Latest / Bloomberg Law / SCOTUS May Cut Agency Power & JetBlue Spirit Deal Nixed
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: It's a landmark legal doctrine that affects agency power over
- 0:14Speaker 2: everything from workplace conditions and drug safety to climate change
- 0:18Speaker 2: and cryptocurrency. The Chevron doctrine requires judges to defer to
- 0:23Speaker 2: agencies when they offer a reasonable interpretation of an ambiguous statute,
- 0:28Speaker 2: and the challenge to the forty year old doctrine puts
- 0:31Speaker 2: regulations in countless areas at risk. Billions of dollars are
- 0:36Speaker 2: potentially at stake in front of a court where four
- 0:39Speaker 2: of its conservative members, including Justice Neil Gorsich, have previously
- 0:44Speaker 2: signaled opposition to Chevron, as they did during the oral arguments.
- 0:48Speaker 3: Is the judge persuaded at the end of the day
- 0:51Speaker 3: with proper deference given to a coequal branch of government?
- 0:54Speaker 3: Or does the judge addicate that responsibility and say automatically
- 0:59Speaker 3: whatever the age and see says Wins.
- 1:01Speaker 2: On the other hand, the three liberal justices supported Chevron
- 1:05Speaker 2: and the expertise of agencies. Here's Justice Katanji Brown Jackson.
- 1:10Speaker 2: I see Chevron as doing the very important work of
- 1:14Speaker 2: helping courts stay away from policy making. The decision may
- 1:20Speaker 2: depend on Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Amy Coney Barrett,
- 1:25Speaker 2: with Barrett repeatedly voicing concerns about a possible legal upheaval
- 1:29Speaker 2: if Chevron is reversed, alluding to the more than fifteen
- 1:33Speaker 2: thousand cases that have cited the doctrine.
- 1:37Speaker 1: So maybe nothing happens immediately to those cases. But isn't
- 1:40Speaker 1: the door then opened for litigants to come back and say, well,
- 1:44Speaker 1: stationary source really means X or you know, broadband or
- 1:48Speaker 1: whatever the specific term was in brand X. So isn't
- 1:52Speaker 1: it inviting a flood of litigation even if for the
- 1:55Speaker 1: moment those holdings stay in tech.
- 1:57Speaker 2: Joining me is constitutional law expert Harold Krant, a professor
- 2:00Speaker 2: with the Chicago Kent College of Law. The Chevron doctrine,
- 2:04Speaker 2: by the way, champion by conservatives when it was established
- 2:07Speaker 2: in a case that cut back on regulations, but now
- 2:11Speaker 2: vilified by them, it's become a pillar of administrative law.
- 2:15Speaker 2: Tell us how it's used in practice, What the practical
- 2:19Speaker 2: application is.
- 2:20Speaker 4: The Pepper application of Chevron is enormous. It allows a
- 2:24Speaker 4: structured way for courts to determine whether to uphold agency
- 2:29Speaker 4: interpretations of statutes, whether it's in woolmaking or in a
- 2:32Speaker 4: case and adjudication, And so if the statute is vague
- 2:37Speaker 4: a reasonable size for a truck or in the famous
- 2:40Speaker 4: case of Chevron itself, what's the stationary source? A court
- 2:43Speaker 4: will have to decide whether Congress has been clear, and
- 2:46Speaker 4: if the Congress has been clear, that's the end of
- 2:49Speaker 4: the matter, and the court's interpretation will hold. The agency
- 2:53Speaker 4: can appeal if it disagrees, up to the Supreme Court,
- 2:55Speaker 4: but in many cases the court are leftlet doubt. I mean,
- 2:59Speaker 4: what is a reasonable investigation? What is an adequate measure?
- 3:03Speaker 4: And they're not certain how to interpret it, and so
- 3:06Speaker 4: then the court will defer to any kind of reasonable
- 3:10Speaker 4: agency interpretation. Reasonableness is in the eye of the beholder.
- 3:15Speaker 4: That means that there's an array of possible interpretations for
- 3:19Speaker 4: one statute and they all would be upheld by a
- 3:22Speaker 4: court on review as long as it's ambiguous and as
- 3:26Speaker 4: long as the agency's interpretation has some degree of plausibility.
- 3:31Speaker 4: That of course gives agencies more power, and it gives
- 3:34Speaker 4: agencies the ability to change their interpretation of regulations as
- 3:39Speaker 4: social or political conditions evolve, and that has enormous significance
- 3:43Speaker 4: both for business and for individuals regulated by the government.
- 3:47Speaker 2: Many of the Conservative justices have expressed opposition to Chevron.
- 3:53Speaker 2: Why are they so opposed to Chevron just as.
- 3:57Speaker 4: I opposed, I think for two different reasons. Is in
- 4:01Speaker 4: all other contexts, judges make the final call as to
- 4:04Speaker 4: what Congress meant in passing statutes. So if there's ambiguity,
- 4:09Speaker 4: courts have the final say. That's what courts do, and
- 4:12Speaker 4: courts think that they're better at it, and that's their
- 4:14Speaker 4: special function. So under Chevron, the courts have to share
- 4:18Speaker 4: this special function with agencies who they view as sort
- 4:21Speaker 4: of unelected bureaucrats or politicians. So that's an affront to
- 4:25Speaker 4: judicial respect. I think that's one argument. The other argument
- 4:29Speaker 4: or reason is that this particular court is very skeptical
- 4:32Speaker 4: of administrative agencies and administrative agencies power. They love presidential power,
- 4:37Speaker 4: they don't like the power of the bureaucrats beneath him.
