Latest / Film And Whiskey / Rope / 1792 Sweet Wheat Bourbon
Transcript
- 0:00In 1948, director Alfred Hitchcock and star John Doll
- 0:04gave the world a pretentious drama about the dangers of
- 0:07unimpeded hubris. In 2023, we try again with a
- 0:12familiar brand and we'll see if Brad likes it.
- 0:15The film is rope. The whiskey is 1792 Sweet Wheat
- 0:20and we'll review them both. This is.
- 0:23The Film and Whiskey podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:45Podcast. For each week we review a
- 0:46classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:49I'm Bob Book. I'm Reggie.
- 0:51And this week we are watching one of my absolute favorite
- 0:54Alfred Hitchcock films, 1940 Eight's Rope.
- 0:58Man, old man Brad, am I pumped to talk about this movie.
- 1:02I have wanted to talk about this movie with you for almost five
- 1:05years now and I just kind of knew we had to get through some
- 1:08other more important movies before we got to this one to 200
- 1:12plus other more important. Movies.
- 1:15But we've arrived, man. We're at the 201st most
- 1:18important movie, and that is Alfred Hitchcock's Rope, the
- 1:22pinnacle that no one knew we were shooting for.
- 1:25I knew it all along, man. I planned this thing out as
- 1:29meticulously as their murder. Brad, I am super excited to talk
- 1:33about this movie today, not least of which because last
- 1:37week's episode Notorious ended up being a movie that neither of
- 1:40us were really like that hot on. You know?
- 1:43We were decidedly cool on that movie.
- 1:46You even more so than me. And that was the first time.
- 1:48Watch for me. So I'm kind of glad we stuck it
- 1:51at the beginning of this Alfred Hitchcock retrospective, because
- 1:54these last four movies on the season are ones that I've all
- 1:57seen and I've all I've liked all of them, especially Rope.
- 2:01And let's be honest here man, part of what the appeal of this
- 2:04movie is, is that it is 80 minutes long.
- 2:09Dude, I absolutely love the 90 minute film.
- 2:12And if you if you sat down and said Brad, I have a spectacular
- 2:15movie for you that is also 10 minutes less than the world
- 2:20famed 90 minute film I am 100% in.
- 2:23Yeah, the crazy thing about Notorious is like, that movie
- 2:26was only an hour and 40, right? Like, and that felt 8 times
- 2:30longer than this movie. Yeah, I love a good, economical
- 2:34film. You know, right up there with
- 2:35paths of Glory. This movie packs a punch in an
- 2:38hour and 20 minutes. Yeah, and the The thing is, it
- 2:41needed to be this short. Like if this was an hour and 37
- 2:45minutes with you know 3 or 4 minutes of of credits, it would
- 2:50feel like it was 3 hours long. Like it is a slow moving film.
- 2:55It's it is meant to move slowly. The the pacing here is really
- 3:00deliberate and it needs to be and because of that it needed to
- 3:05be 80 minutes long. It it ends right when it needs
- 3:08to end, yeah. But part of that is the way that
- 3:10the movie is filmed. So you know the big gimmick of
- 3:13this movie, quote UN quote, is that it is designed to look like
- 3:161 continuous shot for essentially the whole movie.
- 3:19You know, you can now as a viewer you can see some really
- 3:22well disguised cuts, but Hitchcock basically had this
- 3:26whole thing blocked out like a stage play so that they could
- 3:29take a real film. And as the whole thing spooled
- 3:33through, they had it timed out that I think they got like 12
- 3:36minutes a shot. And so they would just film like
- 3:381 extended shot. The camera's constantly moving.
- 3:42And I actually think, Brad, if I was an actor, I would love
- 3:45working like this where you just kind of memorize your moves for
- 3:4712 minutes and you've, you've knocked out, you know, 1/6 of
- 3:51the movie or whatever it is. Yeah, I mean, it still took them
- 3:54a long time to shoot. I know that they were on set for
- 3:57about 14 hours a day and the film ends up being 10 exact
- 4:03shots. Like there are 10s film reels.
- 4:06I think it was anywhere from like 4 minutes from a shot to I
- 4:10think 11 minutes and some seconds was the longest shot.
- 4:14And yes, this was an an absolute bear to make in the sense that
- 4:21they don't have modern, you know, technology to help them
- 4:25make you know, Allah 1917, a one shot movie like Hitchcock is
- 4:31doing this way before anybody else was attempting anything
- 4:36that looked like a oneshot movie.
- 4:40Right before we jumped off of our last call.
- 4:43So we finished doing Notorious and I was trying to pick your
- 4:46brain a little bit about Rope. I didn't know if you had
- 4:48remembered that. I had mentioned this movie a few
- 4:50times on the podcast before and I have never heard you cut me
- 4:54off with such disdain the way you cut me off a couple days
- 4:57ago. You were like, dude.
- 4:59I don't want to know anything. I'm sick and tired of your crap,
- 5:02Bob. Stop spoiling movies for me,
- 5:04Yes. But I what I was really trying
- 5:07to figure out was, did you remember that this was supposed
- 5:10to be a one take or a one shot movie, or was that like a
- 5:14pleasant surprise as you started watching?
- 5:16Honestly I like it didn't even click in my brain that it was
- 5:21one shot until about the 4th or 5th when he zooms in on a black
- 5:26you know, fabric or somebody's code or something like that and
- 5:30you're like oh I see what he's doing here.
- 5:32It's it's it's all one shot nice.
- 5:35And I I think it was a pleasant surprise in the fact that I knew
- 5:38this film was made in 194748 like like that's what makes it
- 5:43so impressive anymore. I I think we have been spoiled
- 5:47by a lot of movies who do it. You know, Children of Men comes
- 5:50to mind, but to see it done in 1948 is especially impressive.
- 5:56I think that my original point though on spoiling movies still
- 6:00stands. Bob, don't spoil my movies.
- 6:02I don't want to spoil it, I just didn't know if you remembered
- 6:04that it was one shot or not, man.
- 6:07So OK, The funny thing though, I texted Bob like halfway through
- 6:12the movie and was like, dude, I'm not going to lie, I'm pretty
- 6:17sure I've seen this before. It was really funny.
- 6:19You were like, I don't know where, I don't know when, but I
- 6:22don't know whom. Yeah, that.
- 6:24And that's the thing. I'm still like racking my brain.
- 6:26The best thing I can come up with is that maybe I watched it
- 6:30in, like college. But you know what?
- 6:33Like this is like a perfect intro to philosophy.
- 6:36You know, you have an hour and a half, a 90 minute class and the
- 6:39professor's like, well, I didn't prepare anything.
- 6:42Let's watch rope and talk about Nietzsche.
- 6:45And honestly, you could do a heck of a lot worse for your
- 6:47intro to philosophy class. Yeah, right.
- 6:50Before we move into our first segment, I want to go back to
- 6:52your statement about the 80 minute movie and why it's
- 6:55perfect for that format. Because this is based on a stage
- 6:59play of the same name from the late 1920s and that play
- 7:03apparently follows a three act structure.
- 7:05It's like a very standard play. I think it's really smart A to
- 7:10basically film it as a one act play instead of a three act play
- 7:14here. But also, you know, we've seen a
- 7:16lot of movies, Brad, that are adaptations of stage plays.
