Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Car Rental: Economic Advantage of Annual Use
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the deep dive. You know that feeling?
- 0:13You've just driven your new car off a lot, maybe signed the loan
- 0:16papers. You think, OK, hurdle cleared.
- 0:18I know my monthly payment. Right.
- 0:20That payment feels solid, predictable.
- 0:24But what we often miss is that it's just the tip of a huge
- 0:27financial iceberg. Exactly.
- 0:29That's what we're tackling today.
- 0:30We want you, the listener, to really get a handle on what
- 0:34owning a car truly costs, day in, day out.
- 0:37Because it's consistently one of the most underestimated expenses
- 0:41for, well, pretty much any household.
- 0:42People focus on the purchase, the loan.
- 0:45But forget all the other sneaky hidden costs.
- 0:48So we're doing a deep dive today.
- 0:49We're comparing the real cost of ownership against newer,
- 0:52flexible options like car sharing.
- 0:54Yeah, we've looked at research from, you know, major groups
- 0:57like AAA, financial sites and transportation policy experts.
- 1:00They really break it down. Our mission?
- 1:03To spell out why traditional ownership might be a bigger
- 1:05burden than you realize, and how these newer mobility models kind
- 1:09of flip the whole cost structure upside down.
- 1:11It's quite a shift in thinking. OK, let's get into it.
- 1:14To really understand the true cost, we need to break it down
- 1:171st. What are the main buckets of
- 1:19expenses? Sure.
- 1:21So the sources basically split it into two main types, fixed
- 1:24costs, sometimes called standing costs, and variable costs or
- 1:28running costs. OK, fixed.
- 1:29Those are the ones you pay no matter what, right?
- 1:31Even if the car just sits there. Exactly.
- 1:33Think insurance premiums, registration, maybe taxes,
- 1:37inspection fees. Those bills land in your mailbox
- 1:41whether you drove 10 miles or 1000.
- 1:43Got it and variable. Those depend completely on how
- 1:46much you use the car. Fuel obviously oil changes, tire
- 1:50wear, tolls, parking. The more you drive, the more you
- 1:53pay. Makes sense.
- 1:54But let's go back to those fixed costs.
- 1:56I think the biggest shocker, the one people really miss, is
- 1:59depreciation. Oh absolutely.
- 2:00It's huge. Depreciation can actually be
- 2:03around half the total cost of running a car for the average
- 2:05owner. Half.
- 2:06Wow. Yeah, and it's the cost people
- 2:08just wildly underestimate. You don't really feel it until
- 2:11you go to sell the car and suddenly it's worth thousands
- 2:13less. OK.
- 2:13So put some numbers on that. Let's say I buy a new car today.
- 2:16What kind of immediate hit are we talking?
- 2:18About It's substantial. On average, a new car drops
- 2:23maybe 15 to 20% in value each year. 15 to 20%.
- 2:27And it's worse at the start, often 10, sometimes even up to
- 2:3030% just in that first year alone.
- 2:33So a $30,000 car, you might have lost what, four or five?
- 2:37Even $6000 in value by its first birthday.
- 2:40That's like a silent tax you're paying just to have it parked
- 2:43outside. You're paying the loan, and this
- 2:45invisible cost is draining its value.
- 2:48Precisely. It's tough to wrap your head
- 2:50around when you're focused on that monthly loan payment and
- 2:52that's just depreciation. There are other fixed costs too.
- 2:56Like what else? Well, if you have a car loan,
- 2:58you're paying interest, right? The actual car value drop is
- 3:01depreciation, but the interest is an extra cost on top of that.
- 3:04OK, the cost of borrowing the money?
- 3:06Exactly. Then there are government
- 3:08charges, Rd. taxes, maybe vehicle excise duty depending on
- 3:12where you are, often tied to engine size or CO2 emissions.
- 3:15And there's one slightly more abstract 1, you mentioned the
- 3:17cost of capital. Can you explain that a bit?
- 3:20Yeah, this is important for understanding the opportunity
- 3:22cost cost. Think about it, if you spent,
- 3:26say, $30,000 on a car, that's $30,000 you didn't put into
- 3:31savings or investments or anything else that might have
- 3:34earned you money. Right.
- 3:35So the money you could have earned but didn't because it was
- 3:38tied up in the car, That's part of the cost too.