- 4:41Speaker 4: And there's no question but that agencies under both Republican
- 4:44Speaker 4: and democratic administration have more authority and more influence. If
- 4:49Speaker 4: the Chevron document is applied accurately.
- 4:53Speaker 2: Members of the Conservative majority, several members of it, immediately
- 4:59Speaker 2: made their concerns known. Justice Neil Gorsich questioned why a
- 5:04Speaker 2: judge who thinks the agency's interpretation of the law is
- 5:07Speaker 2: wrong would quote abdicate that responsibility and say automatically whatever
- 5:13Speaker 2: the agency says wins. Did certain of the justices express
- 5:18Speaker 2: real opposition.
- 5:20Speaker 4: It's clear that a super majority of the Court is
- 5:23Speaker 4: very worried about uncomfortable with Chevron. But it's not clear
- 5:27Speaker 4: whether there is a majority of justice who want to
- 5:31Speaker 4: overturn Chevron outright, as opposed to continue what they've done before,
- 5:35Speaker 4: which is to regin choven for lower courts. And as
- 5:39Speaker 4: the justices themselves noted that several times during the oral argument,
- 5:43Speaker 4: the Supreme Court is not itself relied upon Chevron for
- 5:48Speaker 4: something like seven years in deciding a case, which means
- 5:52Speaker 4: that they're sort of ignoring it because they just try
- 5:55Speaker 4: to decide what a statute means itself without formally using
- 6:00Speaker 4: the Chevron framework. And so the question is whether they
- 6:03Speaker 4: can allow Chevron to die a slow death, or at
- 6:06Speaker 4: least to be left in a weakened state, or whether
- 6:09Speaker 4: instead the conservative justices will decide to overturn Chevron outright,
- 6:14Speaker 4: And as was definitely remarked upon in oral argument, that
- 6:18Speaker 4: would cause a great deal of instability, because the question
- 6:21Speaker 4: would then be, what about all these cases have been
- 6:24Speaker 4: decided in reliance upon Chevron. Does that mean that they
- 6:27Speaker 4: will have to be reopened to determine whether courts want
- 6:31Speaker 4: to rethink what is the correct interpretation to give to
- 6:36Speaker 4: the statute that was challenged?
- 6:39Speaker 2: The liberal justices defended Chevron and the status quo. Justice
- 6:44Speaker 2: Katanji Brown Jackson said Chevron helps courts stay away from policymaking,
- 6:49Speaker 2: just as Elena Kagan gave some practical examples like should
- 6:53Speaker 2: courts defer to an agency's expertise as to whether a
- 6:57Speaker 2: cholesterol lowering product should be classified as a dietary supplement
- 7:01Speaker 2: or a drug? So, I mean those arguments seem to
- 7:05Speaker 2: make sense when you consider you know on the ground
- 7:08Speaker 2: level what agencies are deciding. Well.
- 7:12Speaker 4: In addition to that, there's long been a debate about
- 7:16Speaker 4: what Congress intends. There's been studies that suggest that Congress
- 7:20Speaker 4: is comfortable with Chevron, understand Chevron and indeed would want
- 7:25Speaker 4: the agency to fill in statutory gaps or clarify statutory
- 7:29Speaker 4: language as opposed to the court. Why because agencies are
- 7:32Speaker 4: seen as Congress's partner in trying to you know look
- 7:36Speaker 4: at safe drug policy, or try to understand immigration policy,
- 7:39Speaker 4: or try to understand how to regulate the airwaves. So
- 7:42Speaker 4: Congress indeed would prefer or intend for courts to help
- 7:46Speaker 4: them interstitially by trying to clarify ambiguous language as opposed
- 7:51Speaker 4: to the Court, which doesn't have the same kind of
- 7:53Speaker 4: expertise some kind of flexibility in trying to figure out
- 7:57Speaker 4: what statutes mean. So I view from that perspect cheven
- 8:01Speaker 4: is in the consistent with separation of powers. Once one
- 8:04Speaker 4: comes to the conclusion that Congress would prefer to have
- 8:08Speaker 4: the agency's flesh out statutory meaning if the statute is
- 8:12Speaker 4: unclear as opposed to the Court, because the agency has
- 8:16Speaker 4: the expertise and it works with Congress in trying to
- 8:19Speaker 4: accomplish the congressionally delegated admission. This which is why conservative
- 8:24Speaker 4: justices like antonin Scalia used to applaud it, because it
- 8:28Speaker 4: reflects Congress's intent that the two entities, Congress and agencies
- 8:33Speaker 4: are really working together to accomplish a similar mission.
