Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Real Property Decisions in Trust and Estate Administration
Transcript
- 0:03The Real Property Decisions in Trust and Estate
- 0:06Administration. We are thrilled to have you join
- 0:09us today. My name is Jennifer McNeil -Ozano,
- 0:12and I'm the co -chair of the BHBA's Trust and
- 0:14Estate section. Before we begin, I'd like to
- 0:17take a moment to introduce Brian Joy of the Sanborn
- 0:19team. The Sanborn team have been the official
- 0:22sponsor of this section since 2006. That's 20
- 0:26years. Brian, say hello. Thank you so much, Jennifer.
- 0:29I just want to give everyone a quick reminder
- 0:31about probate sales and that as is doesn't mean
- 0:35don't disclose. In a probate sale, there are
- 0:38exemptions from certain statutory disclosure
- 0:40forms, but that does not eliminate the obligation
- 0:44to disclose known material facts about the property.
- 0:47We see it come up all the time, water intrusion,
- 0:50unpermitted work, fire damage. insurance claims,
- 0:54occupant issues, or something the fiduciary learns
- 0:56about during the administration. Our advice is
- 1:00simple. If you know something material about
- 1:02the property, disclose it. As is addresses the
- 1:05condition in which the buyer is purchasing the
- 1:08property. It's not a shield against disclosure.
- 1:11That's my little tidbit for the day. Enjoy the
- 1:14meeting, everyone. Thanks, Brian. In addition
- 1:18to the Sanborn team, the Trust in a State section
- 1:20is also sponsored by Bond Services of California,
- 1:25Liberty Mutual Surety, California Title Company,
- 1:29and Pickford Escrow Company. Now I'd like to
- 1:33turn things over to Laura Zolnikoff for legal
- 1:36updates. Thank you, Jennifer. This month I'm
- 1:40going to talk about Assembly Bill 2658, which
- 1:43is currently pending before the Assembly Judiciary
- 1:46Committee. AB 2658 addresses an important uncertainty
- 1:51in California community property and estate planning
- 1:54law. If enacted, it would clarify that either
- 1:57spouse may transfer their one half interest in
- 2:00community property into a trust for disposition
- 2:03at their death without requiring the other spouse's
- 2:06consent. Now, this would not change its community
- 2:09property character unless both spouses agree.
- 2:12For estate planners, this is particularly significant
- 2:15in blended families and second marriages where
- 2:17spouses may want their respective halves to pass
- 2:20to different beneficiaries while still preserving
- 2:23the community property treatment, including the
- 2:26potential double step up in basis at death. Now
- 2:29I'll turn it over to Jordan Parr. Thanks, Laura.
- 2:33Now on to the program. I'm delighted to introduce
- 2:36today's speaker, Mark Cianciulli. Mark is a real
- 2:39estate broker, attorney, and CPA and the founder
- 2:42of CREM Group. He specializes in helping fiduciaries
- 2:45and attorneys evaluate, manage, and sell real
- 2:48estate involved in probate, trusts, conservatorships,
- 2:51and other administrations, particularly when
- 2:54the property is high value, complex, or contested.
- 2:57Drawing on his legal, financial, and real estate
- 3:00background, Mark advises fiduciaries and counsel
- 3:03on property strategy. valuation, occupancy, risk,
- 3:07and disposition. Mark serves or has served on
- 3:10the boards of the Beverly Hills and San Fernando
- 3:12Valley estate planning councils and is active
- 3:15in several regional bar associations and professional
- 3:18organizations. Now please welcome Mark Cianciulli.
- 3:24Thanks for having me everyone. Happy Friday.
- 3:29I am going to pull up our first slide and we'll
- 3:32get going. All right. So today's presentation
- 3:45is based on a framework that my team and I have
- 3:50developed for real estate when it's part of the
- 3:52legal administration. For our purposes today,
- 3:56you know, legal administration, of course, needs
- 3:58probate, trust administration, conservatorships,
- 4:00but really the same approach applies to several
- 4:04other types of legal administrations as well.
- 4:08About 10 years ago, I started a real estate brokerage
- 4:12and property management platform focused specifically
- 4:16on administration related real estate. And initially,
- 4:22I thought our job was to become very good handling
- 4:25sales and management. And over time, I started
- 4:31to look at it a little differently, as it became
- 4:34clear that many of the significant real estate
- 4:37related decisions were happening before it's
- 4:41even time to prepare a property for sale or begin
- 4:44managing it. And that led to the approach that
- 4:48I'm going to discuss throughout the presentation,
- 4:50which centers around the concept, you know, when
- 4:54real estate is part of a trust or a state administration.
- 4:59The real estate strategy shouldn't be developed
- 5:02in a vacuum. It should be informed and shaped.
- 5:06by the administration around it. And before we
- 5:10get into that, very quickly, a little bit about
- 5:13me. I know you just heard a little bit, but I
- 5:16always appreciate hearing something other than
- 5:19the typical bio about people. And so on the personal
- 5:27side, I've been married for almost 12 years.