- 3:41You got it. It's the income you forfeit.
- 3:43Even if it was just sitting in a basic savings account earning a
- 3:46little interest, that missed potential income is a real
- 3:50quantifiable cost of owning that car.
- 3:53That really reframes it, doesn't it?
- 3:54It's not just an expense, it's like an anti investment in some
- 3:57ways. It definitely makes you think
- 3:59differently. OK.
- 4:00So moving quickly to the running costs, fuel is usually the next
- 4:04biggest chump after depreciation?
- 4:06And that obviously depends on how much you drive, gas prices,
- 4:09how thirsty your car is. All of that, and then there's
- 4:11maintenance and repairs. Maintenance, tires, oil, brakes.
- 4:15Tends to creep up as the car gets older.
- 4:17But repairs. Repairs are the killer.
- 4:19They're totally unpredictable, right?
- 4:20Yeah. A sudden transmission problem, A
- 4:22dent? Some sensor goes kaput.
- 4:24Exactly, they can just blow your budget out of the water with no
- 4:28warning. And don't forget the little
- 4:29things that add up. Like parking fees.
- 4:31Parking, tolls. Some cities even have congestion
- 4:34charges now, like London or Stockholm just to drive
- 4:38downtown. Right, trying to discourage
- 4:40bridge driving. And even car washes.
- 4:42It sounds minor, but some sources point out that in parts
- 4:45of Europe, washing your car at home is actually illegal because
- 4:48of runoff rules. So you have to pay for a car
- 4:50wash. It all gets nickel and dimed.
- 4:53OK. This is starting to sound like a
- 4:54lot. Let's get to the hard numbers.
- 4:55What does the research say this all adds up to annually?
- 4:58Prepare yourself. The American Automobile
- 5:01Association, AAA, they tracked this stuff really closely.
- 5:04A decade ago it was maybe around $8700 a year.
- 5:07OK, their latest figures from 2023 show the average driver is
- 5:11now spending about $12,182 a year.
- 5:15Twelve way over $12,000 a year just to own and operate an
- 5:18average car. Yep. $12,182 That's over $1000 a
- 5:26month on average when you factor everything in.
- 5:28That's staggering. That's more than rent in some
- 5:31places, or like a huge chunk of tuition.
- 5:33That number needs a minute to sink.
- 5:35In it really does. And it varies, of course.
- 5:38The data clearly shows size matters.
- 5:40Driving a smaller, efficient sedan might cost you closer to,
- 5:43say, $0.60 a mile. But a big SUV that could be
- 5:48pushing $0.80 a mile? That difference, maybe $0.20 a
- 5:51mile, adds up to thousands in savings each year if you go
- 5:54smaller and more efficient. OK, so here's the big question
- 5:57then. If it costs so much, especially
- 6:00those massive fixed costs like depreciation and insurance,
- 6:03yeah, why do we end up driving so much?
- 6:06It fuels counterintuitive. That's the crux of it.
- 6:08It's what the research calls the price structure problem.
- 6:10It's the fundamental issue with private car ownership.
- 6:12The price structure problem explain that.
- 6:14OK. So remember those fixed versus
- 6:16variable costs. The research shows that for a
- 6:18typical privately owned car, almost 77% of the total cost is
- 6:22fixed. That's done percent.
- 6:23Yes, only about 23 percent is variable.
- 6:26The cost that actually changes based on how much you drive.
- 6:29Wow. That's a huge imbalance, So most
- 6:32of the money is already spent essentially before you even turn
- 6:34the key. Exactly.
- 6:36And that creates this perverse incentive.
- 6:38Once you've already sunk all that money into the fixed cost,
- 6:41the loan interest, the insurance that huge depreciation hit you
- 6:45took, you feel like you need to drive it as much as possible to
- 6:47get your money's worth. Right, because the cost per mile
- 6:50feels cheap at that point, you've already paid the big
- 6:52entry fee. Precisely.
- 6:54The marginal cost of driving one extra mile seems really low, so
- 6:57the structure sure itself encourages people to drive more
- 7:00than they might actually need to.