- 8:37Speaker 2: So the Solicitor General Elizabeth free Lager argued that overruling
- 8:42Speaker 2: a past Supreme Court decision requires quote a truly extraordinary
- 8:46Speaker 2: justification and petitioners don't have one, But does it really
- 8:51Speaker 2: require a truly extraordinary justification for this court to overturn precedent.
- 8:56Speaker 4: There was a discussion during the oral argument about what
- 8:58Speaker 4: type of president Chevron was. It's different than the subject
- 9:02Speaker 4: due process question that arose in the Dom's case that
- 9:05Speaker 4: the interpretive approach. The analogy was made to if you
- 9:09Speaker 4: don't rely upon legislative history in the same way in
- 9:13Speaker 4: one case as opposed to another. Yes, were turning a case,
- 9:16Speaker 4: but it's not really a story of SISIs because individuals
- 9:19Speaker 4: haven't relied upon it the same way over the past
- 9:22Speaker 4: fifty years. But I think Congress has legislated in the
- 9:27Speaker 4: wager in the shadow of Chevron, and so it would
- 9:31Speaker 4: be undermining what Congress's intent has been in drafting statutes
- 9:35Speaker 4: for the last fifty years. So I think that would
- 9:38Speaker 4: be the real change. If Chevron is Jettison's as it
- 9:42Speaker 4: looks like it'll least be winnowed down, if not Jettison completely.
- 9:46Speaker 2: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show, I'll continue
- 9:49Speaker 2: this conversation with Professor Harold Krant of the Chicago Kent
- 9:52Speaker 2: College of Law, and we'll look at the possible lineup
- 9:55Speaker 2: of the justices in the case. I'm June Grass. When
- 9:58Speaker 2: you're listening to Bloomberg, I've been talking to Professor Harold
- 10:01Speaker 2: Brentt of Chicago Kent College of Law about Supreme Court
- 10:05Speaker 2: oral arguments today over a longstanding legal doctrine that gives
- 10:09Speaker 2: federal agencies a wide berth to interpret unclear laws. Did
- 10:15Speaker 2: it seem like there were four Justices Clarence Thomas, Neil Gorsich,
- 10:21Speaker 2: Brett Kavanaugh, and Samuel Alito who were ready to completely
- 10:25Speaker 2: jettison Chevron.
- 10:27Speaker 4: My guess would be that the four justices you mentioned, Alito, Thomas, Cavanaugh,
- 10:31Speaker 4: and Gorsch were clearly opposed to Chevron and didn't want
- 10:35Speaker 4: to have any kind of lasting legacy on the Court
- 10:40Speaker 4: at all with respect to that decision, whereas Justice Sparriit
- 10:43Speaker 4: and to Justice Roberts were more on the fence in
- 10:47Speaker 4: terms of what kind of response to court you take.
- 10:50Speaker 4: Should the Court go all the way and over WRLL Chevron,
- 10:54Speaker 4: or should they just limit Chevron even further than had
- 10:58Speaker 4: been previously limited by the Major Question Soccer. Indeed, many
- 11:02Speaker 4: commentators think that because Chevron has been watered down, particularly
- 11:07Speaker 4: with this Major Questions exception that gives the cord enough
- 11:10Speaker 4: leeway to limit the kind of power that agencies would
- 11:13Speaker 4: otherwise wield under Chevron.
- 11:16Speaker 2: Yeah, I'm Barrett express concerns about the disruptive consequences of
- 11:20Speaker 2: overturning the precedent. Yeah.
- 11:22Speaker 4: So one of the things that litigators don't remember today
- 11:27Speaker 4: is what life was like before Chevron. And the problem
- 11:30Speaker 4: that arises is when the agency makes an interpretation, it
- 11:35Speaker 4: can be challenged in many different circuits around the country,
- 11:38Speaker 4: and then oftentimes different district court judges will interpret ambiguous
- 11:43Speaker 4: statutory language differently, and so you have the prospect and
- 11:47Speaker 4: you will have the prospect again if Chevron is overturned
- 11:51Speaker 4: of having a disarray seven different or three different interpretations
- 11:55Speaker 4: of one statute that are enforced in different circuits, and
- 11:59Speaker 4: that may planning and makes even stability for businesses very difficult.
- 12:04Speaker 4: That's the kind of a cacophony that was discussed in
- 12:07Speaker 4: oral argument, and I think it's very real what happened
- 12:10Speaker 4: before Chevron. And one of the advantages with Chevron was
- 12:13Speaker 4: trying to get a uniformity of approach to limit the
- 12:17Speaker 4: splits among the circuits and the delay in trying to
- 12:20Speaker 4: get stability of an interpretation approved and.
- 12:25Speaker 2: Just noting that in these cases, both the DC Circuit
- 12:29Speaker 2: and the First Circuit sided with the federal government affirming
- 12:33Speaker 2: lower court decisions. So this wasn't a case where the
- 12:36Speaker 2: justices had to take it. It was a case where
- 12:38Speaker 2: four of the justices, and I think we probably know
- 12:41Speaker 2: which four took it to change things up right.
