is held as an aggregate, you still
- 22:18have to think of it in terms of individual accounts
- 22:22for each client. And the reason for this is you
- 22:25can't borrow from one client to pay for another
- 22:33client. And I'll show you where this happens
- 22:37frequently. You have a settlement check coming
- 22:42in. You know your clients very excited about
- 22:45the settlement. They want the funds immediately
- 22:47And you're figuring well, I have got plenty of
- 22:51funds in the client trust account to cover and
- 22:55I will just write the check because I know that
- 22:58when the settlement funds come in or either when
- 23:01the check clears It'll all be fine. It'll all
- 23:03come out in the end That's technically a balance
- 23:06dip because you have technically used a different
- 23:10client's funds to write that check to the client
- 23:12because their funds haven't cleared yet. And
- 23:15that is considered a misappropriation. It happens
- 23:17more frequently than you think. So what you need
- 23:20to do, it's a good idea to manage client expectations
- 23:23at the front end and let them know that they
- 23:26are going to, you know, when settlement funds
- 23:29come in, there's going to be a delay. until those
- 23:33funds actually clear and are available. If you've
- 23:36been working with your bank, you generally know
- 23:38whether it's a five -day hold, sometimes a 10
- 23:40-day hold. You need to manage your clients' expectations
- 23:44and make them aware of that. And it's very tempting
- 23:47to want, you know, everybody's excited. You want
- 23:49to write the check and say, here you go. We know
- 23:51you've been waiting for this. Don't use other
- 23:53clients' funds to pay one of your clients. Let's
- 24:00see. What about overdraft protection? Overdraft
- 24:05protection is when a bank offers a program that
- 24:10is designed to assist you in the event that there
- 24:14is an inadvertent overdraft on your account.
- 24:17It's just technically it's considered a loan
- 24:19and the programs take two forms. They will either
- 24:23in the event of an overdraft transfer an amount
- 24:26equal to the amount of the overdraft into your
- 24:29account, and then basically you're required to
- 24:32pay that back. Or they will transfer funds in
- 24:37increments, whether it's $100, $500 increments,
- 24:41whenever there's an overdraft. There is actually
- 24:44an ethics opinion on this. It's Corpac opinion
- 24:502005 -169. It's in your materials. If the bank
- 24:56has the former, where the amount transferred
- 25:00is exactly the amount of the overdraft, it's
- 25:03not considered co -mingling. If, however, the
- 25:07bank has a program where they transfer increments,
- 25:13then technically the amount of the quote -unquote
- 25:16loan that they're giving you, those are your
- 25:18funds that you've borrowed, and then if they've
- 25:20put it into the IOLTA as part of their program,
- 25:24You have now your own funds commingled with client
- 25:29funds in that trust account. The second one is
- 25:33a commingling. The first one is allowed. Frankly,
- 25:36if you are managing your client trust account
- 25:38carefully, there really should be... Honestly,
- 25:42no reason to overdraft, although I understand
- 25:44mistakes do happen. It's probably a good idea
- 25:47not to have overdraft protection. If you want
- 25:50it and want to take advantage of it just in case
- 25:53there's a mistake or an error, just make sure
- 25:57you understand your bank's program and how it
- 25:59works. Otherwise, you're going to get yourself
- 26:02into trouble when logically you're trying to
- 26:05do something that simply makes sense. Next fact,
- 26:12transparency and subpoenas. I mentioned earlier
- 26:16that when the state bar gets a bank report, they
- 26:19may issue a subpoena. When you became a member
- 26:23of the bar, you automatically agreed to allow
- 26:29the State Bar of California access to any client
- 26:33trust account you are holding. They don't need
- 26:36to ask your permission. They don't need to have
- 26:38good cause. They don't even need to tell you
- 26:40they're doing it. They can issue a subpoena for
- 26:42any client trust account that they're aware of
- 26:45that you've reported and access those bank records.
- 26:49They will not necessarily tell you that they
- 26:51are issuing the subpoena. They will, they're
- 26:54supposed to tell you once they've received the
- 26:56records. They will tell you that they have received
- 26:59bank records, but they do not tell you in advance.
- 27:02That is for the client trust account only, for
- 27:05the dedicated accounts. as well as the IOTAs.