- 5:31My wife and I have three kids at home. nine -year
- 5:34-old boy and two girls, five and three. We live
- 5:38in Sherman Oaks. To be candid and in the light
- 5:43of full transparency, it's fair to say that I
- 5:45occasionally exercise some questionable judgment,
- 5:49which could be best illustrated by my decision
- 5:53to do a family trip to Italy for two weeks this
- 5:56summer, which of course had, you know, elements
- 6:00of fun, but it was mostly an exercise in focus,
- 6:05resilience and emotional resolve. One fun fact,
- 6:12I played college football for Jim Harbaugh, who
- 6:15is now the head coach of the LA Chargers and
- 6:18generally one of the bigger personalities as
- 6:20far as NFL head coaches go. And his personality
- 6:24was no different 20 plus years ago. Professionally,
- 6:29as you've already heard, former practicing attorney
- 6:32in CBA founded CREM, again, specifically to focus
- 6:36on real estate connected to legal administrations.
- 6:39And I just, you know, genuinely enjoy working
- 6:43in this space because of the people I get to
- 6:46work with, the work I get to do, and because
- 6:49of the questions. challenges and opportunities
- 6:54that we encounter are very interesting to me.
- 6:58So yeah, with that background, I guess I want
- 7:01to be clear on what today's presentation is and
- 7:04isn't. It's not a presentation on how to sell
- 7:08probate real estate. It is a practical framework
- 7:11for making better real estate decisions in the
- 7:14context of an administration. And I think a good
- 7:18place to start is with the question that I probably
- 7:22hear most. So one of the questions I'm typically
- 7:27asked most frequently at the beginning of a potential
- 7:33engagement is some version of, what should we
- 7:37do with the property? Should we sell it, distribute
- 7:40it, keep it, lease it? And if we keep it, keep
- 7:45it for the short term, keep it for the long term.
- 7:48If we sell, Should we improve it first? Should
- 7:51we sell it as is? And sometimes the answer to
- 7:55those questions seems relatively obvious, but
- 7:59often before landing on a decision, there are
- 8:04several considerations worth working through.
- 8:08So what should inform those decisions? I always
- 8:13start with the administration. As we all know,
- 8:20Fiduciaries or personal representatives in general
- 8:23are expected to act with reasonable care and
- 8:26diligence and make decisions in context. What
- 8:30does that standard look like when applying it
- 8:32to real estate? I think it means the objectives,
- 8:38the limitations, the circumstances of the administration
- 8:40should necessitate or drive the real estate strategy.
- 8:48administration needs liquidity, the real estate
- 8:53strategy is likely gonna be driven by that fact.
- 8:57If there's conflict or litigation that will of
- 9:00course play a significant role, if there's timing
- 9:02pressure, that's gonna guide the strategy. So,
- 9:06you know, as I kind of state in the screen, Hypothetically,
- 9:11we could have the exact same property in two
- 9:13different administrations and reasonably arrive
- 9:16at two different strategies based on what's going
- 9:19on with either of them. And so I'm always happy
- 9:24to dig into a property for someone that needs
- 9:28evaluation or some more broad or involved assessment
- 9:35and opine on options for the property or properties.
- 9:39I really prefer to get as much background information
- 9:42on what's going on with the administration as
- 9:44possible, because I can provide more useful advice
- 9:50when I have that. I certainly don't want to offend
- 9:53anyone, because we're all moving at a pretty
- 9:58quick pace throughout any given day, but it's
- 10:01really tough to give good advice when I get an
- 10:03email that says, hey, here's the address, what
- 10:06do you think? And yet, and I'm probably guilty
- 10:11of sending plenty of those types of emails out
- 10:14in a given week. But yeah, the more context,
- 10:18the better. So, you know, once we understand
- 10:21the administration, how do we actually work through
- 10:24the decision process? That's what I want to look
- 10:26at next. Essentially, there's three disciplines
- 10:31that are running through the rest of this presentation.
- 10:36The first one, judgment. Lots and lots of judgment
- 10:39calls regarding what actually matters and what
- 10:42doesn't. Foresight. Trying to best ascertain
- 10:50how today's decisions affect what happens next.
- 10:57Number three, what has to happen for the strategy
- 11:01to work. And I don't like to talk in the abstract.
- 11:05for too long. So I came with some examples that
- 11:12I think illustrate this best. So in our first
- 11:17example, we have a single family residence with
- 11:22an observable retaining wall condition along
- 11:27the boundary line of the neighboring property.
- 11:31So imagine subject properties on a hillside,
- 11:35boundary line across the back. It is raised so
- 11:40the neighbor sits higher and you have this retaining
- 11:43wall sitting there. And we don't know yet the
- 11:48extent of the problem. What are the costs to
- 11:51address? And in this fact pattern, the neighbor
- 11:55has not been particularly cooperative, but we
- 11:59do know that there's good law to support that
- 12:02the neighbor would share financially. for the
- 12:05cost to fix or rebuild the wall. So what do we
- 12:09do? What would you want to understand first?