- 12:44Speaker 4: I think? So what's intriguing about the case too? This
- 12:47Speaker 4: was a policy that was adopted by the Trump administration
- 12:51Speaker 4: and defended by the Biden administration. You know, would suggests
- 12:54Speaker 4: it's a good vehicle Chevron because it's not a case
- 12:58Speaker 4: that looks more republic it looks more democratic. This just
- 13:02Speaker 4: looks governmental and just this did have an interesting comment
- 13:05Speaker 4: that just like if we get rid of Chevron, businesses
- 13:10Speaker 4: will be advantaged, but at the same time, so may immigrants, veterans,
- 13:16Speaker 4: and social security claimants because all those individuals who litigate
- 13:20Speaker 4: against the government have the burden of trying to persuade
- 13:25Speaker 4: a court that the statutory language has been attributed incorrectly
- 13:30Speaker 4: by the agency. But they can do that more readily
- 13:33Speaker 4: if Chevron doesn't exist, because otherwise they have to overcome
- 13:35Speaker 4: the presumption that the agency's interpretation is correct in case
- 13:39Speaker 4: of an interpretation of a vague statutory provision. And if
- 13:44Speaker 4: Chevron were totally overturned, then if these theoretically and it
- 13:49Speaker 4: would be true in some cases that individuals would have
- 13:52Speaker 4: more advantage in litigating against the government, but of course,
- 13:56Speaker 4: at the same time, so will businesses.
- 13:58Speaker 2: I remember one or argument last term. The Chief Justice
- 14:03Speaker 2: took account of the fact that you know, they're always
- 14:05Speaker 2: saying this is something for Congress, that Congress is gridlocked.
- 14:10Speaker 4: The comment was made from both conservative and liberal justices,
- 14:13Speaker 4: was that that ambiguity exists everywhere. It's impossible to get
- 14:18Speaker 4: rid of ambiguity, and so there was no expectation that
- 14:23Speaker 4: Congress would legislate with much more clarity. And indeed, if
- 14:28Speaker 4: you overturn Chevron at the margin, it would give a
- 14:31Speaker 4: little more incentive for Congress to minimize ambiguity. But they
- 14:35Speaker 4: seem to be dubious that Congress would change very much
- 14:39Speaker 4: at all. So it's not a question of the amount
- 14:42Speaker 4: of legislation. Rather it's the question of what kind of
- 14:45Speaker 4: specificity would Congress legislate.
- 14:47Speaker 2: With these two cases. I'm wondering if there is any
- 14:51Speaker 2: question about whether it's moved because The program that they're
- 14:57Speaker 2: complaining about was suspended last year and the agency reimburse
- 15:02Speaker 2: the monitoring cost that had incurred under it. So why
- 15:06Speaker 2: is this even before the court at this point?
- 15:09Speaker 4: The Court in the past has taken a very narrow
- 15:12Speaker 4: view of routness, and as long as a laws in
- 15:16Speaker 4: the books or could be put easily back on the books,
- 15:19Speaker 4: it is considered that too it is reached out to
- 15:22Speaker 4: answer those kinds of challenges. So my guess is this
- 15:25Speaker 4: will be the same in this case. That the regulation
- 15:30Speaker 4: has not been repealed, it could be reinstated, and therefore
- 15:34Speaker 4: the controversy is still alive. But I will say that
- 15:37Speaker 4: there's very little argument that I heard that were touched
- 15:40Speaker 4: upon that issue whatsoever.
- 15:42Speaker 2: So if they decide to do something limiting Chevron, I mean,
- 15:47Speaker 2: what would that look like.
- 15:49Speaker 4: They might say that Chevron can be used only when
- 15:55Speaker 4: the expertise of an agency is clearly needed, or they
- 15:58Speaker 4: might say that a Chevron can be used only if
- 16:02Speaker 4: the Congress is otherwise indicated that it intends for the
- 16:08Speaker 4: agency to address the issue. So there was discussion to
- 16:13Speaker 4: an alignment today about whether or not one can slice
- 16:16Speaker 4: and dice and get different kinds of context in which
- 16:22Speaker 4: Chevron arises as again to sort of understand that Congress
- 16:28Speaker 4: may have anticipator may welcome agencies interpretations more in some
- 16:33Speaker 4: contexts than others. If in Congress is just silent, as
- 16:37Speaker 4: in this case for the Herring fisherment that there was
- 16:41Speaker 4: nothing in the statute about who pays for monitors on
- 16:45Speaker 4: fishing vessels. In that kind of silence, there would be
- 16:49Speaker 4: no reason to defer to the agency, but rather the
- 16:52Speaker 4: agency should only get difference if there's more peculiar or
- 16:57Speaker 4: more specific indicators that Congress ten of the agencies to
- 17:01Speaker 4: have some kind of interpretive role in administering a statute.
- 17:05Speaker 4: That's when Chevron might be applied, not in the case
- 17:09Speaker 4: with congresseemingly just forgot about an issue as in the
- 17:12Speaker 4: who pays for the fishing monitors that was involved in
- 17:15Speaker 4: this case.
- 17:16Speaker 2: Thanks so much, how that's Professor Harrold Krant of the
- 17:19Speaker 2: Chicago Kent College of Law. Coming up next on the
- 17:22Speaker 2: Bloomberg Law Show, we'll take a look at a judge
- 17:25Speaker 2: blocking the Jet Blue Spirit deal on anti trust grounds.
