Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets: Once Bitten Episode 500 featuring Andy Edstrom & Jesse Myers
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity.
- 0:10Where the? Supply is unaffected by the
- 0:13demand. If you want to preserve your
- 0:16wealth, you have to convert that currency into an asset that's
- 0:21scarce, desirable, portable, durable, and maintainable.
- 0:31This meeting is being recorded. Yes, both sides, I believe,
- 0:35Andy. So you're recording too.
- 0:37We got it. Technical difficulties dealt
- 0:39with. How you doing boys?
- 0:42Great to see you, Princey. I'm well.
- 0:46How are you? We're good.
- 0:49We are very good, mate. Thank you very much.
- 0:51Lawrence here, obviously. Jesse, what's up with you?
- 0:53How's it going guys? Jesse's, Jesse's had a haircut
- 0:57and Andy just keeps looking younger each time I see him.
- 1:00I wish. You're very kind, Princey.
- 1:03You're very kind. Kindest man I know.
- 1:06What's going on? Andy's been Andy's been hanging
- 1:08out at at Muscle Beach, I think. Right, I was going to say, what
- 1:13do you like employees of on ramp?
- 1:15Do you get a free gym membership or something?
- 1:17And like free Barber? What's what?
- 1:20What are the company perks? You know, it's all about
- 1:22employee benefits these days guys.
- 1:23So didn't you? Were you not aware?
- 1:26No perks that I'm aware of. They don't even hardly pay for
- 1:31editing for for our podcasts that we do.
- 1:35The main part is you get to talk about Bitcoin.
- 1:39Well, yeah, you get to hang with Jesse and and and talk about
- 1:42Bitcoin and discuss multi sig and multi institutional multi
- 1:47geographical Bitcoin custody. That's what Lauren's here for.
- 1:52Am I right? Definitely not just to say hi
- 1:55since I have no questions, but. I just said like 3 really weird
- 2:01things. Yeah, multi sig, did you hear
- 2:04that? Yeah.
- 2:07What do you think that is? Oh, that's what you want to get?
- 2:13Into yes, Laura, after 500 shows we're we're just about getting
- 2:18there as a as a partnership. Stronger than ever.
- 2:24Yeah, what is a multi sig? Sure.
- 2:30You want to take it, Jesse? You want me to?
- 2:33Go for it, Andy. Yeah, so as you know, Lauren, to
- 2:42move funds and access your money on the Bitcoin network, you need
- 2:47a key, right? And multi sig is a, it's a part
- 2:54of the Bitcoin protocol. It's native to the software that
- 2:58allows you to require more than one key to move funds, to move
- 3:05money. And so it makes it so that if
- 3:08you've got some arrangement where you don't want any single
- 3:12person to be able to move money, you can give multiple keys to
- 3:16multiple people and require them all to sign.
- 3:19Or if you don't want someone getting your keys or you don't
- 3:24want to have personal access easily to your keys, and
- 3:27therefore you want to require yourself to have to have
- 3:31multiple keys to get the money, you can do that too.
- 3:34So it allows for a lot of interesting ways to improve
- 3:38security of, of holding Bitcoin funds.
- 3:42That's what I would say about it.
- 3:46Yeah, agreed. Did that make sense at all,
- 3:49Lauren? I'm going to try and.
- 3:52So it's basically you keeping your keys to yourself or to
- 4:00other. People kind of thing.
- 4:03But this, Lauren, what if you had a box with 100,000 lbs in
- 4:09it, British pounds, and you had one key to the box and you were
- 4:13worried that someone would find that one key?
- 4:17You know, maybe you'd want to hide, maybe you'd want to
- 4:20require 2 keys, 2 locks to open that box so nobody would steal
- 4:24your money. And that's one thing that multi
- 4:27sig multiple signatures can require.
- 4:31Does that make more sense? That's the analogy, exact
- 4:33analogy I was going to go with. So let's pretend upstairs in
- 4:36your bedroom, you've got your Piggy Bank, right?
- 4:38Imagine that's a box. And on that box there's three
- 4:41padlocks, and each padlock has a unique key.
- 4:45You would have one key. I would have one key, and maybe
- 4:49your best friend might have one key, so the only way you'd ever
- 4:52be able to get to that money is all three of us turned up and
- 4:56opened at the same time. Might be especially useful if a
- 5:01if a burglar came into your house and you know, God forbid,
- 5:04held a gun on you or something, then you couldn't cough up the
- 5:08money. You'd say I only got one key and
- 5:10more than one key is required. OK.
- 5:15Yeah, yeah. So that's that's multi sig
- 5:18explained to a 13 year old. But we do that on Bitcoin
- 5:23network using Bitcoin software, the protocol and it's a little
- 5:27bit techie I was. Going to say, I think I'm going
- 5:29to be a bit complicated, not a bit more complicated than that.
- 5:32Yeah, and that's what on ramp Bitcoin are trying to solve for
- 5:36people. So they help their customers set
- 5:40up their multi sig volts. Yeah.
- 5:44Yeah, Lauren, that what So what we do, what Andy and I do with
- 5:48on ramp is we help people have multi sig wallets where they
- 5:55don't have to set up and manage and control their own keys.
- 5:59And instead they hire 3 separate institutions that do this for
- 6:06their business so that they have higher, they're hiring
- 6:10professional key holders to to hold a key on, on their behalf
- 6:16and in, you know, one of these three key setups.
- 6:19Yeah. And we should state, actually I
- 6:21don't know why we didn't start with this, but multi sig is is
- 6:24short for multiple signatures. Why didn't we think of that?
- 6:32Guy lesson, lesson learned. After years of explaining how
- 6:35things work on Bitcoin, we're still all terrible at it.
- 6:38Yeah. Yes, you're in the weeds.
- 6:42OK. So yeah, does that make it and
- 6:44when when you use your Bitcoin hardware wallet for example,
- 6:47that is also known, it's not a hardware wallet, it's a signing
- 6:51device. So that is making a signature
- 6:54for you. The only you would be able to
- 6:57use because it's your device and you have the password and the
- 7:01pass phrase to it. That device is signing the yes,
- 7:06you own this Bitcoin, and yes, where it's sending to or being
- 7:11sent to is a valid Bitcoin address.
- 7:14Yeah, yeah. I think that would have been a
- 7:16better start. All right, multiple signatures
- 7:19guys. All right, let's get it on the
- 7:20website like, you know, let's. Fair enough, well played,
- 7:25Lauren. Lauren, do you, do you ever use,
- 7:30do you ever do Minecraft? I used to but I don't have it
- 7:35anymore. She's moved past, moved on to
- 7:38better things, just like Satoshi or.
- 7:41Honestly, no. I would have had it if I could,
- 7:43but it was on a different device and that broke down like years
- 7:46ago. But what were you?
- 7:48She's very knowledgeable of Minecraft.
- 7:50I only ask because because my 12 year old's, my 12 year old's
- 7:53into it right now and I thought I might be able to talk about
- 7:57something cool, cool and Internet Y that she might be
- 8:00into. That's not Bitcoin.
- 8:03OK. Lauren, do you do you miss
- 8:06France or are you happy to be in in England?
- 8:11I literally film nothing. Yeah, all right.
- 8:16It's been a seamless transition other than like the, the, the
- 8:20mess of everything and, you know, moving the, the things.
- 8:25Yeah, it still feels as though we're on a home swap or
- 8:29something. Yeah.
- 8:29It's like kind of on holiday, but with all of our stuff.
- 8:32Yeah, yeah. Yeah, that makes sense.
- 8:36It's been good, been, yeah, it's been, it's been a good one.
- 8:39It's been fun. It probably doesn't hurt me as
- 8:42much because I know I'm going to go back to France.
- 8:46If we like lived in Asia and then moved to Europe, I know
- 8:49that's a harder place to go to. In just 20 days, we're going
- 8:54back to France and when we go for a walk along the the, the
- 8:57sea front here on a clear day, you can see France, it's just
- 9:00right there, right across the water.
- 9:04You're on the South, so you're in the OK, you're in the near
- 9:08the channel. Yep.
- 9:10Good for you. Oh yeah.
- 9:12Beautiful murky waters, big Stony beaches.
- 9:15How is it cold? Yeah, big white cliffs, that's.
- 9:19Right, they are very close, the White Cliffs of Dover.
- 9:23Yeah, you've been wanting to go swim in the sea.
- 9:25I know I just got to find the right time.
- 9:28I'm going to go do a cold plunge in the in the channel there.
- 9:32Swim the channel, aren't you? Aren't you a princey?
- 9:37I won't be doing that. Certainly not.
- 9:39I'll go for a dip, but no, no swimming.
- 9:42All right. Well, thanks for your questions.
- 9:43Thank you for having me. Thank you.
- 9:46Bye bye. See you soon.
- 9:48Bye bye. Yeah, guys.
- 9:52So I mean, we usually do the macro monthly that turn into the
- 9:57macro BI monthly that turn into like should we just do this
- 10:00every quarter because we can't organize ourselves?
- 10:02And so here we are back October time, that time of recording
- 10:09what has happened since we last chatted.
- 10:12And let's start with, let's start with on ramp because
- 10:16that's what you're building, that's what you're both involved
- 10:18in. What has what, what strides
- 10:22forward have you taken? What's changed within the
- 10:23company over the last, let's say 6?
- 10:26Months, yeah, six months. The number one thing is
- 10:32momentum. I mean, there's a, there's been
- 10:34a lot of new client signups. The product keeps getting
- 10:40better. It's really cool now.
- 10:43I think the format we've always known that we are, we have a
- 10:46great format for for to offer the market of here's a, here's a
- 10:52potential custody arrangement that depending on your
- 10:57circumstances, could fit into what you're doing already or
- 11:02could be right. For someone who's just coming
- 11:04into the market and isn't tech savvy and doesn't feel like you
- 11:07know, they're up to the task for self custody, but knows enough
- 11:10to know it's not wise to leave your funds on, on exchange
- 11:15anyway. We've always known we've had a,
- 11:16we had a good format and the product has gone from a year
- 11:21ago, I'd say it was pretty clunky to now it's like pretty
- 11:24slick. The user interface and all of
- 11:27the, the steps and processes and engineering behind the scenes is
- 11:33really quite, quite cool. And, and I think people have
- 11:36heard about us a lot more now versus 6 months ago.
- 11:40And so we're getting out, you know, a lot of a lot of sign
- 11:43ups. It's it's been pretty exciting
- 11:46to see. So that yeah, I guess that's the
- 11:49the big, the big, the big news on the on ramp front is, is that
- 11:54people are are really starting to take interest in adding this
- 12:01form of custody to their existing self custody.
- 12:04I think that's kind of the most common scenario.
- 12:07Our most common client is someone who feels a little
- 12:12uncomfortable with all the responsibility of a multi sig
- 12:15setup or even collaborative custody setup.