- 7:19And there's a lot of ways to visually try to give the
- 7:24impression of like you're just watching a filmed version of a
- 7:27play. And when this movie first starts
- 7:29out and you're just kind of like in their apartment and the
- 7:32camera is the 4th wall, you know, the camera like pushes in
- 7:36and pushes out a little bit, but it's kind of just moving on one
- 7:39axis. And I'm thinking like, oh man,
- 7:41I. Are people just going to wander
- 7:43in and out of frame like we're sitting in a fixed place in a
- 7:46theater, and then the first time the camera starts to actually
- 7:49move around the apartment, I'm like, oh, Hitchcock, you're
- 7:52you're really smart because everything you're doing here
- 7:55still gives me the impression that I'm watching a stage play.
- 7:58But you make, like such great use of every single corner of
- 8:03this set. It's a really brilliant way of
- 8:06kind of having your cake and eating it too.
- 8:09Yeah, it makes you feel like you're not watching the play on
- 8:12opening night. You're actually like the
- 8:14director walking around on stage while they are practicing.
- 8:19Yeah, you know. It's a very fly on the wall kind
- 8:21of a thing, yeah. And like a few of the shots that
- 8:24really stood out to me, one of one shot that really stood out
- 8:27to me was when the camera kind of pan while it dollies to the
- 8:31right side of the stage if we're going to keep calling it a
- 8:35stage. And you see the shot of the
- 8:38trunk in the foreground, the hallway in the midground and the
- 8:43kitchen all the way in the background.
- 8:45And I I think the the maid is like taking the candlesticks to
- 8:48the hallway. Like it's shots like that that
- 8:52were incredible. Also the one where the cameras
- 8:54in the hallway looking into the kitchen and I think not, not
- 8:59Brandon. Phillip is talking to somebody
- 9:02and Brandon is putting the rope away and and the door like
- 9:05swings open and you see him dropping it like things like
- 9:11that. Throughout the film I was like,
- 9:12oh, this is clever. Like this feels like a really
- 9:16advanced, intimate version of going to the theater.
- 9:20Well, we've kind of started talking about character names
- 9:22and and important props and set pieces, so it's probably time
- 9:26for us to tell film and Whiskey Nation what the heck this movie
- 9:29is actually about. And to do that, we're going to
- 9:31get to our segment, Brad explains.
- 9:33Brad's going to give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 9:36ticking on the clock, so let's go ahead and do your take with
- 9:40this little segment that we call.
- 9:41Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 9:44podcast where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that he
- 9:47has just seen, often for the first time.
- 9:50Now, this is not Brad's first time, Definitely not.
- 9:54But I don't know when the first time was.
- 9:56I was going to say what counted as like this is this is instance
- 9:591.5. It's not really your second
- 10:02time, but it's not quite your first time either.
- 10:05It's it's in beta testing. Yes, all right man.
- 10:08So you have one minute on the clock to break down and spoil
- 10:11the plot of this movie. And it really, it's kind of a
- 10:14spoiler proof movie because all of the stuff that you need to
- 10:18know happens in the first moments of the movie.
- 10:21But go ahead, man, spoil this movie. 60 Seconds and Go Rope is
- 10:26a film about two young protagonists or antagonists.
- 10:30I don't know, Bob. What?
- 10:31How would you characterize? Antiheroes, man.
- 10:34Antiheroes Brandon and Phillip are definitely not gay lovers,
- 10:39no? Who have murdered their former
- 10:42classmates and throw they throw a dinner party for the father.
- 10:48Actually, I think the parents no, it's the father and his
- 10:51sisterinlaw because the mom can't come anyways.
- 10:54The family of the deceased as well as the girl who is in love
- 10:58with the deceased. And Brandon, the main character
- 11:01tries to manipulate everyone into understanding how brilliant
- 11:06he is while his compatriot coconspirator Philip is
- 11:11terrified that anyone will find out what happens.
- 11:14Jimmy Stewart comes in and blows it all up and has a realization
- 11:19of his own. Boom.
- 11:22This movie is like a perfect Hitchcock movie.
- 11:26Because, you know, we've talked for, I don't know, 5-6, seven
- 11:29movies about Hitchcock now. Brad and all of his weird little
- 11:32psychosexual fetishes and all of the gallows humor and the really
- 11:38kind of gross ways that he finds humor in the the blackest of
- 11:43situations. And this one, man, I got to say
- 11:47to set the stage last night I went and saw this movie in a
- 11:51movie theater film and Whiskey Nation.
- 11:53We were supposed to kick off Hitchcock with this movie.
- 11:57I asked Brad if we could reshuffle a little bit because I
- 11:59saw that this movie was playing at the Cleveland Cinematech, one
- 12:03of the best repertory theaters in the country.
- 12:05I had never been. And I love this movie.
- 12:07And I was like, dude, I want to see Rope in person.
- 12:10And Brad, before we get any further, I got to tell you,
- 12:12dude. There was probably, you know, I
- 12:14don't know, 3540 people at the showing last night.
- 12:17Like it was sold pretty well. This movie plays incredibly well
- 12:22with the crowd. Like, you wouldn't think it
- 12:24because it's almost 80 years old.
- 12:26There were like audible gasps in the audience at multiple points.
- 12:30It was so much fun. We should insert like a sound
- 12:34clip of like. You joke, but that's what it
- 12:40sounded like. It was really cool.
- 12:41Believe it, man. Yeah.
- 12:43And that's we we don't often talk about the actual experience
- 12:49of going to the theater on this podcast, which is like a little
- 12:53bit sad, because at the end of the day, man, going to watch
- 12:56movies in theaters is a way different experience than
- 13:00streaming it on your phone, computer or television.
- 13:04Yeah, well, there, there is something important.
- 13:07Like for me it was Top Gun Maverick.
- 13:09That was like the first time in like 17 years that I felt like I
- 13:13was truly at the theaters again. But all all this to say, go, go
- 13:19watch movies in theaters, people.
- 13:20Well, and and you were making a point earlier about how clever a
- 13:23lot of the things in this movie feel.
- 13:25And when you're watching it at home, you know, once in a while
- 13:28I'll give a movie like a little wry smile and I'm like, oh,
- 13:31Hitchcock, like you sly bastard, you know?
- 13:35Those moments when you're in a crowd, they become actively fun
- 13:39because people get the humor. They start laughing out loud.
- 13:42There's there's so many lines in this movie where someone's like,
- 13:45oh, where's David? I'm dying to see him.
- 13:48And then everyone goes, I see what you did, you know, And I
- 13:51just quickly say for me, I'm going to come down on the the
- 13:56place of, like, this movie's a little bit pretentious and it's
- 13:59stuff like that. It's the fact that he never gave
- 14:02up on those jokes that by the end of it I was like, come on
- 14:06Hitchcock. Like this script is a little, a
- 14:09little much for me. Oh dude, I wish you'd been there
- 14:12last night. I think your whole opinion would
- 14:14be slightly different. It sounds like you enjoyed the
- 14:16movie, though. I did, yeah.
- 14:18My dad and I watched it together.
- 14:20He had never seen it before and he loves old movies and
- 14:23Hitchcock. And honestly, this is a complete
- 14:27aside. The movie opened and I knew it
- 14:29was in 1948, and I had to look to see if, like the they had
- 14:34made a special color version of this like they have with, you
- 14:38know, like It's a Wonderful Life and things like that.
- 14:41Because I was like, oh, I don't want to watch some crappy color
- 14:45remake of this film. And so I, like, legitimately
- 14:48paused it to look. And I was like, oh, this is
- 14:50Alfred Hitchcock's first color film.