- 27:08You've already given them that permission, although
- 27:11you may not have known it. Contrast that to your
- 27:15business operating account. If after reviewing
- 27:19your client trust account, the state bar has
- 27:23questions about maybe transfers that have gone
- 27:25back and forth and they want to see the records
- 27:29for the bank operating account. They can subpoena
- 27:32those, however, they need to show good cause,
- 27:36and I can tell you that that's a very low threshold
- 27:39when you're talking about regulatory agency and
- 27:41potential mishandling of client funds, so that's
- 27:45a pretty easy bar. But they do, in the case of
- 27:50your business operating account, they are required
- 27:52to give you advance notice. So you do have an
- 27:55opportunity to object. I can tell you. Unless
- 28:00it's very unusual circumstances, an objection
- 28:05is rarely ever going to be successful. The state
- 28:12bar has rather strong powers as far as monitoring
- 28:17client trust accounts. Obviously, this is an
- 28:20important issue for them. More so even now, recently,
- 28:25than it has been in the past, and they are very
- 28:27aggressive when they are investigating any potential
- 28:32client trust account issues. So just be aware
- 28:36that they will be asking not just for bank statements,
- 28:40they will get signature cards, they will ask
- 28:44for deposit slips, canceled checks, and wire
- 28:49transfer information. They will get all of that,
- 28:52especially with the canceled checks. They can
- 28:54get a lot of information about the memo lines
- 28:56and the endorsements off the back of those canceled
- 29:00checks. Those are the documents they're going
- 29:03to be looking at. They will not give you a copy
- 29:05if you ask for it. They may as a courtesy, but
- 29:09I have on occasion asked for copies and they've
- 29:12said, no, you should have these anyway. If you
- 29:16don't have them yourself, you have to go back
- 29:17to the bank. The standard for most investigators,
- 29:20they'll get three months. Um, when I was at the
- 29:24state bar and I was working with investigators,
- 29:27I used to ask them to get six months just because
- 29:29it happened so frequently that I get three and
- 29:33three just wasn't enough to be able to track
- 29:35some money that had come in. The money had come
- 29:37in before then. So I used to ask them for six,
- 29:40but it's, it's usually three months that they'll
- 29:43get at least at the beginning. Um, okay. Timeline
- 29:50for funds. These are new rules as of January
- 29:541st of 2023. I think people should be more aware
- 29:57of them now. Once you receive funds on behalf
- 30:01of a client, it used to be that you needed to
- 30:04notify the client promptly. And I'll get to this,
- 30:07but it's not just the client, anyone with an
- 30:10interest in those funds. So the client and any
- 30:12lien holders. The rules changed. This is rule
- 30:161 .15d1, which is in your materials. It's now
- 30:2114 days. So when you get funds in, you have 14
- 30:26days to notify the client, if there are medical
- 30:31lien holders, if they've got perhaps a litigation
- 30:34funding lender. who has a lien on any funds coming
- 30:38in, if there's a prior attorney that has a charging
- 30:41lien. All of them need to be notified that the
- 30:44funds, you've received funds on behalf of this
- 30:47client. The rule technically does not say, I
- 30:51don't believe it says in writing, but obviously
- 30:53anytime you're dealing with anything along these
- 30:56lines, do it in writing, even if it's just an
- 30:59email, but do it in writing so you have proof
- 31:02that you complied with this requirement. Likewise,
- 31:08we now have clarification on the timeline for
- 31:12distribution of client funds. It used to again
- 31:15be promptly, it is now 45 days for undisputed
- 31:20funds. So what are undisputed funds? Undisputed
- 31:24funds are funds where the ownership interest
- 31:28is fixed. This trips people up and it results
- 31:32in a lot of questions. Say you've got a settlement
- 31:37that has come in, personal injury settlement,
- 31:41it's $100 ,000. And your fee is 40%. And then
- 31:49you have a prior attorney with a charging lien.
- 31:53You've already worked out with that prior attorney
- 31:55that you're going to split 50 -50. So as soon
- 31:58as the money comes in, the attorney's fees portion,
- 32:02the 40 % of that, fixed there shouldn't be any
- 32:06dispute about that you should pull out that money
- 32:10within the first 45 days and distribute it to
- 32:13yourself and to your other to the prior attorney
- 32:16with the charging lien 50 -50 that is undisputed
- 32:20the remainder the remainder 60 ,000 say there
- 32:24is a medical lien the amount of the medical lien
- 32:27right now I'm gonna have to write this down so
- 32:30I don't screw up my math The amount of the medical
- 32:33lien is $40 ,000, but that's the maximum amount.
- 32:35You haven't negotiated down that lien yet, but
- 32:38you know it's at least $40 ,000. You know it's
- 32:41going to take maybe a couple of months to negotiate
- 32:45that, so it's not a fixed amount. But you do
- 32:49know that the $20 ,000 left over is undisputed
- 32:54and that should go to the client. So within the
- 32:5745 days, you should ... distribute the 20 ,000
- 33:01that's undisputed to the client, hold back the
- 33:0440 while you negotiate the medical lien. Once
- 33:07the medical lien is negotiated, say you do an
- 33:10amazing job, you negotiate it down to 10 ,000.
- 33:14You distribute the 10 ,000 to the medical lien
- 33:16holder and the remaining 30 ,000 to the client
- 33:19because that's now undisputed and everyone's
- 33:22got their full amounts. Obviously, you prepare
- 33:26a written accounting. to the client, a final
- 33:29accounting that lists everything, all the money
- 33:32that came in, all the money that went out, and
- 33:34where it all went. Those are, if you've got any
- 33:38questions about that, I get a lot of questions
- 33:41about when funds can be released, when they need
- 33:43to be held. Definitely either look at the rules,
- 33:50I'll give you some resources at the end of the
- 33:52program that would also be helpful. call counsel
- 33:56or you call the ethics hotline at the state bar,
- 34:00they may be able to help you if you've got any
- 34:02questions. That's where a lot of people get tripped
- 34:06up is how long to hold things, when to hold things.
- 34:10Now if your client says, I don't want piecemeal
- 34:12checks, I want to check one time, maybe it's
- 34:14the end of the year, they're trying to, you know,
- 34:17when the funds come in. If they want you to hold
- 34:21the funds longer than 45 days, you can hold the
- 34:24funds longer than 45 days, but get it in writing.
- 34:27Always get it in writing to cover yourself so
- 34:30that you can say, I'm holding these for a reason.