- 17:29Speaker 2: What happens next. A federal judge has blocked the three
- 17:33Speaker 2: point eight billion dollar deal between Jet Blue Airways and
- 17:36Speaker 2: Spirit Airlines over anti trust concerns. It leaves the two
- 17:41Speaker 2: carriers adrift and means Jet Blue will continue to be
- 17:44Speaker 2: relegated to second tier status behind the industry's big four carriers,
- 17:50Speaker 2: which wield unmatched pricing power and command vastly bigger fleets,
- 17:55Speaker 2: and for Spirit, the consequences may be Direoin me is
- 18:00Speaker 2: Bloomberg Intelligence senior litigation analyst Jennifer Ree, just how big
- 18:04Speaker 2: a win is this for the Biden administration, which has
- 18:07Speaker 2: been aggressive in antitrust enforcement?
- 18:11Speaker 5: You know, I guess I would classify it as a
- 18:13Speaker 5: big win only because I think the administration needs wins
- 18:19Speaker 5: on the M and A front, the M and A
- 18:20Speaker 5: challenge front. But in terms of this specific case, I
- 18:24Speaker 5: don't necessarily see it as surprising or a big win
- 18:27Speaker 5: because this just seemed like an anti competitive deal from
- 18:30Speaker 5: the beginning, and it seemed like it should have been
- 18:33Speaker 5: an easy case for the Department of Justice to win.
- 18:35Speaker 5: So it's not a great feat in other words, that
- 18:38Speaker 5: they succeeded in court, but just generally, I think in
- 18:41Speaker 5: stopping any kind of consolidation and in kind of furthering
- 18:45Speaker 5: the aggressive push to stop consolidation to stop a lot
- 18:49Speaker 5: of deals in that way. It's a big win.
- 18:52Speaker 2: Tell us why the judge William Young decided against the
- 18:56Speaker 2: merger of Jetblu and Spirit.
- 18:59Speaker 5: You know, I think with this really came down to
- 19:02Speaker 5: is the fact that there are flights that Spirit flies
- 19:06Speaker 5: where Jet Blue doesn't. So it's odd because most deals
- 19:09Speaker 5: will come down to where they compete, but I think
- 19:11Speaker 5: this came down to where they do not compete because
- 19:13Speaker 5: Jet Blue was very clear about plans to take those
- 19:16Speaker 5: Spirit flights, retrofit the planes to the Jet Blue model,
- 19:19Speaker 5: and probably therefore raise the fares and lower capacity because
- 19:23Speaker 5: the seats would be bigger and there would be fewer passengers.
- 19:26Speaker 5: And for those routes, there's no way from an antitrust
- 19:30Speaker 5: perspective that you can fix those higher prices for routes
- 19:34Speaker 5: where they compete. They could sell the route to a
- 19:36Speaker 5: Legiant or two Frontier that might continue to compete as
- 19:39Speaker 5: a very low unbundled fair option. But now what you're
- 19:43Speaker 5: doing is taking Spirit, which is considered an ultra low
- 19:46Speaker 5: cost carrier and offers these very low unbundled fares. You're
- 19:50Speaker 5: taking them out of the market for certain routes altogether.
- 19:53Speaker 5: And there are absolutely consumers that depended on those low
- 19:56Speaker 5: fares for those particular routes, and they would be hurt
- 19:58Speaker 5: by the deal, and that's what the judge ultimately decided.
- 20:02Speaker 2: So that means that Jet Blue will continue to be
- 20:07Speaker 2: relegated to second tier status behind the industries for big carriers,
- 20:13Speaker 2: and Samuel Engel of ICF told Bloomberg they don't have
- 20:17Speaker 2: an easy path to grow. They'll continue to be at
- 20:20Speaker 2: scale disadvantaged compared to the largest airlines. So this decision
- 20:26Speaker 2: sort of relegates Jet Blue, you know, to a position
- 20:29Speaker 2: that's in or even.
- 20:30Speaker 5: Worse, you know, I guess it does. And Jet Blue argued, look,
- 20:34Speaker 5: we need to combine with Spirit in order to grow.
- 20:37Speaker 5: That's really the only way nowadays to grow as an airline.
- 20:40Speaker 5: And if we grow, we can compete more vigorously against
- 20:44Speaker 5: the legacy airlines like Delta, United American, and Southwest, and
- 20:47Speaker 5: that would be a good thing for consumers. That's pro competitive.
