Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️116 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 9th Nov Carbon Calculations Day 1 |
Transcript
- 0:05Unknown: Still in the fog. Well, here we are back in Oma, and on the 50th day of the public inquiry into Dalradian's proposed gold mine in The Sperrins. It's November, and the fog has settled in, which, as it turns out, was a fairly appropriate backdrop for today's proceedings. We spent much of
- 0:24the day examining Daluradian's greenhouse gas calculations, and by the time we had finished, I was left with the distinct impression that the applicants' team had spent a good part of the proceedings scrambling to explain figures, defend assumptions, and when those explanations began to unravel,
- 0:43find another way of calculating things, and all this was on day 50. We began with something as basic as the lifetime of the proposed mine. Across the application documents, we've encountered different estimates for construction, operation, closure, and decommissioning figures as varied as 17 to 20
- 1:06years, 20 to 25 years, and differing periods for closure. Today, we heard that the carbon calculations were based on 25 years of operation, two years of construction, and one year of active closure. Now these aren't minor details when you're calculating the carbon footprint of a mine. Every year of
- 1:29operation means fuel, electricity, transport, processing, and emissions. The assumptions about the mine's lifetime affects the entire calculation, and with that we were off. Commissioner Donhei began by asking Dalradian to explain the boundaries of its greenhouse gas assessment, what
- 1:53emissions had been included, and whether anything material had been left out. Dalradian's consultant, mr. Morrison, maintained that the assessment covered the relevant scope one, two, and three emissions, including refining. I suppose I better stop here and explain what scope one, two, and three
- 2:16emissions are. There are three categories used in greenhouse gas accounting. Scope one means direct emissions from sources owned or controlled by the operator. And in relation to the Coronalt example, this would include diesel-powered machinery, on-site generators, and company-controlled vehicles.
- 2:39In Scope two, we mean indirect emissions from purchased energy, and in relation to the mine proposal, electricity purchased to operate ventilation, pumping, crushing, and other equipment. And finally, we've got scope three, other indirect emissions throughout the value chain, so this would mean for the mine
- 3:05purchase materials, third-party transport, processing by other companies, and relevant downstream activities. And scope three is important because imagine if Dalridian calculates the emissions produced at the mine itself, but the gold concentration is subsequently transported elsewhere for
- 3:25processing. The emissions associated with the transport and processing do not simply disappear because the activities take place outside the mine site. They may fall within scope three, and scope three is potentially one of the most important issues in the climate hearings because it tests
- 3:44whether the environmental assessment captures the consequences of the development beyond its own immediate boundaries. However, scope three accounting and the legal requirements of an environmental impact assessment are not identical. Whether particular downstream emissions must be
- 4:02assessed depends on the circumstances and the applicable law, so that is a kind of an overview of scope one, two, and three. Deludians consultant, mr. Morrison, maintained that the assessment covered the relevant scope one, two, and three emissions, Including refining, and mr. Andy Greenall, speaking
- 4:24for Fermanagh Oma District Council, had a rather different assessment. He identified emissions associated with the proposed use of HVO fuel, including emissions classified as outside the normal reporting scopes, and raised concerns about other parts of the calculation. So we know HVO
- 4:46fuels mean hydrogenated vegetable oil. It's 100% renewable, fossil-free, synthetic diesel made from waste oils, animal fats, and vegetable oils. The distinction between carbon counting and actual emissions became increasingly important as the day went on. An accounting system may place
- 5:09emissions in one category or another. It may classify some as outside scope, but those emissions don't disappear from the atmosphere because somebody has moved them into another column of a spreadsheet, and the commissioners were trying to establish what environmental effects had actually been
- 5:28assessed. The next line of questioning took us away from The Sperrins altogether and across the Atlantic. Dalhradian proposes to produce a gold concentrate, which would then be transported elsewhere for further processing. Canada has been used in the assessment as the reasonable worst-case
- 5:47destination. The commissioners wanted to understand the basis for that assumption, particularly when the applicant acknowledged that the final destination had not been settled. European processing facilities were mentioned. Canada remained the example used in the calculations.