- 12:17Where at the end of the day you have all the majority of the
- 12:20technical and security burden on you and it leaves you worried at
- 12:26night a little bit. You know, just in case you have
- 12:30some vulnerability you're unaware of or if you screwed
- 12:33something up and you have all your eggs in one basket.
- 12:36So I'd say our most common client at this point is someone
- 12:39who's been in that circumstance and wants a little bit more
- 12:42Peace of Mind of having multiple baskets with different that are
- 12:46different custody arrangements. So, you know, keep your keep
- 12:52your collaborative custody, multi sig self custody set up
- 12:56and then add a multi institution custody vault.
- 13:00And then based on however it feels comfortable, split your
- 13:06assets between those two forms of custody and and know that
- 13:09you've kind of distributed your risk between two custody
- 13:12formats. So I think that's, that's kind
- 13:16of the, the, the most common pain point that that we're
- 13:20helping to solve at this point in time.
- 13:23Yeah. And, and that is, you know,
- 13:24probably the number one question we get of like, OK, so 33
- 13:29separate institutions hold a key, but doesn't that mean that
- 13:32a person from two of the institutions, you know, they
- 13:35could collaborate, collude and you got one guy in one
- 13:39institution and one guy in the other institution and they, you
- 13:42know, sign a transaction to, to sweep out your account.
- 13:45But it, you know, it doesn't work that way at an institution.
- 13:48It's not like Bitco's hold is, has one guy with a, a hardware
- 13:51wallet in his desk drawer. And like that's, you know,
- 13:54that's how they're running their multi billion dollar business,
- 13:57their institutional grade key arrangements and then
- 14:01institutional grade processes, personnel access controls and
- 14:06physical access controls that make it so you'd have to, you'd
- 14:12have to have a half dozen plus people in any institution on
- 14:18board and then break all of the personnel and physical access
- 14:22control protocols in place that are, that are designed by each
- 14:27institution in order to be, you know, in impenetrable because,
- 14:33because their entire business relies on them not screwing up
- 14:36something like that. And you know, like in Bicco's
- 14:40case, because one of the key holders for us and they're, they
- 14:46are running the same processes to with that, with that
- 14:51particular key arrangement for an entire ETF.
- 14:56So you know, they're protecting an, an entire ETF with 1/3 of
- 15:00the security that we're that's involved in our custody
- 15:04arrangement because that's one of the keys for us and it's, you
- 15:07know, the entire ET FS protection for, for that ETF.
- 15:11And I, I've got a question about that because there's been a
- 15:14little bit of noise and I've not, I'm not completely up to,
- 15:17to speed on it, but we'll park it for now because I think the
- 15:21pledge listening, I'm probably thinking right now, huh, OK, so
- 15:27multi sig and inheritance because I was just playing
- 15:31around on a dashboard earlier and it's been a while since I
- 15:33logged in actually. And I do remember actually when
- 15:36I was when we were going to and from and I was testing it out
- 15:39when you said, oh, it used to be quite clunky.
- 15:43It is way slicker now when I, when I was on it and take a look
- 15:46at it. And I remember actually when I
- 15:49was doing the practice deposit and withdraw my I had multiple
- 15:54phone calls. I think from bit go you had to
- 15:57go through at least two people, if I'm not mistaken.
- 16:00So that, you know, to your point, the the the chances of
- 16:03there being some kind of collusion between like, you
- 16:07know, bad actors at these different places is, is almost
- 16:11what I just, yeah, I don't want to say never, but.
- 16:15Right, right. So and the last thing, you know,
- 16:18if if somebody if some bad actors at let's say bit go
- 16:23wanted to collude to steal funds, they wouldn't do it in a
- 16:26multi institution custody arrangement to sweep out
- 16:29oneplebs address. They would they would target the
- 16:32ETF that has, you know, the is solely protected by that that
- 16:38one key much more hanging. Fruit.
- 16:41Yeah, much more lucrative. Yeah, you also reminded me that
- 16:45the other big change over the last six months is we, we
- 16:49realized we, we can serve a larger portion of the market
- 16:55then because of our, our, our cost structures to serve an
- 17:01incremental client is it's, it's there's a lot of, there's a lot
- 17:06of fixed costs and then and then variable costs are not so, not
- 17:09so high. So we were able to extend our
- 17:12product offering to a bit further down market than than we
- 17:16previously thought. So our pricing now starts at
- 17:20$150.00 a month and so that's comes out to 1800 a year which
- 17:29is comparable or better than some of the other collaborative
- 17:33custody pricing structures out there.
- 17:36So you know if if people have heard of on rent before and
- 17:40thought well that's for you know for for bigger balances.
- 17:43That's kind of how we started and we have been able to expand
- 17:47our are offering to to folks who who you know may only have
- 17:54100,000 or 200,000 that that and it starts to make sense to to
- 17:59factor that in at that point. So.
- 18:02Yeah, exactly. And that of course that price
- 18:05point will put people off because they will think, well I
- 18:08can just buy a hardware wallet for like 100 bucks.
- 18:11Right. Yep.
- 18:12And if you're comfortable with that one, it's because you're
- 18:15technical enough and you've, you've gone down the, you know,
- 18:19the learning curve to master what's needed there and good for
- 18:23you. Like, like do that.
- 18:25If you can handle self custody and you can sleep well at night,
- 18:28great. Like that's, that's an
- 18:30outstanding outcome. If your balance has grown a
- 18:35little too large for you to sleep comfortably at night.
- 18:38And then maybe that's it's worth looking into.
- 18:42And also like if you're, if you're, if you're trying to get
- 18:45your dad into into Bitcoin and and you're trying to find the
- 18:51right place to, to get him to buy Bitcoin and have it be
- 18:54protected, We can do that. And that he can set up with on
- 18:57ramp, buy Bitcoin at at institutional rates, So like
- 19:03very low trading fees and then have it settle to multi
- 19:08institution custody. So it's vastly better outcome
- 19:11than you know, if he was to buy it on Coinbase or set up his own
- 19:15hardware wallet and screw it up and lose it.
- 19:17And and to him like to to, to carry on that thread with like
- 19:21onboarding your dad, for example, is login.
- 19:24Here's a slick looking website. It's very professional looking.
- 19:27Here's a little dashboard. This is exactly you know what
- 19:30you're holding. This is where you can just hit
- 19:32the buy button, which I think is an upgrade since we last spoke,
- 19:35I can't remember. I think you're just rolling that
- 19:37out so he can buy Bitcoin directly.
- 19:40He can deposit dollars into it. It's just like a a Charles
- 19:43Schwab trading account. You know, it's, it's what we're
- 19:46going for. It's nothing.
- 19:49There's nothing too complicated there.
- 19:51It's not this weird, strange world of Bitcoin.
- 19:54It's like, oh, this just looks normal.
- 19:56So I deposit dollars, I buy Bitcoin and they go straight
- 19:59into multi C You won't even know what those words mean.
- 20:01Multi C you won't need to because to him it'll just be my
- 20:05online. Vault.
- 20:06My online Bitcoin trading account, like if, if that's and
- 20:10the learning comes later. But yeah, to to onboard more
- 20:13people. I think is is critical and key
- 20:17and this is what we're trying to do every single day as plebs on
- 20:19the street. So to have this offering, I
- 20:23think makes a hell of a lot of sense.
- 20:26Yeah, thank you. Yeah.
- 20:28And it, it keeps getting, keeps getting better, which is it's,
- 20:31it's been very exciting. So anyway, I mean, we can talk
- 20:34about other things, but if anybody's interested in learning
- 20:36more about the product, just go to on rampbitcoin.com and click
- 20:39schedule consultation and, and we'll, we'll tell you all about
- 20:43what it is and, and, you know, ask about your, your
- 20:47circumstances and needs and, and maybe it's for you or maybe, you
- 20:50know, we'll point you towards what's right.
- 20:53Yeah, exactly. And if they use that code bits
- 20:55and they will save on the fees, 250 bucks.
- 20:58And last thing about the fees people, again, all right, if
- 21:06you've been investing in a classic pension scheme or index
- 21:12fund or mutual fund or whatever, take a look at those fees.
- 21:16You're used to paying fees, believe me.
- 21:19And they're probably a lot higher and the the asymmetrical
- 21:23gain of what you're holding in a multi sig Volt compared to your
- 21:26fees, it's just going to go up, up the value compared to the
- 21:31fee. You know, the fees are just
- 21:31going to stay, right. They're not going to go up a
- 21:35little bit, but nothing near as much as what you're holding.
- 21:41Yep. All right, Andy, let's bring it
- 21:43in. Well, let me, let me well, let
- 21:46me tell you what I've been having fun with it on Ramp,
- 21:48which is which is our podcast. And we came out of the gate
- 21:55strong. We we first few episodes were
- 21:59Preston Fish and Jeff Booth and Lynn Alden and we had Pierre and
- 22:03Morgan, Richard and Breedlove and Mark Moss and Gladstein and
- 22:07Samson Mao, Dan Tapiero, VJ Lavish, Natalie Brunel and Sam
- 22:15Callahan 2 Fer Then we had Scaramucci and we we we've been
- 22:21going through the the BPI crew, the Bitcoin Policy Institute,
- 22:25Matt Pines and Troy Cross and David Zell, the founder and Ovic
- 22:30Roy who's an advisor. And then we just.
- 22:33Those guys are all so smart, by the way.
- 22:35It's incredible, yeah. So smart, I mean, but just yeah,
- 22:39in my opinion, well, they're my favorite Bitcoin organization,
- 22:44you know, non company organization.
- 22:48And then we had Tomer. Our episode of Tomer just came
- 22:50out and we recorded with the the great whale himself, Michael
- 22:54Saylor, and that'll be episode 21.
- 22:58Nice. Yes, Yeah, Well done.
- 23:02I've got lots to catch up on. I've listened to a few and I was
- 23:04listening to one earlier on actually.
- 23:07So the world of podcasting we've.
- 23:10Learned from you, learned from you, princey.
- 23:12Just been watching you work your magic over the years here and
- 23:17you know, for some reason decided it would be a good idea
- 23:20to to, to try it out and see what happens and, and it's been
- 23:24great. It's been a lot of fun.
- 23:26At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 23:29asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 23:32right. There are shortcomings with
- 23:34keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 23:37up your own self custody arrangement.
- 23:40Onramp solves for these concerns.
- 23:42Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 23:46minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 23:49remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 23:52inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 23:55well. Onramp provides Peace of Mind
- 23:58for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 24:01for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 24:04setup. For more information, check us
- 24:06out at onrampbitcoin.com. Francie, I have, I have a
- 24:10question from our our sailor episode.
- 24:13A major topic in that I want to get your thoughts on was Bitcoin
- 24:18yield, you know, and, and are there ways to do it in a, in a
- 24:25way where it is, it makes sense from a risk perspective or not?
- 24:30What do you think? I, I always default to Alan
- 24:34Farrington. Where does the yield come from
- 24:36and the yield of the friends you make along the way when it, when
- 24:40it comes to this particular. Yeah, how how can you set it up?