- 14:53Well first of all. I'm very proud of you.
- 14:56And secondly, I no longer think you have any room to call
- 15:00anything pretentious like you stopped the movie and said no
- 15:04way I'm watching this bastardized version.
- 15:08It's because of It's A Wonderful Life.
- 15:10Yeah, that's for like a top ten movie for me.
- 15:13The color version just doesn't cut it, man.
- 15:15All right, let's dive into talking about the movie itself
- 15:18so it kicks off immediately with the murder.
- 15:22Like the first thing you hear is a scream.
- 15:24The cameras outside this building and then it cuts inside
- 15:27and you see them with a rope around the victim's neck and he
- 15:31is dead. And they quite visceral, really
- 15:34visceral and quite the jolt, honestly.
- 15:38And one of the things I immediately noticed about this
- 15:40movie is that outside of the opening credits and I guess the
- 15:45closing credits, there's no music in the movie.
- 15:49All the music is diegetic, like every once in a while Philip
- 15:52will play the piano and that's it.
- 15:54But this guy screams and he's murdered.
- 15:56And then it's just silent and you hear a clock ticking in the
- 15:59background. And I just first, First things
- 16:02first, man, the use of sound in this movie for 1948 is
- 16:07absolutely insane. Yeah, he he does a really
- 16:11beautiful job of kind of like what you said earlier.
- 16:15You truly are a fly on the wall for this movie.
- 16:18You you don't feel as if it is staged in the sense that like it
- 16:24it feels like a stage play, but it doesn't feel like you are a
- 16:29audience member watching a stage play.
- 16:31It feels like you are truly there on stage as it's
- 16:35happening. It it, it feels incredibly
- 16:37immersive. Is that I guess what I'm trying
- 16:39to say? Yeah, Well, and again, like,
- 16:41it's things that we're used to seeing now, like a single shot
- 16:45movie or the camera kind of. Moving around inside a cramped
- 16:49space or the lack of music. But this movie is what Brad 75
- 16:54years old this year. This is not the kind of thing
- 16:57you saw in studio movie making of the late 1940s.
- 17:03No, it's not. And I I think about other movies
- 17:06that we've watched in this realm in this era, you know, from the
- 17:10early 40s with like Casablanca or you know, Double Indemnity
- 17:15all the way into the 50s with some of the Billy Wilder things
- 17:17that we've watched. I just don't think that there's
- 17:20many movies quite like this. And I I think that if there's
- 17:25anything that remains similar, it is the sense of melodrama
- 17:29that I'm realizing really just exists.
- 17:31Hardcore in the 40s especially, and like the way that they act
- 17:37has just this heir to it that you're like, Oh yeah, this is
- 17:41the 40s a 100%. But other than that, I think a
- 17:44lot of the camera techniques, the use of sound, as you said,
- 17:48diegetic sound, It really feels way ahead of its time.
- 17:52I think it's a good jumping off point to start talking about the
- 17:55performances in this movie. And the two main characters, the
- 17:59murderers Brandon and Phillip, are really the only people that
- 18:03you see for the first, you know, 15 minutes of the movie.
- 18:06And it took me a minute to remember that, like, Jimmy
- 18:09Stewart doesn't come into this movie until probably like 3035.
- 18:13Minutes in, like it's it's really far into the movie.
- 18:16And I have to say, man, the performance by John Doll as
- 18:21Brandon, who is kind of the mastermind of the whole thing
- 18:24and certifiably insane. Like cold, calm, collected, like
- 18:29toying with people, manipulating clearly the mind of a serial
- 18:34killer. His performance is lights out
- 18:37good. Like I am seeing it on a big
- 18:39screen too. To your point about a lot of the
- 18:42people in this movie act as if they were actors in the 1940s
- 18:46and kind of ham it up. His performance is so
- 18:48naturalistic by by comparison, like little things like even
- 18:52just like scratching his nose in the middle of a take, Things you
- 18:55didn't see Hollywood actors doing.
- 18:58I was blown away by his performance.
- 18:59Brad Yeah, I'm honestly curious if he was more of a stage actor
- 19:05in his career up until this point, because he feels like a
- 19:10stage actor so much more so than most of the other people in this
- 19:15film. I think that Phillip, played by
- 19:17Farley Granger, also has that vibe to him of of hamming it up
- 19:22a little bit in the way you would for a theater performance
- 19:26over a movie. And I think it kind of makes we
- 19:29don't have to get to him yet, but it makes Jimmy Stewart stand
- 19:32out a little bit because like Jimmy Stewart comes on on stage
- 19:36and he's just smooth as butter, man.
- 19:39He like, like, I love the performance by John Doll.
- 19:43I think Farley Granger is great. I think that Jimmy Stewart is
- 19:47out of place here. And yet it it's almost like when
- 19:52you see Will Ferrell come on to the office and you're like, I
- 19:56know that Will Ferrell's not like Hollywood's greatest actor,
- 20:00but he's a way better actor than 92% of the other actors on this
- 20:05television show, you know? What?
- 20:07I mean, it's so funny you bring that up because like with John
- 20:09Doll, he doesn't seem like he's playing to the back row.
- 20:14Like his is much more like, I know there's a camera 5 inches
- 20:17from my face and I'm, I'm going to do it much more subtly.
- 20:20Whereas Farley Granger, like by the end of the movie where he's
- 20:23like just absolutely toasted and he's he's just shouting like he
- 20:27said, you could have a drink, have a drink, man.
- 20:31Like there was audible laughs in my in my theater from that.
- 20:34And Jimmy Stewart, by contrast, is it's almost like a tale of
- 20:40two halves for him. Because when he comes in and
- 20:44he's got that really, like, biting wit and he's just kind of
- 20:48like nothing with people, It's a sight of Jimmy Stewart I've
- 20:51never seen. And it's like really, really
- 20:53charming, but in like a like an A hole kind of way.
- 20:57Like he seems like a jerk. Yeah.
- 20:59Yeah. And I really love that
- 21:01performance. And then at the end of the
- 21:03movie, you know, spoiler alert, Jimmy Stewart figures out what's
- 21:06going on and he has the two guys cornered.
- 21:09And then he gives this big pompous speech about like, the
- 21:13goodness of man and Brad. It reminded me so much of, like
- 21:17the final speech of Henry Fonda in The Grapes of Wrath.
- 21:20It's so Tom Joad and it's it's this like moralizing speech that
- 21:26I don't feel like the movie really needed.
- 21:28Like, we understand what they're doing is wrong.
- 21:30We don't need Jimmy Stewart to have that character realization.
- 21:34And that and the way he delivers it is very much like, oh, this
- 21:38is Jimmy Stewart. This is why he took this role.
- 21:42It kind of sucks because I thought that what he was doing
- 21:44in the rest of the movie was so much better and so different
- 21:49than what I'm used to seeing with him.
- 21:51Yeah, I I mean he turned into Mr. Smith goes to Washington,
- 21:55right? Like he's he is moralizing and
- 21:57giving a speech and I I think that's I'm with you in that that
- 22:02was just the funkiest part of the movie.
- 22:04But also like if you just cut that scene.