- 6:06Other destinations, including places further away, had not been assessed in the same way. Commissioner MacParland pressed the applicants' representatives about why these possible destinations and the reasoning behind their selection were not set out more fully in the environmental information. At
- 6:28around 12, mr. Beatty, counsel for Delraydin, made the distinction that this was a destination, not a project alternative. Well, fair enough as a legal distinction, but from the point of view of carbon emissions, the destination matters enormously. The concentration has to travel
- 6:47somewhere; it has to be processed somewhere, and the energy used in that processing will depend on where it goes and what happens to it when it gets there. mr. Connor Fagan for the council argued that if Canada was being presented as the reasonable worst-case scenario, the environmental statement
- 7:06should explain why. If other destinations had been examined, the basis for choosing them should be available for scrutiny. We then moved into one of the most revealing exchanges of the morning, involving smelting and refining. Now, I have no intention in turning this podcast into a metallurgy
- 7:28lecture, but there is a distinction worth understanding. Smelting involves high-temperature industrial processes to separate and recover metals from material. Refining involves further purification of the recovered metal, the Radiance Greenhouse gas table allocated just 358
- 7:49tonnes of carbon dioxide, equivalent to downstream product refining over the life of the mine. 358 tonnes for a project expected to produce hundreds of 1000s of tonnes of concentrate over its lifetime, that figure attracted a good deal of attention. One of Dalradian's representatives suggested that
- 8:13smelting and refining were terms often used interchangeably in the industry. Now that may be how people sometimes speak about the process, but it still doesn't establish that the emissions from both stages have been included in a calculation. mr. Fagan challenged the explanation directly. He drew
- 8:35the commission's attention to the World Gold Council report being used to support the figures, that report distinguishes concentrating and smelting from refining and recycling. When the applicant maintained that the refining figure covered smelting as well, mr. Fagan rejected the
- 8:56interpretation. His point was that the report itself separates the processes and the emissions factor being used related to refining and recycling. mr. Greenall reinforced that argument. Smelting, he explained, is an extremely energy-intensive industrial activity. He also examined the
- 9:18scale of the operation, roughly 600,000 tonnes of concentrate over the mine's lifetime, ultimately producing a much smaller quantity of gold, and his assessment of the emissions being claimed was memorable. He described the figures as implausible. He brought the discussion back to the basic
- 9:41physics of the industrial processing, converting that quantity of material into a finished metal product requires energy, and the energy has to be accounted for somewhere. Even Commissioner Donohue remarked on how low the smelting figure seemed, particularly when compared with the emissions
- 9:59associated. With transporting the material, it was a strong contribution from mr. Greenall because he kept bringing the discussion back to the actual industrial processes involved, instead of allowing the argument to disappear into accounting terminology. And this brought us to the aforementioned World Gold
- 10:20Council report. There had been discussions of the 2019 and the 2024 publications, and particularly the use of an emissions factor of 3.62, when another figure of 7.02 was being raised from the latest report. Delraydin argued that the higher figure reflected different energy assumptions, and that its
- 10:44chosen destination could benefit from lower carbon electricity. mr. Fagan's concern was far more fundamental. The figures had to relate to the correct stages of the processing. A refining factor could not safely be assumed to include smelting, if the source document treated those activities separately.
- 11:06There was also a procedural difficulty. The 2o two four World Gold Council report was been discussed and relied upon, but the commissioners did not actually have the full document formally before them. So we had a hearing full of experts debating the interpretation of a report, which at that point
- 11:28still needed to be supplied to the commission. It took a long time for the penny to drop, but eventually the commission was offered it, and they agreed to accept it. And arrangements were made for the PDF to be emailed and uploaded. It was funny in a day devoted to carbon accounting. We had managed to
- 11:49generate a fair amount of heat over the whereabouts of a PDF.
- 11:54Still, the commissioners were right to insist on having the document. They needed to see exactly what was being relied upon. After lunch, the folks shifted to another major question: How Delrayan's estimated lifetime emissions had fallen from approximately 640,000 tonnes to 305,000
- 12:14tonnes? The applicant attributed much of the reduction to the assumptions about HVO fuel, renewable electricity, and low-carbon cement. As I've already said, HVO is a renewable diesel substitute, and Dalradian proposed to use it to reduce emissions from machinery and other diesel-powered activities.