- 24:47I like, I I've yet to like. See a.
- 24:51So Taylor's argument, which I find very compelling, is that I
- 24:59think, I think there's an, an unstated assumption in here of
- 25:02like for the short to medium term, like, you know, decade, a
- 25:08decade or so, this is probably viable of if you can borrow
- 25:13from, from JP Morgan, is it borrow or lend to, I guess Andy
- 25:21I. Don't know you're the one
- 25:23explaining this. So you're already in a mess.
- 25:27So you you've have you got to. Give to.
- 25:30JP Morgan, like, is that what you have to do first?
- 25:33Because I'm out straight away. Yeah, I guess the the idea is
- 25:41that JP Morgan is as good as the US government like it, they're
- 25:45connected. And so if if you're if you're
- 25:50yield is coming from JP Morgan. Control the US government, I
- 25:54think is what you're trying to say.
- 25:55Yes, controlled and backstopped by the US government.
- 25:58So if they're saying, you know, we'll give you a 5% yield, you
- 26:04know, we like, let us, let us borrow your, your, your money
- 26:11and we will give you a 5% yield on it, then that's, that's
- 26:18bankable or, or at least, or at least that's, that's low enough
- 26:22risk that it actually makes sense to do that's I guess his
- 26:25argument. So.
- 26:27Which is of course problematic, you know, potentially
- 26:31problematic in that they can't print more Bitcoin.
- 26:35So, you know, if you had some event where Bitcoin just went
- 26:37bananas to the moon and you're or your assets, their liability
- 26:43denominated to you is denominated in Bitcoin.
- 26:45Like they owe you your coins back plus 5% plus the yeah,
- 26:50exactly. Plus the yield.
- 26:52Although they can I guess they can print that part maybe.
- 26:56But the and. I think that Sailor's argument
- 26:58is like, if they're good for the Bitcoin, they're definitely good
- 27:02for the yield, and that there is that assumption that they're
- 27:04good for the Bitcoin and they won't fuck it up.
- 27:06But yeah. Yeah.
- 27:08Who knows? Did you see Mike talk about
- 27:11usury that I went around? I think we're, I think Daniel's
- 27:19setting up his his views here. Yeah.
- 27:22So where does that like? So, yeah, let's say let's walk
- 27:25through it. Well, it's like with any loan,
- 27:27you go, any Fiat loan, you go, you want a mortgage, you want a
- 27:30car, you want a holiday, you want a couch, need the washing
- 27:33machine, whatever it is. And you go in to the showroom
- 27:36and you speak to the salesman. It's like, oh, well, come from
- 27:38you. Oh, it doesn't matter.
- 27:39It's 0% finance and you're, you're good to go because
- 27:44they've got the financial arm of whatever bank backing them
- 27:48underwriting the, the, the salesperson, the showroom.
- 27:51So where does that come from? Well, that's just like credit.
- 27:54It's an expansion of credit. It's not like with they're not
- 27:58literally at that point printing money into the system, but they
- 28:01are expanding the credit in the system.
- 28:03So we've got the, the monetary base that just gets wider,
- 28:07right? So that means at one point the
- 28:10monetary base is going to have to come up to try and meet the
- 28:14the credit at one stage. And this is what Parker talks
- 28:16about in his chapter, Bitcoins not backed by anything.
- 28:20I think we went through it. So the expansion of credit
- 28:22therefore leaves to quantitative easing, let's call it that,
- 28:25printing a shit ton of money to try and bring that.
- 28:27And we'll never get it into balance, right.
- 28:29There's never $1.00 out there for the one credit it it's like
- 28:3312:50 or whatever that the, the numbers are at the moment.
- 28:36Now that that money that gets printed or this credit that just
- 28:40gets like it. So a mortgage is a perfect
- 28:42example. You will, you want the, you want
- 28:45the $500,000 house. You have $100,000 to deposit
- 28:50that $100,000 that you've accrued over the last 10 years
- 28:53of very hard work using your skills and your time and your
- 28:55energy to get the job in the 1st place and work your way out the
- 28:58corporate ladder. That $100,000 represents
- 29:01everything that you've worked for until that point.
- 29:04Now the bank will take that $100,000.
- 29:07Thank you very much. That's just a deposit and we'll
- 29:10give you the other 400,000 in form of a loan.
- 29:14That loan that's not printed at that point, but that is credit
- 29:17that's created and then we're going to charge you interest on
- 29:20that. Now the definition of usury is a
- 29:25an exorbitant charge of interest on lent money.
- 29:29Now if that money is counterfeit, it doesn't matter
- 29:33if it's 0.025% or 15% that you're being charged on it, it's
- 29:38usury because it was non existent in the first place.
- 29:42So that my argument with the whole yield thing with Bitcoin
- 29:45is that if I place first of all, I, you've, I'm not comfortable
- 29:50sending Bitcoin to JP Morgan. And I don't think there's any
- 29:53amount of small print there that you could wade through to be
- 29:58completely, 100% certain that they're going to be good actors
- 30:01in three or four years time, however long the term is for.
- 30:04And they will return the Bitcoin and goodness knows what kind of
- 30:08financial wizardry they're going to get up with to with it whilst
- 30:11they're holding it in that time. But they can return you to fit.
- 30:14Of course they can because they just like they, they just extend
- 30:17the credit. And So what does that do?
- 30:21Well, that instead of, so I know I've heard Sailor talk about
- 30:25dying with your Bitcoin to leave a legacy because you increase
- 30:28the purchasing power of everybody else around you after
- 30:31you've gone. Whereas what's going on right
- 30:34now the, the, the hundreds of millions that are being borrowed
- 30:37and just like printed is devaluing the purchasing power
- 30:42of everybody's dollars whilst we're alive.
- 30:46So there's two sides to every story.
- 30:49And the, the whole yield on Bitcoin thing, I don't know.
- 30:54A friend of mine is in Australia.
- 30:55He's trying to think of a way to do this where you would have
- 31:02fixed term, a four year fixed term and you would draw monthly,
- 31:08you would be paid out monthly in Fiat, but it wouldn't be with
- 31:11banks, it'd be with private investment groups, like multiple
- 31:16institutions that come in to provide the Fiat.
- 31:19Then where are they getting it from?
- 31:21So, you know, it's it's a difficult one.
- 31:25One thing that's happening talk about this with Lavera, is you
- 31:30know I. Think, I think we.
- 31:31Lost your mic, Andy? We lost your mic.
- 31:33We've gone. We've gone back to amateur.
- 31:36Amateur hour here. Per hour mic, Hold on.
- 31:40Yeah. So, Prince, I agree with your,
- 31:45your summary. I think, I think where I come
- 31:49out is that if I was in Michael Saylor's shoes and JP Morgan is,
- 31:55you know, it's possible to have JP Morgan as the counterparty.
- 32:01And you know, I'm valuing I'm, I'm trying to assess the risk
- 32:06of, of default, right, of, of, of non repayment.
- 32:12I think I'm assessing that risk it at 1% or less.
- 32:17And I'm, and I'm happy to take a 5% yield for the right position
- 32:23size, right? Like whatever that means to you.
- 32:26Like I'm personally, I would love to be able to, to lend 10%
- 32:30of my meager stack to JP Morgan and get those terms and get a
- 32:34little like a 5% yield knowing that I'm risking only 10% in
- 32:38that, in that 1% scenario of, of default.
- 32:42You know, I think I feel like so, so I see that argument from
- 32:46Sailor and I feel like I, I guess I'm sort of on his page in
- 32:51terms of like, well, JP Morgan's taking the risk and at the end
- 32:55of the day, like they're going to be backstopped by the US
- 32:57government and I'm going to be made whole, most likely.
- 33:03But there's a 1% risk maybe that I'm not.
- 33:05Yeah. My mind goes to 61 O2, right?
- 33:08I mean, the actual 61O2 attack that occurred in 1933, they had
- 33:13to print in the newspapers. Hey, you guys, get to your
- 33:16nearest Federal Reserve Bank representative bank and turn in
- 33:20your gold now because we're taking that off you.
- 33:23You're not allowed to hold gold. Now, if the same thing was to
- 33:26happen to Bitcoin and it's already in the banks because you
- 33:28placed it there to to to try and score a little bit of yield off
- 33:33it. And let's not forget, like who
- 33:35are the biggest thieves on the street?
- 33:37You know, if we were worried about a $5 wrench attack, I
- 33:40mean, that can happen. Somebody can steal your wallet
- 33:44and steal the $20 out of your wallet anytime.
- 33:46But like. So you're saying is is?
- 33:48Don't trust that small print, really.
- 33:50No, no, because that small print can be usurped and over read.
- 33:54That small print is a wrench, a giant, giant ranch.
- 33:58Yeah. And we, we know, we all know how
- 34:02the the Federal Reserve Bank. If not, then go and read the
- 34:05secrets of the Federal Reserve and look at JP Morgan's
- 34:07involvement in that setup and who actually owns the stake in
- 34:11the the Federal Reserve. And they are, you know, that
- 34:15they're ultimately calling the shots, as we know.
- 34:18And if they put pressure because they want to roll their CBDC
- 34:22out, let's hypothetically they want to roll out Fed coin,
- 34:25whatever, the first thing they're going to do is cripple
- 34:27Bitcoin. And if there's a bunch of
- 34:30Bitcoiners with their Bitcoin sitting, JP Morgan's coffers,
- 34:34one of the closest, most exposed stakeholders to the other
- 34:39Federal Reserve and what they're going to do, they're just going
- 34:41to rub you and they'll probably pay you out and it's OK, but
- 34:45we'll give you the Fed coin equivalent and the, the kicker
- 34:49on top. So, yeah, I, I mean, I've not
- 34:55spoken personally to Sailor about it, but I, I saw the
- 34:58conversation with safe. I look forward to listening to
- 35:00your part about it too. But for for the for the plebs,
- 35:05just just stack. Right, Yeah, for the none of us
- 35:09have access to the potential like negotiations that we, you
- 35:14know, that micro strategy could have with somebody like JP
- 35:16Morgan to say like, all right, here are our terms.
- 35:18Do you accept you're going to be paying us 5% yield under our
- 35:21terms? No pleb has access to that.
- 35:24So you would just get rugged by, you know, by tiptoeing into JP
- 35:29Morgan's world. Can you guys hear me again or is
- 35:32it still busted? Yeah.
- 35:33Come on, Andy, come on. I've been dying to get your take
- 35:36on this. All right, all right, all right.
- 35:37So a couple things. I was, I was talking about this
- 35:39on on Lavera last week, which is what's the other than Bitcoin?
- 35:45What's the big, what's the fastest growing asset class sort
- 35:51of new asset class in the world, anyone.
- 35:55It's this thing called private credit, and what it is, is it's
- 36:01so it's junk credit, OK, It's low quality or highly levered
- 36:06companies that have a lot of debt.