- 20:50Speaker 5: And the judge actually agreed with that in this case,
- 20:53Speaker 5: that this would help Jet Blue if they could combine
- 20:56Speaker 5: with Spirit, help it to grow, increase its map and
- 21:00Speaker 5: or compete with some of the bigger airlines. But it
- 21:02Speaker 5: wasn't enough. It wasn't enough to overcome the harm to
- 21:04Speaker 5: the consumers that I just talked about, And I think
- 21:08Speaker 5: that's why, in a way, yes, the decision does tend
- 21:11Speaker 5: to relegate Jet Blue to its position sort of as
- 21:14Speaker 5: a second tier. But one of the things that happened
- 21:17Speaker 5: here June that was pretty effective is that what the
- 21:20Speaker 5: Department of Justice argued is that look, in this kind
- 21:23Speaker 5: of second tier place that Jet Blue sits, now, it's
- 21:26Speaker 5: a kind of a maverick, right, it does something called
- 21:29Speaker 5: the jet Blue effect. It really competes hard against the
- 21:32Speaker 5: legacy airlines, and when it enters a route or the
- 21:34Speaker 5: route sets in, it forces these airlines to bring down
- 21:37Speaker 5: their prices. And what they argued is, look, if they
- 21:40Speaker 5: buy Spirit, they're telling you they'll better compete against the legacies,
- 21:44Speaker 5: but in fact, they're really just going to become just
- 21:46Speaker 5: like one of them. They're going to be bigger, they're
- 21:49Speaker 5: going to be more in a position that's more similar
- 21:51Speaker 5: to the legacy airlines. They're going to take on a
- 21:54Speaker 5: huge amount of debt from buying Spirit, and they're going
- 21:56Speaker 5: to need to keep their prices up. So instead of
- 21:59Speaker 5: actually continue to exert this competitive pressure, they just become
- 22:03Speaker 5: like the legacies, and they increase their prices.
- 22:06Speaker 2: The market appeared to like the news for Jet Blue.
- 22:08Speaker 2: Jet Blue stock rows almost five percent after the news.
- 22:13Speaker 2: Is that, you think because the company won't have to
- 22:15Speaker 2: shell out billions of dollars and be saddled with a
- 22:19Speaker 2: discount carrier.
- 22:21Speaker 5: I think so. I mean, first, it was a very
- 22:23Speaker 5: large amount of debt they would have taken on to
- 22:25Speaker 5: finish this acquisition. That's the first thing. Their debt debt
- 22:28Speaker 5: ratio would have been much worse than it's been in
- 22:31Speaker 5: the past. And they themselves aren't really doing all that
- 22:34Speaker 5: well right now. You know, all the airlines are struggling
- 22:36Speaker 5: a little bit with air traffic controller shortages and airline shortages,
- 22:40Speaker 5: and there's some engine problems for some planes, and you know,
- 22:42Speaker 5: everybody's recovering after COVID. And then at the same time,
- 22:46Speaker 5: what they're paying for Spirit now seems like an overpayment
- 22:49Speaker 5: given what Spirit is worth today. So I think many
- 22:51Speaker 5: analysts actually saw getting out of this deal is a
- 22:54Speaker 5: good thing for Jet Blue.
- 22:56Speaker 2: For Spirit not so much. It shares We're cut in
- 22:59Speaker 2: hand Tuesday and their worst loss ever. And if Spirit
- 23:04Speaker 2: doesn't survive, doesn't that mean the judges analysis was wrong
- 23:09Speaker 2: or at least was not prescient.
- 23:12Speaker 5: Well, I think what happened here is that Spirits lawyers
- 23:15Speaker 5: could have made a more full throated flailing firm or
- 23:19Speaker 5: failing firm defense. Within the guidelines that the agencies used
- 23:22Speaker 5: to assess the deal, there is a defense to an
- 23:25Speaker 5: otherwise anti competitive deal called a failing firm defense or
- 23:28Speaker 5: a flailing firm defense, and it was sort of suggested
- 23:31Speaker 5: in trial that Spirit's not doing well. They're struggling financially,
- 23:35Speaker 5: they don't expect to make money next year, they don't
- 23:38Speaker 5: know when they'll be in a better financial position going forward,
- 23:41Speaker 5: and some of the issues they're having were outlined, and
- 23:44Speaker 5: the judge said, look, you know, they didn't really meet
- 23:46Speaker 5: the elements they need to meet. Legal cases have set
- 23:49Speaker 5: out the precedent, set out what has to be proven
- 23:52Speaker 5: in order to establish that defense, and the companies just
- 23:55Speaker 5: didn't do it. They didn't meet that defense, and that's
- 23:58Speaker 5: why the judge rejected it. I sat through most of
- 24:01Speaker 5: the trial, and I tend to agree. I don't think
- 24:03Speaker 5: that they provided the evidence they needed to provide that
- 24:06Speaker 5: would have allowed the judge to say, Okay, I'll let
- 24:08Speaker 5: an otherwise the anti competitive deal go forward because of
- 24:11Speaker 5: the fact that Spirit might actually go under if we
- 24:14Speaker 5: don't allow the deal to close.
- 24:16Speaker 2: The judge wrote, the Airlines are welcome to take another
- 24:20Speaker 2: run at a merger at any time. The courthouse doors
- 24:23Speaker 2: remain open should the defendant Airlines decide to try again,
- 24:26Speaker 2: and the government then wishes to prevent such an attempt.
- 24:30Speaker 2: Why say that, Well.