- 7:01That seems backwards. If only 23% of the cost is
- 7:05related to actual driving and the structure pushes us to drive
- 7:09more, it sounds bad for our wallets and probably the
- 7:12environment too. It is, and that leads us
- 7:14perfectly into the alternatives, because what we need is a model
- 7:18that flips that ratio. OK, so let's talk about car
- 7:21sharing and maybe rentals. How do they offer that
- 7:24structural flip? Right car sharing services are
- 7:27basically short term rentals, often parked right in
- 7:30neighborhoods that you can grab by the hour.
- 7:33They're designed as a direct substitute for earning a car.
- 7:36And the cost structure? It's the complete opposite with
- 7:39car sharing. Your fixed costs are usually
- 7:42very low. Maybe a small annual membership
- 7:44fee if anything. But your variable costs what you
- 7:48pay per mile or per hour are much, much higher.
- 7:50How much higher are we talking? Significantly, car share users
- 7:54might pay something like $0.60 per mile driven.
- 7:57That's maybe five times the variable cost of driving your
- 8:01own car. I see, so almost all the cost is
- 8:04tied directly to when you're actually using the car.
- 8:06Exactly, and that completely changes the incentive.
- 8:09Unlike owning where you want to drive more to justify the cost,
- 8:12car sharing gives you a really strong financial reason to
- 8:15minimize your driving. You only use it when you really
- 8:17need it and maybe walk or take the bus or bike for other trips.
- 8:20Precisely. The incentive is to use other,
- 8:23cheaper options whenever possible.
- 8:25And the data shows this works. How so?
- 8:27Well, studies suggest car sharing becomes cheaper than
- 8:29owning if you drive less than about, say, 5000 miles or 8000
- 8:34kilometers a year. That's the tipping point for
- 8:36many people. 5000 miles. Quite low for some, but maybe
- 8:40covers a lot of city dwellers or occasional drivers.
- 8:42It does, and the impact on behavior is huge.
- 8:45Households that switch from owning a car to using car
- 8:47sharing typically cut their annual driving by 40 to 60%. 40
- 8:52to 60% reduction, that's massive.
- 8:54It really is. It highlights the situational
- 8:57advantages too. Like if you live in a city.
- 8:59Yeah, if you're in a dense urban area, trying to own a car means
- 9:02dealing with crazy parking costs, permits, stress.
- 9:06Car sharing fits much better with public transport and
- 9:09walking and you avoid all that hassle.
- 9:12And for people who just don't drive much, yeah, maybe weekend
- 9:14trips only. It's ideal.
- 9:16Why pay that $12,000 plus annual fixed cost for a car that just
- 9:20sits idle most of the week? Plus you get flexibility.
- 9:23Flexibility in what way? Vehicle choice with ownership.
- 9:26You might buy a big SUV just for that one time a year you need to
- 9:30haul something. With sharing or renting, you can
- 9:33pick a small efficient car for city errands, then rent a van.
- 9:37If you need to move furniture. You use the right tool for the
- 9:40job. We're seeing this extend beyond
- 9:42hourly car sharing too, right? Like monthly subscription
- 9:44models. Absolutely.
- 9:46Especially in Europe, we're seeing car companies themselves
- 9:49offer these all inclusive monthly subscriptions.
- 9:51You pay one fee and it covers the car insurance, maintenance,
- 9:56roadside assistance, everything except fuel.
- 9:59So it takes away those big scary fixed cost headaches,
- 10:03depreciation, insurance, surprise repairs.
- 10:06Exactly. It makes the cost predictable.
- 10:08It might range from a few 100 to maybe over €1000 or dollars a
- 10:12month depending on the car, but it bundles those major fixed
- 10:15costs. And businesses use similar logic
- 10:17distinguishing between short term and long term hires.
- 10:19Yeah, definitely. Businesses often need
- 10:21flexibility. Short term hire like for a few
- 10:24days or weeks gives them instant access to vehicles.
- 10:26Maybe for a specific project or a seasonal peak the daily rate
- 10:30is higher, but the flexibility is key.
- 10:32OK, like for a consulting firm needing cars for a short
- 10:35project? Right, whereas long term, higher
- 10:37months, even years is better for ongoing needs like a sales team,
- 10:42the daily rate becomes much lower because it's based on a
- 10:45monthly commitment. It gives them predictable costs
- 10:48and takes away the hassle of managing their own fleet.
- 10:50So whether it's personal business, the core idea is
- 10:53shifting away from owning the asset to just paying for the
- 10:57utility when you need. It that's the fundamental shift.
