Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Stanton Fumes, Ford Employee Purchase, Cybertruck Rescued
Transcript
- 0:00Yo, what's up? Wednesday, lucky 13, December 13th. Uh, we got a couple things to talk to. Mike Stan got, I think, really upset over this one. We're also gonna talk about Ford stocks and a cyber truck being rescued.
- 0:13Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know, who I is- How's that for anticipation? Why is Mike Stan so angry? Give them, give them the stuff that makes them wait, Paul. Oh. Give them the stuff that makes them wait.
- 0:24We could go, I mean, we could... Sometimes I think maybe we should go more sensational- [laughs]... in some of our copy and text because it seems to be working, um, in some other places.
- 0:38Um, you know, we've always focused on substance, but maybe, you know, maybe a little sensational isn't too bad, right? Especially if you have the substance to back it up, right? 'Cause you don't wanna be clickbaity.
- 0:47Yeah. Right? You know. It's- If you got the real substance, I mean, li- listen. Okay... you wait, wait until we tell you how mad Mike Stanton is. All right, let's talk about other news. He is mad, that's for sure.
- 0:57[laughs] Oh, good morning everybody on livestream. Adrian coming in, first comment. If you didn't know, on LinkedIn we livestream this show. We know a lot of you just listen to the audio version.
- 1:06We also livestream on LinkedIn, YouTube, and there's always this competition for who gets the first comment today, and a pretty frequent winner is Adrian Wall Gibbs. Um, just saying good morning on the livestream.
- 1:16And Brian Ortega, he was sleeping yesterday, but here he is. He's in the fight. Hey. Jeffery Hill is up in here. Um, [laughs] Ortega does know sensational. That is for sure.
- 1:24If you've ever seen a Brian Ortega video, you know what sensational, uh, means exactly. Oh, man. Well, speaking of sensational- Hey... we're just gonna do a half segue there.
- 1:33Uh, we do have our year-end extravaganza coming up, uh, just about a week, December 21st, Thursday, LinkedIn Live event. Go to LinkedIn page, search ASOTU, or just go to asotu.com.
- 1:43There's a banner up top, it'll get you right there. Um, live year-end extravaganza. It's gonna, we're gonna have guests and Christmas trees and some other fun surprises.
- 1:52This is our third one, so I think we're just getting warmed up.
- 1:55But we know how to put on one of these things, and it's much better when you're there in the comments with all the other people in the comments, because, uh, that's probably where the real entertainment happens.
- 2:04Oh, it's so much fun. Yeah, just the interaction between the community because I, like, that's what I can never get over, is the fact that ASOTU really becomes a community when it gathers around anything- That's true...
- 2:14whether it be the content or the events or anything like that. And so the year-end extravaganza is one of those unique events. You should be there. Yeah. Yo. Yeah. ASOTU.com, scroll down, boom, right there.
- 2:23LinkedIn, boop, boop, boop. Speaking of, uh, today we have a webinar going on, uh- Oh, we do... at 1:00 PM Eastern. You can still join, you can still sign up for it.
- 2:31It's with our friends at Upstart, Transforming Car Buying: The Power of Connected Auto Retailing. Quick shot, 20, 30 minutes. Kyle and I will be there.
- 2:39We'll be, uh, kind of curating the conversation, taking questions, bringing out the insights. You can also go to asotu.com, just scroll a little bit, you'll see the webinar. Sign up, you're in.
- 2:49Um, we hope to see you there because these are always so much fun. They're so much fun, more fun than a regular old 55-minute webinar- That's right... where you fall asleep halfway through. Boom. In and out, let's go.
- 2:58[laughs] All right, let's talk about some news, 'cause that's kind of what we do here- That's right... on the show. All right, here we go. Let's talk about Mike Stanton and his frustrations, we'll call them.
- 3:07[laughs] The FTC finalized th- a new rule yesterday targeting deceptive car buying practices, including the junk fees, misleading promises.
- 3:15Um, and look, this, this could really transform, they wanna transform the automotive landscape. I don't think it's in the way that they think it's gonna transform the automotive landscape.
- 3:23Uh, but it's gonna, it's gonna head that way in June of, July of 2024, for better or worse. Uh, the rule is set to go in effect in July 30th.
- 3:32Uh, it requires transparent pricing, prohibits non-beneficial add-ons, as they say, such as things like if you buy a, a big maintenance package that has oil changes in it, but you bought an EV.
- 3:43Even if that's bundled in with a bunch of other benefits, they're like, "That doesn't work."
- 3:46Or things like, uh, selling nitrogen in tires, especially if the composition of the air you're putting in the tires doesn't have more nitrogen than normal air. Right.
- 3:54Those seem like, you know, when they put those out front, you're like, "Yeah, those scumbags. Why would they ever sell me that?" It's so much more complex than that.
- 4:02Um, what they're, you know, their goal is to protect consumers, particularly have some s- special provisions for service members, uh, from deceptive practices, which they say costs consumers $3.4 billion annually.