- 34:34I had one client whose client received a large
- 34:39settlement and she was concerned that she was
- 34:43going to spend it all at once and wanted it sort
- 34:47of distributed um periodically and so my client
- 34:55unfortunately this was just an agreement they
- 34:59had and didn't get it in writing and there were
- 35:01issues later what my client should have done
- 35:03it's okay to do that what my client should have
- 35:06done was get in writing from the client i want
- 35:09you to continue holding this please continue
- 35:11holding these funds for me In that case, it would
- 35:15have been fine and my client could have distributed
- 35:18it per the client's request without having problems.
- 35:21You can never assume that there isn't going to
- 35:22be some dispute down the road, even if everyone's
- 35:26getting along fine at the beginning. So that's
- 35:30fact number... The other thing, there are sometimes
- 35:36questions about the charging lanes, meaning if
- 35:39there's multiple attorneys and you've got a prior
- 35:40counsel and there's a dispute over the split
- 35:44on the attorney's fees. There is a recent ethics
- 35:48opinion that's helpful because we needed some
- 35:50guidance on this. It came out from the LA County
- 35:53Bar Association's Professional Responsibility
- 35:55and Ethics Committee. It's opinion number 534.
- 36:00I think it came out in October or November of
- 36:04last year. And I included it in your materials.
- 36:06So if you find yourself in that situation, if
- 36:08that's something that is familiar in your practice,
- 36:12you may want to take a look at that. It gives
- 36:13you some guidelines. Fact number eight, required
- 36:18record keeping. Okay, there are three records.
- 36:23that the state bar requires you maintain relating
- 36:26to your client trust account. And I can tell
- 36:28you virtually no one does this correctly. So
- 36:35after today, you're going to do this correctly.
- 36:38The three records are your client ledger, your
- 36:41trust account journal, and your monthly, and
- 36:44proof of your monthly reconciliation. Okay, the
- 36:47client ledger, if you go back to that visual,
- 36:50in the IALTA, you've got a bunch of smaller,
- 36:53separate client accounts. Each of those individual
- 36:59savings accounts needs to have its own ledger,
- 37:02just like a bank ledger. Money coming in, money
- 37:05coming out. plus, minus, back, forth. Every client
- 37:10for whom you are holding funds, you are required
- 37:14to maintain an individual client ledger. It tracks
- 37:17every transaction per client, costs that are
- 37:21spent on behalf of that particular client, funds
- 37:24that have come in for that client. You need to
- 37:29maintain this both for an IOT, for each client
- 37:32whose money is being held in an IOTA, but also
- 37:35maintain it for the dedicated client account.
- 37:40Think of it as a record of each client's little
- 37:43savings account, and you're going to have a bunch
- 37:45of them. Depending on how many clients you have,
- 37:47you've got 20 clients, you'll have at least 20
- 37:50client ledgers. Okay, the next document is a
- 37:54trust account journal. This is a master record
- 37:58of all bank activity. If you use a program like
- 38:02Quicken, I think Clio has one, they all have
- 38:08an overall journal of all bank activity that
- 38:13goes in and out of your trust accounts. And that
- 38:20record needs to be maintained separately from
- 38:23individual Ledgers and getting back to the ledger.
- 38:28I have had clients who don't keep separate ledgers,
- 38:31but they use their invoices because on their
- 38:34invoice they'll have a running total for the
- 38:36client of expenses in and out. It's not. A great
- 38:41way to do it. When faced with state bar inquiry,
- 38:46I can argue that OK, this this suffices. but
- 38:52that's not really best practices. So we covered
- 38:57the ledger, we covered the journal. Then the
- 39:00third item, which is the one that most people
- 39:03don't maintain, that's the monthly reconciliation.
- 39:08The monthly reconciliation is a comparison of
- 39:11all your client trust account ledgers and your
- 39:14trust account journal to the bank statement that
- 39:17you're going to receive every month. And you
- 39:20need to balance it all and make sure that everything
- 39:24balances out and everything is accurate. This
- 39:28is when you're supposed to, on a month -to -month
- 39:30basis, catch any mistakes that may have occurred
- 39:34and this is your opportunity to correct them.
- 39:37Where people trip up is they don't do this monthly
- 39:40and if they do look at it, they don't keep a
- 39:46written record proving that it was done. So you
- 39:51need to have it in writing, prove that you did
- 39:53it. This will account for checks that haven't,
- 39:59you should be accounting here for checks that
- 40:01haven't yet cleared. This is where you should
- 40:03catch, say you wrote a check to a client or a
- 40:07medical lien holder and it hasn't cleared. And
- 40:10if you see that running for a couple of months,
- 40:15follow up with the client. follow up with the
- 40:18lien holder before they make a complaint to the
- 40:21state bar saying this attorney owes me money
- 40:25and was supposed to have sent me money and never
- 40:27did. You can catch that mistake in advance and
- 40:30save yourself a lot of headaches. In the materials,
- 40:37At the end, I have a monthly client trust account
- 40:41checklist, and it goes through each step as to
- 40:46how you should do these reconciliations. It's
- 40:49at the end of the materials that you got today.
- 40:51There are basically three steps. You reconcile
- 40:54the journal, you reconcile the ledgers, you do
- 40:58a final audit. You total everything the total
- 41:02of all the client ledgers and the adjusted journal
- 41:05balance Which is accounting for checks that haven't
- 41:07cleared yet, right? Should equal the bank balance.