- 24:32Speaker 5: First, the DJ asked for a permanent injunction that would
- 24:35Speaker 5: prevent these two from ever trying to merge again. So
- 24:37Speaker 5: they didn't quite get fully what they wanted. And it's
- 24:40Speaker 5: exactly what's playing out in the marketplace now that this
- 24:43Speaker 5: judge was worried about. I mean, he specifically asked during trial, well,
- 24:47Speaker 5: what happens if there is no Spirit? If I don't
- 24:49Speaker 5: allow this deal, what happens then that's a worse situation.
- 24:52Speaker 5: As he was sort of questioning the lawyers and thinking
- 24:54Speaker 5: through the theories and sort of in a ruminating kind
- 24:57Speaker 5: of way, he was asking that, and if he wanted
- 25:00Speaker 5: to leave the door open if marketplace dynamics did change
- 25:04Speaker 5: to allow these companies to try to merge again in
- 25:06Speaker 5: the future, if in fact Spirit went belly up and
- 25:09Speaker 5: couldn't be restructured out of bankruptcy, or some other suitor
- 25:13Speaker 5: didn't step up, like maybe Frontier to buy Spirit, so
- 25:16Speaker 5: that the Spirit routes would continue to exist. And he
- 25:20Speaker 5: specifically wrote the injunction that way to allow for another
- 25:23Speaker 5: deal possibly to go forward. But you know what, June
- 25:26Speaker 5: easier said than done, because these things are difficult. It's
- 25:30Speaker 5: not just like you can jump into a merger agreement,
- 25:32Speaker 5: get a DOJ investigation finished up, go to trial. It
- 25:35Speaker 5: takes time, it hurts your business, it's expensive, and suffice
- 25:39Speaker 5: it to say, it seems likely that if Frontier or
- 25:43Speaker 5: again jet Blue tried to acquire Spirit, they'd probably still
- 25:47Speaker 5: face another Department of Justice fight.
- 25:50Speaker 2: In a joint statement, jet Blue and Spirit said they're
- 25:53Speaker 2: evaluating their next steps as part of the legal process.
- 25:57Speaker 2: So that means will they appeal or the appeal.
- 26:00Speaker 5: Exactly right, they're thinking about it, and.
- 26:03Speaker 2: What do you think about their chances on appeal?
- 26:06Speaker 5: You know, I think their chances aren't great. And it's
- 26:09Speaker 5: because this was really a question of interpreting the evidence,
- 26:13Speaker 5: the testimony by the experts and the documents and ultimately deciding,
- 26:18Speaker 5: you know, which arguments were stronger and more valid than others.
- 26:22Speaker 5: And that kind of a decision is given deference by
- 26:25Speaker 5: an appellate panel because it needs to be shown that
- 26:27Speaker 5: it was clearly erroneous, and that's hard to meet. So
- 26:31Speaker 5: I do think an appeal would probably be an uphill
- 26:33Speaker 5: climb for the airlines. And time is a little bit
- 26:36Speaker 5: tight too, because it could take five to six months,
- 26:39Speaker 5: let's say, from notice of appeal to decision, and they
- 26:42Speaker 5: do have a merger and date of July twenty fourth,
- 26:44Speaker 5: so the timing's a little tight there too.
- 26:47Speaker 2: And how much does Jet Blue have to pay if
- 26:50Speaker 2: the deal doesn't go through?
- 26:51Speaker 5: So they've agreed to pay four hundred and seventy million.
- 26:54Speaker 5: Part of that goes to shareholders, part of it goes
- 26:57Speaker 5: to Spirit and that's minus some prepayments that have already
- 26:59Speaker 5: been made. I don't actually know how much has been made,
- 27:02Speaker 5: but the whole grand total of pre payments plus post
- 27:05Speaker 5: failure fee is four hundred and seventy million.
- 27:08Speaker 2: Not a drop in the bucket, No, not at all.
- 27:11Speaker 2: Could this ruling spell trouble for Jet blues rival Alaska
- 27:16Speaker 2: Airlines and its acquisition of Hawaiian.
- 27:19Speaker 5: You know, may I may be in the minority here,
- 27:22Speaker 5: but I don't actually think it makes any difference, And
- 27:25Speaker 5: I'll tell you why, because I always thought that that
- 27:28Speaker 5: deal would probably get challenged by the DOJ. Theyre just
- 27:31Speaker 5: simply think that the airline industry is already too consolidated,
- 27:35Speaker 5: and if they go in with that position, they may
- 27:38Speaker 5: be more interested in trying to challenge this deal in
- 27:41Speaker 5: court than allowing it to go through. So I've always
- 27:44Speaker 5: thought that there was a chance of that. I think
- 27:46Speaker 5: that that deal's much easier to fix than this deal is,
- 27:49Speaker 5: because really that's just a straightforward combination of two competitors
- 27:54Speaker 5: that overlap for I understand, a pretty small number of
- 27:58Speaker 5: routes overall, and they can divest those routes to other carriers,
- 28:02Speaker 5: which is generally the way past airline mergers have been
- 28:05Speaker 5: remediated in the past. And I think that if they
- 28:08Speaker 5: can they divest a sufficient number of routes to the
- 28:11Speaker 5: right buyers, it seems to me they have a very
- 28:14Speaker 5: good chance of winning in court. With Jet Blue and Spirit,
- 28:17Speaker 5: you had this whole other problem of these routes where
- 28:19Speaker 5: they didn't compete, where it was only Spirit flying the route,
- 28:22Speaker 5: but it was now going to become Jet Blue, and
- 28:24Speaker 5: the prices we're going to go up, so they had
- 28:27Speaker 5: a different problem then will exist with the Hawaiian Alaska combination.