- 22:09And just showed me that, you know, on a random day that I I
- 22:13wasn't thinking about rope, I'd be like, oh, that's a great
- 22:16speech. Like he like, he knocks it out
- 22:18of the park. It just doesn't fit tonally with
- 22:22what's going on with his character as well as just the
- 22:25rest of the film. So I I've never read the script
- 22:28to the play that this is based on, but I was, you know, doing
- 22:31the next best thing and perusing Wikipedia today.
- 22:34And they said that the the play remains kind of unresolved.
- 22:38Like, he has the realization that his twisted philosophy in
- 22:44teaching these boys about the ubermensch and Nietzschean
- 22:47philosophy is what led to this. But he doesn't have this, you
- 22:52know, standing on a soapbox moment where he says everything.
- 22:55I've believed my whole life is a lie and you've shown it to me
- 22:59and and you know, I think it's probably a better ending.
- 23:02I'm also not surprised that you had to have the moralistic
- 23:06ending in 1948. Yeah, and that's the hard part,
- 23:10is that we're all constrained by the era we live in.
- 23:14And so could this movie have been better if he made it even
- 23:17like 10 years later, like even in 58, he probably could have
- 23:20gotten away with a more morally Gray ending.
- 23:24But it is the movie that we have and you can just take the 1st
- 23:2880%. Of our 80 minute movie and say
- 23:33this is incredible. Getting back to John Doll and
- 23:37Farley Granger, I just have to say this.
- 23:40I think that John Doll in this film, I don't know what he looks
- 23:43like in other films because I've never seen it before.
- 23:46For some reason, I couldn't get it out of my head that he looks
- 23:49like a really young, thin Ben Affleck.
- 23:53You know, it's funny. I was like, I was going through
- 23:55people in my head that he's kind of a combo of and I'm like, oh,
- 23:59the top half of his face is kind of like John Krasinski.
- 24:02But then the shape of his face reminds me of Jon Crier from 2
- 24:061/2 men. And then it was like, you know,
- 24:09but he's also much more dapper and much more sophisticated and
- 24:12suave. I can see the Ben Affleck thing
- 24:14mostly because of body language, like when Ben Affleck is
- 24:18purposely playing a douche, it's very similar to what he's doing.
- 24:22Yeah. Yes, I'm so glad that you saw
- 24:25that because I just spent the whole movie thinking, like, this
- 24:27has to be like Ben Affleck's grandfather or something.
- 24:32So the crazy thing is, you know, Farley Granger is not obviously
- 24:36the world's most famous movie star, but he goes on to
- 24:39collaborate with Hitchcock again in Strangers on a Train a few
- 24:42years after this, and it's a good movie and it's a good
- 24:46performance. I've just always wondered, like,
- 24:48why didn't you do this again with John Doll?
- 24:51Because to me, not only is John Doll the better performance in
- 24:55this movie, he's far and away the better actor between the
- 24:58two. Yeah, I I think that Farley
- 25:02Granger does a really good job with what he is asked to do.
- 25:05I think that it's like a B to B plus performance and I I
- 25:11wouldn't even say that John Doll is that much better.
- 25:13I'd give him like a B plus to an A -.
- 25:16I I just think that. You get a solid performance from
- 25:20Farley for what he's asked to do and and what he's asked to do is
- 25:24basically descend into madness over guilt for what he's done.
- 25:29And I think he does a good job of it.
- 25:31So I I I think the performance isn't noteworthy, but I don't
- 25:36know. I'm saying a lot of things about
- 25:37nothing. Essentially Brad, before we get
- 25:39to break I, I feel like we need to still flush out a little bit
- 25:43like the contents of this movie. So they kill a guy and they have
- 25:47planned out this perfect crime based on their own Nietzschean
- 25:51philosophy. They believe themselves to be of
- 25:53superior intellect. And they think that they can not
- 25:56only get away with murder, but kind of flaunt their own
- 26:00superior intellect by inviting the family members and close
- 26:04friends of this guy over to the house.
- 26:06And they stuff his body in a chest while while this dinner
- 26:10party is going on. And then John Doll's character
- 26:13says, I'm going to one up the gamesmanship here, Let's
- 26:16actually serve food off of the chest that this dead body is
- 26:20stuffed into. And not only that, how about I,
- 26:23I give his dad some books to take home with him and I'm going
- 26:26to use the rope that I killed his son with to tie the books
- 26:30up. There are so many like perverse
- 26:33touches to this movie and it's it's still crazy to me that just
- 26:39thematically they could get away with doing this in 1948.
- 26:43Yeah, it feels like a very dark film to have come out in the 40s
- 26:49and you know, post World War 2, everything's happy sunshine.
- 26:53The amount of turns that it takes to get darker and darker
- 26:57as it goes, I think it might be what necessitates Jimmy
- 27:01Stewart's speech at the end to be like.
- 27:03And by the way, I Alfred Hitch, I mean Jimmy Stewart.
- 27:06I mean whatever Caddell, whatever his name is in the
- 27:10movie. Do not approve of this.
- 27:12It's bad, We the Most Picture Association of America.
- 27:19But at the end of the day, we all know what Hitchcock was
- 27:22really interested in. Like, that's what makes the
- 27:25Jimmy Stewart speech so weird, is that we we all know who
- 27:29Hitchcock is. Like.
- 27:30We might not have known in 1948, but we know that he's way more
- 27:34fascinated and interested in all the dark, perverse turns that he
- 27:38can take. The same way that Tarantino
- 27:40wants a movie to turn violent. Well, and and that's what makes
- 27:43it a perfect Hitchcock movie too, because you could hand this
- 27:46material to like David Fincher today, and you could make a
- 27:50really good David Fincher movie out of this.
- 27:52It just wouldn't be funny. And like, I'm not to spoil my
- 27:55let's make it a double. I have a David Fincher movie in
- 27:57mind for this, but Hitchcock, he does the darkness really well,
- 28:03but he's also, at every point making you find the humor in it
- 28:07and making it fun and like just on its face.
- 28:12The movie is suspenseful because you don't know if these two
- 28:15murderers are going to get found out.
- 28:18And the fact that you even feel suspense kind of indicates a
- 28:22little bit that there's a part of you that is like not wanting
- 28:27them to get found out, because if you wanted to get found out,
- 28:29you'd just be cheering the whole time.
- 28:31So he puts you in a position where you're like subconsciously
- 28:35kind of rooting for the murderers.
- 28:37And it's it's a very weird spot, but it's something that
- 28:39Hitchcock does so well. Yeah, well and he's he's playing
- 28:42like a rope, a dope, like people getting close to the the the
- 28:47cabinet, the chest and then getting further away and then
- 28:50closer and then getting away. And finally, the maid, like,
- 28:53halfway opens it and Brendan has to come over and like, push it
- 28:56down and be like, Nope, you have to come back tomorrow, maid.
- 29:01All right, man. Speaking of coming back in a
- 29:03little bit, let's press pause here.
- 29:06Let's drink this whiskey. I am not so much looking forward
- 29:08to this based on your review last week, but we've got 1792
- 29:13Sweet Wheat to drink. What do you say we get to it,
- 29:16Brent? Let's get to it.
- 29:24All right. So today we are trying again
- 29:26with 1792 as we get into their sweet wheat.
- 29:30Now this is an interesting bourbon Brad, in that it's not
- 29:33age stated, so we don't know exactly how old it is.
- 29:35You know I assume it's blended and that's why we're not getting
- 29:39an age statement on this. The mash bill is also not
- 29:42disclosed on this, but we know that it is a weeded bourbon.