- 12:14And I'll try to keep an eye on chat, because
- 12:18I always try to make it as interactive as possible.
- 12:22And it is tough when we have to do it during
- 12:24chat. But if this were me, I would first want
- 12:28to know, to the best I could, what's going on
- 12:31with the wall? What is causing the issues that
- 12:35you're seeing. Can it be repaired or does it
- 12:39have to be replaced? How urgent is the condition?
- 12:47Who do I think should be responsible for the
- 12:49cost? Does remitting a situation require access
- 12:54to the neighbor's property? And then how does
- 12:59the condition affect the subject property? And
- 13:04just to be clear, the point here isn't that we
- 13:07go looking for every hypothetical problem just
- 13:11because a property is old or has issues. But
- 13:16that's different from a situation like this example
- 13:20where a potentially material condition is already
- 13:24visible or partially visible. If perspective
- 13:29buyers are gonna see the same thing, then leaving
- 13:34the condition undefined may not protect value,
- 13:40as it will leave the market essentially to price
- 13:42that uncertainty. And granted, that sometimes
- 13:46absolutely is the better decision, but it does
- 13:49lead to an important distinction that investigation
- 13:53and remediation, choosing to take action to fix
- 13:58or replace or separate decisions. And so targeted
- 14:04diligence does not mean that personal representative
- 14:08has decided to fix the wall in this case, if
- 14:12they find that there's good reason to learn more
- 14:16about it. The purpose really here is to simply
- 14:20understand the condition well enough to quantify
- 14:24the condition and then be able to compare realistic
- 14:28alternatives. Again, I'm not saying this is always
- 14:32the right answer, but sometimes it is the prudent
- 14:34decision. And so why might developing some additional
- 14:41information be good for an estate? Mainly because
- 14:47the market does not give the seller the benefit
- 14:51of the doubt when the uncertainty is material.
- 14:55If I can see the wall deteriorating, but nobody
- 14:59can tell me whether it's a $75 ,000 problem,
- 15:04a $500 ,000 problem as a buyer, I have to underwrite
- 15:07that uncertainty. And the buyer may and likely
- 15:11will price the worst case scenario into their
- 15:14offer. That doesn't mean, you know, I guess what
- 15:24I should say is what I mean by that is undefined
- 15:27risks can result and usually does result in conservative
- 15:32underwriting. So targeted or specific or limited
- 15:38diligence can improve an administration's position,
- 15:43even if the choice is to sell as is. We may not
- 15:48be trying to solve the problem, but we are trying
- 15:51to define it well enough so that buyers are not
- 15:54left to essentially fill in the blanks for themselves.
- 15:59In other words, buyers price physical problems,
- 16:02but they're also pricing uncertainty. And so
- 16:06in a given situation, if we understand the condition
- 16:10better, we can typically make better choices
- 16:14as to, in this case, whether to repair it, whether
- 16:16to sell as is, whether to seek some resolution
- 16:20with the neighbor and pursue recovery or take
- 16:23some other path. Um, but now we're making decisions
- 16:28from a better position informationally. Um, and
- 16:33I, you know, it's going to be tough again, because
- 16:37of, of, we can only really communicate via chat,
- 16:40but, um, I want to see if anyone, you know, wants
- 16:44to ask a question about this, because I would
- 16:46be shocked if someone doesn't have a thought
- 16:48or position on these types of situations. I mean,
- 16:51even when I was when I was crafting this, the
- 16:56situation that was coming to mind was the can
- 17:00of worms scenario, right? Couldn't an investigation
- 17:04lead to the discovery of more problems? And the
- 17:08answer to that is yes, of course. It can lead
- 17:12to uncovering a can of worms. And these are always
- 17:16judgment calls as to whether it could lead to
- 17:22or the uncertainty itself is likely material
- 17:25enough to affect the sale. And whether this specific
- 17:30or limited diligence has a reasonable chance
- 17:32of just narrowing the uncertain condition enough
- 17:36to improve decision -making or the market outcome
- 17:41in this case, which would be the eventual sale
- 17:44price. And I always say specific diligence like
- 17:48this is usually more compelling when there is
- 17:51like a potential downside range that is really
- 17:54wide. That's when buyers are likely to underwrite
- 17:58towards the bad end of the range. And we believe
- 18:01due diligence could narrow the range. And then
- 18:05also, the cost and delay of getting that information
- 18:09are reasonable relative to whatever the potential
- 18:13benefit that we're seeking. This was, yeah, this
- 18:19was an example of uncertainty regarding, you
- 18:21know, the property itself. And I want to look
- 18:24at another kind of uncertainty. This one relating
- 18:29to humans. All right. So in this example, we
- 18:37have an adult beneficiary occupying a trust property.
- 18:41There is no written lease, no fixed term. no
- 18:46rental payment history, the beneficiary is presently
- 18:51cooperative, friendly and all that. He says he'll
- 18:56move out the property when it's eventually sold.
