Latest / Worderella Reads with Belinda Kroll / 16 | I will totally DNF a book with no yearning, let me tell you why
Transcript
- Hi, I'm Belinda, and this is Worderella Reads, where gentle magic, Jane Austen banter, and all the swoons control our TBR piles.
- Please enjoy these episodes in any order.
- I'm so glad you're here today Hey, kindred spirits This month, I wanna chat with you about a book that I actually did not finish reading, and I think it's gonna be a great example for why I can handle books with no spice, but I cannot handle books without yearning.
- It's an immediate DNF.
- If you wanna know why, great question.
- I'm about to tell you.
- So as an example, there is a book, I think it was written about 2013.
- It's called The Thinking Woman's Guide to Real Magic by Emily Cary Barker, and on paper, this book was made for me.
- Okay? It's about a grad student whose boyfriend just left her.
- She stumbles through a portal into a fantasy world and ends up as this, you know, reluctant student of a reclusive magician with a biting tongue and a tragic past.
- Supposedly, he killed his wife.
- She's stuck-- The-- Our, our heroine is stuck in the world, in his world with no way home, and this has a lot of possibility for yearning, right? And I know exactly what it's supposed to be because Nora, the heroine, walks into this fantasy world literally carrying a copy of Pride and Prejudice.
- The heroine of this book is holding the instruction manual for yearning.
- And I'm ashamed to say, I DNF'd it at the halfway point.
- The writing itself was great.
- The world-building, fantastic.
- I think some of this was actually, it was a victim of marketing, because I went back through some reviews to try to find a passage to read to you today.
- You know, like, what is, like, the moment? What is the almost touch? You know, the glance that was held just, like, a beat too long.
- And there really wasn't one.
- Reviewer after reviewer basically all said the same thing.
- Lots of talk about attraction, but nothing really about building l- like, love.
- So the characters, they fell for each other, but then they don't do anything about it for,, five hundred and sixty-three pages.
- And then the book just ends, without finishing that thread.
- I'm not even sure I would call it a romantic subplot.
- So there's nothing to read to you today, and that's exactly why we're here.
- So real quick, because I think this conflation is actually causing a lot of bad takes, spice and yearning are not the same thing.
- I know I've seen on BookTok and Instagram or Bookstagram, the yearning hero.
- And I think that is...
- The yearning hero is a different thing altogether from whether the book has spice or not.
- So, like, spice is a heat rating, right? How explicit does the book get? Is the door open or closed, or has the door been thrown into the ocean? When it comes to how much we read on the page regarding Physical interactions between the characters.
- Yearning is purely emotional.
- It's the emotional want.
- It's that, that want of something that hasn't been fulfilled yet.
- So it's this emotional anticipation and hope, and it's, is often, at least in the books that I read, it's often between two people, and it's like this gap between them and the distance that's caused between them because of that gap.
- So a book could be like scorching 500,000 peppers hot and have zero yearning A book could be completely innocent, the most they do is hold hands, but could destroy you.
- For instance, I write low spice historical romantasy, and people sometimes ask whether I've ever considered writing something with more heat.
- And the o- the, really, I think the answer is, like, the spice has never been the point for me.
- The yearning has always been the point.
- I am s- fascinated by the emotional connection that happens.
- Like, how is it that two people who were strangers five minutes ago, five days ago, five months ago, five years ago, did not know each other existed.
- And through the course of bumping into each other repeatedly, through their routines of work and home life, through new responsibilities, through moving cities, whatever it was that brought them together, it's interesting that to me how, I think sometimes I write these romance books because a part of real-life romance really still puzzles me, even though I am, married, I'm surrounded by people who are in relationships.
- There's this part of my brain that's kind of like, "Yeah, but how did it happen? Like, what were the steps?" And romance books, in a way, are like an academic study on all the different ways in which humans find each other and decide to stay with each other, and why, and what does that journey feel like.
- So why does yearning matter so much? Okay, here's my best attempt.
- Okay.
- So yearning, creates this gap.
- The gap is actually where the reader lives.
- So two characters want each other.
- They can't have each other.
- That space between them becomes charged, like, with emotional tension, romantic tension, oh, will, will he? Won't he? Am I just imagining things or not? And then the reader gets to move into that space and stay there, sometimes for, hundreds of pages, although most of my, most of the books I read it's not quite that long.
- Because sometimes the journey to getting there, to becoming the couple or whatever the happily ever after or the happily for now looks like for that story, is sometimes honestly more interesting than the, "Oh, we finally got together."