- 36:09This is the market that first sprang out of Michael Milken's
- 36:14head in the. 80s. Right back in the 80s, OK,
- 36:18Drexel made a killing on this, Milken went to prison.
- 36:23There's a great story there. People should definitely read
- 36:26it. Also, he's reinvented himself as
- 36:29a philanthropist. He runs one of the most
- 36:32exclusive and successful conferences globally.
- 36:37It happens every year here in LA, in Los Angeles.
- 36:41Anyway, that's a whole other can of worms.
- 36:44So the, the junk bond market grew rapidly in the 19, really
- 36:51the like the late 80s and and then into the 90s.
- 36:56Then there was a second low quality debt market that sprang
- 37:00out, which is called the leveraged loan market.
- 37:03And that was actually ongoing on the time, you know, when I was
- 37:08on Wall Street, maybe even when, when you were princey, although
- 37:12it might have been a little bit after your time.
- 37:16And it's basically a similar product.
- 37:19You know, you're lending to highly indebted companies, lower
- 37:24quality credits. There's a high risk of default,
- 37:27basically. OK.
- 37:28And what's happened, though, in the last decade or so is in a
- 37:32world after the financial crisis, the banks have actually
- 37:36been pulling back, reducing their lending to low quality or
- 37:42highly indebted companies. And who's stepped into the void,
- 37:46into the breach? It's the big private equity
- 37:48firms primarily. And they have launched these
- 37:51funds, which I think are a little bit similar to what you
- 37:55were describing, which is, you know, there's a bunch of
- 37:57investors, they have lock UPS on the on the funds.
- 38:01They raise funds for multiple years and then they go out and
- 38:04they underwrite loans to indebted, highly indebted
- 38:08companies. Some of them are just too small,
- 38:11frankly, to to issue bonds in the public markets.
- 38:16And so this is now more than a trillion dollar asset class.
- 38:20It's as big as the leveraged loan market.
- 38:22It's as big as the high yield bond market.
- 38:26But it is one step away from huge leverage embedded in the in
- 38:32in the lender itself, like a bank and moving more to toward a
- 38:36fund where you've got matched maturities, right?
- 38:40The capital is committed. You know, you underwrite loans,
- 38:44but the capital cannot be rugged or yanked.
- 38:49You know, it's not like a bank where people can pull their
- 38:51deposits. You can't have a situation like
- 38:54you had in the in the banking crisis 18 months ago.
- 38:59And so, yeah, frankly, it it results in less leverage in the
- 39:04lending system. And that I think is something
- 39:07more like what we'll see in the future with a Bitcoin based
- 39:11system is just overall less leverage in the system.
- 39:14But then, you know, the logical extreme, one of my favorite
- 39:17things about Bitcoiners is they go to logical extremes.
- 39:20And it's not hard to argue that, oh, maybe it won't be 100% this
- 39:24way, but maybe it'll just be 95% this way.
- 39:27And so my sense is that, yeah, they'll be much less debt in the
- 39:31system, much less credit in the system.
- 39:34But will some enterprising, will some enterprising entrepreneur
- 39:38figure out some wizzy new way to make it safe enough that some
- 39:43percentage of hodlers are willing to part with some
- 39:48portion of their stack, you know, to to get a little bit of
- 39:51yield? Yeah, I think that'll likely
- 39:53happen. It also could be much later.
- 39:55I mean it could be in a period when the annual price
- 39:58appreciation of Bitcoin in the annual it is much lower in the
- 40:01annual volatility, annualized volatility in terms of
- 40:05purchasing power is much lower. And that kind of a system
- 40:09fundamentally is less likely to go belly up and may be able to
- 40:14support some amount of credit. On top of Bitcoin, but that
- 40:17could be far away I mean that could be who knows that could be
- 40:20a decade or two away that. Could be 30 years.
- 40:23Yeah. I, I feel like the end state is
- 40:26there is some sort of Bitcoiners are able to achieve like to lend
- 40:30out their Bitcoin in, in a, in a future state where the price of
- 40:33Bitcoin doesn't rise a ton. And and you can lend out your
- 40:38Bitcoin and receive a, you know, with it with under contract of
- 40:43like a 1% yield in Bitcoin terms.
- 40:47And like that's about as extreme as you could ever hope for, you
- 40:52know, realistically. And, and how many people will be
- 40:55how much capital will be interested in that?
- 40:57A lot less than than in the Fiat system, where it makes a ton of
- 41:00sense to run it up, you know, in terms of how much leverage you
- 41:05take on because it's always easy to repay.
- 41:09And Lutnick announced this right from the, the Nashville
- 41:14conference that BGC, Cantor Fitzgerald, we're going to start
- 41:19a Bitcoin, a $2 billion financing Bitcoin product.
- 41:27I, I don't know it, I don't know the insides and outs of that.
- 41:31Did did you guys dig into what? Do you love announcements?
- 41:34Do you love announcements, Princy?
- 41:36Yeah. Announcements with no details?
- 41:40Yeah. How many?
- 41:41How many? How many announcements of new
- 41:43products, new features with no details have we seen over the
- 41:46years in in Bitcoin? It says here and I quote we are
- 41:50excited to help unlock bitcoins full potential and continue
- 41:52bridging the gap between traditional finance and digital
- 41:56assets. Bitcoin investors.
- 42:00Yeah, yeah. We will now build an incredible
- 42:04platform to support Bitcoin investors financing needs.
- 42:08Do you say incredible? Did he actually use the word?
- 42:11I would say it isn't incredible, as in not credible.
- 42:15Because there's. There's no detail like bridging
- 42:19fantastic. I mean, what are we?
- 42:20What are we talking about? I don't know we're.
- 42:23Talking about unlocking Bitcoin's full potential, which
- 42:26is the other phrase in there that is similarly nothingness.
- 42:31Yeah. But.
- 42:32What is that business are are, are they going to do something
- 42:37like you just described, like I send them Bitcoin and they send
- 42:41me cash at the end of the term or on a monthly basis?
- 42:46And am I paying them interest or are they paying me interest?
- 42:52You know what it makes me think of, it just makes me think of
- 42:54Tether. It makes me think of this, you
- 42:56know, giant whatever, $150 billion or something pile of
- 43:00assets. And we know that one of the
- 43:03things in that pile of assets is Bitcoin because they like to buy
- 43:07some Bitcoin, then hold it as part of the portfolio.
- 43:10And obviously I think we know that Cantor, you know, manages
- 43:13the the treasury with respect to Treasuries as in US T-bills that
- 43:21are part of the portfolio, the large part of the portfolio
- 43:24tether. So you know, by by some, by some
- 43:30magic, you know, could there be something going on there?
- 43:35Could you finance, could you know, could investors come
- 43:38partly finance Tethers balance sheet, you know, could you add
- 43:43some leverage on there, you know, backed by some claim
- 43:49against the Treasury? I don't know who knows?
- 43:52I mean, there's a million things you could financially engineer,
- 43:55but until we'll, we'll just have to wait and see.
- 43:59Yeah. I mean in, in theory couldn't
- 44:01you, couldn't you hedge your position and then take the
- 44:05dollars and put that into T-bills and just get that, you
- 44:09know that nominal yield while you're, you're Bitcoin neutral
- 44:13because you've hedged at the outset and you guys know more
- 44:17about this stuff than I do so. It's getting too complicated
- 44:21though, right? Just stay humble stack sets
- 44:23like. That's that's the, yeah, that's.
- 44:26True, if if you want like and this is the thing, right, people
- 44:29are how do I get more Bitcoin? Well, you provide more value in
- 44:33the marketplace. So if that means working
- 44:35overtime, getting a second job, getting a side hustle, do that.
- 44:38If that means, you know, that starting a podcast, writing a
- 44:41book for for Bitcoin as a product, do that that that's the
- 44:47way like that's the traditional way of being able to afford more
- 44:53things is by providing value, not not like OK, how do I
- 44:58financially engineer some yield wizard technique?
- 45:05Yeah, I don't like the that's my kind of PSA pleb service
- 45:10announcement. It's like just keep it simple,
- 45:13follow him at Odell and stay humble.
- 45:16Stack the sets, don't chase the yield because it might just turn
- 45:19around and bite you in the ass. Yeah, any of this stuff is.
- 45:24Really an advice, excellent, advisable.
- 45:27To to, you know, to a company with a billion dollars plus a
- 45:30Bitcoin. Like outside of that, you've got
- 45:33no business wading into this world.
- 45:37Exactly. So staying with institutions and
- 45:42ETFs and Coinbase, did you guys see that?
- 45:46Was this on your radar? Like is something happened with
- 45:49the ETFs now insisting that Coinbase have full proof of
- 45:55reserves of the coins that they are supposedly buying on behalf
- 46:00of the God knows how many customers did the inflows into
- 46:04these these ETFs are huge and they have been since January and
- 46:09that they've shown no sign of slowing down.
- 46:13What what was the what's going on?
- 46:16Like what what Sonia Ray does? And it's amazing that the the
- 46:21the Ethereum ETFs have had a net outflow during their their
- 46:27entire lifespan of a few months, yet now net outflows from from
- 46:32the Ethereum ETF. They're using that as exit
- 46:35liquidity. Large Ethereum holders are using
- 46:37the ETF to get out, which is hilarious.
- 46:40So the place in the ETF and then just taking the haircut that
- 46:44that they're sending Bitcoin to the ET, what, what are they
- 46:47doing? How?
- 46:47How are they working this out? For the Ethereum, yeah, I mean,
- 46:51I guess the mechanics would be that that they are Ethereum
- 46:58holders are probably subscribing in kind to the ETF and then
- 47:04selling to get it like as a net outflow from from the product
- 47:11rather than more dollars coming in than Ethereum coming in to be
- 47:17sold if, if that makes sense. Don't do earth, kids.
- 47:22That's that's that's the underlying message.
- 47:25But. But on, on the, on the Bitcoin
- 47:28ETF side and, and like the Coinbase, but like the
- 47:32tightening up of how Coinbase is has to settle the ETF activity.
- 47:42I think, Annie, I'm sure we'll have a more detailed and
- 47:47informed view of this. But I, I think it's probably,
- 47:50it's a great sign that, that the ETFs are, I think probably
- 47:55honest actors, at least in this regard.
- 47:58And they, so they've got nothing to hide.
- 47:59They've got nothing that they're like been trying to, you know,
- 48:02been trying to do at the margins to, to like squeeze some yield
- 48:07out of nothingness. And so this bad press sort of
- 48:11starts this circle of like, oh, you guys are allowing for, for
- 48:15like slightly opaque settlement. And they were like, oh, well,
- 48:19actually, let's just make it clearer then and, and we'll
- 48:21tighten that that up because we're not doing anything there
- 48:24anyway. So I so I guess it's a good sign
- 48:26ultimately. Yeah, I think it's fair to say
- 48:30that every bridge quote UN quote Speaking of building bridges
- 48:37between the like trad fi system, legacy finance and Bitcoin,
- 48:41there's always a little slippage or a little friction or ways
- 48:44things can go wrong. And if you're talking about, you
- 48:47know, creation and destruction of ETF shares, I mean, this is
- 48:50not my area of expertise should should call Belkunis or safer to
- 48:55the OR the ETF experts. But at it at any rate, if
- 49:04there's any slippage and if there's any errors and if
- 49:07there's any differences between the accounting of someone who
- 49:10owns an ETF share or some custodian who aggregates a bunch
- 49:16of ETF shares in the street name, you know, and, and what
- 49:20they think their their clients own in terms of actual coins,
- 49:23like actual unspent transaction outputs.