- 12:36But several parties challenged how secure those projected savings really were. There were concerns about the availability of HVO over the mine's lifetime, the sustainability of its supply chain, and what would happen if the fuel could not be obtained in the quantities required. Similar questions were raised
- 12:59about low-carbon cement, particularly the availability of the materials used to produce it, and whether the claimed reductions could be guaranteed. The commissioners wanted to understand what would happen to the carbon calculations if these assumptions did not hold. And then we reached the peak
- 13:19calculations during the explanation of the revised emission figures, the applicant's team introduced corrections to its peat calculations. A figure of roughly 354 hectares was being replaced by one of 67.8 hectares for the area requiring restoration. That's an enormous
- 13:43difference. And the difficulty was that the explanation seemed to involve more than correcting an arithmetic effort. It involved a change in the methodology being used. Here we were on the 50th day of the inquiry into a major industrial development, and the commission was having to deal with the
- 14:03introduction of revised calculations during oral evidence, and this is not the first time this has happened. The commission did not resolve that issue there and then. It indicated that further consideration was needed, and we'll hear more about it tomorrow. Anyways, as the
- 14:21afternoon continued, the commissioners examined the assumptions behind the use of low-carbon cement and the treatment of emissions associated with existing buildings on the site. mr. Morrison acknowledged that emissions from those existing buildings had not been included
- 14:37in the assessment being discussed, but described them as very, very small and immaterial to the overall process, and I was afraid we'd heard it in one form or another over the whole length of the public inquiry: small, immaterial, not significant. Fagan made what I thought was one of the most
- 15:01important legal arguments of the hearing. He pointed out that this was not the first occasion on which the applicant had responded to an omission by describing it as small or immaterial. Taken together, he argued, these omissions began to cast doubt on the reliability of the figures before the
- 15:19commission. He then addressed the repeated references to ISO certification. Dalradian had been explaining that carbon emissions would be independently verified through future ISO process, with reductions and, if necessary, offsets used to achieve carbon neutrality. mr. Fagan challenged the suggestion
- 15:44that unresolved matters could simply be dealt with at that later stage. His argument was that decision makers needed the environmental information now, while the planning application was being assessed. If the answer to every concern was that the ISO process would deal with it afterwards? There would be
- 16:04very little purpose in examining climate impacts at the inquiry. I thought he put his finger on a central weakness in the applicant's approach. The commission has been asked to consider the environmental consequences of granting permission. It cannot be expected to leave every disputed
- 16:23assumption for another process, some time in the future when the development may already have been approved. Later in the afternoon, the discussion returned once more to HVO. Pat Haughty raised the concerns about the applicant's assumptions concerning fuel consumption, and the projected
- 16:45carbon savings from operating machinery throughout the mine's lifetime. He also drew attention to Dalradian's own acknowledgement in its 2024 documentation that the HVO market was not yet mature. Pat argued that the assessment should account for the worst-case position if HVO were
- 17:05unavailable, rather than treating the hope for savings as guaranteed. It was another example of the gap between what a company intends to do and what the evidence demonstrates it will be able to do. Towards the end of the day, the discussion returned to the treatment of emissions outside the formal
- 17:26reporting scopes. mr.
