Latest / Revitalizing the Declining Church with Dr. Desmond Barrett / 170. 5 Warning Signs the USA/Canada Region Needs Church Revitalization
Transcript
- 0:04Welcome to Revitalizing the Declining Church with Doctor
- 0:07Desmond Barrett, brought to you by the Brizzy Institute for
- 0:10Church Revitalization, Missional Engagement and Leadership
- 0:14Development, an institute that envisions to partner with
- 0:17churches and her leaders to strategize, strengthen, and
- 0:21discern God's will for the local church.
- 0:29Welcome to episode 170 of Revitalizing Declining Church.
- 0:32I'm your host, Doctor Desmond Baron.
- 0:33On today's episode, I want to talk to you about 5 warning
- 0:36signs that the USA Canada region needs church revitalization.
- 0:41Speaking to a pastoral friend recently, I could sense that
- 0:44they were not sharing something. As I listened and he shared, the
- 0:48pastor began to open up his heart about his local
- 0:51assignment. The church they pastored
- 0:54struggled and he feared that it might close that sentiment.
- 0:59If not the same story has been played out in countless
- 1:02conversations with many leaders at all levels over the years in
- 1:06the Church of the Nazarene. And it has me worried if I'm
- 1:10honest, and I believe we can be honest with each other.
- 1:13The denomination I found Jesus in and was called into ministry
- 1:18in is in trouble. The church in the USA Canada
- 1:22region of the Church of the Nazarene seems to be missing the
- 1:26warning signs from established churches like the one this
- 1:30pastor serves. I want you to hear my heart.
- 1:33I love my church, the Big Sea Church.
- 1:36When I say church, I'm not only Speaking of my local church, but
- 1:40of the denomination in which I have the privilege.
- 1:43Yes, it's a privilege to belong to the Church of the Nazarene
- 1:46family, not growing up in the tribe, but being welcomed in at
- 1:51the age of 22. I have claimed her as my own.
- 1:55For nearly three decades, I have served in the local church as a
- 1:58lay leader and more recently as a pastor.
- 2:01I've been educated in its Bible college and one of its stellar
- 2:05universities, and I have found a home in the global church.
- 2:10I've had the privilege of serving on district boards,
- 2:12teaching church revitalization in nearly 20% of the districts,
- 2:16and speaking at a regional venue.
- 2:19However, there are warning signs, like the pastor I
- 2:22introduced in the opening that indicate a problem ahead.
- 2:27Just a little background, not to gloat, but to share where I'm
- 2:31coming from. Since 2011 I have dived into the
- 2:36topic of church revitalization, renewal and replanting of well
- 2:41established legacy churches. At first it was out of necessity
- 2:45because of the churches I was called to serve in, then out of
- 2:49a passion to help other like minded churches come back from
- 2:53the abyss of a near death experience.
- 2:56As such, I wrote my Master's capstone in doctoral thesis on
- 3:00church revitalization along with seven soon to be 8 books, shared
- 3:05over 200 podcasts like this across several shows on this
- 3:10topic, and wrote over 150 articles for the online edition
- 3:14of Outreach Magazine. I want you to hear my heart.
- 3:17I'm not gloating, I'm just stating where I come from as a
- 3:21church revitalization strategist as I do not want to be labeled a
- 3:26negative grudge holding Nazarene but instead as a local pastor
- 3:31who loves the local and global church that I get to belong to.
- 3:36However, there is a major problem.
- 3:38Death is approaching the church in the USA Canada region of the
- 3:41Church of the Nazarene without revitalization.
- 3:45Recently, district superintendents gathered
- 3:47together for training, encouragement, prayer and
- 3:50renewal and were shown a slide celebrating the region.
- 3:54On face value, it's a beauty to behold.
- 3:57Since 2023, the regional stats state there's been a 10%
- 4:02increase in in person morning worship, a 13% increase in
- 4:08discipleship ministries, 8% increase in NYI, 18% increase in
- 4:15New Nazarenes, 1% increase in ties and offering, and a 20%
- 4:21increase in conversions. And all I can say is thanks be
- 4:28to God. On the face of it, these numbers
- 4:32are hopeful and uplifting, and they should be.
- 4:35But I drove into the numbers and the research that the General
- 4:38Secretary's office provides on the denomination because it just
- 4:42didn't jive with what I was tracking privately by looking at
- 4:47districts and paying attention to individual churches.
- 4:51So taking emotions out of the equation and even my own
- 4:55observation and looking at the black and white numbers of the
- 4:58denomination in which it was surprising.
- 5:01Now hear my heart. Please don't get me wrong, there
- 5:04are other ways to measure that might be more effective, but the
- 5:09numbers that the churches provide the Global Ministry
- 5:11Center are the ones that everyone can review through the
- 5:14General Secretary's office. And here are 5 warning signs
- 5:18that made me pause in looking at these numbers.