- 49:27You know, there can be problems if price moves dramatically and
- 49:31there's, and there's, you know, errors in execution on the, on
- 49:35the dollar to BTC or BTC to dollar flow.
- 49:38And so the tighter you know, the less lag you have.
- 49:43They're both with respect to execution of the trades and also
- 49:47with respect to public reporting of who owns what, you know,
- 49:52including which, which UTXOS are are you know, controlled by
- 49:57Coinbase, which is the custodian of the assets.
- 50:01You know, the, the tighter you make that stuff, probably the
- 50:04better and probably the less likely that there's, yeah, that
- 50:09there's differences between the, the accounting differences
- 50:13between the books on the Fiat side versus on the Bitcoin side.
- 50:18And now we have this extra layer options being approved.
- 50:25Yeah, this has generated some controversy.
- 50:27I mean, there's one guy I think I had a Bitwise, can't remember
- 50:30his name, who suggested that this could increase the
- 50:33volatility of Bitcoin, the dollar price volatility.
- 50:38I and then there are others who think it won't.
- 50:41I don't have AI, don't have an opinion.
- 50:45I think it matters a lot how big these markets get.
- 50:51It's definitely what you know, it's always been one of my
- 50:53concerns. Everybody's concerned right You
- 50:55you've spoken about it before Princey, about the the gold
- 50:58market and manipulation and the multiples of paper claims that
- 51:05sit pyramided on top of the actual underlying.
- 51:08And of course, that was one of the issues with FTX was, you
- 51:12know, a bunch of people quote UN quote, bought Bitcoin on FTX,
- 51:15but either they didn't actually buy the Bitcoin or they sold the
- 51:19Bitcoin later and people had claims, but actually the Bitcoin
- 51:23weren't there. And that does affect price.
- 51:26You know, if if you put in a buy order on whatever exchange and
- 51:33you think he got Bitcoin, but they don't actually buy the
- 51:35Bitcoin, then, you know, prices effectively suppressed.
- 51:39So I watched the futures markets on Bitcoin.
- 51:42I'm kind of worried about, you know, if those get really big,
- 51:45especially compared to the size of the underlying market, you
- 51:49know, could that be a price suppression tool?
- 51:52I suppose you could say the same of options.
- 51:57And then the flip side of it is, well, this is just normal with
- 52:00the normalization of of an asset class.
- 52:02Like you got a trillion dollar asset, you better believe
- 52:05there's going to be an options market on it.
- 52:07You better believe there's going to be a futures market.
- 52:09You better believe that all the tried and true ways of
- 52:15pyramiding and creating derivatives on top of some
- 52:19underlying asset of any size, which is what Wall Street's
- 52:23actually, I guess actually good at.
- 52:27You know, it's going to basically it's going to happen.
- 52:28So it's it's it's adoption, it's normalization.
- 52:32Yeah, it's nothing new under the sun.
- 52:35And so we just have to keep an eye on it.
- 52:38I don't know what the outcome will be other than this is just
- 52:42more normalization and integration of Bitcoin into the
- 52:45financial system. Yeah, the financialization side
- 52:48of Bitcoin, which we've talked about before and we always knew
- 52:51it was going to happen. We knew these markets would
- 52:52spring up out of nowhere because they already exist across the
- 52:55board on everything else. And it is a rent seekers
- 52:57paradise. So they've got it.
- 53:00They've got what they wanted. And Wall Street now are fully,
- 53:05firmly both feet planted in the Bitcoin world.
- 53:09And what worries me to, to echo the point of who whoever it
- 53:14said, well, it's going to bring more volatility.
- 53:16I think it does too. And I think it brings a, a whole
- 53:19new tool and mechanism for price manipulation.
- 53:26Because if, if you think about, let's say you've got proprietary
- 53:29trading funds out there, hedge funds, whatever, taking a punt
- 53:33on specific Bitcoin strike prices and dates like, you know,
- 53:40February 100, like, you know, 100,000 strike price and you're
- 53:46getting towards that expiry date and it's not going your way.
- 53:51Well, what can you do? You can just dip straight into
- 53:54the spot market and start manipulating the price for spot
- 53:57where you need it to go up or down, depending on, you know,
- 54:00what, what side of that trade you are.
- 54:03And I think it's going to create a lot of mess.
- 54:06And I think again, web service announcement sit back and just
- 54:11watch people get burnt because Bitcoin humbles everybody and
- 54:14Wall Street is no that they're going to count.
- 54:18There's going to be such a huge humbling.
- 54:22So let me so let me put forth a scenario because I'm just
- 54:25thinking about it real time and it does worry me too.
- 54:29So every option, let's just take a, you know, a hall option
- 54:33contract, right? You've got the buyer and the
- 54:36seller and so the buyer has unlimited upside on the price of
- 54:41Bitcoin, right. If Bitcoin goes up, the call
- 54:47option owner makes money. And by the way, they make more
- 54:51money, at least in dollar terms, well also in Bitcoin terms than
- 54:55than they would have if they just bought spot Bitcoin.
- 54:58Well, they have to pay the they have to pay the premium to the
- 55:00the yeah, yeah, the options, right, OK.
- 55:02And then if that, if that, if they buy that call option and it
- 55:06goes up through that strike price, come the point of
- 55:09maturity, they have the right to buy Bitcoin.
- 55:11Let's say it's 100,000 strike price.
- 55:13The price of Bitcoin is now 120,000.
- 55:15They have the right to buy Bitcoin at 100,000 from that
- 55:18person that wrote, right. So this is just to get people up
- 55:22to speed. So yeah, carry on.
- 55:24Yeah, yeah. And So what?
- 55:25So why is that useful, let's say for a hedge fund?
- 55:28Well, a hedge fund has only so much capital and they can
- 55:33effectively this creates leverage in terms of rate of
- 55:37return for them, right? Buying a call, this is the whole
- 55:40reason that you had Wall Street bets and you know, all these
- 55:43retail guys buying short dated call options, these lottery
- 55:47tickets is because if they hit, they make tons of money.
- 55:50OK, so that's appealing for a hedge fund.
- 55:52Well, where does that call option arise?
- 55:56It has to be created. So somebody has to be on the
- 55:58other side of that, of that trade, which means they are
- 56:04going to have potentially unlimited downside if Bitcoin
- 56:10price goes to the moon, right? They lose.
- 56:13The seller of that call loses, loses their ass essentially, if
- 56:18if it's exercised. So what?
- 56:21How do they protect themselves from that?
- 56:22Well, they have to probably collateralize it with Bitcoin
- 56:26because they can, the seller can protect themselves from the
- 56:30asset getting called away from them by having the asset right
- 56:33part there. Well, but that means one more
- 56:36Bitcoin in the financial system, right, 'cause it's gonna have to
- 56:40be literally, you know, custodied in the same system,
- 56:45the same account effectively as the call options so that that
- 56:50settlement can happen seamlessly.
- 56:53So it looks like on net that could just suck more coins right
- 56:58into the custodied system and out of, let's call it self
- 57:02custody. So don't feed the beast, keep
- 57:05your coins to yourself and in the multi sig.
- 57:10So Andy, do you think that that's one?
- 57:12What are they settling in? Are they settling just in
- 57:14dollars? So this is just I mean, do they
- 57:17even or are they settling in Bitcoin?
- 57:19I've not read the. I'm guessing they're settling in
- 57:21dollars. I actually don't.
- 57:23I actually don't know. So if they're just settling in
- 57:25dollars, then they're just going to get bailed out like they
- 57:29always do. And yeah, yeah.
- 57:35I mean. That's why I think the
- 57:36volatility, the volatility I think is going to spike in the
- 57:38near term as the financial derivative products hit the
- 57:42market and at the same time that we all know X amount of months
- 57:48after the halving and we're drawing closer every single day.
- 57:52The bulls are going to start running and there's no following
- 57:56rhyme, no reason where that is going to go, and there's no
- 57:59amount of price manipulation techniques or suppression
- 58:03techniques that Wall Street are going to be able to do without
- 58:06getting humbled. You get back to sailor too,
- 58:09right? What happens if you're right,
- 58:11Princey and the and the price volatility goes up?
- 58:14That feeds the micro strategy beast because the higher the
- 58:17volatility, the cheaper he can raise capital because the, you
- 58:22know, basically the cheaper he can underwrite new capital and
- 58:25go buy more Bitcoin. Value of the value of his of the
- 58:30embedded option in his convertible debt that he issues
- 58:34goes up and maybe that'll be a feedback loop.
- 58:38I guess we'll find out. I think that's, that's his
- 58:41thesis and I have so much FOMO about that one.
- 58:43It's the, it's the one, you know, I don't have any Bitcoin
- 58:48in the, in the tax advantage account.
- 58:50So if I was to sell any Bitcoin, it would be a taxable event.
- 58:55And so if I was wanting to get in on micro strategy, I would
- 58:59have a tax event upfront just trying to partake.
- 59:03And that has prevented me so far and still does prevent me from
- 59:08from partaking in that. But he's managed to deliver a
- 59:1017% Bitcoin yield quote UN quote by by doing this, you know, per
- 59:16share, the amount of Bitcoin that each share represents has
- 59:20gone up 17% this year. That's awesome.
- 59:25I wish I could, you know, be a part of be on that train, but
- 59:29unfortunately. And when does this new
- 59:31accounting protocol, it's first quarter of next year, is that
- 59:36right? Yeah, yeah, it's, it goes, it
- 59:38goes into I think it's January 1, 2025.
- 59:41I the option has been in place since January 1, 2024 to
- 59:48electively switch to that form of accounting and then it
- 59:52becomes mandatory. It's either Q1 or I think it's
- 59:56just January 1, 2025. And so micro strategy has not
- 1:00:01yet elected to do that. Of course, you know Wall Street
- 1:00:04is valuing their their holdings accurately, but from a a Fazbee
- 1:00:11Gap perspective, their quarterly reports continue to suck because
- 1:00:17they have to recognize any. Intra period decline in the
- 1:00:22value of their Bitcoin as a realized loss and they're not
- 1:00:26allowed to record a realized gain from any or or an
- 1:00:30unrealized gain from any appreciation in the value of
- 1:00:34their holdings intra quarter. So anyway that'll that'll start
- 1:00:39happening. Q 1/20/25 when they are when
- 1:00:42they have to switch to that. I don't know if there any
- 1:00:45stipulation I like they might be able to stage out how they
- 1:00:50transition to that rather than switching 100% Q 1 and having
- 1:00:56like a massive one time quarterly gain from from the
- 1:01:00unrealized. Quarter big, big quarter micro
- 1:01:02strategy. I know I was thinking like a.