- 17:28Greenall maintained that emissions associated with HVO still needed to be recognised in the environmental assessment, even where the accounting methodology placed them outside of a particular scope. mr. Fagan supported that distinction. Corporate carbon accounting conventions. Oh, that's nice,
- 17:49isn't it? Three seasons in a row seems like the beginning of a nursery rhyme. Anyways, he argued cannot determine the full extent of what must be considered in an environmental impact assessment. An environmental effect remains an environmental effect, and then Dr. Alessandra Akogli, on behalf
- 18:09of Save Our Sperrins, raised the implications of changing the peatland assessment methodology during the inquiry. Here is what she had to say about
- 18:19it. Hi, Marella. So essentially. in relation to the peatlands as a subtopic to the climate topic in the public inquiry, the main concerns are essentially related to the new information was provided today by Dalharian by the applicant, they provided new calculations in relation to peatland emissions. It was
- 18:53unclear to what these calculations referred to, and so a concern in relation to that, firstly, is the fact that that can absolutely be qualified as new information. Does breaching the right to public participation, which is recognised under the Harus Convention, you know, so it is
- 19:22procedurally flawed because, according to the Harris Convention, the public must have access to the relevant information in sufficient time. So must have enough time and in a form that allows meaningful participation in environmental decision making, but on top of that, this is also recognised in
- 19:47the Northern Ireland Environmental Impact Assessment Regulation of 2017. So, so this was certainly a procedural flaw which emerged today, but then more generally in relation to the new assessment. So, what I'm referring to is the PETLA, so the Appendix One PET land emission assessment, which was
- 20:18prepared recently by the applicant, so it's the appendix one peatland carbon emission assessment. So that shows, first of all, there are inconsistencies and lack of clarity around how they got to certain claims and assertions in relation to the emission emission factor used for peat
- 20:48extraction or for peat excavation. The they assume that there is there will be a five year transition to extensive grassland after excavation, which is unsupported by evidence, and then they refer to a figure of 80% of carbon retention, which is unclear where where they got that from.
- 21:17Besides these inconsistencies, the main? Then, if we you know zoom out, and and we consider like the bigger picture here, they essentially adopt so they they overestimate restore the restoration benefits. So they their underlying logic is that peatland can be degraded because then we can reverse that process
- 21:48in a very straightforward and linear way and restore the ecosystem. But this is a very simplified understanding of peatland restoration, which is actually impacted by a lot of different factors, and it also shows a lack of understanding of the peatland ecosystem as complex ecosystems, where there
- 22:10are different factors influencing their existence and their degradation. So that sorry, their existence and their restoration. So that restoration might not necessarily be successful. You might have vegetation on a peatland site, but that doesn't mean that the carbon sink function has been
- 22:32restored. So these are the main concerns, and in fact, you know, peatlands. We know from research, very established research, that peatlands develop over very long timescales. The restoration can take decades to re-establish that carbon sequestration function if it even is successful. So you know
- 23:04this is the main concern here because in the report in the assessment, sorry, especially in sentence 262, they reveal this you know underlying logic where they say that the proposed management peat management contributes negatively to the carbon balance, but this is offset by proposed habitat
- 23:31restoration activities on site. But this is not necessarily what's going to happen, as I said, because as as I just mentioned, pit and restoration really and its success depends on a number of factors like the hydrology, vegetation, soil chemistry, carbon dynamics, and ecological functions. They're
- 23:54all very deeply interconnected, but instead they're just assuming that you can degrade and then fix the problem with closing a few ditches and and you know implementing a few a few practical steps or activities to to to to bring the ecosystem back, but you know this is as I said shows a lack
- 24:16of an understanding of the ecosystem. I
- 24:19have to say it's not the first time a lack of understanding of the ecosystem has shown up during this inquiry. Many thanks, Alessandra, for all of that. That just leaves me to round up here now. By the time the proceedings finished, I felt we'd witnessed a very difficult day for Delrayan's greenhouse
- 24:37gas evidence. The commissioners had worked systematically through the assessment, asking about its boundaries, the destination of the concentrate, downstream processing, the reasons for reduction in lifetime emissions, and the assumptions about future fuels and materials. The council's
- 24:56representatives, particularly mr. Greenall and mr. Fay. Had made strong technical and legal challenges. Pat Ohi and Fidel Mokane and other participants had exposed further uncertainties, and Alessandra had drawn attention to both the scientific and public participation issues surrounding
- 25:16the revised peak calculations. Delradian's representatives offered explanations defending methodology and maintained that the project could meet its carbon commitments. For where I was sitting, too many of these explanations depended on assumptions once again that had not been properly demonstrated,
- 25:37or on future processes that would take place after the planning decision, and the attempt to introduce revised peak calculations during the hearing did little to inspire confidence. We are now 50 days into the public inquiry. We are still trying to establish whether the figures being
- 25:55presented provide a reliable account of the carbon emissions from this proposed mine. Outside, the November fog will eventually lift from OMA. I wish I could say the same for Dal Radians calculations. We'll be back tomorrow. You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from
- 26:13the Front Line. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you need from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends,
- 26:32neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the
- 26:52water, the air, and the people who protect them.