- 41:10So make sure that that happens Make sure you
- 41:13do that monthly and make sure you have a written
- 41:15record that you did it Okay Back to number nine
- 41:23the five -year audit trail State bar discipline
- 41:28cases can go back five years. There are some
- 41:32new New nuances that potentially make it seven
- 41:37But the rule is that for the accounting records
- 41:41you are required to keep them a minimum of five
- 41:43years Do yourself a favor Keep everything for
- 41:51five years. Keep it organized. So if there are
- 41:55inquiries, you can show and prove that you did
- 41:57what you were supposed to do. My last fact for
- 42:03the day is that there are State Bar resources
- 42:07available to you. The State Bar, when I was with
- 42:11the State Bar, we used to offer these, the trial
- 42:14councils were the ones who, you know, we would
- 42:16divvy them up for the, it was, Given an ethics
- 42:20school and a CTA school was offered once a month
- 42:23and we would teach we would teach them ourselves.
- 42:27We would team up and it was incredibly helpful
- 42:31because It's sort of real life stuff. They will
- 42:35tell you, oh, this is what happens. This is what
- 42:38I commonly see. These are the violations that
- 42:40occur. This is how I would address X, Y, or Z.
- 42:43Would I charge this if it were a standalone?
- 42:46Probably not. Would I charge it if it were combined
- 42:50with other violations? Absolutely. So it was
- 42:54very helpful. I believe they have changed it
- 42:57now. I haven't had an opportunity to take it
- 43:00recently. I believe it may be a It may not be
- 43:04a live presentation anymore, but it is still
- 43:07offered. It is offered more frequently now, and
- 43:11it's offered online. You can go on the State
- 43:16Bar website and find eLearning, and you can take
- 43:22it through there. If you are required to take
- 43:29CTA school, which is sometimes a requirement
- 43:31as part of discipline, you don't get MCLE credit
- 43:34for it. If, however, you take it not because
- 43:37it's required, but just because you're interested,
- 43:39and I strongly advise that you do, you do get
- 43:43MCLE credit for it. I did look on their website,
- 43:47and it's a little bit confusing. You need to
- 43:51make sure you sign up through the... alternative
- 43:55enrollment tab. The alternative enrollment, it's
- 43:59the same course, but it's for the people who
- 44:02are taking it voluntarily. If you do the regular,
- 44:05I don't remember what it was called, the general
- 44:07enrollment, that is for people who are required
- 44:09to take it and aren't getting credit. So make
- 44:13sure you sign up correctly through the correct
- 44:16path so that you actually get credit for it.
- 44:20Included in the resources, offered by the state
- 44:24bar and included in that course, they go through
- 44:28all of the trust accounting. They have a handbook
- 44:31of client trust accounting, which is online.
- 44:33It's available online regardless of whether or
- 44:35not you take their course. I would strongly recommend
- 44:38that you download that and look through it. As
- 44:51an aside, just because I've seen where people
- 44:54run into trouble, if you're having someone else
- 44:59do your accounting for you frequently, it's a
- 45:02non -delegable duty. So although you aren't necessarily
- 45:06required to do the bookkeeping for your firm
- 45:08and for your clients yourself, you can delegate
- 45:11that to somebody, you're ultimately on the hook
- 45:13for whatever happens. And I've seen a lot of
- 45:16people run into trouble because You know, they
- 45:19start out with a small firm or solo and the practice
- 45:23just starts growing, which is wonderful. But
- 45:26some things don't always keep up. And sometimes
- 45:29one of the things that doesn't keep up is the
- 45:32bookkeeping and having someone who knows what
- 45:35they're doing, um, doing the bookkeeping. So
- 45:37sometimes it'll be, you know, your, uh, receptionist
- 45:41is also, well, you know, she's just sitting there,
- 45:43let's let her do the bookkeeping as well. Or,
- 45:46um, it can be an assistant. or a spouse that
- 45:50will come in. If they haven't been trained specifically
- 45:54in law firm accounting, even if they've got some
- 45:57background in accounting, make sure that you
- 46:02invest in your people. that they are properly
- 46:05trained so that they know what they're doing.
- 46:07Again, this goes back to that whole idea. Things
- 46:10aren't always logical when it comes to state
- 46:13bar compliance and client trust accounting. So
- 46:16they may do something that they think makes sense.
- 46:18Well, I'm just going to hold all of these funds
- 46:20until we can write one check to the client. Or
- 46:23what's the problem with giving the client the
- 46:27settlement funds today? We know the check's good
- 46:29and we know it's going to clear and there's funds
- 46:31in there from this other thing that we have where
- 46:34we're holding all this money. So there's plenty
- 46:37of money in that account. Why not just write
- 46:39the check to the client? They don't know these
- 46:41things. And the average person wouldn't. So you
- 46:45do need to make sure that the person you're relying
- 46:48on knows what they're doing has been trained
- 46:51and make sure that that training gets updated
- 46:53periodically so invest in that also although
- 46:57i know it's not. Practical necessarily the expectation
- 47:03is that you personally are going to check that
- 47:07month reconciliation every month and. So whether
- 47:12or not you do understand you're gonna be charged
- 47:16with. that responsibility so keep that in mind
- 47:22excuse me and make sure that that's something
- 47:26that you that you do so i see that we do have
- 47:31some questions so i would like if we can now
- 47:35maybe get through some of the questions i can
- 47:37answer them as they come in all righty so starting
- 47:43off uh christina asks if parties sell home If
- 47:47parties sell a home in a divorce and agree that
- 47:49the net proceeds be deposited into an IOLTA rather
- 47:53than an interest -bearing trust for a client,
- 47:55is that still a violation of state bar rules?