- 19:00And for purposes of this example, let's assume
- 19:04that it has been determined that the occupancy
- 19:08constitutes a tenancy at will. And given that,
- 19:14personal representative has the legal ability
- 19:16to terminate the tenancy. But the not so straightforward
- 19:22question here that comes up is, should the personal
- 19:26representative exercise that ability now? I wouldn't,
- 19:32in this example, I wouldn't automatically move
- 19:35to notice the occupant to vacate simply because
- 19:38that remedy's available. Although it's tempting,
- 19:42especially in hindsight into some previous similar
- 19:48fact patterns where an occupant didn't follow
- 19:52through with his or her word. But what we have
- 19:57in this example is a seemingly cooperative occupant.
- 20:02There is, we have time in the administration
- 20:05and so preserving that cooperation may have value.
- 20:11And that is where the distinction I think is
- 20:15made between the legal right and strategy becomes
- 20:19important. As the slide says, having the right
- 20:24to act does not necessarily tell us when or how
- 20:27we should act. The question I'm asking is, can
- 20:33we improve the administration's position today
- 20:38without unnecessarily creating conflict. And
- 20:43so on these facts, what would you recommend?
- 20:51In terms of what I would likely recommend on
- 20:54these set of facts, again, assuming a tendency
- 20:58at will, no other reason requiring immediate
- 21:03formal action, I would generally start with the
- 21:07least adversarial step that still advances the
- 21:11administration. So first I would try to document
- 21:15the understanding and the intent of the occupant.
- 21:21That might be as simple as. just an email confirming
- 21:25that the beneficiary understands that the property
- 21:27is expected to be sold and intends to vacate
- 21:31by a certain date. And if we can get that, we're
- 21:34already in a better position should something
- 21:38change. And of course, depending on the circumstances
- 21:41that can be more formal than that, we might suggest
- 21:46entering into a mutual termination or surrender
- 21:49agreement. In this case, again, it says on the
- 21:56screen, the point is not maximum formality. It's
- 22:00just greater certainty. And importantly, I would
- 22:05want to preserve the ability to become more formal
- 22:08later if circumstances change. If the beneficiary
- 22:15does stop cooperating, pushes the date repeatedly,
- 22:19interferes with access, or the sale timeline
- 22:22becomes more urgent, the recommendation may change,
- 22:27it probably will change. But preserving the ability
- 22:31to become more formal later on doesn't mean we
- 22:36have to get formal now. And so... the foresight
- 22:42here does not mean creating conflict early, in
- 22:45my opinion. It means asking whether maintaining
- 22:51the current cooperation can reduce some sort
- 22:54of later uncertainty while still preserving the
- 22:58personal representative's options. And I wanna
- 23:01comment on what happens in both of these first...
- 23:08A couple examples, with the retaining wall, there
- 23:11were several reasonable paths that we could pursue
- 23:14in the occupant example, same thing. There were
- 23:20a few different strategies or paths we could
- 23:23have pursued and they all could be defensively
- 23:26reasonable. So when we have more than one reasonable
- 23:30path, again, both fact patterns did, how do we
- 23:35decide among them? And this is the lens that
- 23:40I use when assessing potential options. Once
- 23:46we identify realistic options to choose from,
- 23:48I want to understand each path relative to these
- 23:54five concepts. One, how does this path versus
- 23:59this path affect value, first and foremost? And
- 24:03then what risks? does it create? Not just what
- 24:09can go wrong, but how significant is the downside
- 24:12if it does go wrong? How much does the option
- 24:16cost the estate? How long will it take? And then
- 24:20how much certainty does it provide? How predictable
- 24:23is this option that we're considering? And of
- 24:27course, none of these automatically controls
- 24:31or dispositive. One option might create the highest
- 24:37theoretical value, let's say, but require significantly
- 24:41more cost and time to carry out, while another
- 24:46may produce somewhat like less value, but maybe
- 24:49it has greater certainty. And so I certainly
- 24:53don't want to turn every decision into some mechanical
- 24:59formula, but the big purpose is just to make
- 25:03the trade -offs visible. in how these decisions
- 25:08are being made and so that they can be made as
- 25:12best as possible. So once the personal representative
- 25:17can clearly see what is gained and what is given
- 25:20up in each path, they're just in a better position
- 25:25to make decisions. And while value is one of
- 25:31the first things that we focus on, I do wanna
- 25:34talk some about some of the nuances to value
- 25:38and value in real estate because value can be
- 25:42mislead if we're not clear about exactly what
- 25:46we're valuing. Sometimes we're asked to pour
- 25:53a value before we have completely defined what
- 25:57the property actually is. And this example is
- 26:01extrapolated from a recent Real -life example
- 26:05women all these are but this one was very recent
- 26:08We have a trust property owned or the physical
- 26:12configuration didn't line up with public records
- 26:16And you probably can't you know be involved in
- 26:21real property sales Whatever the involvement
- 26:23is in Los Angeles and not deal with a situation
- 26:28like this at some point So with this particular
- 26:33property, there were multiple living areas. There
- 26:38were likely several alterations that were made
- 26:41to this property over time. We were not certain
- 26:45what was permitted, what the legally recognized
- 26:49configuration was, how buyers were ultimately
- 26:52going to view the property. But even in a situation
- 26:59like this, it doesn't mean I can't value the
- 27:03property, but it does mean that the valuation
- 27:06has to be tied to some clearly stated assumptions.