- 29:45So this is kind of 1792, you know the Barton distilleries
- 29:49response to Weller to rebel. So I'm assuming that there is a
- 29:54very high proportion of wheat in this.
- 29:57At the same time, 1792 is known for being a high rye mash bill.
- 30:02So I actually don't know if this is like, oh, we've just swapped
- 30:05out the rye for wheat. I don't know if it's just like
- 30:08no, no, we're taking a high rye mash bill and just adding a
- 30:10touch more wheat. I have no idea really.
- 30:13I guess is what I'm saying if this is actually comparable mash
- 30:16bill wise to Weller or if they've just kind of like
- 30:21touched it up a little bit with wheat?
- 30:23And and I'll also say this. There seems to be in the
- 30:27research I've done a 2015 release that they released, you
- 30:32know, regularly from then on, and it looks like they've had
- 30:37now an updated 2023 release. And I, because we have had this
- 30:43whiskey for long enough, I I can say with with certainty this
- 30:47would be whatever the 2015 edition was that they released
- 30:51for, you know, 6-7 years. This would be from that
- 30:55addition, and I think honestly So it's an annual release and I
- 30:59know that I'm assuming you're looking at the same tasting
- 31:02notes that I did when I was trying to look this up on
- 31:04Breaking Bourbon, because their most recent review is like the
- 31:082023 release. Apparently when this first
- 31:10started being released in 2015, it had an 8 year age statement
- 31:15and then at some point they dropped the age statement.
- 31:18Maybe 2023 is when that dropped. I'm not entirely sure.
- 31:21But Brad, we are for sure drinking a prior to 2023 release
- 31:26on this bad boy. Yes.
- 31:28Yep. All right, man, we've we've
- 31:30given enough background on this. I think it's 91.2 proof.
- 31:33We have no idea how old it is. Let's dive in.
- 31:36What are you picking up on the nose?
- 31:38This one you get the cherries that you normally get on a wheat
- 31:41whiskey. For me, it turns into like a a
- 31:44dusty peanut and then. Overall though, from start to
- 31:49finish on the nose I I gave it a solid 10 to 15 minutes to try
- 31:52and let it air out before I drank it, but I just kept
- 31:56getting that nail Polish remover smell.
- 31:59Wow. It's not terrible.
- 32:02It's not overwhelming, but it was just underlying everything
- 32:06else that I gave it a 6 1/2 out of 10 on the nose.
- 32:09I'm going to give it a 7 1/2, and it's mostly because I'm not
- 32:13getting a lot of the notes. I typically get unweeded
- 32:15bourbons, so I'm getting a lot of that dustiness.
- 32:18I'm getting a lot of oak. And then, like, the predominant
- 32:21note for me is leather. There's a ton of leather on
- 32:24this. There's a little bit of tobacco
- 32:25as well. It kind of reminds me of, like,
- 32:28some of the more oaky Woodford's that we've had.
- 32:31But it's it shouldn't really smell like that.
- 32:34You know what I mean? It should smell more like cherry
- 32:36cola, which is what we get with our weeded bourbons.
- 32:39And that's not to say that like, it has to smell a certain way.
- 32:43It just makes me wonder, like, what exactly is the proportion
- 32:46of rye to wheat in this? Because I'm still picking up
- 32:49some of those things that the high rye mash bill from last
- 32:52week tipped me off to. So I'm going to give it a 7 1/2
- 32:56on the nose and I'm going to take a sip while you give me
- 32:59your tasting score. Yeah, as I got into the pallet,
- 33:02it had some nice notes going on. I got cinnamon, there was
- 33:06cherry, there's vanilla. The peanuts kind of disappear
- 33:09for me a little bit. It has a pleasant flavor, but
- 33:14nothing really stood out to me. There wasn't a depth of of
- 33:17quality to this. It was decent.
- 33:20I give it a 7 out of 10 and this reminds me of some Buffalo Trace
- 33:24stuff. Honestly.
- 33:25Like it it reminds me of almost like standard label Buffalo
- 33:29Trace. Not Even so much.
- 33:30Weller. Yeah, but then when I swallow it
- 33:34gets really char heavy, like it almost gets bitter because it's
- 33:37so burnt tasting. This is not what I anticipated
- 33:42at all. I'm not saying it's a bad
- 33:44whiskey. I'm not even saying that I don't
- 33:46like it necessarily. I would never use the words
- 33:49sweet or wheat to describe this whiskey at all.
- 33:53And it's unfortunate because as you know, the name of the
- 33:56product Brad is sweet wheat. So what to do here?
- 34:01I'm going to, I'm going to give it a 7 out of 10 because it's
- 34:04not bad, it just isn't what is advertised, yes.
- 34:09Yeah, and the finish for me was like really short and sweet,
- 34:12dissipated quickly. I I like your note of something
- 34:16burnt. For me it almost tasted kind of
- 34:18like a a really strong artificial vanilla extract that
- 34:23had been like burnt a tiny bit. Just okay on the finish.
- 34:27I give it a six out of 10 here. Second sip, the sweetness comes
- 34:30out a little bit more. I do get a bit of like a
- 34:33brandied cherry towards the back and then that that char comes
- 34:37back again and it's almost more herbal this time too.
- 34:40It's good, it's fine. I just again, I I don't know
- 34:43that I would have picked this as a weeded bourbon if you just set
- 34:45it down in front of me. I actually like the finish
- 34:48better than I like the palette. I'm going to give it a 7.5 and
- 34:52that takes us to balance where I'm really confused on what to
- 34:56do because it's it's a pretty solid whiskey all the way
- 34:59across. And I will also say in its
- 35:02favor, there was nothing on the nose, pallet or finish that was
- 35:07different from each other, right?
- 35:09Like, it's a very consistent whiskey.
- 35:11It just seems mislabeled to me. So, like, what What do I do with
- 35:15this? Like, it's really, if I didn't
- 35:17know the brand or the name of it, I'd probably give it a
- 35:20really high balance score. But knowing that it's called
- 35:23Sweet Wheat, I want to give it a really low balance score.
- 35:26What are you coming out to here? I gave it a six and a half like
- 35:30it, like the the flavors are there.
- 35:33They're consistent. It has a tiny bit of complexity
- 35:37from the nose through the finish, but overall the the the
- 35:41quality of character just isn't quite there on this one.
- 35:44So you know, a little below what I would consider a good score,
- 35:49I'm going to give it a 7 1/2 once again, just because it is a
- 35:52well above average whiskey on its own merits, right?
- 35:58I just man, I don't know man. What will this run you in the
- 36:02state of Ohio, Brad? This is $38.
- 36:06However, it was saying when I looked at OHLQ that it's
- 36:10unavailable and you have to look at the retailer.
- 36:13And so I so I don't know if it's often available in Ohio, but if
- 36:17it is $38, well, MSRP on the the Breaking Bourbon review of this
- 36:23was $50.00. So I mean, let's call it.
- 36:27You want to call it 38, you want to call it 50.
- 36:29What should we do here? Let's just assume that people
- 36:34are getting well, No, because we're definitely drinking an
- 36:37older addition. Let's let's say $40.
- 36:39All right, at 40 bucks, I don't think this is a bad whiskey at
- 36:42all. Like, if you set this down next
- 36:45to a bottle of Buffalo Trace, I'd probably prefer this.
