Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA Conserves 1st Choice Credit Union of Atlanta
Transcript
- 0:03Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:35Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:38It is I was going to say January.
- 0:40It feels like it's due to be January, but it's June 15th.
- 0:43And this is going to be a podcast on an action NCUA took yesterday, which was
- 0:50a conservatorship action, which doesn't happen probably on average more than
- 0:54one, two, or three, four times a year, depending on the year when things get
- 0:58more challenging economically, they tend to increase, and I want to talk a little
- 1:02bit about the conservatorship action that NCUA published on its website yesterday.
- 1:08In a press release yesterday, NCUA said First Choice Credit Union conserved.
- 1:14Accounts remain protected by share insurance fund.
- 1:17Member service uninterrupted.
- 1:20The NCUA today placed First Choice Credit Union in Atlanta,
- 1:24Georgia into conservatorship.
- 1:26This action was taken in consultation with the Georgia
- 1:29Department of Banking and Finance.
- 1:33Member deposits at First Choice Credit Union remain protected by the
- 1:37NCUSIF, administered by the NCUA.
- 1:41The insurance fund insures individual accounts to, at First Choice,
- 1:46up to 250, 000, and a member's interest in all joint accounts
- 1:50combined is insured up to 250, 000.
- 1:52It goes into more details on the insurance.
- 1:55It indicates member service will continue uninterrupted.
- 1:58Member services will continue uninterrupted at both of the
- 2:01credit unions branches in Atlanta.
- 2:03Members can continue to conduct normal financial transactions, deposit and access
- 2:09funds, make loan payments, and use shares.
- 2:11The offices are open Monday through Friday, 8 30 to 4.
- 2:15If you have questions, You can call the credit union.
- 2:18It shows links to the frequently asked questions page on their website.
- 2:22It shows links to share insurance coverage on NCUA's website and at mycreditunion.
- 2:30gov.
- 2:31First Choice Credit Union is a federally insured, state chartered credit union.
- 2:35With 6, 709 members and assets of approximately 38.
- 2:406 million.
- 2:41According to the credit union's most recent call report, first choice credit
- 2:46union serves employees of Grady hospital, Morehouse school of medicine, faculty,
- 2:53Emory university school of medicine, faculty, Southside healthcare, Atlanta
- 2:58life insurance company, South Fulton community development corporation,
- 3:02credit union staff, and family members.
- 3:06All right.
- 3:06So 38 million, they workers conserved on a Friday back in the day.
- 3:12I would only do conservatorships on Friday.
- 3:14Why is that?
- 3:15You want to take the credit union over at the end of the day so that you could
- 3:20count cash and work over the weekend.
- 3:23See what might come out of the woodwork because stuff always
- 3:26comes out of the woodwork if you're doing a conservatorship.
- 3:29If you had five reasons to conserve it, after you conserved it, you
- 3:33find out there were 10, 15, or 20.
- 3:35If there was just one reason you find out there were five, 10, 15, or 20.
- 3:40It's a complicated process.
- 3:41NCUA does very well.
- 3:43It's a high octane type weekend where you bring in a team of NCUA's best and
- 3:48brightest, and they scrub the books so they can get an understanding of what the
- 3:53true risk is to the insurance fund is.
- 3:55If you look at their most recent FPR, which the press release
- 4:00referred to, they were at 38.
- 4:056 million.
- 4:06They had 26 million in loans.
- 4:09They had total shares of 35 million and they lost 150, 000
- 4:18in the first quarter of 2024.
- 4:24I'm sure if we go over to the income and expense, we're going to
- 4:29see that probably had something to do with provision for loan loss.
- 4:34Let's see.
- 4:35Provision for loan loss they had 137, 000 in provision for loan loss in
- 4:42March and 400, 000 the previous year.
- 4:46They've lost 150, 000.
- 4:48So their expenses are high.
- 4:50And you wonder why does a credit union get conserved?
- 4:54Their key ratios show that they had 8.
- 4:565 percent net worth.
- 4:58If they had 8.
- 4:595 percent net worth and it was real and NSWG wasn't concerned about the 8.