- 27:11Am I valuing it as a single family residence
- 27:15with additional space or am I valuing it as two
- 27:20units, three units? Also, am I assuming that
- 27:26the existing Living areas can continue to be
- 27:30used the way that they're being used right now.
- 27:33And what comparable properties actually belong
- 27:36in this analysis? Those assumptions can change
- 27:41the comparable set, the buyer pool, the income
- 27:45analysis if one's warranted, and ultimately about
- 27:50the valuation. So sometimes, you know, The better
- 27:54question isn't what is the property worth? It's
- 27:57what version of the property are we actually
- 28:00valuing? And the judgment in deciding which unknowns
- 28:04matter enough to resolve before making the decision.
- 28:11We don't necessarily need to resolve every unanswered
- 28:14question, but we do need to identify which unanswered
- 28:18facts are most likely to change the analysis
- 28:22or evaluation. And that leads to another valuation
- 28:27problem. A number can look much more precise
- 28:35than the information supporting it. You know,
- 28:38we all want to give precise, you know, tight
- 28:43numerical ranges when we upon value. And if I
- 28:48tell you a property is worth, you know, 3 .185
- 28:52million, certainly sounds research and confident
- 28:55otherwise, why wouldn't I put 3 .2? And I can
- 28:59give you a very precise number. The problem is
- 29:02I can be precisely wrong. Precision and reliability
- 29:08are not the same thing. If I still have a material
- 29:13question about configuration or use or occupancy
- 29:16income or some other assumption, that's gonna
- 29:20affect how buyers will underwrite the property.
- 29:23making the range narrower does not, in that situation,
- 29:29make the analysis better. Sometimes a range with
- 29:32just very clearly stated assumptions is actually
- 29:38more useful. For example, based on the property
- 29:44as in this case that I personally understood,
- 29:49I think it would be more useful to say, I believe
- 29:51the value is approximately x to y. And if we
- 29:54can confirm a, b, and c, here's how that could
- 29:58change the analysis. That's helpful information
- 30:02that is giving the best information at the time.
- 30:09So now the person representative understands
- 30:14not only the value range, but what's driving
- 30:17it and what could change it. So, let's see, sometimes,
- 30:22like I said, the most useful thing I can say
- 30:25is I can give you a preliminary range, but there's
- 30:28one fact I would want to understand better before
- 30:31I can confidently narrow that range. And so,
- 30:36yeah, I guess the message to leave here is the
- 30:41goal of valuation is not to produce the most
- 30:44precise number. to give the most reliable information
- 30:49and to help decision making. So far, our examples
- 30:57have largely isolated one issue at a time. There
- 31:03was a physical condition with the retaining wall,
- 31:06there was the occupant beneficiary in the trust
- 31:12property, and then there was this valuation assumption.
- 31:17you know, actual administrations rarely cooperate
- 31:20that nicely or neatly. So let me show you an
- 31:24example where several reasonable decisions started
- 31:28to interact with one another. This was a mixed
- 31:35-use property. One of those, you know, classic
- 31:41LA hodgepodge properties, one residential unit,
- 31:44three commercial spaces. The residential tenant
- 31:49was also using two of the commercial spaces as
- 31:55storage. So living at one, using two of the three
- 32:00commercial spaces as storage. And I think my
- 32:04initial thought was relatively straightforward.
- 32:08Oh crap. I remember the residential tenant had
- 32:14no written lease. But there was a rental payment
- 32:18history. So we were dealing with a residential
- 32:22tenancy, the CDMLA, and the tenant protections
- 32:27that come along with it. And at the same time,
- 32:31you know, we believe we had a much cleaner path
- 32:37to recovering the two commercial spaces they
- 32:39were using as storage by simply issuing a notice
- 32:44to revoke their license that used those spaces.
- 32:47and I was feeling real good about, you know,
- 32:50I'm making progress, we're getting two of these
- 32:52spaces back, but once we stepped back and looked
- 32:58at the property as a whole, recovering the two
- 33:01commercial spaces wasn't really the most important
- 33:04issue in this example, the residential tendency
- 33:08was. If we sold subject to that tendency, We
- 33:14believe that would narrow the buyer pool, particularly
- 33:18for owner users. And that matters because an
- 33:23owner user will typically value a property very
- 33:27differently from an investor. Just to expand
- 33:31on that real quickly, an investor is going to
- 33:34underwrite things like income, expenses, and
- 33:36cap rate. Whereas an owner or user wants to run
- 33:39a business at this property and would likely
- 33:43place a substantial value on being able to control
- 33:45and occupy the entire property for their own
- 33:48use. So that question kind of evolved into, it
- 33:53was no longer how do we get back these two commercial
- 33:56spaces, which we thought we had a good strategy
- 33:58for, and it became, does the existing residential
- 34:03tenancy, what does the existing residential tenancy
- 34:07do to the buyer pool and the likely sale price?