- 36:48Especially like, you know it's priced in line with Weller
- 36:52Special Reserve. A little bit cheaper than Weller
- 36:55107, which this doesn't hold the candle to.
- 36:58But I don't think it's a bad value at $40 and I do think this
- 37:02is a better whiskey than what we drank last week.
- 37:05I'm going to give it a 6 1/2 out of 10 on value.
- 37:09Yeah, I I actually don't think that this is a good value of $40
- 37:13Bob. For for me the the quality just
- 37:18isn't there for this to be worth $40.
- 37:21If this was a $30 whiskey, I think it's like a seven and a
- 37:25half eight out of 10 value like that like this is decent.
- 37:27It it's not bad whiskey, but for $40 I just feel like there are
- 37:32way, way more great values out there at this price range.
- 37:38For me to ever pay this, I'll give it a four out of 10 on
- 37:41value. All right, I'm coming out to a
- 37:4436 out of 50. Brad, what are you at?
- 37:48I'm at a 30 out of 50. Once again, we're pretty far
- 37:52apart, although not 11 points apart like we were last week.
- 37:55So we're coming to an average of a 33 out of 50 or a 66 out of
- 38:00100, which is below the mark where we typically start
- 38:04recommending a whiskey. I will say for myself, I'm not
- 38:07going to recommend buying a bottle.
- 38:09I would recommend spending 5 to $7.00 on a pour of this at the
- 38:13bar. Like I I think it's a perfectly
- 38:15fine whiskey, and if this is like your preferred flavor
- 38:19palate, go for it. Yeah, I don't think I'm going to
- 38:22recommend this, Bob, man. We are striking out on 1792,
- 38:27dude. And you've been holding off on
- 38:29it for so long, just like rope. Yeah, luckily I have a higher
- 38:35opinion of rope than I do of 1792.
- 38:37Well, last question, did you get any tasting notes of rope in
- 38:42this I got? So much hemp, just all sorts of
- 38:47fabric hemp. It was pretty incredible.
- 38:50All right, man. Well, what do you say we get
- 38:52back into talking about this movie, Brad?
- 38:54Let's get to him, man. All right, everybody.
- 39:00That was 1792 Sweet Wheat, a bourbon that was neither sweet
- 39:05nor wheatie. I was a liar.
- 39:09I love wheatie as a tasting. Wheatie Breakfast. the
- 39:16Champions, baby. That's what I that's what I'm
- 39:18going for. Hey, man, guess what?
- 39:20Guess what time it is? Oh, I don't know, Bob.
- 39:23What time is it? It's time for me to finally
- 39:25secure a 500 season and at our new game, 2 Facts in a
- 39:29Falsehood. Brad is going to try to stumpy
- 39:32ball to. All right And what is wrong?
- 39:382 facts in a falsehood. That's right, two facts in a
- 39:41falsehood, which I for some reason just called a new game.
- 39:45Multiple seasons old at this point.
- 39:47I was a little curious about that.
- 39:48I was like, man, I I feel like we came up with this in like
- 39:51season five maybe, you know, I'm, I'm just kind of in the
- 39:54mode where I'm like it's a new day, it's a new game, This is my
- 39:58moment now, you know? You're calling your shot. 2
- 40:02Facts in a Falsehood is the part of the podcast where Brad
- 40:05presents three items to me as fact about the making of this
- 40:09movie, one of which is a complete lie, and it is my job
- 40:12to figure out which one is the lie.
- 40:14Brad, as I have mentioned I am hanging out at 15 and 13 on the
- 40:18season. I want to make sure that I hit
- 40:21sixteen wins, so that. You know the the balance will be
- 40:25achieved, right? But this is your chance.
- 40:27It is really, really up in the air as of right now.
- 40:31It sure is. Man, I'm feeling pretty good
- 40:33right now. I think I'm on a three-game
- 40:36winning streak. Yeah, And they were like all
- 40:39with guests. That's supposed to be like my
- 40:41ace in the hole. They let me down repeatedly.
- 40:44Yeah. Trust your gut, man.
- 40:47I will go with my gut today. My gut is currently full of
- 40:50Japanese hibachi food, so I don't know what I'm listening to
- 40:53right now, but bro I we made we had lemon chicken orzo tonight,
- 40:58some fresh bread out of the oven.
- 41:00Man, that sounds good too. All right dude, hit me with your
- 41:02two facts and a falsehood Fact #1.
- 41:05The Cary Grant and Ingrid Bergman film, of which Janet and
- 41:09Mrs. Atwater are struggling to remember, is Notorious from
- 41:151946, also directed I Don't Know If You Knew This Bob by Sir
- 41:19Alfred Hitchcock. Fact #2.
- 41:23This was the only movie that Jimmy Stewart made with
- 41:25Hitchcock that he did not like he being Jimmy Stewart.
- 41:29Stewart later admitted that he felt he was miscast as the
- 41:32Professor and that he had originally recommended Vincent
- 41:35Price to Hitchcock for the role. Fact #3 Screenwriter Arthur
- 41:40Lorenz claimed that originally Hitchcock assured him that the
- 41:45opening of the movie would not show the murder, therefore
- 41:49creating doubt as to whether the two leading characters actually
- 41:52committed the crime and whether the trunk had a corpse inside or
- 41:55not. Oh, interesting.
- 41:59OK, Well, I mean, I'm pretty sure number one is true.
- 42:03It made a lot of sense that that was what they were referring to.
- 42:06And it got a big laugh in my theater.
- 42:07So I'm. If if I'm wrong, then so was
- 42:10everyone else in my theater, because we all laughed at it.
- 42:13Cinematec. Yeah, cinephiles knew what they
- 42:16were talking about. So that means it's either two or
- 42:19three. I don't know that I remember
- 42:22hearing anything about Jimmy Stewart not liking this movie,
- 42:25but we've also established that it is kind of out of character.
- 42:28Not out of character, but like out of the typical realm of
- 42:31characters that he plays. So that typical for his ouvra,
- 42:35not for his ouvra. #3 is interesting just because I'd
- 42:40like, you would expect Hitchcock to show the murder.
- 42:44But yeah, I think that makes it more of a mystery.
- 42:47And Hitchcock has gone on record so many times talking about,
- 42:51like, mystery is when you withhold information from the
- 42:54audience, and suspense is when you give it to them.
- 42:56So I'm going to trust my gut that Hitchcock wanted to give
- 42:59them the murder at the beginning of the movie, and I'm going to
- 43:02say two is the falsehood. Brad, wait a second.
- 43:06You just said that. Wouldn't that make #3?
- 43:13You said that he had been assured by Hitchcock that he
- 43:15would not show the murder, right?
- 43:17Right. And you're saying that Hitchcock
- 43:19would show the murder? Oh yeah, I'm just trying to make
- 43:24sure that your your brains fully.
- 43:27Functioning. Yeah, man.
- 43:29Because at the end of the day, you know that you're going to be
- 43:31wrong. That's true.
- 43:32And it's going to be #1 because you dismissed it immediately.
- 43:37Oh, you're right. So wait, #3.
- 43:40You said that Hitchcock had assured the screenwriter that he
- 43:44would not show the murder, that he would not show the opening
- 43:48murder. All right, fine.
- 43:50Then I'm going to say 3 is the falsehood.
- 43:52Are Are you sure? I'm not sure because #2 sounds
- 43:55false too. I think they're both false.
- 43:56That's what I'm going to go with.