- 11:00You pay for mobility and not for metal sitting in a parking spot.
- 11:03Let's talk convenience and tech for a second, because often the
- 11:06argument for owning is just it's there, it's easy.
- 11:10That's the perception. But think about the hidden work
- 11:12of owning, scheduling maintenance, dealing with
- 11:15insurance, renewals, registrations, finding a
- 11:18mechanic for repairs. It's actually a lot of hassle.
- 11:21OK, Fairpoint, renting or sharing shifts almost all of
- 11:25that burden to the provider, and technology has made it
- 11:28incredibly easy. Now.
- 11:29How so? Smartphone apps for booking
- 11:31instant confirmations, often contactless pickup and drop off
- 11:35using your phone as the key. Some services even deliver the
- 11:38car to you. You might barely interact with a
- 11:41human. And you generally get newer cars
- 11:42too, right? Rental fleets turn over.
- 11:45Pretty quickly, much quicker than most people buy new cars,
- 11:48so you're almost always driving a recent model with the latest
- 11:51safety features, better fuel efficiency, maybe integrated
- 11:55navigation, things you might wait years to upgrade to if you
- 11:58owned. OK, so the convenience argument
- 12:01for ownership is maybe not as strong as it used to be.
- 12:04Let's zoom out to the bigger picture.
- 12:05Societal benefits? What about the environment?
- 12:08There's a strong connection. Think about resource use.
- 12:11Yep, rental and car share vehicles are used much more
- 12:14intensively than private cars, which sit idle maybe 95% of the
- 12:17time. Right, So you need fewer total
- 12:20cars manufactured to provide the same amount of mobility for
- 12:23everyone. That means less resource
- 12:25extraction, less energy used in manufacturing, less pollution
- 12:29from factories. Fewer cars overall makes sense.
- 12:32Plus it gives people easier access to try out greener tech.
- 12:36Renting an electric vehicle or a hybrid for a weekend is a low
- 12:39risk way to experience it without committing to the high
- 12:42purchase price of buying one yourself.
- 12:44It helps accelerate that transition.
- 12:46And what about the equity angle? How does this help people who
- 12:49might be struggling financially? Well, think back to that $12,000
- 12:53plus annual cost of ownership. That's a massive burden,
- 12:57especially for lower or middle income households.
- 13:01Add the risk of a sudden budget breaking repair bill, it's
- 13:04tough. Yeah, a $1000 repair can be
- 13:07devastating. Exactly.
- 13:08Car sharing provides mobility without requiring that huge
- 13:11upfront investment or taking on debt.
- 13:14You can give people affordable access to a car for essential
- 13:16trips, job interviews, doctor's appointments, grocery runs that
- 13:20they might otherwise struggle to make.
- 13:22It helps address transportation disadvantage.
- 13:24OK, so pulling this all together, what's the main take
- 13:26away for you, our listener? I think the big shift is moving
- 13:30from thinking about cars as assets you own to thinking about
- 13:33transportation as a utility you pay for when you need it.
- 13:37And the best financial model really depends on how much you
- 13:39drive. Absolutely.
- 13:41If you're driving significantly less than average, maybe under
- 13:43that 5000 or 8000 mile mark per year, those huge fixed costs of
- 13:49ownership are likely costing you way more than using alternatives
- 13:52like car sharing or occasional rentals would.
- 13:55So it forces a calculation knowing the true average cost is
- 13:58around what, $0.58 per mile? Right about US $8.58 per mile or
- 14:05.32 per kilometer. Knowing that, it makes you
- 14:07wonder, is driving everywhere still the default, or does
- 14:11owning a car become more of a luxury, something you choose for
- 14:14specific needs or high mileage rather than the automatic
- 14:17solution? That's the provocative thought,
- 14:19isn't it? When you compare that true cost
- 14:21per mile to other options, does driving everywhere still make
- 14:24financial sense for everyone or only in student scenarios?
- 14:26Something definitely worth thinking about next time you
- 14:28look at your car expenses. Well, thank you for joining us
- 14:31on this deep dive into the real cost of getting around.
- 14:33I hope it was insightful. We really hope this helps
- 14:35clarify things. Do follow the channel for more
- 14:38deep dives where we try to simplify these complex topics.
- 14:41We always appreciate hearing what resonates with you, so keep
- 14:43learning and exploring.