- 4:13Uh, NADA is obviously criticizing the rule for adding complexity, increasing compliance cost, and, uh, also for not giving this a fair chance, like, to like let's test some of these things out.
- 4:25Let's have a long discussion about them as opposed to just jamming them through, which is, I think, the biggest point of the whole pushback on it.
- 4:31Uh, the Center for Automotive Research suggests these things could add as much as two hours to the transaction time of buying a car. Wow. FTC is saying this is gonna save three hours.
- 4:43It's gonna actually reduce the transaction time by three hours. I don't even know how that- I don't understand how they come up with those numbers.
- 4:49How are three or four pieces of paper gonna add two hours to the transaction time? And more- Mike Stan-... how are you gonna reduce three hours- Mike Stan has an idea...
- 4:58off of, off of a thing that is two and a half hours right now? I don't understand the logic here. We're gonna read Mike Stanton's comment.
- 5:04He has an idea of how the FTC came up with these numbers, uh, buried in his comment.
- 5:08Uh, the same study from the Automotive Research, uh, in, Center for Automotive Research, um, suggests dealers will face 18 to $22 billion in extra compliance costs over the next decade according, uh, as a result of the rule, far exceeding the agency's estimate of 1.3 to 1.5 billion.
- 5:27So if you're doing the math there, that's like 15 times more. [laughs] That's 15x. That's- All right, here we go. Mike Stanton, you can decide whether or not he's angry or not.
- 5:36He said on Tuesday, "This regulation is heavy-handed, bureaucratic overreach and redundancy at its worst that will needlessly lengthen the car sales process by forcing new layers of disclosures and complexity into the transaction."
- 5:49Here's the, here's the one. "The FTC made up data to support its claims, then rejected calls to slow the process down and test the effectiveness of its proposal with real consumers.
- 6:01We're exploring all options on how to keep this ill-conceived rule from taking effect." I don't know, Kyle, do you think he's upset?I think he's upset. And also, like anytime- Kate is upset...
- 6:10anytime you're claiming that the FC- FTC has made up data- Wow... that's a, that's a pretty bold claim. Um, you know, uh, here's, like, here's my level-headed approach to this. First, we did it to ourselves.
- 6:25As an industry, we have brought this rule upon ourselves. Second, the vast majority of dealers are already complying with a large swath of the, the, what this ruling entails. Mm-hmm.
- 6:39Like, they are clearly and transparently presenting prices online, providing products that are actually of value to a consumer in the vehicle that you're purchasing, and not, uh, and don't have ridiculous a- add-ons.
- 6:53There's no consumer that wants any of those things to be that way.
- 6:57So as a, like, large, like, overarching goal and target rule, I think that this does a lot of good for consumers and elevates the best of the dealers out there that are already complying with the majority of these rules.
- 7:10Mm. So, like, just my plain opinion is, like, why wouldn't you wanna comply with something that's better for the consumer?
- 7:17Now, the long tail of what are the things that inhibit the process of a car sale, what are the things that they don't understand in relationship between OEM and dealer and pricing rules and the way that people can click to get a price versus what's available via the manufacturer-approved pricing, how are current, um, uh, F&I providers structured to provide aftermarket products that may or may not include things, and, and what dependencies are gonna be outside of the dealer's control that relates to this, there's just a massive amount of complexity that goes into a car deal- Mm-hmm...
- 7:52that over a six-month timeline is gonna be extremely hard to overcome and is gonna take a ton of retooling from not just dealers, but more importantly the partners that support the transaction process.
- 8:04And so, um, you know, it puts the, uh, let's just call it the...
- 8:09Let's, let's even just call it, like, split the difference, $12 billion, uh, onus on the dealers when a lot of this relies on their partners and the, and, and the inability both from the OEM and the tech partners to support what the, uh, uh, what's going on here, and it gives unfair advantage to some of the new entrants that are going to direct to consumer.
- 8:30And I would watch out for OEMs to go, "Hey, look, we're just gonna solve this on our own." That's a lot packed- That's my, that's my, that's my- There's a lot packed into the two minutes you just delivered...
- 8:38I packed in a lot, but, like, it's just too complex to really go through. It's, I think that's the bottom line. It's a very complex situation.
- 8:45In the end, I think everyone agrees they want the consumer to understand what they're buying- Yep... well and quickly and upfront. And if you don't, it's because you're trying to play a little three-card monte, right?
- 8:58Yep. Which is, back to your very first statement, that's the reason that this rule has just gained steam and momentum. Yep. So the best dealers out there are fighting back.
- 9:08We're trying to help you fight back by making it better, faster, changing the perception and, look, this is, this is something we're dealing with, right?
- 9:15We've been talking about this for six months now, this one thing, and here it is, and we'll see where it goes. But Mike Stanton and, uh, our friends at NADA are certainly all over it. [laughs] They're on it.
- 9:25Uh, speaking of being on it. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] All right. Change the energy of the show a little bit.
- 9:32Ford's electric chief vehicle digital and design officer recently made the largest non-family investment in the company since 2004- Whoa...