- 34:11And once we analyze that, the numbers supported
- 34:14pursuing a tenant buyout agreement. And the expense
- 34:20of this particular tenant buyout agreement was
- 34:23significant in this situation. But there's no
- 34:28standard formula that tells you a tenant buyout
- 34:32agreement, what it should cost in every situation.
- 34:36So the test that we ultimately implemented here
- 34:40was whether the cost was justified by what we
- 34:45expected to gain. And that was possession, flexibility,
- 34:49and this broader buyer pool of certainly improved
- 34:52marketability and a better sale outcome. And
- 34:57so in this case, we believe it was justified.
- 35:01And I remember, I think it was one of the beneficiaries
- 35:04of this particular trust asked me, how do you
- 35:07quantify the negative impact to value of this
- 35:12residential tenancy, because all they saw was
- 35:15a big number to pursue and consummate this tenant
- 35:21buyout agreement. And I told this person, what
- 35:24we look at is the anticipated cost, time, and
- 35:29risk for a buyer to have to step into this other
- 35:31shoes and attempt to recover possessions for
- 35:34themselves. put numbers to those factors based
- 35:41on what we know and based on our own experience
- 35:43in those situations. And so that's how we quantify
- 35:46it. And we gauge whether at any given dollar
- 35:51amount, we think this is a good idea or not.
- 35:56So in this case, presented another decision that
- 36:00initially looked like it can look like obvious
- 36:04value creation. once we recovered the commercial
- 36:09spaces, one of the options we were considering
- 36:11was leasing there. And on its face, it made sense,
- 36:14vacancy goes down, income goes up, beneficiaries,
- 36:20that typically makes beneficiaries happy, more
- 36:24rent, more value, could easily make the connection
- 36:29there. But there was litigation in the background,
- 36:32this particular. And we didn't exactly know where
- 36:38the administration was going to lead. So we had
- 36:40to ask, if a sale was likely, what do leasing
- 36:46these spaces now do to our options moving forward?
- 36:53And again, on its face, leasing vacant commercial
- 36:59space. totally looks like an improvement, right?
- 37:02But what else happens, you know, other than vacancy
- 37:05going down and income going up? If we release
- 37:09those spaces for any particularly meaningful
- 37:12term, we, again, are reducing the property's
- 37:16flexibility for a later sale. And we may also
- 37:21reduce the attractiveness to, again, these owner
- 37:24user buyers who place significant value on being
- 37:27able to occupy and control spaces, and that could
- 37:31shift the eventual buyer pool more heavily towards
- 37:35investors, which again, are just more income
- 37:37and cap rate driven. And there was one more thing,
- 37:43the condition of the space is when we finally
- 37:46got in there, the rent we realistically expected
- 37:50once we were able to ascertain condition. we
- 37:55were going to get modest rents to, I think, what
- 37:58expectations were. So the question became whether
- 38:02the income we could generate was worth giving
- 38:04up this flexibility that we would likely want
- 38:08later. And in this case, we concluded that it
- 38:10wasn't. And I think that illustrates this broader
- 38:16principle of a decision that improves one dimension
- 38:22may make another one worse. So, unfortunately,
- 38:27the question isn't as simple as does this action
- 38:29improve the property? The better question is,
- 38:32and our team is asking this throughout most engagements,
- 38:38is that does this decision further the objectives
- 38:40or the needs of the administration? And that
- 38:43typically brings us back to that filtering our
- 38:47decision through those things, value, risk, cost,
- 38:51time, and certainty. Okay, so that was our last
- 38:57case study to look at. And when I step back from
- 39:05all four examples, there was a fairly consistent
- 39:08decision process underneath all of them. And
- 39:12that's really the framework that I wanted to
- 39:15leave everybody with. And this... This is really
- 39:21the whole presentation on one slide. Just as
- 39:25a recap, we're always starting with the administration.
- 39:28What does it need? What authority exists? Who
- 39:31are the players? And so on. And we understand
- 39:34the real estate within that context. From there,
- 39:38we identify realistic options. Then we compare
- 39:43their consequences. And sometimes we are not
- 39:48just digging into financial, we're looking at
- 39:51regulatory, we're looking at, you know, tax -related,
- 39:54practical -related consequences. And that analysis,
- 39:58you know, supports the personal representative's
- 40:02eventual decision. And when that decision is
- 40:05material, we document the reasoning behind it,
- 40:10in case it's ever needed, ever questioned, doesn't
- 40:14have to be, you know, super formal or lengthy
- 40:17in the way that I think it can be done and still
- 40:20be effective. It can be as simple as here are
- 40:23the facts, here are the options, here are the
- 40:26major trade -offs, and here's my recommendation
- 40:29and that's it. And then of course basically the
- 40:32plan because even a good decision can produce
- 40:36not a great result if the execution doesn't really
- 40:39support the strategy. And so one through six
- 40:43is what I mean. by an administration -led approach
- 40:48to real estate. Rather than starting with how
- 40:52do we sell this property, we start with what
- 40:58does the administration need from this property,
- 41:00and then we build our strategy from there. All
- 41:04right, so rather than continuing to talk framework,
- 41:10I thought we'd finish by applying it. through
- 41:15a game. If everyone could please pull your phones
- 41:24and use the QR code. I have a game set up with
- 41:29nine questions. The last one being for double
- 41:32points. These aren't legal trivia questions.