- 47:58No, not at all. As long as it's held in trust,
- 48:02that's fine. Unfortunately, the clients who are
- 48:06agreeing to that need to be aware they're going
- 48:08to lose the interest. they're not going to get
- 48:10the interest on that amount, that the interest
- 48:13is going to go to the state bar. If they're okay
- 48:15with that, just make sure you get it in writing.
- 48:17As long as you hold it in trust and they've agreed,
- 48:21then that's fine. All right. Thank you. Cynthia
- 48:26asks, is it a violation for a client to agree
- 48:30to a Is it a violation her client agrees to a
- 48:34Zelle an initial retainer payment into the general
- 48:37operating account and then funds are transferred
- 48:40to an IELTA due to the inability to set up the
- 48:44Zelle account directly linked with IELTA? Yeah.
- 48:48So here's the deal. This happens all the time.
- 48:54You can't as the person who's asking the question.
- 48:59Cynthia points out, you can't link Zelle or any
- 49:04of the other Venmo to NIolta. That's just asking
- 49:09for all kinds of problems because they can go
- 49:11in and get money that they can get access. So
- 49:14what you end up doing is if you're going to take
- 49:17payment that way, it goes to the operating account.
- 49:19What I would do is move it quickly if you know
- 49:24the money is coming in at a minimum Weekly I
- 49:29would any any money that has come into the operating
- 49:31account that way if not daily Transfer it immediately
- 49:36Make sure you have a paper trail that you've
- 49:40done it that way you're not you're not gonna
- 49:42get charged with that that that's I Guess technically
- 49:45it's a violation. This is something that we talked
- 49:47about In the CTAs we used to talk about in CTA
- 49:50school all the time. Is it a technical violation?
- 49:54Technically, yeah But it's a practical matter
- 49:56how else you're going to do it, right? So as
- 49:59long as you do it quickly, don't hold it there
- 50:02for any inordinate amount of time and make sure
- 50:05you have a paper trail, it's fine. You're not
- 50:07going to get in trouble for doing that. People,
- 50:13as a practical matter, the rules don't always
- 50:15catch up to what is in practice and what the
- 50:21current ... um ability is so now we've got these
- 50:25we've got zels you got the same issues for people
- 50:28who are um taking payments via credit cards just
- 50:33make sure that if you are using those forms that
- 50:38you document document document and move it quickly
- 50:42to the correct account you should be fine great
- 50:46thank you and Andrea Miller asks, we had a $15
- 50:50,000 client check returned. It did not overdraw
- 50:55the account. Would this still initiate a report
- 50:57to the state bar? No. If the client's check got
- 51:01returned, no. It's only if a check that was written
- 51:05on the IOLTA account. Gets returned that's going
- 51:09to get be reported now obviously That is something
- 51:12you're going to want to be aware of and hopefully
- 51:15you catch that if in your monthly reconciliation
- 51:17if not sooner So that it doesn't cause problems
- 51:21Thinking okay, you didn't realize the check was
- 51:23returned you thought the client according to
- 51:25their ledger had that 15 ,000 and you paid for
- 51:29a court reporter or something and then you overdrew
- 51:32your iota account that would be a problem, but
- 51:36and that would be something that would trigger
- 51:38a bank report. But under the circumstances you
- 51:41said where it was just the client check, no,
- 51:43that's not going to trigger the report. Great,
- 51:46thank you. And Cynthia has another question.
- 51:49Does the notification to the client and lien
- 51:51holders apply to initial retainer deposits made
- 51:54by the client? No, because the client obviously
- 51:59is aware that they gave you the funds, so they're
- 52:01already aware of it. And I'm I'm not aware of
- 52:06any situation where you would already have lean
- 52:08holders before the client even retains you. I
- 52:15mean, I guess if you have some odd situation,
- 52:19if you have some odd situation where there's
- 52:22a... I don't see where you need to... No. Sorry.
- 52:29No. Because the client, you don't need to tell
- 52:31the client that they just gave you money, right?
- 52:33So I wouldn't worry about it. And if there's
- 52:35a lien holder where the client just retained
- 52:38you, yeah, I probably wouldn't notify the lien
- 52:45holder either if the client had paid a retainer.
- 52:49I wouldn't notify anybody of that. All right.
- 52:56Joshua asks, what if we are considering reducing
- 52:58our PI contingency fee pending the outcome of
- 53:02the medical of the medical lien reductions? Should
- 53:06we still take our full fee out and then if we
- 53:08work out a deal later, send money to the client
- 53:10out of our operating account? It depends if you're
- 53:19considering giving them, say they're upside down
- 53:23and you want to help them out and you want them
- 53:25to get something out of the litigation and so
- 53:28you're considering reducing your fee. You can
- 53:32do it either way. The best way to do it would
- 53:36be to take the full fee and then again as you
- 53:42know if you want to provide them a discount you
- 53:44can funnel it through your operating account
- 53:46back into their account as a discount. However,
- 53:49if you are you know if you can just say you know
- 53:52maybe make a notation um in your records that
- 53:57you are considering, you're not taking your full
- 54:02fee because you're considering a discount, then
- 54:04you can probably leave it in. It's probably going
- 54:06to be fine. What you might want to do in that
- 54:09situation, although this can get cumbersome from
- 54:11an accounting perspective, say you're like, well,
- 54:14we routinely offer, you know, when we have situations
- 54:17like that, where the coin gets upside down on
- 54:21medical liens or whatever. And so we want to
- 54:24give them a break on our contingency. If you
- 54:27know that the standard that you do is you reduce
- 54:29your contingency from 40 % to 35 % or 40 % to
- 54:3430%, something like that, maybe take the 30 %
- 54:37or the 35 % that you know you're going to keep
- 54:40and leave the remainder of it until you determine
- 54:43whether or not you're going to give them the
- 54:46discount. But I think as long as you document
- 54:49it, you're probably going to be OK. Already,
- 54:54thank you. And Kenneth, you in here, it looks
- 54:56like he has a hypothetical question. Assume you
- 54:59have a settlement for X amount of dollars. You
- 55:02deposit the check into your IELTA. You distribute
- 55:05the money to the client and you distribute the
- 55:07money to yourself per the agreement. But you
- 55:10make a mistake and you distribute X plus $20.