- 1:01:05$10 billion quarter. You guys on the earnings call,
- 1:01:09you know, that's, that would be I I want yeah.
- 1:01:12I wonder how he's thinking about managing that and the team over
- 1:01:15there, but also think about like, where's where's the price
- 1:01:19of Bitcoin going to be like on that first earnings call?
- 1:01:23Yeah, you know, like. Right.
- 1:01:25Maybe it's 80, maybe it's 100 by then, maybe it's 60.
- 1:01:29We'll see. I think the, I think the really
- 1:01:33cool thing about what that'll start doing is, well,
- 1:01:37microstructure. Degree like $100,000 is this key
- 1:01:42psychological, psychological barrier and as soon as it goes
- 1:01:46to 100 and 100,000 and change. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:01:51We're in a whole new, a whole new.
- 1:01:53Era, I agree you got no reason to sell at 1:30 if you know like
- 1:02:01if if you're like, if you're going to sell, you're going to
- 1:02:03sell, you know, 90 to 110 something.
- 1:02:07You know, that's probably what you've got circled on the chart.
- 1:02:11But anyway, so I think cell cell pressure probably lightens up
- 1:02:15quite a bit once you get in 130 and then you could you could gap
- 1:02:18up to 200 pretty quick. Well, we'll see, but.
- 1:02:22Heard that if you sell any coins below 100K, you're not invited
- 1:02:25to the 100K party. That's funny because I told.
- 1:02:29You guys, I. Told you guys I caught up with
- 1:02:32Valles last night. Shout out JV, we all miss your
- 1:02:34voice. Come back to us.
- 1:02:36He sneakily just removed himself from the podcast scene.
- 1:02:40He didn't give any big farewells like, you know, it's John, John,
- 1:02:45come back to us, brother. But I said to him, well, you
- 1:02:49might be getting that call in about a few months time to start
- 1:02:54sending out the invites. So what are you going to do?
- 1:02:57Just hide in Thailand? And are you just like wherever
- 1:02:59the hell you are or are you going to come and join us?
- 1:03:01Like what's going on? You're you're supposed to be
- 1:03:03organizing this thing. And he's like, do you think,
- 1:03:09wasn't that just a meme? I'm like, yeah, but one of the
- 1:03:12most important. And there are there are a lot of
- 1:03:16people that remember it so. Yeah, that's that's definitely
- 1:03:20real. You know, he can't buy Bow out
- 1:03:23of out of that duty Bow. You got to come back.
- 1:03:29Well, well, Valles was only ever going to be like the deal was
- 1:03:31made that if it hits 100K, sailor throws the party.
- 1:03:35But but John handles the invite up to like 2000 people.
- 1:03:41Yeah, I don't I don't envy that job.
- 1:03:43But yeah, well, one, we got to get there and you know, 2 Mike's
- 1:03:48got to actually have the gas to host a party for a bunch of
- 1:03:52plebs to, you know, there's, there's a lot of variables.
- 1:03:56That's it. Oh, I'm sure.
- 1:03:58I'm sure both those guys will will honor their commitments.
- 1:04:04Through Bitcoiners. That's right.
- 1:04:07We're going to, we're going to hold them.
- 1:04:09We're going to hold them to it. So whilst we're on the this this
- 1:04:13chat of price, which we tend to steer clear of on, on the once
- 1:04:17bits and pot generally, but when you guys are on it's, it's
- 1:04:20always fun to go down these thought processes.
- 1:04:25You're your slideshow. Jesse has been doing the rounds
- 1:04:30of, of conferences. Thanks again to to to Michael,
- 1:04:35who's who's been using some of the slides from there to to
- 1:04:39show, you know, accurately what's been going on and where
- 1:04:43this could go. So do you want to lay out your
- 1:04:46thesis a little bit for those people that haven't heard where
- 1:04:52this might be going in in 10 years and and sailor's thoughts
- 1:04:55after using your using your article on your slideshow?
- 1:04:59Yeah, yeah. So, so I wrote Bitcoin's full
- 1:05:04potential valuation a year and a half ago and and Sailor read it
- 1:05:08at the time and liked it and retweeted it and send me a nice
- 1:05:12note. And then shortly after that, he
- 1:05:16started using the, the kind of framing slide that I used to tee
- 1:05:22up the, the whole article in his presentations.
- 1:05:24And that that slide is just what is the global asset landscape.
- 1:05:28It, it, it's an attempt to show all of the major buckets of
- 1:05:33value in the world and total them all up.
- 1:05:36You know, what, what, what are the subtotals and what does it
- 1:05:38all amount to? And $900 trillion was my, my
- 1:05:44research into trying to get triangulating the right size of
- 1:05:47these buckets and that those buckets are like debt and real
- 1:05:50estate and global equities and gold and money itself and, and
- 1:05:56Bitcoin and Bitcoin obviously is $1 trillion asset in this $900
- 1:06:02trillion C, So that's 0.1. Percent just just just stop
- 1:06:07there. Just.
- 1:06:08Hit one one thousandth of the Yep.
- 1:06:10One trillion in a 900 trillion marketplace.
- 1:06:16Yep, that's right. And, and I think that's why
- 1:06:20he's, he, it's why I wanted to get to that slide and it's why
- 1:06:24he started using that slide because it doesn't, it does a
- 1:06:28good job of like letting laying out how objectively early it is
- 1:06:34for Bitcoin, one, one thousandth of the world's assets.
- 1:06:40It's, and, and so the, the argument in that article goes
- 1:06:45that, and I later found out that Andy had written, written
- 1:06:49something similar in, in his book, similar kind of analysis
- 1:06:55of, of OK, so you have all these buckets.
- 1:06:58And, and if we're, if we're saying that Bitcoin is
- 1:07:00objectively a better store of value asset, has more attractive
- 1:07:04properties as a store of value asset than any of these other
- 1:07:07buckets. And in my opinion, that's
- 1:07:11because of increasing scarcity of supply issuance and the fact
- 1:07:15that there will only ever be 21 million of Bitcoin.
- 1:07:18That's not true of any other asset class, even real estate.
- 1:07:21They're always making more land or building skyscrapers.
- 1:07:26So there's always supply inflation growth with with any
- 1:07:31other store value asset anyway. Bitcoins, a better store value
- 1:07:34asset, how much of the world's value might be interested in
- 1:07:37flowing from the buckets that they're sitting in into this new
- 1:07:41bucket that's tiny now, but is a better store value asset has has
- 1:07:45better prospects of growing than anything else out there.
- 1:07:48And you know that you can stop at that point and say, well,
- 1:07:52obviously a lot. There's some amount, a lot.
- 1:07:56Or you can try to triangulate a reasonable estimate and say,
- 1:08:01well, you know, it seems like maybe you could get this amount
- 1:08:05from bonds, this amount from real estate, yada, yada.
- 1:08:09So I did that exercise and I came up with, well, I think the
- 1:08:12full potential evaluation for Bitcoin in in today's dollars is
- 1:08:17200 trillion out of the 900 trillion.
- 1:08:19So you know, 20% of the world's assets could be Bitcoin
- 1:08:22eventually, which would mean $10 million per Bitcoin in today's
- 1:08:28dollars. And that was that was my
- 1:08:30analysis. And Michael Saylor has started,
- 1:08:35started using those slides and then ended up building his own
- 1:08:39model of taking the same approach on the same methodology
- 1:08:45from, from that article and entering his assumptions, which
- 1:08:50is what I, I encouraged in the article is everybody should do
- 1:08:53this for themselves. What, what, what do you think?
- 1:08:56And so he did it and he built his own, he built his model with
- 1:08:59his team and they just open sourced it.
- 1:09:02So it's available on GitHub for you to download as an Excel
- 1:09:05model. And you could, it's a very well
- 1:09:08made model and you can tinker with the inputs and the
- 1:09:11assumptions of, of what happens. His, his version of it differs a
- 1:09:16little bit from mine, namely in that he, I, I kept all of my
- 1:09:23numbers in today's dollars because I, I feel like it, it's
- 1:09:27hard to make sense. As soon as you're factoring in
- 1:09:31potential inflation, everything gets confusing.
- 1:09:35So I kept it the future state in today's dollars, but he included
- 1:09:417% annualized inflation projection for the next 21
- 1:09:45years. And that basically 4X is all
- 1:09:49assets, the global asset landscape, which really means
- 1:09:54that the dollar becomes 1/4 is valuable and so that the
- 1:09:59existing assets are nominally 4X more in dollar terms.
- 1:10:07But his and from there he came up with his bear case, base case
- 1:10:12and bulk case. His bulk case kind of lines up
- 1:10:14with my full potential evaluation of of well, $49
- 1:10:18million per Bitcoin divided by 4 to get, you know, 12, which is
- 1:10:26pretty close to my 10 million per Bitcoin number.
- 1:10:29His his base case was 13 million per Bitcoin and again, you got
- 1:10:34to divide by 4 to get what that would mean in today's dollar.
- 1:10:37So that's three million, $3,000,000 per Bitcoin in
- 1:10:42today's dollars. And his and his bear case was
- 1:10:44lower, lower than that. But yeah, that's the that's the
- 1:10:47full summary of what I put that article out there.
- 1:10:50Sailors been using that graphic and then and then ended up
- 1:10:54running with that framework and putting out his own model, which
- 1:10:58has been really, really cool to see it it I I told him on our
- 1:11:03podcast it's it's definitely the the biggest honor I've had in in
- 1:11:07my Bitcoin career. So I'm thrilled that it
- 1:11:10happened. And it was projected out over
- 1:11:12how long? Like 10 years or something.
- 1:11:14So I, I didn't, I said decades and I'm and I, you know, I
- 1:11:20didn't put a number to it. He said 21 years.
- 1:11:24So he sort of set the 2045 and obviously using the 21 number as
- 1:11:29a meme. But yeah, that's yeah, full
- 1:11:34potential I think probably takes longer than two decades, but I
- 1:11:37think that's part of why his his base case is lower than full
- 1:11:40potential. Love it.
- 1:11:44So I love the my turn now. I love the full the full
- 1:11:48potential framework. I just celebrated five years
- 1:11:54anniversary of Why Buy Bitcoin and Why Buy Bitcoin includes
- 1:11:59evaluation, you know, evaluation.
- 1:12:02What chapter is it in there? Oh.
- 1:12:06Since you asked Jesse, it's Page 1. 100 Are you sitting
- 1:12:10comfortably, boys and girls? No, it's a, it's Chapter 9 is
- 1:12:17the investment case for Bitcoin and, and so the categories, you
- 1:12:22know for me at the time where it's going to take market share
- 1:12:25from gold, it's going to take market share from Fiat, from
- 1:12:28offshore assets and other stores of value including real estate,
- 1:12:33stocks, etcetera. OK.