- 43:58That's what it is. I'm going to parlay this into
- 44:00two and three, both hitting on falsehood.
- 44:04Double or nothing, baby. So.
- 44:06So 3 is your answer. Three is my answer, Brad.
- 44:08OK, you're wrong. It was 2.
- 44:10God. Bless you.
- 44:10Why did you do that to me? No, you tricky jerk.
- 44:20See, here's the thing though, when you said it, I was like, in
- 44:24my brain. I was like, wait, the logic Bob
- 44:26just used would actually make #3 the falsehood?
- 44:31So wait, he Hitchcock actually did tell the guy I'm not going
- 44:34to show the murder and then did it anyway?
- 44:36Yep. Good for him, man.
- 44:38That was the right choice. Oh, it totally was the right
- 44:41choice, I. Can't believe it.
- 44:42I should have known that you would have stopped me in my
- 44:45tracks when I was about to pull out the victory.
- 44:49You you are one loss closer to not making it to 500.
- 44:55Dude, that was some John doll. Ubermensch trickiness.
- 45:00Right there. I don't like I I am your
- 45:02ubermensch, Bob. All right, Brad, let's get back
- 45:05into talking about the movie. And to talk about the movie, we
- 45:08kind of have to talk about the play a little bit more.
- 45:11The play was similar to like when you see a Law and Order
- 45:15episode and they always advertise it as ripped from the
- 45:18headlines and it's very clear that they did like a real life
- 45:21thing. This was based on perhaps the
- 45:23most famous crime outside of the Lindbergh baby of the early part
- 45:28of the 20th century, which was the murder of a young boy by
- 45:32Leopold and Loeb. It was a hugely famous court
- 45:35case, especially because Clarence Darrow was one of the
- 45:38attorneys for the defense. And they were they were lovers
- 45:43who were college students who had become convinced by this
- 45:46Nietzschean philosophy of the Ubermensch.
- 45:49That they were above morality and could then plan the perfect
- 45:53murder. And not only that, but were
- 45:55justified in murdering this 14 year old boy.
- 45:59Obviously everything went to crap and they got caught and
- 46:03justice was served. In that case, can we just like,
- 46:08like, I know Jimmy Stewart gives the whole speech, but Can you
- 46:12imagine being so full of yourself that you're like, hey,
- 46:18you know that Bob book guy, he just is an inferior human being
- 46:22and I'm so far above him, you know that I should be able to
- 46:27murder him with impunity. I I.
- 46:30Love that given the option to just construct A hypothetical
- 46:34person, you still choose to use me as an example of guy who
- 46:38deserves to be murdered. Yeah, I mean, I'm just.
- 46:42I'm just working out my innermost thoughts here on the
- 46:45podcast. Clearly.
- 46:47Well, one of the things I really love about the script in this
- 46:49movie, Brad, before it tips into this moralizing ending, is that
- 46:54when they try to explain to a rational person what is an
- 46:58ubermensch, how do you even know if you are one?
- 47:01There is like, he's just like, what do you mean if you, if you
- 47:04are one, you would know and I guess you're not one.
- 47:06Yep, you know, and I love that it.
- 47:08It highlights the absurdity of niete and philosophy from the
- 47:13getgo. And it doesn't.
- 47:15The the great thing about the first half of the movie is that
- 47:18it doesn't beat the, you know, beat you over the head with it.
- 47:21It's like you watch Brandon struggle to articulate it in
- 47:25real time and then you understand, oh, this guy
- 47:29actually has no idea what he's talking about.
- 47:31Yeah, well, and it's, it's always been philosophy and a
- 47:35thought experiment to him. And one of the the acting
- 47:39moments that I love the most in this movie is immediately after
- 47:44they murder their friend, like Brandon comes close to breaking
- 47:49down. And like that moment right at
- 47:52the start of the movie sets you up for everything else where
- 47:55you've seen that he's not actually fully in on this.
- 48:00And it plays off then the rest of the movie, as he's not trying
- 48:03to convince everyone else that he is, you know, not morally
- 48:08bound by any law. He's trying to convince himself.
- 48:12And I think that ties the entire movie together for me.
- 48:16Like, if Brandon right after killing him, was just kind of
- 48:19like, well, I'm glad I'm done with that.
- 48:21On to dinner. It it would not have played as
- 48:25well. But because there's this
- 48:26internal struggle, even for Brandon, who is so full of just
- 48:31BS, you realize that he's trying to convince himself.
- 48:36One of the things that. I think Hitchcock has a lot of
- 48:38fun with in this movie is trying to get around the censors of
- 48:421948 to show very obviously that the two main characters are gay.
- 48:47Like they live together, They're very eligible bachelors, they're
- 48:50very dapper. It's like all of the
- 48:52stereotypical things that you would expect of them.
- 48:55But then it's also like, you know, they even have like the
- 48:57gay friend trying to set up as girlfriend. 100%, yeah.
- 49:01Like. But then also there's the little
- 49:03things that he does where it's like, oh, how did you actually
- 49:06get away with that? You know, to your point, right.
- 49:09When they murder the guy at the beginning, it's like a very
- 49:12obvious metaphor for them, like having a homosexual
- 49:17relationship. Like Brandon lets out a a moan
- 49:20and and kind of goes and then and then you watch him light a
- 49:24cigarette. Like it's it's very clearly a
- 49:26picture of like post coital stuff going on.
- 49:30And one of the most interesting ways to think about this movie
- 49:33is like you could read this whole movie as a metaphor for
- 49:37these two guys being gay in 1948 and the body being them, you
- 49:41know, trapped in the closet and people finding out about it.
- 49:44And like, it's an, I mean, I'm not saying that's the way to
- 49:46read the movie, It's just an interesting way to think about
- 49:50it. And to also think about like how
- 49:52Hitchcock could portray those two characters because Leopold
- 49:55and Loeb publicly admitted after they got caught that they were
- 49:59in a homosexual relationship. So it's like it is an integral
- 50:03part of the story that he had to find creative ways to
- 50:07demonstrate. So what I hear you saying is
- 50:10that you, Bob book, are saying that all gay men consider
- 50:15themselves above any moral authority and consider
- 50:19themselves ubermensch. That that's what I hear you
- 50:22saying. I am not going to touch that one
- 50:24at all. Let's let's keep going here,
- 50:27man. All right, man.
- 50:29I think maybe it's time for us to get to our final segment of
- 50:32the day, which we call, let's make it a double.
- 50:36Near the end of the episode. So thanks listening to the film
- 50:39and whiskey show. Let's ever know the film with
- 50:42this one, even if it's struggling.
- 50:43It's a final segment of the day. Now let's make it a double.
- 50:46Let's Make it a double is the part of the podcast where we
- 50:49pick a second movie to pair up with this one to make the
- 50:52perfect double feature. Brad, I had a lot of movies
- 50:56actually popping into my head as I watched this, you know?
- 50:58And I I mentioned earlier that there's not really much sound or
- 51:02much music in this movie. And the kind of haunting ending
- 51:06where you just hear sirens approaching.
- 51:08It reminded me a lot of the end of West Side Story, like after
- 51:11Tony gets shot and the music kind of drains out.
- 51:14So I was like, oh, maybe West Side Story.
- 51:16I thought a lot about morally Gray endings, and it reminded me
- 51:20of Gone Baby Gone. The way we talked about the
- 51:23ending of that movie. I was thinking about that too.