- 55:15You discover this later after reconciling ledgers.
- 55:18What should you do? That is the point of the
- 55:22reconciliation. It depends on who got the extra
- 55:2520. Now, did you take extra 20 over and above
- 55:29what the settlement amount came in or did you
- 55:33just mistakenly give one person 20 % that belonged
- 55:37to the other person, right? First thing you do
- 55:40is correct it and make sure that the person who
- 55:43got short of the 20 gets their 20 and the person
- 55:47who got 20 too much, you try and get it back.
- 55:52If technically, if you took more than the settlement
- 55:56amount, more than X, so if it was X plus 20 total,
- 56:01technically you've misappropriated from another
- 56:03client. That's where we get back to these are
- 56:06individual savings accounts, right? So if there
- 56:10was a, it happens when there's a clerical error.
- 56:13That's why you do the monthly reconciliation.
- 56:16That's the purpose of the monthly reconciliation
- 56:18is to correct, catch those errors and correct
- 56:20them. I think if there's simply a clerical error,
- 56:24particularly for such a small amount, but even
- 56:26if it's a larger amount, if it truly is a clerical
- 56:28error and you caught it on your monthly reconciliation
- 56:31and you fixed it, you should be fine. You may
- 56:34have to do some explaining, but you should be
- 56:36fine. Thank you. Lan is asking, I used bill pay
- 56:43to directly send checks from my bank to the client
- 56:46so the money is gone once the check is cut. Is
- 56:49this a recommended practice? To send, directly
- 56:54send checks from my bank to the client so the
- 56:58money is gone once the check is cut. Is that
- 57:03a recommended practice? Yeah, I mean, it's no
- 57:06different than doing a transfer, an electronic
- 57:09transfer, right? That shouldn't be, yeah, that
- 57:13should be fine. Bill pay, yeah, because bill
- 57:17pay is, you're doing bill pay out of your IOLTA.
- 57:20It's just an electronic transfer and that's fine.
- 57:23That's fine. All right, thank you. And Norman
- 57:26Pine asks, how do associates in the firm who
- 57:29have no access to an IOLTA account report direct
- 57:31property or properly to the state bar CTE? Excuse
- 57:36me. This is the CTAP compliance. truly its own
- 57:41MTLE program. There is something called agency
- 57:44billing. The state bar in its infinite wisdom
- 57:48always calls things, makes confusing names. The
- 57:52people in the firm who don't actually handle
- 57:55the money. There is, if you go through your CTAP
- 57:59compliance, there is a category for them. It
- 58:03asks, do you handle client funds or not? And
- 58:05if you don't, then you check that box. And if
- 58:09you are somewhat responsible for, like say you
- 58:14do maybe have settlement checks come in that
- 58:16you have. handled, but you don't actually do
- 58:19the accounting, you're an associate and there's
- 58:21an accounting department or an accountant, then
- 58:24the accountant, the firm can report for everyone
- 58:26in the firm. It's through agency billing. And
- 58:29that's, that's the, that's what you're looking
- 58:31for is agency billing in that situation. Right.
- 58:36Thank you. And Patrice asks, how many days after
- 58:40the funds are earned, do you have to wait before
- 58:42transferring out of the trust account? You don't
- 58:48have to wait once they're earned if they're truly
- 58:50earned you can transfer them out immediately
- 58:53All right, and Joyce asks is it okay to put Client
- 59:00funds that will not be dispersed for a long time
- 59:03typically probate funds to deposit the beneficiaries
- 59:06money into a higher interest CD account for their
- 59:09benefit Yeah, see I had a client do this. They
- 59:12used a CD and instead of a deposit account. And
- 59:17the reason was the higher interest. And I would
- 59:23argue, yes, but be careful because this was the
- 59:26problem my client ran into. The bank, when creating
- 59:30the CD, created the CD with my client's... Social
- 59:38security number it wasn't even there. I don't
- 59:40even think it was there Their business tax ID
- 59:43number. I think it was their personal social
- 59:44security number So the only thing you have to
- 59:47be aware of I would make sure you you if there
- 59:50are beneficiaries that you want to make aware
- 59:52of this Maybe just in writing say this is what
- 59:55you plan to do and make sure they're okay with
- 59:57it When you are doing sort of your algebra for
- 1:00:01whether or not This is the most You're doing
- 1:00:06this for the benefit of the client right is it
- 1:00:08going to be the best return on the money consider
- 1:00:12the any any penalties for early withdrawal like
- 1:00:15so when you're choosing your cds if. Any additional
- 1:00:19savings they earn because of a higher interest
- 1:00:21rate gets depleted because you know the penalties
- 1:00:25for early withdrawal on cd are. Severe so severe
- 1:00:32that it wipes out any interest you may want to
- 1:00:35factor that in but you should do that set it
- 1:00:39up that it automatically renews that the interest
- 1:00:41is reinvested right from just make sure that
- 1:00:45the clients aware of it. And i don't think there's
- 1:00:48any problem with it i mean i don't i didn't think
- 1:00:50there was any problem with my client having chosen
- 1:00:52a cd rather than. more traditional deposit account,
- 1:00:58it was just that the way it got set up was problematic.