- 1:12:35And then what I did is I, I took a 10 year view.
- 1:12:39I was, I guess I was too short term, too short term greedy here
- 1:12:44people, right? Too high time preference.
- 1:12:49But the number I came out with for the 10 year view and
- 1:12:53remember this is five years ago. So we're halfway there was
- 1:12:57$400,000 per Bitcoin and at the time of publication the the
- 1:13:03price of Bitcoin was like between 8:00 and 9:00 K OK,
- 1:13:07let's call it 9 K. So you're talking about a 10
- 1:13:13year time frame where you go from or let's call it 8 if you
- 1:13:17go from 8K to 400K, that's what multiple 50X OK.
- 1:13:24So, and if you assume it's somewhat exponential, you say,
- 1:13:28OK, what's sqrt 50 roughly? That's sqrt 49.
- 1:13:35So you figure out maybe get 7X and then you get another 7X.
- 1:13:40Well, it's we're halfway there time wise.
- 1:13:41It's five years out of 10 and 7X on 8K or 9K is about 60 K.
- 1:13:50So we're kind of, you know, probably by blind luck right on
- 1:13:54schedule or right on target as far as my 10 year projection.
- 1:14:00But that's just a 10 year view. You know, there's no guarantees.
- 1:14:04That's certainly much. That that 10 years is up in
- 1:14:07what, like 2029? Yeah, five years from now. 5
- 1:14:11Five years from now, 400 OK. Which seems kind of reasonable,
- 1:14:15right? I mean, you know, order of
- 1:14:17magnitude you're talking, you still get one more.
- 1:14:19That's yet another cycle away. It might even be five years
- 1:14:23might be in the teeth of, you know, the final bull move on.
- 1:14:27If we get a bull move in 2025, you know, then four years later,
- 1:14:31you're talking 2029. Look, it could be an under an
- 1:14:35undershot. I, I don't know, time will tell,
- 1:14:37but but that's kind of where I came out.
- 1:14:40That is not my view of potential full valuation.
- 1:14:44I, I like Jesse's framework because that's the, you know,
- 1:14:49that's the apotheosis. That's the the ultimate outcome
- 1:14:52for this thing if it reaches its potential.
- 1:14:55But that's my 10 year view and we're we're kind of halfway
- 1:14:57there, yeah. You kind of you're exactly on
- 1:15:00track. That's going to be a hell of a
- 1:15:02victory lap in five. Years it's.
- 1:15:04Spot on, Andy. Fingers crossed boys, although
- 1:15:08it won't be as fun. It won't be as fun as Grandpa,
- 1:15:11Grandpa Jesse, you know, telling his his kids and or grandkids
- 1:15:15about about the how yeah, we've Bitcoin reached its full
- 1:15:19potential that the grandpa wrote about her dad wrote about, you
- 1:15:23know, 30 years prior, one years prior, whatever it is.
- 1:15:26He'll have his grandkids on his knee reading them Bitcoin on the
- 1:15:29yuppie elite. He's like and here's an old one
- 1:15:32from the from the days of Andy you you've got you've got a
- 1:15:37halving 17th of April 2028 right in there.
- 1:15:41So. Like my chances?
- 1:15:45Yeah, there's your juice to get to 400.
- 1:15:47Yeah, wow, plant that one in your Diaries, plebs.
- 1:15:52But to bring this, I mean, it's been a great meandering
- 1:15:55conversation as always. But to bring it back to what we
- 1:15:58started talking about at the beginning, and this is, I know
- 1:16:03through personal conversations, Jesse, This is why you started
- 1:16:08looking at like the, the cold storage options.
- 1:16:11And how do people protect that? Because if if you're listening
- 1:16:16here and you got a coin or two anywhere that we've just been
- 1:16:25talking about, the next decade or the decade after that just
- 1:16:29becomes like such a significant amount of wealth.
- 1:16:33And if you're holding more than that and you've been stacking
- 1:16:36diligently away for the last five years or so, then this is
- 1:16:40something that you're going to, I really have to think about
- 1:16:43now. And those to your point earlier,
- 1:16:46those hardware wallets, those signing devices, whatever you
- 1:16:49want to call them, they get pretty heavy pretty quickly in
- 1:16:53these ridiculous like RIP UPS and the social engineering
- 1:17:01that's been happening. And I'll point people to go and
- 1:17:05listen to a Jim Seth's podcast. I think he's released another
- 1:17:08one since, but the one I listened to, yeah, I think.
- 1:17:12He said, I think he's had three now.
- 1:17:14Really. Yeah.
- 1:17:17He said, well, the third one, he said that this guy jumped into
- 1:17:21the boat. Like, you know, this fish jumped
- 1:17:23in the boat because he was a hacker who wanted to be
- 1:17:28interviewed about being a hacker.
- 1:17:30And so he proactively sought it out because I guess John Seth
- 1:17:34has become like known among these these hackers.
- 1:17:39I like the the balls on this kid that he like he was still a
- 1:17:45senior, right? He, I think he was like. 15,
- 1:17:47Yeah, He claimed he was a high schooler, Yeah.
- 1:17:50Driving around in the most ridiculous cars.
- 1:17:52And I'm thinking it was really sad actually to listen to
- 1:17:59because the kid thought he had found like the the key to life,
- 1:18:05not realizing there's just a full on felon at the age of 15.
- 1:18:09Like you, you're a criminal. There's no coming back from
- 1:18:11this. Like you, you will not well,
- 1:18:14once you're caught and you will be caught.
- 1:18:18And even if you're not like you know, you know, inside your soul
- 1:18:23knows. And that's never a good place to
- 1:18:25be. But do you want to explain to
- 1:18:27people what's going on, how this is being perpetrated, and what
- 1:18:33people really need to be very, very focused on?
- 1:18:38Yeah, let's tag team that one Andy there.
- 1:18:41There does seem to be an uptick of scammers, scammer activity
- 1:18:48targeting bitcoiners, targeting crypto holders in general.
- 1:18:51I suppose a big part of that is there have been leaks of
- 1:18:55customer databases. Ledger and Swan being two
- 1:19:01companies where their, their databases are, have been leaked
- 1:19:04and are available on the dark web.
- 1:19:06And recently Swan customers received 2 separate phishing
- 1:19:12emails where the emails were sent out.
- 1:19:15And they look, they look like they're official.
- 1:19:17They, you know, they use the, the, the logos and have the
- 1:19:22right kind of voice to them. And they say, you know, they,
- 1:19:26we've had a, a data breach and you can secure your coins by
- 1:19:30following these steps, right? But if you, if you actually, if
- 1:19:34that, if you see that e-mail and you believe it and you start
- 1:19:37taking those steps while you're actually falling into a fishing
- 1:19:41trap and you're, you're handing over your control of your swan
- 1:19:45account to, to hackers who are going to try to log in as you
- 1:19:49and then sweep your funds to, to an on chain address that they
- 1:19:53control. And then you're screwed.
- 1:19:56So you know that that's been going on.
- 1:19:58And then and and part of that too is.
- 1:20:03Customer phone numbers are included in these databases.
- 1:20:06And so there's this cottage industry that's popped up of, of
- 1:20:10scammers who pretend to be tech support calling, trying to help
- 1:20:16you solve some other some kind of crisis with your coins.
- 1:20:21And it's the same outcome of they are trying to social
- 1:20:24engineer you into handing over control of your, of your account
- 1:20:30so that they can sweep the funds out of it.
- 1:20:34And John Seth is an OG Bitcoiner who's who's been recording calls
- 1:20:41that he's received from because he's on these lists and he
- 1:20:46records these calls. And, and weirdly enough, these
- 1:20:51scammers are a few of them have been happy to talk, proud to
- 1:20:55boast about how successful they've been in, in accumulating
- 1:21:01I'll gotten wealth by by perpetrating these frauds.
- 1:21:07And so it's a problem. It's kind of it's a, a silent
- 1:21:11epidemic in a way, because evidently they're being
- 1:21:17successful in, in John Seth's first, first call, the scammer
- 1:21:22bragged about a $1.2 million withdrawal from Swan that John
- 1:21:26Seth was then able to, you know, alert Swan was, was in progress
- 1:21:31and Swan was able to stop it before it happened.
- 1:21:34But if it wasn't for that call, maybe it would have happened.
- 1:21:38And if there's a cottage industry, it means that they're
- 1:21:41having success. And so there's hundreds of
- 1:21:46Bitcoin holders who are being tricked out of their coins.
- 1:21:50And you know, maybe, maybe it's a, maybe it's $100,000 today and
- 1:21:55you get scammed out of that and it hurts immensely, but it's
- 1:22:00just $100,000. And you know, maybe you, your
- 1:22:03salary is $100,000. And so that's will take you a
- 1:22:06few years to to save that back. But this is Bitcoin.
- 1:22:11And if Michael Saylor's projections are right, his base
- 1:22:16case is a 200X over the next 20 years, So that that $100,000 in
- 1:22:22Bitcoin today would become $20 million in Bitcoin in in 20
- 1:22:28years. And so if you lose it today,
- 1:22:30that's, it's a tragedy that that, you know, alters the
- 1:22:38financial trajectory that you as a bitcoiner would have been on.
- 1:22:43And, and you, you, you can be right and you could be early and
- 1:22:45you could have have stacked Bitcoin.
- 1:22:48And if you allow yourself in your security arrangement to be
- 1:22:53breached and you lose that Bitcoin, you may never get that
- 1:22:57opportunity to stack that much Bitcoin and realize the, the
- 1:23:01upside that's coming over the next 20 years.
- 1:23:04So I think that's what's happening.
- 1:23:06What's what's going on? There's an uptick of that.
- 1:23:11And I think it just underlines the importance of having the
- 1:23:16right custody solution. And if you're technical enough,
- 1:23:20if you're up to it, multi sig that you control, you know,
- 1:23:24collaborative custody, great. Like do that.
- 1:23:27Just get your coins off an exchange.
- 1:23:29Like, you know, if, if, if you're using in exchange, don't
- 1:23:33leave them there. If you're using a single Ledger,
- 1:23:35don't leave it there. That's, that's what they're
- 1:23:37targeting. You know, get your, get your
- 1:23:40coins into a multi sig setup. And, and if and if you're
- 1:23:45interested, multi institution custody helps solve this problem
- 1:23:48as well. And, and without the technical
- 1:23:51and security burden on the end user.
- 1:23:53So that's part of our motivation that on ramp is to, you know,
- 1:23:57help people prevent this tragedy of coins that could be lost
- 1:24:02today, preventing the, you know, financial outcome that a
- 1:24:05bitcoiner deserves because they were right and they were early
- 1:24:08and they they stacked their coins.