- This, I feel like this is something that American television struggles with a lot.
- We have all of these Great TV shows where, there's that tension between, the detective and the fiction crime writer author who keeps solving crimes for her.
- And so we love the banter, we love the, her in- incredulity that he knows these things and keeps surprising her with his intellect and she saves him from danger.
- And so they keep having this back and forth, all the while building this bond, but they can't have each other, right? So because I think then what happens is, with American TV, is as soon as the couple gets together, it's like the writers are like, "Wait, what? So what do we do now? They're together now."
- Like as if that's the end.
- Whereas, in a Korean drama, and I actually chat about this a bit with, Sarah Rosette over on How I Met My K-Drama.
- I was a guest over there, and we chatted about the fact that, Korean dramas, not only are they low spice, we get excited when the couples, holds hands or, their fingers graze each other's for the first time.
- But then also, in a 16-episode miniseries, the couple gets together usually around episode seven or eight, and then we're watching all the dynamics of what is the impact of them choosing to be together.
- How does this impact their friends, their friend group, their friendships? How does it impact their families? What is the socioeconomic, influence on their relationship? What are the societal constraints that basically continues to challenge that relationship? So the tension is still there, but now the tension has become external.
- We moved away from this yearning of, "I don't know if they like me the way I like them."
- To, oh, now I've confirmed that they like me, and it's reciprocal, but do they like me enough to s- to overcome XYZ external challenge? So I think I love those stories.
- I'm actually trying to build more of those stories into my books of having a longer denouement after the couple gets together, and that's something I'm doing in my current book that I'm editing.
- And we'll talk a little bit more about that in a second.
- But I think that's the thing, right, is, if you think about your favorite romance moment, the one that lives, rent-free in your head, I bet it's not the, resolution or consummation or anything like that.
- It's the almost, the mo- moment where it could have happened, but it didn't.
- We almost got a kiss, but then someone bounced into the room.
- We almost got a great banter back and forth, but then, an emergency happens, right? Something could have happened, and it didn't, or one character realizes the other one matters and then immediately does something, really stupid about it you know? They start making poor choices because maybe they're freaking out because this is not what they thought, th- how they thought things were gonna go.
- So on page, this could be, like, a glance that's held a beat too long, and then neither character acknowledges it.
- It could be, avoiding someone in a way which then, for the reader automatically proves that you're, like, constantly thinking about them.
- Doing something unprompted, like remembering how they take their tea or, what their favorite, what their favorite color is, and so they're stuck in a cabin, and they grab the blanket that's their favorite color, right? Those little details, the little things that should be mundane, but because it's these two people and the tension between them, that, that attention to detail is actually speaking more than if we had said, "Girl likes guy, guy likes girl."
- I've been trying to figure out, what is it? Like, why do books struggle with yearning? I actually think most DNFs are probably a yearning problem in disguise.
- Insta love doesn't have insta love has no obstacle, right? And if you're looking for insta love, that's awesome.
- That's not what this is about.
- This is for the reader who is looking for some form of tension that stretches out the will they, won't they, and makes it emotionally satisfying when they do get together.
- So in insta love that has no obstacle, the characters meet, they connect, they act on it immediately, and ba-ta-da, that's it.
- Nothing standing in the way.
- Which is different from insta attraction.
- Like, oh no, this is a problem because now the want and the gap is already there.
- Insta love kills that yearning, because there's nothing between the want and the having.
- Whereas insta attraction can actually bring two, can make real, obstacles that we, that this character maybe has these are rules the character has lived by their entire life.
- And now all of a sudden they're attracted to someone who flouts every rule they ever lived by.
- Insta attraction is great.
- Something else that I think can really mess up yearning is when we're told feelings.
- They're over explained.
- The character is unreasonably articulate about what they want and why as if they're picking from a menu.
- It seems like depth, and I can see why it would've been written maybe for a first draft.
- But it removes all the subtext, and the subtext is where the yearning lives.
- And the subtext is where the reader gets to do their imaginative work.
- And if you remove all the subtext, it's kind of like, well, what's left for the reader to bring to the story? And I think the last thing it would be, like, a rushed timeline, right? Yearning requires marination.
- You can't build real ache across two chapters, right? The reader needs to be able to watch characters orbit each other.
- They pull away.
- They start to circle each other a little bit closer.
- That takes multiple chapters.
- For some series it takes multiple books.
- That's usually for, a fantasy series where the romance is the subplot.
- For romance books, we tend to have the whole romantic arc within the single book.