- 51:26I think I'm going to come down on another Ben Affleck movie,
- 51:29though, and it's. One of the most disturbing
- 51:32movies I've ever seen, David Fincher's Gone Girl.
- 51:35A movie that is all about public perception in a missing persons
- 51:41case and twisted games that are being played with murder as the
- 51:45result. It is like the more I think
- 51:48about it, the more I realize Gone Girl is kind of David
- 51:50Fincher's rope. I think Rope is a much more fun
- 51:53movie, and I want to revisit it way more than I want to revisit
- 51:56Gone Girl, which is just deeply disturbing to me.
- 52:00But I I think if you are predisposed to like these kind
- 52:04of movies you could do a lot worse than Gone Girl and Rope.
- 52:08I have two movies that are on my brain.
- 52:11The first one I'll I'll just this is your bonus extra one
- 52:15that you don't have to go watch. I think Clue would be a funny
- 52:17watch with this, that it's a murder mystery stage, obviously
- 52:23stage performance, that it's just one of the funniest movies
- 52:26and you need to watch it. You know what?
- 52:28You've mentioned Clue. Like 2.
- 52:31Yep, two out of the last three weeks, I think.
- 52:33I have never seen clue no. Never seen it bro.
- 52:39When we do another like I get to pick 15 movie season I I might
- 52:44put clue on there just so you have to watch it that.
- 52:46Sounds fun, man. I've always wanted to, yeah.
- 52:49It's it's a it is the definition of camp.
- 52:54Love it, to say the least. The film I'm actually going to
- 52:57push us towards is another film where you have a mentor who
- 53:04pushes past moral and ethical boundaries to see where it takes
- 53:10him and where it takes his students.
- 53:12I think I'm going to pair this with Whiplash.
- 53:15Oh, that's a good one. I don't even like think about
- 53:19that. That's a great pick, man.
- 53:21I think Whiplash ends in a much better place, and yet still a
- 53:25morally great place in the sense that, like, whiplash is like a
- 53:30journey of ascent because of pressure and a certain type of
- 53:34philosophy. Rope is about a journey of
- 53:37descent towards, like, moral depravity.
- 53:40Oh, interesting. And so I I think that they both
- 53:42have interesting ways they could play off of each other.
- 53:45But more people need to see Whiplash, so go watch Whiplash.
- 53:48Oh yeah. I actually think that both of
- 53:50them are journeys into descent. It's just that not everyone dies
- 53:53at the end of one of them. That's that's true.
- 53:57I guess that I guess the the journey of Ascent for Whiplash
- 54:01is more about how much are you willing to descend in order to
- 54:06ascend to greatness. Does that make sense?
- 54:09How? Much of your humanity can you
- 54:10lose? Will you sacrifice?
- 54:13All right man. So those are our our picks, Gone
- 54:15Girl and Whiplash, which might have come out the same calendar
- 54:19year or maybe one year apart, but we went ultra modern with
- 54:23our let's make it a double, which I really, really love and
- 54:27I think that bodes well for our final scores.
- 54:29This is a movie that holds up extraordinarily well for a 75
- 54:34year old film. I feel like we can talk about it
- 54:36in much more modern terms. I hate to say modern, but you
- 54:39know what I mean? Like.
- 54:40We can. We can put a more contemporary
- 54:42lens on this movie, and just the fact that we can do that, I
- 54:46think indicates how well made this film is.
- 54:49I truly hate Jimmy Stewart's speech at the end of this movie,
- 54:54and as I was sitting in this theater having one of the best
- 54:57theatrical experiences I've had in years, thinking to myself,
- 55:01this is a 10 out of 10. That speech alone made me want
- 55:05to lower this movie to a 9.5. I'm not going to do it because I
- 55:09still think that functionally this is a perfectly built
- 55:13machine of a movie. It's a 10 out of 10 for me,
- 55:16Brad, As I think about like what we're going to do at the end of
- 55:19the season when we're listing our favorites, this is going to
- 55:22be a tough movie to beat. It's like the little movie that
- 55:24could for me, and it's a 10 out of 10 for me and I guess to
- 55:29defend where you're at at a 10 out of 10.
- 55:32I think that while his speech is terrible, the final like two or
- 55:36three minutes after the speech is also incredible.
- 55:40Like he shoots the gun to get people's attention and then they
- 55:43just sit there, all of them kind of feeling defeated.
- 55:47And you have like, you know, once again you have Phillip in
- 55:50the background kind of off to the left.
- 55:53You have Jimmy Stewart in the foreground and then Brandon kind
- 55:56of medium. But they're all like laid out
- 55:59sequentially and it just it's just great blocking for me at
- 56:04the overall. Watching this film, I
- 56:07appreciated it. I had fun with certain parts.
- 56:10The script was a little overbearing.
- 56:13It felt a little too clever for itself.
- 56:15At moments. I I liked Brandon, but he just
- 56:19came across so schmoozy and pretentious and that I I
- 56:24struggled to appreciate even what he was trying to do.
- 56:30Overall, I really love this movie.
- 56:31I think it's incredibly well made.
- 56:33I'm at an 8 1/2 out of 10 Bob. 8.5 Brad Come on man.
- 56:40Final question. How much do you think Billy Zane
- 56:43based his Titanic performance on Brandon in this movie?
- 56:47That's an incredible question. And I think that it it has to be
- 56:53like I'm trying to think of any other movie with a more schmoozy
- 56:57condescending but. Just a just a true slimeball.
- 57:00I love it, man. Yeah, it's so good.
- 57:01No, 100%. All right, so those are our
- 57:04scores on Rope. I would love to know what you
- 57:07think. Film and Whiskey Nation.
- 57:09Go watch this 80 minute movie. Like yeah, please, Seriously,
- 57:13please, please. If you've never watched any
- 57:15movie we've recommended you to, you can.
- 57:18You can stop your YouTube scrolling for 80 minutes and
- 57:22watch this movie. And then you can let us know
- 57:24what you think of it by finding us on all of our social medias
- 57:27Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, TikTok or YouTube at Film,
- 57:32Whiskey. And look at us just adding,
- 57:35adding names to that list. Bob, when are you going to throw
- 57:38threads in there? We have a threads account I have
- 57:40posted. No we won one time months ago.
- 57:46Threads really shook up the world.
- 57:48More like thread. Oh man.
- 57:53Well, when you're done sending us a thread, join us on Discord,
- 57:57where we're actually talking about movies in Whiskey.
- 58:01You can find a link to our Discord at the end of every one
- 58:04of our show notes. And I have to say, Bob, we know
- 58:06that the stats on on our episodes are that most people
- 58:09stop listening, like the moment we give our scores.
- 58:13So let this be an example. If you're still listening, we
- 58:16can still be funny even when we're talking about our
- 58:20Instagram and and Threads page. We're so funny that I would dare
- 58:24to call us morally superior to everyone else.
- 58:27Brad I Bob, I've been thinking it.
- 58:30I'm glad you. I'm glad.
- 58:32I'm glad you finally said it. Well, Speaking of movies where a
- 58:35character thinks they are morally superior and that
- 58:37everyone else sucks, we're pivoting to one of Hitchcock's
- 58:40most famous films where there's a The main character is morally
- 58:44superior to everyone. That's what I'm saying.
- 58:46Yeah, exactly. Yeah, 1940, three's shadow of a
- 58:49doubt. So we'll see you next week for
- 58:51that thriller. But until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 58:55I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.