- 1:01:01So just maybe, even though it's for a long time,
- 1:01:05you may discuss it with your client what period
- 1:01:08of time, whether it's a one year, a five year
- 1:01:10CD type situation, what they think is going to
- 1:01:15be most appropriate and how they want to handle
- 1:01:17it. There's a second question I think in there.
- 1:01:21Nope, never mind. This is the next Stevens. Alrighty,
- 1:01:29so Stephen asks. If our firm loses contact with
- 1:01:33a client, and multiple attempts are made over
- 1:01:35the course of a year or more to re -establish
- 1:01:38contact, mail, telephone, email, text, skip trace,
- 1:01:42etc., and client funds, by ultimately negotiation,
- 1:01:45for example, cannot be sent to the client as
- 1:01:48a result, is the lawyer obligated to remit the
- 1:01:51funds to the state controller as unclaimed property?
- 1:01:54Secondly, If a client does not cash their check
- 1:01:57after substantial time or multiple checks, is
- 1:02:00it appropriate to send a cashier's check to the
- 1:02:03client? As to the first question, it was much
- 1:02:08longer than a year, but I did advise the client
- 1:02:10that they needed to remit the funds to the state
- 1:02:12controller as unclaimed property and make sure
- 1:02:16that they kept their documentation of all their
- 1:02:18efforts to get in touch. with the client and
- 1:02:21I'm sorry going back what was the second question
- 1:02:23was oh can you send a cashier's check if they
- 1:02:28haven't cashed oh I see what you're saying so
- 1:02:33if they haven't cashed a check that you've written
- 1:02:35and so that those funds are basically sitting
- 1:02:39can you basically get the funds out of your account
- 1:02:45permanently by um By basically voiding the uncashed
- 1:02:52check or it becomes stale after a certain period
- 1:02:55of time And then use those same funds to get
- 1:02:58a cashier's check, which once you send to them
- 1:03:00The cashier's check was purchased and the funds
- 1:03:03are out of your hands. That's clever under those
- 1:03:08circumstances Yeah, I guess you could do that
- 1:03:15although there's gonna be a quick if there's
- 1:03:17later a question you know the question sort of
- 1:03:21becomes well you knew either there was a bad
- 1:03:24address or there was some sort of a problem right
- 1:03:28so by doing that did you just sort of toss that
- 1:03:32cashier's check into the bin effectively i you
- 1:03:36could certainly argue that it was okay to do
- 1:03:38and that avoids the issue of having to send it
- 1:03:42to the state Um, I would be very careful about
- 1:03:45doing something like that, particularly if you
- 1:03:47have any indication that the reason that the
- 1:03:49check never got cashed was because either there's
- 1:03:53a bad address for the client, the client's incarcerated
- 1:03:56or something else is going on. But I guess technically
- 1:04:00you could do that. I don't know that I'd recommend
- 1:04:04it, but yeah, you could do that. Alrighty. Um,
- 1:04:09Greg asks, When a settlement check is made payable
- 1:04:12directly to the client, but the check is first
- 1:04:14sent to the attorney's office, can that check
- 1:04:17be forwarded to the client without involving
- 1:04:19the trust account? Um, yeah. If it's made directly
- 1:04:29to the client, yes, you can, yeah. I mean, obviously
- 1:04:32you're going to want to, it wouldn't necessarily
- 1:04:35be in your ledger because it hasn't funneled
- 1:04:37through the account. You're going to want to
- 1:04:38make some sort of notation to prove that the
- 1:04:42check when it came in was in the client's name
- 1:04:45and that you sent it to the client. So, you know,
- 1:04:48make sure you get a copy, make a copy of that
- 1:04:51check for your files and make sure when you send
- 1:04:53it to the client, you do it, you know, either
- 1:04:55UPS or certified mail, FedEx, something that
- 1:04:57gives you a tracking number. Great, thank you.
- 1:05:04And let's see. Judy asks, do attorney fee liens
- 1:05:07have priority over other medical liens? Basically,
- 1:05:11once the client signs off on a settlement disbursement
- 1:05:14accounting, the attorney can take their fee even
- 1:05:17if prior to reductions there are insufficient
- 1:05:20funds to cover all medical lien holders. Attorneys
- 1:05:24fees are always per contract and it's separate
- 1:05:27from other liens, right? Because the medical
- 1:05:33liens come out of the client's share. So if you've
- 1:05:38got a situation where you've got a settlement
- 1:05:40and say the attorney is a 40 % contingency, that
- 1:05:4540 % is divvied up among all of the attorneys
- 1:05:49claiming ... rights to attorney's fees, right?
- 1:05:53That is separate than the 60 % half that went
- 1:05:57to the client and out of the client's half or
- 1:06:01portion, the medical needs come out. So yeah,
- 1:06:04I don't know that it would call it taking priority.