- 41:36These are judgment questions and several of them
- 41:38have intentionally plausible answers. So let's
- 41:44see how we can apply this framework. And the
- 41:50winner shall be rewarded handsomely. Let me just
- 41:54pull up the game and share my screen. wait until,
- 42:23here we go. At least eight people are listening.
- 42:32Nine, good. 16, 17, nice. I'm gonna start it.
- 43:06You can still do 33, 34, okay. 35, all right,
- 43:1536. I'm gonna let it go for another few seconds
- 43:18and then I'll start. We go. Most directly shape
- 43:54the initial sale recommendation. Okay, so out
- 44:07of 37, we have four correct answers. And probably
- 44:18everyone's still getting used to the game, so
- 44:20hopefully we have more answers in the next one.
- 44:21What this is gonna do, it's gonna show the score
- 44:23of everyone, the top five I believe. But just
- 44:27to comment on this question, the reason that
- 44:29I like... the trustee wants to complete the administration
- 44:33this year is that it tells us what the administration
- 44:37is trying to accomplish. All the other answers
- 44:40are important, but alone not as significant.
- 44:44If the trustee's objective is to complete the
- 44:46administration this year, that should directly
- 44:50inform the sales strategy. Okay, here we go.
- 44:57Visible wall movement, unknown scope and cost.
- 45:00what should drive investigation. Very nice. So
- 45:32all four facts matter again, but they answer
- 45:37different questions. The threshold question is
- 45:42whether targeted, specific, limited, you know,
- 45:45diligence would meaningfully reduce the uncertainty
- 45:49buyers are likely to price into this property.
- 45:53You know, if yes, the investigation has may have
- 45:58value, even if they ultimately want to sell it
- 46:01as is. So this was that point. Also, just to
- 46:05remember, investigation and remediation are just
- 46:08separate decisions here. All right. So I guess
- 46:11we're not going to know the tally until after.
- 46:13That's OK. Here we go. Which statement is most
- 46:17accurate? Okay. Triangle is the right answer.
- 46:48You know, one of these is really tempting because
- 46:51it sounds, it sounds disappointing. If the price
- 46:54benefit doesn't exceed the cost, why investigate?
- 46:57But that's too narrow. Specific limited targeted
- 47:01diligence can still improve pricing, negotiation,
- 47:04certainty, disclosure. and help the personal
- 47:09representative's decision, even if it can't prove
- 47:12a dollar for dollar return. So that's why I like
- 47:17the triangle answer the best here. All right,
- 47:24next one. The beneficiary occupant agrees to
- 47:26leave before sale and remains cooperative. What
- 47:29is the strongest next step? A lot of people nailed
- 47:54this one. Okay. The reason I like this answer
- 47:57is that it gives us more certainty today without
- 48:00unnecessarily escalating the relationship. We
- 48:04confirm the move out access expectations and
- 48:09writings where there's a clearer record of what
- 48:12everybody understands, but it still preserves
- 48:14the ability to use more formal remedies later
- 48:19if that cooperation changes. Okay. Next question.
- 48:25Third, living area is unconfirmed. Duplex comps
- 48:291 .3 to 1 .4, triplex comps 1 .5 to 1 .65 million.
- 48:34Best valuation approach. Okay, circle is the
- 49:01right answer. Present value scenario is based
- 49:04on clearly stated assumptions. The reason I like
- 49:09this approach is that uncertainty is actually
- 49:14material to value. If the property is treated
- 49:16as a duplex, then comps point us to one range.
- 49:19If the third living area is legally supportable,
- 49:24we may be looking at a different buyer universe
- 49:26in a different range. And so, you know, rather
- 49:28than force a single number, we've, before we've
- 49:33resolved some material facts, I present the valuation
- 49:37under these clearly, whatever the clearly stated
- 49:40assumptions are. Okay. Next one, $200 ,000 of
- 49:46work may add $300 ,000 in value, but it's going
- 49:49to take four months and carrying costs are going
- 49:52to be $12 ,000 a month. What is the best analysis?
- 50:21Square, nice. A lot of people got that. Yeah,
- 50:25the math gets us to about $50 ,000 in their parent
- 50:28upside after the work and caring costs. But that
- 50:32still doesn't answer the question. We also have
- 50:38to consider four months of delay, construction
- 50:41risk, overturns, and what the administration
- 50:43actually needs. So I wouldn't automatically proceed
- 50:46as I would. We can automatically sell as is.