- 5:065% they would not have been conserved.
- 5:08It's difficult to conserve a credit union with a lot of capital, which
- 5:11means there are either accounting issues that are going to erode
- 5:15that, or there are loan issues.
- 5:17Delinquent loans are at 10%, which is in the 99th percentile, meaning they have
- 5:23higher delinquency than 99 percent of the credit unions in their peer group.
- 5:28Their rolling 12 month charge off is 2%, the peer average is 40 basis points,
- 5:34and they're in the 96th percentile, meaning 96 percent of credit unions in
- 5:37their peer group have less charge offs.
- 5:40They are losing money in 2024.
- 5:44So there's a question as to that net worth now, could there be other issues,
- 5:51if that net worth has to be less than that, in my opinion, if they're going
- 5:55to conserve or they think it might be less than that, meaning that there are
- 5:59accounting issues or there's a concern in some way, shape or form about fraud.
- 6:04A lot of small credit unions that are conserved end up being,
- 6:08having done so because of fraud.
- 6:10I'm not saying that I know that.
- 6:11I'm not saying that anybody has told me that.
- 6:14I'm not saying it's necessarily true here.
- 6:16However, when small credit unions with 98 percent net worth get conserved,
- 6:20usually net worth evaporates either by loan losses, accounting losses.
- 6:25Fraud write offs that happened shortly after conservatorship.
- 6:30Now I'll be recording a podcast later this week for distribution.
- 6:35In the future with Todd Miller and Steve Farr of my team, we're
- 6:39gonna talk about uas cease and desist orders and conservatorships.
- 6:42It is likely that NCUA felt in order to minimize loss to the insurance fund and to
- 6:49protect the interest of the credit union, that they felt that there was no other
- 6:52choice but to conserve this credit union.
- 6:55By the way, NCUA has a, there's a redacted version of NCUA's enforcement
- 7:01manual, by the way, which was written by Steve Farr of my team which is an old
- 7:05document it's there, Instruction 4820.
- 7:08If you go to that document, that public document, it says the Federal Credit
- 7:12Union Act empowers the NCUA Board to appoint itself or another, such as a
- 7:17state official, as conservator of any federally insured credit union, when
- 7:21grounds established in the Act are met.
- 7:24This includes circumstances where the board determines that such action is
- 7:28necessary to conserve the assets of any insured credit union or to protect
- 7:32the NCUSIF or the interests of the members of such insured credit union.
- 7:37Any insured credit unions, by a resolution of its board of directors,
- 7:40consents to such an action by the board.
- 7:43The Attorney General of the United States notifies the board in writing
- 7:47that an insured credit union has been found guilty of a criminal offense.
- 7:52There is a willful violation of a cease and desist order, which has become final.
- 7:57There is concealment of books, papers, records, or assets of the credit union,
- 8:02or refusal to submit books, papers, records, or affairs of the credit
- 8:05union for inspection to any examiner or to any lawful agent of the board.
- 8:10And board in this is with a capital B, meaning it's the NCUA board.
- 8:15The credit union is significantly undercapitalized as defined under
- 8:19the Federal Credit Union Act.
- 8:20By the way, they always skip doing it under PCA because it's simpler to
- 8:24do it under their other authorities.
- 8:26Please A conservatorship does not require an administrative hearing.
- 8:29However, the credit union may challenge the action in US District
- 8:32Court within 10 calendar days of the NCA, placing it into conservatorship.
- 8:37Now, by the way, if they do contest it, they have to do with their own funds.
- 8:40They are no longer officials of the credit union.
- 8:43They cannot hire an attorney and expect them to be paid by the credit
- 8:47union because they don't no longer represent the credit union and COA.
- 8:51Serves as the insurer and NCUA serves as the board of directors of the credit
- 8:55union under conservatorship until such time that they decide to return it to the
- 9:00field of membership, which they would pick a board, they'd have an advisory board
- 9:04to get them off the ground and running.