- 1:06:06It's just separate. They're separate pots of
- 1:06:09money. Great. Thank you. And then Zahar asks,
- 1:06:16How do account for client accounts when the credit
- 1:06:20card charges are subtracted from the client's
- 1:06:23money net of credit card charges? Not too sure
- 1:06:31about that question. I'm not sure what you're
- 1:06:33asking, but how do I account for client account
- 1:06:39when the credit card charges are subtracted from
- 1:06:41the client's money? you shouldn't be using a
- 1:06:46credit card from the IOLTA. If an individual
- 1:06:51client is using a credit card to pay you, and
- 1:06:56I'm not even sure how their charges would come
- 1:06:58out of their money, but if it's an individual
- 1:07:03issue related to a single client, you need to
- 1:07:06track all the debits and credits in their ledger.
- 1:07:10So any costs, whether it's charges of any sort
- 1:07:17would be in their ledger. I'm not sure how that
- 1:07:19would happen though. Okay, and let's see. Michael
- 1:07:29asks, if my firm is headquartered outside of
- 1:07:33California in New York, but as California admitted
- 1:07:35attorneys, do we need a California IOLTA account
- 1:07:38in addition to the IOLTA account we already have
- 1:07:40outside of California? Do they do work? It depends
- 1:07:44on whether or not they do work for California
- 1:07:47attorneys and whether they handle money, I'm
- 1:07:51sorry, whether they do work for California clients
- 1:07:53and whether they handle money for clients in
- 1:07:56California. So that's going to be, you should
- 1:08:00follow up, either call me afterwards with my
- 1:08:03numbers on the materials or talk to the State
- 1:08:09Bar Ethics Hotline and they can help you with
- 1:08:10that. All righty. Okay. Baker of the wallpaper.
- 1:08:19That is not wallpaper. That is a wall hanging
- 1:08:21its cloth. And I have no idea who made it. And
- 1:08:25I think it's a fairly traditional pattern, but
- 1:08:28thank you. All righty then. I'm just going to
- 1:08:32skip to our last question then for Ryan Watkins.
- 1:08:36What is your opinion of self -reporting trust
- 1:08:38account issues to the bar? self -reporting trust
- 1:08:42account issues. I guess it would depend on what
- 1:08:48a trust account issue is. I mean, are you talking
- 1:08:53about, I mean, there's no duty to report under
- 1:08:596068. There's a bunch of business and professions
- 1:09:02code 6068. has a bunch of laundry list of things
- 1:09:07that need to be reported to the State Bar and
- 1:09:09when. Trust account problems is not one of them.
- 1:09:15If you're talking about, like for instance, is
- 1:09:22it 8 .3, 8 .4, the snitch rule, where if you
- 1:09:26are aware of known violations, they're supposed
- 1:09:28to be reported. It would really, really depend
- 1:09:31on a case -by -case basis. Generally, I would
- 1:09:33say no. I would say if you've got some trust
- 1:09:36account issue and you've fixed it, I wouldn't
- 1:09:41necessarily report that to the state bar. It
- 1:09:46kind of depends. I will say, I know we're over
- 1:09:49time. I'll just say this very quickly. I have
- 1:09:52had multiple clients who had office managers,
- 1:09:56bookkeepers who embezzled funds from the firm.
- 1:10:00Clients whose partners have embezzled from the
- 1:10:03firm. Did they voluntarily report that embezzlement?
- 1:10:08No. However, you're going to want to document
- 1:10:11it meaning. Police report, you're gonna wanna
- 1:10:13be able to show that you did something about
- 1:10:15it. You didn't just sit there and do nothing.
- 1:10:17So police reports, hire an accountant to do an
- 1:10:20independent audit of the overall books. Do what
- 1:10:23you can, do a fresh start, open a new account
- 1:10:26with a fresh start balance to sort of segregate
- 1:10:30or insulate the problematic client trust account
- 1:10:33from going forward. You take those corrective
- 1:10:36steps, but I don't know that I would report it
- 1:10:39voluntarily to the state. All right, it does
- 1:10:44look like Cynthia has one last question. Do you
- 1:10:46want to take it before we head out for today?
- 1:10:50Yeah, I'll take this. This is the last one because
- 1:10:52then I got it. All right, perfect. So, all right,
- 1:10:56Cynthia, I reconcile my IELTS accounting using
- 1:10:59a spreadsheet which mirrors all of the transactions
- 1:11:01of the bank statement. How do I document that
- 1:11:03I have reconciled? Do I write a note to the side
- 1:11:07stating each time I've completed the reconciliation?
- 1:11:11Well, if you're doing like an Excel spreadsheet,
- 1:11:14you could do like a print screen type thing with
- 1:11:20a date and save that as a separate file and then
- 1:11:24continue using your Excel spreadsheet moving
- 1:11:25forward, right? Because it's a running spreadsheet.
- 1:11:28So at that moment in time, you either do a save
- 1:11:32to print, print to save as a PDF or, you know,
- 1:11:38have a separate maintain a separate memo that
- 1:11:42simply says like, you know, I I reconciled on
- 1:11:45such and such a date like a running I Notation
- 1:11:49that you reconciled it but generally if you look
- 1:11:52at my attachment to the materials It says, you
- 1:11:56know, you want to make a paper trail. So if you
- 1:11:58can like maybe print it Old -school or print
- 1:12:01and save as a PDF. That's the best way All right.
- 1:12:07All right. Well, that's it for today. Thank you
- 1:12:09so much, Christine, for an excellent presentation.
- 1:12:12I know our audience is already sending their
- 1:12:14praise in the Q &A too. Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:12:19And thank you to our audience as well for joining
- 1:12:22us today. Have a good day, everybody. Thanks,
- 1:12:25guys.