- 1:24:11Andy. Yeah, that's really well said,
- 1:24:13Jesse. I think the only thing I would
- 1:24:16add is I, I know two people personally who have been scammed
- 1:24:21specifically out of Bitcoin 1 was scammed out of, you know,
- 1:24:27other crypto as well. And on the one hand, I take the,
- 1:24:33you know, the really high level view.
- 1:24:34There's a whole online scamming industry, you know, that's
- 1:24:39that's grown up over the years. The Internet is the perfect
- 1:24:41place to scam people because you're not face to face and you
- 1:24:45can just, you know, create a connection to someone from the
- 1:24:49other side of the world. And it's a numbers game.
- 1:24:52You know, they contact 1000 potential marks.
- 1:24:55And if one of them pays off, it's worth their it's worth
- 1:24:59their time. And also they get really good at
- 1:25:02it. They get really good at creating
- 1:25:05urgency in particular. So that's one of the red flags
- 1:25:09is, you know, if you get contacted by someone who's
- 1:25:12talking about, oh, you know, there's been some breach or
- 1:25:15there's something wrong with your security setup or there's
- 1:25:19something wrong with, you know, the exchange where you, you got
- 1:25:22coins, you know, and, but, but don't worry, you know, if you
- 1:25:26take the following actions quickly, right?
- 1:25:29Often it's quickly, you can fix it.
- 1:25:33And then the, the, the corollary also is some of these scammers
- 1:25:37play a really long con. Most don't, but some do.
- 1:25:41You know, they get to know you over time.
- 1:25:44They sort of build trust, you know, they can feed you trading
- 1:25:49ideas and and you make money on trading ideas.
- 1:25:53And then they sort of build the trusted relationship over time.
- 1:25:56And then they convince you to part with some of your funds
- 1:26:01while they, you know, set up the next greatest trade or other
- 1:26:06financial transaction idea for you.
- 1:26:07So there's so many ways it can go wrong and obviously education
- 1:26:13is the main thing. Know what you hold under learn
- 1:26:16about understand Bitcoin, you know, listen to listen, listen
- 1:26:20to Princey on the regular, especially those technical
- 1:26:24episodes with people, you know, his brilliant guests that talk
- 1:26:28about how Bitcoin works in detail and how the security
- 1:26:31works and how multi sig works and how to keep your keys away
- 1:26:36from the Internet and all this these important concepts.
- 1:26:39And yeah, that's that's that's all I would add.
- 1:26:43And I think is Bitcoiners, we all go through our journey of
- 1:26:48learning and understanding and we make reasonable decisions and
- 1:26:52trade-offs about, you know, how we want our coins and what
- 1:26:56setups and what baskets, etcetera, etcetera.
- 1:26:59And that's an individual choice that that you have to make on
- 1:27:02your on your own. But the more you know, the
- 1:27:05better off you are, the more confident you're going to be and
- 1:27:09the less likely that you're going to get scammed and tell
- 1:27:12your friends and family and and everyone else too.
- 1:27:15They got a these scammers are out there, scammers everywhere.
- 1:27:18Goldstein is right, everyone's a scammer and be careful.
- 1:27:22Stay safe. And one thing that I will add
- 1:27:25there, because it was that very shocking in the during the
- 1:27:28interview, he was talking about how he was using emails or phone
- 1:27:33numbers or whatever to emails specifically, actually to hack
- 1:27:36into people's Google accounts, For example, you know, if you've
- 1:27:40got the e-mail somehow you can give me the password and all of
- 1:27:43a sudden you're in the Google account.
- 1:27:45And they would just go in through photos.
- 1:27:47Oh, yeah. Look, someone took a picture of
- 1:27:49their seed words. Thank you very much.
- 1:27:50Swept the love. And it's like, no, when I'm
- 1:27:54helping people set them up, get a pen and paper.
- 1:27:57But yeah, yeah, whatever. I'll just take a picture.
- 1:27:58No, no, no, no, no, no, please don't do that.
- 1:28:01Do not do that. Do everything offline and be
- 1:28:05prepared because if they've if they've got your your phone
- 1:28:08number, you've got your address, they've got your Gmail account,
- 1:28:13whatever e-mail then they can hack into or what's the
- 1:28:16Microsoft like OneDrive or is that G Drive?
- 1:28:19Yeah, G Drive for Google OneDrive, they'll get in there.
- 1:28:22So even if you're even if you've written out on your computer,
- 1:28:26even if you're offline and you've written out on your
- 1:28:28computer a file for your wife or your spouse or whatever to do,
- 1:28:35like, no, that's a bad idea. Hand write it because they will
- 1:28:41go to any lengths. But as as we were talking about
- 1:28:45the very beginning of the show with Lauren, if you've got a
- 1:28:48multi 6 setup and you've got something set up with on ramp as
- 1:28:51well, just not they can't get to that.
- 1:28:56There's there's no way like that that wall built around like a
- 1:29:01multi institution, multi geographical multi sig and it's
- 1:29:06multi geographical, right? I'm getting that right.
- 1:29:08Like the the the key holders, are they in different parts or
- 1:29:11are they all in the? US well 2, two of three in our
- 1:29:15in our standard model are in the US in different states, but we
- 1:29:20do have a multi jurisdiction option which is for a premium
- 1:29:25option. Yeah.
- 1:29:26OK. So it's there like if that's as
- 1:29:28tight as it gets, I think on the street right now.
- 1:29:33On ramps building. One day one of the keys will be
- 1:29:36will be held on the Moon and maybe not, maybe not Mars though
- 1:29:40there might be too much too much latency in the signing time,
- 1:29:43but. Multi.
- 1:29:45Planetary, yeah. Multi multi institution, multi
- 1:29:48planetary, multi sig. Yeah, Shoot, shoot for the moon,
- 1:29:52boys. All right.
- 1:29:54So is there anything else that you wanted to touch on before we
- 1:29:58do the final question? It was a great Rep, all right.
- 1:30:03If you want, if you had one last orange pill left to give to
- 1:30:06somebody, who would you give it to and why all.
- 1:30:09Right, I'll go first this time. I was quicker on the draw.
- 1:30:12Kamala Harris. I mean, obviously, you know,
- 1:30:19people are talking about the politics they're talking about.
- 1:30:22You know what, what does the Democratic administration mean
- 1:30:25for Bitcoin going forward? What does the Trump admin mean
- 1:30:29for Bitcoin? I'm not actually sure that it
- 1:30:31makes all that much difference, but I do think that it's
- 1:30:37unlikely that she understands Bitcoin.
- 1:30:41Perhaps she's open to it, but I would feel a lot better about
- 1:30:46policy in the US for the next 4 years.
- 1:30:50You know, if yeah, if, if if any and all current political
- 1:30:55candidates understood Bitcoin and or were.
- 1:30:58Pro Bitcoin, Yeah, that's that's the right answer.
- 1:31:02Actually, before you said that, I jumped to Trump as my answer.
- 1:31:07That's but that's right too. You're correct.
- 1:31:11And, and obviously he's he's closer to understanding Bitcoin
- 1:31:15or the value. Of it, he's very close.
- 1:31:17He's on coin. Exactly, so his his recent
- 1:31:21forays and the shit coining tell me he needs that orange pill
- 1:31:25still. I think that, you know, the what
- 1:31:30Senator Lummus trotted out right after Trump's speech at
- 1:31:35Nashville and and the day after RFK talked about, you know, a 4
- 1:31:42million Bitcoin US strategic reserve.
- 1:31:46And then Senator Alamas comes out with the, you know,
- 1:31:481,000,000 Bitcoin plan, a bill that will get shot down
- 1:31:52immediately. But yeah, I wish, I wish that
- 1:31:56Trump actually like if Trump could could actually believe in
- 1:32:02the imperative of a, of AUS strategic Bitcoin reserve and
- 1:32:07wanted to get to that 4,000,000 number in order to match what we
- 1:32:10have with gold. That would be the biggest yes,
- 1:32:14it does mean government buying Bitcoin.
- 1:32:17But you know, I, I think that's always going to be a part of
- 1:32:20bitcoins maturation as an asset and they would be incredible to
- 1:32:25have that happen. I don't, you know, it won't that
- 1:32:29time will come in the future, but it would it would not only
- 1:32:31be good for Bitcoin, it would be really good for the United
- 1:32:34States. I think it would cement the
- 1:32:36United States pre eminence and the geopolitical realm for the
- 1:32:43next century, which would be fantastic as an American.
- 1:32:49So anyway, that'd be mine and I feel feel more strongly about
- 1:32:52that answer than the in prior episodes.
- 1:32:54So, you know, the potential of a politician understanding Bitcoin
- 1:32:59and having the power to authorize using, you know, a, a
- 1:33:05budget, a national budget to purchase Bitcoin.
- 1:33:09Like we're we're entering into that world.
- 1:33:11And it will be a huge tailwind for for Bitcoin because there's
- 1:33:15how many coins are there that are available to be purchased
- 1:33:19by, by nation states? Not that many.
- 1:33:22So they're going to have to bid like held it to free up more
- 1:33:25supply. Yeah, and I'll, I'll just throw
- 1:33:29in there Scottie Pippen because what's, what's he doing?
- 1:33:36Scotty. It's really sad to watch such a
- 1:33:39legend. Somebody's somebody's in his
- 1:33:43ear, somebody's manipulating him.
- 1:33:45Someone's given him this great freaking idea and that you can
- 1:33:50see what they're doing. You know, he's every tweet is
- 1:33:54hashtag Bitcoin, Bitcoin, Bitcoin, Bitcoin.
- 1:33:56And then you're like, no man, like you're really misleading
- 1:34:00people here. And this is going to it's going
- 1:34:03to end really badly. Like the, the, the, the
- 1:34:06integrity of his whole career will be just come tumbling down
- 1:34:11right in front of his eyes. And somebody behind him who's in
- 1:34:14his ear advising all of this is going to walk off into the
- 1:34:17sunset. Very rich.
- 1:34:20So Scotty, if you're listening, please no more of the shit
- 1:34:24Coining Shield Bitcoin if you understand it and you clearly
- 1:34:28don't. Good advice.
- 1:34:33All right, lads, until next time, when are we going to do
- 1:34:36this? Q1, I guess of of 2025 maybe?
- 1:34:40Yeah. Q1.
- 1:34:42Yeah, we'll set something up. We could do a review of the of
- 1:34:46the MicroStrategy, you know, Q4 or Q1 report and the largest
- 1:34:52largest single quarter profit in probably isn't the largest
- 1:34:57single quarter profit in history, but it'll be up there.
- 1:35:00Yeah, it's going to be absolutely all right.
- 1:35:04Thanks for coming on. Let's take care.
- 1:35:06All the very best. Here's Princey.
- 1:35:10Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:35:12If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:35:14episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:35:17app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:35:19today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:35:22Before we finish, a quick reminder that on Rat Media is
- 1:35:24for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:35:27nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:35:30Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:35:33to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com Contact
- 1:35:36Schedule a consultation with one of our private client advisors.