- 50:53So the point is to evaluate whether the remaining
- 50:55upside is worth this additional risk in time.
- 50:59All right. Three more. Bacon retail could be
- 51:03leased after $75 ,000 of work, but a five -year
- 51:06lease may reduce. I'm going to use a repeal.
- 51:09What is the next best step? Okay, square. A lot
- 51:34of people nailed this one, too. All right, this
- 51:36is a good example of why an action that improves
- 51:39one dimension can harm another, right? Leasing
- 51:42a space may increase NOI net operating income,
- 51:47but a five -year lease could reduce flexibility,
- 51:50narrow the owner -user pool, keeping it vacant
- 51:53preserves flexibility, but sacrifices income.
- 51:58Before committing to either way, I'd wanna compare
- 52:01the likely sale scenario under both strategies.
- 52:05Okay, two more. And this one's gonna have six
- 52:08possible answers. Two buyers move on due to foundation
- 52:14concern. We only have one offer at 2 .5 million.
- 52:20We're listed at 3 .5 million and we have... we
- 52:23can possibly inspect this foundation issue with
- 52:27$15 ,000. What's the best next? Nice. Okay. Diamond,
- 52:55normally, I'd probably counter the offer, anchor
- 52:58the price as high as possible, and let the buyer
- 53:01investigate to an escrow. What changes here is
- 53:05the magnitude of the spread and consistency of
- 53:08the feedback. Two buyers have already moved on
- 53:11from this foundation concern, and one offer that
- 53:14we have is a million dollars less than our asking
- 53:17price. Assuming the original valuation is accurate,
- 53:21We have a $1 million delta and then we have a
- 53:23$15 ,000 opportunity to investigate. I'd rather
- 53:27define the issue before continuing to expose
- 53:31the property, you know, with the same uncertainty.
- 53:35Okay, final question, double points. Here we
- 53:40go. Also six possible questions or answers. $400
- 53:46,000 stabilization may add $800 ,000 to value,
- 53:52but it's going to take 12 to 18 months. Beneficiaries
- 53:55prefer near -term liquidity. What is the best
- 53:58choice? Okay, so this is intentionally uncomfortable
- 54:24because the project has real upside. But the
- 54:29personal representative isn't evaluating the
- 54:32property in isolation. I mean, getting to that
- 54:35upside requires $400 ,000 investment, 12 to 18
- 54:40months. And beneficiaries are, there's a preference
- 54:45for near term liquidity. So if stabilization,
- 54:49even if stabilization is a good, Solid real estate
- 54:52investment decision may not be the best decision
- 54:56for the administration All right. Oh Come on.
- 55:00Tell me tell me Check the podium. Here we go
- 55:06Okay, so Kristen third place camo second place
- 55:16JCP JCP is going to be leaving with a $200 gift
- 55:29card to Mastros in Beverly Hills, so please enjoy
- 55:31your two drinks and one appetizer on me. And
- 55:35I hope that was fun for everybody. And I'm going
- 55:42to go back one last slide and then we're done.
- 55:47All right, let me bring this back up. You know
- 55:51who JCP well JCP you'll have my contact information
- 55:55on the last slide write it down and send me an
- 55:57email Okay All right, so But I'll leave you with
- 56:09three questions if you remember nothing else
- 56:12from from today I think these three things will
- 56:16get you surprisingly far under this framework.
- 56:21First, what does the administration need from
- 56:24the property? Not simply what can we do with
- 56:29it or how much is it worth? What does this particular
- 56:33administration need from this particular asset?
- 56:38Second, what facts could materially change the
- 56:42recommendation? We don't need to investigate
- 56:45everything. We do want to identify the facts
- 56:48that could actually change the decision. And
- 56:53then third, options. What options exist today
- 56:58that may not exist later? Because sometimes the
- 57:02most important thing we can do early is preserving
- 57:05flexibility. This is really the idea behind foresight.
- 57:12It isn't about predicting exactly what's going
- 57:14to happen. It's about understanding enough, early
- 57:18enough to preserve the ability to respond diligently
- 57:22and when circumstances change. So, yeah, I hope
- 57:27that is useful and valuable to everybody. Really
- 57:32appreciate you guys being here, participating
- 57:34in the game. Happy Friday, and if anyone has
- 57:40any questions, I can try and... I can try to
- 57:43answer some of them if we have time. We might
- 57:45not, though. Well, this concludes today's program.
- 57:51We would like to thank our speaker, Mark Chanciulli,
- 57:54for an excellent presentation. We encourage you
- 57:57to join us next week on August 27th for another
- 58:00presentation from Michael A. Hackard and Matthew
- 58:03D. Davis entitled When It Isn't Just Alzheimer's.
- 58:07cognitive decline, undue influence, and elder
- 58:09financial abuse in California trust and civil
- 58:12litigation. We also invite you to join us to
- 58:15the Meet the Probate Judges a Night on October
- 58:1821st at 5 30 p .m. at the Skirball Center. Thank
- 58:22you again for joining us this afternoon and we
- 58:24wish you a great day.