- 5:22The first one warning sign #1 fewer people in the seats
- 5:27weekly. In 2020, the USA Canada region
- 5:31an average average 423,529 people attended our local
- 5:38churches each week. Five years later, that number
- 5:42has dropped, the 364,029. During the pandemic, many
- 5:49churches shifted to the online model, seeing social media
- 5:52platforms as a new campus, an online campus, and trying to
- 5:57engage viewers there. On the surface, the numbers look
- 6:00incredible. 185,367 online members attend average each
- 6:09week, up from 33,000. That's up 33,220 from the year
- 6:15before. These figures however, hide at
- 6:19least or mask the decline in in person attendance as they lack a
- 6:24fundamental reporting model that is equal across all districts
- 6:28and churches. That is followed and the keyword
- 6:32is followed. While the global church has
- 6:35provided guidance to report online participation, let me
- 6:39give you one example, just one of a church that shows the
- 6:43system needs some help. For this true life example, I
- 6:48want to call the church Mountain High Nazarene so as not to call
- 6:52out the pastor or district Superintendent, but to draw
- 6:55attention to the lack of following the guidance that the
- 6:59General Board of Super Superintendents has provided in
- 7:03counting online attendance. For the past five years, the
- 7:07Church This Mountain High Nazarene has registered in
- 7:11between 48 and 54 full members, 23 to 29 in discipleship
- 7:18enrollment, on average 17 to 29 in discipleship attendance and
- 7:25total church income is 29,976 all the way up to 41,401 when
- 7:33you look at Mountain High Nazarene.
- 7:35A true life example, Church of the Nazarene with its name
- 7:39hidden for this podcast. It is a steady average size
- 7:44church that is plateaued. Nothing to be ashamed of.
- 7:48But here is where the problem comes in.
- 7:50When related to reporting, worship attendance has averaged
- 7:54between 20 and 26 people over the past four years.
- 7:59And here's the problem. In 2025 it jumped to 570 people.
- 8:06Clearly there is an error, but the pastor says we have a large
- 8:10Bible study online. Do you see the problem?
- 8:14Hmm. This is where the system broke
- 8:17down. Warning sign #2 closing more
- 8:21churches than planting. In the last two years, the
- 8:24region has closed or merged 150 churches and organized 49,
- 8:31resulting in a net loss of 101 churches in 2024.
- 8:36The Eastern region, the old in ENC field closed or merged 21
- 8:43churches with the next highest being the Southeast field or the
- 8:47TNU field which closed or merged 12 churches.
- 8:52The following year in 2025, it got worse for the Southeast
- 8:56field as they closed 24 churches with the next highest being the
- 9:00South Central field, the SNU field, which closed 13 churches.
- 9:06There was some hope during the same 24 month period, the
- 9:10mentioned fields organized 17 churches but it still had a net
- 9:14loss of 53. Even in my current sub region,
- 9:19the ONU field where Nazarendum is strong, we closed 9 churches,
- 9:25organized three churches resulting in a net loss of 6
- 9:29churches. There are countless districts
- 9:31with strong healthy church growth where churches and parent
- 9:35affiliated congregations are growing, but far too many
- 9:39districts are struggling as a whole.
- 9:42Warning sign #3 questionable online counting by local
- 9:47churches. I already shared by concerned
- 9:50about the renamed Mountain View Nazarene Church regarding online
- 9:55counting earlier. Clearly there is creative
- 9:58accounting or or at least misunderstanding of what should
- 10:02or should not be counted. Let me give you another example
- 10:05of a church that grew 80 people year over year, which would be
- 10:08solid growth. It increased in tides by
- 10:11$15,000. You might say, Desmond, what's
- 10:15wrong with that? Well, that equates to about
- 10:17$187.50 per new person. So I did some digging, and that
- 10:24growth was mainly driven by what online attendance could.
- 10:29Nearly 80 people join on average online for service could happen,
- 10:34but it raises more questions than answers.
- 10:37The reality is is that pastors are doing their best to grow the
- 10:40church. They're using the tools even
- 10:43liberally and counting who attends what constitute a
- 10:47service, such as clicks counted as views, which in turn is
- 10:51counted as attendance. Even if the online watcher only
- 10:55watch for three seconds to be counted in the click, what does
- 11:00that do? It creates a smoke and mirrors
- 11:03that hides the fact that revitalization is needed in our
- 11:07established and legacy churches. Is it a lack of education on
- 11:12what is needed? Is it pressure to show growth or
- 11:15is value found in the numbers for some pastors?
- 11:19Either way, clear direction and training on the topic are needed
- 11:24for pastors. And I include myself in that
- 11:28warning #4 the region accounts for well over 93% of global
- 11:34giving. The Church of the Nazarene is a
- 11:36global church that stretches into 165 world areas.
- 11:41There's a saying that the sun never sets on the Church of the
- 11:44Nazarene because of its vast Kingdom footprint.
- 11:48But what happens when the financial leader USA, Canada
- 11:52region begins to decline and can't provide the resources to
- 11:56expand the global work? Let's dive back into the numbers
- 12:01that came directly from the General Secretary's office.