- 28:31Speaker 2: This is the second time in less than a year
- 28:34Speaker 2: that Jet Blue has lost a federal anti trust challenge.
- 28:38Speaker 2: Is it time to just give up?
- 28:41Speaker 5: I would have said it was time to give up
- 28:43Speaker 5: before they end that the merger agreement with Spirit. I
- 28:46Speaker 5: don't think it's really any big surprise that that deal
- 28:49Speaker 5: was challenged and that the DOJ want it in court.
- 28:52Speaker 5: And I still wonder sometimes whether the whole reason for
- 28:55Speaker 5: entering that agreement was just to stop Frontier in Spirit
- 28:58Speaker 5: from merging. The very skeptical side of me.
- 29:01Speaker 2: I guess, lawyer, I was supposed to be skeptical.
- 29:03Speaker 5: So exactly I'm supposed to approach this skeptically. You know,
- 29:07Speaker 5: I think it's pretty clear that they'd have a tough
- 29:10Speaker 5: time buying up another airline. You know, at the very least,
- 29:13Speaker 5: they would be challenged and have to fight it in
- 29:15Speaker 5: court and try to win in court. I'll tell you
- 29:18Speaker 5: that on the NEA, I was a little bit surprised.
- 29:20Speaker 5: I sat through that trial too, and I actually thought
- 29:23Speaker 5: that the NEA would stay in place with some modifications
- 29:26Speaker 5: to it, and so I was a little bit surprised
- 29:28Speaker 5: that the judge abolished it altogether. And I actually think
- 29:31Speaker 5: that there was a chance that he may have allowed
- 29:33Speaker 5: for the NEA to stay in place, but without the
- 29:37Speaker 5: revenue sharing that was part of it, and without some
- 29:40Speaker 5: capacity coordination that was part of it. So really it
- 29:43Speaker 5: was just a code sharing agreement. But at the time
- 29:45Speaker 5: the companies were ready to present that to the judge,
- 29:48Speaker 5: jet Blue had backed out. The termination date had come
- 29:51Speaker 5: and gone, and Jet Blue had backed out, which was
- 29:53Speaker 5: their right because they thought it would help them to
- 29:55Speaker 5: win this spirit trial, and so the judge never entertained
- 29:58Speaker 5: that possibility.
- 30:00Speaker 2: An administration is doing very well with antitrust concerns in
- 30:04Speaker 2: the airline industry, but what about other industries? Is it
- 30:07Speaker 2: faring as well?
- 30:09Speaker 5: I would say in my mind, they're doing better I
- 30:12Speaker 5: think than many are giving them credit for. And the DOJ.
- 30:16Speaker 5: Now this is three wins in a row for the DOJ,
- 30:18Speaker 5: after the NEAID case that you mentioned and also successfully
- 30:23Speaker 5: blocking Penguin, Random House and Simon and Schuster from completing
- 30:26Speaker 5: their deal. The FTC has had some very big losses
- 30:30Speaker 5: that have been in the news, but they've also succeeded
- 30:33Speaker 5: in achieving a lot of abandonments and abandonments are also
- 30:36Speaker 5: considered a success because essentially it's done what they intend
- 30:40Speaker 5: to do. It has stopped the consolidation that they don't
- 30:43Speaker 5: think should go forward. So I think people aren't really
- 30:45Speaker 5: giving the FTC enough credit for the abandonments of deals
- 30:49Speaker 5: that they've achieved. And I would also say that the
- 30:52Speaker 5: cases that they have brought have been very difficult cases
- 30:54Speaker 5: to win in court. They have been novel theories they challenge,
- 30:58Speaker 5: and Microsoft Activision was a vertical integration case. It's very
- 31:02Speaker 5: hard to win a vertical integration case. And perhaps they
- 31:05Speaker 5: haven't picked and chosen the cases to challenge quite as
- 31:09Speaker 5: well as the Department of Justice has. But I think
- 31:13Speaker 5: that now they're gaining some steam and now they're kind
- 31:16Speaker 5: of getting their legs under them, and I think it
- 31:18Speaker 5: still remains to be seen what happens in the rest
- 31:20Speaker 5: of this year. If the FTC actually does too to
- 31:24Speaker 5: challenge Kroger and Albertson's deal, what happens there and with
- 31:28Speaker 5: other deals that are pending right now as well.
- 31:30Speaker 2: Always a pleasure to have you on, jen That's Bloomberg
- 31:33Speaker 2: Intelligence senior litigation analyst, Jenniferree, And that's it. For this
- 31:37Speaker 2: edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember you've been always
- 31:40Speaker 2: get the latest legal news by subscribing and listening to
- 31:43Speaker 2: the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at Bloomberg dot com,
- 31:47Speaker 2: slash podcast, slash Law. I'm June Grosso, and this is
- 31:51Speaker 2: Bloomberg