- 9:41when least tracking that began, so maybe longer, purchasing $2 million personally of Ford stock, reflecting obviously huge confidence in the automaker future.
- 9:51He's former Tesla, um, there's another company he used to work with, I can't remember. But he's been around the block.
- 9:56Doug Field acquired 182,000 shares at $11.05 each, which doubles the $1 million stock purchase by former COO Jim Farley, when he was just the COO. Uh, bought a million dollars back in 2020, obviously signaling optimism.
- 10:10A Ford sp- spokesperson commented on this transaction, "Doug has substantial ownership interest in Ford stock, which shows he believes in the company's future."
- 10:19Uh, Verified data, the company, uh, notes the purchase, uh, as a sign that Ford, you know, this confidence from an em- employee insider, confidence that Ford is undervalued, right?
- 10:29So, uh, it'll be interesting to see what the stock does. Um, you know, it's a, it's a big deal. I mean- Yeah... $2 million of your own money.
- 10:36Ford stock, uh, although down 7% this year, has risen about 45% since Jim Farley became CEO in 2020, with Field playing a very key role in vehicle services and technology, and certainly the direction of the company moving forward.
- 10:50Yeah, it's really, I mean, to watch, to watch a high-ranking employee buy a whole bunch of stock personally and not from some sort of fund- Mm-hmm... uh, uh, is interesting.
- 10:59Obviously, there's stock in his comp plan, which means if you have an undervalued stock and you purchase a bunch of it and there's perceived raised in, raise in value, you could see the remaining, uh, amount of your stock options, which is probably in your comp plan, go up.
- 11:13Mm-hmm. But also it exudes a lot of confidence.
- 11:15Um, and, and so there's, there's both sides of the coin to this, and I'm, uh, I, I'm pumped because I'm like, all right, if he's ready, if he's, if he's seeing, if he's seeing the light through all of the turbulence in the EV, uh, side of stuff that we've seen in the last two months, then- Makes you feel the way...
- 11:31some- uh, like, let's go. Here we go. Uh, speaking of Ford and confidence- Stop Segway Time... in the same sentence.
- 11:39[upbeat music] [laughs] So a Twitter user captured a Tesla Cybertruck's failed attempt to climb a snowy hill- Mm... requiring his res- a rescue by his friend's, get this, Ford Super Duty. [laughs] Of course.
- 11:51Raising questions about the off-road capabilities of a Cybertruck, uh, and of course slightly em- embarrassing the new vehicle. [laughs] Uh, it- we've got, we've got the video. We wanna play it real quick.
- 12:02Oh, let's watch it. It's just a little bit. You see the, the Tesla's just like- I have so many questions when I see this video.
- 12:07[laughs] And, and so, like-I got more questions about the driver than the truck, honestly If you're just listening, you're watching the vehicle on probably a 15 to 20% incline of packed down snow, which seems a little bit more like ice, with a Christmas tree in the back, and it's just spinning its wheels, going forward a couple inches, sliding back, going forward.
- 12:26And it's probably how far from the road? 15 feet from the road? Yep. Not, not far at all. Yeah. No. Okay.
- 12:32So, um- I mean, the, the Twitter post did say the driver didn't air down the tires, which, uh, typically would, uh, be something that you would do if you were in one of these trucks in deep snow- Yeah...
- 12:42or ice to get a little bit more traction, right? If you, if you really knew what you were doing in the thing. Um,
- 12:48you know, they, they, they didn't show everything, but it was clear that there's a good chance that the low-end weight of that vehicle was making it very, very hard for it to get up the slope.
- 12:59You think the weight might h- fix that one a little bit. Also noted there were no tow hit, like tow hooks or recovery points on the vehicle at all.
- 13:08And now this was one of the, the candidates, it was a release candidate, which is why it's got the big RC on the side door. So it wasn't like a production model. Right. Maybe they added those.
- 13:17Um, but yeah, like, you know, those little hooks under your car, like if you can't, know what I mean?
- 13:21So I think they actually had a hook onto like the control arms, which doesn't sound very great for the truck- Not great for the truck... to tow it out.
- 13:26But if you look at the situation, um, I think this is operator error. Like there's no way they should have gone down that slope to pick up a Christmas tree trying to be all cute and fancy. Not a chance.
- 13:36They did it to themselves because I don't know that the Super Duty would've made it up that incline either without airing down the tires or special tires.
- 13:42But it's still funny, and we're still gonna see more of- Absolutely... more, more TikToks about, and Twitter, uh, videos about Cybertruck. Can't wait for the next one.
- 13:50Hey, if they're hating on you, just means you're probably doing something right. [laughs] There you go. That's usually how it goes.
- 13:54Uh, well we hope, uh, we don't get, hope people are hating on you, but we hope you're doing a lot right today.
- 13:59We know one of those things is focusing on the people side of your business and understanding that is what makes the profitability difference, and then we won't have to worry about rules anymore.
- 14:08[upbeat music]