- 12:05The region distributed distributed over $834 million in
- 12:11missional funds just last year. And my friends, that is
- 12:15something to celebrate and I rejoice that lives are being
- 12:18impacted because of you and because of faithful Nazarenes
- 12:23throughout USA, Canada, the rest of the global church
- 12:27collectively gave 152,934,511. And again I say praise be to
- 12:36God, these are funds expanding the Kingdom, planting new works,
- 12:40expanding existing works, culling, culling, missionary
- 12:44engagement and and the list goes on and on.
- 12:47And this is the global work that needs a healthy USA Canada
- 12:52region. The USA Canada region is a
- 12:55generous region. It gave last year in ties and
- 12:59offering 741 million dollars $741,543,016.00, a $3.5 million
- 13:11increase from the previous year. Again I say praise be to God for
- 13:18the faithful Nazarenes of USA Canada region.
- 13:21Now would you? Minus that figure from the
- 13:23global income total that the rest of the global church
- 13:26provides, which is just over $126 million, you instantly see
- 13:33the need for revitalization in the region.
- 13:36Why? Well, without a healthy strong
- 13:40local church, the region suffers.
- 13:43And if USA, Canada suffers, guess what, The global church is
- 13:48harmed in turn. Warning sign #5 Not every not
- 13:53enough ministers to fill roles globally.
- 13:58When you review the figures globally, the church is strong
- 14:01and has a healthy pipeline of pastors.
- 14:04So let me do some simple math for you.
- 14:07The global church has 20,440 ordained elders in the Church of
- 14:13the Nazarene. Add to that number 10,871
- 14:18district licensed pastors. In total, that is 31,311 pastors
- 14:25for the 29,424 churches globally in the Church of the Nazarene.
- 14:31That seems like a healthy margin until you realize that 13,237 or
- 14:39just over 42% of the elders in district licensed pastors are in
- 14:44USA Canada region. The region only has 4316
- 14:52organized church churches, even though these churches have far
- 14:57too many openings to count because we can't find enough
- 15:02pastors and all you got to do is talk to a district
- 15:05Superintendent and see how many openings they have.
- 15:09You don't have to believe me. Many of our current ministers in
- 15:13the region are aging and not enough students are graduating
- 15:16from our university systems through our religion
- 15:19departments. Thus, there is a need for a
- 15:22robust Nazarene Bible College and Nazarene Theological
- 15:27Seminary educational pipeline, but it is unfortunately not
- 15:32adequately funded by the region. Currently, their funding sources
- 15:37at NBC and NTS are limited and they're not part of the
- 15:42allocation distribution outside of what the global church
- 15:45provides, but not our regional universities.
- 15:50You see, these regional universities receive at least 2%
- 15:54from districts, but NBC and NTS do seek a special offering once
- 16:00a year from churches in the region.
- 16:02But it's not enough to sustain their vital work.
- 16:07You don't have to take my word for it.
- 16:08I I want you to challenge me. E-mail or call the respective
- 16:13presidents and chairs of the Board of Trustees of Nazarene
- 16:16Bible College and Nazarene Theological Seminary and ask the
- 16:20questions yourself. In summary, the Church of the
- 16:24Nazarene and primarily the USA Canada region cannot plant
- 16:29enough churches fast enough to maintain even the status quo.
- 16:34There's a great need to adapt to the realities in which the local
- 16:38church administers. The 78 districts that make up
- 16:41the USA Canada region must develop a form of church
- 16:45revitalization that builds healthy churches that in turns
- 16:49plants healthy churches. I want you to hear my heart.
- 16:54Church revitalization is about redeeming the legacy, the
- 16:58established church. It's not pitting one program or
- 17:02focused against another. However, it is essential to turn
- 17:07the regions regions negative downward trend around.
- 17:12So let me let me reiterate strongly that church
- 17:17revitalization and the renewal of pastoral and lay leadership
- 17:21are needed to establish healthy churches for Kingdom work
- 17:25because we need to plant healthy churches and grow the Kingdom.
- 17:30There are many district leaders, district superintendents, who
- 17:34are leading well, serving with passion and an eye towards
- 17:37revitalizing and planting healthy churches in the
- 17:40districts they oversee. These district superintendents
- 17:44should be cheered on. We should learn from their
- 17:47techniques and for those districts that are struggling,
- 17:51find a way forward that honors God and re establishes healthy
- 17:56church model in the community. Friends, this is just one
- 18:00person's opinion. You don't have to believe me.
- 18:03Dive into the numbers of the General Secretary's office.
- 18:07Dive into your own district, maybe even in your own local
- 18:10church. If you're seeing a struggle,
- 18:13it's not too late to turn around.
- 18:15There is hope. God has a plan for your church.
- 18:19Don't give up on the Church of the Nazarene or your local
- 18:22community. Thanks for listening to
- 18:32Revitalize the Declining Church with Doctor Desmond Barrett.
- 18:35If you liked what you heard today, would you be willing to
- 18:37share it with your colleagues or your local leaders inside your
- 18:40church? Why don't you subscribe so you
- 18:43don't miss the next episode that comes out?
- 18:45As always, my friends, I believe in you.
- 18:47I'm praying for you. Have a great week.