- But yeah, if you rush it, then you're not the story isn't meant to be a microwave, it's meant to be an oven.
- So I think the thing that killed The Thinking Woman's Guide for me is honestly the, a passive protagonist.
- Yearning requires someone who wants something.
- It can't just be something that's not...
- It can't be just about someone who has things happen to them.
- So as a reader, you can't yearn on behalf of the character.
- If the character isn't reaching for anything, then there's nothing to empathize or in their yearning for.
- And the gap can't exist if one half isn't straining and reaching for the other side.
- So those are just a couple of the reasons why I think if you don't do yearning right, it could be because of insta-love without an obstacle, it could be over-explained feelings, it could be a rushed timeline, it could be a passive protagonist.
- And I don't know, think about your last DNF.
- Was it one of those? Was it all four? So you know, take it for what you will.
- What are some examples of books that do this well, like durning, do yearning well? I think mine would be Sorcery of Thorns by Margaret Rogerson.
- So the yearning lives in the competence.
- One character watches the other be genuinely good at something they love, and then that's where it starts.
- So it's not like this dramatic event.
- It just starts to accumulate.
- If you're thinking about a movie, Just Like Heaven, same thing, right? We have one, and of course I reference a movie with a ghost in it.
- But they fall for each other because they both have lost something.
- And they're both trying to find themselves again.
- And in the process of trying to find each other, they are realizing they're seeing, the potential in this other person because the person across the table from them is reminding them of their own potential.
- And but then the thing that's keeping them apart, the external obstacle, is one of them's a ghost.
- But again, it's, it's-- so then we're building, we're yearning.
- We're trying to figure out, how are they gonna make this happen? How are they going to get together? That curiosity, that question, that's the reader yearning to figure out, what-- how does this end? So that's something to consider.
- Persuasion by Jane Austen, yearning one oh one.
- Prior to the book start, Frederick and Anne are in love.
- Her family tells her to break it off.
- She's a good daughter, so she does, and then spends eight years regretting that decision while he goes off and builds his fortune, mostly out of spite comes back.
- Now is this person that everyone's trying to marry their daughter off to, but he can't stop finding Anne in the room.
- He can't help but help her quietly in moments, and she's noticing.
- She thinks it's pity, and it takes a good while to realize, does he still care? Does he still care? Is there still a chance? So persuasion is an excellent example of yearning.
- And then, I know, I'm gonna-- I'm biased for this last one because I wrote it, I'm writing it, actually.
- But, An Uncanny Bargain in book three of The Hesitant Medium series, I actually wrote this specifically because I wanted it to be a book that I wanted to read, but I couldn't find.
- The gist of it is we have our heroine, Edith.
- She's very bad at believing that anyone would choose to stay or see her value.
- And Drew is not the sort of person who leaves.
- He's also half ghost, so he can't leave.
- But that's beside the point.
- If he were one hundred percent living, he wouldn't leave.
- And this is where all the yearning lives in the story.
- So I wanna hear yours.
- I wanna hear a book or a scene or a line that you still think about.
- Reply to my newsletter, or send me a message.
- There may be a follow episode about some of the best yearning scenes you guys send me.
- At the end of the day, yearning is that gap.
- It's a big part of why the ending hits well, and why you're still thinking about that particular chapter, like, three months later.
- So you can write romance without spice, but I don't think you can write romance without yearning, i.e.
- wanting, and have it mean anything.
- For me, I feel like the engine-- that it is the engine, and it has to be there, and everything else is negotiable.
- So those are my thoughts.
- If this episode made you want to feel things in the best way, come find me at wordorella.com.
- You can join my monthly newsletter, Belinda's Broadsheet.
- You can get a free e-book when you sign up, and you'll get to see things mostly about books and sweet ghosts and slow burns.
- And, thanks again for joining.
- I hope you had fun with this episode, and I hope you go find some sort of media, whether it's an e-book, audiobook, print book, K-drama, movie, whatever your media of choice is, go find something that makes you suffer in a good way.
- The one that kind of makes you kick your toes and giggle.
- I hope you can find that.
- I'll chat with you next month.
- Have a great day Wordarella Reads is brought to you by wordarella.com.
- That's Cinderella, but with words.
- Thank you for listening today.
- You can find backlist episodes at wordarella.com/podcast.
- You can get your free cozy fantasy e-book at wordarella.com/news.
- And if you'd like to connect, you can find me on Instagram at Wordarella.
- However you're listening and whenever you're listening, I'm glad you spent time with me.
- I'll see you in the next episode.
- Happy reading