Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Post-IPO Companies Are Buying Back Shares at a Record Pace
Transcript
- Lucas: So we're recording this on June 5, 2026, and if you've glanced at any screen this week, you know it's been brutal out there. The S&P 500 is down over nine percent in just five days. Mega-cap tech is getting crushed — Microsoft off almost ten percent, NVIDIA down eight, Amazon down five. Luna: And yet, right in the middle of this bloodbath, we're seeing something counterintuitive from recently-public tech companies. They're buying back their own stock at a record pace. Lucas: Exactly. And for a lot of people, that feels odd — like, 'Wait, your stock is falling, you're spending cash to prop it up? Isn't that admitting defeat?' But the reality is more nuanced, and it's actually a sign that the IPO class of the last few years is growing up. Luna: If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running — you know, a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going. Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Lucas: Yeah, honestly, it makes a real difference. And speaking of maturity — let's look at Palantir. They went public in 2020 via a direct listing, and for the first couple years, they were all about growth at any cost. But starting in 2024, they shifted hard toward capital discipline. Luna: And part of that shift was authorizing a massive buyback program. I think they announced something like a billion dollars in 2025? Lucas: More, actually. By early 2026, they'd expanded it to two billion. And here's the thing — Palantir's stock has been volatile, down about sixteen percent this week alone. But the buyback sends a signal to the market: management thinks the stock is undervalued, and they're willing to put their money where their mouth is. Luna: Right, because when insiders are selling — and we've seen plenty of that post-lockup — a buyback can absorb that supply. It's like a stabilizing force. Lucas: Exactly. And it's not just Palantir. Shopify did something similar. After their growth slowed post-pandemic, they pivoted hard to profitability, and part of that was a buyback program worth about two and a half billion Canadian dollars. That's a huge commitment for a company that was losing money just a couple years ago. Luna: Shopify's stock is down over twelve percent this week, so the timing is interesting. But I guess if you believe in the long-term thesis, a cheaper stock is actually better for buybacks — you get more shares per dollar. Lucas: That's the arithmetic. And it's exactly what the smart CFOs are doing. They're not trying to time the bottom — they're executing a consistent program. Every quarter, they're in the market buying shares. It reduces the share count, which boosts earnings per share even if net income stays flat. And in this environment, where revenue growth is decelerating for a lot of these companies, EPS growth is how you keep investors happy. Luna: So it's a financial engineering play, but it's also a psychological one. It says, 'We're not a startup anymore. We're a mature company that returns capital to shareholders.' Lucas: Right. And that's a big shift from the 2021 IPO frenzy, where the whole pitch was 'we're going to grow into this valuation.' Now, companies are saying, 'We're going to earn this valuation by being disciplined.' And the market is rewarding that, at least relative to peers who are still burning cash. Luna: Let's talk about the mechanics for a second. How do these buybacks actually work? Are they open market purchases, or tender offers, or what? Lucas: Mostly open market purchases. The company announces a program, and then they buy shares over time through a broker. They have to be careful about insider trading rules — they can't buy back stock when they have material non-public information. But in practice, they set up 10b5-1 plans, which are pre-scheduled trading plans, so they're buying regularly regardless of what's happening day-to-day. Luna: And that's exactly what lets them average into the weakness we're seeing now. They're buying every week, so when the stock drops, they just get more shares for the same money. Lucas: Exactly. And it compounds. If you're buying back two percent of your float every quarter, over a year that's eight percent fewer shares. That alone adds almost nine percent to EPS, assuming no change in net income. In a world where revenue is growing five to ten percent, that's a huge boost. Luna: But there's a flip side. Critics say buybacks are just a way to enrich executives who have stock-based compensation, and that the cash could be better spent on R&D or acquisitions. Lucas: That's a fair critique, especially for a company like Palantir, where R&D is still critical. But look at it this way: if you're a shareholder, you want management to allocate capital efficiently. If the stock is trading at a price to earnings ratio of, say, 30, and the company's organic growth is only 15 percent, then buying back stock is actually a better use of cash than reinvesting in a business that's only growing at 15 percent. It's basic capital allocation. Luna: So it's not necessarily lazy — it's just that the best investment opportunity right now might be their own undervalued shares. Lucas: Precisely. And we're seeing this across the board. Even some earlier-stage companies that haven't turned a profit are starting to think about buybacks, though usually they're restricted by debt covenants or cash needs. But the ones that are cash-flow positive — like Palantir and Shopify — they're leading the charge. Luna: What about the mega-caps like Microsoft and NVIDIA? They've been doing buybacks for years, but they're not exactly 'post ipo.' Though I guess Microsoft went public in 1986, so that's a stretch. Lucas: Right, but the principle is the same. Microsoft is buying back huge amounts — they spent over 20 billion on buybacks in fiscal 2025. And that's part of why their EPS has been so resilient even when revenue growth is in the single digits. But the post ipo companies are interesting because they're adopting these strategies earlier in their life cycle. It's a sign that the market is maturing. Luna: Let's talk about some of the risks. If a company overdoes buybacks and then a recession hits, they could be left with no cash and a lot of debt. Lucas: That's the classic argument against buybacks — you're using cash that could be a buffer. But the companies we're talking about, like Shopify and Palantir, actually have strong balance sheets. Shopify has over 5 billion in cash and equivalents, and Palantir has about 4 billion. So they're not over-levering themselves. They're using excess cash, not borrowing to buy back. Luna: And that's the key distinction. If you're borrowing to buy back stock, you're increasing risk. If you're using free cash flow, you're just returning capital to shareholders. Lucas: Exactly. And one more thing — buybacks can also help with the lockup expiration problem. When insiders are finally allowed to sell after the IPO lockup expires, that can flood the market with shares. A buyback can absorb some of that selling pressure, which is exactly what we saw with some of the 2023 IPO cohort. Luna: So it's almost like a built-in stabilizer for post ipo volatility. And given how volatile this week has been, that's a nice feature to have. Lucas: Absolutely. Look, no one is saying buybacks are a silver bullet. But they're a powerful tool in the toolkit. And the fact that more post ipo companies are using them tells me that the culture is shifting from 'grow at all costs' to 'grow responsibly.' And in a market like this, that's exactly what long-term investors want to see. Luna: I'm curious — are there any post ipo companies that you think are buying back too aggressively? Lucas: I'd be a little worried if a company is buying back while still reporting negative free cash flow. That's not sustainable. But most of the ones we've talked about are cash-flow positive. The ones I'd watch are the growth-stage companies that are barely profitable and decide to do a buyback. That feels like a red flag — like they're trying to juice the stock price instead of fixing the business. Luna: So it comes down to context. Buybacks are a sign of maturity when done right, but they can also be a sign of desperation. Lucas: Exactly. And the market is smart enough to tell the difference. When Palantir announced its buyback expansion, the stock actually went up. When a struggling company announces a buyback, it often goes down — investors see right through it. Luna: Well, with the market down this week, I expect we'll see more buyback announcements in the coming weeks. Companies love to buy at the bottom. Lucas: They do. And if they do it right, it's a win-win. The company gets to deploy capital at a discount, and shareholders get a higher ownership stake in a growing business. It's not the sexiest topic, but it's one of the most important drivers of long-term returns. Luna: And we'll be watching. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. And for anyone listening, if you found this useful, consider supporting the show. It really helps.