- 9:06And then ultimately the NCUA board would have to vote to return it to
- 9:09the members or NCUA decides it's in the best interest to merge it
- 9:13or have a purchase and assumption liquidation into another credit union.
- 9:17Or NCWA decides that the credit union simply just needs to be liquidated.
- 9:22All right.
- 9:23So one other thing that caught my eye is I looked at the notice of the profile.
- 9:31Let's see the profile of the credit union and what it's a low
- 9:37income designated credit union.
- 9:40It's a minority depository institution designates itself as such.
- 9:45Had grants from the National Federation of Community Development Credit Unions.
- 9:51In 2014 the Department of Health and Human Services in 2018 from the National
- 9:57Federation of Community Development Credit Unions in 2020, and those
- 10:02three combined total 48, 58, 61, 000.
- 10:06But the big ticking item here is a Community Development
- 10:10Financial Institution grant of 1.
- 10:138 million in August of 2021.
- 10:16Lots of interesting data here just looking at the their profile,
- 10:20looking at their financial statement, which shows that they're healthy,
- 10:24but clearly they're not if NCUA decided to pursue a conservatorship.
- 10:30Also note that the press release talked about that they consulted
- 10:37What were the words they used?
- 10:39I remember these words.
- 10:40The action was taken in consultation with the Georgia
- 10:42Department of Banking and Finance.
- 10:44That means either Georgia Bank, Department of Banking agreed with
- 10:49it, or Georgia became aware of something and asked NCUA to do it.
- 10:54Or if they didn't agree with it, NCUA board would have to have a vote
- 11:00and give them a few days advance notice before NCUA took that action.
- 11:05So that preserves a little bit of the state's rights for a
- 11:07state chartered credit union.
- 11:08But it's clear that both the banking department and felt
- 11:12this action was necessary.
- 11:14It'll be interesting to see how this plays out.
- 11:17Does the credit union survive?
- 11:18Does it not survive?
- 11:20Are there any prohibitions related to it?
- 11:22And what actually, now you won't find that out until SUA does a postmortem, if they
- 11:27do a postmortem publicly on this matter.
- 11:30But because there was a grant from the CDFI, other government agencies may be
- 11:38interested in seeing how this plays out.
- 11:41All right interesting times with this conservatorships.
- 11:44That's all I've got for you on this short one single credit union topic.
- 11:49First Choice Credit Union, conserved by NCUA, what that means
- 11:53for the members, what it means for credit unions in general.
- 11:57By the way NCUA I've had a lot of questions.
- 12:00Recently about what are NCUA's authorities to remove officials.
- 12:04When NCUA does remove officials, it's just like they did here.
- 12:08They conserve it.
- 12:09They take the whole place over.
- 12:10They do have the legal authority to do it under other portions of the federal credit
- 12:15union act, which have certain requirements where if they wanted to remove a CEO,
- 12:21they could, but the the requirements for that to meet that threshold,
- 12:25I'll cover that in another podcast.
- 12:28They could remove particular board members, but historically NCUA goes
- 12:33straight to the finish line and conserves the credit union, gets rid of all the
- 12:37officials instead of using a rifle, they use a shotgun, and one of the reasons
- 12:42they do that are the the threshold for actually conserving is easier to
- 12:47prove than the threshold for doing an individual, but I'll talk more about
- 12:51that coming up in other podcasts that we have outlined for later this year.
- 12:55I hope you have a wonderful Father's Day for those of you who are a
- 12:59father, for those of you who are going to visit your father it's One
- 13:03of my favorite holidays, if not my most favorite holiday of the year.
- 13:08And I got a chance to see my daughter and granddaughter today.
- 13:12And tomorrow we'll get a chance to see our other daughter
- 13:16and our other granddaughter.
- 13:17So it's a great weekend for family.
- 13:19I hope you spend time with yours.
- 13:22And stay tuned on more on administrative actions, more on conservatorships
- 13:29and more on this particular conservatorship down the road.
- 13:32I appreciate you listening.
- 13:33Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.
- 13:42Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 13:46your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 13:50of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 13:55If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 13:58out our services at marktreichel.
- 14:00com.